Palestinians: What is your solution to the conflict?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 жов 2018
- This project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
![‘If I Don’t Steal [Your Home] Someone Else Will’ Israeli Settler Justifies Forcible Takeover](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KNqozQ8uaV8/mqdefault.jpg)
I like how they're saying that Israelis don't want peace but keep on saying "they need to leave for us to have peace"....that just means you're the one who don't want peace...
Different perception of peace - attaining peace by eliminating rivals.
@@ef2718 you're maybe right but they should at least stop saying that Israel don't want peace ...
Peace means giving back their homes they took all the way back in 48'. Peace means stop killing unarmed Palestinians in the streets.
@@mochilover7053 look I won't blame you because I guess that's what it seems from afar and that's what the media keep on spreading but let me explain you as a citizen that lives here in israel
Unarmed Palestinians will never be attacked nor killed as it's completely forbidden and the soldier would be put in jail for that and also because we're not monsters. All we do is defend ourselves against their attacks and that is totally normal. Just so you know these past two weeks have been terrible for the Israelis as the Palestinians killed innocents on the street everywhere in the country while being armed with weapons (in case you thought they do not have weapons) but I guess you don't know about it cause the media spread only what's benefit for them
We are not monsters but we are not loosers and if they attack we respond and that's it.
You dont live here and you have absolutely no idea about what's really going on so stop believing bullshit and come here to see for yourself if you want to argue with someone about that
Claro que no quieren
Lo que quieren es terminar con Israel
What Western supporters of the Palestinians want for Palestinians and what Palestininans want for themselves have always been two very different things. That is why this conflict has gone on for 80 years.
But it’s not just their land. It’s untrue. Land ownership was split 1/3 Christian, Jewish, Muslim.
@@DeeWeber The land surrounding Israel is over 90% Muslim.
There is ONE Jewish state on the planet and it is the size of New Jersey. How can the Arabs reasonably claim the Jews have too much land? It isn't land that motives the Arabs to destroy Israel. It is hatred for the Jews.
@@DeeWeber I don't think it was split evenly but all three religions lived in that area.
I think it's gone on for so long because the Arabs want to destroy Israel and have not been able to do so.
Exactly, we want to.prorect them and they don't want to protect themselves
“You can’t negotiate with someone that wants to kill ypu.” -Golda Meir
says the one that came and kicked them out of their homes
@@Abey608Golda Meir was famously known as a Palestinian Jew 😂
@@Axlied thats even worse , she betrayed her own people
@@Abey608 Her own people? she was jew and they were arabs. There was no such a thing as Palestinian people back then. It was just a province under the british mandate that arabs and jews came from all over the place looking for jobs. That's why it was called the arab-israeli conflict.
@@Axlied AINT NO WAY YOUR SERIOUS ... BAHAHAHAHA , "arabs and jews came looking for job" HELPPPP
Golda Meir summed it up perfectly: Peace will come, when the Arabs will love their children more, than they hate us.
So true!
No one like invaders.
@@shehrozrajput9174 "Invaders" and "occupation" are only possible, if there is a legal title before. There was no legal title, no recognized palestine. It is all just imagined BS, like unicorns.
So basically, an average palestinian dont want a peaceful solution.
Of course they dont they are muslims.
you think zionists do? they're the ones with the guns
He made the same video with the Israelis, you can see Their answers for yourself, much more peaceful.
@@Dtchmastrkilla7 the answer is yes, Israel made pease with in oslo agreement gave atonomy in west bank and gaza strip but they didn't want pease and a solution and bomb the city of Israel with suicide bombers killing thousands of people in buses and restaurants
@@Dtchmastrkilla7 You need to ask yourself why they have guns. They were not the ones who declared war when they became independent it was seven other countries.
When you want everything, you get nothing...
@@emir-rq3rw 🤷♂️
@@emir-rq3rw I stand with justice, justice may be late but will come one day. May god bless you guys( I’m not a Muslim tho)
Maby ... but You don’t loose your dignity ...
Yes. That’s simple.
You guys see that ?!? They don’t want peace. They want us gone. “To leave back to europe”
Most of us born in Israel. And my parents are from Lybia originally
The conflict would never end because there is no one to speak to on the other side
Thank you for filming this question to palestine. I knew of their murderous intent but this really makes it plain. Thank You
If Israelis were born in Israel, it's their home, they're not gonna leave. The place their parents came from is irrelevant. How does no one seem to get that? Learning history is important but the conflict needs to be solved now, not in 1948
Yes but if your parents went and stole someone’s house and then you were born in that stolen house, does that make it rightfully your house? I think that’s how the Palestinians feel. They feel their house was stolen.
@@pumpkini586 A house and a country are not the same.
@@pumpkini586jews have been here before the romans and zionists came in 1880 when Palestine was a desert buying the lands. Arabs then came from the surrounding countries. You be been fed the same shit story than them. And in 1948 surrounding countries asked the arabs to leave so they could wipe out the jews. All the arabs that refused are now citizen of Israel (their descendants)
These people are so brainwashed. They are arabs who went to these lands by invasions and killed many jews themselfves. The jews come from Judea which is this land.
@@Ariel_is_a_dreamerNo it’s exactly the same concept
To an Israeli peace-supporter this is a very depressing video. It's message is that we are lying to ourselves in thinking that we can solve this conflict. It gives the impression that non of the Palestinians share our vision. They all what us out. Ulfat from Ramalla, the last interviewee, was the only one who expressed a pragmatic, life-seeking way of thinking. I was born here, my parents were born here, and we don't have any other country to "go back" to. We are here to stay. So are the Palestinians. We both have deep historical roots connecting us to this place. We need to reach a compromise. I always believed in it. Was I completely wrong?
me too, as you saied a looking for peace israeli and it is depressing. they are rased with hate and they only want to fight and not to live in peace. looks like we can't do anything for living in peace with them
Sadly I reached that conclusion a few years back. The propaganda is so strong on the other side that they don't even see the truth anymore. Take the claim that you "stole their land" as they say. I got interested in this issue even though I'm neither Jewish nor Muslim so I went and googled the land records to see what lands were owned and by whom. One of the things that blew me away was that Palestinians only owned roughly 3% of the land within the 1948 borders. (I know, yes, im that much of a nerd that I look things up.)
Why did I look that up? Because I believe Israelis have a reason to lie and I believe Palestinians have a reason to lie, but the Ottoman had no reason to lie to themselves when recording land sales.
And still Palestinians will tell me that's wrong. That Palestinians who fled have their land deeds but when I ask them what percentage then did they really own, how deeds would have been issues by Jordan for generational properties and what reason they thought the ottomans would have had to lie it's like I broke the matrix programming.
I've seen video clips similar to this, but asking very similar questions of Israeli Jews. They gave the same answers.
I saw someone saying in one of the interviews that education is wrong. Both sides teaching hate to the other. I think it starts there. And i really think Zionism is the problem here because it doesnt want a solution for the conflict but expand. But there are a little percentage of people in Israel that doesnt agree with this vision and treatment for the Palestinians. And on the Palestinian side, because of the bombing and occupation the grow up in a occupated world where you cant leave and you live also in a bubble with opposite views.
Your intentions were good.
Your assumption was wrong.
"Put both sides in a volcano" I'm dying this guy is the only one who knows anything
LOL I felt that in my soul.
Both countries should accept each other as a country becoz this is right likely solution israel should withdraw from west bank and gaza becoz they are belong from palestine we indians also accept pakistan when india got partitioned back in 1947 i think palestine should accept israel peacefully as per 1948 partioned plan
@@patriciabrenner9974 so what about the Jews in Europe? Or the once’s in the Middle East? Why are they allowed in? But refugees are not allowed back?
At the end of the day you guys need to live together. Clearly walls are not working. Seriously why would you care if you have flag with 2 or 4 colors? Make a new one with 6 colors. So many racist people on both sides.
There enough land for everyone
He's probably more right than most realize. Either learn to live together, or die together.
@@patriciabrenner9974 You talk nonsense Patricia, these people are Eastern Mediterranean people not Arabs.
First guy sums up the cause of endless conflict - "We do not want peace with them."
Give the land back to it's legal owners? The Ottoman Empire will be glad to hear that 😂
The ottoman's lost and failed in history. No empire or nation suddenly gives everything back to failed nations or empires. There have been many tribes over the centuries and many had wars, no tribe ever gives everything back to loosing tribes, no, time moves foward with winners and loosers and most people accept that and move on and live in peace but not some people.
These people have a distorted view of history. I wish peace for the Palestinian people but they are wrong and they are unwilling to compromise.
What do you mean? Many of the Arabs in that region had been there for generations and then one day, and for a number of years, came an influx of foreign Jews from all over the world, choosing Israel as their ancestral homeland from thousands of years ago. Check this out, my ancestors lived in a different land hundreds of years ago - should all of us whom no longer live there have the right to return, displace people who have been there for a long time and build an ethno-state against the wishes of the people whom currently live there? Or is this only the right of the jews?
@@franka2743 Arabs in the Holy Land does not equal Palestinians in the Holy Land. There was never a Palestine run by Palestinian people.
@@MikeOnTheHomestead I know the history very well --after the Ottoman empire I think the just thing to do would have been to assist the indigenous people of that area in creating a state with maybe Jerusalem being an internationally governed City considering its world-wide spiritual significance to Jews, Muslims and Christians.
Whatever the case may be, the state of Israel's behavior is out of order-- if a European country were to act as Israel does *today* there would be international outrage and no doubt some sort of sanctions by the others, but for a variety of reasons Israel gets a free pass.
And even from a religious point of view, the Jews are supposed to be in exile until if/when the "Mashiach" returns (we can debate that until we're blue in the face, but that would be the correct understanding).
Sooner than later the talking and excuses are gonna have to end and an actual peace agreement happen as many amongst the newer generations all over the world are becoming increasingly aware and pissed off about how Palestinians have been-- and continue to be-- treated.
P. S same thing with the USA,, much of the world is getting tired of its global adventures and the younger generations are getting radical when it comes to this stuff.
@@franka2743 In 1947 the U.N. partitioned Palestine into two states, one Jewish, one Arab. The entire West Bank, Gaza and a third of pre-1967 Israel were offered to the Arabs with Jerusalem an international city. If the Arabs had accepted the partition, there would have been no displacement and the Palestinians would be living in their own independent state.
The Arabs rejected the partition and launched a war to destroy Israel and annihilate its Jewish population. This is what created the refugee problem. They tried again to destroy Israel in 1967 and lost again.
In order for their to be peace, both sides are going to have to make concessions. Twice, in 2000 and 2008, Israel made generous offers to the Palestinians. Both offers were rejected. Listening to the comments made by the Palestinians in this video it's obvious why there is no peace. They feel they don't have to make a single concession. If the entire state of Israel is "occupied Palestine", how is Israel supposed to un-occupy itself?
@Terry Jones How many rockets has Hamas bought? How much has Hamas invested in their own infrastructure? All the aid they receive gets squandered on anti-Israel activities and not on bettering the lot of the Palestinian people. It is a shame that there is not clean water but there are many smart and capable Palestinian people who can fix that if those in the Palestinian positions of authority would allow them to focus on it.
I am sure the surviving citizens of Constantinople had the same feelings about the Ottomans. Go away and give us back our lands and our city. But that did not happen for 568 long years and still continues..
So if something happened once historically it is ok to repeat it? Weird way to stand in life.
@guy man Do you believe that people inside a country should be able to decide for themselves wether they want to be part of a new country or not? It is a new country, when the people who live in it accept it like that. That is not the case in that region.
You are trying to relativize and philosophize something which is very simple. The exact same argument that you make about conquest , someone else could make about genocide and ethnic cleansing.
@guy man After their parents or maybe grandparents came there, yeah. So can English people all massively migrate to Ireland and claim 70% of the land and have their children say
"But we also want this land. I don't understand why you guys are mad?"
It really takes very strong mental gymnastics to try to make the Israel-Palestine conflict seem like a story of two equal sides, when it had been VERY one sided in reality.
And you know what? They moved on.
@@AnonYmous-yu6hv I am going to take over your country and tell you to move on.
I've always secretly suspected that this whole thing ends badly for one or both parties. There is really nothing to work with here.
It's looking like after October 7nth, that the process of things ending very, very badly for the Gazans is happening.
This makes me so sad to hear what they think.
I’m Australian and descended from refugees. Some of the refugees in my heritage were Jews.
There is no point in me holding hatred for those who caused the suffering of my ancestors and caused them to flee for their lives.
Now I am here. LET US ALL MAKE PEACE AND BUILD A BETTER FUTURE FOR ALL.
They are not interested. They were never interested. The west keeps trying to push peace agenda while the Palestinians very clearly tell them "we do not want peace". They want us dead or gone.
Would you hate those people if they still caused suffering to you too?
The last one wants Jobs?....20,000 palestinians crosed to Israel from Gaza every day to work!!!
Blame hamas for stoping this!!
Most regufees wamt to become part of a country snd make it better. So many Arabs seem xenophobic; they spund like they want evrryome to be the one nstion a lity/ culture/ religion.
Hold hand and sing kumbaya
Well that went just as I expected.
@Salma Osman should the US eradicate Muslims because of 9/11? Should black South African commit a genocide on white South Africans? Should European Jews commit a Holocaust on white Germans? Should Native Americans take over through murdering anyone who isnt Native? even if Israel is at fault for the suffering of Palestinians, should Palestinians make Israel vanish?
O3.3246 imagine thinking the U.S wasn't the cause of 9/11 after all the perks they got after it
@@ilbiap4862 yes they should because israel is a colonizer state. Let them have their Palestinian state or create a multiethnic state. But an Israeli state is the main fucking problem
@@musaharun2340 the Palis can have their state when they demonstrate they are able and willing to live in peace with Israel. I haven't seen that yet
@Terry Jones you know nothing IV been there 3 times and the majority of Jews were from north Africa and the middle east. The Israelis have no responsibility outside their borders
Big respect to Corey for having the courage to make these important videos
no, no respect, most of his videos are one sided, like he picked his side long ago....and it's not his father's/mother's side, apparently
These "one opinion" Palestinians seem straight out of North Korea.
You know Corey Taylor?
if you read his subtitles carefully, you'll know how he sides with "israel" all the time. Im talking about the ask Palestinian videos. I haven't watched any of the ask israel videos
@@rex_8618 he plays devil's advocate ,for each side ,it's normal in reporting
The last woman is amazing. If more Palestinian people were like her, caring more about having good life than destroying Israel, Israel would have left the west bank long ago and there would be peace. I hope that happens some day, and Palestinians would change their mind about the conflict.
I wish you were right but I am afraid that if more Palestinians were like her, Israel current government would make their life even more miserable, so that they will radicalise and they will have an excuse to keep expanding in their territories. We need more people like her in both sides.
How would you change ur mind if u were in their place? by contemplating Gaza?
@@user-ck6dy9tf2c That is exactly the point.
@@anselmudyes? Just like Israel withdrew from Gaza?
Just like the Arab citizens of Israel enjoy the best quality of life compared to all other muslim countries?
@@anselmudI totally agree. And as the woman said, above all "JUSTICE" is needed.
This should be seen by all the people protesting for a “Free Palestine.” They need to understand that that’s not what the Palestinians want!
This is a really misleading response - they absolutely do want a "free Palestine". They just see Palestine as the entire country they lived in before Israel came into existence in 1948, not just the two slivers of land they now inhabit, one of which is fully under Israeli occupation (the Gaza Strip) and the other (the West Bank) is subject to intense militarization which keeps Palestinians hemmed into particular areas and is slowly being eroded by Israeli "settlers".
There are, of course, Israeli Arabs who have Israeli citizenship, which actually make up around 20% of Israel's population - but they are subject to lots of forms of discrimination.
So when the woman says "We don't want to solve the conflict" what she is saying is "Why should we agree to negotiate over land you stole from us?" There's plenty of Israeli historians now who are talking about the fact that much of the land seized by Israel was taken by force, this isn't some Palestinian conspiracy theory.
@@iwouldprefernotto4381Israel was called Judea before which is land of the Jews. Also all the archaeological evidence says that Jewish people lived there for many years alongside other religions.
@@lynbob1872 yes Arabs came much laater due to invasions
@@SadieCorraliza That´s right... because the muslim arabs are the invaders... now claiming that it is their land. It´s so insane... especially in Bethlehem, the birthplace of Jesus Christ!
The Palestinians: "we'll have peace when Israel stop to exist".
Palestinian-Arabs in Gaza will live in peace if PLO loves them more than they hate Israel. Until then, all will be as it is.
Wise words from the Palestinians
Bingo, they don’t want peace.
@Salma Osman and of course bc of that warlike attitude they r going to keep suffering
Completely understandable.
This is depressing AF
this is the reality. we are here to stay. they won't accept it. they educate kids and babies to fight. we educate kids and babies to hide from their missiles.
@@edenbarlev I think the girl at 3:10 said the truth.
Zionists go back to Europe bcz they are nationalists descendents from Europe, including genes looking languages and ideologies
And she clearly said the Jews are Ok to stay, they simply follow their religion.
@@kobayashibadger6438 false. did you visit israel? it is a holly land for all 3 religions: christinas, muslims and jews. Do your research. BTW Israel exist because the world tried obliterate the jews in the world. All is well documented by the very Accurate Germans. Show me where in the quran "palestine" exist or even slightly mentioned.
@@kobayashibadger6438 Sweety, you have a lot of learning to do on the subject... For once, if your a Jew, it's not only your religion but your ethnicity, hence why Jews are persecuted until today (not for what they believe, but for their blood).
@@mworldxyz5631 nonsense.
A Nigerian being a member of the “ Buddhist RACE” for him believes in Buddhism?
And this guy shares the same race background alongside with Tibetan Japanese Thai and Mongolian?
Still nonsense.
Dude, you need learn some logic : )
And I don’t buy Nazis’ ideologies nor their judgement benchmarks.
Amazing interviews. The content creator is brave to ask hard questions and get such broad cross sections of the Palestinian and Israeli populations. Fascinating stuff!
How did the last woman leave Palestine to go the USA if she apparently was living in a "prison"?
They can go to other countries with the permission of Israel. With a permit.
Out of his own mouth,” we don’t want peace with them”!
Well hard in the context of a genocide being committed against them. What Jews would have say about the nazis?
So there is really no hope for peace
The last gal interviewed actually had the best suggestion, although it didn't originally strike me that way - get everyone employed, make the Pal neighborhoods safe, clean up the streets, put in parks where kids can play, make the areas nice to live in, keep people occupied with a good job and able to support themselves and their families well.
"Busy hands are happy hands", in other words. If people are satisfied with their own situations, have a good job to go to every day and a nice place to live, they'll think less about Great-Uncle Abu's goat farm before 1948 and think more about their bank accounts, their kids' education, buying a car and other personal happiness issues.
They all say the same thing. Like they were programmed to say that. I believe that the momment the Palestinians leaders will say f*** Islam, f*** the wars we had in the past, f*** everything. I want to make my life better and my kids life better and my people life better and I will do whatever it takes. (Non violent of course). Talk with the Israelis and get from them whatever you can, first step at a time, every step is your success. But of course also need to fight the hate to israelis...
@Nir Hakimian so they should suffer quietly..
DoubleDogDare54 100% correct
Sahih
The so call Palestinian are actually arab immigrants who come to look for jobs in the end of the Otman empire era beginning of the British mandate , their claim on the land is ridiculous they are the one who invaded this land through the years
Now u see why there is no peace? It’s like talking to a wall.
Would Jews want to compromise with Hitler?
@@krateproductions4872 how dare u compare it to the holocaust. U just proved me that u know nothing about the conflict
@@orram5507 A group of people claiming it has historical legistmacy over other group of people eventough both sides have lived together for hundreds of years. A police or army meant to suppress any unrest. Using baseless claims like false history to justly taking control of someone else's house or land.
Sure the magnitude is quite different, the Holocaust was much more deadly and brutal and horrific but both reek of the same smell.
@@krateproductions4872 what a bs. If u want to talk history, u can’t start from wherever u want. The Jews came from Judea which is the biblical name of Israel, Islam didn’t even existed until the year 600 or smth. The people who are telling false history are u guys. Btw, Palestinians can come in and out of Israel as much as they want, they just have to be checked (like in an airport) to make sure that they are not caring any weapons, we both know very well that if this country was controlled by Palestinian Authority it would look like syria. Don’t pretend like the Israeli Authority is the bad guy here. Hamas is.
@@orram5507 I didn't even talk about the PA, Hamas or anybody but you dragged it. That means you don't actually have a point.
> The Jews came from Judea which is the biblical name of Israel
Yes they were ancestors that existed thousands of years ago, *not you.*
If you want to go into wHo cAmE fIrSt then a bunch of Africans can claim the whole world. Why are going thousand of years ago in biblical history?
If you really want to talk about being forced from your own country then talk about Nakba which kicked many Palestians from their land in the 20th century only. Some victims live even today! Don't bring up the exiles of Jews thousands of years ago if you can't talk about Nakba which didn't even happen a century ago
> they just have to be checked (like in an airport)
Literally say that to any living in Palestine and they will laugh at you. Checkpoints and borders are there in every city in there own land itself. Tourists from outside have less restrictions than Palestinans living in Palestine,
As long as people are not ready to share and understand that nothing belongs to one group of people the conflict will never end. Nothing belongs to anyone and everything belongs to everybody.
What do you mean nothing belongs to Israel? There is actually a state of Israel that has been there for 75 years, you like it or not. While there is still no such country as Palestine. In another 75 years nobody will even remember that Palestinians used to live on this land before. Israel is not gonna disappear one day, you should make peace with them to make your and your children’s life better.
@@mrsdiii2354 You´ve got the point... I´m from germany. "We" startet two World Wars in Europe... but after that we are able to make peace with all our neighbors. And of course we accapt that we have lost a part of our land... we can live in the past or we can build a better future for ourselfs and the next generations.
Yeah, you are an antisemite we get it. But stop trying to deny 3000 years of history Jews have in that region, they were there first.
@@WTF-md4kcgermany should offer palestinians territory replacement. Half of bayern or something… Its the germans who did the atrocities towards the jews after all.
Why palestinians who have to suffer for germans crime?
@@nukiolbartes6279 What are you talking about? Palestinians aka muslim arabs are the landstealers. The land belong to the jews... read the bible and the q´uran. The "palestinian" fake history is a hoax!
There was never an state called palestine but there was an jewish kingdom thousands of years before the islam was invented.
Gandhi was cool....
"There's no solution"
He might be right
Also Gandhi was Gay ......
@@Bobby-lv2kr no he was not
@@Bobby-lv2kr what has beeing gay to do with solving problems?
im israeli and he is right. and from the video we know why.
he was wrong... there is always a solution but not always a solution you like... if they keep teaching their children there is no solution then they will be in a perpetual losing war and never shine as a people... always in pain
This is amazingly depressing.
2 peoples, each with nowhere else to go. Stuck living with each other probably forever.
when someone crush you're eyes you see now is it unforget
@Mr dark O
The majority of Israelis are descendants of refugees that fled to Israel from Arab countries.500,000-700,000 Arabs fled out of Israel to Arab countries.900,000-1,000,000 Jews fled into Israel from Arab countries their descendants make the majority of Israelis.
..right...it's time to be realistic...both sides..
When you are in Israel you can avoid the Arabs of Judea and Samaria. Israeli Arabs consider themselves Israelis.
@Qasim The fakstinians have turned out very recently as their namnes show. Al Masri, al Moghrabi etc. And theyt are interlopers. This is the land of the Jews.
I think that the next question that you should have asked them is "would you considering engaging a war with Israel to conquer the land, and do you accept the option of losing it?" It seems like they do not want to compromise, but also don't want to take the risk of losing all.
They already lost years ago, that’s the problem.
And Jews were living in Israel for thousands of years, so to say that it’s THEIR land is a lie, it’s delusional.
Anyway you see that most of them are not interested in peace.
So don’t blame Israel, who have been trying for years to reach a peaceful solution.
@@sheri969 Yes, they wanted "historic justice" which is also a lie, and slowly they losing everything.
I love your content Corey! Please ask people if they think they understand the other side, and if so can they explain it.
These people have been conquered by hate.
And ignorance
No one like invaders
@@shehrozrajput9174that's right ,Arabs should've stayed in Arabia where they are from
Palestinians who lives in towns with Hebrew names: Bethlehem(Beit l'Chem), Nazareth(Natzeret), Jerusalem(Yerushalayim), Hevron) telling Jews whose language is Hebrew(Ivrit) to leave.
Hebron is called Al khalil in arabic big boy
@@streety2308are you serious? Jerusalem is also Arabic ? Insane
@@tagtag-connected5263nonsense
@@streety2308 😂 how come it have an arabic word. No wonder Turk are erasing arabic colonization.
Arabs came from arabic peninsula....
The arabs call Jerusalem as Al Quds😂. It doesn't mean the jews are not from Israel or that many town names are not Hebrew, but many other are Arabic too. Both peoples set roots in that land.
I think I favored the final interviewee the best - and not just because she spoke proper English. She appeared authentic and well balanced in her thoughts, her heart appeared a healthier place than the other interviewees.
*_TRUST !!_*
She is not brainwashed as others. Please don't forget that in Palestinian schools, the geography textbooks don't have Israel on the Map. In my mind that should be one of the most demands that Israel has to have towards PA.
A derivative of the name Palestine first appears in Greek literature in the 5th Century BCE when the historian Herodotus called the area Palaistine. In the 2nd century CE, the Romans crushed the revolt of Shimon Bar Kokhba (132 CE), during which Jerusalem and Judea were regained and the area of Judea was renamed by the Roman Emperor Hadrian Palaestina in an attempt to minimize Jewish identification with the land of Israel.
Around the year 390, during the Byzantine period, the imperial province of Syria Palaestina was reorganized into Palaestina Prima, Palaestina Secunda and Palaestina Salutaris. Following the Muslim conquest, place names that were in use by the Byzantine administration generally continued to be used in Arabic and the use of the name “Palestine” became common in Early Modern English.
Under the Ottoman Empire (1517-1917), the term Palestine was used as a general term to describe the land south of Syria; it was not an official designation. In fact, many Ottomans and Arabs who lived in Palestine during this period referred to the area as Southern Syria and not as Palestine.
After World War I, the name Palestine was applied to the territory that was originally expected to be part of the British Mandate; this area included not only present-day Israel but also present-day Jordan. Jews living in Palestine typically referred to it as Eretz Yisrael in Hebrew but would identify as Palestinian Jews in English.
This name that they call themselves doesn’t make sense.. by historical facts
…and that’s why it’s ok to kick innocent people out of their homes
Palestine is what foreigners called the land of Israel. So of course, people belonging to a foreign culture would call it by the outsider’s version.
That's not what he called the land. Greek had no P sound.
Before the Bar Kokhba revolt, what was Palestine called by the Romans?
At the end it doesn’t matter what they call themselves what matters is that they have the right to life there. Wether they would call themselves Israelites or Palestinians i don’t think Israeli settlers would stop killing them and stealing their houses if they call themselves Israelis
And I honestly thought people just wanted to live in peace, I guess I was wrong.
It is very telling when people have had war for decades that they are not about living in peace.
Where did you get that idea?
Genesis 16:12
AMP
“He (Ishmael) will be a wild donkey of a man; His hand will be against every man [continually fighting] And every man’s hand against him; And he will dwell in defiance of all his brothers.”
Hi, Israel does want peace. But wants to have a country to. Palestinians don’t want Israel there. At all.
@@hagitaleinikov8643 Well, yes and no. Depends whom from you ask it but majority at least don't which makes things quite impossible.
Hearing what these palestinians say i must conclude that israel is handling the conflict in a very civil way. The palestinians are radicalized and unable to engage in democratic and civilized negotiations.
I wonder how many of those folk waving Palestinian flags at the recent Labour Party conference have the slightest idea what the claims of Palestinian people actually are.
Their leader, Jeremy Corbyn, intends to recognise Palestine if he ever becomes Prime Minister. No clarity on whether he'll recognis 48 or 67 borders. If he goes for 48 he'd have to end recognition of Israel. If he goes to 67 he's just imposing his will on the Palestinian people like all his predecessors.
solution to that conflict = the zionists should stop their occupation and opression of palestinian lands. then all the problems will be solved. that's it. as long the zionist apartheid state opress palestinians and steal their lands, palestinians have the right to resist.
@@AfghanHearts "apartheid"
Don't you know blacks couldn't vote in South Africa? Well, in Israel there are blacks and arabad in the parlament itself.
Calling Israel an Apartheid is an offense to the people who really lived an Apartheid
Starhopper
To the limited mental abilities of the “Pathological Progressives” who can only see the world as either victims or oppressors, kind of like a demented social worker/social justice WHINER, it works great.
Starstruck, your ignorance on the topic of "apartheid" is towering......there is a LEGAL definition of Apartheid which is outlined in the Rome statutes of the International Criminal Court and the State of Israel meets the requirement of "Apartheid" overwhelmingly. This is why Israel reputation is in the sewer and why Israel relies on US diplomatic protection at the international level. Recently the UN commissioned a report by legal experts of international law, who were American and Jewish, the report wasn't good for your side..... But with pressure from Nikki Haley the UN "pulled the report", to use her words, but it didn't change the fact that Israel is guilty of "APARTHEID" and everyone knows it....no dispute.
Speaking as a Palestinian I can say this is the problem, everyone I know doesn’t agree with this. Israel isn’t going anywhere so we need to coexist peacefully and either a two state or one state with equal rights for both. Palestine will be free one day but Israel is here to stay and we need to face facts. The Israeli government is rage bad guy who made this feeling within Palestinian hearts and minds but many Jewish people are nice respectable people, many protested with us for equal rights but it’s the far right that is the problem
How does this sentence make any sense "Palestine will be free one day but Israel is here to stay"?
If Palestine will be free one day doesn't it mean that Israel will cease to exist?
Is anyone really that naive that they think the Palestinians (or any other Muslim country for that matter) will let Jews live among them freely and equally?
People are talking like history started yesterday, it's absurd
@@yehudagerstle5671 the Palestinians will be free with equal rights whether you like it or not buddy. You can’t keep running an apartheid state with no consequences. Face facts. It’s not happening. The coming generation ain’t gonna tolerate it especially by a country who is supposedly a part of the UN and is supposed to live by the international laws.
@@ArabianConjure cool, how would it go though? How does your sentence make any sense?
@@yehudagerstle5671 i think she talked about the west bank
@@yehudagerstle5671 We are laking about a logic desert.
I dont know if the people interviewed are really random or not. So far, none of them want a peacefull solution
One of the other comments said that many are afraid to express their true beliefs, so that might be why.
This is why there will never be peace, unfortunately.
This is why , palestinians are going to get back to thier homes one day.
@david guez coexistence or no existence
@@adhamghobashy1310 Keep on dreaming, Adham !
@@Spirifiume Do you think we will stop? You dont have to give me an advice . 😂
Eventually, there will be a time which both sides will have leaders willing to co-exist peacefully.
It might take 50 years, 100 years... but eventually someone will say "no more blood".
And a million treaties will be signed with the whole world watching it happen.
it might take another 100 years after that to completly erase the hate through the generations.
The goal will be to reduce the amount of hate for each other little by little with each generation and eventually reach a state where there is no more hate.
Now that's an ideal scenario..Its as realistic as i could think.
The other way is that, no side will ever back down.
And this will keep happening.
Eventually when the world will go boom, in a 3rd world war or something, when human rights, nato, EU, and other peace holding organisations cease to exist, or when they will be all busy looking at something else ( the world war 3), then one of those 2 sides will attack the other side with full force with the intent to erase the other.
With today's standards, that side will be israel.
When the world goes upside down and noone's looking, israel will commit genocide.
Those are my 2 scenarios, based on nothing but MY own logic.
It's heartbreaking. I understand them and their absolute right to live a free life! But the fantasy that Israel will simply disappear is childish and will never happen, so that at this point it's not anymore helpful in anyway to stick to your unrealistic fantasy and see no other option to improve your life and the life or your children.
It's absolutely heartbreaking.
And I am really trying to understand how comes they can't leave free, while Israeli Arabs are more or less free.
The solution is for US to stop backing Israelis illegal occupation and ethnic cleansing and stop blocking any sort of settlement which the US and Israel have unilaterally done in peace negotiations for decades. This is not a both sides issue, there is no symmetry here. Palestinians have no power, right to return to their own homelands, no citizenship. Israel has been acting with impunity on another population, and continues to do so with unlimited US backing.
@@AsirIset Did you not hear every single Palestinian in that video say that they don't want peace *other than* a peace where Israel disappears? How can the problem be the US "blocking any sort of settlement" when the street does not want ANY settlement?
@@michaelpersiyanov6131 I mean the difference is that israili arabs dont want israel gone. say what you want about israel being evil but dont expect then to act against their own self interests. people are selfish.
@@clemroberts1421 Its probably because they see that the other party has no intention of peace. It is hard for them to believe or imagine that kind of scenario that when radical israeli settlements are still happening till date. It is also reflected in the parties they elect and the kind of policies they employ - i.e escalating things that were previously calmed by years of negotiations. They managed to provoke organizations this time that have been on ceasefire for over 10 years.
"Put both sides in a volcano" lol
So sad. And people wonder why there’s constant conflict in the Middle East.
People need to take a more solution orientated approach. I think most outsiders would be shocked with the responses and start to understand the challenges on the ground.
Palestinian Arabs are an integral part of the Sunni Arab majority that dominates the region (Appropriation of the title Palestinian as a national marker is very recent, an initiative that was started on July 1964).
The conflict is between the region's majority that can not even fathom the existence of an independent state of a minority be it Assyrian, Druze, Maronite or most unacceptable of all, an independent state of Jews, which are the single minority in the region that managed to achieve independence
the thief can't be the owner
This Gandhi looks chill af
Looks like their schools are about as good as ours at filling students full of crap
@@DB-pp7kj when was the last time your leaders shot rockets out of said school and other civilian areas and used children as human shields?
@@StyleHard If the Israeli's leave, they won't have these problems. Israel is a British creation and has repeatedly stolen land from the Palestinians.
@@harrietharlow9929 Is Israel occupying Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, Libya. If Israel leaves, they'll be fighting each other. Look what happened when Israel left Gaza.
@@harrietharlow9929 Israel isn't a British creation, the British controlled that area and proposed a split between the Jews and the local Arabs, which the Arabs rejected, and then declared war on Israel (which at the time was pretty much just the Jews in the are). Also, if Israel leaves Gaza, Hamas will have access to much stronger weapons, and they have stated multiple times they want to destroy Israel. As for the West Bank, there is no guarantee, and there is a lot to sort out. Also, they didn't steal land from Palestinians, neighbouring Arabs declared war on Israel in 1967/73, and as a way to stop them, Israel expanded, they gave back most of the territory acquired, however, Jordan wouldn't accept the West Bank (since it was part of Jordan) and Egypt wouldn't accept Gaza (which was under Egyptian military occupation).
Plus, what we call Palestinians today were only starting to be referred to as such around 1964, due to Arafat, before Israelis were considered Palestinians and the Arabs in the West Bank/Gaza were considered to be part of whatever country they were part of (Egypt/Jordan).
A brief history of the region:
The Jews arrived in Israel (from Egypt) circa 1200 BC.
The original Palestinians arrives in the region circa 1100 BC. They were Greeks from Macedonia, a part of the Sea People in.vasion of Egypt and the Levant. They were called the Peleset (Pelestinians), or the PhiIistines in the Bible.
The Jews were kicked out of the region, after the Great Jewish RevoIt in AD 70 and the Bar Kochba uprising in AD 130.
Much later the Arab MusIims arrived, in the 8th century AD, and they caused the greatest gen.ocide in history. Even today, there are the 800 abandoned cities in Syria, which were depopulated by the MusIims. Look up the D.ead Cities of Aleppo. So the Arab MusIims exter.minated the Greek Palestinians, and stoIe their lands and stoIe their name too.
So the modern Arab Palestinians are the last to arrive in this region, with the least claim to the land. And they des.troyed the economy of the region, which had formerly been the richest region in the Roman Empire.
Ralph.
As a European I think there is a lesson for us here. If we continue to allow people from the middle east to come here we will be storing up future trouble for ourselves when these people don't integrate.
You do realize that there wouldn't be so many refugees coming to Europe if Europe wasn't funding a war to remove them from their homeland right? Like you are somehow able to connect some dots aren't you?
Yes, but a lot of dumb people here support terrorists
I think the lesson you should learn is not to invade and colonise other people's lands.
@@divxxx Yeah? Well I didn't. would you like to remake your point?
@@divxxx each succesfull nation did it
The Romans called [referred to] the land of Israel as: "Palestine." Josephus calls the area of "Judea, Galilee, Samaria, the Decapolis, Phoenicia & Perea" as: "Palestine" (The Antiquities of the Jews Ch. 6). The Doctrine of Addai also mentions "Palestine." (Addai 1: 7 [17]). There, "Palestine" probably represents the same area minus "Phoenicia."
The Bible mentions the city/territory: "PELESHEṬ” as early as (Ex. 15:14); on the southern coast of the GREAT (Mediterranean) Sea. PELESHEṬ is also variously transliterated as: “Pelesheth (Philistia, Palestina).” Its inhabitants are: “Pelishtites” - AKA: “Philistine[s]" (KJV). Even earlier, we read that the “Philistines” were the descendants of "Miẓrayim [Egypt]” (Gen. 10:13-14). So they must of migrated to Cenaan (Canaan). Ḥam and his DESCENDANTS (Cush, Miẓrayim, Put & Cenaan) were given land in the SOUTH [Africa] (Jub. 7:13 [16]). However, Cenaan rebelled, stole land & dwelt in a part of Shem’s MIDDLE area & called that land Cenaan (Jub. 10:30, 34 [45, 48]). The Philistines went there also, outside of their territory [Divine Allotment] which Noaḥ uttered. Thus Cenaan's dwelling (living) in or seizure of the land wasn't by Shem's permission. At the time, Shem's descendants and Madai [Yepheṭ’s descendant] were busy building the cities and nations of India, Bela, Leḅanon, Ashshur (Assyria), Elam, Baḅel, Shushan, Madai, Ararat, etc. (Jub. 8:21 [32-35]). Cenaan broke the oath he swore before the Holy Judge and Noaḥ; and hence fell under the curse (Jub. 10:32 [47]). Knowing the bigger picture sure does justify the Israelites destroying the Cenaanites out of their territory.
The “Philistines (Palestinians)” weren’t supposed to be in Israel to begin with. It isn’t their land & they aren’t being occupied. The nation of Israel was established again in 1948 as a legal country. Thus the Palestinians aren’t being occupied. They are occupying Israel. Israel also won the war & later gave up some territory to them in hope for peace. We see that decision didn’t work so well, so a two State solution won’t work either. The “Philistines” want all of the land of Israel. So a two State solution will just make them stronger to fulfill that goal. There needs to be One Nation of Israel with Gaza & the West Bank annexed where everyone has the same rights.
Gazans invaded the Country Israel & committed genocide or slaughter. Israel has the right to defend itself. The war was justified. Israel was also attacked by Iran [the supplier of weapons], Hezbollah & Yemen. Palestinians have no legal, moral or Divine right to resist.
Do they also think Turkey should give Anatolia back to the Greeks and Armenians?
This is my favorite point to bring up and Everytime without exception they play dumb and act like they have never heard of that before lol
I’d love that.
But that’s a question to Israelis, I believe.
Jews say that they lived in these lands, 2.000 years ago.
Palestinians say, that it was along time ago.
There is no fair solution unfortunately.
I can relate to Jews, because I as a Pontian Greek, I see the land of my ancestors, under Turkish rule. But on the other hand, people that live there now, are not responsible for that. Dead end.
@@pogolas So if someone were to push out the Turks now, and that lasts for a few generations, is it legitimized in for example 100 years? Or does it take 500 years? Or 1000 years?
100 years isn't that long, and that would make changing the geopolitical landscape rather easy. China would only have to hold on to Tibet for a few decades more.
If we say 1000 years, then that opens a whole other can of worms.
I agree it is no easy topic, but we see the post WW2 borders being contested more and more. Crimea and Donbas come to mind. Turkey and Kurdistan. China and Taiwan, or China and Vladivostok.
@@leonardodavinci1140 I have no answer.
I love nations and that’s why I always loved history. Every time a nation is disappeared, it is a lost for me. Every time, a nation loses its land, it is sad.
So, It is sad (for me) that I can’t live in Giresun, Trabzon or Ordu (my ancestors lived there). But what can be done realistically and without harming other people? Nothing. So I have to accept it.
In the end, there are more important things in life.
I do
As a jewish and Israeli, i understand the palestinians pain, we both lives in this area in history you can't deny it, i know a lot of you not gonna like but we both own the land and we need to share it, we need to make peace and make a big country that contains both israeli and palestinian lands, but it won't work, for every idea there are people who resist and trying to stop it, both on palestinian side and israeli side.
I wish we could all live together in this beautiful land, we are all humans!
It’s especially hard when no one tries. Obviously establishing a country like that would be hard, but only because we make it hard. But the moment we begin thinking like you, it becomes much easier and more attainable
GOD owns the land and the earth and even you!
@@SarumChoirmaster yes your 100%right. Both Istael and Palestines claim but no substancal evedence documents that the land is there land.
Amen to that.. I wish both groups could find peace and a common ground to solve this problem.
@@CloseCall-fp7opIt belongs to the Romans and the English. lol
That what happens when parents destroy kids mind with false history.
Someone needs to tell them that the "Palestine of 1948" was Jewish and under British Rule. There's even a newspaper of 1948 saying "Arabs invade Palestine".
@@meerpirat508 Both nations invaded Palestine///
@@asafkomemy Palestine is renamed Judea. The land of the Jews. Different people invaded the land but the Jews remain as the original owners.
Thanks for asking these questions. The ignorance of those that call the Israelis fascist etc. is breath-taking.
Well, these interviews support my view of Israel being a fascist country, of course Israeli people are not fascists, but the government is without any doubt, and we don't even need interviews to judge that because it is obvious for many reasons. These answers might sound like a really stupid stubborn "this is my land" attitude, but considering the amount of violence these people have to bear since many decades, I am not surprised at all.
They have completely unrealistic goals. It’s shocking. And sad.
Israel is a fasict state look up the definition Einstein
Nah it's pretty fascist...
@@meganmcmullan1472 Hamas = fascist? Agreed. Israelis = fascist? Google Haj Amin al-Husseini who fomented a lot of the rage for the impending state of Israel back in the 40's. Hamas and the majority of Gaza have the same attitude today. If you couldn't be bothered, al-Husseini spent a lotta time with the actual OG fascists back in WWII.
2:03 "I would make Israelis go back to their country"
Palestinian leaders, and their supporters, have done a great job in firming up Israel as the Jews own country.
3:15 "Jews are just people following their religion"
Makes one suspect that she doesn't have the slightest clue about the Jewish religion and its connection to Eretz Yisrael.
Mark Simons where was every Israeli prime minister until Yitzhak Rabin born?
Israel has made Israel look like Jewish only country by declaring it a Jewish state. You don't get more obvious than that.
منتصب القامة أمشي If an Arab is born in Germany, is he still an Arab? Of course he is. Jews are still ethnically and historically connected to Israel, not Europe. Living in an exile doesn't change that. Begin and Gurion were born in Europe because our ancestors were driven out by the Roman's
@@ForeverRepublic OK I born in Lebanon and i don't carry Lebanese nationality but my grandfather born in "tsipori , Palestine" am i still Palestinian ?!? ......... of course yes ....then i have the right to go back to my home , it is the same case as Israelis ........................but guess what ......i am forbidden to enter Israel ........ why ??????
Mahmoud AbdelHadi
because the return law is only for Hews, yet they say they treat Muslim Arabs and Christians same as Jews!!!
Hell NO!
I get the feeling everyone in this interview either believes what they are saying, or fears that Hamas will cut their throat if they say anything but the party line.
Hamas doesn't rule there it's not Gaza, the PLO rules there, they belive what they are saying
@@noam4832 Hamas doesn't rule Gaza?
@@30RonJon as I said, it's not in gaza...
Where is it Mexico? Of course its Gaza
@@30RonJon very smart comment. No, this is not in mexico, neither in the Gaza strip, it's in the west bank
The only who was concerned with bettering the country was that last one…what a shame.
For a "refugee camp" it looks better than most parts of the world!
As a Palestinian-American, I think the last woman put forth some of the truest needs of the Palestinians, especially Gazans. I respect her a lot.
Well she’s a mother so she deals with practicalities and common sense.
Unfortunately probably most Palestinians don't have her wisdom. They're too angry to think clearly.
Her solution will be best, if people are living a good life they won’t give a fuck about the conflict
Her solutions seemed like the only down to Earth reforms of the video, in marked contrast to most of the earlier interviewees. May be ridiculously too American-centric for me to say but I can't help but feel that if everyone over there woke up 1 day to find that the ONLY ones in power among both people were the Palestinian-Americans & Israeli-Americans then there would be peace, dignity and justice for both peoples by the end of the week.
@@scottwarthin1528 You have to remember this though, we as Americans are more detached from the violence that Israeli’s and Palestinians see. We have a more objective view of things, while over there, because of their experiences, they can’t put that aside because it affected them too harshly. Like for example, we can read about a school shooting, understand what happens and feel sad, but for the people who actually went through it, it’s like hell to them.
They don’t want peace as you can see.
Israel doesn't want either. No one is on the "good side"
@@Kegyetleneper Really?? Israel is the only place in the Middle East that have democracy and is defending themselves from terrorists that are using those people to kill israelis and other people in the whole world. This is our country and no one will change that. In Israel they have everything and they have a large place for them too. We took 29.000 Israelis from “Gush katif” to let those lands to Palestine’s. What they did?? They turn in to a terrorists and are sending bombs from Gaza to us because they don’t want us to exists. They have a big hate in those hearts for free. Anyone of the Arabian countries want them. Only Israel gave them support and they are doing that to us for years!!! So We have no choice and we need to fight back.
@@jessykriok6547 democracy is not to mean well-being, just think about South Africa before 1990s.
Jessy cohen The terrorists whose creation was triggered by your occupation. You are a fool if you think you are on the good side.
@@juliannasreddin5226 And you are fool if you think that you know something about to live in Israel! There are amount of Muslims that live here without any problem and also are being part of our army. So don’t think that you know something because what you know is based on the media that you have in your country or you just don’t like us. And If is the cause so I will not answer you and waist my time. LIVE ISRAEL!!🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Nothing lasts forever, not even this conflict. It will end one day.
lucky to be born in Canada and know what multi ethnic peace really is.
In Israel there are plenty of arabs living among us, I myself have plenty of arab friends from uni
when they say give back the land to the original owners do they mean give it back to Jordan or the Ottoman Empire?
I think they mean the Canaanites.
@@marksimons8861
but the cannits converted to being Hebrew according to archeological excavations in Israel and in the west bank, the Hebrews that came annexed them, like usually happened in wars in the past.
@@somegirl4631 My understanding is that the Late Bronze Age collapse ended all the Canaanite city states, approximately 1187 BCE.
As elsewhere in the Eastern Mediterranean, those who survived fled to the hills, in this case the hills of Judea and Samaria.
Egypt survived, but only just. IMHO this is how the early Hebrews escaped from the traditional hegemony of Egypt in Canaanite territory for some time. It also accounts for the period of Judges which lasted until an old order was reestablished with a Hebrew kingdom.
While it's not quite the same as the Biblical narrative it is more like another interpretation of the same events.
@Archeodoku Well it took a long time for Canaanites to move from being Hebrews and Israelites into becoming Jews. A few hundred years. Essentially with the emergence of a distinct religion associated exclusively with Judea.
@@marksimons8861
actually Hebrews originated from a real city called Ur CASHDIM that is mentioned in both bible and history.
DELUSIONAL. NOT A BIT OF PRAGMATICISM. PITY.
And these are our "peace" partners...🤷♂️
Their definition of peace is very different than yours.
We see clearly here who really does not want a two state solution.
That lady who said "If I were in charge of Palestine I'd get everyone a job..." what Corey didn't realise is that hers is the best answer to the solution to the conflict. Make Palestinian lives better. A part of the anger that they feel is the despair of their living situation.
I'm with you on this. The only ones who have an interest in the conflict are the governments / authorities. I think that the conflict will solve itself once people's lives are getting better.
No ,this is the common misconception that most of the western world had about terrorism , that if you somehow provide enough job /education etc there won't be any conflicts or terrorism ,but the fact is that if you empower a terrorist with education -job he/she will use that to facilitate more such activities. (Bin laden was a civil engineer Al Zawahiri was a doctor) Without changing the education system or their religious upbringing there won't be any significant change in the current situation.
@@kunjukunjunil1481 100%. Most leaders and many people who join violent jihadi movements come from well to do families. Even a billionaire tech mogul who has been brainwashed with Islam will want to become a jihadi.
it's not about their living standards, these are better than all of Africa and most of Asia and Latin America.
It is about the regions majority against minorities.
A majority that is told tales of a grandeur era of glorious conquests of the whole middle east, subjugating all, being superior, defeating everyone else by a superior culture, blessed with the blessings of Allah, with a final message, that came to replace Judaism and Christianity with a final correct truth.
Re-instating a state of Jews in Jewdea shatters this self perception by demonstrating a reversal of the "correct" order of things.
@@cecil123 are Qatar, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia jihadi nations?
Biden - we support a 2 state solution. Statehood for Palestine.
Israel - we supoort a 2 state solution. Statehood for Palestine.
Palestine - No, No, No.
aboslutly crazy... . I can't believe that the palestinians still don't want a peace ..... they should have accepted the partition plan of 1947 and they could have had their country. But after all wars they still don't want peace!
@@s.b.7598 Arabs are very persistent people
It is a majority vs minorities conflict.
Hmm, if you give all West Bank and Gaza to Palestine it's only solution of conflict
Except the conflict started in 1948 and involved all of Israel's neighbors.
The guy who said to put both sides in a volcano was the only one with the correct answer
They do not think like we do.
Nor are their values our values.
This is so sad & scary at the same time!
@Falafelpump rosh your the who are leaving in fear
@@abdinooradan5270 how?
when someone crush you're eyes you see now is it unforget
The summary of the video is "Most Palestinians don't want to make the sacrifices necessary for peace, so they want perpetual war & Palestinian & Jewish Exceptionalism. Israelis just want to be left alone, except for the minority of extremists/Exceptionalists that want more land & also believe it is rightly theirs.
I say "Exceptionalism" because almost all societies on earth have been conquered and people moved on. That includes Muslim conquest of Christian Lands (even something as huge as Constantinople), Muslim lands, other cultures etc. Yet they believe they have suffered some unique injustice, which they have not - it was pretty normal in the past, they have just been taught to value "going back to the past" above absolutely everything else.
@@pebblepod30 seriously all your comments I’ve seen speak facts
I am growing more and more sympathetic to that security fence the Israelis have built. No wonder it looks like a huge slab of concrete in the populated areas, or that it sits on the other side of the "green line".
Less sympathetic. I wasn't persuaded that it would stop suicide bombers, but it seems to have worked.
The yearning for martyrdom has been replaced this year by young people hurling themselves at the Gaza fence. Thankfully the attempts were foiled by prompt Israeli action......until they started sending incendiary kites over the wall.
I suppose I was also persuaded by the idea of two states for two people until I realised that Palestinians are seeking two states for one people (them), and no state for the Jews.
The international community cannot really progress on a two state solution on this basis so consequently won't put pressure on Israel, much to the chagrin (and surprise) of the Arabs.
If there is to be ongoing conflict, from and Israeli point of view it is wiser to ensure that the violence take place in "Palestinian territories" than their own.
true
A few bus blasts and some knifing of non muslims in the name of allah and you might be even more sympathetic. Israelis have been through hundreds of those.
+Anton
Don't forget Chechenya, or the Holdomor, or even the natives of Siberia.
The secular israelis want to give palestinian people a state. I used to think they were the most the reasonable and should be in charge. But I think the majority of palestinians don't want peace and want all of israel as palestine. No matter what the international community wants for the palestinian people, what matters more is what the palestinian people want for themselves. The reason they never accepted a 2 state solution is because the majority don't want one or would use it as a springboard for the rest of israel. In this case, whatever netanyahu is doing is probably the right choice in terms of the palestinian people.
You able to get honest opinions, thanks for that!
I like the last person's answer.. job opportunities, improve infrastructure. thats the way to move froward
Can someone TAG Hamas to this comment !
@@714john
Can someone tag israeli nazi army in comment
Illegal forceful sattelement killed innocent Palestinian and jail
Zionist want a state but now they occupied whole pallestine and infact plo leave arm strugglle and demand Palestine state after 67
@@jethamillionviews560 I find it hilarious how out of touch you are that you think this is all Israel's fault when literally the first guy said that peaceful coexistence is impossible b/c the Palestinian people wouldn't accept it and only solution is for the Palestinians is to take over the whole thing
she is foolish, israel would never empower the palestinian because you can not occupy an empowered society, you have to keep them weak
@@devingiannini2077
Palestinian gov already recognize
But israel land hunger and nazi ideology
They want occupied whole pallestine illegal settlement killing innocent Palestinian
So much hate they have for us it's crazy
Really ? I wonder why..
@@HITBnn Because they teach their kids hate since age 0.
@@rashaahmed3208 because they believe in a delusion
Gee I wonder why Einstein WAKE UP
Its in their book
“You can’t shake hands with a clenched fist”- Golda Meir
This is crazy. Educational reforms are needed badly there.
That last woman was *based*
All these issues are solved by development
Why haven't they developed? That's the problem
@@Yodumeee Good question! Glad you asked.
Well, usually a lack of development comes from corrupt political systems and a lack of resource distribution.
Europe didn't develop until they had the combined resource surplus of the Enclosures Act, the printing press, the Columbian Trade and colonialism *and* the black death (which tripled not just the amount of resources per person, but also each of the other factors).
Only then did we get the nationalist revolution, the enlightenment, the industrial revolution, the Protestant reformation, public education and eventually the civil rights movement.
It's been shown time and time again throughout history and across the globe that development also v reduces rates of crime, racism, bigotry, war, religiosity, sexism, strict social norms etc
Also worth noting is that wherever development happened it was *always* opposed to by most people, especially the older generations, the ethnic majority, and those in power
So we need to find a way to increase the resource availability and reduce this kind of opposition mindset as well as government corruption within the PA and externally from Israel and Hamas.
Based on what?
@@EuroGuy85 Based
Just an internet term referring to someone with an opinion that sees through the nonsense that makes up common discourse
When there’s no solution war seems unavoidable. It’s just Israel doesn’t tend to lose.
Israel and the Jews do seem to lose, on their own. It's when they are backed by other forces, like the USA they don't tend to lose.
@@helligevaar oh well.
If I were Palestinian, I would want Israeli citizenship. Israel is not perfect, but it is a democracy. These videos show that even Palestinians with Israeli citizenship would like a democratic Palestinian state, an Israel-style state, which will never happen if Palestine becomes a state
@@helligevaar I think Israel fought the first war without aid and won.
@@gustavodutra2817 Yup. Arab Israelis were asked whether they would prefer to remain Israeli or be annexed into a future Palestinian state, and 85% said they would wish to remain Israeli. Israel is far from perfect, but what country isn't? That said, I would prefer Israeli democracy any day over the autocracies that largely surround it.
"all of it" "it's ours" something tells me he's not going to get any of it, even if his solution happens
the thief can't be the owner
I want the best for the Palestinian people but this is so painful to watch! They have zero interest in any serious plans for peace. “We like Jews but they should not have a country here.” Do they even know what the name Jerusalem means? It was named after & for Jews Do they not even read their Koran which three times I am told mentions
Isreal as the home for the Jews. It is a shame for Isreal that they have to deal with this Palestinian mind set. It is devastating for the Palestinians
who will suffer indefinitely but obviously they don’t really care. The only true winner of this conflict are the Palestinian leadership & other Arab dictators who will have their permanent excuse to blame Isreal & do the only thing dictators anywhere in the world no how to do......steal there own people blind!
King of Mesopotamia
Umm, I think they have done a fantastic job destroying themselves.
@Mike Stein
You stated "Do they even know what the name Jerusalem means? It was named after & for Jews"
You might want to brush up on your historical knowledge. The name predates the Israelites.
C caymer
It doesn’t even matter anymore. Arabs countries are making Peace with Isreal. Isreal has the eternal backing of Christians, Jews & Hindus and Europe will not even care anymore about the Palestinians delusional position in a few years they will be to busy fighting a civil war against Muslim invaders.
+Mike Stein
"Koran mentions Isreal [sic] as the home for the Jews"
That is because Mohammed did not want Jews in Arabia!
Mark Simons
Ok. My point is this and I hope people with power in Isreal watch this show. Actually I hope people with power watch this show around the world. When Israelis say the land was promised to us in the Bible people don’t care much. However when when you can show that even the Koran, the
Holy book of the Muslims is showing that Isreal is for the Jews than the debate is over!
Where is there Common Sense...?
Just imagine the 15 million german refugees from Schlesien,Sudetenland,east preußen,pommern etc. would still claim that this is there land. There would have never been peace and good economical relationships in europe.
Arabs have 22 countries but there is just 1 israel.
Greetz from Germany
all jews all over the world have right of return to israel cuz they were alleged expelled by romans 2000 yrs ago but palestinians who were explelled by zionists from what is now israel can not return to their homeland? what hypocrisy!
@@smittenbesotted9918first, I don't read zionist propoganda. second, Deal with it that israel is illegitimate, colonial entity built on a land stolen from other people. I mean from med sea to jordan river is called palestine & one day the right of palestinians to their homeland will overcome the might of zionists to colonize palestine
@@hassanmohamudali3065 Almost all Islamic countries are built on other people's lands, and many Islamic countries persecute minorities and dont even allow religious freedom.
@@tubester4567 Islam is not settler colonialism which replaces the native people with settlers. All arabs outside of Arabian peninsula were not arabs before islamic conquests they arabized thus you must know that palestinians are not arabs from Arabia but Arabized canaanites & hebrews who lived there more than 7 millenias. people are same but language, religion & culture changes
@Starhopper they were expelled when the haganah and irgun went on a campaign of mass rape, genocide and explosion in 1947. Burnt down every Palestinian village. Destroyed every home, except nice ones which they killed or exiled the family then gave that home to a Jewish family instead. You need to learn real history. Your idea that 750,000 people willingly left their homes is delusional.
There you go. The reason why this conflict has no solution == Education on the Palestinian side, teaches "We cannot coexist", where in Israel, it teaches western values, such as "accepting the different", LGBTQ rights, Equality of opportunity, etc....
They're both living in different worlds. Forgive my rudeness but comparing the morality of a person that lives in very shit conditions and a person who lives in a prosperous nation is the stupidest thing to do. Nature vs Nurture, There are probably some Palestinians that are downright unhinged, I.E Hamas, but i bet there are actually a lot more who would want peace for all. The conditions beset on them does not nurture such peaceful ideology unfortunately.
I'm living in a very peaceful region and i can 100% say aggressive Palestinians are very having stupid ideology and its very condemnable but I'm in a ridiculously privileged position to think that. They unfortunately aren't
I understand where you are coming from, but what about the arab countries that are "free" just like saudi arabia? They think the same as them@@muhammadsuhairi7510
@@nivarad8497 are you talking about anti-semetism? As I am aware of it, the rise of anti-semetism in the middle east is because of outside European powers carving a piece of land, promised by the very same Europeans to arabs, and gifting to what seems to be Europeans according to the Arabs.
The Damascus affair(an accusation of Jews by Christian Europeans) started alot of targeted attacks on Jews from 1840. Nevertheless blood libel rumours spread across north Africa and the Middle East and Jews were targeted.
The first pogrom happened in 1930s and 1940s, a good 15-20 years since the Balfour declaration. By then, this was the height of the Arab Nationalist conflict with the Zionist "European" Jews and anti-semetism was ever increasing.
Apart from the Damascus affair that imported EUROPEAN Anti-semetic believes, pre 1917, the middle east was a decent place for jews to live. Considering Europe's anti-semetic tendencies happened from the times of the Romans or as early as 1090s if you don't count Roman's as Europeans.
You'd be protected as the state's obligation under sharia, pay jizya, which is at a lower % than the zakat(Muslim tax) and you don't have to serve in the military. By law you're not supposed to be killed(we already knew this was bullshit because alot of "state sponsored" killings happened), freedom of religion and state protects your property(again we already know what happened)
Currently, are they following this? Probably not, everyone has to be a democracy so why bother living in Sharia? Is it good that jews are being targeted who have no relation to Israel? Hell no. I feel the same way although I'm not killed, I'm not deem as trust worthy by my state as there are other malay states nearby so when I serve in my own mandatory military service, Im post to menial jobs and can't enter some parts of the base due to my race.
Can you imagine the outrage if an American said that all Arabs should go back to the Middle East? This is so weird.
Notice, dear viewer, how "oppressed" they appear on the streets of Nablus, etc; the sports cars, the clean clothes, the latest fashions, the total lack of nervousness about speaking their real feelings about Israelis. If this is apartheid, it looks pretty good!
U said it all man.
That’s the kind of rhetoric used to describe plantations in the American south.
idk what exactly you mean but this was years ago
Good point.
@@bm4114 NOPE. There's no forced labor, Palestinians are free to come and go as they please, able to do business in Israel, and they indiscriminately fire thousands of rockets into civilian areas of Israel. They are free to speak their mind (clearly illustrated in this video) and own businesses. Pretty much the opposite of slavery.
"Put both sides in a volcano"... he gets it!
That makes no sense
@@f-jericho4021 What part doesn't make sense? The volcano or he gets it?
@@mr.woowoo8826 putting both sides in a volcano
@@f-jericho4021 I think he meant to solve the problem that both sides should be destroyed.
It makes sense. Because he is palestinian. But he somewhat understand his side is no angel either.
The " put both sides into a volcano guy " wow . He new this shit was going to happen .
Those are the supposed "peace partners"
It seems that they do not want to find a solution, so they want to live for the next 1000 years in the same situation! It is simple sad
It better to live with dignity . You only live 60-90 years
if someone came to ur house and forced u out or locked u in one room of the house and took the rest for himself, would u want peace and solution with them or negotiate with them ?
@@zeyadib1211 When the only other option is living in the basement where the other guy controls the water and and electricity then yes I'd negotiate. You act like Palestine is the state in the world that has lost territory due to military conquest.
@@TWE_2000 not everyone is like u, some people prefer to die defending their homes rather than negotiating u don't negotiate with a thief or a murderer. it's really weird what ur saying instead of blaming the one who steals land and oppresses people ur blaming the people for resisting and not accepting it that's losing mentality
@@zeyadib1211 Again you act as if Palestine is the only state to have lost territory before. Yes I expect the Palestinians to accept their loss and negotiate, just as was done by the Polish, the Germans, the Mexicans, the Japanese, the Turks, the Serbians, the Spanish, etc. Either accept defeat or live eternally under occupation. Israel isn't going anywhere, so either the Palestinians can accept that and have peace, or they can't accept it and luve under occupation and blockade. It's that simple
One of the most important videos in this project
“Put both sides in the Volcano” 😂
So I watched this and the video where you ask the Israelis the same question . I got to say the Israelis sound rational and the Palestinians sound totally unrealistic.. I know they have been done wrong in many ways but it just not as simple as "this is our land" Wanting everything will get them nothing
Do you want peace? Answers A. and B.
"Yes, we should all get a chance to live here."
or
"Yes, the other side should go back to [insert country/continent here]."
Start with having same definition of peace.
FYI in some cultures peace is what one's tribe attains by eliminating rival tribes.
Nothing is unrealistic here,,,they have been abused for too long
Israeli sounds rational? Maybe because they had 6% and then UN gave them 50% before they stole the whole land? Sounds like palestinian are honest in their answers while Israeli who say they want peace are delusional to think building settlement in occupied lands are a sign of peaceful intent
@@fardosahassan9658yeah I wonder why
"Put both sides into volcano"
*likes video*
Suggestion (maybe you have already asked this question): What do you think WILL happen to the conflict? Realistically, how WILL this end? (Maybe in 10 or 100 years).
Arabs will try to destroy the jews and they will lose.
The ignorance and narrow-mindness in the beginning of this video is equally baffling as scary.
They'll end up paying the price for it, without even knowing they are to fully blame themselves.
*---* *THE FACTS ABOUT THE PALESTINIANS* *---*
There has never been such a country called Palestine. Israel was re-formed on land previously ruled by the Ottoman empire, similarly to other countries in the region such as Lebanon, Iraq and others. There is no such thing as "Palestinian people". It's worth noting that newspapers such as the 'Palestine post' were Jewish newspapers (this one for example turned into the 'Jerusalem post'). This is also true about other official "Palestine" related stuff from the time before Israel was re-formed. Hebrews were the majority in Jerusalem even before the birth of the Zionist movement in the 19th century. If someone happened to use the term "Palestine" before the re-formation of Israel, he was referring to the homeland of the Jevvs (the land of Israel) - not the Arabs. It's worth noting that the flag of the "Palestinian Authority" is the flag of Hejaz.
The British Mandate over the land, after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, actually included also what is now Jordan (which includes the "east bank" - part of historic Israel), and according to the League of Nations (precursor of the UN), this Mandate was to become a national homeland for the Jevvs (the Arabs would get their own independent lands in all the rest of the greater middle-east, an area which makes the land of Israel insignificant in comparison). Note that according to the UN's constitution, all the past resolutions of the League of Nation are valid.
The British Authorities, due to their own interests with the Arabs (among others - future oil dealings), gave them 77% of the land - which later became what is now Jordan. There are over 20 Arab countries, and almost 60 lsIamic countries - each on average way bigger than Israel, but the Arabs couldn't tolerate the existence of tiny Israel, even after being given most of the land of the mandate. Instead, they tried to annihilate it by force with the Arab armies the moment it was officially independent (and have attempted to do so several times again since then).
The coIoniaI term "Palestine" was discarded after it was brought to life under the British rule, as it should have been, because the original name for the land - Israel, has been restored (Israel is not Palestine, just like Jerusalem is not Aelia-Capitolina, and Schehem is not Nablus).
It is only in the mid 1960's that the Arabs hijacked the term, and its widespread usage only took off after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. the Arabs used this terminology as a political propaganda tool to de-legitimize Israel, after they failed to steal the Hebrew homeland by force with the Arab armies, by invading and attempting to conquer the land. Ironically, the term "Palestinian" originate from the term 'Pleshet' to describe INVADERS by the Hebrews. Those who willingly identify as "Palestinians" are declaring themselves to be invaders/colonizers in Hebrew land.
It's important to note that this propaganda tool was supported by the Communists/Soviets. On the other hand, just a few decades before that, the Arab "Palestinians" were hand in hand with the Nazis. They have aided them under the leadership of the mufti Amin Al-Husseini - who is often regarded as the 'founding father' of the Arab "Palestinians". During WW2 he became an SS general, but he had anti-Jewish genocidal ideology long before the Nazis rose the power. He has incited and caused violence and terror against the Jewish people in their homeland since the early 1920's (for example: 1929 Hebron massacre).
"Palestinians" are nothing more than bands of foreign invaders, squatters and illegal immigrants from all over the Islamic world - mostly the Arab world (some of them even originating from places that are not part of the middle-east, such as Bosnia), as well as several other places. The overwhelming majority of them first settled in the land of Israel in recent centuries - mostly in the 19th and 20th centuries. Some of them even came to Gaza, Judea and Samaria from Egypt and Jordan while these areas were under Egyptian and Jordanian occupation in the period between 1948 to 1967.
Informative quotes from Arab "Palestinian" leaders:
"There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' was invented by the Zionists. There is no Palestine in the bible ...Palestine is ALIEN to us" - Arab "Palestinian" leader Awni Abdul Hadi, Peel Commission, 1937.
"The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity... Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa, while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan." - Arab "Palestinian" leader & PLO member Zuheir Mohsen, 1977.
"I don’t think there is 'Palestinian People', I don’t think there is a 'Palestinian Nation' at all… 'Palestinian Nation'? I think that is a colonial invention. When were there ever 'Palestinians'?" - Arab "Palestinian" leader Azme Bishara, TV Interview.
"We all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian in Gaza and throughout Palestine can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, Yemen or anywhere else." "... Half the Palestinians are (Arab) Egyptians and the other half are (Arab) Saudis" - Arab "Palestinian" Hamas minister Fathi Hammad, 2012.
Here are some common "Palestinian" families and their place of origin:
Saudi, Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi Arabia
Yamani, Azad - Yemen
Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids)
Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt
Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt (Bedouins)
Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey
Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq
Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria
Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon
Bushnak - Bosnia
Khamis - Bahrain
Afghani - Afghanistan
Mughrabi - Maghreb
Araj - Morocco
Djazair - Algeria
Kurd - Kurdistan
Hindi - Indian Subcontinent
Abid - Sudan
Yasser Arafat, the most famous "Palestinian" and leader of the PLO terrorist organization, was not native to Judea. He called himself a "Palestinian refugee" but spoke Arabic with an Egyptian accent. He was born in 1929 Cairo, Egypt. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956! His full name was Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat Al-Qudwa Al-Husseini.
Yasser Arafat also proudly stated in his authorized biography that: "If there is any such thing as a Palestinian people, it is I, Yasser Arafat, who created them."
Genetic data for "Palestinians":
According to a 2010 study by Behar et al. Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudi Arabians which was described as "consistent with a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula".
A study found that the Palestinians, have what appears to be Female-Mediated gene flow in the form of Maternal DNA Haplogroups from Sub-Saharan Africa. Palestinian individuals tested, carried maternal haplogroups that originated in Sub-Saharan Africa. The explanation for the presence of predominantly female lineages of African origin in these areas is that they trace back to women brought from Africa as part of the Arab slave trade, assimilated into the areas under Arab rule.
In a genetic study of Y-chromosomal STRs in two populations from Israel and the Palestinian Authority Area: Christian and Muslim Palestinians showed genetic differences.
A 2013 study of Haber and et al. found that "The predominantly Muslim populations of Syrians, Palestinians and Jordanians cluster on branches with other Muslim populations as distant as Morocco and Yemen."
The authors explained that "religious affiliation had a strong impact on the genomes of the Levantines. In particular, conversion of the region's populations to Islam appears to have introduced major rearrangements in populations' relations through admixture with culturally similar but geographically remote populations leading to genetic similarities between remarkably distant populations."
Even the Quran:
And thereafter We (Allah) said to the Children of Israel: "Dwell securely in the Promised Land. And when the last warning will come to pass, we will gather you together in a mingled crowd" [17 : 104]
O my people (Jevvs)! Enter the Holy Land, which God has assigned unto you [5 : 21]
We (Allah) settled the Israelites in a blessed land and provided them with good things [10 : 93]
It was our (Allah's) will to favor those who were oppressed (Jevvs) and to make them leaders of man, to bestow on them a noble heritage and to give them power in the land (of Israel) [28 : 5-6]
We (Allah) gave the persecuted people (Jevvs) dominion over the eastern and western lands which We had blessed (the east and west banks of the Jordan River). Thus your Lord's gracious word was fulfilled for the Israelites, because they had endured with fortitude [7 : 137]
Watch:
ua-cam.com/video/IJggz2HIkS4/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/SN838zu6iio/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/u8ELap2uhkA/v-deo.html
AI-Aqsa
Today, Jerusalem's holiness to Sunni MusIims as the third most holy city, is based on a late and political interpretation of a Quranic verse. To Shi'ite MusIims, the third holiest city, ranked below Mecca and Medina, is the city of Najaf in southern Iraq.
Early lsIamic sources state that the "Al Aqsa Mosque" (literal meaning: 'the farther mosque'), mentioned only once in the Quran, was one of two mosques located near Ji'irrana, a village located between Mecca and Taif in Hejaz. One of the mosques was called "al-Masjid al-Adna", meaning the "closer mosque" and the other "al-Masjid al-Aqsa", the "farther mosque". When the Quran refers to the Al Aqsa mosque while telling the story of Muhammad's night time journey from the "holy mosque" of Mecca to Al Aqsa, that is, the "farther mosque", it is referring to the mosque in Ji'irrana.
It's also interesting to note the following Hadith:
Narrated Abu Dhar: I said, “O Allah’s Apostle! Which mosque was first built on the surface of the earth?” He said, “Al-Masjid-al-Haram.” I said, “Which was built next?” He replied “The mosque of Al-Aqsa.” I said, “What was the period of construction between the two?” He said, “Forty years.” - Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 4, Book 55, Number 585 ; Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 4, Book 55, Number 636
Al-Aqsa Mosque can't possibly be referring to the mosque which was built in Jerusalem decades after the time of Muhammad's death.
In 682 C.E., fifty years after Mohammed's death, Abdallah Ibn al-Zubayr, the tough man of Mecca, rebelled against the Umayyads who ruled Damascus and would not allow them to fulfill the Hajj in Mecca. Since the Hajj pilgrimage is one of the five basic lsIamic commandments, they decided to choose Jerusalem as their alternative for a pilgrimage site. In order to justify choosing Jerusalem, the Umayyads rewrote the story told in the Quran, moving the Al Aqsa mosque to Jerusalem, and adding, for good measure, the myth of the night time journey of Mohammed to al Aqsa. This is the reason the Sunnis now consider Jerusalem their third holiest city.
Shia lsIam, mercilessly persecuted by the Umayya Caliphate, did not accept the holy Jerusalem canard, which is the reason the third holiest city to Shi'ites is Najif in Iraq, the burial place of Shi'ite founder Ali bin Abi Talib. Many of the Shi'ite elders - Iranian and Hezbollah - only began to call Jerusalem holy after the Khomeni rebellion in 1979 so as to keep the Sunnis from accusing them of being soft on Israel.
The first lie, in that case, is the spurious claim that the "farther mosque" is in Jerusalem.
More lies were piled on to the first one, the main prevarication being the exact location of this so-called Al Aqsa mosque, which until not very long ago, was the silver-domed building on the southern end of the Temple Mount.
The entire area of the Temple Mount is known as al-Haram al-Sharif - "the holy and noble site"- but a change came about after the Six Day War, when Jevvish voices could be heard, calling for the establishment of a synagogue on the Mount. Immediately after the war, a prominent rabbi also said that he wanted to celebrate religious events on the Temple Mount. It was felt that the MusIims would not object, since Al Aqsa was on the southern edge of the compound and the synagogue would not be nearby.
As a result, however, the MusIims decided to announce that the Al Aqsa mentioned in the Quran refers not only to the mosque on the southern end of the compound, but is the name for the entire Temple Mount area, abandoning the original name, al-Haram al-Sharif. The renaming of the Temple Mount is clearly a canard, with two documents, one known and one less known, revealing the truth.
The source that is more widely known is a booklet prepared in 1924 by none other than the openly Jevv-hating (and later on an SS general) Mufti Hajj Amin Al-Husayni and reprinted many times in the years following its first publication. The booklet's title is "A Brief Guide to al-Haram al-Sharif - Jerusalem". Note that the area is not called Al Aqsa. The Al Aqsa Mosque appears as a chapter in the booklet, after the chapter on the Dome of the Rock, the golden-domed structure in the middle of the compound. It is clear that to Hajj Amin Al-Husayni, the Mufti of Jerusalem, the Al Aqsa Mosque was simply the silver-domed building on the southern end of the compound.
The lesser known of the two documents is an ordinary Jordanian tourist map of Jerusalem that was executed in 1965, two years before the 1967 Six Day War. At that time, East Jerusalem was still illegally occupied by the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, while the entire world kept silent and uttered not a word against this totally illegal occupation. The map was drawn by a Jordanian named Abd al-Rahman Rassas who worked as an official surveyor and was authorized by the Hashemite Tourism Authority of Jordan. The map bears the words: "recommended and approved by the official Jordanian Tourist Authority".
A perusal of the map shows that in 1965 the Temple Mount compound was still called "al-Haram al-Sharif", that it was on "Mount Moriah", and that the "Al Aqsa Mosque" was simply the silver-domed building on the southern end of al-Haram al-Sharif. In other words, thirty years before the peace agreement between Israel and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, the Jordanians identified Al Aqsa as no more than an edifice on the southern end of al-Haram al-Sharif, which in turn is built on Mount Moriah.
Those who lie and deceive in the name of lsIam decided to "expand" Al Aqsa - whose real location is actually in Ji'irrana (in Hejaz) - to encompass the entire Temple Mount area only after the Jevvs liberated the site of their Temples in the June 1967 Six Day War.
For example, Sheikh Ikrima Sabr, Mufti of Jerusalem 1994-2006, in a speech given on Friday, January 4th, 2002, said the following: "Oh ye MusIims (all over the world), when we talk about the blessed Al Aqsa Mosque, we mean a mosque whose area is 144 dunam (the size of al-Haram al-Sharif in its entirety) including the walls, the al-Buraq Wall (their name for the Western Wall), the passages, hallways, entrances and squares, in addition to the part that is roofed (the building in the southern end), the part that is ancient (under the roofed part) and the Foundation Stone (under the Dome of the Rock), the Marwani prayer site (Solomon's Stables), all are Al Aqsa…"
Another lie, revealed as such by the very same map, follows on the heels of this one. It concerns the site of the Jevvish Holy Temples. Some lsIamic preachers even claim nowadays that al-Haykal al-Maz'oum - "the supposed (Jevvish) Temple" - was never in Jerusalem. The Jordanian map puts paid to the lies of every one of these lsIamic orators.
Of course, those who deny the existence of the Temple in Jerusalem also simply contradict the well-established history of the land.
Watch: ua-cam.com/video/cZrLD6TXPtc/v-deo.html
Your comment isnt long enough, Middle East TRUTH.
Middle East TRUTH
The original hebrews and isrealites were NOT consistently of canaanite descent and therefore not true natives to canaan. They were nomads who were an ethnic a mix of chaldean/akkadians, pre arab northern arabians, original egyptians, along with various levantine and canaanite peoples.
Putting aside the biblical mythology and the myth of abraham, the origin point could be anywhere in these areas, even if at one point many jews were descended from caananites, or mixed with them.
Putting aside the kazar myth, it is a definite fact that later on, a significant number of "gentile" pagan middle eastern groups across the region and ethnically unrelated to original hebrews/isrealites, converted to judaism.
Ex. Most of pre islamic saudi arabia i think in the 5th century was 80% jewish. A signicant number of the ishmalite hejazi ethnic pure arabs have been documented as being pure arab jews, not mixed jews with a levantine origin, and these arab jews migrated to southern iraq and syria, making up a significant ancestry of these jewish populations.
This totally weakens the idea of the importance of racial aspect of being jewish, the fact that arab jews dont exist, and that only muslims and christians can be arabs.
Secondly, true arabs are a miniority in palestine. Most are native arabized caananites/aramaeans/various levantine semites that predate juadism, arab migrations, and islam and you cant tell by looking at them, or using a small sample of foreign families.
Middle East TRUTH that is a lot of information 😳
Well said also to point out that the philistines lived in Gaza, were conquered and assimilated by Assyria and Babylon, and the Goliath was a philistine
8:52 "we dont have weapons"
- No, of course you dont. Especially Hamas and Fatah doesnt have any weapons at all never anywhere. So "innocent".
They're in Gaza not the West Bank
My friend lived near Gaza in Israel before this conflict was widely discussed several years ago, and missile sirens went off almost every day. They are armed. Not all Palestinians, obviously, but terrorist groups do exist there and abuse their own civilians. @@derekaitken
@@rublikonemamtucha6966 I am sorry to hear that. Why did you @ me though? I don't know what that has to do with what I said
I thought you were implying that Palestinians of Gaza are actually weaponless @@derekaitken
@@rublikonemamtucha6966 No, I don't know how anyone could possibly think that unless they live under a rock haha
Always great work. I appreciate learning everyone’s perspective on every question. For me, I see no possibility of a negotiated, long term peace. Too much hatred and lies have been taught to school children. As a result, there will always be friction.
I appreciate your bravery in traveling to locations that might not always be hospitable.
This video was made 5 years ago. I wonder what they would have thought of the events of 5 weeks ago. I wonder what things will be like 5 years from now. Judging from the responses here and the events currently unfolding, I am not hopeful.
When the sun rises in the west and sets in the east. When the germans return to the sudetanland and the Chinese to Indonesia and the french to Algeria, will the Palestinians return to Israel
Israel is not real mate
tell me please what palastinian goverment was 1948 ??
@@orlelouch6384 people were living there way before israel you can look on basic demographics from the region in 1917. there was no government because like every other country they were ruled by foreigners. egypt never had a government from 30 bc to 1919 but does that make them not real
@@amrelemary338 lol I don’t think you know what constitutes of a country.
@@Blackbirdinthedeadofnight tell me then what makes them. palestineans have culures and have been living in the area for generations
My dad’s side of the family is from Cyprus, and the consequences of the 1974 Turkish invasion was the displacement of both Greek and Turkish Cypriots on the island, leaving everything to go live somewhere they’ve never lived before. It’s not a happy part of Cypriot history, it’s a sad part. Many Israelis may have come over after 1948, but the children and even adults now of almost every Israeli have lived in that area all their life and the idea that a people who were displaced will further displace other people when they’re victorious is not only unrealistic but would further the pain of the conflict
I agree with you . Israel was attacked in 5 major wars . The Jews are not going anywhere…. These people in the video need to get into reality .
Don't forget they've been offered a state of their own on 5 occasions. If only their leaders would bloody well have accepted one. The only answer now is endless occupation and repression of people who don't want a state but refuse to coexist. Pernanent victimhood. Even other Arab states are fed up with it, even though they once led them to it. It's so stupid.
You bring up an important point that I'm sort of long felt. When I watch Coreys interviews, it's pretty clear to me that while the older men are open to compromise, its the women between the age of about 25-35 and the young men of maybe 16-25 who are the most militant about it all being Palestinian land.
In a way both groups somewhat surprise me. Had the older men been more dogmatic, I would have understood since they would have some connection the land prior to partition and memories of whatever home they might have left due to the war, but I also understand why they may be tired of being locked in to this battle for so many years. I would hope that maybe on some level they understand that it isn't right for their children to inherit a conflict like this, especially knowing that it likely was lost long ago, and as they age I guess i would like to think that they know they owe their children a better birthright than a legacy of endless death and destruction.
For as much as the older men surprised me, what I find utterly baffling is the reaction from the younger groups. Just as you point out that the Israelis now have two generations of people who have no no other homeland but Israel, the Palestinians also have two generations who have never known a Palestine that extended past the 1967 borders. Given that this is land upon which most of them have likely never even stepped foot, I don't understand why they would be the ones most adamant about claiming it. To hear their responses makes me doubt that this will ever be resolved because I have to assume that some extent it's a reflection of having had that propaganda drilled into their heads from a very young age
@@Whoknowsme007Exactly correct. Palestine existed for a short period between two wars. It is now split into Jordan and Israel. Jordan is exclusively arab with no jews. Israel is a mix of arabs and jews. The arabs are happy with Jordan and want the same mix in Israel despite the fact that the jews agree to a mixed community.
Hence to prevent the partial genocide up to now we see Israel adopting measures not acceptable elsewhere.
Martial law will be ended when arabs decide to leave or to accept to live in Israel in peace.
@@jfryer485 the new push is for a one state solution. Unless they settle the land claims as part of the deal and they add in the new territories strictly as legal residents and not citizens I don't see how they can do that in a way where Israel remains a Jewish homeland which is why they Arabs now want to go that route. I see this as the same strategy they are using in an attempt to try and take over the democratic world, one on which they weaponize our general decency and demographics against us. We are idiots if we all that strategy to work in Asia, in Europe, in North America and most especially in Israel. Thankfully israel seems to be more shrewd and to possess more backbone than democrats in America seem to have so I can't imagine Israel will ever going in that direction. I would also hope that an right of return never includes actual land and/or citizenship and that it's dependent upon arab nations settling their debts to the Israelis they dispossessed of their homes.
Someone suggested I look at the new state solution and the idea of Egypt receiving billions in international contracts to rebuild Gaza in exchange for giving up part of the Sinai and that becoming the new palestine.
As for the rest I think the whole of Jerusalem should go to Israel with those residents either getting assigned representation in the Knesset or legal resident status but not citizenship. For the West Bank, israel would officially annex any Jewish communities and the remaining communities would have to choose whether they would like to be annexed by Jordan or by Israel, security checks would have to be performed and if you fail you have to take assignments, people wanting to relocate to the new Palestinian state would have to be bought off etc etc but at the end the West Bank would be split between the two. I don't see how anything else works.