No offense to any other companions, but Clara is the best. Sure Rose is a flower, Donna has a book store named after her, Martha Jones might have the Dow Jones industrial average, but Clara is a hacker. And the doctor probably isn't even a real doctor.
I’m confused, so is her middle name Oswin and her last name Oswald or is it the other way round? Edit: I’m just asking because I got a bit confused while people are using different names in the comments.
@@themoon8321 This version of Clara is just called Oswin Oswald. Victorian Clara is called Clara Oswin Oswald, and Prime Clara is just called Clara Oswald
I have to wonder. Say the Doc wasn't pressed for time. What would he have done with Oswin? She is Dalek, though with the mind of a human. Just figured it would have been interesting to see a few episodes with her as his side kick.
Couldn’t do that. The daleks have always symbolised implacable hatred; the permanent enemy. This was a fantastic interlude and few minutes of unexpected sensitivity but the writers couldn’t destroy the image and existence of the daleks by prolonging this interaction.
Moral of this story. No matter what if you wont let anyone hurt your soul your soul wont get hurt. Even daleks changed her body they couldnt change her mind her soul. Not because she is a genius because she kept reminding herself that she is human she protect her mind her soul. We are stronger if we believe ourself and dont give up. Keep fighting.
Funnily enough, I made a parody comic based on that same idea a while back: www.deviantart.com/zemplintemplar/art/Doctor-Who-Repercussions-of-Souffle-spoof-654070503 :D
we're all Daleks who created an imagined reality for ourselves because the truth was just too painful and the moment we collectively realise the universe is in paril.
Actually, Daleks wanted to destroy the asylum to defend themselves from her.. they knew that she could enter in their common program and EXTERMINATE them.. 😰
@@Zaulhunter since daleks cannot truly die only decompose i would rather be transferred to a human body again so i could die naturally. Never ending bleak hell, Tartarus.
Of course, this kind of stuff does take away some of the distinction between the Daleks and and the Cybermen. I would advise the producers to limit these transformations as much as possible and try to maintain the Daleks' determination to exterminate while the Cybermen can commonly both delete and upgrade.
Guess the problem is that it's somewhat been a factor of the Daleks as early as Invasion of Earth, with the robo-men being precursors to the Cybermen in effect. There's always going to be that thread of the Daleks using people over just constant endless destruction and killing. The real distinction I think is down to a problem with the Cybermen more than the Daleks. The Cybermen are supposed to be converting people as a directive born from the need to survive, something that was basically forgotten until World Enough/Doctor Falls. Revelation certainly brought a unique kind of body horror to humans being turned into Daleks that also remained distinct enough from the cyber-conversion process. But to skip this ramble, I do agree that it should be limited, but not done away with altogether. The only true waste of potential is never exploring it.
This broke my heart first time i saw it. And i cry every time. Every damn time. The impossible girl saving the doctor in all of space and time. All thodr impossible escapes thanks to her and he never knew.
I'm sorry can we just think about how since when the Doctor was in front of Dalek Oswin(Clara), she had a dalek voice because then imagine a Dalek voice saying ""Chinny boy"
Doesn't this make Oswin-Dalek an "impure" one? I mean, if the Daleks are meant to be like Space Nazis, you'd expect them to be incredibly hesitant about anything involving "dirtying the bloodline", so why would they make Oswin a full-fledged Dalek? I mean it'd be more reasonable if they instead just sort of turned her into a biological think-tank computer, given that they still needed her genius. Lesser than a Dalek, but also not really human any more. For effect you can stick an eye stalk on it to make it clear that it's a Dalek-esque creature, but it doesn't really make a lot of sense for the Daleks to accept non-Daleks into their ranks in any manner distinctive from slaves like the Puppets or the Robomen. It's just not their m.o. Think about the first Dalek we saw in the new series, it was willing to seppuku itself over its tainted bloodline. Or consider the New Dalek Paradigm's debut, where they killed of the inferior ones born out of Davros's Kaled DNA. The Daleks are ruthless about ethnic cleansing, and the Asylum Daleks, who are apparently unhinged even by Dalek standards, should be even more so. As good as this episode and its twist was, I don't really like this ideological inconsistency in the Daleks.
I can't say anything about the daleks you mentioned as I stopped watching shortly after the tenth doctor 'died' but if we are keeping to the original first daleks then no it makes perfect sense to turn her. Originally the daleks were, at least in appearances, humans that were mutating and they started to put themselves in protective casing until they could find out why they were mutating (this is back in the fifth doctor's time I believe, could be wrong about which doctor it was a long time ago). I don't know about this ethnic cleansing that you mentioned but as far as I can tell that's not staying true to their origin story at all, the daleks were in my opinion a warning of what can happen if survival is put before everything else, the people wanted to survive so davros made them almost indestructible. Also it could be the one willing to kill itself over blood was a little unhinged furthermore the killing of daleks made from davros' DNA makes no sense since all, at least the orginal, daleks were from the same race as him thus largely similar DNA.
Kaleds and Humans and genetically identical, and several times in Dalek's history, they have taken advantage of this fact: whenever they needed to bolster their numbers, wether because the number of pure Daleks were low, or if they just needed rabid canon fodder, they would make a point to take as many human prisoners as possible, then putting them through the same radiation and psychological conditioning that davros did to his people to make them into Daleks (notable examples of this are at least one of their wars with humanity and the time war). That said, you're correct about the Daleks care about purity and Daleks of human origin (DHO's) are considered inferior, not to mention they had a higher insanity rate due to the human in question not being able to cope with the conversion. Also, I'm not sure how genetically speaking, but they can also create Daleks out of Sontarans if humans aren't available (they'd probably make amazing special weapons Daleks, but that's speculation for another time)
I wonder, is Oswin a disembodied human brain in that Dalek chassis or did they alter her brainwaves and stick her bodily in there? Or did they actually biologically alter her genes until she resembled a Dalek squid-brain-thing?
The look on the doctors face is like Holy # and he stares at her. She doesn’t understand and he said it was a dream but it isn’t though. I still feel back for Clara and it was sad though. Was Clara brainwashed by the Daleks? She seemed self aware though or just the program?! IDK but still sad but awesome though😎
The daleks stuck her in a shell and tried, but her mind built up a defense to maintain her humanity. And since she most likely didnt like the daleks cause of what they did and a dalek can easily kill another dalek, they feared her and locked her up with the other insane daleks. And that has to be the most times I've used dalek in a sentence. Dalek.
The doctor said he was a bit better today but I'm not going to new house for the day and after the sleepover I was just thinking about it when he was in the morning and he said it was beautiful and beautiful where are you from the shop to get there and I will do it now and I can do the same as well as a treat and I will do my best sister forever darling xxxxxxxx
the only other scene which made me equally sad was when dr who said to the dutchess he will be right and and pick a star when he came back she was dead and lots of years or few decades were already passed.
Dalek sobbing...
I've never felt so heartbroken before in my life.
Hahahahahahahahahahah
Help me, poor little thing. But there is no one else coming because their is no one else left. #votedalek
How to make a souffle, recipe by Oswin Oswald
1. Eggs
2. Stir
3. Min 8
thats actually a recipe for a simple egg patty. eggs, then stir but instead of min 8 its minate like minute
And simmer on a medium heat for 20 minutes
Mika oh... Shit
OMG...never understood until now.
I thought she was staying mix bake.
"I'm human. I am not a dalek I am human. I am not dalek I am human!"
Really got me. She reprogrammed the dalek fire word into eggs
"I AM A DALEK. I AM. A DALEK"
1:07
When you realize a Dalek just said "Rescue m-e chinboyyy. And show me.... the starrrs."
I wish I could hear everything they said in the dalek voice.
Yay
RUN YOU CLE-VER BOY! AND RE-MEM-BER!
The Dalek mark 3 transport device (the Kaled Mutant's tank/armour) filters speech so all the Doctor can hear is exterminate.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Imagine if he had taken Oswin as a companion for a bit. Dalek Clara would have been a cool companion and so would Victorian Clara
No offense to any other companions, but Clara is the best. Sure Rose is a flower, Donna has a book store named after her, Martha Jones might have the Dow Jones industrial average, but Clara is a hacker. And the doctor probably isn't even a real doctor.
@Philip Tucker Clara literally saved The Doctor's life on MULTIPLE occasions. What did anyone else do?
@@billcalypso3145 Rose Tyler destroyed an entire Dalek fleet bruh
I’m confused, so is her middle name Oswin and her last name Oswald or is it the other way round?
Edit: I’m just asking because I got a bit confused while people are using different names in the comments.
@@themoon8321 This version of Clara is just called Oswin Oswald. Victorian Clara is called Clara Oswin Oswald, and Prime Clara is just called Clara Oswald
I have to wonder. Say the Doc wasn't pressed for time. What would he have done with Oswin? She is Dalek, though with the mind of a human. Just figured it would have been interesting to see a few episodes with her as his side kick.
If I was the Doctor I would have saved her anyway because the best part of her was human and a genius! No way I would let her die.
He couldn't save her. It was too late. He wants to save everyone, but he can't.
Couldn’t do that. The daleks have always symbolised implacable hatred; the permanent enemy. This was a fantastic interlude and few minutes of unexpected sensitivity but the writers couldn’t destroy the image and existence of the daleks by prolonging this interaction.
I don't think it would've worked, the Dalek conditioning would've gotten to her eventually, wouldn't it?
Truly, one of the most heartbreaking moments in series 2.0...
0:18 imagine a dalek saying that in a cheery tone
This was one of the scariest episodes of doctor who . Got the chills again .
This was one of the most heartbreaking moments for me. I love Clara.
I remember watching this for the first time and was genuinely shocked by the twist in the episode. Fantastic writing and fantastic episode.
Moral of this story. No matter what if you wont let anyone hurt your soul your soul wont get hurt. Even daleks changed her body they couldnt change her mind her soul. Not because she is a genius because she kept reminding herself that she is human she protect her mind her soul. We are stronger if we believe ourself and dont give up. Keep fighting.
moffat''s run had some very 11/10 moments, this was one of them. this reveal was .. shocking. oh goosebumps and tears.
"No! I am not a dalek!" she shouted
The Doctor said "No, Clara. You are the evil"
And then Clara was a dalek.
Funnily enough, I made a parody comic based on that same idea a while back: www.deviantart.com/zemplintemplar/art/Doctor-Who-Repercussions-of-Souffle-spoof-654070503 :D
that's so sad... What if I'm a dalek right now...
LeviTheEntity lol
Self termination would be in order then, wouldn't it?
we're all Daleks who created an imagined reality for ourselves because the truth was just too painful and the moment we collectively realise the universe is in paril.
This was one of the biggest twists in this series
Damn this scene really got to me
Eggs
Eggs
Eggs
Eggs
Stir
Min 8!
Eggsstirmin8!
EXTERMINATE!!!
Ah Yes, get 4 eggs and stir them in something for 8 minutes to exterminate pests.
@@oblivion9619 stir them in the soufflé
I cried when I saw this scene
Just a version of her.
Clara was the best among Doctors’ companions. After that Amy then the “bad wolf 🐺”
And now I'm crying..... for a bloody Dalek! Gah!
SHE IS NOT A DALEK!!!
@@barbora.markova Wow, mad about a year old comment
@@joemaxwel1997 I'm not mad. I just wanted to write it the way she said it.
Lol I started to feel sorry for darlek cann when he committed suicide 🙈🤣
Actually, Daleks wanted to destroy the asylum to defend themselves from her.. they knew that she could enter in their common program and EXTERMINATE them.. 😰
I really wished he could have just taken her and maby like transferred her consciousness in to a human body or something
Fucked up bro
How is that fucked up
@@Zaulhunter since daleks cannot truly die only decompose i would rather be transferred to a human body again so i could die naturally. Never ending bleak hell, Tartarus.
Of course, this kind of stuff does take away some of the distinction between the Daleks and and the Cybermen. I would advise the producers to limit these transformations as much as possible and try to maintain the Daleks' determination to exterminate while the Cybermen can commonly both delete and upgrade.
Guess the problem is that it's somewhat been a factor of the Daleks as early as Invasion of Earth, with the robo-men being precursors to the Cybermen in effect. There's always going to be that thread of the Daleks using people over just constant endless destruction and killing.
The real distinction I think is down to a problem with the Cybermen more than the Daleks. The Cybermen are supposed to be converting people as a directive born from the need to survive, something that was basically forgotten until World Enough/Doctor Falls.
Revelation certainly brought a unique kind of body horror to humans being turned into Daleks that also remained distinct enough from the cyber-conversion process.
But to skip this ramble, I do agree that it should be limited, but not done away with altogether. The only true waste of potential is never exploring it.
Great Doctor Who twist and great intro for Jenna as Clara! 👍
Daleks are my favorite alien race in Doctor Who 👍
Mine are the adiposes they are just so cute
Apart from what I’ve always taken from this and have also taken from it but in a different light. “We have grown stronger in fear of you” is crazy
Huh, first was the Dalek Drone during Eccelsten's era, then Caan in Tennant's, then Clara in Smith's and of course, Rusty in Capaldi's.
This broke my heart first time i saw it. And i cry every time. Every damn time. The impossible girl saving the doctor in all of space and time. All thodr impossible escapes thanks to her and he never knew.
i haven’t seen this show for years and even then i didn’t really follow it properly so i’ve never seen this scene but even i’m heart broken
Omg.. the Daleks are like the Borg..
I'm sorry can we just think about how since when the Doctor was in front of Dalek Oswin(Clara), she had a dalek voice because then imagine a Dalek voice saying ""Chinny boy"
Uno de mis episodios favoritos.
Llore tanto con esta escena.😭😭😭
bro i cried so hard
This has got to be one of my favorite episodes
NAAAAW A DALEK CRYING IS SO PRECIOUS
Too HOT to be a Dalek!!!
Doctor who trying to kill me with the feels.
this episode made me cry like crazy
Huge fan
Why was she chaned to begin with?
Doesn't this make Oswin-Dalek an "impure" one? I mean, if the Daleks are meant to be like Space Nazis, you'd expect them to be incredibly hesitant about anything involving "dirtying the bloodline", so why would they make Oswin a full-fledged Dalek? I mean it'd be more reasonable if they instead just sort of turned her into a biological think-tank computer, given that they still needed her genius. Lesser than a Dalek, but also not really human any more. For effect you can stick an eye stalk on it to make it clear that it's a Dalek-esque creature, but it doesn't really make a lot of sense for the Daleks to accept non-Daleks into their ranks in any manner distinctive from slaves like the Puppets or the Robomen. It's just not their m.o. Think about the first Dalek we saw in the new series, it was willing to seppuku itself over its tainted bloodline. Or consider the New Dalek Paradigm's debut, where they killed of the inferior ones born out of Davros's Kaled DNA. The Daleks are ruthless about ethnic cleansing, and the Asylum Daleks, who are apparently unhinged even by Dalek standards, should be even more so. As good as this episode and its twist was, I don't really like this ideological inconsistency in the Daleks.
I can't say anything about the daleks you mentioned as I stopped watching shortly after the tenth doctor 'died' but if we are keeping to the original first daleks then no it makes perfect sense to turn her. Originally the daleks were, at least in appearances, humans that were mutating and they started to put themselves in protective casing until they could find out why they were mutating (this is back in the fifth doctor's time I believe, could be wrong about which doctor it was a long time ago). I don't know about this ethnic cleansing that you mentioned but as far as I can tell that's not staying true to their origin story at all, the daleks were in my opinion a warning of what can happen if survival is put before everything else, the people wanted to survive so davros made them almost indestructible. Also it could be the one willing to kill itself over blood was a little unhinged furthermore the killing of daleks made from davros' DNA makes no sense since all, at least the orginal, daleks were from the same race as him thus largely similar DNA.
But Oswin was in chains...
I mean, that's why she was there
Kaleds and Humans and genetically identical, and several times in Dalek's history, they have taken advantage of this fact: whenever they needed to bolster their numbers, wether because the number of pure Daleks were low, or if they just needed rabid canon fodder, they would make a point to take as many human prisoners as possible, then putting them through the same radiation and psychological conditioning that davros did to his people to make them into Daleks (notable examples of this are at least one of their wars with humanity and the time war). That said, you're correct about the Daleks care about purity and Daleks of human origin (DHO's) are considered inferior, not to mention they had a higher insanity rate due to the human in question not being able to cope with the conversion. Also, I'm not sure how genetically speaking, but they can also create Daleks out of Sontarans if humans aren't available (they'd probably make amazing special weapons Daleks, but that's speculation for another time)
I wonder, is Oswin a disembodied human brain in that Dalek chassis or did they alter her brainwaves and stick her bodily in there? Or did they actually biologically alter her genes until she resembled a Dalek squid-brain-thing?
Mix between 1 and 3
This has to be the saddest episode of Doctor who ever 😭
Matt Smith. The best doctor !
What's with the 4th wall break right at the end of the clip?
I actually felt guilty then, lmao
Is this how she dies? I've not seen it.
Mikayla Smart this is how Oswin dies, not Clara they're different people
Awesome Person who is oswin? Another version of clara?
Stop It yes
Awesome Person Oswin is Clara's echo
@@kingsavageplays9946 Not everyone remembers every single thing that happened in Doctor Who. Don't be a dick. Some people have shit memories.
This is the only cute dalek ever in existence
The look on the doctors face is like Holy # and he stares at her. She doesn’t understand and he said it was a dream but it isn’t though. I still feel back for Clara and it was sad though. Was Clara brainwashed by the Daleks? She seemed self aware though or just the program?! IDK but still sad but awesome though😎
The daleks stuck her in a shell and tried, but her mind built up a defense to maintain her humanity. And since she most likely didnt like the daleks cause of what they did and a dalek can easily kill another dalek, they feared her and locked her up with the other insane daleks. And that has to be the most times I've used dalek in a sentence. Dalek.
@@nyotamwuaji6484 ehhhh makes sense thank you for summing it up for me.
Dalek error 404, dalek dna not detected hahaha
Oh Clara...😢🤧
Well I liked to be a Dalek and able to show others I'm one of those who aren't always capable of killing.
Impossible girl
WHAT TEH HELLL
This would work well with Fnaf
0:29 wtf does she say here?! It’s so fast!😂
2:38
Spng that starts at 4:00
What if doctor turn into dalek instead of Clara?
What happened though how does she escape to be with peter
Cosmic Donkey thank you I’ve forever been wondering that I only got into doctor who 5 months ago and couldn’t find all the episodes thanks
@@alexdenning7491 Doctor: Kidneys! I got new Kidneys! I don't like the color....
Clara: Of your Kidneys?
So was Oswin related to Clara?
The doctor said he was a bit better today but I'm not going to new house for the day and after the sleepover I was just thinking about it when he was in the morning and he said it was beautiful and beautiful where are you from the shop to get there and I will do it now and I can do the same as well as a treat and I will do my best sister forever darling xxxxxxxx
this is like💅🏽so me rn sis… i ate that up no crumbs nigga
the only other scene which made me equally sad was when dr who said to the dutchess he will be right and and pick a star when he came back she was dead and lots of years or few decades were already passed.