How I Built a Super Solid Recall! What If My Dog REFUSED Come When Called?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 тра 2024
- How should you react if your dog refuses to come when called? Thank you Nom Nom for sponsoring this video! CLICK HERE: trynom.com/zak to get 50% OFF a 2 week supply of Nom Nom’s super fresh dog food!
Join the Dog Training Revolution and learn to train your dog with modern, evidence-based methods! In this informative and engaging video, learn from an evidence-based, positive dog trainer as we explore the most effective techniques to train your dog to come when called, even in the most challenging situations. Discover the magic answer to successful dog training, using only positive reinforcement methods that are kind, humane, and proven to work.
🔔 SUBSCRIBE to see all of our videos (it’s totally free!): tinyurl.com/subzakgeorge
🚨 STATE OF EMERGENCY: The Dog Training Industry is IN CRISIS. You need to know this!!! Learn more here:
• My Thoughts on the Dog...
For more daily dog training tips and videos FOLLOW US!
➡️ @zakgeorge on Instagram: / zakgeorge
➡️ I’m on TikTok too! vm.tiktok.com/fFxPbh/
➡️ Like me on Facebook! / thezakgeorge
😍 @breejustine is on instagram too: / breejustine
Is there another social network you’d like to see us on? Tell us in the comments! ⬇️
🥰 THANK YOU to our Patrons who help us keep this content TOTALLY FREE 🥰 You can help support our videos by making a contribution here: / zakgeorge
📖 If you have a NEW PUPPY or you’re PLANNING FOR THE FUTURE, my FIRST book (broad overview of choosing, raising and training a dog) is the one for you!!! Get it here: amzn.to/1PXH568
📖 Order my NEW BOOK here (💥this one is a deeper dive into troubleshooting the most common training issues💥) amzn.to/2XiER6f
☝️👀👂 If you prefer to LISTEN instead of read... I narrated both of my audiobooks for you guys myself!!! If you listen to the audio versions be sure to let me know what you think! 🎙😜 You can find audio (and Kindle) versions at the links above as well.
0:00 intro
0:25 what really happened
1:37 what has helped me build confidence
1:55 my protocol for teaching off leash
2:30 example from 2020 of my dog in training
3:12 Inertia has a ton of experience listening while distracted
3:35 another possible strategy
4:08 how often and how long to work on this
4:22 electric collars
4:50 fetch training hack
5:35 What if she didn't come?
6:04 how to be consistent
6:18 most important point in this video!
6:42 get 50% off at trynom.com/ZAK - Домашні улюбленці та дикі тварини
Here’s the full episode which I strongly recommend you watch! ua-cam.com/video/qItwbJ0pOsQ/v-deo.html Have you already seen it?
You make it sound so easy. I, hand on my heart, can say that my dog is well trained. I can take her pretty much anywhere and she behaves. But recall is something I still do not trust her with. She's broken that trust so many times. We practice our recall word every day even on a leash around distractions, but in our home forest I still have her on a long lead. She's such a momma's girl that she would eventually come back, but I'm afraid she'll start driving game and run under a car or stumble upon one of the predators of which we have many and be left second in that battle. So whenever I'm alone with her in the forest, she's on the long lead and I blast a video or something from my phone in my pocket to make constant sound, driving animals further and in a sense controlling our surroundings also in that way.
It's not always easy. It's not only down to your training technique but it's down to your dog too. My lady dog wasn't good at recall but my current dog which is the same breed of dog is very good at recall.
I gave up trying to get my dog do anything
I have a question. Do you think more practice is what is needed? Do you think that your dog doesn’t understand what you want at this point or do you believe they want to ignore and chase prey?
@@Steve30x balanced training provides any dog with guaranteed recall.
@@Mwyse414 It's not really that the dog wants to ignore you, if it comes to prey drive it's just really hard for them to fight the instinct. Or it may be that the reward for coming back doesn't compensate what they could've gotten from the chase, so next time they will choose something that has more value. That's why practice is so important, alongside with HIIIIGH value rewards. Doing it often enough will definitely improve recall, but overdoing it may decrease value of the reward, and you may end up having to take a step back. It's very veeeeery hard to have perfect recall, and even a well trained dog (as the one the first commenter owns), may not always react. Practice not always makes perfect, but definitely creates progress, and that's what dog owners should aim for
I always find your videos highly educational and I love the content but I'll be honest I learn the most when you hit real-life experiences when your dog partner doesn't auto-magically do the right thing. Watching the correction and evolution of trust is where I get the most hope for my own pup and training.
All my dogs had/have a great recall, even my Akita can walk off leash in the forest. I always use a super treat for recall. One they get only when being called so it's special and highly rewarding. Also keep recall fun and diverse. Sometimes it's just that treat, sometimes it's a fun game, sometimes both and another time we do some tricks, play a search game or I call them when standing beside something interesting to show it to them afterwards.
I agree with the long leash. I use them for a long time, many people take the leash off way too early and that ruins a lot of training and makes it harder and longer.
Thanks for the great reminders and tips! My dog and I have been working on his recall since I got him as a puppy two years ago. His recall still needs work as he still gets distracted by smells and some other things like pheseants or squirrels... for most instances, he does come but not right away.
This is a good reminder of what to do when your dog listens "most of the time," like my dog does 😁 keep up the great work !
Thanks for sharing these tips.
I have a whippet and live on the edge of a nature reserve where we often walk. Sometimes she scents a deer, rabbit, or squirrel and chases them. In these moments she won't come back when called. The switch has flicked, the eyes are closed (so to speak), the ears are back and she's gone. But I'm fine with this! She's living her best life, free and happy. If I wait around close to the place where she last saw me she'll eventually come back. Occasionally I shout her name, especially if we're deep in the woods, so she knows which direction to come back to, and when she's ready she comes back, panting like crazy. The longest I've ever had to wait is 15 minutes. She doesn't want to run away from me, she loves me and wants to live with me forever, but sometimes she goes off on the hunt and I have to wait. I'm fine waiting because I'm not in a hurry. It's her walk, not mine. I want her to live her dog life to the fullest.
When I used to walk out in the open with my dog off leach and she was distracted by a rabit or something I would call her name and whistle one time very loud and then start to walk slowly in the other direction. In a way im telling her I know you want to chase the rabit, but I am going the other way. This method has never failed once and worked with all the dogs I had.
Interested to know what breeds this worked with
You the man
Okay but what happens when you ask your dog to come and they won’t until they see the treat? 😂
Take a step back and prioritize your recall training has advised in this video! No magic answers here.
Or what to do when your dog comes 1m away from you and you reach your hand to grab it and reward it and it just decides to run away?
@@kostanikolic4379 I’ve found benefit in just gently grabbing my dogs collar when they come or having him come and perform a sit position and then rewarding. My labradoodle used to come, grab the treat, and run back to what they were focused on so being able to gently grab the collar/harness + sit position has helped him tremendously!
@@Crxny02 yep i try to do that but when i reach my hand out he imidietly starts running away. I tried to tell him to sit and he does and when i reach my hand he runs away again ahaha so yeah really stubborn dog
Some youtubers said that you should walk to your dog and grab him and pull him to a spot from where you called him but that's useless if my dog is running away from me and if i chase him my dog will think it's a game and he will take it as a reward
I am hoping it will fix it's self since my dog is around year and a half so I'm thinking it's just a phase like many other phases before that
@Zak George’s Dog Training Revolution if you have a quick tip or an opinion or maybe a video about a dog with similar behavior i would very much appreciate the help
Thank you!
Now I understand your point of view if the E-collar all of sudden stop working. The same can be said if your dog see something its never seen before and runs off. So there's literally two negatives with both Balance and Positive training for off leash. With positive training there's no guarantee no matter how much your dog loves you if there's that one thing or something its never seen and that dog runs it's gone. Same for the E-collar by some 1% chance it fails hopefully by the corrections that been made by not recalling your pup will come or not
Moral of the story: there's always a risk if you have your dog offleash no matter which training methods you use
I'm a balance trainer just for flawless recall, venomous snakes, and chasing vehicles and large predatory animals (or small animals that will still mangle them).
Failing on any of these has that 1% chance of getting you a dead dog, so I don't mess around, especially since all my dogs are off-leash at least 90% of the time.
I don't think most owners of pets require this high level of demand, but my dogs are either problem foster dogs in professional behavior training or my own working dogs. Most owners use a leash off-property, don't have a dangerous dog, and/or don't work in dangerous environments with public access.
My puppie is now 13 months old I've used your channel to train her.she labxcollie her heel is good but she does get distracted.I've got her on long lead for park play and beach play she has taken off on beach to play with another dog.but the owner grabbed her lead.treats did not entice her not did her ball.she was in a safe enviroment luckly the dog was good with her.I want you opinion on using a Halti to stop her jumping at people as that big problem.thank you so much for your channel I have a happy dog.
Hi @zakgeorge, what is brand is that pouch you're wearing at 2:34?
What kind of long line do you use Zak. Mine always gets so dirty and knotted. Yours also looks thinner. Is thin best. And what material would you recommend?
What Frisbees do you use I have a Kong one but it doesn't roll !!! Also tried a child's one which her teeth went through. I have collie cross. Any help would be helpful
Great video. What are the different items hanging around your waist?
Do you have any tips about car-anxiety? My 2-year-old swedish vallhund was really calm in the car when she was a puppy, but then started to become more and more anxious about a year ago. She does not take treats in the car, but takes treats and plays with toys "normaly".
Sorry about any spelling or grammar mistakes!
So you said about reinforcing 'come' with treats so she wants to come, but I had signed up for an online course, called Cattle Dog Academy to use with my cattle dog. The guy on that said to not use treats to reinforce the command 'come' because coming to you can NOT be seen as an option to the dog. Both ways make sense to me, so what should I do? I do highly praise my puppy when she comes, but I'm worried it might not be enough if she sees something more interesting than me and takes off chasing it. Which do you think I should do?
All of this, yes! I can recall my sprinter off deer. Most of our training has simply been adding a cue when he’s already running toward me. #pavlovonmyshoulder
Do you have a link for the harness you use?
@zakgeorge Quick question: Is that long lead made out of biothane? Do you have any recommendations about minimizing the risk of our pups getting tangled or stuck on such long leads? Thanks!
I personally make sure the leash is always loose, and attach it to the back of a pull/sled harness rather than a collar so it's more likely to trail behind than get caught-up in their feet. I also don't use multiple long lines at once, though, so I can't help with that, but the pull harness won't make them face-plant if the other steps on their line.
Personally, biothane is my favorite. I have two nice leather ones that were made out of a single hide each (cut in a curl), but it takes a lot of oiling, use and stretching to get the curl out, and they're hard to find of decent quality leather and not just barely tanned cowhide you need to heavily work yourself (I have one of each, and the one that was already beautiful and ready to go cost a small fortune). And pressed leather hide is trash, and nylon will cut you like a squirrely guy in a dark alley. 😂
Amazing video as always! Zak do you have any videos on essentials for puppy's? I'm getting my border collie puppy mid April and have a bunch of stuff including things you've recommended but I can't help but feel I'm missing something. I'm also worried of getting something of poor quality.
The wonderful thing about collies is that they get addicted to things and as long as it’s something that you have control of you are in a very powerful position. Marzieh is addicted to jumping for bubbles so as long as I have a tub of bubble stuff in my pocket I have complete control. Jasper was addicted to catching balls rather than chasing them before he got cataracts. Another collie would “find” me. I would hide behind a tree and keep very quiet. He would run past and catch my scent and turn straight to me. Air sniffing!
If you have any questions on why I like a specific item or items I’d gladly explain why
HI ZAC APPROXIMATELY HOW LONG DOES IT TAKE TO TRAIN YOUR DOG TO COME WHEN CALL I KNOW YOU HAVE TO KEEP TRAINING THEM
This is interesting. How do you decide when it is a situation to 'test' their recall vs let them have freedom to go where they want if it seems like the recall might fail and it's otherwise a safe situation? For example, if my dog is playing with a friend, and it's all going well, I'm not going to call her right in the thick of things, like if she's mid-chase, unless I really need to. I'm going to wait until there is a short pause where I think I can catch her attention and she'll be more likely to succeed. In this situation I would probably have let my dog run to their other human and not used a recall cue if they seemed likely to blow it off. On the other hand if she was running toward a stranger or strange dogs I'd have called her and hoped for the best. Is the importance of maintaining the structure and focus of 'fetch' the priority for you here? Inertia's interest in fetch is probably higher than my dog's, who LOVES to run to one of her people, which seems to be part of what naturally reinforces her recall. I'd probably have let her run to her other person, then called her back, ie get her when I know I can get her, and then she hasn't refused to come when called. She would have, however, broken the structure of the fetch game. This isn't crucial for us since I let her choose when she wants to play fetch and it isn't a major reinforcer for her or one I can expect to rely on in most contexts.
I call my dog randomly even in safe environments and when he’s obviously busy doing something because I want him to listen to me in everyday life if he doesn’t then then he won’t listen when he needs to listen. If he doesn’t listen in the training safe environment then he goes on a long line even if the environment is safe because he didn’t listen and he definitely understands that. He can have freedom if he listens to me
I consider myself a balance trainer, but the only things I will use aversive training methods for are 1) avoiding venomous snakes, 2) plastering themselves to the ground at the sight of a moving vehicle, and 3) recall. If they're not all FLAWLESS, you've got a dead dog.
Most dogs can absolutely learn them with strictly positive techniques, but some can't do so quickly.
I have used shock collars for this, especially with snakes and recall around large predators, but only after they have learned the recall command and it is already excellent around normal distractions.
The snake thing is important to me because the punishment must be associated with the snake, not you. They're going to see and smell it long before you are in situ, so they need a safe situation set up where you can see the snake quicker than they can and you can issue the "punishment" as soon as they approach and they don't know that you issued the punishment. I combine it with an auto-recall so they can be rewarded, as well.
Our elderly pup really loves her walks, and we love taking her. She has a bad habit of stopping as we head back (she’s not sniffing) and no amount of cajoling or excitement or pulling on the leash (gently) will budge her. There have been a few emergencies when we’ve had to head back and even in her harness, it feels like we’re dragging her. I’ve recently tried stopping with her on a short leash and praising the heck out of her when she starts moving again but honestly, I’m not sure how to handle a reluctance to come back from a walk. What would your suggestions be?
Has she always done this (stopping), or is it a newer behavior? From your description, I wondered if it's a medical issue; maybe arthritis pain getting bad after a long-ish distance. In that case, it wouldn't be a training issue at all...
A neighbour had a dog that tended to attack other dogs (especially mine) and it wore a shock collar. Then one day the dog attacked my Jasper and she’d forgotten to turn the collar on! It wasn’t a bad attack.
15yr old Jasper is now deaf and I don’t want to have to chase him round the house so I have convenient little tubs of cat kibble scattered about and I just have to hold out a few kibble and he comes fast 😂
Also I didn't use a long lead when training my dog. I used an extendable lead. I know most trainers don't like extendable leads but what I done on every walk is I set the lead to a certain length depending on where we were and locked it at that length. Like if I was on a footpath on a main road I would reel it out no further than the edge of the footpath then let it slack off when she wasn't pulling. Or if I was in a park or grassed area she would get the full length of the 15' lead.
All tools require responsible use :)
I like the flexis better than the long lines because they don't tangle around my feet
I have a 6m old mini bernedoodle and training goes very well in our home. But every time we leave the house, she has no interest in the treats or toys we use to train. It's like everything goes out the window. Especially with leash training. She pulls no matter the command or distraction I use. I have spent time with gentle socializing and exposing her to all different situations. What can I do instead to keep her focused on me or understand that she needs to heel and not pull?
Recall is hard with a Siberian husky she is prey motivated loves the feral chickens in our neighborhood
I'm really struggling with my dog in agility classes. This is where she won't recall. The excitement of agility winds her up and then she won't come back. I really want to compete with her, but i can't until she can recall. She's 23 months old.
Great tips. My dog, cocker, is not so willing to give up meeting or playing with other dogs. If his is already "talking" with other dog, he tends to "grow deaf". We do practise recall with treats or toys, but... He would rather ignore a rabbit and come back to me than leave his new dog-friend. I sometimes think its unfixable. Usually I try to pretend I am going away to make him a little afraid of being left alone - it helps, but I would rather have him come back without it. Guess we need some dog-actors😂
Work on engagement with ur dog.
I'm working on this with my dog.
The things that have helped are asking her to sit before she give me eye contact, then giving the cue 'go play' I only letting her play for 30 40 seconds before calling her back with 3 bursts on the whistle. Then do it again. The reason for only letting her play for such a short time is I've noticed the recall has a higher chance of failing if I let her play longer.
As the owner of a dog which is reactive I would recommend keeping your dog on a long line. Your dog means no harm by greeting the other dogs, but if he came up to mine for example (who is always on lead if there are other dogs), there would be teeth. And then my dogs reactivity is getting worse, your dog becomes nervous of other dogs which could in turn make him reactive. We're working to reduce my dog's reactivity but as of 6months training, I have to be honest, I'm seeing no improvement (and we're working with a nationally certified +ve only trainer).
@@irishmiddle +1
@@irishmiddle i see your point, however we know most dogs in our area, and luckily they are not this reactive. If I am in the place where I am not sure what to expect, I usually keep him on the leash.
I'm training a dog who is resistant to coming when called and is prone to bolting. I have been advising to keep that dog on a long line. I have been asked, will he ever be reliable and not run away? This dog is fearful. What are your thoughts
I think if there’s a considerable chance the dog won’t listen that we must make sure our dogs are managed and under control. Every dog is different. Really depends on the training for many dogs as to whether or not they will be reliable off leash in my view.
Have you tried to practice recall without a leash in a closed and safe area like a backyard garden?
e-collar recall training can help
@@zakgeorge What happens if the leash or collar comes off or gets cut accidentally? A fearful, panicking dog is likely to run away without thinking.
@@akusalum5762 , that is the reason I have suggested keeping the do on a long line until recall is reliable
What if you did not have time to tire Inertia out beforehand, you are with her on one side of a busy highway with cars speeding by and Inertia sees that Bree and Veronica were both on the other side. You have no treats and no Frisbee in sight. Would Inertia reliably come to you when you call her?
Who on earth would let their dog off leash in that scenario
@@KS-yv7tw Accidently got out. This does happen.
@@cyborg8623 I'm waiting for Zak to respond to enlighten me on how he thinks Inertia would behave. I continue to wait...
@@akusalum5762 I bet she would because she wouldn’t know he didn’t have a treat but idk I know my dog would because he gets treats or a ball often enough that he assumes I’ll always have something so he comes lol
@@akusalum5762 he cant stop her from a drone in a fence park.....so
Any tips when a dog is hyper focused on a distraction (human far away, dog far away, a squirrel, segull etc) and is not interested in treats at all? And won't look at you at either.
We use the ecollar for emergency situations. I think a lot of positive reinforcement trainers see it as a lazy way to "train" a dog recall, and I think bad dog owners/trainers do use it this way.
However we put in the work to train recall without the use of tools, with longlines and a ton of cheese :) If we go out and I have to use the ecollar more than one time, that tells me my dog is not in an emotional state where she should be off leash. We pack up and go home or I take out my longline. Then we do recall drills at home for a while before we try offleash time again. We have only had to pack up and go home once in two years of ecollar use and that was over a year ago.
I'm not a dog trainer but I truly believe my dog would be fine offleash without the ecollar, and I think it'd make my life a lot easier if we went without it. However, if for some reason my dog blows a recall cue, I'd rather have it than nothing else.
Good approach ! E-collars can save ur dog from death if it decides to bolt and run towards a busy street or when u have to teach them to never go near rattlesnakes (how do u teach that with pure +R?)?
The word I use for my dog to stay is "Wait!" And she will stop and wait. Most of the time she will wait and whine because she wants to go but she won't go unless I say "ok" or I take a step forward.
She is like your dog inertia. She will come back to me 95% of the time.
Just two weeks ago I had her off lead and we came across another person walking their dog. I didn't know they were so close and that they were in the park.
But I looked over to my left and my dog was walking their way. I told her wait and she stopped for a second then started heading their way. So I said no , wait. And she stopped. She was unsure what to do and she was about 6" away from the other person and their dog. So I told her "come". She then came to me and followed me.
My dog is very friendly but if I knew that person was there I would have had her on a lead before they got that close because I know my dog would have tried to approach them and I didn't know if that person would have been ok with her approaching them or if the other dog would have attacked her.
I'm just lucky my dog will do what I ask her to do most of the time.
Thanks to Zack and other training channels I watch I've used various positive reinforcement techniques to train my dog myself. When she does what I ask her to do she gets her favourite treat , lots of love and praise.
For a two year old dog she's a very well behaved dog.
You were very fortunate that the other dog was not aggressive. 6" is no distance at all for a dog.
@@akusalum5762 the other dog was on a lead
@@Steve30x They can lunge.
@@akusalum5762 they can? Really? I never knew that. That was my first time ever walking my dog.
@@akusalum5762 did I say I didn't know the person was there with the dog until I looked over to see them there. I'm sure I did.
omg
We have a dog that if she gets off leash even with a treat she won’t come when called.
My Westie is like that. Great dog, well trained but if he sees another animal, he takes off. I was told his breed can't be trusted not to run towards other animals because the prey instinct in his breed is too strong. I wonder if that's a fact.
I've had that happen, use a higher reward treat. I use freeze dried chicken hearts. If they won't come all the way I'll throw one half way then hold a second one out so they have to come to me for the second treat.
@@ThatsY2 my dog is a hunting dog too she does the same thing😅
Try this, get there attention then squat down with your arms open, no treats. This worked for my wolf hound and border collie.
My dog always comes when I call ...but it might take 5 minutes until she gets to it :( She'll just mosey on over at her own pace sniffing around and enjoying the scenery and maybe to chase a squirrel or two up a tree
without that ball....she would be gone lol
My dog has a very weak recall she has slipped out of her harness and gone afterafter chickens and kangaroos multiple times!😅
She needs strong and consistent training for at least a year to be trusted off lead
She is also a terrier which makes the drive stronger 😅
Although Zak seems like a legit nice guy trying his best, I don't feel he has what it takes to train a serious dog or have the ability to work with dogs with severe reactivity and or aggression. Until he works and raises a dog like a Dogo Argentino, a Cane Corso, a Tibetan Mastiff I don't feel he will be a top trainer. He is always training easy dogs, which is fine but until he proves his methods with a serious breed I can't get behind everything he says. I would absolutely love to be proven wrong and see him train a police or military dog with his methods and have it a success but I think that's just fantasy and can't happen.
Have you ever stop to think that what youare calling “easy dogs”is me connecting with the individual dogs so that the training process is easy. I come at this from such a different place than the types of dog trainers you are likely use to. The reason you think people are working with harder dogs are because they are literally provoking and promoting conflict between a person and a dog to cater to their ego. Stop falling for it!
Agreed. Zak is entertaining. He first caught my eye with his trick training but that gets old. I wouldn't trust him with a serious dog. He only picks the nice, easy ones to work with and always in a completely controlled environment (although he claims otherwise). His methods wouldn't hold up in the real world.
@@akusalum5762 they would with certain dogs but not all of them. Until he shows training one of these more dominant serious breeds with his methods I don't buy in.
@@zakgeorge so your saying how you train dogs you could use your exact approach and could train police and military dogs? I have a very hard time believing that.
@@JLCsyr yeah maybe a 13 year old pug
My dog doesn't value playing with people and doesnt really like to be around other dogs to run around so i struggle to get her the excercise she needs since she also doesnt care for walks :((
Was her distraction a big deal though? It seemed like she was always coming back but just looking at them as she did.
This is my biggest problem. My dog is a runner. She’ll run in the street in traffic. I just adopted her last year at eight years old. Not sure why she thinks it’s a game when I’m having a heart attack from fear of her getting killed.
And what do you do when your dog is a 10 month husky pup...the CATS of the dog world!??
"Cat!!"..."Squirrel!!" ... "Rabbit!!"..."Deer!!"..."Bird"!! ... Human!?? Not so much!?? LOL
We struggle with the come command unless our little dude has his electric collar on. With it on he has 100% recall command attention. I set it on an 18 out of 100 strength and it just is a little buzz to him. I tested it for any type of pain on my wife and she only yelped once it went over 40. As for not having your dog on leash...maybe every dog, including ones trained by you should never be off leash.
Is it cruel to NEVER let your dog completely off lead outside? Because I have tried , and she will never come back to me willingly. I always have to sneak up on her, and she has nearly got killed so many times from running into a road. She is completely unmotivated by toys and food. So am at my wits end.
I had the same problem with my gsp. I live two blocks from a very busy road and I couldn't risk him getting run over if he got away from me one more time. Got an e-collar for him, problem solved. And no, you don't have to use the electric function. Beep and vibrate will work just fine. He can run off lash at the beach now, and I have no doubt he will come every time I call him.
@@pumpkinhead8593 Tried it! And she is not remotely bothered. There is literally nothing I can think of.
I think it's more cruel to put your dog in a situation where she's likely to get hurt than to always keep her on a leash. When my dog was a puppy and didn't have a reliable recall, I put a medium length leash on her, but didn't hold on to it when we were in places like a fenced-in yard . Then she could move freely, but if she tried to bolt when it was time to come in, I could catch the leash even if I couldn't catch her.
@@pumpkinhead8593 Tried it. She was surprised at first. But now just ignores it.
@@cyborg8623 Thank you. She has been to the vet, and a clean bill of health. I train her everyday, and work hard to build trust. It was hard when she was a puppy, but i have trained her to do everything else, just though her genuine adoration of me! But i cannot whole heartedly trust her to com back to me in a public area.
I need them in a populated area😅😅😅😅 this is a joke
Not a good idea to throw ball on a sandy place. It can get into dog’s stomack and can cause eaven death.
Bruh, how you have almost 4 million subs and get like 20k views on videos? Oh wait nevermind i know
Why would you shock your dog to get them used to the collar? Do you expose your child to heat in case they touch the hot stove? They come programmed to know and understand how to respond to to a bad stimulus. That is how they navigate the world
Electric collar trainers would say that you need to find your working levels and provide the meaning behind the shock. Obviously I think that is a primitive way to communicate with a dog. But apparently a good half of the dog training world or more disagrees with me… go figure… And it’s 2023.
@@zakgeorge just like in the +R world. There are good trainers and some that aren’t as good. In my opinion this is a very bad approach. Puts the dog through a lot of unnecessary stress and is confusing to them. Not to mention the reliance it will create on the e collar especially if they are not following the laws of classical conditioning to ensure the dog is responding to voice and not the collar
Recall can be trained using the beeping sound option with e-collar. It's not all about shocks.
@@zakgeorge Proper use of an appropriate ecollar is not using the kind of "shock" that you make it out to be. A normal working level is a slight stimulation that are below detection on most people.
@@powerliftingpremedcrafter473 Or, you can just use a whistle…
See going back to what we said yesterday that I also agree with ecollas allow u to have a chance at a off leash life but they can and do. Ignore it unless u increase the voltage even I said no at that point my poor dog was basically tazed to stop
That I don't see as a good experience for any normal house hold pet
Or any pet really outside of marines or police or any type of canine combat scinaro
I tried it and it works to a degree but it's not nice I don't feel comfortable and
These level 6 or 7's I'm hearing my dog shrugs off like it's nothing x by 10 then ur close to getting my old dog to listen
And its not fair
100%agree on that
When using an E collar for recall when that fails to work what next??? This is the problem as e collar are last result! If you haven’t spend enough time working on recall
Yes. I agree. People should not be relying on the electric collar if they think their dog is unlikely to listen without it. Of course you know my recommendation is to never use a shock collar.
Work with an experienced dog trainer when wanting to implement the e-collar. It's a tool that requires skill to use.
The proper use of an ecollar requires that the dog already have a strong recall, most likely taught using R+ methods. There's no shortcut. The ecollar is like a remote tap on the shoulder saying "hey Buddy, go home" when they are outside of vocal range or too distracted to pay attention to it.
And when not using an e collar for recall and the dog blows off the command then what???? There's always a risk to having your dog offleash. I'd personally rather have the ecollar as a back up then nothing. And the goal of using the ecollar is to ~not~ use it. If trained properly you shouldn't have to use.
Risking her life.
The E-Collar is an attention grabber that causes no physical damage. You just are limited in your talent and would prefer to waste massive amounts of time on the simplest things like recall. So please stop sounding foolish when you talk about advanced technology that you know nothing about. Also, if e-collar is used correctly then it is more so there for emergencies not for training. You better hope your frisbee or treat helps in sticky situations but more than likely you would avoid those situations so there will be nothing to prove.
You seem confused. Are you saying e collars would make recall training faster (presumably because you use them for that training)? Or are you saying that an e collar when “used correctly” is there for emergencies and not used for training?
@Tony DiGiorno 🤦🏻♂️ You definitely should not be using a E-collar your the type of person is the reason why E-collar get such a bad reputation.. E-collar is used for Training/recall. You need to teach your dog and make sure they know the commands by treat or toy training 1st then. Start using leash corrections outside then when they passed that pair it with the E-collar on low level.. If you have your dog off leash and its not trained to understand sit or down or stay when its off leash and you have a kid or dog running by WTF are you going to do?!?
Actually @zakgeorge is talented with certain dogs and if you don't have the time or patience to train a dog then you should not have one
@@beastmode3266
You sound so special Ed.
An E-Collar doesn’t zap intelligence into a dog. Of course you have to train them before you use it. Can you read ?
I said it’s an attention grabber. You shouldn’t be using it if you’re correcting a dog with it. Sounds like you push it when you’re mad.
Its supposed to be used to get their attention when they’re stimulated and accidentally tune you out.
I didn’t say push it and watch it magically make them do obedience. Next time read carefully.
@@zakgeorge
Recall, leash and basic obedience are clearly skills that are carefully taught without the need for e-collar up front . To sharpen their skills and gain faster results, then pairing voice commands with the e-collar after the dog knows the commands is highly effective and works faster than trying to throw toys and food around. especially in loud and distracting environments.