The War in Ukraine Could Change Everything | Yuval Noah Harari | TED
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 тра 2024
- Concerned about the war Ukraine? You're not alone. Historian Yuval Noah Harari provides important context on the Russian invasion, including Ukraine's long history of resistance, the specter of nuclear war and his view of why, even if Putin wins all the military battles, he's already lost the war.
This conversation, hosted by TED global curator Bruno Giussani, was part of a TED Membership event on March 1, 2022. Visit ted.com/membership to become a TED Member and support our mission of spreading ideas.
Follow TED!
Twitter: / tedtalks
Instagram: / ted
Facebook: / ted
LinkedIn: / ted-conferences
TikTok: / tedtoks
The TED Talks channel features talks, performances and original series from the world's leading thinkers and doers. Subscribe to our channel for videos on Technology, Entertainment and Design - plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more. Visit TED.com to get our entire library of TED Talks, transcripts, translations, personalized talk recommendations and more.
Watch more: go.ted.com/yuvalnoahharari22
• The War in Ukraine Cou...
TED's videos may be used for non-commercial purposes under a Creative Commons License, Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (or the CC BY - NC - ND 4.0 International) and in accordance with our TED Talks Usage Policy (www.ted.com/about/our-organiz.... For more information on using TED for commercial purposes (e.g. employee learning, in a film or online course), please submit a Media Request at media-requests.ted.com
#TED #YuvalNoahHarari - Наука та технологія
I am from Vietnam, daughter of former solider to against Pol Pot for 7 years. When I born, my country was peace. But I tell someone the fact, the war still affect myself and my family even my children on the mental, body, etc...for the long time for the next and next generation. So, I pray the peace for Ukraine, for Russia, for the world every single day. PEACE FOR ALL
Keep going strong ❤
Thank you for sharing this. Peace to you and your family, who knows what nightmare your country and people had to live through🕊☮️✌🏻
Thankyou !
Yes your right
I was born in Europe before the end of WW2. As a child, I saw bombed out buildings reduced to rubble. I am thinking of my parents now, who lived through it and how it changed their lives. I remember rationing books-you could only buy a certain amount of dairy products, butter, etc. Yes, deep traumas come from these upheavals and last for generations. ☮️
As a Kurdish man from Iran, i was born right in the starting point of the 8 years of war between Iran and Iraq 40 yars ago. Let me clarify what the war is:
Some rich politicians who know eachother very well, sitting in their comfortable palaces, dream of their ambitions, force young soldiers who even don't know eachother to kill eachother.
And finally after a while they again shake their hands and have a nice meal together in front of cameras while parents of young soldiers still suffering from their absence.
STOP WAR PLEASE
This is the best description of war I have ever heard. Thank you!
very true byt then again why are soldiers accept this and kill each other??? dont they have responsibility as well?
@@ctscan2801 They are tricked into thinking they're after fighting for their country. And the social pressure to join, since soliders have high status. They are told they are fighting for noble reasons, but in reality they are fighting a rich man's battle.
Some people are not aware of this fact, and join the army.
@@hello-ep6ch so they pay for their inability to think
Just look at World War 1, I and how many soldiers died, because of some Kings and Generals!!!!
The unacknowledged fictions of Yuval Harari
This man is Klaus Schwab's top WEF advisor 🤣 What a beautiful disconnected reality
And?
I recognized the name and was immediately suspicious.
The Goddamned devil liar, now giving another lecture.
“What we learn from history, is that no one learns from history.”
Bismark
...and everyone uses history
History is repeated...😎
@@macabrette86 missuses
@@bennowak8555 by itself
Doesn't this man work for Klauss Schwab? The guy who says you will own nothing and be happy. This man Yuval endorses "hacking" humans and reducing humanity to cyborgs aka an advocate for Transhumanism. 🤔
“Just repeating history for some people is always much easier than learning something from it” - My HISTORY teacher.
"Those who don't remember the history are doomed to live trough it again" - My history teacher
All of this is true only and only if Choice is given. My history teacher.
It is not history that repeats, it is the cycle of life and demography. In this way, 'every generation makes its own mistakes' is more truthful.
Why are WE capitalizing RANDOM words?
That's true! However, history doesn't have to be repeated at all. It only happens 'cause stupid people that learned the destructive ways of before that choose to see if they can finish an incomplete mission or just simply do the impossible.
when this video was published, and while Yuval was explaining that this war is the first time since WW2 that one country was invaded/bombarded, there was a question from audience for Yuval to explain war on Kosovo that happened 1999 when Belgrade was bombarded by NATO and he didn't explain analogy and relations for that happened with this war...now I can't find that part of conversation in this video...
Exactly !! You are absolutly right, we do not need propaganda, world need to hear truth !
The doesn’t believe in God.
And you don't see connection of the Serbian aggression and genocide of Albanian ( and other, don't remember) to the bombing. Camps where women were raped and forced to give birth, killing of male population of the villages.
Ukrainian didn't do anything like Serbs,, there were already invaded - Dombas and Crimea.
@@Elizabeth-pg1rq you are making a digression here - it is not a question who is more to blame Serbs or Ukrainians, it's a reminder it already happened that one Country evaded another with bombs since WW2 and before war in Ukraine. Ukrainians and Serbs are actually in opposite position here in terms of the role in their conflicts - ones provoked the attack and another react on a provocation. So, who is to blame for fight?
Harari speaks with passion about SOVEREIGNTY and freedom!! The irony of someone who has declared the age of own will is over??
Mr. Harari is interviewed in this video. He speaks to champion democracy (Ukraine) and decry tyranny/authoritarianism (Russia). However, I have ALSO listened and watched Mr. Harari speaking to the WEF (World Economic Forum) and serving as an advisor to Klaus Schwab who is the president of WEF. When Mr. Harari is speaking in his capacity as a member of the WEF, he strongly supports tyranny/authoritarianism as personified by the WEF elites (perched at the top of humanity) rather than democratic nations (whom he must see as the serfs of the world who will own nothing and be happy). So my question to Mr. Harari is: Who is the real Yuval Noah Harari...the man speaking in this interview with TED? or the one speaking to the WEF at their annual meetings? I would like to know please.
I watched that same WEF video and agree with your comments totally. Had I not seen that previously I would have had a completely different opinion, but during this video he discusses ways that this Ukrainian war can resolve the culture wars between the right and left. That same guy is talking here, he’s just a very smart and charismatic guy and is still pushing the WEF agenda.
Indeed….would like to know?
This^^^ I wouldn't trust Harai as far as I could throw him, his WEF speech was one of the most arrogant, inhuman and downright sinister examples of contempt for humanity that I have ever heard.
Why this comment doesn't have millions of likes?
@@MrBrotigan 100% I wouldn't trust this man as far as I could throw him.
one of my best friend is now fighting in Kiev for his country. I cannot sleep thinking of this war . May God stop this war immediately. 🙏🙏🙏
May Putin stop this war, you meant.
This is not true. Poland have the biggest Ukrainian community in Europe (in 2020 that was 1,3 mln, now it is about 2 mln people).
I hope for your friends safety
If your best friend would have been fighting in Iraq or Afghanistan would you be asking Your God stop this war as well ?
@@elisabeth400 Poland has really stepped up
YNH: "you know empires are often the creation of a very small gang of people at the top." he perfectly described the U.S.
foolish
I have one question do you want freedom or bandage, think before you answer 1 is to God 2 the other to be classified as a traitor going against God principles , an Ameruca is tge shinning light after we get rid of traitors an deep state
That small gang of people is the 13 bloodlines of the Illuminati.
They are the Council Of Seven and the Illuminati.
The situation in Ukraine is more complex than described here - just check what Kissinger has been telling about the tragic situation with Ukraine, NATO, USA and Russia...the whole world should prey for all parties involved to apply common sense and diplomacy and strategic collaboration for creating and maintaining much needed peace.
Pray.
Kissinger? Really? "Once you've been to Cambodia, you will never stop wanting to beat Henry Kissinger to death with your bare hands." Anthony Bourdain
Agree
Dude looks like a worn out used up Qtip with specs. And you know where to deposit those. And thats being very nice and respectful im told
Yeah since Kissingers had so many strategic achievements. Right?
I am German and was born in 1957. Noah is right this "we are Nazis "sticks to my Generation. I live in the US today and often I was kind of sad that as a German you can not show that you are proud of what Germany has become. We are not Nazis . Thank you Noah for recognizing us and Humans and reminding us of Germany's leadership challenge in Europe.
Antony Sutton "Wall street and the rise of Hitler"
Vor, your sentiments are just and true. I would take it one more turn though, at any time, esp under the duresss, ANY population has the ability for the masses to be fooled into giving up its free will / individual freedoms under the propaganda. ==> 'As not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.' Eloquent, but assymptotical approach towards a bad end.
The only people who believe everything they hear are people who are not in touch with who they are there is beauty in us all that’s what binds us…..I’m sending you love and thoughts of hope and peace for us all……
I am born in the 80s and generally we don’t see our peers in Germany like that. But we blame a lot of the older generations for the continued racism and xenophobia and religious extremism that exist today. I think younger generations realize we are not so different. Unfortunately Putin and his older supporters have sold out the younger generations for some fantasy of the USSR one that no younger person in Russia wants or dreams of rather they wanted to be proud of being Russian while being considered European and hold many of the same values and wanting to be able to look forward to living standards and lives parallel to their western counterparts. Unfortunately that will be the complete opposite of that and they should blame their elders.
You can. “Long live Sacred Germany”
As a Ukrainian, truly appreciate all the support we are given all over the world.
But despite that, we all have to remember that in this war people are not fighting against each other. Putin has chosen to start it, and nor the Russians, nor the other nations have to be treated differently because of his dumb actions.
Whatever happens people have to stay united, we all are the same human beings 🙏🏻❤️
The words are so true♥
Spot on
It's your comedian President who choose war by trying to join NATO 🥴
@@phamhuuphuc8050
Well comedian or not, he got lawyer degree, stands with his people and fights for our country, UNLIKE most other presidents that weren’t, unfortunately, comedians like Zelenskiy 😥
@@phamhuuphuc8050 and also it’s so dumb saying that he started it. As if it was him who invaded a country and started to bomb peoples houses 💀
Maybe his actions LED to that war, but it wasn’t him who started it. And also by guessing who actually did start it, we will do nothing but argue with each other over nothing
As a German I want to thank you for what you said about us. It's basically the first time I heard this from a foreigner. I think it would help us all, if we would hear that more often.
That was something, wasn't it? I agree.
I am sure, many people think the same. It's unfare to keep traumatizing an outstanding culture, because something that some people did in the past was awful. Germany is a huge candidate to lead important matters in earth. They are not perfect, but a very evolved society, organized, productive, open to human value; they have been through to painful things in history and learnt wisdom...
@@Keokanis we gonna send someone we dont need from austria and everything gonna be alright lol what could go wrong
ich verstehe was du meinst , aber die selben interessensgruppen welche uns seit 45 die alleinschuld mantraartig vorbeten hetzen gleichzeitig gegen die russen , bitte vergiß nicht wer uns was einreden will, es sind fast alle die selben akteure
@@Keokanis Germany has always been an evolved society: before, during, and after Hitler. The problem is they've been demonized with a dishonest account of history (the victor always rewrites history). Germans are guilt-ridden, left-leaning pacifists. The men are emasculated from childhood with heavy, institutionalized guilting. Germany has great potential but Izrayel and J lobbies have profited immensely with this game. I know all too well - my family is German
" And I stood upon the sand of the sea, and saw a Beast rise up "... Rev.13:1
- 2:15 What does Putin think of Ukraine and What Ukraine politically wants
- 7:13 Why Putin has already lost this (Long time) War
- 11:25 Why this War needs to end; Military Budget; And this is much much bigger than another regional conflict;
- 14:40 How Putin united Europe and NATO and how this war can bridge the Left and Right Cultural Divide
- 21:30 On Nuclear Weapons;
- 26:05 Seeds of War; War has its roots in previous conflicts.
- 30:52 A new Kind of War
- 35:20 Did Diplomacy fail us? Why did it?;
- 37:05 Why this war is Different than other wars currently happening in the World?
- 40:00 Possibility and Hope of a Green Manhattan Project
- 42:00 On President Zelensky
- 45:00 Putin's Russia is weaker than the Soviet Union
Very much appreciated!
Thank you. Obrigado 🙏
Were you bored 🤣
And where is the "How To" ?
@@cssoversimplified Nope. Just interested and focused on what was being said.
Thank you for your words. I'm from Russia and starting from yesterday there is a law which allows our government throw people protesting against the war in a prison for up to 5 years. It's incredibly that asking for peace in Russia is against the law but no problems if you want to support the war.
This is happening in other places, too. Canadian government froze bank accounts of people supporting trucker convoy and declared protestors to be domestic terrorists. Just because they were against covid passport mandates. Organizers of the protest are in jail without bail right now.
@@rachelkent3180 No, it's because the trucker convoy went beyond protest, and decided to disable commerce. Please, don't try to ride the coat tails of Ukrainians with anti-vac garbage.
@@stanfrymann That is an unmitigated lie ,are you listening to MSM and believe every word they tell you?
@@rachelkent3180 This is not the same Rachel, I am all for the anti-covid passports but this is Anti-Russian propaganda by US controlled Ukraine to Keep the status quo. Otherwise they'll have NATO on their doorstep as happened to Americans when Russia put their bombs in Cuba and it nearly started a world war. Do not expect Russia not to protect themselves and their people.
@@rachelkent3180 Oh, stop it. Those convey people are being charged for occupying our capital & blocking our trade routes, not for protesting. People organizing and leading the convey are not even truckers. They are demanding to dismantle our democratically elected government, they are anarchistes. .
When the legend becomes truth, print the legend! Mr. Harry you are a story teller as all the historians. some of your tales are even interestingly entertaining but sometimes you star believing to the stories you tell and it is sad...
"you will own nothing and you will be happy. You useless eaters are hackable." WEF and harari
To someone who knows nothing about politics, everything this man says would make sense.
This man is brilliant, that’s why he is working as a adviser for Klaus Schwabs. why doesn’t he speak about Israel bombing Gaza ! Israel is doing the same what Ukraine is doing with the Russians in donbass!
@@viktoranton ботик,здесь не заработаешь много. Иди пиши бредни в другом месте.
@@viktoranton Exactly. Thank you.
@@jean-claudeb3235 I’m a child was born at Donbas and moved out of my home in 2014. My grandparents are Russians, but they decide to move to Lugansk at the time of USSR, so please respect their choice. It’s Ukrainian territory, so why Russia decide to take it in 2014 because “Russians live there and they are bullied”? Does that mean that if a group of Ukrainian people will move to Moscow than we would be able to start war by saying that Russia is bulling us at their territory and we want it’s territory to become Ukraine? WTF, guys?
@@hannahg7130 Lol, no Russia didn't decide "to take it". Russia decided to act after 20 years of useless warnings against NATO's expansion eastwards. If you do some basic (I mean really basic) research on how ballistics and defense systems works, you would know that every km matter. To have US nuclear weapons in Ukrainian soil is a red line that any country with a decent army would not accept.
So, please start deflecting from the main topic here, nothing to do with the "rich" Donbass (invading for their coal - Russia is making a fortune...). The issue here is purely military.
Hello! I am from Kazakhstan, people here shocked and feeling anxious about all this situation. Praying for Ukraina, for peace.
And this year, your leader let the Russians reoccupy your country too.
@Zhuka Aisa The several thousand Russian troops dispatched to Kazakhstan were there to suppress the protestors of the govt. and prop up that govt.
Occupied is too much, you are right but still there is a question as to how much independence in actuality, Kazakhstan now has v. Russia.
Yaksamash!
@Zhuka Aisa Propaganda seems to have gotten the best of your analysis. You obviously don't know your history concerning the US and its allies in Europe.
@Zhuka Aisa If you understand the history of Europe and the USA then you could not intimate that Europe is not fully independent from the US and has demonstrated that independence repeatedly since 1945.
However, it is difficult to say the same in a former Soviet Republic, such as Kazakhstan, when we see the type of dependence such as recent events have demonstrated.
I would not say the same about all or even most of the former republics btw.
I am from Colombia. I was born in a country that was at war for so long. War destroyed our country and society. Seeds of hatred and violence are still present in our community, people's mindsets are still affected, and quite frankly would be so hard to overcome it.
War is absurd!
Humans are also!
Fake comment
The fact is that we are screaming war now and we’re silent for the ongoing war in eastern Ukraine the last 8 years
lol how is this no body from rosh ha hayn, harari, got 4+ million views
no one even look at him in his country lol
and guess who started and benefited from the war! its the people from hararis clique!
But he wants it to be like that!
He's so happy about any paradigm shift.
Especially when it comes to other people's and nations property, income, livelihood, ...
Very prophetic and well explained.
Everyone should go watch his “hack humans” speech and listen to him talking about systematically hacking humans and getting rid of all free will.
This is the first comment I've seen to mention this... The whole thing is terrifying.
People are so asleep, even if you push the truth up their noses, they will not smell it.
Yes. Try and understand the agenda to this Talk. Do the Work.
Exactly right. Whatever this guy says, do the opposite
Was hoping to see more comments like this. It’s scary how far I had to scroll. Most are eating up whatever he says.
Yuval is very right when he says that most who suffer are ordinary people. And ordinary people don’t want this war. Thank you for voicing that.
In war everyone loses. Unfortunately sometimes violence is necessary to defend. Noone wants this war, yet so many ordinary people took up arms. I respect their bravery immensly.
It also says a lot about the fundamental differences in leadearship. President Zelensky sending a message to the world staying in Kyiv to defend his country, despite assasins send to take his life, and on the other side Putin, far away from the war zone, sitting distanced even from his closest advisors on his long table is exactly the difference between leading from withing, inspiring people with taking action, and leading with fear and retaliation.
YOU ARE ALWAYS RIGHT SIR
He looked like such a fool
yuval speeking of peace while is planning war.
You silly people. Can't you see what this is? This is the globalists trying to extend and grow by taking in Ukraine. Nato is bad.evil. they want a NWO
That goes for all ordinary people
The unseen resolve is enlightened culture that raises the mass-consciousness for any nation. The inspirational background characters of Film, Books, Art, Music, Networks, Visionaries of all sorts greatly affect and unite people to higher awareness... What we have now in USA is short-circuited by way too much negative lower frequency shallowness that doesn't inspire intellect or wisdom
Conquering the world on horseback is easy; it is dismounting and governing that is hard.
~ Genghis Khan
I am a survivor Iran , Iraq war. I was pregnant with my first child, in the middle of the night we had to run to basement , waiting for Iraqi airplane to bomb and leave . We were lucky to survive . My son is suffering from insomnia.
❤️ i know such stories from my parents, who were kids in the WW II
إيران❤️❤️❤️
@@vorun7710 😮😮 wake up man wake up, I love Russian people more then Americans, but you my man are fooled. Feel sorry for you
@@vorun7710 Putin has invaded crimea in 2014 and now is trying to take over the whole country. There was fighting between the separatists and the government in donbass, and sure there are neo nazis in ukraine, as there are in Russia and in europe. But there was no genocide, Ukraine just wanted to join the european countries, become a democracy and join the EU. That's what putin is afraid, of having a successful wealthy democracy at it's border.
I hope the war ends soon, and that we the europeans, the ukrainians and the russians can live in peace and prosper together.
Why not imagine russia and ukraine both in the EU? A union of states with free borders and free trade. In the EU we are all countries with totally diferent cultures and languages, why not add Ukraine and Russia?
because u people produced clothes watering powder ...
"We suffer from too much history, we must liberate ourselves from past" - Powerful message there by Yuval Noah Harari!
Yes! Let's all march out together, hand in hand, and smash the statues and monuments our ancestors built to pass down the lessons of the world wars, so that we are finally free to repeat.
@@TheLivirus that person is not good to who u replied, hes from india, and everyone knows
@@TheLivirus that how poor and bad people they r, totally untrustworthy
Mao Zedong said that.
by a historian
What does everyone think about the world economic forum? Depending on your perspective of the WEF is dependent on your thoughts of this guy who I an advisor to the creator of the WEF
Dwie siły walcza w ( nie w każdym ) człowieku.....umiłowanie pokoju i potrzeba walki ( wojny)......
എന്താണിത്. മനസിലായില്ല. ഏതു ഭാഷ?
I'm from Russia. Thank you so much for this amazing interview, TED & Yuval Harari.
I can say this: all your theses and explanations are spinning in my head too. Horror, anxiety, shame and shock from what happened are also spinning.
On February 24, life was divided into before and after. I do not want this war, I do not want the destroyed cities of Ukraine, I do not want people killed, I do not want poverty and the fall of the economy in Russia.
We, as a country, have fallen into a hole on the road to Evolution. It's scary and painful for me to realize this.
I can’t even speak up or protest on the street: the police here put people in jail for reposting on Facebook. They beat people at protests. People get fired after signing petitions. And soon it will get worse.
I hope this will be a lesson for someone. I hope for a better life than this.
Well Sandra you will never understand. Nobody wants a war. The people of Donetsk have been for a long time under threat. Leaving all of that behind, Ukraine have been poking their fingers in the eyes of the Russian government. You know what I will do when someone pokes me in the eye? I will smash that person.
The problem with the younger population in Russia is that they are too dependent on the west's goodies. They are okay to be rags on which you step on provided they are allowed to club, drink, make noise and mess around.
Please go watch videos of John Miershemear. In the international and political realm things are different.
@@davidnwulu748 I understand, believe me. I know what happened there, and it's terrible also. But answering for violence with bigger violence - it's not an option. This interview is all about it, as I see. And I agree. Throwing whole countries into poverty is not the option. I'm not depending on clubs, messing around and goodies, I want to live in the open world and create something, instead of going backward towards the history of progress
@@sandravichuk my dear, life has taught me that some times you have to take one step backwards and two steps forward. Mr Putin has for so many years tried to bring the nations together to talk, explained to the media, talked and talked. Did you ever see Joe Biden explain anything about Donbass? Nobody wants war, nobody wants conflicts but there is a point when enough is enough. So it's not only about saying no to war, we should also say no to American foreign policy, no to provocations, no to NATO expansion because you know what will happen if these aspects don't change? Next will be in Asia. Watch and see. America just needs to stop. They did it in Libya, Japan, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria etc.
I am sorry for the innocent people involved in this conflict, whether it’s the people in Ukraine, the Russian soldiers who got involved unknowingly /unwillingly or the Russian people who oppose what their government is doing. May love and courage be with us all and help everyone affected through the situation.
This interview should not be lost among other content on UA-cam. This should be shared, talked about and commented on.
Why?
@@miravu4638 This is a remarkable merge of culture and common sense that should be listened by all of us, worldwide. Actually, we are living on the edge, a crucial moment in History, when we can succed to face real problems or go back to 1936. Now, there is an ancient country just returned to the scene at the top which has an excellent oportunity to gain the respect of all, but remains quiet instead. Why?
@@joseignaciovivas4372 Which country you are talking about , please, could you be more transparent?
Ancient, at the top?
I would say he is referring to China
This FKing clown didn’t say anything that public doesn’t know already smfh
this video has aged pretty well in the month its been out except he made one factual error when he said all Russia has is oil and gas. They are the worlds biggest grain exporter and one of the biggest fertilizer raw ingredient producers
The demand for oil and gas is already declining, electric cars (heat, etc.) will take it down even more in the next few years. Russia needs Ukraine's rich farm lands to stay afloat, and Putin knows that.
@@gmaureen and what will fuel your electric car? your electric plug lol , even nuclear facilities need gas emegency plants to buffer the mainframe of the electric system , even more since renewables are on the rise , i installed solar systems for 10 years , i stopped because its a fraud in current technologigal status , and only cheap because of asian slave labour ,stolen rare earths and state regulation and this is more reason for war atm , then oil or gas ,
btw , russia is the last country which needs fertile soil , the US stole the Ukraine land since 8 years with landlease contracts -weapons for land ,now their contracts for the eastern parts are invalid lol ....
this comment is not even an argument , when efficient electrical storage finally is invented russia has a sibiria full of rare metals to fuel battery production and hired the best technicians the world can find ,
like they did with german farmers in the last 10 years to become food sufficiant by themselves
@@gmaureen nope.... you need even more oil and gas to power electric vehicle as they demand very high energy output from the grid.
Guess where the energy is produced for the grid? From powerplants....
@@gmaureen How would you explain next decrease of oil- & gas demand?
Recession? Total collapse of the Industry?
Definition of Economy is Energy transformed.
@@ConstantineJoseph - Precisely. This WEF transhumanist wants to get rid of others, for example Israelites, The fact that some people are able to listen to his lies is surprising. Russia has the complete Mendeleiev table (elements).
"It's russian people who want the war. " I thought the same 1 year ago.
Try to speak to them and write in ukrainian. I've heard a lot of insults when I tryed to ask to stop the war in February 2023. They don't consider us as a nation. Ofc, not all of them like that, but the biggest part, unfortunately.
I'm a German watching. What you said, Professor Harari, brought tears to my eyes. "We know you are not Nazis." Thank you.
Many ordinary Europeans know Germany and it's people are not Nazis. Some who try to beat your nation with that stick are themselves closer to that label than the German people.
You should hear his speech at the WEF. He wants to take away all free will and replace with technology.
Du bedankst dich für eine Selbstverständlichkeit? Na Mahlzeit.
Edit:
This guy is by the way someone who is singing the Song of Solomon of the so called World Economic Forum.
Of course you’re not nazis!🥰
@@teaves8251 Agreed, his "elites" rant at the WEF reminded me of the post-modernist dictum; "there is no truth. there is only power."
Just as an
FYI this guy is not just a historian - he is an advisor to the WEF and everything he says should be looked at through that lens.
Believes in doing away with people's free will smh
This guy speaks about authoritarian hierarchal structures and yet he's a mouthpiece for the W.E.F. and Transhumanist movement. He's a wolf in sheep's clothing. NATO and the US want this "war" because they will make billions and because Russia doesn't want to part of the Great Reset and the central banks
introduction to a digital currency.
Why are you trying to undermine his opinion with no facts to bring up. Most you know about Hararis scientific work must be from some conspiracy social media sites or memes. Of course he's a scientist and why not be an advisor for the WEF. The WEF isn't perfect, yes there are a lot of individuals there trying to further their own interest, but Harari is an advisor there for exactly that reason, to give counter arguments for a more humanitarian society. The story is a bit more complex than a good vs evil world view, Im sorry to tell you this.
He wants to remove your mind and thoughts and change them. He is a very sick man. Speaks very well though, but I am cautious at his words.
@@catcar9157 Again, go listen to the full interview and not parts that are taken out of context. I know its harder to listen to a 1 hour interview than a 1 minute clip, but these co spiracies dont do Harari justice. This ignorance is a shame.
so far, we've watching the War for a year. now I can say that HE WAS RIGHT. in a year, I have seen numerous lectures, speeches, and analyses about the Ukranian War, but nothing has been more acurate than this analyzeand predict.
Lots of armchair philosophers in the comment section calling this man evil. IDK about that, he seems pretty chill to me, he's calling for the immediate end to the war in Ukraine to prevent human suffering after all.
There were so many eye opening quotes in this conversation, I can't count them. Let me say as a German myself, only about 1000 km away from the war in Ukraine, we all are very worried, but also surprised by the relatively quick and determined actions by our government and the EU. Thank you a lot for your insight and knowledge you share with us. Best wishes.
rallied and lead by the US or I don't believe that this action would have happened as quickly as it has
@@Balaganbetty No dude, the *_vast_* majority here in Germany *_heavily_* supports Ukraine! Olaf Scholz's career would be wrecked if he decided different.
And our nation definitely has its very own will (...unfortunately not always in positive ways in the past). You seem to forget that it was our very own reunification, which brought an end to the cold war and led to the dissolvement of the Soviet Union > liberating the Eastern European countries from Russian dictatorship. And you seem to forget that it was our nation, that then supported an united and peaceful Europe, to make Europe more political and economic independent. Today the US _have to_ cooperate and coordinate with us instead of dictating political decisions, that's the actual reality.
*Ukrainians are a strong and independent people! Don't give up, Europe stays on your side!* 🇪🇺 💪 🇺🇦
@@Khabaal87 Lol. sure you share some good points but also some blind spots and biases. Ha, you can’t pretend that Germany initiated everything alone without the foundational US support and activism that created a West Germany to reunify with and initiate that reunification, as well as today being critical getting Scholz convinced to be more active in supporting Ukraine militarily. Without US and their creation and military basis behind NATO, you all would be sweating behind Russian bullets, no doubt, esp. because Germany has such relatively low military spending and such a weak military vis-a-vis Russia
Sending you love and light .
my roommate just found a video of soldiers nailing a man to a cross and then burning him alive. She is going to upload it to UA-cam, and is afraid of getting kicked off her account. She is freaking out right now. The soldiers are supposedly Ukrainian neo-nazis, but she says the only man talking sounded American, but the voice was muffled and the video blurry.
I love Harari his books helped to see the world in different way. As a Ukrainian I am really thankful for that support.
I wish peace for my country and people.
My sister has 4 babies and the smallest one is 6 months.
And there’s so many family’s like that that are waiting for help .If you’re feeling like you wanna help somehow you can share about what’s going on in Ukraine on your social media or help Ukrainian army with money. Thanks to everyone
If you want to live, raise the white flag, and go towards the brave Russian warriors. A Russian warrior will not hurt a child. But you can be shot in the back by your own. So sit peacefully in the basement, they'll pull you out and send you home when it's over. You can also jump and bite the throat to the Russian warriot, but then you will be mercilessly beaten. The choice is yours.
@@Redfvvg You poor, deluded soul... God bless you.
@@jennarose60monroe51 OH, MAN. Do you claim to be holy? Are you wrong about me. It's just that I've been through all this catharsis already. I wish you the same.
@@Redfvvg russians have hellfirebombs...
this will not only kill ukrainian soldiers, this will kill all the babys in the metro and children in the cancer hospital basements waiting for peace.
Life without freedom is not worth living. Keep your independent spirit, god bless you! 👊🙏 Respect and Love from Brazil, ukrainians. Our "president" 🤢 is pro-Russia but brazilian people stands by Ukraine!
Great video. Thanks 👍
I'm happy that people around the world grow their humanistic approach. As a result, humans start to support humans whether they are not the same nation or continent. Their tree of kindness in heart is blooming. I can see that now people feel others pain when something bad happens in another place.
Oh how you are young and don’t see he/she calling human species and also has great plan for that species
I really appreciate him saying out loud that it's not the Russian people who want this war.
Lol...Keep dreaming 😂😂😂
It’s Obvious this is Putin War!!..& Putins Mindset! There are So many Russian People Protesting this War!! I feel bad for the Russian people that will suffer from these Sanctions!! Praying for Russia!!😭🙏🙏🇷🇺💔📖🎚👑🕊🕊🕊🌿🌿🌿
Thats very true. We dont want all of this, people here are losing jobs because of hyperinflation and we are about to be blocked from the entire world by the rest of the world. And that fact terrifies me. I am Russian myself and i believe in democracy. I hope the people on top will think with their brains finally. Nobody here wants all this chaos.
Yes. It’s Russians who support their favorite Putin. Its Russians who look down on everyone else. Chauvinists and prejudiced agains everyone different. I’m ethnically Russian.
@@zubatski where were you for 20 years? How did Putin get 82%of support after 2014? Or 70% support now? I’m also Russian. I do know what my former people are.
“Life is very short and anxious for those who forget the past, neglect the present, and fear the future.”
Seneca
Let's make them fight against each other and we will watch and rise when they will fall....
As a german I can say well said about germans, its on the point and true.
Your govt is expecting you to freeze and live with high inflation because they refuse to enter peace talks with Putin.
As a German, I appreciate what he said. Though, having been to school here, I think it is beneficial to be reminded of your country's mistakes, so that we no repeat them. But yes, being reminded what other countries did to yours might just foster hate and not be beneficial at all
As a Fin I can say that even if everyone always talks about the negative side of what Hitler did, his "greed" also made it possible for us to be free. It might have been a cruel act in history but I'm happy that I was born in Finland and not in Russia. When germany stated that they will increase their military I felt a sense of increased security because I have always lived in a small sense of fear what the Russian leadership will do next(since I was a child the russian military has reminded us that they are there by flying military planes into our airspace or something similar, thus reminding our people that "fear us"). I do know that most of the russian people do not agree with their leadership atleast the ones I know but they don't seem to be able to gain any power without getting in worst cases killed. Everything my grandparents told me about Russia has proven to be true, so I have never blamed german people for what happened same as I have never blamed the russian people. We just need to create a world were the few in power can ruin everyone elses lives, yes we need someone to lead but the voices of the people should always be stronger than the voice of a small group :D But germans could start to speak english in games, like eng ain't my mothertongue either but...
Then the victors of a war writes the history and the propaganda was massive. Was the outcome really the best possible for the humans and did the outcome save lives, I don't know but it made "peace". I only know it saved a lot of jews and killed a lot of eastern europeans. From what I have seen from the victors of WW2 I sometimes think "Would the world have been a better place if the other side would have won". USA is bullying every country with fossile fuels(when norway found oil the first joke was "Soon USA will find weapons of mass destruction in Norway", Russia keeps "I don't know what to call it", China is what it is, UK sits like a little kid behind daddy's(USA) back and fcks everyone off. Europe excluding UK tried to better itself, Japan is more conserned about the next bright color in pokemon than wars. All the loosing parts became better while the victors only becomes worse and worse. Russia could have become a great nation, communism is one of the best government types if the ones in charge would follow the rules. USA are lost, its ruled by capitalism and everything is about money and 1 being better than the other person. USA makes life into a competition spreading their "¤%#¤" everywhere when we should try to find a way together. Europe has a chance if we just focus on following the rules we set up in EU(I know Finland follows em like word for word while some just see em as guidelines that you can follow if you want). So my point is that Germans has nothing to be ashamed of cause they have improved while the ones still running the WW2 propaganda only managed to become worse.
@@amadeuz8161 "Saved a lot of Jews," lol. You have a lot of smoke for somebody who is massively generalising. There's a reason most of Europe is successful.
Which countries in Europe are capitalist?
"Basically every country in Europe. Don’t be fooled by the American “propaganda”, Europe is not dominated by socialists or communists, it is a continent full of capitalistic countries that implemented more or less social policies aiming at increase the welfare of the citizens: public education, public healthcare etc. The closest you can get to the capitalistic USA is probably switzerland. Taxes at a minimum, federal states, private (but mandatory) healthcare." (Nice quick breakdown by Alessandro Fuga.)
There's a reason communism doesn't work when implemented, and every "they're just not doing it the right way" just furthers the image that Marxism is fed by narcissism.
@@msshannonigans Jews and eastern europeans was the short version. Point was that people suffered whatever the outcome was. Won't even try to guess if the other outcome would have been better, I just sometime wonder if it would have been. Avoiding WW1 would have been the best possible outcome, we had solar panels, we had electrical cars, we were on the way to create a world that might not have created the situation we have today.
Like I said Europe has tried to better itself and that we still have a chance. I do know america has infected us with "the #"%&¤ dream" but still we haven't hit rock bottom as they have.
You never know if communism works in the future, could be that humans will get wiser or even give the leadership to something that is able to be neutral. In our current world it can't work not as long as we are not equal and money is worth more than our future.
Let's say my love for USA is so great that I don't think I would ever believe their propaganda, but I have fallen for their way when it comes to some comforts(I do try to only use what I need but it's not easy to hinder yourself from some luxuries, I'm not a monk).
Totally agreed. It is important to remind ourselves of our mistake, especially for the talented countries like Germany.
I like the fact that Prof Harari openly said that he doesn't know enough about China to make proclamations. Rather than pontificate and make proclamations beyond his realm of expertise, he offered hopes rather than opinions-masquerading-as-knowledge. I think this makes him a true intellectual. Too many so-called intellectuals these days are grubby opportunists who will spout their opinions without really knowing what they're talking about. I think I'm going to have to buy one of his books.
You will love them. Might not agree on everything he exposes there, but there are some true gems in his writing... I've read them all
He is Klaus Swaab's right hand man. Do you want to own nothing and be happy?
Well put. I'm not opposed to opinions and theories being shared, but shownyour sources and cite it as an opinion.
Debate and discussion have become 4 letter words these days. Communication is the foundation of negotiation and society, we must encourage exchange of ideas to bring US forward...
Putin is an antique of a time that should be left in the past, not emulated
Harari is atheist. Unless he says Jesus Christ is Lord, walk away from him or anyone. Do not trust this man, please. Please please. Research him. He sounds great, he decieved me too, but once I realized he was a WEF poney, I quickly backed away.
@@lahair5751 I don't care, man. I'm a Muslim, and he's an israeli atheist. So what? I've read his books. There are lots of valuable pieces of knowledge and insights that he offered in his books. I don't always agree with him, but I'm not gonna reject everything that he said just because he had some views that are different from mine.
As long as he cites his sources, and presents logical arguments that are also backed up by the shreds of evidence from his sources, it doesn't matter whether he's a Christian, a Muslim like me, an agnostic, atheist, or whatever. Einstein was a deist. Newton was an Arian (a heresy branch of Christianity). Al-Khawarizmi was a muslim. And these people's insights and discoveries built our civilization.
Even when they were wrong about something, we can always point out where they were mistaken. It's not like everything that he said suddenly becomes false or lies.
Heck, even the devil spoke the truth sometimes. And when it is the truth we're talking about, don't miss the opportunity. We should sit down and listen, and then decide for ourselves whether to believe it or not.
I have to disagree in some regard. Kiev was the heart of the proto state of the Kievan Rus and was never a part of Poland until the Union of Lublin in 1569 when the city came under Polish administration. To say Kiev was Polish is as insulting as to say that it was Russian.
@ It is not an academic discussion - you can go to library and check everything he said
Ukraine is a laundromat for the American tax payers money. Period. Btw, harari says u are useless.
Not even one mention on the fact that Nato tried to add ukraine to the alliance knowing very well that it would lead to war which reveals what Natos stands for in the question war or peace.
"Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed.
"This world in arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children." President Dwight D. Eisenhower
Well if god didn't want us to go hungry, he wouldn't have given us stomachs. Take that Dwight.
@@etsequentia6765 no, god is counting on humans to make sure no one goes hungry
@@sueconkle7562 Christians have no idea who god really is. So keep god out of it.
“Humans are now hackable animals, this idea that they have this soul or spirit or they have free will and ‘nobody knows what’s happening inside me so whatever I choose whether in the election or in the supermarket this is my free will’ that’s over.” “today we have the technology to hack human beings on a massive scale” “it’s often said you should never allow a good crisis to go to waste” “people could look back in 100 years and identify the c*r*n*v*r*s epidemic as the moment a new regime of surveillance took over, especially surveillance under the skin” - Yuval Noah Harari
That is true enough.
But I believe he also once said “No victory is won at bargain prices.”
Mr Harari ,I read one of your books Sapiens ,ultimately a book that question and put in doubt every essence of your Jewish belief. You are a Trans humanist & top Advisor to Klaus Schwab , and therefore you are an important member , if not part , of the World Economic Forum . You also write on The Guardian.
You have talked very openly about the necessity of governments to control the population , “men are trackable AND when they are tracked they can be engineered “.
It is that what you are trying to do here as you answer the questions. Are you telling us the truth or are you trying to configuraste our mind so we think the way you want.?
This man should not be given a platform. It's unbelievable he isn't being called out for his eugenics agenda.
The question about sanctions was not about whether the sanctions might work but have such sanctions worked in the past.
"Since 1945 not a single internationally recognised country was wiped off the map" - what about the Indonesian invasion of East Timor?
I love how he said that most of the wealth is sucked to the top in Russia, but he knows damn well this occurs everywhere in the world!
You're right. But at the same time, it is in Russia and in countries like this that people are very poor. It's not normal. I think you are aware of this and can compare the standard of living in different countries.
@@arthurvolokhov1911 Yes i do agree the standard of living in other countries is much better. I do wonder for how much longer though with all the instability. I pray for the people who are effected more then others of course.
He probably knows that too, but we are discussing Russia as a country, as a political structure, so it doesn't really matter to the debate.
@@DarkAngelEU This was not a debate it was a fact. Also hes Klaus Shwabs right wing man so im positive that hes well aware of money flowing to the top spots all around the world. We are a bunch of useless eaters to them!
@@halleyevans1980 Still, why does that matter when we are debating Russia? If we are discussing lemons, should I start complaining we aren't discussing limes enough? Or oranges? What about ALL THE CITRUS FRUITS!!???
I'm Ukrainian and it was very interesting to listen your point of view! Thank you for your support!
слава Україні
You know this psychopath wants to change your God Created DNA... ????
Slava Ukraini
@@ascadianwhipmaster31 Russia was founded in Kiev.
Yuval promotes the view of the Zionists who deny the Russians that they are Ukrainians and vice versa. His wealth-rich compatriots always lead both sides to war. The fewer white people, the better! Why does Ukraine have the coat of arms of Khazaria, and why does Putin use Z (Zion) as a sign?
💛💙
Two months ago it seemed for Professor Harari that the russian society is not for the war. Well, the time has passed and we see with our own eyes the opinions and the actions of many russian «people«, whether they are in russia or in berlin or wherever.
I'm from 9 months in the future. The fight is still raging on. Ukraine is now fighting not for survival, but for victory. Bruised Russia begs for peace talks. However we don't stop. We are not done yet. Don't be afraid. The future is bright. 🙂
Я тоже из будущего.
Россия не навязывается ни на какие переговоры(переговоры это фейк).
Второе,ушибленная Россия ждёт,когда всему миру надоест кормить чёкнутых нацистов,и они это перестанут делать.
Тогда Украина сама рассыпиться как бусы.
@@Golenberg, Вы забыли упомянуть что Украина замёрзнет вместе с Европой 😆
Серьёзно, Вы не заметили что Вы разговариваете и похоже думаете пропагандистскими шаблонами?
Вам не стыдно защищать фашистский режим?
I am from Russia my life was divided 2 parts after February 24th. I'm horrified and still can't believe what's happening. Complete despair and powerlessness. My grandparents survived World War II and never wanted to talk about it. "Just no war," they repeated this all their lives. All my childhood fears came to life and became a reality. I don't see anything bright in the future.
God bless your family and god bless this mess and may god keep us all safe.
Our leaders have failed us miserably, unfortunately.
if you want the war to end, do something, not write sad comments. people in Ukraine are dying from your indifference...
@@blue1409 shut up...
@@blue1409 who are you to judge me? If you live in Russia and you are in prison for your views, then, it's OK. But if you are sitting on the sofa in a foreign country, pass by. Even if we will have millions imprisoned, for you it will be just a TV show, and it will never be enough.
@@user-rp3qb7qs2l I am from Ukraine, and yes, you remarked well, Ukrainians, unlike you, are not slaves of their own country.
As a Russian I want to thank you for sharing this. It is really important to show as many people as possible what's actually going on. Sadly my nation mostly fail to understand it or so we are made to believe by those who in power. I am not going to give up anyway and wish everyone to stay strong
yea for some reasons, the western democracy always leads to war....
Я не понимаю, Юваль говорит что Москва и Киев были разными политическими единицами. Он явно не знает, что история России началась в Киеве, а потом Юрий Долгорукий перенёс столицу в Москву.
@@evelinamean3642 боже, да он либо дурак, либо врун. И самое страшное, что тут все пишут, как он их "просветил". Вот так вот люди учат историю через Ютуб от псевдоисториков. Приравнивать нынешнюю Украину к Киевской Руси - это фейспалм. Ага, а Италия - это та же Римская Империя.
True or False?
UKRAINE BECAME A FAILED STATE WHEN THE WEST BACKED A VIOLENT COUP IN FEBRUARY 2014 AND ALLOWED NEO-NAZIS TO MARAUD THROUGH THE STREETS AND DOMINATE SOME OF THE HIGHER ECHOLONS OF THE MILITARY RANKS AND THEN FLOODED THE COUNTRY WITH WEAPONS.
For Democracy, the US overthrew a democratically elected government to install leaders more to its liking and has invested $5B.
2014: US-UK-EU-NATO BACKED VIOLENT COUP D'ETAT IN KIEV
2014-2015: UKRAINE MILITARYY 'ANTI-TERROR' BLITZKRIEG ATTACK AGAINST DONBAS (Dubbing the entire Russian speaking population "terrorists".)
2014-2015: Minsk I & II ACCORDS - PEACE PROCESS
2015-2022: UKRAINE GOVERNMENT STATED POLICY NOT TO RATIFY NOR IMPLEMENT MINSK ACCORDS
2014-2022: KIEV REGIME OUTLAWS RUSSIAN LANGUAGE, LEGALISED DISCRIMINATION AGAINST ETHNIC RUSSIANS (Arresting television staff, journalists, editors, taking tv off the air.)
2014-2022: KIEV REGIME OUTLAWS CERTAIN RUSSIAN OPPOSITION PARTIES
2015-2022: UKRAINE FORCES SHELLING CIVILIANS IN DONBAS (POPULATION 4 MILLION)
LAST STRAW: ZELENSKY TALKS ABOUT PURSUING NUCLEAR PROGRAM TO COUNTER RUSSIA
@@evelinamean3642 не знаете потому что вы необразованный человек.
One can only HOPE!
well teached .
I was expecting a more academic approach to the issue from Yuval, rather than talking about a fantasy in Putin's head similar to what we have been hearing from the mainstream media. He did not say one single thing that we already do not know. I believe John Mearsheimer is the guy to go about this issue.
100% - this is basically simplistic assumptions about the motivations f the main players - i expected more from Yuval than hyperbole
I absolutely agree! It seems that when it comes to Russia, even the most respected scholars lose their objectivity and follow the trend of triggering public emotions. Unfortunately , for them reputation is more important than truth.
Absolutely agree with this. It's not about absorbing Ukraine into Russia, for the sake of expanding an empire, but rather keeping a buffer between East and West. Pretty unbalanced analysis of a more complex and long standing issue
SAME!!!!! I could’ve watched this from a cnn reporter 😒. Come on Noah. seems like an emotional response rather than an intelligent one
...I agree...He's deliberately downplaying the main issue with Putin...
He want's his audience to believe that Putin is living in a fantasy world...Which isn't the case!
Notice that he...( and the facilitator)...touches on the issue of Russia's National security...but does not honestly discuss it!
I could go on...but...
Here's what I know...In order to solve any problem... you have to first...understand ...the problem...what caused the problem!
For instance...If your car has an engine malfunction...and you delude yourself into believing that the issue is with the braking system....
You're never going to resolve the real...problem!
That's what's happening here!
It's a pity though...that Ukraine is being made..." The Sacrificial Lamb!"
For me as an italian-german it was very moving to hear from Mr. Harari that he doesn't consider the present german people being Nazis. Thank you very much for saying this plainly.
But his own country has become today's Nazis.
@@kayem3824
BS. The Palestinians were allied with the Nazis in WWII because they hated Jews. Racists, terrorists, authoritarians and refuse peace and to recognize Israel.
Yuri is a communist!
@@justgivemethetruth Because it's an apartheid state.
You don’t have to be on your knees when you say this. Rise up. Stop groveling. Stand on your feet and try being a man.
2022(G) “Respect and dignity.” Furthermore:
He's on his way to be leveled.
As a German who worked as software developer in Tel Aviv between 1999 ans 2001 I am very happy about the trust you have in German generations after the war. When I was in Israel I was so deligthen that I didn't face any hate because I was a German. After visiting Yat Vashem I was sure people can overcome hate and this is the grace of life.
I am also married to russian woman, her name is Svetlana. She came to Germany in 1997 because of the big quarelles in Russia at that time. She spoke German very well. My russian was very poor (though I stayed two years in Israel ;-)) but we fell in love and married and have a great boy. If some had told me in 1990 before the German reunification I had told him or her you are absolutely insane. Me wife and me, both raised in the cold war, I in west Germany and she in the Soviet Union. We even had problems to marry because Germany didn't accept her papers but we managed to get the contract. Since then we go through life together. I visited several times my parents in law that are the best parents in law you can think of. My family is as well a proof that families with very different history and background can peacefully come together. Ok my wife and me we had also some trouble and different opinions about how way of life should be. But we always managed to sort it out. Our family is not a fantasy. It was created on the end of cold war between the super powers and we will defend it and we support in every way the Ukranian people with their great and heroic brave fight. Gospadin Putin: You have already lost the war, be so brave to accept it. We don't want to fight against Russia but if you don't stop we must.
He will not accept it. He can finish the world pushing the bottom, then we’re all gone!
People can overcome it even without visiting Yat Vashem. But by visiting it, you'd probably upset people with less cordial relations with Israel, and who also can tell their side of the story. The whole Palestinian-Israeli conflict. And yes, the Israeli's also can tell other stories than those about WW 2: 1967, 1974, Olympic Games of München etc. The past always will cast a shadow on the future. See how Putin goes back to the 9th century to try to make his arguments stick. It is as if Italy all of a sudden would start making claims on parts of Belgium "because it once belonged to the Roman empire". And what about the poor black tribes in South Africa, that were chased away by the Zulu's, who in turn were dominated for decades by the Whites, who in turn were replaced by the ANC... Who started out with a promising future... But who led the country to complete chaos, anarchy, corruption and kleptocracy ?
"You'll Own Nothing. And You'll Be Happy."
505,184 views • Jul 19, 2021 • The globalist World Economic Forum-which Trudeau,
Putin does not want American missiles aimed at Russia
He addressed this for 20 years
@@Retroscoop Well said.
So painstakingly accurate this man: more healthcare-less military tanks! Godspeed to Peace in Ukraine.
Except he omitted China’s obliteration of Tibet. (Around 36’.)
Socialised medicine nothing to do with defence. Socialised medicine in UK & France both Nuclear Powers, & Two of the permanent members of UN security council. Both have continued to spend 3 to 5% on Defence. Socialised medicine is actually more economical & efficient & has allowed more spend on defence...... Basic economics
How people could remain so naive after the 2 last years ? Socialised medicine is being destroyed by the western politicians, can't you see it ? it's being replaced by Big data, bio-tech and medical industry all under control of big pharma and financial world
I agree with 112deeps that the difference is not healthcare. The US actually spends a huge proportion of GDP on healthcare although it is in the private sector. I guess (but have not checked) that the higher spending compared with the US would be social benefits or perhaps infrastructure. Whatever the cause, Europe and the UK will have to make some difficult choices. Harari is not criticising Germany for raising defence spending - he says it is reasonable - but it is tragic that the invasion will push countries into a logical but negative increase in spending. A relatively peaceful world and productive use of resources benefits from a stable international system based on law, rather than on a world governed by power relations alone, which means that only military strength counts.
Maybe the accurate way to put this was: more healthcare -less terrorist dictators leading countries-who engage arsenals to even take the socialized/private medicine question *off the map*. Let’s get to zero lunatics leading countries-as a first step.
I am a bit discouraged that Mr.Hariri as a historian does not know that Kievskaya Rus’ and Ukraine are not one and the same and that it was Russian tsar dynasties that reigned in Kiev. So I stopped listening on the third minute due to rude historical mistakes.
People from the tribe of Europe and North America (in earthly language Western society) often measure their experience with the entire world. The Western mind set if there is no war in Europe, then the world is a peaceful place, and they often disregard the wars and turmoil in Africa, the Middle East, Asia and South America.
Dear Ukraine you are not alone! Stay strong! We are crying all of our tears for this tragedy and waking up at night thinking about you all. We are also close to all of those Russians who do not want this war to be done in their names. Much love from Italy ❤ PEACE
I am from Poland, I was on the border to take few people to Warsaw and I just must say that I admire social aspect and conclusions of mr Yuval - even experiencing war very gently, at the border, for couple hours changed me deeply, I will never forget it and I will always feel great pain about civilians experiencing such a tragedy. Every day for milions of people is a game changer for generetions, it must be stopped as soon as possible!!
Tell Zelenskiy to surrender, that move will save Ukranian lives. But he won't. He's a puppet of the Russia hawk/globalist wing of the U.S. State Department.
Plus the Zelenskiy's Jewish, he's not a Slav, so what does he care if Slav's are suffering and dying? I pray for peace.
P. S. Tell your Government Thank You for telling the U.S. State Department to fly the MiG-29's to Ukraine themselves!! That was an excellent and very wise move.
Interesting, my replies dissapear!
Regular folks should be excluded from fighting wars, only the generals, president and high ranking officials are to be sent to wars.
@IonCrox jo mamma got censored, so we will never know what you replying to.
I know of Volhynia, and the deeply rooted animosity between Ukrainians and Poles, so I only have respect for Poles who help Ukrainians.
But really, what's about the about the"Drawing lines -in -Sand", "Sykes-Pikot Line in the Sand creating 'Fiefdoms'. We have many issues!
Like everything in life, it’s about balance. War is just another way of nature seeking balance . Sadly, Nature is not always kind, it can at times be cruel.
Im Russian and Im praying for Ukranians. This Ted talk really helped me understand the motives of why certain things happened (its still hard to believe its happening, but it does). Thank you!
Also from Russia, praying for peace in our countries, my heart is bleeding watching the events unfold each day. Please, please may peace be restored!! PLEASE!!!
I am with Russia due to it's security issues but not Putin, USA uses its money and media power to influence people, Ukraine should have balanced itself... Instead of tilting any sides...
can you tell what's the perspective in (younger) russian society now? Because russian media just say 70 percent of russians support Putin
@@rajatshinde5395 i cant speak for everybody but none of young people i know supoort Putin (at least those who know the truth). But all people can do is pray and stay patient and wait.
@@rajatshinde5395 support for Putin come from poorest areas mostly, just one reason mostly - no alternative media to get news, only tv (all channels controlled by government censorship) and papers (also almost none against current regime, but few trying to speak, and their newspapers get confiscated before local release). Almost everyone who use internet can get alternative sources of news. (Many people still have slow internet, so they are can’t see video etc, but can read) also, you need to be tech savvy at least a bit, because most internet resources blocked atm, just searching won’t help, you need to know when, like telegram channels etc.
Many many Russians have relatives in Ukraine and that’s definitely help, because they can speak through regular phone.
People still in shock. Lugansk and Donetsk situation wasn’t really popular after 2015. So when people start to see that dollar and euro rise up they are try to search for info, and most of the time start with tv ofc, but because Ukraine still stand times go and more more people realize what actually happened. Recently more that 3000 moms start to try get info where they’re sons really is… and that moms from poor areas mostly…
I’m Russian citizen, but half Ukraine and have relatives in Ukraine, as most Russian I guest. Many people in Russia in deep regrets of what happening right now, and try to spread alternative news, sending money to help, but our government making that more harder and harder each day. ( we can’t donate to Red Cross for example, but we are still finding ways to donate and help 🤫)
"I need ammunition, not a ride" is hands down the most badass response I've ever heard, movies and television shows included.
Agree. He could have taken his money and his family and fled like so many others have thru out the years. I feel this was something Putin and Biden did not anticipate. He stayed and rallied people in Ukraine and around the world. We can only hope a cease fire and peace negotiations happen soon. If not, this will be a long war and the world will be very tense for a long time.
@Brittany, I laughed when I heard it too. It really shows that although Zelensky is fierce and serious, you can tell he had a comedic past.
@@angeltobit878 no, President is fierce and serious. Full stop.
I also liked the "Russian warship, go f*ck yourselves" quote from Snake Island. 👍
With due respect to the knowledge of the guest historian, the history of the people who form the today's Ukraine is much more complex.
Oh my God he said we were living in a peaceful world fro 2,3 decades, it means he does not give weight of human to unfortunate Syrians ,Iraqians, Afgahnians, and Kashmiri Palastinians????? He just understand humans West and Us
I live in Romania, I have been experienced communism for only 16 years of my life, but those memories are still vivid, as the stories taught by my parents and grandparents. Even after 30 years since 1989, when we got rid of a mad communist power-hunger leader, I still feel the horror and threat of Russian tanks entering my country, to "free" us. We do not want Russians to enter any country, any more. Enough. Slava Ukraine.
Like seriously - can't he stay within his borders? That's the minimum we want.Stay the fk home without "liberating" or "anexing" territories.
Same here. I'm heart sick. Was born into the soviet occupation in Poland and remember the huge changes the minute it all colapsed here. I just know Id also be able to die for freedom to never ever be occupied like this ever again. I feel the anxiety everyday these days watching the news and only smile when I read some some success Ukrainians had. I start crying out of nowhere in the middle of the supermarket for example, and my British Jamaican partner cannot understand me. And I know he cannot. One Has to live thru this to really understand.
But at the same time you are welcoming USA missiles and NATO troops in your country? Very weird...
I am from China and still suffering under the disgusting ruling of communism. I hate it.
@@johnnysgamingclub2126 The US doesn't impose a dictatorship to Romania, but Russia did
I am amazed that the guest is able to say that there has been no war in the recent decades. Has he been living in a cave somewhere. Yes there has been no war in Europe but Europe is no longer the center of the world and certainly not the world.what is happening in Ukraine is absolutely horrible. But I wish the same narrative was laid out for the people of Iraq , syria and afghanisthan who have suffered worst with nowhere to go.
There has been war in Europe. The illegal bombing of Belgrade by NATO in 1999 for 78 days non stop.
Respects from Pakistan!
Egocentric view... everything that is not western or European aligned is irrelevant... The arrogance is incomprehensible
@@pepedass7488 You do know that basically every technology you use was invented by the west or recently in China? Your countries have, unfortunately, no innovation.
In fact, we all know that at least the middle east was once leading in science. It was back in the Middle ages, with the fall of constantinople in 1453 it declined and the people there made a step backwards. All of your scientists fled to europe and started the renaissance. You innovated alot back then, but today you are irrelevant in science and innovation.
I have to urge you, that we the people in the west and China are fighting against extinction due to climate change. If the US, EU or China declines too much it might be game over. Humanity is at the mercy of these nations.
And I wanna pressure you to read about climate change, because africa and the middle east would become inhabitable first.
A lot of people enjoy the western lifestyle. Especially young russians. The west is not at all that bad.
I agree. More than 25,000 children have been killed in the Syrian civil war and if I remember correctly, over 400,000 adults. Thats absolutely terrible.
Many technologies that were developed for defense,now have applications in healthcare//money should go to all sciences equally bc you never know which one can emerge to be a "market" favourite
For a 'Historian' YNH doesn't give any, let alone 'sufficient' references to dates, treaties, historical records. Those would help more than anecdotes from a brief tour of the country.
I'm russian. I live in Nizhny Novgorod. All my friends hate the war. A huge amount people hate this war there. But people are intimidated. I hope that world community could divide the Criminal Russian Government and Russian people, who hate this war. NO TO WAR. Слава Украине!
Ты прав, друг мой. All those around me make a sharp distinction between the Russian people and the Russian leadership. In fact, most of the Russian people have for a long time now been victims of their own leadership. That’s sad, because it doesn’t need to be like this. We certainly hope for a better future for both the Ukrainian and the Russian “everyday” people.
The population is also to blame. You are supporting Putin by not doing nothing. They can't arrest the entire population if they protest. Most of the Russians are complacent and don:t care what îs happening în Ukraine.
Only the US can end this war by not meddling and provoking the other country.
Freedom does not come from wanting alone-- it must be fought for-- by the Russian people. Last century there was a Russian Revolution where ordinary Russians brought down the Czar. This needs to happen again to bring down Putin and his cronies. Only when you are willing to die for your freedom do you merit it.
liviu simioanca said it!
With great respect to you, Yuval N Harari, let me ask you - why you didn't show the same empathy and sympathy to the Iraqis and Afghans when these countries were invaded! According to you, the ordinary people of these countries didn't suffer in those invasions? Of course, I agree that what Ukrainians are going through is quite unfortunate and should be stopped.
yeah, poor Afghan women, they were so much better off during Taliban regimes than under the brutal American rule giving them right to vote, work, and educate and all that western nonsense, right?
@@roddydelipsa1769 So your invasions were liberations, and others do invasions !!! Wow. Please keep such arguments in some local pubs where it will have great acceptance.
That's ture we need to liberty from our history. Global intellectual and leader should collaborate to stop this disaster war. Because this world is the only home we share together.
Key words in first sentence. Thank you for telling important information. I love TED
💩🤦😂
Guys could you please add the Russian subtitles, i want to share it with my friends who actually dont even know historical details and the key issue like Yuval said.
P.s. i am from Russia and i am praying for Ukrain
Каким образом ты собираешься получить достоверную информацию у человека вообще не имеющего отношения к данному конфликту, наблюдающему его со стороны и потом дающему интервью, переворачивая ситуацию с ног на голову - в угоду обласкавшим его сми Запада и США. Этот человек - псевдоисторик, судя по тому что я услышала уже в первые минуты.
This WEF good 'ol boy that lets us know humans have no soul, is also a history and geopolitics expert. Amazing
I am so surprised that the people in the comments are looking up to him!
I watched that clip where he mentioned that . They don't care about the people just policies .
Shocked reading the comments until I came across this comment .
He said we were “Hackable Humans”
He’s a historian who went to Oxford and has a doctorate and post doctorate degrees. Also he believes humans don’t have souls. There I fixed it for you.
I guess the animals in the comments have already been hacked. Glad I came across one comment that makes sense.
joining this guy will end in non human entitys
Its a common fact that Poroshenko (or Valcman?) was sending trains with armory and weapons over 1.5 month to Donetsk for the “enemies” the during 2014 so that it can be a real war instead. Howso?
For such a renowned historian, I'd expect him to be more precise. Saying that "Kyiv was a major metropolis and cultural center when Moscow was not even a village," while true, is EXTREMELY REDUCTIVE. Russia and Ukraine, as well as Belarus, share a common ancestry in Kievan Rus, which was a loose federation of medieval city-states with its capital in Kyiv. But in the 13th century, the area which became Russia was conquered by the Mongol Golden Horde, while western portions later fell to the Polish-Lithuanian Empire. From there, three separate languages and national identities evolved. We were the same people. I am Russian, and I hate what Putin is doing to my brothers and sisters in Ukraine, but you can't make reductive arguments for the sake of a jab.
Thanks for pointing out.
So true
I agree with your take on the history, but you have to also admit Putin’s soul is so twisted by his own false understanding of history.
I found it amusing that this “Jewish” historian wants to speak about how Ukrainian people are not Russians because they existed before Russia … while he says their president is Jewish. So the president is not even pure-Ukrainian.
FYI - have you listened to this psychopath Yuval brag about how they are now able to “hack” humans. This guy is pure evil with a Satanic agenda!
Your information is very interesting, but I'm so grateful the speaker didn't get side-tracked from what he was saying by including more "precisions" than needed for the flow of his discussion. Why don't you record a talk for UA-cam so we can hear what you know. .
@@lancealbon46 Lance youve obviously didnt take the time to listen to the whole talk about bioengineering, it's not about 'hacking' people like so man in this comments falsly proclaim. Stop watching reduced 1 minute compilations that dont show the full picture, go listen to the whole thing. Theyre taking his words out of context, of course youre not understanding him correctly. Hes not evil in any way.
I appreciate all your speech, thank you for the interview. Yuval Noah is such intelligent person. I'm Russian, and I am against the war. I want Peace!
I am in Canada and I know that most Russians do not want this war!! I sincerely wish the Russian people the best and I hope this whole situation will turn in the favor of the Russian people and the Ukrainian people. Peace to you
I don't understand why young russian people is not in the streets demanding for peace. You, russians, have not much time left to show to the rest of the world that you don't suport Putin in this absurd war. Like Harari said, the seeds of hate are been planted right now. And the russians will be the victims of that in the future.
@@antonioteixeira7820 They do not have freedom of expression in Russia, they get arrested and beaten up if they protest!! Really sad situation.
War is such a waste of human potential.
@@hayalet7156 This person is saying they dont like war!! If you need to provoke people, there are enough troublemakers like you in other comments on here!!
Thank you
More than a year has passed since the recording of this interview, and the war is still going on and it is not clear when it will end ... Much of what was said turned out to be a 100% hit. The situation is exactly as described: there are many victims and half of them are civilians, the destruction of cities and villages is terrible. Some of the towns and villages simply do not exist anymore. Hatred of Russians makes it difficult to think, live and breathe. This state is not for years. It will spread through generations. It's sad but true. This, perhaps, is something that will have to be accepted as given and build life on the basis of this fact. Unfortunately.
Yuval never said anything about Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria.. war but seems very passionate anti Russian-ukraine war
Most people in the west dont even know other wars are going on like jemen, syria..
classic j3vv hypocrisy ( I am j3vvish too but can see these things)
Hello! I really love what you do and lots of my friends from Russia read Yuval’s books. But not many of Russians speak English and they’re struggling to understand this conversation.
Please, add Russian subtitles to this video! We should give Russians an opportunity to see the truth. Especially when all independent media have closed.
We can help with translation on Russian, but please let’s give Russian people more information!
Thank you.
You will have to look somewhere else for truth, nothing but biased propaganda here..
Найдите "Scott Ritter ukraine" и послушате, что говорят американцы, которые были в системе. А этот чувак НЕ геополитик, НЕ военный, у него свой взгляд историка/писателя
@@johnnysgamingclub2126 No. It's your bias. I guess you prefer to have hatred.
Do you believe Russian people will be effected by Yuval Noah Harari? If so do you believe the people around putin and his oligarchs will hear and understand Yuval Noah Harari and be positively effected and feel the same? If so release this video in Russian language.
@@robertlee8805 in another comment Johnny states that the Russians founded Kyiv. Talk about not knowing history. He is an idiot but there are many of those around these days
" Those who forget their history are DOOMED to repeat it "
- George Santayana
Doesn't this man work for Klauss Schwab? The guy who says you will own nothing and be happy. This man Yuval endorses "hacking" humans and reducing humanity to cyborgs aka an advocate for Transhumanism. 🤔
I think what he was trying to say was not to forget history, that doesn't make sense. He was intending to say not to keep grudges, not to dwell on resentment about events in the past. You are right that studying history should lead to a better understanding of what not to do and many cautionary tales.
@@faithesprit81 I don't see that he endorsed anything like that in his writings. He was warning us of what it there in store for us in the future. He is just doing his job.
"The sea creates waves so to be able to experience companionship itself. Knowing this. What is there to argue about? What is there to fight over? Nothing is more absurd than conflict. The one and only purpose of life is companionship otherwise known as love." Wald Wassermann, Physicist
Now….everyone back to work and finish that bomb!
The Great Deceiver's disciple.