The creation of modern India and Pakistan, explained
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 сер 2017
- The creation of India and Pakistan, explained
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
We dont hate each other.We are made to hate other.
Smith The Dark Angel thanks but we r happy as a Pakistani
Correct
Waiting to see this day
sayd al hind P learn from the west they don't war with each other they play sports with each other and break barriers not put them up..that's y they are the developed world and u live in the 3rd world with ur small mentality.
Ali Asad FS : No, once Kashmir, Hyderabad and Junagarh is part of Pakistan, this region will be peaceful.
Funny how no one will blame Britishers for this in the comment section.
Akshay Sheth I will
Akshay Sheth nope Indians will blame Pakistanis and vice versa it's sad
Because as shocking as it may sound many Hindus and Sikhs preferred British rule over Islamic rule.
Ya that's why they were fighting for Independence from the British.
@Akshay, what goes around, comes around! British played huge role in dividing India and see now Scotland seeks freedom from UK! They break up some one else house and 70 years on their own house is on verge of break up! Your deeds always back to you!
We must not fight each other. No matter what religion, nationality or caste we belong to, we are all humans...
Muhammad Hasan, there r another 20 crore people in pakistan who don't think it so
Yeah......thats y... U need dfrnt country.
First, not true. I had a chance to see propaganda on both sides. Indian propaganda is crazy extreme. Its like a constant war drum in everything you watch.... I'm not saying that there isn't pakistani propaganda... Regardless, Its not helping either side. We could easily build bridges by just changing the tone of media dialogue.
Indeed buddy 👍
Right All Indians must unite
The long and short of it is that Kashmir was deliberately left ambiguous by the English.
Absolutely not, Kashmir was an independent kingdom with it's own Maharaja who had the option to choose to join India, Pakistan, or remain independent. After Pakistan started sending over armed insurgents into Kashmir to topple the Maharaja so that he didn't end up choosing India (He was a Hindu, so they were very concerned that he would out of religious allegiance), the Maharaja retaliated by requesting the Indian military for help in pushing back terrorists from infiltrating his kingdom. He chose to join India. Ironically, he might have chosen to stay independent, and there was indication that he would, had Pakistan not jumped the gun and decided that terrorism was the appropriate response to democratic process. The Indian army pushed back against Pakistan and regained 2/3 of the territory, and that became the modern day division of Kashmir - 2/3 remains with India, 1/3 with Pakistan.
The second war was literally started for the same reason. I'm not making this up you can verify these facts incredibly easily. India had just lost a war to China in 1962, so Pakistan was convinced that they were weak and could not fight back. In 1965 Pakistan launched 40 000 armed (non-military aka terrorist) insurgents into Kashmir for round 2. They codenamed this plan "Operation Gibraltar" to refer to the Muslim invasion of Spain that was launched from the port of Gibraltar.
There are more conflicts that follow the same pattern - Pakistan launches an invasion of Kashmir, pretends that it's just rebels and not Pakistani military, get's called out when internal documents and organizational plans leak, the UN has to intervene and negotiate a ceasefire because the Pakistanis are on the brink of losing a war they started.
So you tell me what is ambiguous about the situation in Kashmir? The Independent Maharaja of Kashmir chose to join India, Pakistan decided that territory mattered more than democracy, tried to annex Kashmir, India interfered and pushed them back.
i think englsih was culprit but jinnah and neheru is much to blame that why they arranged seperation in that way?? who flamed the fire of sepration??
@@desidark1243 You talk too much kid. Plz read carefully what he wrote. British gave princely states the right to join either Pakistan or India with a purpose. They knew that Kashmir gonna become a problem with muslim majority and a hindu king. It would become a dispute so that Britishers can sell weapons to both countries and make money.
@@desidark1243 Whenever you wanna have a debate on Kashmir, let me know.
@Random Videos Kashmiri Pundit problem happened after 1990.
🤔Strange how all the worlds problems somehow always lead back to the British
The English*. Ireland and Scotland want no part of it and have been opressed by England just as much here.
You mean always leads back to religion
The people don't hate each other but the Zionist Jews always find a way to divide people
@@ckbs1 'Ireland and Scotland want no part of it'? Are you off your silly little head? The Scots were the most ardent colonisers. The East India Company was pretty-much a Scots-ran enterprise. Scots are up to their armpits in Empire.
Strange how Jews always project there misdeeds on to others
It would be great if we could create a alliance like EU of india, pakistan, Bangladesh, nepal and Bhutan...open border, open trades etc....we were never supposed to be divided...but we cant reunite also because we have 70 years of history now...and we all take pride on our countries' names....all our countries are like different part of the same puzzle....all we need to do is glue them the way they were supposed to be.....
Rohit singh Great Idea. But our elders won't do it it's on us young generation of the subcontinent. I am Pakistani BTW.
I doubt Indian or Nepal would wish to take on the mess that is Pakistan
+Rohit singh.....we can clearly see the difference in the mindset of young generation. the previous 2 generations purely hated each other but many in the current generation wants a reunion because they can see a bright future if the reunion happens. mostly because the current generation are educated and are aware of the history we had together.
but the problem is, many are not openly admitting this out of ego. like if we take the example of you tube, if someone commented positive, the replies following will be positive but in middle a negative comment appears and all the following comments turns negative. so the main problem is the ego. but a reunion is possible in the future maybe 50-100 years because the only possible way for us to remain strong in the competitive future is a reunion.
Exactly this is what I was thinking
sayd al hind P okay, genius tell me this, the subcontinent was divided with religious point in mind but why was Kashmir left alone in this process...Not to mention it is in the middle of both these huge countries!?
Why a million people have to suffer because of one stupid person drawing wrong lines all over India...
The Truth, have you ever studied it or just watched this idiotic video.
My guess is you know less than the dim-wit who made this video.
India wouldn't even be one country if it weren't for the British.
LightShadow 49 But Pakistan's land is so valuable. It gives a much needed border with Iran and Afghanistan, who are important allies of India and it is part of incredibly valuable potential trade routes. Pakistan is just terrible at using its position.
Uh no. Based on historical fact that India was not one country before British rule. Without Britain expanding so quickly, the southern states would have remained independent from the north. Also, the north eastern provinces would not be India.
"India" was not a state before 1947. It was the British Raj
India and Pakistan didn’t fight for Bangladesh
India supported Bangladesh
Bangladeshis fought for their country
Sacrificed their blood
Then India stole their land after Bangladesh was made. the land where shrilong is
incorrect Bangladesh was given there land they didn't fight for It they had no man power to fight.
@@jayspeople7854 do some study. India and then USSR helped Bangladesh in international politics. Indian army trained our mukti bahinis. The war of independent started 26th of march, and finished at 16th December 71. Among the whole 9 month of war, Indian army directly engaged in the war just 2 months before the war finished.
@@SalvaDoppel There isn't any land named Shrilong. You just made it up. And secondly, India didn't take any Bangladeshi land in the 1971 war. Stop spreading misinformation.
A gross over-simplification, but I guess that's the best you could do in 5 minutes.
Joseph Yang io
Division of India is like what would happen if Manchuria is separated from South China.
Murari Kaushik Unnecessary man. Unnecessary. We should work on building bridges not burning them.
How so? It was simple divide and conquer. Same recipe was used in Somalia
Ohios Finest ... I've read some of the history ... definitely divide and conquer but also much more complicated ...doing readings, I encountered this statement (paraphrased): the greatest accomplishment of colonial rule was the edifice of institutionalized intellectual discourse used to convince the colonized that they had no history and were intrinsically barbaric, uncontrollably religious and inferior to the colonizer. --- Talking to my father who lived in colonial india, his stories of education in british indian schools was very very enlightening.... the real nuance is in how the British institutionalized this colonial education system that eventually led to the Hindu Muslim split.
I cried while watching. Britishers Stabbed us and broke us into pieces. God will not forgive them. I Love India and also love Pakistan and Bangladesh. But I surely hate those politician who are still using the divide and rule policy.
me same jinnah and neheru is much to blame ,so much lives lost ,why ,u make what ever u want but why peopel pay their lives for nothing. it simply does not go into my head .
They don't believe in your god anyway so we all know nothing will happen to them.
India was not United before British. British left india more united
Thta is now uselss to think but i cannot imagine why and how so much millionpeople would be displaced and move romone disde to another and million also killed, zinnah and neheru equaly faulty and responsible for it, land is for the people but if million of thousands dies what for is land needed, i reject it .,thpse leaders was in ill thought.british was a;ways criminal but that is something else in this case.
@Seerat J i think you should confess directly and bluntly that partition in that way was meaningless,it could divide much later as happend between pakistan and bangladesh if needed but in that way of millions displaced migrated and millionslost their lives? i would never do that ,u stills hould remmber that inindi alives mor emuslim 300 milion than in bangladeshor paksitan ,solearn to respect a life it is after allmuslim lives were lost too. one india was beterat that time partion in that way is not acceptable but may be god allahwanted so happened but we should bot support that in that way like self fish bcz we had to respect those lives as like ours was.thanks
Factually incorrect storytelling. Jinnah changed his views after 1929 when he gave his 14 Points. He wanted a united sub-continent before that
Don't forget his opposition to satyagraha
A united sub continent would have 1.7 billion people it would be nearly 25% of humanity. That is simply too many ppl. Also, we are already poor if there was more violence it just make the region even more poorer.
Yeah right after Lahore party meet
i think there should more than 25% of total humanity living there if partitiion didnt happened becuase during migration million of people died and got homeless
Wait but if he wanted a United subcontenet why didn't it happen? Jinnah was the only opposition right?
"If you wondered what Indians were doing at Dunkirk, now you know.. " 😂
A very well made video. At the end, I was like " I just watched Master piece"
We've not hated each other. There has been numerous ups and downs in our relationship, that's it.
My reaction is the same whenever some firanghi says "you people hate eachothers" *sighs*
Rahul Kumar we hate u
We not hate each other...
But we always fooled by British's Divide and Conquor....
Just because you don't,doesn't mean that we don't.
@MR. Right We hate each other on our lands but get united when we are in other countries . Migrant Indians and Pakistanis reside together on foreign lands .
We are brothers
But fight for no reason😢
Great video. Got my A-Levels tomorrow and this is one of the core topics, it is way easier to understand the topic with this video. Thank you!
The only Al jajeera video report i ever liked.
raw Lemon lol same here
Mohammed Ali jinnah was the greatest leader ever in the history of this world he created a new country for the oppress minority
Aren't Hindus oppressed???
@@Abhi-gx4lj I as a Muslim can say Jinnah was a deciever of the Masses same as Savarkar both hungry for power .
If these countries can rally behind each other imagine how powerful they will become ! Not under one flag ( these are too proud nations to give up their flags) but for the idea of prosperity, brotherhood and uniting the people who were only divided because of British policies.
No thanks. We don't need Pakistan. We are already quite powerful, getting Pakistan will add only a little more power. And besides we will lose more in feeding that debt ridden country.
Emperor Penguin funny how you speak for more than 1 billion people....
marathas ar no goood ,they do not want the best o south asia .If indi awa s governed by bengalees it was much peaceful and beter
h are not just divided because of British policy we are divided because we are different it was our leaders who came up with the two nation theory
we did not left because we hated the hindu we left because we feared them and boy we were correct the way they treat us there is terrible
we have our flaws and stuff but the freedom is everything
my people almost the majority doesnt want to mirge with them
@@nashearehman4279 it was not good in that way wheer milions died and displaced, i cannot even imagine how that decision came those leaders,well british has planted teh seed of haterd and division by ginving one groeup privilage to make their vile policy sucessful but that never shuld have happened .a life is very precious and tahtthey should understand
I am glad my grandparents shifted to east pakistan Dhaka Bangladesh from India in 1947 (leaving all property behind) I am thankful to them. love west pakistan 🇧🇩🇵🇰
What do you mean by glad! No one wanted partition
How many bangla woman raped by pakistani soldiers.. Can you pleas tell me
the brits will one day pay for this!!
Im so proud, Nepal is not in that mess.
Yes, Because Brave Nepali Gurkhas decided to work for British and shoot at Innocent women and kids when commanded.. Like they did at Jallianwalabagh Massacre ! This is why British exchanged Freedom to Nepal in exchange for being their slave.
"not in that mess?" nepalis are still here 😂😂 hamari har gali nukkar mein noodles bechtey hain 😂😂 yeah! you should be proud of that!
Ajay Kunwar ya good for you🤭
daljinder moten don't bring occupation here. You don't feel shame in bullying people by their jobs. Your citizens comes to nepal for job and our people goes to your country. And I'm not mentioning types of jobs your people do in our country because I respect people and their jobs.
MelodicNostalgic ya and you forgot that when our students used to go india and study there they supported mahatma gandhi and marched against British and they were imprisoned by them and after india got freedom our people brought various reforms in our system. But you are talking about nepal helping British for wars only because you couldn't digest the fact that nepal was never ruled by any country.
Imagine the Indian subcontinent together.. How strong we will be..✌
no need
@@sirat_ul_jannah57 yeah we are different people with different religon so no need
Thank you very much for making this video! It really helped me with my school presentation. A lot of good facts in this video. Thank you!
......so basically, White people happened to India.
Classic.
The frensh made the same promesses to their colonies and broke them, and used same tactics. Not a coincidence for sure !
Guys let’s just blame the guy who didn’t draw the border properly
How sad and sorrowful is that!
How sedition and division can truly destroy the peace and identity of a country that has always proven able to welcome different religions and ideology and keep the harmony between them!
People do know that before the British came India wasn't united, right?
Alpha india was united
Depends on the century you're talking bout. India was United a lot of times. Sometimes it was stretched till Combodia and south east asia like in Ashoka Empire and sometimes it was stretched till Afghanistan in West like in the Mughal Empire.
However there were thousands of indigenous groups having 100 of diff. names of this One Country.
Search for chanakya's akhand bharat and king ashoka before that. Also watch crash course world history channel where it is mentioned that one of the first recorded human civilization was the indus vally civilization and how india kept out the mongols and romans later on.
@@snowmoon7385 Who was he then?Oh yeah a Afghan
Does your history begin in the 17th century?? There have been many empires that united India throughout history. Check the Mauryan empire map. It was spread across the whole sub-continent including Afghanistan and even parts of Iran.
"didn't finish his job though , he didn't draw the line for Kashmir", the video is a joke .. dude it was one among many other princely states ,which had the right to either remain independent , join India or join pakistan . An excellent example of fact checking by a very "respectable and esteemed "news channel ..
What about haidrabad then?
Abhinav Sood What about Hyderabad and junagadh and Goa! Which you Indians invaded
well when maharaja hari singh acceded to india , its written in the "instrument of accesion " that kashmiris will be given a chance for referendum , thats what we kashmiris demand , referendum tu choose between india pakistan or independent nation , we want an independent nation ,
yessssssssssssssssssss and they missed the whole ALLABAD address and what not
AGAIN ALL THINGS THEY ROUTINELY KNEW WOULD HAPPEN. THERE IS NO TRANSFER OF POWER IN THE MOST IMPORTANT OF AREAS!!!!
It sounds funny when someone says we are different.
Punjabis live in both India and Pakistan.
Bengalis live in both India and Bangladesh.
And this comes from an Indian Bengali.
I get where you're coming from but this is a little simplified isnt it? For e.g, punjabis in current day india are a small part of the north. Punjabis in Pakistan are a majority. The ethnic makeup is different overall, but that doesn't mean they can't all get along.
This was the best summary I've ever seen - I hope the people and leaders of today are able keep their differences aside and re-unite these wonderful heavily embroided nations with deep rooted traditions of immense variations.
Even after all done and said .
After 1947, Indian leaders still made it a secular state.
Haha what a joke
@@HassanAli-qx2yu Tera baap is a joke!
@@warnpassion haha endians
@Akansha what is humanity in your oponion
This was an unbiased perspective, well made video.
This channel is biased... There wasn't any promise of freedom made by british before the great war.
simply and clearly explained, thank you Al jazeera.
you made my life soo easy..thanks
Correction: Radcliffe didn't draw a line for all princely states (including Kashmir) because the princely states were sort of autonomous. India and Pakistan also gained Independence in the midnight between the 14th of August and the 15th of August. India did not gain independence a whole day later. Both countries just choose to celebrate independence on different days
That last sentence hits hard
It's not People hate people, it's government hate government
Yeah think so
This video forgets that the lahore resolution didn't occur until 1940. And even jinnah was reluctant to produce a separate state . The fact it that Nehru wanted a very powerful central government and people were weary of that .
but the plan to ask for a seperate state was given in 1930 and it was by iqbal
like they complete missed it we all pakistan IQBAL KA KHAWAB
For a change, I liked this one. Proper reporting without playing with our emotions or taking sides.
I love being pakistani and I don't hate anyone. Iam thankful to Allah for having free state like Pakistan
This video explained about relationships between India and Pakistan more accurately than my history textbook.
That was emotional yaar
_"I don't believe in taking the right decision. I take a decision and make it right!"_ - *Quaid-e-Azam, Muhammad Ali Jinnah*
It is not the quote of your so called qaide azam....
It is the quote of RATAN TATA...
Muslim league made in Dhaka
Bangali Muslim who make Pakistan!
India freedom from British
Also big contributor is Bangali
Excellent excalty want I needed to know this about my country conflict
Perfect Video Nice observation
we are all THE SAME! we are all HUMAN RACE! ....we must LOVE EACH OTHER & our environment!
"Indian empire" ??? India wasn't an empire at the time; itself was a colony of the British.
In fact the British created both Pakistan & India. Prior WW2 there was no country named "India"; the name "india" was the creation of the British. Before thr British ruled "india" the northern half of it(pakistan included) was rulled by the Persians and it was called "Hindustan". The souther part of the subcontinent was a different country called Dravidia. Thr British joined Dravidia & Hindustan and creayed a new country called "India" which was later further divided to Pakistan & Bangladesh (or as it used be known Eastern Pakistan, & todays Pakistan was known as "Western Pakistan").
Yeah created both Indian and Pakistan by robbing natural resources, killing wildlife, killing indigenous people...
@@chetansingh422 , no one denied that, but "indian empire"??? What a load of garbage to tamper w the history.
@@jaywolf4183 They called it Indian empire
love you aljazeera from India
Facts are debatable,but this video pretty much sums up the story...good job Al Jazeera.
Talk about Baluchistan
They wouldn't coz thats not to their agenda's advantage
Talk about khalistan mate. All in for it
Balochistan is an integral part of Pakistan.
It is an Integral Part of Indus Valley currently occupied by irani kurdish migrants it belongs to Punjabis and Samat Sindhis only
Great presentation. Kudos to Aljazeera for making such a concise and comprehensive video on the important yet highly neglected subject of the diabolical role of British in partitioning India and creating these hatreds that has become such a bane for the people of the sub continent.
I don't consider India, Pakistan and Bangladesh to be separate nations. We are one nation. And I truly believe that the day will come when we all with be united once again. May be not exactly like how we use to be but in some other form. Insha Allah! Jai Hind! Allahu Akbar!
maaz amjad i wish the same
Ritu Paswan don't wish for it again 🙂
We r much more devloped than present pakistan.. our GDP is much more than GDP of pakistan..
We have real metros and they call their buses as metros..
If India and pakistan get United some day then that will cause problem to present Indians coz we have to share whole GDP.. that means pakistanis per capital income will increase and Indias per capital income will decrease
Ritu Paswan Haan u want Pakistan,then we will send u to pakistan.even if they tell us to occupy we wld never,because it act as buffer state between us and Islamic states.
zizasu behera we don't care if it is buffer state or not.. if pakistan joins India back. Then that would create problems in the lives of presentIndians only
we are from Mohenjo-Daro, we are from Indus, we are from India, Indus is india
what the dude said in the end was just epic.
British stopped civil war , after their leave . Great example today's Kashmir , left as it was ....
Well, it all started with the British. They did that in most countries all over the world by colonialism.
Mimi N u mean suthisticated it
I'm from India, and I hope that we and Pakistan become good and friendly neighbors. Love and peace from your neighbor 😘
@MR. Right brother srilanka never actually used to be a part of india never
@MR. Right yeah but never a part of greater hindustan
@MR. Right yeah sure why not
Thanks for this video! It's very informative! 👍
Partition was a blessing in disguise
Not fully factual and 100% correct. Patronising Pakistan's viewpoint only. We know why!!!!!
a2015 tnv28
Dude there no Pakistan or India. We are all part of Hind. All of our people have origins from Indus Valley Civilization and Indus River.
We are the same people.
Just thought I should ask. Which parts were wrong? I am indian, both of us have learned (info and pak) biased history. What did u learn?
Ahmad Jutt yap ur ancestors were Hindus nd buddhists during Maurya and Kushan dynasty.. It is ur pisslam which created mess
I thought first time Al-Jazeera has created video with indian point of view..
How is it patronizing Pakistan's views?
Too early they left us. Under british this land was safe and peAce
Bangladesh wasn't a result of India-Pakistan war. Bangladesh started its own liberation war against Pakistan. India provided shelter to the refugees and in the last 1 month of a 9 months long liberation war, they came in with their military, by when it was already clear that Bangladesh is going to win the war. Stop lying Aljazeera. Know the facts and don't alter history. If you say it in Bangladesh that liberation was a result of Indo-Pak war, you would be beaten to death by people. Because people living in this country know their history better.
Well the topic on music is debatable
Thanks to Allah that He gives Jinnah to Muslim..... He was great Muslim leader.... Jinnah Zindabad
The reason behind 1million deaths.
@@vaibhavsingh3708 He saved 100 millions of people....
@@shahidhassan5881 how
Very interesting video, it's the first time I see both the crimes of the British coloniser in the case of India and also the naivety of some people who was trapped in the ethnic divide british plan.
People who were same but divided deep . That was powerful
History can't be altered.. Be proud of your country and serve your nation..... 😎
1:39 Hindus an Sikhs also fought in WWII, check you facts first.
Actually netaji said no,Gandhi and nehru said yes to fighting in WWII
Jinnah was the SON of DAVIL
Eh I'm a Canadian, and we had the British draw us a border once when the Americas wanted out. Then we had to fight them again after, because it's normal not to be content. After a while I hope that India and Pakistan realize like we did that we have a lot more to gain by cooperation and friendship. Then by the resentments towards each other. I hope that they can appreciate each other, and be the Super Power that help everyone knows that they can be.
Al Jazeera is matchless am on his counterparts over the world. A straight forward, logical and realitistic analysis in just a few minutes, presents it's source ,credibility and nonpartiality.
Love and respect from Pakistan.
We are all one nation we don't hate each other but we love each other so please live in peace.
Always do goodness Never gonna happen
@@Chiefab22 why not?
d4s0n yo just my opinion after all studying History & Politics!!
@@Chiefab22 what?, have you heard of young generations in India/Pakistan? bec it seems they want to improve the relation
d4s0n yo From many Books 📚 📖 I read about History of The British Empire 🇬🇧
what goes around comes around. I feel sorry for Britain. They are goimg to pay for this for thousands of years.
the last sentence speaks volumes
nice work
We don't speak the same as Pakistanis, nor do we eat or dress the same. India is a land of many different ethnicities and cultures. Generalising it would be nothing but insult to this great land. 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Yousaf Awan Sorry but I couldn't understand what you were trying to imply.
Indians and Pakistani's speak the same language. Urdu was spoken in UP and punjab is spoken on both sides of the border. Also Pakistan is home to many cultures, such as punjabi culture, sindhi culture, balochi culture and the culture of the people of KPK particularly of the Chitral district up north
UP and Punjab doesn't represent the whole of India. India is much more than that. India and being Indian means a large number of diverse people cohabiting together and respecting each other's culture. The correct way of describing your point would be by saying "People in Pakistan and some parts of India speak the same language / Pakistanis and some Indians speak the same language."
If there is one country that has no shame in this modern age it is the 'United Kingdom' !
We can also conclude from this that Politics and Leadership is also about seizing the moment in time.
That was enlightening.
Gainers Bangladesh!!
We do look the same
Eat the same
But we have our differences
.
This make me sad but what can I do 😢
The situation is now off the hand brother, many Illiterates will not agree with us.
Can you eat cow beef
Totally agree
jinnah seized opportunity
Vikram Thakur and Nahru accepted...
Vikram Thakur technically Nehru did that too .
He saved us all.If there would not have been partition there won't be more than half of the current people here and also india.And I can't bear living in a secular state by name country under radical lunatics.
Jinnah was a British stooge. He even ate pork and drank alcohol despite claiming to be a Muslim!
@@beastvader yet the plan to leave was not even is it was given first by Iqbal in 1930 and like everyone accepted it
only one,now happy country... Bangladesh
Funny video 420 bangladesh is so successful among three nations .they don’t have religious panic like India 🇮🇳 and Pakistan 🇵🇰 have .everyone is living peacefully and I heard there several opportunities for minorities
Which is impressive
Robi U.K. lol Bangladesh has problem with atheist.
Robi U.K.
Bullshit.
Robi U.K. Yes because they have hero alom JAI HIND JAI INDIA
Funny video 420 Difficult to be happy when you have genocidal Burma on your border.
That is absolutely right that is also happen in Philistine
Nicely said
WTF why didn't this mention Hyderabad which India annexed...
SHAHEER AWAN hyderabad was not Muslim majority. People there wanted to live in India. I am a hyderabadi.
Why it doesn't show balochistan, which pakistan annexed
AFRIDI 1 true kashmir is Muslim majority. Unfortunately Kashmir was not under direct British control and decision was left to maharaja.
The rule was Muslim majority provinces under DIRECT British control were to go to Pakistan. Princely states had their freedom to choose. It's not like Pakistan has claim over all Muslim majority provinces in the entire world is it?
However Pakistan wanted to force the maharaja and sent lashkars from kpk region . This forced maharaja to take Indian protection.
That is why UN said Pakistan and India should withdraw its forces for plebiscite to be held. Pakistan did not withdraw forces at that time despite being the one to start the fight. So plebiscite could not be held
Hence Indian government negotiated with representatives of the kashmiri people in India at the time, Sheik Abdullah who agreed to become part of India with increased autonomy. That's why kashmir is integral part of India. Because we did it the legal fair and transparent manner . We did not send savage tribesmen to get what we want
That's why in 1965 operation Gibraltar of Pak army failed. They tried to make kashmiri people revolt by sending commandos. Kashmiris responded by handing over the commandos to Indian army.
AFRIDI 1 do you even read bruh? Read my comment. Now. Then read it again very slowly. Now go back encyclopedia Brittanica or any neutral source of history and cross verify whatever I have said ( or Google it if your too lazy).
Then go and read about Independence of India act. Go to the provisions regarding princely states. Once you have done that then type comments about me reading up my history. Deal?
PS : Oh since your an afridi I'm assuming your a pathan. So you must be knowing about Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan. The giant among Pashtuns. Go read what he has to say about partition. You might find it interesting.
that is again other thing,we know that,indi a is to blame . and hyderabd also to blame ,thenthe ruler of hyderabad had to join with paksitan and bangladesh but they did not .
Please do your research properly. Several incorrect details all through the video.
Amit Mallick do please cite some instances for us people who don't know this history to better understand it
Karl C out of 1million deaths during partition .7m were moslims.
Kashmir is majority moslims so Mr.Radcliff thought it should be Pakistan but the ruler there was in favour of remaining neutral.
Gandhi preached for peace
The whole video except the Kashmir part is somewhat correct.
oles leo bro u wrong it's decided by Jammu king not British Srinagar under Jammu king
Wrote a letter to India to protect from Pakistan Srinagar is property of Jammu king
I am from jammu
Jai dogra
Jai bharat
Watcher Node There were several other independent states in India under the British Raj such as Mysore Travancore, Rajputana, Tripura and notably, Hyderabad. The Nizam of Hyderabad wanted to remain independent but India annexed it. Pakistan tried to do the same with Kashmir but only could take a third of it.
Maybe it was bound to happen but I hope in future both live in harmony and unity prevails
Ur said correct...
Killings in the Punjab was due to the blunders of Akali leader Tara Singh (master) real name Nank Chand Malhotra.!
Baldev ji mitti pao...aage bado!
Jim Raza bhai it is according to Pak history books
Vishal Mishra's and we assume u r talking from indian history books..
Murmad Man ask the old people if they wanted partition. They say no. Its the younger generation which has been filled with hate even though they never saw partition
Allah will judge on the judgement day.
Kamon achen apni
Yes after 70 years of independence they still fighting , blame the British
What you said at the beginning is exactly the same as the situation in Britain today.
Both are the victim of the invaders..both are indian a noble race who fought against the invader
Both are the race who denounce imperialism of the british.
I hope for the Peace for both country
Pakistan & indian
Hope for a progress for a Peace & better Ally Union
My great grandfather was in India because his cow was pregnant and he told his wife that he would come to Pakistan after the cow gave birth but a Hindu killed him
did ur grandfather make the cow pregnant.....
ankur sharma ,z😂😂😂😂😂😂
were you there or was your great gran there to see it ?, bro dont blame anyone without proof ,maybe he got lost in the chaos, lots did.
Sad.
ankur sharma Thats impossible only uneducated indians like you wont understand
Good work by Al Jazeera
What about Shubas Chandra Bose?
I love my nation Pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Many Indians love Pakistanis as well brother. We just want peace. Your prime minister is trying his best but now we have a stubborn leader.
William S. True brother, we will be peacefully waiting to welcome you to our country and hope you prime leaders understand!
@@abdullahmohammad6803 hope your prime minister understands too
Pakistanis continue to support the talibans, lashkar-e-Taiba, Al Qaeda etc. They continue to infiltrate Indian side of Kashmir and instigate youths into millitancy.. Yes, Imran khan wants peace but he is not all powerful in Pakistan.. Pakistan military won't allow peace.. Don't tag it on Modi.. He's just defending our country.. Enough innocent Indians have already died..
Pakistan should split, half given back to india & the other half back to afghanistan.