I once had the fortune to speak to David Bowie on Rockline. I asked him what he thought of working with Trent Reznor and him as an artist, if he would work with Trent again. He said, "Trent is the greatest creative mind of his generation and the only one that will be around in a decade." He was 200% correct. Cause he's Bowie.
1,5 years later this shit will be 30 years old, and Tren'ts old stuff still sounds like it was made yesterday. When it comes to audio engineering and production, Trent is among the untouchables.
It’s also the timelessness of the sound that he makes & how what he made back then shaped the future of music so much- true genius- probably the greatest musical mind from America for the era
I'm very happy to have grown up in the mid 80s with my mother having this album (Pretty Hate Machine) frequently in the tape deck of the family car. Trent just finds a way to open "shared" wounds as his own while quickly putting you in his own uncomfortable space for a sec just before the sly probe and tickle towards a taboo subject, then jab a finger into it just to remind you of reality. Then will slowly caress the anger or sorrow of your soul and basically have you begging for more. Like getting ink but a million times better and more fulfilling.
When I was 13 I met a new kid from out of town on the school bus. He lived right next to me. I went to his house after school. He randomly put this video on. That event dramatically altered the course of my life and I have been NIN obsessed ever since.
I met these chicks in high school who introduced me to Nine Inch Nails and dated both of them at different times. One of them took me to see NIN and Bowie at Brendan Bern Arena and we made out the whole show. I think that was around our 3rd date or so. Cool chick. She is the mother of my 2 amazing daughters and my wife of 17 years. Fucking angel in my life and demon in the sack. I love the shit out of that woman.
So is the one from Broken to TDS, then from TDS to The Fragile. Trent literally turned shit (anger, hate, isolation) into gold. But then, he did something even more astounding: he transformed gold back into shit. This is how the Slip, Year zero and virtually all post-the Fragile efforts came about. True story.
Ma/ Prz/ shut the hell up. Just because he progressed as an artist and went a different direction does not mean that the music was shit. Maybe it wasn't your cup of tea, and that's fine, but there clearly was an audience for because he still making music today. Ass.
More often than not, that's what happens when you get sober as an artist. I loved everything he touched when he was all smacked out in the 90's but we probably would've lost him. Not a fan of anything after 2000 really but don't blame him for anything.
Its the trent reznor/jonatham davis method where you can literally hear that they have sucessfully and completely worked through their young adult turmoil and at this point still continue to write about even tho the emotion is no longer there like seriouslt trent and jon youre both like 50 now how long will you continue to write about how depressed you were in 1994
This is such a perfect depiction of the anxiety and agony that is in the lyrics. If there is a soundtrack to a deep human crisis which makes one teeter on the brink of total implosion, this is it.
Anyone wondering, the short haired guy playing guitar and giving backing vocals is Richard Patrick, the future singer/guitarist/programmer for Filter. He played guitar for NIN from 1989 to 1994, mostly live only as Trent didn't allow his playing to be recorded on albums (the only part of his on Pretty Hate Machine is the guitar wailing part at the end of Sanctified and at the start of Something I Can Never Have.) The guy with long hair pulled back and 3-day beard in front of a computer is Brian Liesegang who is also one of the two starting members of Filter, and of course the long haired guy playing guitar and giving backing vocals is Marilyn Manson before his fame.
Richard Patrick's brother Robert has had a fair amount of acting success, starring in Terminator 2 and late seasons of The X Files, and Chris Vrenna (AKA Tweaker), the drummer for early live NIN, now teaches at Calhoun State Community College in Decatur, AL, not far from where I grew up. Because everyone was waiting for those details. =)
Manson wasn't ever innocent, persay. However, the world hadn't ate him up and spit him back out from the infection yet. Manson graduated from Ft. Lauderdale with a journalism degree. He got a job quickly doing a music column. He was asked out of the blue one day to interview Reznor. On the way out the door, he quietly left a demo for early Smells Like Children with his number. Trent eventually picked it up and listened to it by mistake, but feel in love with it's unique raw sound. He called the magazine again and asked if they'd like another interview and requested Brian specifically. Reznor put him on the spot with changes that the songs needed. Manson done most of what was suggested, and Reznor helped them get a record deal later. They remained close friends for a long time afterwards until Trent realized Manson was part of the crew holding him back from sobriety. Forget who's bio that all comes from. Read both bios for NiNs and Reznor, and Manson's Long Hard Road Out of Hell, so it's all a hodgepodge probably.
@@Nga_Babaye thank you.. that was informative AF..I wasn't sure if that was Manson, but I'd recognize those arms tattoos anywhere...even if just for a sec!
@@armandoosuna6525 For whatever reason in the video, it shows Manson singing Patricks parts and Patrick singing Manson's parts. It always fucks with me.
this is possibly the most intense studio session I've ever seen so much energy and precision and then you have the emotional output of trent . this is fabulous and special
This is gold. Not only is this captured when Trent was unhinged AF but we also got to see Marilyn Manson on guitar and completely hinged! Absolute GOLD!
Perfect little dream the kind that hurts the most Forgot how it feels well almost No one to blame always the same Open my eyes wake up in flames It took you to make me realize It took you to make me realize It took you to make me realize It took you to make me see the light Smashed up my sanity Smashed up my integrity Smashed up what I believed in Smashed up what's left of me Smashed up my everything Smashed up all that was true Gonna smash myself to pieces I don't know what else to do Covered in hope and Vaseline Still cannot fix this broken machine Watching the hole it used to be mine Just watching it burn in my steady systematic decline Of the trust I will betray Give it to me I throw it away After everything I've done I hate myself for what I've become I tried I gave up Throw it away
So, this video version has 2 additional lines that the Broken version doesn’t... and I’ve been trying to figure out what they are for years. Right before the “Throw it away” climax, he repeats a phrase twice, which is seemingly only 2 words. If I’m not mistaken, this is exclusive to this video version and doesn’t appear on the Broken version. Anyone have an idea of what he’s screaming? First at 3:32, which is off camera, but the second one at 3:35 clearly shows him shouting whatever it is... any info would be greatly appreciated.
So much passion after that final chorus. So. Much. Passion. He, my friends, is a true music maker and such a passionate music lover. It is his life and you can definitely see his emotions through his music.
All of Trent's expressions: the way he looks at the camera, the way he grabs his head, moves the microphone and turns sideways his face; they add so much emotion to the lyrics. Honestly this version is so much better than the original record. Plus, the presence of Reznor, Manson and Patrick together in the same room... insane
Manson didn't know how to play the guitar during this period of time. he mentions it in an interview and in his book. reznor just handed him the guitar and told him to fake it along with the vocals just for the video.
@@CewyahAlt It's the Tate house where the Manson murders occurred. The mixer is right where Sharon Tate's body was, the American flag draped over the mixer is where the American flag was draped over Sharon Tate's couch. It's like Trent is screaming at the couch. He moved out of the house because the vibes were too much.
Broken, what a great album. Now I do love PHM but Broken spoke to me on a visceral level. It was just so raw and heavy - it was right up my alley as a pissed off teen in the 90s.
It terrifies me seeing the emotion he puts into his music, he is absolutely incredible for the way he makes you feel it too. Had me clawing at my own face wanting everything to go away.
"I went back and recently listened to Antichrist Superstar and it brought back a flood of memories. It's one of the proudest things musically that I've ever done. It felt like the right people and the right time doing the right thing. I had a lot of fucking fun doing a lot of stupid things, but that was then. I had a lot of fun at my birthday party when I was eight but I wouldn't want that same party now. As for Manson, during the Spiral tour we propped them up to get our audience turned on to them, and at that time a lot of the people in my circle were pretty far down the road as alcoholics. Not Manson. His drive for success and self-preservation was so high, he pretended to be fucked up a lot when he wasn't. Things got shitty between us and I'm not blameless. The majority of it though was coming from a resentful guy who finally got out from under the master's umbrella and was able to stab him in the back. He is a malicious guy and will step on anybody's face to succeed and cross any line of decency. Seeing him now, drugs and alcohol now rule his life and he's become a dopey clown. He used to be the smartest guy in the room. And as a fan of his talents, I hope he gets his shit together." -Trent Reznor on Marilyn Manson, 2009
Trent Reznor, Richard Patrick, Chris Vrenna and Brian Liesegang, all together in the same place. It's like a dream come true. *edit* It's somehow silly, but I just had to modify this comment and remove the name
Trent you have seriously been the soundtrack to my life. the Fragile and D.S. was what I listened to during my Meth addiction and then With Teeth is literally what helped me get and stay sober for a couple years (even went to your PHX show sober) and then when I got hooked on Heroin while backpacking for 3 yrs, Year Zero was the ONLY album I had in my pack with an old discman. Now that ive been clean for over 6 yrs and have children, I still manage to listen to you everyday. I don't mean to associate your art with drugs but its the only thing that got me through and its still what gets me through sobriety. Thank you for always being there.
Been a fan since 90'. NIN was my soundtrack at college when I was a kid and still defines many aspects of who I am as an artist. From one artist to another, thank you!
I like Trent because of all the musicians, he stands up for his work more than any of them. He did not let his original label violate his creation, he made sure people respected his music. Most musicians just do not care, their music just something else they can pimp off, its all bs. But to Trent, it has meaning to him, he wont do that, meaning you know what he is saying is coming from someone with integrity in their heart, however grey it may be.
@@boskoantonijevic I'm not a fan of Apple due to their misguided fanboys, their tendency to attempt to warp reality to their will, and their constant desire to lock people in to their ecosystem (culminating in their terrible credit card that is supported by Goldman Sachs of all fucking companies), but they pay well and their work ethic is decent. It would be reaching to say that Apple practices "modern day slavery". Don't try to be an edgy douche.
Not only is this song STILL badass as all hell, but the video shows Trent, Richard Patrick, Brian Liesegang, and Brian Warner (aka Marilyn Manson). God, I wish that we had some sort of analogous situation in music today; but we don't. I think that because this was but a tiny musical footprint in time, that it makes it that much more special.
@@slamshammers eXAcTLy!!! I was just like...how da fuck could the most intelligent band on planet earth be not included with anything that came out of the 90's.
@@BrandonEmerson-yj2jo Roadiohead??... It makes no sense to me. If there one band I do not understand is Radiohead. I guess it is music for gay people with schizophrenia and depression and some sort of mix of sadness and weird uncorrespondent hipster love. I really do not understand how they are so popular and got so famous and respected. It is probably the band I least understand.
@@CzechRiot You are totally right about them and I dont get that their hype about them either. This is the only band I cant stand them. I thought I was the only one who thought about this.
Yero Probably, but i don't think is just that, he just looks different. I can't find the right words to describe my initial thought about how he looks here.
Lilly The Narcoleptic Kitty dude he is 23 yo in thie video and he was not so much in drugs like he was later during 1996-2003, he is 47 now and he took so much drugs u cant even imagine so its pretty obvious he looks bad btw ur father also looked better in 20 and old in 50
There are several kinds of people/support to be grateful for in life; for the rare person who listens to you when no one else does, for yourself, when you need to be your own best friend & for people like Trent who you can listen to when you feel rage & need support. Thank You! ❤️🔥
I like this version better than the album version. The song needed those background vocals. Up until now, I didn't realize why I liked this version so much more.
after watching this for the first time a few years ago I genuinely thought Trent had committed suicide. I'm very glad he's still alive and very well. Moral of the story: 3:50 - 3:58 If your suffering inside, Express it, Don't compress it.
Recorded in the Sharon Tate Charles Manson murder house live different from studio version featuring Marilyn Manson and Richard Patrick on guitars. 10050 cielo dr. California. Trent called it la pig of Beverly Hills. He still owns the door they wrote pigs on with Sharon’s blood and it’s the front door to his New Orleans studio. Enjoy…
This was my favorite nin album. I know there was only 8 songs and I’m sure someone will point out it’s not an album but an e.p. Either way, every song is sick.
Broken built the bridge from PHM to TDWS. Trent had found his live groove and sound and captured it in the studio. NIN live before and after "Broken" feels like going from High School to the CEO of misspent youth culture. Everything from 1989 to 1999 is sacrosanct to me. They lost me on "With Teeth" but "Year Zero" sounded like a return to the darkest angst - this time with the perspective of a grown ass family man
Fascinated at 13yrs old when this came out, by him and his music, and never lost its touch. Just helped me in different ways throughout my life, like all of his stuff. Will never stop listening to him. True talent that is hard to find in music today.
Really interesting watching this after seeing episode 3 of The Defiant Ones. They talk about how Interscope painstakingly ended up getting NIN from TVT records which Trent hated being on, but who he was stuck with in a 7 record deal. It happened just before the recording of this video. Trent gave Interscope Broken for free. You'll notice on the computer screen at 35 seconds it says Sequence P: "Fuck you steve" which is a nice little taunt at Steve Gottlieb from TVT who made life very bad for Trent and wouldn't let him out of the deal, and now when the video was recorded he was is free to make such excellent music without constraint. Check it out if you have a chance. Interviews with Trent and everyone else involved even Steve.
I once had the fortune to speak to David Bowie on Rockline. I asked him what he thought of working with Trent Reznor and him as an artist, if he would work with Trent again. He said, "Trent is the greatest creative mind of his generation and the only one that will be around in a decade." He was 200% correct. Cause he's Bowie.
Totally agree.
There is also Maynard, with Tool. Just sayin. No hate to NIN. I love them both.
@@slamshammers He/they rocks!
If Bowie could see him now, boy, I bet he'd be really proud.
@@Labyrinthine_Complexities facts
No one talks about dude killing it on drums...
There were so many killings going on in this house for sure! One of those killings being Chris Vrenna on those drums
He is absolutely amazing! Thanks for giving his name!
@@sadorrangel9166 Man.. after googling him I went down into a rabbit hole, and end up with a Head like a hole remix with Carly Rae
That’s cause no one cares
Personally like freese better
1,5 years later this shit will be 30 years old, and Tren'ts old stuff still sounds like it was made yesterday. When it comes to audio engineering and production, Trent is among the untouchables.
maybe you should read the production credits...
It’s also the timelessness of the sound that he makes & how what he made back then shaped the future of music so much- true genius- probably the greatest musical mind from America for the era
@@kingbernie4303 he is our Beethoven
I'm very happy to have grown up in the mid 80s with my mother having this album (Pretty Hate Machine) frequently in the tape deck of the family car. Trent just finds a way to open "shared" wounds as his own while quickly putting you in his own uncomfortable space for a sec just before the sly probe and tickle towards a taboo subject, then jab a finger into it just to remind you of reality. Then will slowly caress the anger or sorrow of your soul and basically have you begging for more. Like getting ink but a million times better and more fulfilling.
According to YT and when this comment was commented, ~.5 years left and we’ll be there.
When I was 13 I met a new kid from out of town on the school bus. He lived right next to me. I went to his house after school. He randomly put this video on. That event dramatically altered the course of my life and I have been NIN obsessed ever since.
Let me guess, you're bisexual now?
I met these chicks in high school who introduced me to Nine Inch Nails and dated both of them at different times.
One of them took me to see NIN and Bowie at Brendan Bern Arena and we made out the whole show. I think that was around our 3rd date or so.
Cool chick.
She is the mother of my 2 amazing daughters and my wife of 17 years.
Fucking angel in my life and demon in the sack. I love the shit out of that woman.
@@jeffgillsonpretty cool story man
The transition from Pretty Hate Machine to Broken was just... astounding.
So is the one from Broken to TDS, then from TDS to The Fragile. Trent literally turned shit (anger, hate, isolation) into gold. But then, he did something even more astounding: he transformed gold back into shit. This is how the Slip, Year zero and virtually all post-the Fragile efforts came about. True story.
Ma/ Prz/ shut the hell up. Just because he progressed as an artist and went a different direction does not mean that the music was shit. Maybe it wasn't your cup of tea, and that's fine, but there clearly was an audience for because he still making music today. Ass.
More often than not, that's what happens when you get sober as an artist. I loved everything he touched when he was all smacked out in the 90's but we probably would've lost him. Not a fan of anything after 2000 really but don't blame him for anything.
Its the trent reznor/jonatham davis method where you can literally hear that they have sucessfully and completely worked through their young adult turmoil and at this point still continue to write about even tho the emotion is no longer there like seriouslt trent and jon youre both like 50 now how long will you continue to write about how depressed you were in 1994
Burroughs Golden Speedballs I love the artists still, but you are right they are in old ruts.
Trent's vocals on this version are just that much more intense compared to the studio version, actually gave me goosebumps.
idk how he still has working vocal cords after that ending
I had never heard this until now (why bother, I had the CD, you know?) but you are so right!!!
and uh the Internet didn't really exist back then
I just love the dudes sitting on the side, so high they're barely even there. That's a real recording session.
@@winilula it did but I wasn't anything like now
This is such a perfect depiction of the anxiety and agony that is in the lyrics. If there is a soundtrack to a deep human crisis which makes one teeter on the brink of total implosion, this is it.
Still in love with this song. Patrick, Reznor and Manson... I mean holy shit. Early NIN is still unmatched.
Not to mention the guy from Filter lmao
@@RikerLovesWorf The guy from Filter was their first guitarist.
agreed!!
@Marcus he did mention Patrick
This would have been an incredible official lineup!
Anyone wondering, the short haired guy playing guitar and giving backing vocals is Richard Patrick, the future singer/guitarist/programmer for Filter. He played guitar for NIN from 1989 to 1994, mostly live only as Trent didn't allow his playing to be recorded on albums (the only part of his on Pretty Hate Machine is the guitar wailing part at the end of Sanctified and at the start of Something I Can Never Have.)
The guy with long hair pulled back and 3-day beard in front of a computer is Brian Liesegang who is also one of the two starting members of Filter, and of course the long haired guy playing guitar and giving backing vocals is Marilyn Manson before his fame.
He is "piggy" .
He also drummed during this album's live tour
Richard Patrick's brother Robert has had a fair amount of acting success, starring in Terminator 2 and late seasons of The X Files, and Chris Vrenna (AKA Tweaker), the drummer for early live NIN, now teaches at Calhoun State Community College in Decatur, AL, not far from where I grew up. Because everyone was waiting for those details. =)
toejam119 who’s the drummer?, is the same guy from the video “March of the pigs”?
@@yoempaquetado Yes, it's Chris Vrenna. He was part of the live band for several years, through the PHM, Broken, and TDS tours.
It's almost as if they're performing an exorcism on the house
Yup
Speaking of exorcisms the video itself looks like it's been directed by William Friedkin
ISNT THIS THE HOUSE THE FAMILY GOT MURDERED IN!?!?!?!?!?!?
Amy Hulett yep. At the time it was repurposed as a recording studio. Not sure if it’s still one.
damn... I heard Trent Reznor saying that this house is very haunted
The energy of that damn house was sucked up and injected into this track. Astonishing.
Still my favorite NIN album. Amazing to see Reznor, Patrick and Manson all together in the same video. All three frontmen for great bands.
Naja, funny that i know Filter the longest time, of all of them, but jet the weakest One, on my opinion
With the new allegations towards Manson this comment aged well...
Which band is (or were, I don't know) Patrick?
@@Lunaticaceleste Patrick is Filter
@@Hazmathavok1222 Was waiting to see this comment lol
Manson looks so innocent here
*JUST LIKE YOU*
No. I bet he was high as fuck in this video
Manson wasn't ever innocent, persay. However, the world hadn't ate him up and spit him back out from the infection yet. Manson graduated from Ft. Lauderdale with a journalism degree. He got a job quickly doing a music column. He was asked out of the blue one day to interview Reznor. On the way out the door, he quietly left a demo for early Smells Like Children with his number. Trent eventually picked it up and listened to it by mistake, but feel in love with it's unique raw sound. He called the magazine again and asked if they'd like another interview and requested Brian specifically. Reznor put him on the spot with changes that the songs needed. Manson done most of what was suggested, and Reznor helped them get a record deal later. They remained close friends for a long time afterwards until Trent realized Manson was part of the crew holding him back from sobriety. Forget who's bio that all comes from. Read both bios for NiNs and Reznor, and Manson's Long Hard Road Out of Hell, so it's all a hodgepodge probably.
@@Nga_Babaye thank you.. that was informative AF..I wasn't sure if that was Manson, but I'd recognize those arms tattoos anywhere...even if just for a sec!
@@armandoosuna6525 For whatever reason in the video, it shows Manson singing Patricks parts and Patrick singing Manson's parts. It always fucks with me.
I prefer this live version much more than the studio version.
So much angst.
Solid, rock solid!
I hear that! The drummer always at least brings a smile to my face when I see him really getting into the song!
Yeah!
He's lost in it!!
Yeah I 100% agree with you. Even the intro is better. I love his screams at the end as well. It's so much more raw!
Does anyone know where I can find "this" version on CD?
even though it might sound more "real" Manson is completely faking it.
0:36 - “Sequence F: “fuck you steve” “ on the computer lmao
Also "paddypod & the jerkoff bunch" 😅
LMAOOOO HAHAHAHAHA best name for a sequence
Eat your heart out Stevieee
Thirty years later and I still sing along word for word.
i dont know anysong word for word
@@antoinebergeron4083 learn
This NEVER gets old.
Indeed!!!
Agreed!!
Never!! Fucking awesome!!!
That is unfortunate. This is horrible music. Best to be forgotten soon.
It’s been 8 years since you commented this. Are you still listening to this song? And how are you doing bro? If your even still alive 8 years later
It's so cool to see Trent, Manson and Richard Patrick all performing together. 3 great songwriters in one room laying down some badassness.
Every single guy in this lovely little house is gorgeous. Trent #1 of course 😅❤
This is one the most iconic videos from their period together. Don't forget Chris Vrenna as well!
this is possibly the most intense studio session I've ever seen so much energy and precision and then you have the emotional output of trent . this is fabulous and special
Except... for that dude on keyboard
@@fertilityqueen7880 he had focus!
@@fertilityqueen7880 Don't disrespect James like that
@@L0zza I'm pretty sure that's Brian Liesegang.
This video was shot in the room that Sharon Tate was killed in.
This is gold. Not only is this captured when Trent was unhinged AF but we also got to see Marilyn Manson on guitar and completely hinged! Absolute GOLD!
Perfect little dream the kind that hurts the most
Forgot how it feels well almost
No one to blame always the same
Open my eyes wake up in flames
It took you to make me realize
It took you to make me realize
It took you to make me realize
It took you to make me see the light
Smashed up my sanity
Smashed up my integrity
Smashed up what I believed in
Smashed up what's left of me
Smashed up my everything
Smashed up all that was true
Gonna smash myself to pieces
I don't know what else to do
Covered in hope and Vaseline
Still cannot fix this broken machine
Watching the hole it used to be mine
Just watching it burn in my steady systematic decline
Of the trust I will betray
Give it to me I throw it away
After everything I've done I hate myself for what I've become
I tried
I gave up
Throw it away
Thank you!
So, this video version has 2 additional lines that the Broken version doesn’t... and I’ve been trying to figure out what they are for years. Right before the “Throw it away” climax, he repeats a phrase twice, which is seemingly only 2 words. If I’m not mistaken, this is exclusive to this video version and doesn’t appear on the Broken version. Anyone have an idea of what he’s screaming? First at 3:32, which is off camera, but the second one at 3:35 clearly shows him shouting whatever it is... any info would be greatly appreciated.
I fckn can relate so much to this lyrics right now....
@@BornToLoveJoker never give up xx
thanks mang but if you dont know the words to this song you arent a true fan
THAT RIFF AT THE END!
Try hearing that live if you haven't... Pure bliss!
Is epic.
Loader is better. Love it!
The ferocity of this era is something special.
They are all giving it! But Chris on drums is going so hard! I love the vibe of this video!
So much passion after that final chorus. So. Much. Passion. He, my friends, is a true music maker and such a passionate music lover. It is his life and you can definitely see his emotions through his music.
Same dude! haha
I wouldn't have described it better. I just adore to Trent because of that (not to mention his physical attractive).
Well said. He is my favorite songwriter because of the music he makes, absolutely insane.
Yesssssss
Back when Trent Reznor was wilder than Marilyn Manson...
Well, Manson's live shows were the wild part
today trent still wilder than manson, specially ilive, honestly i love manson but is more shock and image than energy live
He still is...Reznor is refined Cabernet and Manson is a luke warm can of pabst...
Trent live is like military boot camp
Manson live is all props and clumsiness
@@carcillian facts
All of Trent's expressions: the way he looks at the camera, the way he grabs his head, moves the microphone and turns sideways his face; they add so much emotion to the lyrics. Honestly this version is so much better than the original record. Plus, the presence of Reznor, Manson and Patrick together in the same room... insane
The eeriness of the location this video was shot in & the fact that MM is also part of it.
To be a fly on the wall in this crazy energy moment.
This performance's just amazing. It has both young Marilyn Manson and Filter's Richard Patrick rockin' it out.
Nine Inch Nails Richard Patrick. This was a while before he quit and formed Filter.
Also before Piggy was written about Richard Patrick.
Manson wasn't able to play the guitar. He was pretending, he told himself in his autobiography
Matteo Fazio look up Down In The Park. You will see Manson playing the guitar.
Manson didn't know how to play the guitar during this period of time. he mentions it in an interview and in his book. reznor just handed him the guitar and told him to fake it along with the vocals just for the video.
I’m saying ……THIS VERSION IS A BEAST.
the creepy of that house adds onto the song or something
@@CewyahAlt It's the Tate house where the Manson murders occurred. The mixer is right where Sharon Tate's body was, the American flag draped over the mixer is where the American flag was draped over Sharon Tate's couch. It's like Trent is screaming at the couch. He moved out of the house because the vibes were too much.
Broken, what a great album. Now I do love PHM but Broken spoke to me on a visceral level. It was just so raw and heavy - it was right up my alley as a pissed off teen in the 90s.
It terrifies me seeing the emotion he puts into his music, he is absolutely incredible for the way he makes you feel it too. Had me clawing at my own face wanting everything to go away.
You should check out the BROKEN movie.
It's on youtube in clips...talk about some weird stuff.
I love it tho
Yo it’s been 9 years since you commented this, how have you been? If your even alive still?
"I went back and recently listened to Antichrist Superstar and it brought back a flood of memories. It's one of the proudest things musically that I've ever done. It felt like the right people and the right time doing the right thing. I had a lot of fucking fun doing a lot of stupid things, but that was then. I had a lot of fun at my birthday party when I was eight but I wouldn't want that same party now.
As for Manson, during the Spiral tour we propped them up to get our audience turned on to them, and at that time a lot of the people in my circle were pretty far down the road as alcoholics. Not Manson. His drive for success and self-preservation was so high, he pretended to be fucked up a lot when he wasn't.
Things got shitty between us and I'm not blameless. The majority of it though was coming from a resentful guy who finally got out from under the master's umbrella and was able to stab him in the back. He is a malicious guy and will step on anybody's face to succeed and cross any line of decency. Seeing him now, drugs and alcohol now rule his life and he's become a dopey clown. He used to be the smartest guy in the room. And as a fan of his talents, I hope he gets his shit together."
-Trent Reznor on Marilyn Manson, 2009
Nice
love! where can I find this, and the rest?
He read him to filth
They've since squashed their beef.
Let's be brutally honest, mansons early shit was a cheap NIN rip off.
So glad Rich Patrick got a shout out from Trent during Rock Hall Of Fame speech
The way he holds himself at the beginning... Awww such a raw incredible human being!!!
This song is so raw. Even in 2018. I've been listening to this song since middle school
still raw in 2024
The American flag is a nice touch. Old NiN was so damned intense, even for the early 90s when a lot of music was much more intense than now.
oh fuck,,,,do some research you stupid kid, it was a goof on the crime scene , as a flag was left there ,,don't you little fuck ever look shit up?
I love seeing everyone intensely focused on making great music!
Best cut of this song I've ever heard. Patrick and Manson with Reznor and the riff to close shreds.
Trent Reznor, Richard Patrick, Chris Vrenna and Brian Liesegang, all together in the same place. It's like a dream come true.
*edit*
It's somehow silly, but I just had to modify this comment and remove the name
Danny Lohner!!
Which one is Lohner?
Trent reznor, young Manson, Chris Vrena, Dany Lohner and many more, that was perfect squad....
Marylin Manson is born in this Le Pig studio
I believe Chris Vrenna on drums
Trent you have seriously been the soundtrack to my life. the Fragile and D.S. was what I listened to during my Meth addiction and then With Teeth is literally what helped me get and stay sober for a couple years (even went to your PHX show sober) and then when I got hooked on Heroin while backpacking for 3 yrs, Year Zero was the ONLY album I had in my pack with an old discman. Now that ive been clean for over 6 yrs and have children, I still manage to listen to you everyday. I don't mean to associate your art with drugs but its the only thing that got me through and its still what gets me through sobriety. Thank you for always being there.
Woah, man, that's a strong story right there. Kudos for staying sober!
Best wishes to you for staying clean. It’s a rough road that never ends...and yes, art/music help!
Amhetamine IS the addiction of my Life, did you know, that the Most good artista of the 9o's we're Amphetamine addicts at theire beak ?
Trent sings and plays from his heart.he can completely transmit his feelings to others. I adore him
NIN, Tweaker, Filter and Mansun - a lot of my favourite albums all in one video
"Baby" Manson!!
ThunderGod 'Baby' Manson is Brian Warner😊
Spooky Kid Manson.
That’s one talented room, miss these days.
Been a fan since 90'. NIN was my soundtrack at college when I was a kid and still defines many aspects of who I am as an artist. From one artist to another, thank you!
This is one of my favorite songs.
One of the fucking best videos on youtube.
Baby manson
More like big
Daddy Manson
♥️
Incredible. I can't believe that he did this and Pretty Hate Machines on his own and when he was just a kid essentially. Bravo Trent. HATS OFF.
SANDRA: He was 24 years old. Not a kid but an adult.
Incredible video. First time I saw it - it felt like you were in the studio. It had that fresh Windows 95 computer smell.
Covered with hope, and vaseline... and suddenly I'm a teenager in the 90s again. Really surprised I didn't catch anything.
BEST COMMENT!!!!!!!! :D :D :D
you probably did but it hasnt manifested yet,lol jk!
😂😂😂😂
now 51...we made it, no clue how...but here we are
When you just missed your uncle Charles by a few years and by proxy💆🏻♂️
That riff at the end doe....Mmm
One of the best and most visceral music videos ever! This was perfect alignment of stars.
@@chairmanofthebored8684 Mehh. Not a fan really.
@@tidalboxer we're not a fan of you, trash hippo suc k boy
I could watch this all day. Studio live. Nothing like it. So much energy in the room. 🤯
My very first time watching this video. That's Sharon Tate's house on Cielo Drive.
I love the guitar tone in this version especially the end where its just the 2 guitars playing that sweet lil riff
Still keep coming back to this track. Fantastic track off an awesome album.
NOTHING. makes me feel more alive than this song at this point in time.
I like Trent because of all the musicians, he stands up for his work more than any of them. He did not let his original label violate his creation, he made sure people respected his music. Most musicians just do not care, their music just something else they can pimp off, its all bs. But to Trent, it has meaning to him, he wont do that, meaning you know what he is saying is coming from someone with integrity in their heart, however grey it may be.
jasmine elaya he works for Apple now
***** oh????.... cant blame him. a man has to pay bills......
the guy who wrote Happinnes in slavery works for company that practice modern slavery
@@boskoantonijevic I guess he found happiness in it 😳
@@boskoantonijevic I'm not a fan of Apple due to their misguided fanboys, their tendency to attempt to warp reality to their will, and their constant desire to lock people in to their ecosystem (culminating in their terrible credit card that is supported by Goldman Sachs of all fucking companies), but they pay well and their work ethic is decent. It would be reaching to say that Apple practices "modern day slavery". Don't try to be an edgy douche.
young moody trent 💖
Yesss unf
Rita Ann and Trent just looks better every. .decade!
The best Trent
Young Trent high on H. Such dreamy eyes,
Manson is a great collab partner. Look how good they are!
No one talks about the dude killing it on the computer! Seriously.
I noticed and his shiny pretty hair
Not only is this song STILL badass as all hell, but the video shows Trent, Richard Patrick, Brian Liesegang, and Brian Warner (aka Marilyn Manson). God, I wish that we had some sort of analogous situation in music today; but we don't. I think that because this was but a tiny musical footprint in time, that it makes it that much more special.
its almost 2024 and i still cannot fix this broken machine.
Me too, bro
Nine Inch Nails and Radiohead are the best bands to come out of the 90’s. Love their live performances
You forgot to add Tool in there.
@@slamshammers eXAcTLy!!! I was just like...how da fuck could the most intelligent band on planet earth be not included with anything that came out of the 90's.
@@BrandonEmerson-yj2jo Roadiohead??... It makes no sense to me. If there one band I do not understand is Radiohead. I guess it is music for gay people with schizophrenia and depression and some sort of mix of sadness and weird uncorrespondent hipster love. I really do not understand how they are so popular and got so famous and respected. It is probably the band I least understand.
@@CzechRiot You are totally right about them and I dont get that their hype about them either. This is the only band I cant stand them. I thought I was the only one who thought about this.
Trent ... such an incredible musician...such an incredible mouth
...still cannot fix this broken machine...
HoustonGothic what about now?
J
F
This comment is really funny in 2020
Did I just see Manson with a lip ring?!
He had one in the late 80's and early 90's.. around the time of Smells Like Children he removed it
He had it before modern day emos made them stupid
Alex Smallex Modern day Emo's only wear the shit... They didn't much make it stupid, fucking generation disser
Sincerely Crazed I bet you have them and feel the need to defend it. Don't worry 😂
Alex Smallex no... I'll give you this though, I have considered it
There is 3 lead singers in this music video. Love it!
That guitar riff at the end is so awesome 🤘🤘🤘
And that’s why this is my favourite version 🤘
MM looks so different here, looks better, i think.
Lilly The Narcoleptic Kitty He had eyebrows.
Nar Comic Underworld yup lol
+Lilly The Narcoleptic Kitty because he is young??
Yero Probably, but i don't think is just that, he just looks different. I can't find the right words to describe my initial thought about how he looks here.
Lilly The Narcoleptic Kitty dude he is 23 yo in thie video and he was not so much in drugs like he was later during 1996-2003, he is 47 now and he took so much drugs u cant even imagine so its pretty obvious he looks bad btw ur father also looked better in 20 and old in 50
Amazing, this looks like it was made in 2016
Being recorded in Sharon Tates 1969 murder house adds something very Haunting to this video. The clips of the house at the beginning is so eerie.
Manson
They never should have torn that house down
There are several kinds of people/support to be grateful for in life; for the rare person who listens to you when no one else does, for yourself, when you need to be your own best friend & for people like Trent who you can listen to when you feel rage & need support. Thank You! ❤️🔥
😀
I like this version better than the album version. The song needed those background vocals. Up until now, I didn't realize why I liked this version so much more.
this is the album version... ... lol
@@dr.decker3623 no its not, listen to the chorus back to back on each version
@@dr.decker3623 it's not.
At all...
after watching this for the first time a few years ago I genuinely thought Trent had committed suicide.
I'm very glad he's still alive and very well.
Moral of the story: 3:50 - 3:58
If your suffering inside, Express it, Don't compress it.
Oooooooooh ja, Emergency ti let It out somehow
Recorded in the Sharon Tate Charles Manson murder house live different from studio version featuring Marilyn Manson and Richard Patrick on guitars. 10050 cielo dr. California. Trent called it la pig of Beverly Hills. He still owns the door they wrote pigs on with Sharon’s blood and it’s the front door to his New Orleans studio. Enjoy…
This was the last documented appearance of Mansons original Eyebrows.
Trent Reznor was the final resident of 10050 Cielo Drive in LA, where this was filmed.
I find myself here everyday
This is addictive, thanks Reznor
This was my favorite nin album. I know there was only 8 songs and I’m sure someone will point out it’s not an album but an e.p. Either way, every song is sick.
It's the one I've listened to more than any other 🙂 Downward Spiral close second.
It's not an album, it's an E.P.
Kidding aside, this was my first NIN album. And it's definitely the one that hits hardest musically.
Broken built the bridge from PHM to TDWS. Trent had found his live groove and sound and captured it in the studio. NIN live before and after "Broken" feels like going from High School to the CEO of misspent youth culture.
Everything from 1989 to 1999 is sacrosanct to me.
They lost me on "With Teeth" but "Year Zero" sounded like a return to the darkest angst - this time with the perspective of a grown ass family man
😃💦🐱-😳😈НЕ🤬 ВОТ😡😱
ВОСПИТ...👹НЕ👺😈😭😭☹😮-😈😱😱🙊😱😱💋👉🧙♂
Been listening to nin for 20+ years and doubt I'll ever get over them.
Fascinated at 13yrs old when this came out, by him and his music, and never lost its touch. Just helped me in different ways throughout my life, like all of his stuff. Will never stop listening to him. True talent that is hard to find in music today.
How could you dislike this video?
They don't know about good music :P
Love this video and how it enhances the sonic effects in the song.
The music on this song is just amazing!
f****n legendary visionaries. the 90s are prime musicianship.
Beauty at its finest 💕
Ja, best of the nineties
I've been a fan of NIN and Filter for 22+ years, I'm absolutely ashamed of myself for never having seen this before now.
Still my favorite after all these years....
Great version live in the studio. Love NIN.
dam I grew up listening to nin can't believe most of my favorite songs are 25-30+ years old now...
still good as fuck
This is awesome!!! I need more NIN!!!!!
28 years later and I'm still here for this !!!
Best music ever
This is my all-time fav NIN song
Really interesting watching this after seeing episode 3 of The Defiant Ones. They talk about how Interscope painstakingly ended up getting NIN from TVT records which Trent hated being on, but who he was stuck with in a 7 record deal. It happened just before the recording of this video.
Trent gave Interscope Broken for free. You'll notice on the computer screen at 35 seconds it says Sequence P: "Fuck you steve" which is a nice little taunt at Steve Gottlieb from TVT who made life very bad for Trent and wouldn't let him out of the deal, and now when the video was recorded he was is free to make such excellent music without constraint.
Check it out if you have a chance. Interviews with Trent and everyone else involved even Steve.
"TVT was just a collection of shit."
-Trent Reznor (from The Defiant Ones)
In his songs Trent like Prince, made dozens of insanely cool five seconds riffs/beats that became other artists complete albums.
Been a long time since 89 and growing up then with Trent and company...but what memories...
You all are helping me thru hard times. Your sound soothes me. I dance sing until exhausted. Then i can sleep.