@@robbytomminson5807 I think what they mean is, the reason he's underrated is because he refused to be associated with the show. The guy was great in doctor who but the actor himself is sort of a prick, he once said the reason doctor who is so popular was because of him
@@ICantThinkOfANameSVT no he didn't and even if he did he's technically right. It would not matter how good the writing was if the execution was shit. That is the most important part and nobody would have done it better than Chris
To the people on his side, he's a warrior and a hero that comes and goes as he pleases, but seemingly makes the impossible possible. To the people against him he's a genocidal god-like being that, no matter what you do, will find you and will at the very least stop you. Most likely kill you. And kill your your entire species if unlucky. Both are true. He's seen what nothing but rage and hatred and violence can do during the time war. So he made a ton of rules for himself, which he promised himself to never break through his name. Because of his rules he is mostly kind and good-willed. But as was said in "a good man goes to war", a good man doesn't need rules. And it's a bad idea to try to find out why he has so many.
I think one of the darkest moments was in "The Doctor's Wife". House: "Fear me. I've killed hundreds of Time Lords." The Doctor: "Fear me. I've killed all of them." Or in "A Good Man Goes to War", when he tells Colonel Manton to run away. Kovarian: "The anger of a good man is not a problem. Good men have too many rules." The Doctor: "Good men don't need rules. Today is not the day to find out why I have so many."
Given how he lets the TARDIS kill the House moments later I'd say it's pretty dark. Also, just the way he says "I've killed all of them." is dark to me. He sounds so casual, like he didn't just allude to having committed genocide. But maybe it's just the whole episode that's dark. It's definitely my favourite:)
"She's a girl, and she's my TARDIS." "Did you wish really hard?" I wouldn't say the whole episode was dark. But the way he delivered that line, so nonchalantly....yeah. It was pretty dark.
"No. Colonel Mountain, I want you to tell your men to run away." "What?" "Those words, run away, I want you to be famous for those exact words. I want people to call you Colonel Runaway. I want children laughing outside your door because they've found the house of Colonel Runaway. And when people come to you and ask if trying to get to me, through the people I love, is in any way a good idea... I want you to tell them your name... Oh look, I'm angry, that's new. I'm really not sure what's going to happen now."
No, the "fear me" line isn't really angry, though it IS a little dark, but it would definitely go well in a compilation of the Doctor being a badass! Also the "if you value your continued existence, there is one thing you never, ever put in a trap" speech.
"Don't you think she looks tired" Is the single greatest Doctor moment. No grand armies, no ancient evil outsmarted, he knew 6 words to start a chain reaction that would start an upheaval in he government. Just six words, spoken to some random bodyguard.
Necrobadger I hate it tho because Christopher was such good friends with her...It really showed how much darker David was going to be tho, which I like.
@@Honeey-moth the way I always saw it was the doctor always strived to defend the earth and humanity in (for the most part) the path of least destruction and death. When Harriet Jones armed the earth with alien technology and destroyed a fleeing ship she made the doctor realise just how narrow minded she really was, and he couldn't stand a murderer in such a strong place of power
Vincent Shayler-Day that’s true, still I wish he had gone about it differently...Oh idk, in a perfect world, they would still be friends but it doesn’t actually make that much sense in context.
@@Honeey-moth Imagine you just saved your best friend from an attack, and scared the attackers away. Now imagine your best friend calling snipers to pick their attackers off. How would you feel?
The smile he has while saying: "Oh, yes you can, and you will, or I will show your funny little town to the whole world. I will bring Unit and the Zygon. Give me a minute and I will bring the Daleks and the Cyberman"
Personally, The Waters of Mars is the closest thing we'll ever have to the Doctor becoming morally corrupt and evil. If not for Adelaide I think the Doctor would've finally snapped and realized that he was an unstoppable God that didn't need to show mercy and that to me, is the most frightening reality.
What is more terrifying is what he would do with the Time War. I feel like he would save Gallifrey only to use the Time Lords as a weapon. He could very easily rule the universe. A theory that I read recently is that the Doctor would have opened the Time Vortex and become god. Even the Doctor himself said that a Time Lord with that power would be a god. Imagine what a raging Doctor could do. At that point he could rewrite the whole universe into his image.
Because the Doctor realised he had gone too far when Adelaide killed herself at the end of the episode. He saw how saving everybody just because you can isn't always the right thing to do. That was how the Master started.
sorry but i have to respectfully disagree theace king. the time lord victorious is my number 2, the end of family of blood is the darkest/scariest we have seen the dr, imho
By comparing Classic Who to New Who you can really see how the Time War affected the Doctor. It made him a much darker angrier character, but as the show went on he gets inspired by his companions to have more compassion..
There's a reason the Doctor has had so many human companions. It's because he knows he needs someone to teach him compassion, and humans are best at it. Because if he doesn't have compassion, he becomes dark and lonesome. Hell, it even got him killed in another timeline
Ay, you could make the argument that Doctors like the Seventh Doctor went through anger and darkness as well, and that he needs other to help him along.
War, like any other traumatic event, does change people. For some the change is instant for others it can take days, months or years to manifest. When I talk about my wartime experience I use the analogy that I died, the man I was, was killed and a stranger took my place. I am more cynical, more violent, more dark in my humor and seriousness. I build up walls and let no one in. There are things that I carry inside of which no one should ever know, secrets that will die with me. Because ignorance truly is bliss.
I think Tennant and Capaldi nail the darkness of the Doctor the most effectively - Tennant particularly possessing a chilling ruthlessness, as the Time Lord Victorious and when he's holding a gun to the colonel's head. Whereas, Eccleston gets the anger spot on, with Smith's sporadic ferociousness being a scary watch.
Yes these two Doctors are my favourite of New Who because you felt safe and scared at the same time because you didn't want to get on the wrong side of The Doctor.
I beg to differ. Matt had his own darkness that was really scary. "I want you to be known as Colonel RunAway, I want children laughing because they found the house of Colonel RunAway, and when... people ask you if getting to me through the PEOPLE I LOVE... (everyone stands there shocked) ... is in any way a good idea... I want you to tell them your name." "Look now, I'm angry, that's new... I don't know what's going to happen next." Madam K: "The anger of a good man is not a concern. Good men have too many rules." The Doctor, face half-dark, turns to her: "Good men don't need rules... (he rounds on her) and today is not the day to find out why I have so many!"
There is nothing scarier in Doctor Who, than an angry Doctor. Not the daleks, not the cybermen, not even the silence, can be that scary when you have a angry Doctor on your tail.
I really enjoyed matts quiet fury is chilling because he seemed the most loving, emotional until that point but he hid so much pain smith acted it beautifully for me
As heartbreaking as Clara's death was its quite amazing seeing Ashildir break. She went from the story teller of the village, to someone who had lost all emotion only for it to come rushing back when she saw what she had done, to someone whose job was to clean up after the doctor. She was still cold and distant but when she saw the doctor mad? She went right back to the terrified child. She's immortal to the point she can outlive other immortals and the Doctor angry still terrifies her. If that doesnt tell you everything you need to know about him then nothing will. Clara dead hurt. Ashildir scared? Felt like justice.
She should have understood that the doctor is both a great hero but also the most feared person to ever walk the universe, his titles arent just for show you know
"I knew The Doctor. The Doctor would never-" "The Doctor is no longer here, you are stuck with me!" I love the way he delivers that line, like he's speaking down to a child.
We all know “The Doctor” is not his real name. He chose that name to help people. In the moment where he tells her that “the Doctor is gone now, you’re stuck with ME!!!” is scary… because for as long as we have known his character he doesn’t even like to hear or utter his true name. When River tells 10 his real name in order for him to trust her, she even apologizes for having to utter it. The POINT being: Who he truly is deep, deep, deep down must be so damn terrifying that if he’s willing to abandon being the Doctor due to the depths of his true nature’s wrath… God help you.
0:27 You know, I just realised something, Cassandra said that was the last ostrich egg so if the Doctor was wrong about it being a fake then he would have just committed genocide... again
@@swordo21 what they're saying is it was a kind of schrodinger's cat. Before he broke it, he had no real idea whether it was a real egg still able to hatch or the fake egg that he thought it was. Had it been real, he would've just caused another extinction but luckily it wasn't and it was, as you said, just a shell.
@@_kyarumii_ By that point, though, I think it would have been nore of a fossil then a living egg. I mean, this is like 4 million years in the future or whatever
@@_kyarumii_ It was a deduction The Doctor made. There had to have been a feed to power a teleportation that far away. There was only one thing Cassandra brought with her that got left behind after the teleportation. Therefor, the feed had to have been inside it. He didn't gamble on anything. The feed was in there because it was literally the only place it could be and therefor no risk was taken.
Not to blow your mind with logic or anything but if a species in down to one lone survivor they are extinct, even if it were a female and could breed with anything else it would be an offshoot of that species not that species. Also, much like the Doctor himself.
@@thedrinkinggamemaker9749 I seem to remember another line somewhere about that the Doctor doesn't kill people..he convinces other people to do it. Or his enemies to kill themselves.
"If you think because she's dead I am weak, then you understand very little. If you were any part of killing her, and you're not afraid, then you understand nothing at all. So for your own sake understand this: I am The Doctor. I'm coming to find you. And I will never, ever stop." Nobody does Badass Doctor like Capaldi.
TheLongDark to me he is just a very arrogant and cringey character. What was that whole shit near the end where every person he saves he goes on a rant about how 'you don't know who I am but you will look back on this day and always wonder' blah blah blah I mean, seriously??
I agree that the Twelfth Doctor is generally badly written, but Capaldi still portrays him extremely well - you can tell the man grew up loving this shit and is determined to keep the light burning - but the thing is, when you get a show like Doctor Who where there's speech after speech after speech, that means the screenwriters are writing a heap of speeches, so by the law of averages some of them have to be epic.
When we saw Waters of Mars we thought it was so unexpected but having watched this, it makes sense. They’d been building up to the Time Lord Victorious all throughout 10’s run.
12 doctor is my favourite because of the way he is and how the 11th doctor regenerated in to him he like 9 regenerated after battle this one was on trenselore that lasted 900 years witch took a emotional toll on the doctor witch could be seen at the beginning of his run and in season 9 episode 8 we begin to understand with why the doctor is closed off and seems uncaring with the speech about the screams of the time war and why he moves on so quickly like in season 10 episode when a kid died he didn't have time to mourn and let that distracted him because he has more important matters to attend to like stopping the creature and him wrestling with weather he was a good man I liked that a lot and his sarcastic nature was funny as well
I think it's the best of Doctor Who, and personally one of the reasons why I like Ecclestone's and Tennant's periods better than Smith's. I think they did dark better.
Several people have questioned the Doctor's power. All of the companions have. They simply tell him to stop and he listens because he loves them and knows they're right (with some exceptions).
There have been quite a few who questioned his power, but she had such unique and utter conviction in her argument that it shook him to his core and snapped him out of it.
If I'm being honest I think Matt smiths doctor had a lot more angry moments like for example the part in "A good man goes to war" the part with "Colonel Runaway"
I missed out Colonel Runaway and possibly others, which was a pretty big mistake, but it's also true that compared to 9 or 10 he didn't have nearly as many dark moments.
10:55 is the scariest Doctor moment for me, the way he says “I genuinely don’t know” strikes a chord with me that I can’t quite compare with anything else. He was contemplating shooting someone straight in the face, so different to the Doctor he strives to be.
Honestly? I think Tennant's the scariest when angry, mostly because he rarely ever gets so angry which makes it so that when he is, he's very, very angry, and quietly so. Which, to me, is one of the scariest kinds of anger. Though between Capaldi and Eccleston, I'd say Capaldi.
@@johnmurphy6474and it would be the right way to do it. Harriet was right, the Doctor isn’t always there. And even when he js, he commits genocide more often than anyone else. Case in point: Silence, Racnoss, Daleks, etc.
I love how Eleven can be so goofy and lovable but becomes downright scary when he's angry. The moment in The Beast Below when he yells "nobody human has anything to say to me today" and the Colonel Runaway scene are among my favorites.
5:46 The itsy bitsy spiders climbed up the water spout Down came the rain and washed the spiders out Up came the sun and dried up all the rain And the itsy bitsy spiders were never found again.
That “don’t you think she looks tired” that’s gold. He is being undermined to the point where he shuts down her hole career. And he does it so quickly, easily and calmly as well. It’s amazing.
I mean when someone like The Doctor, whose influence in the militaries is huge as well as other areas, suggests a government official might not be able to handle their new duties without it having too heavy an impact on them, that is a very fast track to people starting rumours and questioning her every decision.
It's also that she doesn't know what he whispered. It's something that would make him look at her quizzically. But the paranoia. That's the slow killer.
The doctor is such a good and fun character but to see him all dark is good to. Remember he's an old man who saw the time war end in flames and lost his home planet even if he saved it he still remembers destroying it
To those talking about "Dark" Doctors - first of all, angry isn't dark. Remember when 10 said to Wilfred "I've taken lives, but I got smart, I got clever - manipulated people into taking their own" - yes, he is talking about the Seventh Doctor. If you want an example of the one and only 'dark' doctor, type "Big Finish 181 Afterlife" in search and click the (Fear Me) speech - and remember, kids, don't mess with the Umbrella man.
I think the twelfth doctor is more manipulative than any of his past incarnations apart from seventh doctor, I mean, look at the interaction with Twelve and Davros, Twelve manipulated Davros into "destroying" the TARDIS, "Killing" both missy and clara (when intentionally they teleported and the TARDIS literally hid away until needed) and manipulated Davros into taking some regeneration energy in order to wake the "dead" daleks in the mud. I think both Seven and Twelve are on par with each other for being manipulative towards everyone and yes, when you look at both those incarnations, you can't help but remember what ten said to Wilfred about being clever and making people into taking their own life, even to the point where ten admonished his human counterpart for committing mass genocide on the Daleks and Davros. I personally also loved Eight in "The Night Of The Doctor" episode where he physically understood that he needed to be in the time war because the person he was trying to save ended up pretty much betraying him and telling him to go to hell and told the sisters of kairn to get out in an angry voice.
12 is nowhere near 7's level of manipulation - not even close. 10's quote to Wilfred is a direct reference to 7. He isn't called the 'chess master' for a laugh, you know. His entire personality was based on duplicity and manipulation, so much so that he had the fate of everyone plotted so far in advance that he was rarely ever in danger - nobody knew where they stood with him, not even his own companion (who he cared for deeply, enough to try and mould her into a Time Lady without her even knowing it). Remember when 4th Doctor struggled with the concept of ending the Daleks for good? Yeah, 7 is the one who didn't think twice about it and inflicted near genocide without a second thought. That isn't even scratching the surface of what he got up to with his manipulative ways. He is beyond compare when it comes to master-planning and manipulation, and is still the darkest and most mysterious incarnation the show has had to date. Secondly, the girl didn't 'betray' the 8th Doctor, he could have left at any time but he decided to stay in the vain hope of saving her because, like NuWho Doctors, he was a compassionate incarnation.
Rachel Lofgran Ghost light, Curse of Fenric or Remembrance of the Daleks I think show it the most in the actual show anyway. And by the way you’ll need to pay close attention with Ghost Light because while it’s a great story it’s hard to understand without concentrating.
9 and 12's idea of darkness was to be shouty and aggressive which was definitely intimidating, but 10 and 11's ability to be incredibly dark and intimidating without raising their voices was much more chilling to me - even 12 showed it at the end of Face the Raven - the evil in their eyes just showed how much they were capable of, if they let themselves do so.
ten is kind of a mix of both worlds for me. he has the ability to be angry and shouty when he wants/needs to, but he can give an honest to god chilling performance without raising his voice, too. he reminds me of a lost kid who had to grow up too fast to face the dangerous world and survive.
The 9th doc will always be one of my favorites. A fair ways more agressive than any of the later loads. Angrier, by a fair mark. Plus, the outfit was slick.
Number nine was fresh from the Time War and no doubt was carrying a lot of guilt which came out as anger especially towards the Daleks that had forced him to destroy Gallifrey.
There was the scene in a good man goes to war ('good men dont need rules nows nkt a good time to find out why i have so many')and also the scene in the doctors wife(I Think) when house said 'fear me I have killed hundreds of time lords' and the doctor replies 'fear me I killed them all'
I personally think that the darkest Doctor moment is at the end of The Waters of Mars. He's so far gone and suddenly just after that he's brought right back to realise what he's done. Someone should do an alternate timeline series/webcomic/fanfic along the lines that he keeps going like that, like with The Superior Iron Man.
Air Vent Think the comics covered a similar scenario albeit briefly as part of a crossover event involving dark alt timelines for Docs 10, 11 & 12 (ironically 9 didn’t have a possible darker path at all, survivors guilt and all). In 10’s alt timeline, he leaves Wilfred to die in a pod from The End of Time via radiation. Selfishly deciding his own life was worth more than his friend’s, he would then go on to constantly change the universe & create a new Empire as its new emperor “Time Lord Victorious”. Lasting a few decades, cleansing the universe of all evil, but eventually a rebellion would form and he would be slain by a slitheen with a anti-Galifrayian weapon canceling out his last regeneration.
When Peter Capaldi said that little rage speech to Maisie William’s character, “Now, save Clara! Or, I will end you and everything you love!” You can see what the Daleks saw.
2:04 and the rest of that scene with the dalek and the doctor has always given me chills, the fact that the doctor is told he would make a good dalek, you can see the look on his face as he his told he would be good at being the very thing he hates, this then questions me sometimes, what did the 9th think of himself?
Nivane H I love the part where's in the cell torturing the Dalek. "You're right. Maybe we are the same. Because I know what you deserve. Exterminate!" "Have pity!" "WHY? YOU NEVER DID!"
Nivane H 9 was angry at himself, and more so the daleks for forcing his hand in the war. 10 continues this trauma culminating in by the time he "goes" someone so reckless with their decisions because if the trauma they experienced. 11 "forgets" the meat of his problems but keeps an underlying layer of anger underneath his facade of a goofball, and 12 is regret and anguish for what he had done, 12 finally began to put his demons away and begin to heal, (which was why he was perfect for the xygon war compromise) . Hopefully the 13th doctor will carry less scars of the time war, and maybe even add in stuff from her past, because we need more old who integration. If love to see her go back to gallifrey. I mean it will be so diff
He very obviously hates himself. He feels guilty and knows he was wrong to burn up Gallifrey. He probably wants to kill himself too but can't because he's a Time Lord.
12:58 I love how the Doctor towers over her, it really drives in how pissed off he is. For real, the Doctor is the one being in the whole wide universe that you do not want to anger. Also, note how she cannot even look at him in the eyes, she is literally crapping herself in fear
I liek capaldi so much but i felt like they messed him up when he was the doctor. It should have been focused on the doctor growing old and giving up on being THE doctor. Its why hes so good at being dark and aged and just feel like they threw it all away and cant help but feel a bit sad :/
StarTuber I absolutely agree. While his anger and ferocity is frightening, this scene made me rethink everything about the doctor and genuinely fear him. It really does make you think about the power he has, and we side with the person we normally wouldn't side with instead of the blazing hero of the doctor. I really agreed with Adelaide. No one *should* have this much power.
yes,that arrogant look at his face when adelaide was talking and how doctor pointed out that people who he saved are unimportant. Tennant is so good at portraing this dark side of doctor,I've believed him,he looks like a villain in this scene.
A golden era. So sad that Who of this quality is largely lost now. Last three episodes of Moffat era were amazing, but RTD's was pure knockout 95% of the time.
I actually agree with your preferences almost exactly if you mean what I think you do. I have a strong preference for RTD seasons but damn was the end of season 10 good
I would like to see the 13th doctor's angry and dark side a bit more. She always seems happy and funny all the time. Peter capaldi's speechs gave me chills he was great at them.
10 is by far the scariest and most amazing Doctor, 9 was fantastic as well but I feel like his character was cut too short. 11 was funny and quirky and was great but was just too damn silly and unserious all the time. I kinda like it whenever the doctor gets angry, it’s like his stress release after dealing with murderers and evil people of the highest order I think he’s allowed to shout every once and a awhile.
I love the look on 9's face after he told those people that one of their own is died. You can tell he's both saddened and angry that he had to break the news when he turns around.
I always loved Tens darker moments. It showed what the time war had done to him and who he became because of it. I didn't love the time lord victorious but then, the Doctor repented when he'd realised he'd gone too far. I miss ten 💔
It's been a long time since I've seen Eccelston. I forgot how very, very angry he could be. In some ways the whole new series has been about getting him from the Warrior Doctor to the Pacifist Doctor.
It shows you how much he changes personality wise and how much he buries his pain. People who bury their pain more and more tend to have more violent outbursts of rage and anger
"AND I'M NOT LISTENING!" Always love it when he goes on that tirade against Mr. Connolly. But also, Capaldi's speech on war is just godly. People have said it before, but the writing, acting, camera/visuals, its just so damn good.
Okay, well start with the modern Doctors, since they are the most people are familiar with. The 8th Doctor regenerated during the heat of ending the Time War and we get the 9th Doctor, bitter & wrathful but simultaneously wracked with guilt. Then we the 10th who is born from an act of love and we have the happiest and youthful Doctor in the series. Matt Smith wasn't a great actor in the beginning, so I can't tell if he was pantomiming Tennant and doing nonsense quirks to standout or echoing the really early Doctors. I am not as familiar with the older series, but Davison's Fifth Doctor episodes are still around. He was kind and sacrificed himself for his companion, but his foe was still at large and he turned into my most hated Doctor, Colin Baker. The Sixth was an unstable twat prone to random bouts of anger, bitter at having to lose himself. I am sure there's more to talk about outside of a comments section.
The zygon speech is my favorite moment in the entire show. When she said that he would never understand I had to pause it and prepare myself for the next bit because whatever it would be I'd probably cry and I was right I did cry
That scene in the Runaway Bride still gives me chills. The menacing music is one thing, David standing there stock-still as he literally commits an act of genocide is another. Say what you will about the silliness of the episode, that’s still my favourite Tenth Doctor moment, after his TLV moments in Waters of Mars.
This is a fantastic compilation and I love how you made sure Eccleston got his proper due, but Smith had a lot more darker moments. But thanks for this I really enjoyed seeing everyone side by side
StarTuber I always thought that made his darker moments more pronounced actually. Light and shade and his angry moments we don't really see enough of in this compilation show the illusion he's hundreds of years old.
This is brilliant writing when you think about it. When the 10th first encounter an invading species he lets them retreat, but when the 11th meets the Atraxi, he makes SURE they not only retreat but never come back for their safety as well.
I love that moment in the doctors daughter. You can see the look on Martha and Donna's faces, a few seconds of them genuinely not knowing if he will pull the trigger.
“You’ll find that it’s a very small universe when I’m angry with you.” I bet it’s so small in way, you’ll never be able to hide. He’ll find you. He’ll sass you to death.
13:45 consider this from the doctor’s perspective, someone very close to him had just died and he has just teleported to a random place in the universe because someone wanted him, look how he immediately gains control in seconds.
You left the Captain Runaway bit out, and part where 11 beats a Dalek with a giant wrench while screaming at it in Churchill's bunker, the speech at the Pandorica, the "one thing you never put in a trap" speech, the part where 11 screams at Amy while pondering whether to kill the star whale or the bit where 11 is yelling at House in the Tardis console room
My personal favorite is Tennant’s run and destruction of the New Dalek Empire, with the final speech by Davros: DAVROS: Never forget, Doctor, you did this. I name you. Forever, you are the Destroyer of the Worlds!
Thinking about compiling another video to include all of the bits I missed... any special suggestions?
lixerman99 - Games & Music the Doctor kindest moments
Now THAT's a video idea...
lixerman99 - Games & Music the Doctor's best episodes!
lixerman99 - Games & Music Do one on the hope of the Doctor. The uplifting scenes where his name alone inspires people and gives them hope
His rant to Wilf after hearing the four knocks.
"You'll find that it's a very small universe when im angry with you" probably one of his most powerful lines the Doctor has ever said when he is angry
that line gives me chills
It wins the unlimited rice pudding award.
Yeah, and then she doesn't see him again, from her perspective, til the literal end of the universe. Turned out pretty meaningless.
out of every doctor who lines I have ever heard. That one is my favorite line. Which is ironic since my favorite doctor wasn't the one to say it.
I actually use that line when I am absolutely livid with someone. It seems to be very effective when they do not get the reference.
"you would make a good dalek" STILL gives me chills
Its the joy in its voice i think at seeing a kindred spirit filled with hate.
i should have told them to run to run and hide cause the monsters are coming the human race
Didn't expect to see you here.
Joa wtf are you doing here
bro what you doing here
This is why Eccleston is criminally underrated as the doctor.
he is still my favorite one
I think it has something with his constant refusal to associate with the show.
@@darthportus but you have to rank them on how good they were on the show not how long they were on it. That is why Eccleston is my favourite
@@robbytomminson5807 I think what they mean is, the reason he's underrated is because he refused to be associated with the show. The guy was great in doctor who but the actor himself is sort of a prick, he once said the reason doctor who is so popular was because of him
@@ICantThinkOfANameSVT no he didn't and even if he did he's technically right. It would not matter how good the writing was if the execution was shit. That is the most important part and nobody would have done it better than Chris
I always felt like Tennant was the saddest doctor, so much anger and guilt inside. He will always be my doctor
Tennant was the saddest,
Capaldi was the darkest
Mine too
12th was born from hope
Caitlin Fletcher Matt Smith was definitely the darkest
@@tacticalginger9623 Eccelston was the angriest.
Smith was the silliest.
The most friendliest person who takes you on the most wonderful adventures,
Is also, the most feared person in the universe.
To the people on his side, he's a warrior and a hero that comes and goes as he pleases, but seemingly makes the impossible possible. To the people against him he's a genocidal god-like being that, no matter what you do, will find you and will at the very least stop you. Most likely kill you. And kill your your entire species if unlucky.
Both are true. He's seen what nothing but rage and hatred and violence can do during the time war. So he made a ton of rules for himself, which he promised himself to never break through his name. Because of his rules he is mostly kind and good-willed. But as was said in "a good man goes to war", a good man doesn't need rules. And it's a bad idea to try to find out why he has so many.
Most friendliest?
'The man who can turn an army around at the mention of his name.'
The Oncoming Storm
I think one of the darkest moments was in "The Doctor's Wife".
House: "Fear me. I've killed hundreds of Time Lords."
The Doctor: "Fear me. I've killed all of them."
Or in "A Good Man Goes to War", when he tells Colonel Manton to run away.
Kovarian: "The anger of a good man is not a problem. Good men have too many rules."
The Doctor: "Good men don't need rules. Today is not the day to find out why I have so many."
The second one is definitely a dark moment I missed. The first one I wouldn't say is particularly dark or angry, but is pretty awesome.
Given how he lets the TARDIS kill the House moments later I'd say it's pretty dark. Also, just the way he says "I've killed all of them." is dark to me. He sounds so casual, like he didn't just allude to having committed genocide. But maybe it's just the whole episode that's dark. It's definitely my favourite:)
"She's a girl, and she's my TARDIS."
"Did you wish really hard?"
I wouldn't say the whole episode was dark. But the way he delivered that line, so nonchalantly....yeah. It was pretty dark.
"No. Colonel Mountain, I want you to tell your men to run away."
"What?"
"Those words, run away, I want you to be famous for those exact words. I want people to call you Colonel Runaway. I want children laughing outside your door because they've found the house of Colonel Runaway. And when people come to you and ask if trying to get to me, through the people I love, is in any way a good idea... I want you to tell them your name...
Oh look, I'm angry, that's new. I'm really not sure what's going to happen now."
No, the "fear me" line isn't really angry, though it IS a little dark, but it would definitely go well in a compilation of the Doctor being a badass!
Also the "if you value your continued existence, there is one thing you never, ever put in a trap" speech.
"Don't you think she looks tired" Is the single greatest Doctor moment. No grand armies, no ancient evil outsmarted, he knew 6 words to start a chain reaction that would start an upheaval in he government. Just six words, spoken to some random bodyguard.
Necrobadger I hate it tho because Christopher was such good friends with her...It really showed how much darker David was going to be tho, which I like.
@@Honeey-moth the way I always saw it was the doctor always strived to defend the earth and humanity in (for the most part) the path of least destruction and death. When Harriet Jones armed the earth with alien technology and destroyed a fleeing ship she made the doctor realise just how narrow minded she really was, and he couldn't stand a murderer in such a strong place of power
Vincent Shayler-Day that’s true, still I wish he had gone about it differently...Oh idk, in a perfect world, they would still be friends but it doesn’t actually make that much sense in context.
@@Honeey-moth Imagine you just saved your best friend from an attack, and scared the attackers away. Now imagine your best friend calling snipers to pick their attackers off. How would you feel?
Confused
"The Doctor is not here! You're left with ME!" Oh god, that's scary!
“And I will end you”
@Yup that's my name 😁
The smile he has while saying: "Oh, yes you can, and you will, or I will show your funny little town to the whole world. I will bring Unit and the Zygon. Give me a minute and I will bring the Daleks and the Cyberman"
When he said that one of my friends was like "What if he's the Valeyard now?
Dude I completely forgot I said this
Personally, The Waters of Mars is the closest thing we'll ever have to the Doctor becoming morally corrupt and evil. If not for Adelaide I think the Doctor would've finally snapped and realized that he was an unstoppable God that didn't need to show mercy and that to me, is the most frightening reality.
What is more terrifying is what he would do with the Time War. I feel like he would save Gallifrey only to use the Time Lords as a weapon. He could very easily rule the universe. A theory that I read recently is that the Doctor would have opened the Time Vortex and become god. Even the Doctor himself said that a Time Lord with that power would be a god. Imagine what a raging Doctor could do. At that point he could rewrite the whole universe into his image.
E
He would have become The Valeyard
So "mercy" = "running away and letting them die".
@@Kaplz01 thats what he did. why do you think humans and timelords look so similar?
Time Lord Victorious, is with out a doubt the scariest version of the Doctor, in my opinion
Because the Doctor realised he had gone too far when Adelaide killed herself at the end of the episode. He saw how saving everybody just because you can isn't always the right thing to do. That was how the Master started.
About as close as we’ll get to the Valeyard
sorry but i have to respectfully disagree theace king. the time lord victorious is my number 2, the end of family of blood is the darkest/scariest we have seen the dr, imho
Absolutely mate...that's was without a doubt the most terrifying Tennant ever
I agree without a doubt.. Sometimes those with good intentions are the most fearsome, especially with that much power.
By comparing Classic Who to New Who you can really see how the Time War affected the Doctor. It made him a much darker angrier character, but as the show went on he gets inspired by his companions to have more compassion..
There's a reason the Doctor has had so many human companions. It's because he knows he needs someone to teach him compassion, and humans are best at it. Because if he doesn't have compassion, he becomes dark and lonesome.
Hell, it even got him killed in another timeline
Anger is not against compassion.
Ay, you could make the argument that Doctors like the Seventh Doctor went through anger and darkness as well, and that he needs other to help him along.
War, like any other traumatic event, does change people. For some the change is instant for others it can take days, months or years to manifest. When I talk about my wartime experience I use the analogy that I died, the man I was, was killed and a stranger took my place. I am more cynical, more violent, more dark in my humor and seriousness. I build up walls and let no one in. There are things that I carry inside of which no one should ever know, secrets that will die with me. Because ignorance truly is bliss.
They made it kid friendly
I wish you could've included "I'm so old...I used to have so much mercy." From School Reunion.
Oh, and "Nobody human has anything to say to me today!" From the star whale.
@@BenVarkentine he turned pretty dark at the end of that (star whale) while talking to amy, didnt he? i need to rewatch that i guess
"you have no weapons! No defenses! No plan!"
"Yeah. And doesn't that scare ya to death"?
It probably has made people kill them selves out of fear
Im only recently getting into this so dont get it
True, your foes can't predict your tactics if you don't know what you're doing (i.e. improvise)
I think Tennant and Capaldi nail the darkness of the Doctor the most effectively - Tennant particularly possessing a chilling ruthlessness, as the Time Lord Victorious and when he's holding a gun to the colonel's head. Whereas, Eccleston gets the anger spot on, with Smith's sporadic ferociousness being a scary watch.
Agreed on all points.
Yes these two Doctors are my favourite of New Who because you felt safe and scared at the same time because you didn't want to get on the wrong side of The Doctor.
I beg to differ. Matt had his own darkness that was really scary.
"I want you to be known as Colonel RunAway, I want children laughing because they found the house of Colonel RunAway, and when... people ask you if getting to me through the PEOPLE I LOVE... (everyone stands there shocked) ... is in any way a good idea... I want you to tell them your name."
"Look now, I'm angry, that's new... I don't know what's going to happen next."
Madam K: "The anger of a good man is not a concern. Good men have too many rules."
The Doctor, face half-dark, turns to her: "Good men don't need rules... (he rounds on her) and today is not the day to find out why I have so many!"
There is nothing scarier in Doctor Who, than an angry Doctor. Not the daleks, not the cybermen, not even the silence, can be that scary when you have a angry Doctor on your tail.
Capaldi's fury is only matched by eccelston's, they had the most fire.
Its the scot in capaldi
His eyebrows were always angry.
I really enjoyed matts quiet fury is chilling because he seemed the most loving, emotional until that point but he hid so much pain smith acted it beautifully for me
Tennant was more fiery than Eccleston
As for the eyebrows, “they’re attack eyebrows”
As heartbreaking as Clara's death was its quite amazing seeing Ashildir break. She went from the story teller of the village, to someone who had lost all emotion only for it to come rushing back when she saw what she had done, to someone whose job was to clean up after the doctor. She was still cold and distant but when she saw the doctor mad? She went right back to the terrified child. She's immortal to the point she can outlive other immortals and the Doctor angry still terrifies her. If that doesnt tell you everything you need to know about him then nothing will. Clara dead hurt. Ashildir scared? Felt like justice.
She should have understood that the doctor is both a great hero but also the most feared person to ever walk the universe, his titles arent just for show you know
Never liked that she got high and mighty
11:16
I wished more people were taking THIS particular speech to heart. There are no takebacks in war.
Blimmo D. Clown listen to when he said die carefully
damat 960 There are no takebacks in war. Except in that one war that drove the plot of the first five seasons. Yeah we just kind of took that back.
Every doctor has has their speciality. 9 was angry, 10 was clever, 11 was quick, and 12 was dark.
12 was awesome he just got overshadowed by FUCKING CLARA WHO. Who should have died on earth along with her dead boyfriend.
10 was depressed as hell too
Master of Amber so far but we thought the same for eleven
Cupcake Pooper 11 was the darkest wym
I agree if anyone has seen the 13 th doctor I think they would agree she’s the curious one
"AND I'M NOT LISTENINGAA!"
The best line ever
"I knew The Doctor. The Doctor would never-"
"The Doctor is no longer here, you are stuck with me!"
I love the way he delivers that line, like he's speaking down to a child.
We all know “The Doctor” is not his real name. He chose that name to help people. In the moment where he tells her that “the Doctor is gone now, you’re stuck with ME!!!” is scary… because for as long as we have known his character he doesn’t even like to hear or utter his true name. When River tells 10 his real name in order for him to trust her, she even apologizes for having to utter it.
The POINT being: Who he truly is deep, deep, deep down must be so damn terrifying that if he’s willing to abandon being the Doctor due to the depths of his true nature’s wrath… God help you.
Everyone technically is a child to him. There are very veiw beings that are as old or older than him.
@@heatherfeather7199well, you’ve gotta remember this is the same man who destroyed the two strongest and most advanced warrior races on his own
0:27 You know, I just realised something, Cassandra said that was the last ostrich egg so if the Doctor was wrong about it being a fake then he would have just committed genocide... again
There was no albumin or yolk inside. Even if it was once real it was only a petrified shell by the time the doctor smashed it
@@swordo21 what they're saying is it was a kind of schrodinger's cat. Before he broke it, he had no real idea whether it was a real egg still able to hatch or the fake egg that he thought it was. Had it been real, he would've just caused another extinction but luckily it wasn't and it was, as you said, just a shell.
@@_kyarumii_ By that point, though, I think it would have been nore of a fossil then a living egg. I mean, this is like 4 million years in the future or whatever
@@_kyarumii_ It was a deduction The Doctor made. There had to have been a feed to power a teleportation that far away. There was only one thing Cassandra brought with her that got left behind after the teleportation. Therefor, the feed had to have been inside it. He didn't gamble on anything. The feed was in there because it was literally the only place it could be and therefor no risk was taken.
Not to blow your mind with logic or anything but if a species in down to one lone survivor they are extinct, even if it were a female and could breed with anything else it would be an offshoot of that species not that species. Also, much like the Doctor himself.
the doctor doesnt like guns, so you know when he gets one, it's serious. whenever the doctor is mad, it's serious
"The man who abhors violence, never carrying a gun. But this is the truth, Doctor. You take ordinary people and fashion them into weapons"
@@thedrinkinggamemaker9749 I seem to remember another line somewhere about that the Doctor doesn't kill people..he convinces other people to do it. Or his enemies to kill themselves.
@@VulpisFoxfire yeah 10 was basically explaining how bad he is to Wilf in End of time p2 at approximately 27:33
"If you think because she's dead I am weak, then you understand very little. If you were any part of killing her, and you're not afraid, then you understand nothing at all. So for your own sake understand this: I am The Doctor. I'm coming to find you. And I will never, ever stop." Nobody does Badass Doctor like Capaldi.
I feel he sounds a bit Baker in that speech
Which Baker? Colin or Tom?
Good point - Tom!
TheLongDark to me he is just a very arrogant and cringey character. What was that whole shit near the end where every person he saves he goes on a rant about how 'you don't know who I am but you will look back on this day and always wonder' blah blah blah
I mean, seriously??
I agree that the Twelfth Doctor is generally badly written, but Capaldi still portrays him extremely well - you can tell the man grew up loving this shit and is determined to keep the light burning - but the thing is, when you get a show like Doctor Who where there's speech after speech after speech, that means the screenwriters are writing a heap of speeches, so by the law of averages some of them have to be epic.
When we saw Waters of Mars we thought it was so unexpected but having watched this, it makes sense. They’d been building up to the Time Lord Victorious all throughout 10’s run.
Capaldi is my favourite in doing the Dark Doctor. He nailed it. Especially with Ashilda after Clara's death. Always gives me the chills.
Julfy JD Project MY NAME IS NOT ASHILDR ANYMORE
I feel like Christophet Eccleston was the best when it came to being dark since he did it so casually.
Julfy JD Project Ashildr*
12 doctor is my favourite because of the way he is and how the 11th doctor regenerated in to him he like 9 regenerated after battle this one was on trenselore that lasted 900 years witch took a emotional toll on the doctor witch could be seen at the beginning of his run and in season 9 episode 8 we begin to understand with why the doctor is closed off and seems uncaring with the speech about the screams of the time war and why he moves on so quickly like in season 10 episode when a kid died he didn't have time to mourn and let that distracted him because he has more important matters to attend to like stopping the creature and him wrestling with weather he was a good man I liked that a lot and his sarcastic nature was funny as well
THE DOCTOR IS NO LONGER HERE YOU ARE STUCK WITH ME
- But...but who are you?
- My fucking name is Malcolm Tucker.
YEESS XDD
The Newt Same
The Newt I would just do what he wants me to do.
AND MY REAL NAME IS VALEYARD!!!!
Being so powerful and good... seeing the Doctor at his lowest and worst is soooo good to see... Does that make me bad?!
I think it's the best of Doctor Who, and personally one of the reasons why I like Ecclestone's and Tennant's periods better than Smith's. I think they did dark better.
I agree they do do dark a lot better than smith was great at changing from... ya know, 11, to angry and it was AWESOME
lixerman99 - Games & Music Exactly
Mark Forgette you may be BAD...but you'll never be BADWOLF
Ecclestone's Doctor was fresh from the Time War and was still angry.
I loved Adelaide Brooke. One of the few to question the Doctor's power.
Like Harriet Jones - one of the good characters who disagree with the Doctor.
She stood up to him when he was wrong. A true hero
Several people have questioned the Doctor's power. All of the companions have. They simply tell him to stop and he listens because he loves them and knows they're right (with some exceptions).
There have been quite a few who questioned his power, but she had such unique and utter conviction in her argument that it shook him to his core and snapped him out of it.
If I'm being honest I think Matt smiths doctor had a lot more angry moments like for example the part in "A good man goes to war" the part with "Colonel Runaway"
I missed out Colonel Runaway and possibly others, which was a pretty big mistake, but it's also true that compared to 9 or 10 he didn't have nearly as many dark moments.
Ya but it was still a great video!😁
Thanks G
Theblueninja 777 Matts doctor I felt was sick and tired of everyone's shit
dragonball bows no he wasn't taking it anymore in season 7
10:55 is the scariest Doctor moment for me, the way he says “I genuinely don’t know” strikes a chord with me that I can’t quite compare with anything else. He was contemplating shooting someone straight in the face, so different to the Doctor he strives to be.
Yeah
What about the scene in school reunion Doctor: " I'm so old I use to have so much mercy"
i can't tell who's scarier. Christopher eccleston or peter capaldi
Fucking donald duck is the answer.
Honestly? I think Tennant's the scariest when angry, mostly because he rarely ever gets so angry which makes it so that when he is, he's very, very angry, and quietly so. Which, to me, is one of the scariest kinds of anger. Though between Capaldi and Eccleston, I'd say Capaldi.
Colin Baker
jhibbitt1 David Tennant
Tippetarius I mean have you seen that Zettaflare? Donald Duck can be pretty scary xD
Doctor: i should have told them to run and hide cause the monsters are coming, the human race
Rose: uh...im literally standing right here dude
He means you and your lot blondie 😂
He was right though. That is probably how we would respond to aliens
@@johnmurphy6474 I would hope so. If we don't defend ourselves they would just keep coming back.
@@johnmurphy6474and it would be the right way to do it. Harriet was right, the Doctor isn’t always there. And even when he js, he commits genocide more often than anyone else. Case in point: Silence, Racnoss, Daleks, etc.
You know it's serious when the Doctor gets mad.
I love how Eleven can be so goofy and lovable but becomes downright scary when he's angry. The moment in The Beast Below when he yells "nobody human has anything to say to me today" and the Colonel Runaway scene are among my favorites.
You mean The doctor
@@Suleiman-y8r Eleven is a common way to refer to the Eleventh Doctor
@@AWinterLullaby ahh now I get it
5:46 The itsy bitsy spiders climbed up the water spout
Down came the rain and washed the spiders out
Up came the sun and dried up all the rain
And the itsy bitsy spiders were never found again.
That is messed up..!
That “don’t you think she looks tired” that’s gold. He is being undermined to the point where he shuts down her hole career. And he does it so quickly, easily and calmly as well. It’s amazing.
I mean when someone like The Doctor, whose influence in the militaries is huge as well as other areas, suggests a government official might not be able to handle their new duties without it having too heavy an impact on them, that is a very fast track to people starting rumours and questioning her every decision.
It's also that she doesn't know what he whispered. It's something that would make him look at her quizzically. But the paranoia. That's the slow killer.
The doctor is such a good and fun character but to see him all dark is good to. Remember he's an old man who saw the time war end in flames and lost his home planet even if he saved it he still remembers destroying it
The Family of Blood and The Waters of Mars was probably his saddest and darkest.
Agreed
To those talking about "Dark" Doctors - first of all, angry isn't dark. Remember when 10 said to Wilfred "I've taken lives, but I got smart, I got clever - manipulated people into taking their own" - yes, he is talking about the Seventh Doctor. If you want an example of the one and only 'dark' doctor, type "Big Finish 181 Afterlife" in search and click the (Fear Me) speech - and remember, kids, don't mess with the Umbrella man.
I think the twelfth doctor is more manipulative than any of his past incarnations apart from seventh doctor, I mean, look at the interaction with Twelve and Davros, Twelve manipulated Davros into "destroying" the TARDIS, "Killing" both missy and clara (when intentionally they teleported and the TARDIS literally hid away until needed) and manipulated Davros into taking some regeneration energy in order to wake the "dead" daleks in the mud.
I think both Seven and Twelve are on par with each other for being manipulative towards everyone and yes, when you look at both those incarnations, you can't help but remember what ten said to Wilfred about being clever and making people into taking their own life, even to the point where ten admonished his human counterpart for committing mass genocide on the Daleks and Davros.
I personally also loved Eight in "The Night Of The Doctor" episode where he physically understood that he needed to be in the time war because the person he was trying to save ended up pretty much betraying him and telling him to go to hell and told the sisters of kairn to get out in an angry voice.
12 is nowhere near 7's level of manipulation - not even close. 10's quote to Wilfred is a direct reference to 7. He isn't called the 'chess master' for a laugh, you know. His entire personality was based on duplicity and manipulation, so much so that he had the fate of everyone plotted so far in advance that he was rarely ever in danger - nobody knew where they stood with him, not even his own companion (who he cared for deeply, enough to try and mould her into a Time Lady without her even knowing it). Remember when 4th Doctor struggled with the concept of ending the Daleks for good? Yeah, 7 is the one who didn't think twice about it and inflicted near genocide without a second thought. That isn't even scratching the surface of what he got up to with his manipulative ways.
He is beyond compare when it comes to master-planning and manipulation, and is still the darkest and most mysterious incarnation the show has had to date.
Secondly, the girl didn't 'betray' the 8th Doctor, he could have left at any time but he decided to stay in the vain hope of saving her because, like NuWho Doctors, he was a compassionate incarnation.
Is there a specific instance or story that shows the Seventh Doctor like that? I haven't had time to watch the older Doctors yet.
Rachel Lofgran Ghost light, Curse of Fenric or Remembrance of the Daleks I think show it the most in the actual show anyway. And by the way you’ll need to pay close attention with Ghost Light because while it’s a great story it’s hard to understand without concentrating.
RopeDrink i believe ten was referring to adelaide commuting suicide at the end of waters of mars
9 and 12's idea of darkness was to be shouty and aggressive which was definitely intimidating, but 10 and 11's ability to be incredibly dark and intimidating without raising their voices was much more chilling to me - even 12 showed it at the end of Face the Raven - the evil in their eyes just showed how much they were capable of, if they let themselves do so.
ten is kind of a mix of both worlds for me. he has the ability to be angry and shouty when he wants/needs to, but he can give an honest to god chilling performance without raising his voice, too. he reminds me of a lost kid who had to grow up too fast to face the dangerous world and survive.
The 9th doc will always be one of my favorites.
A fair ways more agressive than any of the later loads. Angrier, by a fair mark.
Plus, the outfit was slick.
Number nine was fresh from the Time War and no doubt was carrying a lot of guilt which came out as anger especially towards the Daleks that had forced him to destroy Gallifrey.
DoktorKebab aggressive but somehow also kinder
Not to be picky but you missed a lot of Matt smiths best moments like in the beast below
They missed so many because the doctor is such a dark character
There was the scene in a good man goes to war ('good men dont need rules nows nkt a good time to find out why i have so many')and also the scene in the doctors wife(I Think) when house said 'fear me I have killed hundreds of time lords' and the doctor replies 'fear me I killed them all'
I personally think that the darkest Doctor moment is at the end of The Waters of Mars. He's so far gone and suddenly just after that he's brought right back to realise what he's done. Someone should do an alternate timeline series/webcomic/fanfic along the lines that he keeps going like that, like with The Superior Iron Man.
Air Vent Think the comics covered a similar scenario albeit briefly as part of a crossover event involving dark alt timelines for Docs 10, 11 & 12 (ironically 9 didn’t have a possible darker path at all, survivors guilt and all).
In 10’s alt timeline, he leaves Wilfred to die in a pod from The End of Time via radiation. Selfishly deciding his own life was worth more than his friend’s, he would then go on to constantly change the universe & create a new Empire as its new emperor “Time Lord Victorious”. Lasting a few decades, cleansing the universe of all evil, but eventually a rebellion would form and he would be slain by a slitheen with a anti-Galifrayian weapon canceling out his last regeneration.
When Peter Capaldi said that little rage speech to Maisie William’s character,
“Now, save Clara! Or, I will end you and everything you love!”
You can see what the Daleks saw.
The hybrid. Time Lord with the hate of a Dalek
2:04 and the rest of that scene with the dalek and the doctor has always given me chills, the fact that the doctor is told he would make a good dalek, you can see the look on his face as he his told he would be good at being the very thing he hates, this then questions me sometimes, what did the 9th think of himself?
Nivane H I love the part where's in the cell torturing the Dalek.
"You're right. Maybe we are the same. Because I know what you deserve. Exterminate!"
"Have pity!"
"WHY? YOU NEVER DID!"
Nivane H 9 was angry at himself, and more so the daleks for forcing his hand in the war. 10 continues this trauma culminating in by the time he "goes" someone so reckless with their decisions because if the trauma they experienced. 11 "forgets" the meat of his problems but keeps an underlying layer of anger underneath his facade of a goofball, and 12 is regret and anguish for what he had done, 12 finally began to put his demons away and begin to heal, (which was why he was perfect for the xygon war compromise) . Hopefully the 13th doctor will carry less scars of the time war, and maybe even add in stuff from her past, because we need more old who integration. If love to see her go back to gallifrey. I mean it will be so diff
9 hated himself
He Hurt, of course...
He very obviously hates himself. He feels guilty and knows he was wrong to burn up Gallifrey. He probably wants to kill himself too but can't because he's a Time Lord.
12:58 I love how the Doctor towers over her, it really drives in how pissed off he is. For real, the Doctor is the one being in the whole wide universe that you do not want to anger.
Also, note how she cannot even look at him in the eyes, she is literally crapping herself in fear
Peter Capaldi perfectly shows the Doctor's dark side.
Erik Lehnsherr I completely disagree (no offence) but I think he is cringy and not the best actor for the doctor
@@faymorr3706 Capaldi in my eyes shows a great side of the dark side of the doctor, but he doesn't hide it
I liek capaldi so much but i felt like they messed him up when he was the doctor. It should have been focused on the doctor growing old and giving up on being THE doctor. Its why hes so good at being dark and aged and just feel like they threw it all away and cant help but feel a bit sad :/
I like how scared 9th is of daleks, then 12th asks if they want to play Dodgems.
12:05 he's suffered so much, I just wanna hug him
"The Doctor is no longer here, you are stuck with me" - The Valeyard
8:58-9:57 the only time the doctor scared me
StarTuber I absolutely agree. While his anger and ferocity is frightening, this scene made me rethink everything about the doctor and genuinely fear him. It really does make you think about the power he has, and we side with the person we normally wouldn't side with instead of the blazing hero of the doctor. I really agreed with Adelaide. No one *should* have this much power.
I think him murdering the spider woman with out a look of remorse on his face shook me to the bone
He was so calm.. Like he just give up all his emotions and feeling to the his power.. It is very scary and sad 💔
Its the fact he refers to some people as 'little people.' Im so used to him believing everyone is important
yes,that arrogant look at his face when adelaide was talking and how doctor pointed out that people who he saved are unimportant. Tennant is so good at portraing this dark side of doctor,I've believed him,he looks like a villain in this scene.
0:28 Imagine if he was wrong. His face would have been priceless.
The line from 'The Waters of Mars', "The laws of time are mine, and THEY WILL OBEY ME!" is possibly the most badass, yet terrifying line spoken in DW.
A golden era. So sad that Who of this quality is largely lost now. Last three episodes of Moffat era were amazing, but RTD's was pure knockout 95% of the time.
I actually agree with your preferences almost exactly if you mean what I think you do. I have a strong preference for RTD seasons but damn was the end of season 10 good
It was always going to be easier for RTD as he had so many modern ideas to work with. Still got the most out of them
I completely understand The Doctor's rage against the Daleks
Tennant saying "NO second chances, I am that sort of a man." always gives me chills.
I would like to see the 13th doctor's angry and dark side a bit more. She always seems happy and funny all the time. Peter capaldi's speechs gave me chills he was great at them.
God, Christopher Eccleston is just the best. And there's a sense of Malcolm Tucker when 12 gets angry.
Exactly what I was thinking!
10 is by far the scariest and most amazing Doctor, 9 was fantastic as well but I feel like his character was cut too short. 11 was funny and quirky and was great but was just too damn silly and unserious all the time.
I kinda like it whenever the doctor gets angry, it’s like his stress release after dealing with murderers and evil people of the highest order I think he’s allowed to shout every once and a awhile.
I love Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant so much. The true doctors
they all are good doctors. you need to calm down.
you havent met the first four classic doctors especially baker, these men leave these newbies in the dust!
I love the look on 9's face after he told those people that one of their own is died. You can tell he's both saddened and angry that he had to break the news when he turns around.
“You would make a good Dalek”
One of the best lines in the show ever
12:55 And the time where that alien lifeform stole my voice and the people on that shuttle nearly threw me out doesn't count.
I always loved Tens darker moments. It showed what the time war had done to him and who he became because of it. I didn't love the time lord victorious but then, the Doctor repented when he'd realised he'd gone too far. I miss ten 💔
He freaking destroyed a wall of Adamantium with his bare fists.
Noriel Sylvire lol Adamantium - I rate
Doesn't 'adamant' literally translate to "hard" in Latin lol
Give or take 4.5 billion years to do it.
"Good men don't need rules. Today is not the day to find out why I have so many."
It's been a long time since I've seen Eccelston. I forgot how very, very angry he could be. In some ways the whole new series has been about getting him from the Warrior Doctor to the Pacifist Doctor.
It shows you how much he changes personality wise and how much he buries his pain. People who bury their pain more and more tend to have more violent outbursts of rage and anger
8:57 this feels like one of the darkest performances of the Doctor that David Tennant ever gave.
1:45 the dalek just freakin rapped... damn
I can't unhear that now, God damn it!
5:35
The Doctor yells at Mr Connolly.
What does Rose do?
Smile awkwardly XD
"AND I'M NOT LISTENING!" Always love it when he goes on that tirade against Mr. Connolly. But also, Capaldi's speech on war is just godly. People have said it before, but the writing, acting, camera/visuals, its just so damn good.
The scene from beast below, the doctor killing jack the ripper, 'I could do so much more'.
That Peter Capaldi speech in "The Zygon Inversion" is the greatest Doctor speech. It's legendary.
I like how each form behaves in response to the event that resulted in his regeneration.
Terrakinetic elaborate
Okay, well start with the modern Doctors, since they are the most people are familiar with. The 8th Doctor regenerated during the heat of ending the Time War and we get the 9th Doctor, bitter & wrathful but simultaneously wracked with guilt. Then we the 10th who is born from an act of love and we have the happiest and youthful Doctor in the series. Matt Smith wasn't a great actor in the beginning, so I can't tell if he was pantomiming Tennant and doing nonsense quirks to standout or echoing the really early Doctors.
I am not as familiar with the older series, but Davison's Fifth Doctor episodes are still around. He was kind and sacrificed himself for his companion, but his foe was still at large and he turned into my most hated Doctor, Colin Baker. The Sixth was an unstable twat prone to random bouts of anger, bitter at having to lose himself. I am sure there's more to talk about outside of a comments section.
The zygon speech is my favorite moment in the entire show. When she said that he would never understand I had to pause it and prepare myself for the next bit because whatever it would be I'd probably cry and I was right I did cry
That scene in the Runaway Bride still gives me chills.
The menacing music is one thing, David standing there stock-still as he literally commits an act of genocide is another.
Say what you will about the silliness of the episode, that’s still my favourite Tenth Doctor moment, after his TLV moments in Waters of Mars.
"MMMMMMMMMMMMMMAAAAAAAAAAAARTTTTTTTTTTTTHAAAAAA!!!!"
"He never raised his voice"
He’s talking about when he dealt with the Family.
11:20 this scene is so so powerful... I literally cried here
I already liked Capaldi but the scaled model of war speech cemented my love for him as the doctor.
This is a fantastic compilation and I love how you made sure Eccleston got his proper due, but Smith had a lot more darker moments.
But thanks for this I really enjoyed seeing everyone side by side
“I never would. Okay? I. Never. Would.” Tbh tht was a cool beans line
i love david's cold rage it gives me always goose bumps
I just can't take eleven seriously because he's all goofy and comedic! Still my fave doctor.
StarTuber I always thought that made his darker moments more pronounced actually. Light and shade and his angry moments we don't really see enough of in this compilation show the illusion he's hundreds of years old.
Yoooohhh this is the best of Doctor Who’s darkest moments! 😄 7:22
2:41 "I'm going to rescue her. ROPE!"
2:17 - the entire internet in a nutshell.
Liam Daly oh fuck I laughed out loud
😳
This is brilliant writing when you think about it. When the 10th first encounter an invading species he lets them retreat, but when the 11th meets the Atraxi, he makes SURE they not only retreat but never come back for their safety as well.
I love that moment in the doctors daughter. You can see the look on Martha and Donna's faces, a few seconds of them genuinely not knowing if he will pull the trigger.
“You’ll find that it’s a very small universe when I’m angry with you.”
I bet it’s so small in way, you’ll never be able to hide. He’ll find you. He’ll sass you to death.
6:13 when the boss battle takes several minutes and the boss keeps repeating the same dialog
10:16 - That must've really hurt for River 😢
"THE DOCTOR IS NO LONGER HERE. YOU ARE STUCK WITH ME."
he scary :(
9:32 The closest The Doctor has come to becoming The Master.
13:45 consider this from the doctor’s perspective, someone very close to him had just died and he has just teleported to a random place in the universe because someone wanted him, look how he immediately gains control in seconds.
You left the Captain Runaway bit out, and part where 11 beats a Dalek with a giant wrench while screaming at it in Churchill's bunker, the speech at the Pandorica, the "one thing you never put in a trap" speech, the part where 11 screams at Amy while pondering whether to kill the star whale or the bit where 11 is yelling at House in the Tardis console room
My personal favorite is Tennant’s run and destruction of the New Dalek Empire, with the final speech by Davros:
DAVROS: Never forget, Doctor, you did this. I name you. Forever, you are the Destroyer of the Worlds!