The whole story is mainly abt an outlaw who wants the family life witch is exactly what John has this is why Arthur’s shows some resentment based on jealousy he later sees what he could’ve had in John and others that he’s wronged At the end of the day being a good man is abt being there for your family and exactly that’s what Arthur and John did…
@user-zf7pf7qu8p Nah fam that's today. In those times with much less light/noise pollution, there's practical certainty that the kid's sleeping. Also maybe try to be a bit more respectful in the future, not everyone's just gonna brush it off and then you've just ruined the discussion
@@lahocsinszkyzalan5227Mostly has to do with the cutscenes being all motion capture, so Roger Clark acted his ass off even with facial and body expressions
I've said this about alot of good protagonists, Arthur, Kratos in the remakes. You can see the pain or loss in their eyes, that's how you know they aren't just stoic main characters that kill the bad guys and get the girl or treasure, these are People...and that's why we get so attached and emotional when they do
This game has such an amazing storyline. I used to take care of 104 year old man with my mom. He loves Western so I played this game for him. He said out of all the westerns he's seen that's the best story he's ever experienced.
I just playing this game for the first time. Just finished this part a day ago. I was so greedy that I didn't give her the fake money and the game forced me to forgive the debt. I wanted the food out her belly. 🤦
@@uzifromtwitter5257ik I'm late here, but "us" is so right. Twice rdr made us a good man - robbing and killing was easy. But hunting and working those real jobs? John and Arthur both. John learned from his big brother. And so did jack from his uncle.
Have you guys ever notice ? The last 2 debtors are John and Arthur. Just like John and Arthur will pay their debt. Arthur trying his best until his end, leaving his " family " behind. John running with his family but eventually the past will catch up to him
No it's actually foreshadowing arthur the first one foreshadowing what happen when arthur ran away with mary and the last one foreshadowing what happened if arthur dies instead of his family
@@ericbelander2319 you really think they will put it on your nose like that ? J. John running away with his wife and child being hunted. Do i need to say more
@@DeadX2 Not overrated I shall say cause he actually get a good character development but more overshadowed on the fact that how much of an evil character he is. People sugar coat him too much which I hate the most and do not even acknowledging the fact that he is a cold blooded killer still say he is good, lol.
@@DeadX2 What aspect of him do you think is overrated? You are saying it is overrated means you are implying that fans are actually giving some aspect or aspects of his characters more value or praise than it actually deserves, right? I am seriously curious about which aspect do you think it is true. I have seen some people saying he has got the best character development in the gaming history which is nonsense I agree but other that I don't think any part of Arthur's character have been praised more than it should have been. As I said he has got good character development but far from best, so that part is out of question. Do you have anything else in mind?
This scene is alternate life of Arthur. Because in one of the mission when Arthur was haning with Rains Falls, he said that he had a family and a son but both later killed. This family is the opposite, Arthur was killed but his family left. That's why he felt sad.
He saw his previous girlfriend and his son,isaac. Arthur says that people robbed and killed them for measly cash, so when he sees the Londonderry family he realises how he has become the bastards that took his family away. That's why you get to absolve the debt and give money, to show how Arthur is better than some cash and wants the Londonderry's to survive
More like he’s become a reason that’s a possibility for that family. Imagina a household with no man back then, what they did to Sadie and her husband? Probably worse with no strength behind you
My mother always kept telling me for all the people that did me wrong, used me, lied, betrayed me. "Dont worry everything will catch them up". Even tho I seem to not see that, maybe I'm wrong. This the first time I realised what my mother was saying behind it. Arthur that gave everything died... so Arthur that gave Dutch everything also died. Both Arthurs suffered the same ending.
@@Takinthehobbitstoisengardit’s not that nothing happened to those people, maybe this guy (and them ofc) is too young. It will catch up with them in the long run, but it can’t be something you worry about, or it eats you inside
@@Angel-Otk the thing I don't understand is why anybody would decive their kids like that when they know that realistically, that person will probably never get karma.
@@Takinthehobbitstoisengard nah a person that lives a life of “attracting” bad karma get what they deserve at the end. No so much because of a higher power but more because of their reckless decisions
You're an idiot if you believe it. There is no cosmic magical balance. Bad people live lavish lives into their 80s, 90s and 100s all the time. People live horrible lives despite being good people.
Arthur saw them as the family that he lost so long ago, and he pays them because he wants to give them the life that his wife and son lost all those years ago.
@@navjotkhalsa7577Just remember, Dutch has a plan. It definitely gets better once the snow missions over. And the gang definitely makes it to Tahiti.😂
@@navjotkhalsa7577 Explore as much as you can and do as much stranger missions as you can, it makes the game so much more interesting and deep. Also, remeber how you want to play± low honor or high honor. The way you play the game changes your gaming experience :) Have fun!
It hit home the hardest when she said, “You want the food from our bellies, what little there is?” You never know what it’s like to not have anything to eat and hoping the next day is something better but it isn’t 😭😭.
I believe that Arthur was already good before, but this was the moment when he snapped then turned totally against Dutch, and of course, Strauss (I know its optional but for me this mission is "canon" for me, like the good morality status)
I think one of the big themes from Red Dead 2 is that good people can do bad things and vice versa. Arthur is a good person inside, he was just dealt a bad hand and grew up in a gang of outlaws which led him down a bad path. Dutch is the opposite, he wanted to be Robin Hood and a messiah but in the end he just ended up as another scumbag robbing and killing for cash.
Look. The voice actor for Arthur usually outshines everyone in any scene’s he’s in. But the widow’s voice actor killed it. Her little monologue was so, so, good.
Hearing "Arthurs dead" when i played, caught me off guard and made me feel silent inside while the emotions bubbled up. Imagine youre gonna die and someone says the person with your name is dead, thats deep
There are several deeds that Arthur does in the game to help gain redemption for the sins he’s caused. This one was I think the one that truly saved his soul and made him see the ramifications of killing an innocent person for money can do to their loved ones.
As much as I love Arthur and the change you can have him make. I do fucking hate Everytime you go to collect a debt the people give you lip. They are borrowing money and expecting to not have to pay it back.
I think a lot of it has to do with Arthur being brutal and nasty about it. The people the gang lend money too are so desperate that they have no other choice but to turn to taking debts. This family had no other option, and sadly lost the father to it
Exactly my thoughts. So many people in the comments saying to forgive them… umm no thats not how it works, if u borrow money u should pay it back its not that hard. If he died well that just prolonged it cus he would’ve dies alot sooner if he didnt lent the &&$ to him.
@@TheLuckyLuke314Herr Strauss is picked up by the Pinkertons and dies being tortured by them trying to get the location of the gang. He doesn't betray them, unlike Micah, who managed to dissolve the gang
It wasn't Arthur's fault that some of those people died trying to pay back the money they borrowed from a loan shark after agreeing to the terms. But it was very good of Arthur to forgive some of those debts.
"Arthur's dead" really hit home for Arthur and I think it made him realize that he wasn't much different than the Arthur who took out a loan to support his wife and kid and worked himself into the grave. In another timeline, Arthur Morgan lived this Arthur's life. A family man being loved by a wife and child.
Can we appreciate the voice actress, Erica Sweany, here? She plays such a relatively small role in the huge scope of this game, but she nails this scene. Brings so much emotion. Really amplifies Arthur Morgan's story.
Arthur tried to be a good man just because of TB. He knew he'll die soon so he decided to do sth good before dying. If it wasen for TB, he'd remain an heartless outlaw for a long time. He'd probably team up with micah and dutch too.
So you never caught up on him actually struggling with onlyx being good at being bad? And what exactly stops you amassing a high honor score? Man, to live in a one-dimensional Lego world like you do. Must be a simple, easy life.
@Muschelschubs3r lol what ? 🤣 you had a rough day I guess lol All I'm saying is arthur was a bad person by nature he was a murderer who killed hundreds even thousands of people. Now at some point of his life he got unlucky and got TB. he saw his life was about to end very soon so he decided to so sth good and help some people (john and his family). But that doesn't make him a honorable or good person. He is still an heartless outlaw. I believe you can't understand or process any of this 🤣🤣🤣
“She would have been a good woman,” The Misfit said, “if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life.” - Flannery O'Connor, A Good Man is Hard to Find
Hey Strauss got caught by the pinkertons, tortured and never ratted out the gang, he was lowkey one of the most loyal members, sure he wasn’t a great person he was only doin his job like the others
Yes, in the chapter six debt collection missions you don’t actually collect debts, you pardon the debtors and have the choice to give them money. After completing the missions you go back to camp to kick out Strauss.
@foeton3582 yeah I'm currently going through the epilogue after my 1st playthrough. I didn't have the highest honor but it was definitely out of the gray and in the positive. I'm not far into the epilogue just after tearing down the shack but so far? I gotta say I hate Abigail atm... so superficially shallow with trying to be prim and proper while ignoring some of the necessities John had to make.
I agree it was good Arthur relieved their debt and Strauss' loan shark business was evil but I have always been bothered by her attitude, "Arthur gave EVERYTHING to pay YOUR bills" like... uh..? No? They were his bills. Yalls bills. He took money from a loan shark. It's shitty business HE CHOSE to get wrapped up in. Ik she's grieving and Arthur's an enforcer to blame but where's the accountability?
The way Arthur look to the side when he see the boy … I can imagine all the thoughts in his mind. Maybe he sees himself or Jack in that kid and decide to do good by this family if he can’t do it for his own. This character still makes me cry years later
Hands down, some of the best voice acting ever done in a video game. If RDR were a motion film, it would receive an Academy Award. The cutscenes were easily the best parts of the game.
Our first play through can never be replicated. But this game is an absolute masterpiece that deserves many play throughs. This is the greatest game ever created
He saw himself when he looked at the little boy.He remembered what it’s like losing a parent just like his mom when he was a little boy
He also saw his son Isaac in him...
@@sxrdoI always thought that he saw his son in jack especially how he talks in the last ride to him
@@mikeyg9203Jack is John's son, not Arthur's 😂
The whole story is mainly abt an outlaw who wants the family life witch is exactly what John has this is why Arthur’s shows some resentment based on jealousy he later sees what he could’ve had in John and others that he’s wronged
At the end of the day being a good man is abt being there for your family and exactly that’s what Arthur and John did…
Didn't seem to remember when making Downes son fatherless
I like that you physically HAVE TO relieve the debt, shows how much arthur changes
If there was an option to keep the debt some mfs would still do it 💀
@@sxrdono there isn’t it’s either relieve the debt or relieve the debt and give money
Read the comment again @@chancellor1055
@@chancellor1055he’s saying if there was an option are u stupid
@@chancellor1055he said IF
This scene works better at night.
Fr
No the kid would be asleep. Except maybe if he's severely malnourished but it's probably not that bad
@@mucicafrajernot child sleeps as reliably as an alarm clock. They get up sometimes at odd hours… smh you made a very stupid comment.
@user-zf7pf7qu8p Nah fam that's today. In those times with much less light/noise pollution, there's practical certainty that the kid's sleeping.
Also maybe try to be a bit more respectful in the future, not everyone's just gonna brush it off and then you've just ruined the discussion
I saw this scene when it was raining
the pain in his eye makes me want to cry
this game is animated so well, like the fact that you can see the characters' feelings in their eyes
Same man...
@@lahocsinszkyzalan5227Mostly has to do with the cutscenes being all motion capture, so Roger Clark acted his ass off even with facial and body expressions
I've said this about alot of good protagonists, Arthur, Kratos in the remakes. You can see the pain or loss in their eyes, that's how you know they aren't just stoic main characters that kill the bad guys and get the girl or treasure, these are People...and that's why we get so attached and emotional when they do
@@chriswilliams4700I remember that the guy that played Dutch bawled his eyes out after doing that scene when Dutch walks away from a Dying Arthur
That "im sorry" hurt bro
True 🥺 the pain which we can feel...
"I really am"
Hits even harder knowing arthur's wife and kid got killed for 10 bucks
@@kimbaldun facts
You can see the pain and sympathy in his eyes
Yep😅
This game has such an amazing storyline. I used to take care of 104 year old man with my mom. He loves Western so I played this game for him. He said out of all the westerns he's seen that's the best story he's ever experienced.
I love this
@@replayreplay1829 thank you
I just playing this game for the first time. Just finished this part a day ago. I was so greedy that I didn't give her the fake money and the game forced me to forgive the debt. I wanted the food out her belly. 🤦
@@replayreplay1829 me too, it's beautiful
That's beautiful
"Arthur's dead" is a powerful line here.
“I know”
why does john look like arthur
@@Reqt12Because that’s Arthur not John…
@@Reqt12😂😂
@@Reqt12thats shaved arthur
"Arthur gave everything" hit me hard, because before Arthur died he said to Dutch "I gave you everything"
"I gave you all I had. I really did!" John with every thing Arthur had: 😅
💔💔💔 Dutch didn’t deserve us man
Fuck Dutch. Listened to that rat Micah instead of listening to Arthur, HIS DAY ONE .
Fuck that's true
@@uzifromtwitter5257ik I'm late here, but "us" is so right. Twice rdr made us a good man - robbing and killing was easy. But hunting and working those real jobs? John and Arthur both.
John learned from his big brother.
And so did jack from his uncle.
Have you guys ever notice ? The last 2 debtors are John and Arthur.
Just like John and Arthur will pay their debt. Arthur trying his best until his end, leaving his " family " behind.
John running with his family but eventually the past will catch up to him
No it's actually foreshadowing arthur the first one foreshadowing what happen when arthur ran away with mary and the last one foreshadowing what happened if arthur dies instead of his family
J john. I doubt his name is "John John Weathers"
@@ericbelander2319 you really think they will put it on your nose like that ? J. John running away with his wife and child being hunted. Do i need to say more
@@kenzi_rxx6297 i believe J. John is for John Marston
@@ericbelander2319John jim milton
That "I'm sorry mam" you can literally feel the pain.
*ma’am
Arthur was an amazing character, loved how he evolved through the game especially if you had good honor
I hate that he dies
Overated
@@DeadX2 Not overrated I shall say cause he actually get a good character development but more overshadowed on the fact that how much of an evil character he is. People sugar coat him too much which I hate the most and do not even acknowledging the fact that he is a cold blooded killer still say he is good, lol.
@@satyakeesarkar1256 it is overrated lol also just cause he gets a good character development doesn’t mean it’s not overrated lol
@@DeadX2 What aspect of him do you think is overrated? You are saying it is overrated means you are implying that fans are actually giving some aspect or aspects of his characters more value or praise than it actually deserves, right? I am seriously curious about which aspect do you think it is true. I have seen some people saying he has got the best character development in the gaming history which is nonsense I agree but other that I don't think any part of Arthur's character have been praised more than it should have been. As I said he has got good character development but far from best, so that part is out of question. Do you have anything else in mind?
The "I'm sorry ma'am" at the end is f**king heartbreaking.
Word
Couldnt care less if you don’t wanna be in debt don’t borrow money
This scene is alternate life of Arthur. Because in one of the mission when Arthur was haning with Rains Falls, he said that he had a family and a son but both later killed. This family is the opposite, Arthur was killed but his family left. That's why he felt sad.
That's a nice interpretation
No he was talking to Rains Fall, Eagle Flies is Rain Falls’ son
@@roblitz12 - Oh yeah, my bad, Homie. I miswrote their names. Thanks for help. 👍🏻
@@mafia_gamer_official30973 No problem 😉
Then why not just hook up with the widow? That's what I'd do. Take advantage of the wife's grief.
He saw his previous girlfriend and his son,isaac. Arthur says that people robbed and killed them for measly cash, so when he sees the Londonderry family he realises how he has become the bastards that took his family away. That's why you get to absolve the debt and give money, to show how Arthur is better than some cash and wants the Londonderry's to survive
the way he's saying "im sorry ma'am"
He was speaking for his son & wife that he lost from an outlaw robbery.
More like he’s become a reason that’s a possibility for that family. Imagina a household with no man back then, what they did to Sadie and her husband? Probably worse with no strength behind you
Bruh no it’s the downes family that’s very clearly what he’s thinking about in this scene lmao
@@Jacob-rf8biwhat? Are you high? This isn't the Downes famliy, because the debtor was Thomas Downes and he's son was already grown up
@@enbybeanie666 Are you high? It is obvious that Jacob meant Arthur was THINKING of the downes family during this scene.
"Arthur's dead"
"I'm standing right here though?"
nice one..
Not for long though 😢
How do I get to this bit?
😂😂😂 her hasbund had the same name😅
"Arthur's Dead" but Arthur knows. He's dying.
The voice acting even with random people is incredible
Just acting not voice acting since every scene in the game was done with performance capture
@@user-hx6gs9rq7uit is voice acting too tho, since this isn't a live action
Bruh, one of the very few times the voice actor for Arthur got outshone. The VA was powerful for the widow.
incredible voice acting
You could see the pain in his eyes as he said his sorrys
My mother always kept telling me for all the people that did me wrong, used me, lied, betrayed me. "Dont worry everything will catch them up". Even tho I seem to not see that, maybe I'm wrong. This the first time I realised what my mother was saying behind it. Arthur that gave everything died... so Arthur that gave Dutch everything also died. Both Arthurs suffered the same ending.
What did she mean then, if nothing happened to those people?
@@Takinthehobbitstoisengardit’s not that nothing happened to those people, maybe this guy (and them ofc) is too young. It will catch up with them in the long run, but it can’t be something you worry about, or it eats you inside
@@Angel-Otk the thing I don't understand is why anybody would decive their kids like that when they know that realistically, that person will probably never get karma.
@@Takinthehobbitstoisengard nah a person that lives a life of “attracting” bad karma get what they deserve at the end. No so much because of a higher power but more because of their reckless decisions
You're an idiot if you believe it. There is no cosmic magical balance. Bad people live lavish lives into their 80s, 90s and 100s all the time. People live horrible lives despite being good people.
Chapter 6. ...i cried almost in every misson 😢
А это разве сюжетная миссия? Я просто что-то не припомню такую...
@@Владимир-ц4ь7ыI believe it’s a side quest.
@@Владимир-ц4ь7ы side quest .. after it u kick Strauss outta the camp
Lady: “Do you want my sons shoes”
Arthur: “yes”
😂Reading through all the poignant and heartfelt comments then this banger comes along 👌
Arthur: *gleefully runs around the wilderness with tiny shoes on*
Ultra low honor Arthur be like 😂
lmao 😂 that comment came out of nowhere ahah
Throw shoes at em?
Arthur saw them as the family that he lost so long ago, and he pays them because he wants to give them the life that his wife and son lost all those years ago.
“Your a terrible man”
A few seconds later
“Why,why your a good man”
The power of money 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
because, he IS and WAS a good man
True
I wish she asked his name so that she knew his name was Arthur too
It should be 😊❤
I am so excited as very soon i am going to play this game just in days😊❤
Any tips?
@@navjotkhalsa7577Just remember, Dutch has a plan. It definitely gets better once the snow missions over. And the gang definitely makes it to Tahiti.😂
@@navjotkhalsa7577 Explore as much as you can and do as much stranger missions as you can, it makes the game so much more interesting and deep. Also, remeber how you want to play± low honor or high honor. The way you play the game changes your gaming experience :) Have fun!
@@navjotkhalsa7577 dont look at spoilers. it ruins the experience
"My name is Morgan"
It was PERFECT voice acting from that lady « There is nothing left, MISTER »
This made so many grown men cry. 😢
castrated*
That “I’m sorry” and the look he gave to her makes me wanna cry every time I see this scene
It hit home the hardest when she said, “You want the food from our bellies, what little there is?”
You never know what it’s like to not have anything to eat and hoping the next day is something better but it isn’t 😭😭.
I believe that Arthur was already good before, but this was the moment when he snapped then turned totally against Dutch, and of course, Strauss
(I know its optional but for me this mission is "canon" for me, like the good morality status)
I agree
I think one of the big themes from Red Dead 2 is that good people can do bad things and vice versa. Arthur is a good person inside, he was just dealt a bad hand and grew up in a gang of outlaws which led him down a bad path. Dutch is the opposite, he wanted to be Robin Hood and a messiah but in the end he just ended up as another scumbag robbing and killing for cash.
Where can I find this mission?
@@davesmilingcoyote Side mission in Chapter 6.
You have to talk to Strauss
@@davesmilingcoyote its the last Strauss mission before Arthur kicks him out of the gang
Arthur was always a good man, he just never realized it was there inside
Look. The voice actor for Arthur usually outshines everyone in any scene’s he’s in. But the widow’s voice actor killed it. Her little monologue was so, so, good.
Seeing Arthur’s redemption is very heartwarming yet so sad at the same time
Hearing "Arthurs dead" when i played, caught me off guard and made me feel silent inside while the emotions bubbled up. Imagine youre gonna die and someone says the person with your name is dead, thats deep
That's still the most sincere apology I've ever heard.
There are several deeds that Arthur does in the game to help gain redemption for the sins he’s caused. This one was I think the one that truly saved his soul and made him see the ramifications of killing an innocent person for money can do to their loved ones.
This was really good voice acting
Just acting, not voice acting. Every cutscene in the game was done by the actors using motion capture
arthur simply gained sympathy for the people they were hurting.
As much as I love Arthur and the change you can have him make. I do fucking hate Everytime you go to collect a debt the people give you lip. They are borrowing money and expecting to not have to pay it back.
I think a lot of it has to do with Arthur being brutal and nasty about it. The people the gang lend money too are so desperate that they have no other choice but to turn to taking debts. This family had no other option, and sadly lost the father to it
@@chriswilliams4700 I get that with Downes, Arthur was brutal, but all Arthur did was say they lent him some money, and she calls him a son of bi*ch
@@chriswilliams4700u want him to get on his knees and beg? Fuck that lol pay your bills
Exactly my thoughts. So many people in the comments saying to forgive them… umm no thats not how it works, if u borrow money u should pay it back its not that hard. If he died well that just prolonged it cus he would’ve dies alot sooner if he didnt lent the &&$ to him.
You know that haircut really looks natural on Arthur
how can i get this haircut
@@riyadratul966 Modded
Arthur is the best story character in existence I could shaed a tear watching this😢
The greatest video game ever! My mom saw me playing this she loves it! She says it just like a movie
I play through this game like 5 times and I’m just now realizing you can visit the woman Arthur taught to survive near annesburg as John
One of THE greatest stories in gaming history.
He saw Issac and Eliza in them 😕 we should’ve been able to kill struass
Nah you did, not Arthur
Yea we should have been able to kill him for sure .. 😅
I second this,
I don't know if Leopold gets killed or dies "naturally", but however he goes he deserved it 20x worse! 😤
@@Angel-Otk wdym
@@TheLuckyLuke314Herr Strauss is picked up by the Pinkertons and dies being tortured by them trying to get the location of the gang. He doesn't betray them, unlike Micah, who managed to dissolve the gang
Oh my God, I never thought I would see Kid Arthur
It wasn't Arthur's fault that some of those people died trying to pay back the money they borrowed from a loan shark after agreeing to the terms. But it was very good of Arthur to forgive some of those debts.
I swear, this is the only game that ever jerked tears out of my eyes.
Smh.
Rip Arthur.
I was expecting him to say “me too” like he wished he realized this sooner as well
Bro rockstars voice actors are amazing, i felt that ''everything..!'' i've heard that tone before, so real:D
Every scene in this game was done using performance captures so they’re just actors not voice actors
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u you mean they are both? or first motion capture and then voice actors? Atleast the main characters used both
Why is your Arthur looking a lil’ Colm O Driscolly
The woman voice actor did an incredible job here
Wow.. I fukking love Arthur. This is only one of the good deeds he did 😎
You can see how emotional he got when he said I’m sorry In the end
“Want me to lie down!?”
“… Yes.”
A
Yea fr
be kind and good brothers, there's no fun in being evil
“I'm sorry ma'am... I really am...”💔
At first I thought it was a random person saying Arthur Morgan is dead to John then I heard Arthur speak
The story of rdr2 is the most emotional rollercoaster journey one gamer could ever experience.
"I'm sorry Mam" hit hard :'(
Mine was always a good man... High honor
Whoever voiced this lady absolutely killed it. Every VA in this game did, but she KILLED it man
"Arthur's dead" really hit home for Arthur and I think it made him realize that he wasn't much different than the Arthur who took out a loan to support his wife and kid and worked himself into the grave.
In another timeline, Arthur Morgan lived this Arthur's life. A family man being loved by a wife and child.
God damn these games were pure art.
I hope they never stop making them.
And they keep bringing us such wonderful stories and characters.
Can we appreciate the voice actress, Erica Sweany, here? She plays such a relatively small role in the huge scope of this game, but she nails this scene. Brings so much emotion. Really amplifies Arthur Morgan's story.
Such a great story. I don't even think of it as a game anymore; it's an experience, a place to travel to and miss when you are not there.
Arthur tried to be a good man just because of TB. He knew he'll die soon so he decided to do sth good before dying. If it wasen for TB, he'd remain an heartless outlaw for a long time. He'd probably team up with micah and dutch too.
Disagree he was never as cruel as Micah. And if you pay attention he was already slowly changing.
So you never caught up on him actually struggling with onlyx being good at being bad? And what exactly stops you amassing a high honor score? Man, to live in a one-dimensional Lego world like you do. Must be a simple, easy life.
@Muschelschubs3r lol what ? 🤣 you had a rough day I guess lol
All I'm saying is arthur was a bad person by nature he was a murderer who killed hundreds even thousands of people. Now at some point of his life he got unlucky and got TB. he saw his life was about to end very soon so he decided to so sth good and help some people (john and his family). But that doesn't make him a honorable or good person. He is still an heartless outlaw.
I believe you can't understand or process any of this 🤣🤣🤣
“She would have been a good woman,” The Misfit said, “if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life.” - Flannery O'Connor, A Good Man is Hard to Find
How can an animated character give such expressions? Truly a movie to lived.
Glad stauss got kicked out and killer later
Hey Strauss got caught by the pinkertons, tortured and never ratted out the gang, he was lowkey one of the most loyal members, sure he wasn’t a great person he was only doin his job like the others
@@DemonSlayer-h7n he got arthur tb from Thomas downed and made arthur beat so many more people for a few bucks
@@DemonSlayer-h7nHe didn’t make him do anything. Nothing was stopping Arthur from saying no, he’s a grown man and can make his own decisions
Arthur was always a good man I think he just felt trapped in the life he was in since its all he ever knew and he felt loyalty to his friends.
Was this a Chapter 6 debt collection? I stopped doing those when I knew Dutch was getting greedy and secretive.
Yes, in the chapter six debt collection missions you don’t actually collect debts, you pardon the debtors and have the choice to give them money. After completing the missions you go back to camp to kick out Strauss.
@foeton3582 that is actually nice to know...
I stopped doing them around chapter 3.
@@Things_I_wish_I_knew forgot to mention but you can also get a good amount of honor by doing the missions
@foeton3582 yeah I'm currently going through the epilogue after my 1st playthrough.
I didn't have the highest honor but it was definitely out of the gray and in the positive.
I'm not far into the epilogue just after tearing down the shack but so far?
I gotta say I hate Abigail atm... so superficially shallow with trying to be prim and proper while ignoring some of the necessities John had to make.
@@foeton3582 I was already high high honor by Chapter 6, like almost all the way right, so I just didn't want to give anymore to Dutch.
The voice acting for basically every character in this game is wonderful, but Arthur's is phenomenal
Lady: "You want me to lie down for you?"
Arthur: SHOAR!
Arthur to me is the best character in a all. Of fiction his reliablety to how he changes trough the story 10/10
That’s nice and all but does she have oil
💀
Get oiled up lil bigger
@@francescacastronovo647 nah thats crazy
the acting in this game is just on it's own level
What’s the mission name I can’t remember
Money Lending and Other Sins VII or something
I cried on this scene, what a masterpiece of this game
I agree it was good Arthur relieved their debt and Strauss' loan shark business was evil but I have always been bothered by her attitude, "Arthur gave EVERYTHING to pay YOUR bills" like... uh..? No? They were his bills. Yalls bills. He took money from a loan shark. It's shitty business HE CHOSE to get wrapped up in. Ik she's grieving and Arthur's an enforcer to blame but where's the accountability?
Man I want to cry the parallels with Arthur This is why I love this game it makes me feel something. ❤
Not in my game. 😆
Each mission during this chapter almost makes me cry. It kept getting harder and harder.
Relieved and gave her money. This scene was pretty heartbreaking...
The "im sorry mam" at the end is so filled with bitterness
You can tell this is the peak of his shift to morality. Powerful moment.
That's why I antagonize Strauss every time I see him at the camp every time I play RDR2
Lol i never get enough of these clips, loved being Arthur was a special time, iam glad I've got it and can go back whenever x
I love how he looks regretful, so well done with face expressions. Sadness, regret, pain
‘’I’m sorry ma’am’’😔
The way Arthur look to the side when he see the boy … I can imagine all the thoughts in his mind. Maybe he sees himself or Jack in that kid and decide to do good by this family if he can’t do it for his own. This character still makes me cry years later
This game is an absolute masterpiece and it's one of my all time favourite games, Arthurs character was absolutely incredible
“I’m sorry ma’am” he seemed so sad for her and the boy. Like he saw himself
One of the best scripts and characters dialogue ever in a video game. Just FANTASTIC!👍🏾
This is such a great moment. The writing and acting are top notch for sure.
I love this whole story. Him absolving the debts is just beautiful
“I’m sorry, ma’am. I really am.” Bro looked like he was so close to tears I almost started crying😭
Sad sad scene. This is the movie we all wanted and got to play. RIP Arthur,...both of them.
“Arthur’s dead”
The foreshadowed ng
this scene speaks of situations in the past. Forgiveness like this is rare now-adays 😢
Hands down, some of the best voice acting ever done in a video game. If RDR were a motion film, it would receive an Academy Award. The cutscenes were easily the best parts of the game.
Our first play through can never be replicated. But this game is an absolute masterpiece that deserves many play throughs. This is the greatest game ever created
His eyes and voice breaking when he says "I'm sorry, ma'am"