If you ask me, seasons 8-10 look just as yellow as season 11. The only reason I think people bring up the yellowish lighting of season 11 is probably because it was the first season made in HD, so it probably looked more yellow to the average fan because of the upgrade to HD.
The Skarloey railway clearly did not want to add drivers to its cabins (which were notoriously empty), and the rest even had the new engines despite the fact that they no longer interacted.
Great video my friend. Obviously the change of camera during the HiT Era had an impact on the quality but I personally don't mind the Season 11 resolution. Classic Era is the best though obviously 😉. Well done on another great video ☺️🚂🚃
Other reasons: - Lighting is dim - Cloud backdrops are too symetrical - Repainted faces look objectively worse - Human figurine faces look objectively worse and scare the daylights out of me. [Like seriously, what is this anime/Dora the explorer asf hybrid they are going for] - Lighting, again. [Its flat] - Most sets are generic and bland. - Lazy production work [ Applying filters to scenes to represent snow and rain instead of actually wetting the scene. -Lack of deph/implied distance in scenes. - This video seems unifinished honestly.
I can understand you think I should have said more and admittedly really should have. I kinda just when off of what I was thinking going threw seasons 8-10
If I had to describe what I feel soil's the HiT aesthetic... Weird yellow lighting, the lighting isn't as bright, a lot of the sets are either redundant or lacking something to make them stand out, and the models look a bit too... polished? I dunno, I never bothered with these seasons. I'm just going off what little I remember and from watching Unlucky tug's videos.
The 35mm theatrical prints of digitally filmed movies (eg: the Star Wars prequels) look way better than the home video/DVD versions. It makes me wonder if film prints of the New Series would make it look any better. haha
One thing I do kinda like about the HiT Era is the music. The new intro, although not great, is still quite memorable, and it fits THIS interpretation of the era really well.
Good video! One tip I would make though is that ending is very abrupt and out of nowhere lol. Like, I didn’t see how long the video was, but nice job at keeping short and to the point, and I thought it would go for a little longer, but it Js ended. Try to change your voice to sound like you’re reading the end of a story maybe, kinda gradually closing it off. Here, it just kinda ends lol. What I’m trying to say is make your voice sound like you’re about to stop talking, and make the end a little more gradual, like recapping what the video was abt or something. Still a great video tho!
@@spiderfan2003 same lol. As you saw, I also suck at explaining things lol. Anyway, you got a new sub, love the content, been watching your other videos and they’re very well done. 👍🏾
@@spiderfan2003 np. What drives video ideas for you, like, if you were to check out my page (which you are free to do 😏) I don’t have many videos other than my series since idrk what to make other then that. What gives you those types of ideas. I’ve just started another series cause I like making them lol
Something the contrasts Seasons 8-12 and the classic series, is how Seasons 1-5 and even 6-7 have something unique to that season. For example, Season 3 used a lot of working water, Season 4 had its impressive sets, Season 5 had everything, Season 6 had its music, etc. Each season has its own unique feel, you can easily tell Season 2 from 1, Season 4 from 3, even Season 7 from 6. While Seasons 8-12 don’t really have that much distinct feel, aside from maybe the yellow tint in Season 11, and the ugly CGI elements of Season 12, there’s really not that much.
Pardon me, but I believe you're a bit mistaken. I'm pretty sure that Series 8-12 or 10 can't be scanned, because it was shot on video, it was filmed in that format. Film reel can be scanned, but video is video, based off what TheGermanofSodor and TheUnluckyTug has told us.
@@spiderfan2003 But I will say one thing regarding the CGI era, it wasn't as bad at first but after Nitrogen stopped making the cgi era was when the show had its downfall
@thomas2themaximus913 The thing isn't about resolution seasons 1-10 !re 480p. But seasons 1-7 are shot on 35mm film while 8-10 are shot on betacams. Also, 11 and 12 were shot 1080p.
Now I do respect the older seasons I just like season 9 a lot It’s my childhood but also don’t hate me for that they just didn’t have the older seasons on what ever I watched it on
I totally understand and respect your opinion, but for me, seasons 8-12 were overall okay seasons. They’re not as good as seasons 1-7, but they’re definitely better than All Engines Go in terms of pacing and consistency (for the most part).
"Peeped Percy", Toby lacking confidences, Emily being bossy, Skarloey being childish
Those did happen
Henry being a wuss, Edward being young and naive instead of old and wise.
@@gregkiteos1936Thomas’s maturity from seasons 1-6 completely thrown out the window
@@mastermaker352 *HiS fIrEbOx WaS oN fIrE*
@@gregkiteos1936 What is a wuss?
If you ask me, seasons 8-10 look just as yellow as season 11. The only reason I think people bring up the yellowish lighting of season 11 is probably because it was the first season made in HD, so it probably looked more yellow to the average fan because of the upgrade to HD.
Honestly I don't really see the yellow in 8-10 but, that's ok you're point is still valid
@@spiderfan2003 I think this is only true of 10
The Skarloey railway clearly did not want to add drivers to its cabins (which were notoriously empty), and the rest even had the new engines despite the fact that they no longer interacted.
Ya it's odd
@@spiderfan2003 Yes, it is strange and for some reason people have not noticed that detail.
@@crisnacho8261 ya
Great video my friend. Obviously the change of camera during the HiT Era had an impact on the quality but I personally don't mind the Season 11 resolution. Classic Era is the best though obviously 😉. Well done on another great video ☺️🚂🚃
Thanks, always happy to see comments from you, all I don't mind season 11's yellow I just being funny
Other reasons:
- Lighting is dim
- Cloud backdrops are too symetrical
- Repainted faces look objectively worse
- Human figurine faces look objectively worse and scare the daylights out of me. [Like seriously, what is this anime/Dora the explorer asf hybrid they are going for]
- Lighting, again. [Its flat]
- Most sets are generic and bland.
- Lazy production work [ Applying filters to scenes to represent snow and rain instead of actually wetting the scene.
-Lack of deph/implied distance in scenes.
-
This video seems unifinished honestly.
I can understand you think I should have said more and admittedly really should have. I kinda just when off of what I was thinking going threw seasons 8-10
The characters eyes look like googly eyes in the HiT era
They honestly do
If I had to describe what I feel soil's the HiT aesthetic...
Weird yellow lighting,
the lighting isn't as bright,
a lot of the sets are either redundant or lacking something to make them stand out,
and the models look a bit too... polished?
I dunno, I never bothered with these seasons. I'm just going off what little I remember and from watching Unlucky tug's videos.
Agreed
I love how short and simple that was-
Thanks, I like getting to the point.
@@spiderfan2003 tbh i laughed at the abrupt ending of the vid since the vid's runtime completely slipped from my mind while watching 😭😭
@@Queen_Miku that's funny
The 35mm theatrical prints of digitally filmed movies (eg: the Star Wars prequels) look way better than the home video/DVD versions. It makes me wonder if film prints of the New Series would make it look any better. haha
@@JacksonBegleymusicguy probably
One thing I do kinda like about the HiT Era is the music.
The new intro, although not great, is still quite memorable, and it fits THIS interpretation of the era really well.
Understandable, there's some charm
Tbh, I don't hate the HiT Era visuals in general.
Honestly they are nostalgic to me
Season 11 would have looked better with Season 12 lighting, which is kinda the same as Season 11 lighting, but without the yellow filter
Very true
Good video! One tip I would make though is that ending is very abrupt and out of nowhere lol. Like, I didn’t see how long the video was, but nice job at keeping short and to the point, and I thought it would go for a little longer, but it Js ended. Try to change your voice to sound like you’re reading the end of a story maybe, kinda gradually closing it off. Here, it just kinda ends lol. What I’m trying to say is make your voice sound like you’re about to stop talking, and make the end a little more gradual, like recapping what the video was abt or something. Still a great video tho!
Thanks for watching, and ya I have trouble ending things
@@spiderfan2003 same lol. As you saw, I also suck at explaining things lol. Anyway, you got a new sub, love the content, been watching your other videos and they’re very well done. 👍🏾
@@ThomasTheTankEngineFan thanks
@@spiderfan2003 np. What drives video ideas for you, like, if you were to check out my page (which you are free to do 😏) I don’t have many videos other than my series since idrk what to make other then that. What gives you those types of ideas. I’ve just started another series cause I like making them lol
@@ThomasTheTankEngineFan I just kinda think of things id want to see videos and just make it
Honestly doesn’t have that much (bad) stories it only has boring stories if it had somewhat intresting stories I would love this era despite the looks
@@SparklingJam understandable
@@spiderfan2003 dang your fast at replies
@@SparklingJam yup
Something the contrasts Seasons 8-12 and the classic series, is how Seasons 1-5 and even 6-7 have something unique to that season. For example, Season 3 used a lot of working water, Season 4 had its impressive sets, Season 5 had everything, Season 6 had its music, etc. Each season has its own unique feel, you can easily tell Season 2 from 1, Season 4 from 3, even Season 7 from 6. While Seasons 8-12 don’t really have that much distinct feel, aside from maybe the yellow tint in Season 11, and the ugly CGI elements of Season 12, there’s really not that much.
@@ryanfuller912 agreed
hm! never knew they used the 35mm camera untill series 7
Ya
I do not know what the people at HiT were smoking to make Emily a Karen on wheels during those seasons.
Lol
@@spiderfan2003 I just find it funny on how Emily's character was fucked up.
And in an era where karen didn't have that meaning, nonetheless
That dreaded pitch bible or whatever it was
Can I go full tech nerd here on why it looks bad?
Sure
he never did 😢
We should ask for Toby's original bell sound in "all engines go"
I honestly find Season 8 nostalgic and cool (except for Emily and Gordon’s personality), but I can respect your opinion on these seasons.
Tbh, this video is More about the visual content of the seasons, 8-11 I just find alright all around.
@@spiderfan2003you know what, i now only season 10 to 11 is kinda bad
I always thought that seasons 1 and 2 looked different compared to season 3. Is there a reason for that?
@@jvbndofvbnebe there was a 6 year gap between seasons
Clearwater Studios made Season 1 & 2 but went bust before Season 3 started production.
Season 1 2 were made in a low budget
My favorite season 10 episode is James the second best
That's a great episode
@@spiderfan2003 it sure is
I’m pretty sure it’s everyone’s favorite season 10 episode.
@@ryanfuller912 me Too
Season 11 is the best looking hit season
Definitely the most distinct for sure
@@spiderfan2003 But the lighting in Season 12 feels even better despite being a mediocre season
Pardon me, but I believe you're a bit mistaken. I'm pretty sure that Series 8-12 or 10 can't be scanned, because it was shot on video, it was filmed in that format. Film reel can be scanned, but video is video, based off what TheGermanofSodor and TheUnluckyTug has told us.
@thomas2themaximus913 That's correct that was my point in the video
@@spiderfan2003 I see.
I like the look of the hit era
That's fair, it does have a nostalgic quality to me,. For I was more talking about the objective downgrade from the first 7.
@@spiderfan2003 yea, the look of S1 makes sodor feel more like a real place, rough and dirty
I like the model series better than the cgi series since I find the CGI versions to look kind of creepy
Makes sense
@@spiderfan2003 But I will say one thing regarding the CGI era, it wasn't as bad at first but after Nitrogen stopped making the cgi era was when the show had its downfall
@MrRandomUA-camr1996 really i feel it picked up a little after nitrogen left but then declined when bwba started
Wait, if Series 8-12 where at 480p, then what resolution was Series 1-7 at? 720p?
@thomas2themaximus913 The thing isn't about resolution seasons 1-10 !re 480p. But seasons 1-7 are shot on 35mm film while 8-10 are shot on betacams. Also, 11 and 12 were shot 1080p.
@@spiderfan2003 Thank you for telling me.
Did you mean to type "are" when you typed "!re"?
@@thomas2themaximus913 no problem, also yes
I Loved The Hit Era From Thomas And Friends
That's good to hear
Now I do respect the older seasons I just like season 9 a lot
It’s my childhood but also don’t hate me for that they just didn’t have the older seasons on what ever I watched it on
@@DAsethShowYT understandable
another reason (in my opinion) is the dull colors and worse sets
@@dhomastheroblox1411 agreed
This video is good however 1 think that you could do is use color correction on hits later model stuff.
That would look good
Any redeeming qualities?
I mean it's cool these seasons are 60 fps
Correction: 50fps
@@garrettsmith2776 your correct, My bad
I totally understand and respect your opinion, but for me, seasons 8-12 were overall okay seasons. They’re not as good as seasons 1-7, but they’re definitely better than All Engines Go in terms of pacing and consistency (for the most part).
Honestly I do think 8-11 are ok, this video was complaining more about the visual aspects
1: Lifeless models
2: Lifeless models
3: Lifeless models
4: Lifeless models
5: Lifeless models
6: Lifeless models
7: Lifeless models
8: Lifeless models
9: Lifeless models
10: Lifeless models
Guess that sums it up
11. Lifeless models
Wouldn't they be locked to 576p?
Ya
Honstly seasons 8 and 9 dont look that bad they actually look pretty clean on the dvds but season 10 yea... it looks bad.
Fair
I understand you didn’t like a show’s era, and that is fine. I respect your opinion!
I mean, this video is more about the era's visuals. Overall, 8-11 are OK in my opinion
@@spiderfan2003 I know.
It was a masterpiece not bad
This video is More About the seasons picture quality, honestly I find 8-11 ok overall
Season 8 is still good, right?
Eh, I honestly think this whole is ok, this video is about the seasons video quality btw
I love ya'll, but its seasons 1-5 or nothing.
@@gregtaras7789 understandable
It doesn’t look bad at all 💀
To be honest, I was exaggerating a bit
@@spiderfan2003 I don’t think any of the model series looks bad. The same for cgi tbh
Untill they made the engines bounce and forgot physics existed 😂
@@Alfiegould7822 fair point
Excuse me this is bad? No all engines go is Bad
I was talking about the picture quality of the seasons, I think 8-11 as season are alright
The hit era seasons are good so shut up
@@White_sox_fan there alright
@@spiderfan2003I grew up watching them
Wrong
Understandable
The cinematography is like breaking bad excellent
@@Breakfastman343MIC if that's how you see it, understandable
@@Breakfastman343MICi wouldn't even compare season 1-5 to breaking bad 😭