This Could've Saved the Jedi Order
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лют 2023
- WIN A FREE LIGHTSABER! Enter the Competition 2/20 at 10:00am CDT @OwnASaber's
Instagram: / ownasaber
TikTok: / ownasaber
For a chance to win a FREE LIGHT SABER! All you have to do is score higher than 80 on their Star Wars Quiz and you will qualify for their online spinning wheel in which 3 participants will win a 100% FREE saber of their choice.
- After 24 hours the star wars quiz link will be removed and we will hold the online spinning wheel containing the qualifying participants.
- On February 22nd at 10:00am cdt, we will post the Online Spinning wheel results and contact the 3 winners via email.
- Those not interested in the giveaway but would like to get themselves a saber can use the code "VAL15" for FREE Shipping on their order.
OwnASaber: ownasaber.com/
Instagram: / ownasaber
TikTok: / ownasaber
When an organization isn't challenged for nearly a thousand years, it becomes stagnant and closed minded. I believe the Jedi Order would've greatly benefited from oversight and checks & balances on its power. This would allow for the organization to grow and evolve to face the many challenges the galaxy was facing.
2nd Channel: / @generationtechshorts
Follow Generation Tech on Instagram: / generationtechofficial
Follow Generation Tech on Facebook: bit.ly/GenerationTechFB
Latest Videos: bit.ly/LatestGT
Popular Videos: bit.ly/GTPopular
Please help our channel by becoming a Patron: bit.ly/GTPatreon
Follow our Host
ALLEN XIE
UA-cam / @thebeardedasianman
INSTAGRAM AXIEFILMS
TIKTOK AXIEFILMS
FACEBOOK / axiefilms - Розваги
WIN A FREE LIGHTSABER! Enter the Competition 2/20 at 10:00am CDT @OwnASaber's
Instagram: instagram.com/ownasaber/
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@ownasaber
Most of time people under tyrannical governments just leave go off into the woods firm their own communities . Join Ganges and . Or they take over communities cartel's . And the Government decays . Often smaller communities userp the tyrannical government but the dictatorship goes any possible changes before that that might lead organized full rebellion.
Organized
" but alan?" dolphins are perfect?
Hey fellow dolphine hater could you do a review of shrouded Destiny a star Wars fan film Lars Mikkelsen is in it and the creator behind it has spend a lot of money and talent love your content
@@davidfrederiksen3185 "hey" I love dolphines?😟🥺🤨
Bro i died laughing so hard at the sith Lord nextdoor neighbor bit. "Because he's stealing all my packages and turning my lawn yellow because hes sucking all the life out of the grass" 🤣🤣🤣🤣
And now I'm picturing you having a lightsaber duel with your Sith neighbor, on your front lawn, because you caught him mid-theft, and are determined to put a stop to this evil. lol
Here's a video idea for you: compare the je'daii, kotor jedi, old Republic mmo jedi, prequel jedi, and luke's new jedi order and give pros and cons to all of them. Which one is the "ideal' Jedi Order?
I personally believe the Je'daii were probably closer to harmony than any of the organizations that followed them. But they definitely weren't as effective back then as a fighting force.
Would be a good video.
@@GenerationTech Nothing is perfect but it would be a great video.
sounds good
@@GenerationTech do a jedi v real world comparison like Knights templars
In Legends, this already happened with the Ruusan Reformation, where the Jedi would placed themselves under the supervision of the Supreme Chancellor and the Judicial Department. The Jedi couldn't just go and accept any mission that they wanted, they needed the permission of the Supreme Chancellor. That's why a lot of Jedi liked Chancellor Valorum and to some extent Chancellor Palpatine because they would send the Jedi on more missions than the prior Chancellors.
*thumbnail*
Alan: "Take my hand! Come on, Yoda! Would you take a poor sinner's hand?"
😂
ARE YOU REAAADY
Don't blame me! Blame my friendssss
ON THE OTHERRRRR SIDEEEEE!
Ever hear of Agricorps? The Jedi run agricultural company that produced a massive amount of food, and thus provided the income for the order. The Jedi had canon income, it's just not in the center screen.
With the Dragon Age example we should keep in mind that the Templars also have their own set of problems as an institution. A recurring issue in that setting is the difficulty in balancing authority and autonomy between two different groups. So in Star Wars we have to consider how the Jedi fit into the establishment AND how that establishment affects them in good and bad ways. (i.e. High Republic era vs Empire era)
The jedi were so wealthy that Kenobi was complaining about his personal ship not having a built-in hyperdrive.
Except most ships *do* have built-in hyperdrives.
Imagine having a mobile phone these days with no built-in wifi connectivity. It just seems arbitrarily limiting.
@gryphonbotha1880 He was talking about a small fighter. Barley large enough for 1 person. It didn't even have enough space for a complete astromeck like a R2 unit.
@gryphonbotha1880 He was talking about a small fighter. Barley large enough for 1 person. It didn't even have enough space for a complete astromeck like a R2 unit.
@@dawall3732 tie fighters didn't have hyperdrives either. Except for Vaders.
In my view, the problems ultimately lied with the Republic itself because there are times that the Republic has become the very thing the Jedi despised, with or without the manipulations of the Sith Lords. Also, I always think the Jedi Order isn't supposed to become part of the Republic at all. So the best solution to me is for the Jedi to leave the Republic and become its own entity with neutrality to the ones who are part of the Republic and those who are not. As for dealing with the Sith, the Jedi can only come when the threats of the Sith emerged and the Republic actually made a plea for help from them for real.
Like the separation of church & state
Sort of like the New Jedi Academy in the EU :)
To paraphrase Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett in Good Omens: "One one side were the Jedi, on the other the Sith, and if you looked *really* carefully, you *might* be able to tell the difference."
The problem with that is the Mandalorian crusades and the Sith empire.
Due to those threats the jedi had no option but to directly involved themselves in Republic politics.
Laid.
More internal democracy; transparency by the Council; term limits; more diversity in the fields of study (more focus on science and history and less on police work and mystical philosophy); a less centralised system with Jedi commanderie on the Rim or Beyond..
that's actually a good point with the less centralized system
@@homer6292 Shame for you, because that is one of those words that is both useful and used often. I can't really think of a homonym for it that has the same diversity of uses.
@@GenerationTech the Jedi Council was far from the order and the order far from the Galaxy. No wonder it came crumbling down
I agree with a lot of what you said except the mystical philosophy part. It's literally the foundation of the Jedi Order.
@@arthurbriand2175 breadth, multitude, range, mixture...
You are ignoring the Russan Reformation, which took place after the Sith were (mostly) destroyed by the Thought bomb. The Jedi WERE restricted and their role in the republic was limited. They could however be sent on missions by the Chancellor of the republic. Which was well and good until Palpatine became Chancellor and made the Jedi the figure-heads of the clone wars. A master plan indeed to destroy them.
The original mistake of the Jedi was in associating themselves with the Republic to begin with.
9:59 you’re basically describing the problems that lead to the events in the Fate of the Jedi series, though in that series the Jedi eventually cut themselves off from the NR and go semi join the Hapes consortium
In the Meiji period of Japan, a national police force was created that had as one of its duties, the regulation of the Samurai class to prevent hem from just running amok. It was actually filled with a lot of commoners and Samurai loyal to the Emperor. As all of Star Wars is inspired by feudal Japan, this proposed regulatory force actually sounds quite reasonable.
I like the dragon age comparison but it technically creates another problem. Quite a few Templars abused their power and mages suffered a lot as a result. Eventually getting so bad that the mages rebelled
True but they rebelled with a barely over 50% majority vote. And it was mostly sprung from a single event (Kirkwall). The issue was that the mage circles were so diverse in how they were run. Some were havens for mages to learn and be protected, with good relationships between mages and templars. Others were oppressive hells that repressed and harmed mages. The circles were isolated with their own leaders and structures and were spread out on a pre industrial society with primatial communication and no way to centralise. In a modern/future setting with the technology level of Star Wars, I’m sure you could revise the Templar-mage model to fit the Jedi in a way that wouldn’t have the same shortcomings
10:48 Here's a great solution: Clone one of the last few Mandolorians, change his DNA to make the clones more agreeable so they're a functional army, put the army under direct control of the Senate, and then have that army work alongside the Jedi.
Woah!!! I can't believe no one ever thought of that ! But wait wouldn't those clones be also really good at killing Jedis ? I hope no one nefarious ever takes control of such a force.
Yeah I mean I really love that the problems he points out in the Jedi simply don't exist in the highest canon, the movies, their problems are all the opposite (they're puppets of the Republic) and we watch any independence they have left get eroded and go along with it meekly until they finally give a little push back, Palpatine uses that against them, and suddenly they find themselves backs against the corner and then he lets them find out who he really is so that they have no choice but to do a blind assault which he uses as pretext to wipe them out. The entire narrative of the Jedi Order in the prequels is the exact opposite of the one Alan lays out. He is 180 degrees off.
It's an interesting thought. While the Mandalorian are the modern Canon compliant choice, my first thought was actually the Imperial Knights from the old Canon, the ones who served under Roan Fel. They weren't Jedi, but were Force users sworn to serve the Empire while remaining on the light side. And part of their oath was to take down the Emperor himself, should he turn to the Dark Side, an oath which at least one of them carried out, if I remember correctly. They weren't really a safeguard against the Jedi, more of a counterpart to them within the Imperial Remnant. Perhaps a rival Order like that could serve the purpose of keeping the Jedi in line and actually assist the Jedi in hunting down any of their number that should happen to turn, the same way they would take down their own leader should he turn. Of course the Mandalorian idea is probably a much simpler way to go. But then again, even in Dragon Age most of the Templars took their duties TOO far, to the point where they became less guardian and more...well, prison guard. If that sounds the same, consider the difference between a parental figure referred to as a Guardian versus a Prison Guard, and you'll get my meaning. So maybe of the Mandalorian guardians included Jedi or non-Jedi Force users in their numbers, ones who would be more inclined to treat a Dark Jedi threat appropriately without going too far?
The Jedi Service Corps could have been decent overseers if they were spun off from the Jedi. That gives you force-sensitive individuals who understand the Jedi order overall, but who have been more or less rejected from becoming Jedi Knights.
Allen, the Jedi did answer to the senate, and the Senate had a tendency to wield them in place of a centralized military instead of letting them be as a monastic order focused on the force. I always think that’s one of the biggest reasons the Jedi were prone to corruption. They had too many tangled strings attached to their relationship to the republic, too many duties to questionable interests.
UA-cam lost 3/4 of my comment. Let’s try to type this out again. One of the more notable instances that I think illustrates this was the Arkanian Rebellion, in 50 ABY. The senate sent Mace Windu to quell an uprising on the world of Arkania, and it was a disaster. The Arkanian government was infamously corrupt, racist, and generally prone to operating like mad scientists without an ethical review board. When it came to light that they had completely and deliberately subverted the evolution of an entire sentient species in a nearby system in the process of their experiments, a section of the population decided they’d had enough and rose up in armed rebellion, intent on replacing the Arkanian Dominion with more moderate leadership. Mace Windu and the other Jedi sent were merciless and brutal in their crushing of the rebels and they did the senate’s bidding without question or putting weight to both sides in the conflict.
It’s the same thing that Dooku encountered again and again and led to him turning against the order. The Jedi should never have been enforcers for a government body or bound to other groups’ political interests, and I believe that this is what led them to decline in force sensitivity and become stagnant and corrupt. When you are beholden to outside forces whose interests run against your own, it is easy to lose your own personal direction. By the time of the clone wars, the Jedi had long forgotten who they were, and were tangled up in dogmatic adherence to rules that they no longer remembered the purpose of, and therefore could no longer critically examine when it was most important. This is why it was so easy for Sidious to push them further into becoming unfit military leaders, and stretched them to such a point they were easily broken. The Jedi should have been monks, allowed to follow and study the force. They needed better internal governance and policing, and to treat themselves as an allied body instead of a branch of the senate. I would say your suggested third party should exist, but as ambassadors, certainly not sending jackboots to watch their every move and tell them when to go to war... Though I suspect you were joking about putting the Mandos in charge of them.
Anyway, I love your videos, you’re probably my favorite Star Wars UA-camr because you have a damn heart about some things that most others don’t. I do think we have some different points of focus when it comes to lore, and therefore a difference of perspective. Keep bringing us the excellent insights!
The Imperial Knights from the Legacy comics were a great example of how much better a Force-using organization could be when it *was* subject to rules and regulations. I do like the idea of Mandalorian "internal affairs" officers, perhaps with little backpacks inside their armour holding ysalamiri. Also, Ahsoka, as a Republic citizen, should have got a lawyer, a good one, and sued the Jedi for defamation and wrongful dismissal at the very least.
The Imperial Knights were a joke and nothing more than a puppet of imperial power. I realize that by the late EU the fans and many writers were basically pro Empire, but anybody who read that and thought "good idea" is just completely gone over to imperial ideology.
Did... did GT just propose Dragon Age's literal Knights Templar as a workable solution? Wasn't there a constant narrative throughout the DA games that the Mage Vs Templar split was a terrible system which existed because in Dark Fantasy we can't have nice things?
Silence mage!
Jk lol
Eh yeah.
Society can kinda suck. Look at us.
They had an Andraste, a chance to go a good way, and they blew it lol
Dark fantasy is often just a creative metaphor for reality when you know enough history/the condition of humanity. Truth is often *worse than fiction
And I'm sure going in that many templars meant well abd wanted to protect people: Gregor was pretty reasonable and lenient if you made a good case, Alistair was almost one, and there was a really nice one in the tower until demon invasion gave him ptsd and galvanized him to follow after the corrupt leadership of the Order, which like any organization with 'authority', becomes a power structure that lile the jedi order can be abused.
"We have learned by sad experience that, often, ~as soon as a man gets any authority, as he may suppose, they immediately begin to exercise unrighteous dominion thereof(?)..."
... don't you also run into the conflict of Avengers Civil War, also how would you stop someone like Palpatine from Becoming in charge of the 3rd party that regulates the Jedi?
Or that party becoming a dictatorial secret violent police
I think it’s most important to know they Jedi are not bad people. They just made mistakes like all of us do. They had good intentions and were acted in good intentions, they just didn’t know what they were doing would lead to their downfall or else they definitely would’ve changed some of their ways
Parallels can eternally be drawn between the Jedi Order, and the Catholic Church. As I'm sure George Lucas intended.
@@jacob4920 ya I’ve heard that theory as there are a lot of resemblances
Had the Jedi admitted the fear of the Dark Side lead to their fall they wouldn't had been in that mess which they repeated twice.
yet the Dark Side is type thing we should fear for it leads to Sith and other dangerous cults that causes damage to the galaxy
@@DeathScepter too much light can be dangerous as well.
@@luisemoralesfalcon4716there’s not such a thing as too much light
I always felt the Jedi order needed more visibility and accountability to their order. They should have also been given a seat in the senate as they always claimed to be separate from the government so the people that had a gripe with the Jedi had a proper avenue to file their complaints. You did bring up a great point, where did the Jedi come by their funding, the temple, many workers that they hired to cook and clean and maintain everything, their ships all of that was expensive.
Basically the Jedi needed someone like a Batman is for the Justice League, someone to tell them no and have a contingency plan for them all in case they got out of control. Wonder if someone like a Qui Gon could have been that for them
He refused a position on the Council. I don't think he wanted the job
The issue is what happens if the guy with the contingencies goes insane? You'd get a purge from the inside.
That's why he'd be the best on there, though the part of the Advisor/Truthsayer is always the hardest. A single person as the check and balance, however, is a near impossible and not sustainable task. He did get killed....
If Qui-Gon Jin hadn't died in Episode I, the entire Star Wars saga would have turned out VERY differently! Certainly a lot rosier than what actually happened.
George Lucas not selling out could have saved the Jedi Order.
How so? Do you mean he sold out by making the prequels?
Your math is off
I think you're right that some sort of regulatory body might have been able to keep the Jedi Order from getting in its own way. They might have been able to prevent the likes of Exar Kun from rising. But who would they answer to? If it's the Chancellor's office, which seems like the most obvious choice, I think things will play out mostly the same. It was the Chancellor that wanted the Jedi to lead the GAR after all. If this organization answers to him, they would likely encourage the Jedi to integrate with the GAR more quickly and completely. Under those circumstances, Order 66 might have happened sooner.
I'm not sure that the Mandalorians would be the best choice to make up this group. Sure, they have the equipment and training to take on a Jedi, but your typical Mando is way to aggressive to really fill this role. They are always look for the next biggest fight, which tends to be Jedi. Lots of room for abuse.
And speaking of abuse, modeling this organization after the Templars of Dragon Age is not a great a idea either. The Templars were mostly religious fanatics that were taught to hate and fear magic. They essentially applied the Tarkin Doctrine to the mages. Which had the exact result as in Star Wars. Rebellion.
the Templars of the dragon age games are a terrible example as they were well known for abusing and murdering the mages in their care, they even tried to seize power for themselves. the Templar - Mage relationship was more like jailers and prisoners rather than two trying to keep each other in line as mages were almost never allowed out of their towers without special permission.
Who would then keep the Mandalorians in check? Good idea, that is the only problem I have with it. Who watches the watchers?
I think their biggest problem was they were so in bed with the Republic that they didn't follow the force. Oversight would have worsened this problem
What types of Earth firearms (most likely military grade ones) would fit the Bad Batch, include Omega?
@@TopG371 😭💀
Its a nice notion, but what happens when Sith agents infiltrate and try to manipulate the 3rd party organization? I think the idea would have made the Sith rise to power harder, but I don't know it would have stopped it. Any government agency is just as prone to corruption as the senate and chancellorship
Well it must be said that the Templars in Dragon Age more often than not hated mages with one of their prime doctrines being the cleansing of a Circle if an incursion happened. They even had magical lobotomies as a safeguard. That all ended in a civil war. Imagine if Jedi lobotomized padawans if they were caught pursuing a relationship because it was too much of a risk to fall to the Dark Side. Children like Anakin would have just been executed if they were considered too old for Jedi training. They were definitely underregulated but the comparison was a fairly negative one.
Yogurt's leadership 😵 hit me in the feels box on that one but still facts on the points made.
Isn't this exactly what Atris wanted to do in Kotor 2, rebuilding the Jedi Order with the Echani sisterhood as "templars" keeping watch on the Jedi?
I think you miss something with this line of thinking. The Templeres in Dragon Age have a dubious reputation. Often nobody can question their decisions. While there are good examples of decent Templeres, more often than not, they view mages like a plague and all must be prisoners to them. While partially necessary, I'd say half the general population still viewed them as evil. And in turn, I found them more of an organization that would be happy if they could just kill all mages and we're at the core corrupt and evil in their self deceiving way.
The Templars in Dragon Age are a bad thing. The mages are little more than prisoners with them around, and eventually they rise up. It also would have been easier for Palpatine to wipe the Jedi out. In DA lore there are several examples of Circles of Mages getting completely wiped out if the Templars deem them beyond rescue.
Breaking news, the Mandalorians were severely defeated by the Jedi many times, and the reason why the Jedi fought against them was that the Mandalorians decided that they were going to be conquers.
9:49 Is that from World of Warcraft?
Your channel is becoming my favorite...I love the sociological, psychological, and economic analysis. I especially love the fact that you criticize the Jedi also. I'm with you, I prefer the Jedi to the Sith, but we should criticize anyone in power.
5:07 Gungi's in that scene! That's funny.
I doubt this would really work. Imagine you have an organization of anti-Jedi run independently. Palpatine gains political power, takes control of this organization as Chancellor, and slaughters the Jedi with it. Such an organization would be perfect for Sith manipulation. If anything, it actually sounds a lot like the Mutant Registration Act in X-Men or the Sokovia Accords; a way of counteracting the power of one group that only leads to potentially more problems.
In a universe with Jedi/mutants/superheroes, where some people are just enormously more powerful than others, and are capable of taking over control of planets entirely on their own (either through their combat abilities or mind tricks), I'm not sure US-style democracy with checks and balances really makes sense. The real reason the Jedi were nearly wiped out was because the Republic's style of government was vulnerable to Sith manipulation, and the Jedi were conveniently incapable of realizing it. After all, the Jedi Order system resulted in peace for over 1000 years, which is pretty good for a galaxy-spanning government.
I once took a course on Roman history, and the professor made a compelling point that, despite all the imperfections of the Roman Imperial system, it was actually fully capable of surviving on its own. He argued, convincingly, that the Roman Empire fell because external threats, not internal ones. The Jedi Order seems similar--flawed, but not doomed to fail. Palpatine was just too good.
Did you know that New York was an Dutch colonie New Amsterdam and it was first created by the Zweeds
This is pure genius.
Your suggestions would have saved the Jedi in the sense that Sidious would not have exterminated them -- he would have instead just taken control of the organization along with the rest of the galaxy.
Blink twice if you're in distress Allen. The Sith and Dolphins are putting you up to this aren't they..?? I've heard you point out how to fix them before.
PS Anakin an Obi Wan was asked to stop by later
Somehow I always thought the very opposite. The flaw of the Jed came from being too closely tight to the Republic, being too much under the impression to be an extra arm OF the Republic, when like Qui-Gon, they should serve the Force alone, and not any government or organization or exterior rules.
My guy is trying to bring Naatsi Daala’s policy into Canon
0:21 Yogurt, The Great master jedi Yogurt.🤣
The Schwartz was with him.
The problem with the 3rd party organization is that
1. How would it enforce its authority? Even a single Jedi can just walk all over pretty much anything.
2. That organization will have the issue of staying non corrupt in the long run.
As long as the Templars Inquisitorius doesn't get too powerful itself or they'll have Jedi powering ftl drives like the Rakatans and start yelling Exterminatus at everything.
Yoda blew all the Jedi Funds on his Ketamite Addiction.
0:21 YOGURT! Such a nice Spaceballs easter egg (-x
It probably could have saved the jedi from order 66 since the mandolorians would be able to smell the betrayal from mile away and might hav fought againt the clones or been a middle ground and sorted them both out
I have something in my fanon in form of the first rebellion while trying to know the siths plans after the death of qui gon and the clone wars they are literally trained at first to overthrow the republic before they turned into something horrid, but ended in the clone wars to make sure the republic and the Jedi don’t did anything stupid or get a planet killed, they are trained to resist force powers, to literally used lightsaber proof weapons, and even martial arts the Jedi had forgotten, until the accidentally discovered order 66, and having hatred of them the Jedi just called them traitors that finally snapped, and it forced them to flee to wait 20 years to rebuild their strength while the Jedi is banished their last guard dog, and their special needs help
You launch a good discussion here. Definitely food for thought.
But while you have the 3rd party checking the Jedi, who would check the checkers? Who would ensure the Sith wouldn't infiltrate the organization checking the Jedi. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Not to mention if you told Mandalorians that there was an organization meant to keep the Jedi in check they'd probably volunteer just for the chance to punch either Windu or Kenobi in the face.
Not gonna lie, not sure that the DA mage circles are the best example. Though it all existed for a reason (those dam Tevinter Magisters) they were a liiiiitle bit extreme (on both sides granted) when it came to things like basic human rights. I mean mages not being able to be in relationships, own property, get married, and in some cases not even leave the circle grounds (and like in DA2 forced into confinement and constant invasive searches for bloodmagic). Not to say that the concept is bad, but a central focus of dragon age was just how corrupt and divisive this system had become. DA2 i think showed it best, all it takes is someone like Meredith and Orsino creating tension, then one extremist like Anders then boom, global scale war.
The Jedi would be in Mage Circles if the people of Star Wars remembered the Rakatans as force users instead of an ancient evil species.
@@zacharyhansen9103 Good point. I may have sort of forgotten about that cause I fill my head with videogame lore instead of star wars lore lol. Regardless, I think a whole check system like the DA Templars might have actually worked provided there was a bit more attentiveness payed to the rights of force sensitives as well as Government oversight for both parties (as compared to the DA templars/chantry system). What do u think?
@@canyonduck2022 I don’t think there is a perfect system that will work indefinitely.
The Templars worked as long as they did because they had more rights and responsibilities than the mages. So long as they took their responsibilities to the mages as seriously as they took their responsibilities to the larger public than things worked fine enough. However once they started disregarding their responsibilities their extra rights became a means of corruption and encouraged the rise of evil not good within their ranks.
If the Mandalorians were in the same situation as the Templars the same thing would happen. It would probably happen sooner rather than later given how pride tends to be a more common trait in Mandalorians than a sense of duty is.
Maybe 🤔
Love the mandalorian Templar check and balance idea. I think it’d be helpful and bring more favoritism to the mandalorians in the galaxy of Star Wars instead of this view that they are primarily. like death watch, ruthless and only caring for blood and glory and themselves. The mandalorians would have more honor and respect of the wider range of the galaxy and would also be a great military presence. Point is that if the mandalorians were ever to be apart of the republic militarily as the Jedi’s counterpart. The galaxy would probably be a lot safer if a place.
I agree. They could also have a sort of assassin branch that's just the emotion overwhelming techniques from kotor2.
It would be cool as hell for that to be a new I'll be it difficult technique and open the ways mandalorians can be politically cunning while dangerous.
I feel like it's too much to expect the mandalorians to ever genuinely serve the republic.
@@gryphonbotha1880
It would be between the madalorian extremes of the Duchess and Death watch most likely appealing to most members of both sides. This way they can still have their warrior creed without glassing every third planet.
It was tried. It didn't end well. At all.
Maybe a video going more into Kix’s back story during the clone wars and even after
Taron malikos said it best when he said that the jedi fell a long time before the purge because they became to controlling of there own people and also they would do whatever it took to look good in front of the republic even if that meant throwing some of there own members under the bus.
Pissing your self with an arc out of your pant waiyis freaking talent
great video. it's good to see you feeling good and healthy again. thanks for your work!
So the Starwars version of something like SWAP, tarred and equipped for extreme circumstances specifically regarding Jedi. If not other force users.
The drunk guy who unleashes the full power of the dark side on his pants.
0:07 Yeah, it's more based than biased
You should make a video on the nihl from the books the high Republic
Say in an alternate situation, instead of Anakin reporting Palps as the "Sith Lord", he or someone else reported the "Chancellor" as the puppet master behind the war. Do the Jedi still go in unilaterally, or do they get Republic law enforcement involved? Because looking solely at Palps as a Sith, the Jedi have some (flawed) legitimacy in how they handled things. In the alternative scenario I'm not so sure that he would have been able to manipulate his way out of the situation. At least not so easily.
I have thought about this too. If the jedi had confronted Palpatine with cameras rolling and a live feed to all holo-projectors, Palpatine might not have been able to turn the clones on the jedi. Lest he be seen as the dictator he really was. Also, since it was not illegal for a Chancler to be a Sith lord, once they confronted him with this knowledge, they could have said 'okay, that's fine.' and left the room, if he didn't admit to being the one who started the war in the first place. What could Palpatine do?
GT the Jedi are a great thing to have had you are one of those who can't be pleased
You said mass effect really oddly
😂 did he say Yogurt in the beginning, like Space Balls
It's all about Merchandising...
Didn't daala in legends try this with the mandalorians and it worked out horribly?
Who’s side would you be on in Marvel’s Civil War, Alan?
in the words of Yogurt.. " Do or do not. There is no try." I like to add a probably true future statement from Grogurt. " There is only the way."
*Gogurt (inspired by the portable yogurt product targeted towards kids..and yes there IS a star wars variant in packaging!)
Using the Mandalorians to police the Jedi? Didn't Natasi Daala try that when she was head of the Galactic Alliance? As I recall, it went horribly wrong
The Republic deserves a lot of blame in this scenario also. They are the ones who refused to change the status quo, and to demand more oversight of the Jedi organization. They ALLOWED the Jedi Order to become corrupted by their power, because they felt the Jedi were uncorruptible (and they also had their own systems to worry about). Also, why spend ridiculous amounts of money and resources on a Grand Army of the Republic, when the Jedi Order will happily "keep the peace" for free?
Here is another thing that would have been good for the Jedi. Instead of just taking the young. They should have adopted the families too. I do not think Anakin would have fallen so easy if they had taken his mother with them.
At least if said family was in dire straits.
Mandalorians should've been contracted as a 3rd party as a balancer for Jedi.
I love your setting
Perhaps some sort of charter from the Senate actually defining what the Jedi were authorized to do and what their actual relationship with the Republic was, rather than just this vaguely defined policing military philosophical order?
Bruh… less toking before filming 😂 I’m kidding of course love the content
I love that he called Yoda yogurt
Jedi also overly ridged lead to stagnation and zealotry to their destruction.Much of rules and such inplace allowing jedi to some major manipulation by the Senate .
Thing is, if Kotor is canon the Jedi should've learnt the lessons they got fucked by during the clone wars, but the Jedi were trying to fight a foe who'd changed up the game entirely.
Your shirt isn't nearly as open and unbuttoned as usual, I will take that as a sign of respect for the Jedi for this video
You can look at old paps and tell he's up to no good lol
I appreciate your criticism of the Jedi.
Btw, are you buzzed?
The only lighsaber I want is the Youngling Slayer 2000.
If your neighbor is a Sith Lord, you will not live long enough. Forget about the grass dying off.
And who would have kept this third order from being corrupted? Or infiltrated by rogue Jedi?
Wasn't the Senate supposed to regulate the Jedi?
Dragon age is an amazing series
Yogurt? 00:20 - just plain Yoghurt? 😉
Bureaucrats innit
How dare you for calling him YOGURT! 😵😱😫😩😫😖
Didn't Chief of State formerly Admiral Dala try to regulate the Jedi Luke's reborn Order? That failed miserably and the Jedi took over. The Jedi specifically Jaina Solo didn't like having her privacy taken away by such regulations. Everything has it's downsides if overused.