Atheists, Christians, Jews, and Muslims on Rights | Dirty Data - Ep 6 | Cut
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 жов 2024
- Watch more Dirty Data: • Dirty Data | Cut
About Dirty Data:
We see political polls all the time, but do we ask how they come to represent the truth? We invite crowds of people to weigh in on politics, and see what a mess it is when they get counted.
One-click YT subscribe: bit.ly/CutSubs...
✨ Keep up with us! ✨
Official Site | cut.com
Instagram | cut.com/ig
TikTok | cut.com/tiktok
Facebook | cut.com/facebook
Twitter | / cut
Snapchat | @watchcut
About Cut:
Small questions have powerful effects when they go viral. Cut spreads stories for fun, for serious, and for real - bringing the internet together one awkward moment at a time.
Produced, directed, and edited by Cut.
Want to work with us? cut.com/jobs
Want to be in a video? cut.com/casting
Want to sponsor a video? cut.com/sponso...
About this video:
Atheists, Muslims, Christians, and Jews respond to Yes/No questions.
Atheists, Christians, Jews, and Muslims on Rights | Dirty Data - Ep 6 | Cut
• Atheists, Christians, ...
Cut
/ watchcut
I love how they just went and invented their own category of 'undecided'
The girl with the green shirt did
Sara Melle aka muslims women...
@@hani0910 Wtf just because they are muslim doesn't mean they are doing wrong things all the time 😑
Raima_ Is_Lovely bruh you guys get angry all the time lmao? She said the girl in the green, I told her that she is a Muslim, is something wrong bout it?!?
@@hani0910 no it's fine
I feel as if the answers would be more genuine if the people were questioned privately or wore masks so it was anonymous. Being in a large group of people can pressure people to conform to what the majority thinks in order to fit in even if they wholeheartedly disagree with it.
I think mask is a good idea
Malacki 655 that’s a pretty dumb thing to say . All the answers were very split and they explained the reasons clearly . There was nobody following anyone .
@@Jay-cy4js how is that a dumb thing to say? The first question alone would have caused people to hide their honest opinion if they were the only one standing in the opposite circle.
If I asked a group of people if they were racist, the ones who were would say no because of how they would be percieved by others.
Malacki 655 I agree
This is called Group Think,
An example is in the video, amazingly!
They Muslim girl stood in the middle, before then nobody thought it was and answered afterwards more people stood in the middle.
Jesse.S
I agree with you I think your example is a little weak
Not all Racist believe they are racist. Not all bigots are aware of their bigotry.
American Jews*
American christians*
American Muslims*
American atheist*
That changes a lot of things
CirrusRoD No it doesn't. What is affecting it is how religious these people are but that has nothing to do with were they live. There are more and less religious people everywhere.
Specifically Californian, which makes them more liberal than the average American.
Sebastian Mustermann If you were to do the same game in Pakistan or Egypt, do you think the results would be the same?
MrTwarner I believe this is in Seattle, but yes, still more liberal than the average American.
well those are the people that vote so...
Lesson learned:
Human beings are hypocrites
STOP SPREADING OPINIONS ABOIT LESSONS LEARN
True
Including you
@@nathgraza9408 actually this video show me really how people can be hypocrites. Especially those muslims who support the same sex marriage. They didn't bring muslims but rather a bunch of hypocrites people who pretend to be muslims. I really want it to see a muslims who follow really their faith over other people's opinions .
@@hornerfarah2282 I’d say it’s because they were being recorded or peer pressured. There’s a lot of people out there ready to dox someone because their religion doesn’t accustom to western culture.
Peer pressure definitely had an impact on this lol
Most definitely!
But doesn't it in real life tho?
@@calebwalton8408 that doesn't make it ok
Yes!!!!!
@@calebwalton8408 exactly. We may not see what they really think, but we see what they will say and how they will act.
Most of these people are lying. Would've been much more genuine with more anonymity.
I agree
AGREE
yeah i bet they would be more honest
PythonMan ah okay because you know exactly what they’re thinking so you know when they’re lying right?
Hark Movies I consult PythonMan whenever I need answers to the questions of the universe. He knows all.
I really admire that Muslim girl who stood in the middle. She knew her religion shouldn't get in the way of what legal rights other people have, but still accepts it is ok while still following her religion that says it's not.
I like that it sounds like she has put some thought into it.
Yes, as a muslim she deserved my choice too..
I am a person of faith but not muslim and I agree with that too. Since America has an amendment of freedom of religion the laws have to be unbiased and not based on religious views.
Hailie The pope is christian though
Hailie one pope supported facism.
According to all of their religions, they don’t know their beliefs
Except for the atheists, because we have no ridiculous rules. We just don’t believe in a god
@@specialgradetre sadly bro, I hope you come to the truth tho
@@AnonymousTaco3472 Hey man I'm christian too, but I dont think it's cool to do that, if he's content being an atheist let him be, he's doing you no harm
@@yuritardid7761 What did Jesus tell us to do. I love him, I want him to be saved, and overcome what I’ve overcome. The Bible says if I let some continue in there wrong doings their bloods on my hand, that’s why I warn and Jesus told us to go into the world proclaiming the Gospel of the kingdom. I’m not forcing him, I told him what Jesus has to offer, he never responded, I didn’t harass him. Brother, I’m serving Jesus. Why are you telling me not to. Anyone who has been set free how I’ve been set free will know why I love God, and want everyone else to Love him too. God bless you brother, I hope share the Gospel too.
@@AnonymousTaco3472 Yea I understand what you're trying to do man but as someone whose had points in my life where I was an agnostic/atheist I can tell you this approach doesn't work very well, they need to find love for God within themselves on their own rather than other people telling them, things like this can make them resent it. Anyways I hope you have a great day brother
You guys clearly dont know of the impact "follow the herd" mentality has. I wonder how the responses would have differed if this was done anonymously.
They'll still do the same cuz they are recorded and know what will happened on the interet
Yeah they shouldve turned off the lights every time theyre moving to their answer so they cant see the other's answers
Ramieverse ! Lol everyone would bump into each other and they wouldn’t know if they’re in the circle or not 😂
Even tho they are all wearing masks, don't know each other, and only represent themselves, there are still peer pressure there.
A religious group work that way. And if I'm not wrong democratic world also works that way. It's just human brain. Lol
LMAO this is the worst way of knowing of people think, its known in every scientific field if you ask them individually anonymously they will more likely be true to themselves
TheBlackIndy who cares ita not meant to be taken on as actually true in every way anyway.
yeh I mean its like 1.2 Million subs no way are they trying to prove they're own bias to the masses
TheBlackIndy yes maby but its not spose to scientifly prove anything. its just a bit of fun
lmao there is no fun, they just asked big questions to a bunch of religious people, who clearly take they're faith seriously. 2 circles to divide yes/no, its there to be provocative
TheBlackIndy yes but the poeple are not there to take part in a serious survay which will be used anywhere. they are there to see how they react to each queston
What a stupid way to test.
People will lie because they don't want to be treated badly.
Rrabbix I know right? People will go where most people would. It's in our nature to fit in.
ao true
Group think
Imagine that. Lying because you don’t want to be treated badly and yet being against gays and women.
True
Keep in mind this is filmed in California
@AWKSON Ignorant
@Sabir music is also only forbidden when it's bad music talking or singing about haram stuff, this mans insane
@AWKSON the prophet Muhammads wife khadijah was literally a business owner and he was a shephard, girls jobs and women leadership is not forbidden
@AWKSON I couldn’t imagine how dumb you could be..
@Sabir wow u are ignorant as fuck and u are allah is a dickhead if music is forbidden
Peer pressure 100%. This is incredibly flawed...
Imagine being the only one on the ‘no’ circle on the first question lol
@@frednelson4562 guarantee if you were to go to Pakistan, there would be people in the no circle. It’s based out of Seattle, two different worlds.
@@johnberlinski4015 yes im pakistan and i will chose NO
@@blacksheep6174 why
@@dalfokane Equal rights dont make sense men women are two diff genders two diff builts there is division of labour both think different made different . Humans rights must not ve violated . There are men rights and there are women rights . Both cannot be treatee equally cuz they are not same . There must be no descrimination tho
They literally pressured that guy into choosing their side, how is this showing us their real opinions when peer pressure is so evident in this experiment?
William Levy That's not at all what the experiment is about, Mr r/iamverysmart.
William Levy Never said you were :)
Sean Freeman I totally agree but one way to look at that is exactly how life works. People are sometimes peer pressured or heavily influenced by their peers opinions. Just think about all the jury interviews on countless cases. Jury often regret their decisions I’m sure.
But i also think that his answer on the question was more of a yes than a no the question wasn't specific and people were trying to tell him that. But peer pressure is definitely a thing here.
Cope
"Do you support same sex marriage?"
Muslims in the show: yes
Real Muslims: wait what?!?!?!
ahmed alsukaiti im muslin and i agree with yes
@@muffintime175 Are you sure you know Quran?
I'm really interested to know why you said yes so give me a better communication method like Instagram or Twitter so we can talk easier
@@ahmedalsukaiti3446 i really dont know much about the coran im 13 so thats why and im sry i dont have any other platform that i can talk on i know that its says in the coran that thats not alouwd but like the woman said i think its bad but not as bad as murder and those types of things i think its like not wearing a hijab its bad but you wont sit in hell forever Also sry if im this is just based on what i know of right now :)
ahmed alsukaiti thank you so much 😊 people like you make the world a better place and thanks for not going of on me
1st of all .you have to understand to what they mean as support.i support them as human and since their is no sharia law I can't do anything and in islam you are told to follow the laws of the place you are in unless it is targeting your religion or it clashes with your religion
"do you support same sex marriage"
LMAOO IM NOT EVEN IN THE GAME AND THE PEER PRESSURE I FELT WAS IMMACULATE HSHSHAFHDSJ
Yeah LMAO!
I was really nervous...
But, I'm really surprise about it!
Allah - there is no deity except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer of [all] existence. Neither drowsiness overtakes Him nor sleep. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. Who is it that can intercede with Him except by His permission? He knows what is [presently] before them and what will be after them, and they encompass not a thing of His knowledge except for what He wills. His Knowledge [throne] extends over the heavens and the earth, and their preservation tires Him not. And He is the Most High, the Most Quran 2. 255 please study Islam ,,,,,,
Straight NOO for me
If you're a devot muslim/christian/jew you physically cannot support same-sex marriage.
@@ratemate458 Yes it's against the Bible and Quran
They should’ve done more questions this was cool
There are more episodes.
Tasnim تسنيم I realized that after I posted it lmao
SO YOU LIKE BULLSHITT GAMES THIS IS AN 🇺🇸 ILLUSTION
LION MAN it’s not a bullshit game.. it gives insight on what the majority of different religious groups believe.. and it’s spelled illusion
@@michaelasuorsa pleas miss what insight are you talking about this was individual opinions okay they are free to have it ofcourse i dont mind but pleas dont tell me God says yes to same sex marriage no monotheistic religion accepts this rotten satanic lusty behavior pleas. Now days they use excuses oh it 21ch or dont be prejudice oh pleas this Generation is doomed with such kind of ideas thas why i say it a shitty game my religion Islam prohibites Same sex marriage regardless of their opinion have a nice day
This doesn't show you the perspective of those religions it just show you that every person has their own personal points of view regardless of their religion!
Abdulrhman Aljuhani That's the point of the video
This video hosts Muslims, Christians, Jews and atheist. It doesn't host the personification of these belief system. So yes, this videos shows the opinion of different followers of different relegions.
chemsou bouaziz no, it shows that really, opinion is based on the individual and is shaped by their values and experiences.
0:34 tells it all that this is fake.
How the hell majority can be feminists?
whole point of the video m8
This is not valid at all There was tremendous peer pressure in this and they had to confirm to what society thinks is the norm...ask them in a single blind questionnaire and the stats will be so different
sasuke3690 Exactly there are a couple confounding variables
Hence the name 'dirty data.' Anyone with a high school education can see that these results are heavily skewed (due to the small, localized sample group: totally throws the concept of SRS out the window) and don't hold any real information. However, the purpose of these videos is clearly to provide entertainment over all else, and perhaps to project the overall message of 'we're all not as different as we think we are' or something as equally kumbaya-y.
sasuke3690 Yup
I was thinking the same thing
Exactly
They went completely against what their religions say. Well done hypocrites
I’m a Christian and I approve what u said
They are hypocrites and they wanna act woke because of pressure lmao
Hypovrites? You worship an unproven, bigoted, murderous god and you call them hypocrites? You have a scholars arguing about which interpretations are the right ones and it’s all very uncertain, yet you think your subjective interpretation of your ancient book justo go is bigotry
@@memeuninstall4983 the problem is that they do not follow what their religions say even tho they believe in it that is by definition hypocrisy personally i am an atheist because religion is fucking bullshit
@@GA-od1fv frl
At the end of the day, it was still great to see nobody standing on the "no" side on women's rights.
Peer pressure
@@FirstnameLastname-pt5ss that's bs unless u think u would stand on that side
@LeviAckerman well, from what I know, us christians haven't been all about women rights for a long time either, but the time has changed and we have changed (a lot) and so as they will, soon... I mean, they better.
@LeviAckerman you don't seem ro know all that much about Islam aswell.
Mohammeds first wife, Chadidscha, ran her own business, long before marrying him, was a very successful and independent woman and she didn't profit from marriage with Mohammed in any way really. But he was, though her, able to get up in society, gain influence and at some point, she allowed him to be part of her business, but until her death, she was the one in control. Chadidscha is one of the central female figures in islam. Sure, for about 14 centuries, women in the muslim world suffered from huge injustice, but in its background, islam is much more pro equal rights than Christianity. Or jews, for that matter.
@LeviAckerman oh I'm no Muslim... I'm a Christian.
This seemed unfair. You're putting people in a vulnerable situation here and I'm sure most of them were lying about their answers because they don't want to be judged or mistreated by others because they have an opinion. I'm sure some of them were just going with the answers they think people want to hear. And it's sad that we can't have different opinions without being judged.
It's an absolutely useless video
Agree. Should be anonymous answers
I think these people were given a choice to be "put in" this experiment. There are a lot of familiar faces from other videos like this one as well. They knew there would be vulnerable topics
they also can selectively choose which people they want
When you think about it though, it may be the point of the experiment here. When confronted with reality, as in, standing next to people who you know may not agree with your views, you opt to choose what's best for the majority, in fear of backlash or cast out. However, when anonymity plays a role in your decision making, you are probably going to be more selfish in your choice.
Wait this is not buzzfeed
İdil Tanrıöver of course!
if this is buzzfeed , they will rig the whole survey
Catherine tt Nice comment there bud
İdil Tanrıöver the Muslims who “support” equal rights are no part of Islam aparently
İdil Tanrıöver
might as well be
İdil Tanrıöver nope... just more staged liberal bull shit
I honestly think many of the answers would be different if they were in smaller groups
@AWKSON ur mind and iq - low
@AWKSON
Literally nothing you said is forbidden in Islam.. And Stop lying and spreading hate..
Only birth control is forbidden, because its something inhuman, and killing your child just because you don't want it is a sin.. Because by doing this, youre ending a life.
@@ayhemshaban9745
No, brith control is not forbidden there is nothing in quran or hadith say it's haram
@AWKSON speedrunning argument simulator lmao
@Hamza Alkayyali bro what? The sahaba literally used to wrestle for sport. You don’t know Islam akhi, Quran doesn’t say to be disrespectful to gays. Just that we shouldn’t support it because Allah has forbid it and Allah guides who he wills.
They are so uncomfortable...
wish there were more questions
Shandog 2018 ofcourse...
because they are conflicted with their real opinion vs. what people will think of their opinion hence you dont see dark shits.... just pure political correctness
Shandog 2018 im glad that they are not arguing
It's because people are so divided nowadays that they have their own groups especially according to their beliefs, cultures, and other things so it's pretty obvious that they aren't comfortable in that situation while talking about rights smh
Peer pressure...
Norppa46 Kana exactly
Right
adr cue lol
SirReii these people probably don't know each other. They just don't want to be judged especially in such a judgmental city as Los Angeles. Any introvert or unconfident person would just go where the majority goes and the producers know this. If anyone in the crowd wasn't for equal rights and walked to the right they would be crucified so no one did it. It's their way of pushing an agenda and making it seem like "dirty data". If they did this anywhere outside of California they would not have gotten the same results. I will give the props though, it's very smart. Dishonest and dirty but smart.
Group mentality.
Can you guys do this again but maybe have everyone wear masks so that they might answer more honestly. Also more questions and more groups would be greatly appreciated.
This aged well
Mari M Was thinking the comment was published during corona time too
Oh they will..
They can edit the comment and try to trick us?
@@morshedahmed6064 I don't see "(edited)" next to his comment, are you new to UA-cam?
"Do you support gay marriage"
Some muslims: *Y E S*
me: *shooks in zemzem water*
I think if you are friends with a non muslim and they are doing it then you could support them as a person but if you are muslim and doing that YOU ARE MESSED UP
@Bassie B If u don’t like religion why bash it? Also search up inventions of muslims u will find better things. Also the first University was opened by a Muslim woman in Morocco.
@Bassie B I really don't wanna argue about this but in yeah lets go waste my life by representing my point of view on the internet I guess, someone else would have invented. It dosen't tehnically matter on a whole stand point of things, sure it would set humanity back in progress or hell maybe a person would have thought of a better idea for that spesific system, but it would have still goten invented. Humans have a thinking to make more things to make everyones lives even easier, or just their own but get soceity to progress anyway. Saying that the entire human race would have been stuck in the same age if it weren't for just one person existing is purely idiotic. That also stands on the muslim golden age part, somone else would have made something similar in a diffrent point of time, it might have worked in some sort of a easier or harder way, or had a diffrent desing but it would have served the same purpose.
@Bassie B awsome reply
@@alivingpun3121 You can accept a person but not support the community. It's still haram.
That one person decides to create a new category called undecided....and now everyone wants to join in
THE ANIMAL FARM
Some people are saying peer pressure wasn’t a factor and look what happened there lmao 100% peer pressure
lol
The girl who stood in the middle is so important. No ones religion can dictate someone elses lives
SwedishNerd and its a muslim ! Then they call us terroristd
SwedishNerd So true 👍
Yes.
SwedishNerd that’s not what she was trying to say
She said that she has to follow the law, thats all lol
As an atheist, I'm glad to see our group being represented.
Not in terms of capital punishment for me but otherwise yes. :)
yeah surprised me that so many chose yes on capital punishment.
I would only choose against capital punishment because death is too easy for some crimes.
I think there is an inherent thing about Americans and the media they create which always has a pro-capital punishment message. I think it's easy to say yes when you're given the mindset of "it only happens ever to the worst people who have done the worst things and it works"
As an agnostic.... hi
Most of the people in this video are too afraid to express their true opinion.
Yup mostly liberal
Lmao keep coping
That's a horrible way to test, conformity will pressure people to change their views to fit the group even though they may not truly believe it, this video is bad, biased, untrue and scripted, as well as not truly representative Of The people's typical religious beliefs
Eoghan Mc Mullan Agreed
Same
Eoghan Mc Mullan Thats we they called it as "Dirty Data" where the data is extremely inacurate. You can 'google' If you want the right and officially true data
100% true
It is practically impossible to get authentic answers from people when it comes to these kind of questions as the pressure of not fitting in with society is way to immense.
I love Cut. But I honestly don't believe that someone would take a stand on something so controversial - like saying publicly 'I don't think men and women deserve the same rights'. I admire the initiative and I love the video, but I don't think the results are trustworthy... An anonymous poll would give us more reliable results, in my opinion.
Edit: just realised, 5 months after making this comment, that this series is called "Dirty Data". Duh, myself.
I agree, but I think that's why it's called "Dirty Data" It's not as much about the statistics as the interaction and even the light amounts of discussion we see on these issues.
Julia Grosvenor True, Julia. And that's something nice about it, how the participants are nice to each other. No hate.
Actually an anonymous poll in addition to this would be the most interesting, since you could see the differences.
Chirepy yes!
Sophia Wapelhorst That's true, Sophia. And there's another point there: maybe one believes in equal rights for men and women, but does not consider oneself feminist - because of the stigma this word carries. I know many women who say that: "I'm all for girl power, men and women should have equal salaries in the same position, but I'm not a feminist and I don't like feminists"... when feminist is about those things.
They skipped abortion
Previous video.
They did ?
Another video !
Muslims and Jews during the first question: "Smile and wave boys, smile and wave..."
are you-
HEY! MUSLIMS AND JEWS GAVE THOSE RIGHTS FOR A VERY LONG TIME
Allah - there is no deity except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer of [all] existence. Neither drowsiness overtakes Him nor sleep. To Him belongs whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth. Who is it that can intercede with Him except by His permission? He knows what is [presently] before them and what will be after them, and they encompass not a thing of His knowledge except for what He wills. His Knowledge [throne] extends over the heavens and the earth, and their preservation tires Him not. And He is the Most High, the Most Quran 2. 255 please study Islam ,,,,,,
@@littlefab5389 No thanks I know Christianity is true
wut? jew here, our religon have much to offer for woman and directly points throw womans rights
howerver i wouldnt consider myself a feminist cuz modarn feminism is NOT for equle rights
That one muslim girl is so smart. I admire her for that.
Nickholai Echevarria i admire u because your ears are huge
+Any Body *awkward thumbs up*
Nickholai Echevarria my nickels pend back from 50teen years in china so whenever u go back to jail lemme no that ya mommie was there fightin back strangers ona railroad bus becaus srsly im so accurate an sh* omg i wood of just dieeeeed
+Any Body lol
Nickholai Echevarria you support equal rights but Dont support samesdx marriage? Thats rubbish
I thought it was a Harry Potter meetup of the different houses when I saw the thumbnail
Chealsiea Williams Lol gryffindor is orange
Preet Bhandal Gryffindor is red and gold.
I love the black Harry Potter house!
Yusuf Gazi their isn’t a black Harry Potter house😂
Chealsiea Williams
exactly
There are so many problems with the way they carry out such "presentation". They fail to take "peer pressure" into consideration. In addition to that, they should've define the question because there are participants who clearly do not understand the questions.
I agree. “Group Think” is a huge part of decision making. If you asked each one of these individuals privately, the outcomes for each question could (probably would) be massively different.
that's why it's called dirty data
It's just a fun video to watch its not intended to prove anything it's is simply for entertainment
That is the whole point of these videos. To point out peer pressure and how these few people do not represent everyone of the country or even the world.
For example what is feminism. It clearly doesn't mean believing in equal right of men and women, because that was already asked in the first question. So.. more rights for women than for men? Equal rights when is suits women and women privileges when it suits them?
nah, Muslims agreeing with same sex marriage?? Them man ain’t Muslim
Simple.
I think that capital punishment should be only for very serious crimes AND only if there is complete proof that they are guilty.
oreomonogatari Only war crimes
Trnava Mapper war or rape
Salvador Luna the word rape was not even in there
oreomonogatari o
i like the way my country handled capital punishment... by banning it in the middle ages and now capital punishment is viewed as an absurd statement since if we don't like murder than we shouldn't let the judicial system sometimes say that murder is ok. this kind of mindset also stops a lot of people of justifying to themselves that this or that person dying is justice since we didn't say killing is bad except when, we just say that killing is bad
You left out the ultimate moral question: does pineapple go on pizza?
*No*
Jimmy Martin these are truly the questions we should be asking ourselves
@Kawaii Potato PINEAPPLE AND PIZZA GO TOGETHER LIKE PUTTING HAND SANITIZER ON YOUR SALAD AND THEN EATING A CUM BURGER.
They also left out this question:
Is it a sin to drink orange juice after using the toothpaste?
*nope*
how the hell do you tame a horse in minecraft
😂😂😂
Jared K give it carrots
Jared K sit on it until it stops throwing you off
and shows hearts
OMG TO IS SERIOUSLY MADE MY DAY!!!
"I believe in capitol punishment sometimes". "then go to the yes circle". "I'm gonna go to the no circle". Huh?!?
Yeah 😂 bunch of hypocrites
they should have been blindfolded
apare677 then they would all crashed and die
+Any Body tr😮ue
honestly that's really THE only method of gaining no bias answers
Thank god there is no fight in here
LoL
Randian poor spotted
God is only one. But they called it differently
@@GuyScott1 because you dont know about islam.
@@KemoGames
Alright big boy.
Not to be a downer, but the first question was probably affected by peer pressure. If the same question was asked privately and anonymously there probably would have been some honest "no's".
Other questions were probably affected too, but not as much as one with a 100-0 split.
Carl Smith agreed
Definitely in the Islamic community
***** When did I ever claim the religion of Islam to be oppressive *though I do believe it is*. I claimed their culture and tradition as an Islamic COMMUNITY as oppressive.
***** Islamic communities as in Islamic states. There are no separate islamic communities in America, Canada, and UK. They represent their culture and their beliefs. That is what I am speaking of. Their culture as a society. The islamic states in the Middle East are what I am speaking about. You're speaking of the cultural groups within one's country. They usually do not represent their culture in their country if they're the minority. Hence the name, ISLAMIC state
***** And claim? I don't have to claim. What the hell was the Taliban? What the hell is ISIS? What is the whole fucking middle east? The Islamic culture shows it primal nature within modern ideas and beliefs, as it is seen within much of the Eastern world, India especially with their damn caste system. Oppressive nature is certainly prominent.
The amount of muslims in this video going against what theyre religion says makes me question if they understand islam.
Dude, even according to christians, women shouldn't have the same rights
we completely throughly understand islam just because some muslims accept same sex marriage because of their support for certain you are judging them as they have less knowledge of their religion . seriously
@@mojojojo8631 lol yes that’s exactly the case and you’ve proved my point 😂 I rest my case
@@mojojojo8631 If you support same sex marriage you can't call yourself a Christian, Muslim or Jew. You have call yourself a sinner.
That's it?
RyanHardt exactly my thoughts lol
I said the exact same thing when it ended lol
I said the same thing but I think there are more videos in the series
i literally said those words when it ended
i know right wish they had more questions liek on abortion, guns, islam, terrroists, migrants, and trump
Do you believe in equal rights:YES!
Are you a feminist: ....
Well feminism by definition is just the advocacy of women's rights and the belief that all sexes are equal
Private Snowball well shit. You got me
I would ask them to define feminist because it's really a vague term nowadays
I think the problem lies in how feminism has turned into simply an advertising gimmick, misandrist women use feminism as an excuse to treat men badly now. The word feminism has ended up being surrounded by all this negative energy and so nobody wants to associate themselves with this warped version of feminism
Feminism is about equal rights.
I like how these 4 separate religions could come to a safe environment together and share their thoughts without meeting any conflict. I though that was nice.
3 Religions and atheists. Atheism is not a religion.
+TheShadowOfMadness of course it is ^^
+Mr.Jasaw wtf no it isnt.
atheism is the lack of religion
but I totally agree. religion doesn't need to separate people. we all have more similarities than differences
do u think men and women deserve equal rights?: *everyone* YES
ru a feminist?: *some people who said yes to the 1st question* NO
Do u want water?: no, i want h2o
You said it girl!!
I was thinking the same...
You don't have to be feminist to believe that men and women deserve equal rights. What you implied is just a falacy. Feminism nowadays, unfortunatelly, turned to other agendas than just equal rights and we know that a lot of the feminists are intolerant and dumb people. Feminism stands for so many differents subjects that is almost impossible to agree with it. For that reason, not only the feminists can believe in equal rights to man and woman.
(By the way, sorry if something is mispelled, I'm learning english)
@@filipe.sm31 okay, feminism is abt equality but obviously its more concentrated on women liberation. women have been the oppressed ones since the beginning of humanity
@@luisaxbet and I agree with that, but there's a lot of other aspects of the feminism that I completelly disagree, so I'm not a feminist. But that doesn't mean that I'm against equal rights for men and women, like you implied in the first comment
@@luisaxbet
I support equal rights but not feminism.
Due to the very loud "feminists" that basically just scream at your face to join the cause. I know all feminists aren't like this but I'm just a bit tired of it.
And I do agree with most of your points.
don't judge a person by what group they're a part of. people need to realize everyone is different. so please judge them Individually.
Zech yes you shouldn't judge people on their religion but it's important to see how other religions view the world.
Ye right if a perosn is part of the kkk totally not judge them 😑😂 You are not the smartest i guess.
overlord haterqueen tera the kkk is not a religion though it is a hate group
Right, because every religuous inquisitions never happened as a result of religion ? Convenient? I studied history, and when religuous nut bags were being ingorant they were burning people at the stake, beheading and stoning them to death. Please feel free to announce your athiest views in the middle East and see how long you live. History doesn't change because you chose to ignore what these people stand for. By the very definition athiest aren't inhernetly on the same page as religuous doctrines. Unequivocally there's never been a terrorist organisation that's athiest or that's occured as a result of their views relating to atheism.
TheArtOfDragons 121
Like Islam is peacefully despite objectifying women ? Like how far right republican conservatives in the west borough Baptist church have had numerous affiliations and connections with the KKK, who also sympathise with christianity and neoNazi ideals? It's rich coming from inbread purists.
trump and hilary supporters next!!! now that'd be entertaining!
they already have one :)
littlemisscupcake really??? link?
Yeah,Democrats and Republicans
This test is flawed so the Killary supporters should feel right at home.
Cami marie Triggered(?), Sorry that you were offended enough to write such a long and indepth rebuttal. Hopefully you were close to a sanctioned safe zone when you were triggered. Did you get the complimentary hug, blankie, soother or did you just skip to the prozac filled sippy cup? It is you that needs to grow up cami not I..
These are very interesting but please make them longer
Im expecting them to fight brutally to death.
Moral. It's not the religion. It's the people's mindset.
no nigga u stupid
No nigga u stupid (2)
People will always find a way to argue, even without religion
Majidul - what did I tell then? Lol
01:13 observe and learn
WatchCut you guys need to make your videos longer, it used to be 10 min average now ehhh
nobody got time to watch a fucking 10 minute video wtf
aha a lot of people do, don't make assumptions just because you have a short attention span.
Many people do, that's why UA-cam is "secretly" promoting 10min> videos, more details on Google.
carlos Wudup i didn't even know when the video ended
Now they just need to stop makinh videos
I'm atheist, but I support people for what they believe in
nightcoreluver 346 thank you
nightcoreluver 346 there's god 0+0+0#1 so how this world came what is the purpose of life??? think
AlessiaCara Fans An atheist could apply the same logic to the origin of God so that's not a good argument
hammad lali
let us talk about that
everything in this universe has a beginning?
the big bang you may say but sceintists say the big bang is a reaction of something else
so that something is the main cause
but that something also needs a beginning
and we remain like that with no stop
untill we get to god
but then?
what created god?
and what created the creator of god?
these questions are flawed
and are flawed because of your understanding of god
which ends us with two possible explanations
1-it created itself
which is stupid how can something create itself
2-its eternal and is outside of the creation which includes time
back to what created god?
when you think of god what do you think?
jesus?
zeus?
an old man in the ssky?
or perhaps the greek gods?
all these do not fit our criteria
since all of them are eeither created and dependant(need food air and water to live)
or are inside the realm of creation
and then you have the quran
the quran is a book written by an illetarate man
who can neither write or read
1400 years ago
a man who has never written a single line of poetry in his life
and is called the truthful by his own enemies
and yet he created a book that no one was even close to being able to match its linguistic style
and the arabs were the best of poets at the time and they failed
and even with out current understanding and knowledge and technology
we still aren't able to even match a small part of it
its basicly perfect and inpossible to remake
and allegedly contains sceintific facts and miracles
so it has to be the word of this creator
Allah
which the name itself fits our criteria of creator
and he shows us that he fits this criteria in surah al ikhlas(surah 112)
say, "He is Allah, [who is] One,(1)
Allah, the Eternal Refuge.(2)
He neither begets nor is born,(3)
Nor is there to Him any equivalent."(4)
a perfect match
the me I get what you're saying but why couldn't the universe just be eternal like the God who didn't need to create himself
You cant say anything about the beliefs of atheists. Atheist simply means you do not believe in a God/are not religous. Such a person could have any kind of position concerning rights. Atheism is not a belief system like these other things, it is just a stance concerning one subject.
Yess
I don't think the opinions got decided by their religions but I think it's based on their own personalities, so don't include their religions
sherly M I believe that was one of the points the video was creating. we have beliefs, religious or not it may be, but opinions on matters can differ from the religion they practice.
There were ppl in the same religion but had different opinions, different choices, it means the religion didn't affect them much, it's still based on their personality
Whoaw
Why not? It'll make more views
sherly M exactly
People should learn about their religion before they label themselves .
Don't ask people but rather research each individual religion about those issues.
I found that video very misleading and inaccurate in my opinion
Mosab Alnaddaf that is what I have Ben thinking about
Mosab Alnaddaf yes i do agree... islam do not support the same sex marriage!
Mosab Alnaddaf yes true
when no one standed against same sex marriage from the muslims i dropped my jaw to the floor ...
plot twist: the yes and no circles are switched
Oof
suprised they said no for same sex marriage
atheists: N A N I ?
@@mistah.yaseen3667 christian count won't change XD
@@IronycheinPain dont know what u said but ok
If you're not a feminist you don't believe in equel rights smh
Women don't have to be femenists to believe in equal rights.
Another brainwashed moron. Modern day feminism is a cancer to society, and promotes the unfair treatment of men along with a plethora of degeneracy.
@@grimmylane7590 Feminism literally stands for equality of the sexes.
@@GpL_2000 Unfair treatment? What unfair treatment? Give me some examples.
So Jewish people are really accepting
Jews in the US always been super liberal.
Mike Hunt I know so many Jews that married non-Jews
Obviously you dont know that Koreans and Jews in US love each other for some reason. In California there are tons of Korean converts with half-Korean Jewish kids. I know its funny, but this is so true!
Not really...they only support the "same sex marriage". Apart from the same sex marriage, the Muslims seemed much more liberal. Actually there were more Muslims against the capital punishment ( there was literally 0 person in the circle) and 94% of them ( highest percentage) considered themselves as feminists.
keptins you know Schlafly used to be a feminist
It doesn't depend on the religion it depends on the person
Ali The Artist
Quite short, but very well said. Couldn't agree any more than this.
i agree
Yes but religion typically shapes the person you become when all you know your whole life is Christian or Muslim. especially if religion is pushed pretty hard on you as a child. that's why stereo types exist! But as you grow older, gain experiences and knowledge you start to develop your own opinions and the ones the open their eyes really wide, start to question their own religion and start looking at other people's point of views.
I feel that it depends on the person.since his/her decision is dependent upon the culture they were raised in.
Ali The Artist Well, and their upbringing.
I dream of a day where same sex marriage and womens rights dont have to be debated.
Same.. Hopefully that day comes soon
@10 LMS The day same sex marriage and womens rights are "cut in America" is the day that the people begin to overthrow it. Those are obvious steps backwards in society. Don't rule modern america with a bronze age fist.
I wish these videos were longer, I just finished microwaving my popcorn.
That hijabi girl is awesome... The way she talks is so mature
Edit: the amount of hate towards Islam breaks my heart
She should just say no
1:10 was my favourite part.
Maturity she has but her facts are where she is wronged
Cringe
@Vasilijan Nikolovskirespect others' religion
IN THE COMMENT SECTION
80%- oooooh stop the fight over religion we are the saaaaaaame!#?!
10%- this video isnt accurate
9%- other comments about the video
1%- fight over religion
EDIT: this is the most amount of likes I ever got.
Lmao I am arminian too
I like religious flame wars.
Hoi19448239345 why so rude?
Gayane Hasratyan *armenian
Hoi19448239345 wait what? Could you explain what you are talking about?
Christians, Jews, and Muslims, not being Christians, Jews, and Muslims.
I like how the athiests are wearing black
Bruh I see you everywhere
Cause black is cool
And we're cool
@@superdolphin440 ifkr
@@superdolphin440 edgy much
@@undergroundrapfan9018 no. It's just a nice colour. Black doesn't equal edgy.
After seeing both videos, muslims seem to understand more about human and women's rights than the others.
Huyen Nguyen muslim from the west and middle east are different.
john nguyen nope. people are different in general. no matter where they're from.
Huyen Nguyen yes, people r different but not to a religious country as the government law is beneath religious law. compare that to muslim from West vs M.East.
They are not Muslims.
YouB Hb, Why that's ignorant.
I love how none of my atheist fam went into the no circle when asked about same-sex marriage
was disappointed when 56% of the atheists went into the yes circle when asked about capital punishment
Liam Burr-Knight capital punishment is ok lol you play in the mud you get dirty
@@alanacaldwell07 it isnt okay because it puts you on the same level as a murderer. at the end of the day, do you worship a killer so much you want to emulate their actions? i know i dont.
Liam Burr-Knight no they took someone’s life so they deserve what they get
@@alanacaldwell07 i understand why you think that killing a murderer is okay, but to me, that means stooping to their level. they do deserve death, but i refuse to be the one to be responsible for ending their life.
are we gonna ignore how freakin GORGEOUS the girl at 1:01 is
Eh, definitely not my type.
The God Of Nothing um okay
Yea she is beautiful!
The God Of Nothing stfu
@@nellybegic2292 Uhh, I just shared my opinion. Are you really hurt? And, if you were, don't be that big of a simp.
They should give everyone an iPad or any device in a room alone and each will vote for yes without seeing others answers so they don't follow or Effect others. Like 1:33
affect*
yes ye
Lol ,this is not how it works.
Jabrane Amami holy shit I stared at this comment for a long ass time trying to remember when I wrote it until realizing this is youtube and not instagram where we have the same profile pic 😂. My ig is @metal_guitar_covers if you wanna check me out! I have a few Wintersun covers
You're a very special type of idiot m8
Do you seriously think i would actually want anyone to die ?
Its a joke.
Kaaz suicide isn't a joke m8
actually, it is.
Kaaz no it is not.
It kinda hurts me seeing how people say religions about love but hate me and dont support me because of who i LOVE
Demelza Konoplyanka uh a bunch of people literally just said I shouldn’t have the right to get married. I think that’s a cause for concern.
Demelza Konoplyanka I mean of course they’re allowed to have their beliefs. But you’d be surprised at how many people believe those things and because of that, are extremely hateful towards the LGBT community. A lot of Christians tell me that I shouldn’t be allowed to marry who I want, which is why I don’t really view having those beliefs and disrespecting the LGBT community as different things. Of course, they are separate things, but they often go hand in hand.
God create female and male to married ,so earth can be filled with God creatures, that's for our good
Demelza Konoplyanka WHO cares about there brainwashed beliegs
Demelza Konoplyanka they disagree with what?? Some ppl are attracted to the same sex, and they can’t change that. That’s like saying “I disagree with black ppl due to my religion but I’m not racist” like tf
majority of muslims accept same sex marriages? now that's a bullsh!t
I love how Atheist are more Open minded when it come to Same sex marriage, everyone went YES
Update: thanks for the likes
Just because they all say yes doesnt mean they are all open minded, it probably mean the opposite
You cant judge people from outside lmao
definitely does not mean that they're all open minded
Robert Lienthang They probably only think that because they don’t think that god exists therefore they don’t have a reason i guess to think it is wrong. But for the religious people in most religions we believe that marriage was defined by god as a man and a women and so altering the rules is extremely wrong and something know one should ever do.
Also that does not indicate open mindedness and if i had to guess, a lot of them didn’t have to think twice about saying yea to this question because it would make them look like better people and it would make the lgbtq community join their side.
"Do you support same sex marriage?" 100%of athiests said yes.
I like that
Of course, they're Atheists, they have no morals except morals of Christianity with a twist
@@subifyouhatetiktokandreddit234 🤦🏻♀️u crazy homophobic
@@bratz1679 suprised at how many are homophobes commenting on this video...
@@eevee1791 me too
Love that all Atheists 100% supported same sex marriage,makes my gay self happy 😊
K
Yess,cause we know it doesn’t make sense not to let people love each other
I’m a bisexual atheist and I’m happy that all the atheists supported same sex marriage. Love is love! 🏳️🌈
@@partiallytoovegan4755 aren't vegans supposed to be liberal?
@@partiallytoovegan4755 some people are atheists for a reason. You can't tell her what is right and what is not. She can love anyone she wants.
... I'm sorry to break it out, I don't think every question has been truly measured
I am a muslim and i am dissapointed with their answers
What's wrong
@LegendaryScar 14 stfu
Yeah and Muslims believe in capital punishment
@@AthosRespecter what he said was true tho
@@TheAlmightyGream some do
They need to do it again but take away the peer pressure factor
Many of them might be actors or are subject to echopraxia, this is not an accurate test, the sample size is also not large enough and is not representative of the proportion of people depending on context. Take this information lightly for it is not exactly accurate.
YZ M Nobody claimed it was a study.
That's how it's like in the real world. The people around you influence your views.
Exactly why it's called dirty data
So then don’t believe it, believe whatever you want. Up to you.
All of the atheists saying yes to same sex marriage, says a lot about morality and it destroys the claim that you can't be moral if you are not religious
The problem with this video is that now people are going to automatically assume that’s what everyone in that particular religion is like. Which is false because everyone is different and has different beliefs. That’s really sad that this channel feels like it has to post about someone religion and beliefs to get veiws.
It's inconclusive. Only concerning the equal rights question were people of same belief on one side. The rest of the time people of the same religion weren't uniform in their opinions so no can assume, for example, all muslims are against gay marriage.
Avery gomric only if they are stupid. They are only representing their opinions as individuals
+Jeovana Nascimento but what is the point in exploiting what people's beliefs? What is the point in racially dividing people and making them answer controversial questions about their beliefs. It doesn't educate me on a specific race because I know that not everyone believes the same thing even if they share a religion. I think the video is pointless and quite sad because they have made many videos like this and it's most likely for views. I like this channel but this specific type of video is so far from what people should be consuming their time on.
Avery gomric that's because you are thinking of them 4 groups of people instead of singular individuals. Not every atheist have the same opinion about every subject . And the same goes to the other groups. I guess the point is, not putting people in a box and expect everyone to fit into the labels that I unconsciously placed on them. That's what I got from it anyway. If you get diverse answers in small groups there is a POSSIBILITY that the same COULD happen in a bigger one.
Avery gomric I do understand what you are saying. But here is the thing. Race doesn't mean anything in terms of believe. Culture? yeah sure there is a certain influence and not always as big as some people believe. But the understanding that you are looking for only comes from having conversations with the people who are a part of that culture. And sorry if I made any grammar mistakes English is not my first language.
More more..........
Theres more on facebook...
There is?? Where?
In their official facebook page
Soviet Union yes
Soviet Union isn't your profile pic from hearts of iron 3
● Small sample size.
● Herd behaviour because everyone can see what their owne and the other group does.
● ( Feel free to and if I forgot something )
Sqocks some questions were asked very wildly. They didn't asked a lot controversially questions that people mostly argue about ( abortion etc)
This was obviously a setup
Sqocks people obviously never got to know 3rd wave campus feminism
Sqocks Muslims also don't know that in Koran there's written that women have to do what the men say
This is all total FUCKING BULLSHIT!
I want you guys to do this again I love how it was quick and there was no arguments 😊❤️
0% of western muslims supported capital punishment, but if it was done in maybe Saudi Arabia, the numbers would of been different. This just shows that peoples way of thinking aren't fully influenced by their religion but by their culture and upbringing
Some these Muslim women don't even wear hijabs. Don't know if they just identify as Muslim or actually practice it.
Hype Spade Ummmm you do understand that Saudi doesn't practice Sharia/Islamic law correctly right? It's annoying when people judge religion by the way dictators or governments run..they run things to suit their interests not to practice religion correctly
Zaha S Why did you say Sharia/ Islamic law like there the same thing when there not. And if you read my post all i said was the numbers would be different
Ones man made and the other was stated by the prophet and in a religious book. Sharia has over 6000 laws while in islam there were only a few dozen laws that were stated, and it may be called "Islamic Law" but its really not. Thats why in their courts they dont open up the Quran, they use their sharia law because its two different things.
Lol there is no country on earth that currently practices Islamic law as the Quran/Hadith states...And for starters,
a monarchy is in no way an Islamic concept..I believe you're the one that needs educating..
When they ask the same question twice and you get different answers...
Haha No i was thinking the same thing smh
Feminism =/= equal rights.
mate spark
Feminism = Equal rights for both genders
mate spark feminism is more than that now....
Isabel Garcia Feminists = Do not support equal rights.
But also there are probably elements of group think and conformity....
This little survey is probably not as valid as it may appear
Joshua Ogunlolu not to mention sample size
Joshua Ogunlolu True but the idea I think is to break some pre existing stigmas
It's not so much a study and concrete data as "here is a handful of people this is more or less what they believe"
The series is called "Dirty Data"
Joshua Ogunlolu As a Muslim, it's not accurate at all.
Equal rights no matter the gender - yes
Feminism - no
? 😂 it is literally the same
Yeah. I was just laughing the whole time over this
Well I wouldn’t call myself a feminist because I don’t a vague understanding of feminism maybe one day I’ll read a lot more about it and decide but I do believe in equal rights, hopefully I made this clear 😂
I do think men and women should have equal rights, but feminism has gone way to far and everything it has been advocating for lately is women's rights above men's and that ain't it for me. I'm not interested in abolish the patriarchy or having abortion legal and so I don't identify myself as part of that movement, and hating all white men isn't very worth-following I'd say, they're still people ya know.
Yet I will always support equal rights for every human, being that a baby in the womb, a white man or a black woman, we are all the same and should be treated with respect.
@@monicaambrosio2938 sorry, you're not interested in abolishing the system of power imbalances that lead to women's rights being trampled upon, but you support women's rights? Pick a lane, Mònica.
@@monicaambrosio2938 You're not interested in abolishing the patriarchy but you support equal rights? The patriarchy harms both men and women. You don't make much sense.
Wait, is that it? I thought it's gonna be 5-8min long
Theres more videos on them
not just that, alot of parts were missing
so if one of those people commits something bad, the whole religion is guilty? because it's not about the religion in this video it's about the single peoples point of view smh
Selin - very well said. I agree.
Selin - finally someone on planet earth is not brain dead
Selin - I agree
religions like islam has moderate believers but the religion isn't so face the fact that some religions make a bad affect on its believers
these people say that you're not braindead but that statement makes no absoluye sense and application in our society
"Do you deserve everyone should have equal rights?"-All goes in
Me:Heck yeah
"Are you a feminist?"-Alot said yes
Me:What the fuck happened to equal rights?
Illusive Ashby exactly XD
Illusive Ashby feminism and equality arent the same now, the question shouldve been "are you an egalitarian" Which is a damn shame too
The concept of equal rights is not copyrighted by feminism.
Illusive Ashby Women have more rights than men and feminism is about wanting women to be all-powerful. Get the fuck over yourself.
SebaSWBRL and that's against equal rights, equal rights is making both genders equal, the rights of both genders are necessary. Feminism is making girls or women have more power than men which IS NOT equal rights
1:04 no your religion does dictate what the law says. It is a complete code of life and it forbids same sex marriage. End of story.
Sounds like an awful way to live.
An eye for an eye leaves everybody blind.
- Mahatma Gandhi
don't you have 2 eyes?
In Islam there’s no such thing as an eye for an eye if that girl read the Quran she would know. So many verses in the Quran that tell Muslims to show mercy. An eye for an eye is only the last resort. God give us the right to defend and seek retribution for a wrong but there’s always a verse after that emphasise mercy is better.
Gandhi was not a muslim.
An eye for an eye leaves everybody blind tells that it's bad to think so.
That's great and all that you have a little quote you can run around with in your drum circle but it has no value and means nothing for real life policy. It doesn't make any real point
yeah show them mercy if they surrender, but if they dont, kill them, kill their children, kill their wives, kill their cattle.