Oshi no Ko is Finally BACK! Psychologist Reacts to Season 2 Episode 1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 сер 2024
- All Vods up on Twitch.
/ psyculturists
Follow us on
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / psyculturists
Instagram: / psyculturists
And Twitch: / psyculturists
Edited: ProXyt
Thumbnail: ProXyt
#psyculturists #reaction #anime #psychology #disucssion #indepthanalysis
Ed is so good at Pre-reading he guessed plot points months before they were even written by the Mangaka into the latest Manga chapters!
I think that's because both Ed and Akasaka are astute observers of human behavior, so they think about character development along the same lines.
Fr
"I'll let the scene play out cause wtf this is beautiful" - Ed, LITERALLY 4 seconds before pausing. Let's go! Peak Ed. This is gonna be beautiful.
Also, Ed watching op without pausing must be torture.
Hey! 4 seconds is a new record for him in Oshi No Ko! 😂
Now no one can accuse him of pre-reading. Because he figured it out BEFORE it was written
ED: "people need to stop simplifying adaptations expecting that people won't be able to understand complex plots"
Mushoku Tensei: *Doesn't simplify complex themes
People: *Don't understand the complex plot
ED: "...you got me there"
But for real. That's the reason why Witcher, Rings of Power or Star Wars are in so disgusting shape
@@rotmistrzjanm8776 true, well, that and the fact writters nowadays have less time, less manpower and less salary to make the movies/series as well, so i guess one can't expect masterpieces being released like they were back in the day.
what i meant is that while i disagree there is an argument to be made about "simpler" shows since a lot of the audience often don't understand more complex shows, like what happened to Mushoku Tensei
I mean... there's not understanding a complex plot and then there's an MC who treats women like NPCs, gropes (to put it lightly) a minor, and gets a perfect life with all the women he lied to and groomed when they were children into being his romantic partners all while having a backstory that's more unbelievable than most fantasy shows. I can get behind redemption stories, but I kinda draw the line at banging a minor when you're 40. Comparing it to ReZero and MushoTen is just egregious. When Subaru treats them like NPCs the writer punishes him for it. Subaru acts like someone completely incompetent at social interaction and makes mistakes he has to fix because of it. When a 12 year old expresses romantic interest in him, he says "god you're so fucking cute," then goes back to the girl his age. He doesn't willingly hide the truth of his life and in fact desperately wishes to talk about it.
I'll admit I haven't even watched the show fully yet, but acting like Rudeus deserves redemption, much less a harem made up of the children he groomed, is fucking insane to me. Roxy is literally the only one I'd be fine with him getting with, and it's only if he were to actually open up about his reincarnation. With them both having young appearances with a 40 year old mind it is actually wild to me they went with a harem in the end. And frankly I think I'd prefer none of them getting with him in the end, he needs to learn how to live without romance first.
Also all three romantic interests being into him after the bare minimum of effort on his part makes them feel extremely shallow as characters, compared to Emilia, who still isn't entirely sure how she feels about Subaru after 2 full seasons.
@@mr.stuffdoer8483 I must say: thank you, without your comment i don't think i could have ever proven my point in such a spectacular and clear way, so thank you, for showing how on the mark i was XD
I's reccomend you to not only watch the show before making conclusions next time, but also to watch ED's reaction and analysis on the subject, it might do wonders towards your views XD
@@Ricardo_Rick 1. I plan to watch. I’m busy.
2. Having seen his first Oshi no Ko reaction, I’ve come to realize he and I have very different views on the concept of reincarnation, which I strongly suspect will be his justification offered for statutory r@pe. He treats the character as though they weren’t reincarnated. For the Oshi no ko example, he seems to view Aqua witnessing AI’s death as a child who watched their mother die, ignoring the mental age of the character, as well as dismissing the core nature of him having decades of experience in coping with difficult emotions.
3. I must also thank you for being the perfect example of everything that is infuriating about discussing modern fiction, by claiming people just don’t understand the story then refusing to elaborate in even the most moderate way, and completely dismissing the mere concept of discussion with perspectives outside of your own. You even dismissed things that have nothing to do with misinterpretation of a narrative, such as me claiming Rudy’s former life managing to break my suspension of disbelief harder than the concept of the isekai itself.
18:45 we can see visible pain caused by the urge to pause and analise 😂
I've not read the manga, so I'm just speculating (also, please don't confirm or deny this if you know the answer), but my current guess is that the door in the ED is the door she had to sit behind while Ai died, only able to hear her final words, but never able to see her fully, including the unplesant aspects of Ai and her life. Just like Aqua cant stop her from bleedibg out in front of him, she can't open the locked door
Two hours, not bad! And of course the OP analysis makes up more than half of it 💀
1:13:30 the hard cut is diabolical
Thank you! I watched that live, so I would've missed this perfect edit
I would say Aqua is no longer Gorou, or JUST Gorou.
Ruby is reskinned Sarina. As a kid she barely got to live a life but now she got a second chance at that. Dancing in s1 was exactly that.
Aqua said in season 1 that he might be "Aqua, haunted by the ghost of Gorou". If Ruby is still Sarina it's more because Sarina had lived so little that she more seamlessly became the seed from which Ruby grew.
My immediate reaction to seeing this in my recommended was "Only 2 hours?!?"
dw, next time he’ll be analyzing the OP/ED lyrics 👀
as someone who has read the manga, the ending was a trip to watch
you're in for a wild ride this season
I'm freaking out with the opening. Hope it got an analisys in every episode
11:07 "Just bear with me for a second"
My guy, it's the FIRST SCENE!!! 😂
Ugh, I love this channel. 😊
This is my favorite arc of the manga and the anime has already taken it to another level in a single episode, super fucking hyped for this season
47:40 one other thing to note is that when she claps, it syncs with a subtle yet ominous piano (?) "ting" in the background, THEN what appears to be a skeleton emerges as Aqua, yet wear a white blouse. It feels as if she did some sort of magic clap that made doctor Aqua come back from death.
I love how I can take a break on the “A Silent Voice” reaction and watch this one instead lmao😂
lmao same
47:35 "Why is she clapping? She scares me"
Good. 😂
FINALLY!!!! THE PEAK IS BACK!!!!
Wdym? We’ve been getting peak back to back this year! Frieren, Mushoku, Oshi no Ko, Rezero. Back to back Peak!
Oh yeah. So true.
we're back in the kitchen! really excited to see what things you'll cook with this new season :)
Ed's Warehouse. You're going to love the way he cooks. We guarantee it.
Crows are regarded as a symbol of death in Japanese culture. They were already used a fair amount in season one, for instance when the doctor gets pushed off the cliff, a flock of crows flies up from the trees where he fell.
I love how coincidentally the censor thing only covered the stage and not the audience
"I think I went a little overboard with only 7 hours of just analyzing the OP"
We'll be beating that this season, don't worry.😂
Oshi No Peak
"How dark is Oshi no Ko gonna get?"
... **Flashbacks to seeing Ai get murdered**
I mean, how do you think it could get worse?
I‘m excited for you to listen to the full OP and ED, with their lyrics! I personally interpret the OP from Aquas perspective and the ED (aside from the visuals convincing me more) from Rubys! Looking forward to next week ^^
couldn't catch the stream, but im so happy that peak is back!!
Great analysis of this episode as always. Not everything he says comes to pass but I start flipping out whenever he makes a perfect prediction. I still remember season 1 episode 1 when Ed randomly said Ai should lock her door mere minutes before she was stabbed. I lost it lol. Keep cooking!
30:05 Kana is best for Aqua, but is Aqua best for Kana? That's what I'm thinking
Nah, therapy is what's best for both of them
Nah akane is best for kana, and aqua deserve Therapy
1:59:20 Everyone forgets about the key chain from season one.
2:01:17 Damn, Ed. I somehow totally overlooked that. Like a Denji moment.
56:13 Well to answer your question, Yes there is, I'm not gonna say what trauma or how but he got trauma from the entertainment industry. If you wanna see what type of trauma you'll have to read the manga or wait for season 3 even season 4
And also, Ed is truly a wizard. Time and time again.
WE ARE BACK BABY!!!!
Aqua's negative self-talk about his acting is actually pretty ironic, since he's always comparing himself to Ai, saying that he doesn't really feel the things he's portraying in his acting, but rather just making the expressions and using the lighting etc. to create the response the audience should have. Meanwhile, he seems to think Ai was a natural who's sparkling personality just came across from the inside, not realizing that she actually did exactly the same thing he does, calculating every expression to be exactly what her fans wanted to see without any of it coming from a natural emotion. She openly said as much when they first talked on the hospital rooftop, but I guess he was too busy being enchanted by her act to pay attention.
i never thought i would see Ed twerking (i am not complaining though)
I love the new underlying philosophical concepts that we are introducing here. While the first season was an absolute masterpiece, i feel like the first season was obviously a build up towards a more intense conflict that will explore different aspects of the self,considering how flawed and complex Rubys and Aquas sense of self is. I am extremely excited for this season because you can clearly see these themes and concepts emerging. The complexity of the self and how it will be portrayed in Oshi no Ko, and the psychologidcal conflicts/realizations it will create will be nothing but captivating
Let's go, time to watch Oshi No Ko analysis!!
Just yesterday watched the episode and I think you're going to cook
In the past few years I have been more and more concious of changes adaptations have made from source, and become more picky about how characters are adapted. I cheered when the mangaka stood up for themselves in this episode. It was awesome.
So many shows are dumbed down, simplified, or rushed. It's sad. Just this season My Wife Has No Emotion is falling victim to it. The whole premise of the manga is Mina - the robot wife - expressing something similar to emotion despite being a robot. In the manga her emotions are entirely implied by her actions and what other characters think, but the anime is spoon feeding us by literally writing on screen what emotions she is feeling - many of which i think are not aligned with how she was actually feeling in the source. The subtleness of the story is destroyed for simplicity. Not to mention the break neck pace preventing the viewer from absorbing anything.
I don't mind changes that need to happen to fit a new medium, but I can't help but feel as though many folks think dumbing down character motives is always a requirement.
I worry that too many authors are happy just to get an anime, and are afraid to involve themselves in production even when it doesn't meet their expectations. Or worse, they aren't able to intervene at all.
Hoping this season will provide me with some catharsis to that end. From what I've heard of Oshi no Ko and it's mangaka... I'm rather excited.
11:22 something beyond my comprehension happened here
Your insight is sharp as ever!
48:45 A cadaver? Isn't it Dr. Goro's body with his Aqua head?
56:10 Well, if their dad knocked up a 15 year old Ai, either he was around her same age, and we already know that being a child actor/star is an extremely positive and healthy environment to grow up in, or he was considerably older than Ai, which would lead to the presumption that he has already been in the industry for a while, and if he is accepting of having unprotected sex with a 15 year old minor who is in that same industry, he likely has plenty of truma or "nurturing" which lead to such a choice.
1:04:10 This shot of Ai has actually made me tear up every time I see it. :/
1:57:40 This grimace on Ruby's face is just so fukn impactful and saddening. We see her giggling and grinning through 85% of the manga/anime up to this point. So, seeing a look on her face that said, "Shite is NOT okay" makes me so uncomfortable, and I'm caught yp on the manga!! One doesn't need to know what cones next to see this ED and know that the "happy ending" is a fukn misty fart of a dream.
What type of acting does Aqua use?
Ed, way to ask one of the main aspects of the whole arc!!! Not just with Aqua 🤣
I was waiting for this!! ❤❤❤
So excited!
1 hour OP analysis let's goooooo
Finally, lets gooo
Finally! My favorite arc!
Woo!
59:40 the rose burned in S1 OP
About those crows: Season 1 also ended with a crow spying on Aqua and Ruby. 🙂
Hey Ed, I love watching The reacts on UA-cam, and I get that you cant put The opening song BC of copyright, but is there a way to make The anime easier to see? At least on the phone is quite hard to read The subs sometimes, I ONLY get by BC I watch The episode right before The reacts and know a little japanese 😅
What i.mean is if like it to BE a bit bigger, and The squares to BE more translucent, I believe they were before.
@@filipesimoes1343 You can zoom the screen with the UA-cam App.
ahhh man I missed this stream. Well, at least we got the vod
This episode, despite being a bit slow, was really nice and I think set the mood well for the next episodes (I haven't read the manga tho, so maybe its the opposite and the manga readers might be going nuts rn lol). I personally think this play is going to change a lot of dynamics, maybe even reveal some character traits we haven't seen before, just because of how its getting structured (we literally have the two big rivals here, Akane and Kana).
Also I found it interesting that months passed by and only mini concerts happened with MEM, Ruby and Kana. Are they taking their time because of Kana, or is it some problem that rose up which we haven't seen yet? A lot of ongoing questions right now, I'm so excited for the next few episodes, and your analysis of them too.
30:00 Man. This question get reeeeaaaaally fucking loaded for us manga readers. However, while I have witnessed and attested to Kana's positive influence and reactions toward Aqua, I have always seen Akane as the ultimate choice for him. If....Aqua wasn't a fuckboi for revenge.
It's here!!!
18:46 Ed ASMR (real)
36:40 , the right one is team akane, the left one is team kana.
When they showed Ai in the theater seat clapping, my first thought was, if whatever higher power was able to reincarnate the doctor and patient, who died tragically before their time, could that power have then reincarnated Ai, who would then only be a few years younger than the siblings, and Ai is following their careers likeca momma bird?
"If you have a character that monologues for more than five pages, we have an issue."
... I'm not going to, but I want you to know anyway that there are a couple manga pages I want to show you for a show you've watched, and they're hilarious. Over 10 pages worth of monologue in 2 pages. We're talking like... LITERAL Walls of Text. The pages are just... The character, and then MASSIVE speech bubble. I don't know how the anime will adapt it. I don't know if it CAN, but if it does, the for one the studio are fuckin' madlads, and secondly mark my words. It will be hilarious. Just one character yapping for like... I think it'd be a good quarter of an episode at least. 😂
Raven is a religious symbol of Japanese culture.
9:00 japan has more money for this shit because everything is gacha, big IP like this don't sell tickets but "give" them trough gacha
22:00 food for though do you guys think that Sarina wold be in "Doctor Play"?
45:00 we need a crow emote to be OnK rat
Here we gooooo
38:19 Man, I wasn't seeing any spoiler type shite, besides one guy's vagueposting.
Ed was overcooking a good bit here.
44:53 Cute Ed. This long on burnt toast.
In season 1 I could relate so much to the trauma of Ai and Akane that I really loved the series. For now, Season 2 doesn't seem to have that same impact so far, from this first episode it's looking like more of a season where we explore the character dynamics and relationships between Aqua and Kana/Akane and a possible love triangle.
I still hope this season is just as good as the first, and I look forward to your analysis as usual!
i wont spoil and be specific but they do explore other characters’ trauma this season!
What about for eval's?
Because honestly never seen someone that was not taking notes during and basically everytime it was for an eval. The couple times it was not them writing stuff down during I took as them being serious about what I was saying.
Cannot speak for others but my memory in general is trash so note taking is so I do not forget the details.
But at least ask first.
I don't know if i should watch.. i mean i don't wanna get spoiled
Let Ed cook 🗣🔥
29:20 Healthy for who? If for Aqua, Kana, likely. How3ver, I see he4 suffering greatly and fervently, if A1ua is still on the war path.
If we're talking about the average healthiness for both parties , I'd say Akane. She doesn't have the lifetime of abandonment issues and fear of obscurity, like Kana has. Akane could oeep ip with Aqua, match him, and support him to the end. I zee a relationship with Kana getting broken beyond repair, and then la5er, when what the issue was ge5s cleared up, and Kana tri3d to be with Aqua again, it ends up too painful or just too late. If a relationship with Akane were to peter out or implodez it would be after Aqua take his head, and the dynamic between them no longer fits what has been working until then.
107 degrees? *non-US left the chat*
32:29 Ed keeps asking about the crows while his chat is screaming at him "Spoilers!" Lolz
34:06 I can't tell this is irritating or hilarious. Ask questions, ya might get answers, and often, eith anime, that would be a bad thing
i want to see you react to suicide squad anime
cognitive distortion lil pop called me out fr... well i guess it is what it is, huh 😂
The Kana agenda continues
Wizard
too much stop
almost Over Interpret
just play
welcome to psyculturist
The whole point of this channel is to analyse
0:38
@@user-ow3mx9fw6j Ed says it all the time he's no emoji reactor he analyzes
14:44 "Maybe the real us is the masks we made along the way"
It got me