Dominika Cheatbulkova - zero class, zero sportsmanship, a player not worth any respect at all in that particular situation. How she dares saying it should be 0-40 when she saw the ball going in?
@@alejandromottalopez6153 Hsieh lost 4-6 1-6. EDIT: In the very next Slam (US Open) she actually lost 6-7 6-4 4-6 against Cheatbulkova. I claimed she won because I looked up at stevegtennis which has bugs :/
i'm not saying that cibulkova is the fairest player ever, but in her defence, i can imagine she didn't remember that hsieh hit the ball inside the court. all she thinks about at that moment is her own return and the challenge. i think it's possible she had no idea where hsieh hit that shot
@@lukaswiesinger8689 She can not interfere and if umpire asks her, she can tell that she remembers as net but not sure. I hv seen more or less same sight from Juli Georges against Hercog. Even Hercog was fully right, Georges interfered and asked Hercog to move on with referee's decision.
For the first one, why doesn't the umpire or supervisor just ask 2 or 3 of the lines people or ball people if they saw her return go inside. It's so simple.
@@BWcapture - Yes, informally ask line judges to help with their observations (because they are accredited & trusted officials), but ultimate responsibility for deciding matters of fact (about what happened) goes to the chair umpire. This umpire is incompetent, but her call must stand. Ball kids are technically spectators. Spectators are prohibited from interfering with umpiring decisions. Referee can judge on matters of law but not override the umpire on matters of fact. This whole incident goes against the Rules of Tennis.
lets be honest for a second this cibulkova player was very disgusting i have to tell you...Shell knew the ball was in in her part after de referee called out the other one before
@@colesmith7509 I could but it wouldn't be that interesting to be honest. If I remember correctly, she spoke up in her match against Sabalenka in Birmingham 2019, against Tomljanovic in Seoul 2019 and quite a few matches in Hiroshima 2019. She and the Taiwanese tennis federation don't get along too well because of her 'outspokeness'. That's why I love her, she beats to her own drum and plays own style of tennis, has no sponsors because she doesn't want to be controlled. I feel also there is some tension between her and Latisha Chan (fellow Taiwanese Grand slam champion) as well.
The fact that Cibulkova didn't intervene and stand behind the truth, tells me what kind of character she has. You know the rules, be honest and a good sportsman. Geez. Respect the game and your opponent.
Or at least stay out of it. What garbage sportsmanship. Why can’t the ump just ask for a video replay? This is what makes them so useless. The sport doesn’t need these people anymore, yet they still have jobs just like in baseball.
It is not Cibulkova's responsibility to speak for her opponent or do the Chair Umpire's job for her. Cibulkova's objective is to win. Would it have been "nice" if she "set it straight?" Of course. But this is not on Cibulkova. This is an embarrassing display by the chair umpire, and she deserves 100% of the responsibility for the situation she put herself and the players in.
@@MH3GL Cibulkova isn’t obligated to do the morally right thing, and she was also not obligated to do the morally wrong thing of lying about the play to sway the umpire’s decision. Don’t conflate the umpire’s actions with Cibulkova’s, because the umpire is just trying to do her job, however poorly she might be doing it.
@@kh2freek if the chair umpire had done her job, and made the correct call, none of this would have been an issue. To insinuate that the chair umpire could be "swayed" by Cibulkova's response is to call into to question the integrity of the umpire, because the umpire is supposed to be IMPARTIAL, and should not be making her decisions based on the opinion of the players, but on the happenings occurring on the court. So, are you telling me that you wish to call the umpire's integrity into question?
@@milliehayes Hawkeye only shows where the ball bounced. Tennis does not yet allow instant replay for sequence-of-event plays like this where the umpire needs a video to understand what happened. They have trialed something like that at the ATP Cup so I would guess it’s coming soon.
@@kh2freek I’m afraid that’s false. Hawkeye does not actually show where the ball bounced. It is a model that estimates where it bounced within a margin of error (this is not the same thing). It is probably more reliable than line judges eyes but not necessarily ’right’ all the time. I wish the commentators would admit that it is not a factual replay but a good estimate that’s better than not having it. High def SLO mo replays would show that some Hawkeye calls are actually wrong, so when it’s showing incredibly fine margins as ‘facts’ it is misleading. A fuzzy grey line / margin of error would be better, but doesn’t give the binary answer that tennis wants.
The Umpire made a mistake, don't blame it on her. If the Umpire says she don't remember or thought it was net then there was technicallly no ground on changing the initial call even tho it was incorrect. Umpire can't rely on video nor supervisor to make this kind of calls. Changing décision was wrong on a purely legal point of vue. All my sympathy to Hsieh of course. She was absolutly right with the initial call. But don't bring hate on Cibulkova it was not her responsability.
@@sampaio True. But sehr refused to give an honest answer when she was asked. She Made the choice to lie and refuse to replay because that happened to her earlier. She even Said this in the Press conference. This ist Low character even though the empire shouldnt have changed her call. Sportmanship makes this call and she has None.
@@unknownpixels9521 what good would it make ? Interviewers shouldn't have ask the question to her in the first place nor the Umpire. All sportsmans are biaised and maybe she doesnt remember clearly as did the Umpire ?So what, it's not her job to do so. I'm under the impression that people are always searching for a scapegoat to funel angryness on theses social networks. Creating artificial reasons for it.
@@sampaio what? Of course the Interviewer asked her that question, IT was the Highlight of the Match. There are plenty of scenes were Players showed sportmanship and Fairplay. Everything would have eben fine when she didnt intervene with the empires but she was asked and Lied because she experienced disadvantages in the past which she Denied all the sudden in the interview.no need of a scapegoat, she showed poor sportmanship and was greedy for a point, nothing big but nonetheless a disgusting trait since she fought for her lie.
I think it is because the umpire make a mistake on a "fact", not a "judgement". If it is about a judgement then the supervisor can do nothing but respect the judgement.
@@romnt Again, English isn't a language that you have to know how to speak to give an argument. Him calling someone dumb because of someone's lack of reasoning is truly valuable even if you speak other languages. Can't tell if you're a troll or if you're serious.
we are in a tennis match video... british start to see who "speaks" better in a COMMENT section... explains everything in the video... btw english is not my first language even if it was this is a youtube comment not a fucking english test so stfu... dam polite people... xD
Wow, how on earth Cibulkova can try and steal that point. An absolute disgrace. Any other (and I mean like 99.9% of players) would’ve just said “she’s right”
Cibulkova is so sly. Everyone saw that this point belonged to Hsieh but she tried to outsmart the whole world. I'm so glad that she's retired. Maybe I'm a little bit cruel but justice is the main thing on the planet
She's stupid like that. All the tools in the world she COULD HAVE been using, but it's all in the brains, you know. That 'I know better' attitude, high horse umpire are just the WORST. They should really change some of these extreme umpires that make too many mistakes.
@@rodrickdubose659 But still, they are umpires as well, a team with the chair umpire so if a chair umpire can ask a linesman for an opinion on lines surely can ask opinion about anything because they are all a team which is paid and approved by atp /wta?
“I’ve never had this happen to me in my entire career!” 5 seconds later: “I’ve had this happen to me SO MANY times!” 2 seconds later: “I’ve never had this happen to me NEVER!” Uhh which is it??
Cibulkova could just pretended she didn't see anything but she tried to interfere the discussion by calling Hsieh's return was in the net. Seriously? I didn't even notice that when I was watching this match. Thank you for uploading this video.
She is a total liar when she said this situation happned so many times to her and she always gave the points to the opponents. Those people should not play professional sports, bad apples.
She really is. So many of these videos that include her. She is a disgrace to the sport and it wouldn't surprise me if she was corrupt. Besides the bad sportsmanship shown by cibulkova( so glad this bitch retired now) zhang should be fired and banned from the sport forever
Here the situation is entirely caused by Zhang "forgetting" where the ball landed, or not paying enough attention to the return that clearly landed in the middle of the court. BUT, she has made several correct calls on previous videos on this channel, so calling her "the worst" or a "disgrace" is a bit much even though she butchered it in this clip.
The irony about this is that this is like the first time I have seen a supervisor overrule a chair umpire, in this case the overrule was completely right because the chair was completely wrong and Cibulkova still has the balls to claim she got the short end on this one. WHAT BS
Man... The one with Mahut being beaten, it's just so bad... reminds me of the viral video circulating a few years ago about that goalkeeper stopping all penalty kicks with the face.
I am from Slovakia, we tend to really appreciate pro athletes since we don't have many but Cibulkova is very unpopular here as well. She is extremely arrogant, full of herself, always makes stupid comments, wears expensive fur coats from foxes etc. Nobody likes her
Primitiv252 Bulo shows that she trash wannabe. She should have really focused on her tennis, blame less people, treat people with respect and then maybe she would have been more successful in her career. Throwing tantrums, cheating, treating people like crap and talking utter bullshit about other players has brought her own failure. It’s an incredible achievement to be where she was in the tennis world but she could have achieved greater success had she kept her head and attitude in check and not in the clouds or in this case, gutter.
It's unbelievable to me that Cibulkova didn't cut this problem short by simply telling the truth. She's acting somewhat irritated and it's her OWN fault. Clearly she's trying to steal this point. Shame on her! 😡
As an umpire how do you forget what happened literally 10 seconds ago? Yet players get fined for yelling expletives while umpires get no punishment for their mistakes.
its obvious that Cibulkova tried her luck, the empire made a mistake. Even afterwards Cibulkova had no sportsmanship in her interview, saying dont know they were speaking in they're own language, like that's the reason the point got taken off! And where has it happened to her so many times, she's claiming?
EXACTLY! The conversation was mostly in english with probably less than 10 words in Chinese. And even when they were conversing in Chinese they said nothing that wasn't previously said in english. They were just repeating.
@@myerklamb8529 Racist? You'd better learn meaning of the word before writing it. The official language is English, so speaking in Chinese could be considered as an attempt to unfairly impact on umpires' decision. It seemed she wanted to hide something from the opponent. Although, Hsu was right.
9:48 the fact that she can say - and actually wholehartedly believe, apparently - that she is a fair minded player, after that totally irrational, hard-headed and self centered argument. Wow!
Looooool at Cibulková being the only person in the stadium who say the ball “hit the net” then have the audacity to say she was treated unfairly. Happy retirement to her :) she deserves it
@@mecool9897 there isnt a rule about that, you cant just make a random rule yourself but there is var in the next gen finals, which could be implemented in other tournaments in the future
up until the atp cup there was no facility to ask for a replay.. its to protect the officials from terrible and incompetent calls ... now, because they will be fired it seems its ok to review every single thing they say and do..
Come on just give the referee a tablet or some sort of device to watch replays, the whole matter would be resolved in six seconds instead of six minutes
Cibulkova's post-match interview: "I'm a fair player" (proceeds to argue that because she's been the victim of wrong calls at times in her life, she doesn't deserve to be robbed of the opportunity to profit from an umpire failing to notice that Hsieh's return was over & in by at least 15 feet, distraction or not. So this is what goes into her tally of "wrong calls" she's been the victim of. Mahut got a bit testy, took it out on the (absolutely correct) umpire.
I remember up until a few years back Cibulkova was one of my favourite players. I went off her because of her unsportsmanlike, cheating conduct during matches. I can't stand her now. Absolutely zero class!
@@LoosSerine Dude its literally her JOB if she cant do it then just retire from beeing a referee. Coute: I cant remember! How the heck cant an referee dont remember the last Point played? Even everyone in the Audience saw that + she has Linesmen to back her up.
@@thefirstk6331 I don't think you watch or play enough tennis to know how difficult it is to see, especially at lower level tournaments. Also, the problem is that players often cheat and try to undermine the umpire, you stating the umpire should ignore another player (even though she was cheating) over another could be inferred as bias.
@@fgdh2460 Dude did you even watch the Video? The Problem was not the mistake himself the problem was how she handled it afterwards and not beeing able to remember the last played point on the biggest Tennis Tournament out there is more then an siple mistake.
If I was Hsieh , I wouldn’t be as patient with umpire J. Zhang ! Gurlllll you can’t just say you don’t REMEMBER the part where she hit the ball back in the court. You have ONE job and that’s to pay attention to the match.
And she had the audacity to say they were talking in “Chinese or whatever language” as if that’s the reason they changed the decision? What a disgraceful joke, Cibulkova
The funniest part is that if you speak Chinese, Hsieh was basically repeating the same things she was saying in English. Literally didn’t affect the call at all. Cibulkova’s such a bad sport.
Definition of a great youtube channel like yours: although you know you will probably getting striked from Wimblecrydon you still upload this beautiful series. Good job buddy
At 8:05 when she say "this" she means the case of an umpire that changed its call because a player argued never happened to her, she completes the sentence at 8:10 but you ignore it. At 9:35 she says that the same point happened to her many times and the umpire haven't changed the decision, just reinforcing her first statement, there's nothing contradicting between the two statements, you just understood them wrong.
She has never been in a position where it takes six minutes for an umpire to put her foot down. But she has been in positions where she just had to deal with an umpires decision that wasn't in her favour. That's why she was like:"stick to your decision, you're the umpire!" And I also would not appreciate Hsieh conversing in Chinese. Puts the umpire in a very awkward position. If I were the umpire, I would just say: I did not see it land. The ball is called in. If you don't agree I can bring the supervisor but it won't make a difference. End of discussion.
It’s great to see how Hsieh was able to stand her ground and fight for her right assertively 👍. On the other hand, the opponent, who claimed she got treated unfairly so many times, not only hesitated to clarify the fact for Hsieh, but also challenged the decision of replay. She has neither empathy nor sportsmanship in her 😡.
This is the hazard of standing too close to the net in doubles. Ive been criticized for the opposite ie standing too close to the service line (end of the service box) in doubles BUT it gives me half to one full second MORE time to react and hit a confident or well placed return instead of getting jammed up trying to defend myself against slammers. My husband and i won the spring mxd doubles event (all age group) recently in a good sized club and no one critiqued me after that; which consisted of 8 matches.
Horrible umpiring by J Zhang and absolute lies by Cibulkova. I used to like her but not anymore. Hsieh hit the ball back into the court, replay the point, Cibulkova kept insisting Hsieh hit the ball in the net. Horrible umpiring as well, good job by supervisor to enforce replaying the point.
I feel so bad for laughing at the guy who kept getting hit. The chances of it happening over and over are so small and you know the opponents didn’t mean any of them. Poor dude, I hope he wasn’t bruised too badly. I’ll just laugh at the unfortunate circumstances from afar
Is Cibulkova actually trying to say the ball hit the net, after all that? And then saying it was unfair?? If so, that's probably the most unsportsmanlike thing I've ever seen, in any sport.
Incidentally, Cibulkova was Cirstea's opponent too in that famous streak of 6 successful Hawkeye challenges that the Romanian had in just one set. In one of those challenges, the call was reverted by the referee in Sorana's favour after a similar, very lengthy argument. She instinctively raised her finger to chalenge but when heard the umpire call the ball long, pointed out to Cirstea that the umpire called it out. Fair player. 🤔
I'm kind of new to tennis but watching some of these bad decisions by the umpires is bewildering, I mean how hard can it be to umpire a tennis match. Also, don't they have some kind of VR system to replay the video back if they need to?
@@1998rg It doesnt matter if it is a line call in that particular situation the Problem here is that the Referee is such garbage and didnt saw that the ball did go in the court she thought that Hsieh missed the ball so with the Challange the Referee would had seen that the ball was in the Court the idea of the Main Comment is pretty good.
Thank you Tennis Advocate for putting subtitles (I guess I don't know what to call it) in this video because usually in videos like this there are none
The whole concept of “sportsmanship” seems to be a thing of the past. Standing back and watching an opponent argue with the umpire while you try to take a point that you didn’t win is disgusting. Cibulkova isn’t quite as loathsome as Kyle Edmund, who stole a break point by getting away with an obvious double-bounce, but she’s in his general neighborhood.
Honestly though sometimes you dig for a short ball and your eyes aren’t even on the ball anymore. You can’t tell if the ball bounced twice or not. If it were me I’d have taken any decision, especially after speculation, bc maybe I didn’t see.
Are we really not going to talk about Mahut getting hit hard 3 times? It’s like that soccer video with the umpire getting hit in the face every shot on goal 😂😂.
It's so ridiculous that they couldn't just use the video replay to review it back and move on. Of course if Shitbulkova was a decent human being she would've confirmed that the ball was in and have the point replayed.
Hsieh continued playing despite the wrong „out“ call of the linesman, and she successfully returned the ball. Cibulkova stopped playing, and therefore she deserved to LOSE the point, and not to win it as she contends. Replaying the point was a fair decision, but Cibulkova unfortunately did not see the truth in that, and believes that she should have been awarded the point, although is was she, and not Hsieh who stopped playing. Unfair, tunnel vision !
Hsieh is right , if the chair umpire couldnt remember it, it is Her Freaking problem ! Hsieh did not lose the point , she put the ball back to the other side, how could she possibly lose the point, what a Joke, what an Umpire !
11:00 Is this for real?! It seems like it is like those videos where that one guy is the goalie for soccer and gets hit all the time and in volleyball too LOL
Have you ever been hit by a tennis ball that close? It fucking hurts! The ball is small too so the hit is concentrated. He got hit right in the forehead!
Hsieh was right to call for Referee,Good call by Referee,Bad sportsmanship from opposite player, so much time wasted in arguments when tech could have resolved it in seconds
Everyone here are so happy to hate Cibulkova and claim she cheated or lied, but When looking at the replay you can see that when the ball pass over the net and hit the court(6:18) Cibulkova is raising her hand for a challenge and looking directly at the umpire and not the at the ball, look at 0:06, even when the ball rolls on the ground she doesn't look at it but on the umpire and then she looks forward at Hsieh, she didn't looked at the ball even for a split second the entire time, she could have really didn't see if it was net or inside the court because her attention was to the umpire, when asked she didn't said she saw it was net, watch at 5:54, she says the umpire or the lines judge said that it was net. Cibulkova's only claim was that the umpire made a call, and after she made the call she can't change it just because the player argues, the umpire didn't said she was wrong on her call, she said she doesn't remember what happened and then she said she didn't saw where the ball landed, so Cibulkova said that on that basis the umpire can't just change her first call, she didn't cheat, she didn't lied, all of the insults and names people are calling her here are not justified, it may not nice to hear but she's right, if the umpire didn't know for certain that her call was wrong she needed to stick with her first call.
Seriously. How do you have the technology to follow the ball and spot within a centimeter whether it hit the line but can't just watch a 10 second video replay? Which we all saw a dozen times while they were gabbing about it.
@@christopherborum6551 As a tennis official myself, VAR has been introduced lately to the next gen tournaments and seems pretty good. Personally, I don't think it will take much for it to become a standard. It should be a standard for every sport that exists.... If a referee can go to the monitor and have a second pair of eyes (and 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th.... in case of multiple camera angles...) it would be great for everyone. Fans, coaches, players, officials... :-)
Dominika Cheatbulkova - zero class, zero sportsmanship, a player not worth any respect at all in that particular situation. How she dares saying it should be 0-40 when she saw the ball going in?
totally agree. And how that match ended?
@@alejandromottalopez6153 Hsieh lost 4-6 1-6.
EDIT: In the very next Slam (US Open) she actually lost 6-7 6-4 4-6 against Cheatbulkova. I claimed she won because I looked up at stevegtennis which has bugs :/
What a huge lie! Disgrace, she will regret for this moment all of her life.
i'm not saying that cibulkova is the fairest player ever, but in her defence, i can imagine she didn't remember that hsieh hit the ball inside the court. all she thinks about at that moment is her own return and the challenge.
i think it's possible she had no idea where hsieh hit that shot
@@lukaswiesinger8689 She can not interfere and if umpire asks her, she can tell that she remembers as net but not sure. I hv seen more or less same sight from Juli Georges against Hercog. Even Hercog was fully right, Georges interfered and asked Hercog to move on with referee's decision.
Cibulkova "I am a fair player"
No girl,you are not
omg,such bad sportmanship
For the first one, why doesn't the umpire or supervisor just ask 2 or 3 of the lines people or ball people if they saw her return go inside. It's so simple.
Yeah but she dummy thicc so it's alright
Horrible person that one. I agree with you 1 zillion percent.
@@BWcapture - Yes, informally ask line judges to help with their observations (because they are accredited & trusted officials), but ultimate responsibility for deciding matters of fact (about what happened) goes to the chair umpire. This umpire is incompetent, but her call must stand. Ball kids are technically spectators. Spectators are prohibited from interfering with umpiring decisions. Referee can judge on matters of law but not override the umpire on matters of fact. This whole incident goes against the Rules of Tennis.
lets be honest for a second this cibulkova player was very disgusting i have to tell you...Shell knew the ball was in in her part after de referee called out the other one before
I’ve never seen the clip of Hsieh. That’s that first time I’ve ever seen her complain and she was completely right
Did the umpire get fired? This is bad.
Hsieh is pretty outspoken when she knows something is wrong or when she knows something is injust, I've seen her speak up a handful of times.
@@curt8806 Did she got fired ? ... hmm ... "I don't remember" ... 🤣
@@TennisAdvocate oh I had no idea... could you make a compilation of Hsieh being right lol
@@colesmith7509 I could but it wouldn't be that interesting to be honest. If I remember correctly, she spoke up in her match against Sabalenka in Birmingham 2019, against Tomljanovic in Seoul 2019 and quite a few matches in Hiroshima 2019. She and the Taiwanese tennis federation don't get along too well because of her 'outspokeness'. That's why I love her, she beats to her own drum and plays own style of tennis, has no sponsors because she doesn't want to be controlled. I feel also there is some tension between her and Latisha Chan (fellow Taiwanese Grand slam champion) as well.
The fact that Cibulkova didn't intervene and stand behind the truth, tells me what kind of character she has. You know the rules, be honest and a good sportsman. Geez. Respect the game and your opponent.
She's awful player lied and disrespectful to her opponent and to herself as well she's not worth mention it ever
Or at least stay out of it. What garbage sportsmanship. Why can’t the ump just ask for a video replay? This is what makes them so useless. The sport doesn’t need these people anymore, yet they still have jobs just like in baseball.
It is not Cibulkova's responsibility to speak for her opponent or do the Chair Umpire's job for her. Cibulkova's objective is to win. Would it have been "nice" if she "set it straight?" Of course. But this is not on Cibulkova. This is an embarrassing display by the chair umpire, and she deserves 100% of the responsibility for the situation she put herself and the players in.
@@MH3GL Cibulkova isn’t obligated to do the morally right thing, and she was also not obligated to do the morally wrong thing of lying about the play to sway the umpire’s decision. Don’t conflate the umpire’s actions with Cibulkova’s, because the umpire is just trying to do her job, however poorly she might be doing it.
@@kh2freek if the chair umpire had done her job, and made the correct call, none of this would have been an issue. To insinuate that the chair umpire could be "swayed" by Cibulkova's response is to call into to question the integrity of the umpire, because the umpire is supposed to be IMPARTIAL, and should not be making her decisions based on the opinion of the players, but on the happenings occurring on the court.
So, are you telling me that you wish to call the umpire's integrity into question?
Why doesn’t Wimbledon (and all the Opens for that matter) , simply have an instant replay when there is a dispute between the linesman and the umpire?
Isn't that Hawkeye?
@@milliehayes Hawkeye only shows where the ball bounced. Tennis does not yet allow instant replay for sequence-of-event plays like this where the umpire needs a video to understand what happened. They have trialed something like that at the ATP Cup so I would guess it’s coming soon.
cause they need to be smarter
@@kh2freek I’m afraid that’s false. Hawkeye does not actually show where the ball bounced. It is a model that estimates where it bounced within a margin of error (this is not the same thing). It is probably more reliable than line judges eyes but not necessarily ’right’ all the time. I wish the commentators would admit that it is not a factual replay but a good estimate that’s better than not having it. High def SLO mo replays would show that some Hawkeye calls are actually wrong, so when it’s showing incredibly fine margins as ‘facts’ it is misleading. A fuzzy grey line / margin of error would be better, but doesn’t give the binary answer that tennis wants.
Yeah but then we dont get oscar worthy dramas like this..
"Sorry, I din't remember that part." This is most atrocious thing I've ever heard.
Yeah its literally her Job no offence but she should be fired watching this is so horrible dafuq.
I you cant remember then ask another official ..... duh ! chair umpires need refs to keep it honest and fair. And computers have glitches too
I cringed so hard watching that
Exactly this type of stuff does not depend on your freaking memory if you can’t rmb that’s ur problem
Umpire you have one job.
Cibulkova: "I'm a fair player"
Also Cibulkova: **refuses to replay a point she was mistakenly awarded with**
The Umpire made a mistake, don't blame it on her. If the Umpire says she don't remember or thought it was net then there was technicallly no ground on changing the initial call even tho it was incorrect. Umpire can't rely on video nor supervisor to make this kind of calls. Changing décision was wrong on a purely legal point of vue.
All my sympathy to Hsieh of course. She was absolutly right with the initial call. But don't bring hate on Cibulkova it was not her responsability.
@@sampaio True. But sehr refused to give an honest answer when she was asked. She Made the choice to lie and refuse to replay because that happened to her earlier. She even Said this in the Press conference. This ist Low character even though the empire shouldnt have changed her call. Sportmanship makes this call and she has None.
@@unknownpixels9521 what good would it make ? Interviewers shouldn't have ask the question to her in the first place nor the Umpire. All sportsmans are biaised and maybe she doesnt remember clearly as did the Umpire ?So what, it's not her job to do so. I'm under the impression that people are always searching for a scapegoat to funel angryness on theses social networks. Creating artificial reasons for it.
@@sampaio what? Of course the Interviewer asked her that question, IT was the Highlight of the Match. There are plenty of scenes were Players showed sportmanship and Fairplay. Everything would have eben fine when she didnt intervene with the empires but she was asked and Lied because she experienced disadvantages in the past which she Denied all the sudden in the interview.no need of a scapegoat, she showed poor sportmanship and was greedy for a point, nothing big but nonetheless a disgusting trait since she fought for her lie.
I'm a fair player, Really
Jesus cibulkova is a horrible sport and a compulsive liar. Also imagine if that umpire did a Kyrgios match.....
Although he usually acts fine with female umpires but if Murphy made such a call lol
Kyrgios would've gone home probably
"I DON'T REMEMBER !?" That umpire should be sacked and the blonde player would carry-on in the same way but worse.
that umpire should be removed, even someonme who learned the rules yesterday couldo better.
Add the Ref and that’s a ménage a trios car wreck in full view of international tennis.
Cibulkova's ignorance to Hsieh's argument is definitely considered as cheating as well.
"It never happened to me in my career"
"It happened to me so many times"
I know- just pick one for crying out loud 😆
No, what happened to her lots of times is getting the unfair call. What never happened to her is the umpire reversing the decision
@@ivanschweizer9146 no what happened is that she got caught and tangled in her lies.
Such a clown
@@ivanschweizer9146 only sensible comment I've seen in this comments section.
Cibulkova: " I aM a FaIr PLayEr" lmao
She is the absolute worst. I'm glad she retired.
She is a fat cheater
She is a cheater
The only word for her is Bitch
@Azshishchenkovy Andreyuskins mate, your name looks like when a cat walks across a keyboard
This is like the first time the supervisor has actually ever done anything :O *applause*
I think it is because the umpire make a mistake on a "fact", not a "judgement".
If it is about a judgement then the supervisor can do nothing but respect the judgement.
Yeah the judgment was that she couldn't remember lol.
Because that umpire is ridiculously bad
Classic Karen
my question is: they have technology to detect if ball was in or out by milimeters...
still cant have a replay of a video? bruh...
We are here for you it’s the same in all tournaments across the world that’s why your considered dumb 😐
@@romnt It obviously seems like english isn't his first language, just cause you don't speak English doesn't mean you are dumb.
@@romnt Again, English isn't a language that you have to know how to speak to give an argument. Him calling someone dumb because of someone's lack of reasoning is truly valuable even if you speak other languages. Can't tell if you're a troll or if you're serious.
"Dumb ".......unable or unwilling to speak. Chew on that one,folks.
we are in a tennis match video... british start to see who "speaks" better in a COMMENT section... explains everything in the video... btw english is not my first language even if it was this is a youtube comment not a fucking english test so stfu... dam polite people... xD
Wow, how on earth Cibulkova can try and steal that point. An absolute disgrace. Any other (and I mean like 99.9% of players) would’ve just said “she’s right”
Well done for standing your ground Hsieh👊
And she still lost the match
@@allthekingshorses7178 what matters she got her justice
Cibulkova is so sly. Everyone saw that this point belonged to Hsieh but she tried to outsmart the whole world. I'm so glad that she's retired. Maybe I'm a little bit cruel but justice is the main thing on the planet
@@Pens4Life85 oh yes you're absolutely right. I didn't think about this. Do you know who won this point? Just wondering
@@Pens4Life85 yes, I know that. Who won this replayed point? Maybe I don't express my thoughts well. I'm not a native speaker
@@Pens4Life85 yeah but someone won the replayed point, and that's what he's obviously asking about
She is retired? Good. Shit sportsman.
@@Pens4Life85 dumb fuck lol
Dominika is so lame for behaving like this. I’m sure there’s been bad calls made in her past matches but that doesn’t mean that is ok
i agree with you to against her in this case but her ass looks great in that dress so its kinda hard.
She is awful. Bad sportsmanship.
@@umaga jo
umaga wtf
This is idiotic. Why didn't the umpire ask the linesmen? There are six of them!
I was just wondering the same
She's stupid like that. All the tools in the world she COULD HAVE been using, but it's all in the brains, you know. That 'I know better' attitude, high horse umpire are just the WORST.
They should really change some of these extreme umpires that make too many mistakes.
I guess linemen are just for lines😁
@@rodrickdubose659 But still, they are umpires as well, a team with the chair umpire so if a chair umpire can ask a linesman for an opinion on lines surely can ask opinion about anything because they are all a team which is paid and approved by atp /wta?
why cant they use the tv-pictures??
The dude getting hit repeatedly reminds me of that comedy bit with the goalkeeper stopping every soccer shot with his face
Mahut is really clumsy
thats exactly what i was thinking
YES! Exactly!
SCOTT STERLING!!!!!!! The man the myth the legend!
“I’ve never had this happen to me in my entire career!”
5 seconds later: “I’ve had this happen to me SO MANY times!”
2 seconds later: “I’ve never had this happen to me NEVER!”
Uhh which is it??
she also starts with "I don't wanna talk about that"
then she talks about "that" for several minutes
Hseih: Come on you gotta call the referee man,,,, LOL love her!!
so clever she is
Love her❤
Lol Hsieh got hood 😆
Another reason why I like Hsieh
Cibulkova could just pretended she didn't see anything but she tried to interfere the discussion by calling Hsieh's return was in the net. Seriously? I didn't even notice that when I was watching this match. Thank you for uploading this video.
She also tried to blame the fact that Hsieh could speak the same language as the ref
She is a total liar when she said this situation happned so many times to her and she always gave the points to the opponents. Those people should not play professional sports, bad apples.
Nobody talking about Hsieh hugging the ball girl? That was cute.
I thought I'd had some bad days on the court, but Mahut... I feel for you, buddy.
I had no respect for that umpire Zhang even before this, she's useless. I lost all respect for Cibulkova as a result of this.
And the Ref was just as feeble.
J Zhang the worst umpire always makes mistakes why does she still here anyway
She really is. So many of these videos that include her. She is a disgrace to the sport and it wouldn't surprise me if she was corrupt. Besides the bad sportsmanship shown by cibulkova( so glad this bitch retired now) zhang should be fired and banned from the sport forever
@@TheMitchie21 dang...you gangsta
@@dadsfreetimeclassicgaming1220 I'm far too white to ever be called gangsta but ill take it
Here the situation is entirely caused by Zhang "forgetting" where the ball landed, or not paying enough attention to the return that clearly landed in the middle of the court.
BUT, she has made several correct calls on previous videos on this channel, so calling her "the worst" or a "disgrace" is a bit much even though she butchered it in this clip.
@@TheMitchie21 what's wrong with cibuljkobva?
The irony about this is that this is like the first time I have seen a supervisor overrule a chair umpire, in this case the overrule was completely right because the chair was completely wrong and Cibulkova still has the balls to claim she got the short end on this one. WHAT BS
Interviewer: can you understand your opponent’s frustrations?
Cilbukova: no, because it happened to me
Her refusal to empathise is quite revealing.
Man... The one with Mahut being beaten, it's just so bad... reminds me of the viral video circulating a few years ago about that goalkeeper stopping all penalty kicks with the face.
Scott Sterling. 😂🙋🏾♂️
lamao!
:Dominika says, "In Chinese or whatever language that was." What a shabby comment.
Rick Bombard agree
Kinda racist ngl
Absolutely disgusting behaviour. She has zero class.
I am from Slovakia, we tend to really appreciate pro athletes since we don't have many but Cibulkova is very unpopular here as well. She is extremely arrogant, full of herself, always makes stupid comments, wears expensive fur coats from foxes etc. Nobody likes her
Primitiv252 Bulo shows that she trash wannabe. She should have really focused on her tennis, blame less people, treat people with respect and then maybe she would have been more successful in her career. Throwing tantrums, cheating, treating people like crap and talking utter bullshit about other players has brought her own failure. It’s an incredible achievement to be where she was in the tennis world but she could have achieved greater success had she kept her head and attitude in check and not in the clouds or in this case, gutter.
so glad Cibulkova is retired. Terrible sport
It's unbelievable to me that Cibulkova didn't cut this problem short by simply telling the truth. She's acting somewhat irritated and it's her OWN fault. Clearly she's trying to steal this point. Shame on her! 😡
Cibulkova: "The ball was in the net" "I am a fair player" xDDDDD
Man, its just not a good day for Nicholas Mahut.
absolutly not, he also lost wimbledon final, hahaha
@@Jeteso2009 Yeah I would so pissed if I were in his position, getting hit 3+ times and still losing
@@Jeteso2009 he's won everything there is to win in doubles tennis
The lesson was...
wear a cup.
I think he's getting in the way on purpose for sympathy bc he sux.
As an umpire how do you forget what happened literally 10 seconds ago? Yet players get fined for yelling expletives while umpires get no punishment for their mistakes.
Wait the supervisor did something
That’s a miracle
Maxinator 123 I know lol
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
This is the time in short notice that I would really demand to see the manager. Minus the haircut and Capri pants, of course.
"that's what counts your first feeling" lol okay now you're desperate. I'm glad hseih spoke up
Mahut had a tough day, but ump did make the right call on that Hawkeye challenge
That Cibulkova has zero respect for her opponent. Ball was clearly knocked back in by her opponent so stop being disrespectful
It's not up to Cibulkova to award points, hardly her fault that the umpire messed up
@@allthekingshorses7178 you are correct. Nevertheless a fair player would have said something.
Cibulkova: Reality doesn't matter. The umpire should stay with the call that benefits me.
its obvious that Cibulkova tried her luck, the empire made a mistake. Even afterwards Cibulkova had no sportsmanship in her interview, saying dont know they were speaking in they're own language, like that's the reason the point got taken off! And where has it happened to her so many times, she's claiming?
“...and they were talking in Chinese or whatever.” - Irrelevant! I bet you cared less about their conversation until the point was taken from you!
EXACTLY! The conversation was mostly in english with probably less than 10 words in Chinese. And even when they were conversing in Chinese they said nothing that wasn't previously said in english. They were just repeating.
@@rebeccatang9383 Not to mention that they didn't agree at all.
*uck off from this discussion!
Irrelevant and racist
@@myerklamb8529 Racist? You'd better learn meaning of the word before writing it. The official language is English, so speaking in Chinese could be considered as an attempt to unfairly impact on umpires' decision. It seemed she wanted to hide something from the opponent. Although, Hsu was right.
9:48 the fact that she can say - and actually wholehartedly believe, apparently - that she is a fair minded player, after that totally irrational, hard-headed and self centered argument. Wow!
9:49 No Cibulkova, you are not a fair player, you see the ball return!! And please look to the foward not to ground! 😂😅😅
Looooool at Cibulková being the only person in the stadium who say the ball “hit the net” then have the audacity to say she was treated unfairly. Happy retirement to her :) she deserves it
Why did the supervisor not ask for a video replay of the point?
beause you cant, theres no such thing
@@samuelgl why tho?
@@mecool9897 there isnt a rule about that, you cant just make a random rule yourself
but there is var in the next gen finals, which could be implemented in other tournaments in the future
up until the atp cup there was no facility to ask for a replay.. its to protect the officials from terrible and incompetent calls ... now, because they will be fired it seems its ok to review every single thing they say and do..
Come on just give the referee a tablet or some sort of device to watch replays, the whole matter would be resolved in six seconds instead of six minutes
Random PC-User yeah seriously...almost 2020 why isn’t this already a thing? Other sports have had this for decades.
ATP and WTA are the most dimwit people on the planet...
Cibulkova's post-match interview:
"I'm a fair player" (proceeds to argue that because she's been the victim of wrong calls at times in her life, she doesn't deserve to be robbed of the opportunity to profit from an umpire failing to notice that Hsieh's return was over & in by at least 15 feet, distraction or not.
So this is what goes into her tally of "wrong calls" she's been the victim of.
Mahut got a bit testy, took it out on the (absolutely correct) umpire.
I remember up until a few years back Cibulkova was one of my favourite players. I went off her because of her unsportsmanlike, cheating conduct during matches. I can't stand her now. Absolutely zero class!
Cibulkova was unfair and had zero class, true.
But the one who created this mess was the Umpire who didn't pay attention and made a horrible call
People make mistakes, want to solve that issue, introduce VAR.
@@LoosSerine Dude its literally her JOB if she cant do it then just retire from beeing a referee. Coute: I cant remember! How the heck cant an referee dont remember the last Point played? Even everyone in the Audience saw that + she has Linesmen to back her up.
@@thefirstk6331 I don't think you watch or play enough tennis to know how difficult it is to see, especially at lower level tournaments. Also, the problem is that players often cheat and try to undermine the umpire, you stating the umpire should ignore another player (even though she was cheating) over another could be inferred as bias.
@@thefirstk6331 Because you never made mistakes in your life....
@@fgdh2460 Dude did you even watch the Video? The Problem was not the mistake himself the problem was how she handled it afterwards and not beeing able to remember the last played point on the biggest Tennis Tournament out there is more then an siple mistake.
Totally unsportsmanlike from cibulkova.
If I was Hsieh , I wouldn’t be as patient with umpire J. Zhang ! Gurlllll you can’t just say you don’t REMEMBER the part where she hit the ball back in the court. You have ONE job and that’s to pay attention to the match.
Tennis fans need a 'Cheat, cheat, cheat..." chant to move these cheats forward.
And she had the audacity to say they were talking in “Chinese or whatever language” as if that’s the reason they changed the decision? What a disgraceful joke, Cibulkova
Was it chinese tho...?
The funniest part is that if you speak Chinese, Hsieh was basically repeating the same things she was saying in English. Literally didn’t affect the call at all. Cibulkova’s such a bad sport.
@@Drbolbolpilote 2:40 the umpire speaks in chinese I assume bcs I can't get sh** 😅
12:05 I just like how strategically that dude is holding the umbrella with no one underneath it but him
AJsVIEW he’d better hold it if not he won’t probably his check 😂😂😂😂
Glad you said something 😂
The sun is probably behind him, so the angle is getting shade on the players chairs.
Dude? That's a woman. 😂
Definition of a great youtube channel like yours: although you know you will probably getting striked from Wimblecrydon you still upload this beautiful series. Good job buddy
Thanks man, I appreciate it. I really enjoy your videos, the Troicki 'Are you shaking' one was hilarious! 😆
8:05 : “this has never happened to me in my career”
also 9:35 : “this exact point has happend to me many times”
... okay buddy
At 8:05 when she say "this" she means the case of an umpire that changed its call because a player argued never happened to her, she completes the sentence at 8:10 but you ignore it.
At 9:35 she says that the same point happened to her many times and the umpire haven't changed the decision, just reinforcing her first statement, there's nothing contradicting between the two statements, you just understood them wrong.
@@E_y_a_l The fact the she is an idiot remains.
she also starts his answer with
"I don't wanna talk about that"
1 sec later, she starts talking about that for several minutes
She has never been in a position where it takes six minutes for an umpire to put her foot down.
But she has been in positions where she just had to deal with an umpires decision that wasn't in her favour. That's why she was like:"stick to your decision, you're the umpire!" And I also would not appreciate Hsieh conversing in Chinese. Puts the umpire in a very awkward position. If I were the umpire, I would just say: I did not see it land. The ball is called in. If you don't agree I can bring the supervisor but it won't make a difference. End of discussion.
@@boraxsopanic2670 it doesn't. If she was on the level of idiocy she'd be a para-athlete. She's just not a very nice person.
It’s great to see how Hsieh was able to stand her ground and fight for her right assertively 👍.
On the other hand, the opponent, who claimed she got treated unfairly so many times, not only hesitated to clarify the fact for Hsieh, but also challenged the decision of replay. She has neither empathy nor sportsmanship in her 😡.
My heart broke to see his reaction at 18:33 .It's shocking to see such mistakes happening at the biggest tennis tournament.
What mistakes? The return wasn't affected by the call. You can see it when you play it in slo motion
You need to make one of these for the whole decade... I love this series!
Cibulkova retired last month so, "bibye!"
"I'm a fair player" LOL
This is the hazard of standing too close to the net in doubles. Ive been criticized for the opposite ie standing too close to the service line (end of the service box) in doubles BUT it gives me half to one full second MORE time to react and hit a confident or well placed return instead of getting jammed up trying to defend myself against slammers. My husband and i won the spring mxd doubles event (all age group) recently in a good sized club and no one critiqued me after that; which consisted of 8 matches.
Man I've never had more sympathy for a player than I have for Mahut
Because he’s ugly?
This J Zhang umpire seems to be having some sort of blank trance quite frequently. In other videos drama compilation she said she "forget" too. Weird.
She's the Mariah Carey of the tennis world.
Horrible umpiring by J Zhang and absolute lies by Cibulkova. I used to like her but not anymore. Hsieh hit the ball back into the court, replay the point, Cibulkova kept insisting Hsieh hit the ball in the net. Horrible umpiring as well, good job by supervisor to enforce replaying the point.
I don't know how she could say it hit the net when it's so obviously in. It's like saying something ridiculous like cows can fly.
@@ecor150 the chair umpires should have access to the constant replays the TV audience were getting so umpire could correct her error.
I feel so bad for laughing at the guy who kept getting hit. The chances of it happening over and over are so small and you know the opponents didn’t mean any of them. Poor dude, I hope he wasn’t bruised too badly. I’ll just laugh at the unfortunate circumstances from afar
Is Cibulkova actually trying to say the ball hit the net, after all that? And then saying it was unfair?? If so, that's probably the most unsportsmanlike thing I've ever seen, in any sport.
Zhang is such a terrible umpire, there's so many instances of her "not remembering" what just happened in the game
My mom: what are you laughing at?
Me: this guy got hit with a tennis ball like 8 times lmao
hahahahhahahaahha
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Same to Barbora 😂😂😂😂
"I am a fair player"
But it's my score. And I don't care if she was right, I have no empathy because they shouldn't take MY point. 💁🏻♀️ Logic
Incidentally, Cibulkova was Cirstea's opponent too in that famous streak of 6 successful Hawkeye challenges that the Romanian had in just one set. In one of those challenges, the call was reverted by the referee in Sorana's favour after a similar, very lengthy argument. She instinctively raised her finger to chalenge but when heard the umpire call the ball long, pointed out to Cirstea that the umpire called it out. Fair player. 🤔
She says "she doesn't want to talk about it" but yet she does!!! LOL 😂 bad sport 😝
I'm kind of new to tennis but watching some of these bad decisions by the umpires is bewildering, I mean how hard can it be to umpire a tennis match. Also, don't they have some kind of VR system to replay the video back if they need to?
When the hell is tennis going to get with the times! Replay is used in so many sports now
What if Hsieh just would have challenged her last ball haha
eddiarmenia96 you can only challenge line judges calls which is why the atp cup var May be a good thing lmao
@@1998rg It doesnt matter if it is a line call in that particular situation the Problem here is that the Referee is such garbage and didnt saw that the ball did go in the court she thought that Hsieh missed the ball so with the Challange the Referee would had seen that the ball was in the Court the idea of the Main Comment is pretty good.
Wow...that's actually a good question. Good point
Thank you Tennis Advocate for putting subtitles (I guess I don't know what to call it) in this video because usually in videos like this there are none
That doubles match was actually hilarious
man I felt sorry for Nicholas Mahut there. he must have been thinking "what have I done to deserve this"
The whole concept of “sportsmanship” seems to be a thing of the past.
Standing back and watching an opponent argue with the umpire while you try to take a point that you didn’t win is disgusting.
Cibulkova isn’t quite as loathsome as Kyle Edmund, who stole a break point by getting away with an obvious double-bounce, but she’s in his general neighborhood.
Honestly though sometimes you dig for a short ball and your eyes aren’t even on the ball anymore. You can’t tell if the ball bounced twice or not. If it were me I’d have taken any decision, especially after speculation, bc maybe I didn’t see.
Feel sorry for Mahut. He cant catch a break🙁
Are we really not going to talk about Mahut getting hit hard 3 times? It’s like that soccer video with the umpire getting hit in the face every shot on goal 😂😂.
It's so ridiculous that they couldn't just use the video replay to review it back and move on. Of course if Shitbulkova was a decent human being she would've confirmed that the ball was in and have the point replayed.
Great channel subbed.
🙏💚
Hsieh continued playing despite the wrong „out“ call of the linesman, and she successfully returned the ball. Cibulkova stopped playing, and therefore she deserved to LOSE the point, and not to win it as she contends. Replaying the point was a fair decision, but Cibulkova unfortunately did not see the truth in that, and believes that she should have been awarded the point, although is was she, and not Hsieh who stopped playing. Unfair, tunnel vision !
I absolutely love this UA-cam channel.I wonder where you get these moments
Hsieh is right , if the chair umpire couldnt remember it, it is Her Freaking problem ! Hsieh did not lose the point , she put the ball back to the other side, how could she possibly lose the point, what a Joke, what an Umpire !
11:00 Is this for real?! It seems like it is like those videos where that one guy is the goalie for soccer and gets hit all the time and in volleyball too LOL
Hahaha yeah I thought the same. I was literally In tears from laughing so hard because I knew it was for real 🤣
Scott Sterling at it again!
Have you ever been hit by a tennis ball that close? It fucking hurts! The ball is small too so the hit is concentrated. He got hit right in the forehead!
this is the first time i've seen a supervisor actually do something
Hsieh was right to call for Referee,Good call by Referee,Bad sportsmanship from opposite player, so much time wasted in arguments when tech could have resolved it in seconds
Cibulkova has no class at all. I'm glad the cheater retired.
At least Cibulkova is pretty, Hsieh has a face like a suntanned horse
Bonus content? Man this channel is the best.
Cibulkova -8000 on fair play's level. Thank you to show us the truth about some players
Everyone here are so happy to hate Cibulkova and claim she cheated or lied, but When looking at the replay you can see that when the ball pass over the net and hit the court(6:18) Cibulkova is raising her hand for a challenge and looking directly at the umpire and not the at the ball, look at 0:06, even when the ball rolls on the ground she doesn't look at it but on the umpire and then she looks forward at Hsieh, she didn't looked at the ball even for a split second the entire time, she could have really didn't see if it was net or inside the court because her attention was to the umpire, when asked she didn't said she saw it was net, watch at 5:54, she says the umpire or the lines judge said that it was net.
Cibulkova's only claim was that the umpire made a call, and after she made the call she can't change it just because the player argues, the umpire didn't said she was wrong on her call, she said she doesn't remember what happened and then she said she didn't saw where the ball landed, so Cibulkova said that on that basis the umpire can't just change her first call, she didn't cheat, she didn't lied, all of the insults and names people are calling her here are not justified, it may not nice to hear but she's right, if the umpire didn't know for certain that her call was wrong she needed to stick with her first call.
Imagine if Troicki vs Kirgios played this game
11:00 a tennis version of Scott Sterling
So, when the VAR is gonna be in use? a ten-minute argument will be cut to just a minute or so....
Seriously. How do you have the technology to follow the ball and spot within a centimeter whether it hit the line but can't just watch a 10 second video replay? Which we all saw a dozen times while they were gabbing about it.
@@christopherborum6551
I mean to put the VAR to be a standard, just as the Hawk Eye has been a standard for like... i don't know... ~15 years???
@@RoniRonkoKovatch I agree. How hard would it be to have the referee go to a replay monitor just like every other major sport does?
@@christopherborum6551
As a tennis official myself, VAR has been introduced lately to the next gen tournaments and seems pretty good. Personally, I don't think it will take much for it to become a standard. It should be a standard for every sport that exists.... If a referee can go to the monitor and have a second pair of eyes (and 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th.... in case of multiple camera angles...) it would be great for everyone. Fans, coaches, players, officials... :-)
After seeing this I’m glad to hear Cibulkova retired.
Cibulkova is damn hot though 😍
Mahut got tore up in that match, I remember seeing the first hit live 😂
Saw all of them live. It was becoming comical by the third hit. Felt so bad 😭
@@bobanmihajlov338 he ran into every single one tho
Her first feeling matters the most...😅😂😂😂
It is always good to be fair to your opponent, you'll get it back one way or another.