Aryan Invasion Theory is a LIE - Evidence Based Explanation By An Archaeologist
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 січ 2023
- Watch The Full Episode Here: • Indian Archaeologist S...
Listen To The Full Episode On Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/2lyZ...
🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
open.spotify.com/show/6ZcvVBP...
Follow Disha Ahluwalia's Social Media Handles:-
Instagram: / dishaahluwalia
Twitter: / ahluwaliadisha
✅ Subscribe To Our Other UA-cam Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
BigBrainco. :
/ @raaazofficial
BigBrainco. Shorts :
/ @raaazclips
Bringing you a "History" special episode with Archaeologist Disha Ahluwalia. She is the founder of a page called Confessions of an archaeologist - Link here: / confessions. .
History is a subject that most kids tend to dislike in school, they say it's no point knowing about the past, and they find it to be boring. But, what if I tell you that history has so much to do with the future and even more lessons to be learned for the present. This is one of the most interesting episodes we've created on the show, talking about my favorite subject which is "Historical Facts, Vedic Truths & The Aryan Theory".
In this episode, we speak about archeological truths about the world that are kept hidden from the general public. Only deep researchers, Archaeologists, and historians with enormous research and digging can find out hidden facts and have evidence for the same. This Episode on TRS brings you a mind-blowing conversation of all the findings of India's True History uncovering India's real past.
#archaeology #1796
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.
Link to our blog - beerbiceps.com/indian-archaeologist-shares-vedic-truths-breaks-aryan-theory/
Aryan Invasion Theory is TRUE, just like Mohal's invasion.. First of all She does not even look like a archeologist. Better luck next time.
Hi bro , I read one article on times of india news of a lost city in southern India which is called Poompuhar port city . They mentioned that this city may be over 15000 years old . Bring an archaeologist who knows about it to your show .
In my South India ..... Karnataka Kerala Telangana ap .. fair to brown yellowish skin hai ....aur straight hair bhi hai... Sharp facial structure ....but malayali Have curly hair .... With fair skin Sharp facial structure .... Tamilnadu people are dark skin
already proved aryan invation theory. your channel promoting lies without giving proof and so called archaelogist lol
Few years back somebody had filed an RTI asking proof of the Aryan Invasion/Migration theory . The answer was "Sorry the information is not available" . Likewise many such RTIs have been sent to ask the proof of the so called benevolence of Mughals. And the answer was the same. This shows how badly Leftists and self proclaimed historians like To mila Thapar, Irfan Habib and others have manipulated their thoughts into our minds.
Self proclaimed Historians claim to justify AIT/AIM -- Aryans brought horses to India during 2500BCE.
Scientific Proof - Inscriptions of Horses and Chariots have been found in Bhimbetaka caves and rocks which are as old as 4500 BCE .
Fake Historians Claim - Vedas were written in between 800-1000BCE .
Scientific Claim- In Vedas , Saraswati river which vanished completely by 3000 BCE has been mentioned prominently . Now, when Vedas mention a river prominently it shows that , at that time when Vedas were written , Saraswati river was flowing in its full swing when there was no any possibility of river getting vanished . This ultimately supports the fact that Vedas were written THOUSANDS years ago from the fake timeline told by these fake historians.
Fake Historians claim that Sanskrit is a foreign language that originated from Steppes and Caspian sea. 😅😅
Our take - Why on Earth would these so called outsiders would migration such a fertile soil like Steppe grassland and Caspian Sea kinda one of the largest fresh water lakes ??
When a Western scholar give something about India, people don't ask proofs and sources. But when an Indian scholar gives something with facts and proofs, people dislike and criticize it. Colonial mindset still prevails.
Yep 👍
Worshipping west is in our blood
Remember, they taught you your history. Before that you were illiterates. Don't bite the hand that feeds you
In my South India ..... Karnataka Kerala Telangana ap .. fair to brown yellowish skin hai ....aur straight hair bhi hai... Sharp facial structure ....but malayali Have curly hair .... With fair skin Sharp facial structure .... Tamilnadu people are dark skin
So you mean to say that there is no proof on which western historians suggest a theory?? Such an ignorant mindset.
A friend of mine once said "If you want to convince Indians of something just convince some foreigner to your point and let the foreigner speak to the Indians"
The timeline started by British in india since 1800s-
1) Arryan invasion theory - 1800s to 2010
2) aaryan migration Theory- 2010 to 2022
3) aaryan holiday theory - 2022 to 2050
4) aaryan picnic theory - the last straw
🤣 so true...
5) aaryan vlogging theory - 2018 - present. They came to explore india they also vlogged.
Indoeuropeans invaded all over Eurasia, get over it. That doesn't mean Harappans + other autoctonous people didn't already were advanced, they obviously were. That's why Sanatana Dharma is so unique, because it's a mixture of Indoeuropeans (specifically Andronovo Aryans) mythology and very advanced autoctonous mythology.
PS: Indians are Aryans, Europeans are Yamnaya. Cousins
Epic 🤣🤣🤣
@@swampraider3488 Europeans are also aryans if you look at Spanish, English, Portuguese languages are derived from Sanskrit language
I was waiting for the expert to give her conclusions on the Aryan topic when Ranveer has to interrupt and goes off on an absurd irrelevant tangent. Please let the expert fully answer your previous question 🙏
@@Remielsekai wait for the host to complete answering your previous question before cross questioning. That's called etiquette. Once you understand that you can tell me what to do and not.
@@Remielsekai fetch a dictionary and look up interruption.
Ranveer needs to learn a lot from Joe Rogan.
@@Rajatha_kshetra I agree! Sometimes he asks some stupid questions. Also asks the hosts to explain the fundemantals which most of the viewers already have an idea about.
Auntie ji ka dimag garam ho rai....or thori der rukhi naa toh jhagra ho jaaiga😅
Alexander did not invaded. He got his ass kicked, and ran away.
LOL thats clearly a lie
@@wyattwanders whitey how does it feel to know your ancestors were browns from Asia?
He didn't ran away in one day but his rule was crushed in Afghanistan in phases, I mean he didn't died because of an Indian sword but by Indian mosquitoes...Maybe...
@@theaborigine1119 maybe our mosquitoes were enough for alx and his so called great army🤣
He don't have the GUTS to attack the large Indian kingdom of that time that is " magadha ".......... because one of its (magadha's) small western neighbour ruled bya person named Porus has thareshed Alexander and his forces black and blue .............
Out of fear Alexander went back
Bhagwat Geeta was spoken around 5,450 years back .
This one fact is enough to destroy fake aryan Invasion theory.
sources- you still have dwarka in Gujrat and Ram setu in South which can still be seen .
Finished 😂😂
Bhagwad gita was written around 100CE
@@neollalobo wrong its around 5450 years old .
@@ThEEqualizer93or maybe 5451 years? Around that...maybe 3 months more lol
@@ThEEqualizer93 I doubt it, chief. 5500 years ago was when the Rgveda was compiled in a WRITTEN form in the Brahmi script. Krshna and Shiva are barely mentioned in it. Even the mentions are later additions from 100-600 CE. The original Rgveda had only Varuna, Indra, Agni, Ashwin Twins, Vayu, and most importantly Dyaus Pitr (cognate with Jupiter and Zeus Pater) who was the most important God.
Yes a bridge built by monkeys and squirrels… it is nothing but a natural formation.. if only these politicians keep religion aside and implement sethu samudra plan India would have gained a lot economically
2022 I was taught about Aryans... And 2023 my under class students are reading the same bull shit over years.
Please read DAVID REICH DNA report its scientifically proved 🤫
Aryan Migration did happen brother.. our culture is a mix of steppes from Central Asia and the later Harappan period
@@bharathanand1762 proof ?
@@bharathanand1762 aryan migration happen but to europe as mentioned in vedas
@@bharathanand1762 this kid is still believing it after seeing this video 😂 pajest 🇵🇰
Plz bring Rajeshri Nandy sir again.....🙏
Bring back Acharya prashant
@@robertK1889 bring both together 🤣
@@robertK1889 No we don't need him
Another merothi with their poor pathetic vocab & wrong spelling 💩 rAjEsHri does NOT exist FYI, Rajashri does but it's a feminine name. Is it too hard to understand or the ignorance is deliberate??! It's RA-JAR-SHI, quite common Bengali "masculine" name.
Bring only if someone has the ability to ask right questions to him not about ghost
Ranveer Bro you showed WRONG picture of John Marshall. she was talking about Archaeologist John Marshall, you showed US Politician John Marshall
hey that's just a matter of your opinion😉
@@gaswhole How??
@@bhavikpatil2564 havent you heard facts are opinions
hahahah GOOGLE's mistake..
@@magesh7046
Google does not; we do.
As a scholar of history, this lady's fresh approach gives me hope for academic discourses around the Indian history, which will be unburdened from any limited thinking towards our collective past.
So sad to see a history scholar is making a ridiculous comment like this.
@@siva1515 no doubt, one's hope can be another's despair. ... it's only human 😊
@@dreamsofadaffodil650 she is saying that aryan invasion is a myth cause there is no scientific evidence.
She is forced to say this because we are the decent of aryan's. The real vedic culture is not the culture of the country called india. If this truth comes out propaganda campaign will lose its authenticity
I can give u more logical reasonings . I'm just a curious one not a scholar.
The lady ur talking about is a scholar in Archaeology & Ancient History and as years of experience and is important part in Excavation at Rakhighari (largest Harappan site) so please see credentials before saying anything
I always put this theory of mine regarding similarities between Sanatana Dharma and Zoroastrianism-
In the Battle of 10 kings there were a clan named Parsua which is basically of people of Persia means Iran,
And in the battle of 10 Kings Bharata King was helped by Lord Indra which helped him to win the war and probably after that the poeple of Parsua stopped worshipping Indra and devas and may be they assumed that Asura or Ahuras are good and may be that's how Zoroastrianism's perspective about Daiva or Deva is always demonic, just because Indra didn't help them.
So you're agreeing the Aryan invasion happened?
@ARYAN MIZDHA you need medicine
You might be correct to some extend. It would be great to discuss this further, if you care to reply..
I think you have a point
The Iranians called Sindh as Hindu
Likely therefore called Asura as Ahura
Possibly a inability to use S but replace with H
Interestingly the Zoroastrian culture was an existing civilization with Darius as the Emperor
As Usual the invasion of Persia threw them to the sea and they migrated East to India and today’s Pakistan
Persia was known as Parama Kamboja in ancient times. Persia was the name given to it by Greeks named after the province of Pars from where the Achaemenid dynasty kings originated. Which means the so called Persians were actually related to Kambojas, Daradas and Madras.
What about the DNA traces shared amongst light-skin indians and Yamnaya? I believe this archaeologist problem is the word "invasion". Call it what you want. Modern day indians have Western Europe DNA.
Europeans have Indian DNA
India has a glorious history which dates back to thousands of years...at that time Europeans were just barbarians 😊
Yes! They need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
colour or facial feature doesnt depend on race but geography
I'd recommend you to listen to the talk delivered by Mr. Raj Vedam on the UA-cam channel Sangam Talks titled Indian Civilization: The Untold Story.
It's a fascinating lecture where he speaks in length about the veracity of the Aryan Invasion Theory with lots of diverse evidence. He speaks about Yamnaya as well and also presents further evidence that disproves it.
I hope you will find it very illuminating.
I wish now children has to be taught right history , children must know our rich culture,they must know about our Rishi Muni, like sushrut who was perfect surgeon agastya, vashist Rishi there are so manyrishi
Ranveer make podcast on our saptrishis🙏❤️
This will not happen until and unless we have communist mindset people in our Universities.
Those great people you talking about came from Europe and Central Asia thousands of years ago. Who knows. Why do you think North Indians have more european features?? Because they came and mixed with native indian population. This is enough proof to support the theory.
@@Ranger-ly5qf no saar our ancestors is Rishi sunak he use to rule along time ago and had a great empire saar
BJP print's and change history
name of ram
@@babupasha3491 was ram even a real person or was he a fictional character ? I've heard many theories that if ramayan happened then it must have happened somewhere near the Afghanistan iran side , it must be some conflict between the Aryan tribes which might have gotten exaggerated over time or it might be a complete forged up fake story.
there was nothing like invasion or migration
Not an invasion yes, but definitely migration you know "nomads" from central asia💯
@@nimalanmathew no
@@nimalanmathew it was a female mediated migration that contributed minorly to India's genetics. It was completely unrelated to the Indo-Europeans.
@@nimalanmathew no . there was no migration from central Asia either
@@atacama1000 Genetic date has shown that a migration by the aryans is true. Honestly if your from north indian this is badass, it just sucks if your from south india because you were enslaved
Even without the discovery of Harappa it is sheer nonsense to think that Indian civilization started with Alexander. What about the thousands of temples and palaces in the Indian subcontinent that show architecture but also art and designs unrelated to Greek or Roman.
No one believed or believes Indian history began with Alexander. That was her own absurd prejudiced emotional interjection.
Without the Aryan invasion theory, how do we explain the radical difference in the South Indian languages originating from Old Tamil and the North Indian languages originating from Sanskrit?
How do you explain the commonalities in pronunciation and the substratum influence in North Indian languages? Even the oldest stage of Sanskrit in the Rigveda has words of Dravidian origin.
@@SugiSeufz I have not read much into Aryan Invasion theory. I suppose the Aryans conquered the Dravidian races and subjugated them, but as the Dravidian races were more advanced culturally, the Aryan adopted the ideas and practices of the Dravidians in their own writings and lifestyle.
@@melroycorrea7720 If we look at History, irrespective of the geographical location, then any Invasion and subsequent Subjugation resulted in the complete loss of the native culture or the native culture had next to no influence on the invading culture. That was seen in the invasion of the Americas by the Europeans. In the case of India it must've been a peaceful intermingling, otherwise there wouldn't have been the adoption of Dravidian words into Sanskrit, no Synthesis of Aryan and Dravidian beliefs to result in what we now know as Hinduism and there wouldn't be any male mediated Aryan DNA as far south as South India and Sri Lanka and male mediated Dravidian DNA influence as far north as Afghanistan.
Right
Here's how: The presenters did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
She needs UA-cam channel Or an explainer video she has immense knowledge of History.
@@twiceistheworstgirlgroup3223Cry more i love it.
Ghantaa
literally knows nothing
@@RustieFawn yup right
Please bring authors like Amish Tripathi and Sobers Rodrigues.
Her historical factual perspective and point making is to the mark. Good to hear her. Please keep her as recurring guest ❤
But she needs to be true to her word. She said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Interesting topic, thanks 🙂
But there is linguistic relation between the ancient mother language of north india i.e sanskrit with the other ancient european languages. Because of which we term this language class as indo-european languages. So it could be a defined proof of the aryan migration theory. And the localisation of the dravidian languages to south india could also show some kind of pushing from north during earlier times.
Yes. The presenters need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Linguistics are indeed the reason the invasion/migration theory was first proposed, by William Jones in the 18th century.
There is also a small local dravidian language in Pakistan which suggests Dravidian was spoken all across the subcontinent before Sanskrit took over the north. In western Europe the local Basque language (northern Spain/southern France) also survived from neolithic times while Indo European languages spread everywhere else.
Aryans were just one Indo European tribe from the steppe, other tribes also migrated all over Europe, which was then peopled with indigenous Europeans (the ones who put up standing stones like Stonehenge). It's something people who reject the migration don't even know. IE tribes were from around the Black Sea. Not Europe per se. They migrated to Europe the same way they migrated to India.
Also, recent DNA studies show all modern Indians have some steppe ancestry, while IVC people didn't have it. Suggesting steppe migrants came in after the times of IVC.
Aryans weren’t europeans or whites 😂😂😂 They were from central asia region
The presenters need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Meenakshi Jain would be a good guest to invite for historical content.
Whether Aryan invasion theory is true or false is not a question. The question is using the theory according to convenience. The upper caste during the colonial period used this theory to show the close relations with Europeans. But now when it is discussed in a public sphere where everybody gets the knowledge about the original places of Aryans, a competition is started to disprove the theory.
It's false and the premise of your that's the upper caste was living it up during in the colonial period my guy Bharmins along with of every other caste and religions went to the Caribbean under indentured workers into colonial slavery so your whole special treatment speal is pretty garbage. Everyone suffered during the colonial period only the people who did not is the ones who made deals with the Bristish did not that's a fact.
Stop smoking so much!!!!! 🤦♀️
NO ONE in the upper caste used the theory to their advantage , your source is :- Trust me bro.
Upper caste were also slaves as lower and everybody else in colonial period
@@VSM101 They need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
It is a fact that Aryans came into India from outside during the timeframe that was mentioned, Nowadays the propaganda tries to show nothing of that sort happened - which are lies and misinformation in the name of nationalism.
By this, I don't mean Aryans were superior - they were just different people who needed to come to India for a better life here. And in no way is a White superior to a Brown or a brown superior to a Black - that's bullshit.
But the truth remains that Aryans came from outside (specifically from Kazakh - Ukraine belt) and settled here and mingled with the local guys forming the crux of the major Indians today.
Yes. They need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Thank you for calling out this video and establishing actual facts! 👍
Congratulations to you on your delusion 👏🏽
@@januprajapati7880 what is delusion? DNA evidence?
@@januprajapati7880 you are ignorant.
Please also Bring Nilesh Oak / J Sai Deepak / Aditya Satsangi on this podcast.
Sorry they are talking about Archeology and Anthropology.... Are those guys in the list any of those? 🤔
You might wanna explore the dev culture of himachal where gods enter the body of certain pundits
It's in Uttarakhand as well, we call it Jagar. We can communicate with our ancestors and certain other deities and gods by invoking their spirits in a human body.
They are not god's but shayak Shaktis of God's. God's cannot come inside any human body
@@andhkasur What is a shayak shakti ?
@@rohitghildiyal8643 Har devi devtà ka gan hote hai Bhagwati ki Yogniya, Bhairavi hoti hai
Possession is part of rituals in old gods or worshipping natural spirit. Its very complex and need lot of research both in folklore and psychological ascept.
There has been similarity in the R1A1 haplogroup among the high caste in North india and the eastern european country which suggests that in history these people were related. Yamnaya people had the same features in both of them. Yamnaya violently attacked the neolithic culture of Western europe. But what happened in the Indian subcontinent is still unknown
Maybe almost no one understand your this comment.
did you see how many of the samples & from where??? did you check which were termed as higher caste?? and do you think there was one migration INTO India?? There is archelogy, sociology, anthropology, history, epigraphy, philology etc BUT people want to CONFIRM based just on EPIGENETICS alone. Not only that politics/political party & ostracization just based on maximum 5 scientific journals. BS to say it kindly
The last Rakighar excavation debunked this narrative also.
@@bonitokumar4977 Actually it's proved it. How can people lived in Indus valley doesn't have Aryan DNA or whatever u call it. But today's North Indians have it?. Where did this DNA entered India. That is where Aryan migration theory comes to solve this missed piece.
@@gobimurugesan2411 out of India theory is father of your false indo -aryan theory...and in few years our history books will change that falsehood
Thank you for this informative video. Very interesting and detailed.
Note: I believe you had a picture of the wrong John Marshall about 3 1/2 minutes in. You had a picture of John Marshall, US statesman from the 1700's and 1800's, not the English archeologist from the 1900's. (I didn't see where anyone else had let you know of this small thing.)
Thanks again.
The Aryan invasion theory was also used to drive a deep wedge between North and South India. South Indians were told you are the original Indians etc etc etc
They said to unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
@@christianfrommuslimyour name says it alll😂
This is interesting podcast that came on my utube feed today, for 2 reasons.
1. I was discussing this with one guy in office after I overheard a discussion where same pedantic obnoxious stuff came up where that guy was talking of Dravidian & Tamil culture being great & the usual Dravidian Political language dressed with sickular idea that more bloody conversion & killings happened in ancient India & almost everything was of Buddhist or of Jain orgin, etc.
2.Other reason it is interesting is that this feed came up, indicating the umpteenth time to me that Google (UA-cam/Android) is listening conversations.
don't use google. use Indian systems
@@gaswhole you probably didn't understand what you read in the 2nd point I mentioned. It didn't have anything to do with nationality. But it's okay, everyone cannot use their brain effectively to understand things when it conflicts with their biases they have carefully grown in their head.
@@EXPLORADVEN You didn't understand his point. He meant it purely as an alternative to google.
@@rohitghildiyal8643 I got that point, but was there any need to add "Indian" system in there ?? Which is the Indian system S/he is referring to?? Let me know if you are aware of.
But, while I mentioned this, even then, I can say that I can be wrong in here, to read the sarcastic intention of his/her comment. May be S/he was not being sarcastic or rather caustic with his/her response. But who knows.
@@EXPLORADVEN Only he/she knows, let him/her reply.
No one says the "Aryans" are Europeans. They were Central Asian herders from the Amu Dharya valleys.
Please bring J Sai Deepak sir....
Bhai ye ab ranbir singh jaiso ko layega j sai deepak ko nhi
Who’s that ?
@@blueshoes5145 chup be what u want
Ranveeer let the guests talk u can show off your knowledge on spirituality and othe things to them in your personal conversations
I would highly recommend to decipher Rigveda to understand the history as it talks about Saraswati river as existed about 20000 BCE back, which has been proved by the archiological survey of Saraswati. There is a program by Nilesh Oak, which can be found on UA-cam.
This piece needs get viral
👇
Few years back somebody had filed an RTI asking proof of the Aryan Invasion/Migration theory . The answer was "Sorry the information is not available" . Likewise many such RTIs have been sent to ask the proof of the so called benevolence of Mughals. And the answer was the same. This shows how badly Leftists and self proclaimed historians like To mila Thapar, Irfan Habib and others have manipulated their thoughts into our minds.
Self proclaimed Historians claim to justify AIT/AIM -- Aryans brought horses to India during 2500BCE.
Scientific Proof - Inscriptions of Horses and Chariots have been found in Bhimbetaka caves and rocks which are as old as 4500 BCE .
Fake Historians Claim - Vedas were written in between 800-1000BCE .
Scientific Claim- In Vedas , Saraswati river which vanished completely by 3000 BCE has been mentioned prominently . Now, when Vedas mention a river prominently it shows that , at that time when Vedas were written , Saraswati river was flowing in its full swing when there was no any possibility of river getting vanished . This ultimately supports the fact that Vedas were written THOUSANDS years ago from the fake timeline told by these fake historians.
Fake Historians claim that Sanskrit is a foreign language that originated from Steppes and Caspian sea. 😅😅
Our take - Why on Earth would these so called outsiders would migration such a fertile soil like Steppe grassland and Caspian Sea kinda one of the largest fresh water lakes ??
The Rg veda also mentions the Aryan invasion theory. That is where it comes from. The Aryas vs the Dasyus.
What do you mean Alexander's "supposed" invasion. Do you mean he never invaded?
Ranveer, please will you give the name of your interviewee. Thank you.
I think some questions are pertinent:
1) Why do skeletons excavated from Rakhigarhi (an Indus Valley site) lack any steppe, anatolian or Iranian farmer genetic components which are otherwise found in abundance in modern day indians, particularly among north indians?
2) What can be the possible explanations for linguistic similarities between Dravidian languages of the South, and the northern dravidian languages and dialects?
South India was almost never invaded so you can't find their genes, and you will these elements in North because they assimilated with us.
Not just similarities betweensouth languages for example many words in Telugu have exact matching word in pure Hindi. Today's Hindi is islamised.
@@bharata_paksha North Indian and South DNA difference is of thousands of years, and Islamic invasion is came long after Aryan Migration
ANCIENT IRAN AFGHANISTAN TURKMENISTAN KHAZAKISTAN ETC AREAS WERE PART OF ANCIENT VEDIC SANATAN BHARAT AND THESE AREAS ARE MENTIONED IN MAHABHARATA.
@@bharata_paksha my skin it's called genetic diversity. It doesn't mean sperate race. Every race has many sub races and indians went to Europe it's mentioned in vedas.
@@Vpr2255 my skin it's called genetic diversity. It doesn't mean sperate race. Every race has many sub races and indians went to Europe it's mentioned in vedas.
The way she says " Nothing, we were all barbaric "😍
What about Bhudha or Bimbisara or AJATHASHATRU EVEN WITHOUT THE ivc.
What about vedas without the ivc.?
What about janapadas?
What about suryasidhanth.?
What about ithihaasa?.
Was that the correct picture of John Marshall...? He is a founding father of the United States... not the archeologist of the 19th century...
Humans originated from India.
what abt the DRAVIDIANS?? Bro we Need to know abt it.. Educate us
Much like the Indus valley and vedic they also were existing before hand no. The main point is that there was not much connection till the early vedic period, due to both the terrain and the distance and less transport mechanism. Later things changed and rest is history. Never believe what Britishers told us, I can vouch as a Tamilian myself.
Dravidian is just a linguistic classification and nothing beyond that.
Finally, a true Archeologists with a neutral approach, thank you.
There is not "neutral" approach. Indians have indo DNA and were ruled over by indo-europeans for thousands of years. Much like the mongols didn't with india.
@@RustieFawn Yes! They need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
What if dasaranjana war happened in that time?
all i could hear "then what happened "
Indus valley civilization is 8000 yrs old and they are way more developed cities. They use to live peacefully. No politics, no religion, no army, no Natural enemies. This civilization stays for 5000 yrs. They migrated from sindhu to Ganga river. Why they Vanished there are no evidence..From Harappa to mohenjodaro the distance is 690km. So they use to well connected too.
Request to all Hindus to wear a Raksha Dhaga to show unity and respect to our ancestors
in the rig veda, the eclipse, (in the myth of Indra and the theft of the cows by the panis) has been dated in 1998 by two french astronomers to the october 21 th 3784 BCE.
Kya kaha aapne samajh nahi aaya
@@deepakkhatri2005 किस लिए? लेकिन मैं सही कह रहा हूँ... यह ग्रहण आंशिक ग्रहण था। मुझे एक और तारीख मिली: 19 फरवरी, 3929 ईसा पूर्व। औद्योगिक जगत पर पूर्ण ग्रहण
Very sweet and persuasive voice she has😘
when will this gentleman have a rounded discussion on the Dalits and baba saheb ambedkar , to get the real perspective of " culture" , that he always goes abt gassing rather than the biased bamanical Kaleidoscope he perceives his reality
PLZ bring more exp ones ....like Sanjay Dixit SIR ........no offence ...but it requires huge amount of knowledge ....Thanks
Well explained
but troy theory states that there was thesis sea on India which is also known as mother sea 9000yrs ago ...... mixed
They say to take emotion out of the consideration of Aryan involvement. OK, let's look at science:
Now there are many, many genetic studies which scientifically prove that the Yamnaya people of the Russian steppes, aka Aryans, migrated into and genetically mixed with all the native races in the Indo-European language map. This includes North Indians. Why is that hard to accept?
Because its not true? since if that was the case where did the original people live and how is our civilization way older? Makes no sense.
@@rickycool6083 The Yamnaya/Aryans came from the Russian steppes.
The oldest peoples in India are in the south. There is evidence that they migrated there from Africa.
Kindly do a podcast on Keezhadi excavation, Sangam civilization.
E kaun sabhyata baa?
You think he will?
@@bharathanand1762 I don't think he will, but hope he does.
The readily apparent differences in physical appearance within the Indian population, unlike the more uniform features observed in populations from regions like China, Africa, and Europe, suggest a historical mixing of distinct groups. The general variation in skin color and physical traits between North and South Indians points to the integration of two different populations in the past. These observable distinctions lend credence to the concept of the Aryan Migration Theory (AMT), which, rather than suggesting an invasion, implies a gradual blending of cultures and peoples. This theory is more accurately termed the Aryan Migration Theory instead of the Aryan Invasion Theory, reflecting a more nuanced understanding of historical population movements.
Yes, according to physical appearance, there are many races within India. That is OK.
However, The presenters need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
@@christianfrommuslim Your point about Yamnaya DNA and its connection to Indo-European languages is indeed insightful, reflecting the significant role of steppe migrations in shaping the genetic and linguistic landscape of Eurasia. Nearly all critics of the AIT are unaware of the legendary Yamnaya culture.
Ait was given before Discovery of Sindhu Saraswati Civilization.
We need more of this.
oldest evidence of r1a1 haplogroup gene is in India and India has highest diversity of r1a1 gene and this is rule of nature, the place where gene has highest diversity is the origin of that gene which proves India was the origin of r1a1 gene just google it Is from india, it spread across whole europe central asia and whole middle east like iran iraq arab, russia, china, this tells that Indians are the people who did aryan invasion on Europe and not vise versa, and every south east asian which inclued whole india pakistan bangladesh shri lanka has same DNA and more than 90% men are descendants of genetic lineage haplogroup F and it originates in India so we are the ancestors of more than 90% of world. There is mention of river of floods sarsvati in vedas many many times and now this river has been found. last time it was in its prime was 9000 years ago this times Europeans were in stone age also theres mention in greek books that Ashoka the great's empire already had calendars dating back to 6700 years and ashoka empire existed 2500+ years ago he met budhha Means 10200 years, 9000 year old submerged city dwarka mentioned in mahabharat has been found in the same place there's documentary about that city on yt. oldest indo european Language is dev bhasha Sanskrit. you completely ignored DNA, yoga statues, lord shiva statue, swastik symbol and om symbol found in indus velley so called dravidian civilization.
Abhijit chavda (he's scientist historian Physicist ) made video about this theory also watch rajvedams lecture about this he debunked it with DNA proofs. Abhijit himself Believed this theory before doing his own research.
There are many lies about are history like sati pratha which is also widely belived by people so kindly do your own research everything written in history and widely believed is not true always. there are western universities teaching thei students that hinduism has three hundred million gods when in reality vedas belive in one formless parmatma and those are 33 devtas not gods. Just accept widely believed lies exists in current time.
Moshin Raza Khan was very biased while talking about Aryan Invasion Theory. I commented when he was in the podcast, and I comment now whe she is here. Not speculating, I don't know his motivations behind promoting and promulgating aryan invasion Theory in a podcast that so many watch despite there being no evidence to substantiate his words.
One more thing he said about the origins or various religions was that" religion evolved over time in order to incorporate more and more people into it. Newer the religion more inclusive it is, all to bring a universality ". However the newer religions are the most exclusive if one goes by the theological texts and practices worldover. I don't want to sound communal but it was apparent that he wanted to put Islam, one among the newest religions, into somewhat a good light or make an impression that it is the most inclusive and universal. Putting superlatives over ones beliefs is the worst practice an individual can do, especially when so many are listening.
Why to be afraid of being communal?
There is nothing bad or wrong in professing one’s loyalty and affinity to one’s community.
They need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Yes please we want rajeshri nandi again.
0:31 welp definitely not being taught in the schools today 💀
Well it's false
Visit Abhijeet Chavda
She agrees with Abhijeet
@@robertK1889 yeah that's what I'm saying
@@nicholasphelps3872 indo Greek
@@ttdx6851 not at all.
Abhijeet is one the biggest copers lol.
10:34 in rigveda the main entity is Indra. And Indra God is present in many European civilization as Zeus, Daeus, etc
another european trying to justify their theory .
@@ThEEqualizer93 They need to be true to their word. She said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Ranveer bro plz … bring medium n graphologist Dr. Manish Pande. Pune on this show…
Yes. Aryan invasion theory has no evidence. Aryan migration theory does have.
Very logical and honest presentation !
Good one! Indus script has been successfully deciphered in the paper 'Deciphering Indus script as a Cryptogram by Yajnadevam' and he explains the whole decipherment in a video presentation given to Sangam talks on UA-cam. His decipherment shows the Indus seals and other artifacts are used to write a form of Sanskrit and the symbols used there are pre-cursor of Brahmi script ( from which today's Hindi, Tamil and other North Indian scripts are derived. Kannada and Telugu have their own modern script but before that they might've used Brahmi too )
Most importantly, there are so many Vedic references like Ravi, Varuna, Agni etc... in Indus seals and writings.
Nonsense every language evolved from brahmi
@@bharata_paksha what was the nonsense part?
@@chethan93
Script and language are different. You do know that right? Putting Hindi and Tamil one the same linguistic origin is entirely not correct.
@@stardust2045 did you even read my comment or just saw Hindi and Tamil used in a single sentence and started typing your response?!!
Today's Hindi and Tamil both have their scripts derived from same script i.e. Brahmi. That's what I've said in the original comment as well.
Also I now learnt that Kannada-Telugu script is also inspired by Brahmi. Brahmi to Southern Brahmi ( with 3-4 extra letters ) to Kadamba script to Today's Kannada Telugu script.
The most important point I was trying to make in the original comment was that, we had a wrong assumption so far that Brahmi itself is derived from Aramaic but by Yajnadevam's decipherment of Indus script, we now know with proof that Brahmi is derived from Sindhu Saraswathi script!!
@@chethan93 were has the Indus script bee decifered? No such thing has happened
But what about Dna analysis of North Indian and South indian??
Ranveer , you do not mention speaker name in any clips , you should
Please bring j sai deepak ji
Dude..shes talking very casually..see genetic tests were conducted and some indicated foreign mix (no not aryan)...so there are gaps in the theory..what is believed widely now is frequent mixes of foreign people (I didn't say europe)...we still have historical proofs of mixes later on like kanishka...sakas..huns etc..Matlab yaar expert bane ho..aur itna bhi nhi bataoge..toh kya bataye ab.
As she said there along with all civilizational settlements there were waves of migration of many people groups you do know that the r1 male ancestor that went into central Asia was originally an Indian ancestor right?
She indirectly mentioned herself as archeologist but she can't talk about latest keeledi, ramgad excavation, dna concept.... Nonsense
Aryans are children of Bharat and Bahubali. Those who ruled Aryavarta. Before that Bharat's grandfather, father and Bharat ruled entire planet
timid, incompetent archeology dept. of india not explored:
1. temples of tajmahal, kutubminar,
2. ellora kailasa mandir
3. carbon dating of gyanwapi
4. dwaraka - ocenography evidence
5. mathura temple inside mosque
6. carvings , carbon dating of thousands of temples wrapped as superficial mosque
7 carvings of thousands of temples which praveen mohan explored
and apologetic tries to slow poision that sanatan civilization is not the greatest.
They need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Who ever mentioned where that Alexander started Indian civilization. From what little I know of Alexander's quest to conquer the world he was encouraged by his teacher to lands of mystics in the east which he had heard of perhaps by earlier greek philosophers (Scylax and Ctesias) who happened to go east wards and meet ancient Indians. People should be careful on what they say especially when they are trying to justify their point.
So narrative is change from Aryan invasion to Aryan migration. Still not clear on indo European language birth how vedas and upanishad come into existence. How ramayan and Mahabharata fit in
Good point! The presenters need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Very nice quote pointed........ "That the givers (so called aryan race of europe) of vedic culture forgot the same completely, of owns culture when we, the so called adopter of culture is so deeply inrooted in it and carry it with us till date inspite of so much invasion and intermingling......." so rather vedic culture was indigenous rather an exotic culture.
Babban, who cleared his history and geo papers by a pathbreaking 3rd suply in matric.
Intellectually Disagrees 🤡❤️
oldest evidence of r1a1 haplogroup gene is in India and India has highest diversity of r1a1 gene and this is rule of nature, the place where gene has highest diversity is the origin of that gene which proves India was the origin of r1a1 gene just google it Is from india, it spread across whole europe central asia and whole middle east like iran iraq arab, russia, china, this tells that Indians are the people who did aryan invasion on Europe and not vise versa, and every south east asian which inclued whole india pakistan bangladesh shri lanka has same DNA and more than 90% men are descendants of genetic lineage haplogroup F and it originates in India so we are the ancestors of more than 90% of world. There is mention of river of floods sarsvati in vedas many many times and now this river has been found. last time it was in its prime was 9000 years ago this times Europeans were in stone age also theres mention in greek books that Ashoka the great's empire already had calendars dating back to 6700 years and ashoka empire existed 2500+ years ago he met budhha Means 10200 years, 9000 year old submerged city dwarka mentioned in mahabharat has been found in the same place there's documentary about that city on yt. oldest indo european Language is dev bhasha Sanskrit. you completely ignored DNA, yoga statues, lord shiva statue, swastik symbol and om symbol found in indus velley so called dravidian civilization.
Abhijit chavda (he's scientist historian Physicist ) made video about this theory also watch rajvedams lecture about this he debunked it with DNA proofs. Abhijit himself Believed this theory before doing his own research.
There are many lies about are history like sati pratha which is also widely belived by people so kindly do your own research everything written in history and widely believed is not true always. there are western universities teaching thei students that hinduism has three hundred million gods when in reality vedas belive in one formless parmatma and those are 33 devtas not gods. Just accept widely believed lies exists in current time.
Wdym my son
This channel has become source of misinformation. Kisi ko bhi bula ke expert bol deta hai ye nalla.
the narrative that aryan migration brought caste system is very weak especially the way its told by tony joseph, the mentioned timeline dint have caste but 1000 years later they had.The reason because there were "liberal" aryan who were against caste system. Then after 1000 years they decided it seems "okay lets have the caste system " 🤣🤣
If there was no aryan migration or invation then this show would have been in sanskrit and all the indians would have understood that intead of english
The British did this all over the world.
But we are yet to remove that mindset
can you please explain me about this a poem from one of our sangam literature "Natrinai" which states "Ariyar thuvandriya perisai mulurp palarudan kazhindha olvaal malaiyanadhu oruverku oodi yaangu "
There was a king called malayamaan who drove away the Mauriyan invaders who are mentioned as aaryans in this.
And also one other sangam literature which mentions about pandiyan neduncheliyan who drove away the aaryans ?
We dont know the context. Lot can be changed with translation!! Also, aryans means any good person in sanskrit
I thought that was was solved a long time ago.
Who's that archaeologist..what's his/her authority? Reputation? International journal publication?
It's strange how an archaeologist wouldn't speak about DNA evidence.
Most of this anti-AIT proponents cite their evidence from religious texts,scriptures, mythological stories rather than from scientifically validated genetic data and then go on to explain why Aryan migration theory is false.
@@abandoned-user genetics itself disproves the Aryan migration.
@@atacama1000 wrong...dna differences exist between north and south indians
@@JT-zl8yp very minor differences exist.
@@atacama1000 the difference shows that upper caste north indians have high steppe ancestry which came from central asia
Like so many non-scientists is Ranveer looking for traces of his own identity while the scientists are interested in the broader picture. Egocentric vs enlightened
You should have watch other podcasts of him before telling it Egocentric.
@@Noyon-kd3in maybe... but do you recognize what I observe in this podcast ?
@@alfreddaniels3817 I think you're referring to the true self of an individual human being, who am I, why am I here, and things like these. In that case, I would suggest you watch his other podcasts. Those topics have also been discussed many times in different podcasts of his
What is name of archeologist
Her stance is very similar to Prof Vasant Shinde from IISER Pune.
Internet actually used right with podcasts like this 👌
Its clear from comments section that many of us Indians want only the "Out of India theory" (OIT) and see AMT as a European conspiracy. Anyone who disagrees even with counter evidence is slandered in the most un-Hindu manner. Interestingly, when the same foreign historians unearthed and praised Indus Valley Civilization, deciphered Brahmi script, made Sanskrit/Buddhism/Yoga/Indian Temple architecture popular, we loved it!! No questions asked!!
It’s an interesting display of narcissistic "we are better than you / we are victims" bipolar attitude.
Science says mixed race happens when mammals of purer race (नस्ल या जाति) mingle. Same thing can be seen by pet lovers (eg. Interbreeding between different types (race if you will) of dogs). But for these OIT supporters, reverse is true. Aryans in Steppes region were created from Mixed race Indians (Aryans + natives) who travelled to Steppes. Go figure!!
Yes. The presenters need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
@@christianfrommuslim These are "woke" historians who will make unscientific and emotional claims without adequate evidence. They will not be able to publish their work in any international journal. Not even Africa.
North india, central Asia, west Asia long inhabited by indo-iranian people .
Later turks invaded central Asia replacing indo-iranian people there.
Thus creating huge barrier between russia and India.
Thus creating illusion that Aryans might have come to india from Russia.
But this is wrong.
Aryans are indigenous to India.
Today the Truth is Revealing itself...
UK is crumbling...
India is becoming the world leader without any aggression...
I'm preparing for upsc and my teacher again and again forces their fake aryan invesion theory on us.
Because ur teacher backing something fully evidence based not feelings based.
@@gobimurugesan2411 fully "evidence based" ☠️☠️
konsa nasha karte ho???
@@indiangirl4081 Inga evidence na language and DNA results of North Indians and Europeans.
@@gobimurugesan2411 stop this Okey, first they coined aryan invesion theory then aryan migration theory and in future they will say aryan came here for picnic but didn't went back and stayed here and if invesion is true then where is evidence of invesion like massacred skeletons of thousands of people living in india already .Have u heard about sinauli . It was contemporary of harappan civilization. They were following vedic dharma and evidences says these all . They were using horse chariot and copper weapons for warfare. But acc to u guys aryan came in india after harappan civilisation. Then how people of sinauli were following vedic dharma .
@@NikhilSingh-ce7gv U know what bro that is y science is good. It's getting evolving to give more accurate results. Untill some one proves Aryan migration is wrong, this theory stays. Aryans definitely faught local people. When did last time humans mixed with out any fight?. They changed the name because it's a wave of migrations not a single invasion. U won't get evidence for 4000 years old things. But u can search about recent Aryans like indo Huns, indo sciythens. They also migrated to India the same way as other Aryans. Even Muslim invasions also same. These central Asian tribes invaded India before their islamization are today living in India as Indians just like how Muslims today living in India and Pakistan. Only difference is non Muslim invaders mixed with local people and become Hindus. Muslim invaders mixed with local people but still following their religion.
You should do a round table podcast like what rajiv masand did!!.. Think about it.. People knowledge on history and with abhijeet chavda on the table🔥🔥🔥
Really good idea 👌
Yes a good round table podcast will be so much informative
They gave us the rigveda and they forgot rigveda !! Wow what a logic
Wow .. thanks !
But - The presenters need to be true to their word. They said unemotionally look at facts. But they did not mention the overwhelming evidence of the Yamnaya (Aryan) DNA shared by all peoples of Indo-European languages.
Please invite Padmashree Meenakshi Jain. Ppl will unlearn a lot especially on Sati