All new J40 sporty, Have they gone a step to far?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 29

  • @SuperSventizeMe
    @SuperSventizeMe День тому +7

    Bravo. I admire reviewers who are not afraid to give honest reviews- it makes your enthusiasm for boats such as the Moodys and Garcias more meaningful. I sail the J/105 and J/35c all the time, so love J Boats, but this J/40 doesn't do much for me. You are right to compare it to the Dehler- I've been able to sail the Dehler 38 SQ recently and it's a great boat. The J/40 is also weirdly heavy for a racing boat- fully a 1000# heavier than the old Jeanneau Sun Odyssey 40.

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  17 годин тому

      Glad you liked it, I was so excited to get on this boat, as a fan of J boats I was expecting big things. Well, it's sad to say but it was a big let down and I know Toby's test sail went well, they were getting boat speed slightly faster than wind speed (downwind I might add with a lot of canvas) but that's nothing new with J boats. We have been invited to test the RM1080 in February/March 2025, we can't wait as we know the shipyard has made a few little changes.

  • @graemeday4195
    @graemeday4195 23 години тому +1

    Firstly, thanks for another boat tour. Secondly, Merry Chrimbo to you and yours. Lastly, it's so refreshing to see and hear someone be completely open and honest on a review. If a manufacturer is cutting corners on build, then call them out on it. Its not just about money, it's also people's lives.

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  17 годин тому +1

      Happy you liked it and a happy Christmas to you and yours as well. I feel it's time in my reviews to be a little more open and honest about what I see and think of the yachts. Nothing disrespectful but anything we believe you should know or see we are going to put out there.

  • @thomasniederl1589
    @thomasniederl1589 День тому +4

    Thank you for your honesty... I agree with you 100%... maybe it's a bit unfair to be so harsh without having been on the water but to be honest I don't think there would be any big surprises on the water either.

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому

      It was a little hard but it was a boat we were expecting a lot from being the history and DNA of J,boats but was so sadly disappointed. I would love to get out on the water with one of these and be shown that once again they have in fact built a great boat, but I can't see that happening.

  • @brettroman3218
    @brettroman3218 21 годину тому +1

    Love the honesty! Hard to come by these days..

  • @joseerazevedo
    @joseerazevedo День тому +3

    Hi! I follow a couple who's going on a circumnavigation on the route I find more interesting: throught Patagonia. They're americans and sail a J46 with a few years. Their backround is regatta sailing. It's great to see how one understand the other's moves, they a very fine tuned sailing couple. It is a pleasure to see how their boat navigates. On Cape Horn it reminded me of my crazy sailing days on a Laser under heavy weather in Búzios. great fun, fast, wind on the face, water splashing - but they were on a 46 foot very stable boat. Beautiful! J Boats left an impression on me due to "Sweet Ruca".
    I find this J 40 a somewhat strange boat. I believe it must be a nice sailing one, due to J's DNA. But lacks a definition, a reason to exist. It''s a mutant in the middle of the transformation. It has dual helm but it's not that wide. The hull look a mix of an older project with a renewd interior. The single bathroom is very small. Ok, it's a day regatta sail boat, one can say. But its kitchen and saloon go in the other direction. And it has a nav table!
    Anything that tries to be everything ends up being nothing. Seems to be the case here. And that price!! You're perfectly right! Wow! I'd prefer a well defined Halberg Rassy 340 - or a bigger used one - to this without a blink of the eyes. It's an american boat. Maybe in America they like specs this way and have money to spend on it.
    But I'm with you: this is the most nonsense boat ever on this channel!
    A VERY Merry Christmas to you all, have a great family time and Happy Holidays!

    • @brownnoise357
      @brownnoise357 День тому +1

      Damn, thanks for putting me Straight, I was sure Sweet Ruca was a J45 lol Brain Fart time again 🤣 Merry Christmas. Bob.👍🌟❤️⛵️🎄

    • @brownnoise357
      @brownnoise357 День тому +1

      Damn, thanks for putting me Straight, I was sure Sweet Ruca was a J45 lol Brain Fart time again 🤣 Merry Christmas. Bob.👍🌟❤️⛵️🎄 Well said by the way I agree with all you said. 👍

    • @joseerazevedo
      @joseerazevedo 20 годин тому +1

      @@brownnoise357 😂 It''s a 2000 J46

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому +2

      That's it exactly, you hit the nail on the head it is trying to be too many things at once.

  • @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD
    @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD День тому +3

    I'm in Virginia, U.S.A.🎉 it's a great vessel, I'm stoked😮

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому

      Just checked out your channel, are there any adventures on the horizon?

  • @robertjfsoper
    @robertjfsoper День тому +1

    Great video, what makes your reviews stand out, is they are authentic, and because you don’t bullshit. Many other reviews out there are more like sales videos.
    I get the impression that the boats in the 35-40ft range seem to have adequate kitchen / lounge space, but where they fall short is the bedrooms. However, a 40ft catamaran has more than enough space. I’d be interested to see your perspective on cat Vs monohul 👍

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому +1

      Ok, I will think on that as it's a great subject on which I think we can stir up a bit of a debate.

  • @adrianvanveen9912
    @adrianvanveen9912 7 годин тому

    Your opinion counts. I too would enjoy seeing you at sail. The J40 should be impressive in its element. Enjoy that Day.

  • @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD
    @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD День тому +1

    I just bought an old Southerly 115, a 1984 the last year of solid fiberglass Hull....sometimes an older vessel is less maintenance...oh, by the way, my Lady you would look very good in a white captain hat ... BUT... YOUR A YACHTY, AND YOUR A DIFFERENT BREED....God Bless on your Success and Channel....we both gotta quit smoking 😮

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому +1

      I do have a white captain hat tucked away somewhere, it only comes out with the whisky and cigars.

    • @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD
      @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD 15 годин тому +1

      @SVTONICBoatWives hottie

    • @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD
      @SAILINGDIRTYBIRD 15 годин тому +1

      @SVTONICBoatWives hottie

  • @brownnoise357
    @brownnoise357 22 години тому

    Side note Sailing Sweet Ruca are a really nice Couple, but not a channel in line with my type of Sailing, and this was really brought home by them being forced to anchor outside the Reef of a Pacific island lagoon, because the Draft of their boat was way too deep to let them Sail in. All of my prior Classic Sailboats have had close to a 4 foot Draft, loved the heavily built Bilge Keel Sailboats, and particularly my friend ‘Crasher’ Steve’s Macwester 25, which was the first Comfortable Sailboat I Crewed on, and that thing was
    as tougher than an outside Toilet, and even survived Steve ignoring instructions that the final buoy marking where to turn to Port to avoid the Rocks going fast in an inflowing Tide, had him crashing the Boat at full speed into the Rocks, such that the Mast with a loud audible Twang went forward, as did the boat until it left the rocks, none of the standing rigging Broke, no water came in below, and we waited until the boat dried out to check for damage, and there were just small gelcoat hips in each keel, which I fixed before the tide came n. That’s how Crasher got his nickname, and if it was possible to embed it in a Sandbar Crasher would embed it in a Sandbar. Great guy though, other than being a Sailing incompetent. A genius with Horses and making Money though, he was a self made millionaire three times, and three wives ended up swell off, when a million was still a lot of money. I would have gone anywhere on that tough as old boots Macwester though, talk about a boat to inspire Confidence.The only thing it needed was a major upgrade in Engine power, as the Dolphin two stroke inboard totally Sucked. 🤔🌟🌟🌟👍🎄❤️⛵️

  • @brownnoise357
    @brownnoise357 День тому +1

    PS. Great Tour, and very well said by the Way, that is a hell of a lot of money for a 40 foot Sailboat. While NOT a Racing Sailboat, I can get a far Superior Cruising Catalina 425 Brand New unused 2023 model for close to 200,000 dollars less than that believe it or not, which is fully kitted out and ready to go,and if it is still available when my Piggybank finally fills back up, I will expect an even lower price to snap their hands off, even with a 5 Foot Draft, and ICW friendly Mast Height. I will be forced to suffer in Comfort thanks very much, or a similar discount on the Catalina 445.Tough Choice. Expect similar discounts on Unsold 2024/2025 model 426 and 446 Sailboats as well frankly. All those models, plus if big enough the 380 based models are extremely well performing excellent Live aboard Sailboats. The 385 for example can be had with I think a 4 ft 8 inch Draft plus ICW friendly Mast Height, but unfortunately I really need a bigger Sailboat. All with nice Curvy in all the right places and Beamy ish hulls,and not sure about engine options with the 380 class, but larger have very nice larger engine options, for example 57 hp Yanmar option with the 425 and direct drive. Any Anchor will fit on the Bowsprit too. Great leak proof Standing Rigging Deck fittings, and so much good stuff built up from years of Customer feedback.I think I have finally found a Sailboat that I can live Comfortably with, though access into and out of places I would like to go - into estuaries and up Rivers is pretty much Ruled Out - still,can’t win them all,and all Compromises are very easy to live with, a bit better than usual tankage, a water desalinator takes care of extra needs, good enough beam for adequate Solar , decent Northern Lights Generator - not dodgy Fischer Panda, so looking after batteries to keep them in tip top Condition is no problem and a shocking amount of other well designed very good liveaboard Stuff along with it, and all to an outstanding build standard. To be honest, Only a Beneteau Oceanis comes close and for less Mondy. Is the extra for a Catalina worth it as some Ask ? Well if you are very careful about when you buy an overbought unsold model after the launch of a new model year, that new unused Catalina might just cost you less, for a much better long term live aboard Sailboat ? It’s the little but highly intelligent features that rapidly mount up, such as the Chain plates accessibility, the bowsprit that can handle pretty much any anchor, plus a second one, and the large chain locker, really nice galley that is secure to use under way, I like the forward Pullman berth with the heads and shower forward, and an ok with the Day head being a set head in the Tropics, just get a Wand Shower Head for it and with a nice pumpy soap Dispenser and a micro fiber hand towel, you have a hygienic Bidet setup for the Tropics, and easy wash and dry towels system for them to dry off on the side rails, even without a Washing Machine.I know, I’ve Rabbited on again, but it is a bit exciting to finally find a Sailboat that I can live with, even if I have to make a few Sacrifices in the places I would really like to get to with one, and I still have the 4 foot Draft Island Packet 349 in Second place to fall ack on if needed, but the Catalina pips it. Merry Christmas To All. Bob. ❤️⛵️🎄

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому

      I can't wait for the day you eventually get your boat, Bob, it will be all the Christmases in one.

  • @brownnoise357
    @brownnoise357 День тому +1

    Hi Ladies. I forget the name of the Channel on UA-cam now, but the Owners of a J45 took theirs successfully around Cape Horn, and when in the Pacific took on a Catamaran in a Race and I was Cheering them on as they Comfortably won that Race. 😅 Other than that though, tbh Sailboats like this are so diametrically opposite my kind of Sailboat, such that it wouldn’t be fair to comment that there isn’t anything on this Sailboat, no matter how well built and equipped it might be, other than hoping it is available with a Yanmar inboard diesel, for much better global availability of Spares. Volvo seriously need to get their act together in that regard frankly and I actually like their engines, but even though Volvo spares are chronically overpriced, at least make them easily globally available? I ❤ their Saildrives too, so it is more than a bit sad really, as you need to go to at least the 80 hp Yanmar, to get Anna’s good ZF Saildrive, though to be fair the often unmentioned problem Cone issue with Yanmar Saildrives did receive a significant Upgrade kit fix several years ago now, so owners need to check whether the Upgrade Fix has been done to theirs, or has been already applied to new Saildrives. Too much silence has surrounded this issue frankly. Usual moan over, so a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to All. Bob.🤔🌟🌟🌟👍❤️⛵️🎄🎄🎄

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому

      I know who you mean, superb sailboat and great sailors to.

  • @brownnoise357
    @brownnoise357 23 години тому +1

    PPS. Yep 2.2 mtr Draft Way too deep for me, but you may have noticed that I have pretty much Surrendered Big Time for a 5 foot Draft and an ICW friendly Mast height to get a very Comfortable Live Aboard Catalina 42/44 of 5 or 6 series production which buggers right up my plans of Continuing to get into Estuaries and up navigable Rivers, which has been a real passion of mine. Ah well, Sacrifices and compromises have to be made, even if glumly, until the right boxes to tick start appearing on Construction Option Lists I suppose. Final Live Aboard Boat being a Motor Cruiser can recover the Fun of that, with no Draft or Mast height problems to worry about, plus Canal (which I usually find claustrophobic) Route through France and down to the Med Though I have done that a few times by Motorbike, may have me getting there by Michael of Sailing Gently Channel, could well have me doing his Gentle Sailing Route to the Med, along the Coasts of France, Spain, and Portugal, which should be just as wonderful a trip, as it is by Sailboat. That route is so popular, it is now in its 12th Edition. The poor guy broke his leg, a week before he was due to fly out post Hurricane Season to his Beneteau Oceanis 323 which this season he kept in Martinique. But he is back on board now, and faces the soon arriving mending leg insufferable itching, and he may not have the usual relief of a knitting needle to scratch inside his plaster cast with. I am presently going through Similar with the New skin starting to appear, mostly on my left leg and foot, and the itching after I apply the Epaderm moisturiser is indescribable. In very good news, my heart efficiency is now stable and my kidney efficiency has gone up from 26% to 30% and as my kidney efficiency sister says, we must be doing something right. 😅😅😅 Have a Great Christmas, and best of luck flipping your house, it looks lovely, and a lot like a Mid Wales Traditional Farm House, but as France was part of Britain back around then, perhaps not that Surprising 😅 👍🌟❤️⛵️🎄

    • @SVTONICBoatWives
      @SVTONICBoatWives  16 годин тому

      Unfortunately that's boat ownership, sometimes there are a lot of sacrifices and to many compromises but hey it's a great lifestyle that only a few get to discover. Well worth it I think.

  • @brownnoise357
    @brownnoise357 23 години тому

    PPS. Yep 2.2 mtr Draft Way too deep for me, but you may have noticed that I have pretty much Surrendered Big Time for a 5 foot Draft and an ICW friendly Mast height to get a very Comfortable Live Aboard Catalina 42/44 of 5 or 6 series production which buggers right up my plans of Continuing to get into Estuaries and up navigable Rivers, which has been a real passion of mine. Ah well, Sacrifices and compromises have to be made, even if glumly, until the right boxes to tick start appearing on Construction Option Lists I suppose. Final Live Aboard Boat being a Motor Cruiser can recover the Fun of that, with no Draft or Mast height problems to worry about, plus Canal (which I usually find claustrophobic) Route through France and down to the Med Though I have done that a few times by Motorbike, may have me getting there by Michael of Sailing Gently Channel, could well have me doing his Gentle Sailing Route to the Med, along the Coasts of France, Spain, and Portugal, which should be just as wonderful a trip, as it is by Sailboat. That route is so popular, it is now in its 12th Edition. The poor guy broke his leg, a week before he was due to fly out post Hurricane Season to his Beneteau Oceanis 323 which this season he kept in Martinique. But he is back on board now, and faces the soon arriving mending leg insufferable itching, and he may not have the usual relief of a knitting needle to scratch inside his plaster cast with. I am presently going through Similar with the New skin starting to appear, mostly on my left leg and foot, and the itching after I apply the Epaderm moisturiser is indescribable. In very good news, my heart efficiency is now stable and my kidney efficiency has gone up from 26% to 30% and as my kidney efficiency sister says, we must be doing something right. 😅😅😅 Have a Great Christmas, and best of luck flipping your house, it looks lovely, and a lot like a Mid Wales Traditional Farm House, but as France was part of Britain back around then, perhaps not that Surprising 😅 👍🌟❤️⛵️🎄