As someone who spent the first 20 years of his life in the US and moved to Sweden I will tell you that this kind of uninformed-crusader fighting for what they “feel” vs facts is universal🤦🏻
Walk into a pub in England you are very likely to hear moans about immigrants. Prince Harry isn't making it up about England. There are a lot of nice people in the UK, but it's got issues man.
Immigration is capitalism importing an over supply of labour in, which is a race to the bottom particularly for the working class. Oligarchs love immigration. Capitalism will never invest in training or increase pay and conditions if it can just fly in labour. Back in the day the Left understood this even Bernie Sanders was anti immigration.
@@Jack-e5t It will not be a landslide my friend. Lots of people are going to vote for the smaller parties. I agree with her in her original statement that protests are a nuisance in London. They have cost people's jobs and lives! James didn't like what she said so he took her on an intellectual merry-go-round to put her off! You have drawn a wild conclusion from my comment, that I am right wing! Laughable! I will not vote Tory.
@@Jack-e5t To assume I'm a right winger from what I have said is laughable! I will not vote Tory but I will not vote Labour either. Labour will not have a landslide as a lot of people will vote for the smaller parties!
As an American who works in radio, this sounds eerily familiar to some of the callers we have here. But O'Brien is a master at letting these people talk themselves into a knot. This was a masterclass.
@@sublime3784 I actually rarely meet Brits that have spent time in the states . Most have an opinion of course but they mirror what they think is American xenophobia. I enjoyed my time in North America. LA , San Francisco and New York . People were intelligent, caring, inclusive and slim 🤣
Probably because she most likely got her 'facts' from news pumped out by the same Aussie media mogul that provides the same 'facts' to the nutcases in your country. Murdoch is a menace and the day he is no longer on this earth is the day many sensible people will breathe a huge sign of relief
Masterfully done Sir. As a visa holder in the UK who pays DOUBLE for the NHS, and does not qualify for any benefits, I appreciate this. What a willfully dense individual.
Thanks for posting, Tavera. Welcome to the UK, and thank you for contributing to the economy ❤. The caller probably thinks you were given a Ferrari, a 15-bedroom council house, a villa in Tuscany, £20,000 a week of benefits money, and Apple Mac, iPad, iPhone and a Playstation3, but at least two of us know, and probably the majority of the population knows, she hasn't got a clue.🤫
@@edforbes1563, on application for a visa there is a set NHS fee, which is non-refundable. Once sich a person starts working they start paying national insurance, hence double payment.
@@edforbes1563 There are caveats to accessing the NHS. Just existing on UK soil does not give you free healthcare. The NHS will treat you because that's the humane thing to do, but you may well be charged either directly, or to your home nations government.
That is a shocking example of cognitive dissonance in action. "This is a thing that is true." "How do you know?" "I don't have a clue." "Why do you believe it?" "Because it's true."
And why do you think that, realistic UK population around 100, million, and we're allowing millions of more people into the country illegally, we don't have the resources to deal with this amount of people, on our tiny islands
@@ellismeah8110 we have more than enough and our country is run on immigration! We built our wealth and welfare state on the backs of European and Commonwealth nations, this is a pure and utter lie saying we don’t have enough Too many people at the top have most of it, that’s your issue and rather than fix the system, they’ll tell you it’s poor immigrants on the boats that are the problem Please Ellis, stop hating for once
@@oldishandwoke-ish1181 I'll warrant she's claiming benefits and using food banks for an army of kids. People reliant on the system seem to care most about a perceived allocation of resources in the system.
James Obrien does understand how peoples lives have been unsettled by criminals coming from violent countries. He is the embodiment of 'no one hates the working class like a socialist'.
@@jamiebill2664she is all over the place, she doesn't know about why Ukrainians don't stop in Poland, and she doesnt want all them foreigners over in the town centre, unless they have a job, which she can't tell
If you truly want someone to change there mind or move there position a more tactful approach would be important. Certainly fewer interruptions on both sides are essential, greater chances to speak for both sides. Talk of fact should be substantiated with evidence where possible - James often has factual evidence to rely on but callers rarely have this to hand or the opportunity to provide it where they have some evidence. As James is a professional I can absolutely understand that he will be better resourced and better prepared. Whilst I understand James's style is quite adversarial - this will not help with many callers that have opposing views. Perhaps James should chair a debate with two callers with opposing views from opposite sides of the spectrum and manage such a discussion as an impartial/neutral chair. This may lead to one caller to actually reconsider and revise their position having considered the facts and having a chance to contribute from their own perspective.
@@lloydjones7925 Only people who is willing to listen to someone else can have their minds changed. She wasn't listening to a single thing he was saying. When confronted, her first words are "how can I trust you?" ... eventhough she doesn't know anything. Not everyone can have their minds changed.
Baffled as to how these low-info, high-octane right-wing cheerleaders manage to remain constantly teetering upon that sweet-spot between apocalyptic rage at all the things they don't know about & the predetermination to never-ever find out more.
Because when your whole world is denial of the failure of brexit, the warm s**t spoonfed you by GB News and the Daily Mail and your personal revolting natter-circle nurturing your horrible and thought-free prejudices over the years you decline into the sort of delusional idiot who thinks they'll out-manoeuvre James O'Brien who Jacob Rees-Mogg is too scared to be interviewed by.
Sounds like my mother in law. Had almost this exact conversation a few months ago. I started asking exactly the same questions as JoB, she started crying, said I was a bully and she was feeling sick. So I carried on. And on. And on. If we allow these scumbags to escape responsibility for their disgusting, ignorant, and ill-educated opinions the cycle continues. I made sure it won't continue in my family.
Yep, similar with my mother. One of my few delights at the moment is reminding her she voted Brexit and bathing in the awkward silence on a regular basis
@@richardneild2076 props to you. I know more than one educated, politically moderate person who avoids these conversations with close family and friends. I can't understand it at all. If we need to challenge these views then it has to start with those around us 🤷🏻♂️👍🏻
Listening to the woman was like the Daily Mail was given human form and could speak. In less than 20 minutes she managed to verbalise every Daily Mail headline from the past 20 years. Seldom have I heard the entirety of the mentality of the 1970s encapsulated in one person.
If 99% of British people agree with her, but GB News gets 5 views per video, either Britain's population numbers are a lie, or GB News's are. Obviously it's not her numbers which're wrong, no one can speak so confidently and be wrong, if that was the case, there'd be a thread on reddit for such people called r/confidentlywrong or something. 😏
Sad thing is that she has completely convinced herself this is the case and will never alter her opinion no matter how much evidence you put in front of her.
@@camerondjmcgregor O'Brien neither villified her nor insulted her. All he did was question her assertions, which is also why he did not need to provide any evidence
@@crizzl380 The caller was very honest on very SPECFIC points that 'she had no idea'. James then attempted to make out she knew nothing about anything. Attempting to make out that she had called having no knowledge on the entirety of the topic. And by the end of the video he is bullying her into 'tell me anything you have got a clue about'. I think that kind of character destruction and humiliation is absolutely disgusting. He's a very intelligent man and he knows what he's doing when he does this.
There’s a LOT of these people in Britain, well, mostly England unfortunately. I have no doubt that this lady is actually a nice, warm hearted person who has simply been completely brainwashed by the media here and is blinkered beyond belief when it comes to certain subjects. They don’t realise how much damage they do
I have the impression that countries with less tabloid culture would not be so obtuse, but I don't have data to support my thesis. I'd say maybe the French?
“I haven’t a clue, and I haven’t got the proof”. But utterly and completely committed to believing lies. This is so ingrained in our society that I don’t understand how it can get any better in the U.K.
In about 10 years, train an advanced AI on 3,000 years' worth of compassionate humanist philosophy and literature, put it in charge of government as a benevolent dictator. Train a second AI to write hateful Daily Mail flavoured headlines that are still subtly in support of the first AI to make sure the Jackies of the world don't try to destroy it. Train a third AI on James O'Brien clips mocking the second AI to keep the rest of us too entertained to misguidedly overthrow the first AI.
It's so infuriating when he says, "What's the legal way?" and she has no idea that there is no legal way. The level of tabloid brainwashing these people have been through is terrifying.
From watching the select committee asking Suella Braverman if there’s a legal route by giving her an example of a teen wanting to flee, she openly admitted there was no legal route.
Two things sprung to mind - 1) Did 99% of people REALLY agree with her (she seemed very sure of her statistics) and 2) She certainly proved the saying "Empty barrels make the most noise."
The main thing people can take from this is that there’s no reasoning with these people. You can point out the facts and how they can be incorrect on every topic they bring up, and ask questions that make their points null and void. But they will continue to say the same things. How is it possible to rescue these people from where they’ve ended up?
the moment you start trying to dismantle one lie, they're spewing another 3. Its why the tactic is so effective, you say something short quippy and wrong, and the person on the other (correct) side has to spend 5 times as long picking the lie apart.
The way of the Tory party, aided by the right-wing press. Look over there. Those people are not like you. They want your small part of the pie. Be scared of them. Meanwhile the rich steal most of the pie.
I’ll tell you why. Because culture *IS* the most important aspect of every nation. Without one homogeneous culture, society collapses. It always has done through history, and it always will do. That’s why immigration makes us furious. Its a threat to our existence.
@@Cal-Valhallaour absolutely clueless brother. The Roman Empire was a lot more multi cultured than modern day UK & that’s literally one of the largest empires in all of human history! The UK has also been a multi cultured country for over 100 years & it has been 100% beneficial to how beautiful this country CAN be at its best! Get with reality & maybe READ A HISTORY BOOK OR 2…… thousand…..BROTHER!
@@Kwest727 Most people start at perception because of all the seeds the media plants. When it goes up against reality they begin to get wiser until something challenges that.
@@nauxsiEven the most rational people will make an emotional decision and justify it afterwards with some semblance of logic. I won't pretend that I'm immune to this. It's just a subconscious fact of ourselves, but there's nothing wrong with admitting that you were wrong or conceding that you do not know. That isn't shameful. What I think is shameful is not having the self-reflection to realize that there's nothing constructive to be gained by the passionately fighting in something that you don't even have a horse in the race for. If you say something is true and you don't know that it is, that's shameful and destructive. We should all try to avoid that.
She was going from one sun headline to another, i couldnt keep up🤣. Love this constantly repeated line of 'you can't say anything', when they never stop saying the thing they're supposedly not allowed to say. Yesterday a bloke in the pub told me 6 'p' word jokes about people from Pakistan. Then he got onto complaining about them all coming over, and finished off with the his only actual funny joke, "but you can't say anything about them". I tried to reply with, 'but i cant turn on a news channel, pick up a paper or even go to the pub without hearing all the stuff you're saying you can't say', but i couldn't stop laughing at his accidental joke
The brilliant thing about JoB is that he challenges callers by simply asking them to explain their viewpoints. It's amazing how much these people know about the inner workings of immigration, the NHS, policing bills etc until they're actually asked to explain their opinions.
Deflecting the conversation about minutiae rather than the overall results. Since 1990 the UK population has increased by at least 10 million (17%) so perhaps it is no surprise that UK infrastructure is under pressure eg housing, NHS etc,. Why does anyone concerned about immigration need to know anything about the process, it the results of immigration that are her concern. (I'm concerned about getting cancer, so do I need to be an oncologist?) So there must be a legal immigration routes, but of course O'Brien deflects the conversation to asylum seekers rather than the much broader issue. O'Brien's a master of deflection.
@@davidreece1642 I think u should phone in. Honestly. Cause it. Seems a lot of the people that phone in don't know what they are actually talking about. It's like they say things without thinking it through. U seem to know what ur talking about. Phone in mate.
@@davidreece1642 agreed. I tend to agree with James on a lot of things but I’m rarely convinced by these videos of him ‘destroying’ people. I feel like he tends to focus on why the caller themself is uninformed/an idiot, as opposed to actually countering the arguments and ideas they put across
@@Frank.and.Beanzz I think there's a difference between listening to this 3-4 times to see what he's up to and actually being able to put a rational point of view sensibly. Don't forget he does this several times a day. For example the increase in population has multiple factors , legal immigration, birth rates in non indigenous communities, increased life span etc plenty of rabbit holes to fall down. But thanks for your vote. 👍👍
This is an amazing call. The cognitive dissonance between her confidently sounding off whilst admitting she doesn't have the first clue about anything! 🤦🏼♂
@@justinday5961 James never said he did, while the caller was unapologetic about her convictions based solely on her personal bias rather then any real knowledge. Hardly the same, don’t you think?
@@twisted_void what this woman says is tangerble if you go about any of the big cities in the uk what james o Brian is saying is not the downside of mass unselctive immigration can be seen all round the benefits can not
My wife was pregnant and had atrotious morning sickness. We were on the very other side of Edinburugh when they closed the roads and cancled the busses for the political parade in the name of the queen. Had to carry her all the way home and she was feeling rotten. Because an elderly woman died many miles away
still an elderly woman, who ended up in the ground like many others. The only difference is she never had to worry about heating or eating, and lived a nice comfy life at the expense of others. @@LeComtedeSaintDomingue
@@LeComtedeSaintDomingueas much as I liked the Queen, she was the head of state purely through an accident of birth, same as her parents and her children. She has no more or less value than any other person
@sircaballero and some people are born into rich 1st world countries by accident of birth? So what? Should people give up their citizenship because they did nothing but be born in a country that is safe and secure and wealthy? And she also got her position because her family was able to hold it for centuries which is no easy task her son got his postion because his mother was able to hold it which actually is incredible since most of the world of republics....banana republics in my opinion but still. Democracy and absence of monarchy doesn't mean freedom and meritocracy in fact it usually doesn't. Take America for example elections everywhere no monarchy or hereditary aristocracy but the inequality is rampant and believe you me there is a class in America of the same sort of families being in government getting into top universities etc. One is just easier to hide when it comes to unearned privilege
Conservatives knows they’re ancient worldview is obsolete. They’ve known that since the 1960s. They’re in a panic because they believe they’re bigotry and superstitions are the glue holding civilization together and it will collapse without them. Many think they’re living in the end times and it’s driving them crazy.
Not a Lie in all she Said . Your Opinion is What??? Your Opinion is a Minority Opinion... You watch this Programme and Idolise this Ignorant Broadcaster . Your Delusional if you think What that Lady Said is Wrong ... What Frightens You????
Immigration is capitalism importing an over supply of labour in, which is a race to the bottom particularly for the working class. Oligarchs love immigration. Capitalism will never invest in training or increase pay and conditions if it can just fly in labour. Back in the day the Left understood this, even Bernie Sanders was anti immigration.
@@richiem7716 How is just stop oil related to immigration or the NHS lol. It's just a list of things this woman doesn't like strung loosely together. All emotion no facts like so much of modern politics (be it ignorant right wing populists like her or screechy SJWs or religious politics). I so wish that sane socialists and sane conservatives could have somewhat rational debates and come to compromises again.
@@uniquevideosUk I'm sorry to say, but if you can't justify and defend your views they are worthless. The fact that you don't understand this is troubling.
James O'brien is not the best person to talk to fearful people. People are justifiably fearful of immigration because we are being flooded with violent criminals at the moment, not the kind if immigration that we had when eastern Europeans came over. O'brien is incredibly patronising and pushes working class Tory voters towards the far right. He's recruiting for the BNP.
@@PpPp-ku4sy James defending immigrants? I listened carefully and I heard no defense of immigrants. He did allow the anti-immigrant caller prove herself a fool but that is not defending immigrants. He did point out the the Tories lie about the actual immigration rules in place and how people are misled, but that is not defending immigrants. Maybe you didn't appreciate James pointing out all of the anti-immigrant claptrap and decided that was "defending immigrants"
@@PpPp-ku4sy what are you trying to say here? No need to be shy or cryptic. If you want to accuse someone at least have the decency to be clear about it, instead of attempting to spread unfunded rumours to try and hurt someone. Or should I ask your mommy why you still wet the bed?
@@kwaynr1301 I made a suggestion but I wasn't rude to you. Just like James you seem very angry and overestimate your own intelligence. You should really comment back to people using language you would use to their face. You're comment is just embarrassing.
@Pp Pp when the useless, part time PM Liz Truss and her equally useless Chancellor were giving tax cuts out to the wealthy, James was not happy about it and said so On Air. He would have been a beneficiary but knew it was a wrong and immoral given lower paid people are struggling.
That woman is completely ignorant on immigration. Once you go through the process of citizenship, there is a period of 10 years where you have to pay into the NHS. Every 2 1/2 years you pay something like £650 per year. It's also worth noting that despite making up 15% of the total population of UK, those who are of BAME background make up roughly 46% of all NHS medica staff. You only need to walk into your local hospital/dental practice etc to see it for your self. Furthermore, when you go through the process, you are not allowed to claim benefits/public funds. I know this because I am going through such process atm. I have already paid over £15k in application fees and solicitor costs. EDIT: It is possible to claim benefits if you're a parent of minors or disabled(not all cases), but this is rare. And the benefits you receive will be no different to what everyone else receives. There is no special treatment.
Yes. My sons partner has been through exactly the same process - paying huge sums for NHS cover (which of course she has not used), taking a citizenship test which most British citizens would almost certainly fail, paying for sitting the citizenship exam itself, restrictions on foreign travel,while the application is pending (which she has really needed to do for her work), and the interminable waiting at each stage of the process. And all the time she has been working as a structural engineer for a civil engineering company, paying tax and NI and therefore contributing to the U.K. economy.
@@srp01983 "restriction on foreign travels" This has been one of the hardest things for me 😢😢😢. 21 years in the country and I have never been on holiday. All I want to do is visit my friend in Italy for a week.
@@kitcole4927 Spouse visas work differently. It's usually 6 years before you can apply for IRL. Yes, spousal visas are slightly less but it still costs about £500 per year. But this just proves that most immigrants have to contribute to NHS.
Did Jackie low key admit that her or someone she knows is regularly breaching data rules by looking up gp patients details to see if they are foreign and live in social housing? Jackie you really shouldn’t be doing that!!
I heard this live. Jackie, or Colleen from Portsmouth, seems confused and certain simultaneously. Full of hate and spite and certain that 99% of the UK agree with her although she hasn’t a clue about all that much. James’s ‘love to the family’ at the end sailed above her tiny mind. What an awful woman.
@domhardy no.. he's done it with rational people. He does it in every interview Seems he doesn't know the golden rule... If someone is embarrassing them digging a hole, talking nonsense, let them 😅 It makes you look better and you don't have to do anything
@@nezkeys79 - he's a talk show host! Pretty sure the golden rule is to talk to people. Can someone be rational, digging a hole _and_ talking nonsense?? If so - share the link for who he has done this to!
What I love about how James takes these calls is that he doesn't want to disprove what these people are saying but rather expose their general agenda behind all the slogans they use. And what's scary is that these people are fed those slogans by those who would toss them to the hounds if they could make a penny out of it.
No whats scary is that they all seem to have and understanding of the underlining theme of the slogans and are just using the slogans as a means to identify each other and communicate. Thousands of these people exist in the open and we allow them to shout their hate because its under the tile of political speech and slogans. People need to start shutting them down strongly and stop giving them air
@@ppo2424 O'Brien is actually asking questions upon which their opinions are founded, and they flounder. Because it's obvious from the start that their opinions are based on misinformation and emotional bias, filling in the gaps of the relevant information. O'Brien asks questions that expose the holes in their argument.
I can understand why she’s so frustrated. When you start an argument that’s driven by emotion instead of facts is easily to lose control of the whole conversation.
I don't think emotion is the problem. People in my country, for example, are SO angry about the lack of response to mass shootings and it drives them to action. Her argument is driven by prejudice and ignorance. That's the problem.
@@rachelk4805 But being upset and wanting to stop something isn't an argument. If someone said we need to stop gun violence by arresting bald people because they radiate gun violence thoughts, that's an argument but it's fiction driven by a hate of baldness.
I am one of them Eastern Europeans who came into this country 23 years ago. (Just for the record, I've been employed the entire time, payed my taxes NI, I have private health insurance, and never claimed any benefits) . Now that's out of the way, I would like to say that I love the UK, and I love the people!!! In my experience the UK is by and large welcoming, tolerant and accepting of immigrants. This country gave me a home, a great job, prospects, a wonderful husband, and great friends. The opinions expressed by this lady are in the minority. Every country has their fair share of bigots, including the UK, but in my opinion the UK is still one of the most welcoming and tolerant countries.
I was born in England and I'm still often made to feel like I don't belong here - and that has happened all if my life. My parents came from the Caribbean but I am not am immigrant - and my grand children are still seen as immigrants. Your experience is different to mine.
As an immigrant here in the UK that has done the only legal route that this woman thinks is right I would like to ask for the benefits she seems to think we are/can get 🤣 It’s so sad the compassion seems to going away in people these days.
I do know so many people who think this way - everyone needs a scapegoat for their failing country - instead of pitching in and helping resolve issues, or voting for change
@JwayT The Tories have, over the past 12 years, also caused catastrophe and continue to do so currently. Labour might cause just as many issues. In a decision between bad things maybe happening or certainly happening, the choice should be clear.
I agree with her 100%. James is intentionally twisting her words and asking her whataboutery questions. For example, she says that protesters should not be allowed to block public roads due to the disruption it causes workers and emergency services. Instead of actually addressing that issue (Which I think is a perfectly reasonable and fair point) James starts questioning her about the Queen's funeral. As if that somehow excuses him from rebutting her argument about blocked roads. Same with the immigration questions. She said we should not allow people to come here illegally on small boats. James asked her what is the process for her to arrive. When she didn't know the immigration process, James considers that a win and doesn't ever have to deal with her concerns about people arriving via boat. He does this again and again, twisting her words and pivoting away from her points by asking something else and ignoring it. He's a competent journalist. He's an intelligent man, he KNOWS what he's doing. It's dishonest and does nothing to heal the divides in society.
the mad thing is that when you point to and show them the actual cause of them problems it's blanked or brushed aside or completely ignored n they just divert back to the scapegoating.
Again and again I am so astonished how JO'B keeps his nerves. I'm 5 minutes in and I want to crawl up my wall and scream. I hear the same tripe here in Germany. Chapeau James. Carry on
@@justwannashagmorechix638 yeah, and I'm a German one. Sorry for that, I thought Your comment was Your handle and Your name Your comment. But really, it doesn't make much difference.
Uurgh... sends a shiver of horror down my spine. She sounds like my mum...hence why I haven't spoken to my parents for the last couple of years. Wow James is so unbelievably calm and controlled... I can't help but shake with fury at the stupidity...
@@Baggers_Corner Just because somebody opened their legs & squeezed you out as a child nine months later, doesn't mean that you have to put up with their toxicity all your life, nor should you. Not all families are nice to be around, I should know.
I love the idea that asylum seekers magically get houses despite the chronic housing shortage. Eh ! Are they not just doctors , do you care where someone comes from if they are treating you to make you better. Hope Scotland escapes these lunatics soon.
I live in the U.S. and it’s uncomfortable to admit. I get an odd sense of comfort knowing we’re not the only ones with such imbeciles
As someone who spent the first 20 years of his life in the US and moved to Sweden I will tell you that this kind of uninformed-crusader fighting for what they “feel” vs facts is universal🤦🏻
I know right? Idiots are everywhere.
Same here my US family 😂🤣😂 the whole world is a 💩 show.
I think our imbeciles are 'world beating' 🤣
Walk into a pub in England you are very likely to hear moans about immigrants. Prince Harry isn't making it up about England. There are a lot of nice people in the UK, but it's got issues man.
She's literally a prime example of how successful the right wing press is in the manipulation of people's views and beliefs.
most people don't rely on newspapers for their beliefs
They always call it 'common sense'
So very true....
Are England!
Immigration is capitalism importing an over supply of labour in, which is a race to the bottom particularly for the working class. Oligarchs love immigration.
Capitalism will never invest in training or increase pay and conditions if it can just fly in labour.
Back in the day the Left understood this even Bernie Sanders was anti immigration.
My goodness. This caller managed to simultaneously admit to really knowing nothing and claiming to know everything at the same time. Fascinating.
Schrodinger's Logic 🤪
i actually quite like her.
That sounded very Vulcan, as in, like something Spock would say. Fascinating.🤣🤣🤣👍
Dunning-Kruger effect
@@1plus11000 Same. She does deserve our sympathy for being so obnoxious,with a loud opinion about things she knows nothing about🙌🏾
😂😂🤣🤣🤣 listening to that call was so exhausting and hilarious, she was babbling and talking in circles but it was pure comedy gold.
No it wasn't. She talked sense.
@@Dentistmentalustbahahaha
@@Dentistmentalustwhere will you creatures crawl back to after you lose in a landslide this month? lol
@@Jack-e5t It will not be a landslide my friend. Lots of people are going to vote for the smaller parties. I agree with her in her original statement that protests are a nuisance in London. They have cost people's jobs and lives! James didn't like what she said so he took her on an intellectual merry-go-round to put her off! You have drawn a wild conclusion from my comment, that I am right wing! Laughable! I will not vote Tory.
@@Jack-e5t To assume I'm a right winger from what I have said is laughable! I will not vote Tory but I will not vote Labour either. Labour will not have a landslide as a lot of people will vote for the smaller parties!
Wow, she literally covered every Daily Mail headline of the last five years! 😂
😂
Sorry I thought the interview was with the Daily Mail editor
😂
It was like Right Wing slogan Bingo. I was just missing ‘Single Mums’ for a Full House.
@@claudioricci1 But did she mention woke? I went into a trance halfway through that roller-coaster.
As an American who works in radio, this sounds eerily familiar to some of the callers we have here. But O'Brien is a master at letting these people talk themselves into a knot. This was a masterclass.
He would be excellent on a US talk radio station.
@@johnchrysostomou9417 I’m American and I listen to James frequently just to know we aren’t alone.
@@sublime3784 I actually rarely meet Brits that have spent time in the states . Most have an opinion of course but they mirror what they think is American xenophobia. I enjoyed my time in North America. LA , San Francisco and New York . People were intelligent, caring, inclusive and slim 🤣
Probably because she most likely got her 'facts' from news pumped out by the same Aussie media mogul that provides the same 'facts' to the nutcases in your country. Murdoch is a menace and the day he is no longer on this earth is the day many sensible people will breathe a huge sign of relief
Except in the US, they don't admit that they haven't got a clue.
“I haven’t got a clue or evidence but I know it’s true” 😂😂😂😂
This kept getting better 😂😂😂
Christianity or all religions?
I feel so sorry for her husband! 😆
It’s like teaching Shakespeare to a dog.
@@stormyweathers9887they probably think alike
oh no, she didn't! (Excuse me while I eat my fingers)
Masterfully done Sir. As a visa holder in the UK who pays DOUBLE for the NHS, and does not qualify for any benefits, I appreciate this. What a willfully dense individual.
Well said
Thanks for posting, Tavera. Welcome to the UK, and thank you for contributing to the economy ❤. The caller probably thinks you were given a Ferrari, a 15-bedroom council house, a villa in Tuscany, £20,000 a week of benefits money, and Apple Mac, iPad, iPhone and a Playstation3, but at least two of us know, and probably the majority of the population knows, she hasn't got a clue.🤫
How do you pay double for the NHS?
@@edforbes1563, on application for a visa there is a set NHS fee, which is non-refundable. Once sich a person starts working they start paying national insurance, hence double payment.
@@edforbes1563 There are caveats to accessing the NHS. Just existing on UK soil does not give you free healthcare. The NHS will treat you because that's the humane thing to do, but you may well be charged either directly, or to your home nations government.
That is a shocking example of cognitive dissonance in action.
"This is a thing that is true."
"How do you know?"
"I don't have a clue."
"Why do you believe it?"
"Because it's true."
Typical Daily Mail reader
the sad part is their inability to realize it
It's true, in their minds, because they read it in a newspaper. It shows the power of the media.
Wow that's perfectly concise summary. The only thing to add is the 5 different subjects.
Sounds like a religion to me
'Nobody will come out and say it.' Is she serious? I never hear anything BUT people moaning about immigration in the UK.
And why do you think that, realistic UK population around 100, million, and we're allowing millions of more people into the country illegally, we don't have the resources to deal with this amount of people, on our tiny islands
@@ellismeah8110 we have more than enough and our country is run on immigration! We built our wealth and welfare state on the backs of European and Commonwealth nations, this is a pure and utter lie saying we don’t have enough
Too many people at the top have most of it, that’s your issue and rather than fix the system, they’ll tell you it’s poor immigrants on the boats that are the problem
Please Ellis, stop hating for once
@@ellismeah8110 Hi Suella, I thought you would too busy to be surfing the comments on UA-cam.
@@ellismeah8110 VERY well said!!
@@ellismeah8110hi Suella Cruella 😂😂😂
Imagine this woman being part of a jury:
"He's guilty"
"Why?"
"I've no idea, no evidence and no proof...but he is!!!!!"
Because he's an immigrant/unemployed/a disability benefit claimant/transgender/a foreigner/using a food bank .....
@@oldishandwoke-ish1181 I'll warrant she's claiming benefits and using food banks for an army of kids. People reliant on the system seem to care most about a perceived allocation of resources in the system.
My Uncle did jury duty and apparently one of the juror’s arguments was “Well, he looks guilty.”
@@attackpatterndelta8949 you can in fact look guilty but that in itself cannot be a use for presuming ones guilt.
"He looks furin"
She was against foreign people talking in their own native language in the NHS waiting room. She does not care if they are working or not.
Yet people like that woman go abroad and expect everyone to speak English.
This woman is purest embodiment of the average Daily Mail reader
Sadly my mum and dad reads that tripe! And she sounds just like them...
@@petemartin998 I feel your pain 🙄
The average daily mail reader will read a little into the article and then not research the suggest and form their opinions based on the headlines
@@petemartin998 oh dear...
Daily Express
Daily Mail Bingo. Her Ann Widdecombe impersonation is spot on as well.
As soon as she said NHS we all knew we had BINGO.
She’s okay with white Ukrainians coming here but not people with brown or black skin , that’s what she is really saying.
That's not what she's saying. She literally said those fleeing Ukraine should stop in the first country they get to. Listen better
James Obrien does understand how peoples lives have been unsettled by criminals coming from violent countries. He is the embodiment of 'no one hates the working class like a socialist'.
None of them should be here!
@@jamiebill2664she is all over the place, she doesn't know about why Ukrainians don't stop in Poland, and she doesnt want all them foreigners over in the town centre, unless they have a job, which she can't tell
@@troywright359As a result of that, the lesson is... Don't judge immigrants unfairly.
Sad thing is the moment she put the phone down, she'll have decided she wasn't allowed to speak, and that she's still right.
If you truly want someone to change there mind or move there position a more tactful approach would be important. Certainly fewer interruptions on both sides are essential, greater chances to speak for both sides. Talk of fact should be substantiated with evidence where possible - James often has factual evidence to rely on but callers rarely have this to hand or the opportunity to provide it where they have some evidence.
As James is a professional I can absolutely understand that he will be better resourced and better prepared.
Whilst I understand James's style is quite adversarial - this will not help with many callers that have opposing views.
Perhaps James should chair a debate with two callers with opposing views from opposite sides of the spectrum and manage such a discussion as an impartial/neutral chair. This may lead to one caller to actually reconsider and revise their position having considered the facts and having a chance to contribute from their own perspective.
@@lloydjones7925 I don't think these people call to change their minds.
@@lloydjones7925 what exactly would be the tactful approach to this level of wilful ignorance to justify her own horrible biases.
@@lloydjones7925 Only people who is willing to listen to someone else can have their minds changed.
She wasn't listening to a single thing he was saying. When confronted, her first words are "how can I trust you?" ... eventhough she doesn't know anything.
Not everyone can have their minds changed.
“He provoked me to hang up because I was right”
Baffled as to how these low-info, high-octane right-wing cheerleaders manage to remain constantly teetering upon that sweet-spot between apocalyptic rage at all the things they don't know about & the predetermination to never-ever find out more.
They can't memorize paragraphs, just short, definitive statements.
Because when your whole world is denial of the failure of brexit, the warm s**t spoonfed you by GB News and the Daily Mail and your personal revolting natter-circle nurturing your horrible and thought-free prejudices over the years you decline into the sort of delusional idiot who thinks they'll out-manoeuvre James O'Brien who Jacob Rees-Mogg is too scared to be interviewed by.
@@danmayberry1185 Which is why the Tories communicate in three word slogans
@@boogaloo4640 Deliver, deliver, deliver. Oh, that's one word .. from a head of lettuce, to be fair.
That’s what’s surprising. If you’re going to get so worked up about something you’d at least double check the facts.
As an atheist. Jesus effing christ. Everything she said was straight out of the mail. They walk amongst us. We are doomed.
She has a different opinion to you. No more, no less.
@@trytellingthetruth.2068 and her opinion is based on a misappropriation of facts.
@@intergalactic92
The same could be said of you.
She is typical of people blaming others for our politicians making decisions over the last 13 years.
@@trytellingthetruth.2068 It really couldn't.
Can we just take a moment to acknowledge that this lady said that she WORKS FOR A LOCAL AUTHORITY 😳
I missed that! You'd have thought she'd have been better informed....
@@Braderz888probably a school crossing attendant although I may be wrong and she might be a chief executive...😂
I have no ‘clue’ how she has a job let alone one in local authority.
Trust me! Local authority employees are the worst! I work for one and the racism is prevalent
To be fair that could mean she makes the sandwiches
James is a master at holding up a mirror to this type of caller.
But she won't look, like she won't look at anything she doesn't like.
😆😆💯💯
James is a master at twisting things and making stuipid people think he's always right.
Yes he makes dumb people think he James is right
@@jawsjaws4018 oh what did he twist
Who gave grandma a can of energy drink?
.....all for some ageism to make a point....😊
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ageism... it's sad that being called a grandmother is an insult.
@@mlouise5655 there was no insult, my dainty snowflake.
@@chatham43some things are factual
Sounds like my mother in law. Had almost this exact conversation a few months ago. I started asking exactly the same questions as JoB, she started crying, said I was a bully and she was feeling sick. So I carried on. And on. And on.
If we allow these scumbags to escape responsibility for their disgusting, ignorant, and ill-educated opinions the cycle continues. I made sure it won't continue in my family.
Yep, similar with my mother. One of my few delights at the moment is reminding her she voted Brexit and bathing in the awkward silence on a regular basis
@@richardneild2076 props to you. I know more than one educated, politically moderate person who avoids these conversations with close family and friends. I can't understand it at all. If we need to challenge these views then it has to start with those around us 🤷🏻♂️👍🏻
Well done Tom for walking the talk.we have so many more people like you but they keep their thoughts to themselves.
@@Castdeath 💯
Oh you hero making your mother in law cry, what a man you are.
I've listened to this so many times. It's fascinating, and It's great to see James do his thing with ease
Be obnoxious and not listen you mean. 😅
Must be only James who likes the illegals flooding in
I haven't laughed so much for a very long time. James you are wicked. You made her talk on so many subjects in 10 minutes!!
Listening to the woman was like the Daily Mail was given human form and could speak. In less than 20 minutes she managed to verbalise every Daily Mail headline from the past 20 years. Seldom have I heard the entirety of the mentality of the 1970s encapsulated in one person.
she's correct in many ways but represents her argument poorly
@@leonhughes9014 Name one.
@@Saor_Alba he haven’t got a clue 😂
@Soar_Alba Stating that Stop Oil protests blocking the M25 are a completely different set of circumstances to the queens funeral
@@Saor_Alba Problematic illegal immigrants.
Read the Daily Mail for a few years and then shout it all out, without breathing, as fast as you can
Genius
Speedrun any %
This woman has stumbled down every rabbit hole. The Tories love people like this.
didn't miss one... All the cliches were ticked with her
8:25 "to be fair Jackie, I've heard LOADS of people say it and they're all wrong" had me SCREAMIN
This is a persons mind on GB News and Daily Mail.
If 99% of British people agree with her, but GB News gets 5 views per video, either Britain's population numbers are a lie, or GB News's are.
Obviously it's not her numbers which're wrong, no one can speak so confidently and be wrong, if that was the case, there'd be a thread on reddit for such people called r/confidentlywrong or something. 😏
Sad thing is that she has completely convinced herself this is the case and will never alter her opinion no matter how much evidence you put in front of her.
Well James put no evidence in front of her. He just spent the entire call trying to vilify and insult her.
@@camerondjmcgregor O'Brien neither villified her nor insulted her. All he did was question her assertions, which is also why he did not need to provide any evidence
👍🏾
@@camerondjmcgregor You mean he did something like this: "Tell me where in the video he insulted her?"
@@crizzl380 The caller was very honest on very SPECFIC points that 'she had no idea'. James then attempted to make out she knew nothing about anything. Attempting to make out that she had called having no knowledge on the entirety of the topic. And by the end of the video he is bullying her into 'tell me anything you have got a clue about'. I think that kind of character destruction and humiliation is absolutely disgusting. He's a very intelligent man and he knows what he's doing when he does this.
Says, "I haven't got a clue!" and continues to argue! 😂😂
This just makes me depressed and ashamed. I can’t believe the country that I grew up in is in this state!
👍🏾
Just thinking the same
Sad thing is, it's always been the same, and likely always will be
There’s a LOT of these people in Britain, well, mostly England unfortunately. I have no doubt that this lady is actually a nice, warm hearted person who has simply been completely brainwashed by the media here and is blinkered beyond belief when it comes to certain subjects. They don’t realise how much damage they do
I have the impression that countries with less tabloid culture would not be so obtuse, but I don't have data to support my thesis. I'd say maybe the French?
“I haven’t a clue, and I haven’t got the proof”. But utterly and completely committed to believing lies. This is so ingrained in our society that I don’t understand how it can get any better in the U.K.
Vibe based political views
self confirmation bias
In about 10 years, train an advanced AI on 3,000 years' worth of compassionate humanist philosophy and literature, put it in charge of government as a benevolent dictator. Train a second AI to write hateful Daily Mail flavoured headlines that are still subtly in support of the first AI to make sure the Jackies of the world don't try to destroy it. Train a third AI on James O'Brien clips mocking the second AI to keep the rest of us too entertained to misguidedly overthrow the first AI.
It's so infuriating when he says, "What's the legal way?" and she has no idea that there is no legal way. The level of tabloid brainwashing these people have been through is terrifying.
There's no legal way to organise a protest? Of course there is
@@lewis123417 if you wanted to show you didn't watch the video, great job. She was talking about refugees.
@@lewis123417 Hilarious first hurdle fall
From watching the select committee asking Suella Braverman if there’s a legal route by giving her an example of a teen wanting to flee, she openly admitted there was no legal route.
Seems like UA-cam Viewer deleted their comment.
I’m brazilian, I’ve nothing to do with London, but I love this guy hahah
Two things sprung to mind - 1) Did 99% of people REALLY agree with her (she seemed very sure of her statistics) and 2) She certainly proved the saying "Empty barrels make the most noise."
I think, actually, it's empty vessels? Same difference, though 😇
It's impossible that only 1% disagree with her. The % of immigrated alone is about 3,5 and if you add the likes of Antifa to it....
@@prendersmack1643 empty barrels make the most noise when being scraped for new Tory deputy chairs, certainly.
The main thing people can take from this is that there’s no reasoning with these people.
You can point out the facts and how they can be incorrect on every topic they bring up, and ask questions that make their points null and void. But they will continue to say the same things.
How is it possible to rescue these people from where they’ve ended up?
the moment you start trying to dismantle one lie, they're spewing another 3. Its why the tactic is so effective, you say something short quippy and wrong, and the person on the other (correct) side has to spend 5 times as long picking the lie apart.
Stopping them from gish galloping and keeping them on point until they're forced to concede is the most difficult thing to do
Everyday I meet somebody who makes me ask myself this question. The manipulation is definitely strong with this one.
You are so right.
Many folk will not allow the facts to interfere with their prejudices.
how about the fact that we are being forcefully turned into minorties in our own ancestral homeland you utter speng?
Dear Lord, this woman puts Vicky Pollard to shame.
Yep, and that's "amazing".
Yeah but, no but…… ✈️
18:44 name something that you have a clue about….silence. That was golden 😂
It’s a shame people actually don’t get angry about millionaires cheating the tax system or issues that actually have a negative impact on our lives.
It's easier for them to punch down.
The way of the Tory party, aided by the right-wing press.
Look over there. Those people are not like you. They want your small part of the pie. Be scared of them.
Meanwhile the rich steal most of the pie.
thats not the topic, the topic is why wouldn't you get mad at illegal refugees wanting to come over here??!
I’ll tell you why.
Because culture *IS* the most important aspect of every nation.
Without one homogeneous culture, society collapses.
It always has done through history, and it always will do.
That’s why immigration makes us furious.
Its a threat to our existence.
@@Cal-Valhallaour absolutely clueless brother. The Roman Empire was a lot more multi cultured than modern day UK & that’s literally one of the largest empires in all of human history! The UK has also been a multi cultured country for over 100 years & it has been 100% beneficial to how beautiful this country CAN be at its best!
Get with reality & maybe READ A HISTORY BOOK OR 2…… thousand…..BROTHER!
The sad part is this woman probably hung up thinking “I got em”.
Yep , like many if not all the red wall Keyboard Enoch’s. Blind hatred
Also probably claimed to have been silenced, despite having the longest phone-in appearance in recent memory
yep - little info can be more dangerous than non at all -
And in her world "everybody clapped".
@@bumberClart1000 Is that resentment because immigration is destroying the fabric of there communities?
That is insane that people have such strong opinions on things they genuinely know nothing about.
You have to start somewhere. Then you can change it when you have heard a stronger opinion.
@@nauxsithe "start" is having no opinion because you realize you know nothing about the subject. You don't start with a strong opinion.
@@Kwest727 Most people start at perception because of all the seeds the media plants. When it goes up against reality they begin to get wiser until something challenges that.
@@nauxsiEven the most rational people will make an emotional decision and justify it afterwards with some semblance of logic. I won't pretend that I'm immune to this. It's just a subconscious fact of ourselves, but there's nothing wrong with admitting that you were wrong or conceding that you do not know. That isn't shameful.
What I think is shameful is not having the self-reflection to realize that there's nothing constructive to be gained by the passionately fighting in something that you don't even have a horse in the race for. If you say something is true and you don't know that it is, that's shameful and destructive. We should all try to avoid that.
And they can vote
She was going from one sun headline to another, i couldnt keep up🤣. Love this constantly repeated line of 'you can't say anything', when they never stop saying the thing they're supposedly not allowed to say. Yesterday a bloke in the pub told me 6 'p' word jokes about people from Pakistan. Then he got onto complaining about them all coming over, and finished off with the his only actual funny joke, "but you can't say anything about them". I tried to reply with, 'but i cant turn on a news channel, pick up a paper or even go to the pub without hearing all the stuff you're saying you can't say', but i couldn't stop laughing at his accidental joke
I bet he still went home and had a curry
@stephenowen6862 I mean tbf our food is amazing.
Jackie: they don't speak a word of English!
Also jackie: HoW cOmEs tHaT iS tHeN
I always wonder what people like Jackie think about the fact that literally millions of British people live in 'foreign' countries?
But they're not immigrants, they are 'ex-pats', don't you know?! 😉
Legally or illegally? You appear to be getting mixed up. If you want to live and work in another country you would have to get a visa or work permit.
@@monikacox6785 exactly 😅
@@DrMontague Such as a visa afforded to an asylum seeker once their application has been reviewed and accepted in a timely fashion? That kind of visa?
@@DrMontague What happens when there is no legal way to get to a country, like the UK for example?
This call was like GAMMON BINGO!😂😂
The brilliant thing about JoB is that he challenges callers by simply asking them to explain their viewpoints. It's amazing how much these people know about the inner workings of immigration, the NHS, policing bills etc until they're actually asked to explain their opinions.
Deflecting the conversation about minutiae rather than the overall results. Since 1990 the UK population has increased by at least 10 million (17%) so perhaps it is no surprise that UK infrastructure is under pressure eg housing, NHS etc,.
Why does anyone concerned about immigration need to know anything about the process, it the results of immigration that are her concern. (I'm concerned about getting cancer, so do I need to be an oncologist?)
So there must be a legal immigration routes, but of course O'Brien deflects the conversation to asylum seekers rather than the much broader issue.
O'Brien's a master of deflection.
@@davidreece1642 I think u should phone in. Honestly. Cause it. Seems a lot of the people that phone in don't know what they are actually talking about. It's like they say things without thinking it through. U seem to know what ur talking about. Phone in mate.
@@davidreece1642 agreed. I tend to agree with James on a lot of things but I’m rarely convinced by these videos of him ‘destroying’ people. I feel like he tends to focus on why the caller themself is uninformed/an idiot, as opposed to actually countering the arguments and ideas they put across
@@Frank.and.Beanzz I think there's a difference between listening to this 3-4 times to see what he's up to and actually being able to put a rational point of view sensibly. Don't forget he does this several times a day. For example the increase in population has multiple factors , legal immigration, birth rates in non indigenous communities, increased life span etc plenty of rabbit holes to fall down. But thanks for your vote. 👍👍
@@jadgf Agree, as this vid shows.
Tory Britain 13 years later.
Oh Jackie...
This keeps popping up on my feed and can't help but I keep listening
. It's becoming a guilty pleasure.
Yep. I’m still listening to the savant that is Jackie whenever it appears in my feed. Simultaneously hilarious and tragic.
“Love to the family Jackie” when I tell you I spat out my coffee 😂 the patience of the man.
This is an amazing call. The cognitive dissonance between her confidently sounding off whilst admitting she doesn't have the first clue about anything! 🤦🏼♂
Exactly the same as James!
@@justinday5961 James never said he did, while the caller was unapologetic about her convictions based solely on her personal bias rather then any real knowledge. Hardly the same, don’t you think?
Nor dose james o Brian
@@twisted_void what this woman says is tangerble if you go about any of the big cities in the uk what james o Brian is saying is not the downside of mass unselctive immigration can be seen all round the benefits can not
@@justinday5961 wow, what a rebuttal!😅
Geez she fought long & hard to confirm her stupidity 🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ikr lol
stupidity? so your ok paying your taxes to house illegal immigrants most of them come from safe countries
She left no doubt. Respect.
But she left us in no doubt by the end of the call
“I don’t know the system but I know for a fact…” I despair 😩
The Daily Mail has a lot to answer for!
My wife was pregnant and had atrotious morning sickness. We were on the very other side of Edinburugh when they closed the roads and cancled the busses for the political parade in the name of the queen. Had to carry her all the way home and she was feeling rotten.
Because an elderly woman died many miles away
That woman was the Head of State of the nation. There's a big difference between your common wife and the late Queen
still an elderly woman, who ended up in the ground like many others. The only difference is she never had to worry about heating or eating, and lived a nice comfy life at the expense of others. @@LeComtedeSaintDomingue
@@LeComtedeSaintDominguewhy should it be different? And what do you mean common wife? So it’s ok for someone to die if there are ‘common’?
@@LeComtedeSaintDomingueas much as I liked the Queen, she was the head of state purely through an accident of birth, same as her parents and her children. She has no more or less value than any other person
@sircaballero and some people are born into rich 1st world countries by accident of birth? So what? Should people give up their citizenship because they did nothing but be born in a country that is safe and secure and wealthy? And she also got her position because her family was able to hold it for centuries which is no easy task her son got his postion because his mother was able to hold it which actually is incredible since most of the world of republics....banana republics in my opinion but still. Democracy and absence of monarchy doesn't mean freedom and meritocracy in fact it usually doesn't. Take America for example elections everywhere no monarchy or hereditary aristocracy but the inequality is rampant and believe you me there is a class in America of the same sort of families being in government getting into top universities etc. One is just easier to hide when it comes to unearned privilege
Best thing she said: "I haven't a clue."
Certainly the only accurate thing she said
I love how the Brits don't want foreigners come into Britain but then have the cheek to demand frictionless entry into other countries
We Brits truly are the Americans of Europe
And don’t forget they invaded most of the planet and colonised (robbed up) everywhere themselves.
@@sarangistudent8614 Along with the Dutch and French, yes.
They are recruiting people from common wealth countries to work at the moment !
@@lukemwill99 The Indian sub-continent, ruled by the Brtish, comprised 1/5 of humanity.
That was a masterclass in getting someone to debate themselves because they are just spouting utter bs
It’s amazing how this woman believes every single right wing lie that there is… and she connects them all together in the span of this call.
Conservatives knows they’re ancient worldview is obsolete. They’ve known that since the 1960s. They’re in a panic because they believe they’re bigotry and superstitions are the glue holding civilization together and it will collapse without them. Many think they’re living in the end times and it’s driving them crazy.
Terryfying... Weirdly this sounds like my Mother albeit with a Southern accent!
@@monsterforge1763 I'm just short of seventy. I hope I will never talk like that
This is not about right wing and left wing, it’s about right and wrong. And sadly the left is heading down a destructive downward spiral.
Not a Lie in all she Said . Your Opinion is What??? Your Opinion is a Minority Opinion... You watch this Programme and Idolise this Ignorant Broadcaster . Your Delusional if you think What that Lady Said is Wrong ... What Frightens You????
Yes people are frightened - that such ignorance and prejudice not only exists, it persists and is exploited by the powerful to keep people down.
Immigration is capitalism importing an over supply of labour in, which is a race to the bottom particularly for the working class.
Oligarchs love immigration.
Capitalism will never invest in training or increase pay and conditions if it can just fly in labour.
Back in the day the Left understood this, even Bernie Sanders was anti immigration.
The dude above is farting the same comment all over.....
Any excuse to hate on brown folks huh?
@@evolassunglasses4673
Blair was a great one for high continued immigration.
@@trytellingthetruth.2068 Yes, Bliar started it.
@@evolassunglasses4673 Exactly. Complaints/strikes about low wages and the Left want more cheap labour to undermine wages.
James just got an entire weeks worth of topics covered in under 20 minutes.
In fairness its all tied together
@@richiem7716 How is just stop oil related to immigration or the NHS lol.
It's just a list of things this woman doesn't like strung loosely together. All emotion no facts like so much of modern politics (be it ignorant right wing populists like her or screechy SJWs or religious politics). I so wish that sane socialists and sane conservatives could have somewhat rational debates and come to compromises again.
James?...plonka...Ha ha
@@4bigmonk He don't let others have views, he's always been the same rude.
@@uniquevideosUk I'm sorry to say, but if you can't justify and defend your views they are worthless. The fact that you don't understand this is troubling.
What an angry, fearful and sad little woman. Designed by our media to vote Tory.
James O'brien is not the best person to talk to fearful people. People are justifiably fearful of immigration because we are being flooded with violent criminals at the moment, not the kind if immigration that we had when eastern Europeans came over. O'brien is incredibly patronising and pushes working class Tory voters towards the far right. He's recruiting for the BNP.
She makes more sense than lest it’s o Brian who talks to people in a condescending manner worst broadcaster on the Radio
Little euro file ache remoanerlol
@@sarahknowler5348 I made sure to "file" my taxes when I voted, as a proud Europhile, to remain.
**woosh** and I bet that has gone over your head.
😉
@@timothydempsey6597 Totally agree with you Timothy!
people dont realise theres a better world out there than ENGLAND
book our flights.. let's get out of here.
and it's not the US cause that country is feckin' doomed.
This show is rapidly turning into my favourite comedy podcast
I love James' under-his-breath "there it is" when she first brings up immigrants.
🤣
I imagine many listeners did the same - I did 🤣
Oh wow . James defending immigrants again. Yeah, non of us saw that coming.
😂😂
@@PpPp-ku4sy James defending immigrants? I listened carefully and I heard no defense of immigrants. He did allow the anti-immigrant caller prove herself a fool but that is not defending immigrants. He did point out the the Tories lie about the actual immigration rules in place and how people are misled, but that is not defending immigrants. Maybe you didn't appreciate James pointing out all of the anti-immigrant claptrap and decided that was "defending immigrants"
She sounds painfully British.
It's embarrassing
Painfull to be british thats a new one
No, she sounds painfully ignorant and naive.
And here I was thinking it was rich people not paying their taxes. 🙄
Ask James how much tax he pays after he does his creative accounting.
@@PpPp-ku4sy what are you trying to say here? No need to be shy or cryptic. If you want to accuse someone at least have the decency to be clear about it, instead of attempting to spread unfunded rumours to try and hurt someone. Or should I ask your mommy why you still wet the bed?
@@kwaynr1301 I made a suggestion but I wasn't rude to you. Just like James you seem very angry and overestimate your own intelligence. You should really comment back to people using language you would use to their face. You're comment is just embarrassing.
@@PpPp-ku4sy you do know he constantly talks about how he doesn't pay enough in tax right?
@Pp Pp when the useless, part time PM Liz Truss and her equally useless Chancellor were giving tax cuts out to the wealthy, James was not happy about it and said so On Air. He would have been a beneficiary but knew it was a wrong and immoral given lower paid people are struggling.
She is what happens when the Daily Mail attains sentience
I bet she thought "I'll show him" before calling.
They all do
Unfortunately, she thought "I showed him" after the call.
Her family must be cringing.
That woman is completely ignorant on immigration. Once you go through the process of citizenship, there is a period of 10 years where you have to pay into the NHS. Every 2 1/2 years you pay something like £650 per year. It's also worth noting that despite making up 15% of the total population of UK, those who are of BAME background make up roughly 46% of all NHS medica staff. You only need to walk into your local hospital/dental practice etc to see it for your self. Furthermore, when you go through the process, you are not allowed to claim benefits/public funds. I know this because I am going through such process atm. I have already paid over £15k in application fees and solicitor costs.
EDIT: It is possible to claim benefits if you're a parent of minors or disabled(not all cases), but this is rare. And the benefits you receive will be no different to what everyone else receives. There is no special treatment.
I think shes probably completely wrong on a lot more than that, to be fair.
Yes. My sons partner has been through exactly the same process - paying huge sums for NHS cover (which of course she has not used), taking a citizenship test which most British citizens would almost certainly fail, paying for sitting the citizenship exam itself, restrictions on foreign travel,while the application is pending (which she has really needed to do for her work), and the interminable waiting at each stage of the process. And all the time she has been working as a structural engineer for a civil engineering company, paying tax and NI and therefore contributing to the U.K. economy.
The problem is that England is not an Empire anymore.
Now brown people who work hard make more money than English idlers... the lazies don't like it.
@@srp01983 "restriction on foreign travels" This has been one of the hardest things for me 😢😢😢. 21 years in the country and I have never been on holiday. All I want to do is visit my friend in Italy for a week.
@@kitcole4927 Spouse visas work differently. It's usually 6 years before you can apply for IRL. Yes, spousal visas are slightly less but it still costs about £500 per year. But this just proves that most immigrants have to contribute to NHS.
Did Jackie low key admit that her or someone she knows is regularly breaching data rules by looking up gp patients details to see if they are foreign and live in social housing?
Jackie you really shouldn’t be doing that!!
I listened to this live and I was staggered... Possibly the best 20 minutes of radio in the last five years on LBC.
I delayed a call at work to keep listening to this, was worth it
She needs to get her facts right before she opens her mouth.
That should take all of a nanosecond. 🤣
She doesnt care about facts. She is sold out to ignorance. Too far down the track in her stupidity
If facts are petrol, that would be like filling up a car with no engine.
She is right on a lot of it
@@tiffa01What specifically?
This was absolutely amazing. You could fill a hundred Daily Mail reader bingo cards with this clip.
If ‘I haven’t got a clue’ was a person
😂
17.4 million of them
I’m so embarrassed listening to this “all these foreigners”
I'd have laughed at this five years ago, but not anymore.
I wish I could leave but they've taken away my EU passport
Yeah. Right there with you.
Let's move to Scotland and vote in indyref? Loophole?
I could not agree more. This lady and many like her likely voted to leave the EU. A decision which has had awful consequences for our country. 😔
@@annearmstrong7493 you don’t know that
The literal motto for a protest is
“getting organised” 😂😂😂
I heard this live. Jackie, or Colleen from Portsmouth, seems confused and certain simultaneously. Full of hate and spite and certain that 99% of the UK agree with her although she hasn’t a clue about all that much.
James’s ‘love to the family’ at the end sailed above her tiny mind.
What an awful woman.
Same. She was properly on one. I forgot what the original topic was! 😂
Daily Mail personified
She sounds like my mum. Think it gave me PTSD
Just another Red wall Enoch
A Murdoch babe🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
UK is up the creek cos we’re just too kind🤣🤣🤣🤣only thing she said that was true was”I haven’t a clue”! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I swear…. at random times during the day, “blocking roads, blocking roads” plays in my head 😂
I think James should do an entire show just talking to this woman.
He talks like this to everyone
@@nezkeys79 Only the idiotic ones!.
@domhardy no.. he's done it with rational people. He does it in every interview
Seems he doesn't know the golden rule...
If someone is embarrassing them digging a hole, talking nonsense, let them 😅 It makes you look better and you don't have to do anything
@@nezkeys79 - he's a talk show host! Pretty sure the golden rule is to talk to people.
Can someone be rational, digging a hole _and_ talking nonsense?? If so - share the link for who he has done this to!
😂😂 “Love to the family” kills me everytime
Hahaha 😂
What I love about how James takes these calls is that he doesn't want to disprove what these people are saying but rather expose their general agenda behind all the slogans they use. And what's scary is that these people are fed those slogans by those who would toss them to the hounds if they could make a penny out of it.
No whats scary is that they all seem to have and understanding of the underlining theme of the slogans and are just using the slogans as a means to identify each other and communicate. Thousands of these people exist in the open and we allow them to shout their hate because its under the tile of political speech and slogans. People need to start shutting them down strongly and stop giving them air
Yeah, Like he did with Carl Beech and Oh Darren 🙄
@@dooda77penn19 Tis a pity he never admitted his terrible errors & apologised profusely, eh?
No,he's trying to impose his assumptions about the caller on them.
@@ppo2424 O'Brien is actually asking questions upon which their opinions are founded, and they flounder. Because it's obvious from the start that their opinions are based on misinformation and emotional bias, filling in the gaps of the relevant information. O'Brien asks questions that expose the holes in their argument.
'Can't arrest someone who's not done anything wrong yet'
And 3 months later, we've had exactly that happen.
I can understand why she’s so frustrated. When you start an argument that’s driven by emotion instead of facts is easily to lose control of the whole conversation.
I don't think emotion is the problem. People in my country, for example, are SO angry about the lack of response to mass shootings and it drives them to action. Her argument is driven by prejudice and ignorance. That's the problem.
@@rachelk4805
But being upset and wanting to stop something isn't an argument. If someone said we need to stop gun violence by arresting bald people because they radiate gun violence thoughts, that's an argument but it's fiction driven by a hate of baldness.
I am one of them Eastern Europeans who came into this country 23 years ago. (Just for the record, I've been employed the entire time, payed my taxes NI, I have private health insurance, and never claimed any benefits) . Now that's out of the way, I would like to say that I love the UK, and I love the people!!! In my experience the UK is by and large welcoming, tolerant and accepting of immigrants. This country gave me a home, a great job, prospects, a wonderful husband, and great friends. The opinions expressed by this lady are in the minority. Every country has their fair share of bigots, including the UK, but in my opinion the UK is still one of the most welcoming and tolerant countries.
It is heartwarming to hear that, for the most part, you were made welcome here and that you have built a happy life. Bless you.
Fabulous ! And as statistics show immigrants (first generation) in work contribute more per head to the state than those born in this country
I was born in England and I'm still often made to feel like I don't belong here - and that has happened all if my life. My parents came from the Caribbean but I am not am immigrant - and my grand children are still seen as immigrants.
Your experience is different to mine.
@@footballsoccerx2021 Just tell people you are an expat. Works Everytime.
As an immigrant here in the UK that has done the only legal route that this woman thinks is right I would like to ask for the benefits she seems to think we are/can get 🤣
It’s so sad the compassion seems to going away in people these days.
Don't forget the free cars 😂
@@franklingoodwin I could do with a free motor!
not from us all. Not all of us Ænglisc descendants are so inhospitable and ignorant.
so you only came for the benefits
@@markohenry5891 your spot on mate, most the people on here are delusional like James o brian hes clearly in denial
Says unemployed foreigners are the problem and then complains about the amount of foreigners working in Kings hospital in London!
I do know so many people who think this way - everyone needs a scapegoat for their failing country - instead of pitching in and helping resolve issues, or voting for change
And who should we vote for exactly? I grew up under three consecutive terms of labour with majorities and it was a total catastrophe.
@JwayT The Tories have, over the past 12 years, also caused catastrophe and continue to do so currently. Labour might cause just as many issues.
In a decision between bad things maybe happening or certainly happening, the choice should be clear.
I agree with her 100%. James is intentionally twisting her words and asking her whataboutery questions. For example, she says that protesters should not be allowed to block public roads due to the disruption it causes workers and emergency services. Instead of actually addressing that issue (Which I think is a perfectly reasonable and fair point) James starts questioning her about the Queen's funeral. As if that somehow excuses him from rebutting her argument about blocked roads. Same with the immigration questions. She said we should not allow people to come here illegally on small boats. James asked her what is the process for her to arrive. When she didn't know the immigration process, James considers that a win and doesn't ever have to deal with her concerns about people arriving via boat. He does this again and again, twisting her words and pivoting away from her points by asking something else and ignoring it. He's a competent journalist. He's an intelligent man, he KNOWS what he's doing. It's dishonest and does nothing to heal the divides in society.
@@stuartmacpherson7948 well said 👍
the mad thing is that when you point to and show them the actual cause of them problems it's blanked or brushed aside or completely ignored n they just divert back to the scapegoating.
This is funny and scary at the same time. I hope James had a cup of tea and a lie down after this, he certainly needed a break!
Na he probably paid to see a Dr privately and not waited in NHS queue. 👍
Do you think he lives in the same area is that woman does ,did you know that he went to a public boys school
He’s not working class
@@paddybrennan3644 all I can say to that is 😂😂😂😂😂
Personally I need a lemsip after that.
@@paddybrennan3644 He freely admits to having had a privileged upbringing, so your 'gotcha' falls a little flat.
Again and again I am so astonished how JO'B keeps his nerves. I'm 5 minutes in and I want to crawl up my wall and scream. I hear the same tripe here in Germany.
Chapeau James. Carry on
@@justwannashagmorechix638 who? You? Don't worry, that's normal. But You will grow up, I promise.
@@justwannashagmorechix638 yeah, and I'm a German one. Sorry for that, I thought Your comment was Your handle and Your name Your comment. But really, it doesn't make much difference.
She got one thing right, she hasn't got a clue
Uurgh... sends a shiver of horror down my spine. She sounds like my mum...hence why I haven't spoken to my parents for the last couple of years.
Wow James is so unbelievably calm and controlled... I can't help but shake with fury at the stupidity...
What a totally disrespectful comment to make about the person who brought you into this world! you should be ashamed of yourself.
Mine too
Family should transcend politics.
@@Baggers_Corner so parents should have free rein to behave as bigoted as they like?
@@Baggers_Corner Just because somebody opened their legs & squeezed you out as a child nine months later, doesn't mean that you have to put up with their toxicity all your life, nor should you. Not all families are nice to be around, I should know.
I love the idea that asylum seekers magically get houses despite the chronic housing shortage.
Eh ! Are they not just doctors , do you care where someone comes from if they are treating you to make you better.
Hope Scotland escapes these lunatics soon.
Such anger and frustration directed at people more vulnerable than the caller themselves. Divided we fall.
How can you compare the queens funeral with a random protest. Jeez
'The problem with these protests is that they're not organised' shows a brilliant understanding of the point of protest.
How many clueless clichés can a person get in one phone call? Thanks for putting us all right Karen
Speaking of clueless cliches... Her name's Jackie.
@kalo I liked the comment, then unliked
@@clarkkl100 I liked your comment so much, i've put a laughing emoji at the end of my comment.😆
I haven't a clue
She won't understand the "karen" reference. She"ll write in saying that's not her name. Ignorance knows no bounds.