okay buddy give me one reason why they wouldn't be honest? everyone else is agreeing with you so anyone else can go ahead and tell me why too, seems like you guys are being pretty fuckin judgmental about a person based off of some sort of negative connotation with their beliefs. why would someone lie about a belief that they hold above themselves even? why would they give a shit what other people think about them and their beliefs?
@@uraniumbolt7594 when a channel is known for bringing compars & less knowwn youtubers. you start questionning if they staged it even when you like the results. like when watching some social expiriments i just wish the acts were not staged. an honest opinion i disagree with is better than a fake one even if it's similar to mine.
As an scientific researcher, this is the worse most inaccurate kind of polling you can do with a small sample time with induced peer-bias. Absolutely ridiculous, nobody would admit to kill for their religion ffs
As a scientific researcher, you'll know then that they're not collecting data for a peer reviewed paper or anything, just trying to visually display general trends in opinion across religious groups for a 2 minute youtube video
@@willherondale6367 The point is that the experiment is fundamentally flawed. The only "Trend" they showed is that most people lie in public to fit in.
@@Novozymandiaz No. It does not work. The premise isn't less flawed because the time is shorter. The point ts the give an idea of the views of certain groups. This does not do that.
You have to raed about islam and Studied and Ask Muslim Sheikhs to find out more about islam listen to Sheikh ahmed deedat and Sheikh zakir naik and i am proud to be muslim Because it Is the right relgion and the religion of truth and for the scound time you Must seriously raed and Studied and Ask Muslim Sheikhs to find out more about islam listen to Sheikh ahmed deedat and Sheikh zakir naik
Halapecia shaniqua Why presume every Muslim family is necessarily like yours? I doubt a Malay Muslim in Singapore, a Hui Muslim in China, and an Albanian Muslim in Kosovo have too much in common.
This video is progressive/Islamist propaganda to try to give u an imaginary image of islam, islam as I know and lived under will do all the atrocities to advance the cause but With Qatari funded propaganda like this you would not get that image
*1 CORINTHIANS 11:4* Every man who prays or prophesies with his head covered dishonors his head. But every woman who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonors her head-it is the same as having her head shaved. For if a woman does not cover her head, she might as well have her hair cut off; but if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, then she should cover her head. A man ought not to cover his head, since he is the image and glory of God; but woman is the glory of man. For man did not come from woman, but woman from man; neither was man created for woman, but woman for man. It is for this reason that a woman ought to have authority over her own head, because of the angels. Nevertheless, in the Lord woman is not independent of man, nor is man independent of woman. For as woman came from man, so also man is born of woman. But everything comes from God. Judge for yourselves: Is it proper for a woman to pray to God with her head uncovered?
@@eliasziad7864 it was written in Chortians because of social and convenience issues, not because God says that, there are bigger issues than what someone wears or not anyways
Lav her my parents are Muslim too and they support gay/lesbian people to live the way they want to live. Islam says don’t force anyone to believe in your religion but try to tell them this is the right one. For me it isn’t and that’s why I don’t believe in any books and my Muslim parents are okay with it. You only know as much as media shows you. You talk due to Islamic countries but how they live is not Islam. Also almost every religion against gay/lesbian people not only Islam.
r Bruh, you’re acting like the person is homosexual. Besides, why go against something natural over religion. You’re a cold hearted person to go out of your way not to support someone over faith.
r You faith is about YOU, not others. Whatever you think is gonna happen to you if you follow it, is gonna happen to you. But what you believe in doesn’t apply to others, since that’s an belief. If this person supports Lgbtq+ since going against it is morally wrong, that’s their business and a preference in beliefs that I appreciate. You don’t have to follow everything in an religion. The Bible supports slavery but do you see any Christians supporting it? No! People choose what they believe in because it applies to them...not others. Thank you for choosing to force homophobia down respectful Muslims throats.
@allah satangod So, you just denied the 99.99% of moderate muslims and said that they are fake and accepted 0.001% of extremist muslims who recently came to arise that the are real? I pity your knowledge
I'm not agreeing with @allah satangod. But I think there is more than 0.001% extremist. I mean ever since Trump put in the travel ban. I've seen nothing violent happening here. If we were to just completely open our boarders and remove the travel ban, along with removing the 2nd Amendment. This country would be destroyed. I mean look at the UK right now. They obviously don't give a shit, I mean their cops don't even have guns anymore. Terrorists are coming in with AKs and bombs screaming "ALLAH AKBAR". Look at this big picture my friend.
CE Ker i never said it was “cool” to be an atheist? religion (in my opinion) comes from humans not understanding what happens after death and the fright in that non understanding made them want to have something to look forward to. humans can not comprehend pure nothingness and there, religion is born. they need something greater than themself to believe in, i’m not gonna force you to believe the same as me, so i suggest you do the same, and don’t pray for me. i don’t want or need it. just because someone doesn’t have the same set of beliefs as you doesn’t mean they’re lesser or not as smart or need to be changed. move on with your day, and i’ll move on with mine!
bee Except for the fact that this is a subjective truth. Religion used to exist solely to explain nature and environments. Look at the Greeks and the Romans etc. However, religion still exists today as people have grasped how science works. I think everyone should be on the same page at least on whether religion is right or wrong because a good 3 billion people either way would be wasting their lives.
+MepsiCax In Christianity, in the Old Testament, the Israelites were lead by God to claim the Promised Land. After that killing was not accepted, except in defending one's own people by necessity.
All these videos are biased unfortunately, not all people could express their ideas within the public freely. If you apply closed vote with same questions on this same sample, you will see the difference.
@@karmicobsession1636 thats correct though, in another video they're 100% anti-capital punishment and more support than against for same sex marriage no religious muslim nations or societies ever did this, literally
Rather dying instead of religion being forced onto you. I mean I would just act to be because it's kind of easy to but if it was an actual war (atheist Vs any religion) then I would first try peace unless and later violence when absolutely necessary
Honestly very surprised to see that most of the atheists would die for their belief Edit: I wasn’t trying to say they shouldn’t or that I was judging them. I’m not sure I can explain why it surprised me, it just did. It’s not really something I’d thought about. Thanks to the people who replied respectfully, I genuinely enjoy broadening my understanding of people whose perspective I don’t necessarily agree with
Its because were not saying that we are absolutely right. If you can prove your beliefs, atheists will change their mind. We basically just accept that we cannot prove (and therefore know) if there's a certain God etc. at this point
They tried to flip the Christian thing of “I will love you no matter what” on him. I think that is a good thing to do, but they tried to make him out as the bad guy.
John Power stop bullshitting about stuff that don’t exist. Muslims and Jews lived together for centuries it’s only recently there has been a big problem. just let there be love
For the people fighting in the comments, grow up. This video was about how four different groups of people could meet in a room and express their beliefs without argument. There was no fighting. Put aside your personal agenda or bias and just love one another.
allah satangod Still believing that lie even when the people you're talking about are denouncing it? The Muslims didn't even vote the most extreme out of the groups, for fuck's sake.
So easy, but no. We are not stupid. We know that this is not an actual representation of what most Muslims, Christians, atheists and Jews think out there. There is Gallup and Pew Research. Go find them out instead of being so triumphant over a completely tiny and preselected sample. Gosh. People are so manipulable.
Notice how all the Muslims would not kill for their religion but all said they would die for their religion. Idk why but I thought that was beautiful. I’m Muslim btw
هههههه ويا ترى هالشي صح ولا عم يكذبوا، كلنا بنعرف انو 90% من المسلمين مستعدين يقتلوا منشان معتقداتهن، انا استنيت واحد بس واحد منهم يقول الحقيقة بس منافقين مو بإيدهن
@@haydarr7903 (لكم دينكم ولي دين) مو كل شخص مسلم يمثل الإسلام وبنعمم فعله على المسلمين كافه لان كل شخص يخطئ ومو كل شخص يسوي محرمات اقول ان كل المسلمين زيه وعموما حرام قتل الكافر المسالم.
@@AzizanShaib السؤال كان كتير بسيط اذا دينك امرك بالقتل، بتقتل ولا لا؟! بعدين حاجتك ترقيع حرام قتل الكافر المسالم؟! المجرم غير المسلم=المجرم المسلم، يعني مثلا لو مسلمين حاربوا مسلمين تانيين مو نفس الشي لما غير مسلمين بحاربوا مسلمين مثلا؟! ولا كيف بتفكروا انتو؟ يعني مثلا "الكافر" هو بطبيعته غير مسالم فحلال قتله؟!، فمنجي نحن هون منعطي استثناء انو لاء المسالمين منهن حرام قتلهم ههههه
Not really, if he is a true Christian then he would love everyone just as God does; he just doesn't see people without the dedication towards God that he has as moral.
Jaz Caz I agree with you I'm also surprised that more Christians did not join him seeing as they know everyone is born in sin therefore they everyone is immoral unless they come to Christ
Paint It black You do believe morality comes from god and the bible? If yes, you would think atheists are immoral because they think sin is a religious concept.
Not saying he should be shunned or shamed, just saying that praising people with problematic views just because they're "different" isn't the thing to do either
Did you hear what the person had told him? I still love you, I know you don't love me but I love you. Clearly she does not know the mentality of a true Christian lol.
Also she said "I know you don't love me" how does she know that? The ironic thing is that she is accusing him of being immoral by saying that he is unloving
Juliana Silva Are you kidding me? Is the christian nun's headscarf oppressive? Is the sikh turban oppressive? Nope. The same applies to the hijab. Women wear it because that is the dress code in their religion, not because they are oppressed.
JNike Sikh turban is worn only by men you idiot. You dont have to be killed for not wearing one. the quran doesnt say that. But the bible clearly says women who dont cover their hair should shave off their head! The hijab is just a dress code. it is not oppressive
Skywalker everything that it's written in the Bible stay in the Bible we don't use the Bible as a law and nobody is forcing to wear something in our western countries. "The hijab it's just a dress code. It is not oppressive" how can you even say that? If it wasn't oppressive they would have let women decide what to wear
Tommaso P. If someone is forcing it, that person's action is oppressive. Not the dress itself. Woman have the right to choose whether to wear a hijab or not, just like I have the right whether to wear pants or not. Just because my religion says I need to wear pants doesn't mean wearing pants is oppressive. There are many woman who choose to wear it, and there is nothing wrong with that.
I'd be a lot more interested to see anonymous responses. There is likely a lot of social pressure here to answer questions one way or another in groups this large. Still, I suppose someone REALLY has to hold a certain opinion to answer in decent.
Incorrect ! Many hold these views ! Also you always had a few that would change ! American Muslims are some of the most secular integrated patriotic in the world
I agree the results would be more accurate if done privately. However, even in real life there is pressure to change your opinion/beliefs by the people and culture we are around and I think in general the results would not be too different. But I agree with you.
@VIII Maus I have never seen a person thinking that. On the other side, most people in my country are atheists so religious people are the minority (well not really a minority, because there are many, but still, both "sides" know each other and just ignore beliefs because it's not important for being friends etc)
I’m just making a guess but I don’t think he is saying this I’m such a bad way as we are interpreting it. If he had a chance to explain I’m sure that would make him look at least a little better... Or he would just look like a douche but I guess we’ll never know🤷🏼♀️
@@user-me8hy8ew4o actually 60% of your country is religious, so you would be the minority. In fact out of the 40% that are irreligious, most are agnostic. Atheists are a minority in every country and virtually in every social circle.
xAnnax Playz i would not be friends with any christian, i dont hate them i just dont like them .. they steal our natural resources, they force Muslims to accept their ideology, they destroy muslim country for no reason (iraq, libya and now they tried to destroy syria) they are hypocrites ..
@@littlefennik6799 I agree, as an Indonesian. We'll welcome you! But be careful for the people who are biased and hates Christmas for some reason. Not saying that alot of people are. Just saying that you should be careful
It's kinda beautiful seeing that atheist lady say to the guy that says yes to the question "are non religious people immoral" that she still loves him :]
Christianity teaches that no one is a good person, and that that's why we need Christ. No one is better than another person. So yes, he's thinking that unbelievers are immoral because everyone is immoral. We cannot be good without Christ. That doesn't mean he hates someone who he believes to be immoral.
then look at majority muslim countries. all shitholes. Theft is punishable by amputation of the hands (Quran 5:38). • Criticizing or denying any part of the Quran is punishable by death. • Criticizing Muhammad or denying that he is a prophet is punishable by death. • Criticizing or denying Allah is punishable by death (see Allah moon god). • A Muslim who becomes a non-Muslim is punishable by death (See Compulsion). • A non-Muslim who leads a Muslim away from Islam is punishable by death. • A non-Muslim man who marries a Muslim woman is punishable by death. • A woman or girl who has been raped cannot testify in court against her rapist(s). • Testimonies of 4 male witnesses are required to prove rape of a female (Quran 24:13). • A woman or girl who alleges rape without producing 4 male witnesses is guilty of adultery. • A woman or girl found guilty of adultery is punishable by death (see "Islamophobia"). • A male convicted of rape can have his conviction dismissed by marrying his victim. • Muslim men have sexual rights to any woman/girl not wearing the Hijab (see Taharrush). • A woman can have 1 husband, who can have up to 4 wives; Muhammad can have more. • A man can marry an infant girl and consummate the marriage when she is 9 years old. • Girls' clitoris should be cut (Muhammad's words, Book 41, Kitab Al-Adab, Hadith 5251). • A man can beat his wife for insubordination (see Quran 4:34 and Religion of Peace). • A man can unilaterally divorce his wife; a wife needs her husband's consent to divorce. • A divorced wife loses custody of all children over 6 years of age or when they exceed it. • A woman's testimony in court, allowed in property cases, carries ½ the weight of a man's. • A female heir inherits half of what a male heir inherits (see Mathematics in Quran). • A woman cannot speak alone to a man who is not her husband or relative. • Meat to eat must come from animals that have been sacrificed to Allah - i.e., be "Halal." • Muslims should engage in Taqiyya and lie to non-Muslims to advance Islam.
I believe the guy that said non-religious people are immoral was going on the fact that he thinks all people are immoral. Christianity teaches that everyone is messed up, even Christians. It's just that christians rely on god to forgive them for it. I could be wrong, but I'm almost certain that's where he was coming from.
yes i agree... we teach forgiveness, and none of us even Christians and their priests are not sinners, we are all sinners and should depend on Jesus and not to ourselves
I'm atheist (and that's why I'm asking) but I do not understand why another atheist would die for their lack of belief. You have nothing to die for, and, thus, it makes no sense.
it does make sense. if someone put a gun to your head and told you to profess that their God is the REAL God would you rather lie and say that he is or live but lie about your beliefs.
I agree I doesn't make any sense. How could you be willing to put your life at risk for something that is not relevant. I didn't get that one its like pride was more important than your life. Christians, Jews and Muslims on the other hand, if we are close to God we should be willing to sacrifice our life out of love to God. Love to someone Vs pride.
yeah but if you believe there is no God then just pretend to believe or accept whatever you need to so you won't be killed. There is no God to please or whatever.
The first question is terrible. No, a piece of clothing itself is not indicative of oppression. Being forced to wear a piece of clothing under serious threats is.
I agree. I believe it to be a symbol of faith. However, I find it oppressive when women are forced to wear it because of their culture and/or religion. The question itself wasn't specific enough.
When you have muslim women telling you they don't feel oppressed why do you feel like you can speak incorrectly for them? I'm a Muslim woman, I choose to wear the hijab and if tomorrow I took it off I wouldn't be threatened nor ostracized because my parents are humans who know what morals are just like any other human. You are a massive idiot.
This showed that Atheists are really chill and share all of my morals. They seem more chill than Jews and Christians. Muslims are also disproving a lot of America's stereotypes about them, and that is really awesome.
Don't get too ahead of yourself, this is a small group of people. It would be really cool if WatchCut could manage to get 100 people per group. Of course, that would be very expensive and difficult.
Yes its true. Because as a true Christians we don't believes in any religion. As a christian its not about religion its about relationship with Christ.
@@AAA-kh6qi LOL, Uneducated? Do you know what the "Law" means? Call the police fuckwit Rape or Murder or Pedophilia, you have no right to kill. However justified it may seem. Nobody is above the law: This has no meaning to you? Have the maturity to do the right thing. Call the cops. Also, in this video, "Beliefs" means Religious Beliefs. (Context Sherlock) Nobody is talking about the personal beliefs you have against Rapists or Murderers. The questions asked are asked according to what one's Religious Beliefs are.
Except some did say they would kill for their religion. ...Though considering killing is a major sin in all three Abrahamic religions, those who said "no" were actually being good followers of their religions.
It is incredibly unscientific with a tiny sample size, but it's interesting to see the numbers represented by real people, especially for the people in the video who get to interact with one another. And it is likely telling when one groups is >90% for yes or no on a question. I'd love to see the same questions asked to a much larger, more diverse sample size, but without that I still enjoyed watching this video even though from a statistical standpoint it doesn't really tell much.
I think they sampled more liberals than conservatives. If you were to ask conservative christians if non religious people were immoral, I'd say a high percentage would say yes.
I love these videos. Of course it's not scientific data but it shows the human, and the social side of controversial issues. I especially like when interaction between the participants is highlighted.
This was really interesting! I really like you guys' channel because it's much more genuine-feeling than a lot of the other big channels who do polls. *cough* Buzzfeed sold their soul *cough*
lhamilt Yeah, and not only that, it felt like they had to tell the morale of the story in each video, or else organize events in such a way that it told a false narrative or the one that they chose. In essence, it feels like they are pandering to their audiences with cheesy obvious taglines, like women should have equality. Cut is much more unexpected and it doesn't cram one way of thinking upon its viewers. Even though I agreed with the world-views of Buzzfeed, it was like watching a children's show!
It's mainly because younger Christians like myself are studying and reading the bible for ourselves and not simply accepting what others are teaching us. We're being more critical.
@@theorange9426 the Muslims were 100 percent for everything almost except the last thing, atheists were also pretty united, but overall I think this proves that people of all religons and all races can have similar or different beleifs
jackrush 122 I don’t think he meant to be rude. All morals stem from religion. Not saying that makes you religious. But if you go all the way back, that’s where they came from. All the different religions. So he’s saying you can’t be moral without religion
So happy to see you put atheist in here. I'm Christian and my girlfriend is atheist and people in my family always get this wrong assumption that because she doesn't believe in God or religion, she has to be a horrible human being. Most of the atheist that I've met are judgmental free and live without impose their views. Anyways as a religious person I'm very happy.
Maria Fuentes a gay Christian? Honey your dead meat. People are just WAYYYY too cruel. Maybe take the girlfriend part off but say like you know her or something. Also I support it
While I do agree that this is not a perfect reflection on the beliefs held by these people, I still think it's an interesting way to gather data and it's fairly accurate to where the answers make sense
That person who said that "we still love you even though you don't love me" Like what? Just because she/he thinks your immoral doesn't mean they hate you
M Meidiano Al Fajri think if your brother or sister or friend is living a lifestyle you think is wrong. That doesn’t mean you don’t love them. Christians are called to love both their enemies and their neighbors. It may sound stupid but it is possible.
@@emi11iana no in His eyes those who dont know God are like his "lost sheep" that he would go to the ends of the earth to find. Those who do not know God are judged more people who say they know God and disobey Him.
Hi, i think what in iran it is more on political statement. Wearing scarves in iran is their dress code, even a foreigner have to follow. I would rather see the purpose of muslim women asked to do, but if they are not covering it well they decided not to. So oppression is not an issue when someone decided by herself not by force. Thats my opinion as a Muslim.
Well, as a justification for why cover was applied in these two religions? Its not because of someone idea about this and that.. look why God ask nun to cover? Any reason...? Please understand from both religion views without bias. I respect both christian n muslim. I dont understand how wearing hijab is submissive to men, actually they are controlling men from being uncontrollable. submission to men is like you are doing what men like n u please to do it, not for self but to please them. Wearing hijab, will not pleasing for those men in lust i think. U think?
0:23 I liked how those people talked to each other regardless of religious beliefs. And that touched my heart. Regardless of our political beliefs, religion, gender, race, ethnicity, etc, we should be kind to each other
Because they are ill-informed yes :-) I do not really think it is very moral to be a Theist and believe that (2/3 if you’re Christian) (4/5 if you’re Muslim) and (9,5/10 if you’re Jew) are going to burn in hell for eternity is particularly moral either.
Eric Mago Im an agnostic but a lot of theists believe in a god who is completely just but at the same time merciful. They believe that God will righteously judge the world. One of the things people may say is that God punishing nonbelievers is immoral but their God is a god of truth who cannot tolerate any wrongdoing, not because he hates people but he hates sin, and to not judge people and ignore the fact that they did wrong is in itself immoral. But if people genuinely have a change of heart he would show mercy. The thing is God also cares about truth, and denying God as the one true lord of everything is in their eyes a sin (and it makes sense) because those people dwell in falsehood, whether they realize it or not.
WOW this is really legitimately interesting. As a muslim myself, I was surprised that there were a lot more progressive than I expected them to be. Should have gotten some native saudis in there now that would have been interesting
I believe all the people on dirty data are Americans, but correct me if I'm wrong. Sure seemed like it because the questions usually have connection to American politics and discussions.
Radeiculas true but I feel like due to the public nature of this people would feel public pressure, not saying the Muslims would not be progressive. but the thing is it's better polling to do in private.
Religion is what you are taught by a certain group honey. Nothing personal about it. And also, when the atheists said they would die for there beliefs I was like....but that’s the point. You don’t have beliefs to die for.
atheism is a belief you do know that right? www.google.com.ph/search?q=belief+meaning&oq=belief+m&aqs=chrome.1.69i57j0j69i60j0l3.9596j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 in case you still dont know the meaning of it click the link
Just because they don't believe in a godly power doesn't mean they don't have beliefs in human made systems. Maybe they would die to defend the laws they think are right or die to stand up for what they think is right.
"Is the Hijab a Symbol of oppression?" It depends entirely on where you live. Claiming that the Hijab isn't a method to oppress women in certain countries is not only incorrect, it's irresponsible.
@@king-yp9wm Did you read my comment? And was your reply a question? I think people should be able to wear what they want to wear. If they want to wear a Hijab they should have the right to do so no matter our opinion on the matter. That is as long as THEY choose to do so. PS: yes, nuns as well
@MaryTisdell You think these are real Muslims, lol you are disllusioned. These are Muslims that must follow American Law and Order not the Law of Islam, bring some real Muslims from one of those backward totallaterian states and you will see what a difference it is.
I say say i Frankly, it seemed to me like the person saying “we love you” was giving a ridiculously rude and back-handed “compliment” trying to get a reaction out of that guy. In my opinion, good for him for being honest and then not engaging with the rude people.
@@snastehsketlen5852 how was that person being rude? They just wanted to let him know that they dont hate him even though he hated thwn. Idk but i dont think its rude
I'll take this chance two years later to update my position. I remain a Christian: Due to the yes/no format for answers I'll put any commentary in brackets in order to elaborate on my full position 1. No (Unless the Government or prominent cultural institutions forces you to) 2. Yes (If someone is trying to strip me of my right to hold those beliefs or is mistreating me because of those beliefs and killing is my only resort to stop that) 3. Yes 4. Undecided leaning yes (Define immoral; as a Christian, I believe it is immoral to reject God/Jesus and all humans have committed immoral activity. That said non-religious people can and often do, do a great amount of good in the world.) 5. Yes (I believe abortion for any reason at any point in pregnancy should be permitted but I believe the majority of reasons for getting an abortion aren't morally justified. The reason for this apparent contradiction is that I believe the instances where abortion is morally justified in effect require the full legalization of on-demand abortion). This was nice. Maybe I'll see you in another 2 years lol.
Main lessons of christianity (at least for me): be good to others; love the ones who hate you; if someone hurts you, give them your other cheek; even if you don't have much you can allways give something for those in need, etc. -would you kill for your beliefs? Chistian people: yes 😐😐😐😐 i mean, that's a mortal sin bruh
A better way to do this might be to have everyone blindfolded and raise their hand for “yes” just so there’s no peer pressure dynamic.
Yes it is actually
thank you
Yeah
Ikr
Sure. But in real life, our beliefs are also influenced by people around us and their perception of us.
I got the feeling they ain’t downright honest at all.
Of course, but some of them are.
They wish to avoid looking bad. It's pathetic.
jubilee plays this game it's staged.
okay buddy give me one reason why they wouldn't be honest? everyone else is agreeing with you so anyone else can go ahead and tell me why too, seems like you guys are being pretty fuckin judgmental about a person based off of some sort of negative connotation with their beliefs. why would someone lie about a belief that they hold above themselves even? why would they give a shit what other people think about them and their beliefs?
@@uraniumbolt7594 when a channel is known for bringing compars & less knowwn youtubers. you start questionning if they staged it even when you like the results. like when watching some social expiriments i just wish the acts were not staged. an honest opinion i disagree with is better than a fake one even if it's similar to mine.
As an scientific researcher, this is the worse most inaccurate kind of polling you can do with a small sample time with induced peer-bias.
Absolutely ridiculous, nobody would admit to kill for their religion ffs
As a scientific researcher, you'll know then that they're not collecting data for a peer reviewed paper or anything, just trying to visually display general trends in opinion across religious groups for a 2 minute youtube video
@@willherondale6367 The point is that the experiment is fundamentally flawed. The only "Trend" they showed is that most people lie in public to fit in.
@@willkrueger3857 Yeah, but it works for a 2 minute UA-cam video. Which is the entire point of this whole thing.
@@Novozymandiaz No. It does not work. The premise isn't less flawed because the time is shorter. The point ts the give an idea of the views of certain groups. This does not do that.
@@willkrueger3857 The point is to make a UA-cam video that's entertaining. And it certainly got your attention. It doesn't seem flawed to me.
I think some people go with the flow.
90%of them in fact
But I don’t think the majority would like to underestimate this crucial question
Some people don't go with the flow
It’s definitely a factor
You have to raed about islam and Studied and Ask Muslim Sheikhs to find out more about islam listen to Sheikh ahmed deedat and Sheikh zakir naik and i am proud to be muslim Because it Is the right relgion and the religion of truth and for the scound time you Must seriously raed and Studied and Ask Muslim Sheikhs to find out more about islam listen to Sheikh ahmed deedat and Sheikh zakir naik
Maybe people would respond more genuinely if they were asked one by one ? I feel like they're very influenced each by other 😶
pieulpe This is really obvious when it came to the first question.
***** Oh ok then ^^ I thought it was called ''dirty data'' because you tried to choose sort of ''taboo'' questions
I think it's better this way because people will look at it from the other perspective as well.
Halapecia shaniqua but you know not everyone has to follow " EVERYTHING " their religion says. It's their choice. So in your claim it's fairly okay
Halapecia shaniqua Why presume every Muslim family is necessarily like yours? I doubt a Malay Muslim in Singapore, a Hui Muslim in China, and an Albanian Muslim in Kosovo have too much in common.
These are so interesting. I only wish they were longer :c
sambeawesome they didn't drink enough milk
I wish they were real
sambeawesome I agree. They should make these longer
This video is progressive/Islamist propaganda to try to give u an imaginary image of islam, islam as I know and lived under will do all the atrocities to advance the cause but With Qatari funded propaganda like this you would not get that image
sambeawesome and honest
The thumbnail of the Jewish woman holding hands with the Muslim woman made me feel proud.
dude saaame...i wish us and the jews would just stop fighting over politics
Peace from now on is the only answer.
awksya f. I feel like i wanna cry seeing that
Made me tear up a little lol
Same. I'm Jewish and I think that peace will be the best thing to ever happen.
it would be hilarious if an atheist said “yes” at the question “are non religious people immoral”
HAHAHHAAHA
*1 CORINTHIANS 11:4*
Every man who prays or prophesies with his head covered dishonors his head. But every woman who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonors her head-it is the same as having her head shaved. For if a woman does not cover her head, she might as well have her hair cut off; but if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, then she should cover her head. A man ought not to cover his head, since he is the image and glory of God; but woman is the glory of man. For man did not come from woman, but woman from man; neither was man created for woman, but woman for man. It is for this reason that a woman ought to have authority over her own head, because of the angels. Nevertheless, in the Lord woman is not independent of man, nor is man independent of woman. For as woman came from man, so also man is born of woman. But everything comes from God. Judge for yourselves: Is it proper for a woman to pray to God with her head uncovered?
@@eliasziad7864 I’m sorry this is pure evil pure sexism and misogyny
@@eliasziad7864 I’ll pray for you tonight, I will pray that your soul finds peace and comes out of evil
@@eliasziad7864 it was written in Chortians because of social and convenience issues, not because God says that, there are bigger issues than what someone wears or not anyways
The 2 most united were the Atheists and Muslims. Usually (in their group) they had very similar beliefs. You would see a lot of 100% in both of them
The atheists make sense. They don't have any holy book or set of rules to follow so it's easier to agree on things.
No
@@lllool8404 thank you!
Parker Westman wtf 🤣
@@lllool8404 Same with everyone
I’m Muslim , and seeing people be so kind to eachother is so heartwarming 💖💖
- thanks for the likes but I don’t support but Ofc I respect ❤️
Sara Harake and you know it’s lie Muslim people don’t agree with same sex marriage the would kill this person immediately
Lav her My family supports gay marriage and we’re Muslim. The elders don’t support it though. It’s not religion, it’s the mindset they were taught
Lav her my parents are Muslim too and they support gay/lesbian people to live the way they want to live. Islam says don’t force anyone to believe in your religion but try to tell them this is the right one. For me it isn’t and that’s why I don’t believe in any books and my Muslim parents are okay with it. You only know as much as media shows you. You talk due to Islamic countries but how they live is not Islam. Also almost every religion against gay/lesbian people not only Islam.
r Bruh, you’re acting like the person is homosexual. Besides, why go against something natural over religion. You’re a cold hearted person to go out of your way not to support someone over faith.
r You faith is about YOU, not others. Whatever you think is gonna happen to you if you follow it, is gonna happen to you. But what you believe in doesn’t apply to others, since that’s an belief. If this person supports Lgbtq+ since going against it is morally wrong, that’s their business and a preference in beliefs that I appreciate. You don’t have to follow everything in an religion. The Bible supports slavery but do you see any Christians supporting it? No!
People choose what they believe in because it applies to them...not others. Thank you for choosing to force homophobia down respectful Muslims throats.
0:21 I'm a Muslim & seeing a Jew touching a Muslim arm really holded me 😢 😢 😢!
@allah satangod So, you just denied the 99.99% of moderate muslims and said that they are fake and accepted 0.001% of extremist muslims who recently came to arise that the are real? I pity your knowledge
@allah satangod you are more stupid than a dead clam. ISIS is a terrorist group. Not a religion.
I'm not agreeing with @allah satangod. But I think there is more than 0.001% extremist. I mean ever since Trump put in the travel ban. I've seen nothing violent happening here. If we were to just completely open our boarders and remove the travel ban, along with removing the 2nd Amendment. This country would be destroyed. I mean look at the UK right now. They obviously don't give a shit, I mean their cops don't even have guns anymore. Terrorists are coming in with AKs and bombs screaming "ALLAH AKBAR". Look at this big picture my friend.
@@benson5798 So don't run away from the shit you created
@@benson5798 Ummmmm... SCHOOL SHOOTINGS doesn't count as violence???
when the athiest woman was saying she still loved the guy who thought she was immoral. that was so sweet.
Athiesm is not a a religion so they shouldn't be here in the first place. I am agnostic athiest btw.
Prakash Kumar the title says “beliefs” not religion,, atheism is a belief. (i am an atheist)
bee When did it become cool to be an atheist? I’m praying for you guys.
CE Ker i never said it was “cool” to be an atheist? religion (in my opinion) comes from humans not understanding what happens after death and the fright in that non understanding made them want to have something to look forward to. humans can not comprehend pure nothingness and there, religion is born. they need something greater than themself to believe in, i’m not gonna force you to believe the same as me, so i suggest you do the same, and don’t pray for me. i don’t want or need it. just because someone doesn’t have the same set of beliefs as you doesn’t mean they’re lesser or not as smart or need to be changed. move on with your day, and i’ll move on with mine!
bee Except for the fact that this is a subjective truth. Religion used to exist solely to explain nature and environments. Look at the Greeks and the Romans etc. However, religion still exists today as people have grasped how science works. I think everyone should be on the same page at least on whether religion is right or wrong because a good 3 billion people either way would be wasting their lives.
"Would you kill for your beliefs?"
Don't your religions tell you not to kill though?
MepsiCax the Bible is weird and contradictory.
Religions say both to kill and not to kill. Depends how you choose to interpret them.
Yes... Christians should not kill, that person must not be putting Jesus as his role model properly -_-
+MepsiCax
In Christianity, in the Old Testament, the Israelites were lead by God to claim the Promised Land.
After that killing was not accepted, except in defending one's own people by necessity.
SirCutRy yes... because everyone who kills by sword will be killed by sword... even Peter who defended Jesus was reprimanded 😂😂😂
All these videos are biased unfortunately, not all people could express their ideas within the public freely. If you apply closed vote with same questions on this same sample, you will see the difference.
Yeah it would be much more interesting to do a random polls with anonymous people.
Esp. the green t shirt people.
Crazy Flossin you mean the muslims
@@karmicobsession1636 thats correct though, in another video they're 100% anti-capital punishment and more support than against for same sex marriage
no religious muslim nations or societies ever did this, literally
Warhamer 40k way to generalize
1:01 what defines “dying for your beliefs” to an atheist??????? 🤔
totally not chloe I don't know cause I'm atheist and I wouldn't
Rather dying instead of religion being forced onto you. I mean I would just act to be because it's kind of easy to but if it was an actual war (atheist Vs any religion) then I would first try peace unless and later violence when absolutely necessary
I’m an atheist and if someone threatened to kill me if I said I weren’t Christian, I could easily pretend I’m one.
totally not chloe An Atheist could believe in the values of America and would want to die to defend them
totally not chloe EXACTLY IM AN ATHEIST AND I WAS SO CONFUSED
Honestly very surprised to see that most of the atheists would die for their belief
Edit: I wasn’t trying to say they shouldn’t or that I was judging them. I’m not sure I can explain why it surprised me, it just did. It’s not really something I’d thought about. Thanks to the people who replied respectfully, I genuinely enjoy broadening my understanding of people whose perspective I don’t necessarily agree with
I'm really confused what the fuck is that even supposed to mean
It means that they would rather die than forced to join a religion.
Its because were not saying that we are absolutely right. If you can prove your beliefs, atheists will change their mind. We basically just accept that we cannot prove (and therefore know) if there's a certain God etc. at this point
Alicelise as a Christian I believe that trying to prove or disprove belief is dumb
@anzarazz as a christian i agree converting someone into your own religion is dumb i have to say just let people believe what the want to believe
Atheist: I know you don't love us, but we love you.
The one with the yellow shirt: Ok thanks
Really?
Theltion Non I
They tried to flip the Christian thing of “I will love you no matter what” on him. I think that is a good thing to do, but they tried to make him out as the bad guy.
King Carterico But they barely know the guy how is it fair?
Well, what else is he supposed to say? That's what I'd say
Savage 😂😂😂😂😂😂
the part where the Jewish woman and Muslim woman were clasping hands was the cutest thing I've ever seen
Elizabeth Johnson SAME
Elizabeth Johnson
it was cringe and just a way to show how great of a person they are seriously how can you not see it
ZIGGY exactly. It was so fucking forced
Shame how if America was an Islamic country the Jewish woman would be killed immediately or banished.
John Power stop bullshitting about stuff that don’t exist. Muslims and Jews lived together for centuries it’s only recently there has been a big problem. just let there be love
For the people fighting in the comments, grow up. This video was about how four different groups of people could meet in a room and express their beliefs without argument. There was no fighting. Put aside your personal agenda or bias and just love one another.
GracefulSwanHurricane I totally agree
Best comment Bryer!
1:8 yeah especially 1:18
allah satangod Still believing that lie even when the people you're talking about are denouncing it? The Muslims didn't even vote the most extreme out of the groups, for fuck's sake.
So easy, but no. We are not stupid. We know that this is not an actual representation of what most Muslims, Christians, atheists and Jews think out there.
There is Gallup and Pew Research. Go find them out instead of being so triumphant over a completely tiny and preselected sample.
Gosh. People are so manipulable.
Notice how all the Muslims would not kill for their religion but all said they would die for their religion. Idk why but I thought that was beautiful.
I’m Muslim btw
هههههه ويا ترى هالشي صح ولا عم يكذبوا، كلنا بنعرف انو 90% من المسلمين مستعدين يقتلوا منشان معتقداتهن، انا استنيت واحد بس واحد منهم يقول الحقيقة بس منافقين مو بإيدهن
MH Videos bruh you don’t know them how can you just assume that they are lying
@@haydarr7903 (لكم دينكم ولي دين) مو كل شخص مسلم يمثل الإسلام وبنعمم فعله على المسلمين كافه لان كل شخص يخطئ ومو كل شخص يسوي محرمات اقول ان كل المسلمين زيه وعموما حرام قتل الكافر المسالم.
@@rightpickles6307
i don't know them
but they are either not representing their religion or lying..
there is no another option 🙂
@@AzizanShaib
السؤال كان كتير بسيط
اذا دينك امرك بالقتل، بتقتل ولا لا؟!
بعدين حاجتك ترقيع
حرام قتل الكافر المسالم؟!
المجرم غير المسلم=المجرم المسلم،
يعني مثلا لو مسلمين حاربوا مسلمين تانيين مو نفس الشي لما غير مسلمين بحاربوا مسلمين مثلا؟!
ولا كيف بتفكروا انتو؟
يعني مثلا "الكافر" هو بطبيعته غير مسالم فحلال قتله؟!، فمنجي نحن هون منعطي استثناء انو لاء المسالمين منهن حرام قتلهم ههههه
"we still love you. i know you don't love me, but i love you." amazing
Not really, if he is a true Christian then he would love everyone just as God does; he just doesn't see people without the dedication towards God that he has as moral.
What a condescending and presumptive thing to say to a stranger "I know you don't love me"
Jaz Caz I agree with you I'm also surprised that more Christians did not join him seeing as they know everyone is born in sin therefore they everyone is immoral unless they come to Christ
Paint It black You do believe morality comes from god and the bible? If yes, you would think atheists are immoral because they think sin is a religious concept.
Paint It black Yep that's why I picked that circle
Why do I have the feeling that every Christian in this video is not quite convinced about what they’re saying/doing...???🤷♀️
Just agree with both of you
Because you are biased against Christians?
Because Christianity was corrupted.
We actually are, we disagree on some matters but we all believe in the same god which is why I’m in the religion...because I believe in God
@Hola et Amigo No i indeed was, and lots of priests admited
I luv that the Muslims always shared the same answer. I think it's a sign of unity.
Salmah Eljammal it’s a sign of not wanting to answer wrong and then be called out.
Historical Review they’re fully grown adults, they’re not indoctrinated at all
Salmah Eljammal or herd mentality
More like they're a bunch of sheeps
King Carterico no man they are saying the truth dwry
1:20 I can respect this guy though, he didn't follow everyone else
He's judgemental about others, close-minded, and not afraid to flaunt it! woo!
Not saying he should be shunned or shamed, just saying that praising people with problematic views just because they're "different" isn't the thing to do either
He was honest but he came across as veru naive and ignorant on that moral question..
dyiah M He’s literally right though, you cannot have morals without beliefs/scripture from which to draw them
@@wetshoelaze1055 Nope, just no.
This is awesome. More videos like these please.
guys thease vidoes are so fun to watch make a fuck ton of them
WatchCut Video I saw one of my friends in these videos, if you are near Seattle how do I join up?
Starchild91 ddd
iam agree with you
As a christian, many of my fellow christians answers were very disappointing
LowkeyRari amen
same. Smh
Agreed, the killing one is shocking!!
same
No devout Christian would kill for Jesus when they know very well what the Bible says about murder
1:13 That's one brave dude
Magalí Fernández i thought it was a lesbian lol
being a christian, you have to not be afraid of persecution.
unfunny uncreative as a Christian I'm glad at least one of them have some decency
Did you hear what the person had told him? I still love you, I know you don't love me but I love you. Clearly she does not know the mentality of a true Christian lol.
Also she said "I know you don't love me" how does she know that?
The ironic thing is that she is accusing him of being immoral by saying that he is unloving
0:22 and then the high five at the end! It makes me so happy! (I’m Jewish)
John Johnson Outside politics and all Jews are really kind and we are all humans ! (I am Muslim)
Same
John Johnson
It doesn’t matter how it makes you feel
I just had to do it lol
the arabian falcon WE WUZ KANGZ it’s ok!
I'm Muslim and i give you my full respect!
0:21 Such a beautiful sight. That's how humanity should be!
Juliana Silva Are you kidding me?
Is the christian nun's headscarf oppressive? Is the sikh turban oppressive? Nope. The same applies to the hijab. Women wear it because that is the dress code in their religion, not because they are oppressed.
Skywalker nobody is forcing you to become a nun that's the point, you must were an hijab
JNike Sikh turban is worn only by men you idiot.
You dont have to be killed for not wearing one. the quran doesnt say that. But the bible clearly says women who dont cover their hair should shave off their head!
The hijab is just a dress code. it is not oppressive
Skywalker everything that it's written in the Bible stay in the Bible we don't use the Bible as a law and nobody is forcing to wear something in our western countries.
"The hijab it's just a dress code. It is not oppressive" how can you even say that? If it wasn't oppressive they would have let women decide what to wear
Tommaso P. If someone is forcing it, that person's action is oppressive. Not the dress itself.
Woman have the right to choose whether to wear a hijab or not, just like I have the right whether to wear pants or not. Just because my religion says I need to wear pants doesn't mean wearing pants is oppressive. There are many woman who choose to wear it, and there is nothing wrong with that.
I'd be a lot more interested to see anonymous responses. There is likely a lot of social pressure here to answer questions one way or another in groups this large. Still, I suppose someone REALLY has to hold a certain opinion to answer in decent.
Incorrect ! Many hold these views ! Also you always had a few that would change ! American Muslims are some of the most secular integrated patriotic in the world
According to what study, Jenna? You need to back up a statement like that with atleast one source.
I agree the results would be more accurate if done privately. However, even in real life there is pressure to change your opinion/beliefs by the people and culture we are around and I think in general the results would not be too different. But I agree with you.
This is so bias, "give me a mask and I will tell the truth"
This is also done with a younger generation, If this was done with Muslims from the old generation, it would be very different.
Tank Tonka well that's kinda why this is called "dirty data" for a reason. Its purely for entertainment and some knowledge
If I used this data for my PHD thesis, I'd get knocked the fuck out by the board at my uni
Tank Tonka lollllll
Geraldine Alvarado the new generation of muslims are an improvment, but still the least open minded of all the groups shown in this video.
I'm really surprised about the "Are nonreligious people immoral?" question.
Yes, how could one person stand on the "yes" side?
@VIII Maus I have never seen a person thinking that. On the other side, most people in my country are atheists so religious people are the minority (well not really a minority, because there are many, but still, both "sides" know each other and just ignore beliefs because it's not important for being friends etc)
@VIII Maus Germany
I’m just making a guess but I don’t think he is saying this I’m such a bad way as we are interpreting it. If he had a chance to explain I’m sure that would make him look at least a little better...
Or he would just look like a douche but I guess we’ll never know🤷🏼♀️
@@user-me8hy8ew4o actually 60% of your country is religious, so you would be the minority. In fact out of the 40% that are irreligious, most are agnostic. Atheists are a minority in every country and virtually in every social circle.
0:22 I’m a Muslim and this made me cry! I want all the religions to be friends like this!
xAnnax Playz i would not be friends with any christian, i dont hate them i just dont like them ..
they steal our natural resources, they force Muslims to accept their ideology, they destroy muslim country for no reason (iraq, libya and now they tried to destroy syria) they are hypocrites ..
A F Don’t generalize all Christians. There are bad apples in every religion
@@af8915 replace Christian's with capitalist and communist governments
I would say SOME Christians are bad .
A F politicians do that not every Christian the same.
When the Jew and Muslim held hands I shed a tear. ❤️
dues vult have proof? No then shut up
dues vult fucketh you good sir
Me too
Yeah these people are all actors, sorry.
Harold Moore, how do you know? I'm not tryna be sassy or whatever, I just wanna know.
OH MY GOD! I never realized how optimistic and united we muslims are
you're not. only few college kids in this video.
@@Andrej158158 You're just being biased
Come here to Indonesia, we have 6 main religions, loving each other. all religions were united, especially for Muslim to the other muslims.
@@littlefennik6799 I agree, as an Indonesian. We'll welcome you! But be careful for the people who are biased and hates Christmas for some reason. Not saying that alot of people are. Just saying that you should be careful
So, who should succeed Mohammed, as leader...?
"I love you even if you don't love me"
"Ok, thanks"
LMFAOOOOO I don't know why but I died when he said that.
The guy was like I still think the same lol
@@salwaas938 many of those aren't true religious at all
@@lebaneseproud7930 does not mean they cant choose that religion.
@@salwaas938 so you mean a msulim can vote in the name of a jew?
@@lebaneseproud7930 what?
I believe that there are some false religions but that does not mean i have the right to disrespect them
See the Christian data can be dubious, since you could have extremely socially liberal Catholics and equally extremely conservative evangelicals
0:14 look who's fuckin back
Borat Assamat exactly what I was thinking
the republican :p
Hahahaha that's what i thought aswell!
that fucking bitch. omg i disagree with EVERYTHING she sais
You guys its her opinion, let her be..
More Dirty Data please
PPL around me : "I love you even you don't love me "
Me as an introvert : "Ok ,thanks"
That was you i’m confused???
It's kinda beautiful seeing that atheist lady say to the guy that says yes to the question "are non religious people immoral" that she still loves him :]
I am a follower of christ and I would have stood where most atheist and muslims...I am so ashamed of people in my own faith. :(
aallhh A hey don't be ^^ it's just one person..
Christianity teaches that no one is a good person, and that that's why we need Christ. No one is better than another person. So yes, he's thinking that unbelievers are immoral because everyone is immoral. We cannot be good without Christ. That doesn't mean he hates someone who he believes to be immoral.
I'm actually surprise by the results for this one since every human being is immoral no matter the religion.
The video showed how people can tolerate each other regardless of the different opinions they hold. That's the key to a beautiful life❤
Atheists pick the chillest answers
Jakeshapedworld "chillest"
Jakeshapedworld
Jesus Christ I hate my generation.
Kenny Day
I hate your generation too but mine is fine
Define "chillest".
I don't believe that these people would die for their beliefs at all
I would though
litty lit I would
litty lit I would do anything for god
look up "shahid death" on google
That is what are you saying,but when there will be the choice in real life you wont propably died for your beliefs
Can we just appreciate how many Muslims think the same?
@@stratant.8722 Or... Get this: They aren't evil. A fact that you are too brainwashed to acknowledge.
Psycho Gamer no because they actually follow and 100% believe in their religion
Psycho Gamer these are rare and christians barely follow their religion lmao they don’t even know their religion
@@stratant.8722 Ottoman didn't force anyone to be muslim, instead they respected everyone's religion
Stratan T.
They go to church and you say they are Muslim?
Are you high my guy ?
Basically all I learnt is that muslims are awesome people
then look at majority muslim countries. all shitholes.
Theft is punishable by amputation of the hands (Quran 5:38).
• Criticizing or denying any part of the Quran is punishable by death.
• Criticizing Muhammad or denying that he is a prophet is punishable by death.
• Criticizing or denying Allah is punishable by death (see Allah moon god).
• A Muslim who becomes a non-Muslim is punishable by death (See Compulsion).
• A non-Muslim who leads a Muslim away from Islam is punishable by death.
• A non-Muslim man who marries a Muslim woman is punishable by death.
• A woman or girl who has been raped cannot testify in court against her rapist(s).
• Testimonies of 4 male witnesses are required to prove rape of a female (Quran 24:13).
• A woman or girl who alleges rape without producing 4 male witnesses is guilty of adultery.
• A woman or girl found guilty of adultery is punishable by death (see "Islamophobia").
• A male convicted of rape can have his conviction dismissed by marrying his victim.
• Muslim men have sexual rights to any woman/girl not wearing the Hijab (see Taharrush).
• A woman can have 1 husband, who can have up to 4 wives; Muhammad can have more.
• A man can marry an infant girl and consummate the marriage when she is 9 years old.
• Girls' clitoris should be cut (Muhammad's words, Book 41, Kitab Al-Adab, Hadith 5251).
• A man can beat his wife for insubordination (see Quran 4:34 and Religion of Peace).
• A man can unilaterally divorce his wife; a wife needs her husband's consent to divorce.
• A divorced wife loses custody of all children over 6 years of age or when they exceed it.
• A woman's testimony in court, allowed in property cases, carries ½ the weight of a man's.
• A female heir inherits half of what a male heir inherits (see Mathematics in Quran).
• A woman cannot speak alone to a man who is not her husband or relative.
• Meat to eat must come from animals that have been sacrificed to Allah - i.e., be "Halal."
• Muslims should engage in Taqiyya and lie to non-Muslims to advance Islam.
@@bosnia7429 literally every single thing you wrote is incorrect. And you're confusing religion with culture.
@@bosnia7429 this isn't from the Quran. This is just the law of some countries
@@bosnia7429 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 😂 I used to get sad when I see hate comments but this is banter. Cuz everything u said is the opposite.
longshlong32 You are talking about a dictatorship not the Quran I’m an Atheist and I know that’s not in the Quran.
I believe the guy that said non-religious people are immoral was going on the fact that he thinks all people are immoral. Christianity teaches that everyone is messed up, even Christians. It's just that christians rely on god to forgive them for it. I could be wrong, but I'm almost certain that's where he was coming from.
PainfullyClear you can't tell where he is coming from. You're not him...
yes i agree... we teach forgiveness, and none of us even Christians and their priests are not sinners, we are all sinners and should depend on Jesus and not to ourselves
Toulouse The Cat I know! I said I could be wrong. Just speculating.
I totally agree, I think a lot of people got the wrong idea about him saying that though.
oooh I see. Thank you for your optimism!
I'm atheist (and that's why I'm asking) but I do not understand why another atheist would die for their lack of belief. You have nothing to die for, and, thus, it makes no sense.
it does make sense. if someone put a gun to your head and told you to profess that their God is the REAL God would you rather lie and say that he is or live but lie about your beliefs.
I agree I doesn't make any sense. How could you be willing to put your life at risk for something that is not relevant. I didn't get that one its like pride was more important than your life. Christians, Jews and Muslims on the other hand, if we are close to God we should be willing to sacrifice our life out of love to God. Love to someone Vs pride.
Promethium61 01 I had the exact same question! I'm an atheist too and defo wouldn't die for my belief in science and a lack of a God😂
Maybe they were thinking of non-religious belifs.
Fiorella Bak could be but they will be missing the point of the excersise
Omg that was so emotional when the hands were holding together at 0:21
Muslim love all the religions 🔥🕍🕋💒
B.S The Quaran literally says Christians and Jews are the " worst of creatures"
B.S The Quaran literally says Christians and Jews are the " worst of creatures"
B.S The Quaran literally says Christians and Jews are the " worst of creatures"
Peñalty for APOSTASY plz
@@ameghm6382 recite me the verse in quran
Atheists would "die for their beliefs" ..What beliefs?
Lol
Buddhist, Wicca, Syntheism those are all religious affiliations that are either accepting of atheist ideology or are centered around atheism
And technically atheists believe that there is no god so theres that.
Maybe they'll rather die than be forced to believe in one of the religions.
yeah but if you believe there is no God then just pretend to believe or accept whatever you need to so you won't be killed. There is no God to please or whatever.
The first question is terrible. No, a piece of clothing itself is not indicative of oppression. Being forced to wear a piece of clothing under serious threats is.
Some people believe that the piece of clothing itself is a sign of oppression. That was the question.
Or being forced to not wear it
I agree. I believe it to be a symbol of faith. However, I find it oppressive when women are forced to wear it because of their culture and/or religion. The question itself wasn't specific enough.
When you have muslim women telling you they don't feel oppressed why do you feel like you can speak incorrectly for them? I'm a Muslim woman, I choose to wear the hijab and if tomorrow I took it off I wouldn't be threatened nor ostracized because my parents are humans who know what morals are just like any other human. You are a massive idiot.
This showed that Atheists are really chill and share all of my morals. They seem more chill than Jews and Christians. Muslims are also disproving a lot of America's stereotypes about them, and that is really awesome.
Don't get too ahead of yourself, this is a small group of people. It would be really cool if WatchCut could manage to get 100 people per group. Of course, that would be very expensive and difficult.
As a follower of Christ, I shared the similar standings as the atheist in the video... I'm so disappointed at the people who are in my faith... :(
Annette S well Atheists are most excepted compared to the other religions.
Annette S Atheists are more chill than all 3 religous groups
Yes its true. Because as a true Christians we don't believes in any religion. As a christian its not about religion its about relationship with Christ.
The people who said they'd kill for their belifs should be locked up.
Let's be happy no one did.
@@AAA-kh6qi murder is a sin. and unjust. and i dont think ANYONE thinks its wrong to rape anyone or murder babies or anyone (which is contradicting)
Would you go to war for religious freedom? I feel like a lot of people would say yes to that.
@@AAA-kh6qi LOL, Uneducated?
Do you know what the "Law" means?
Call the police fuckwit
Rape or Murder or Pedophilia, you have no right to kill. However justified it may seem.
Nobody is above the law: This has no meaning to you?
Have the maturity to do the right thing. Call the cops.
Also, in this video, "Beliefs" means Religious Beliefs. (Context Sherlock)
Nobody is talking about the personal beliefs you have against Rapists or Murderers.
The questions asked are asked according to what one's Religious Beliefs are.
More like people who lied about it should be locked up.
would you kill for your religion was a good question and yess no one would openly answer truthfully.
Except some did say they would kill for their religion. ...Though considering killing is a major sin in all three Abrahamic religions, those who said "no" were actually being good followers of their religions.
Doommagic agree. preach!!
BuT ME I WouLd diE FoR AtHeiSm ANy daY
sure you would.
MinecraftLetsplayer1969 1 and all the stupidity came from your mind is here at the moment.
+MinecraftLetsplayer1969 1 what the fuck did u say...u wanna punch?
What an incredibly unscientific method.
It is incredibly unscientific with a tiny sample size, but it's interesting to see the numbers represented by real people, especially for the people in the video who get to interact with one another. And it is likely telling when one groups is >90% for yes or no on a question. I'd love to see the same questions asked to a much larger, more diverse sample size, but without that I still enjoyed watching this video even though from a statistical standpoint it doesn't really tell much.
I think they sampled more liberals than conservatives. If you were to ask conservative christians if non religious people were immoral, I'd say a high percentage would say yes.
It is good for visual presentation. No one is doing a research here.
This video is just supposed to make muslims look better than everyone else.
"We still love you, you may not love us but we still love you" that part cracked me
when I saw the muslim & jewish woman holding hands it made my heart warm up😭
Awww me too, I’m Muslim btw
That made me cry as a Jew
say it again , today it israel palestine conflict .
@@opai1821 LMFAOOOOOOOOOOO
@@opai1821 Israel is not a jewish nation
I love these videos. Of course it's not scientific data but it shows the human, and the social side of controversial issues. I especially like when interaction between the participants is highlighted.
vindelanda doesn't change the fact that it doesn't mean anything, if you wanted to have a good conversation, you would bring up statistics.
This was really interesting! I really like you guys' channel because it's much more genuine-feeling than a lot of the other big channels who do polls. *cough* Buzzfeed sold their soul *cough*
Ender Wiggins totally agreed, I unsubed from BF awhile back. Just always felt like it was only for entertainment purposes.
lhamilt Yeah, and not only that, it felt like they had to tell the morale of the story in each video, or else organize events in such a way that it told a false narrative or the one that they chose. In essence, it feels like they are pandering to their audiences with cheesy obvious taglines, like women should have equality. Cut is much more unexpected and it doesn't cram one way of thinking upon its viewers. Even though I agreed with the world-views of Buzzfeed, it was like watching a children's show!
Wow...I'm really shocked by the results by the Christians.
Actually same to be honest, it shows a lot of progress within the Church to be more accepting of new ideas and people.
It's mainly because younger Christians like myself are studying and reading the bible for ourselves and not simply accepting what others are teaching us. We're being more critical.
what do you mean like accepting sin like homosexuality?
OMI lmao
+Nicholas Pereiro shut up.
The only thing this proves is that people in the same religion thinks wildly different. Religion means different things to different people.
Atheists were pretty united. This just shows that not having a book to tell you what to do actually helps to build consensus rather than not.
@@theorange9426 didn't think about that, good point.
@@theorange9426 the Muslims were 100 percent for everything almost except the last thing, atheists were also pretty united, but overall I think this proves that people of all religons and all races can have similar or different beleifs
Muslims think the same, alhamdulillah
THe ORange what about Muslims? They were united as well
Gosh, I wish I could be a part of this! Please keep doing more of these!
My fellow Athiests in this video have made me proud ♡
Brynn C. Like her rude behavior @1:19 yeah
Deja Anderson how was she rude?
Olav M. Honestly the amount of sarcasm in her voice. You can’t tell me that was genuine. It was out of spite
I think she was just offended though not saying what she did was right but why she did it we still need to consider that
jackrush 122 I don’t think he meant to be rude. All morals stem from religion. Not saying that makes you religious. But if you go all the way back, that’s where they came from. All the different religions. So he’s saying you can’t be moral without religion
0:21
I'm dying of happiness :")
Same.. Its heart touching..
Jews and Muslims should unite. Like we both don’t eat pork
psycho bish HAHAA
psycho bish I love u sister (I’m Muslim) 🥺💕
@@realhotgirlshit9144 its hard to unite espiecially with different gods but its possible
i love the togetherness of every religion in this it almost makes me want to cry :')
The Muslims made me so proud !🥺 I’m so proud to be Muslim
Noni Macaroni you go queen!! I’m Christian 😊
The Luckiest Gaming thank uuu kweeennnnn love our Christian sisters!!
Noni Macaroni yessss i love u all 🥺🥺
@@nicola_x you are such amazing person 🥺💜❤️💞 thank you for existing 🌺😊
These are too short
The thumbnail is really sweet , it made me cry :'( . I wish we live like that
1:26
When you're the only guy who is still laughing on old memes
0:21 I bawled my eyes out
So happy to see you put atheist in here. I'm Christian and my girlfriend is atheist and people in my family always get this wrong assumption that because she doesn't believe in God or religion, she has to be a horrible human being. Most of the atheist that I've met are judgmental free and live without impose their views. Anyways as a religious person I'm very happy.
Maria Fuentes a gay Christian? Honey your dead meat. People are just WAYYYY too cruel. Maybe take the girlfriend part off but say like you know her or something. Also
I support it
1. The questions aren't really clear
2. People are influenced by one another, thats incorrect data
3. Do a better job next time
LotusEater Chill, it's not a serious investigation
That's why it is called "dirty data"
LotusEater If under 1000+ people are participating, results aren't reliable either
Tenshikichi1 they should specify what they mean by that in the video itself, one line of text could do that job.
While I do agree that this is not a perfect reflection on the beliefs held by these people, I still think it's an interesting way to gather data and it's fairly accurate to where the answers make sense
Please do more of these. Very eye opening
That person who said that "we still love you even though you don't love me"
Like what? Just because she/he thinks your immoral doesn't mean they hate you
"U are immoral, but I love you. "
U know it's stupid if u think about it
M Meidiano Al Fajri think if your brother or sister or friend is living a lifestyle you think is wrong. That doesn’t mean you don’t love them. Christians are called to love both their enemies and their neighbors. It may sound stupid but it is possible.
@@tomball8092 i guess that's okaaayyy
M Meidiano Al Fajri Its actually not god loves all his children yet if you are non religious you are immoral in his eyes
@@emi11iana no in His eyes those who dont know God are like his "lost sheep" that he would go to the ends of the earth to find. Those who do not know God are judged more people who say they know God and disobey Him.
Hijab a symbol of oppression, depends where you are! For example in Iran you have no chance to decide whether you want or not ;)
Hi, i think what in iran it is more on political statement. Wearing scarves in iran is their dress code, even a foreigner have to follow. I would rather see the purpose of muslim women asked to do, but if they are not covering it well they decided not to. So oppression is not an issue when someone decided by herself not by force. Thats my opinion as a Muslim.
BuyingOGNames no its not because nuns are submissive to god but hijab is made for be submissive to men and be a nun is a choice
BuyingOGNames and why men dont cover their head and why they should wear it only in front of them
Well, as a justification for why cover was applied in these two religions? Its not because of someone idea about this and that.. look why God ask nun to cover? Any reason...? Please understand from both religion views without bias. I respect both christian n muslim. I dont understand how wearing hijab is submissive to men, actually they are controlling men from being uncontrollable. submission to men is like you are doing what men like n u please to do it, not for self but to please them. Wearing hijab, will not pleasing for those men in lust i think. U think?
BuyingOGNames sexism
nobody is going to say yes
4 guys: challenge accepted
Are these filmed in California by any chance?
Kermit The Toad This one was Seattle so pretty much the same lol
Tbh i feel that this type of experiment should be done anonymously so no one would feel judged by the choices they make
i dont feel these are fully accurate as i would be entirely swayed by the majority
0:23 I liked how those people talked to each other regardless of religious beliefs. And that touched my heart. Regardless of our political beliefs, religion, gender, race, ethnicity, etc, we should be kind to each other
Wording the last question "Are you Pro-Choice" should have been followed up by "Are you Pro-Life?" or worded differently entirely.
"On the topic of Abortion, are you pro-choice?" This would have been a far better and accurate question.
1:07 If they all wore masks and random clothing, they would've picked yes, for sure
Because they are ill-informed yes :-) I do not really think it is very moral to be a Theist and believe that (2/3 if you’re Christian) (4/5 if you’re Muslim) and (9,5/10 if you’re Jew) are going to burn in hell for eternity is particularly moral either.
@@ericmago4110 you all....stop putting hate between us we all the same
Eric Mago Im an agnostic but a lot of theists believe in a god who is completely just but at the same time merciful. They believe that God will righteously judge the world. One of the things people may say is that God punishing nonbelievers is immoral but their God is a god of truth who cannot tolerate any wrongdoing, not because he hates people but he hates sin, and to not judge people and ignore the fact that they did wrong is in itself immoral. But if people genuinely have a change of heart he would show mercy. The thing is God also cares about truth, and denying God as the one true lord of everything is in their eyes a sin (and it makes sense) because those people dwell in falsehood, whether they realize it or not.
Lmao I don’t think so
@@tomball8092 jesus said to the pharasese "I love the sinner not the sin"
WOW this is really legitimately interesting. As a muslim myself, I was surprised that there were a lot more progressive than I expected them to be. Should have gotten some native saudis in there now that would have been interesting
I believe all the people on dirty data are Americans, but correct me if I'm wrong. Sure seemed like it because the questions usually have connection to American politics and discussions.
Radeiculas true but I feel like due to the public nature of this people would feel public pressure, not saying the Muslims would not be progressive. but the thing is it's better polling to do in private.
Saudis don't represent Islam
Yes they are Muslims but their are more Muslims around the globe
Radeiculas I believe that Saudi muslims will react the same way as the one in the video.
getting a bunch of brain washed wahhabis isnt a good sample of us
This is beautiful ❤ #loveeachother
Amazing how the Jewish person held the Muslims hand now I’m proud to have a bit of Jewish blood in me :3
This is the kind of amazing videos you'll get if you want quality over quantity. Unlike buzzfeed, where they're all about quantity over quality.
0:21 - Awww!
these people's personal beliefs didn't line up with their religion.
Not true at all! Your religion is personal ! You can be secular progressive politically
Religion is what you are taught by a certain group honey. Nothing personal about it. And also, when the atheists said they would die for there beliefs I was like....but that’s the point. You don’t have beliefs to die for.
King Carterico atheism isn't a lack of beliefs, it's a lack of belief in a god or gods.
atheism is a belief you do know that right?
www.google.com.ph/search?q=belief+meaning&oq=belief+m&aqs=chrome.1.69i57j0j69i60j0l3.9596j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
in case you still dont know the meaning of it click the link
I don’t know why but that guy with the woolly hat and mittens I like he seems so happy and full of joy which is something the world needs
Sweet sweet herd mentality
Masha Allah the green one (Muslim) 💖
Yeah Proud Turk and 100% Muslim Masha Allah💖
hardly any of the "Christians" are actually followers of Christ. scary and unpleasant sight.
I agree, and over half of them said they were pro choice. It doesn't make any sense.
@@light8214 infact Muslims too
@@nariahmay5565 Nah. Islam gives women abortion rights (to a certain extent)
@@zayna8517 no such a thing as abortion rights in islam, we could say its sometimes allowed for certain accidents, but originally its not allowed.
@@zayna8517
I don't want to argue about this ether, maybe if you want more details about this you can check.
1:10 Brave. I don’t agree with him but brave.
Exactly my thoughts. He's also the only person whom I might believe on the question "would you die for you faith". He's got balls.
Atheists would die for their beliefs ? What beliefs ?
Just because they don't believe in a godly power doesn't mean they don't have beliefs in human made systems. Maybe they would die to defend the laws they think are right or die to stand up for what they think is right.
Missy Larsson But those things aren't beliefs but ideals. The difference being that one exists and one is believed to exist.
Missy Larsson the video is titled "religion" and im an atheist, therefore i dont have any religious beliefs.
Missy Larsson exactly! Beliefs aren't always religious. Maybe it's your own moral code or ideas.
Ntinides The belief that gods do not exist and science is the only logical explanation for phenomena
"Is the Hijab a Symbol of oppression?" It depends entirely on where you live. Claiming that the Hijab isn't a method to oppress women in certain countries is not only incorrect, it's irresponsible.
Eva Kaye the question was if THEY view it as one not if other people do.
@@mmawithsubtitles7460 don't nuns wear hijab too are they oppressed
@@king-yp9wm Did you read my comment? And was your reply a question?
I think people should be able to wear what they want to wear.
If they want to wear a Hijab they should have the right to do so no matter our opinion on the matter. That is as long as THEY choose to do so.
PS: yes, nuns as well
@@mmawithsubtitles7460 sorry i meant to reply to eva
@@king-yp9wm don't worry about it
I love dirty data
@MaryTisdell You think these are real Muslims, lol you are disllusioned. These are Muslims that must follow American Law and Order not the Law of Islam, bring some real Muslims from one of those backward totallaterian states and you will see what a difference it is.
Ur comment has 51 likes and you're Alexander Hamilton
We are waiting in the wings for you.... (Get the reference?)
"i know you don't love me, but I love you"
"Thanks"
😂🤣😂🤣 you peeped that. His receives but his not giving any love back
I say say i Frankly, it seemed to me like the person saying “we love you” was giving a ridiculously rude and back-handed “compliment” trying to get a reaction out of that guy. In my opinion, good for him for being honest and then not engaging with the rude people.
@@snastehsketlen5852 how was that person being rude? They just wanted to let him know that they dont hate him even though he hated thwn. Idk but i dont think its rude
I am a Christian and here's my view: The numbers will represent the questions
1. Undecided
2. No
3. Yes
4. No
5. Undecided
@@callsignjoker2686 How so?
I'll take this chance two years later to update my position. I remain a Christian: Due to the yes/no format for answers I'll put any commentary in brackets in order to elaborate on my full position
1. No (Unless the Government or prominent cultural institutions forces you to)
2. Yes (If someone is trying to strip me of my right to hold those beliefs or is mistreating me because of those beliefs and killing is my only resort to stop that)
3. Yes
4. Undecided leaning yes (Define immoral; as a Christian, I believe it is immoral to reject God/Jesus and all humans have committed immoral activity. That said non-religious people can and often do, do a great amount of good in the world.)
5. Yes (I believe abortion for any reason at any point in pregnancy should be permitted but I believe the majority of reasons for getting an abortion aren't morally justified. The reason for this apparent contradiction is that I believe the instances where abortion is morally justified in effect require the full legalization of on-demand abortion).
This was nice. Maybe I'll see you in another 2 years lol.
0:22 this moment make me so emotional 😐
Main lessons of christianity (at least for me): be good to others; love the ones who hate you; if someone hurts you, give them your other cheek; even if you don't have much you can allways give something for those in need, etc.
-would you kill for your beliefs?
Chistian people: yes
😐😐😐😐 i mean, that's a mortal sin bruh
I think there should be more asking about people’s beliefs. I’d really like to hear the perspectives of the people who’d kill for their beliefs
0:22 so beautiful
Mad Crownner Ikr :)