'What fool thinks we don't need high-speed trains?' - Santhosh George Kulangara | Interview | TNIE

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
  • In this interview with The New Indian Express - Kerala, Santhosh George Kulangara talks about why it is important that we need high-speed railway projects like the 'K-Rail' project. Santhosh George Kulangara says that India needs high-speed trains and we should remember that we are competing like countries like China who already have high-speed trains. Santhosh George says that people who are against such projects should update their thinking.
    #SanthoshGeorgeKulangara #KRail #India #ExpressDialogues
    News from across the state as well as the latest updates on Kochi curated and shared here, the official account of New Indian Express for Kerala.

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @rajeshshark
    @rajeshshark Місяць тому +188

    Kerala with a dense population along a 20 km wide 600 km long stretch is one of the most ideal places in the world for a high speed rail. We can only feel sorry for people who do not realise its potential.

    • @sankarnath
      @sankarnath Місяць тому +6

      We can decide to stop paying taxes and move out of the country.

    • @Indhra07
      @Indhra07 Місяць тому +10

      I also want high speed rail to come but it should be done properly not like pr works like k rail or silver line. How much money is wasted now on this

    • @mohithmanoj8228
      @mohithmanoj8228 Місяць тому +7

      You just contradict yourself , in a densely populated area a parallel rail line is not practical and it also has challenges . Best method is to straighten out the existing railway lines and do effectively increase the stress limit of the tracks and we can easily run a high speed network here .

    • @rajeshshark
      @rajeshshark Місяць тому +4

      @@mohithmanoj8228 The current line used by goods vehicles, passenger trains, long-distance trains, inspection locomotives etc cannot be used for a high speed rail.high speed lanes cannot be even linked to slower traffic lanes for great risk of mishaps and accidents. High speed rail every where in the world is an exclusive automated, evenly timed system which will not allow any other traffic for sheer efficiency and safety.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE.

  • @jcubeentertainers
    @jcubeentertainers Місяць тому +323

    I always stood for K Rail. Glad to hear.

    • @adityak6684
      @adityak6684 Місяць тому +4

      Yes

    • @jcubeentertainers
      @jcubeentertainers Місяць тому +2

      @ salute 🫡

    • @ajmal3256
      @ajmal3256 Місяць тому +12

      KRail venam but maasapadi Vedi Veena Vijyante labelil alla

    • @jopez1478
      @jopez1478 Місяць тому +13

      The current proposal for K rail is absolute disaster... Zero foresight for the future ...
      The Dpr is available online ane one could see.. it is worse than elementary school presentation... with no actual research..
      I object Krail for this sole reason .

    • @InkuruKunkuru-xx5cviiii
      @InkuruKunkuru-xx5cviiii Місяць тому

      ​@@ajmal3256good language, it says alot about your culture 😅 grow up brother, stop slut shaming

  • @TubeDirektor
    @TubeDirektor Місяць тому +57

    This is the first time I've heard someone speak so authoritatively with solid facts to back their points. He's absolutely correct about how we often compare ourselves to China without fully understanding their advancements. I’d wager most people haven’t even watched videos showcasing China's infrastructure.
    I had the privilege of experiencing China’s train system firsthand. About 20 years ago, a train ride from Shanghai to Wuxi took around three hours with multiple stops, similar to what we see in India today. Fast forward to now, and the high-speed rail between Shanghai and Wuxi takes just 45 minutes! This transformation saves people significant time. Wuxi, being much more affordable than Shanghai, allows people to live there and commute daily for work.
    Moreover, China’s rail infrastructure and stations are so advanced that they outshine many Indian airports. This highlights the importance of visionary planning-thinking 30 to 50 years ahead to benefit future generations. I believe people will start to appreciate this when projects like the six-lane NH66 connecting North and South Kerala are completed. Once you experience world-class infrastructure, there’s no going back.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @RaviShankar-oh4is
    @RaviShankar-oh4is Місяць тому +392

    ഇതൊക്കെ ആരോട് പറയാനാണ് സാർ ഒരു വകതിരിവും ഇല്ലാത്ത കുറേ രാഷ്ട്രീയ നേതാക്കളും കുറേ നാറിയ മാധ്യമങ്ങളും ഉണ്ട് കേരളത്തിൽ

  • @DifferentGeordie
    @DifferentGeordie Місяць тому +210

    A friend of mine who works in Asianet News told me that there was a big debate in the studio amongst employees about KRail. Vinu v john and Suresh had no valid points against KRail. Their single agenda was to work against Pinarayi.

    • @roypaul5229
      @roypaul5229 Місяць тому +8

      There is valid point raised by many to oppose k rail frst of all this krail Is planning to make a different rail path that will divide kerala into two I don't think a state who has suffered two floods will survive a divide .

    • @aaro7788
      @aaro7788 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@roypaul5229lol where does such fools like you come from??a railpath will divide kerala into two?? 🤣😂 Grow up അമ്മാവാ

    • @aaro7788
      @aaro7788 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@roypaul5229And by the way the present railway tracks in kerala cannot handle 200km/hr trains because of curves and bends... So k rail needs a separate path...and can u explain how a railpath will divide kerala into two??

    • @nikhilreji4581
      @nikhilreji4581 Місяць тому +18

      @@roypaul5229 WHAT ABT NH 66? It is also dividing kerala?

    • @Neo.555
      @Neo.555 Місяць тому +7

      Lol.. There's a reason why many opposed Krail.. It's in the dpr.. Why no one's raising objection against NH66 or the greenfield highway? It's not about Krail but the way government is trying to implement it.

  • @jayaprakashbalan2510
    @jayaprakashbalan2510 Місяць тому +85

    What Santosh is saying is absolutely right. Its not about K-Rail or Silver Line or anything else. Its about the speed and quickness and comfortable travel that everybody should get in today's world for everybody to reach from one end to other and no excuse for that, it is required, so that more people and youth travel and there is uniform development everywhere. Yes, but as said, those villagers who doesn't want to go anywhere far or has a shop nearby or has an ancestral land (not even earned by themselves) will be the ones who are deadly against and protesting against such things. The only way out is that those who lose land should be compensated very well as per market rate and little more money, but here too Govt. tries to squeeze and give them peanuts. Also the viability and analysis of the hi speed rail has to be studied. Here when jobs and earnings are not there, and with high ticket rates, only percentage of people who have money will travel. So, will the investment be worth. This is the question everybody will ask in Kerala. But unless and until new things come, one cannot judge the profitability or sustainance of the project. Problem in India and kerala is when every development and issue becomes political and is done for personal and party credibility and agenda.

    • @thelastgs-pian9965
      @thelastgs-pian9965 Місяць тому +1

      I am from kochi, just look at the state of the container road connecting ernakulam to nh66. Hawkers and icecream stalls all around, max speed capped for bikes to 60km. Roads sshould bemeant for travel only , strictly prohibit sales around highways, no fish, or Hindi hawkers selling their wares, pedestrian crossings only through zebra lanes. Strictly no animal grazing,catch all cows and goats grazing on the medians.. As to speed itcan be incrementally increased by railways , straightening the curves and doubling tracks should be the first priority, rather than laying a single line that would eatup precious land. Some years ago while traveling through boat from Ekm to fortkochi, we could see a high speed hydrofoil boat lying at willingdon island port, it was never put to trial, if that was tested we would have people traveling at average speed above vande that's trains, but our because it wont fill someone's pockets the idea was flushed down the drain, now the munnar seaplane might face the same issue.

    • @surendranc7184
      @surendranc7184 Місяць тому

      Govt gave a very good compensation in the case of national high way. They are ready in this case also. But the shameless political leaders of opposition are playing the game here for electoral benefits and power.

    • @jayaprakashbalan2510
      @jayaprakashbalan2510 Місяць тому

      @@thelastgs-pian9965 You observation of most of the things mentioned is right, but then seems you have only seen Kochi and no other parts of the country, because the situation is only just worse elsewhere. Definitely, that in anyway doesn't save Kochi to be good and the authorities and Govt. to be irresponsible from. But then, thats India, unless and until some pockets are filled, nothing will move or be made better in India because the mindset of Indians are such. Hence I would not just blame the Govt. or concerned authorities, simply because people themselves are like that and has corrupt and selfish mind, only worried about themselves and their family, nothing else. Forget worrying, they are even careless about other things. Kerala should have been better, but unfortunately, except for boasting of fake literacy, there is nothing Kerala is better in. And they have only one thing, that is to criticize rest of the country or talk about international countries and waste their time in petty things, than doing something good. So, its only a curse for people to be like that.

  • @sreesharks
    @sreesharks Місяць тому +56

    സന്തോഷ്‌ ജോർജ് കുളങ്ങര 👌👌👌👌👌👌

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @muhammedniyas7708
    @muhammedniyas7708 Місяць тому +17

    We have 75 years old leaders with 150 years old ideas 🙂

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

    • @Sne-cu7nx
      @Sne-cu7nx Місяць тому +1

      കോൺഗ്രസ്‌ 🤷‍♀️

    • @PazhaniAppan-b6s
      @PazhaniAppan-b6s 16 днів тому

      All party​@@Sne-cu7nx

  • @pseudonym9215
    @pseudonym9215 Місяць тому +33

    Its not about speed, but about connecting Kerala in such a way that business and opportunity is more easily available to everyone. Not everyone will have to move to Kochi or Calicut or Trivandrum for jobs. High speed rail (Which K-rail is not) will economically link places unlike ever before. The benefits are not just high speed.
    But the question is valid that at cost? It has to be a balance. Not every project can be canceled in the name of environmental concerns and not every project can be green lit in the name of economic prosperity. The pros and cons have to be evaluated at short, long and very long term effects.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @yathindrak1295
    @yathindrak1295 Місяць тому +16

    പുരോഗതിക്ക് എപ്പോഴും മാറ്റങ്ങൾ ആവശ്യമാണ്. നമ്മുടെ റെയിൽവേയ്ക്ക് കേന്ദ്രത്തിൽ നിന്ന് വൻതോതിൽ വിഭവങ്ങൾ ആവശ്യമാണ്. അതിനാൽ ആധുനികവൽക്കരണം മന്ദഗതിയിലാണ്. മാറ്റങ്ങൾ വേഗത്തിലാക്കാനും സൂപ്പർ ഫാസ്റ്റ് ട്രെയിനുകൾ ആരംഭിക്കാനും കൂടുതൽ ആളുകളുടെ സമ്മർദ്ദം ആവശ്യമാണ്. കൂടുതൽ ആളുകൾ ഇതുപോലുള്ള മികച്ച വീഡിയോകൾ കാണുമെന്നും രാഷ്ട്രീയ സമ്മർദ്ദത്തിലൂടെ മാറ്റങ്ങൾ വേഗത്തിലാക്കുമെന്നും പ്രതീക്ഷിക്കുന്നു.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @Manumurukesan
    @Manumurukesan Місяць тому +6

    Travelling from London to Manchester takes 2 hours by train (It goes up to 250 km/h). To cover the same distance, it takes 5-6 hours in India.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @velociraptor7110
    @velociraptor7110 Місяць тому +11

    Absolutely true, look at how the roads of Kerala are congested. Rapid and high speed transportation is the need of the hour.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @AlphinTom
    @AlphinTom Місяць тому +66

    I live in Munich... And munich to Berlin is same distance as Thiruvananthapuram to Kasaragod.. Here it will take 4 hours to do this journey. And in kerala even with VB it will take over 8 hours.. And forget about driving takes over 16 hours.. And Germany doesn't even have the fastest of rail networks.. It's faster in Italy and France... Even Spain has really fast connections now... Better not to even talk about China. Thats on another level...
    I had once debated with a few of friends back in Kerala over a high speed rail and everyone wanted to protect land owners interests and K rail or silver line is not needed.
    Last month, I was in a northern city of Germany and met at least 50 young malayalees... 2 years ago that number would have almost zero... Its a number that's increasing every month...
    Without a major change of mindset kerala won't survive for long.
    Also remember, money and people coming back from Gulf countries will have a very steep decline soon.

    • @anandnaa
      @anandnaa Місяць тому +2

      There are flights available from Kannur Airport to trivandrum it takes max 1-1.5 hr

    • @vishnusivadas285
      @vishnusivadas285 Місяць тому +7

      😂😂​@@anandnaa

    • @NishMurale-hf5cy
      @NishMurale-hf5cy Місяць тому

      What is the fare you pay?

    • @Chaos96_
      @Chaos96_ Місяць тому +6

      ​@@anandnaa wow variety sanm 😂😂

    • @naveenjames674
      @naveenjames674 Місяць тому +2

      At what cost?​@@anandnaa

  • @sidharthsidhu293
    @sidharthsidhu293 Місяць тому +18

    Well said Sir 🙌

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @exgod1
    @exgod1 Місяць тому +50

    Santosh George Kulangara & Prof C Ravichandran ഇവർ ആണ് എന്റെ ഹീറോസ്.
    Kerala state politics yil ഇവരെ പോലുള്ള വ്യക്തികൾ ആണ് വരേണ്ടത്.❤️❤️

    • @alanp227
      @alanp227 Місяць тому

      നേരാം വണ്ണം ഗൂഗിൾ ഉപയോഗിക്കാൻ പോലും അറിയാതെ അവിടെന്നും ഇവിടെന്നും മുറിച്ച് എടുത്ത് സ്വന്തം ആയി facts fabricate ചെയ്യുന്ന ആളാണ് രവിചന്ദ്രൻ
      അയാളെ ഒന്നും സന്തോഷ് ജോർജ് ൻ്റെ കൂടെ compare ചെയ്യരുത്

    • @Alliswell-jz9ft
      @Alliswell-jz9ft Місяць тому +1

      C രചന്ദ്രൻ 🤣🤣 അയാളുടെ പൊട്ടത്തരം മാത്രം എടുത്താൽ പത്തു ബുക്ക്‌ എഴുതാം

    • @Alliswell-jz9ft
      @Alliswell-jz9ft Місяць тому

      സന്തോഷ്‌ ok rc തികഞ്ഞ തോൽവി ആണ്

    • @infokites3994
      @infokites3994 Місяць тому

      C Ravichandran is a psuedo atheist, actually a sanghi hidden atheists gown

    • @jomu4297
      @jomu4297 Місяць тому +1

      അതെ, അതുകൊണ്ട് ആണ് ആ മൈരേൻ 8 നിലയിൽ പൊട്ടിയേത്

  • @akhileshanand1252
    @akhileshanand1252 Місяць тому +10

    ഒരു പ്രവാസിയുടെ അവസ്ഥ. കുവൈറ്റിൽ നിന്നും കൊച്ചിയിൽ എത്താൻ 4.30 മണിക്കൂർ മതി എന്നാൽ കൊച്ചിയിൽ നിന്നും വീട്ടിൽ എത്താൻ 5 മണിക്കൂറിൽ മേലെ വേണം. ഇവിടുത്തെ രാഷ്ട്രീകാര് നേരെ ആവാതെ ഈ നാട് നന്നാവില്ല

  • @TheJohn2272
    @TheJohn2272 Місяць тому +20

    I always stand for k-rail

  • @Lakme03-91
    @Lakme03-91 8 днів тому

    He's such a great man with good experiences.

  • @meerapatankar7275
    @meerapatankar7275 Місяць тому +2

    Great points made by Mr. Santosh!

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @rajanmathai
    @rajanmathai Місяць тому +37

    Maprakal should ask standard question ?

  • @krishnar4239
    @krishnar4239 Місяць тому +9

    Very true!

  • @anusree7687
    @anusree7687 Місяць тому +2

    Very very correct!! Well said sir❤️

  • @jamesarems
    @jamesarems Місяць тому +4

    If the infrastructure satisfies the climate needs (especially monsoon downpours) then its totally acceptable.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @jacob4318
    @jacob4318 Місяць тому +6

    High speed train is a necessity for persons traveling across Kerala and other parts of India.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @yourshowtime009
    @yourshowtime009 Місяць тому +10

    Yes u correct

  • @sumayyacm4170
    @sumayyacm4170 9 днів тому

    Sir👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻

  • @greennature4414
    @greennature4414 Місяць тому +15

    ഉമാ തോമസ് 😎

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @rejenraju4778
    @rejenraju4778 Місяць тому +1

    Spitting facts…. 💯💯💯. right question that needs to be asked??
    Why don’t take lead for that much needed transformation???

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @sreerakshith
    @sreerakshith Місяць тому +18

    K Rail verum keto❤

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

    • @Sne-cu7nx
      @Sne-cu7nx Місяць тому +2

      പിണറായി ❤️

  • @roshnnjabir
    @roshnnjabir Місяць тому

    Always Standing With George Sir

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @amalsebastian391
    @amalsebastian391 Місяць тому +8

    We need speed rail network soon possible. No doubt about that

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @hyundai100100
    @hyundai100100 29 днів тому

    Yes we need high speed train. Still traveling in age old Memu train..
    or adjusting ourselves in reserved compartments

  • @abduljaleeljalu2002
    @abduljaleeljalu2002 Місяць тому +2

    6 lines NH 66 വന്നപ്പോൾ തന്നെ ജനങ്ങൾക്ക് മനസ്സിലായി തുടങ്ങിയിട്ടുണ്ട് വേഗത വേണമെന്ന്...!

  • @TheArunpaul
    @TheArunpaul Місяць тому +2

    Indian Railway High Speed is a better alternative than standalone
    K Rail

  • @JoJ134
    @JoJ134 Місяць тому +2

    Krail പോലെ ഉള്ള പദ്ധദികൾ ഏറ്റവും യോജിക്കുന്ന ഇന്ത്യൻ സംസ്ഥാനം കേരളം ആണു. കേരളത്തിൽ ഓരോ ജില്ലയിലും പ്രധാനപ്പെട്ട നഗരങ്ങൾ വളർന്നു വരുന്നുണ്ട്. അവ തമ്മിൽ കണക്ട് ചെയ്യുന്ന അതിവേഗ റെയിൽ പാത അത്യവശ്യമാണ് .

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES. 😊

  • @arunrejimangalath427
    @arunrejimangalath427 Місяць тому +25

    K റെയിൽ കൊണ്ടുവന്നാൽ ഈ govt നെ ഭാവി തലമുറ സ്മരിക്കും .. k റെയിൽ മുടക്കാൻ നോക്കുന്നരേയും അവരുടെ കുടുംബത്തെയും സ്മരിക്കപ്പെടും

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @JithinPaul-et1vk
    @JithinPaul-et1vk Місяць тому +2

    Krail is needed, this could free existing rail lines for more connectivity to other states, which brings in more service related business to Kerala, this is what is needed for educated Kerala society. Also more and business will come in considering the talents could move more freely within the state, will even consider setting up offices in kasargod/ Kollam etc. Also more freight trains could run in this slot and which free up the truck movement within the roads ( Ro Ro ) environmentally friendly. Existing property price will shoot up best in the country. Companies in Pune, Delhi and Mumbai will set up offices in Kerala considering availability of talents and better infrastructure. If you need your next generation to have a better life, please support. PS- I have already left the country, but always wish to come back, having lived in many countries, there is no place like Kerala, you would always want to come back to.

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @GROMHELLSCREAM7
    @GROMHELLSCREAM7 Місяць тому +7

    Even when the London underground was being built that faced a lot of backlash from the people in London during that time cause they were digging up the beautiful london city centres and creating traffic jams . But now london cant live without its underground and thats a fact . That paved way for other underground metros around the world . London Underground was only possible and was built in 1868 cause of the monarch. In kerala the government doesn’t want to go against people and build it cause they may loose votes for the next election. But if the government goes against everyone and builds this in the future the it will be called as a revolutionary idea that changed kerala its infrastructure and business possibilities. Mark my words

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @agarshk1413
    @agarshk1413 Місяць тому +8

    അവിടെ ആണ് പ്രശനം ഇന്ന് തുടങ്ങി എന്നോ തീരാൻ പോകുന്ന ഈ പ്രൊജക്റ്റ്‌ ണ് 200 km വേഗത മതിയോ Atleast സമയ താമസം അഡ്വാൻസ് ചെയ്യണ്ടേ 10 കൊല്ലത്തിനു ശേഷം നമുക്ക് 200 km സ്പീഡിൽ പോയാൽ മതിയോ
    പോരാ കാരണം അവിടെ നമ്മൾ വീണ്ടും പിന്നിലേക്കാണ് പോകുന്നത്

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @theduke1654
    @theduke1654 Місяць тому +4

    The high speed rail is absolutely essential here in India. Nobody disagrees with that but the problem occurs when a state begins to create this network without the necessary funding . The high speed networks in other countries are developed in hand with the central government not with the provinces. In the case of India the indian Railways should be initializing this process along with the state working in hand to hand.

  • @awizard-iam
    @awizard-iam 29 днів тому

    The problem with current project is its only semi high speed with maximum speed of 200 km/hr only... even new vande bharath has 200 km/hr max. Speed.. we need high speed rail or hyper loop trains for future use

  • @FreethinkerReborn
    @FreethinkerReborn Місяць тому +2

    With proper planning, convincing and after settling peoples projects need to be done. Not like just laying stones and waiting for years to start it

  • @nikhil.k8938
    @nikhil.k8938 Місяць тому +6

    old people live in stone age

  • @amalkrishnan8838
    @amalkrishnan8838 Місяць тому +2

    K rail വേണം അത് വേണ്ട എന്ന് പറയുന്നില്ല but before that അടിസ്ഥാന വികസനം വേണ്ടേ.സുഖമമായി പോകാൻ നല്ല റോഡ്, പാവപ്പെട്ടവർക്ക് കിടക്കാൻ വീട്, പുതു തലമുറയ്ക്ക് ജോലി,നല്ല ജീവിത്ചുറ്റുപാട് ….ഇതൊക്കെ നിലനിൽകുമ്പോൾ ആണോ k rail… ശമ്പളം കൊടുക്കുന്നില്ല, psc വിജ്ഞാപനം കുറയ്ക്കുന്നു,വൃദ്ധജനങ്ങൾക്ക് പെൻഷൻ ഇല്ല…ഇത്രയും ബുദ്ധിമുട്ടുകൾ അനുഭവിക്കുമ്പോഴും k rail is more essential for kerala govt …..

    • @aswinsadanandan4110
      @aswinsadanandan4110 Місяць тому

      ലോകത്തിൽ ഏറ്റവും പട്ടിണി ഉള്ള രാജ്യമാണ് ഇന്ത്യ. എന്ന് വെച്ച് ISRO പിരിച്ചു വിടേണ്ട അവശ്യം ഇല്ലല്ലോ.

    • @HamsterWorld007
      @HamsterWorld007 Місяць тому

      Krail start cheythal ethra perk joli kittumennu ariyalo

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      By loan from wprld bank t hat You will pay.
      DID YOUR WATER BILL AND ELECTRICITY BILL RISE. WHAT ABOUT FINES, 😂​@@HamsterWorld007

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      ​@@HamsterWorld007 KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @abijithp92
    @abijithp92 Місяць тому +20

    കേരളത്തിൽ krail വരാൻ ഒരിക്കലും കേന്ദ്രസർക്കാർ സമ്മതിക്കില്ല
    ഇന്ത്യൻ റെയിൽവേയിലേക്ക് ഏറ്റവും കൂടുതൽ വരുമാനം നൽകുന്നത് കേരളമാണ് . അത് നശിപ്പിക്കാൻ അവർ സമ്മതിക്കില്ല

    • @Pau-g8f
      @Pau-g8f Місяць тому +2

      Always politics politics politics. Just think what you want rather than blaming politics.

    • @badbad-cat
      @badbad-cat Місяць тому

      ​@@Pau-g8f it's central government politics against federalism

    • @aiswaryagirishkumar94
      @aiswaryagirishkumar94 Місяць тому

      Ath shariya metro cities & janasankhya kuduthalulla statesnekkalum Indian railwayk labham keralathil odunna trainludeya😝😝

    • @noobpolymath3771
      @noobpolymath3771 23 дні тому

      ​@@aiswaryagirishkumar94 research aanu main ennu thonunundu..😂

  • @sarathsk849
    @sarathsk849 Місяць тому +1

    WE ARE NOT AT ALL IMPROVING ENOUGH, EVEN IN INDIAN RAILWAY SPEED,THE LARGEST TRANSPORTER.

  • @bijudevasia4416
    @bijudevasia4416 Місяць тому

    Appreciate your views. this is the truth. here the dirty politics is spoiling every initiative.

  • @nikhil.k8938
    @nikhil.k8938 Місяць тому +5

    he should be our cm

    • @badbad-cat
      @badbad-cat Місяць тому

      എന്നിട്ട് വേണം അയാളെ തെറിവിളിക്കാൻ

  • @sujithkumar2041
    @sujithkumar2041 Місяць тому +10

    We want a high speed rail owned by state gvt, not by union gvt.

    • @roypaul5229
      @roypaul5229 Місяць тому +5

      Athentha keralathil ullever high speedil poyi vere statesil work cheyenda ennano

    • @Nnss-yb6vb
      @Nnss-yb6vb Місяць тому +2

      Ath thanghal mathram paranna mathiyo
      Central government manage cheythal atha kuzhappam?

    • @Karthii077
      @Karthii077 Місяць тому +2

      Also say, don't want money from union govt

    • @sujithkumar2041
      @sujithkumar2041 Місяць тому +1

      @ The money that Union Gvt collects is from the ppl and the gst contributions from state gvt. They are bound to serve the ppl.

    • @daniel11111
      @daniel11111 Місяць тому

      @@Karthii077we will when union government stop stealing tax from Kerala.

  • @tenzoccamaario
    @tenzoccamaario Місяць тому +1

    SGK💯💯🔥

  • @nasrani9936
    @nasrani9936 29 днів тому

    It is good to have high speed rail(not the semi HSR Silver Line). But the finances of kerala is not good for the job. Kerala can’t afford such an expensive project. Environmental concerns exist too.
    Best option is to build on the existing Rail line and work with Indian Railways to improve the speeds.

  • @aiswaryagirishkumar94
    @aiswaryagirishkumar94 Місяць тому +1

    To all who blindly follows SGK, with all due respect, let me say appreciate his enthusiasm for developments, but to blindly trust kerala govt is stupidity in this scenario since we're already in debt. Besides, K-rail is a state initiative project, whereas a highway is a national initiative project. Hence, the k-rail is not completely funded by central govt. Let the state government fulfil all the requirements of flood affected people beginning from 2018 & afterwards let's talk.!
    To top it off, does people really expect cost of high-speed train reasonable? How about maintenance charges? My recent daytrip from Paris to Strasbourg costed 50k up & down (2 people) for a high speed train. Not exaggerating or bluffing, I've travelled in Europe, MiddleEast & Asian countries & frankly do not expect a high speed train for 1000/- Rs. ticket.! If only, our state is open to business we can improve economically & without that development at first, what's the use of being inspired by rail story of Europe building tracks but train during iron age.?! Yes, we need developments but the vision should be executed from scratch..
    Also, to add with this view, comparisons with a disciplined nation like China though populated is of no use, likewise a comparison with less populated western & european countries again a moot point.!

    • @CONTINENTALSONGS
      @CONTINENTALSONGS Місяць тому

      True
      KERALA IS A STATE WITH NO INCOME. NO INCOME EXCEPT TAXES TAXES. WILL YOU BUY A BMW WHEN YOU ARE BROKE. WE HAVE NO LARGE INDUSTRIES. AI CAN DESTROY OUR TECHNKPARK. WE ARE UNDER MORE THAN 4.5LAKH CRORE IN DEBT. WHO WILL PAY THIS LOAN. OUR 71 PERCENTAGE OF STATE INCOME IS SENT TO PAY INTREST AND SALARY. KERALA IS A FAILED STATE IF FOREIGN MONEY CEASES TO COME. POINT TO BE NOTED MANY ARE SETTLING IN FOREIGN COUNTRIES.

  • @Visible_god
    @Visible_god Місяць тому +2

    We need k rail❤

  • @Jesssco
    @Jesssco 28 днів тому +1

    Most of the mallu people have high vidyabyasm. But no Vivaram!

  • @sajinahamed9156
    @sajinahamed9156 9 днів тому

    The simple.fact is that it is not affordable for most people.
    Building highways is a more viable option.
    A vandhebharat ticket from ernakulam to calicut is 780 inr and a round trip 1,600 and who in their right mind would pay this sum of money for daily commute

  • @AbinSajiSebastian
    @AbinSajiSebastian Місяць тому +1

    SGK for PM

  • @grenjith
    @grenjith Місяць тому +1

    Somebody will send innova to his house. He has been consistently talking and raising awareness to improve our state. I don’t think he will succeed in his life time in seeing a real improvement , but he still continues to try. Only result I see is young people get frustrated and get out of here. They realized that they are taken for a ride by authorities and don’t want it anymore.

  • @thomasanil77
    @thomasanil77 Місяць тому +1

    High speed train may be good but do we have employment industries in Kerala to reach at this speed. First we need employment and to reach our employment place may be these speedy train useful.

  • @danieldenomandenza
    @danieldenomandenza Місяць тому

    🎉🎉🎉🎉 Speed rail should come.

  • @prabutruth
    @prabutruth Місяць тому +8

    its about feasibility

    • @dabbbaded1342
      @dabbbaded1342 Місяць тому +5

      feasibility for old people and those nearing retirement.
      future for young generation.
      If you stop basic projects like high speed transportation citing feasibility, kerala will lose even more young people to permanent migration to other countries or other indian metro cities.
      I understand you, and other k7 old thantha vibe people will probably die in like 20 years maximum and so its not your problem. also you may have already sent your children to uk and canada.
      cheers. aarka ithra dhrithi.

    • @prabutruth
      @prabutruth Місяць тому

      @dabbbaded1342 do you even know what feasibility is

    • @aaro7788
      @aaro7788 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@prabutruthnothing will be feasible if foolish people like u try to bring down a project from the root itself

    • @MithunOnTheNet
      @MithunOnTheNet Місяць тому

      It will be feasible in the long run, no doubt about it! No HSR project turned profitable overnight. Do you know China's HSR network, despite all their bragging, is sitting on 900 BILLION of debt?! That's what happens when you chase records instead of being practical. Indian government isn't trying to launch an HSR network that rivals China's length in 10 or 20 years. It may take us 40 or 50 years, so be it! Let's do it phase-by-phase, and based on demand and per capita incomes.
      My only issue with Silverline was Kerala govt. was going to use older technology to travel less than 280 kms at a lower cost. Fine, but is that future proof? What if we need to upgrade the trains later in the future to make them up to speed with the Bengaluru to Chennair route which will be 300+ kmph at launch? Silverline's same tracks can be used? Our politicians NEVER think longterm.

    • @divin74
      @divin74 Місяць тому

      In India highest occupancy rate of Vande Bharat is in KERALA. So high speed rail system is very feasible in Kerala.

  • @shameerks8242
    @shameerks8242 Місяць тому +2

    ഇന്ത്യൻ റെയിൽവേയിൽ യാത്ര ചെയ്യുന്ന ഒരാൾ എന്ന നിലക് ഇന്ത്യൻ റൈലിന്റെ ചില സവിശേഷതകൾ പറയാം 20 ഡേയ്സ് മുൻപ് ബുക്ക് ചെയ്താലും ടിക്കറ്റ് കൺഫോം ആകില്ലേ.3 ac യിൽ വരെ ടിക്കറ്റ് ഇല്ലാത്തവരും ഉള്ളവരും വന്നു tt ക്ക് പൈസ കൊടുത്ത് തള്ളി കയറുന്നു. ടോയ്ലറ്റ് വൃത്തി അടുത്ത് പോലും ഇല്ല നോർത്തിൽ പ്രത്യേകിച്ച്. Time ൽ എത്താൻ വളരെ സാധ്യത കുറവ്. സ്വാതന്ത്ര്യം കിട്ടിയിട്ട് ഇത്ര ആയിട്ടും ഇതൊന്നു ശരിയാക്കാൻ ഇതുവരെ കഴിഞ്ഞില്ല ഇനി വേണ്ടത് hi സ്പീഡിൽ എത്താവുന്ന പുതിയ ഗതാഗത മാർഗമാണ് വേണ്ടത് എപ്പോൾ ബുക്ക് ചെയ്താലും മിനിമം അന്ന് തന്നെ ഇരുന്നെങ്കിലും യാത്ര ചെയ്യാൻ പറ്റാവുന്ന വേഗത്തിൽ ഏതാവുന്ന

  • @rashid9826
    @rashid9826 Місяць тому

    Option 1 - Upgrading Existing Line: Costs ₹26,600-₹53,200 crore, with faster implementation, minimal land acquisition, and alignment constraints resolved for consistent 300 km/h speeds.
    Option 2 - Greenfield Line: Costs ₹79,800-₹1,33,000 crore, ensures a dedicated high-speed corridor but involves higher costs, extensive land acquisition, and longer timelines.
    Which is better option?

    • @noobpolymath3771
      @noobpolymath3771 23 дні тому

      In India existing trains cannot run beyond 180kmph..
      That is why ahemdabad, Mumbai bullet train needs a seperate line..
      The specifications for high speed railway is very high, existing lanes cannot be brought to that level.with out a MAJOR overhaul...

  • @anoopsivadas
    @anoopsivadas Місяць тому +1

    🔥❤️❤️

  • @Indhra07
    @Indhra07 Місяць тому +1

    It is not about the facility, it's about affordability. Reason I believe K rail should not come.
    1. This should be a national project with proper standardization, we cannot decide things like this and remake everything when high speed rails are introduced nationwide.
    2. Cost of travel and affordability. The k rail is a huge project but is it affordable by the state government, it's a different story for the central government but the state government is in huge debt and is not economically feasible with the state budget.
    3. Environment impact study, all the studies on the project is like engineering students project work without and proper studies. No proper studies are conducted till now.
    4. Highly corrupt government. This govt has been spending money and wasting money on new bus converting old bus to class room, wasting money on Kerala tour in luxury bus, no proper state development work anywhere. And all interest in just k rail.
    5. Is it currently demanded by the public, the requirement of travel from kasarkod to trivandrum is low but even when the requirement is high what we actually need is additional railway lines for parallel travel and more number of trains. The government is not doing that because it is not economical. They say if one more train started from kasarkod to trivandrum it will lead to loss because there are not enough passengers to fill a complete new train. Now we are discussing creating a new railway system with a different gauge than the national gauge, with standalone railway lines, station and everything to increase speed just 40km/hr than vande bharat.
    6. People are not too concerned about time. All these can be easily achieved by flights from different districts to districts. But it is very costly now because there are not enough requirements for fast travel. If 10% of this cost can be invested in airports and airlines the same time can be saved. Unlike China US employs this strategy.
    7. High speed roadways. An 6 lain or 8 lain road way is the first we need to control traffic and connectivity Kerala with 600 km can easily be covered in lass than 6 hr with this road connectivity and can extend to parallel districts like Idukki palakkad Pathanamthitta etc. it can also be easily connected with interstate highways.
    This project is not like creating a statue the cost is huge, very huge.
    Let's follow how china built this and do thing step by step. Like first road ways, increase economy, eliminate corruption, plan properly, do feasibility study and then create a high speed rail properly.

  • @Yxhap-id8bj
    @Yxhap-id8bj Місяць тому +2

    We are 30 yr behind world

  • @raizamrn7118
    @raizamrn7118 Місяць тому

  • @s_s_rsh
    @s_s_rsh Місяць тому +3

    Njan uaeyil daily 120km one side travel cheyth jolikk pokunna oraal aanu. Less than 1.5 hrs required.
    Nattil ethelum kaalath ithu chinthikkan pattumo?

  • @sajith8287
    @sajith8287 24 дні тому

    The geographical and demographical condition of kerala is different from European countries.
    We need speed but that doesn't means we should compromise on ecological side.

  • @skz1722
    @skz1722 Місяць тому

    Having a good fast rail system is good
    But the issue is people dont trust the present governance to do a good job
    When they cant even provide good roads
    Just as rail is important
    Roads are important too
    Its basically lack of trust of the people not lack of knowing we need fast trains

  • @tomjose3340
    @tomjose3340 Місяць тому

    💯

  • @farhananishad1611
    @farhananishad1611 Місяць тому

    👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @Aneeshr717
    @Aneeshr717 Місяць тому +3

    സന്തോഷേട്ടൻ .. 🥰 ഒറ്റ പേര് .. SGK ..

  • @robinxeona99
    @robinxeona99 Місяць тому +3

    ചൈനയിലെ ഭൂപ്രകൃതി അല്ല നമ്മുടെ ഭൂപ്രകൃതി.

    • @tomvarghesejoy9334
      @tomvarghesejoy9334 Місяць тому +1

      Athaaanu

    • @nasrani9936
      @nasrani9936 29 днів тому +1

      ചൈനയുടെ സാമ്പത്തിക സ്ഥിതി അല്ല നമ്മുടെ സാമ്പത്തിക സ്ഥിതി.

    • @robinxeona99
      @robinxeona99 29 днів тому

      അതും ശരിയാണ് നമുക്ക് വേണ്ടത് നമ്മുടെ മണ്ണിന് ചേരുന്ന വികസനമാണ്. അല്ലാതെ ലോകത്ത് ഉള്ളത് എല്ലാം ഇവിടെ പ്രായോഗികം ആവണം എന്ന് ഒരു നിർബന്ധവും ഇല്ല.

  • @technoville
    @technoville 29 днів тому

    Do whatever you want! But people have sovereignty over their land!

  • @newtrendzzzzappu5757
    @newtrendzzzzappu5757 25 днів тому

    But it should not affect people by demolishing their homes...where will I go if they demolish my home

  • @anwarsadik9155
    @anwarsadik9155 Місяць тому +1

    എനിക്ക് കിട്ടിയില്ല സോ ബാകിയുള്ളവർക്കും കിട്ടേണ്ട ഈ ഒരു മൈൻഡ്സെറ്റ് മാത്രമാണ് എതിർക്കുന്നവർക്കെല്ലാം

  • @sohrabmohamed1213
    @sohrabmohamed1213 Місяць тому

    And people who are projecting Vande bharat as tye alternative, Try booking ine when you want to go somewhere in two days. Highspeed trains are the need of the hour

  • @Itsmeonline7
    @Itsmeonline7 Місяць тому +1

    We need speed , paying taxes like england and getting services like somalia , that's what I wanna mention here

  • @hr_47
    @hr_47 Місяць тому +31

    We need a fast rail, but not the way it was proposed through K- Rail. Proposal was inherently infeasible and such an inefficient way to spend money.

    • @exgod1
      @exgod1 Місяць тому +13

      Please watch Prof C Ravichandran"s analysis abt K- Rail & fluff off. Your statement can be regurgitated about any project.

    • @azharanvar3207
      @azharanvar3207 Місяць тому +12

      Brother..I can strongly say that Kerala will be the only state which can run bullet train or high speed train in feasible way..not a single state can run like that..they can do it in city only..

    • @LucatheShibaPrince
      @LucatheShibaPrince Місяць тому

      On what basis you are saying krail is ineffient, you are a blind moron

    • @ajmalghan
      @ajmalghan Місяць тому +2

      Bullet train, 300kmphr, is not suitable for Kerala. Because in that case, Train will have a smaller number of stops.

    • @ajmal3256
      @ajmal3256 Місяць тому +4

      Yes proposal was just not improve infrastructure but a way to improve Maasapadi of maasapdi Vedi Veena Bijyan

  • @vipincool5475
    @vipincool5475 Місяць тому +1

    💯✅

  • @madhusudanpunnakkalappu5253
    @madhusudanpunnakkalappu5253 Місяць тому +1

    High speed transportation is certainly a requirement but for that existing rail network needs to be upgraded. Peoples doubts about K-rail project is still not clarified by the incumbent government and hence the backlash.

  • @jayanthlaxman9188
    @jayanthlaxman9188 Місяць тому +5

    We need to build a high speed rail on pillars on top of the existing rails. No need to aquire new land. By the way, give the contract to Chinese. We would have a world-class railway by 2028.

    • @adkrsh3995
      @adkrsh3995 Місяць тому +2

      Too many curves

    • @rithwikkuzhippat3450
      @rithwikkuzhippat3450 29 днів тому

      This leads to capacity issues. The construction of a new lines will be required if we need to maintain a high speed high frequency line alongside our current fleet.

  • @Sasuke-04
    @Sasuke-04 Місяць тому +3

    K rail matti 300+km/hr HSR conduvaram

  • @helium369
    @helium369 Місяць тому +6

    Please manage the existing Rail network to global standards

    • @GenesisPaul-y2f
      @GenesisPaul-y2f Місяць тому +8

      That belongs to central government.. not gonna happen in near future .. Because ours is a big country..

    • @vishnujain7645
      @vishnujain7645 Місяць тому

      ​@@GenesisPaul-y2fAnd you think for the state government a project like K-rail will be feasible?😂.
      Kerala is already in huge debt, this kind of mega projects is impossible. It's common sense an economy like ours can't afford this type of public transportation. This will only stay on paper and the parties involved wil make some quick bucks.
      Projects like Sabari rail hasn't received any support from various governments in Kerala , if the adequate support from state was given the central ministry could have gone with project like that. But it's been been more than 25 years and many funds were allocated. It's still mired in troubles between centre and state.
      The K-rail is just a vanity project to make some money.

    • @How_to_become_an_atheistt
      @How_to_become_an_atheistt Місяць тому

      Not possible

    • @akshaimurali668
      @akshaimurali668 Місяць тому

      ​@@vishnujain7645enn oru sanga putran

  • @krishnakumarunnithan387
    @krishnakumarunnithan387 Місяць тому

    Thank God at least our national highway work is in (slow ) progress due to Nithin Gadkari and our kochi metro in working condition due to Metro Sreedharan Sir with support of central and state government ❤

  • @francofrancis7439
    @francofrancis7439 Місяць тому

    Yes we need trains if there is no fiscal deficit.

  • @jalfar24
    @jalfar24 Місяць тому

    Please make him the Chief Minister of Kerala...

  • @amalraj8032
    @amalraj8032 Місяць тому

    11:26 ഞാൻ അങ്ങനെ ചിന്തിക്കുന്ന ഒരു വ്യക്തി ആണ് 😜😜

  • @damayanthi9528
    @damayanthi9528 Місяць тому +1

    The political parties like the Indian National Congress and bjp prioritize power and personal gain over the welfare of their citizens. For India to truly rival China's remarkable progress, we must put aside our differences and unite for a common goal: building a brighter future for every Indian.

  • @nizamoomer5182
    @nizamoomer5182 Місяць тому +12

    വിമാനം ആകാശത്തു കൂടി ആണ് പറക്കുന്നത്. പക്ഷെ k റെയിൽ കഷ്ടപ്പെട്ട് ഉണ്ടാക്കിയ സമ്പാദ്യമായ ഒരു വീട് പൊളിച്ചു കൊണ്ട് ആണ് എന്നത് ആണ് പ്രശ്നം... അതിന് നഷ്ടം ഉണ്ടാകാതെ മാന്യമായി തന്നെ പുനരദിവാസം ഉറപ്പാക്കിയാൽ മാത്രം മതി... ആർക്കാണ് k റെയിൽ വേണ്ടെന്ന് അഭിപ്രായം... അതിന്റെ ആശങ്കകൾ ആണ് പരിഹരിക്കേണ്ടത്

    • @harikrishnanuk2330
      @harikrishnanuk2330 Місяць тому +15

      കെ റെയിൽ വേണ്ട എന്നാണോ പറയുന്നത്?? കഷ്ടം കേരളത്തെ രണ്ടാക്കി മുറിക്കും എന്നാണ് കെ റെയിൽ വിരുദ്ധർ പറയുന്നത്.. ഏറ്റവും മികച്ച രീതിയിൽ ഉള്ള നഷ്ടപരിഹാരം ആണ് നൽ lകുന്നത് അത് ലഭിച്ച ശേഷം മാത്രം വീട് ഒഴിഞ്ഞു കൊടുത്താൽ മതി......ഇന്ന് കാണുന്ന റോഡുകൾ എല്ലാം ഒരു കാലത്ത് മറ്റുള്ളവരുടെ വീടും പറമ്പും ഒക്കെ ആയിരുന്നു എന്ന് കൂടി ഓർക്കണം

    • @zackbackyardiz
      @zackbackyardiz Місяць тому +1

      ​@harikrishnanuk2330 yes highway ullavrk ellam same price avar udeshichath kitiyirunnu athum market value spot value

    • @raghunathtk7945
      @raghunathtk7945 Місяць тому

      George Kulangara thinks that he is the jack of all. You stick to your Safari travel channel, please don't meddle in everything and start preaching to others.

    • @roypaul5229
      @roypaul5229 Місяць тому

      ​@@harikrishnanuk2330krail keralathe randayi murikum ennulla ashanka anu athu thetanegil adhine vishidhekerikendunethu sarkar alle enthe aver reply therunila

    • @aaro7788
      @aaro7788 Місяць тому +1

      First of all ജീവിത സമ്പാദ്യം വീടിനു വേണ്ടി invest ചെയിത ചേട്ടൻ എന്റെ നടു വിരൽ നമസ്കാരം 🤣😂4 പേരെ കാണിക്കാൻ മാളിക പോലെ വീട് പണിയും എന്നിട്ട് കൊച്ചുങ്ങൾ പഠിക്കുമ്പോൾ അത് 10 20 ലക്ഷം rs loan എടുത്തു വീണ്ടും വാടക വീട്ടിൽ താമസിക്കുന്നത് പോലെ താമസിക്കും...പുനരദിവസം ഏത് project included ആണ്... അതിനെ പറ്റി സംസാരിക്കാൻ പോലും കൂട്ടക്കാതെ ഏഷ്യാനെറ്റ്‌ പോലെ മാധ്യമ വേശ്യകളും വാക്കി political പാർട്ടി വാണങ്ങളും ഇല്ലാതെ ആക്കിയതാണ് krail പോലെ ഒരു project

  • @BasilAzeez
    @BasilAzeez 29 днів тому

    Do you want names? Or was that a rhetorical question?

  • @rashid9826
    @rashid9826 Місяць тому +1

    As first option, Exiting railway line need to be increased to 4 lanes and made fully efficient.
    Krail should be secondary option.

    • @vinayak90417
      @vinayak90417 Місяць тому

      If such a railway transportation exist then why 4 lanes!!?? Noone goes on road by that time lol

  • @blackdragon9582
    @blackdragon9582 Місяць тому +6

    Umma Thomas😂

  • @syam401
    @syam401 Місяць тому +2

    well said, sir
    ethokke kelkkumbol chirichu pokuvanu, pravasi title peri 7 kollamunne naadu vitta birudanandhara birudhadhari aanu njn, anikku offer cheytha salary 11500 rs per month aayirunnu, aah same figure dirhathil medikkuvanu eppol..!! melle pokku nayam aanu marendath.
    Job security aanu gvt employees melle pokkukar aayi mariyathinu karanam, target, perfomance okke evaluate cheythu salary kodukkukaum, job nashtapedukaum, kittukaum okke aayirunnel nammude naadu rakshapettene pande!

  • @iiissasuttu7
    @iiissasuttu7 29 днів тому

    K rail, വേണം വാട്ടർ സർവീസ് വേണം , എല്ലാ പുരോഗമനവും വേണം, എല്ലാവര്ക്കും അത് ഉപയോഗപ്പെടുത്താൻ ആഗ്രഹവുമുണ്ട്, പക്ഷെ അത് മൂലമുണ്ടാകുന്ന ജനങ്ങളുടെ displacement ജനങ്ങളുടെ കൃഷി, വീടും സ്ഥലവും തുടങ്ങിയ ഒരു ആയുസു കൊണ്ട് ഉണ്ടാക്കിയ ബൗദ്ധിക സാഹചര്യങ്ങളെ ഒരു തരത്തിലുള്ള ലാഭവുമില്ലാതെ കൊടുക്കാൻ ഈ തൊപ്പിയിട്ട വലിയവായിൽ സംസാരിക്കുന്ന ‘സഞ്ചാരി’ പോലും തയ്യാറാവില്ല. തൊട്ടടുത്ത സംസ്ഥാനത്തെ റേഷൻ കടകളിലൂടെ 30 kg അരിയും പരിപ്പും കടലയും പഞ്ചസാരയും തികച്ചും സൗജന്യമായി ( APL , BPL കാർഡ് വ്യത്യാസമില്ലാതെ ) ഇവിടേ ജനങ്ങൾ വിലക്കയറ്റത്തെ പേടിയോടെ കണ്ടു ജീവിച്ചു മരിക്കുകയാണ്. ഇത്ര അധികം അനീതി നിറഞ്ഞ ഒരു ഭരണ കാലം ഉണ്ടായിട്ടില്ല

    • @noobpolymath3771
      @noobpolymath3771 23 дні тому

      😂... Government cash marathinnu kulukki undakunathalla..

  • @hariknr3025
    @hariknr3025 Місяць тому +12

    But what's our income? Are we getting salaries same as china and Europe?howany can afford daily high speed trains?

    • @alfredsunny800
      @alfredsunny800 Місяць тому +13

      Vandhebharat is running profits krail ticket rate is also similar to vandebharat

    • @ALOYSIUSANTOK
      @ALOYSIUSANTOK Місяць тому +14

      High speed transport directly contributes to economics growth and development.

    • @user-ng3rl5tb1q
      @user-ng3rl5tb1q Місяць тому +11

      Deyyy ....ethu lokhath aadeyy jeevikkunne .....

    • @arvi8873
      @arvi8873 Місяць тому +6

      Income varane development kude side il varanam mr. Alpam bhudhi upayogik mr. Metro vannapo ninne pole ullavar eth tanne paranje epol enthayi

    • @cientiste
      @cientiste Місяць тому +3

      developmnt illenkil.. pinne engneya slary kooduthak kitta..

  • @josephooken83
    @josephooken83 Місяць тому +12

    we needs at first good roads !! china and india ,day and night !!

  • @ashin2252
    @ashin2252 Місяць тому

    6:35 വിദേശത്തൊക്കെ അവിടെ ഉള്ളവർക്കു അറിയാം ഭാവിയിൽ വാഹനം കൂടും. അതിന് അനുസരിച്ച് കെട്ടിടവും റോഡും ഉണ്ടാകും. ഇവിടെ നേരെ ഓപ്പോസിറ്റ്

  • @pnsasi4720
    @pnsasi4720 Місяць тому +14

    എന്താണിത്ര ധൃതി എന്ന് ചോദിച്ച് കുറ്റി പറിക്കാൻ നടക്കുന്ന കോൺഗ്രസ് നേതാക്കളാണ് ഇവിടെ ഉള്ളത്

  • @benjaminmathew4108
    @benjaminmathew4108 Місяць тому

    Not KRail but a fast train under the Indian railway