The Gathering Storm (Wheel Of Time) Speculation, Ideas & Theories | Part 1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 62

  • @DavyCDiamondback
    @DavyCDiamondback Рік тому +1

    The Egweyen Julius Caesar, parallels made my ❤

  • @DmGray
    @DmGray Рік тому +1

    Reading Sanderson's WoT entries was my introduction to his work.
    The fact he did such a good job is very revealing. Respectful of a man whose work he loved, genuinely trying to fulfil all of the promises RJ made and, if you ever listen to his commentary on the subject, EXTREMELY humble about the flaws he sees. We were robbed of what RJ might have made of the last books, but I think every WoT fan can have nothing but respect for the man who gave us the resolution that the story deserved.
    I personally also think Taim was meant to be an original forsaken, indeed Damandred. I actually think I like the change tbh. The idea that a forsaken was operating ENTIRELY unapposed and was very much the hero of his own story... I like that. As much as Jordan absolutely loved the trope of evil being its own worst enemy, I also think he very much pointed to the flaws of even the best of people planting the seeds of malice. If Lews-Therin had not been such an arrogant jerk, it is unlikely Demandred would have switched sides. His first steps towards the Dark One were made through jealousy, for sure, but ALSO through mistreatment both real and perceived. And I think that is often mirrored in the real world. (almost every bully was a victim first. But not every victim chooses to become a bully. Demandred's choices are not justified, but they are not without genuine motive. Including wanting to save people... he just lacked the hope to do so by opposing the dark one)
    And you absolutely smashed the Semirhage interrogation Cadsuane goes for.
    Humiliation is *absolutely* used as a technique to break people, and Cadsuane is VERY aware of her own pride. Her thinking in these scenes is part of why I love her character so much. She might be old and wise, but that doesn't make her perfect. She simply understands herself better than most.

  • @kutlwanomongae152
    @kutlwanomongae152 Рік тому +2

    Elayne for sure. Perin's story is I feel the most looked over. Having your entire family killed, then finding love just to have her kidnapped. I can't imagine what's going on psychologicaly.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      Yeah I agree, he has had a very mundane battle also, in comparison to Mats rollercoaster ride being kept on the rails by his luck and Rands (although awful) being aided by his incredible chanelling ability.
      However I’d much rather have Perrins arc then Rands, the madness would be too much for me

  • @gizmoochi
    @gizmoochi Рік тому +2

    Ahhh, Avienda's punishment. Such great memories....

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      Yeah it seems to keep worsening! Excited to find out what the point is!

  • @theRumbleChannel
    @theRumbleChannel Рік тому +4

    Love watching your videos. It reminds me of my first time reading the Wheel of Time :). And your speculations are always interesting too. Sometimes astoundingly accurate, sometimes wrong, but even those make sense most of the time :)
    I'm excited for your upcoming videos as you finish this journey through one of the most epic stories ever written (IMO) :)

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      Thanks Rumble! It’s been fun, frustrating, epic, surprising, beautiful and at time dulls. However, the sheer vastness of the world and the story itself coupled with the depth of characters and lore it definitely puts it near or at the top of the list of epic fantasies.

    • @theRumbleChannel
      @theRumbleChannel Рік тому +1

      ​@@conorreads I suppose it's a different experience when you read everything in one go. When I started "only" the first 7 books where released, so whenever the the next one came out I was all too happy to return to Rand Land :). And the last three books had a profound impact on how I view the series as whole. Enjoy the ride :)!

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      @@theRumbleChannel yeah overall I think being able to read them all at my leisure is better because the waiting would kill me. However, I do think I’d be a bit disappointed after waiting a year or two for one or two books.
      Overall though I like being able yo go through them, and I feel like it is probably a very different experience

  • @raea29
    @raea29 Рік тому +2

    Glad you are enjoying the book and haven't been put off by the writing style. Sanderson has said he didn't want to just emulate Jordan because it would feel wrong and simply not be as good anyway, so the content is what Jordan laid out but the writing is Sandersons. I do believe as well that Harriet gave huge amounts of freedom to fill the gaps with characters and stories that hadn't specifically been penned by Jordan. On top of that the end was supposed to be 1 (maybe 2) books and not 3.
    As for your question, if you include Elayne on that list it has to be her who had the easiest time. As you said, she has achieved and developed in her own right but she has rarely if at all had to struggle to do something completely alone. Also many of her struggles (approaching the Black in Caemlyn) were caused directly by her not taking advantage of those people she has relied so heavily on.
    I think everyone else has had aspects of support and things handed to them but have really had to overcome things completely alone a number of times.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      His style is more simplistic I would say, I’ve not read from all the characters perspectives yet so and on out about 250 pages in rn so hard to make a judgement.
      But I don’t think it’s noticeably worse, in any way, just not as descriptive. I have enjoyed the lack of skirt smoothing so far though! He also tends not to comment on the size of every woman’s buxom aha.
      Yes I saw it was supposed to be 1! Glad there is 3!

    • @raea29
      @raea29 Рік тому +1

      @@conorreads Nail on the head with that one. He is often criticized for having basic prose but I guess it comes down to what you want/appreciate in reading. I love Tolkien but for his world and stories first and his style after.
      So true, what you lose in general description you gain by not having as many arms crossed under breasts.
      As an aside, it would be nice to have something after this book or the next (definitely before the final book) where you make some bigger predictions about the 'Last Battle' such as casualties (if you think there will be any), more than just the general theorizing during these videos.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      @@raea29 that’s a good idea, I could do one before the final book, or attach those into the final video of the penultimate book! Thanks!
      Yeah I feel like this deep into a beautifully described world I automatically imagine every woman crossing their arms under their breasts, smoothing their skirts and sniffing at anything they disagree with. So not having it constantly written in is not a problem 😂😂

    • @raea29
      @raea29 Рік тому +1

      @Conor Reads I know what you mean because on my most recent reread I didn't even notice they stopped being included in the text and I had just been mentally adding them throughout.

  • @Roski365
    @Roski365 Рік тому +2

    Elayne gets the princess ride for sure

  • @Kpchanneler
    @Kpchanneler Рік тому +1

    The thing i enjoyed the most about all the sanderson books is that i think he got to think like an editor and write what was needed which means he was less likely get lost in the world like jordan did during the slog.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      Yeah I see that, he must’ve trimmed a fair bit to make it so streamlined

  • @jarkody
    @jarkody Рік тому +2

    I thought at first we were picking from the Emonds Fielders, but yes Elayne has not had to pay as much dues as the rest of them. She thought she lost her mother too. Nynaeve was my next pick even though she paid lots of dues too. I love how all of these young people have become absolutely legendary. There is such a great need for them to do great things and to rise to the occasion, with the occasion being the Last Battle. I loved that Rand and the female Emonds Fielders were able to learn some lost weaves from the Forsaken.
    I’m finishing up book 13, but I’m sure you’re gonna beat me to it Conor lol. I think I’ll be sad to finish, but it’s gonna be fun to read it all over again.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      Yeah it’s incredible the impact that these people have had! Even people like gawyn and Galad etc!

  • @andrewolesen8773
    @andrewolesen8773 Рік тому +2

    I think Mat up to this point had it easier, the first two books with the sickness from the dagger were rough on him but that was self inflicted. Elayne's few calamity came from other people.

  • @Mahalleinir
    @Mahalleinir Рік тому +1

    I’ve never died either 🤪
    Lol I also really liked Masema’s moment of clarity, it doesn’t get a ton of attention from readers and fans so thanks for acknowledging it! I think upon reread, you’ll notice the hints for Masema, especially in the second and third books.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      Yeah I’m sure Jordan foreshadowed it

  • @stephenlogsdon8266
    @stephenlogsdon8266 Рік тому +1

    I’d be interested in hearing you go through the last 3 books. I loved this one, but liked them less and less as they continued, and for specific reasons.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      I went through them all my friend, why’s that?

  • @jamesmacleod9382
    @jamesmacleod9382 Рік тому +1

    Nobody really has an easy go of it, but Elayne perhaps to this point has a relatively smooth ride. She _was_ almost killed by the Golem but Mat saved her and she was also almost killed when her gate exploded but there's still a couple of thousand pages left. Anything can happen.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      Yeah I’m sure nobody has an easy ride at the end!
      True with regard to the Golem and the gate, there is definitely a lot of things I’ve forgotten as it’s such an epic sized adventure!
      Thanks for commenting

  • @0Arman0
    @0Arman0 Рік тому +1

    I would love for you to go back and do a "where my predictions right or wrong" video at the end !

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      I think I will do a look back at my predictions for Eye Of The World, I could be very funny as it was one of my very first videos on UA-cam also

  • @0Arman0
    @0Arman0 Рік тому +1

    Great recap! The foreward was incredible and had me tearing up for sure haha. He doesn't do it in either other book just so much respect for RJ. If you do go for a Sanderson book try mistborn era 1! Storm light archive is his epic but you probably need something short after this haha ;). Probably agree with you on Elayne. I really felt like the prologue too felt like this ominous spooky pre Halloween vibes like you know shits going down soon. Gahhh ending of this book is so good. Can't wait to see more vids!

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      Yeah it was very respectful and got me excited to read it!
      The farmer bit was so well done! Very Halloween now that you mention it.
      Yes bro I’ll see you at the end!

  • @LeahB31
    @LeahB31 Рік тому +1

    Elayne would also be my pick.

  • @aldan7812
    @aldan7812 Рік тому +1

    As always awesome vid bruv - I dont think anyone's cruised to success lol BUT who has had it the least hard? Out of the EF5 i'd have to say Nynaeve. Of our main cast i'd have to say Elayne

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      Yeah Nynaeve really had her development arc banged out in the early/mid books

  • @mcina001
    @mcina001 Рік тому +1

    Agreed among the 6 characters, Elayne has had the easiest road so far. You’re in for a treat. A fair number of people consider book 12 to be the best, and almost everyone agrees books 12-14 are a superb end to this epic journey.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      What did you think of the writing style change bro?

    • @mcina001
      @mcina001 Рік тому +1

      @@conorreads Didn’t bother me too much, since I assumed it would happen. I felt Mat was written most differently. I appreciated the focus on moving the plot along for sure!

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      @@mcina001 yeah your right that it was never going to be the same! The plot is flying now!

    • @mcina001
      @mcina001 Рік тому

      @@conorreads Soak it in. Looking forward to the rest of your reactions.

  • @Nathius_16
    @Nathius_16 Рік тому +1

    Your Demanded=Mazrim Taim theory is great! After you finish the books, I hope someone will be able to tell you a certain detail. Please remember to pick up that theory once you are all done, especially trying to figure out how you came up with this prediction.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      I’ll be deep diving all conspiracy theories and rabbit hole ideas around wheel of time once I’m finished!

    • @Nathius_16
      @Nathius_16 Рік тому +1

      @@conorreads Great! I am so looking forward to that! But for now, I am looking forward to each and every episode of your reading experience! Enjoy the ride! The rollercoaster has begun! 😉

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому +1

      @@Nathius_16 thanks brother

  • @gearomkologenas5458
    @gearomkologenas5458 Рік тому +1

    Nice start.
    This novel had some of the worst and best of post Jordan Death writing because it largely focuses on two main staging areas, with relatively short detours.
    The answer to your question actually might help with the later Seasons of the TV adaptation, if they’re open minded enough to understand how best to use it.
    Elayne is definitely the Main Character who has had the smoothest run. And that makes sense because she was part of the ruling fabric of the world when the story started and given the relative independence she’s enjoyed as a result of teaming up with our Duopotamian Adventurers, she’s been able to largely avoid the worst travails things like her Aes Sedai Training might have entailed.
    She’s had her skull cracked a couple of times while questing, but like you said, someone (Nynaeve in this case) has always been there to save her skin.
    Also, even though her Mother ‘Died’ according to what she knew, she was insulated from that by both her upbringing and expectation of Succession as Daughter-Heir. Not to mention her deep involvement with unfolding events in Salidar, at about the time she would have found out.
    Moiraine has also had a pretty easy run of it, given that while she may have occasionally been frustrated by Rand and Mat and to a lesser extent Perrin and the girls, she ended up in a kind of purgatorial stasis, waiting for Mat to come and save her, after ambushing Lanfear into Finnland before she could complete her destruction of a nonsensically chivalrous Rand.
    I was never a fan of Egwene, but this is perhaps her best Arc throughout the series, because she’s awesome throughout the whole book.
    Looking forward to seeing your reaction to Mat from here on out.
    Cheers Conor. Almost there mate!

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      You use some very fancy words and that was very fun to read!
      I really didn’t like Egwene at all (not sure I do now!) but I can’t argue against her being the most effective leader and the purest to her ideals now!
      Buzzing for the rest of the book!

  • @shellysedai1930
    @shellysedai1930 Рік тому +1

    Hello Conor. Great review as usual. I'd probably have to agree about Elayne being the one who has had it the (relatively) easiest up to this point. I can't wait for you to get further into the book. It happens to be one of my top 5. So-o-o-o-o-o-o much good stuff happens. Tons of OMG moments :). BTW, season 2 of the Wheel of Time on Amazon is coming out on September 1st! do you think you will be done with all of the books to watch season 1 & start season 2...? Enquiring minds wanna know :)

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      I believe I should be done by then! I haven’t gotten around to watching it yet….
      Your thoughts 💭 ?

    • @shellysedai1930
      @shellysedai1930 Рік тому +1

      @@conorreads well, I liked the show. Although there were some who did not. I would suggest you watch the shows and do reviews for your channel about them. How you like them overall, as adaptations, and stuff you like and don’t like (both based on books and not). Book fans would watch your reviews 😉

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      @@shellysedai1930 that’s a good idea, I’ll add it to my list!

  • @Mahalleinir
    @Mahalleinir Рік тому +1

    You at least one very good spot on prediction in this video😉

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      Gotta be right every once in a while

  • @yuri40
    @yuri40 Рік тому +1

    Great video as always. I agree with Elayne having the easiest time so far. I'd almost say Mat had an easier time, but he has to deal with some of the most arrogant & obnoxious women ever written, including Elayne, and that can't be easy.
    I have a question for you. Did you notice any difference in writing style for this book? I noticed there seemed to be more dialogue and less descriptions of things in some chapters, but there were many chapters that felt like the same old Robert Jordan. If I had to guess this book was mostly written by Robert Jordan and the later ones will feel more Sanderson.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      It was more simplistic and faster moving! I agree I think things would’ve moved quickly if Jordan had written it also.
      But I enjoyed the directness of this one so far!

    • @1m1s
      @1m1s Рік тому +1

      @@conorreads With Sanderson we don't get horses' names anymore, or people's clothes, or what kind of rug there is on the floor in a tent. The world is a bit more bland. Instead we get a lot of characters that appear once for no plot reason just to drop the name of a friend or fan of Sanderson. I think he always does this kind of fan-service, I just wished he hadn't done it in WoT. But the biggest difference for me is that Jordan often wrote scenes with a lot of ambiguity. A lot of things were not spelled out in the inner monologue, and you had to guess. Or the PoV person doesn't understand what's going on, but the reader does, like when Perrin accidentally talks Alliandre into fealty just because he doesn't know how to talk to a queen. With Sanderson there's no room for misunderstanding anymore. The plot is spelled out clearly. From what I heard, it seems a lot of people actually prefer it that way. But I think Jordan was the way better writer. However, I'm sooo glad we got the final three books at all. And I doubt any other writer could have done a significantly better job than Sanderson did.

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      @@1m1s that’s such a good explanation of what is now missing, I loved how Jordan didn’t spell it out, it felt like the real world!

  • @joeramulders
    @joeramulders Рік тому +2

    I don't think there are easy paths, not in life, not in a good written book. The POV 's show the world and their self image through their own character. Elayne has a good-hearted, positive nature. She isnt the person who mulls over a setback for long. She won't share her struggles with you the reader as dramatic Rand, self-important Egwene, gloomy Perrin and whining Mat do. Elayne is claiming the throne without her brother, without her mother, while being pregnant of twins, whose father is missing in action. Chew on that.
    There is another arc that seems to be especially written to make the point that there are no easy paths. We all struggle in our own ways: whether nobly born or a farmer. It's an arc that will activate shortly. Already said too much!

    • @conorreads
      @conorreads  Рік тому

      A cool viewpoint I haven’t heard on Elayne, some good ideas!
      You have made me even more curious as to the future now!

  • @DavyCDiamondback
    @DavyCDiamondback Рік тому

    Vladimir Putin is M'Hael