broo believe me, imran khan is doing that the whole time but they are just far too powerful. And nobody is blaming india, we know that its the fault of the government, army and police. Everything is so corrupted
@@Parallaxxx28 And here is the living example of why you failed as a citizen of Pakistan, Stable govt = stable economy which provides more investment and less begging for aids
the romans the mongols the macadonian the prussian the german the swedes the russians the japanese the chinesse and many others started the same way .... there is no winter without summer no no pleasure without pain no victory without loss no sunshine without rain remember nothing ever remains the same documentery on the hundred years war the great northen war the second worldwar and golden hordes chinesse history and roman history will show you... i pray may your conqurer show you mercy because you will need it
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_Vehicle All created on purpose and predicted (or denounced) by conservative and anticommunist Larry McDonald (D) Georgia, reason why the plane he was travelling in was downed in 1983 by the Soviets in cahoots with American leftist socialist pro-world government conspirators.
@@aruji-sama here in india government is thinking about getting over Pakistani nukes if pakistan fails .. I dont think Pakistan will collapse that is just too much
@@anonymouskumar3261 Pakistan has evey reason to collapse. There is no sign of them doing anything to get back up. And a country which can't stand on its own stands on someone else's feet. So sure USA China may be able to save them yet again. But it's not possible if no one comes to save Pakistan. Pakistan will become like Mayanmar, Somalia or Yemen. Playground for the big powers. They may not fall like the Soviet union did but they will find their own way to fall.
@@muneebahmed1848 Before Pakistan was created the Indus Valley was a strategic region and launchpad for the British Empire 200 years ago for conducting the Anglo-Afghan wars. This began with the overthrow of King Dost Khan of Afghanistan to prevent Afghanistan forming diplomatic relations (and an eventual alliance) with Russia. The Great Game. Britain created Pakistan to continue the Great Game (U2 pilot Gary Powers takes off from Pakistan, flies over Afghanistan and Central Asia and is shot down over the Soviet Union). The first secretary general of NATO, General Ismay was a veteran of the Anglo-Afghan wars.
Britain created the dysfunctional state of Pakistan as part of an Anglo-Muslim alliance comprising of Turkey, Iran, Iraq [CENTO, SEATO, Baghdad Pact]) to counter the atheist Soviet Union (Ghazwa-e-Rus) and continue Britain's imperial fantasy of The Great Game (renamed as the Cold War). The Royal Grand Indus Army that owns, occupies and ru(i)ns Pakistan maintains Britain's imperial legacy and enforces British messianic ideology (foreign policy) of everlasting hostility towards Russia in Afghanistan and Indus valley for a fistful of $$$ and a few $$$ more. Read: 'The Shadow of the Great Game' by Narendra Singh Sarila; 'Indian Summer: The Secret History of the End of an Empire' by Alex von Tunzelmann and 'The Grand Chessboard' by Zbigniew Brzezinski.
As Shekar Gupta ones said "Pakistan always points a gun at its own head and negotiates with others either to give us money or see what kind of mess I am going to cause here"
It's absolutely true, the only country that has milked it's geography and nuclear ability to the maximum, unfortunately to just benefit the politicians and generals
@@specialnewb9821 even North Korea is not that pathetic. North Korea will leave alone any country that doesn't side with South Korea in it territorial dispute.
@@whentheimposterissus8376 yes. All they did was spewing false narratives and stories to their own people and had the audacity to call it *"Raaa Ki Sajish"* . Because all they can do is spew lies.
@@whentheimposterissus8376 RAW was never offensive. RAW always succeeded because RAW was DEFENSIVE . RAW only defended its Motherland. If anything happened in Pak it was in reality the Boomerang of ISI's deeds.
@@discovermajid not mostly my friend. Entirely. I've verified this claim myself by looking at the number of years served by each PM. Not even a single has 5 years.
Pakistan was created on the basis of religion and not on the basis of a common political, geographical or cultural identity. This leads to uncontrolled religious extremism and terrorism. Despite the best efforts of the West, Pakistan had split into two parts in the past and it will split into many parts again.
Bro,the sunnah of our beloved prophet(P.B.U.H) give us the one of the best political and administral system in the world and inshallah soon we will be able to aply this system in our country with proper laws,where injustice will not exist
Bro its not a joke.We will also give rights to minorities not like the western countries where most of countries baned hijaab and we will also give all rights to women's
@Goodlife-iu6dk 😂😂😂 "we will"... when ? Have you not had enough time to do so in the last 70 years ? In the last 13 centuries ? Criticizing "most western countries that banned hijab" because it's just à male oriented control of women's bodies, and overlooking Pak's (and most Muslim dictatorships) absence of rights for women, gays, jews and other religious minorities, etc....? YOU are the joke.
@@GreenTree-iu6dk yeah the same rights where its written in sahi hadees dat men are allowed to beat their women , and men can consent fully for not consent fully have sax with their wide anytime they want.
But then the really unfortunate statement; " ...the costs of living beginning to outweigh the benefits ( ...of living). This begins to have zuicide connotations
Economics is not a gun. But the philosophical explaining of the production of goods and services in a division of labor society. That explains trade and commerce. How that can you claimed that economics is a gun. Pretending that ecomonic power is political power, is where you go wrong, with such a bad anology. To separate domains. The military is the tool or the guns, politics is who are always pulling the trigger. That is the weapon, war is therefore the natural outgrowth of political discourse. There is no other outcome.
@@moxinghbian Correct 💯. Since the military is the weapon, politicians are who pulls the trigger. All that industry can do is provide the material to support the war effort.
13:00 There is an old saying. "If you owe the bank one hundred dollars and can't repay it, You have a problem. If you owe the bank one million dollars, and can't repay it, The Bank has a problem."
American Dollar collapsing, France ready to handover colonial periods territories to China and Germany facing slowdown economy ??? China is backing Pakistan everywhere. On the other side Democratic India is one of the largest population of beggars, homeless, jobless people. Hate, Discrimination, biased system, crimes against females, caste system and intolerance against minorities etc. etc.
@@only_fair23 what about India? Looks like it’s one of the most dangerous place for women so far, especially doctors and then they would barely get justice. That country has 0 safety for women
@@only_fair23 what about India? Looks like it’s one of the most dangerous place for women so far, especially doctors and then they would barely get justice. That country has 0 safety for women
Pakistan has no geographic boundaries. Some of it is geographically India, some of it is geographically Afghanistan, most of it is Balochistan. The reason for this is that Pakistan is a country based not on geography or territory but on religion.
Umm... We know that... That's literally our ideology, you didn't discover anything new AND we also know that it's not a good idea for a state to be dependent upon one religion and forgetting about others😂
No, they are neither. An example of to dangerous to fail would be China, US, and Russia.... these 3 countries controls the economy now, if anything happens between the 3, the politicians when get rich and the citizens are paying for it
@@svcby ❝ Hindus should not harbour anger against Muslims even if Muslims destroy kill us all. We should face death bravely. If Muslims established their rule after killings Hindus we'd be ushering in a new India.❞ - Mahatma Gandhi (Book: The Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Page 219)
1. Stop dealing in $US 2. Stop blaming India for your issues. See that giant as a trading partner, not an enemy. Fight your battles on the cricket pitch, not with weapons. 3. Support what makes you great. Textiles and motorcycle clothing. 4. Recognise the World Bank/IMF/USA are not your friends and dealing with them will keep you poor. 5. Beware of China. They play a long game.
Not blaming India goes against the narrative Pakistan has created for themselves. They literally cannot take care of their own country, yet they want Kashmir from India and India is the devil for not complying lol.
Idk why every India thinks that an average Pakistani thinks of them as an enemy we don’t we blame our government and army for everything but honestly people in Pakistan are cowards we don’t protest
@@nathanruben-tv5lf how? India's the only non Muslim majority country in the entire world which had four former Muslim presidents and three former Muslim vice presidents. And recent election of India where bjp failed to secure simple majority itself says Indian constitution of equality and justice still stands shove all
Time for the banks to collect the natural resources as collateral and give it to the mining and oil companies they invested in. Which probably was the plan from the very beginning.
Maybe the creditor nations of the world should make forgiving their debts and lending them any more money contingent on them giving up their nuclear weapons.
"As a cricket player, Khan was no stranger to spin" - This is gold. Thank you for the analysis of the crisis in my home country, I look from afar in sadness.
@@apiklala this stupid in-fighting is the reason we are failing. its a slow suicide. we keep fighting our own people, keep holding the gun to our head. but alas theres nothing we can do. our nation is dying, whether you like it or not, and we are all watching it in real time
@@apiklala It's okay man, denial is the first stage. No need for name calling. There is no "we", nobody outside the government bureaucracy is dealing with or solving this on a united front. What have you done?
@@Chico1747 Only the name of India was changed. Earlier there was Bharat and after independence both India and Bharat became official names. The country which was captured by the British was India. You will not find mention of a country called Pakistan anywhere in history.
@@varman001 If you have time to learn rather than watching GODI media you would know what "Independence" means. It means "the fact or state of being independent" In this case Pakistan was Independent from British rule along with India, because Pakistan and India never existed as a same country ever before, it was just a colony of Britain that was united under force.
Even at the height of crisis, there are no signs of fundamental change in Pakistan's policies. They could've prospered had they engaged positively with neighbours and giving religion a backseat.They fought 4 unnecessary wars with India without any substantial gains, supported mujahideen fighters in Afghanistan and later helped Taliban to wreck havoc in that country,still supporting separatist forces and terrorist groups clandestinely to foment troubles in neighbouring countries.Just imagine the amount of money they had spent all these years for such unscrupulous acts. Pakistan itself is responsible for its downfall.
@@Sobanhassan1761 worry for ur existence bro Who knows before india would make it's move ur existence as a country would be in danger from ur internal enemies 😂😂
"Economics is the gun but politics is knowing when to pull the trigger." "Not long before the cost of living outweighs the benefits." "Given Pakistan's nuclear arsenal, some might find it too big to fail, but its foreign debt is too big for it to succeed." "Debt that can't be repaid, won't be repaid." The word wizardry in this video is arguably your best ever.
More like a narrative building effort to Salvage of whatever Pak will be left. Since sympathy card lost its validity post Covid, the last card that Pakistan has is that of N blackmail. Host Shirvan has on most occasions been very generous to Pak in previous documentaries too.. no surprise. This video seems for global creditors mind making purpose.
@@fluxacadmey5836 Maybe the first sentence a little bit. But rest are far from RSS. Modi lifted 150+ Million People Out Of Poverty In A Decade. Your kaum will achieve in 2070 as much which is probably the least of what RSS has achieved for India.
@@fluxacadmey5836 bhai academy ka spelling thik karle pehle aur ha vese rss se compare na kar vo bas ek religious organisation hai unko itna seriously lena bhi nhi
@@josecipriano3048 just because that man does not succumb to your propaganda, he ain't a fascist🗣, fascist were the previous leaders who even sold out the power of veto to china, stfu
Thats why I never saw a problem when europeans complained about migrants and refugees, like it will get worse in years to come. If we don't want these problems we need to fix the problems in their home countries.
@@tstcikhthys it's autocorrect's fault, its code is not good enough to understand when it's supposed to replace its with it's and when its intervention is not required.
Even if all debt were to be "forgiven" or more accurately written off, this would not solve Pakistan's economic problems. The country simply lives beyond its means. It can't feed itself, has incredible levels of corruption at all levels of society and is essentially run by the military, who have a huge economic stake. I expect another military coup soon, but this will not fix their problems. They are in the process of total economic collapse and famine may follow. There is no way out this time. Perhaps India should offer to buy their nuclear weapons for food soon?
That's why Imran Khan said on German DW media Pakistan's future is tied with Russia for cheap energy and food. Otherwise Pakistanis are going to freeze and starve to death.
Pakistan's young population is radicalized beyond the point of no return. Whatever education they give in their schools takes care of that. We, Bharatiyas, want nothing to do with Pakistan. Except for getting the illegal Pakistan occupied Kashmir.
Dont spread pessimism. Pakistani s usually bounce back when they become cornered tiger. Best wishes for Pakistani s and long live Pakistan. Love from Bangladesh
As a fellow UA-cam content creator myself, and a couple of channels who are quite minuscule, but also as a avid absorber of intelligent, informative and well researched content, I want to applaud your channel and the work that you do. Your videos are some of the cleanest, well researched, most impeccably produced pieces of work on the entire world stage of media. Obviously most, if not all of the popular mass media sources have nothing on you-you, sir, and I say this without any kind of reservation or inclination to receive anything from you at all are an absolute boss. Love your work. Bravo.
@@stranger6797 No Indians snuck into Pakistan and committed an act like the Mumbai blasts, Pakistan literally held Osama bin laden near military presence. Pakistan has a long history of colluding and supporting terrorists man. The afghan taliban was literally propped up by the Pakistanis. There is no comparison, among the south Asian countries, paks terrorist moniker is well deserved.
@@nik9643 Pakistan was never made on the name of Islam. They used Islam for their dirty interests. We better be silent if we don't know anything. It is a wise approach!
@@blackagent4754 Then check, why Pakistan was created in the first place!! This place has erased its true history, culture and legacy to suit the Islamist agenda. It exists in the name of Islam. They want to live in stone age Arabia. Bin Laden is a national hero and most Islamist terror organisations in the world are found here. It is a Islamist terror hub.
I don't know if you were aware of this before making this video, but it has been pakistan's whole policy for last 2 decades to threaten other countries to provide money, and if they don't, a nuclear Pakistan will self destruct. Not many takers of these threats nowadays.
PAKISTAN never threatened anyone by shouting I have nukes rather the enemy's of PAKISTAN are sacred before attacking PAKISTAN that they already know we have nukes use ur brains even if we don't have nukes we use gorilla tactic to fight which is very effective and was firstly used by PUNJABIS 👑🦁🏴☝️ against afghan invaders specially the time of abdali and we lead afghans in battle against Soviet training them this tactic that's why USA retreated against Taliban today use ur brains before u blatter nonsense
Indians looking at their neighbouring countries falling like Domino's 👀 Afghanistan: Taliban take over Shrilanka : Defaulted Myanmar : Civil war Nepal : Economic crisis Pakistan : on Verge of civil war and economic crisis Edit: Maldives : Going underwater
India have nice Hindutva Fascists in government so they dont have to worry. The modi government can just commit some cheeky genocide against muslims or sikhs and a large proportion of indian men will let them do what thry want economically. /s
This is what happens when you focus more on hate towards another nation (India) than on putting food on your own table. This disaster is Pakistan's own making, and also it's own choosing. They chose to put Kashmir issues with India (which doesnt even matter to them) over everything else. Selling themselves out to China, harbouring violent terrorists in Afghanistan, and lobbying hard against India has further completely crippled them. Honestly, Pakistan completely deserves all that is happening right now
Yeah, Im sure Kashmir doesnt matter to Mr. Modi whatsoever. He could just let it go and not worry. India-Pakistan is such obvious tit for tat behaviour. British fault of course in historical sense but it takes two to tango.
Their whole poltics revolve around India and Kashmir. They didn't settle this down cause then how come they can claim Pak need this big of army and military budget. They need a scapegoat and it was kashmir. They spend 15% of they GDP budget on military budget that also doesn't include the pention army give to theirs general and normal soldiers. No one in Pak can have the power now to ask why Pak has this big of army. If u ask a normal he would say india scare our army that's why they want us to defame their army. Their whole jeehadi mind Thinks their military scares india. Whereas india spend only 2% of its budget on military still having more than double military power. Every war has been initiated by Pakistan and they still talk about India will attack us if we don't have big army. So the common idiot man beleive them like a fool and eat dirt to feed those generals homes.
@@CommunistLlama We let go Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, now kashmir is dispute and you are telling let kashmir go to. Nice thought, thought of a great and very kind person.
@@CommunistLlama The difference is India focuses more on its economy than the remaining Kashmir and Pakistan does the opposite. Tell me if that's not the case.
@@mike-oj7sy😂 AT LEAST IT DIDNT DAMAGE INDIA AND NEITHER WILL IN FUTURE BECAUSE ITS IN USA ANYWAY THANKS TO SHEIKH MUJIBUR REHMAN AND IMRAN KHAN FOR BEING RAW AGENT XD
No country is too big to fail. If that was the case then USSR would not have collapsed. The world community should manage the collapse of pakistan in a similar way like they did with USSR and should together secure their nuclear arms which are indeed a threat to the world in the hands of ideologically driven army and radicalized population as evident by the army’s support to terrorism making it the country to host the highest number of banned terrorist organizations and terrorists in the world. P.S Osama Bin Laden was found in the army town of Abbottabad in Pakistan.
The USSR arsenals mostly transfered to the different successor nations, with the nuclear arsenal in Russia. We didn't get to see a nuclear-armed post-soviet minor nation.
Difference is the USSR divided into several states, but didn't turn into a failed state. Which is the worrying scenario here, where the nukes are "loose".
@kira Ukraine should have kept their nukes and all delivery systems. Had they done so, Russia would never have invaded. A nuclear arsenal is worth much more than security agreements and promises to respect sovereignty.
The bedrock issue isn't the debt, the main issue is accountability. Over the decades it has constantly squandered the bailouts and loans instead of building its economy infrastructure and education. The amount of money it's gotten over the years is insane. And yet countries in southeast Asia with lesser funding have been able to build themselves into a stronger more stable government, provide basic necessities to it's people and jobs( eg Vietnam and Iran, and they both went through alot more than Pakistan.)
Exactly. If the IMF/China/etc. bails out Pakistan again, they'll just spend the money building even more fundamentalist Islamic madrassas. Even in the middle of the current crisis, Imran Khan's headline policy was giving tens of millions of dollars more funding to the terrorist factories.
My impression of Pakistan since during Afghanistan era, as a nation, was that they were double-crossing and definitely not to be trusted. And since Afghanistan, the influence of China (in the region) has become much clearer. (Somewhat strange bedfellows since Communists are godless and have shown less than regard for Pakistan's and Afghanistan's Muslim brethren.) In any event, as far as I'm concerned, Pakistan is reaping all it has sown. And they deserve every bit of it.
@@rohand04 yupp i know but as an INDIAN i still feel sorry for the PEOPLE.....i know they hate us especially someone like me Indian and upon that a HINDU 🕉......but let's just pray 🙏 that the people get through this with the least difficulties.😢
Indeed it was Pakistan who was helping Talibans in Afghanistan, now it fires back to them back. Pakistan is with China because of animosity with india, because China and India have long time conflict about rivers and borders. It is indeed funny as you said that great muslims and believers as they like to represent themselves are co-operating with China who has put Uyghur muslims whole nation in concentration camps. All their trouble comes from their hypocritical politics, not to mention corruption and other problems.
@@zexer_ity What kind of a moronic statement is this ! " They hate me but I'll pray for them . " What are you ? A Gandhi fanboy i assume , no other sane person could say this with a straight face !
@@rvharikrishnasudan, chad etc etc. A country is as good as it's military institutions are loyal. Some countries are so military dependant that their military end up with all the power.
Its funny how people blame Chinese unconditional loans for breaking countries economies but here us yet another great example of how its American and IMF conditional loans that break economies.
Pakistan has been on a spree to going to IMF & other institutions for credit so long,but never introspected itself that there is some thing wrong with themself. Pakistan is the best example of spolied nation who never learns from past mistakes ,but keeps committing blunder mistakes.
India is never gonna extend the claim. Indian government would just be looking to take back POK form Pakistan, we don't desire even an inch of Pakistani land, we'll just take what's ours. And it's not the question of If but when.
*No outside force should be blamed for any mishaps in Pakistan,* it was the work of our own army, our own corrupt politicians, our own policies, our own blunders and ignorance of each and everyone of us(citizens). It is saddening but it's true, although external factors do play a major role but we should've had resilient inside. As a Pakistani I promise that I will work hard for the betterment of my country. Cause at the end of the day no one can help us if we dont want change ourselves and are willing to work hard for it. Thx for this video @Caspian report!
@@ans42131 he sold religion to people after living a lavish life all those years and made himself a hero. And people actually bought this. I don’t know when people will understand this.
Every muslim knows only the first four halifs were righteous. It's ingrained in islamic dogma. Why are you expecting a righteous leader? It's not happening. Decentralized jamaats is the only way.
Pakistani army is the most unique army of this world it owns lands and industry of Pakistan and there general owns papa John's in USA but when it comes to war then they only know how to do surrender 😂😂😂😂
@@hke.4475 There is a looooong list of Pakistani military failure my friend. Interestingly, in your answer you mention MI17, which was downed by India itself 😂, an officer's mistake on our side. You see, your army isn't what it portrays itself to be. Wake up and smell the coffee.
@@hke.4475 😂 these mindset dragged u down to beg infront of imf and every country in the world your people eyes in pakistan blinded by Qur'an and now begging from other countries for dollars
@@matheistician andhbhakt at it again stupid tuhh! destabilized Pakistan is threat to India too! a military coup will happen and the stupid deep state will call a war on us and it's be so taxing on us and our economy! and imagine an Taliban like organisation conquer them. india's half budget will go in security rather than helping us! toh stop watching that stupid study iq channel and learn some good stuff by books and unbiased channel!
Bangladeshis count their blessings for not living under Pakistani army rule anymore. They made great sacrifices for their independence but ensure beneficial life for their fellow Bangladeshis.
As indian i could say pakistan still has the mentality of colonial era and using relegion than development and mistreatment of minorities and relegious minorities. As whole Pakistanis are awesome and kind people but compared to other Muslims natuons they are radicalized to core and cannot live in a secular aociety unless they reform themselves.
Nah the only problem is foreign controlled and foreign governed politics, only on religion can unity be accomplished. Ultimately Secularism should be thrown out of the window. We will Inshallah follow the route of Afghanistan and Iran, this puppet and unstable regime will fall and give way to an Islamic Revolution which will end all the corruption and destruction that have been commited by these secular nationalist regimes
That's most muslim countries, turns out that when you're a theocratic ethnostate you begin fucking people over horribly. Until people stop turning places into theocracies, doesn't matter if it's a Christian, jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, or Hindu, any of them really, this shit will never end. Religion taken to its logical conclusion is fucking horrifyingly brutal on every level, and radicalization is the general end point for when a religion is taken too far.
@@jubnaa International law? It's a bilateral issue between India and Pakistan... nevermind, the world is watching the riots happening in PoK for freedom from Pakistan 🤣
@@GMS0011 Riots are what every pakistani does against the govt. The fact that the people of kashmir are rioting means that they are just like the people in lahore or karachi. Also U.N resolution makes it an international dispute.
@@jubnaa The fact that your country doesn't have a stable government and you live under the rule of your army, riots are bound to happen😂 Secondly, Pakistan should concentrate on repaying it's loans to IMF instead of Kashmir. Your country is in such a dire situation that even UN resolutions wouldn't be helpful... Kashmiris suffering the attrocities of Pakistan in illegaly occupied PoK would themselves want to merge with Bharat. So, Repeated after me... The entire Jammu and Kashmir, WAS, IS, AND ALWAYS WILL BE a part of Bharat! Bharat Mata Ki Jai!
I don't understand how these countries can pay for these nuclear weapons that can destroy billions of lives of other countries yet can't lift the millions of lives of their own from abject poverty.
This has never happened, except a Christian country America did, No Muslim country has hit another country with nuclear weapons. What did the Christians do? You remember Nagasaki and Hiroshima country, Japan.?Non muslim country hited non muslim country Japan. What if Afghanistan had nuclear weapons?Afghanistan can do 100% nuclear attack on PakistanFor no reason other than jealousy I have been to Pakistan many times over the years, Pakistani people are 100% nice and friendly And I have never seen a place like Pakistan, even the West cannot compete with Pakistan in many thingsThis has never happened.If we study the case that Japan's services were acquired by America, the facts show that there is no reason other than jealousy. America wanted to destroy Japan's trade.The war was in Europe and America dropped the atomic bomb on Japan, an Asian country, even though Japan was not a part of the world war.
@@rositalondon6439 maybe you're missing the point... Forget about superficial brownie points if you can. The government has the purpose of serving the best interests of the people. To judge this approximately, look at the general average standard of living (don't cherry pick a homeless fentanyl addict) to see if the best interests of the people are being served.
@@raplopez4258 This has never happened, except a Christian country America did, No Muslim country has hit another country with nuclear weapons. What did the Christians do? You remember Nagasaki and Hiroshima country, Japan.?Non muslim country hited non muslim country Japan. What if Afghanistan had nuclear weapons?Afghanistan can do 100% nuclear attack on PakistanFor no reason other than jealousy I have been to Pakistan many times over the years, Pakistani people are 100% nice and friendly And I have never seen a place like Pakistan, even the West cannot compete with Pakistan in many thingsThis has never happened.If we study the case that Japan's services were acquired by America, the facts show that there is no reason other than jealousy. America wanted to destroy Japan's trade.The war was in Europe and America dropped the atomic bomb on Japan, an Asian country, even though Japan was not a part of the world war.
Burning with jealousy, this is a big burden on this upload, this media has no effect and has zero value, only man can be busy filling the sack of sins of lies, nothing more.i can geuss that caspian repot id holder is an afhani hinding behind propeganda cronicles..pakistan is feeding 7 millions Afghanis immigrants
The main reason for Pakistan to not progress and stay politically unstable is military establishment. Every time Pakistan gets a stable government who tries to take some corrective measures, military generals jump in to save the status-quo. Its unfortunate but true and hence the cycle of turmoil goes on.
This is also the first time in the history of the country that the population has raised against the military. Totally unprecedented, but completely justified. Down with the corrupt generals
It's also because of the way the country was founded - muslim leaguers didn't have much organic support in present Pakistan territories (unionist party feudals were strong there) and middle Indian migrants only made up 10% of the population - concentrated in Karachi. The political elites sabotaged democracy because they realized they could not win elections in the new country. They started this 'technocratic rule' nonsense - which the military eventually took over.
Well you need PEOPLE to ALLOW the cycle of turmoil to go on...........like autocracy in China keeps going on and on and on...............and army rule (also autocracy, learned from China, maybe??) still keeps on and on and on. It takes a certain kind of mindset TO BOOT THE INVADERS OUT OF YOUR COUNTRY
As an Indian I'd say we don't want any tainted land of Pakistan. Gilgit Baltistan is our land which is illegally occupied by Pakistan (or POK) and they have to evacuate it ASAP.
@@jubnaa junagarh nawab signed the petition with pakistan government without the consent of civilians of Junagarh where 80% hindu and 20% muslim population.... He betrayed his civilians thus the civilians started a revolt against their king and that coward fleed to pakistan... even Indian administration hosted him for the consent agreement of Junagarh but that coward never came back and resided in paxtan and when asked why then your government denied to talk on the decision... thus with consent of all civilians Junagarh came under India... and lemme tell you despite 80% hindu,96% civilians of junagarh voted to stay with India... I dunno what your illiterate maulvis told you, but this is the truth... and that's the reason no revolt in Gujarat ever witnessed to separate from India..
@@kushagrasrivastava3030 were the 75% Muslim population of Kashmir consulted by the Maharaja before signing an instrument to India? Are you forgetting the history of poonch rebellion? Are you forgetting how the population of Gilgit Baltistan fought alongside the Gilgit scouts for a year and a half against the indian army? Mounbatten stopped the ruler of jaipur from joining india because of it being a hindu majority state but kashmir he had no problem with joining india despite it being a muslim majority state. Also the people of gilgit baltistan are not kashmiris, they never associated themselves with kashmir, gilgit agency was ruled seperately from the pricely state. it was only returned to the maharaja , just weeks before partition.
@@jubnaa You should thank your Mohammad ali jinnah for the atrocities and poor condition amd administration of pakistan....If he didn't decided to make Pakistan independent....you would be living a peaceful and happy life with an easy day everyday with us brother.... But history has been created and it cannot be changed "tumhara pakistan tumko mubarak" lekin kashmir legally india ka part hai aur china and pakistan se hum bharat ka taaj vapas le bhi lenge... You continue your cry for Kashmir, islam economy,food and sanity...India is on it's way to dominate the world and by 2027 we will occupy the position of 3rd largest economy of this whole world.... India is sufficiently capable to capture the land of Baltistan by declaring war now which will last less than a week but we prioritise the safety of our citizens and humanity first, We are not heartless and ruthless like you that's why India is not taking ultimate actions for the sake of the innocent citizens of pakistan who are struggling to make their ends meet.. Cry as far as you can... Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳❤️
@@jubnaa You should thank your Mohammad ali jinnah for the atrocities and poor condition amd administration of pakistan....If he didn't decided to make Pakistan independent....you would be living a peaceful and happy life with an easy day everyday with us brother.... But history has been created and it cannot be changed.. "tumhara pakistan tumko mubarak" lekin kashmir legally india ka part hai aur china and pakistan se hum bharat ka taaj vapas le bhi lenge... You continue your cry for Kashmir, islam economy,food and sanity...India is on it's way to dominate the world and by 2027 we will occupy the position of 3rd largest economy of this whole world.... India is sufficiently capable to capture the land of Baltistan by declaring war now which will last less than a week but we prioritise the safety of our citizens and humanity first, We are not heartless and ruthless like you that's why India is not taking ultimate actions for the sake of the innocent citizens of pakistan who are struggling to make their ends meet.. Cry as far as you can... Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳❤️
Pakistan and India are natural trade partners, but ideology and boarder conflict has kept up embargos that effect Pakistan far more negatively than India.
🇮🇳 has no problem yaar!! They want us and not the other way around. U guys are busy thinking it has nukes, so it’s too big to fall!! Well, USSR had the world’s largest nukes and got disintegrated.!! 🇮🇳 knows when and where to strike and we will take our land back without the people whose ancestors voted to bifurcate Bharat on the basis of religion!! It’s gonna get interesting from now because west no longer can support 🇵🇰 to counter 🇮🇳!! End of colonialism happening from 28 May 2023!! Akhand Bharat will no longer be a dream!!
Pakistan does not trade with India over Kashmir. They prefer to buy the same potatoes and tomatoes from the UAE (at a very high cost )that the UAE bought from India for its own consumption. Pakistan also built a very expensive metro in Lahore with help of china on more debt even though they are already in debt. Pakistan is mess but doesn't want to change itself.
@@sneha6652 completely agree with what you said, my own nation's government and military are full of such ignorants who prefer their inflated egos over the development and peace.
Yeah living in this country nowadays literally feels like hell. Sometimes I think about suicide but then I remember that I can't left my family behind.
It is never that bad. I know sometimes it feels like nothing you do works but you have to hang in there. Once the storm passes, you will realize the world still has plenty of good in it. Even in Pakistan. Be strong.
Well this is quite the predicament isn't it. I'm a Pakistani being told by a guy who speaks in English (my second language) that my country is a failed nation 😢. And funnily, I agree with his statements
In a sense, nothing is over until its actually over. The world has had sudden changes before. I wonder if you were to list the top 10 problems for Pakistan now and try to deal with just one of them. Which would be the least hard to deal with? Hope comes from picking a large impossible problem into smaller components.
Well what about India? Looks like it’s one of the most dangerous country for women, especially doctors! Yk how may women get r@9ed every year in India?? And then they barely get any justice
The biggest problem with PAK government(not people) is that despite looking at their internal downfall...they tend to focus more on external useless affairs...I agree that Indo-Pak relationships are not as we would desire...but this is absolutely not the time for terrorism or poking on external matters be it internal Talibans or attacking India. It's primary focus should be boosting economy as we know the inflation in PAK is at its peak. People want 💰,🍞,🏠 not 💣...No hate!✌️
That is a tactic used by all pak govt in power ...to divert attention from their own wrong doings , they keep bringing up kashmir,human rights in india ....human rights , uh ? Pakistan talking about human rights of minorities in other countries is an irony...
Why not people? Who eventually forms the government? Its the people!! Pakistan's people have been fed wrong versions of history in school, they have been living in a world of their own since 1947!!! What's happening now was bound to happen
Pakistani government and media or people hardly care or talk about India. No political party go to elections talking about india. It’s always indian where pakistan live rent free in everyone brain.
This is why you don't build a country based purely off religion, all it can lead to is instability, compared with India which more or less learnt to have different groups working together (but even that isn't perfect)
I don't have the numbers but if you were to do a study on the subject matter I wouldn't be surprised if the reversed is true. Multicultural states often goes to shit as soon as the economy does poorly. That's why a lot of the successful ones are here because the bad ones died out.
@@The_Midnight_Bear that or the Indian subcontinent should have never been divided. If India's infrastructure extended into modern day Pakistan, the standard of living would have been actually okay. Plus, a higher Muslim population would force Hindu nationalist movements to yield, possibly allowing for more religious tolerance in India. Modi is a symptom of this mistake.
You can build a country based purely off religion. Just that the religion has to be malleable and liberal to changing times with the ability to criticize and discuss.
military dictatorship is one thing, Pakistan is a military dictatorship which is funded and dictated by the British MI6 and American Cia . A honest , pure selfless military dictatorship would be great . Pakistan is a British-American satellite state.
0:06: Pakistan's import-dependent economy has run out of foreign exchange, causing food and energy shortages. 0:21: The resulting economic hardship is driving political polarization, radicalization, and extremism. 0:30: The domestic instability in Pakistan could escalate border disputes and potentially destabilize South Asia. 9:25: Pakistan's growing $130 billion external debt is unsustainable and draining foreign exchange. 10:03: Haircuts, debt restructuring, and postponement of interest payments are necessary for recovery. 10:31: Private creditors and multilateral institutions hold a significant portion of Pakistan's debt and may hinder resolution efforts. Recap by Tammy AI
This is so dumb. Why would Afghanistan invade Pakistan? They are allies. Even if the taliban decides to invade Pakistan the military will easily crush them. A militia group can’t defeat one of the worlds strongest militaries.
Really, stop living in a fancy world, especially when Pakistan owes 130 billion in debt and nobody wants to bail Pakistan out because Financial institutions and donor countries know that Pakistan is unable to pay them back. Military however strong needs munitions and to make or buy them also needs financial resources which Pakistan does not have at the moment.
@@soldierof-allah11 You have some serious misconceptions and loose grip on geopolitics. What happened was the matter of past. Afghanistan and Pakistan are hardcore enemies now. There are multiple reasons for a future conflict b/w two. The most dominant one is Taliban's claim over Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa region of Pakistan. Taliban doesn't recognise Durand Line (Afghan-Pak international border) drawn by British (Sir Durand). Now coming to the Pakistan's Military Strength, there are several anti-state/separatist rebel groups inside Pakistan like BLA and TTP and they keep capturing pieces of land in Pakistan and bring enough casualties to the army. They may calture some really important strategic locations in the time of war. Addition to that Pakistan lack money to keep up fight for a longer period of time. Pakistan is a doomed state.
This is the 3rd video/article I've read on the threat of Pakistan's nuclear weapons falling in the wrong hands. Their nuclear weapons have already fallen into the wrong hands several times. A stable Pakistan was a rogue state anyway. There seems to be a concerted effort by DGISPR to get their hands on the IMF loans by scaring everyone as usual
Reasons behind the army state of Pakistan's sufferings 1. USA's exit from Afghanistan and subsequent stoppage of donations to Pakistan from USA. 2. Pakistan has fooled the IMF 22 times but this time IMF took tough stance and that country is suffering.
All Indians pls ask this channel to use correct Indian map. J and k ,aksai chin is integral part of India. India has a border shared with Afganistan. Pls all guys ask this channel and other channels to use correct Indian maps
Fun fact: When pakistan suspended trade with India in 2019, they didn't technically stop buying Indian goods. Distributors in the UAE and Kenya(maybe others) just bought cheap Indian goods, slapped a fake sticker on it and sold it to Pakistan for an increased price.
@@AbdullahHashi-kw3qj that's the truth...what's the joke in real sense is the entire political spectrum in Pakistan and the concept of Pakistan as a nation... Nations born out of hatred are bound to break.... It happened in 1971... It will happen again
@@Dexter_Diesel pak wasn't born out of hate, it was born out of safe guarding Muslim interest in india, and infact even Indians will tell you that it was GOOD that pak separated, bcuz would be at each others throats constantly Jinnah the founder of Pakistan thought and acted like ataturk, it's those after him who made everything about religion
@@AbdullahHashi-kw3qj That belief that jinnah asked for pakistan to safeguard so and so doesn't stand tall outside pakistan. The same country killed the founder's sister and none of the founder's family stayed a muslim, married a muslim and remained in pakistan.
@@AbdullahHashi-kw3qjtrue, imagine Pakistan wasn't created , our (Hindus) response against the genocides during direct action day would have been catastrophic for Muslims It's fine as it is now , although I hope we Indians can take advantage of this scenario and take back our territories in POK That will be risky as hell but worth it
It's important to consider that a country's status as a nuclear power doesn't justify all actions. Pakistan faces challenges such as corruption, military involvement in politics, and terrorist activities. Merely providing bailouts without addressing underlying issues won't lead to positive progress. One possible approach could be linking assistance to the condition of nuclear disarmament. When helping a troubled nation, it may be beneficial to reduce their empowerment.
I'd like to see what China wants to do. I know they have kept channels with Afghanistan, Pakistan etc. They're an option for nations that don't want demands on democracy and such. The PRC hasn't stopped the ongoing korean republic's nuclear program, they're still a chinese client state.
The disarmament of Pakistan would almost certainly lead to India invading. Nuclear weapons and Pakistan's relationship with China are the only reasons why India has been kept at bay.
People usually say East India Company vanished. The way I see the world today, it has just diversified in pockets of the world and evolved with time. Pakistan army is one such subsidiary of EIC. The harsh truth...
Yes Britain Soviet Great Game Pakistan as Major Non NATO ally Pakistan selling out 🇦🇫 to 🇺🇸🇬🇧 Pakistan supporting US backed Libyan "Rebels" Pakistan is there to keep 🇮🇳 in check for 🇬🇧
Can you elaborate on that? The EIC certainly left wealth and influence in various British families and companies evolving from it. Colonial administrations and connections also certainly somehow survived. But are these connections still visible or effective? It's embarrassing to see how little I know about any of this, even though I spend a lot of time reading about everything.
@@michaelutech4786 most of the institutions gained legitimately. The concept Nationstates saw some popularity peaking in the cold war. But as corporate power centers became evident, the once that inherited colonial structures sought a unchallenged slice of growth. The military industrial complex in Burma, Pakistan, and even India or Singapore for that matter are noteworthy. The share size of India & population made it impossible for unicentric institutions. Yet it suffers from military cantonments in the middle of cities that too the south. While Pakistan or Burma does not suffer from such challenges. There is not a list of power structures ever built in those countries more powerful than inherited colonial ones. To state an example of imagine Samsung is for South Korea. Yet Pak & Burma could be called lucky as they have a localised identity and have to justify crimes. On the other hand most African nations are yet under direct rule of western secret services.
@@MWaheduzzamanKhan1 if indian navy didn't block Pakistani supply then you people would have been massacred by now Have some gratitude. I know we can't expect that from mu$lim.
Having visited Pakistan many times and come across it's peoples generous hospitality and the stunning natural beauty, sadly the only question I have is: How did Pakistan even make it so far? The levels of rampant corruption in Government, the social services, the military and the police are astounding. And it has been this way for decades.
At the beginning it was good, even south korea came to Pakistan to learn. However more corrupt leaders and the army having power led to them just begging for money
Hospitality and generosity is only for foreigners and for temporary period , once u ask to stay there and if u are a non muslim ,then u will be converted or killed.
Strange that you visited Pakistan many times and were able to figure out the country's military is corrupt. Question is where did you come across the military's corruption while you visited the country "many times". Somebody whose was born and lived there I have come across the military many time while visiting cantonment areas perhaps a dozen times a year but was never exposed to their "corruption". I am not saying the military isn't corrupt in the least but for somebody whose visited Pakistan "many times" the comment seems more so a fabrication than reality. Cool comment though, first make them feel you bode well 'come across it's peoples generous hospitality and the stunning natural beauty,' and then go for the hit.
As an ex-pat Pakistani, I left when I was 6 -- I guess I knew what life in Pakistan would portend. As said by an elder in my family, many years ago, "Pakistan has to be ruled with an iron fist." I was sad then, but always believed the Pakistani people, rugged, hard-working, gracious, intelligent and family-centered, did not need an iron fist to rule them, but a common vision. That is what has yet to materialize out of Pakistan.
@@lolololllll I have 50-50 on that. I talked to a few pakistani guys and they were very sweet. At the same time I've seen quite radicalized people (and high intolerance for other religions in general too)
@@hidum5779 oh yea there is a serious issue in pakistan with religious extremism and in my personal opinion it’s one of the main reasons pakistan has been failing as a nation. However, even the extremists are not particularly against india, they are against everyone who is against their views (even other muslims of different sects or beliefs) regardless of their nationality, ethnicity or even family relationship. My point is that other than the issue of kashmir, pakistanis don’t have a grudge against indians. Even in the rare occasions when india is mentioned on pakistani media or by the people, the ratio is overwhelming positive or at least respectful
@@lolololllll like I said 50-50 I was honestly shocked when I talked to a Pakistani man (and much older than me) and he was extremely respectful to me. Addressing me as "ji bhai". Honestly speaking at that moment it felt like Indians can learn a few things from Pakistanis in addressing others especially. Really humble guy. But I have definitely seen the other side too, so there's that.
@@lolololllll we in the West are always reading about how Christians and Hindus in Pakistan, who are not Indians but Pakistanis, are being persecuted. This makes difficult for Western liberals, who are predominantly of Christian heritage but also have a lot of Hindu sympathies, to sympathise with Pakistan. Western conservatives (I am one) could possibly come around to pro-Islam sympathy but we will not accept persecution of Christians.
@@lolololllllwe watch videos of local youtubers interacting with locals in Pakistan 😅the amount of poison in their minds about India and Hindus is quite visible so we know the reality
These are self inflicted wounds I am a Pakistani and have done much research on the military establishment. They are the ones who are responsible for this...
The longest running collapse in history. I remember an American expert talking about the collapse in Afpak, a portmanteau of Afghanistan and Pakistan in the early 2000's.
9/11 happened and America started handing out billions of dollars to Pakistan and so did IMF for 14 times in a row. Those are the only things that kept Pakistan alive for 2 decades. Now that it’s gone no wonder Pakistan is dying.
I had a map of the AfPak by National Geographic in my office cubicle for years. Also, being of a Pakistani dad and an American mom, I am a HalfPak 🤡🤷🏽♂
Go to brilliant.org/caspianreport to get a 30-day free trial + the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual subscription.
Thanks for all your work.
Pakistan, like the country of Azerbaijan, has existed for less than a few decades
Pakistan is the country which has been supporting Taliban and other such groups its no wonder that they fail.
Pakistan is like an artificial country made from nothingness
@@Charlie-phlezk❤
Never won a war, never lost an election - Pakistan Army
😂😂😂😂😂😊
1965 was won. And 1999 would have been as well if it was for international pressure. One that that is known the world over, Hindus are a cowardly race
yet nobody dares to invade 😂
@Sunny Sanatan only in your Bollywood
@@AkxTremisTDid you forgot 93k Pakistani soldiers surrender in 1971
As an Indian I believe that 90% problems of Pakistan will be solved if they ask the establishment for accountability instead of blaming India.
broo believe me, imran khan is doing that the whole time but they are just far too powerful. And nobody is blaming india, we know that its the fault of the government, army and police. Everything is so corrupted
Innit
pakistan has the same corruption problems as india
@@henrykjohn78 innit? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That wouldn't be fun or part of the game
A military regime is a curse to any country
Like American's pentagon and a deep state?
Chile, Paraguay and South Korea are exceptions
Only corrupt ones
Those aren't exceptions.
@@kral16643 Since when are those exceptions?
The fact that no Prime Minister in the history of Pakistan has yet to serve a full five-year term should tell you something about this country.
Millitary leaders has served a full term😂
What should it tell you about this country?
@@Parallaxxx28 the failure in it's foundation
It's not a true democracy
@@Parallaxxx28 And here is the living example of why you failed as a citizen of Pakistan, Stable govt = stable economy which provides more investment and less begging for aids
"India is a nation with an army. Pakistan is an army with a nation."
- a Pakistani journalist whose name I unfortunately cannot recall
no it was told by an indian army general. he took that line from probably uk who said it about yogoslavia or someone idk
the romans the mongols the macadonian the prussian the german the swedes the russians the japanese the chinesse and many others started the same way .... there is no winter without summer no no pleasure without pain no victory without loss no sunshine without rain remember nothing ever remains the same documentery on the hundred years war the great northen war the second worldwar and golden hordes chinesse history and roman history will show you... i pray may your conqurer show you mercy because you will need it
- Anwar Maqsood
the original quote was by Bismarck and he was talking about Prussia.
The quote is by Voltaire and it goes like this: Where some states have an army, the Prussian Army has a state.
"The cost of living starts to outweigh the benefits" is an insanely strong line.
_Fate, is never without irony_
It perfectly describes my situation living in the U.S.. The U.S. used to be a heck of a deal, now its ridiculous.
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_Vehicle All created on purpose and predicted (or denounced) by conservative and anticommunist Larry McDonald (D) Georgia, reason why the plane he was travelling in was downed in 1983 by the Soviets in cahoots with American leftist socialist pro-world government conspirators.
@@HTV-2_Hypersonic_Glide_Vehicleyou are kidding, right? You wouldn't last a week in Brazil then.
I didn't understand it....What are the benefits of the rise in cost of living?
You translated the final situation very well. "Pakistan is a military State too big to fail, but have a external debt burden too big to succeed"
that sounds like soviet union isn't it 😅
@@utubetruthtellerliterally. Breaking of Pakistan is a very real threat. I am just afraid about their nukes.
@@aruji-sama here in india government is thinking about getting over Pakistani nukes if pakistan fails ..
I dont think Pakistan will collapse that is just too much
@@anonymouskumar3261 Pakistan has evey reason to collapse. There is no sign of them doing anything to get back up. And a country which can't stand on its own stands on someone else's feet.
So sure USA China may be able to save them yet again. But it's not possible if no one comes to save Pakistan.
Pakistan will become like Mayanmar, Somalia or Yemen. Playground for the big powers.
They may not fall like the Soviet union did but they will find their own way to fall.
@@utubetruthteller USA debt siling
Update 8 months later: Iran has fired missles into Pakistan..
and pakistan gave it right back to iran the very next day.
@@jubnaa maybe stop giving shelter to terrorist
@@jubnaaand Iran again killed pak's citizens
Interesting times ahead me thinks.
@@jubnaa Why are you pretending as if that's something to be proud about. It just shows bad foreign policy on both sides
Pakistan is run by its military chief with help from intelligence chief. not by its "selected" government.
The Anglo-Saxons run Pakistan to continue the Great Game.
@@unibks4382 Can you elaborate on this point? Why do you think this?
It's like Prussia if it was managed by donkeys that dont know how to eat their hay.
@@muneebahmed1848
Before Pakistan was created the Indus Valley was a strategic region and launchpad for the British Empire 200 years ago for conducting the Anglo-Afghan wars. This began with the overthrow of King Dost Khan of Afghanistan to prevent Afghanistan forming diplomatic relations (and an eventual alliance) with Russia. The Great Game. Britain created Pakistan to continue the Great Game (U2 pilot Gary Powers takes off from Pakistan, flies over Afghanistan and Central Asia and is shot down over the Soviet Union). The first secretary general of NATO, General Ismay was a veteran of the Anglo-Afghan wars.
Britain created the dysfunctional state of Pakistan as part of an Anglo-Muslim alliance comprising of Turkey, Iran, Iraq [CENTO, SEATO, Baghdad Pact]) to counter the atheist Soviet Union (Ghazwa-e-Rus) and continue Britain's imperial fantasy of The Great Game (renamed as the Cold War). The Royal Grand Indus Army that owns, occupies and ru(i)ns Pakistan maintains Britain's imperial legacy and enforces British messianic ideology (foreign policy) of everlasting hostility towards Russia in Afghanistan and Indus valley for a fistful of $$$ and a few $$$ more. Read: 'The Shadow of the Great Game' by Narendra Singh Sarila; 'Indian Summer: The Secret History of the End of an Empire' by Alex von Tunzelmann and 'The Grand Chessboard' by Zbigniew Brzezinski.
If you don't patch up your ship in calm seas, don't expect to stay afloat when the storm hits.
Damn. What a proverb
@@nknkannadiga9742 "i am 14 and thats deep"
something something russia
Smooth seas dont make good sailors
@@AESTHETIC-yk3zk 😂😂😂 good sailors need challenges
As Shekar Gupta ones said
"Pakistan always points a gun at its own head and negotiates with others either to give us money or see what kind of mess I am going to cause here"
It's absolutely true, the only country that has milked it's geography and nuclear ability to the maximum, unfortunately to just benefit the politicians and generals
North Korea strategy
@@specialnewb9821 they learned that negotiation tactic from pakistan
@@specialnewb9821 even North Korea is not that pathetic. North Korea will leave alone any country that doesn't side with South Korea in it territorial dispute.
@Satyaki Sil when it comes to nuclear war there will be no one left along
Population-5th
Economy - not even in top 40.
This sums up the blunders committed by pak establishment and govt.
And looks like India is one of the most dangerous place for women, especially doctors
An army that is supposed to protect its country, instead of killing it.
Their hate for Kafirs is stronger than their love for their own .
@@tamarabenjamin2762 this is the only reason why Pakistani Army exist to be honest .
@@tamarabenjamin2762 no TRUE army would harm their own. Soldiers give their life for their OWN people. They do NOT turn the tanks towards them.
@@whentheimposterissus8376 yes. All they did was spewing false narratives and stories to their own people and had the audacity to call it *"Raaa Ki Sajish"* . Because all they can do is spew lies.
@@whentheimposterissus8376 RAW was never offensive. RAW always succeeded because RAW was DEFENSIVE . RAW only defended its Motherland. If anything happened in Pak it was in reality the Boomerang of ISI's deeds.
As a Pakistani, I solely blame the generals and the political elite in Pakistan who have radicalised the masses and, in turn, looted the country.
how is the current government handling the flooding crisis ? and do you think Imran khan would have handled the situation differently ?
how is the current government handling the flooding crisis ? and do you think Imran khan would have handled the situation differently ?
OMG, a Pakistani who does not blame India but his own governing bodies!
@docrex1678 No one blames India in Pakistan for this situation....
@@vijayiyer8518he would have had atlesst some planning as he did with as someone tweeted a wameing month prior to.the flooding if that makes sense
Not so Fun Fact: since its independence, not even a single Pakistani Prime Minister has completed a full term.
This is mostly true
@@discovermajid not mostly my friend. Entirely. I've verified this claim myself by looking at the number of years served by each PM. Not even a single has 5 years.
@@sidv4615 yes as a Pakistani, I can certify you....
damn, that's a crazy record
@@afrazamjad1644 oh my good then how come pakistan will ever develop
Pakistan was created on the basis of religion and not on the basis of a common political, geographical or cultural identity. This leads to uncontrolled religious extremism and terrorism. Despite the best efforts of the West, Pakistan had split into two parts in the past and it will split into many parts again.
Bro,the sunnah of our beloved prophet(P.B.U.H) give us the one of the best political and administral system in the world and inshallah soon we will be able to aply this system in our country with proper laws,where injustice will not exist
@@GreenTree-iu6dk 🤣😂😅🙃🤯
Bro its not a joke.We will also give rights to minorities not like the western countries where most of countries baned hijaab and we will also give all rights to women's
@Goodlife-iu6dk 😂😂😂 "we will"... when ? Have you not had enough time to do so in the last 70 years ? In the last 13 centuries ?
Criticizing "most western countries that banned hijab" because it's just à male oriented control of women's bodies, and overlooking Pak's (and most Muslim dictatorships) absence of rights for women, gays, jews and other religious minorities, etc....? YOU are the joke.
@@GreenTree-iu6dk yeah the same rights where its written in sahi hadees dat men are allowed to beat their women , and men can consent fully for not consent fully have sax with their wide anytime they want.
"While economics is a gun, politics is knowing when to pull the trigger."
Well said.
Looks like you have Don Lucchesi's influence
terrible analogy that makes very little sense.
But then the really unfortunate statement; " ...the costs of living beginning to outweigh the benefits ( ...of living). This begins to have zuicide connotations
Economics is not a gun. But the philosophical explaining of the production of goods and services in a division of labor society. That explains trade and commerce.
How that can you claimed that economics is a gun. Pretending that ecomonic power is political power, is where you go wrong, with such a bad anology. To separate domains. The military is the tool or the guns, politics is who are always pulling the trigger. That is the weapon, war is therefore the natural outgrowth of political discourse. There is no other outcome.
@@moxinghbian Correct 💯. Since the military is the weapon, politicians are who pulls the trigger. All that industry can do is provide the material to support the war effort.
13:00 There is an old saying. "If you owe the bank one hundred dollars and can't repay it, You have a problem. If you owe the bank one million dollars, and can't repay it, The Bank has a problem."
"Pakistan now negotiates with its allies and friends by pointing a gun to its own head. " - Stephen Cohen (The idea of Pakistan)
2 guns. One at itself, one at everyone else
American Dollar collapsing, France ready to handover colonial periods territories to China and Germany facing slowdown economy ???
China is backing Pakistan everywhere.
On the other side Democratic India is one of the largest population of beggars, homeless, jobless people. Hate, Discrimination, biased system, crimes against females, caste system and intolerance against minorities etc. etc.
@@only_fair23 what about India? Looks like it’s one of the most dangerous place for women so far, especially doctors and then they would barely get justice. That country has 0 safety for women
@@only_fair23 what about India? Looks like it’s one of the most dangerous place for women so far, especially doctors and then they would barely get justice. That country has 0 safety for women
Pakistan has no geographic boundaries. Some of it is geographically India, some of it is geographically Afghanistan, most of it is Balochistan.
The reason for this is that Pakistan is a country based not on geography or territory but on religion.
Umm... We know that... That's literally our ideology, you didn't discover anything new AND we also know that it's not a good idea for a state to be dependent upon one religion and forgetting about others😂
@@Uno_organizedIt's a drug 2 billion are hooked on. Instant Allah. Just add sand
Pakistan is not "too big to fail", just too dangerous to fail.
Agreed
USSR was also considered too big and too dangerous to fail.
That's what he meant, bro. Too big = too dangerous.
A stable pakistan is only India's problem but a failed pakisran is whole worlds problem.
So India's option is very clearly a failed pakistan.
No, they are neither. An example of to dangerous to fail would be China, US, and Russia.... these 3 countries controls the economy now, if anything happens between the 3, the politicians when get rich and the citizens are paying for it
Never let any military to run their own country. A live example is Pakistan.
never let islam run a nation.
If they are too strong what one can do???
@@atifrana5470 Believe in Allah (SWT)...Remember Feron of Egypt was powerful too.
@@Arcane_Pulse-f7n InshahAllah. In the long run they will be defeated by the mercy of Allah but I said in the present moment they are Firons
@@atifrana5470wage war with pen and paper
❝ Every country has an army but in Pakistan, an army has a country.❞
- G. Parthasarathy
Egypt too, sadly.
"Evey country has political party & army but in China, a political party has a country & army"
- SunTzu
Peace is only options even when you are being genocided
- gandhi
@@svcby
❝ Hindus should not harbour anger against Muslims even if Muslims destroy kill us all. We should face death bravely. If Muslims established their rule after killings Hindus we'd be ushering in a new India.❞
- Mahatma Gandhi (Book: The Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Page 219)
And G(andu) Parthasarathy should ask Indian Government as to how come it's Soldier's don't wear Full Pants!
1. Stop dealing in $US
2. Stop blaming India for your issues. See that giant as a trading partner, not an enemy. Fight your battles on the cricket pitch, not with weapons.
3. Support what makes you great. Textiles and motorcycle clothing.
4. Recognise the World Bank/IMF/USA are not your friends and dealing with them will keep you poor.
5. Beware of China. They play a long game.
Not blaming India goes against the narrative Pakistan has created for themselves. They literally cannot take care of their own country, yet they want Kashmir from India and India is the devil for not complying lol.
Idk why every India thinks that an average Pakistani thinks of them as an enemy we don’t we blame our government and army for everything but honestly people in Pakistan are cowards we don’t protest
India has becoming an apparheid state, hostile to 200million muslim population including other religions. India will suffer problems too...
Well said
@@nathanruben-tv5lf how? India's the only non Muslim majority country in the entire world which had four former Muslim presidents and three former Muslim vice presidents. And recent election of India where bjp failed to secure simple majority itself says Indian constitution of equality and justice still stands shove all
"Debt that cannot be repaid won't be repaid." - Shirvan
Classic. 😎👍
Time for the banks to collect the natural resources as collateral and give it to the mining and oil companies they invested in. Which probably was the plan from the very beginning.
@@laaaliiiluuu this is what will happen, the house always wins
@@laaaliiiluuu banks collapse without the govt propping them up .
That quote is from the economist Michael Hudson.
Not with that attitude, it won't! -- Creditor.
"Debt cannot be repaid, wont be repaid". So true from individual humans to institutions and even countries. Stay far away from it if you really can.
Very true. Debtors make more money from interest.
Debt is a means. It needs that the debter to know finances.
Debt to buy groceries vs debt for investment.
A reasonable debt Is what makes millionaires
When you owe the bank $1,000 then you have a problem.
When you owe the bank $1,000,000 it is the bank that has the problem.
Maybe the creditor nations of the world should make forgiving their debts and lending them any more money contingent on them giving up their nuclear weapons.
"As a cricket player, Khan was no stranger to spin" - This is gold. Thank you for the analysis of the crisis in my home country, I look from afar in sadness.
There is no crisis here , you must be a Patwari. We will deal with your fauj first and then all patwari
@@apiklala this stupid in-fighting is the reason we are failing. its a slow suicide. we keep fighting our own people, keep holding the gun to our head. but alas theres nothing we can do. our nation is dying, whether you like it or not, and we are all watching it in real time
@@apiklala It's okay man, denial is the first stage. No need for name calling.
There is no "we", nobody outside the government bureaucracy is dealing with or solving this on a united front. What have you done?
@@apiklala yeah man congrats , people like u r the major reason for ur destruction
@@Roma-tp9nw he was arrested in the malik riaz funding case for which his tramp wife got a diamond ring. IK is a lunatic
1:49 Pakistan did not become independent in 1947 but was born after breaking away from India. 😢
nah it was independent
Pakistan was born out of British India!@@Coxirt
So was India itself lol what's your point @@varman001
@@Chico1747 Only the name of India was changed. Earlier there was Bharat and after independence both India and Bharat became official names.
The country which was captured by the British was India. You will not find mention of a country called Pakistan anywhere in history.
@@varman001 If you have time to learn rather than watching GODI media you would know what "Independence" means. It means "the fact or state of being independent" In this case Pakistan was Independent from British rule along with India, because Pakistan and India never existed as a same country ever before, it was just a colony of Britain that was united under force.
Even at the height of crisis, there are no signs of fundamental change in Pakistan's policies. They could've prospered had they engaged positively with neighbours and giving religion a backseat.They fought 4 unnecessary wars with India without any substantial gains, supported mujahideen fighters in Afghanistan and later helped Taliban to wreck havoc in that country,still supporting separatist forces and terrorist groups clandestinely to foment troubles in neighbouring countries.Just imagine the amount of money they had spent all these years for such unscrupulous acts. Pakistan itself is responsible for its downfall.
Pakistan is a CIA colony with MI6 .
substantial gain?they lost half of their territory in war to us😂
We made mistakes but India is an existential threat for us. We haven't forgotten anything. All will be settled once we make a comeback and we will.
@@Sobanhassan1761Continue the cycle of mutual hatred between the two countries and there will never be peace.
@@Sobanhassan1761 worry for ur existence bro
Who knows before india would make it's move ur existence as a country would be in danger from ur internal enemies 😂😂
"Economics is the gun but politics is knowing when to pull the trigger."
"Not long before the cost of living outweighs the benefits."
"Given Pakistan's nuclear arsenal, some might find it too big to fail, but its foreign debt is too big for it to succeed."
"Debt that can't be repaid, won't be repaid."
The word wizardry in this video is arguably your best ever.
We could test on RSS
More like a narrative building effort to Salvage of whatever Pak will be left. Since sympathy card lost its validity post Covid, the last card that Pakistan has is that of N blackmail. Host Shirvan has on most occasions been very generous to Pak in previous documentaries too.. no surprise. This video seems for global creditors mind making purpose.
@@fluxacadmey5836 Maybe the first sentence a little bit. But rest are far from RSS. Modi lifted 150+ Million People Out Of Poverty In A Decade. Your kaum will achieve in 2070 as much which is probably the least of what RSS has achieved for India.
@@fluxacadmey5836 bhai academy ka spelling thik karle pehle aur ha vese rss se compare na kar vo bas ek religious organisation hai unko itna seriously lena bhi nhi
@@fluxacadmey5836 Paxtan school system is a joke. Academy ki spelling to yaha ke 4th standard ke bacche sahi se likh denge.
In India government commands army, in Pakistan army commands government.
In India, a fascist commands the army.
@@josecipriano3048 just because that man does not succumb to your propaganda, he ain't a fascist🗣, fascist were the previous leaders who even sold out the power of veto to china, stfu
Liberals 🤡
@@josecipriano3048 who told you that BBC 😆😆
@@josecipriano3048when you graduate from BBC 😂😂😂
This nation is a joke.
India should start tightening the border security. A huge flow of refugees is not far. We don't want Jihadis who chose their death 75 years ago.
@ha sahi bol raha hai vo
Thats why I never saw a problem when europeans complained about migrants and refugees, like it will get worse in years to come. If we don't want these problems we need to fix the problems in their home countries.
Ah yes, they should have stayed and then India would be spared from the BJP. Your government justifies Pakistan's existence.
haha! refugees aur wo bhi India me jaha pehle bhi hm ko koi psand nai krta aur wha aa kr mrna he kia? No-one is coming to you..... don't panic lol
@@zainbaloch4850 lmao bhaijaan zara search karlo asspass konsa desh hai jahan aap jaa sakte ho iran, ya Afghanistan
Pakistan focuses more on countering India than on it's own growth. This was very much unavoidable, even without the flood and Ukraine war.
No they focus more on their own pockets and power
@@tstcikhthys it's autocorrect's fault, its code is not good enough to understand when it's supposed to replace its with it's and when its intervention is not required.
@@noticing33 yeah that is why their economy is skyrocketing.
@@tstcikhthys don't correct our english it's our second language and we have no respect for it.
imagine if all that research in plutonium bombs had been spent on safe plutonium nuclear-reactors
pakistan would be rich enough to buy the IMF
Even if all debt were to be "forgiven" or more accurately written off, this would not solve Pakistan's economic problems. The country simply lives beyond its means. It can't feed itself, has incredible levels of corruption at all levels of society and is essentially run by the military, who have a huge economic stake. I expect another military coup soon, but this will not fix their problems.
They are in the process of total economic collapse and famine may follow. There is no way out this time.
Perhaps India should offer to buy their nuclear weapons for food soon?
Legit. All the loans and bailouts in the world aren't enough to fix Pakistan's economy as it is now. It quite literally has _nothing_ going for it.
That's why Imran Khan said on German DW media Pakistan's future is tied with Russia for cheap energy and food. Otherwise Pakistanis are going to freeze and starve to death.
A reduced debt load is the first step to fixing the country’s various issues
Pakistan's young population is radicalized beyond the point of no return. Whatever education they give in their schools takes care of that. We, Bharatiyas, want nothing to do with Pakistan. Except for getting the illegal Pakistan occupied Kashmir.
Dont spread pessimism. Pakistani s usually bounce back when they become cornered tiger. Best wishes for Pakistani s and long live Pakistan. Love from Bangladesh
As a fellow UA-cam content creator myself, and a couple of channels who are quite minuscule, but also as a avid absorber of intelligent, informative and well researched content, I want to applaud your channel and the work that you do. Your videos are some of the cleanest, well researched, most impeccably produced pieces of work on the entire world stage of media. Obviously most, if not all of the popular mass media sources have nothing on you-you, sir, and I say this without any kind of reservation or inclination to receive anything from you at all are an absolute boss. Love your work. Bravo.
Realistically speaking, Establishment is Pakistan's main problem.
The Establishment = Criminal Enterprise...
Religion is
@@HeavenRacer422establishment not religion
@@izoo-mm9uk establishment? When it used to rule before 1968 Pakistan developed. When is|am started taking more relevance it started struggling.
@@HeavenRacer422 are u dumb? Pakistan was paritioned for the sole cause of establishing a seperate muslim nation
Terrorism and Pakistan have deep relationship which led them to this situation.
@@stranger6797 Pakistan has the most number of banned islamic terror organisations.
@@stranger6797 No Indians snuck into Pakistan and committed an act like the Mumbai blasts, Pakistan literally held Osama bin laden near military presence. Pakistan has a long history of colluding and supporting terrorists man. The afghan taliban was literally propped up by the Pakistanis. There is no comparison, among the south Asian countries, paks terrorist moniker is well deserved.
@@stranger6797lol
@@stranger6797 Pak army created Taliban in Pakistan and they are attacking the army now.
@@stranger6797 wtf? everyone person there talks about Gazwa E Hind
There is a " State within State" in Pakistan. And that state is responsible for all the crisis in our country.
State inside state ..Islam is the cause...
@@nik9643 Pakistan was never made on the name of Islam. They used Islam for their dirty interests. We better be silent if we don't know anything. It is a wise approach!
@@nik9643 Here we go with this bull crap..... Where did you draw that conclusion from?
@@blackagent4754 Then check, why Pakistan was created in the first place!! This place has erased its true history, culture and legacy to suit the Islamist agenda. It exists in the name of Islam. They want to live in stone age Arabia. Bin Laden is a national hero and most Islamist terror organisations in the world are found here. It is a Islamist terror hub.
@@GayM0hammed-ChiIdrap1st I was asking Nik. He is supposed to answer me, but clearly he seems unable to defend his claim.
Most people forget that Pakistan ended in 1971. What exists now is just a rump albeit with the same name.
East Pakistan ended yes. But not the whole country
@@mohammadahmad3455😂🤡
@@mohammadahmad3455 pakistan is just man alive in comma
@@indianhurricane5793 not in comma exactly . But yeah things are really bad
Tbh actual Pakistan was always East Pakistan
I don't know if you were aware of this before making this video, but it has been pakistan's whole policy for last 2 decades to threaten other countries to provide money, and if they don't, a nuclear Pakistan will self destruct.
Not many takers of these threats nowadays.
Yes. They blackmail. Shameless
You can only cry wolf so many times
PAKISTAN never threatened anyone by shouting I have nukes rather the enemy's of PAKISTAN are sacred before attacking PAKISTAN that they already know we have nukes use ur brains even if we don't have nukes we use gorilla tactic to fight which is very effective and was firstly used by PUNJABIS 👑🦁🏴☝️ against afghan invaders specially the time of abdali and we lead afghans in battle against Soviet training them this tactic that's why USA retreated against Taliban today use ur brains before u blatter nonsense
Indians looking at their neighbouring countries falling like Domino's 👀
Afghanistan: Taliban take over
Shrilanka : Defaulted
Myanmar : Civil war
Nepal : Economic crisis
Pakistan : on Verge of civil war and economic crisis
Edit:
Maldives : Going underwater
India have seen many things like that in his last 5000 years history and we have learned from our mistakes so no worries
👁👄👁
That's what happens when you don't listen to India & instead sell yourselves to China.
Bangladesh should be more worried tbh
India have nice Hindutva Fascists in government so they dont have to worry. The modi government can just commit some cheeky genocide against muslims or sikhs and a large proportion of indian men will let them do what thry want economically. /s
This is what happens when you focus more on hate towards another nation (India) than on putting food on your own table. This disaster is Pakistan's own making, and also it's own choosing. They chose to put Kashmir issues with India (which doesnt even matter to them) over everything else. Selling themselves out to China, harbouring violent terrorists in Afghanistan, and lobbying hard against India has further completely crippled them.
Honestly, Pakistan completely deserves all that is happening right now
Yeah, Im sure Kashmir doesnt matter to Mr. Modi whatsoever. He could just let it go and not worry. India-Pakistan is such obvious tit for tat behaviour. British fault of course in historical sense but it takes two to tango.
@@CommunistLlama Well the OG comment did not say not to tango ... But first eat breakfast then come to dance floor
Their whole poltics revolve around India and Kashmir. They didn't settle this down cause then how come they can claim Pak need this big of army and military budget. They need a scapegoat and it was kashmir. They spend 15% of they GDP budget on military budget that also doesn't include the pention army give to theirs general and normal soldiers. No one in Pak can have the power now to ask why Pak has this big of army. If u ask a normal he would say india scare our army that's why they want us to defame their army. Their whole jeehadi mind Thinks their military scares india. Whereas india spend only 2% of its budget on military still having more than double military power. Every war has been initiated by Pakistan and they still talk about India will attack us if we don't have big army. So the common idiot man beleive them like a fool and eat dirt to feed those generals homes.
@@CommunistLlama We let go Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, now kashmir is dispute and you are telling let kashmir go to. Nice thought, thought of a great and very kind person.
@@CommunistLlama The difference is India focuses more on its economy than the remaining Kashmir and Pakistan does the opposite. Tell me if that's not the case.
Morarji Desai the Indian PM responsible for Pakistan's nuclear weapon 🤬
Our secret ISI Agent Your PM "Moraji Desai. Thanks Moraji 🙏😅😅
@@mike-oj7sy😂 AT LEAST IT DIDNT DAMAGE INDIA AND NEITHER WILL IN FUTURE BECAUSE ITS IN USA ANYWAY THANKS TO SHEIKH MUJIBUR REHMAN AND IMRAN KHAN FOR BEING RAW AGENT XD
True
No country is too big to fail. If that was the case then USSR would not have collapsed. The world community should manage the collapse of pakistan in a similar way like they did with USSR and should together secure their nuclear arms which are indeed a threat to the world in the hands of ideologically driven army and radicalized population as evident by the army’s support to terrorism making it the country to host the highest number of banned terrorist organizations and terrorists in the world.
P.S Osama Bin Laden was found in the army town of Abbottabad in Pakistan.
The USSR arsenals mostly transfered to the different successor nations, with the nuclear arsenal in Russia. We didn't get to see a nuclear-armed post-soviet minor nation.
P. S osama bin laden worked in the CIA.
Difference is the USSR divided into several states, but didn't turn into a failed state.
Which is the worrying scenario here, where the nukes are "loose".
@kira Ukraine should have kept their nukes and all delivery systems. Had they done so, Russia would never have invaded. A nuclear arsenal is worth much more than security agreements and promises to respect sovereignty.
USSR was not a country but a Zionists creation.
The bedrock issue isn't the debt, the main issue is accountability. Over the decades it has constantly squandered the bailouts and loans instead of building its economy infrastructure and education. The amount of money it's gotten over the years is insane. And yet countries in southeast Asia with lesser funding have been able to build themselves into a stronger more stable government, provide basic necessities to it's people and jobs( eg Vietnam and Iran, and they both went through alot more than Pakistan.)
oh i'd not be so sure of Iran
@@zimriel it’s a lot better than Syria or post gaddafi libya.
NOTHING has been squandered. The $$$ are allegedly "invested" in private fortunes overseas , in countries that preach fiscal transparency but....
Exactly. If the IMF/China/etc. bails out Pakistan again, they'll just spend the money building even more fundamentalist Islamic madrassas. Even in the middle of the current crisis, Imran Khan's headline policy was giving tens of millions of dollars more funding to the terrorist factories.
It's not the country's people, the puppet governments and their leaders raped pillaged looted the country's wealth, as most do...
Every country has an army but incase of Pakistan an army have a country
Worked for Prussia...
The other example I can think of is Egypt, where the army keeps turning up in everything from construction to the tourist industry.
@@ArawnOfAnnwn find Prussia on a map then... Oh yeah, its called Poland now. RIP
@@Barwasser butthurt poltard
@@ArawnOfAnnwn Until it collapsed a couple years later….
World's 4th largest oil reserve has been found in Pakistan about 3 weeks ago
🇺🇸: hi
@aqua2poweros699 hello 🇧🇩
My impression of Pakistan since during Afghanistan era, as a nation, was that they were double-crossing and definitely not to be trusted. And since Afghanistan, the influence of China (in the region) has become much clearer. (Somewhat strange bedfellows since Communists are godless and have shown less than regard for Pakistan's and Afghanistan's Muslim brethren.)
In any event, as far as I'm concerned, Pakistan is reaping all it has sown. And they deserve every bit of it.
L comment!
@@rohand04 yupp i know but as an INDIAN i still feel sorry for the PEOPLE.....i know they hate us especially someone like me Indian and upon that a HINDU 🕉......but let's just pray 🙏 that the people get through this with the least difficulties.😢
Indeed it was Pakistan who was helping Talibans in Afghanistan, now it fires back to them back. Pakistan is with China because of animosity with india, because China and India have long time conflict about rivers and borders. It is indeed funny as you said that great muslims and believers as they like to represent themselves are co-operating with China who has put Uyghur muslims whole nation in concentration camps. All their trouble comes from their hypocritical politics, not to mention corruption and other problems.
@@tipus737 stfu do u even know how they treat everyone?
@@zexer_ity What kind of a moronic statement is this ! " They hate me but I'll pray for them . " What are you ? A Gandhi fanboy i assume , no other sane person could say this with a straight face !
Every country have army...but in Pakistan army have a country 😅😊
😂
Nice one
Same in Burma, Egypt and perhaps a few other countries, Pak isn’t alone.
Same goes for Endia , where military will kill anyone that is Muslim
@@rvharikrishnasudan, chad etc etc. A country is as good as it's military institutions are loyal. Some countries are so military dependant that their military end up with all the power.
"While Economies is a gun Politics is knowing when to pull the trigger"
That line - Genius 😁🔥
That line is taken from Godfather 3. Watch that movie if you can. The entire Godfather trilogy is a masterpiece
Frim Godfather III
Those movies are way overrated
Trash
Godfather lll, Don Lucchesi speaking to Vincent Mancini.
@@ivanr4300 You must not be a movie fan. Radio is more your speed.
Its funny how people blame Chinese unconditional loans for breaking countries economies but here us yet another great example of how its American and IMF conditional loans that break economies.
When the topic is about india
Indians will assemble
When the topic is about Pakistan
Indians will assemble.
Keep your friends close and enemy more closer
Avengers, assemble!
Unsecured nation for a reason
There is a reason why they are called R,ndians
@@User50981 Haha Nice joke My T€®®0rist Neighbour.
World knows about paapistan.
Corruption and no rule of law is the biggest disaster for Pakistan
Pakistan has been on a spree to going to IMF & other institutions for credit so long,but never introspected itself that there is some thing wrong with themself.
Pakistan is the best example of spolied nation who never learns from past mistakes ,but keeps committing blunder mistakes.
Pakistan is pathological liar. A country based on 7th century fascist pdofile ideology will obviously fail.
I hope the masses get it that their military just wants to keep their people poor and on their toes.
You must be indian😂😂
@@TheShadowPerson. yes and he is right
@@somnambulist6636 i know. i can just tell when indians rant about pakistan😂😂im american you guys have no chill
"Economics is gun, and politics is when to pull the trigger." WOW
India is never gonna extend the claim. Indian government would just be looking to take back POK form Pakistan, we don't desire even an inch of Pakistani land, we'll just take what's ours. And it's not the question of If but when.
Kashmir will never be urs, kewp dreaming
@@hhydar883 Most of it has been ours for the last 75 years! Don't worry, the rest will be too. Peace❤✌
@@hhydar883 Once your Army stops getting required funds due to economic crisis, pok is in our hands.
Pok ? Try talking an inch every Indian will be turned to nuclear dust
@@debarghyaroy9948 no lol india only has 47% rest is with Pakistan and China
*No outside force should be blamed for any mishaps in Pakistan,* it was the work of our own army, our own corrupt politicians, our own policies, our own blunders and ignorance of each and everyone of us(citizens). It is saddening but it's true, although external factors do play a major role but we should've had resilient inside.
As a Pakistani I promise that I will work hard for the betterment of my country. Cause at the end of the day no one can help us if we dont want change ourselves and are willing to work hard for it.
Thx for this video @Caspian report!
There are a lot of people who work hard here, brother. We need some sensible person in politics too!
@@mantasha_binte_idrees.20 yea, I hope Imran khan is best for us.
@@ans42131 he sold religion to people after living a lavish life all those years and made himself a hero. And people actually bought this. I don’t know when people will understand this.
@@mantasha_binte_idrees.20 then idk if we'll ever get a good leader, cause we certainly don't have anyone right now if we even exclude Imran khan.
Every muslim knows only the first four halifs were righteous. It's ingrained in islamic dogma. Why are you expecting a righteous leader? It's not happening.
Decentralized jamaats is the only way.
Pakistani army is the most unique army of this world it owns lands and industry of Pakistan and there general owns papa John's in USA but when it comes to war then they only know how to do surrender 😂😂😂😂
Couple of days back they were boasting we can take fight to enemy land and now their army commander fled his house.
Abhinandan mi 17 chopper kulbushan all these ring a bell ?
@@hke.4475 There is a looooong list of Pakistani military failure my friend.
Interestingly, in your answer you mention MI17, which was downed by India itself 😂, an officer's mistake on our side.
You see, your army isn't what it portrays itself to be. Wake up and smell the coffee.
@@hke.4475 😂 these mindset dragged u down to beg infront of imf and every country in the world your people eyes in pakistan blinded by Qur'an and now begging from other countries for dollars
@@hke.4475 Can not hear it as 93000 bells are ringing till date with more than 1000 decibels.
the day india completely boycotted pakistan it fell off
😂 SINCE MODIJI CAME INTO POWER PAKISTAN IS STRUGGLING TO FIND A LOAF OF BREAD
@@matheistician andhbhakt at it again stupid tuhh! destabilized Pakistan is threat to India too! a military coup will happen and the stupid deep state will call a war on us and it's be so taxing on us and our economy! and imagine an Taliban like organisation conquer them. india's half budget will go in security rather than helping us! toh stop watching that stupid study iq channel and learn some good stuff by books and unbiased channel!
We Pakistanis have a simple problem: the only language the people understand is religion while the elite only understand greed.
Thank God East Pakistan gained independance from you
@@hackromplayer5122 nahh this hate was first started in East pakistan only(Calcutta and Noakhali Riots are prime examples)
We Pakistanis don't use religion as opium but as panadol. No matter what disease you are suffering from you can always swallow a tablet of it 😂😂😂😂😂
@DarkKnight-db1dy Do you know why that happened?
@@hackromplayer5122what when did they gain own Pakistan
Bangladeshis count their blessings for not living under Pakistani army rule anymore. They made great sacrifices for their independence but ensure beneficial life for their fellow Bangladeshis.
As indian i could say pakistan still has the mentality of colonial era and using relegion than development and mistreatment of minorities and relegious minorities. As whole Pakistanis are awesome and kind people but compared to other Muslims natuons they are radicalized to core and cannot live in a secular aociety unless they reform themselves.
Reformation of minds takes decades. Do you think it’s possible in 1-2 years?
Nah the only problem is foreign controlled and foreign governed politics, only on religion can unity be accomplished. Ultimately Secularism should be thrown out of the window. We will Inshallah follow the route of Afghanistan and Iran, this puppet and unstable regime will fall and give way to an Islamic Revolution which will end all the corruption and destruction that have been commited by these secular nationalist regimes
That's most muslim countries, turns out that when you're a theocratic ethnostate you begin fucking people over horribly. Until people stop turning places into theocracies, doesn't matter if it's a Christian, jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, or Hindu, any of them really, this shit will never end. Religion taken to its logical conclusion is fucking horrifyingly brutal on every level, and radicalization is the general end point for when a religion is taken too far.
Least delusional Indian 😂
Islam promotes terrorism
Show the right map of Kashmir brother, it's an integral part of 🇮🇳 ❤
no its not. its a disputed territory under international law.
@@jubnaa International law? It's a bilateral issue between India and Pakistan... nevermind, the world is watching the riots happening in PoK for freedom from Pakistan 🤣
@@GMS0011 Riots are what every pakistani does against the govt. The fact that the people of kashmir are rioting means that they are just like the people in lahore or karachi. Also U.N resolution makes it an international dispute.
@@jubnaa The fact that your country doesn't have a stable government and you live under the rule of your army, riots are bound to happen😂
Secondly, Pakistan should concentrate on repaying it's loans to IMF instead of Kashmir. Your country is in such a dire situation that even UN resolutions wouldn't be helpful... Kashmiris suffering the attrocities of Pakistan in illegaly occupied PoK would themselves want to merge with Bharat. So, Repeated after me...
The entire Jammu and Kashmir, WAS, IS, AND ALWAYS WILL BE a part of Bharat! Bharat Mata Ki Jai!
It's still partitioned idk what your on lil bro.
I don't understand how these countries can pay for these nuclear weapons that can destroy billions of lives of other countries yet can't lift the millions of lives of their own from abject poverty.
This has never happened, except a Christian country America did, No Muslim country has hit another country with nuclear weapons. What did the Christians do? You remember Nagasaki and Hiroshima country, Japan.?Non muslim country hited non muslim country Japan.
What if Afghanistan had nuclear weapons?Afghanistan can do 100% nuclear attack on PakistanFor no reason other than jealousy
I have been to Pakistan many times over the years, Pakistani people are 100% nice and friendly
And I have never seen a place like Pakistan, even the West cannot compete with Pakistan in many thingsThis has never happened.If we study the case that Japan's services were acquired by America, the facts show that there is no reason other than jealousy. America wanted to destroy Japan's trade.The war was in Europe and America dropped the atomic bomb on Japan, an Asian country, even though Japan was not a part of the world war.
@@rositalondon6439 maybe you're missing the point... Forget about superficial brownie points if you can. The government has the purpose of serving the best interests of the people. To judge this approximately, look at the general average standard of living (don't cherry pick a homeless fentanyl addict) to see if the best interests of the people are being served.
@@raplopez4258 This has never happened, except a Christian country America did, No Muslim country has hit another country with nuclear weapons. What did the Christians do? You remember Nagasaki and Hiroshima country, Japan.?Non muslim country hited non muslim country Japan.
What if Afghanistan had nuclear weapons?Afghanistan can do 100% nuclear attack on PakistanFor no reason other than jealousy
I have been to Pakistan many times over the years, Pakistani people are 100% nice and friendly
And I have never seen a place like Pakistan, even the West cannot compete with Pakistan in many thingsThis has never happened.If we study the case that Japan's services were acquired by America, the facts show that there is no reason other than jealousy. America wanted to destroy Japan's trade.The war was in Europe and America dropped the atomic bomb on Japan, an Asian country, even though Japan was not a part of the world war.
@@rositalondon6439 Muslim Nations to poor
Burning with jealousy, this is a big burden on this upload, this media has no effect and has zero value, only man can be busy filling the sack of sins of lies, nothing more.i can geuss that caspian repot id holder is an afhani hinding behind propeganda cronicles..pakistan is feeding 7 millions Afghanis immigrants
The main reason for Pakistan to not progress and stay politically unstable is military establishment. Every time Pakistan gets a stable government who tries to take some corrective measures, military generals jump in to save the status-quo. Its unfortunate but true and hence the cycle of turmoil goes on.
This is also the first time in the history of the country that the population has raised against the military. Totally unprecedented, but completely justified. Down with the corrupt generals
It's also because of the way the country was founded - muslim leaguers didn't have much organic support in present Pakistan territories (unionist party feudals were strong there) and middle Indian migrants only made up 10% of the population - concentrated in Karachi. The political elites sabotaged democracy because they realized they could not win elections in the new country.
They started this 'technocratic rule' nonsense - which the military eventually took over.
mm makes sense
Well you need PEOPLE to ALLOW the cycle of turmoil to go on...........like autocracy in China keeps going on and on and on...............and army rule (also autocracy, learned from China, maybe??) still keeps on and on and on. It takes a certain kind of mindset TO BOOT THE INVADERS OUT OF YOUR COUNTRY
Also Islam
A nation born out of hate, will die out of hate.
More true words could not be spoken
That's every other country lol
@@moizahmed7392 you did not get it
Yes
Agr hum gaye to India ko sath Leke jayegy aur sab dushmano ko bhi
As an Indian I'd say we don't want any tainted land of Pakistan. Gilgit Baltistan is our land which is illegally occupied by Pakistan (or POK) and they have to evacuate it ASAP.
lol. why dont you evacuate Junagadh first then. if we have to go by instrument of accession.
@@jubnaa junagarh nawab signed the petition with pakistan government without the consent of civilians of Junagarh where 80% hindu and 20% muslim population.... He betrayed his civilians thus the civilians started a revolt against their king and that coward fleed to pakistan... even Indian administration hosted him for the consent agreement of Junagarh but that coward never came back and resided in paxtan and when asked why then your government denied to talk on the decision... thus with consent of all civilians Junagarh came under India... and lemme tell you despite 80% hindu,96% civilians of junagarh voted to stay with India...
I dunno what your illiterate maulvis told you, but this is the truth... and that's the reason no revolt in Gujarat ever witnessed to separate from India..
@@kushagrasrivastava3030 were the 75% Muslim population of Kashmir consulted by the Maharaja before signing an instrument to India? Are you forgetting the history of poonch rebellion? Are you forgetting how the population of Gilgit Baltistan fought alongside the Gilgit scouts for a year and a half against the indian army? Mounbatten stopped the ruler of jaipur from joining india because of it being a hindu majority state but kashmir he had no problem with joining india despite it being a muslim majority state. Also the people of gilgit baltistan are not kashmiris, they never associated themselves with kashmir, gilgit agency was ruled seperately from the pricely state. it was only returned to the maharaja , just weeks before partition.
@@jubnaa You should thank your Mohammad ali jinnah for the atrocities and poor condition amd administration of pakistan....If he didn't decided to make Pakistan independent....you would be living a peaceful and happy life with an easy day everyday with us brother....
But history has been created and it cannot be changed
"tumhara pakistan tumko mubarak"
lekin kashmir legally india ka part hai aur china and pakistan se hum bharat ka taaj vapas le bhi lenge...
You continue your cry for Kashmir, islam economy,food and sanity...India is on it's way to dominate the world and by 2027 we will occupy the position of 3rd largest economy of this whole world.... India is sufficiently capable to capture the land of Baltistan by declaring war now which will last less than a week but we prioritise the safety of our citizens and humanity first, We are not heartless and ruthless like you that's why India is not taking ultimate actions for the sake of the innocent citizens of pakistan who are struggling to make their ends meet..
Cry as far as you can...
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳❤️
@@jubnaa You should thank your Mohammad ali jinnah for the atrocities and poor condition amd administration of pakistan....If he didn't decided to make Pakistan independent....you would be living a peaceful and happy life with an easy day everyday with us brother....
But history has been created and it cannot be changed..
"tumhara pakistan tumko mubarak"
lekin kashmir legally india ka part hai aur china and pakistan se hum bharat ka taaj vapas le bhi lenge...
You continue your cry for Kashmir, islam economy,food and sanity...India is on it's way to dominate the world and by 2027 we will occupy the position of 3rd largest economy of this whole world.... India is sufficiently capable to capture the land of Baltistan by declaring war now which will last less than a week but we prioritise the safety of our citizens and humanity first, We are not heartless and ruthless like you that's why India is not taking ultimate actions for the sake of the innocent citizens of pakistan who are struggling to make their ends meet..
Cry as far as you can...
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳❤️
Wish we all had "cooler heads and better policymaking" right now, around the world.
Thanks again, Shirvan. 👏👏❤️🌎😎
For sure!
>"Cooler head and better
policymaking"
Sadly that is sorely lacking these days.
me too, homie
Who's Shirvan?
@@ArmageddonIsHere
The guy who makes Caspian Reports
Fun Fact: since its independence, not even a single Pakistani Prime Minister has completed a full term.
Fun Fact: People like you cant help but copycat other popular comments to get upvotes
@@ZX235w3 Fun Fact: Your ass burns evetime someone make a copycat comments'
Funfact : prime ministers have no power the army controls em
@Jonathan bro can't accept the truth tho...
@@ZX235w3 what is your point?
He true though
Pakistan and India are natural trade partners, but ideology and boarder conflict has kept up embargos that effect Pakistan far more negatively than India.
They never wanted to trade with hindoos. That is reason they wanted separation
🇮🇳 has no problem yaar!!
They want us and not the other way around. U guys are busy thinking it has nukes, so it’s too big to fall!!
Well, USSR had the world’s largest nukes and got disintegrated.!!
🇮🇳 knows when and where to strike and we will take our land back without the people whose ancestors voted to bifurcate Bharat on the basis of religion!!
It’s gonna get interesting from now because west no longer can support 🇵🇰 to counter 🇮🇳!!
End of colonialism happening from 28 May 2023!!
Akhand Bharat will no longer be a dream!!
Pakistan does not trade with India over Kashmir. They prefer to buy the same potatoes and tomatoes from the UAE (at a very high cost )that the UAE bought from India for its own consumption. Pakistan also built a very expensive metro in Lahore with help of china on more debt even though they are already in debt. Pakistan is mess but doesn't want to change itself.
@@sneha6652 because Pakistan's policies are stupid.
@@sneha6652 completely agree with what you said, my own nation's government and military are full of such ignorants who prefer their inflated egos over the development and peace.
the pakistani map is wrong. Kashmir is part of India
Those are international recognized borders
well ofcourse u point that out just be real that is part of pakistan and indians have their own
Line Of Control. Where delusion ends and cold hard reality begins.
Yeah living in this country nowadays literally feels like hell. Sometimes I think about suicide but then I remember that I can't left my family behind.
Bro please don't do anything like that. Let's hope there is a better future and there will be love from India🇮🇳
Come to US, we have community in Michigan that are Muslim oriented. I’m sure they would except you.
Your GDP per capita is 1500 usd and yet you are a nuclear state. This is very bad
Move out to any country , if u don’t have money move to any country in middle east or Africa
It is never that bad. I know sometimes it feels like nothing you do works but you have to hang in there. Once the storm passes, you will realize the world still has plenty of good in it. Even in Pakistan. Be strong.
Well this is quite the predicament isn't it. I'm a Pakistani being told by a guy who speaks in English (my second language) that my country is a failed nation 😢.
And funnily, I agree with his statements
How are the sentiments within the Pak at the moment? What does local media talk about the national loans/debt?
@@AnshulChauhan95 I'm scared. That is all you have to know.
In a sense, nothing is over until its actually over. The world has had sudden changes before. I wonder if you were to list the top 10 problems for Pakistan now and try to deal with just one of them.
Which would be the least hard to deal with?
Hope comes from picking a large impossible problem into smaller components.
@@PuskasW Will the nation fall? What about the war you have with Talibans?
Tell me about it!!!!
Next video: "the world is dying" (and that's a global problem)
Ok chill out there Greta
(and thats no ones problem)
(And that's a good thing)
You are gdmn right
That's a universal problem 😂
Pakistan gave about 25,000 muslim girls to Chinese men in exchange of loan. Marriage with Chinese men become a new trend in Pakistan. 😊
Well what about India? Looks like it’s one of the most dangerous country for women, especially doctors! Yk how may women get r@9ed every year in India?? And then they barely get any justice
Absolutely beautiful presentation. As far as Pakistan goes, it is paying for its distorted policies and bad management/ loot by army.
Army ? What about the politicians like PMLN and PPP ?
“Finance is a gun. Politics is knowing when to pull the trigger,” Mario Puzo, The Godfather
Wise words, Shirvan
@A B his name is not shivram 😊
@@WaveRider1989 oh silly me. It is Shirvan, meaning a Lion-Rider in sweet Persian.
@@A_R_B_G doesn't end in m, look at the credits 15:04
@@naeemformuli6830 thanks for translation, that's pretty cool!
Seems like pak army doesn't know to pull the trigger...😂
The biggest problem with PAK government(not people) is that despite looking at their internal downfall...they tend to focus more on external useless affairs...I agree that Indo-Pak relationships are not as we would desire...but this is absolutely not the time for terrorism or poking on external matters be it internal Talibans or attacking India. It's primary focus should be boosting economy as we know the inflation in PAK is at its peak. People want 💰,🍞,🏠 not 💣...No hate!✌️
That is a tactic used by all pak govt in power ...to divert attention from their own wrong doings , they keep bringing up kashmir,human rights in india ....human rights , uh ? Pakistan talking about human rights of minorities in other countries is an irony...
@@vrindabolinjkar3861 not just pak
Why not people? Who eventually forms the government? Its the people!! Pakistan's people have been fed wrong versions of history in school, they have been living in a world of their own since 1947!!! What's happening now was bound to happen
Pakistani government and media or people hardly care or talk about India. No political party go to elections talking about india. It’s always indian where pakistan live rent free in everyone brain.
the biggest problem with Pakistan is the people. They are obsessed with hating India and Hindus and yet they sit on Hindu lands.
The only solution Is Free Balochistan.
Free yourself then 😂😂 no army and even half the population of balochs live in other provinces. Who’s gonna fight for you against our army 😢😢😂😂
Any new country will just die of without any resources even a sea to trade it's just a blunder if it happens
Are you also going to do the same in Iranian balochistan?
Support azad balochistan from india
This is why you don't build a country based purely off religion, all it can lead to is instability, compared with India which more or less learnt to have different groups working together (but even that isn't perfect)
This.
Pakistan should split into 4 nation-states, so they can follow a more european model of development.
Especially Islam, it's bad for every nation.
I don't have the numbers but if you were to do a study on the subject matter I wouldn't be surprised if the reversed is true. Multicultural states often goes to shit as soon as the economy does poorly. That's why a lot of the successful ones are here because the bad ones died out.
@@The_Midnight_Bear that or the Indian subcontinent should have never been divided. If India's infrastructure extended into modern day Pakistan, the standard of living would have been actually okay. Plus, a higher Muslim population would force Hindu nationalist movements to yield, possibly allowing for more religious tolerance in India. Modi is a symptom of this mistake.
You can build a country based purely off religion. Just that the religion has to be malleable and liberal to changing times with the ability to criticize and discuss.
What can you expect from a military ditactorship! You need intellectuals, policy makers and diplomats to run a Nation, not just Military Dictatorship.
military dictatorship is one thing, Pakistan is a military dictatorship which is funded and dictated by the British MI6 and American Cia . A honest , pure selfless military dictatorship would be great . Pakistan is a British-American satellite state.
@@shaniell.mathur6372 Absolutely, no doubt about that.
0:06: Pakistan's import-dependent economy has run out of foreign exchange, causing food and energy shortages.
0:21: The resulting economic hardship is driving political polarization, radicalization, and extremism.
0:30: The domestic instability in Pakistan could escalate border disputes and potentially destabilize South Asia.
9:25: Pakistan's growing $130 billion external debt is unsustainable and draining foreign exchange.
10:03: Haircuts, debt restructuring, and postponement of interest payments are necessary for recovery.
10:31: Private creditors and multilateral institutions hold a significant portion of Pakistan's debt and may hinder resolution efforts.
Recap by Tammy AI
This is so dumb. Why would Afghanistan invade Pakistan? They are allies. Even if the taliban decides to invade Pakistan the military will easily crush them. A militia group can’t defeat one of the worlds strongest militaries.
Really, stop living in a fancy world, especially when Pakistan owes 130 billion in debt and nobody wants to bail Pakistan out because Financial institutions and donor countries know that Pakistan is unable to pay them back. Military however strong needs munitions and to make or buy them also needs financial resources which Pakistan does not have at the moment.
@@soldierof-allah11 You have some serious misconceptions and loose grip on geopolitics. What happened was the matter of past. Afghanistan and Pakistan are hardcore enemies now. There are multiple reasons for a future conflict b/w two. The most dominant one is Taliban's claim over Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa region of Pakistan. Taliban doesn't recognise Durand Line (Afghan-Pak international border) drawn by British (Sir Durand). Now coming to the Pakistan's Military Strength, there are several anti-state/separatist rebel groups inside Pakistan like BLA and TTP and they keep capturing pieces of land in Pakistan and bring enough casualties to the army. They may calture some really important strategic locations in the time of war. Addition to that Pakistan lack money to keep up fight for a longer period of time. Pakistan is a doomed state.
@@_omnipotent07 This is wrong. I agree there are seperatist groups but they control no land and exist only as insurgencies
Pakistan is most underdeveloped nation and very much poor and high inflation but they have billionaire army generals that is the main problem.
This is the 3rd video/article I've read on the threat of Pakistan's nuclear weapons falling in the wrong hands. Their nuclear weapons have already fallen into the wrong hands several times. A stable Pakistan was a rogue state anyway. There seems to be a concerted effort by DGISPR to get their hands on the IMF loans by scaring everyone as usual
Beggars turning to dacoity, this is how Mughal became rich. You think these people made india rich 😂
Might be best to just eliminate Pakistan altogether.
Reasons behind the army state of Pakistan's sufferings
1. USA's exit from Afghanistan and subsequent stoppage of donations to Pakistan from USA.
2. Pakistan has fooled the IMF 22 times but this time IMF took tough stance and that country is suffering.
Wow, IMF got fooled 22 times. India should take advantage of the IMF. Just stop at 21 times, else IMF will wise up.
Nope
Pakistan has never learned from its mistakes that's why we have this situation today in Pakistan ( i am an Indian)
Pakistan will never bow down before India.
@@yasirshahani2544already begging IMF for food🤣🤣
@@yasirshahani2544 fine fine we don't like groveling anyway.
Do whatever you wish
@@yasirshahani2544 already did in 1971 you are high on weed 😂😂😂
@@yasirshahani2544eat grass
All Indians pls ask this channel to use correct Indian map.
J and k ,aksai chin is integral part of India.
India has a border shared with Afganistan.
Pls all guys ask this channel and other channels to use correct Indian maps
I feel sad about their status. They are ethnically and culturally almost same as us and I hope they recover from crisis, Love from India
Thanks brother love from Pakistan
aji mera kaddu similar, atankwadi pille hai sale...
Thanks for the comment.
Where are you from, both Hetansh and Moin?
Good to receive love from you brother
Fun fact: When pakistan suspended trade with India in 2019, they didn't technically stop buying Indian goods.
Distributors in the UAE and Kenya(maybe others) just bought cheap Indian goods, slapped a fake sticker on it and sold it to Pakistan for an increased price.
Lol
What a joke
@@AbdullahHashi-kw3qj that's the truth...what's the joke in real sense is the entire political spectrum in Pakistan and the concept of Pakistan as a nation... Nations born out of hatred are bound to break.... It happened in 1971... It will happen again
@@Dexter_Diesel pak wasn't born out of hate, it was born out of safe guarding Muslim interest in india, and infact even Indians will tell you that it was GOOD that pak separated, bcuz would be at each others throats constantly
Jinnah the founder of Pakistan thought and acted like ataturk, it's those after him who made everything about religion
@@AbdullahHashi-kw3qj That belief that jinnah asked for pakistan to safeguard so and so doesn't stand tall outside pakistan. The same country killed the founder's sister and none of the founder's family stayed a muslim, married a muslim and remained in pakistan.
@@AbdullahHashi-kw3qjtrue, imagine Pakistan wasn't created , our (Hindus) response against the genocides during direct action day would have been catastrophic for Muslims
It's fine as it is now , although I hope we Indians can take advantage of this scenario and take back our territories in POK
That will be risky as hell but worth it
It's important to consider that a country's status as a nuclear power doesn't justify all actions. Pakistan faces challenges such as corruption, military involvement in politics, and terrorist activities. Merely providing bailouts without addressing underlying issues won't lead to positive progress. One possible approach could be linking assistance to the condition of nuclear disarmament. When helping a troubled nation, it may be beneficial to reduce their empowerment.
I'd like to see what China wants to do. I know they have kept channels with Afghanistan, Pakistan etc. They're an option for nations that don't want demands on democracy and such. The PRC hasn't stopped the ongoing korean republic's nuclear program, they're still a chinese client state.
The problem is the sheer risk involved for everyone. Better to have a poor but stable nuclear State than a collapsed one
They will never give up on the nuclear weapons as they are in conflict with India, another nuclear state. There is no solution there yet.
The disarmament of Pakistan would almost certainly lead to India invading. Nuclear weapons and Pakistan's relationship with China are the only reasons why India has been kept at bay.
@@ContraVsGigi they should stop funding terrorists...that is the simple and only solution.....
1:59 wrong map of INDIA , Kashmir is an entegral part of INDIA illegally occupied by Pakistan.
no its not. its a disputed territory under international law.
People usually say East India Company vanished. The way I see the world today, it has just diversified in pockets of the world and evolved with time. Pakistan army is one such subsidiary of EIC.
The harsh truth...
Yes Britain Soviet Great Game
Pakistan as Major Non NATO ally
Pakistan selling out 🇦🇫 to 🇺🇸🇬🇧
Pakistan supporting US backed Libyan "Rebels"
Pakistan is there to keep 🇮🇳 in check for 🇬🇧
Can you elaborate on that? The EIC certainly left wealth and influence in various British families and companies evolving from it. Colonial administrations and connections also certainly somehow survived. But are these connections still visible or effective?
It's embarrassing to see how little I know about any of this, even though I spend a lot of time reading about everything.
@@michaelutech4786 most of the institutions gained legitimately. The concept Nationstates saw some popularity peaking in the cold war.
But as corporate power centers became evident, the once that inherited colonial structures sought a unchallenged slice of growth.
The military industrial complex in Burma, Pakistan, and even India or Singapore for that matter are noteworthy.
The share size of India & population made it impossible for unicentric institutions. Yet it suffers from military cantonments in the middle of cities that too the south.
While Pakistan or Burma does not suffer from such challenges.
There is not a list of power structures ever built in those countries more powerful than inherited colonial ones.
To state an example of imagine Samsung is for South Korea.
Yet Pak & Burma could be called lucky as they have a localised identity and have to justify crimes. On the other hand most African nations are yet under direct rule of western secret services.
We are so grateful to get separated from Pakistan in 1971. Such a terribly conflicted nation
Thank india for that
@@mayankimmortal Great salute to the late Indira Gandhi and Sam Manekshaw
@@mayankimmortal Why? India did nothing. Its the Bangladeshis who fought for 9 months.
@@MWaheduzzamanKhan1 if indian navy didn't block Pakistani supply then you people would have been massacred by now
Have some gratitude.
I know we can't expect that from mu$lim.
@@MWaheduzzamanKhan1 because India wouldn't have supported then Bangladesh wouldn't have won.
Having visited Pakistan many times and come across it's peoples generous hospitality and the stunning natural beauty, sadly the only question I have is:
How did Pakistan even make it so far?
The levels of rampant corruption in Government, the social services, the military and the police are astounding. And it has been this way for decades.
Deep rooted Islamic fundamentalism and hate towards Hindus and India led this situation in which Pakistan is.
75 years of just hobbling ahead.
At the beginning it was good, even south korea came to Pakistan to learn. However more corrupt leaders and the army having power led to them just begging for money
Hospitality and generosity is only for foreigners and for temporary period , once u ask to stay there and if u are a non muslim ,then u will be converted or killed.
Strange that you visited Pakistan many times and were able to figure out the country's military is corrupt. Question is where did you come across the military's corruption while you visited the country "many times". Somebody whose was born and lived there I have come across the military many time while visiting cantonment areas perhaps a dozen times a year but was never exposed to their "corruption". I am not saying the military isn't corrupt in the least but for somebody whose visited Pakistan "many times" the comment seems more so a fabrication than reality. Cool comment though, first make them feel you bode well 'come across it's peoples generous hospitality and the stunning natural beauty,' and then go for the hit.
As an ex-pat Pakistani, I left when I was 6 -- I guess I knew what life in Pakistan would portend. As said by an elder in my family, many years ago, "Pakistan has to be ruled with an iron fist." I was sad then, but always believed the Pakistani people, rugged, hard-working, gracious, intelligent and family-centered, did not need an iron fist to rule them, but a common vision. That is what has yet to materialize out of Pakistan.
" Pakistan is worried more about India's growth and not their own collapsing Country "
@@lolololllll I have 50-50 on that. I talked to a few pakistani guys and they were very sweet. At the same time I've seen quite radicalized people (and high intolerance for other religions in general too)
@@hidum5779 oh yea there is a serious issue in pakistan with religious extremism and in my personal opinion it’s one of the main reasons pakistan has been failing as a nation.
However, even the extremists are not particularly against india, they are against everyone who is against their views (even other muslims of different sects or beliefs) regardless of their nationality, ethnicity or even family relationship.
My point is that other than the issue of kashmir, pakistanis don’t have a grudge against indians. Even in the rare occasions when india is mentioned on pakistani media or by the people, the ratio is overwhelming positive or at least respectful
@@lolololllll like I said 50-50
I was honestly shocked when I talked to a Pakistani man (and much older than me) and he was extremely respectful to me. Addressing me as "ji bhai".
Honestly speaking at that moment it felt like Indians can learn a few things from Pakistanis in addressing others especially. Really humble guy.
But I have definitely seen the other side too, so there's that.
@@lolololllll we in the West are always reading about how Christians and Hindus in Pakistan, who are not Indians but Pakistanis, are being persecuted.
This makes difficult for Western liberals, who are predominantly of Christian heritage but also have a lot of Hindu sympathies, to sympathise with Pakistan.
Western conservatives (I am one) could possibly come around to pro-Islam sympathy but we will not accept persecution of Christians.
@@lolololllllwe watch videos of local youtubers interacting with locals in Pakistan 😅the amount of poison in their minds about India and Hindus is quite visible so we know the reality
These are self inflicted wounds I am a Pakistani and have done much research on the military establishment. They are the ones who are responsible for this...
The longest running collapse in history. I remember an American expert talking about the collapse in Afpak, a portmanteau of Afghanistan and Pakistan in the early 2000's.
9/11 happened and America started handing out billions of dollars to Pakistan and so did IMF for 14 times in a row. Those are the only things that kept Pakistan alive for 2 decades.
Now that it’s gone no wonder Pakistan is dying.
I had a map of the AfPak by National Geographic in my office cubicle for years. Also, being of a Pakistani dad and an American mom, I am a HalfPak 🤡🤷🏽♂