Disney and Pixar werr close though. Watterson was open to animated media but that was about it and the only reason he changed his mind was due to his insistence on not wanting to hear what Calvin would sound like as that would ruin the point of making up your own voices for the characters
A Choking Fish I remember one of those week long series in the funnies where Garfield literally kicks Odie into next week and like he’s just above them for a few days until falling back down. That was locked away in the recesses of my mind but now I’ve remembered it so ty for that 😂
One thing I always found weird about the live-action Garfield movies was the fact that Garfield himself is the only cartoonish character while all the other animals are realistic and don't even resemble their cartoon counterparts at all. Not even Odie is cartoonish, he's just a normal real life dog. Also, is it bad that I actually _want_ to see Garfield's Judgement Day as a legitimate Garfield movie? It sounds like a more surreal and somewhat philosophical version of Barnyard, and certainly sounds far better than the Bill Murray films.
Completely agree. Garfield resembling his cartoon self, but Odie, Arlene and Nermal doesn't is really strange. Yeah, Garfield's Judgment Day would've been awesome. Why do you think it's bad that you want to see it? It isn't.
@@abdullahibouraleh6919 Odie being realistic and not cartoonish is ESPECIALLY baffling given how much of a core character he is to the franchise, but I have a feeling they just didn't care one bit when making this movie.
i always found it so weird how different Nermal and Arlene look too... like i get that, if everyone but Garfield is realistic, that having a real pink cat would be weird, but Nermal? why is Nermal suddenly like, a teenager Siamese cat instead of a little grey striped kitten? even Odie kinda looks like Odie, why is it different for Nermal and Arlene? so many questions...
I LOVED "His 9 Lives" as a kid - the book, not the cartoon. I mean loved it. I must have read it a 100 times. I still get chills thinking about it. It was so darn creepy, especially because it was supposed to be a *Garfield comic* - only reason my parents let me have it at such a young age. Watching this video and learning that Jim Davis wanted to make artsy comics but "sold out" with Garfield to become successful, it makes a lot more sense why he would have written a book like that (and those creepy Halloween strips.) But at the time, it was just some inexplicable artifact that should not exist... half of my fascination with it was the stories in it, but half was that *this was a book that simply shouldn't be.*
I don't know why nobody talks about the 1989 four part garfield comic strip "alone", a tale where Garfield is allegedly abandonned, going crazy denying the fact that no one is there for him anymore
The implication that strip sets up - that every Garfield comic from the 90s onward was the fevered dream of a starving Garfield trapped in a derelict abandoned house - fucked with me REAL hard as a kid
How did you talk about Garfield's Nine Lives without touching on the best one??? The piano cat segment is legitimately heartbreaking, I watched Nine Lives for shits and giggles, but it made me cry my eyes out.
I legit wanted to call your mom up Quinton and tell her you arent going to be invited to my birthday party after school anymore when you said there wasnt anything good about this movie. That Diana part is so beautiful and intimately sad especially if you ever have loved and lost a close pet. You monster! 😭😂
@@MeMeMcsplosion , I'm not a republic *serial* villain. Do you really think I'd explain my *master stroke* if there remained the slightest chance of you affecting the outcome? Garfield's been naked for 41 years
As soon as I heard the name "Garfield's Judgement Day", I immediately thought of Terminator 2 and imagined Garfield having to team up with the T-800 and stuff like that
Same but I thought of Garfield seeing the world set on fire and all the people including john and odie get burned to death like in the dream part of the beginning
@@Mario_Angel_Medina Right! This is partially why I think we should make Garfield a leftist figure. It's no coincidence that Thought Slime makes a video about Garfield and them the bread book makes an appearance here.
I honestly really love 'Garfield His Nine Lives' (film version, never had the book) and had no idea it was so poorly regarded. I especially liked "Diana's Piano", which is very touching (and I do find it interesting that they have Garfield be unambiguously female in a previous life and make no jokes about it.) "Lab Animal" is also very good.
The part of His Nine Lives that sticks with me is the reveal at the end that God is a cat, using a visual callback to the most upsetting segment of the special, which gives the reveal an unintentionally sinister undertone. As if God is a cat in His Nine Lives the same way that God is a spider in Through a Glass Darkly.
@The Very Edgy Yoshi Not at all! If I had come across those comics as a mature adult with a logical brain instead of as an impressionable child with a vivid imagination, I think I would have appreciated them more. As it stands, I can't look at them without getting that little-kid-oh-no feeling in my gut.
Garfield has a complex multiverse Earth 295: Garfield Judgement Day Earth 616: Comic Garfield Earth 666: Lasagna Cat Earth 1610: Garfield and Friends Earth 2149: Gorefield Earth 8096: The Garfield Show Earth 199999: Garfield the movie
Garfield's 9 lives is my absolute favorite of the specials. I loved the different artstyle changes it felt like a nice anthology story. The piano, experiment, and jazz one being some of the most memorable ones.
It just seemed really dry and unfunny. Main problem was you needed to have watched the movie to find the joke funny. He expects you to understand how bad it was. But I've never heard of this movie, so I have no clue what it's like.
You would consider smurfs a talking animal movie? Not only this but you use it to define the whole genre, Your truly insane in the membrain! Come on gentlecats let’s try and suppress our zombie rage
I just discovered your channels literally the other day (I still can’t believe I watched every second of your recently uploaded “iBinged iCarly” project) and loved the abundance of Garfield paraphernalia in the background. I didn’t want to take away from the tremendous work on that project so I didn’t comment saying anything about the Garfield goodness. But I did subscribe because wow, you are talented. And now, just a few days later, the algorithm has gifted me with TWO GARFIELD VIDEOS from you. Hearing your story about how you got into Garfield comics resonated with me heavily because my poppop told me before he passed away that he was so happy to give me the comics portion of the newspaper every week just because it was a bit of a connection to the past nostalgia and a way to relate to me as a younger kid growing up in a totally different world. I got so into the comics at the time, unknowingly, for the same reason - as a way to relate to him. Media is wild. Keep up the great work! - with love, new fan
Here's how Judgement Day should have gone: "Jon, animal law says I can't talk to you but I literally do not care about that. There's a storm or something, pack up the lasagna and I'll meet you in the car."
Yeah! And then by kiddy cartoon contrivance, if Jim Davis wants to get his status quo reset at the end, all he has to do is make Jon have an accident that causes him some amnesia- maybe he opens a closet and the junk inside topples on his head or a tree falls on him or jokey electrocution gag, typical 90s /Gilligans Island cliche fare...and Jon wakes up, saying "WOW Garfield! I just had the silliest kooky dream! You and Odie could TALK, isn't that silly??"
My idea for a Garfield movie: they visit John's parents farm, Garfield learns to get along with the other animals, and Jon finds out Lyman got hired as a farmhand and they become friends again. Yes its simple, BUT its light and harmless.
Garfeilds Judgement day would have been a good change of pace and make Garfeild have something going for him agianst other comic strips. Garfeild was always missing that IMO. Its a shame it was scraped for being to dark. The movie would have probably be longer than the book
I'm so glad you talked about Garfield: His 9 lives. I watched it when I was 7, and even then I could tell how intensely weird it was. I only found out about it again recently, and up to that point, it always felt more like a half-remembered fever dream than something that actually aired on TV.
It was genuinely so refreshing to see this in my sub box amongst all the dramatic bs that's going on at the moment. No emotionally manipulative overreacting to petty crap, just content that I am so ready to spend 20 minutes discovering I am super interested in despite never having thought about it before in my life.
Actually y'all, Marx thought that the state was an extension of the capitalist society he wanted to dismantle, leaders are just another part of the hiearchy
“The Garden” worked better in the book, probably because of the delicate airbrush art and being able to imagine the narrator sounding like whatever you want.
Garfield His Nine Lives has beautifully unique animated segments. I'm glad you showed the Disney quality footage from Lab Animal. I also really love the modern style in Court Musician and the painterly experimental look of Diana's Piano.
Anyone who had their childhood turned inside-out by that book is in a special club. The only thing that messed with my mind as much as a kid was "I am the Cheese." I still can't believe that's marketed as a YA novel.
Judgement Day isn't the only dark Garfield adaptation out there. I remember owning a book called "Garfield's Scary Tales" as a kid, which was a series of five illustrated short horror stories featuring the orange feline. Tales included a bestial midnight stalker, a woodland encounter with an axe-wielding maniac (actually the tamest of the bunch), a near-death experience involving a giant spider, a malevolent computer that drained people's minds and an unresolved psychological cliffhanger involving a monster that may or may not be real. The spider one left the biggest impression on me on account of its final illustration. Garfield inadvertently saves himself from being eaten alive by fainting on top of the spider and crushing it with his body. The reader is then treated to a grotesque image of the flattened spider, its corpse framed by a splattering of blood, guts and internal organs.
i’ve had garfield’s nine lives, the book, since i was a kid. i remember being little and feeling like i shouldn’t have this book, like i’m looking into something i shouldn’t see: garfield’s private history.
I remember reading "Garfield: His 9 Lives" a while back. That book was weird. "Tonal whiplash" is what comes to mind, but seems like quite the understatement.
Gotta be honest, Garfield His 9 Lives is a case where its worst parts are when it sticks too close to the comic. The Garden story and the Eightth Life in particular both work WAY better in the comic--the garden is genuinely kind of heartwarming there, but in the animated special its just saccharine and tedious, and being animated inherently spoils the ending gag of Life Eight--its just so much funnier when the joke is "Panel A: Garfield says one thing--Cut to Panel B where he's saying the opposite," whereas the cartoon gives too much padding and ruins it. .... But I will never brook criticism of Diana's Piano. That bit makes the whole movie worth it. Also, any Megaman Legends fans here who think that ship Garfield pilots on his last life looks a lot like the Flutter?
I'm about 9 minutes in, and I need to tell you how deeply it's shaken me to my core to see Garfield dance to Audrey's Dance, then get suckerpunched by your mention of Conquest of Bread and Garfield media in the same sentence. I'm dissociating now, Quinton. I love all 3 of those things, but, somehow, at the same time, it's... removing me from this plane.
I unironically love the fully-CGI Garfield movie trilogy. I think it has interesting stories, exciting action scenes, emotional moments, and a great soundtrack. I wish more people talked about it.
It’s so weird that Bill Murray from Meatballs and Caddyshack feels like a different time than Garfield Bill Murray and another time from Wes Anderson Bill Murray
The Garfield holiday specials are my favourites to watch every year. I’m really glad I found your channel it’s great to see someone my age with the same niche of interests as me. Also my dad had that same Garfield plush while I was growing up and I’d love to get my own.
and here i thought Garfield: Judgement Day was gonna be able the rapture coming and Garfield having to fight his way out of the circles of hell Dante's Inferno style
Any regrets? "Garfield maybe"
-Bill Murray
Manuel my favorite line from “Zombieland”
Yes.
*Bill Murray, as Bill Murray
@@josephikrakowski1137 Bill Murray's delivery is so great
A fellow Zombielander, I see
“Garfield, we gotta save the universe!”
“Jon, I’m a cat.”
Isn’t it “We gotta save the *_universe,_* Garfield!”
“john i’m a cat”
garfield pickle
*Garfield sits there as the world gets obliterated*
"Let me serve you Jon's lasagne"
Makes me thing of that quote from the guys who made the Cats stage musical. “Hal, it’s about cats.”
The addition of
“Elaborate on that”
“No”
literally made me crack up so damn hard
A lot of good Lynch references in this one.
Same, and youtube videos rarely have that effect on me.
With all this context it's no wonder Bill Waterson refused to adapt Calvin and Hobbes
Disney and Pixar werr close though. Watterson was open to animated media but that was about it and the only reason he changed his mind was due to his insistence on not wanting to hear what Calvin would sound like as that would ruin the point of making up your own voices for the characters
All I’m certain of is that the voice of Calvin would be Tara Strong. I can’t think of anyone else’s voices
@@mikeholcomb9013 me too, even as a kid I always pictured a "Timmy Turner" voice
@@mikeholcomb9013 I hear him more as a Grey Delisle kind of person.
Someone with a more pompus voice
Or just use a real kid VA...
Me: *opens video* maybe I'll enjoy this one idk
Quinton: June 2009, Garfield holds a woman at gunpoint
This is the content I live and breathe for
End of the roadie mister odie
I had watched a lot of this guys videos before this, but that intro is what got me to subscribe.
A Choking Fish I remember one of those week long series in the funnies where Garfield literally kicks Odie into next week and like he’s just above them for a few days until falling back down. That was locked away in the recesses of my mind but now I’ve remembered it so ty for that 😂
Something like this seems like an online cartoon.
garfield pickle
Garfield before: Hmmmm Lasagna
Garfield now: *Heaven is void of light, Jon. I'm Eternal, Jon*
Is your profile picture inflation fetish art
@@mynameismmandimheretosay7979 Wat
Looks like somebody doesn't know their rule34slang and e621isms.
He just updated it so my joke is now ruined
@@mynameismmandimheretosay7979 f
Endgame Spoilers: Garfield defeated Thanos and used the infinity gaunlet to snap Mondays out of existence.
the scene of him kickin Odie for the Soul Stone is gut wrenching
Remember when Batman tried to stop Garfeild from earasing monday.It was so sad when we had to see Gatfield shoot is life long friend.
Cant believe Garfield betrays john by stealing his girl
But if he snapped away Mondays, then wouldn't Tuesdays become the new Mondays?
These are good comments.
One thing I always found weird about the live-action Garfield movies was the fact that Garfield himself is the only cartoonish character while all the other animals are realistic and don't even resemble their cartoon counterparts at all. Not even Odie is cartoonish, he's just a normal real life dog.
Also, is it bad that I actually _want_ to see Garfield's Judgement Day as a legitimate Garfield movie? It sounds like a more surreal and somewhat philosophical version of Barnyard, and certainly sounds far better than the Bill Murray films.
Completely agree. Garfield resembling his cartoon self, but Odie, Arlene and Nermal doesn't is really strange.
Yeah, Garfield's Judgment Day would've been awesome. Why do you think it's bad that you want to see it? It isn't.
@@abdullahibouraleh6919 Odie being realistic and not cartoonish is ESPECIALLY baffling given how much of a core character he is to the franchise, but I have a feeling they just didn't care one bit when making this movie.
i always found it so weird how different Nermal and Arlene look too... like i get that, if everyone but Garfield is realistic, that having a real pink cat would be weird, but Nermal? why is Nermal suddenly like, a teenager Siamese cat instead of a little grey striped kitten? even Odie kinda looks like Odie, why is it different for Nermal and Arlene? so many questions...
Not gonna lie I would totally see Garfield Judgment Day. Not because it would be good but because how bizzare and insane it would be.
No one will go into that expecting it to be good
Just go to r/imsorryjon
I LOVED "His 9 Lives" as a kid - the book, not the cartoon. I mean loved it. I must have read it a 100 times. I still get chills thinking about it. It was so darn creepy, especially because it was supposed to be a *Garfield comic* - only reason my parents let me have it at such a young age.
Watching this video and learning that Jim Davis wanted to make artsy comics but "sold out" with Garfield to become successful, it makes a lot more sense why he would have written a book like that (and those creepy Halloween strips.) But at the time, it was just some inexplicable artifact that should not exist... half of my fascination with it was the stories in it, but half was that *this was a book that simply shouldn't be.*
Levi I didn’t know you were interested in Garfield
@@chuchulovely3276 Yes Garfield is something I secretly enjoy. Wouldn't want the scouting legion to find out.
Actually Arlene is canonically homeless in the comics, too
but why
Liz G maybe her owners left
ownerless cats aren't that uncommon guys
I don't know why nobody talks about the 1989 four part garfield comic strip "alone", a tale where Garfield is allegedly abandonned, going crazy denying the fact that no one is there for him anymore
Dude I think about that one a lot
Yeah, and yet most garfield analysis I see on youtube never mention it
The implication that strip sets up - that every Garfield comic from the 90s onward was the fevered dream of a starving Garfield trapped in a derelict abandoned house - fucked with me REAL hard as a kid
Weird seeing how bogged down the comic is now compared to back then. Those Halloween strips were intense.
@@eruption257 it would explain a lot and it still fucks me up to think about that.
Jon, I require lasagna.
Jon, where is my lasagna.
Jon, I can smell your scent.
Bullets don't work, Jon.
The world is going to end, Jon.
Theres no light in heaven, Jon.
Jon, I will eat the sun, and there will never be mondays again.
DONT RUIN IT DAMI-
nice lumpytorch ref my guy 👌
@@gunkwizardry slash William Burke ref
How did you talk about Garfield's Nine Lives without touching on the best one??? The piano cat segment is legitimately heartbreaking, I watched Nine Lives for shits and giggles, but it made me cry my eyes out.
Yes, I remembered that. Felt more like an artsy anime than any form of content related to Garfield.
I love that short. its so beautiful
I legit wanted to call your mom up Quinton and tell her you arent going to be invited to my birthday party after school anymore when you said there wasnt anything good about this movie. That Diana part is so beautiful and intimately sad especially if you ever have loved and lost a close pet. You monster! 😭😂
"The Conquest of Lasagna" by Peter Garpotkin
that intro makes me want to see a terrible spin-off of Garfield in watchmen, preferably as doctor Manhattan
You just want to see garfield naked
@@MeMeMcsplosion B-but.. He's always naked. DUN DUN DUNNNNN
Garfield's big limp orange cock
@@MeMeMcsplosion , I'm not a republic *serial* villain. Do you really think I'd explain my *master stroke* if there remained the slightest chance of you affecting the outcome?
Garfield's been naked for 41 years
Odie-mandius
As soon as I heard the name "Garfield's
Judgement Day", I immediately thought of Terminator 2 and imagined Garfield having to team up with the T-800 and stuff like that
I thought of those awful "Left Behind" movies but with Garfield in Kirk Cameron's place
Same but I thought of Garfield seeing the world set on fire and all the people including john and odie get burned to death like in the dream part of the beginning
I turned myself into a pickle Jon Im pickle Garfield
No.
I'll turn you into vantage 3
@@myssledissle don't do that daddy uwu I'm not sorry for this comment
Ruthless
No, Garfield has obviously inhaled too much Ketamine and he is going to die ARGAGAGAGAGA
Thank you for respecting the spirit of the character by not releasing the video on a Monday
I've always loved the fact that Bill Murray voiced Garfield in the movie where as Lorenzo Music voiced Peter Venkmen in the Ghostbusters cartoon.
MBMBAM reference by any chance?
Then Bill Murray wanted him replaced as it made him sound like Garfield
Oh wow, Rick, is it like that in this reality, too?
Regardless of what Murray says, I think he knew full well about the Garfield movie and did it anyway- as a nod/apology to Lorenzo Music for Venkman.
Is Garfield an official leftist figure? Quinton, please answer this, I honestly need to know. My comrades in discord won't give me a straight answer.
I'd argue he's a product of all the failures of capitalism
Maybe... After all leftist youtuber Thought Slime made a video about the Garfield EATS app
@@Mario_Angel_Medina Right! This is partially why I think we should make Garfield a leftist figure. It's no coincidence that Thought Slime makes a video about Garfield and them the bread book makes an appearance here.
I hate Mondays because the fruits of my labor go to the bosses
Cats who hate Mondays, they've been the mascot of the IWW for like over a century
I can't believe Garfield died in End Game....
Fancy .Fancington :(
I will never get tired of this joke.
Fancy .Fancington NO SPOILERS! Lol jk I saw endgame on opening day, it’s too sad he died.
BRO I TOTALLY EXPECTED CAPTAIN NERMAL TO DIE, I WAS SO SURPRISED WHEN GARFIELD DIED! IM SO SAD RIGHT NOW!!!
DAMN YOU JHONOS
R.i.p: iron garf
I honestly really love 'Garfield His Nine Lives' (film version, never had the book) and had no idea it was so poorly regarded. I especially liked "Diana's Piano", which is very touching (and I do find it interesting that they have Garfield be unambiguously female in a previous life and make no jokes about it.) "Lab Animal" is also very good.
Yeah I loved it as a kid!
@@raisedfromash kind of like a package film reminiscent to what Disney made, right?
THIS
Quinton's obsession with Bee Movie is weird.
But justified
Don't *bee* judgemental
Nothing else to do with Bee Movie can be as strange as Bee Movie itself.
You're not ready for the rest of the internet
I thought he meant a B movie, like mediocre... 🤔
Wait, I always assumed Arlene was a stray anyway. How's that edgy? Cats are barely domesticated in the first place.
Infinity War copied Garfield's Petforce
The part of His Nine Lives that sticks with me is the reveal at the end that God is a cat, using a visual callback to the most upsetting segment of the special, which gives the reveal an unintentionally sinister undertone. As if God is a cat in His Nine Lives the same way that God is a spider in Through a Glass Darkly.
Garfield's Nine Lives SCARRED ME as a child. What the HELL Jim Davis?!
Don't forget the "Halloween series" of the syndicated strip.
@The Very Edgy Yoshi Not at all! If I had come across those comics as a mature adult with a logical brain instead of as an impressionable child with a vivid imagination, I think I would have appreciated them more. As it stands, I can't look at them without getting that little-kid-oh-no feeling in my gut.
Life no.3, 6 and 7 were trippy as hell.
The life with Diana the fluffy white piano cat is so beautiful and sad
Russo Bros: Can I copy your homework?
Pet Force director: Sure, just make it look different.
"Diana's Piano" absolutely destroyed me, like, it's impossible to watch that segment without crying
Garfield has a complex multiverse
Earth 295: Garfield Judgement Day
Earth 616: Comic Garfield
Earth 666: Lasagna Cat
Earth 1610: Garfield and Friends
Earth 2149: Gorefield
Earth 8096: The Garfield Show
Earth 199999: Garfield the movie
Earth 3313 : Fist of the b0rf star
U forgot garfielf
Which one is Gazorfazorfield?
Earths 12529-79243 are all devoted to SROMGverse timelines
Earth-3166 is the SCP universe
Soundwave petting Ravage on the shelf in the background is adorable
June, 2009.
Garfield holds a woman at gunpoint.
When did this start?
When will it end?
Only Jim knows.
And he will never tell.
Quinton Reviews is my favorite Garfield news channel.
I can't believe you talked about Garfield: His Nine Lives without discussing Diana's Piano. That made me cry every single time I watched it as a kid
Fun fact: My first introduction to Garfield was with the first Live Action movie
The second one was actually okay. I watched every night to put me to sleep for awhile.
Also reading the comics for me. Never watched the animated stuff until later
Garfield's 9 lives is my absolute favorite of the specials. I loved the different artstyle changes it felt like a nice anthology story. The piano, experiment, and jazz one being some of the most memorable ones.
It really made me uncomfortable to hear the Garfield guy describing Garfield's Pet Force as Endgame. Reay uncomfortable. Not sure why.
To me it sounded like he was reading a script aloud ad verbatim. Maybe that's why.
Because you're an MCU fanboy?
It just seemed really dry and unfunny. Main problem was you needed to have watched the movie to find the joke funny. He expects you to understand how bad it was. But I've never heard of this movie, so I have no clue what it's like.
i sorted getting creeped out when he described the last dance
I'm pretty sure he was just being sarcastic though
When I was a kid, I always thought it was weird how Odie was an actual living dog but Garfield was a creepy, animated, uncanny valley creature.
Paddington is the only good Garfield/smurfs/hop-esque CGI talking animal movie
It really is.
and g-force
I love Paddington
j98 G-Force is terrible.
You would consider smurfs a talking animal movie? Not only this but you use it to define the whole genre, Your truly insane in the membrain! Come on gentlecats let’s try and suppress our zombie rage
I just discovered your channels literally the other day (I still can’t believe I watched every second of your recently uploaded “iBinged iCarly” project) and loved the abundance of Garfield paraphernalia in the background. I didn’t want to take away from the tremendous work on that project so I didn’t comment saying anything about the Garfield goodness. But I did subscribe because wow, you are talented. And now, just a few days later, the algorithm has gifted me with TWO GARFIELD VIDEOS from you. Hearing your story about how you got into Garfield comics resonated with me heavily because my poppop told me before he passed away that he was so happy to give me the comics portion of the newspaper every week just because it was a bit of a connection to the past nostalgia and a way to relate to me as a younger kid growing up in a totally different world. I got so into the comics at the time, unknowingly, for the same reason - as a way to relate to him. Media is wild. Keep up the great work! - with love, new fan
Jim Davis really snapped, didn’t he?!
Says the one who opened a US acres book at the end of his segment
This Niche fanservice makes me feel too happy.
Here's how Judgement Day should have gone:
"Jon, animal law says I can't talk to you but I literally do not care about that. There's a storm or something, pack up the lasagna and I'll meet you in the car."
Yeah! And then by kiddy cartoon contrivance, if Jim Davis wants to get his status quo reset at the end, all he has to do is make Jon have an accident that causes him some amnesia- maybe he opens a closet and the junk inside topples on his head or a tree falls on him or jokey electrocution gag, typical 90s /Gilligans Island cliche fare...and Jon wakes up, saying "WOW Garfield! I just had the silliest kooky dream! You and Odie could TALK, isn't that silly??"
That sultry Garfield dance tho
Ngl made me a lil uncomfortable xd
My idea for a Garfield movie: they visit John's parents farm, Garfield learns to get along with the other animals, and Jon finds out Lyman got hired as a farmhand and they become friends again. Yes its simple, BUT its light and harmless.
Garfeilds Judgement day would have been a good change of pace and make Garfeild have something going for him agianst other comic strips. Garfeild was always missing that IMO. Its a shame it was scraped for being to dark. The movie would have probably be longer than the book
I'm so glad you talked about Garfield: His 9 lives. I watched it when I was 7, and even then I could tell how intensely weird it was. I only found out about it again recently, and up to that point, it always felt more like a half-remembered fever dream than something that actually aired on TV.
You didn't mention the best movie of them all... Sex Survey Results (February 23, 2017)
At least the Pipe Strip got ample recognition
Jon Arbuckle, 2
@@toaster9922 Jon Arbuckle, 0
Couple of jems in there, left it going for 4 hours doing housework .
Anime Weedlord, 420
Why does the Garfield writer keep trying to make him a Stanley Kubrick protagonist???
Elaborate on that.
@@lyleabner2475 No
@@unnamed7485 Yes.
@@lyleabner2475 deadpan and stares at the screen fir a long time
I was born on June 16th. I share a birthday with superhero Garfield movie. Good.
It was genuinely so refreshing to see this in my sub box amongst all the dramatic bs that's going on at the moment. No emotionally manipulative overreacting to petty crap, just content that I am so ready to spend 20 minutes discovering I am super interested in despite never having thought about it before in my life.
Comrade Quinton reviews the bread book and single-handedly carries out the glorious anarchist revolution when?
Capital>>>>>>>>>bread book
@@ronanjm that's not very left unity of you
"anarchist"
"revolution"
Pick one.
@Ryan Kruse authoritarian communism is just capitalism with a red hat. Left unity with libertarian communists always
Actually y'all, Marx thought that the state was an extension of the capitalist society he wanted to dismantle, leaders are just another part of the hiearchy
“The Garden” worked better in the book, probably because of the delicate airbrush art and being able to imagine the narrator sounding like whatever you want.
Did Quinton make a video about Endgame without making a video about Endgame?
I am BEGGING YOU to talk about the connections between Garfield and Communism
Okay!
I am a communist, I am more than excited
@@ilyavaschillo9631 it’s a joke genius
@@ilyavaschillo9631 so having everyone be equal is a plague
@@ilyavaschillo9631 i’m not a communist, but it’s not a bad idea. It’s bad in execution because it needs very specific conditions
Conquest of Bread?
Oh shit, is Quinton a comrade?!
He's part of breadtube, yeah.
Is that why it’s called Breadtube?
@@andrewollmann304 yes
Garfield His Nine Lives has beautifully unique animated segments. I'm glad you showed the Disney quality footage from Lab Animal. I also really love the modern style in Court Musician and the painterly experimental look of Diana's Piano.
Yes! Someone online talked about "9 Lives"! I thought that I was the only one who knew :D
Anyone who had their childhood turned inside-out by that book is in a special club. The only thing that messed with my mind as much as a kid was "I am the Cheese." I still can't believe that's marketed as a YA novel.
Judgement Day isn't the only dark Garfield adaptation out there. I remember owning a book called "Garfield's Scary Tales" as a kid, which was a series of five illustrated short horror stories featuring the orange feline. Tales included a bestial midnight stalker, a woodland encounter with an axe-wielding maniac (actually the tamest of the bunch), a near-death experience involving a giant spider, a malevolent computer that drained people's minds and an unresolved psychological cliffhanger involving a monster that may or may not be real. The spider one left the biggest impression on me on account of its final illustration. Garfield inadvertently saves himself from being eaten alive by fainting on top of the spider and crushing it with his body. The reader is then treated to a grotesque image of the flattened spider, its corpse framed by a splattering of blood, guts and internal organs.
"Screw Bouguise hack Jim Davis"
-Bill Waterson... well I'm paraphrasing
Review Kropotkin
Adrian Dezendegui Well, he *did* literary call US Acres “an abomination.”
i’ve had garfield’s nine lives, the book, since i was a kid. i remember being little and feeling like i shouldn’t have this book, like i’m looking into something i shouldn’t see: garfield’s private history.
More like the Conquest of Beard haha look at that thing
Dammit, I'm gonna have to actually read theory at some point aren't I
Who needs theory when you have leftist meme pages on facebook
Who needs theory when you have funny politics man
*"Garfield holds a woman at gunpoint"* is gonna be my main sentence to use to describe Garfield
I'm seriously interested in seeing what "Garfield's Judgement Day" would have been as an animated feature. It's been bugging me for decades.
I remember reading "Garfield: His 9 Lives" a while back. That book was weird. "Tonal whiplash" is what comes to mind, but seems like quite the understatement.
“I persume that he hates himself”
Made me laugh for about a solid half a minute
"When did this start? When will it end?"
End? Nothing ends, Quinton. Nothing ever ends.
I remember watching the 3D Garfield movies when I was younger and thinking it was really weird.
Gotta be honest, Garfield His 9 Lives is a case where its worst parts are when it sticks too close to the comic. The Garden story and the Eightth Life in particular both work WAY better in the comic--the garden is genuinely kind of heartwarming there, but in the animated special its just saccharine and tedious, and being animated inherently spoils the ending gag of Life Eight--its just so much funnier when the joke is "Panel A: Garfield says one thing--Cut to Panel B where he's saying the opposite," whereas the cartoon gives too much padding and ruins it.
.... But I will never brook criticism of Diana's Piano. That bit makes the whole movie worth it.
Also, any Megaman Legends fans here who think that ship Garfield pilots on his last life looks a lot like the Flutter?
Another Garfield video from Quinton. The best birthday gift I could ask for.
Christopher White Happy late Birthday
@@clean310 Oh it'll happen eventually so can do, buddy.
@@keepyourshoesathedoor Thank you!
Happy birthday
I love Garfield's Nine Lives, the part about the cat dying was actually really sad
I’m a simple man. I see Garfield, I click
I'm about 9 minutes in, and I need to tell you how deeply it's shaken me to my core to see Garfield dance to Audrey's Dance, then get suckerpunched by your mention of Conquest of Bread and Garfield media in the same sentence. I'm dissociating now, Quinton. I love all 3 of those things, but, somehow, at the same time, it's... removing me from this plane.
Pet Force is just really a watered down version of Infinity War
PixelKnight 076
No, infinity war is just a watered down version of pet force
Oh god when you mentioned ‘Garfield’s 9 Lives’ a memory just came out of nowhere
"I FEEL GOOD , I KNOW THAT I WOULD NOW "
- Garfield
The dark stories of realistic cat Garfield are so awesome. I would love a series on just those.
Did not expect a Game Grumps shoutout in the opening.
I finally found it
The only person on youtube who Unironically deeply analyses the Garfield Movies
Garfield was my childhood waifu
I swear that this ain't a joke
what
What.
I'd make a furry joke, but garfield isnt even one, he's just straight up a cat
please tell me you arent into cats like that
XamiNaxamis I mean he is kind of anthropomorphic, as he walks on his hind legs and acts like a human, but it’s kind of stretching it
Maybe it's the fu**-me eyes.
I unironically love the fully-CGI Garfield movie trilogy. I think it has interesting stories, exciting action scenes, emotional moments, and a great soundtrack. I wish more people talked about it.
It’s so weird that Bill Murray from Meatballs and Caddyshack feels like a different time than Garfield Bill Murray and another time from Wes Anderson Bill Murray
Avengers Endgame: We’re the greatest superhero movie of all time
Garfield Pet Force: I’m about to end this man’s whole career
THIS UPLOAD SCHEDULE IS UNSETTLING ME
I remember reading the Garfield judgement day book when I was young. Confused me a lot honestly
The heck, why Garfield suddenly go all Plague Dogs In is
That's what I thought too.
but you ONLY ever talked about the modern Garfield movies, the older ones actually do capture the spirit of garfield!
The Garfield holiday specials are my favourites to watch every year. I’m really glad I found your channel it’s great to see someone my age with the same niche of interests as me. Also my dad had that same Garfield plush while I was growing up and I’d love to get my own.
I know I’ve seen at least one Garfield movie, but I definitely don’t remember anything about it except for Jennifer Love Hewitt.
Does anyone notice he has an Odd1sout Garfild plushie
For some reason, there was a period of my life where Garfield the Movie was up there alongside Toy Story and Shrek for me.
I was a weird kid.
“June 2009, Garfield holds a woman at gun point.”
and here i thought Garfield: Judgement Day was gonna be able the rapture coming and Garfield having to fight his way out of the circles of hell Dante's Inferno style
Garfield movie and the tail of two kitties were timeless masterpieces and I think they should make the third one that was planned
“This is a transition to another part of the video” I laughed inside.
8:44 - best moment of the whole review. God-tier editing and timing
Just realized that Secret Life of Pets is basically the Garfield movie without Garfield
Funny how the Sonic movie ended up being really good
Somebody get Jim Davis a Kickstarter for this his judgment day movie
Garfield Pet Force > Avengers
Garfield a tail of two kitties is a cinematic masterpiece that will be worshipped in the future.