How to make thumbnails to get more VIEWS- In just 5 minutes!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 282

  • @CP-dl4nc
    @CP-dl4nc 3 місяці тому +116

    The rate of these videos being published is insane. These videos aren't random, badly made videos that some people post. Every one of these videos is high quality, useful and a masterclass in a topic about video creation.

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  3 місяці тому +15

      That’s is the best compliment! Thank you! So glad it’s been helpful!

    • @Taragraceruiz
      @Taragraceruiz 3 місяці тому +4

      Totally agree! ❤

    • @dianesgardeninspiration
      @dianesgardeninspiration 3 місяці тому +3

      You are on FIRE! You go girl!!! 🙌 I love your energy, information and inspiration 🌻🌻🌻

    • @srfirehorseart
      @srfirehorseart 3 місяці тому +2

      Agreed. These videos make a great course of bite sized tips. 💚

    • @amusicmama891
      @amusicmama891 2 місяці тому

      Agree!!! 👍

  • @2Blessed2bStressed-v6w
    @2Blessed2bStressed-v6w 28 днів тому +17

    I just started my own channel. I am sharing scripture and worship daily! Praying many people hear the gospel through this platform! God bless you 🙏

  • @JetLagRecords
    @JetLagRecords 3 місяці тому +43

    This Is Virginia Kerr, you're making UA-cam a better place

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  3 місяці тому +4

      Awwww you made me smile. Thank you!

    • @crowdvibesJH
      @crowdvibesJH 2 місяці тому

      @@ThisIsVirginiaKerr Sounds like a great tagline :)

  • @knoxlowe1
    @knoxlowe1 Місяць тому +2

    Hey Virginia! Two things.... on your thumbnails, something (anything) showing you smiling automatically gives you at least 30 seconds. Very pretty with a nice smile! Also, your comments about larger fonts on the thumbnail that can be read on a cell phone is the BEST ADVICE EVER? Anybody with less than perfect vision will skip small text! I do!!

  • @TVTheories
    @TVTheories 2 місяці тому +11

    1:09 Connect with audience
    1:18 Emotion
    2:29 Easy to read, four words 3:06 Large Fonts, Fonts on the left side
    3:42 The Thumbnail should evoke emotion, different from the title
    4:39 Take pictures of yourself and your Instagram background, take a screenshot from the video, and create a template in canva.

    • @crowdvibesJH
      @crowdvibesJH 2 місяці тому +2

      Copy and paste this into your summary :)

  • @HaveABetterPurpose
    @HaveABetterPurpose 2 місяці тому +18

    7:06 Your content is just like everyone else’s that’s posing on these same topics… except that it’s precise, practical, and actionable. You are very good at what you do ❤

  • @Skippingtowardsdreamsafter50
    @Skippingtowardsdreamsafter50 13 годин тому

    Learning how to do this before I start posting videos and MY GOODNESS, you made this SO easy! I love your channel!

  • @The_Nomad_Rad
    @The_Nomad_Rad 6 днів тому

    Just started my channel and thumbnails have taken forever as I have no creative or artistic skill! This is super helpful, thank you!

  • @loanalacy4701
    @loanalacy4701 3 місяці тому +7

    Virginia!!! You are on Fire!!! I truly believe that this series was a Devine Download from The Lord!!!! No kidding. Answered prayers for me! You have made it simple, understandable, I’ve learned more from you in one week than I have in the past year. Thank you ❤

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  3 місяці тому

      That’s wonderful to hear! Thank you so much for the encouraging comment! ❤️

  • @realonebusinessschool
    @realonebusinessschool 3 місяці тому +5

    Virginia, you've done it again 🎉. Detailed guide, powerful presentation, high tech visuals, all these make your videos interesting to watch.
    Your contents are always awesome 💯

  • @AdrenaMonic
    @AdrenaMonic 3 місяці тому +4

    Love this! Full of gems. Thank you. Woman, you've taught me more about UA-cam in your short videos than anyone I've watched in the last 6 months!

  • @meade916
    @meade916 26 днів тому

    I spend a lot of time on my thumbnails (usually). I think the most time I spend is not being able to choose what I want to use because I like so much of what I am doing. I have the problem of information overload. I want to put so much in the thumb I have tried to teach myself to tone it down some. But as I said, I love my subject matter and it's hard to decide my approach. It might take me 3 hours to make a thumb...I am a new sub to your channel and even though I have 18 years of youtube experience I have found your tips to be very useful and I am taking notes...I would love to talk to you someday!

  • @GracefullyKaren
    @GracefullyKaren Місяць тому +2

    Canva is amazing. Thank you for sharing. I think my thumbnails are good but I’m still learning. I appreciate you sharing.

    • @JJRWolff
      @JJRWolff Місяць тому

      I've been using canva to create this videos I just started uploading and I love it!

  • @allenreid62
    @allenreid62 3 місяці тому +3

    I've found that your #3 suggestion is best for me, taking a screenshot and using Canva for the graphics. Keep the tips coming!

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  3 місяці тому +2

      Yes it’s the fastest. I hate taking my picture 🤣

  • @Spendinglifetogether
    @Spendinglifetogether 3 місяці тому +8

    I started my 7 day challenge today! Not a lot of views today, however I hope the algorithm catches on.😊

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  3 місяці тому +4

      Congratulations 🎉 Give it time ❤️ it’s a computer that needs input.

    • @ATOoMamre
      @ATOoMamre 2 місяці тому +1

      Sandy, I just watched your video and its well made. I really liked the house tour. Great work and keep it up.

    • @Spendinglifetogether
      @Spendinglifetogether 2 місяці тому +1

      @@ATOoMamre thank you, I really appreciate that!😀❤️

    • @Nurturingmeals
      @Nurturingmeals 2 місяці тому

      I am in the same boat. 😢

  • @burtonmakelo
    @burtonmakelo 2 місяці тому +2

    Thanks Virginia for these life-changing insights.

  • @hopecreekranch365
    @hopecreekranch365 3 місяці тому +1

    I love, love this challenge! I’ve been dragging my feet to get started for years (so embarrassing), but i keep getting hung up on all the details and the process. This is the BEST content on content creation. I love how you film while going about your day. Thank you for all you do!

  • @biker_dan
    @biker_dan Місяць тому

    I have been watching your tips on video etc. I have a channel but recently I had to retire early at 61 due to mental illness. I started working on my bikes and using this to build up my old channel in the hope to be able to sustain my retirement. Thanks for the helpful work you are doing, I'm hoping it will help boost my channel.
    Cheers Dan

  • @TheRussRyde
    @TheRussRyde 3 місяці тому +1

    Thank you Virginia, you are right! I never considered the placement of text on the left. Thank you!!! Russ

  • @areyoufit9047
    @areyoufit9047 3 місяці тому +1

    Past few months I’ve been doing your 3rd option which is simply taking a pic from the video I just made. I’ve also been placing on right side to make room for words on left side. You mentioned UA-cam puts stuff on right side which I never thought about. I try to limit words from Mr beast tutorials. And NEVER say the same thing in thumbnail and title. Good stuff in this video

  • @lasuretv
    @lasuretv 26 днів тому

    Kudos to you for jumping on every day! I’m playing around with 2-3 times per week to get in a routine. Then I can adjust from there.

  • @heyjasminek
    @heyjasminek 3 місяці тому +2

    Im glad UA-cam is moving from the over the top expressive thumbnails & getting simpler

  • @pureandcoco
    @pureandcoco 3 місяці тому +2

    Your videos are so helpful, I just binged 3 or 4 just now. Thank you!

  • @AaarBokTV
    @AaarBokTV 2 місяці тому +1

    "Thank you, Virginia. Your tutorial has been a huge help for someone like me who is just starting out. Among all the tutorials about thumbnails, I found yours the most enlightening." watching from philippines.

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  2 місяці тому

      That’s great to hear they were easy to follow and use! Congratulations on your new adventure!❤️

  • @AchievingPotential
    @AchievingPotential 2 місяці тому +1

    Hi Virginia, your sincerity comes through in your videos. You’ve gained a subscriber. I’m a senior nurse looking to start a channel. Thanks

  • @grandmabente123
    @grandmabente123 15 днів тому +1

    a few days ago I watch this... used it and it works wonders... found out how to do thumbnails from video itself... and ad text... am using Premier Pro for editing ... THANK YOU FOR ADVISE... also the other video on uploading .. you adviced to upload with the actual title of the video... great... makes sense THANK YOU... now I need to learn how to both voice over and to just comment keeping orinal sound... HOW TO ?????

    • @freelancingsmartitinstitute
      @freelancingsmartitinstitute 5 днів тому

      Boost your UA-cam Channel`s visibility and grow your audience with my expert SEO services! 📢
      Optimize titles, tags, and descriptions for maximum reach.
      🔥 Get discovered, gain subscribers, and watch your views soar!
      ⭐ Start today and transform your channel!

  • @therealmellooner9298
    @therealmellooner9298 2 місяці тому +1

    Thank you Virginia. I'm coming back here when my Channel explodes to thank you personally!!!

  • @yolandawhitejohnsonphd
    @yolandawhitejohnsonphd 3 місяці тому +1

    I'm an overthinker for sure. But your videos are definitely helping me to move through the video making and posting process faster. I hate making thumbnails and I have to admit it took up way too much of my time. I use Canva and have a free pro account as an educator. Going to definitely start using that screenshot method and 4 words or less!👍

  • @Woven_n_Yarn
    @Woven_n_Yarn 24 дні тому

    Thankyou so much. Your tutorials are really easy to follow and straight to the point. I've come to a halt unfortunately, but after viewing your videos, I've now gone through all my reels etc and back on track! Thankyou so much :)

  • @OptimalTrainingGroup
    @OptimalTrainingGroup Місяць тому

    Young lady, you have made my world so much easier. I didn't know it was so easy to create thumbnails, especially for Instagram. I always wondered about that. Thank you soo much!!

  • @benjaminthorp2208
    @benjaminthorp2208 3 місяці тому +1

    Impressive Virginia and super helpful. I recently started a channel and struggle with overcomplicating everything. Thanks for what you do!

  • @fishonlinecanada
    @fishonlinecanada 3 місяці тому +1

    Awesome job! Useful and fast moving information. I have tried a 30 days challenge on an other channel, where I uploaded a short everyday for thirty days. What time do you upload your videos?

  • @moniquelemaire5333
    @moniquelemaire5333 Місяць тому +1

    I made a bunch of thumbnails on Canva, haven't made a video yet!!!
    How do I put the thumbnail onto the video itself. Is it when the video is uploaded???
    Still trying to figure it out before I do anything else 😉.
    Thanks again and God bless 🙏.
    Miss Monique 🙂 🙏 🌷 💗

  • @FrugalFishkeeping
    @FrugalFishkeeping 3 місяці тому

    I just discovered your channel and, so far, am both learning and getting inspired. I stepped away from my channel for a year and am starting it up again. Your videos are just what I needed. Thank you!

  • @sarafrancesca
    @sarafrancesca 8 днів тому

    Just starting to challenge myself to post 1 video a day for a year!!! 🎉 will start Dec 1 😊 and use your tips for thumbnails !

  • @Sadia_AustralianJourneys
    @Sadia_AustralianJourneys Місяць тому

    YOU ARE AMAZING!!! you have no idea how much you are helping other people.

  • @Myperspective1802
    @Myperspective1802 3 місяці тому

    Your videos are now helping me generate titles much easier, and now the thumbnails. I feel confident I will start growing my channel from zero. Thank you ❤❤

  • @intentionaltom9447
    @intentionaltom9447 Місяць тому

    Virginia I love you so much right now! You just saved me so much time! I had know idea my iPhone had that feature of removing the background so quickly. What a time saver!

  • @earthangel6858
    @earthangel6858 Місяць тому

    This was actually quick and easy advice! Haven' t seen anyone else give such great options! Thank you!

  • @CrafteewithAmandaJane
    @CrafteewithAmandaJane Місяць тому

    I love how I learn things in every one of your videos. Thank you!

  • @cleanwithcharm
    @cleanwithcharm 3 місяці тому

    I struggle with showing emotion on my face in photos, I'll have to practice and definitely going to make my template today on canvas. Thank you

  • @SomniSol
    @SomniSol Місяць тому

    Wow, thank you so much for sharing how to quickly create a thumb nail. I didn't know that there were programs that automatically remove the backgrund. I once sat on Photoshop for 2 to 3 hours to crop out my face for a thumbnail 😁. What's also very admirable about you is how you get most important things straight to the point!

  • @TalesKraft
    @TalesKraft 2 місяці тому

    Thanks Virginia for this free masterclass. You're good❤

  • @rgyoho
    @rgyoho 26 днів тому

    Thanks for the tips. Best UA-cam advice I've found anywhere!

  • @hajiranankoma4255
    @hajiranankoma4255 3 місяці тому

    Thank you so much for educating us ,I'm a new creator and have been struggling with thumbnails so much

  • @travelbookingo
    @travelbookingo Місяць тому

    Thanks for nice explanation for new channel !

  • @YuniPalmer
    @YuniPalmer 3 місяці тому

    Thank you Virginia, I have been struggling with creating the thumbnails, you made this sound so easy.

  • @DiamondW.H876JA
    @DiamondW.H876JA Місяць тому

    Thank You for sharing these great tips with us 🌹🙏🏾💙

  • @wendydashwood7879
    @wendydashwood7879 2 місяці тому +1

    Hi Virginia. I have a QUESTION: as an artist I am more attracted by a thumbnail with a lovely artwork than the face of the artist. Would thumbnails showing a finished artwork work too? plus I'm in my 60s and don't always look great in fotos! 😢😂

  • @normajeanplusone9772
    @normajeanplusone9772 Місяць тому

    So glad I came across your channel . I need all the help I can get. Thanks for sharing

  • @tresseyadams
    @tresseyadams Місяць тому

    You had my attention at thumbnails in 5 minutes because it can take me hours, days even and still my thumbnails are "ok". One point you shared about using your space as backdrops for the thumbnails, brilliant. What your process for making them look as though you are part of the image and not an add-in? This is an issue I am running into. Thanks.

  • @HEISTMANDAFOE
    @HEISTMANDAFOE Місяць тому

    thank you for this...very information...and you weren't annoying...straight to the point...I rocks wit it💪🏾

  • @crowdvibesJH
    @crowdvibesJH 2 місяці тому

    I'm loving the validation from your video. I literally just created a thumbnail template in Canva this weekend. I probably didn't choose the best font and have too many words, but it's on brand and we're experimenting. Thanks for sharing what you've learned. 🌺🤙

  • @PlantingDiversity
    @PlantingDiversity 3 місяці тому

    Thank you so much ☺️ I’m a new channel and was struggling to know what facial expressions to use on my thumbnails ✨

  • @SmartStockMoves
    @SmartStockMoves Місяць тому

    Thanks for the tips might try it for my next video

  • @ysabeltabernerphoto
    @ysabeltabernerphoto 2 місяці тому

    You are great!! I will be doing my next thumbnail like this!!!

  • @johnsartmaterialguidestuto7757
    @johnsartmaterialguidestuto7757 Місяць тому

    Loving the tip Virginia. You are sooooo much help!

  • @righteousriverfishinginoregon7
    @righteousriverfishinginoregon7 Місяць тому

    Your advice is on point and I'm learning alot.

  • @Theinsightfulgentleman2024
    @Theinsightfulgentleman2024 24 дні тому

    Thank you today im going to attempt to make a good thumbnail for my next video

  • @balrojmusic
    @balrojmusic 3 місяці тому

    I'm loving your hacks, Virginia, thank you and God bless!!!

  • @addylaingg
    @addylaingg Місяць тому

    This is great! I'm going to be using these tips for sure! Thank you!

  • @SavvySelf-Publishing
    @SavvySelf-Publishing 22 дні тому

    I can't wait to improve my thumnails!

  • @performancephysicaltherapy143
    @performancephysicaltherapy143 Місяць тому

    Very helpful video with practical tips. Easy to do, hard to perfect! Also, hard to be patient enough to get enough data to know how to course correct. I will be watching your other videos (this is only my second video, but it is def worth watching!) Bravo!

  • @Ridgelysradar
    @Ridgelysradar 3 місяці тому

    So helpful! Love how your videos are keeping it simple & easy.

  • @DonLPrice
    @DonLPrice 7 днів тому

    Excellent as always!

  • @denisethomas718
    @denisethomas718 2 місяці тому

    Thank you, your suggestions have been very helpful ❤

  • @LifelFinanceRealEstate
    @LifelFinanceRealEstate 2 місяці тому

    Very informative video. Thx for sharing your expertise!

  • @Taragraceruiz
    @Taragraceruiz 3 місяці тому

    You’re doing a great job of being consistent & so relevant! Way to go! Keep it up! We’re loving it & cheering for you, while working on our own! 💪🏆

  • @scottmoa
    @scottmoa Місяць тому

    You’re brilliant! Thank you!

  • @MyTimeInChrist
    @MyTimeInChrist 3 місяці тому

    Wow I just found your videos yesterday and been binge watching ever since. The say is true. When the student is ready the teacher will appear. Your videos has helped me so much. I’ve been wondering about the video file name when you upload to UA-cam but wasn’t sure. Thanks.

  • @LoveGuruBlaire
    @LoveGuruBlaire 11 днів тому

    Super helpful! Just found your channel and you're rockin' it out! Some things are super obvious, but I appreciate hearing them so I don't have to do the mental figurings myself and just fast track my success. THANK YOU!

    • @freelancingsmartitinstitute
      @freelancingsmartitinstitute 5 днів тому

      Boost your UA-cam Channel`s visibility and grow your audience with my expert SEO services! 📢
      Optimize titles, tags, and descriptions for maximum reach.
      🔥 Get discovered, gain subscribers, and watch your views soar!
      ⭐ Start today and transform your channel!

  • @colleenforcier
    @colleenforcier 3 місяці тому

    I am really loving these videos. I haven't started my channel yet, but with this series I have already scripted 4 videos and plan on recording very soon.

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  3 місяці тому

      That’s HUGE!!! planning is so important! Congrats!🎊

  • @JusOleHutch
    @JusOleHutch 3 місяці тому

    Good stuff, as a newbie, I am taking plenty of notes from your videos. Thank you.

  • @krishna_blossommiinds
    @krishna_blossommiinds 2 місяці тому +1

    I have been optimising both video files and of course uploading both. But struggling to get views while subscription is moving at snails speed.😌

  • @tigersbudgetingcashstuffin4573
    @tigersbudgetingcashstuffin4573 3 місяці тому

    I have been racking my brain about thumbnails and you made that so simple thanks great job 👍 👏 🙌

  • @SkyVsMama
    @SkyVsMama 3 місяці тому

    I would love to know how you make a template in Canva for the thumbnail. I've been watching all your recent videos. I'm trying to get my channel up and going again. I love all the info. Thank you so much! 💜

  • @Jackiesharonhill
    @Jackiesharonhill 2 місяці тому

    Great value Virginia! Thank you ❤

  • @Gaming-Enthusiast
    @Gaming-Enthusiast 3 місяці тому

    Great informative video , you are a massive inspiration to us smaller creators 👍👍

  • @anewlifeinthevan
    @anewlifeinthevan Місяць тому

    Really brilliant advice, thank you ❤

  • @BlessingJohansson
    @BlessingJohansson 2 місяці тому

    Amazing video it's been 7 months for me, and I am enjoying the journey slowly. Its also yo set your mind in the reason why you started a channel, if you burn ypurself for growth UA-cam can dissapoint you but if ypu focus on creating content that you enjoy, the algorithm will find ypu itself. Keep on creating, and I am doing the same ❤

  • @BebaCalvert
    @BebaCalvert 3 місяці тому

    Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge. ❤

  • @PatriciaMuirMaestroQ
    @PatriciaMuirMaestroQ Місяць тому +1

    @Virgina. Thank you for this valuable and timely nudge to overhaul the rather boring thumbnails that I create for UA-cam and LinkedIn posts.
    My biggest takeaway is, "Don't use the title of the video on the thumbnail!"
    Your advice helped me finally decide to stop including my guests' headshots on my thumbnails. I have been including my guests' photos to promote them as well. It's taking up valuable real estate, and there's no return on the investment on all the work I put into customizing to include the guest.
    I noticed that you do not change your podcast thumbnail for each episode. I am going to embrace this time-saving best practice as well.
    Could you please comment on the use of intro/outro screens? There seem to be very different opinions and contradictory advice, particularly on the intro. You might have created a video on this topic already, but I cannot find it at the moment.

  • @FrancheskaS
    @FrancheskaS 3 місяці тому +1

    Makes sense 🤔 Thank you for sharing

  • @CPAHallTalk
    @CPAHallTalk Місяць тому

    Thank you. Very helpful. My thumbnails have far too many words.

  • @OnHamsteadHill
    @OnHamsteadHill Місяць тому

    Great video! Very helpful content.

  • @Kathykels
    @Kathykels 2 місяці тому

    Hey I did what you said… changed my thumbnail and minimised text to 4 words and doubled my views overnight!!! Thankyou. I’m subscribing to you!

    • @ThisIsVirginiaKerr
      @ThisIsVirginiaKerr  2 місяці тому +1

      That’s amazing!!!!!! Congratulations!!

    • @Kathykels
      @Kathykels 2 місяці тому

      @@ThisIsVirginiaKerr I’m a new utuber finding my way. Thankyou for your info. I’ll keep working on it

  • @rubylimey7614
    @rubylimey7614 2 місяці тому

    Thank you for sharing.... Small youtuber here. I'm a senior n this is work🙆 I have a LOT to learn😆😆😂

  • @edredBryan
    @edredBryan Місяць тому

    Hi Virginia, thanks a million for sharing! I'm trying to decide between resurrecting my old channel or starting a new one and thumbnails were asuch a chore. Ques: Regarding Canva, are you using the free or paid version? I was wondering if the "remove the background feature" is available in the free version. Thanks again. Peace and blessings.

  • @DoubleDeeeZSlings
    @DoubleDeeeZSlings Місяць тому

    Thank you for this video!

  • @KirbyEnthusiast
    @KirbyEnthusiast 3 місяці тому

    Great upload, very informative.
    You are a massive inspiration to us smaller creators 👍👍👍

  • @kristenwilliams9123
    @kristenwilliams9123 3 місяці тому +1

    wow! Thank you!

  • @Melliottfineart
    @Melliottfineart Місяць тому

    I can’t process the info as fast as you say it! Lol do you have a more detailed slower version of using Instagram for thumbnails? Love the info

  • @gratitudeprayers
    @gratitudeprayers Місяць тому

    Great tips & thanks for this video

  • @RotterStudios
    @RotterStudios Місяць тому

    LOVE YOUR CHANNEL. You've grown a lot since I subbed. Congrats!

  • @The_Travelling_Tradesman
    @The_Travelling_Tradesman 3 місяці тому

    Very helpful content. THANK YOU!

  • @maxstone9999
    @maxstone9999 Місяць тому

    Great video with good tips. The topic itself is also important. You can make the best thumbnail and title but if the video idea is "episode X of super Mario brothers" there is just too much competition for that topic. I'm running into that issue and I know I have to try to figure out better ideas.

  • @Penfriendrocks
    @Penfriendrocks 2 місяці тому

    I've recently been despairing about my thumbnails. They *seem* fine, but my videos aren't being shown widely...so *something* is up! I don't make advice videos, so I know it's always going to be a bit harder, but still...273 videos in I sometimes feel like it's a waste of time. I'm going to keep watching your videos and trying your suggestions, and just wanted to say thanks again for all this wonderful advice.

  • @chineyeonyeka
    @chineyeonyeka 2 місяці тому

    These are really helpful tips thank you ❤

  • @mikestewart4733
    @mikestewart4733 3 місяці тому

    great information...and great series! Love this.

  • @RonOnTheGrill
    @RonOnTheGrill 2 місяці тому

    This is one I find tough to navigate as a food channel. I know what what gets the click for me is the best-looking photo of the dish or food item I'm looking to make. But all the biggest creators in my channel kinda do their thumbnails the same way. It's a picture of them smiling and holding or pointing at the dish, most of the time. I definitely get the need for facial recognition, but I'm often torn between putting that same old big smile holding holding a plate of food style thumbnail and just trying to make a really great looking thumbnail of the food with text that helps grab the viewer. I was excited about the new thumbnail testing feature because I thought it would help me figure out which kind works better, but it's been kind of random. Often it's too close to call, even.