Though I agree to sadhguru's teachings a lot, would not consider his argument valid here. If we stop consuming milk collectively, there would be decline in further forceful impregnantion of cows and lesser calves. Male calves are a burden to this industry and are slaughtered. In fact all industries be it poultry,milk ,honey all have a dark side where the poor animal are exploited. Even for our vegan sources, trees are cut to use for farm land. Some people may have a problem with that too. It all depends where we stop our moral compass.
I understand your concern, you are a nice people to think like that but the world don't work according to vegan people. God created all creatures to help mutually, not to torture I agree. If you take the argument of vegan people then why God kept the humans and other creatures in the same planet. Cows are very important for our human society. When you come to rural area., You will feel the importance of cow . When rain is not happening somewhere in rural area, no agriculture is possible, then cow only save us. And for the problem with male calves, there are some initiatives that has been taken. To make the use of bull power to make electricity, water pumping by running them in trademeal, and many things people started doing. I know it just started, in many areas it is not there , but I hope in most areas, Goshalas and this kind of intiatives will definitely help. And this is a green and sustainable solutions. Even if they don't give milk, they are stil valuable, no need to kill them, we have to find some ideas so that we can make work out of them in a more ethical way. They give organic fertilizer, which is the main backbone of organic farming, you can not get any microbial activity in other chemical fertilizer. Many benifits are there. We have to support those people who are doing this and taking this initiative by means of financial aspect or if you have any other idea. I believe it will definitely succeed one day.
You are fool, we don't milk chicken, is there any decline in population of chicken, in Europe cows are raised only for meat sometimes, even if you don't milk cows they will be slaughtered like goat and hen, So it is better to utilize cows to give them long life and many a times they die natural death
@@subhajitmondal1391 The problem is not this. The problem is you are giving money to dairies who are making cattle a milk machine.. I'm just saying buying milk form ruler areas or from local milkman is right rather than from national dairy companies...
As a spiritual leader he should care for animals too not just humans beings. He should let people know how cruel Dairy industry is and that no one has right to harm/ torture another being. Being VEGAN in today’s world is spiritually 🙏🏼💚
What an illogical explanation by Sadguru. This is not by chance that India is among no. One in both Milk consumption and beef exporting. Milk producing cows and buffaloes are being breeded and reproduced in such large number to meet the demand of dairy industry. After they are not useful, they are either left on roads or sent to slaughter house. If milk n milk products would not be in such demand by a large population, they will be present around us only in that number, which nature wants them to be. Sadguru should reflect what mean practices are being used in breeding cows and buffaloes and what happens to them when they are not useful. Who wants to keep the male calves and non milking old cows/buffaloes. No one or very very few ones. All send them to slaughter houses to reduce their costs and to make extra money from them. In modern time Milk consumption is essentially related to animal cruelty. We want to consume milk and their products in large quantities. So we produce those animals by injecting semen in female cows/ buffaloes, producing more offspring. The male offspring sent to slaughter house or on roads and females ones are kept till they can provide babies and milk. After that, even those females cows/ buffaloes, our Gau Mata are sold to slaughter house. That is why we have topped in Beef export. This is whole bullshit game of demand and supply.
You are so right. People should watch the video Dairy is Scary. The dairy industry is a machine that chews up cows and spits out their dead bodies without care or concern. The dairy industry has people fooled into believing this is a natural process. Yet everything about it is cruel. They take the baby cow from the mother immediately after birth. In nature a cow will stand up to wolves to protect their baby yet the dairy industry tells us it does not bother the mother. And the mothers cry for their babies for weeks calling and calling and calling. This is because they dont want the baby cow having the mothers milk they have to take it for people. They also milk the cow to the brink of death. The moment the cow is not profitable they either get thrown to the street and more often taken to be killed. This is brutal. This is a thousand times worse than sending a child to school to get an education. I am not sure if i can respect this many any more after such an incredibly unenlightened response. Also milk, cheese are horrible for the human body. It is full of estrogen and many other hormones present in the female cow after she gave birth. It is full of saturated fat which clogs arteries. destroys bone health, causes prostate cancer in men and breast cancer in women. A gallon of milk generally takes 1000 gallons of water to produce. Two cups of milk uses more water than I drink in a year. Guru just does not want to change or enlighten anyone on this subject because he fears he will lose followers.
Yes, we need to stop using animals for our gain. Stop using buffalos in fields, donkeys to carry burden, horses and camels to carry us, dogs to protect us.
@@The_capable_man People won't change overnight. As more and more people will go vegan, less and less cows will be bred into existence. And one day we will stop this cruelty. Be moral, be vegan 🌱
So glad I saw the video. I had so much respect and it's destroyed in seconds. Blind people laughing at anything he says. Have people really lost their brains and became part of a cult? Absolute aweful thought.
I can't believe some enlightened person is not talking about karma n suffering here, what karma /action we do with others we get it back equally. So be ready to live a life of cow if you are in favour of drinking milk , milk products, leather , honey, cosmetics that comes by torchering animal. Spirituality means we all are spirit, animals also have the soul n emotions , cows cry when they loose their babies , but who cares...we are feeling proud to give them a life , it doesn't matter if it is hell for them
In another video , Sadhguru said - after 2 years of age, nobody should be drinking cow's milk. Cows should never be used for meat, that I totally agree. Even buffaloes. Today they are talking lab grown meat - if you must eat, why not eat that ?
I really wonder why Sadhguru said this. I’ve been listening to him for years and have found some clarity by a lot of things he’s said. But this is one thing he’s said that I truly disagree with based on what I have learned about the dairy industry. I have learned that the use of animals for food sources is completely wrong in our time. It is completely cruel and completely unnecessary. Not just meat, but dairy, eggs and honey have cruelty involved. The way dairy is produced is by selectively breeding cows to produce an unnatural amount of milk which causes harm to their bodies. Furthermore they only produce it after they’ve been inseminated by a human who impregnates them forcefully with a bulls semen-you see how this sounds? There are alternatives to dairy. Many plant based milk sources are there. And if we stop using dairy- the cows need not be slaughtered because we are not using them. If we all stop using the cows for dairy, we can let them live out their lives to old age and their numbers will gradually decline. What’s the problem with that? They are only being bred because humans are calling for more supply of the products which they exploit them for. And finally, if we wanted to expand our sense of inclusion for these animals then we could use our resources which we are using anyway to give this (what could be) last generation of these exploited animals a beautiful life on a sanctuary, living better than they would if they were to be sent to slaughter and/or milked or otherwise exploited for the things we take from them to eat. I actually quite detest what Sadhguru has said here and has me questioning him a lot more than I ever have.
In what kind of utopia are u referring to? Get back on planet earth... Sadhguru explained it well enough, if u cannot understand what he said that means u don't accept the reality of planet earth. That kind of animals cannot survive out in the wild alone, they will get slaughtered either by predator animals or by humans. Also there's no logic behind keeping a cow as a pet feeding it for no reason.
@@jim.carras I’m really not sure why you’re saying what you are… the reality of planet earth as it is now is that humans are destroying it. And by raising an incredible number of creatures just to be killed for our consumption is one of the most damaging things to planet earth. That’s the reality of planet earth. And furthermore, the solution in my view is to stop breeding these animals which, if you could understand, would not exist if not for selective breeding by humans. They would slowly dwindle in numbers. We need not slaughter them. Giving them a nice quality of life and then letting them die of natural causes would be most ideal. Humans can live on a vegan diet. And a vegan diet is most sensible for humans and planet earth.
This is why you should not attach your identity with a human being “guru” rather with truth and truth only. This man has audacity to deny a thousand million industry that runs in torture and misery of innocent animals which is so evident. I hope the people who are brainwashed by him realise this soon.
@@Inertsky What do you mean by grow up and know about nature. I don't understand. I do not find his arguments clear and logical on this issue. That's it. I am not saying anything about his other insights, his contribution. Definitely, he is a very active charismatic personality. I also like to hear him on many other topics.
@@nirajkumarbharat bcz he stated the facts but ur saying he's ignorant,,,it is not his job to please others, he is here to answer ur questions now u may not like it from the heart but reality wouldn't change,,,not just him, those who have cows in their homes will also find it stupid if someone says milking from a cow is an animal cruelty
@@Inertsky Of course it sounds stupid, if we are considering only people having cows in their house in an ideal condition, where cows are the backbone of their family livelihood and culture. But I am putting my arguments here considering cows and buffaloes from full grown dairy industries. Plz try to get some information on that. Are same milking methods, cultural ethics are followed there also? And it's a big industry. Plz help me in understanding why India tops in both Milk producing country and beef exporting country. Plz 🙏 help me in understanding this relationship rest I will understand by itself
@@t.a6159 well looks like someone skipped biology class. Hate to break it to you but plants don’t have a central nervous system therefore cannot feel pain. Sad you compare plants to a living breathing animal that holds blood.
Sometimes if you are unsure what to say, you should not answer the question because you don't have adequate knowledge. Maybe you have some knowledge but unless you have complete knowledge you should keep quiet.
Many people talk about how cruel things are and do nothing but talk. There is a man who quietly grew a huge forest, the elephants and other animals even came back. He didn’t talk, just did and people noticed. It would be nice if those concerned about milking of cows would get all the money together and build sanctuaries, not talk about it
I have to somewhat agree with sadhguru in this one because completly stop drinking milk then who will feed them or even bother to spend money. Just completely stop drinking the milk is not realistic in todays society. There should be some regulation on dairy the way they treat animal atleast if it giving us milk it should be treated with that level of respect and care.
Yeah yeah we can't just stop spending money on your mther. we should think a way to slowly reduce harvesting and consuming milk from your mther. Just kidding
It is not just possible but EASY today. You have a lot of good alternatives. Also, if you don’t support the industry, they will breed less suffering cows into existence.
cows are tortured for 5 years because they have a reproduction system and some adults still want to ween off of an animal, they stop weening off milk from their mothers and start weening from cows. Cows are impregnated for 4-6 years EVERY SINGLE YEAR they go through pregnancy which takes a toll on their mental and physical health in most cases their calves are taken away from them, male calves are sent to slaughter houses since no one really plow their fields with bulls/ox any more or VERY rarely, and female calves are given milk barely just to survive, and when they turn 1 year they go through this continuous cycle of pregnancy, and the process is pretty painful too, and after they turn 5 years and their physical body start to decline they are either smuggled to states where cows are legal to slaughter and then sold off as buffalo meat which is legal to slaughter in every single state, or they are left on streets to die or they hundred and hundreds of cows are kept in a closed space to starve to death and their bodies are thrown into the water bodies, milk industry is pretty brutal also, he gave an illogical reason of school being a cruel place and if someone doesn't go to school they will end up killing people or go on wrong path, or end up in poverty. first off, school is not a cruel place the atmosphere depends on teachers, peers and study load in schools there are a lot of toxic teachers bully peers and unrealistic amount of syllabus but that's just a flaw in Indian education system. but school is never meant to be a cruel place, its a place to enrich your brain and get knowledge. secondly, it DOESN'T mean that if someone doesn't go to school they will be bad people or something, not going school and having bad morals have nothing to do with each other, your morals will not go away if you don't go to school you can be a kind, compassionate and street smart person without going to school you just won't have professional knowledge, and not going to school and being poor is also not quite accurate, there is a correlational relationship between these two factors, but correlation doesn't equal causation.
At first I thought to be utter nonsense. But when I listened carefully again. I understood he is just saying that if we lose a job or don't work we get depressed fat unhealthy same way. If bulls same as man and cows as women don't work then they die soon. Secondly if if we leave them alone the reality is they go to slaughter house this is really true, he wants to give life not take it away. We don't use our money on something which is unselfish which has no use for us this is also so true. If we become like this it's not enough another person will take advantage of it. He also mentions we should not drink any animal milk even cows milk. Also this is not the full video like half knowledge is dangerous. Full video is beutiful and he is just trying to make people be less serious and laugh.
You have a point but if there's no demand of milk, there will be demand of meat so the animals will be slaughtered. For veganism to succeed, both milk and meat consumption has be stopped simultaneously.
Jai Jinendra, It’s an absolute blessing to see so many compassionate beings in these comments. Many vegan blessings to all participating in freedom and equality for all regardless the body they are in. Continue practicing ahimsa and we will soon see Earth transform to its natural blissful state. Jai Jinendra 🙏🧘♀️🙏
Why cant we leave them alone like a street dog they will eat grass and left over Vegetable. Why can't every home make at least 2 rotis extra for street cows, this way they will live their whole life with freedom, and govt should ban slaughtering of cows.
Dogs are carnivore, he said they ate human children's. And he is supporting cows by making them willingly work no injections or bad treatment. If cows are left alone people take them to slaughter house he is saving them read ankur's reply really good.
@@Flower_girl-x6o Do you not know cows are raped and impregnated in order to give birth to a calf so they can produce milk? Do you not know male calves are sent to the slaughterhouses? Do you not know that old cows, and many bullocks are sent to slaughterhouses? Do you not know that India is #2nd largest beef exporter in the whole world? Do you live so much in ignorance?
Just leave them alone. Why rape the cows, why take the male cows away from the mother cow after birth? Why breed them? All because of human greed ms. Why Gurus like you advertise dairy knowing the cruelty in todays world😢
@@UmeshKumar-qt4cm not I am not defending my guru Pls you do research on this topic because you don't know the actual condition. I am farmer son, so I don't need to do research.
my one comment got deleted here, sadguru... milk n milk product companies torturing, exploiting cows very cruelly for their benefit... how things should go for this issue? kindly lighten up...
It means used these poor animals , harass them all their life on the name of these useless logic n at last leave them to slaughter, if any human will be given a choice 1. Live a hell life and at the end we will send you in a slaughter house 2. No harresment at all, n leave them for their destiny that will be decided by nature. We will choose 2nd , then why for our benefit we are saying option 1 is right. Cows are raped 4-5 times, if you will see you could never take a sip of milk, , their baby is taken away in front of them , they have no freedom, all their life they will be tied with a small rope, at the end when there is no use left they are send for slaughter, in slaughter house they don't slaughter directly, they take their skin out when they are still alive, and we say them mother, will be do this with our mother? But human is so selfish, he can't leave his greed n craving for milk so he feels he I helping cow to alive while he is using her like hell. Sad Guru is not against cruality, he himself takes milk which comes from tears of cows, he suggests honey which is life time saving of a bee for her survival, he does not know the law of karma yet, nature's law is simple what you will do , you will get the return exactly same , all this depression , sadness n restless is coming because the emotion of cow while giving milk is adding it, from the day I know this I left all milk products n honey n any food coming by torching animals n I felt joy, calmness n peace. If someone will do cruality with us , we will believe that with the law of karma, one day that person will be get the equal pain so why we are so foolish to understand that if we are doing this cruality directly or indirectly with any animal or human, we won't get the equal pain in future
No. If we do not consume them, then the problem will be solved. Along with the ill effects and diseases from its consumption. Milk is made specifically for the baby of the species.
Flaws as in...? I get your point though. Sadhguru seems to think there are two options only...? There could be MANY options but MAYBE at the end, this might end up happening. We can see everything immediately right? Sadhguru has much more experience and his wisdom, as you said, i believe in it too.
Why flaws? he is just making a practical, objective statement. There are cows in his ashram. If he releases them tomorrow, someone will catch them and eat them up. This is true not only there, but everywhere. So where is the flaw?
Why not ? Are a Prude or what? Breeding is essential even the cows would say this if they could talk! You want them to go extinct or do you want them to roam without purpose like wild animals or want to pet them without being productive! This is not love this is lethargy! The must have a purpose to live and survive
In one of Sadhguru's Save Soil video(ua-cam.com/video/WQp8ikLx3Vc/v-deo.html), he has mentioned that about 77% of world's agricultural land is utilized for raising cattles & their feeds and to change the situation meat consumption has to be reduced. That's right...But actually Dairy industry is creating these animals for dairy products...So which should be addressed first, Dairy industry or Meat industry ? ..I don't understand , why he is saying dairy consumption is fine and not cruel.....If I'm wrong please correct me 🙏
His argument is Illogical. Animals may be any like cow, dog ,elephant etc. are to live freely in jungle and not meant for human pleasure or satisfy his taste bud.
Putting aside whether this scientifically makes sense. May be it is. But sometimes he does talk in a tone that resembles some elders in my family that I genuinely despise. Experience gives you the right to enlighten people not condescend them, deride or any other smug emotion. A whole generation looks up to Sadhguru for enlightenment. I'm 100% true his Guru Rishi Prabhakhar whom he never really acknowledged as a Guru would have condescended him. That is why he is an enlightened human being today. I have nothing against him based on how far my knowledge about him goes, but he can get a bit carried away at time :)
He is human not god ,i am a vegan and i also not complete agreed on he said but i get what his intention was ,maybe one day if i met him i will ask the right questions about milk .
If other wild animals can live freely then why not cows and buffaloes? Who made them pet? If humans stop petting them, their population will be less. Drinking milk for saving from slaughter is not a logical answer. It is like doing one small sin behind the bigger sin. Whether you drink milk or slaughter them, both are cruel. Every creature is born to live naturally. I don't agree with Sadhguru here. I know why he is giving such arguments, because he is running gaushala. 😂😂
Do you eat grain or legumes or any kind of seeds? Those are meant to feed the young growing seedling. Do you eat greens of any kind like spinach and lettuce? Those are meant to provide energy to the plant which grew them
You can’t live in this world without killing. Even breathing kills microscopic worlds. The goal is to take the least amount of life to reduce your karmic payback
What a misleading answer! Dairy is not saving cows and bulls from slaughter. It is the industry that provides cheap raw materials (innocent cows, bulls, etc) to the beef exporters. This enables them to compete very well in the international market. Do you think it is a coincidence that India has become one of the top two exporters of beef globally in the same period as it has become one of the top 2 producers of milk in the world? Dairy industry breeds crores of these animals every year using forced artificial insemination (sexual assault on gai mata?) and sells crores of bulls and non milk producing cows to the slaughterhouses. The only way to stop this is to stop consuming dairy products. That will stop this massive breeding exercise and will make beef too expensive for most people to consume. #GoVegan #jeevdaya #ahinsaparmodharma
Just tell me this idiot , even if , ok if people by some miracle stop drinking milk , the Breeding process will still go on as people still need beef , and the milk will also needed to produce products that are very important like icecream which 99% of the people eat ( including you perhaps) cheese , butter and many more And now let's just imagine that the people and the kids just became mature which is practically impossible , but it happens then all the cows will be focused on beef production and as beef becomes costly , it will become a delicacy as it will be rare and what will come next, it's simple , the cows will go extinct and this not shocking at all because we humans have never let anyone to stay something peacefully as it is , Look at the bigger picture here
@@adityathakur5308 at first place log chhodenge kyu doodh pina, karan to 2 hai mainly ki pehla koi virus ya koi bimaari aa jaye ya phir log mansahaar chhod ke shakahaar apnaye dono hi cases mein log animal products bhi nhi khayenge aur ye need nhi hoti hai beef ki samjha janwar ye hawas hai jo khilwati hai meat zindagi to thoda sa khao jine bhar bahut hai aur rahi baat log agar dono mein so koi bhi reason pakadte hai to wo animal product kuchh bhi nhi khayenge even cheese ice cream, aur aisa kaunsa janwaar hai jo vilupt hua hai apne aap pagal balki insaano ki WAJAH se hi hue hai bechare vilupt jungle kat gye sab
@@grumpytank2927 He consumes body parts and secretions of abused animals into his body. He has a long way to go to be a realized person. Leonardo Da Vinci said I will not have my body be the tomb for innocent beings. That response was realised.
They will eventually slaughter the cow after they have tortured for years, I do not agree with what he speaks here, also if the demand for milk goes down then there would not be so many cows commercially created, this is not ok Sadguru I’m very disappointed
By his explanation, On one hand these cows will suffer death by slaughter in quick time and on the other hand by a life of torture and suffering and them slaughter. Would he care to explain what happens to these cows after they are beyond child rearing age. Perhaps india's beef export status may help him comment better
Thanku Sadhguru 🙏 🙏 🙏 🙏 🙏 Cows ,buffaloes and goats number has to be increased to meet daily requirements. Nowadays they are putting injection to get more milk this is cruelty. If simply milk is taken in natural way then it is good . Isha foundation has 25 indigenous breed of cows and bulls feed them with 10 different types of grains.
I agree wth Sadguru in almost all his explanations and logic...but this logic he gave was pretty mixed up.... wasn't a convincing answer at all.... And I wonder why he had to be sarcastic to the woman who simple heartedly asked the question....not usual of him. My Pranam to him as always though🙏
That is his way of creulty...if we don't milk..there wi be no more huge productions of bulls and less is the chance of going to slaughter house..with limited animals..we can manage to create a habitat for them...like we do for other animals who are going extinct..so I don't agree with him on this statement...bu I do follow him and admire him🙏🏽
Dear Sadhguru, I am following you since 6years but today I want to say that you are wrong.... Firstly its not joke.... That cruality is there in milk and I want to ask you why are you accepting that milk is cruality free product. And you are saying that they should work or get slauted.... Is this I can do thus with my mother that if she is giving me food I keep her and after getting disabled can I send her to Vradha ashram???? Shame....Shame.....Shame.... Unfollowing you from today dear sadguru you can't support cruality being a spiritual leader. ❌❌❌❌❌
Poor sarcasm, how did sadhguru assume the questionnaire was asking about herself, as I click this video because she represents the question for what I was looking the answer for. So making fun for her without knowing the fact whether she consume milk or not. It’s poor judgment and sarcasm. Lastly who says we only breed them to milk it. They are used as reproductive system until they no longer can procreate when they will be discarded as beef. So in short their life is full of suffering. During their life they are used for milk and when they can no longer get more milk from them they will be slaughtered for beef.
Sadguru seems to be a sad guru here. If someone asks him a question he puts that person down first. He does not need to be condescending. Stargate that he is enlightened but does not know that milking cow is cruel because they are impregnated forcefully before they even stop producing milk from previous pregnancy. He should know that India is number one in beef export because those dairy cows are eventually slaughtered once they don't produce enough milk for profit. He does not seem compassionate in this video. May be he likes consuming milk and ghee.
Acharya Prashant ji se k pass jaa krr inn Sadhguru ji ko siksha Leni chahiye....taaki phir logo ko sahi direction de paaye, otherwise ese hi mislead krte rhenge.....
I dont agree this......cruelty me zinda rehne se acha toh....chota life h acha h....har din marne se acha ek baar maro....if animal ki tarah situation ho toh.........god life is better than cruel earth life....if living life is painful...
He's just defending his statement because he wants to do milk Abhishekam to Shiva Lingas but when did God say he wanted artificially inseminated cows to get Abhishekam, he's just talking about the current situation in the world but not saying what could happen if everyone stops consuming it.
Naturally the cow is supposed to have milk only enough for her child. People have bred them to produce excess milk. So it is *NEVER* ok to consume a cow's milk. Not your mom, not your milk, its as simple as that.
Isn't a Spiritual guru means to teach humans the very morals, not to tell if you don't do that humans will kill and closed the discussion. When he can teach not to eat meat, what stops him from teaching not to drink milk? The lady asked she didn't understand, because his joke in between her question is double meaning, 32 years age is too late to drink milk, as only infants need milk. School comparison, kids learn even the cruelty he thinks in school is forcing to study, lift bags, etc, but later they come out of school and live his life. What a disappointing comparison from a Sadhguru who so many people follow.
He you idiot , Sadhguru knows that the humans are not that kind hearted as to follow the Morals that other guru that you approve of teaches , only a few people will follow that guru for some time and that's it , He is someone that takes the situation into consideration and thinks logically and by his experience and then answers the question , His answer will not satisfy perhaps but it will atleast work. People like him are rare , And he teaches spirituality to people who can actually practice them and the people who can't, blames him cause other guru teach all
These days so called vegans say dont put milk on shiv ling This ritual has been going for thousands of years Who are they to say like this But those people dont utter a word on other religions brutal killing of animals on festivals
Vegans do protest on other religious practice as well as slaughter houses and clothing. The problem is when people just listen to one person and doesn't do own research.
Ye Sadhguru bilkul hi bewakoof h kya , sharm aani chahiye aapko aise baatein karte hue . Cows buffalo ko forcefully pregnant kiya jata hai for milk and all this process for milk and meat are one and very brutal . If we stopped drinking milk, artificially pregnancy will be stopped and cruelty will be stopped . Ye Sadhguru ko koi puchta hi kyu hai.
Ur an ideal guru, im an atheist nd got many doubts about our culture but ur really impressive nd a grown up whom others should listen.. Long live our sanatani sages🙏
Seems you just growing up, that's I see everywhere you use the word "Grow up" or "Grown up". Long live sanatan dharma. But not promoting hurting other animals for the sake of human benefits.
@@ChakrasMusicLab hurting animals???😂.. Tell me which animal or living being don't suffer in this world?? U ppl just want a answer which will make u happy, bcz u have a wrong image about this world..we extract milk from a animal, instead we love em, we treat em when they get ill, we play with em, we cry so much when they pass away,,,u going to teach us how to love animals??? Everyone of us r biased at some point even u bcz u have a different image about humanity nd cruelty..that old man is really a grown up, he speaks the truth doesn't matter if his viewers like it or not, u ppl r not ready for sages teachings
@@Inertsky You are referring to that man what he spoke is true just because it pleased you and other non-vegetarians as well. He is doing politics to get as many followers as he can. I am not looking for an answer, you are looking, unfortunately he didn't answer the true way so you people can be happy. You said you take milk from cow and love them. Do you even know how they get milk? This is basic thing you didn't know, but speaking about loving and caring them and crying when they pass away. What you do when she passes away? Where are her kids born every year?
@@ChakrasMusicLab ru stupid?? I have both village house nd house in city.. I have cows in my home, i have milked many times, nd the cow never ever hated me, her child loves playing with me,, i grew up with animals, so find someone else,,, nd for ur knowledge that child will get sick if we let him/her drink all that milk
@@Inertsky Using such language explains a lot. Doesn't matter. A child will stop drinking milk when it feels enough. I'm not talking about if you are letting them drink or not. How does a cow start to give milk, you didn't answer. How what happens with all the calves born every year? How many calves you must be having by today? Including males. If I continue to reply your stupidity answers, I'll be a fool really. I stand with my original comment.
Ahimsa parmo dharma phir bhi is fakeguru Ko suffering nahi dhikhai de rahi.english me nonsense and illogical batein karta hai.fakeguru ham kon hote hain kisi animals ka sath kya hoga decide karne walee.
Please educate yourself. There are many good people on youtube, listen to them. You have no idea what veganism is, what empathy is. Listen to Acharya Prashant to begin with.
@@AntonDee The dairy and egg industries are brutally cruel. Comparing sending a child to school to what they do to dairy cows is a joke. I think Sadhguru knows perfectly well the brutality and killing that takes place. He just does not want to lose followers. He also says it is ok to kill animals for their flesh. This is not enlightenment. Rather it is simply making excuses for people who do not want to know reality. The dairy industry hides their cruelty and guru is helping them.
Kindly watch other videos from Indian dairy industries. He told male will work for humans, female will milk for humans, or else humans will kill. Isn't he here to teach people what is moral or leave some morals for granted? How many males are alive and working? Should have been reached more than 500 all these years only with him, where are they? How a village milk farmer can handle each new born? He didn't answer well in my opinion.
Guruji spitting facts, as expected.. Nd yes letting their childs drink all the milk will put em in danger, so it's better to not let em drink all that milk.. Nd cows don't suffer much when we extract milk from em, in my village house we have cows, nd that cow who gives us milk love my family very much, never felt that animal got some hatred towards us... Sadguru is absolutely right
Sadhguru darte hain un lobbies ko lobbies milk se kai sare products banta hai, school kabhi cruel nahi raha yeh ek niyam se chalta hai bas wakt ke hisab se badla hai, gaay ka dudh bhi pehle sahi tarike se liya jata tha per ab bade bade farms main unko takhleef diya jata hai fir dudh dena band ho jaye toh unko khane ke liye becha jata hai...school main wohi log padhte hain jinki jubaan hai agar school main cruelty kiya jata bhi hai toh insaan awaz utha sakta hai pr bejubaan janwar par atyachar ka awaaz kaun uthayega...bas apni tark se hi santusth ho jane pr kuch nhi hota reality bolne ki himmat honi chahiye bhale hi apni tark bakwas bhi ho...kutte bhi bezubaan hi hote hain unhe liye bhi hume hi sochna chahiye aur packed dudh ko packed paneer aur sehri dudh ko avoid karna chahiye... Edited:- milk se bane sarr products ko avoid karna chahiye... Aise toh aaj duniya kuch lobby ka hi gulam hai pr kisi ki tark de apne sir na hilayen khud sochen ki iski kitna kimat hame chukane padh rahe hain...
Brilliant answer? Didn't he or atleast you didn't know a cow needs to get pregnant continuously for the production of milk? And what if a male cow is born? How many calves should be born and where are those calves raised and maintained? His intelligence is a conflict when he said where she saw milk diyas when he don't understand ghee was from that milk. Humans will kill anything that is not useful for humans so he doesn't want to change them. Brilliant you said.
@@triller269 He is not ignorant, or else the title Sadhguru could be invalid. He deliberately diverts. Where is leaving cows to live by themselves and where is slaughtering if he really tried to suggest people to stop meat eating? I used to like him too.
Talking without logic.......comparing artificial insemination and lifelong torture with schooling of child is foolish logic......u can't be expert in every topic.....so stop speading lies🙏🙏
Though I agree to sadhguru's teachings a lot, would not consider his argument valid here. If we stop consuming milk collectively, there would be decline in further forceful impregnantion of cows and lesser calves. Male calves are a burden to this industry and are slaughtered. In fact all industries be it poultry,milk ,honey all have a dark side where the poor animal are exploited. Even for our vegan sources, trees are cut to use for farm land. Some people may have a problem with that too.
It all depends where we stop our moral compass.
Then you want to ultimately extinct the cow species from the planet earth.
I understand your concern, you are a nice people to think like that but the world don't work according to vegan people. God created all creatures to help mutually, not to torture I agree. If you take the argument of vegan people then why God kept the humans and other creatures in the same planet.
Cows are very important for our human society. When you come to rural area., You will feel the importance of cow . When rain is not happening somewhere in rural area, no agriculture is possible, then cow only save us.
And for the problem with male calves, there are some initiatives that has been taken. To make the use of bull power to make electricity, water pumping by running them in trademeal, and many things people started doing. I know it just started, in many areas it is not there , but I hope in most areas, Goshalas and this kind of intiatives will definitely help. And this is a green and sustainable solutions.
Even if they don't give milk, they are stil valuable, no need to kill them, we have to find some ideas so that we can make work out of them in a more ethical way.
They give organic fertilizer, which is the main backbone of organic farming, you can not get any microbial activity in other chemical fertilizer.
Many benifits are there. We have to support those people who are doing this and taking this initiative by means of financial aspect or if you have any other idea. I believe it will definitely succeed one day.
Sadghuru is totally full of bull##t. He is so fake.
You are fool, we don't milk chicken, is there any decline in population of chicken, in Europe cows are raised only for meat sometimes, even if you don't milk cows they will be slaughtered like goat and hen, So it is better to utilize cows to give them long life and many a times they die natural death
@@subhajitmondal1391
The problem is not this.
The problem is you are giving money to dairies who are making cattle a milk machine..
I'm just saying buying milk form ruler areas or from local milkman is right rather than from national dairy companies...
As a spiritual leader he should care for animals too not just humans beings. He should let people know how cruel Dairy industry is and that no one has right to harm/ torture another being. Being VEGAN in today’s world is spiritually 🙏🏼💚
Right,
What an illogical explanation by Sadguru. This is not by chance that India is among no. One in both Milk consumption and beef exporting. Milk producing cows and buffaloes are being breeded and reproduced in such large number to meet the demand of dairy industry. After they are not useful, they are either left on roads or sent to slaughter house. If milk n milk products would not be in such demand by a large population, they will be present around us only in that number, which nature wants them to be. Sadguru should reflect what mean practices are being used in breeding cows and buffaloes and what happens to them when they are not useful. Who wants to keep the male calves and non milking old cows/buffaloes. No one or very very few ones. All send them to slaughter houses to reduce their costs and to make extra money from them. In modern time Milk consumption is essentially related to animal cruelty. We want to consume milk and their products in large quantities. So we produce those animals by injecting semen in female cows/ buffaloes, producing more offspring. The male offspring sent to slaughter house or on roads and females ones are kept till they can provide babies and milk. After that, even those females cows/ buffaloes, our Gau Mata are sold to slaughter house. That is why we have topped in Beef export. This is whole bullshit game of demand and supply.
You are so right. People should watch the video Dairy is Scary. The dairy industry is a machine that chews up cows and spits out their dead bodies without care or concern.
The dairy industry has people fooled into believing this is a natural process. Yet everything about it is cruel. They take the baby cow from the mother immediately after birth. In nature a cow will stand up to wolves to protect their baby yet the dairy industry tells us it does not bother the mother. And the mothers cry for their babies for weeks calling and calling and calling. This is because they dont want the baby cow having the mothers milk they have to take it for people. They also milk the cow to the brink of death. The moment the cow is not profitable they either get thrown to the street and more often taken to be killed. This is brutal. This is a thousand times worse than sending a child to school to get an education.
I am not sure if i can respect this many any more after such an incredibly unenlightened response. Also milk, cheese are horrible for the human body. It is full of estrogen and many other hormones present in the female cow after she gave birth. It is full of saturated fat which clogs arteries. destroys bone health, causes prostate cancer in men and breast cancer in women. A gallon of milk generally takes 1000 gallons of water to produce. Two cups of milk uses more water than I drink in a year.
Guru just does not want to change or enlighten anyone on this subject because he fears he will lose followers.
omgg i agree with you 100% he gave a lot of illogical arguments
Yes, we need to stop using animals for our gain. Stop using buffalos in fields, donkeys to carry burden, horses and camels to carry us, dogs to protect us.
@@shreyaaashree😂😂
You are right ❤ Thank You so much for this valuable comment ❤️
He is so proud of his answer. Thinks he’s absolutely nailing it when in reality he is talking utter bollocks.
Ok
so you want all the billions of cows to be left free???
Anybody knows, He is total troll, full of bull##t
@@The_capable_man People won't change overnight. As more and more people will go vegan, less and less cows will be bred into existence. And one day we will stop this cruelty.
Be moral, be vegan 🌱
Yes, like any other wild animal in the greens.
So glad I saw the video. I had so much respect and it's destroyed in seconds. Blind people laughing at anything he says. Have people really lost their brains and became part of a cult? Absolute aweful thought.
True
damn even sarcasm is losing respect now.
I agree
I agree with him being practical
I can't believe some enlightened person is not talking about karma n suffering here, what karma /action we do with others we get it back equally. So be ready to live a life of cow if you are in favour of drinking milk , milk products, leather , honey, cosmetics that comes by torchering animal. Spirituality means we all are spirit, animals also have the soul n emotions , cows cry when they loose their babies , but who cares...we are feeling proud to give them a life , it doesn't matter if it is hell for them
This is not how karma works, as i understood it.
You are jain and you are vegan , thats great ,, i thought all jain are crazy for milk ,ghee , cheese ice creams,
In another video , Sadhguru said - after 2 years of age, nobody should be drinking cow's milk. Cows should never be used for meat, that I totally agree. Even buffaloes. Today they are talking lab grown meat - if you must eat, why not eat that ?
I really wonder why Sadhguru said this. I’ve been listening to him for years and have found some clarity by a lot of things he’s said. But this is one thing he’s said that I truly disagree with based on what I have learned about the dairy industry. I have learned that the use of animals for food sources is completely wrong in our time. It is completely cruel and completely unnecessary. Not just meat, but dairy, eggs and honey have cruelty involved.
The way dairy is produced is by selectively breeding cows to produce an unnatural amount of milk which causes harm to their bodies. Furthermore they only produce it after they’ve been inseminated by a human who impregnates them forcefully with a bulls semen-you see how this sounds?
There are alternatives to dairy. Many plant based milk sources are there. And if we stop using dairy- the cows need not be slaughtered because we are not using them. If we all stop using the cows for dairy, we can let them live out their lives to old age and their numbers will gradually decline. What’s the problem with that? They are only being bred because humans are calling for more supply of the products which they exploit them for.
And finally, if we wanted to expand our sense of inclusion for these animals then we could use our resources which we are using anyway to give this (what could be) last generation of these exploited animals a beautiful life on a sanctuary, living better than they would if they were to be sent to slaughter and/or milked or otherwise exploited for the things we take from them to eat.
I actually quite detest what Sadhguru has said here and has me questioning him a lot more than I ever have.
In what kind of utopia are u referring to? Get back on planet earth... Sadhguru explained it well enough, if u cannot understand what he said that means u don't accept the reality of planet earth.
That kind of animals cannot survive out in the wild alone, they will get slaughtered either by predator animals or by humans. Also there's no logic behind keeping a cow as a pet feeding it for no reason.
@@jim.carras I’m really not sure why you’re saying what you are… the reality of planet earth as it is now is that humans are destroying it. And by raising an incredible number of creatures just to be killed for our consumption is one of the most damaging things to planet earth. That’s the reality of planet earth. And furthermore, the solution in my view is to stop breeding these animals which, if you could understand, would not exist if not for selective breeding by humans. They would slowly dwindle in numbers. We need not slaughter them. Giving them a nice quality of life and then letting them die of natural causes would be most ideal. Humans can live on a vegan diet. And a vegan diet is most sensible for humans and planet earth.
True i also don't agree with Sadhguru on these.
Well you should maybe also question yourself more :)
@@raouf31 Please elaborate. Your response has no substance in regards to the subject matter of my comment.
This is why you should not attach your identity with a human being “guru” rather with truth and truth only. This man has audacity to deny a thousand million industry that runs in torture and misery of innocent animals which is so evident. I hope the people who are brainwashed by him realise this soon.
Sadguru seems to be ignorant on this topic.
I don't think he is ignorant. He don't want to stop and know twisting answers.
Grow up nd know about nature.. U will like him alot
@@Inertsky
What do you mean by grow up and know about nature. I don't understand. I do not find his arguments clear and logical on this issue. That's it. I am not saying anything about his other insights, his contribution. Definitely, he is a very active charismatic personality. I also like to hear him on many other topics.
@@nirajkumarbharat bcz he stated the facts but ur saying he's ignorant,,,it is not his job to please others, he is here to answer ur questions now u may not like it from the heart but reality wouldn't change,,,not just him, those who have cows in their homes will also find it stupid if someone says milking from a cow is an animal cruelty
@@Inertsky
Of course it sounds stupid, if we are considering only people having cows in their house in an ideal condition, where cows are the backbone of their family livelihood and culture. But I am putting my arguments here considering cows and buffaloes from full grown dairy industries. Plz try to get some information on that. Are same milking methods, cultural ethics are followed there also? And it's a big industry. Plz help me in understanding why India tops in both Milk producing country and beef exporting country. Plz 🙏 help me in understanding this relationship rest I will understand by itself
First time I don't agree with him at all. The way we torture them, it is better for them to die. Humans are the worst creatures.🙏
Vegan 🌱 live cruelty-free
Simple and Clear and truly Free!
Spirit, Mind, and Body! Thank you!
😇
yeah no... its more like Vegan 🌱 live life with fake moral superiority
Why you wanna kill plants.😢
@@t.a6159 well looks like someone skipped biology class. Hate to break it to you but plants don’t have a central nervous system therefore cannot feel pain. Sad you compare plants to a living breathing animal that holds blood.
We should not kill plants. They have life.
Sometimes if you are unsure what to say, you should not answer the question because you don't have adequate knowledge. Maybe you have some knowledge but unless you have complete knowledge you should keep quiet.
Many people talk about how cruel things are and do nothing but talk. There is a man who quietly grew a huge forest, the elephants and other animals even came back. He didn’t talk, just did and people noticed. It would be nice if those concerned about milking of cows would get all the money together and build sanctuaries, not talk about it
Well Said Friend!
But he still treats this woman very disrespectfully and dominates her.
Yes, I agree wth him in almost all his beliefs...but this logic of his was pretty mixed up..
@@zinilebt6002dominates? it was sarcasm 🗿
I have to somewhat agree with sadhguru in this one because completly stop drinking milk then who will feed them or even bother to spend money. Just completely stop drinking the milk is not realistic in todays society. There should be some regulation on dairy the way they treat animal atleast if it giving us milk it should be treated with that level of respect and care.
Yeah yeah we can't just stop spending money on your mther. we should think a way to slowly reduce harvesting and consuming milk from your mther.
Just kidding
It is not just possible but EASY today. You have a lot of good alternatives. Also, if you don’t support the industry, they will breed less suffering cows into existence.
cows are tortured for 5 years because they have a reproduction system and some adults still want to ween off of an animal, they stop weening off milk from their mothers and start weening from cows. Cows are impregnated for 4-6 years EVERY SINGLE YEAR they go through pregnancy which takes a toll on their mental and physical health in most cases their calves are taken away from them, male calves are sent to slaughter houses since no one really plow their fields with bulls/ox any more or VERY rarely, and female calves are given milk barely just to survive, and when they turn 1 year they go through this continuous cycle of pregnancy, and the process is pretty painful too, and after they turn 5 years and their physical body start to decline they are either smuggled to states where cows are legal to slaughter and then sold off as buffalo meat which is legal to slaughter in every single state, or they are left on streets to die or they hundred and hundreds of cows are kept in a closed space to starve to death and their bodies are thrown into the water bodies, milk industry is pretty brutal
also, he gave an illogical reason of school being a cruel place and if someone doesn't go to school they will end up killing people or go on wrong path, or end up in poverty.
first off, school is not a cruel place the atmosphere depends on teachers, peers and study load in schools there are a lot of toxic teachers bully peers and unrealistic amount of syllabus but that's just a flaw in Indian education system. but school is never meant to be a cruel place, its a place to enrich your brain and get knowledge.
secondly, it DOESN'T mean that if someone doesn't go to school they will be bad people or something, not going school and having bad morals have nothing to do with each other, your morals will not go away if you don't go to school you can be a kind, compassionate and street smart person without going to school you just won't have professional knowledge, and not going to school and being poor is also not quite accurate, there is a correlational relationship between these two factors, but correlation doesn't equal causation.
🙏🏼🙏🏼💚
At first I thought to be utter nonsense. But when I listened carefully again. I understood he is just saying that if we lose a job or don't work we get depressed fat unhealthy same way. If bulls same as man and cows as women don't work then they die soon. Secondly if if we leave them alone the reality is they go to slaughter house this is really true, he wants to give life not take it away. We don't use our money on something which is unselfish which has no use for us this is also so true. If we become like this it's not enough another person will take advantage of it. He also mentions we should not drink any animal milk even cows milk. Also this is not the full video like half knowledge is dangerous. Full video is beutiful and he is just trying to make people be less serious and laugh.
Agree 👍🏻
Makes sense. Even the fact about dogs killing children just like uneducated child leads to become poor, rowdy and criminals is also true.
True
Strangely agree with you and Sadhgury. He is showing reality of the current times what can be done best.
Send me a link to the full video sir
If we dont buy egg then hen would be slaughtered so should we buy eggs?
Exactly, Sadhguru made eggs sound bad but way of getting dairy is equally bad
@@ikg459 Yes you are right, choose neither, be vegan 🌱
You have a point but if there's no demand of milk, there will be demand of meat so the animals will be slaughtered. For veganism to succeed, both milk and meat consumption has be stopped simultaneously.
Absolutely Correct .
Jai Jinendra, It’s an absolute blessing to see so many compassionate beings in these comments. Many vegan blessings to all participating in freedom and equality for all regardless the body they are in. Continue practicing ahimsa and we will soon see Earth transform to its natural blissful state. Jai Jinendra 🙏🧘♀️🙏
Why cant we leave them alone like a street dog they will eat grass and left over Vegetable. Why can't every home make at least 2 rotis extra for street cows, this way they will live their whole life with freedom, and govt should ban slaughtering of cows.
Wheat, grains etc are not healthy for cows. They need fresh grases, water and sunlight.
Dogs are carnivore, he said they ate human children's. And he is supporting cows by making them willingly work no injections or bad treatment. If cows are left alone people take them to slaughter house he is saving them read ankur's reply really good.
@@Flower_girl-x6owhich ankur?
@@Flower_girl-x6o Do you not know cows are raped and impregnated in order to give birth to a calf so they can produce milk?
Do you not know male calves are sent to the slaughterhouses?
Do you not know that old cows, and many bullocks are sent to slaughterhouses?
Do you not know that India is #2nd largest beef exporter in the whole world?
Do you live so much in ignorance?
Totally disagree respectfully. Every sin has to be paid back with interest.. knowingly doing it is worse sin.
It's not a sin, feeding all the milk will put that child in danger, nd sad guru is spitting facts.. He's an ideal sage, ppl like u aren't ready for em
It is practiced for a very long time. We have many other animals. Do you ever think why cow only? Because cow can produce more milk than it's cub need
make them work and make them to be tortured, there's a huge difference. 🙏
First time can't agree
Just leave them alone. Why rape the cows, why take the male cows away from the mother cow after birth? Why breed them?
All because of human greed ms.
Why Gurus like you advertise dairy knowing the cruelty in todays world😢
He did not answer, question was not about milking Vs slaughtering , question was why can't we leave them alone.
He was totally right brother
You not knowing the condition after the situation of not milking
@@theyashap are you yourself convinced with your reply? please do some research on this topic before jumping to defend your guru
@@UmeshKumar-qt4cm not I am not defending my guru
Pls you do research on this topic because you don't know the actual condition.
I am farmer son, so I don't need to do research.
Yes
my one comment got deleted here,
sadguru... milk n milk product companies torturing, exploiting cows very cruelly for their benefit...
how things should go for this issue? kindly lighten up...
It means used these poor animals , harass them all their life on the name of these useless logic n at last leave them to slaughter, if any human will be given a choice 1. Live a hell life and at the end we will send you in a slaughter house 2. No harresment at all, n leave them for their destiny that will be decided by nature. We will choose 2nd , then why for our benefit we are saying option 1 is right. Cows are raped 4-5 times, if you will see you could never take a sip of milk, , their baby is taken away in front of them , they have no freedom, all their life they will be tied with a small rope, at the end when there is no use left they are send for slaughter, in slaughter house they don't slaughter directly, they take their skin out when they are still alive, and we say them mother, will be do this with our mother? But human is so selfish, he can't leave his greed n craving for milk so he feels he I helping cow to alive while he is using her like hell. Sad Guru is not against cruality, he himself takes milk which comes from tears of cows, he suggests honey which is life time saving of a bee for her survival, he does not know the law of karma yet, nature's law is simple what you will do , you will get the return exactly same , all this depression , sadness n restless is coming because the emotion of cow while giving milk is adding it, from the day I know this I left all milk products n honey n any food coming by torching animals n I felt joy, calmness n peace. If someone will do cruality with us , we will believe that with the law of karma, one day that person will be get the equal pain so why we are so foolish to understand that if we are doing this cruality directly or indirectly with any animal or human, we won't get the equal pain in future
No. If we do not consume them, then the problem will be solved. Along with the ill effects and diseases from its consumption. Milk is made specifically for the baby of the species.
This makes me think that he has flaws just like any human.. but, i believe in your wisdom
WAHT THE HEALTH ON NETFLIX
Flaws as in...?
I get your point though. Sadhguru seems to think there are two options only...?
There could be MANY options but MAYBE at the end, this might end up happening.
We can see everything immediately right? Sadhguru has much more experience and his wisdom, as you said, i believe in it too.
What are flaws? He is human anyways. Why do you believe in something when u haven't experienced?
And this should be taken in Indian context
Why flaws? he is just making a practical, objective statement. There are cows in his ashram. If he releases them tomorrow, someone will catch them and eat them up. This is true not only there, but everywhere. So where is the flaw?
The right question to sadguru is wether breeding of cows and buffaloes ethical?
Why not ?
Are a Prude or what?
Breeding is essential even the cows would say this if they could talk!
You want them to go extinct or do you want them to roam without purpose like wild animals or want to pet them without being productive!
This is not love this is lethargy!
The must have a purpose to live and survive
First 30 seconds he rudely interrups and makes fun of her.
guru LOL. this guy is a nightmare
In one of Sadhguru's Save Soil video(ua-cam.com/video/WQp8ikLx3Vc/v-deo.html), he has mentioned that about 77% of world's agricultural land is utilized for raising cattles & their feeds and to change the situation meat consumption has to be reduced. That's right...But actually Dairy industry is creating these animals for dairy products...So which should be addressed first, Dairy industry or Meat industry ? ..I don't understand , why he is saying dairy consumption is fine and not cruel.....If I'm wrong please correct me 🙏
His argument is Illogical. Animals may be any like cow, dog ,elephant etc. are to live freely in jungle and not meant for human pleasure or satisfy his taste bud.
You realise other animals will eat them while they are still alive watching themselves being eaten.
But using mahine may be harmful. Should take mil from conventional way
I think too
I have to agree with Sadhguru, you were sent to school it’s a very cruel place 😂
Putting aside whether this scientifically makes sense. May be it is. But sometimes he does talk in a tone that resembles some elders in my family that I genuinely despise.
Experience gives you the right to enlighten people not condescend them, deride or any other smug emotion. A whole generation looks up to Sadhguru for enlightenment. I'm 100% true his Guru Rishi Prabhakhar whom he never really acknowledged as a Guru would have condescended him. That is why he is an enlightened human being today.
I have nothing against him based on how far my knowledge about him goes, but he can get a bit carried away at time :)
He is human not god ,i am a vegan and i also not complete agreed on he said but i get what his intention was ,maybe one day if i met him i will ask the right questions about milk .
Dude live and let live🤣don't give ur load of cra always
@@cubeometry2699he' just round off the talk
If other wild animals can live freely then why not cows and buffaloes? Who made them pet? If humans stop petting them, their population will be less. Drinking milk for saving from slaughter is not a logical answer. It is like doing one small sin behind the bigger sin. Whether you drink milk or slaughter them, both are cruel. Every creature is born to live naturally. I don't agree with Sadhguru here. I know why he is giving such arguments, because he is running gaushala. 😂😂
Do you eat grain or legumes or any kind of seeds? Those are meant to feed the young growing seedling. Do you eat greens of any kind like spinach and lettuce? Those are meant to provide energy to the plant which grew them
they’re not as dense and easier to absorb. it causes less oxidative stress if you eat something more proportional to your diaphragm
those are all anti nutrients
Plants have only one active element, water so much less karmic pay back compared to taking or hurting an animal
You can’t live in this world without killing. Even breathing kills microscopic worlds. The goal is to take the least amount of life to reduce your karmic payback
Who taught you such logic😂😂
@@Nayan-ic3igEven so, being vegan is still the natrual deduction from your reasoning. And I hope you adhere to it.
why is he making fun of her? This is so embarrassing for her. He really puts her down and makes her look stupid. Seems very sexist to me.
What a misleading answer!
Dairy is not saving cows and bulls from slaughter. It is the industry that provides cheap raw materials (innocent cows, bulls, etc) to the beef exporters. This enables them to compete very well in the international market.
Do you think it is a coincidence that India has become one of the top two exporters of beef globally in the same period as it has become one of the top 2 producers of milk in the world?
Dairy industry breeds crores of these animals every year using forced artificial insemination (sexual assault on gai mata?) and sells crores of bulls and non milk producing cows to the slaughterhouses.
The only way to stop this is to stop consuming dairy products. That will stop this massive breeding exercise and will make beef too expensive for most people to consume.
#GoVegan #jeevdaya #ahinsaparmodharma
Just tell me this idiot , even if , ok if people by some miracle stop drinking milk , the Breeding process will still go on as people still need beef , and the milk will also needed to produce products that are very important like icecream which 99% of the people eat ( including you perhaps) cheese , butter and many more
And now let's just imagine that the people and the kids just became mature which is practically impossible , but it happens then all the cows will be focused on beef production and as beef becomes costly , it will become a delicacy as it will be rare and what will come next, it's simple , the cows will go extinct and this not shocking at all because we humans have never let anyone to stay something peacefully as it is ,
Look at the bigger picture here
Agree he sounds very ignorant here not his finest moment...lost bit of respect for him
@@adityathakur5308 at first place log chhodenge kyu doodh pina, karan to 2 hai mainly ki pehla koi virus ya koi bimaari aa jaye ya phir log mansahaar chhod ke shakahaar apnaye dono hi cases mein log animal products bhi nhi khayenge aur ye need nhi hoti hai beef ki samjha janwar ye hawas hai jo khilwati hai meat zindagi to thoda sa khao jine bhar bahut hai aur rahi baat log agar dono mein so koi bhi reason pakadte hai to wo animal product kuchh bhi nhi khayenge even cheese ice cream, aur aisa kaunsa janwaar hai jo vilupt hua hai apne aap pagal balki insaano ki WAJAH se hi hue hai bechare vilupt jungle kat gye sab
Sadhguru is a realised being
He is way more aware and conscious than any one of us
@@grumpytank2927 He consumes body parts and secretions of abused animals into his body. He has a long way to go to be a realized person. Leonardo Da Vinci said I will not have my body be the tomb for innocent beings. That response was realised.
They will eventually slaughter the cow after they have tortured for years, I do not agree with what he speaks here, also if the demand for milk goes down then there would not be so many cows commercially created, this is not ok Sadguru I’m very disappointed
By his explanation, On one hand these cows will suffer death by slaughter in quick time and on the other hand by a life of torture and suffering and them slaughter.
Would he care to explain what happens to these cows after they are beyond child rearing age. Perhaps india's beef export status may help him comment better
I disagree with Sadhguru too.
Thanku Sadhguru 🙏 🙏 🙏 🙏 🙏
Cows ,buffaloes and goats number has to be increased to meet daily requirements.
Nowadays they are putting injection to get more milk this is cruelty.
If simply milk is taken in natural way then it is good .
Isha foundation has 25 indigenous breed of cows and bulls feed them with 10 different types of grains.
Totally disagree with him herre. He is quite ignorant about this topic. Dairy is completely cruel
He killed her wife what you expect from him
Cows loved being milked 🤷
@@darkking141
You have killed your brain by not utilising it , and just for sake of spreading false informations you have become Cruel .
Compared to sadhguru you know nothing lol
I have two cows at home only i have the right to get a part of their milk not you who is sitting in 2bhk flat and doing nothing for any cows
I agree wth Sadguru in almost all his explanations and logic...but this logic he gave was pretty mixed up.... wasn't a convincing answer at all.... And I wonder why he had to be sarcastic to the woman who simple heartedly asked the question....not usual of him. My Pranam to him as always though🙏
Sadguru fans are laughing always even he is not funny. You consider this man enlightened who don't have sensitivity towards animals
That is his way of creulty...if we don't milk..there wi be no more huge productions of bulls and less is the chance of going to slaughter house..with limited animals..we can manage to create a habitat for them...like we do for other animals who are going extinct..so I don't agree with him on this statement...bu I do follow him and admire him🙏🏽
Dear Sadhguru,
I am following you since 6years but today I want to say that you are wrong....
Firstly its not joke.... That cruality is there in milk and I want to ask you why are you accepting that milk is cruality free product.
And you are saying that they should work or get slauted.... Is this I can do thus with my mother that if she is giving me food I keep her and after getting disabled can I send her to Vradha ashram????
Shame....Shame.....Shame....
Unfollowing you from today dear sadguru you can't support cruality being a spiritual leader. ❌❌❌❌❌
You have little sense of realism and how the world works.
Poor sarcasm, how did sadhguru assume the questionnaire was asking about herself, as I click this video because she represents the question for what I was looking the answer for. So making fun for her without knowing the fact whether she consume milk or not. It’s poor judgment and sarcasm.
Lastly who says we only breed them to milk it. They are used as reproductive system until they no longer can procreate when they will be discarded as beef. So in short their life is full of suffering. During their life they are used for milk and when they can no longer get more milk from them they will be slaughtered for beef.
Sadguru seems to be a sad guru here. If someone asks him a question he puts that person down first. He does not need to be condescending. Stargate that he is enlightened but does not know that milking cow is cruel because they are impregnated forcefully before they even stop producing milk from previous pregnancy. He should know that India is number one in beef export because those dairy cows are eventually slaughtered once they don't produce enough milk for profit. He does not seem compassionate in this video. May be he likes consuming milk and ghee.
Sorry but this didn't made any sense
Acharya Prashant ji se k pass jaa krr inn Sadhguru ji ko siksha Leni chahiye....taaki phir logo ko sahi direction de paaye, otherwise ese hi mislead krte rhenge.....
Acharya Prashant khud ganja aur old monk Fook rahe hai
Nopee
I dont agree this......cruelty me zinda rehne se acha toh....chota life h acha h....har din marne se acha ek baar maro....if animal ki tarah situation ho toh.........god life is better than cruel earth life....if living life is painful...
Badhguru, that’s all I’m going to say.
He is totally wrong on this
He's just defending his statement because he wants to do milk Abhishekam to Shiva Lingas but when did God say he wanted artificially inseminated cows to get Abhishekam, he's just talking about the current situation in the world but not saying what could happen if everyone stops consuming it.
Aacharya Prashant is a real Krishna for cow
This was a rediculous explanation.
Refer Acharya Prashant ji to know true knowledge. its misleading bhai
this 32 year old child wants all the billions of cows to be left free ... she has no understanding of consequences.
The truth about cows milk is that it is ok to consume only if the animal is treated lovingly & only the excess taken, leaving enough for the calfs
Naturally the cow is supposed to have milk only enough for her child. People have bred them to produce excess milk.
So it is *NEVER* ok to consume a cow's milk. Not your mom, not your milk, its as simple as that.
Yes🙏
Isn't a Spiritual guru means to teach humans the very morals, not to tell if you don't do that humans will kill and closed the discussion. When he can teach not to eat meat, what stops him from teaching not to drink milk?
The lady asked she didn't understand, because his joke in between her question is double meaning, 32 years age is too late to drink milk, as only infants need milk.
School comparison, kids learn even the cruelty he thinks in school is forcing to study, lift bags, etc, but later they come out of school and live his life. What a disappointing comparison from a Sadhguru who so many people follow.
He you idiot , Sadhguru knows that the humans are not that kind hearted as to follow the Morals that other guru that you approve of teaches , only a few people will follow that guru for some time and that's it ,
He is someone that takes the situation into consideration and thinks logically and by his experience and then answers the question ,
His answer will not satisfy perhaps but it will atleast work.
People like him are rare ,
And he teaches spirituality to people who can actually practice them and the people who can't, blames him cause other guru teach all
Sadhguru is a realised being
He is more aware and conscious than any one of us
These days so called vegans say dont put milk on shiv ling
This ritual has been going for thousands of years
Who are they to say like this
But those people dont utter a word on other religions brutal killing of animals on festivals
Vegans do protest on other religious practice as well as slaughter houses and clothing. The problem is when people just listen to one person and doesn't do own research.
Yes, Sadguru explanation is really disappointing and misleading.
Ye Sadhguru bilkul hi bewakoof h kya , sharm aani chahiye aapko aise baatein karte hue . Cows buffalo ko forcefully pregnant kiya jata hai for milk and all this process for milk and meat are one and very brutal .
If we stopped drinking milk, artificially pregnancy will be stopped and cruelty will be stopped .
Ye Sadhguru ko koi puchta hi kyu hai.
Hasta kese h sadguru ? Hasthmethun ki tarah
He sounded like : two sides of the same coin (answer by guru)
People, atheist, are so cruel. So we tie them with some religion. Is that correct? No sarcasm. I think he is brilliant.
He shut down was savage…yea yea alright 😂🤣😂🤣
Sorry but this is illogical
Ur an ideal guru, im an atheist nd got many doubts about our culture but ur really impressive nd a grown up whom others should listen.. Long live our sanatani sages🙏
Seems you just growing up, that's I see everywhere you use the word "Grow up" or "Grown up". Long live sanatan dharma. But not promoting hurting other animals for the sake of human benefits.
@@ChakrasMusicLab hurting animals???😂.. Tell me which animal or living being don't suffer in this world?? U ppl just want a answer which will make u happy, bcz u have a wrong image about this world..we extract milk from a animal, instead we love em, we treat em when they get ill, we play with em, we cry so much when they pass away,,,u going to teach us how to love animals??? Everyone of us r biased at some point even u bcz u have a different image about humanity nd cruelty..that old man is really a grown up, he speaks the truth doesn't matter if his viewers like it or not, u ppl r not ready for sages teachings
@@Inertsky You are referring to that man what he spoke is true just because it pleased you and other non-vegetarians as well. He is doing politics to get as many followers as he can. I am not looking for an answer, you are looking, unfortunately he didn't answer the true way so you people can be happy. You said you take milk from cow and love them. Do you even know how they get milk? This is basic thing you didn't know, but speaking about loving and caring them and crying when they pass away. What you do when she passes away? Where are her kids born every year?
@@ChakrasMusicLab ru stupid?? I have both village house nd house in city.. I have cows in my home, i have milked many times, nd the cow never ever hated me, her child loves playing with me,, i grew up with animals, so find someone else,,, nd for ur knowledge that child will get sick if we let him/her drink all that milk
@@Inertsky Using such language explains a lot. Doesn't matter. A child will stop drinking milk when it feels enough. I'm not talking about if you are letting them drink or not. How does a cow start to give milk, you didn't answer. How what happens with all the calves born every year? How many calves you must be having by today? Including males. If I continue to reply your stupidity answers, I'll be a fool really. I stand with my original comment.
Ahimsa parmo dharma phir bhi is fakeguru Ko suffering nahi dhikhai de rahi.english me nonsense and illogical batein karta hai.fakeguru ham kon hote hain kisi animals ka sath kya hoga decide karne walee.
Please educate yourself. There are many good people on youtube, listen to them. You have no idea what veganism is, what empathy is.
Listen to Acharya Prashant to begin with.
Torture is better than instant death? hmmmm
I don't get him, I respect him but not on this topic after listening to this video
This is the wrong answer
This is the right answer
Shut up
Yes he sounds ignorant here...not his finest moment
@@AntonDee The dairy and egg industries are brutally cruel. Comparing sending a child to school to what they do to dairy cows is a joke. I think Sadhguru knows perfectly well the brutality and killing that takes place. He just does not want to lose followers. He also says it is ok to kill animals for their flesh. This is not enlightenment. Rather it is simply making excuses for people who do not want to know reality. The dairy industry hides their cruelty and guru is helping them.
@@AntonDee why these ppl can't understand reality??? I guess these ppl have a very good image about the nature
Very realistic answer Sadhguru ji.
Kindly watch other videos from Indian dairy industries. He told male will work for humans, female will milk for humans, or else humans will kill. Isn't he here to teach people what is moral or leave some morals for granted? How many males are alive and working? Should have been reached more than 500 all these years only with him, where are they? How a village milk farmer can handle each new born? He didn't answer well in my opinion.
I also got the same logic when I attended the satvik movement.. because if we don't have milk they will slaughter cows😔
@@priyanka1506 if we have milk also they will slaughter. How one can manage all the new borns?
COWS GIVE LIFE
Very nice explanation Sadhguruji !
Why cant you stay vegan by not also killing or drinking their 🥛
@@thingstoknow2208 be cause there is only two options , and it's logic . If humans not gonna milk them then they slaughter them
I 100% agree but wants to follow vagen life
Guruji spitting facts, as expected.. Nd yes letting their childs drink all the milk will put em in danger, so it's better to not let em drink all that milk.. Nd cows don't suffer much when we extract milk from em, in my village house we have cows, nd that cow who gives us milk love my family very much, never felt that animal got some hatred towards us... Sadguru is absolutely right
That's right
Totally agree with Sadhguru ji
Can you even reformulate what he said in your own words? For me, it was utter nonsense.
Sita Ram
There is no justification in this vdo🙂🙂🙂
Question to poochha lekin Sahi tarike se inhone jawab nahin diya iska bilkul galat tarike se Satguru
Best answer Sadguru ji!
What the fuck. You don‘t even need their milk. His ego is speaking here.
Sadhguru darte hain un lobbies ko lobbies milk se kai sare products banta hai, school kabhi cruel nahi raha yeh ek niyam se chalta hai bas wakt ke hisab se badla hai, gaay ka dudh bhi pehle sahi tarike se liya jata tha per ab bade bade farms main unko takhleef diya jata hai fir dudh dena band ho jaye toh unko khane ke liye becha jata hai...school main wohi log padhte hain jinki jubaan hai agar school main cruelty kiya jata bhi hai toh insaan awaz utha sakta hai pr bejubaan janwar par atyachar ka awaaz kaun uthayega...bas apni tark se hi santusth ho jane pr kuch nhi hota reality bolne ki himmat honi chahiye bhale hi apni tark bakwas bhi ho...kutte bhi bezubaan hi hote hain unhe liye bhi hume hi sochna chahiye aur packed dudh ko packed paneer aur sehri dudh ko avoid karna chahiye...
Edited:- milk se bane sarr products ko avoid karna chahiye...
Aise toh aaj duniya kuch lobby ka hi gulam hai pr kisi ki tark de apne sir na hilayen khud sochen ki iski kitna kimat hame chukane padh rahe hain...
ramdev baba is the biggest 🐄 milker and he is his friend
Brilliant answer 🌟
Brilliant answer? Didn't he or atleast you didn't know a cow needs to get pregnant continuously for the production of milk? And what if a male cow is born? How many calves should be born and where are those calves raised and maintained? His intelligence is a conflict when he said where she saw milk diyas when he don't understand ghee was from that milk. Humans will kill anything that is not useful for humans so he doesn't want to change them. Brilliant you said.
I like sadhguru but he sounds ignorant in this situation
Lol he is a realised being
We are average in front of him
@@grumpytank2927 he has flaws just like any human
@@triller269 He is not ignorant, or else the title Sadhguru could be invalid. He deliberately diverts. Where is leaving cows to live by themselves and where is slaughtering if he really tried to suggest people to stop meat eating? I used to like him too.
@@ChakrasMusicLab anyone can give themselves a title lol
@@triller269 haha. True
Wrf are u for real sadhguru 😂
Guys pregnant them for milk many nmbr of times
Answer ❌ Cover drive ✅ 😂
So true and practical advise Sadguru ji
He ll say anything you wish if you feed enough cash in his as
Wonderful answer
So true.
Nirmal baba 2
Totally illogical!
Title of the video - False money greedy corporate guru and his dumb disciples .
ye bewkoof hai bhai koi sr pr hai ess baat ka
Talking without logic.......comparing artificial insemination and lifelong torture with schooling of child is foolish logic......u can't be expert in every topic.....so stop speading lies🙏🙏
Absolutely rubbish answer