I Entered a Catan Cash Tournament against Pros...
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
- ➡️ Start Playing Catan FOR FREE: bit.ly/Colonis...
⭐️Follow Me If You Are Awesome:
➡️ Play in Tournaments HERE: / discord
➡️ TWITCH: / dylighted_catan
➡️ DyLighted Discord: / discord
when u talkin about philosophy in Catan then you know it's a cash game
12:27 Bot Edit
Might be the best piece of Catan content I've seen!
Well done.
Free card trade is a dog move. Also, no style points for playing insurance.
dylighted is so good he even extorts the bots in bot only games
I think hes completely right. It bends the rules and the mentality of it being risky to end a turn with 6 or more cards. You provided no counter argument besides yelling.
Within a competitive environment, usually players try everything within the rules to win. If you don't like it, you should try to convince the devs/revs that it should not be allowed. But even in important over the board tournaments, it is allowed
I think the more important argument is the complication factor. It takes up a pretty decent chunk of time, even just explaining it if there are new players on the board. In real world tournament play these sort of time extenders make the whole day take longer for everyone there. I would prefer a world where insurance is not allowed, but I can accept that others think otherwise! I’m just sick of long trade talks when people could be playing.
@@cptobvius the talking is part of the game, arguably the one that makes the game truly skillful
It doesn't bend the rules. The counter-argument is that it's good for the players involved and harms everyone else not involved. However, performing these kinds of "non-binding" agreements is just bad for the person receiving the "insurance" since the theoretically optimal play is just to lie and not give the cards back. Sadly in reality people don't lie so it essentially winds up all happening anyway.
@@Ohrami but in theory by lying once you'll be unable to make similar deals for the entire session.
Therefore only beeing at the receiving end of that disadvantage
Think red deserved it really, I know it's technically legal but it's a bad faith move to use multiple trades to get free cards imo, i was a little suprised to see that. I guess its a tournament though so do what you gotta do. Love the vids, keep up the good work mate
I feel like trades like that should not be allowed
@@92snp
its still possible so noone really cared right?
@@92snp disagree, this game needs all extra ways of creative trading, makes it much more interesting, and it also makes it much easier to combat one player getting lucky
I don't agree allowing gifting cards makes the game better
Free cards are against the rules. They made it against the rules for a reason. So doing multiple trades to have the same result is a way to circumvent a rule that exists for a reason. There are tournaments that explicitly forbid this. The only reason this was able to fly is because the app doesn’t flag this.
Nice game, thanks for the upload! Cool to see cash games for the highest tier of gameplay.
I like the editing of this video! Well done
Was a pleasure to play with you!
Well played. To be honest, I don't think there was anything anyone could have done different to stop you from winning this. Is was obvious from the setup that Red and Blue will be fighting for road, and you had an almost uncontested army, with the best production in the game. I was a bit surprised that red even came close.
Great… what a spoiler 🥲
Ugh spoilers from the top comment
man spoilers 😭
ימטורף מאיפה אתה בארץ אחי
I totally agree, Insurance deals are just a bunch of BS where the player in the best position is leveraging their positioning to not lay a target on their back with whom they make the deal with
I NEED MORE CATAN
I hope you keep grinding and post more. LOVE your videos
know this is pog before watching it
Came for Catan, left with new philosophical views 🤯
Someone finally spoke the truth... Dylighted have been doing his darty move for too long now.. 🌚🌚🌚
unfortunate ending probably should have plowed orange to the the 5 ore, although it was very unclear
You should really proud of how far youve come in terms video production!
Thoughts on 2/4/9 point left, then 8/5/3 or 8/5/10 for starters? Quick build to 5/2 wheat port. It is a slightly less blocking setup, but might help fill the gaps mid game, and might give you a better shot at supplementing your game with devs or a chance of city.
I actually like this idea a lot. The only major problem is 643 is pretty strong for black. Could be devastating for the table if 3s and 4s snowball.
Yeah I had the same thoughts
I love the videos. The production value is great. Could you consider not saying "question mark" after asking question? Great stuff
Yall really ganged up on red in the beginning.
Love to see the upload
I would have gone 5 4 11, and then the 8 5 10, and you are.guaranteed the expansion spot to the 6 11 with the free road. You get all 5 resources once you expand. And, you probably get the 8 3 expansion spot as well.
I think that would have been the nuts.
You are like Grima wormtongue on a catan board yo
8/5/10 and 4/5/11 and build the 6/11 was the play imo. Blocks the 5/6/11 and you get to play all 5 res with good production.
Yep. Just wrote this out myself. You probably also get the 8-3 port & I think you just crush at that point.
At 10:26 you made a trade. You needed to keep your 2 wood there and build between reds settlements to go for road.
Great editing
I enjoyed this video
Hey what is the thing that you play this on?
Where does he stream? Dont see him on twitch
Its Philisocial bro
Black was completely unreasonable here. Sitting at basically zero probability to win he just decided you should win instead of red. He just played horrible
Why did you never even consider taking the brick port?
Should only be nonverbal trade offers
cheater!
now that I have your attention, thanks for your videos, I really enjoy them😍
what do u mean by pacing problem
Pog
not going for city on double wheat when u could have the wheat port was a mstake... having the brick get bloked doesnt matter for ur game much
Really hate nonblock trades. Watched a three person game where they just did that the entire game vs one player. Pathetic way to play
Hey Dylan! Please please please stream more
hi Dylan. nationals thats cool but im from europe. and im more about cash competitive games. im good at poker and im also master level in backgammon. my question is - how to find leauges and pool of players for cash games? i just cant grow up in skills without money. im watchin all catan videos since Neonate. and i played sometimes. i really can be good at this game but... i hope we get some chances on video about this theme. thx a lot for all what you do.
@@roykorthouwer389 yeah. cash games for closed hidden games. but i think some small cash tournaments its pretty often thing.
I think 643 5810 has significant more merit than 642 5810 SBS with full brick control good ports to back up that production. Makes the loop around 6 brick more practical. Can still expand to 25 as well. Dav not taking 345 is puzzling to me because that shuts you down hard.
Where is the stream?
Dylighted on Twitch
@@omercohen2480 but when I search that the most recent videos are a year old can you send me a link to the channel?
Where do you stream?
Yes where
Dylighted on Twitch
@@omercohen2480 But it says he last streamed 2 months ago? Are these old streams?
These are pretty old streams, I'm going to start again in a week on Twitch.
@@DyLightedPlaysCatan Mind sending out a message, sometimes I don't get the notifcations
someone is close to winning, so you try to negotiate to win yourself? hm...