🔌Watch our EverSolo Amp review to get caught up on today’s UNPLUGGED! ua-cam.com/video/JKTnJ_S1v-Q/v-deo.html 📌Considering the AMP-F2? Find it here bit.ly/4aw7lzr • bit.ly/3PZzdnf 😀We’re so glad you joined us! If you enjoyed this video, please hit the 👍button! 🙏 Please stay on topic and be respectful. 🚫No links, self-promotion, or personal info.
Yep, I have great Class A/B (Parasound 2125v2, Arcam AVR5) and shitty Class A/B (Emotiva BasX-A3, Denon x3700H). I also have great Class D (NAD C298 which is similar to NAD M23, Parasound Zonemaster 2). Apple Music lossless
Fast fashion is actually a really good analogy to what’s happening. And like fast fashion, we as consumers should be thoughtful about the waste being generated by being overly consumptive of these products. Clothing and textiles are already a major problem, but the kind of chemicals being used that leach out of these things when they’re in dumps are on a whole Nother level of damage. Food for thought.
@@r423sdex I think sustainability scoring our hobby would actually be a good thing. It makes the further point that durability isn’t just about dollar value - it’s also for a better world. Something worth bringing up at the expos and conferences and generating a score that takes various factors into account.
Good morning! I had a rough night's sleep so I'm just getting my day going. Andrew is a saint and let me sleep in. I hope everyone is having a great day. We really appreciate you watching!
Everyone I talked to today seemed to have a crap sleep. Sorry you had a rough night too. I took our dog out at 5 am for his walk instead of my wife who said she didn't have the zoom to take him this morning. Got another couple of hours to finish this week off. Always look forward to all your episodes and reviews. Plugged and Unplugged! Cheers from Ian in Canada!
One of the things I appreciate most about your episodes is your experienced, professional and knowledgeable comments backed up by full disclosure measurements. You are NOT a BS artist. Keep up the great work Andrew! We love what you do here. And always love both your opinions. You do good work! Cheers!
I've been in the hifi game for almost 50 years. I've owned reference gear in the 70-80's (class A, tubes...), no gear so to speak in the early 90's, slowly getting back into hifi in the late 90's (Rega, Cambridge, Rotel, Naim, etc) I finally settled down on a Naim XS2 which I've owned for about ten years. It's not a power house; no huge dynamics, bone rattling bass, ultra detailed highs or velvety mids. Its major strength being that it looks good, is well balanced, doesn't offend in any particular way and has been rock solid reliable. The newer XS3 which is pretty much the same amp with the addition of a phono stage sells for about $4000(5200 CDN +15% taxes here in Canada) On a whim I recently bought the ''class D flavor of the month'' Fosi ZA3 for $129. Long story, short: I haven't used the Naim ever since. So I can only imagine what $4000 worth of class D could get me.
I have an integrated tube amp and tube dac. I also tried the fosi za3 mono setup and was blown away from the sound quality of those little amps. It was rich sounding and wide sound stage, it is pretty good for the money.
Awesome video, great conversation, and thank you so much for choosing my question. ❤️ Very honored! You know, part of your conversation rightly focused on this new dynamic around cheap audio equipment being churned out quickly and how the buying habits of even enthusiasts have changed a little bit toward these products. I would like to know your thoughts as to whether you think that listening habits are also contributing to this. In other words, IMHO the average consumer's expectation of quality audio seems uniquely different than 10 years ago. (And is that also happening to enthusiasts?) Thoughts?
I think I purchased an XTZ Edge A300 at your recommendation way back. It’s a small amp that I’ve been very happy with. May even add a second at some point. Scandinavian design. Still available. Affordable. Open box deals.
This is good conversation! Price point is a manufacturer's bottom line and the more expense, the less obtainable result. That stated, I hear the difference in a torodial power source to others as an more clear and the larger it is the better as it avoids signal compression with lots of head room. I am willing to spend up to a point for the sound I like.
At the end of the day, Class D is still Class D. My buddy bought the Fosi ZA3 and put it up against his $1500 Deer Creek Hypex, and could not believe that the $100 Fosi was sonically, just about there with the $1500 Hypex. The diminishing returns of Class D. I can say a single Fosi ZA3 ran my Magnepan LRS+ speakers without breaking a sweat, and did sound very good. But! It was still Class D, very sterile and two dimensional. And that is the issue to my ears, that 2D clinical sound. And the rolling R&D on these cheap amps... Key word here is "cheap", and 99% of the time they work as advertised, and can get very close sonically with more expensive offerings, so they sell like hotcakes.
I keep buying class D's like hotcakes. Just ordered #5 with a GaN power supply and upgraded opamps. Amps 6-10 are V3 monos. I like having A LOT of speakers (used), amps (class D), switches, ps's, tubes, EQ's, pre-amps, dacs and streamers for less than the cost of 1 "good" AB amp. Amps are ridiculous for the cost/value ratio they provide.
300 sq ft room, Zu Audio DW6(12 ohm nom. 95 db SPL) powered by 2 Fosi ZA3's, home built tube preamp, will easily reach 95 db's for hours without faltering. My VTL tube monoblocks have been sitting idle for months now.
I still have a fosi amp in my garage system that shoots sparks out of the power supply when you plug it in. It came with a note that said basically, "we know about the sparks, don't worry about it." I was wondering why they didn't just fix that before selling it, but whatever, it still works now six years later.
Thanks for pointing this out Kristi because when I saw that Eversolo amp I automatically knew that was a Starke amp...I was like 'what is going on here?!!"
Class D, and its close cousin, H, have been in use for over 40 years. Done with care, they achieve low distortion levels that leave A, A/B in the dust. The high frequency carrier is immune to all the unavoidable drawbacks of pure analog amps. For those who absolutely need fidelity, such as professional mixers, it’s the only way to go. Only the ‘hi-fi’ dullards seem to miss this obvious point.
I think you make an excellent point at ~13:50 in. I had an older 6th Gen iPad laying around. For a 2-channel setup to stream hi-res audio to a pair of open baffles I'm building: Old iPad (original cost around $500) iPad stand w/ PD & USB: $99 Fiio K9 AKM: $529 2 @ Outlaw Audio 2220 Monoblocks: $769 delivered 2 Mogami XLR cables: ~$100 Total cost: $1997 (excluding speakers) This stuff gets expensive quickly, even when you aren't spending top $$ on individual components.
Perhaps having the PSU being a separate "brick" rather than internal to the amp might decrease the impact of the electrical "noise" generated the PSU components on the rest of the audio components in the amp.
Another great episode! Do we get a Magic 8 ball to answer some questions with next week's episode? Unplugged really makes the viewer feel more engaged - involved.
Good day, I just got home from work and watched the Lucky#7 episode.. This was an excellent, thought provoking and insightful unplugged. There were some pretty tough questions that gave us ( your audience ) a better understanding as to how you came to your results especially your use of the graph supporting what you were hearing in the review. Thanks for a better understanding as to why you chose your crown and how others used this particular model to bench test the amps they are developing. Consistency is all too important. Yes those Crown amps are solid as I still have my D70 amps since the 80's. Kristi, thank you including my question in today episode of unplugged. Until Sunday, Cheers ...
I, for one, appreciate FOSI’s business model, in that they are willing to listen to reviewers and customers regarding the issues with their products and attempt to fix them. I think we have seen in the recent weeks that the opposite model is not good. This , of course, is just my opinion and I do understand the “get it right the first time“ perspective.
I'm all for a brand wanting to correct its mistakes and/or improve its products; please do not get me wrong. However, the V3 isn't yet shipping to genuine customers, and Fosi is, quite literally, soliciting R&D advice from ASR (a forum they financially contribute to) for what will be the V3's update or perhaps replacement. They began their solicitation yesterday and admit development is already underway. It just doesn't feel like a "fix" but rather a pump and dump --but that's just my opinion.
I run a Fiera 8 to power my 4 surrounds and 4 height speakers and have absolutely no complaints... especially at the price Starke often sells it. I have no problem running at Reference Level - which is really too loud for my tastes and I'm using 60% of a large open room for my set up.
I'm running an Audiocontrol Pantages G4 class H amp connected to a Marantz Cinema 40 for my belayer speakers and use the receiver for my Atmos speakers. I ended up getting the Pantages amp for is small footprint, lightweight (compared to A/B amps) and high power/low heat and I love it. The biggest difference that I have noticed is that all the subtle noises (including ones I didn't previously hear, I've retested before and after with some movies) are more pronounced and my surrounds have become more fuller sound and with more umph. Movies have become more immersive with all the minute details becoming audible now, ex: scene takes place in a house, but you can hear people walking outdoors or birds or crickets chirping like crazy. My surrounds have more rumble and it feels like bass is hitting from the rears now. Years down the road when I replace my current receiver, I'll probably go with a preamp as I already have one amp, and amps usually last many years or decades. Damn, this hobby can be expensive but very satisfying at the same time.....
You basically have my dream set up. I'm hoping to upgrade from a smaller/older Marantz AVR to the Cinema 40, I didn't think I would need to pair an amp with it but after reading your comments I will give that a shot. Congrats and enjoy. On a side note, do you use a streamer, and if so which one?
@@Paul-tw3yi it sounded great without an amp, I just wanted to squeeze as much out as I could so to say. It brought out more subtle details that were probably always there but just needed more power to bring those sounds alive such as footsteps, horses outside walking, etc. And I do love the improvements I got adding Dirac Live with Bass Control, since you can tune each speaker individually it really made my surrounds and height channels come alive. Even though my system sounds great, I’m now looking at swapping out my speakers for more higher end ones to try and squeeze even more detail out, but I am happy with what I have now so the speaker swap I’m not in any rush.
@@Paul-tw3yi and one more thing I forgot to mention after adding the amp, dialogue improved a bunch, I haven’t had any “what did they say” moments… I also turned off loudness management. Hope that helps…
My only firsthand experience with class D was a hybrid class D with tube preamp on the Rogue Audio Sphinx. It was a great sounding amp, which ultimately led me to the full tube integrated amp I have now from Black Ice Audio. I love how tubes make things sound more organic and natural. I don't think an all class D design can do this. At least not yet. Personally, before I would buy an all class D design in a low price point I would look at a lower price class A/B design from Schiit Audio.
I also play electric bass guitar as a hobbyist (was once in bands, but that’s not in the cards nowadays) - and have the exact same experience. The Class D sound, even with a multi-12AX7 tube pre-amp, a claimed 2000 Watt bass amp didn’t have the earthiness of a 70-Watt head unit! But I know musicians use them for backups and for small gigs, and they hold their own there. I’m saving up for a good class A tube combo amp that functions as a medium to large practice amp, it was perfect testing it in the store.
You know, I got the ML XT F100’s 6 months ago and I got an Onkyo RZ50 (open box $890) for my HT set up all ML. Although the RZ sound good with the ML I know I am not getting 100% out of them for stereo music so I have been saving up for an Anthem 225 AMP V2 for the F100’s because I know is an amazing amp combo with the ML’s. Then I see all the rage on these Fosi mono blocks V3 and how amazing the are and handle 4ohm loads with ease. I almost ordered them since they are so cheap but had a bad feeling about doing so. I see your review of the EverSolo and convinced me to get back in to savings mode and just be patient and buy the Anthem amp (I can not find a used one ever), I have a feeling I have not truly heard the full potential of my F100 until I get that Anthem powering them.
Just my personal opinion, all these amps (power section) will sound the same under distortion levels when volume matched. I would buy the highest power measured and it has to be load independent. Then I would buy a pre section to suit my personal taste because the pre is the one that makes the biggest difference in sound IMO. Thats what I would personally do.
Not sure I'd agree. My setup consisted of a MiniDSP Flex HT going into an Audiolab 6000A as power amp. Sounded good, but there were obvious flaws, it distorted a bit, wasn't perfectly clean, ... Now I have the same setup, but with a Benchmark AHB2 as power amp. Big difference. And I haven't tried it yet, but I suspect using the Audiolab as pre amp would also sound great. Must try that before I sell the Audiolab... The MiniDSP is fantastic though. It helped me get rid of the bass bump that my Focal Kanta 1 have.
@@kadajawi2 i have not seen measurements of the 6000A so I dont know it compares to the AHB2 UNDER DISTORTION LEVELS. What do you not agree with? When you say distortion, what kind of distortion? Harmonics? Clipping?
This makes sense to me. Amps are commodity items at a certain spec. Fosi hit it with the small V3 monos. Load independent class D. I like small form factors separates and low cost because I can tinker with power, op amps, and most importantly pre-amps and other inputs. I have a Fosi tube pre-amp for $50 and have a few different tubes. It changes the sound to "warm" and makes my family happy bc we can still afford to eat. Is it the best? Heck no, does it change the sound? Heck yeah!
@@mattmiller4978 pres matter. Lmfao! You are injecting noise and distortion with tubes, and they will sound different. As long as it suits ya, go right ahead! Matching pres to suit personal preference is way better than hoping and waiting for a speaker to match your load dependent amp. A power is supposed to be a power amp, supply needed power in a linear way and thats it!
I think the low price points of offerings from Fosi/Aiyima etc. is a major reason why people really don't mind the shortcomings and are willing to try out multiple versions.
I went with the Sabaj A30a. No power brick. No need for as DAC. A compact all in one solution that sounds great. For $450-500usd it hits the sweet spot IMO.
The more you spend on Class D, better performance is apparent. Emotiva & NAD are HiFi worthy, Jeff Rowland & Aavik are top class units. Integrated models have synergy & room saving simplification. It is tomorrow’s topography for today & the future😎.
I have a pair of Rokit 5 studio monitors, which are small 2 way items that have separate 35W class D amps for each driver. Really excellent and far ahead of previous setups with a Technics A/B class amp and various different speakers. In the application as a desktop speaker, with good control over spacing and focus, they produce a better mid- and top end response than a pair of Krix (can't recall the model) in the lounge room listening environment. they were also very sensitive to placement. The really impressive thing is the clarity that these things produce, even at very low levels. Obviously it's partly down to the good quality of the drivers, but garbage in/garbage out obviously applies.
To the point of figuring out the kinks after the product is released. The car companies have done this for decades and consumers don’t seem to care. Extensive R&D would likely drive costs beyond what we are willing to pay. I did the kickstarter on the v3 monos, it’s only $300 CDN with two power supplies, when you have several amps I believe it’s worth experimenting. This is my first Class D so we will see how it goes.
Totally agree with all your comments. It's not unlike streaming services. Half the time, the first 3-6 episodes of a new series is totally undercooked. It's starting to change thankfully
As far as the customer doing the R & D for a company, essentially computer program developers have been doing this for years. In fact the major players, AAA game developers, consistently put out broken or unfinished games and have ZERO problem taking peoples' money. Sometimes never even fixing or finishing their product. This is becoming the norm not an outlier.
I think the key point here is:- will these ‘inexpensive’ class-D amps, which are updated more frequently than my wife updates her handbag, stand the test of time? In the late 80s I invested in a Rega Elicit, British integrated amp. That proudly remained the beating heart of my hi-fi rig for well over 30 years. I upgraded recently to a pair of class-AB monoblocks. Not that there was anything wrong with my class-AB Rega, simply that 30 years on, I have more disposable income to play with. I honestly believe that in 30 years time, those class-AB monoblocks will still be sitting proud in my hi-fi rack. Highly unlikely I’ll still be around to enjoy them though! I wonder how many of these ‘affordable’ class-D amps will still be around in 10 years, let alone 30 years? Oh, that Rega of mine, I’ve still got it. I can’t bring myself to sell it, even though it’s used market value still means I could sell it for considerably more than the cost of an entry level or even mid tear, compact, class-D. I think that speaks volumes!
You know who I haven’t heard from in awhile? Schiit Audio. I know they have a knack for small form factor desktop gear. They had a lot of buzz a few years ago. Maybe they don’t play in the same space.
I've had a good number of class D amps going way back to the original Bal Canto and ending with the Nad M33 which I have had for about 3 years. I am not sold on any of them so far. The sound.....something ain't right.
I have the opportunity to be able to use an Audio Precision in my job, and all inexpensive class D amps exhibit load dependancy which will make them sound brighter. You can solve load dependancy, but it requires high quality filtering that doesnt fit into an ultra cheap price point. The other major downside to class D in terms of sound quality (especially cheap class D) is how quickly it ramps into distortion. A high quality class AB will be able to go fairly far into clip before it's audible. Meanwhile a cheap class D audibly clips before the rails are even touched.
Check out Fosi Audio V3 Mono or if you have a little bit DIY blood: 3E Audio 260-2-29A. Both use PFFB and dont have the downsides you mention. And cheap as hell for the performance.
@@TheSaNiOnE I just checked out Amirs measurements, and it did extremely well in THD and noise floor, but did still exhibit both of the characteristics I described. Load dependency, and an extremely sharp knee. If you're going to judge an amplifier based on whether it has 0.001 vs 0.0001% thd, you should also care about an entire +0.5 DB rise in the treble.
Yep, I have great Class A/B (Parasound 2125v2, Arcam AVR5) and shitty Class A/B (Emotiva BasX-A3, Denon x3700H). I also have great Class D (NAD C298 which is similar to NAD M23, Parasound Zonemaster 2). Apple Music lossless
For most people, the value less expensive amps bring is the disruption to the rest of the amp industry that will drive value and innovation. They are not for everyone, but that is OK if it forces the rest of the industry to try to be better in their own unique ways.
Fosi is running a Toyota development model. They are not starting from scratch, they talk to their customers & accordingly refine their product over time. Like, how many Mark versions for a Spitfire in WWII? Many manufacturers don’t really talk to their customers very much & keep on releasing new models built from the ground up. Sounds like GM doesn’t it?
the smaller amps also provide another way to lower distortion and allow louder playback. we all have speakers with biwire/bi-amp terminals. identical amps for vertical bi-amping or a lesser powered stereo amp for the mid/tweeters and a little beefier stereo amp for the lows. of course using them as monoblocks for each channel is for those that either want it simpler or for speakers with only one input per loudspeaker. as for the slight model changes that are incremental but with the same form factor, I think its honest to do it that way but perhaps without hype or significant price increase. audio research used to indicate those changes with lower case letters and perhaps a number....such as my preamp which is further improved from SP3 to SP3a, to SP3a1. the final improvement on that design was the SP3 (c) which was a fairly large retrofit. class D amps HAVE come a long way and some have gotten large and heavy. not having owned one that wasn't in a subwoofer, I can't comment on the warmth or lack of it. i would love to hear a Spectron (no longer made as John Ulrick, the developer of class D for Infinity Systems has passed away) or some of the current NAD line.
It’s all about cost tolerance. If you spend $90 on an amp that has some kinks, usually they are livable. If you spend $900 on an amp with kinks, you’re going to be bent out of shape. I can buy 10 versions of the cheaper amp before buying 1 of the more expensive. My personal preference is to buy the high quality amp, but used. Save myself at least half and know it’s a proven product.
I’m going to respond to the comments in the video firstly, these amps, again, and I’m running in mono, CAN fill big rooms, and drive speakers. I’m powering a pair of Polk Audio RTA 15 TLs AT volume, and they are barely warm. And, they aren’t FALLING APART.
No one is saying they can't play loud or fill a room with sound. Our, or my issue, with these amps, goes beyond whether or not they can simply play loud.
There is no place to lump together single chip chiFi class-D (ayima etc), with the module amps(ICE/Hypex/pascal/Purify), in the same basket. Funny that audiophools the CD digital haters crowed, foolishly complain about the audio being chopped up into stairs, all the while CLASS-AB literally cut the waveform into 2 halves, a positive and a negative, each half is amplified by a separate and different set of devices (p-channel, N-channel, PNP,NPN), and then glued back together using HUGE amounts of feedback to repair the seam (notch distortion, class-b crossover ). and after this explanation, still relish class-ab
I bought a pair of ION PA speakers at CostCo last year. At first I was amazed at how good the class D amp sounded. But then I noticed a very obvious hiss no matter what the volume was set to. I returned them. Then I bought a Line6 PowerCab class D powered speaker, and it was amazing. Definitely a keeper for electric guitar modeler FRFR. Eventually I will probably get another one for stereo.
Listen NAD, Hi-Fi Rose, and many other Hi End companies are using Class D. GanFet is next level with the right input stage. The days of Class D being crap is over. I think the dilatation is in the Source Input stage and power stage.
Love your viewpoints on the analog versus digital amplifiers! I’m still enjoying my SMSL AO200 and DO200 mkII DAC powering two Q Acoustic Concept 20 speakers that I purchased for $249. Then I have a 10” Jamo sub for the low end. After dialing in the sub just so that you hear it, it sounds pretty damn good and plays very loud and clear! I do hear a bit more on the top end with my Yamaha A8A running Monitor Audio Bronze 200 speakers in our living room, but I think those metal tweeters are brighter and a bit more revealing anyway! Both systems are fun to listen to for different reasons, but I would like to get new speakers for 2-channel listening in our living room.
Congratulations on E7 of Unplugged; yet another great piece of content and conversation, and I appreciate the effort. As I've mentioned many times before, one cannot lose objectivity for equipment applications, and I believe you did a great job in your initial review, as well as your follow-up today. I'm not sure why equipment applciation seems to escape so many, and when put in proper context, I think there's a case to be made that these amps are not the high value many purport. Having a significant amount of experience with Chinese products, specifically IEM's, and as you mentioned, the Chinese are producing quickly and flooding the market. The result is a very poor level of quality control - no secret there! They take the same approach with IEMS; literally producing a new varient of a specific model every 3-4mos. Therefore, this process requires speed and market testing, not a great approach in my humble opinion. I think this Class D craze is very similar to the market prior to the EIA establishing some consitency with specifications (1970's I believe). Manufacturer's were producig products and promoting ridiculous specifications. Poorly informed consumers or those freshly embarking upon their audio journey, would not have the knowledge to understand overall performance beyond the specs. I believe these lower cost Class D designs are effecting consumers in a very similar manner; wattage and THD driving those to believe that these little jelly beans will perform identical to Class AB designs of similar specs. Your review touches on this and explains by recommending usage for lower volume levels or desktop applications. And when we consider "tonality," there's likely even a larger void between the two designs. As with any subjective hobby, new consumers do best to absorb as much information as possible, SUBSCRIBE to your channel, and first focus on properly identifying THEIR NEEDS. This is likely the most important element of the journey; before you can determine if a piece of equipment is appropriate for yourself, you MUST UNDERSTAND your personal needs. As a result, one can minimize the many pitfalls this hobby contains. Finally, I do believe there is a place for Class D, but it's not currently available at these price points (i.e. the Heaven 11 Billie Amp MkII - $1939 base price). You reviewed this amp many years ago, and I think you should revisit as the timing seems perfect. The Billie MkII has doubled in power (120W 8ohms / 215W 4ohms) with many firmware updates, and as you've likely seen, has received some incredible reviews! I'm actually considering purchasing one for my Martin Logan Quest Z speaks; I believe it may do a wonderful job, AND, if I ever decide to add a stronger outboard 2ch amplifer, it then becomes quite the Class A Preamp!! Again, great topic and well handled - kudos to both of you! Happy Friday!
QC cost 💲…same as the mass market vinyl pressing plants. Budget records come really dirty with pops and clicks and sharp edges. More “audiophile” pressings tend to go through some QC and are a lot cleaner. (Generally) I did buy a $150 record that came with so much warp that my stylist would jump out the groove. It was replaced.
Hello Eversolo F2 is not really that bad, I listened to it in two systems, mine and a friend's and I liked it, it was not that far from my Classe amplifier which is several times more expensive. Its great advantage in my opinion, is that it sounds very good at low volume. Here in Europe we don't have big houses like in the USA, many of us live in apartments and you can't listen as loud as you want, or you risk neighbors coming to the door with a bat (yes, unfortunately in Europe we don't have either shotguns) About small Chinese amplifiers that flooded the market, what can I say, I haven't listened to any of them but they don't inspire me much confidence. The world went crazy because they are very cheap and they don't really care about the rest. And all the propaganda they get on the internet and UA-cam by guys who claim they are giant slayers just adds fuel to the fire. But considering that you can buy a whole cargo ship with Fosi & Co for the price of a Dan D'Agostino Relentless Epic 1600 Mono Amplifier (one, not a pair) I don't think they can be a big deal. Probably in a few months most of them will be for sale for $25 on eBay
Just getting a chance to watch… there is a comment under this video (I’m not saying which one) that might just be the most ridiculous comment I’ve ever seen on this channel. Be well. Here’s some $ as a token of appreciation for all you two do (and put up with).
All these rave Class D generalizations of sounding sterile will blow out of the water if you listen to Leema Acoustics Elements AMP with Just 56Watts or RMS power @ 8 Ohms. Okay I agree it aint cheap. But What a Bass and Control Bruh 😮. And yes you do get those technical things too so called 3D Soundstage, Imaging, Instrument seperation. Watts aint everything. But its how the amp was designed. Just try it if you can. As someone mentioned here , Class D for summer and my 300B for winter.
I have a cheap Rockville BLUAMP 2.1 Bluetooth powering 2 Infinity Outrigger Jr outdoor speakers and a cheap 8" passive base tube for my back yard system. It actually works and sounds great!
I say this with no ill intent, but what we're seeing is textbook disruption. While there are things that appear to be "unfair" to incumbents, that's exactly how disruption happens. As Americans we usually root for the disrupters since that's what's celebrated in our culture, but as you can see from an incumbent's perspective it's confusing / unfair etc. The easy thing to say is that the incumbent industry needs to learn to adapt, but adapting/change is very hard to do.
I agree with you both. I prefer a more stable and less frequent product release cycle. It tells me they have engineering discipline worked out and a serious company that's not tinkering to make it a hobby company. IN software you typically see 3 week sprint releases I don't think this should be the case with hardware.
Andrew thanks for the wisdom on speakers and electronics. It helped me start my audiophile journey. Just bought a pair of Evo 4, 4C, Rel Acoustics 1205 Mk II powered by Marantz Cinema 50.
great talk guys....i guess budget, expensive, capable, are getting mixed out of the type "class or type" labels. class d amps have budget and expensive amps, so A or AB... maybe we have to frame that...just live av receivers ...different standars...
The age of class D is upon us. Hypex, and Purifi have plenty of power for full size speakers; measure, and perform near the same levels of the Benchmark AHB2.
Absolutely. At least Purifi. HypeX it depends. I think UcD is sub par, to me it easily got beaten by the (admittedly pretty good) Audiolab 6000A. nCore and Nilai I have no experience with, but I expect the Nilai to be a good Purifi competitor. As for Purifi vs Benchmark... that's something I am keen on trying out sooner or later. I own an AHB2 now, two friends have the NAD C298. It's probably too old and too niche for Andrew and Kristi, but... a Benchmark AHB2 review perhaps? There aren't many out there...
@@kadajawi2 I have a Purifi 1ET400A amplifier (Apollon), and its quite amazing. I haven't personally compared it the AHB2, but on paper it seems very competitive. I hope Andrew and Kristi do a review of a Purifi amp, and ABH2.
*What new artists are you all enjoying these days? I just discovered the all-girl band The Last Dinner Party. Something about the lead singer's voice reminds me of early, early No Doubt Gwen Stefani. Think The Beacon Street Collections, if you're familiar.*
@@danab7472 I'll have to check that out! I've seen them a couple of times live and they sound great. I'm trying to get into the new Local Natives album in prep to see them live but I'm struggling with it. Love their other albums.
Not a new band but love The Mona Lisa Twins. Kristi, check out their UA-cam performing Please Mr. Postman live, so good, always love 4 chord progression.
Another thought on ASR is that they measure to very specific metrics. Having good THD and SINAD numbers are important and speak to an amp's quality but there's no objective test that I know of which will determine instrument separation or how well an amplifier handles complex passages. I have an XTZ Edge A2-300 that performs well, controls woofers as you'd expect, but directly comparing it with a quality AB amplifier reveals the class D tendency to smear details just a bit, especially when things get hectic. No bench test is going to tell you that. Subjective reviews are just as important as data based reviews in my opinion. You two do a great job.
Around the 11:00 minutes mark, let's not forget, Emotiva processors and multiple bugs, LG TV's and multiple updates due to bugs of which I had/have, early amps from Buckeye amps that had issues....so to your point it's not "uncommon", further Fosi has not shipped the kickstarters v3 mono to a paying customers only to reviewers. Now I agree in the grand scheme of things, but it happens.
We're not saying it isn't uncommon for products to have bugs or for brands to play games and we routinely point out issues when we see them. No matter who is doing it, it's wrong. As for Fosi not having shipped any of the V3s yet, I guess that's a good thing. However, if I'm someone who bought into the V3 on Kickstarter, seeing the company already seeking user-generated input for V4 would have me feeling a certain way.
@@KristiWright oddly it reminds me when a restaurant has a "soft opening" come try this out, how do you like it? Fosi might be employing the reviewers in an odd way by sending out free samples to get reviews? See what they find and react before shipping? Seems odd, but could be effectively a strategy. By the way I run a full 7.2.4 Emotiva, Denon and SVS setup, have 1 Fosi BT20pro in my basement laundry room setup with some old RCA speakers and in that application, perfect! 😁 😂
@@KristiWright True. I think as long as customers know what they are getting into, know that they are essentially beta testers and there will be new, improved products soon, that's ok. I'd hold out, but there's always the risk that the improved products will cost more.
I have been entertaining the idea of a class d and was going to order a ice module off parts express and building my own case. But I decided I already have some decent amps and instead of buying a bunch of inexpensive amps that I'm not totally satisfied with I'm just going to save up enough until I get something that I can be happy with. I'm actually leaning towards kinki studio intergraded because I can cut out the middle man and it's a beast for the money.
@@WeeWeeJumbo That's what I was thinking that they were doing, same with denefrips. They have some nice pre amps and amp combos for the money. But right now I have an AVR for my home theater and a Dayton hta 200 hybrid tube amp with just a wiim mini and smsl su 1 DAC and some really nice diy speakers that I designed and built myself and it sounds really good and I didn't spend a fortune. So I'm going to wait awhile until my finances are better.
Hello Andrew and Kristi! Thanks for bringing up this topic ;) I can fully understand Your point about the quality of the product and being a R&D as a consumer. Valid point. I would like to also share my thoughts as I own two fosi za3 amps in my main stereo system. Probably I am lucky enough having no quality issues with them. Moreover, they replaced my way more expensive AB hybrid amp. Having cambridge cxn as a source and dynaudio special 40, I found this is so far the best matching for my system ever heard. (Before I had a lot of troubles to drive dyn's with other amps). Always looking forward to see more of Your great contect! Happy to be here cheers! ;)
Only just started, and definitely got a feeling this is gonna be a fun ride. Witnessing the badinage between you two is as enjoyable as whatever the topic. Cocktail parties casa Wright/Robinson must be an absolute delight. “Fosi time” just entered my lexicon, can’t wait to find someone who gets the reference without crying foul - “but, my sponsors😢”
As I say in the discussion, the more I listened the more I just felt as if the Class D amp, in this case the F2, felt as if it was bringing out more of, or exciting the tweeters in a way that just didn't seem as noticeable through the other amps. It wasn't a radical shift, but something I felt I was experiencing. I couldn't fully put my finger on it. I was struggling to determine if it was, maybe, a lack or loss of bass which tilted my perception of the sound more towards the higher frequencies, or was the highs themselves? This is why I took a bevy of measurements to see if there was anything I could maybe (BIG MAYBE) point to as a cause. Like I say, I'm not saying my graph or near-field sweeps prove anything, but they do appear to show, like a lot of more inexpensive Class D amps we have in house, that there MAY BE a subtle rise in treble energy with these types of amplifiers that could be audible, or give off a sensation to some listeners of there being more top-end energy. Personally, I didn't care for what I heard at higher volumes, but others may feel differently.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews all I meant with the comment was that your hearing and hi-fi knowledge is admirable and that it’s sad that you have to explain yourself and explain the reason of why you use the graphs, and that they are a representation of the product in your room. Your skill in hifi is really good, and like I’ve said multiple times, this is the only channel I trust.
@11:40 the specific trend you’re discussing started with software companies and moved on to hardware. Microsoft or Apple would release for eg a buggy OS version and then through customers’ feedback would release several updates till it got to the point they wanted the software to be since Day 1. The main difference is, unlike software, hardware updates are NOT free and you have to pay quite a bit of money for their laziness and comfort zone they chose to be in order to develop a product using customers as guinea pigs. It’s preposterous!!
I think the F2 is noteworthy because it fills in a hole in Eversolo's product stack and its cool to see them expand their lineup. Its also interesting because it uses Class D tech from a pretty unknown (US based I think) startup. I don't think I've seen anyone benchmark them but its bit disappointing it doesn't feel like they have their rated power, and also they are not so great on the top-end particularly compared to IcePower based amps (not a class D tech I care for).
I have had an A8 for several months and it does a good job. The issue is it's still not Roon certified and Roon has again told me 4 weeks ago that ES is still waiting for Roon certification. Only Apple air play will run on Roon with low resolution AC3 files and it sucks. I run Tidal Connect to run high rez. I recently bought a Hifi Rose and Denafrips Pontis 2 and am a lot happier. I'm going to fetch the original A8 packaging and sell the DMP A8.
Well... I'll point out the obvious. You would have 2 stereo amps, 2 mono blocks, a preamp and cables. It depends if you are content with just one system. Because you are well on your way to 3 if that is what you are going for. You can also change out components, ps's, dacs, pre amps, op amps. So way more optionality and probably 3x more sound coverage in terms of square feet and rooms playing HiFi music.
@@KristiWright if you've been following smsl for any length of time you will know the price categories they operate at have been increasing exponentially. Whether people want to believe it or not, it happens to all maturing companies as they grow and expand. My smsl ao200 is an incredible value but the usb dac is buggy and the bt never fully turns off. It's damn annoying. So much potential. But they always kneecap themselves somehow.
@@WeeWeeJumbo that D1se retails for 750usd. Hot damn. And that's just a dac. Vmv is a recent addition to the smsl lineup right? I bought a sa60 just after the lepai 2020 hit the scene for 20usd around 2012ish. That's how I got into the chi-fi scene. Always loved hi-fi but couldn't afford anything. The reality is as they gain experience they go upmarket and I'm seeing smsl hardware at prices I never saw them before. Back in 2014 I didn't think I'd see anything over 100 usd from smsl. But here we are. Did they have anything over 100usd back then? I don't know of a way to check that.
@@WeeWeeJumbo my bad here. My smsl a100 has the usb issue. When I used the usb dac, the volume control on my pc would often and for no reason go up and down in it's own. Also the Bluetooth range is terrible. The AO200 outside of the Bluetooth being detectable when the unit is off and the unit coming up in a power on state after an electricity outage, has to be one of the best integrated amps I've ever bought from smsl. I really want to get the AO300 for the hdmi arc, but I don't know how good the implementation is, and I doubt they would put out a firmware updates to fix any issues. Ayrilic does to their credit.
So ever since the reviews on the emotiva amps ive really been stuck on those for price & performance. Growing up ive always known Class A/B amps especially in mid 80s & 90s technics intregated amps. So all these class D amps is really new to me. From my experience the majority of class D amps seem to have boosted highs and tend to rob a little sparkle and dynamics. That being said ive been on a battle of being in between a rotel 1592 mk2 or a eversolo dmp8 and emotiva hc1 combo. Both class A/B or “H” whatever emotiva claims. But i havent given up hope yet on Class D amps. If there was one i could honestly check out it would be the Ati at52x series atleast they claim its one of their signature amps to get as close to A/B as much as possible and at 200 watts into 8ohms seems very nice and if your like carl running 100db or higher wouldnt run the odds of having such a hot amp.
I have owned some of the highest end gear from krell , Macintosh , Rotel etc . I just got into the little inexpensive Type D amplifiers a couple of years ago due to mostly space or lack there of but all of these Amps may use the same chip they are not however manufactured to the same standard. I have had issues with Fosi audio products so I just dont trust them . Aiyima on the other hand with at least the nine products I've purchased have exceeded my expectations. These cheap little amps are just fun and if it brings new people into the hobby I'm fully for it
I have IOTA amps. They have worked very well. I had an issue with the integrated amp and the company took care of it quickly. For the money, at the time, it looked like a good purchase. You and Kristi might want to give them a try. Mr. Pete---------> aging hippie
The only problem I have with the asian amps, power supplys is that they times everything by three, they say 300 you test and find RMS if you are lucky of 100 power supplys are the same. I had to buy 350w toroidal transformers and 50 amp bridge rectifiers plus caps to make my own power supplys after I had gone through no less than four of the mains switching rubbish that asian companys seem to prefer I would guess through production cost. Have to say one thing though while they worked the sound quality was fantastic. These amps power supplys you talk about could be differnt but I have had so many problems with Chinese electronics that I now had to go back to my trade and build my own.
Great video. I like the small class d amps for certain applications but prefer classic 70s amps. I have a Pioneer SA-8500II integrated amp in my speakeasy. I would love to see more reviews on the classic amps like mine.
The Fosi and SMSL product cycle seems to closely resemble agile development in software. Deploy often, fail fast. They seem to be pushing these products to market on an accelerated timeframe where each "new" release incorporates some amount of consumer feedback about the previous iteration. On the one hand, this does demonstrate that a brand is responsive to consumer issues and suggestions. On the other hand, it does kinda feel hap-hazard, and they're flooding the market with tons of models that aren't always easily distinguishable from the rest of their product line. It feels like they're just diluting their brand and value offering at the current pace. I agree they should have a longer cycle. If it were me, I'd push it to a yearly cycle until they have such a solid product that (like you said) they've reached the level of the Rotels of the world.
Yeah, it feels a little wasteful, and I'm at a loss regarding why or how so many enthusiasts are okay with having multiple copies of products that are more or less the same thing.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews Oh I definitely agree. It works in software because we can deploy continuously. And if firmware issues or features were addressed for these products in the way that Wiim seems to do, that would still accomplish the same goal of appearing responsive to your consumer base without shipping excessive hardware. I'm not sure why people seem to be ok with what the Fosi kind of product release cycle either.
@@fuzz_splcontrary to popular belief, agile did not start with software. “Agile” is short for lean/agile and it was pioneered by Toyota… a manufacture of cars. Not a software company. If you know anything about the automobile manufacturing industry then you will appreciate why an agile style development makes the most sense. To spend a ton of time coming to market with a product that has lackluster reception and then being pigeon-holed into that direction without the ability to course correct quickly will kill any manufacture be it hardware or software or both. Similar to developing a single platform of which you can develop several cars off of, Fosi is taking an approach of continual refinement of what is clearly a modular or extendable design. From the V3, to the ZA3, back to the V3 Mono and now coming the ZA5, it’s a continual refinement of the same product. Ford does the same thing with something like the F150 or the Mustang. Continued refinement of the same platform. At 130-150 a pop the overall investment is small. I rather spend less than $300 to find out if something is going to work for me or not Vs spending $1000 to make the same determination with a traditional product. It’s a win in my book. It’s very disruptive to the industry as a whole but that’s their problem not mine!
@@morgande I'm familiar with agile/lean and it's origins. I was simply using my frame of reference, which is software. My main point was that the process of continual refinement has a point of diminishing returns before you reach consumer fatigue. In your example, imagine if Toyota was releasing a new car every 3 months. They'd have so many models to choose from, with just enough difference in features that consumers would suffer from decision paralysis, and parts maintenance would become a nightmare. Fosi, et al, may be disrupting the market with the frequent releases, but I wouldn't bet on that being successful long term. There's a reason so many products are on an annual or bi-annual release schedule.
@@fuzz_splthat remains to be seen. You’re making an assumption that these companies are seeing a backlash due to customer fatigue. Quite the opposite. The price point reduces the risk. These are not cars that cost 10s of thousands of dollars and have maintenance and ownership cost associated with them. These are cheap little desktop amps. Home audio is a guilty pleasure, and many people aspire to own different sets of equipment but the price of equipment is a limiting factor. At the price these come in, you can try and re-purpose easy enough such that it’s not a big deal if something bigger and better comes along.
The Audiophonics HPA-S400ET should power them. There's a YT video of a reviewer who powered his pair of Infinity Kappa 8 with one, & those are notorious wattage vampires.
10:58 I agree with the fact that not-quite-ready-baked products is sent out into the world. However, this is by no means something unheard of with more traditional brands and it definitely is true for other industries too. Granted, it is to be expected to be more frequent with these “fast fashion” brands for sure. Just look at the gaming industry: it’s almost unheard of a game that is released without MAJOR issues even years after release (I doubt there’s been more than… 3(?) AAA games that didn’t have a first day patch.
I think that there is pressure from above to push these products as quickly as possible, in order to see which brand will eventually survive. Eversolo OTOH, does not seem to have competition from other Chinese manufacturers.
I started watching you based on your Crown XLS 1002 review. I ordered one off Amazon and tried it and it absolutely destroyed my Rotel RA-1520, a circa 2000, 60 watt per channel class A/B integrated (probably around $1000 at the time). The Crown had a bigger sound, better soundstage and was much more forward and exciting and the bass was no contest better. I was sold on class D right away. I ended up returning this and purchasing an XTZ Edge A2-300 based on both aesthetics and it being a bit more quiet and again, your review. I then bought a Denon PMA 1700 NE out of desire for an integrated again, which was nice and again loads better than the Rotel but after listening to it for several months, I ended up hooking my XTZ back up and the Denon is collecting dust. The dynamics, instrument separation and articulateness of Class D is just so much better in my opinion. Class A/B sounds warmer and fatter but also slower and I feel like I'm missing out on nuance. While you say the TPA 3255 amps are outclassed by higher end Class D and even relatively low end class A/B, I'm anxious to try the new Fosi monoblocks with some Sparkos Op amp upgrades as I suspect they might better the XTZ. Other reviewers put them up against significantly more expensive amps and find them superior. But I think some audiophiles have a bias toward the A/B sound and unconsciously or not feel that equipment that comes in bigger boxes is better. Also regarding the power supply issue, keep in mind the Fosi's aren't actually shipping till June, so they have time to remedy this before anyone besides reviewers actually gets their hands on one.
I found Sabaton a bit hard to listen to with the XTZ. Switching to a NAD C298 made a small but notable difference, Sabaton (and other metal bands) became much more bearable / pleasant. But for the price the XTZ is a pretty nice unit, granted.
@@kadajawi2 Certainly depends on the music you listen to, speakers and your subjective taste like anything else. I'm running KLH Model 5's and listen to mostly jazz, electronic and house and this combo works really well. My metal days are behind me. Well recorded albums, like Daft Punk's Get Lucky sound nothing short of amazing.
@@robertgruber982 That's true. Maybe it's the complexity of metal? In my experience that's the real test. Making audiophile recordings sound good seems easy. But how about something that has a ton of distortion? The system with XTZ Edge A2-300 and NAD C298 had Nubert nuVero 140 speakers.
@@kadajawi2 Well audiophiles always talk about being "transparent" and "true to the source" so it could be the more accurate the system, the more revealing it is of poor recordings or music that is deliberately or not more cacophonous or grating. I have some 70s and 80s rock albums that sound terrible because they were recorded really badly where some 50s and 60s jazz sounds really good. I think class A/B amps in particular tend to smooth over and mask worse recordings and fatten up thin sounding ones which might be beneficial depending on what you listen to.
Personally, I think there was some dancing around the fact that most of these cheaper entry brands are Asian based. Made in China doesnt always mean poor R & D but often does. Depends on the brand. Personally, Fiio and Cayin are the two Chinese brands i respect the most. They make amazing audio products. But for hifi amplifiers, Id look at products made elsewhere. Schiit audio are reasonably priced. They have power amps and mono blocks but they are Made in America. You get what you pay for.
Love the commentary on the review. It might be nice for a class A, Class AB, Class D comparison. What is the actual difference besides price and brand names?
Good day to both of you, Andrew and Kristin. If you have to pick an active speaker in the $1500-2000 range, what speaker will that be ? And Big Thanks! to your very knowledgeable insight into this topic each and every time. You are both wonderful people.
While small, cheap class D amps aren't for anybody, my experience so far is extremely positive. I'm using the Fosi ZA3 with an SMSL M300 DAC/pre-amp (under $300 in total) through a couple of rather large but easy to drive hand-made speakers (originally built as stage monitors). I feed them with Tidal via Bluetooth from my iPhone which works fine, but have ordered the small Wiim streamer. With this I can play much louder than what the neighbours would be happy with, so no problem there. My only problem is that the varying quality of recordings is becoming very apparent. Maybe it is too transparent? The first speaker pair I tried this setup with were my old Technics speakers, notoriously difficult to drive. In some ways, that combo sounded more "musical", but there was a lack of dynamics once the volume was increased. So there are limitations, and "horses for courses" is still true. I might try the new V3 mono blocks on the Technics speakers though... with separate power supplies. I doubt that I will go back to an old style setup again. This is simply too convenient.
The question is: if the F2 is too neutral/bright and there’re some bright speakers, what would be the amp to pair an A8 with to getting into the smoother zone?
One of the reasons that Fosi releases so many amps is that they actually listen and consider the feedback from their customers and improve the products. I am not saying that this makes them better than brands that do not do this. I am just saying it is one reason for all the V2s and frequent product releases.
But stop and think-they've made money and maybe even profit from all of their mistakes because no one appears to call them out for flooding the market with what could be perceived as half-baked products that need fixing.
Primare A35.2 This stronger one has so much residual power and the sound still sounds perfect in all volume areas. it is a very expensive amplifier that is more than worth its value. Even have the. After considering the C298, the Primare is perfect in every respect, a much better product. I have now connected the 35.2 to the Nad c5030 and only now does everything fall into place. We thought c3050 sounded a bit thin, but now in combination with primare it is a perfect set. Compared to Primare i25 prism in combination with Primare 35.2, I did not think the combination had any more value, because i25 prism is a great amplifier in itself. Play this set alternately between the Chora 816 and the Chora 826. These speakers both have an incredibly wide sound stage that I have never experienced elsewhere. great combination with the previously mentioned combinations.
Also...Have I thought about attaching the Fosi monos and use my marantz as a preamp....yes...lol that would be a nice test. Specifically the Marantz Stereo 70s. I'm using Paradigm 3000F so not in the "high end" space. Thoughts?
It will probably sound rather thin, 2 dimensional and sterile with the Fosi's. Your speakers are 91db, so easy to drive, I would find a nice used Class A/B amp or tube amp to pair with those speakers and skip the Fosi, or go with a vintage stereo unit. US AudioMart is a good place to look.
That's a great idea as I get into vintage and modern both and do have a pair of za3 models, that's an interesting pairing and I'd imagine it would turn out pretty well, just my opinion.
🔌Watch our EverSolo Amp review to get caught up on today’s UNPLUGGED! ua-cam.com/video/JKTnJ_S1v-Q/v-deo.html
📌Considering the AMP-F2? Find it here bit.ly/4aw7lzr • bit.ly/3PZzdnf
😀We’re so glad you joined us! If you enjoyed this video, please hit the 👍button!
🙏 Please stay on topic and be respectful. 🚫No links, self-promotion, or personal info.
I run Hypex N core class D mono blocks 2 x 270 W in 4 ohm - 2x 130W in 8 ohm. What a wonderful sound!
Yep, I have great Class A/B (Parasound 2125v2, Arcam AVR5) and shitty Class A/B (Emotiva BasX-A3, Denon x3700H).
I also have great Class D (NAD C298 which is similar to NAD M23, Parasound Zonemaster 2).
Apple Music lossless
Fast fashion is actually a really good analogy to what’s happening. And like fast fashion, we as consumers should be thoughtful about the waste being generated by being overly consumptive of these products. Clothing and textiles are already a major problem, but the kind of chemicals being used that leach out of these things when they’re in dumps are on a whole Nother level of damage. Food for thought.
Appreciate you sharing your thoughts and for watching!
What do you think can be done to change it.
@@r423sdex I think sustainability scoring our hobby would actually be a good thing. It makes the further point that durability isn’t just about dollar value - it’s also for a better world. Something worth bringing up at the expos and conferences and generating a score that takes various factors into account.
Good morning! I had a rough night's sleep so I'm just getting my day going. Andrew is a saint and let me sleep in. I hope everyone is having a great day. We really appreciate you watching!
Everyone I talked to today seemed to have a crap sleep. Sorry you had a rough night too. I took our dog out at 5 am for his walk instead of my wife who said she didn't have the zoom to take him this morning. Got another couple of hours to finish this week off. Always look forward to all your episodes and reviews. Plugged and Unplugged! Cheers from Ian in Canada!
@@IanMacDonald-u1v Thank you so much for saying hello and watching! Here's hoping to everyone having a restful weekend.
Sorry to hear that ma’am! Hopefully you can have some good rest today and some better sleep tonight! Wishing you both a lovely day!
@@gavriushka Appreciate that!! You have a good one!
@@KristiWright I hope your sleep tonight is a better, more restful and regenerative nod. My sleep has been derailing my days lately so I get it.
One of the things I appreciate most about your episodes is your experienced, professional and knowledgeable comments backed up by full disclosure measurements. You are NOT a BS artist. Keep up the great work Andrew! We love what you do here. And always love both your opinions. You do good work! Cheers!
I've been in the hifi game for almost 50 years. I've owned reference gear in the 70-80's (class A, tubes...), no gear so to speak in the early 90's, slowly getting back into hifi in the late 90's (Rega, Cambridge, Rotel, Naim, etc) I finally settled down on a Naim XS2 which I've owned for about ten years. It's not a power house; no huge dynamics, bone rattling bass, ultra detailed highs or velvety mids. Its major strength being that it looks good, is well balanced, doesn't offend in any particular way and has been rock solid reliable. The newer XS3 which is pretty much the same amp with the addition of a phono stage sells for about $4000(5200 CDN +15% taxes here in Canada) On a whim I recently bought the ''class D flavor of the month'' Fosi ZA3 for $129. Long story, short: I haven't used the Naim ever since. So I can only imagine what $4000 worth of class D could get me.
I have an integrated tube amp and tube dac. I also tried the fosi za3 mono setup and was blown away from the sound quality of those little amps. It was rich sounding and wide sound stage, it is pretty good for the money.
I love these after review commentaries. Keep up the good work you two!
Thanks so much, Carlos! So glad you enjoy the show!
My XTZ A2-400 are running for 2 years now without any problems and I couldn’t be happier. They are absolutely amazing.
Awesome video, great conversation, and thank you so much for choosing my question. ❤️ Very honored! You know, part of your conversation rightly focused on this new dynamic around cheap audio equipment being churned out quickly and how the buying habits of even enthusiasts have changed a little bit toward these products. I would like to know your thoughts as to whether you think that listening habits are also contributing to this. In other words, IMHO the average consumer's expectation of quality audio seems uniquely different than 10 years ago. (And is that also happening to enthusiasts?) Thoughts?
I think I purchased an XTZ Edge A300 at your recommendation way back. It’s a small amp that I’ve been very happy with. May even add a second at some point. Scandinavian design. Still available. Affordable. Open box deals.
This is good conversation! Price point is a manufacturer's bottom line and the more expense, the less obtainable result. That stated, I hear the difference in a torodial power source to others as an more clear and the larger it is the better as it avoids signal compression with lots of head room. I am willing to spend up to a point for the sound I like.
28 seconds ago... so fresh. Always good to see you guys. Now, it's time to watch the video... hehe ;-)
Enjoy the show!
At the end of the day, Class D is still Class D. My buddy bought the Fosi ZA3 and put it up against his $1500 Deer Creek Hypex, and could not believe that the $100 Fosi was sonically, just about there with the $1500 Hypex. The diminishing returns of Class D. I can say a single Fosi ZA3 ran my Magnepan LRS+ speakers without breaking a sweat, and did sound very good. But! It was still Class D, very sterile and two dimensional. And that is the issue to my ears, that 2D clinical sound. And the rolling R&D on these cheap amps... Key word here is "cheap", and 99% of the time they work as advertised, and can get very close sonically with more expensive offerings, so they sell like hotcakes.
I keep buying class D's like hotcakes. Just ordered #5 with a GaN power supply and upgraded opamps. Amps 6-10 are V3 monos.
I like having A LOT of speakers (used), amps (class D), switches, ps's, tubes, EQ's, pre-amps, dacs and streamers for less than the cost of 1 "good" AB amp.
Amps are ridiculous for the cost/value ratio they provide.
@@mattmiller4978 I agree, I have four of them here, and will more than likely get the V3 monos. They are just too cheap not to purchase.
Afternoon Andrew & Kristi 👍👍
Good morning KJ ! Thanks for joining us this fine Friday!
Hi KJ!
300 sq ft room, Zu Audio DW6(12 ohm nom. 95 db SPL) powered by 2 Fosi ZA3's, home built tube preamp, will easily reach 95 db's for hours without faltering. My VTL tube monoblocks have been sitting idle for months now.
I still have a fosi amp in my garage system that shoots sparks out of the power supply when you plug it in. It came with a note that said basically, "we know about the sparks, don't worry about it." I was wondering why they didn't just fix that before selling it, but whatever, it still works now six years later.
Thanks for pointing this out Kristi because when I saw that Eversolo amp I automatically knew that was a Starke amp...I was like 'what is going on here?!!"
Yeah, Eversolo should've done more to differentiate this amp from Starke.
I had the Eversolo AMP-F2 and found it unengaging. Sold it after a couple of months, and don't regret it.
Class D, and its close cousin, H, have been in use for over 40 years. Done with care, they achieve low distortion levels that leave A, A/B in the dust. The high frequency carrier is immune to all the unavoidable drawbacks of pure analog amps. For those who absolutely need fidelity, such as professional mixers, it’s the only way to go. Only the ‘hi-fi’ dullards seem to miss this obvious point.
Man, something good to watch when I get home. Can’t wait
Hope you enjoy the show when you get home!
Another great unplugged. Thank you!!!
Thank you for watching!
Thanks for watching!
I think you make an excellent point at ~13:50 in. I had an older 6th Gen iPad laying around. For a 2-channel setup to stream hi-res audio to a pair of open baffles I'm building:
Old iPad (original cost around $500)
iPad stand w/ PD & USB: $99
Fiio K9 AKM: $529
2 @ Outlaw Audio 2220 Monoblocks: $769 delivered
2 Mogami XLR cables: ~$100
Total cost: $1997 (excluding speakers)
This stuff gets expensive quickly, even when you aren't spending top $$ on individual components.
Perhaps having the PSU being a separate "brick" rather than internal to the amp might decrease the impact of the electrical "noise" generated the PSU components on the rest of the audio components in the amp.
Another great episode! Do we get a Magic 8 ball to answer some questions with next week's episode? Unplugged really makes the viewer feel more engaged - involved.
Good day, I just got home from work and watched the Lucky#7 episode.. This was an excellent, thought provoking and insightful unplugged. There were some pretty tough questions that gave us ( your audience ) a better understanding as to how you came to your results especially your use of the graph supporting what you were hearing in the review. Thanks for a better understanding as to why you chose your crown and how others used this particular model to bench test the amps they are developing. Consistency is all too important. Yes those Crown amps are solid as I still have my D70 amps since the 80's. Kristi, thank you including my question in today episode of unplugged. Until Sunday, Cheers ...
Always a pleasure, Brian! Thanks for contributing to the conversation.
I, for one, appreciate FOSI’s business model, in that they are willing to listen to reviewers and customers regarding the issues with their products and attempt to fix them. I think we have seen in the recent weeks that the opposite model is not good. This , of course, is just my opinion and I do understand the “get it right the first time“ perspective.
I'm all for a brand wanting to correct its mistakes and/or improve its products; please do not get me wrong. However, the V3 isn't yet shipping to genuine customers, and Fosi is, quite literally, soliciting R&D advice from ASR (a forum they financially contribute to) for what will be the V3's update or perhaps replacement. They began their solicitation yesterday and admit development is already underway. It just doesn't feel like a "fix" but rather a pump and dump --but that's just my opinion.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews Well no one can accuse you for not bringing the facts with your opinion 😎🙌🏼
I run a Fiera 8 to power my 4 surrounds and 4 height speakers and have absolutely no complaints... especially at the price Starke often sells it. I have no problem running at Reference Level - which is really too loud for my tastes and I'm using 60% of a large open room for my set up.
I'm running an Audiocontrol Pantages G4 class H amp connected to a Marantz Cinema 40 for my belayer speakers and use the receiver for my Atmos speakers. I ended up getting the Pantages amp for is small footprint, lightweight (compared to A/B amps) and high power/low heat and I love it. The biggest difference that I have noticed is that all the subtle noises (including ones I didn't previously hear, I've retested before and after with some movies) are more pronounced and my surrounds have become more fuller sound and with more umph. Movies have become more immersive with all the minute details becoming audible now, ex: scene takes place in a house, but you can hear people walking outdoors or birds or crickets chirping like crazy. My surrounds have more rumble and it feels like bass is hitting from the rears now. Years down the road when I replace my current receiver, I'll probably go with a preamp as I already have one amp, and amps usually last many years or decades. Damn, this hobby can be expensive but very satisfying at the same time.....
You basically have my dream set up. I'm hoping to upgrade from a smaller/older Marantz AVR to the Cinema 40, I didn't think I would need to pair an amp with it but after reading your comments I will give that a shot. Congrats and enjoy. On a side note, do you use a streamer, and if so which one?
@@Paul-tw3yi it sounded great without an amp, I just wanted to squeeze as much out as I could so to say. It brought out more subtle details that were probably always there but just needed more power to bring those sounds alive such as footsteps, horses outside walking, etc. And I do love the improvements I got adding Dirac Live with Bass Control, since you can tune each speaker individually it really made my surrounds and height channels come alive. Even though my system sounds great, I’m now looking at swapping out my speakers for more higher end ones to try and squeeze even more detail out, but I am happy with what I have now so the speaker swap I’m not in any rush.
@@PinkstonFilms thanks for sharing this info. All the best.
@@Paul-tw3yi and one more thing I forgot to mention after adding the amp, dialogue improved a bunch, I haven’t had any “what did they say” moments… I also turned off loudness management. Hope that helps…
@@PinkstonFilms hmmmm....that might push me to get an amp, I hate not being able to hear dialog clearly.
My only firsthand experience with class D was a hybrid class D with tube preamp on the Rogue Audio Sphinx. It was a great sounding amp, which ultimately led me to the full tube integrated amp I have now from Black Ice Audio. I love how tubes make things sound more organic and natural. I don't think an all class D design can do this. At least not yet. Personally, before I would buy an all class D design in a low price point I would look at a lower price class A/B design from Schiit Audio.
I also play electric bass guitar as a hobbyist (was once in bands, but that’s not in the cards nowadays) - and have the exact same experience. The Class D sound, even with a multi-12AX7 tube pre-amp, a claimed 2000 Watt bass amp didn’t have the earthiness of a 70-Watt head unit! But I know musicians use them for backups and for small gigs, and they hold their own there. I’m saving up for a good class A tube combo amp that functions as a medium to large practice amp, it was perfect testing it in the store.
You know, I got the ML XT F100’s 6 months ago and I got an Onkyo RZ50 (open box $890) for my HT set up all ML. Although the RZ sound good with the ML I know I am not getting 100% out of them for stereo music so I have been saving up for an Anthem 225 AMP V2 for the F100’s because I know is an amazing amp combo with the ML’s. Then I see all the rage on these Fosi mono blocks V3 and how amazing the are and handle 4ohm loads with ease. I almost ordered them since they are so cheap but had a bad feeling about doing so. I see your review of the EverSolo and convinced me to get back in to savings mode and just be patient and buy the Anthem amp (I can not find a used one ever), I have a feeling I have not truly heard the full potential of my F100 until I get that Anthem powering them.
Just my personal opinion, all these amps (power section) will sound the same under distortion levels when volume matched. I would buy the highest power measured and it has to be load independent. Then I would buy a pre section to suit my personal taste because the pre is the one that makes the biggest difference in sound IMO. Thats what I would personally do.
Not sure I'd agree. My setup consisted of a MiniDSP Flex HT going into an Audiolab 6000A as power amp. Sounded good, but there were obvious flaws, it distorted a bit, wasn't perfectly clean, ... Now I have the same setup, but with a Benchmark AHB2 as power amp. Big difference. And I haven't tried it yet, but I suspect using the Audiolab as pre amp would also sound great. Must try that before I sell the Audiolab...
The MiniDSP is fantastic though. It helped me get rid of the bass bump that my Focal Kanta 1 have.
@@kadajawi2 i have not seen measurements of the 6000A so I dont know it compares to the AHB2 UNDER DISTORTION LEVELS. What do you not agree with? When you say distortion, what kind of distortion? Harmonics? Clipping?
This makes sense to me. Amps are commodity items at a certain spec. Fosi hit it with the small V3 monos. Load independent class D.
I like small form factors separates and low cost because I can tinker with power, op amps, and most importantly pre-amps and other inputs.
I have a Fosi tube pre-amp for $50 and have a few different tubes. It changes the sound to "warm" and makes my family happy bc we can still afford to eat. Is it the best? Heck no, does it change the sound? Heck yeah!
@@mattmiller4978 pres matter. Lmfao! You are injecting noise and distortion with tubes, and they will sound different. As long as it suits ya, go right ahead! Matching pres to suit personal preference is way better than hoping and waiting for a speaker to match your load dependent amp. A power is supposed to be a power amp, supply needed power in a linear way and thats it!
I think the low price points of offerings from Fosi/Aiyima etc. is a major reason why people really don't mind the shortcomings and are willing to try out multiple versions.
I'd wager it's the ONLY reason. I wonder how many of these products people go through in the process.
Sorry I am late! But I had to watch Sunday’s video before I could watch this!!💞
Yep. Q acoustics work well on everything. Great speakers, especially the cabinets.
I went with the Sabaj A30a. No power brick. No need for as DAC. A compact all in one solution that sounds great. For $450-500usd it hits the sweet spot IMO.
The more you spend on Class D, better performance is apparent. Emotiva & NAD are HiFi worthy, Jeff Rowland & Aavik are top class units. Integrated models have synergy & room saving simplification. It is tomorrow’s topography for today & the future😎.
I have a pair of Rokit 5 studio monitors, which are small 2 way items that have separate 35W class D amps for each driver. Really excellent and far ahead of previous setups with a Technics A/B class amp and various different speakers. In the application as a desktop speaker, with good control over spacing and focus, they produce a better mid- and top end response than a pair of Krix (can't recall the model) in the lounge room listening environment. they were also very sensitive to placement.
The really impressive thing is the clarity that these things produce, even at very low levels. Obviously it's partly down to the good quality of the drivers, but garbage in/garbage out obviously applies.
To the point of figuring out the kinks after the product is released. The car companies have done this for decades and consumers don’t seem to care. Extensive R&D would likely drive costs beyond what we are willing to pay. I did the kickstarter on the v3 monos, it’s only $300 CDN with two power supplies, when you have several amps I believe it’s worth experimenting. This is my first Class D so we will see how it goes.
Totally agree with all your comments. It's not unlike streaming services. Half the time, the first 3-6 episodes of a new series is totally undercooked. It's starting to change thankfully
As far as the customer doing the R & D for a company, essentially computer program developers have been doing this for years. In fact the major players, AAA game developers, consistently put out broken or unfinished games and have ZERO problem taking peoples' money. Sometimes never even fixing or finishing their product. This is becoming the norm not an outlier.
This is unfortunately so true. Long gone are the days of a gold release. RIP
I think the key point here is:- will these ‘inexpensive’ class-D amps, which are updated more frequently than my wife updates her handbag, stand the test of time? In the late 80s I invested in a Rega Elicit, British integrated amp. That proudly remained the beating heart of my hi-fi rig for well over 30 years. I upgraded recently to a pair of class-AB monoblocks. Not that there was anything wrong with my class-AB Rega, simply that 30 years on, I have more disposable income to play with. I honestly believe that in 30 years time, those class-AB monoblocks will still be sitting proud in my hi-fi rack. Highly unlikely I’ll still be around to enjoy them though! I wonder how many of these ‘affordable’ class-D amps will still be around in 10 years, let alone 30 years?
Oh, that Rega of mine, I’ve still got it. I can’t bring myself to sell it, even though it’s used market value still means I could sell it for considerably more than the cost of an entry level or even mid tear, compact, class-D. I think that speaks volumes!
You know who I haven’t heard from in awhile? Schiit Audio. I know they have a knack for small form factor desktop gear. They had a lot of buzz a few years ago. Maybe they don’t play in the same space.
Schiit is very anti class d. They actually use this type of language on their product/amp description.
I've had a good number of class D amps going way back to the original Bal Canto and ending with the Nad M33 which I have had for about 3 years. I am not sold on any of them so far. The sound.....something ain't right.
I find them to be the opposite of tubes. Soulless and clinical.
Like a room of candles/fireplace verses lights in a hospital.
I have the opportunity to be able to use an Audio Precision in my job, and all inexpensive class D amps exhibit load dependancy which will make them sound brighter. You can solve load dependancy, but it requires high quality filtering that doesnt fit into an ultra cheap price point.
The other major downside to class D in terms of sound quality (especially cheap class D) is how quickly it ramps into distortion. A high quality class AB will be able to go fairly far into clip before it's audible. Meanwhile a cheap class D audibly clips before the rails are even touched.
Check out Fosi Audio V3 Mono or if you have a little bit DIY blood: 3E Audio 260-2-29A. Both use PFFB and dont have the downsides you mention. And cheap as hell for the performance.
@@TheSaNiOnE I just checked out Amirs measurements, and it did extremely well in THD and noise floor, but did still exhibit both of the characteristics I described. Load dependency, and an extremely sharp knee.
If you're going to judge an amplifier based on whether it has 0.001 vs 0.0001% thd, you should also care about an entire +0.5 DB rise in the treble.
@@blakebrockhaus347 I know and I cant hear a difference of 0,5db at 15-20khz. At 200-250w 4Ohms before 1% THD, I would be deaf with my speakers.
Yep, I have great Class A/B (Parasound 2125v2, Arcam AVR5) and shitty Class A/B (Emotiva BasX-A3, Denon x3700H).
I also have great Class D (NAD C298 which is similar to NAD M23, Parasound Zonemaster 2).
Apple Music lossless
I have the Marantz Cinema 50 and the NAD C298. I think it's a great combo. Never at a loss for power.
For most people, the value less expensive amps bring is the disruption to the rest of the amp industry that will drive value and innovation. They are not for everyone, but that is OK if it forces the rest of the industry to try to be better in their own unique ways.
Fosi is running a Toyota development model. They are not starting from scratch, they talk to their customers & accordingly refine their product over time. Like, how many Mark versions for a Spitfire in WWII? Many manufacturers don’t really talk to their customers very much & keep on releasing new models built from the ground up. Sounds like GM doesn’t it?
the smaller amps also provide another way to lower distortion and allow louder playback. we all have speakers with biwire/bi-amp terminals. identical amps for vertical bi-amping or a lesser powered stereo amp for the mid/tweeters and a little beefier stereo amp for the lows. of course using them as monoblocks for each channel is for those that either want it simpler or for speakers with only one input per loudspeaker.
as for the slight model changes that are incremental but with the same form factor, I think its honest to do it that way but perhaps without hype or significant price increase. audio research used to indicate those changes with lower case letters and perhaps a number....such as my preamp which is further improved from SP3 to SP3a, to SP3a1. the final improvement on that design was the SP3 (c) which was a fairly large retrofit.
class D amps HAVE come a long way and some have gotten large and heavy. not having owned one that wasn't in a subwoofer, I can't comment on the warmth or lack of it. i would love to hear a Spectron (no longer made as John Ulrick, the developer of class D for Infinity Systems has passed away) or some of the current NAD line.
It’s all about cost tolerance. If you spend $90 on an amp that has some kinks, usually they are livable. If you spend $900 on an amp with kinks, you’re going to be bent out of shape. I can buy 10 versions of the cheaper amp before buying 1 of the more expensive.
My personal preference is to buy the high quality amp, but used. Save myself at least half and know it’s a proven product.
I’m going to respond to the comments in the video firstly, these amps, again, and I’m running in mono, CAN fill big rooms, and drive speakers. I’m powering a pair of Polk Audio RTA 15 TLs AT volume, and they are barely warm. And, they aren’t FALLING APART.
No one is saying they can't play loud or fill a room with sound. Our, or my issue, with these amps, goes beyond whether or not they can simply play loud.
I love my class D periFi amp from Buckeye.
There is no place to lump together
single chip chiFi class-D (ayima etc), with the module amps(ICE/Hypex/pascal/Purify), in the same basket.
Funny that audiophools the CD digital haters crowed, foolishly complain about the audio being chopped up into stairs,
all the while CLASS-AB literally cut the waveform into 2 halves, a positive and a negative, each half is amplified by a separate and different set of devices (p-channel, N-channel, PNP,NPN), and then glued back together using HUGE amounts of feedback to repair the seam (notch distortion, class-b crossover ). and after this explanation, still relish class-ab
I bought a pair of ION PA speakers at CostCo last year. At first I was amazed at how good the class D amp sounded. But then I noticed a very obvious hiss no matter what the volume was set to. I returned them. Then I bought a Line6 PowerCab class D powered speaker, and it was amazing. Definitely a keeper for electric guitar modeler FRFR. Eventually I will probably get another one for stereo.
Listen NAD, Hi-Fi Rose, and many other Hi End companies are using Class D. GanFet is next level with the right input stage. The days of Class D being crap is over. I think the dilatation is in the Source Input stage and power stage.
Love your viewpoints on the analog versus digital amplifiers! I’m still enjoying my SMSL AO200 and DO200 mkII DAC powering two Q Acoustic Concept 20 speakers that I purchased for $249. Then I have a 10” Jamo sub for the low end. After dialing in the sub just so that you hear it, it sounds pretty damn good and plays very loud and clear! I do hear a bit more on the top end with my Yamaha A8A running Monitor Audio Bronze 200 speakers in our living room, but I think those metal tweeters are brighter and a bit more revealing anyway! Both systems are fun to listen to for different reasons, but I would like to get new speakers for 2-channel listening in our living room.
Congratulations on E7 of Unplugged; yet another great piece of content and conversation, and I appreciate the effort. As I've mentioned many times before, one cannot lose objectivity for equipment applications, and I believe you did a great job in your initial review, as well as your follow-up today. I'm not sure why equipment applciation seems to escape so many, and when put in proper context, I think there's a case to be made that these amps are not the high value many purport.
Having a significant amount of experience with Chinese products, specifically IEM's, and as you mentioned, the Chinese are producing quickly and flooding the market. The result is a very poor level of quality control - no secret there! They take the same approach with IEMS; literally producing a new varient of a specific model every 3-4mos. Therefore, this process requires speed and market testing, not a great approach in my humble opinion.
I think this Class D craze is very similar to the market prior to the EIA establishing some consitency with specifications (1970's I believe). Manufacturer's were producig products and promoting ridiculous specifications. Poorly informed consumers or those freshly embarking upon their audio journey, would not have the knowledge to understand overall performance beyond the specs. I believe these lower cost Class D designs are effecting consumers in a very similar manner; wattage and THD driving those to believe that these little jelly beans will perform identical to Class AB designs of similar specs. Your review touches on this and explains by recommending usage for lower volume levels or desktop applications. And when we consider "tonality," there's likely even a larger void between the two designs.
As with any subjective hobby, new consumers do best to absorb as much information as possible, SUBSCRIBE to your channel, and first focus on properly identifying THEIR NEEDS. This is likely the most important element of the journey; before you can determine if a piece of equipment is appropriate for yourself, you MUST UNDERSTAND your personal needs. As a result, one can minimize the many pitfalls this hobby contains.
Finally, I do believe there is a place for Class D, but it's not currently available at these price points (i.e. the Heaven 11 Billie Amp MkII - $1939 base price). You reviewed this amp many years ago, and I think you should revisit as the timing seems perfect. The Billie MkII has doubled in power (120W 8ohms / 215W 4ohms) with many firmware updates, and as you've likely seen, has received some incredible reviews! I'm actually considering purchasing one for my Martin Logan Quest Z speaks; I believe it may do a wonderful job, AND, if I ever decide to add a stronger outboard 2ch amplifer, it then becomes quite the Class A Preamp!!
Again, great topic and well handled - kudos to both of you! Happy Friday!
Im running 2 x f2 bridged on my a8 into my q acoustic 5050 in a big room and they kick ass!!!
QC cost 💲…same as the mass market vinyl pressing plants. Budget records come really dirty with pops and clicks and sharp edges. More “audiophile” pressings tend to go through some QC and are a lot cleaner. (Generally) I did buy a $150 record that came with so much warp that my stylist would jump out the groove. It was replaced.
Nuprime makes great D-class amps. I have Omnia A-300: small all-in-one integrated amp.
Hello
Eversolo F2 is not really that bad, I listened to it in two systems, mine and a friend's and I liked it, it was not that far from my Classe amplifier which is several times more expensive. Its great advantage in my opinion, is that it sounds very good at low volume. Here in Europe we don't have big houses like in the USA, many of us live in apartments and you can't listen as loud as you want, or you risk neighbors coming to the door with a bat (yes, unfortunately in Europe we don't have either shotguns) About small Chinese amplifiers that flooded the market, what can I say, I haven't listened to any of them but they don't inspire me much confidence. The world went crazy because they are very cheap and they don't really care about the rest. And all the propaganda they get on the internet and UA-cam by guys who claim they are giant slayers just adds fuel to the fire.
But considering that you can buy a whole cargo ship with Fosi & Co for the price of a Dan D'Agostino Relentless Epic 1600 Mono Amplifier (one, not a pair) I don't think they can be a big deal. Probably in a few months most of them will be for sale for $25 on eBay
Just getting a chance to watch… there is a comment under this video (I’m not saying which one) that might just be the most ridiculous comment I’ve ever seen on this channel.
Be well. Here’s some $ as a token of appreciation for all you two do (and put up with).
Oh you’re going to have to be a little more specific.
All these rave Class D generalizations of sounding sterile will blow out of the water if you listen to Leema Acoustics Elements AMP with Just 56Watts or RMS power @ 8 Ohms. Okay I agree it aint cheap. But What a Bass and Control Bruh 😮. And yes you do get those technical things too so called 3D Soundstage, Imaging, Instrument seperation. Watts aint everything. But its how the amp was designed. Just try it if you can. As someone mentioned here , Class D for summer and my 300B for winter.
I have a cheap Rockville BLUAMP 2.1 Bluetooth powering 2 Infinity Outrigger Jr outdoor speakers and a cheap 8" passive base tube for my back yard system. It actually works and sounds great!
Hi, Andrew and Kristi!
Hi Hammer!
I say this with no ill intent, but what we're seeing is textbook disruption. While there are things that appear to be "unfair" to incumbents, that's exactly how disruption happens. As Americans we usually root for the disrupters since that's what's celebrated in our culture, but as you can see from an incumbent's perspective it's confusing / unfair etc. The easy thing to say is that the incumbent industry needs to learn to adapt, but adapting/change is very hard to do.
I agree with you both. I prefer a more stable and less frequent product release cycle. It tells me they have engineering discipline worked out and a serious company that's not tinkering to make it a hobby company. IN software you typically see 3 week sprint releases I don't think this should be the case with hardware.
Andrew thanks for the wisdom on speakers and electronics. It helped me start my audiophile journey. Just bought a pair of Evo 4, 4C, Rel Acoustics 1205 Mk II powered by Marantz Cinema 50.
great talk guys....i guess budget, expensive, capable, are getting mixed out of the type "class or type" labels. class d amps have budget and expensive amps, so A or AB... maybe we have to frame that...just live av receivers ...different standars...
The age of class D is upon us. Hypex, and Purifi have plenty of power for full size speakers; measure, and perform near the same levels of the Benchmark AHB2.
Oh for sure, and for what it's worth, both Hypex and Purifi make great Class D modules in my experience.
Absolutely. At least Purifi. HypeX it depends. I think UcD is sub par, to me it easily got beaten by the (admittedly pretty good) Audiolab 6000A. nCore and Nilai I have no experience with, but I expect the Nilai to be a good Purifi competitor.
As for Purifi vs Benchmark... that's something I am keen on trying out sooner or later. I own an AHB2 now, two friends have the NAD C298.
It's probably too old and too niche for Andrew and Kristi, but... a Benchmark AHB2 review perhaps? There aren't many out there...
@@kadajawi2 I have a Purifi 1ET400A amplifier (Apollon), and its quite amazing. I haven't personally compared it the AHB2, but on paper it seems very competitive. I hope Andrew and Kristi do a review of a Purifi amp, and ABH2.
@@dillonbray I believe they have reviewed the NAD M33, which contains a Purifi module. But that's different from a Purifi based power amp of course.
this makes me more confident that i should just save up a little more and get an AHB2
*What new artists are you all enjoying these days? I just discovered the all-girl band The Last Dinner Party. Something about the lead singer's voice reminds me of early, early No Doubt Gwen Stefani. Think The Beacon Street Collections, if you're familiar.*
I’m loving the new Real Estate album.
@@danab7472 I'll have to check that out! I've seen them a couple of times live and they sound great. I'm trying to get into the new Local Natives album in prep to see them live but I'm struggling with it. Love their other albums.
Not new but have been really liking Blue Tofu lately and Rhodes.
Not a new band but love The Mona Lisa Twins. Kristi, check out their UA-cam performing Please Mr. Postman live, so good, always love 4 chord progression.
Not new as such (2022), but I’ve been following a NYC duo called TOLEDO. Their debut is called “How It Ends“ and it has some very good songs.
Another thought on ASR is that they measure to very specific metrics. Having good THD and SINAD numbers are important and speak to an amp's quality but there's no objective test that I know of which will determine instrument separation or how well an amplifier handles complex passages. I have an XTZ Edge A2-300 that performs well, controls woofers as you'd expect, but directly comparing it with a quality AB amplifier reveals the class D tendency to smear details just a bit, especially when things get hectic. No bench test is going to tell you that.
Subjective reviews are just as important as data based reviews in my opinion. You two do a great job.
@@danab7472 I have Purified from VTV and XTZ 200. Purified is leaps and bounds better
Around the 11:00 minutes mark, let's not forget, Emotiva processors and multiple bugs, LG TV's and multiple updates due to bugs of which I had/have, early amps from Buckeye amps that had issues....so to your point it's not "uncommon", further Fosi has not shipped the kickstarters v3 mono to a paying customers only to reviewers. Now I agree in the grand scheme of things, but it happens.
We're not saying it isn't uncommon for products to have bugs or for brands to play games and we routinely point out issues when we see them. No matter who is doing it, it's wrong.
As for Fosi not having shipped any of the V3s yet, I guess that's a good thing. However, if I'm someone who bought into the V3 on Kickstarter, seeing the company already seeking user-generated input for V4 would have me feeling a certain way.
@@KristiWright oddly it reminds me when a restaurant has a "soft opening" come try this out, how do you like it? Fosi might be employing the reviewers in an odd way by sending out free samples to get reviews? See what they find and react before shipping? Seems odd, but could be effectively a strategy. By the way I run a full 7.2.4 Emotiva, Denon and SVS setup, have 1 Fosi BT20pro in my basement laundry room setup with some old RCA speakers and in that application, perfect! 😁 😂
@@KristiWright True. I think as long as customers know what they are getting into, know that they are essentially beta testers and there will be new, improved products soon, that's ok. I'd hold out, but there's always the risk that the improved products will cost more.
I have been entertaining the idea of a class d and was going to order a ice module off parts express and building my own case. But I decided I already have some decent amps and instead of buying a bunch of inexpensive amps that I'm not totally satisfied with I'm just going to save up enough until I get something that I can be happy with. I'm actually leaning towards kinki studio intergraded because I can cut out the middle man and it's a beast for the money.
Kinki’s products look too good to be true, but that’s a strategy lots of new businesses deploy (sell loss leaders while building a reputation)
@@WeeWeeJumbo That's what I was thinking that they were doing, same with denefrips. They have some nice pre amps and amp combos for the money. But right now I have an AVR for my home theater and a Dayton hta 200 hybrid tube amp with just a wiim mini and smsl su 1 DAC and some really nice diy speakers that I designed and built myself and it sounds really good and I didn't spend a fortune. So I'm going to wait awhile until my finances are better.
Hello Andrew and Kristi! Thanks for bringing up this topic ;) I can fully understand Your point about the quality of the product and being a R&D as a consumer. Valid point. I would like to also share my thoughts as I own two fosi za3 amps in my main stereo system. Probably I am lucky enough having no quality issues with them. Moreover, they replaced my way more expensive AB hybrid amp. Having cambridge cxn as a source and dynaudio special 40, I found this is so far the best matching for my system ever heard. (Before I had a lot of troubles to drive dyn's with other amps).
Always looking forward to see more of Your great contect! Happy to be here cheers! ;)
Only just started, and definitely got a feeling this is gonna be a fun ride. Witnessing the badinage between you two is as enjoyable as whatever the topic. Cocktail parties casa Wright/Robinson must be an absolute delight.
“Fosi time” just entered my lexicon, can’t wait to find someone who gets the reference without crying foul - “but, my sponsors😢”
So glad you're enjoying these videos. We love bringing them to you every week! Thanks for watching!
It's crazy that you guys were able to recognise a 1db (in spots) difference in the trebble by ear, wow.
As I say in the discussion, the more I listened the more I just felt as if the Class D amp, in this case the F2, felt as if it was bringing out more of, or exciting the tweeters in a way that just didn't seem as noticeable through the other amps. It wasn't a radical shift, but something I felt I was experiencing.
I couldn't fully put my finger on it. I was struggling to determine if it was, maybe, a lack or loss of bass which tilted my perception of the sound more towards the higher frequencies, or was the highs themselves? This is why I took a bevy of measurements to see if there was anything I could maybe (BIG MAYBE) point to as a cause.
Like I say, I'm not saying my graph or near-field sweeps prove anything, but they do appear to show, like a lot of more inexpensive Class D amps we have in house, that there MAY BE a subtle rise in treble energy with these types of amplifiers that could be audible, or give off a sensation to some listeners of there being more top-end energy.
Personally, I didn't care for what I heard at higher volumes, but others may feel differently.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews all I meant with the comment was that your hearing and hi-fi knowledge is admirable and that it’s sad that you have to explain yourself and explain the reason of why you use the graphs, and that they are a representation of the product in your room. Your skill in hifi is really good, and like I’ve said multiple times, this is the only channel I trust.
@11:40 the specific trend you’re discussing started with software companies and moved on to hardware. Microsoft or Apple would release for eg a buggy OS version and then through customers’ feedback would release several updates till it got to the point they wanted the software to be since Day 1. The main difference is, unlike software, hardware updates are NOT free and you have to pay quite a bit of money for their laziness and comfort zone they chose to be in order to develop a product using customers as guinea pigs. It’s preposterous!!
I think the F2 is noteworthy because it fills in a hole in Eversolo's product stack and its cool to see them expand their lineup. Its also interesting because it uses Class D tech from a pretty unknown (US based I think) startup. I don't think I've seen anyone benchmark them but its bit disappointing it doesn't feel like they have their rated power, and also they are not so great on the top-end particularly compared to IcePower based amps (not a class D tech I care for).
I have had an A8 for several months and it does a good job. The issue is it's still not Roon certified and Roon has again told me 4 weeks ago that ES is still waiting for Roon certification. Only Apple air play will run on Roon with low resolution AC3 files and it sucks. I run Tidal Connect to run high rez. I recently bought a Hifi Rose and Denafrips Pontis 2 and am a lot happier. I'm going to fetch the original A8 packaging and sell the DMP A8.
People buy each version of the amp now the monoblock then a preamp then cables end up spending more than a good conventional amp would.cost
BINGO!
Well... I'll point out the obvious. You would have 2 stereo amps, 2 mono blocks, a preamp and cables. It depends if you are content with just one system. Because you are well on your way to 3 if that is what you are going for. You can also change out components, ps's, dacs, pre amps, op amps. So way more optionality and probably 3x more sound coverage in terms of square feet and rooms playing HiFi music.
The price is why people engage in these devices. But as the price goes up, the leeway they get from customers will dry up.
I get the feeling that people don't believe the prices will ever change.
@@KristiWright if you've been following smsl for any length of time you will know the price categories they operate at have been increasing exponentially. Whether people want to believe it or not, it happens to all maturing companies as they grow and expand. My smsl ao200 is an incredible value but the usb dac is buggy and the bt never fully turns off. It's damn annoying. So much potential. But they always kneecap themselves somehow.
@@VeerMaharajexponentially? -are you sure?
also my D1SE has only ever operated flawlessly…
@@WeeWeeJumbo that D1se retails for 750usd. Hot damn. And that's just a dac. Vmv is a recent addition to the smsl lineup right? I bought a sa60 just after the lepai 2020 hit the scene for 20usd around 2012ish. That's how I got into the chi-fi scene. Always loved hi-fi but couldn't afford anything.
The reality is as they gain experience they go upmarket and I'm seeing smsl hardware at prices I never saw them before. Back in 2014 I didn't think I'd see anything over 100 usd from smsl. But here we are. Did they have anything over 100usd back then? I don't know of a way to check that.
@@WeeWeeJumbo my bad here. My smsl a100 has the usb issue. When I used the usb dac, the volume control on my pc would often and for no reason go up and down in it's own. Also the Bluetooth range is terrible.
The AO200 outside of the Bluetooth being detectable when the unit is off and the unit coming up in a power on state after an electricity outage, has to be one of the best integrated amps I've ever bought from smsl.
I really want to get the AO300 for the hdmi arc, but I don't know how good the implementation is, and I doubt they would put out a firmware updates to fix any issues. Ayrilic does to their credit.
Hey Guys!
Hey Roy! Hope you're having a good Friday so far.
So ever since the reviews on the emotiva amps ive really been stuck on those for price & performance. Growing up ive always known Class A/B amps especially in mid 80s & 90s technics intregated amps. So all these class D amps is really new to me. From my experience the majority of class D amps seem to have boosted highs and tend to rob a little sparkle and dynamics.
That being said ive been on a battle of being in between a rotel 1592 mk2 or a eversolo dmp8 and emotiva hc1 combo.
Both class A/B or “H” whatever emotiva claims. But i havent given up hope yet on Class D amps. If there was one i could honestly check out it would be the Ati at52x series atleast they claim its one of their signature amps to get as close to A/B as much as possible and at 200 watts into 8ohms seems very nice and if your like carl running 100db or higher wouldnt run the odds of having such a hot amp.
I have owned some of the highest end gear from krell , Macintosh , Rotel etc .
I just got into the little inexpensive Type D amplifiers a couple of years ago due to mostly space or lack there of but all of these Amps may use the same chip they are not however manufactured to the same standard.
I have had issues with Fosi audio products so I just dont trust them .
Aiyima on the other hand with at least the nine products I've purchased have exceeded my expectations.
These cheap little amps are just fun and if it brings new people into the hobby I'm fully for it
I have IOTA amps. They have worked very well. I had an issue with the integrated amp and the company took care of it quickly. For the money, at the time, it looked like a good purchase. You and Kristi might want to give them a try.
Mr. Pete--------->
aging hippie
The only problem I have with the asian amps, power supplys is that they times everything by three, they say 300 you test and find RMS if you are lucky of 100 power supplys are the same.
I had to buy 350w toroidal transformers and 50 amp bridge rectifiers plus caps to make my own power supplys after I had gone through no less than four of the mains switching rubbish that asian companys seem to prefer I would guess through production cost.
Have to say one thing though while they worked the sound quality was fantastic.
These amps power supplys you talk about could be differnt but I have had so many problems with Chinese electronics that I now had to go back to my trade and build my own.
Great video. I like the small class d amps for certain applications but prefer classic 70s amps. I have a Pioneer SA-8500II integrated amp in my speakeasy. I would love to see more reviews on the classic amps like mine.
The Fosi and SMSL product cycle seems to closely resemble agile development in software. Deploy often, fail fast. They seem to be pushing these products to market on an accelerated timeframe where each "new" release incorporates some amount of consumer feedback about the previous iteration. On the one hand, this does demonstrate that a brand is responsive to consumer issues and suggestions. On the other hand, it does kinda feel hap-hazard, and they're flooding the market with tons of models that aren't always easily distinguishable from the rest of their product line. It feels like they're just diluting their brand and value offering at the current pace. I agree they should have a longer cycle. If it were me, I'd push it to a yearly cycle until they have such a solid product that (like you said) they've reached the level of the Rotels of the world.
Yeah, it feels a little wasteful, and I'm at a loss regarding why or how so many enthusiasts are okay with having multiple copies of products that are more or less the same thing.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews Oh I definitely agree. It works in software because we can deploy continuously. And if firmware issues or features were addressed for these products in the way that Wiim seems to do, that would still accomplish the same goal of appearing responsive to your consumer base without shipping excessive hardware. I'm not sure why people seem to be ok with what the Fosi kind of product release cycle either.
@@fuzz_splcontrary to popular belief, agile did not start with software. “Agile” is short for lean/agile and it was pioneered by Toyota… a manufacture of cars. Not a software company.
If you know anything about the automobile manufacturing industry then you will appreciate why an agile style development makes the most sense. To spend a ton of time coming to market with a product that has lackluster reception and then being pigeon-holed into that direction without the ability to course correct quickly will kill any manufacture be it hardware or software or both.
Similar to developing a single platform of which you can develop several cars off of, Fosi is taking an approach of continual refinement of what is clearly a modular or extendable design.
From the V3, to the ZA3, back to the V3 Mono and now coming the ZA5, it’s a continual refinement of the same product. Ford does the same thing with something like the F150 or the Mustang. Continued refinement of the same platform.
At 130-150 a pop the overall investment is small. I rather spend less than $300 to find out if something is going to work for me or not Vs spending $1000 to make the same determination with a traditional product.
It’s a win in my book. It’s very disruptive to the industry as a whole but that’s their problem not mine!
@@morgande I'm familiar with agile/lean and it's origins. I was simply using my frame of reference, which is software. My main point was that the process of continual refinement has a point of diminishing returns before you reach consumer fatigue. In your example, imagine if Toyota was releasing a new car every 3 months. They'd have so many models to choose from, with just enough difference in features that consumers would suffer from decision paralysis, and parts maintenance would become a nightmare.
Fosi, et al, may be disrupting the market with the frequent releases, but I wouldn't bet on that being successful long term. There's a reason so many products are on an annual or bi-annual release schedule.
@@fuzz_splthat remains to be seen. You’re making an assumption that these companies are seeing a backlash due to customer fatigue. Quite the opposite.
The price point reduces the risk. These are not cars that cost 10s of thousands of dollars and have maintenance and ownership cost associated with them. These are cheap little desktop amps. Home audio is a guilty pleasure, and many people aspire to own different sets of equipment but the price of equipment is a limiting factor. At the price these come in, you can try and re-purpose easy enough such that it’s not a big deal if something bigger and better comes along.
I'm waiting for an affordable class D to power my Maggies. Then we can talk about a capable amp.
The Audiophonics HPA-S400ET should power them. There's a YT video of a reviewer who powered his pair of Infinity Kappa 8 with one, & those are notorious wattage vampires.
No matter the subject, Kristi’s videos are soooo much better… 😅😊
10:58 I agree with the fact that not-quite-ready-baked products is sent out into the world. However, this is by no means something unheard of with more traditional brands and it definitely is true for other industries too. Granted, it is to be expected to be more frequent with these “fast fashion” brands for sure.
Just look at the gaming industry: it’s almost unheard of a game that is released without MAJOR issues even years after release (I doubt there’s been more than… 3(?) AAA games that didn’t have a first day patch.
I think that there is pressure from above to push these products as quickly as possible, in order to see which brand will eventually survive. Eversolo OTOH, does not seem to have competition from other Chinese manufacturers.
I started watching you based on your Crown XLS 1002 review. I ordered one off Amazon and tried it and it absolutely destroyed my Rotel RA-1520, a circa 2000, 60 watt per channel class A/B integrated (probably around $1000 at the time). The Crown had a bigger sound, better soundstage and was much more forward and exciting and the bass was no contest better. I was sold on class D right away. I ended up returning this and purchasing an XTZ Edge A2-300 based on both aesthetics and it being a bit more quiet and again, your review. I then bought a Denon PMA 1700 NE out of desire for an integrated again, which was nice and again loads better than the Rotel but after listening to it for several months, I ended up hooking my XTZ back up and the Denon is collecting dust. The dynamics, instrument separation and articulateness of Class D is just so much better in my opinion. Class A/B sounds warmer and fatter but also slower and I feel like I'm missing out on nuance. While you say the TPA 3255 amps are outclassed by higher end Class D and even relatively low end class A/B, I'm anxious to try the new Fosi monoblocks with some Sparkos Op amp upgrades as I suspect they might better the XTZ. Other reviewers put them up against significantly more expensive amps and find them superior. But I think some audiophiles have a bias toward the A/B sound and unconsciously or not feel that equipment that comes in bigger boxes is better.
Also regarding the power supply issue, keep in mind the Fosi's aren't actually shipping till June, so they have time to remedy this before anyone besides reviewers actually gets their hands on one.
I found Sabaton a bit hard to listen to with the XTZ. Switching to a NAD C298 made a small but notable difference, Sabaton (and other metal bands) became much more bearable / pleasant. But for the price the XTZ is a pretty nice unit, granted.
@@kadajawi2 Certainly depends on the music you listen to, speakers and your subjective taste like anything else. I'm running KLH Model 5's and listen to mostly jazz, electronic and house and this combo works really well. My metal days are behind me. Well recorded albums, like Daft Punk's Get Lucky sound nothing short of amazing.
@@robertgruber982 That's true. Maybe it's the complexity of metal? In my experience that's the real test. Making audiophile recordings sound good seems easy. But how about something that has a ton of distortion?
The system with XTZ Edge A2-300 and NAD C298 had Nubert nuVero 140 speakers.
@@kadajawi2 Well audiophiles always talk about being "transparent" and "true to the source" so it could be the more accurate the system, the more revealing it is of poor recordings or music that is deliberately or not more cacophonous or grating. I have some 70s and 80s rock albums that sound terrible because they were recorded really badly where some 50s and 60s jazz sounds really good. I think class A/B amps in particular tend to smooth over and mask worse recordings and fatten up thin sounding ones which might be beneficial depending on what you listen to.
Personally, I think there was some dancing around the fact that most of these cheaper entry brands are Asian based. Made in China doesnt always mean poor R & D but often does. Depends on the brand. Personally, Fiio and Cayin are the two Chinese brands i respect the most. They make amazing audio products. But for hifi amplifiers, Id look at products made elsewhere. Schiit audio are reasonably priced. They have power amps and mono blocks but they are Made in America. You get what you pay for.
Love the commentary on the review.
It might be nice for a class A, Class AB, Class D comparison. What is the actual difference besides price and brand names?
Good day to both of you, Andrew and Kristin. If you have to pick an active speaker in the $1500-2000 range, what speaker will that be ? And Big Thanks! to your very knowledgeable insight into this topic each and every time. You are both wonderful people.
While small, cheap class D amps aren't for anybody, my experience so far is extremely positive. I'm using the Fosi ZA3 with an SMSL M300 DAC/pre-amp (under $300 in total) through a couple of rather large but easy to drive hand-made speakers (originally built as stage monitors). I feed them with Tidal via Bluetooth from my iPhone which works fine, but have ordered the small Wiim streamer. With this I can play much louder than what the neighbours would be happy with, so no problem there. My only problem is that the varying quality of recordings is becoming very apparent. Maybe it is too transparent?
The first speaker pair I tried this setup with were my old Technics speakers, notoriously difficult to drive. In some ways, that combo sounded more "musical", but there was a lack of dynamics once the volume was increased. So there are limitations, and "horses for courses" is still true. I might try the new V3 mono blocks on the Technics speakers though... with separate power supplies.
I doubt that I will go back to an old style setup again. This is simply too convenient.
Agreed 💯. Maybe I'll mix up different vintage preamps and different speakers new and old with the za3 and such but that's a wrap for me.
The question is: if the F2 is too neutral/bright and there’re some bright speakers, what would be the amp to pair an A8 with to getting into the smoother zone?
Good question, I saw that you listened to it with Audiolab - 8300XP which from what I heard is a very good amplifier. How do you like it?
One of the reasons that Fosi releases so many amps is that they actually listen and consider the feedback from their customers and improve the products. I am not saying that this makes them better than brands that do not do this. I am just saying it is one reason for all the V2s and frequent product releases.
But stop and think-they've made money and maybe even profit from all of their mistakes because no one appears to call them out for flooding the market with what could be perceived as half-baked products that need fixing.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews Yes, that is true and why I am not 100% on board with their business practices.
Primare A35.2 This stronger one has so much residual power and the sound still sounds perfect in all volume areas. it is a very expensive amplifier that is more than worth its value. Even have the. After considering the C298, the Primare is perfect in every respect, a much better product. I have now connected the 35.2 to the Nad c5030 and only now does everything fall into place. We thought c3050 sounded a bit thin, but now in combination with primare it is a perfect set. Compared to Primare i25 prism in combination with Primare 35.2, I did not think the combination had any more value, because i25 prism is a great amplifier in itself. Play this set alternately between the Chora 816 and the Chora 826. These speakers both have an incredibly wide sound stage that I have never experienced elsewhere. great combination with the previously mentioned combinations.
Also...Have I thought about attaching the Fosi monos and use my marantz as a preamp....yes...lol that would be a nice test. Specifically the Marantz Stereo 70s. I'm using Paradigm 3000F so not in the "high end" space. Thoughts?
It will probably sound rather thin, 2 dimensional and sterile with the Fosi's. Your speakers are 91db, so easy to drive, I would find a nice used Class A/B amp or tube amp to pair with those speakers and skip the Fosi, or go with a vintage stereo unit. US AudioMart is a good place to look.
That's a great idea as I get into vintage and modern both and do have a pair of za3 models, that's an interesting pairing and I'd imagine it would turn out pretty well, just my opinion.