Israelis: What do you think of the one state solution? (2021)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Filmed during the Covid-19 pandemic
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
What is this project?: Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
Why do I do this?: See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
"The problem is the kitsonim (extremists)!"
The last guy knows what he's saying. He's married to one!
lol
🤣🤣
The others were more political in their response. But essentially they all have the same opinion.
@@iliaselhayani8122 *Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Lol true I feel sorry for him lol that's one of a hell Karen 🤣
That woman. Wow. The husband trying to be diplomatic but he knows who his wife is.
The fact is, they are all ex-army personnel.
Was what she was saying wrong?
@abhijit toiletwala
As an Israeli can tell you the answer now, it's quite simple.
The more religious ones would say no because it's forbidden in Judaism to marry someone who is not Jewish.
The more secular ones would answer like anyone else, following more personal opinions you'll hear from anyone around the world.
@@rudman97
Almost all Israelis served in the army, it doesn't explain the personal political opinions of each individual.
For example the leaders of many pro Palestinian and extreme left organizations are former high ranked officers from the IDF.
@@daviddavid866 The land is strange to fit in a arab world....
There are people more orthodox than muslims and also, there are people more secular and atheist than even in West.
And all are genius in science, arts, warfare..... everything possible.
I just feel bad for the last guy who has to live with his wife...
She speaks the truth you a hole
Karma!, He must have been a Nazi or Hamas leader in,his past life.
@@rachelsamuel3328 and his wife was Goebbels or what
@@1995yuda obama disagrees
@@abidsyed6160 Who gives a fck what that clown thinks, Israelis know their enemies
For anyone wondering the word the last woman used to refer to Obama is closer to the n word than what it was translated as
Cushi isn't really like the n word.
Its a biblical word jihadiboy.
Kudshi?
Kinda means sudani
@@yahudi9936
"Cushi isn't really like the n word."
So if I were to visit Israel and I call every black I run into on the street with the name "Cushi", will I get hugs or punches from them?
@@johns22 probably neither
Imagine if you interviewed Europeans and asked them the same question about African migrants, and they gave the same answers about reproduction rates... It would be labelled disgusting and racist.
Imagine Europeans killing 1/3 of an entire ethnic group… oh wait
there's a difference, those migrants don't have an open policy of genocide against Europeans
I would totally understand such europeans.
@@isaacperess8852 Every nation deserves the opportunity to be concerned with their demographic future.
@@shadowlinks99 you really did skip the last 2000 years of european leadership blaming everything on der juden.....
Someone doesn't understand the US's two term policy 🙄
😂😂
that was so funny🤣🤣🤣, also the dumbest comparison i have heard in a long time.
right. she thought she did something lmao
That woman gave me a stroke
yeah but you have to understand, for an israeli 8 years of being in power is like a few days for other people
I'm palestinian and I don't write often opinions here (quick presentation: from the WB; Hebron).
Many people in Palestine wants a 1 state solutions and many don't (in a recent polls it was about 30% to support it in the WB).
However, I know it's not possible (not now and not in the near future either).
too much difference: economically (minimum wage here 1800nis; in Israel it's 3 to 4 times higher ); we are ruled by corrupt leaders (as strange as it can be I don't consider them to be more corrupt than others Arab leaders, tbh less, however when we compare to Israel it's another world) and I think most important one: lack of trust; it's not a difference but it explains everything; and no; It's not the intifada that provoked it.
Lying to ourselves doesn't serve anyone and we have to say it: we hate each other.
But starting with small steps (increasing our freedom of movement, allowing us to have an airport without passing by Jordan, allowing us to trade more freely with outside world) will not damage you. So when I see that people from the other side of the barrier just wants to maintain the status quo purposely ignoring that for us this status quo is unbelievable. It's just angering me.
i dont think its hate , It's more distrust .. There is no faith.. it's always been like this
This is why from the beginning in 1948 when the British left Jews wanted an Israeli state under Jewish rule ONLY rather than an Islamic state under Muslim rule.
Without insulting but Israel can be corrupt, but at least she is not a terrorist!!! That is why there are millions of Arabs in Israel. If you have an extreme On the Palestinian side
, then it is really terrorist , Because he will only kill you for being a Jew (not a Muslim)
you said something true, there's a huge difference and if there's one state it'll damage Israeli economy because the WB and Gaza it'd need lot of money and stuff to improve it... there's a lack of trust but it's not something new, it happened already more of 100 years ago when the Ottomans decided Jews have rights too, we felt hurt when the Arab leaders here objected it and started massacres against Jews bc they wanted to retain their legal superiority, when the early Zionist proposed one state for both (even recognizing some of the Arabs were descendants too of Jews) they said no and started a war on us, there are Arab clans and communities Jews blindly trust like the Druze or the Arabs of Abu Ghosh who never took part of the other Arab policies and aggressions... honestly it's pretty hard to forget this, of course with reconciliation and stuff this will improve but so far things will remain as it is sadly, mostly because even mentally we are different and have different views on every matter (for example religion, Arabs want Islam as the one and only official religion while Jews, even religious, don't want a State with an official religion nor fav any of them)
Interesting to hear directly from someone who’s actually on the ground.
What solution do you personally prefer? And do you really hate Israelis? Do you go there or have any friends / acquaintances there?
As long as Hamas and Islamic Jihad receive weapons smuggled from Iran and Qatar, Palestinians will never have an airport. It is a high security risk for Israel. Since 1993 the Palestinian Authority receives around 10 billion dollars a year from European Union, USA, Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries, UN and so on. Where is all that money going to?
Before the Intafadas there was more open trade and freedom of movement. The Checkpoints and most restrictions were put in place after the 1990s. The Palestinians brought weapons in through the boats in the Harbour of Gaza, before that there was a 24 mile limit like all others have. Israel decreased the limit 3 times because they were buying and bringing in weapons via the Sea.
The Israelis had allowed all type of building materials Into Gaza, but instead of building schools or hospitals, they built terror tunnels, concrete was used underground to harm Israel. What you did, so shall you reap.
I am amazed by the interviewer who said they should go back to their countries yet she admits that Israeli state was formed in 1948!!!
that was a funny one
Hah! That woman in the end, no matter what your national/ethnic background is, you definitely encountered this type of people. :)
What type of person is that?
Aah yes, in every country there are those types of people that lived their entire lives in a conflict like this and they all give their opinion in this emotional and decisive way.
I think she reacted that way bc how Arabs started a revolt against their Jewish neighbors in Ramle, Lod, Akko, Haifa and many other mixed cities... honestly many Israelis lost their hopes of living together and in peace because of that
True
oh yes, I was actually raised by one like that. Now pity me, please
I really wish you added, as a follow up question to who says no:
Do they still support the whole A/B/C area division, settlement building in the west bank, checkpoints etc.?
If they don't believe in a one state solution, clearly it must mean they want a two state solution. You can't use an independent state as your backyard.
Israel has no intention of displacing 700,000 israelis from their own controled areas
@@habbomaniacos100 they also have no intention of slowing down the building of illegal settlements and migration of Israelis (sometimes literally just arrived via Ailyah) to those areas
sg
@@snowwhite7704 It makes them safer in their illegal settlement in occupied land. I would love if there was a future in which israelis could freely live in Palestine, either following palestinian law or within a unified Israeli state, what you cannot do is say you want Palestine to remain """"independent"""" so they don't get israeli ID and rights while continuing to erode their land.
@@snowwhite7704 First of all, being in the power position does not absolve you of all moral duties, especially when it's explicitly against international law.
Then, for FACT2, that's the core of the issue, Israel wants to have their pie and eat it too, they want the land while not having to handle the current inhabitants in a dignified way. I'm sure there are also Israelis who would be ok with just settling for peace and the territory they already fully control, but that's not the majority opinion.
As for the Palestinians (and you facts 3, 4, 6) while the most extremist groups want nothing less than all zionists out of Israel, there are also more nuanced positions, and what they would want in an ideal world is also different to what they would realistically agree to when looking at it pragmatically, if there saw a real chance at peace and stability. This trust has to be built both ways though, and stuff like settlement building while not allowing the return of even a fraction of palestinians to their land is definitely making it harder rather than easier.
I don't know if a one state solution would "destroy Israel", I usually don't like religiously motivated ethnostates and I think it would be the ideal solution given that you can't ask Israelis to just leave, and many Palestinians already make their living across the border while having to be subjected to hours of checkpoints every day, random searches, random denials of entry etc. But if we want to take for granted that it would, then Israel has to come to terms with it and start working on a 2 state solution instead. This means abandoning the West bank, allowing them to create and official state able to issue their own passports and handle their internal affairs (do you know Palestine has been banned from having 4g telcos by Israel since the technology was created? Just a random example I found out visiting), and stopping the flow of jews into the only land Palestinians still have for themselves. What other solution is there on the long run? What will happen when the remaining land is not enough to sustain the population? Until 100 years ago, when people reasoned with "they're stronger what are you going to do" like you did, the end solution was usually genocide. I hope we can find a better way today.
I'm not really surprised but I'm amazed at how natural it is for Israelis (most of them) to dispose of the life of Palestinians, move them around, decide what they would be allowed to do or not. They seem blind to the fact that they are human beings with aspirations and dignity.
Power of occupation.
I simply think they are Tired of years and years of Palestinian terrorist attacks on Jews, the inability of Jews to enter Palestinian areas if a vehicle accidentally enters a Palestinian area, it is directly embroidered with stones and violence, the Palestinian Authority's disbelief in the existence of the State of Israel and the Jews' right to land. Still do not forget that there is a lot of extremist Islamic terrorism that the Palestinian side ignores
..
@@mor43311 @mor19 I'm not surprised either of this interpretation, in short, they are terrorists.
We can endlessly talk about the succession of events in Palestine for the last 3 or 4 millenias, who's there first, who's legitimate who kicked out whom, moral bases etc.
At the end, Israel is the ruling power, it succeeded convincing its population that this situation/ statusquo is sustainable isolating itself behind strong fences and that slowly slowly, Arabs will either disappear or will be totally submissive to the Israeli Jewish rules. Almost all interviewees think they are being nice and open-minded when saying they accept Arabs but don't want them to have equal rights with jews.
No power supriority is eternal, fences endup always fissurating, if nothing is done to find solutions based on other things than power unbalance, it is gonna be ugly.
@@mor43311 I don't know my reply was constantly deleted 😯
@@zetto814 there is words that are not allowed in UA-cam communities , try without some words
The lady at the end is a real piece of work. Jesus.
Real piece of racism :/
@@halimanairalopeznayar9518 *Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Non è una lady. È una stronza!
i love how people are trying to defend the racist lady at the end.
blows my mind.
How dare she refuse to live with people that are proud of slaughtering and enslaving her family 1400 years !!! Waycistt lol
@@dogbert52 are you referring to Palestinians? so you’re saying Palestinians have existed for 1400 years? I’m confused - i thought Israel supporters deny Palestinians exist - but now you’re saying they’ve been around for 1400 years. So technically….
@@dogbert52
i said it blows my mind..
thanks for proving me right.
You are a muslim the son of Amin Huseyni. what did you do the jews in 1929??
@@KaramKettanie says a lot about your mind.
very funny to me that the last woman was saying that palestinians shoud go back to the countries they come from, while her family probably came from Morroco/Poland/Iraq/whatever..
Yes. The ar abs will be returned to their 22 ar ab states
All Jews originated from Judea all Jews come from judea idiot! All Jews originated from Israel Jews are indigiunous to Judea arabs indigiunous to Arabia
All Jews originated from Judea all Jews come from judea idiot! All Jews originated from Israel Jews are indigiunous to Judea arabs indigiunous to Arabia
All Jews originated from Judea all Jews come from judea idiot! All Jews originated from Israel Jews are indigiunous to Judea arabs indigiunous to Arabia
All Jews originated from Judea all Jews come from judea idiot! All Jews originated from Israel Jews are indigiunous to Judea arabs indigiunous to Arabia
I believe both sides would disagree with one state solution because this will make the conflict worse also if they were supposed to even negotiate they won't stand each other...they won't agree on any agreement.
It's a sad situtation and as a Jewish Israeli I totally agree.
My view is that if both cultures live peacefully for 3 generations only then will 1 state be possible...
But all we can do is hope for the best and try to be decent humans I guess.
Wish you a good day and health though!
the main thing is that mentally we are different, we have different world views even though culturally we are likely the same, even we can see a difference between Israeli Arabs and the Palestinians (the polls shows Muslims in Israel are the less religious in all the region and many women even don't use hijab even though they're religious)... the main disagree from the Jewish perspective was the unwilling of the Arabs to live in one country (as proposed by early Zionist), the massacres and discriminatory policies regarding to Jews as second-class citizens (dhimmi status), and nowadays the Jews in Israel have almost abandoned all things that related to their past, we don't see anymore Jewish women using traditional clothes as it did in the 1800's, 1900's and even in the 48, there's this sentiment of we can't trust them because they'll betray (of course not all thinks this way) and many other things, that's a huge obstacle, the Jews believe they'll be a minority in their own land and country and then it'll became an authoritarian regime and all their rights stripped out, that's the main thing sadly
Where are you from actually?
My sister I agree with you.Best wishes from Turkey.ALLAH bless you.
A one state solution would be a civil war. Israel would win and we'd be right back in the same place except a lot of people would die and the battle lines would be even further dug in. We need 2 states.
Wow... these people are incredibly racist 😲😲
how are they racist ? the palestinians dont have any single race. blond bushnak ahed tamimi is in the same boat as afro palestinians... while we consider druze arabs and cherkes muslims as our brothers(and they vote to zionist parties and serve in the idf...) .its not about race.we wont agree to live under pan arabs or islamists,because we saw what happened to the jews and other minorities i muslim countries( not to mention massacres against the palestinian jews-in hebron and motza in 1929,in pekiekn silwana and tiberis in 1938...)
@@user-we4ih1tp7nIndian Negro??? Really!!! It doesn't sound racist at all to you 🙄
@@haroonsuresh2326 that was a single lady at the end. how many of them said "negro" or mentioned race? its like hearing an article about persecution of albinos in africa and saying "those people(africans) are all racist"
it's not racism. it's a conflict between two people. they want us dead. what don't you understand?
Muslims are the most racist ever to jews
Oh my god I've never seen such hate and racism in my whole life. Despicable. The looks in those people's eyes sent chills down my spine
Saaaameee!!!!!
You will be racist too after having a weekly terror attack in your country for decades straight
Just 2 days ago 4 people died by Palestinian stabber
Edit: Ok, I just finished the video and saw the last woman speaking... feel free to burn us, I don't want to be here anymore
@@Tomer-oy1hj no I won't be racist. Don't play the victim here. Palestinians are daily being killed by Israeli settlers and soldiers but we seldom hear about that in western media. What Palestinians are doing are fighting a despicable racist apartheid occupation. You want to live in peace get out of the occupied territories. Ohhhh I forgot god gave you that land in the Torah 😂😂😂😂
@יואב דניאל יוסית you're probably so used to it you don't see it as hate. Others do.
@יואב דניאל יוסית
You're clearly thoroughly indoctrinated and see this as normal and reasonable and not in any way questionable and hateful.
Israelis: "we dont want a two state solution" "we don' t want a one state solution"
It means" we want the apartheid system forever"
also" why do they hate us?" " they are so aggresive!"
Show me an offer the Palestinians made.
Less than 30 percent support one state solution support for two state is not far from that.
What is their solution?
It’s amazing how many Jews in this video used the exact talking points WWII Germany used regarding their ancestors
Not exactly. Nazi Germany called them the most derisive terms and actually conducted a systematic extermination against them. Jews in Israel want the Palestinians to live anywhere but their country. You can definitely say it’s racist or xenophobic of them to think so, but keep in mind that they had a few bloody wars with all the neighbouring Arab nations and had to endure countless terrorist attacks from Palestinians in the two Intifadas and also today. It’s perfectly understandable why they wouldn’t want them in the same country.
It only took England and Ireland 800 years to get along with one another so good luck 👍 😀 👏 😉
.....
1947- 800 divided by the year 605 (Babylonian)...
The Jews and Palestinians should be getting along in 1.89 years....
My mathematics my be flimsy...
Well white Europeans are a little different then middle eastern Jews and Palestinians.
@@JohnDoe-zg6fn we're all humans ♥
@@guruchintanan5686 Ummm, I disagree.
@@johnnypatrickhaus890 Yeah, we all may be the same species but we are definitely not the same.
@@JohnDoe-zg6fn we are all the same.
Love is the most important thing ❤
Haha the last couple could be a german couple in 1930s Germany speaking about Jews as well
Rubbish 🗑
Wow, scandinavian specialist about Nationalsocialism. Typical is here the equation Nazi-Germany and Israel. I say from Germany "Blödsinn"
@@Linda43 No, truth!
The last two people (especially the woman) represent the opinion of most commentators here
good video! but it should be followed by a next question, "then what?" if they don't want one state solution, well, will they accept another state? and if so, where and how, and in what fair way? and if not, what are they going to do with all the people living there, expel them?
Or wait 2-3 generations for the cultural disparity to diminish.
Then do the palarabs the same thing they plan , chant , yell and scream they will do to israel..... justice peace love and baklawa.
Yes 👏
the plestinian can go and we will be happy to know where and how 70 % of jordan are palestinian they can go there
@@musclesup1 yeah uproot their whole lives where they were born and raised, where they have businesses where their ancestors lived 100s of years before your colonizing asses came. They should leave. So glad you’re outwardly racist bc the only way Israel will be stopped is if the rest of the world including the United States stops them. And the only way the United States stops Israel from operating with impunity is when the people put pressure on the government. The tides are turning my friends and you have yourselves and your outwardly racist comments etc to thank for it. You’re going to make Palestinians citizens or you’re going to let them self determine where they are you can’t have it both ways. Expel them? You’re animals, animals have more humanity than you
I love how we are pretending we don't know what would happen if Jews become a minority in a country.
Wdym? Jews before 1948 were always a minority, especially in Europe. and they lived beside the Europeans, which at some point tried giving the Jews emancipation following the french revolution, yet that has failed and pogroms and the holocaust happened.
@@ramnaftaliavni6532
True, there were attempts to give emancipation, and it's a lot more complicated than "Jews poor minority vs baddies European ".
My point is that, since we have enough data to show that governments have no qualms in persecuting Jews at any given time, why not have a Jewish State?
Yeah I mean Palestine initially didn't protect Jews during the Holocaust.
@@houseofsofia6650 Oh Sorry, I thought you meant something completely different-- I thought you ment that if Jews would be a minority, they too will have many extreme organizations to go and kill each other because they are not the majority
@@ramnaftaliavni6532
No problem.
Whew watching this after that Apartheid video from Amnesty is...rough. Also this is SO similar to how white ppl talk about Black ppl. "They can exist but not near me". "They can exist but not really running the country". "They can be around but they have to have distance because they're violent".
We are ALL Human begins! Damn why is this so hard for everyone to figure out????
Anyway good video as usual Corey. You, Asian Boss, and The Japanese Man Yuta do a very good job asking questions and getting longer answers out of the common people without pushing them in either direction. I appreciate that.
But the Palestinian Humans started attacking the Jews before their was an Israel. There was progroms and attacks, Jews were killed in their sleep. In 1947, there was an Arab blockade of Jerusalem, not 1 truck could get through to bring food, Medicines, or petrol, the Jews were near starvation. You never hear about that, but you will hear about Dier Yassin, that village was attacked to try to stop the blockade, after Dier Yassin, the Arabs attacked the Hadassah Hospital convoy, Did you ever hear of that? They all want you to believe it is all one sided.
I hope one day israelis can reciprocate for 1400 years of dhimmi enslavment by the "minority" of 2 billion ppl.
@@rachelsamuel3328 that’s true, but some of these Israelis (particularly that last lady) was explicitly racist
I agree, it gave me chills and reminded me of slavery times in the US where they values their lives over others.
You do know that report is biased right? I haven't read it but I understand they talk about the Arabs inside Israel which are definitely not under any apartheid regime.
This is one video you can't say CGS edited it or picked answers for!
Why should two different nations live in one state? Especially when one of the nations always show intentions to eliminate the other one.
You are too stupid. There are the locals who have been living in Palestine for generations and then they are a imported invaders who are running around Palestine like a Nazi in Poland
@@chugalongway01 Yes Jews have lived for generations before Islam occupation
@@chugalongway01 you do realise that plenty of the ancestors of "Palestinians" only arrived in the 19th century or during the mandate? Are the Bushnaks, the Algerians and Cypriot Turks Palestinians?
@@brennanando do you realise that you are taking Zionist propaganda that was discredited decades ago by Israeli academics. You should read a book before you repeat junk hasbara
lol you idolise Churchill who is responsible for the death of millions of indians.
I think what most people don't fully understand is that it already is one state. The two societies are completely mixed yet living in separate communities next to each other. The Israelis in this videos have constant, daily interactions with Palestinians on the roads, at work, at restaurants, at the car garage, and in the malls. Depending on their jurisdiction of origin, the Palestinians already have varying degrees of rights from full citizenship to stateless & trapped. The only question is whether Israel will grant Palestinians more and more rights over time. It seems inevitable as Palestinians become more and more integrated into the Israeli economy and when there is external pressure to grant them these rights. I doubt that Israel will willingly extend full rights in one full swoop. But it will happen. Mark my words.
it never will
giving arabs citizenship is antithesis to the whole point of zionism
we want our own country, where we are the majority, we make the rules, and no person can expel us, murder us, steal from us, rape us, put us in gas chambers.
thats the point of zionism
giving arabs citizenship will de facto mean the end of the jewish state and we will never agree to it
@@liljackass6998 “giving arabs citizenship” you know Palestinians have the similar ancestors as the Jews? The Israelites were a sub group of the Canaanites and Jews descend from them. The Palestinians descend from Canaanites from each group off the levantine basin coast. This idea of “having a jewish state” isn’t working well and is just as impossible as living in peace with Palestinians
@@liljackass6998 -- I fully understand the rationale of how you think, your fears, dreams and your overall worldview as a Jew and a Zionist. What you fail to understand dear little jackass is the inevitable march of history. If anything in this video stood out more than anything else, it was a horrifying fear of the Palestinian birthrate. Here's the thing though, whether true or not, a high Palestinian birthrate will exist in any scenario where the two populations are mixed. Let me remind you again and in no uncertain terms, the two populations are completely mixed and fully dependent on each other. There is no scenario other than transfer or extermination that can forever preserve or guarantee a Jewish majority in the land. The only other options are Democracy or continued Apartheid. The woman at [4:28] perfectly exemplifies the prevailing Israeli attitude which is "The status quo is good. They can live here but with no rights" ...
@@mtolives People like you have been prematurely celebrating Israel's destruction/demise for almost 75 years now. We'll see where "the inevitable march of history" takes Israel, dear little arrogant ^&%*.
@@jibaruz According to Palestinian historian Muhammad Y. Muslih, during the entire 400 year period of Ottoman rule (1517-1918), before the British set up the 30-year-long Palestine Mandate, “There was no political unit known as Palestine.”
The resolutions of the Jerusalem Congress were as follows:
"We consider Palestine nothing but part of Arab Syria and it has never been separated from it at any stage. We are tied to it by national, religious, linguistic, moral, economic, and geographic bounds."
The first Palestine Arab Congress met from 27 January to 10 February 1919,
In July 1937, the Arab Higher Committee (AHC) justified its rejection of the Peel Commission’s recommendation for the partition of Palestine on the grounds that “this country does not belong only to [the] Palestine Arabs but to the whole Arab and Muslim Worlds.”
In 1996, even that bastion which proclaims itself as the leader in the “struggle” for the Palestinian “people”, Hamas, said this, “Islamic and traditional views reject the notion of establishing an independent Palestinian state … In the past, there was no independent Palestinian state. … [Hence] our main goal is to establish a great Islamic state, be it pan-Arabic or pan-Islamic… This…land…is not the property of the Palestinians…. This land is the property of all Muslims in all parts of the world.” (senior Hamas leader Mahmud Zahar, 1996)
love these videos as always! as a palestinian from the west bank, the last guy was 100% correct. many of us are dying to live in israel and to be in the israeli society. if i could vote tomorrow for a 1 state solution under israel, i would do it in a heart beat so would many many palestinians under the PA. the people here are hungry, they want to make money and make a comfortable living so they and their families can live comfortably. that’s impossible with the current government we have unfortunately, because they are all thieves. Hopefully i can make the cut one day so i can state my opinion on the whole conflict :)
Well, they don't want you around them and they say it directly to everybody. They aren't ashamed of saying it eventhough it is a straightforward racism and apartheid. Most Israelis share such ideas whether you die to live there or dream to do so. You are under military occupation that is supported by most Israelis. You have zero control or freedom to build a road or small house in your own land in area b or c.
As an Israeli Jew, I hope reasonable people like you can someday make it to Israel and live here and enjoy all the rights and freedoms as a citizen. You are brave to speak the truth. This is your home as much as ours
Want to talk about it on my podcast? I was in the Israeli army.
You can use a fake name if you’re worried about your identity
Lies. You want one state to cause constant problems see multicultural Europe and the US but in this future one state it would 500x worse.
The last lady doesn't know two-term limit in the USA and thinks Barack Obama was gone because of "working for African interests" LOL
The couple at the end - איטלעכס טעפּל געפֿינט זיך זײַן דעקל - Every pot finds it's own lid..🤩
Settler colonialism and racism are closely connected to each other. Settler colonialists always see themselves as superior to the indigenous people. They always feel unsafe, because they know that they are just a bunch of thieves. That's why they feel the need to keep the separation between the two peoples ongoing.
The old apartheid system in South Africa was also a good example for this close relation between settler colonialism and racism. In other words, apartheid is the settler colonialism's child.
There is no Apartheid in Israel.
The term Apartheid has become just another antisemitic trope used to undermine the Jewish State.
The Jewish People are endemic to the Southern Levant with a continuous presence of more than 4ooo years
The Arabs are immigrants from Arabia who occupied and colonized Eretz Yisroel during the Arab Conquests 1400 years ago and again during WW2 when Jewish immigration was limited by the British at the behest of the Arab leadership ( White Papers) and massive Arab immigration from the region was encouraged
So the Arabs when they overtook the Land were settler colonialists, as the Jews are the Indigenous people of Israel. I just want to make sure we are all on the same page.
Thanks for the info about apartheid in South Africa but it's completly unrelated to the video
@@Linda43 skip the manipulative history lessons and arguments about whose god is "better." . The reality here and now is what matters and there are clearly apartheid elements to the way Israel, the occupied territories and Gaza are managed. If there is no racial separation then why are there overtly Jewish only settlements throughout these lands? If you tried that in the West there would be endless protests and litigation. It comes down to simple human rights and fundamental civil liberties.
@@cinnaminson0653
Everything is online.
Apartheid means separation
Jews and Arabs have lived together, worked together, gone to school together and served in the army and government together.
No Apartheid
Almost two million Arabs accepted Israeli citizenship for its political and social freedoms and the rest are permanent residents who have the same rights.
Arabs are represented proportionally in the Knesset. There is one Arab party in the Coalition and a Arab minister.
Israel just appointed six Arab judges and six Arab jurists to prominent positions.Half are women.
No Apartheid.
So, after all, there is apartheid in Israel both practically and mentally.
apartheid against people who want to banish the jews from israel...against people who are either islamists or pan arabs,regardless of their skin color or racial origin(blond ahed tamimi from the bushnak-bosniak clan is in the same boat with the "afro palestinians") while arabs who respect israel(like people from many christian communities,most druze arabs and most cherkes muslims) who are equal rights citizens-enjoy equal rights as citizens...
“Apartheid” doesn’t mean what it meant in South Africa. Now it just means “Jews taking up space.”
I don’t care how much money the Rockefellers spend, I’m not falling for it.
@@user-we4ih1tp7n thieves get hand chopped up, boy, oy vey.
@@user-we4ih1tp7n jews only existed in israel after 1800s, go back to you shitty europe
@@user-we4ih1tp7n your people literally expelled Palestinians from their villages! Living in denial won’t end well for your supposed “nation”
I am from israel What happened in Latest operation in the mixd citis Destroyed all the hope we might had for a life together,Hope that will be hard to build again. You can see alot of difference between this video and the older videos.
It's sad to see😢
You know the world's media didn't show the Arabs rioting in the streets of Israel. The media was focused on the battle with Gaza.
So the world doesn't understand or even know about this anger Israeli Jews now feel.
I was very disheartened by the Arab Israelis attacking Jews in the mixed cities. At heart they showed that thet cab not be trusted, they should be kept as a minority.
@@rachelsamuel3328 unfortunately this may be true. I'm a right-wing 1-stater that believes we can establish limits and boundaries in law, but, I don't know that in the smaller details it'll ever be possible to execute such a thing. It's very possible that civil dissent would naturally happen without regard for any specific law or requirement.
@@Theouterrim77 Not even the Israeli media reported on the pogroms. And now, they're busy trying to revive the fantasy of "coexistence", but it's too late, people woke up.
If israeli je ws knew ar abic , they wouldnt be surprised by their "fellow citizens" jihadonazism. Good luck and all the best
That second interviwee has the best viewpoint. I understand how the one-state solution could be bad for the jews, but none the less still has to happen if they want the violence and thrmoil to stop.
It is frightening how openly racism appears to be practiced in Israel. Saying hateful statements on the street or in a cafe without anyone nearby doing anything about it is frightening and disgusting.
and this from a people who experienced the worst genocide less than 100 years ago.
Above all, call yourself democratic and sovereign.
I visited South Africa in 1984, the tone of the Israelis remind me so much of the people and the apartheid there…
Well, if you think about, a form of one state solution already exists , with Palestinians being under a separate, semi-antonymous, administrative unit within the borders of Israel.
We want two states as you heard the reality is after we offered 3 times we got 3 rejections to their own state in west bank and gaza
apartheid isnt really a one state solution
@@joshuahandfinger9154 There is NO Apartheid in Israel. All citizens have the same rights. There is no Jews-only water fountains or Arab-only busses, there is no segregated theaters in all of Israel.
@@rachelsamuel3328 so i must be totally lied to about this, do nonjewish israelis have the exact same rights as jews?
@@joshuahandfinger9154 Yes, all citizens get the same healthcare, voting rights, Schooling, social security, and other rights, All the same.
That last woman is a disgrace. Using a racial slur against Obama wasn't necessary at all.
Excepting that uncalled part, everything she said was absolutely right.
Yes she is extremely racist, uninformed and quite difficult to listen to .She made me ashamed that she’s Israeli! I feel sorry for her husband
Racial slur is the least of my worries with people like her
What was the racial slur? She said Negro not the N word? I did t watch it all though. Did she say the N word?
What racial slur? She called him a Negro. Now, while it's not polite, it's not a racial slur.
And what she is saying about the Arab Muslims is correct.
What an ignorant, hateful old shrew there at the end. Good on Corey for pushing back, at least a little! Intimidating to be sure.
She is honest and Corey needs 🌈 to be a supremacist
It‘s funny how to see the contrast to her husband. He was calm and open for debate.
And her arguments were so poorly thought through😂
„They should go back to where they came from“ then do so yourself
„They got rid of obama after 8 years“ is there any other option?😂
Lol she was funny as hell to listen to in Hebrew, but anyways she had some points, money flying in Aza and what do they do? Use it to dig tunnels and execute terror attacks
@@theholoren to be honest, i can‘t really blame them. Gaza doesn‘t have the size, resources or infrastructure to support 1.8 million people. The people are depending on handouts, with no chance to ever have a career, wealth or nice future. As it seems even water now turn into an issue because an overpopulation like that is bound to threaten the health of the groundwater. I would be building rockets too. With oppression always comes resistance
@@tschabow5608 They do have the recourses and infrastrucure to build shelters, schools and productive structures, but like I said they use the money to make tunnels and fund terror attacks.
"it's like Americans won't let a black rule them"
that last woman said the true reason for refusal
Makes zero sense in this context. Perhaps if there were no black or brown Jews. But unfortunately the reality doesnt support your narrative.
@@mattnewhouse1781 she says that they cannot accept an arab to be their prime minister just like how americans couldn't accept an african man to be their president.... she considers a "Jew" as an ethnicity not a religion and refuse one-state solution because they would have to give "non-jews" civilian rights such as political rights
@@hashemahmed1402 its a stupid comparison, becuase it tries to compare two very different issues. The woman was stupid to say it, because it looks racist. However, not wanting the people who want to murder you to be your room mate is the real comparison. Non jews already have full rights in Israel.
And why do you quote jew? Should i say "muslim" ? What is the quotation for? For us ethnicity and religion are one. We arent going around converting people in mass numbers like other groups do.
@@mattnewhouse1781 they don't, palestinians living in israel don't get the right to vote or participate in the military service
No. Next question.
@Marcus Apartheid
@Marcus Well my opinion is that the Arab part of the mandate area is on the other side of the river. That said, if things changed drastically, one state might be possible far in the future. Nowhere close now.
@Marcus No hostilities or attacks for 3 generations in my opinion would be the only reality in which trust could fully be rebuilt between the 2...
How we get there is just for people on both sides to be decent people to the best of their capabilities.
@Marcus I agree. Hate will always bring more hate, and there can be no peace with hate...
That was some authentic hilarious rant at the end
I'm very proud to say Corey is from ottawa canada 🇨🇦
This question hard than equation with five unknowns-:)Two different societies who had war many times,two religion and culture, millions of refugees whose land,homes had been occupied. In my opinion, one state might be hard to govern but two separate states or under confederation two states would be sensible solution.It'll take a long time to heal wounds.
500,000-700,000 Arabs fled into Arab Countries from Israel and became refugees.
900,000-1,000,000 Jews fled from Arab Countries into Israel and became refugees, their descendants make the majority of Israelis.
The difference being, Israel has absorbed those incoming refugees, while the Arab countries for the most part did not, they use them as a political tool (a common cause, a unifying topic, a diversion from poverty, poor health care, poor education and corrupt governments).
All refugees should get compensation, note however overwhelming majority of Jews were city dwellers, hence their lost property worth is much higher, in addition to them being higher in number, a reason for Arab regimes to object to reparations.
60 million people were refugees on the 20th century, they all have moved on, except for those Arabs of Palestine/Israel, who are kept a refugee status by Arab countries, UNRWA and their own political leaders.
@@hasangul2132 *Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
@@jasonkemmerer5654 Catholics are correct and you should become a Catholic is you wish to be at all eligible of entering Heaven☩☧☨☦✝☦☦✝☦☩☧☨☦✝☦☦✝☦☩☧☨
@@stlouisix3 please do not be mad at me sir, but along time ago i was a catholic but realized they put tradition over what the bible teaches and go against the actual WORD OF THE LORD. which no one can serve two Masters; therefore the roman catholics serve tradition instead of serving THE LORD HIMSELF. no to mentioned, no offense sir, but if really closely inspect roman catholicism with an open mind you will find that they actual promote roman paganism hiding behind Christian symbols; which was done when they baptized pagan rituals into "Christian" practices which ought not be done; as True Christians we are called to be separate from the world. examples are halloween is from celtic paganism, christmas is from roman paganism of sol invictus (aslo on december 25), and so on. please i don't wanna offend you but in short roman catholicism is not True Christianity and if you pray to THE LORD to sincerely show you The Truth and you mean that pray and earnestly seek after The Truth no matter where it leads you will surely find The Truth and by The Truth be set free from the many lies of this world. of which is what i hope for you and to one day truly call you brother.
Operation Susannah, conducted in Egypt in the summer of 1954. As part of the false flag operation,[1] a group of Egyptian Jews were recruited by Israeli military intelligence to plant bombs inside Egyptian-, American-, and British-owned civilian targets: cinemas, libraries, and American educational centers. The bombs were timed to detonate several hours after closing time. The attacks were to be blamed on the Muslim Brotherhood
The last guys wife is a true example of yell bad ideas loudly to overpower the debate
Did she call Obama an n-word??? 🤣😂 I just can't.
Why This question still up for 80 years ???????? Only tiny country that’s is not Muslim in the Middle East
This tiny country had people living there before you came, maybe it’s just a reason ? No ?
@@basirj8578 thats why the entire middle east except israel is cleansed of jwws?
Thats why 22 ar ab is lamic ethno dictatorships are totally cool but heaven forbid the yahood will have a their state?
Khaybar khaybar?
Hamas charter?
Who do you think you are fooling jihadiboy?
@@basirj8578
50,000-75,000 Christians under the PA (Palestinian Authority).
1,000 Christians under Hamas (and dwindling).
1:20 if it was the land of the Jews why did they leave it in the first place? Not even the Palestinians are leaving despite the deplorable living situation.
Are you stupid? We were conquered and expelled, and we came back twice. We rebelled against the Romans more than any other nation until they utterly destroyed us. The Palestinians fled without firing a shot.
They were expelled by the Romans sparking a mass migration into various directions, not by choice. Same for Armenians in Western Armenia (modern day East Turkey) or Circassians (modern day Sochi area in Russia), they got killed or expelled
Thanks for the second question of the week.
Look how these Jews are acting now after coming out of nowhere
The last woman is so despicable.
The lady used the word "negro"....😅...classic
she used a worst word
Israelis saw everything coming but how was possible to prevent October 7?so sad
10:09 "if it's not good for them here they should go back to the countries they came from" - does she not realise the irony in this statement? is she suggesting they take back their homes in tel aviv and surrounding villages/cities? because thats where they'll be going.
Palestinians already have a state its called Jordan
Jordan’s like 4 times the size of Israel not including the West Bank.
And most of Jordanians are Palestinian
I‘m palastinan and i want leave my Home when i get New York London fort knox Washington Paris Berlin moskow and Vatikan for my People + 7,5 Trillion is Dollar Cash and Microsoft
And Jews have a state it’s called New York
@@dannyh7894 the Jews aren’t a majority in NY State.
All the people cr_pping on Israel here ought to see all the videos where Corey asks Palis some variation of "is any form of peace possible?" and most say no and they say that the Jews (referred to as Israelites in the Koran) have no business being in Israel. As well, Israel offered all of Gaza, the WB and East Jerusalem twice to the Palis over the past 30 years and they rejected it both times because they insisted on an unlimited "right of return" of Palis not only to a prospective Pali state but to Israel itself. In other words, they tried using the peace negotations to insert a poison pill that would ultimately destroy Israel -- the REAL goal of the Palis and most of their supporters here on this board.
Very true.
most of the time they say there cant be peace because the ievil israelis dont want peace they want all the land, we can´t trust them
and the israelis say "there cant be peace cause the ievil arabis dont want peace, they want all the land and we can´t trust them"
At least they agree on that
Perfectly said!!
I think some ppl are aware of the genocidal intents of the ar abs towards the jwws and are just very supportive of such genocide. In the name of "human rights/climate change/ dimocracia" and other irrelevant buzzwords used to hide their genocidal antisemitism.
@@hanginggardenerofbabylon1046 both sides might say that, but it's only true for one.
-Palestinians say they want peace... But then they also want their own country, with an army, an airport, and other thing that demands massive amounts of trust from Israel.
-Then they want all the territory the Jordanians lost in 67, nothing less.
-And of course, not only do they want a country, but also all their refugees returning to Israel, which would change the demographics and eventually create 2 Palestinian countries with a Jewish minority...
While Israelis want them to stop attacking, and have a military-less country until trust is regained. Security is the only thing that matters (at least to the majority of the population and the government. thankfully, the fanatic religious minority is too small to matter).
One side obviously has less demands. If Israel wanted all the land it wouldn't agree to the partition plan in the first place (like Palestinians)... and it would already be theirs.
Thank you for your bravery Corey
Just imagine if this was reversed how they would moan about Anti semitism and cry
Yeah they cry anti semitism everywhere
I live in Lebanon here Muslims and Christians live in peace, on the same street, buildings, work together, etc. It was not always this way, it took some time and large areas, actually the majority of the country is not mixed, however it is open for all to visit.
One state solution is the ONLY solution. People need to be able to live together and it needs to be an open country for all and that is how people will learn to live in peace. People will never learn to live in peace with each other when they are separated by a wall and pointing weapons at each other, relying on biased media to learn about others.
Concessions will need to be made but it's worth it.
If "Israel" does not renew and redefine itself it will die.
Why don't you worry about Lebanon?? How many Palestinians are living in Lebanon as refugees? How many were born in that country, yet are not citizens?? How is your economy? I would say you have enough issues to worry about in Lebanon, please try to solve your own issues, then tell others how to run their countries.
Lebanon , a model of tolerance and stability lol
@@dogbert52 especially because Christian's make up 30% of the population LL
Lebanon had an interreligious war and relations between the different groups are rather lukewarm. Christians live in totally different neighbourhoods and towns than Sunnis, and Sunnis live separate from Shia etc. Lebanon is one of the worst example to pick.
@@rachelsamuel3328 death to Israel in its current form. One state is without question the most humane option.It is how civilized people must exist.
That was eye opening... and not in a good way a lot of the time. The first guy actually most succinctly answered why a one state solution simply won't work without getting, ya know, super bigoted. And the sheer hatred and mistrust you hear from both sides is only further proof that two (or three) states for two people is the only realistic solution to both ensure Israel's future as a Jewish AND democratic state, and to ensure that Palestinian Arabs enjoy the same self-determination by being full-fledged citizens in their own state. Not that I expect it to happen anytime soon.
Most of those Jews he spoke to have grandparents from Arab lands. Look up what the Houthis recently did to the last few Jewish families in Yemen (where the Jewish presence extends back about 900 years further than the advent of Islam). Jews from Arab lands know the reality of survival in the Middle East while you moralize from the comfort of some rich Western multicultural country.
@@camillabruford7216 Well, I'm from South Africa so "rich" is a bit of a stretch. But we're not actually disagreeing here. That's why I specifically focused on the first guy and why I'm stressing that a one-state solution is not a solution. Why an Israel with an Arab majority will be disastrous either by not allowing the Arab population equal rights, which actually will be Apartheid, or by allowing them equal rights and risking Israel becoming another Islamic nation hostile to its Jews.
Or are you complaining about my point about their being highly prejudiced against the Palestinians? This is not a judgement call either way, but is a sad acknowledgement of what seems to be the reality on the ground. And it certainly goes both ways and, based on the evidence of Cory's videos, looks even worse on the Palestinian side. We can argue the whys and wherefores of this, but my point, really, is simply that forcing two people with real animosity between them into a single country is a recipe for total disaster.
I see exactly what you mean and this is not new i think everyone would agree that the two state situation is the best way to make peace BUT the conflict isn’t about that it’s about where this state would be because since the oslo agreement until today israel is taking more and more lands and builds more settlements and on top of all keep destroying houses so it’s not about how to make peace it’s about where and how would we agree to make the peace
@@camillabruford7216 well i can understand that point of view 100 years ago
Let’s talk facts Israel has the strongest well trained most equipped the newest most advanced weapons and army in the Middle East
Israel had a war against egypt 🇪🇬 and jordan 🇯🇴 since 60 there were peace it holds up still and the Countries have been best buds until the Abraham agreements witch we all can see how well and strong this relations are growing everyday
In sense Israel is well capable to defend it self and more important it’s been recognized by it’s neighbors including the Palestinians them selfs and by a 5 6 more islamic countries last 2 years alone
Now my question is when you say they can’t be trusted what is that mean ? Is it a fake peace and you’re not trusting your new and old friends?
@@charlieharper2694 come to London and let's talk about why we can't trust
Wow! that last woman was a piece of work.
It doesn't matter if they still hate each other under one state. They just have to not kill each other.
מה שטראמפ התחיל ככה צריכים להמשיך…פשוט הסכמי שלום מסביב 💁🏻♀️
The older Israelis aren't 'buying into the Dream of Peace' - they've become cynical, and with good reason.
Don't worry, us younger Israelis buy it even less.
Why hate? Peace ✌️
I think the world as a whole will see progressive change once the baby boomers are gone. I hope among the changes are a 2 state solution.
I don't think any israeli want peace or else they would have to leave palestinian land, distribute water equally and most importantly not be able to gatgher support from abroad because they won't have an enemy they blame for all their problems. Victimization is part of their mentality and if they can't portray they are victims, they aren't true israilies. Shamefully a large percentage of these israilies came from Muslim countries where they lived not for centuries. They weren't forced to covnert or change their way of life but ask any israeli now and they will all tell you, they were pursecuted.
All the ppl here that write about apartheid understand that Palestinians don't live in Israel? It doesn't seem like jt
Guy: *Trying to be polite and reconciliatory*
His wife: *Racist diatribe after racist diatribe*
Cue the Curb Your Enthusiasm soundtrack
Truth hurts.
In(s)ane. A one state "solution" is no solution at all. A "final solution", maybe.
That’s what the KKK says in America about the White Aryan Nation. Now you understand “Jews Will Not Replace Us “
@@chugalongway01 jews in america speak english accept the american idea and the constitution "palestinians" want to change the flag, anthem, language and they are not 1 mlion they are 20 milion and we are 7 milion jews here with 2 milion arab citizens
.... its very diffrent from what u say
@@bashbash7 it's happening in America now with the influx of 3rd world people. They want to throw eveything away. Unfortunately, multicultural societies dont work and dont last long.
@@chugalongway01 Did you know the first KKK robes had the crescent and star logo?
Wow the last lady made me feel sick
A democratic state with one religion as the precursor(Jewish/Islamist Democratic state) is an oxymoron!!
That last woman... Wow... Pinnacle of ignorance.
whats so dificult about : live and let live!!! 🥺
like all over the middle east and north Africa.
Ask the Palestinians why they've several times rejected a two-state peace plan, whereas Israel accepted it
@@Jay_in_Japanalmost all of them were dogshit
the plo since 1988 has recognised israel and the 2 state solution on 1967 borders
almost every single offer from israel was a straight up joke
the 2000 one for example
palestine was to be fragmented into 3 seperate regions, with them being completely inside israel with no borders to jordan, they would also cede the entirety of east jersualem which was their internationally recognised capital
12:00 thanks crazy lady, that’s all we needed to know about you
"yeah we can share a state with them"
"it's a problem that they sit in the parliament"
That last lady was a super Karen, she was glitching out
She will soon rot in the fires of Hell.
Interesting that all questioned Israelis don’t want to live equally with Palestinians in one country. In other countries this is called RACISM. Considering that the Palestinians are the original inhabitants of the land Israelis are migrants from all over the world, this is called APARTHEID.
Belgians also dont want to live with french . But thats fine because they arent jwwish . And i am sure your not a nazi at all. Lol
@@dogbert52 Belgians have sovereignty over their land and borders, the Palestinians have no sovereignty over any of their land or borders. The Israelis control the whole land, country, and borders but refuses to treat the Palestinians equally. If that’s not racism or apartheid what is?
@@dogbert52 The Belgians have sovereignty over their land and borders. Palestinians have no sovereignty over any of their land or borders. Israel controls all the land and borders. Yet it refuses to treat Palestinians equally if that is not apartheid what is?
“Original inhabitants” not according to archaeology or history but w/e
@@scharb To most people what happened 2000 have no relationship to what’s happening today. For eg no one in his right mind would assume that England should cease to be an Anglo Saxon country (who are ancient migrants from Germany) and return to being a Celtic county (its ancient original inhabitants).
If you are referring to history and archeology, the Canaanites lived in Palestinian/Israel before the Jews. Why should the Jews today be more entitled to it. This doesn’t make sense.
Today the vast majority of the Israelis in Palestinian/Israel are migrants from other countries (except for Arab Israelis). Many still hold the nationality of their home countries which they came from. While the Palestinians lived there for centuries and have no where else to call home.
The last lady called the term negro and told the cameraman that i can see in your eyes that you support them
.are you being serious... she was too too personal attacking.
He was only asking questions.
"we gave them gush katif " so someone who was born in europe gave the land to people who are indgenious to that land ?? the arrogance of these guys god
I admit as an outsider one state with equal rights for all looks like the logical solution .
A secular state , not a religious state .
I admit looking at the racism and bigotry as an outsider it will have to be forced on Israel
by outside forces .
Does not look close to happening but that does not mean it is not worth aspiring to .
80% of west bank palastinian support hamas, and the rest support even more extreme groups if that is even possible. i would die before agreeing to a one state solution. I would rather die defending my country than to be raped and burned alive by Palestinians under "one state"
Their guilty conscience makes them fear giving them their full sovereignty, freedom and autonomy. They fear retribution.
It seems people are confusing Israeli Arabs and Arabs in the PA. The answers sometimes seem to refer to one state with the Israeli Arabs, which already are in the same state as the Jews, and creating a new state uniting Israel and the PA.
yeah that’s never going to happen
I think the respondents purposely confused it in some cases to make it look like they already have a one state.
Erm... I'm guessing "no" 🤔 😅
It’s crazy how they just openly support apartheid and everybody sees it as normal
Its crazy how people just make up stuff and write nonsense on the internet and see it as normal
A one state "solution" will create a failed state which would quickly disintegrate in civil war. In this civil war the Muslim world will aid the Palestinians, and might intervene on their behalf, and I suspect the west will aid the Palestinians as well. It will be the end of not just Israel, but of the Hebrew speaking society in Israel ("Yishuv") as well.
The whole idea is nonsensical and stems from a fundamental misdiagnosis of the Israeli Arab conflict. The source of the conflict is not the occupation of 1967, and not the refugees of 1948, and not even the Zionist state and the unequal distribution of power and resources, the source of the conflict is a fundamental disagreement on the cultural and civilizational belonging and identity of the land we call Israel and they call Palestine. The Palestinians do not fight for human rights, they fight for their ethnic, national, religious and civilizational sentiments and interests. Many Jews do not fight for security and freedom but are driven more or less by the same motivations as the Palestinians. I don't see any willingness for compromise that the land will be both Hebrew and Jewish and Arab and Muslim. The cultures in the middle east do not create liberal societies, it doesn't exist. Lebanon tried to be a "middle eastern Switzerland" and failed miserably and the whole thing exploded in sectarian strife and civil war. Due to its internal divisions and sectarian strife Lebanon has a weak central government and is not even a state according to strict Weberian reasoning as it doesn't have a monopoly on the use of force within its territory. Lebanon is controlled by Hezbollah, an Iranian funded Shia militia which is a separate body that is independent of the Lebanese state. Only the situation in Israel/Palestine will be worse than Lebanon, the cultural differences are greater, the economic disparities are great too and that will add to the animosity, and the memories of the conflict will not go away.
Israelis don't want one state solution and won't allow Palestinians to have their own state 🤣 like WTF
It’s exactly what the KKK wants for white Christian Anglo Saxons in America… ZZZ = KKK
John, they have dozens of opportunities. Just take 1948-67 as an example, they had all the lands, why didn't they establish a state??
Lol you heard them only 2 states
They offered a state 5 separate times, the British offered them 80% of the land that is now Israel. That was no good as they didn't want the Jews to have even,20%.
@@chugalongway01 Please get new material, your elegiance to Nazis is getting boring.
There is already a 2 states solution : Israel and Jordan
Which the Arabs rejected; and Jordan massacred over 20,000 Palestinians during Black September.
@@avi3860 after the Palestinians killed the Jordanian king and the Jordanian prime minister
@@ShikaStyle123 Israeli spies did that do you forgot your Eli Cohen who went Syria to do the same with Syrian president
@@ozorg6023 the PLO literally claimed responsibility so I doubt it was israeli spies
you can't be that stupid!!
That last lady needs her meds
She would be considered a "centrist" in the Israeli Knesset🤣
No Jewish person could live in let alone be in parliament on idk Jordan or Surya. Dude getting people mad who fight hard to protect their country. You saying they should give it up
The woman at the end is the true face of Israel
Jordan is 90% palestinian, jordan will annex parts of west bank and and there you have a palestinian country
There is plenty of room in Jordan. They did illegally annex "the West Bank" once already. They do not want the Palestinians,
@@rachelsamuel3328 they are "palestinians" lol even the queen of jordan
They could do that, if they wanted to... their benefits of continue the conflict are too high for centuries.
Im confused… is this Germany in 1940 or what exactly ??
pretty much
Very funny occupying someone's house and ask him to go out because you want that only you live in it😁
The young woman at 4:45 is a big fan of the current apartheid state 😂
Get a life Moe 🤣
No, she just prefers that to living as a minority in an apartheid Arab or apartheid Muslim state. You know, she'd be a dhimmi under that, plus possibly would have to look walk around in a black body bag. Or rely on a man to even step foot outside the house. Who'd want to live like that?
Written by KD:
If the United Nations (UN) is going to hold an inquiry into the clashes between Israel and Hamas last May, surely the person heading the inquiry should be impartial?
This is the point behind a 30-page complaint released by UN Watch this week, which called on retired South African jurist Navi Pillay to resign from heading up a new UN inquiry into the conflict.
According to the complaint submitted to the UN on 14 February 2022 by UN Watch, Pillay, a retired South African judge and former UN human rights chief, violated UN rules by failing to disclose numerous prior statements that directly prejudge the matters before the inquiry.
“Never throughout her UN tenure did Pillay use such dismissive language regarding any other country, not even against serial abusers such as China, Russia, Iran, Syria, or North Korea,” says Hillel Neuer, the executive director of UN Watch and an international human rights lawyer.
“Her narrative of who is the villain is set in stone. Ms Pillay has long ago made up her mind. Asking Navi Pillay to head an inquiry examining Israel is like asking a vegetarian to review a steakhouse. When it comes to Israel, as our legal brief demonstrates, Pillay is the complete opposite of impartial.”
UN Watch is an independent nongovernmental organisation that monitors the UN for bias and impartiality.
“Many of the utterances in question occurred mere weeks before she was appointed by the UN, leaving little room to imagine how Pillay could envisage the issues any differently so soon afterwards,” says Neuer. “It’s astonishing that the United Nations appointed an individual as the supposedly impartial chair of an inquiry immediately after she declared one of the parties guilty in the very controversies that are at issue in the investigation.
“By heading this inquiry in spite of having repeatedly declared Israel ‘guilty’, Pillay embodies the injustice of the UN and its Human Rights Council when it comes to the selective treatment of the Jewish state,” he says.
In June 2020, Pillay signed a petition, organised by the South African Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions coalition, titled “Sanction Apartheid Israel!”
In June 2021, she signed a joint letter to United States President Joe Biden against Israel’s “domination and oppression of the Palestinian people”. She wrote that the April 2021 clashes at Al-Aqsa in Jerusalem - also to be examined by the inquiry - constituted “aggressive actions by Israeli forces” against “peaceful protesters and worshippers”, which amounted to “forced dispossession of Palestinians”, the “latest evidence of a separate and unequal governing system”.
In a May 2021 lecture, Pillay described Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians as “inhuman”. She compared Israel to apartheid South Africa, and defended the systematic singling-out of Israel under a targeted agenda item at the UN Human Rights Council.
Her anti-Israel bias can be traced even further back. In 2009, Pillay headed the UN’s follow-up to the 2001 Durban conference on racism, an event tainted by unprecedented displays of antisemitism. When Jewish community activists around the world sounded the alarm, Pillay repeatedly demonised them at the UN and in the media as “lobby groups” that were “focused on single issues”.
In May 2010, while serving as UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Pillay declared that “the Israeli government treats international law with perpetual disdain”.
In November 2017, she stated, “Apartheid is now being declared a crime against humanity in the Rome Statute, and it means the enforced segregation of people on racial lines, and that is what is happening in Israel.”
Neuer says that in contrast to former UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon and her predecessor, High Commissioner Louise Arbour, who both criticised the UN Human Rights Commission for its notorious agenda item targeting Israel, Pillay repeatedly defended this discrimination.
the un is the world biggest crime organization at this point .
God bless Hillel Neuer! He is always fighting for Israel.
@@rachelsamuel3328
He is a genuine hero of the Jewish People ✡
Refusing one state solution and made the two state solution impossible by the expansion of settlements 😂, what do these guys want.
If anything this shows that Israel is not a true democracy. In Canada we have to learn to get along with each other - French, English, Jew, Muslim, Hindu, Chinese, Indigineous, every type of religion and nationality. You simply cannot have a true democracy if you are worried about one group overtaking another. True democracies change and adapt to the people it serves. While I understand that Jews want to keep their Jewishness to make sure that they have a safe haven country, Israel should just stop pretending that they are a true democracy.
Look at the racism of these Jews - 12:00
As if Palestinians have ever done anything to show that they want peace.
How about recognising Israel on 78% of the Land Of Palestine that was 100% theirs….., the Zios are like the settlers who invaded America and wiped out the natives. You call it progress , remember. You even think that the slaves that were kidnapped from Africa were lucky to be slaves….. you are too stupid
@@chugalongway01 None of it ever belonged to them, nor will it.
@Karthik please list what these peaceful things they did were.
@@chugalongway01 ? 78% of what? gur rah, enough with your bullshit, try really giving us your opinion.
If only the zionists like u can leave the land, peace can happen
maybe its because i am american, but the one state solution seems like the only way.
was a two state solution ever a popular idea in the united states after slavery ended? this situation feels like it has many parallels with the american integration of black people into society. i
OMG So much hatred , and racism on both sides, no wonder its a challenge to find a common ground and acceptable solution