What?! Bob Dylan WROTE it?! I'm 47 y.o. and time and time again Bob Dylan shows himself as being the total man when it comes to songwriting. I always really liked this song but if Bob wrote it then I like it even more. The man is a living legend.
@@TracyAdams-ry2fc Yeah, I've heard that one too as a kid and liked it. I'm 47 and sappy love song haven't done jack shit for me in something like 20 years, but some of them like a lot. Why Worry by Dire Straits is an all-time favourite of mine. So is Time After Time by Cyndi Lauper. I usually find mushy songs annoying but those ones are very moving. As for this song, I'm not sure it's a mushy love song about a chick. It could very well have been about Bob's fondness for creative expression, for example. Or it could be about a spiritual worldview? Or both and how they relate to each other? I don't know.
No one, no living beings ( human, animals , aquatic, plants...) has actually died, just the OLD material body that No longer suitable to keep the SOUL within the core of the Heart. 🌷🌻🪷 Since Time Immemorial, each unique soul (living force/symptom of life) remains it's Individuality. The soul never takes Birth this never dies. The soul is always Active. #Near Death Experience (NDE) by Dr Bruce Greyson. #OBE (Out of Body Experience)
George was a damn good friend to have and I only wish I was able to have been one. I can claim to be a devoted fan for my entire life after seeing him on The Ed Sullivan Show In 1964. I love you George.
me too love you Kath...your kool and you have good taste in music I remember that Ed Sullivan show ..when they did a close-up of John Lennon the cation under him said "Sorry girls....he's married"! Saw the Beatles for 5 bucks at the Philadelphia Convention Center in 64...
I’ve never heard George Harrison sing this song. Indisputable proof that I’ve been living under a rock forever! Love this wonderful man and his magic music.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
yes he was definitely 1 of the beautiful people...i still think theres some of them left around today...there just a little harder to find (and they are mostly Republicans)lol
@@crazyantny9161 I prefer George’s vocals on this Dylan classic and slide guitar works somehow. It’s a hit! Dylan wrote a lot of songs that became hits by other bands covering them and singers. This song and Hendrix covering All along the Watchtower are the best examples!
What utter nonsense. George was a great guitar player, but he had the great fortune to be a schoolmate of one of the two greatest rock and roll songwriters ever.
George Harrison was always my favourite beatle since around 1966, he made some real good songs in his lifetime and they will live on forever as will my memories of him and the rest of the band ❤👍RIP Boss
@@johnbrattan9341 I believe it went number one, a first for an ex-Beatle. As a triple album, that's amazing. I was one of the buyers, all those years ago.
Unlike Material Body which is temporary, the atomic Spiritual spark, the SOUL is eternal and always Active, Never dies... Each individual soul remains As It Is, never change since time Immemorial..... George Harrison understands this Truth. Death means getting another New Body to continue to progress to reach the Ultimate Goal of Eternity. 🙏🕉️🪷🌷 Hari Om Tat Sat
Битлы будут всегда . Четверо ливерпульских парней в начале 60-х годов покорили меня и всех моих друзей. И вот 2024 год и я с огромным удовольствием вспоминаю те давние времена нашей юности и слушаю прекрасные песни любимой группы. Браво Джон,Пол,Джордж и Ринго!
Bob Dylan wrote “If Not For You” in 1970 - George sings it perfectly with Dylan on guitar & harmonica. It’s a tribute to the respect Dylan had for George!
Bob Dylan wrote “If Not for You” in 1970. George sings it perfectly here m. Fact that Dylan accompanied on guitar and harmonica show the respect Dylan had for George! I love this version!
Bob Dylan wrote “If Not for You” in 1970. George sings it perfectly here m. Fact that Dylan accompanied on guitar and harmonica show the respect Dylan had for George! I love this version!
Brilliant, absolutely fab.........💯💯💯 Sounds like its done during the All things must must pass sessions.........Billy Preston and Bobby Whitlock and The horn players from those sessions, properly Jin Gordon on drums.......... AWESOME.......👌👌👌👌
As a North Midlander, you want to attach this beautiful song to your Bleeding Heart?!!! Hold onto your Shirttails, my Lovely, we are Making America Great Again!
@@eveboyle109. I was referred to the album All Things Must Pass. It’s always been a healing, uplifting and meditative experience for me. LOVE IT❤. I melt when I hear If Not For You by George. Thanks for your thought.
George Harrison, what can I say only that he is Truely missed as a person that was good when walking on this earth now he may be walking upon the clouds. Wonderful song. His songs will never die... Biggest fan
Seeing George support his friend who wrote this song, while he sings it, for some reason makes me cry. The strength, the lack of ego. Bob was not so sure of himself that day. Bob: even his simpler songs have heart and soul, and melodies that stick. George: knew how to be a friend. Great vocal.
Can't pick a favorite, all the Beatles were different but exceptional in their own way. That mix gave us the sound we heard and their songs changed music forever. Dylan is an exceptional talent, a savant of musical literature, unparalleled in our time. But here's a curve ball, thank you google play lists for recreating the best of the best music memories. If AI is truly developing a sentient state it's going to be immersed in the sixties and seventies, just like we all are.😊😊😊😊
If not for you Babe, I couldn't even find the door I couldn't even see the floor I'd be sad and blue, if not for you If not for you Babe, the night would see me wide awake The day would surely have to break It would not be new, if not for you If not for you, my sky would fall Rain would gather, too Without your love I'd be nowhere at all I'd be lost, if not for you If not for you The winter would hold no spring Couldn't hear a robin sing I just wouldn't have a clue, if not for you If not for you, my sky would fall Rain would gather, too Without your love I'd be nowhere at all I'd be lost, if not for you If not for you The winter would hold no spring Couldn't hear a robin sing I just wouldn't have a clue, if not for you If not for you
amazingly its hard to say. Ringo the least,but in fact the guy was a great drummer for the band. If Moon drummed for the Beatles the songs would possibly have sufferred.
Love George my second favourite Beatle after John but this track is certainly up there with the best of them. Written by Dylan but George has made it his own and one I play often. Great La!!!
Настоящий шедерв 60-х годов.Отлично помню какое было впечатление,когда в 7 классе впервые услышал этих ребят. Все мои друзья были потрясены. Благодарю то замечательное время!
As a kid, like most,,Paul was my favorite beatle..They were a few years before my time. I was born in 68,,,but still very much popular when I got older,,.after they separated, HANDS down, George trounced all of them,,,and that's saying something...funny thing, the Band didn't realize what they had with George..
What's with the multiple punctuation marks and why do you say "the band didn't realise what they had with George" ? Bit of a sweeping statement and a pretty silly one in most people's opinions I would imagine!
@@Jo-we9ht Paul and John didn't want George's songs on the Beatles albums. George said he had to push and push just to get one song included because John and Paul would say it wasn't good enough or it wasn't what the album needed, etc. So, yes, John and Paul did not know the extent of George's songwriting talent. George said sometimes he would say he had written a new song and John and Paul didn't even want to hear it. Luckily, George kept at his songwriting and after the Beatles broke up, he had more than enough for his first solo album "All Things Must Pass".
I miss George too. What a lyrical, instinctive, creative soul! Plus -- he even had the good sense to have a vacation pad in Maui near Hana. Bless his memory! * Cav *
You see 2/5 of the Travelin' Wilburys coming together here. LOVE IT!! The song must be quite new for George, as he is reading the music or lyrics or both.
Although far beyond my ability its a quite simple arrangement but executed so so well by special people well done I’m 74 going on 75 not to old but also not to well just now thank you 🙏especially UA-cam Mike Sol’s
My thought is the "you" is a reference to God. I can tell why we have Spring and Fall, as well as having Summer and Winter. But it is from God, which is why there is faith.
This video is amazing!!! 👍🏼👏🏼
❤❤❤LOVE❤❤❤
YES.
Thank you Bob Dylan for writing this beautiful song! Thank you George Harrison for singing it best😄♥️
To live in 60s.says it all ❤😅❤😅
Agree
What?! Bob Dylan WROTE it?! I'm 47 y.o. and time and time again Bob Dylan shows himself as being the total man when it comes to songwriting. I always really liked this song but if Bob wrote it then I like it even more.
The man is a living legend.
I like Olivia Newton John’s version too. She sings it softly.
@@TracyAdams-ry2fc Yeah, I've heard that one too as a kid and liked it. I'm 47 and sappy love song haven't done jack shit for me in something like 20 years, but some of them like a lot. Why Worry by Dire Straits is an all-time favourite of mine. So is Time After Time by Cyndi Lauper. I usually find mushy songs annoying but those ones are very moving.
As for this song, I'm not sure it's a mushy love song about a chick. It could very well have been about Bob's fondness for creative expression, for example. Or it could be about a spiritual worldview? Or both and how they relate to each other? I don't know.
George may have been called the quiet Beatle, but he was the one who was open to collaborate with so many other musicians.
Jorje e Dylan nice moments legends
Note the collaboration team of The Traveling Wilburys!
George didn’t pass up any opportunity. ❤
George Harrison did his best work after the Beatles split up.
Missing George hearing this song. RIP❤
When my wife passed away I knew this was the song I knew we had to have this was the song to say goodbye A beautiful song.
No one, no living beings ( human, animals , aquatic, plants...) has actually died, just the OLD material body that No longer suitable to keep the SOUL within the core of the Heart. 🌷🌻🪷 Since Time Immemorial, each unique soul (living force/symptom of life) remains it's Individuality. The soul never takes Birth this never dies. The soul is always Active.
#Near Death Experience (NDE) by Dr Bruce Greyson. #OBE (Out of Body Experience)
George was a damn good friend to have and I only wish I was able to have been one. I can claim to be a devoted fan for my entire life after seeing him on The Ed Sullivan Show In 1964. I love you George.
me too love you Kath...your kool and you have good taste in music I remember that Ed Sullivan show ..when they did a close-up of John Lennon the cation under him said "Sorry girls....he's married"! Saw the Beatles for 5 bucks at the Philadelphia Convention Center in 64...
He was a good friend until he fancied your wife
@@CL-vx9dr maureen starr?
I’ve never heard George Harrison sing this song. Indisputable proof that I’ve been living under a rock forever! Love this wonderful man and his magic music.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
George is a source of inspiration
He wrote this, I think
No,this was written by Dylan.
Yes. Where have you been? ❤
@@wigellaDefinitely written by Dylan. ❤
Some music simply gets better over time. Thank you, George Harrison
Beautiful song by a beautiful man.
Rest In Peace beautiful George. 🙏🏻
Indeed, written by Dylan. :)
@@CHlEFFIN yeah not your classic beauty
yes he was definitely 1 of the beautiful people...i still think theres some of them left around today...there just a little harder to find (and they are mostly Republicans)lol
The author, Bob Dylan, must be proud and happy to hear his song on Beatle George’s voice, beautiful message!
Jaime B sure
isn't this song co written with Dylan?
Yes, much easier to understand too😂😂😂😂😂
@@crazyantny9161
I prefer George’s vocals on this Dylan classic and slide guitar works somehow. It’s a hit! Dylan wrote a lot of songs that became hits by other bands covering them and singers. This song and Hendrix covering All along the Watchtower are the best examples!
🙏💕George Harrison 1943-2001, rests in blissful, eternal peace.💕🙏
While we get to continue to hear what he gave the world. 🙏
Are Yeshua about that?
he'll be back again
The best Beatle imo
Love it have a tear in my eye!!
🙏
Bob Dylan and George Harrison are just like two Good Old brothers... In deed They ARE..🌻🌷💟
Love this song. From my era. Never gets old.
Forever George❤
RIP, George. You were one of the best. My favorite of the Beatles!
My beautiful George Harrison,and his beautiful voice and songs I love him❤❤❤
Amen, definitely a classic, ❤ I'm forever grateful to Mr George Harrison 🙏 THANK YOU SOO VERY MUCH APPRECIATED & LOVED
Great entanterer thanks alot George Harrison great music value for us to hear from them life goes on lucky enough to hear that beautiful music
Ah young George! Hard to believe it's 23 years.
That's hard to believe , but he did leave us with some great memories though.
Man I’m friggin old I bought that album when it came out 😂. I love that song and many other George sang. Love the Willburys too
The best Beatle .
What utter nonsense. George was a great guitar player, but he had the great fortune to be a schoolmate of one of the two greatest rock and roll songwriters ever.
There are four best beatle… it was symbiotic
@@os5484As Mick Jagger said, the four-headed monster..
love the lyrics beautiful music easy listening 🎧
Bob Dylan wrote this song.
George Harrison was always my favourite beatle since around 1966, he made some real good songs in his lifetime and they will live on forever as will my memories of him and the rest of the band ❤👍RIP Boss
My favorite also.
The best ...George had hearrt
Best version by far, sung with feeling. Great song written by Bob Dylan.
So great, saltwater runs from my eyes…
You Atlantians get so emotional. ❤❤ bless you. 😊
George, the best Beatle and singer-songwriter. Still miss him dearly. Thank you for leaving us so many beautiful songs and memories.
No John.. But George 2nd and best solo career
But he did not write this classic song lol
This here song was given to us by Mr. Robert Zimmerman. Olivia Newton-John had a big hit with this in the 70's.
The handsome one,the beautiful voice, beautiful songs, beautiful guitarrist from the Beatles ❤❤❤❤❤
@@MariaChacon-dd4cxThe quiet one !
George Harrison, my favourite Beatle! An incredibly talented musician! Love you for ever George ♥️
I always loved George's version of this song and All Things Must Pass is a masterpiece in itself.
I believe 'All things Must Pass" outsold every individual Beatles album.
@@johnbrattan9341
I believe it went number one, a first for an ex-Beatle. As a triple album, that's amazing. I was one of the buyers, all those years ago.
The best version of this song I've heard.
I just love George.... period ❤️💜❤️
Unlike Material Body which is temporary, the atomic Spiritual spark, the SOUL is eternal and always Active, Never dies... Each individual soul remains As It Is, never change since time Immemorial..... George Harrison understands this Truth. Death means getting another New Body to continue to progress to reach the Ultimate Goal of Eternity.
🙏🕉️🪷🌷 Hari Om Tat Sat
Битлы будут всегда . Четверо ливерпульских парней в начале 60-х годов покорили меня и всех моих друзей. И вот 2024 год и я с огромным удовольствием вспоминаю те давние времена нашей юности и слушаю прекрасные песни любимой группы. Браво Джон,Пол,Джордж и Ринго!
This is one of George's great love songs. It is definitely a favorite of mine.
Not a George song
Billy Preston on the organ! What a treasure.
RIP George. Thank you very much indeed to make me happy with your marvelous songs. RIP George!
Bob Dylan wrote “If Not For You” in 1970 - George sings it perfectly with Dylan on guitar & harmonica. It’s a tribute to the respect Dylan had for George!
Bob Dylan wrote “If Not for You” in 1970. George sings it perfectly here m. Fact that Dylan accompanied on guitar and harmonica show the respect Dylan had for George! I love this version!
Bob Dylan wrote “If Not for You” in 1970. George sings it perfectly here m. Fact that Dylan accompanied on guitar and harmonica show the respect Dylan had for George! I love this version!
George was so gifted loved all of his songs !
We are all gifted...we just have to find our gift...and share it with everyone...love+light!
George, the quintessential Beatle. How we love this guy! Love hearing him always, lifts my soul and mind! God Bless!
You are right - so much inner light in his music! "Here comes the sun"
Brilliant, absolutely fab.........💯💯💯
Sounds like its done during the All things must must pass sessions.........Billy Preston and Bobby Whitlock and The horn players from those sessions, properly Jin Gordon on drums.......... AWESOME.......👌👌👌👌
Much thanks for wonderful video❤❤❤
Truly one of the greatest artist ever. Love the truth of his lyrics
Absolutely
George lived his life in truth and love
Nádherná píseň, krásně zazpívaná a zahraná.
Beautifully done rest in peace❤
If not for you, George, my life would have been far less enjoyable, RIP, my good man.
Word!😀 God Bless.
Hermosa canción.Con George Harrison .Bonito recuerdo.
Post election results 😢. Listening to All Things Must Pass. A perfect song of encouragement. Thanks George❤
Yes. I’ve been listening to George too…to make it through these hard times.
As a North Midlander, you want to attach this beautiful song to your Bleeding Heart?!!! Hold onto your Shirttails, my Lovely, we are Making America Great Again!
@@eveboyle109. I was referred to the album All Things Must Pass. It’s always been a healing, uplifting and meditative experience for me. LOVE IT❤.
I melt when I hear If Not For You by George. Thanks for your thought.
GOD bless you George. I hope that I meet you in ("HEAVEN") one day.
The best version !! Dylan can’t hold a candle !!!!
Very true today, theme for 2024. People do not honor greed and stupidity. We have had enough.
George Harrison, what can I say only that he is Truely missed as a person that was good when walking on this earth now he may be walking upon the clouds. Wonderful song. His songs will never die... Biggest fan
He sings sooo very nice ..love this version
💖
Youve shared an very special song of two wonderful musicians . The booth of them will never be forgotten. Thank you for sharing!
Waterloo Sunset … listening to this beauty is always like a walk on the park … nice an easy , superb song ,
Seeing George support his friend who wrote this song, while he sings it, for some reason makes me cry. The strength, the lack of ego. Bob was not so sure of himself that day. Bob: even his simpler songs have heart and soul, and melodies that stick. George: knew how to be a friend. Great vocal.
the silent/quiet beatle;had a heavinly voice. R. I. P. George.
Love, love, love George❤
Can't pick a favorite, all the Beatles were different but exceptional in their own way.
That mix gave us the sound we heard and their songs changed music forever.
Dylan is an exceptional talent, a savant of musical literature, unparalleled in our time.
But here's a curve ball, thank you google play lists for recreating the best of the best music memories. If AI is truly developing a sentient state it's going to be immersed in the sixties and seventies, just like we all are.😊😊😊😊
Love the video and the song- nicely done.
George was always my fave
Bob, George and Leon.
Classic!
George Harrison my Beatle 4ever 💯🌹🕊thank you from Elli ✌❤
My Favorite as well ❤
Hasta ahora escucho cantar a Yosy ya está mayor como yo y revivío los recuerdos, hermosos vividos época maravillosa.
.magnificent footages!!! Never seen so assembled. Very good work. Compliments Lo Giudice and thank you!!!
Thank you so much Gisella 🙏
Lindo George ❤
If not for you
Babe, I couldn't even find the door
I couldn't even see the floor
I'd be sad and blue, if not for you
If not for you
Babe, the night would see me wide awake
The day would surely have to break
It would not be new, if not for you
If not for you, my sky would fall
Rain would gather, too
Without your love I'd be nowhere at all
I'd be lost, if not for you
If not for you
The winter would hold no spring
Couldn't hear a robin sing
I just wouldn't have a clue, if not for you
If not for you, my sky would fall
Rain would gather, too
Without your love I'd be nowhere at all
I'd be lost, if not for you
If not for you
The winter would hold no spring
Couldn't hear a robin sing
I just wouldn't have a clue, if not for you
If not for you
What a great song! One from my youth.
This is the most beautiful melody from Georgie..Gosh I miss you!💙🎶
nanag 123 My favorite beatle🙁
Dylan wrote it. Anyway it isn't as beautiful as "Something" ( in the way) or, "Within You and Without You".
George Harrison … a very remarkable man!
Maravilhosos George e bob
Beau compositeur et merveilleux guitariste ...
Harrison. Truly the greatest Beatle.
yesss ... .
Loved it when he grew his hair out again. Heavenly hippie.
Nah....
I love him still.
amazingly its hard to say. Ringo the least,but in fact the guy was a great drummer for the band. If Moon drummed for the Beatles the songs would possibly have sufferred.
This song gives me all the feels & makes me cry like a baby
Dylan songs do that to people.
Such a GREAT TALENT
What a great song
he sings with so much emotion . he probable sang that song a 1000 times but the emotion and facial expressions its like the first time he sang it
My favorite Beatle.
Talk about ,ALL STAR.... MISS THEM...🎸🙏
Love George my second favourite Beatle after John but this track is certainly up there with the best of them. Written by Dylan but George has made it his own and one I play often. Great La!!!
Every time I hear the song I think of my wonderful Creator and Lord Jesus. If it were not for you. My life would have no meaning at all
I always think of Santa Claus.
Настоящий шедерв 60-х годов.Отлично помню какое было впечатление,когда в 7 классе впервые услышал этих ребят. Все мои друзья были потрясены. Благодарю то замечательное время!
As a kid, like most,,Paul was my favorite beatle..They were a few years before my time. I was born in 68,,,but still very much popular when I got older,,.after they separated, HANDS down, George trounced all of them,,,and that's saying something...funny thing, the Band didn't realize what they had with George..
What's with the multiple punctuation marks and why do you say "the band didn't realise what they had with George" ?
Bit of a sweeping statement and a pretty silly one in most people's opinions I would imagine!
@@Jo-we9ht Paul and John didn't want George's songs on the Beatles albums. George said he had to push and push just to get one song included because John and Paul would say it wasn't good enough or it wasn't what the album needed, etc. So, yes, John and Paul did not know the extent of George's songwriting talent. George said sometimes he would say he had written a new song and John and Paul didn't even want to hear it. Luckily, George kept at his songwriting and after the Beatles broke up, he had more than enough for his first solo album "All Things Must Pass".
YEAH BOYS YOU ARE THE LEGENDS FOR WHOM IF NOT FOR ME YOU GEORGE ARE WITH YOUR SWEET LORD AND YOU BOB ARE MY MAN
Fantastic😊
The genius of a Beatle is unsurpassed.
My favorite Beatle, he always seemed so grounded. One of the only people that could make spiritual music sound so cool.
R.I.P. George! Great compilation.
I miss George too. What a lyrical, instinctive, creative soul! Plus -- he even had the good sense to have a vacation pad in Maui near Hana. Bless his memory! * Cav *
Beautiful man RIP ❤
Great song for George.
Oh man, look , listen to these masters. Wow beautiful
George sings with his heart and soul: lovely music
You see 2/5 of the Travelin' Wilburys coming together here. LOVE IT!!
The song must be quite new for George, as he is reading the music or lyrics or both.
That's a beautiful song, and amazing performance.
❤❤❤Soy Fan de El ! Me encantan sus temas
Esses ícones da música Internacional com suas vozes e seus instrumentos deixam nossos ouvidos e nossa alma cheia de satisfação.
Although far beyond my ability its a quite simple arrangement but executed so so well by special people well done I’m 74 going on 75 not to old but also not to well just now thank you 🙏especially UA-cam Mike Sol’s
If it not for you, my Guardian I would not have had a safe and enjoybale life. Thank you for ll the treats, hugs and taking care of me. Meow!
Sweet. 💕
My thought is the "you" is a reference to God. I can tell why we have Spring and Fall, as well as having Summer and Winter. But it is from God, which is why there is faith.
Bob Dylan wrote this as a love song for his first wife which was released in 1969 or 1970.
Good job editing the video! Proud to say that I was at the Concert for Bangladesh and Dylan's 50th anniversary concert both held at MSG.
Música linda George e Dylan que dupla magistral pra sempre abraço ❤🎉