Yes, not the ones that get angry at you for sharing an answer they perceive to be incorrect. This is a professor that may well be aware of the fact that your answer is off but does not show you that. She simply responds with questions and ideas in order to get you to think a little more or to get you to consider the ideas of those around you.
As long as your ideologies align. In this case there was clearly a preferred answer which also happen to give students an opportunity to virtue signal. Classic positive reinforcement for the students who shared her opinion.
This is the type of educators who encourage you to state your opinions in a wide perspective ways and of course someone that I wish I had in my life, or probably I would someday😻😻
@@arjumandayub9049 missed the point, he said they are lucky to have a good teacher. He did not say they are lucky to be at Harvard . U can work hard and get to Harvard and still get a bad teacher.
I stopped listening to my teachers this year. It was the best idea I had. I have rules tho to get a great knowledge on your own: be passionate/curious in everything that can help you achieve your rational but still idealistic goal, work everyday but not a lot of hours just a few like 2 or 3 hours then stop and practice what you learnt some days later. And finally listen only to certified people not those dummies that give their opinion, just the facts. For example, i stopped maths last year because i thought it was boring but now that I have a goal it is all different. I was not passionate about it maybe because my teachers were cold hearted and only cared about the pay check. It is an hobbie now to learn maths, i learn more efficiently and faster because i don't have strict rules to follow and i found good resources that are interesting. Plus stop toxic habits like eating fast food, a lot of sugar... Do some sports, go to sleep early, stop going out with superficial people. Those easy things can really change your life on the long term. It's a good investment. Do not fall for the easy traps of pleasure and the environment around you.
Absolutely agree. During highschool I absolutely hated my anatomy and physiology classes, mainly blaming it on my general dislike of memorisation heavy subjects. I ended up studying medicine and excelling in said classes, developing a deep passion for understanding the ins and outs of the human body only then did I realize the difference in my professors. My highschool professor would sit and just read from the book, showing up late to class and for the most part refusing to answer questions, she wouldn't address us or even notice if someone was missing from class and during exams you could easily pull out your phone and cheat. My university professor stressed the importance of knowing anatomy and physiology, she gave us the reasons for knowing it and how valuable it will be not only during other subjects in our course but once we enter the world as physicians and take care of our patients. Every time she would show up for class you could see that she fully believed what she said and was willing to push us to see it with the same passion.
I hated anything math related back in hs and there was this month wherein our professor was temporarily changed nd in that month, no, in the first 2 days that the sub prof came in i realized that math was actually fun & i looked forward to it everyday. Profs do matter. I excelled in Sci back in hs but on my last year science was my lowest subject simply because the prof wasnt as good as tbe one who taught me throughout hs. just sharing. :D
Same. Introvert doesnt equal shy. For me it just means I get exhausted from social interaction a bit faster than someone who's extroverted, especially if it's shallow, although i love it sometimes. But I thrive in constructive discussions like this
I'm sure, not every teacher at Harvard teaches like her. It is not Harvard, but the teacher who is making the difference here. She is an incredible teacher.
Some people may say she's putting on a show for marketing purposes. However, I've actually had a professor like this at my institution who showed up with amazing energy and excitement towards the course at least 97% of the time. There are professors out there like this who exist, who make learning fun, comfortable, engaging, and extremely valuable.
We called these business case Studies. In my classes the students did most of the talking which in my opinion is the idea because it brings out their creativity. The professor joined then every now and then when he thought it was necessary. I learned a lot from this course. The subject matter provided its own energy.
@@Ghostrider-xc2hgCoca cola has marketing. Mcdonald’s has marketing. Reputation does not negate the need for marketing. And this video IS obviously marketing. But the professor is not putting on a show. The opposite is more likely to be true - that she was chosen for this video as a result of her energy.
Most people find they hated the teachers of the subjects they hated. So how often were we repelled from a subject because the teacher repelled us? This is perhaps why online teaching is much better in some ways: You can choose the teacher (in a good system). Some people just rub us the wrong way. Its hard to counteract. And a student shouldn't have to. Their education is just so much more important. Never let personality interfere with your learning. Life is too short for that and we have a lot of problems to solve.
@@huyyyshaa6284 no i mean the interactions and the teacher is what I like regardless if its boring as long as the environment is positive no judgements
Today I phisically attended one of the MBA classes at Harvard as a visitor (you can do too, it is open). I thought the video was probably one of the most successful classes that can be shown publicly. But the real lesson was even better than this. Atmosphere, teaching, coordination, students are just unbelieveable. Around 70-80% students out of 95 (!) spoke at least once. The teacher did a great job in coordination. There was 20 minute summary presentation by her, which was cherry on top. I can't believe just a casual lesson can be in such a high quality
@@racboo8777 Nothing equates investing and when it's done properly, you don't need to get all worked up about money any more as it creates a lot of extra income.
@@jessenoah6113 I wanted to trade crypto on my own but got confused by the fluctuations in price and lost a lot of my fund, sincerely I don't think investing is for me!
Both of my English professors (undergrad) had this same contagious energy! Not only did we learn how to write better, we became listeners, active listeners and enthusiastic learners.
It all boils down to manners. True education is having manners, not flexing intelligence over the other, but hearing them out to broaden your perspective. In the end, the truly educated person is one with respect.
It will be an asian citizen lol. Im an asian, but I do prefer to speak up, while they think' Im too pretend to have teacher / lecture attention lol. Im not
Omg what da environment! People have freedom to share without judging and bullying. The dynamic of teacher is so fun and involving everybody together. I respect her and students so much! This is education not copying or just sitting and listening and lecturing. Congrats guys! Thx for big inspiration
@@popsiwapat This is not how academics discuss things amongst each other. These are kids who are being sold a bill of goods by a teacher who is full of herself. It is entertaining and that is all it is. If you are willing to pay Harvard a hefty fee for entertainment, who is going to stop you?
@Latrease Leah I graduated from UC Berkeley and took some classes at Stanford…best teacher I had was at a community college. My mom was a professor at Cal State Long Beach who received her PhD from Vassar. She was a lot like this professor…simply passionate about the subject with an actual love for teaching. Good professors like this can be found at every level of education. Many believe it’s the brand name of the university. Not true. The higher the university the more those professors usually have to publish and do research if on a tenure track, leaving less time for students.
My favorite all-time teacher was at San Francisco State. I'm sure most people don't even know that's a school, but it's one of the better communications universities in the Bay Area. He loved teaching and the biggest part of his class was making sure he was engaging with us and we were engaging with each other. He probably taught at max half the class every time, the rest of the time was conversations. Best two classes I ever took, also the two hardest classes I ever took lol.
@Latrease Leah yea that is exactly what ivy league schools want people to believe, because that is how they justify the high tuition bill. It simply isn't true. I mean I don't know about at the community college level but I do know for a fact there are amazing university professors who are not in the ivy league that are more effective than many of their ivy league counterparts.
The energetic Harvard professor is igniting minds, transforming passive listeners into active contributors. She is incredibly awesome ! Professor "Tsedel Neeley" we Love you....
The case she’s talking about was a decision made by CEO Cynthia Carroll, who decided to SHUT DOWN 2 platinum mines to take time to promote safety training
Temporarily shut down or permanently shut down? Because I feel like if I was in that position, I'd temporary shut down the operation to do some investigations, it could be the site, it could be the equipment, etc and then proceed upon the result of the investigation before resuming the operation.
Why am I crying? I really want to experience Education like this. In our school there is always favoritism. How I wish I can attend to a School just like this. Fair and equal.
Same sentiments. I thought I'm crazy for tearing up, how I wish I learned this way in university. Sadly, more than 1 year of my college life was spent in home because of COVID.
Excuse me for pointing out my view, I think that everybody needs a teacher who can see their talents and guid them to achieve that what they want. For everyone it's different and for somebodies she wouldn't be the right teacher.
gotta disagree. in high school i had an amazing legal teacher who was motivated just like this. she gave us so many resources, real life examples, tips to succeed in the subject yet so many students could care less about their education.
The first time I watched this, I can barely understand them without subtitles. Right now, I can totally understand them without subtitles. I'm so happy!
This is not for students, this is actually for teachers to learn how they need to be passionate and create an environment for the students especially for those who are not so expressive or introverts
I don't understand how people blame and insist that the teachers are driving the social atmosphere, this problem legitimately resides on the students shoulders, the engagement usually depends on the students interest in the subject.
This is grad school not elementary school. You go to this to learn how to manage groups of people - if you are not expressive, introverted to the point of not being able to participate in a conversation you are not ready to lead anyone. People will be coming to you for solutions right or wrong you have to think quick and make a choice. If you spend your time getting anxious about having to speak in front of folks who might disagree with you. Not sure what to tell you but you won't be running a good business or managing people well.
It's not just the teacher that's creating this wonderful learning environment. The main contributors are the students who are willing and eager to participating in this exchange. From my experience from a small local college, getting a class like this is also every teacher's dream, because the fun part of teaching is in the class
I agree. If the students are interactive enough, the teacher can maintain this sort of atmosphere where students are pushed through the limits and made to think about different possibilities of a situation. This makes students smarter and helps them grow personally and professionally.
Totally enabled by the teacher. I was an introvert and wouldn't say a word in class until I met a teacher who encouraged me to. Now, I always look forward to contributing not minding the vulnerability. 100% on the teacher.
@@iamrising7176 Yes, enabling is definitely needed for this environment and there will always be students like you who are willing to open up to that enabling. But from a teacher's perspective, just like how students find different kinds of teachers, they also find that different classes have different collective nature. It will just depend on what mindset most of the students have. Some students are receptive while some are not, and in college level it's extremely difficult to give enough individuals attention to each student and employ what they are receptive towards. For a teacher, every class is different.
i truly truly truly admire the way she teaches and how engaging the students are. This is exactly what i crave in teaching and learning at school, unlike what i am now experiencing which is so boring and tiring.
My IB history teacher teaches like this and barely ever gives out homework and all of his students have As because we learn more through engaging conversations and not through lecture/note taking
My high-school teacher was like that and unfortunately she left for retirement last year, right as I entered my senior year at the age of 81. I now plan to study History after my gap year all because of that wonderful woman.
My IB business teacher is like this. She’s so amazing at explaining things I come out of her class sad because it ended yet full of ideas and knowledge. I love her!
If they teach kids like this in primary school and higher, then we wouldn't need a Harvard Edit: cheers for the likes. Goes to show how bad the system is
@@helloeveryone0123 well you can get better than whats available now. If teachers were paid better and vetted with excellent grades and teaching ability then we wouldn't have a stupid society. Same goes for police
I totally agree. And I’m guessing here, but I think what you’re pointing out is not having doctors and professors teaching elementary subjects, but rather instilling a culture in the classroom of vulnerability, authentic engagement, comfort with failing and doing so with intention. That is something all grades desperately need.
For sustainability it would be an advantage. Usually, people think too much on the short term. Business education is often too much short term thinking.
@@nanashipersonne4151 So you're sayin' it's all about the sustainability of profit? And any heart stuff is a means to an end? You're trying to kill two birds with one stone. Might work, but more likely one needs prioritizing over the other as they're inherently in conflict. That means policy needs to flexibly fit the situation. How is that possible if the policy is written from above? Should the workers make policy? Standard procedure would continue operations while someone investigated. Better would stop the operation and have the CEO fly down with her own interpreter to interview workers to find the problem and solution. Can't use a local interpreter as the workers would not trust them. I'd guess the CEO would learn all about everything allowing her to elevate safety, satisfaction, and profit. Would get to know the people too; every CEO should know the people underlying her operation.
after seeing this , i want to give every student that doesn't have good grades in the world an opportunity to witness what school was really meant to be.
This professor is passionate about teaching and her field. It comes across clearly. She is in constant motion around the room. She is sparking interest and conversation. When you get a professor like this it makes all the difference in your education. I was a Political Science major and one of my professors was former CIA. He had such high energy. He loved teaching and had a great wealth of first hand knowledge.
Ich würde es als typisch "Ami" bezeichnen. Vielleicht hätte die "Dame" eher Schauspielerin in Hollywood werden sollen *augenroll*. In Europa wären ihre Chancen und ihre Glaubwürdigkeit bei.... ungefähr.... NULL.
Bruh, I paid $650 USD+ on a degree each month and still find some lecturer absent in class, not even mention that I can't even access the internet properly when my degree is in computer engineering.
Even if I get social anxiety when it comes to talking to a lot of people I can definitely say I would love this class, I would participate very eagerly
You can get the same information for 1/20th the price these days anyway. The Ivy League schools were only ever a rich status symbol. There are passionate and incredibly talented teachers in schools all over the world--not just Harvard.
Bruh why even bother wasting time getting an admission, at the end we all are gonna die anyways, live your life to the fullest you never know if death comes at your door tommorow itself
@@justsomeguy4260 cuz then we dont get into better jobs . cuz u see the guy next seat has a Harvard degree and more qualifications . a higher paying job will equal to ( for me) atleast getting out of my country and seeing the world . I am not even asking much like being in Harvard. I just want enough qualifications that is needed for me to get into a business mnc abroad to see the world. but the problem is I am not rlly aware of what is needed. neither google searches solves it when literally they can be one thousand variant of the same question by different people
@@justsomeguy4260 maybe to some people that's how they live their life to the fullest. some people spend their time differently enjoy things differently. it's good to live to the fullest, but every person takes it in their own ways, so it's not a waste of time.
I’m probably one of the oldest MBA students to be found anywhere. At 65 I’m learning more from the programme than I could possibly have imagined. This professor has so beautifully articulated the joy and value of learning by orchestrating her students into the realm of critical thinking. To all of you that may be pondering the value of an MBA, think no more. The value is incalculable - do whatever you can to follow this course of learning. You’ll never regret it.
If the world had more educators such as Professor Neeley, I guarantee the drop out rates would significantly decline and more people would yearn for education. Amazing job!
If the world had more students like the students in the video, the amount of teachers willing to improve their teaching methods will probably be higher...
@@BlackCat-yt4gp I love how people blame the education system for failing to nurture their children, which is not their responsibility, and whenever they propose new education methods it's usually some secular or liberal political justice issue.
I'm a medical officer who currently specialized in Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health and hearing all of this discussion really open my mind. Really inspire.
I see all of them laughing all the time, but yet here I am wanting to CRY everyday I go to class. I wish I had the brains and dedication like they do. Truly inspiring!
May I offer the comment, you may definitely have the brains but possibly not a dedicated teacher like the one in this video. 🤷🏽♀️ . affirm yourself always 💛
Don’t worry you got the brains. Plus this is exactly how this video is meant to make you feel,it’s made by Harvard and edited for publicity. Focus your study on what you like and don’t forget that education is a personal quest for knowledge: you decide the ending and the way.
Having brains will likely keep you out of a classroom like this. These universities aren’t the end all be all. I noticed that not one person said, “I need more information before making this decision.” Some of them went straight for the race card, etc. Dedication comes in many forms and they aren’t all in a classroom setting 👍🏽
AWESOME, i am from Pakistan. This type of study culture is new to me. What the incredible 10 minutes i consumed to see and learn this lecture not only view but see by heart. The professor you are remarkable. Hats off.
I'm jealous of classes like this. Some teachers in the schools I've been to require "class participation" yet shut down/shame/intimidate students the moment they answered incorrectly in class. Moreover, some students get shamed for being stupid or being smart (ie. teacher's pet, a showoff, or overachiever). In some cases, students would be waiting on whoever raises a hand first before they even attempt to participate in classroom discussions. It's probably why my Literature teacher back in high school was the one I remember the most: she instilled the idea that "there are no wrong answers in her class" because everyone has a different interpretation whenever we were discussing literary works - my answers may not be perfect all the time, but I felt more confident in participating because I wasn't scared of sharing my thoughts on the topic.
The reason why she is a good teacher is because the students are paying so much money to be in her class they paid at least $25,000 to be at this college, so of course she's going to be a good teacher, after all you get what you pay for.
In a well run MBA course there are no right or wrong answers. Simply participating on the topic at hand is enough… and everything else required in the course flows right along by doing that.
@@grimmygrinda3267 but the fact that she was chosen to be a teacher there means that she is a professional, so it's not only about the amount of salary that is given to her, but her own skills that she is paid for
For real and I graduated uni last year and never looked back in being in a classroom but this ..omg take my money introduce me this teacher and give me the learning experience I’ve always wanted 🥲
I really feel the synergy in this workplace culture. The customer journey one goes through on this deep dive really allows them to ballpark their future in possible startups. The visibility on these pain points is so important to improve product sustainability and genuine core competency within the next generation of hyperlocal to nationwide companies. It is so holistic to teach logistics in a way that doesn't only focus on what their quotas and quick wins would be, rather aligning with an ecosystem of good business. These students have such high bandwidth and placing them in such an ecosystem really incentivizes them to see all the big data and move the needle in a positive direction!
@@chandyalexander9504 Not everyone gets scholarships lol. Only a few get it. Imagine living in a poor country where the government does NOT want to spend on education at all.
The way Professor keep challenging the students leadership qualities is commendable. A teacher must have high level of energy to keep the class on toes and that exactly what she was doing. Fantastic.
I've had the privilege of sitting in the classroom of a teacher with an extraordinary presence-passionate, brilliant, and masterfully engaging, leaving the class captivated with his thought-provoking orchestration of each case.
I had a teacher like her in college. I wished she was my teacher in elementary and high school so that we started a great foundation making us interested in the idea of school.
Yea, I've had one or two like this. I promise you not all teachers are like this in Ivy League campuses. They have just as many dry, boring, and unreasonable or disinterested professors as anywhere else.
To those whom isn’t lucky to be there, become an entrepreneur today. You will learn from real life, experiences, failures, mistakes, struggles, tears, successes, personal growth, everything. I would argue it’s more satisfying especially when you experience success from your own doing. You don’t need Harvard. You need you.
Professor Neeley - your approach, attitude, excitement, passion and ability to engage in the conversation! Simply amazing! I wish all professors could share the same charisma! Hats Off!
Let's take a moment to appreciate the teacher, She's not just hearing but listening to the student's responses! Every student deserves a teacher like her!
Omg, I love the professor, her energy, her knowledge, and especially her smile, her spirit and the way she teach made an often times, dark and dividing case study like this, to become a form of unity where at the end of the day we’re all working towards one goal. Love the energy of the classroom as well, their all so determined, but it’s not in the form of competition rather their all one team but with different opinions and ideas👏👏👏
Harvard doesn't have this type of learning everyday. It's a promotional video designed to engage with the viewer. I guarantee that most of the other MBA courses aren't this exciting to watch. A lot of work in everyday life is boring, but you still have to put in the time and effort to do it. You need to find something interesting about it. This is probably why most people don't want to go to class. You can't sit around and expect it to be as fun as a promotional UA-cam video like this. If you're better prepared for class and read the assigned reading or did the work before hand, you would probably find it more exciting that day. Most people don't do this.
Tsedal Neeley, you are an incredible teacher. Whenever I am watching the video, I feel like I am sitting in front of you and literally I am answering. Love the method
As a person with ADHD this is the only teaching method that actually engaged me in any class I've been in. I remember professors with this teaching style quite fondly
Watching this video makes me think in-person class never be the same as online class. I admire with the way that professor facilitated the clas and how all the students expressed their ideas.
@Rieski Kurniasari R. RE: "Watching this video makes me think in-person class never be the same as online class." I could've told you that in a heartbeat! Given a choice, I would ALWAYS choose an in-person class over an on-line class.
@@marcomoriarty6049 This is a slight variation of The Socratic method - which derived from the Greek philosopher, Socrates. SO no Harvard didn't "create" this methodology of teaching.
I have so many opinions I want to share but I get too anxious talking in front of the class, perks of online schooling is I can use the chat and I don't see other people's face and they don't get to see mine if I don't want to show it. My teachers have the choice either they see my face but don't hear me talk or I don't show my face and I make the class 10 times more interesting for everyone
You are the embodiment of what teaching should be. You're amazing and spectacular. I wish I could be in one of your class. Transmitting information through excitement involvement with an emotional connection is called Education. This should be the norm. Not the exception.
Having teachers that are passionate about what they're teaching is a huge key in students actively wanting to learn and retain information. Too many classes I've had monotoned professors who just ramble information at us and we have to take notes and study notes. That sucked and frankly is hard to learn. Then I've had professors who care about what they're teaching, and teach us through conversation and engagement to the point where you never really even have a chance to take notes because you're so engaged in the lesson. Yet even without the notes, everything that was spoke on that day, you retained and remembered, and enjoyed. We need more teachers like this.
It’s still just business school and not rocket science as they say. Apparently some people in the class still aren’t smart enough to pick the obvious answer the SJW professor was looking for. Fall in line with your professor’s ideology and preserve your GPA, especially when being judged on an opinion as opposed to true or false.
@@LetterSignedBy51SpiesWasA-Coup you have to be kidding me right? their acceptance rate for the business school is 12%. Whilst, "Smart" maybe subjective, the fact is everyone of them are on the above average at the least.
@@junyaophoon7671 again, most of the people pursuing MBAs in Ivy Leagues, are already in some sort of managerial position. Academics is one of the many factors taken into consideration for acceptance into Ivy leagues, you need to have a bunch load of extra curricular achievements to even be considered.
What an amazing educator - so inspiring, engaging, dynamic, passionate and powerful. Although I’ve been teaching for 30 years, I can still do better and do more after watching this professor - thank you maam 🙏 for being such an aspirational teacher ❤
This is how my Architecture Design class is, especially when we’re critiquing; I definitely learn better this way than having a boring instructor read word from word out of a book.
This is my issue with MBA Programs. I was in one after being in the real world for about five years and they don't relate to the real world in anyway. They teach you how to value money over people. If you put the value in People the bottom line will increase. I have always and will always hire experience over education
@@danmorowitz that's great but what about beginners? They have to start somewhere to build up "experience". And in some countries it's strict that you don't get an employment below 18. So they try to get into best colleges like these where getting your first job is more likely than not.
"One day, not only that could be you, I know that one day it will be you" This is the best punchline not me crying in my seat while studying, such a great motivation that I need.
I’ve worked with many of MBA grads, in all sorts of industries, both as coworkers or clients. I have worked with thousands of clients, save hundreds of millions of dollars in annualized savings. Many MBA-ers I’ve struggled with were those who had difficulty relating to the working people who’s jobs they’re trying to affect: above all the skill of listening. Classroom brainstorming and debates has a place, certainly, but an important lesson often missed by most MBA-ers is actually listening to the people. I must say 80% of my work is listening to everyone (to see how the system functions or not), and 20% is getting these people to work together as a team to accomplish the company’s business plan. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard, “We’ve been telling them (mgt) for years and no one listens to use. Workers - management work together as a team to solve problems before it requires any serious changes, like shutting down an operation, except of course due to safety reasons.
agreed. The guy who wanted to do the review was pushed into a "decision" for show. Vs getting to any detail about the fatality. Pretty quick analysis can determine if there's a systemic factor at play, be it culture, equipment maintenance, training, that necessitate a safety stand down - or if it's pretty clearly a one off that has more of a nudge solution to prevent in future.
@@brentdavidson1 The guy who wanted to do the review was *not* pushed into a 'decision' for show. She asked a second time, he stayed with wanting an investigation, she switched to "What are you learning in this investigation?" She asked for *exactly* the answer you just gave.
"If the world had more educators like her" honestly it plays both ways. I've seen students not raising their hands, not participating and no engaging with the lessons despite how amazing the teacher is. Education can definitely be like what's in the video if teachers are ready to orchestrate and students are ready to play.
That's true but at the same time a class consist of a lot more students for 1 educator, if only 50% of the students are willing to play it's already a step into the right direction and will influence the 50% remaining, on the other side if the only educator isn't willing to orchestrate then it just does nothing.
Sure but, wouldn’t it make more sense if a passionate teacher who is willing to bring out the best in students no matter how much it takes be more better than a participating student? I mean what’s the point of participating if doing so won’t do anything for you. A good teacher wouldn’t need to have all kids be able to participate, a good teacher will inspire them to.
@@lethalbutterknife2311it should be a two way street. & you shouldn’t just do things just to get something out of it for your sole benefit. Being a teacher is hard work & they deserve to have students interacting. It’s not their job to make you put effort in.
@@kendramills2138 Right, both teachers and students should participate, but it’s more important to have a passionate teacher. Think of it, what would be the point of buying a whole car but not the steering wheel…it wouldn’t be reasonable. In the same way, although it’s a factor to have students participate, it is of much more importance for a teacher to be driven to teach them, to work with them to make them a better..more knowledgeable person. That is what a teacher is, and that is the point of teaching.
@@lethalbutterknife2311 There's no but in this. It's an equal two way traffic. I've been in a class of a very lively and engaging lecturer but we the students just didn't catch the vibe.
This is the type of educator that makes you feel safe to share your thoughts.
Yes, not the ones that get angry at you for sharing an answer they perceive to be incorrect. This is a professor that may well be aware of the fact that your answer is off but does not show you that. She simply responds with questions and ideas in order to get you to think a little more or to get you to consider the ideas of those around you.
As long as your ideologies align. In this case there was clearly a preferred answer which also happen to give students an opportunity to virtue signal. Classic positive reinforcement for the students who shared her opinion.
This is the type of educators who encourage you to state your opinions in a wide perspective ways and of course someone that I wish I had in my life, or probably I would someday😻😻
@@-TheMaskedMan- yeah, that technique is called coaching
Couldn't agree more
These students are not lucky not cuz it's Harvard , they're lucky they got such a passionate teacher.
and wouldn't you know it? Harvard, the best university in the world, has the best teachers in the world.
You believe too much in appearances. Quite american.
It's not luck.. Most of them worked really hard to reach Harvard
I don't think its luck they worked hard for it
@@arjumandayub9049 missed the point, he said they are lucky to have a good teacher. He did not say they are lucky to be at Harvard . U can work hard and get to Harvard and still get a bad teacher.
This professor here proves the quote -'If you find your studies boring, probably you are learning from the wrong teacher'.
1st comment
I stopped listening to my teachers this year. It was the best idea I had. I have rules tho to get a great knowledge on your own: be passionate/curious in everything that can help you achieve your rational but still idealistic goal, work everyday but not a lot of hours just a few like 2 or 3 hours then stop and practice what you learnt some days later. And finally listen only to certified people not those dummies that give their opinion, just the facts.
For example, i stopped maths last year because i thought it was boring but now that I have a goal it is all different. I was not passionate about it maybe because my teachers were cold hearted and only cared about the pay check. It is an hobbie now to learn maths, i learn more efficiently and faster because i don't have strict rules to follow and i found good resources that are interesting. Plus stop toxic habits like eating fast food, a lot of sugar... Do some sports, go to sleep early, stop going out with superficial people. Those easy things can really change your life on the long term. It's a good investment. Do not fall for the easy traps of pleasure and the environment around you.
So true!
Absolutely agree. During highschool I absolutely hated my anatomy and physiology classes, mainly blaming it on my general dislike of memorisation heavy subjects. I ended up studying medicine and excelling in said classes, developing a deep passion for understanding the ins and outs of the human body only then did I realize the difference in my professors. My highschool professor would sit and just read from the book, showing up late to class and for the most part refusing to answer questions, she wouldn't address us or even notice if someone was missing from class and during exams you could easily pull out your phone and cheat. My university professor stressed the importance of knowing anatomy and physiology, she gave us the reasons for knowing it and how valuable it will be not only during other subjects in our course but once we enter the world as physicians and take care of our patients. Every time she would show up for class you could see that she fully believed what she said and was willing to push us to see it with the same passion.
I hated anything math related back in hs and there was this month wherein our professor was temporarily changed nd in that month, no, in the first 2 days that the sub prof came in i realized that math was actually fun & i looked forward to it everyday. Profs do matter. I excelled in Sci back in hs but on my last year science was my lowest subject simply because the prof wasnt as good as tbe one who taught me throughout hs. just sharing. :D
This is the type of educator that makes you feel safe to share your thoughts.
Lies again? Apex Predator Must Be Professional
Classes need to be more like this. It’s more of a conversation rather than just teaching material
This is so true ... you learn so much through just communicating with people in society. But students must also be willing to participate.
Totally agree
it is a graduate class. at that level it is more conversation and less teaching.
@@Icecube88 thank u for taking some sense here
Korea Japan china left the chat
I am an introvert, but sitting with these people and having those kinds of conversation is something I love to engage with
Same. Introvert doesnt equal shy. For me it just means I get exhausted from social interaction a bit faster than someone who's extroverted, especially if it's shallow, although i love it sometimes. But I thrive in constructive discussions like this
Me too
Usually introverts just don’t like small talk but are fine with deep, stimulating conversations
same
Same here :))
I'm sure, not every teacher at Harvard teaches like her. It is not Harvard, but the teacher who is making the difference here. She is an incredible teacher.
Very true
And Harvard has the very best teachers in the world.
Much too much drama. Your taste buds should scream.
I really hope not every teacher at Harvard is like her. I really hope nobody else is like that
@@boringmanager9559 why
Some people may say she's putting on a show for marketing purposes. However, I've actually had a professor like this at my institution who showed up with amazing energy and excitement towards the course at least 97% of the time. There are professors out there like this who exist, who make learning fun, comfortable, engaging, and extremely valuable.
i wish i could understand what she is talking about ... my english is to bad to understand this.
And I have promised myself that I am going to be one of those professors.
Just 3 more years of waiting and working.
We called these business case Studies. In my classes the students did most of the talking which in my opinion is the idea because it brings out their creativity. The professor joined then every now and then when he thought it was necessary. I learned a lot from this course. The subject matter provided its own energy.
why marketing? It's harvard
@@Ghostrider-xc2hgCoca cola has marketing. Mcdonald’s has marketing.
Reputation does not negate the need for marketing. And this video IS obviously marketing. But the professor is not putting on a show. The opposite is more likely to be true - that she was chosen for this video as a result of her energy.
Imagine if every single person in the world were given the opportunity to an education like this from the very beginning of their schooling life
This is the very best education, obviously the most deserving will get it lol
Welcome to UA-cam.
Yeah, that would happen when education fully goes to the internet
You have to earn it buddy, I know your too lazy that’s why you just want it to be handed to you but that’s not the way the world works.
Then I could become the president... OK maybe not...
I never hated learning, I just hated school.
Mood
Underrated comment
so fucking true
love the comment
Most people find they hated the teachers of the subjects they hated. So how often were we repelled from a subject because the teacher repelled us? This is perhaps why online teaching is much better in some ways: You can choose the teacher (in a good system). Some people just rub us the wrong way. Its hard to counteract. And a student shouldn't have to. Their education is just so much more important. Never let personality interfere with your learning. Life is too short for that and we have a lot of problems to solve.
I wanna cry... this is what education should feels like 😭
Na the background music fooling u, this boring asf😂
@@huyyyshaa6284 no i mean the interactions and the teacher is what I like regardless if its boring as long as the environment is positive no judgements
@@huyyyshaa6284 no is not,the teacher really good
*feel*
@@huyyyshaa6284 This right here, is the thinking that holds people back.
Today I phisically attended one of the MBA classes at Harvard as a visitor (you can do too, it is open). I thought the video was probably one of the most successful classes that can be shown publicly. But the real lesson was even better than this. Atmosphere, teaching, coordination, students are just unbelieveable. Around 70-80% students out of 95 (!) spoke at least once. The teacher did a great job in coordination. There was 20 minute summary presentation by her, which was cherry on top. I can't believe just a casual lesson can be in such a high quality
She’s such a vibrant and inspiring professor. This is a class room culture you don’t see very often and this is beautiful.
well, yea. its marketing.
Than pay the same at that level :)
OMG SO DIVERSE! YAS QUEEN
@@huytran9823 Hahaha. I thought so too. How can a professor do that every time in class? Nice marketing strategy though.
@@huytran9823 hmm, you have to watch cs50
Lets be honest here..even if this education is accessible to everyone, still, this type of students are special.. they WANT to learn..
I believe a lot of people want to learn, but these particular individuals are undoubtedly highly intelligent.
Education and qualifications doesn't determine your success. Work hard, think outside the box and invest. That's the keys to greatness.
@@racboo8777 Nothing equates investing and when it's done properly, you don't need to get all worked up about money any more as it creates a lot of extra income.
@@thenavigator8052 You're 100% correct! making a habit of saving and investing can change not just your life but your closed relatives life too!
@@jessenoah6113 I wanted to trade crypto on my own but got confused by the fluctuations in price and lost a lot of my fund, sincerely I don't think investing is for me!
We stan a passionate teacher
P
Ayy osu brings us together to this vidja ;0
And an Ethiopian 🇪🇹 professor at that. We love to see it
Funny this kind of language is not Harvard-esque
“histrionic” would be a better word for her.
Both of my English professors (undergrad) had this same contagious energy! Not only did we learn how to write better, we became listeners, active listeners and enthusiastic learners.
It all boils down to manners. True education is having manners, not flexing intelligence over the other, but hearing them out to broaden your perspective. In the end, the truly educated person is one with respect.
The truly educated person is the person who realizes they know nothing.
@@TechViking Since knowledge is endless 😄
You're are amazing. What an insight.🙏
Imagine everyone already spoke but you’re the only one haven’t
And then say something stupid like " my name is jeeeefff" 😂
Me in a class full of ambitious students
Scary for introverts
Is that feeling worth the money 😀?
It will be an asian citizen lol. Im an asian, but I do prefer to speak up, while they think' Im too pretend to have teacher / lecture attention lol. Im not
Omg what da environment! People have freedom to share without judging and bullying. The dynamic of teacher is so fun and involving everybody together. I respect her and students so much! This is education not copying or just sitting and listening and lecturing. Congrats guys! Thx for big inspiration
You clearly have never seen any discussion between academics. :-)
@@schmetterling4477 i have seen some but not like this. I like this ^^
@@popsiwapat This is not how academics discuss things amongst each other. These are kids who are being sold a bill of goods by a teacher who is full of herself. It is entertaining and that is all it is. If you are willing to pay Harvard a hefty fee for entertainment, who is going to stop you?
@@schmetterling4477 lol. You seem pressed for no reason. Some of yall are just born haters apparently. Kinda sad tbh
@@tanmaywarekar1662 You sound like someone who had a poor high school experience. :-)
She is such an incredible teacher! Loved how exciting, fun, challenging, and vulnerable she made the class all in one go.
I Love her ENERGY 🥰🥰🥰🥰 shes FIRE!!
She ducks
She is such an incredible teacher loved how exciting fun.challenging and variable she made the class all in the one.♥️♥️♥️🤝🤝🤝🙏🙏🙏
the same teacher can be at a community college, regardless the school, actual college professors that are that in tune with students are a W
@Latrease Leah I graduated from UC Berkeley and took some classes at Stanford…best teacher I had was at a community college. My mom was a professor at Cal State Long Beach who received her PhD from Vassar. She was a lot like this professor…simply passionate about the subject with an actual love for teaching. Good professors like this can be found at every level of education. Many believe it’s the brand name of the university. Not true. The higher the university the more those professors usually have to publish and do research if on a tenure track, leaving less time for students.
I took local community college and had some passionate educators. They got me motivated to keep going
My favorite all-time teacher was at San Francisco State. I'm sure most people don't even know that's a school, but it's one of the better communications universities in the Bay Area. He loved teaching and the biggest part of his class was making sure he was engaging with us and we were engaging with each other. He probably taught at max half the class every time, the rest of the time was conversations. Best two classes I ever took, also the two hardest classes I ever took lol.
@@Simitachi My dad went to SF state and was an Apple Engineer in the 90s. It wasn't always as much about Ivy League as it is now.
@Latrease Leah yea that is exactly what ivy league schools want people to believe, because that is how they justify the high tuition bill. It simply isn't true. I mean I don't know about at the community college level but I do know for a fact there are amazing university professors who are not in the ivy league that are more effective than many of their ivy league counterparts.
As an introvert, this type of classroom scares the hell out of me, haha.
Och you, come on, little pet.
I think she only approached students who raised their hands,
So you won't be caught off guard
Hahaha, that's what I am thinking. This 10 minutes gave me anxiety and sweaty palms.😫😨😓
Lol, well to be fair this is a Masters class...at that level there is no such thing as stage fright tbh
This isn't an introvert thing, it's a shy person thing.
when talented and bright people disagree, they laugh. that's the difference 👍
I can conform that’s is 100% true!
Wise words from a clearly wise person .👌🏾
Well put - Beautiful
So true!
LOL how innocent kid, when that happens people start creating tribal groups to cancel the wrog opinion
The energetic Harvard professor is igniting minds, transforming passive listeners into active contributors. She is incredibly awesome ! Professor "Tsedel Neeley" we Love you....
The case she’s talking about was a decision made by CEO Cynthia Carroll, who decided to SHUT DOWN 2 platinum mines to take time to promote safety training
Thanks .... I COMPLETELY spaced out and didn't know what happened
?
Temporarily shut down or permanently shut down?
Because I feel like if I was in that position, I'd temporary shut down the operation to do some investigations, it could be the site, it could be the equipment, etc and then proceed upon the result of the investigation before resuming the operation.
@@angcil88 temporarily of course
@@angcil88 that’s what I was also thinking
Why am I crying? I really want to experience Education like this. In our school there is always favoritism. How I wish I can attend to a School just like this. Fair and equal.
We’re talking about Harvard. . .
+++
@@anthonyraymundo9102 and we still can expect good school in our community , but we arent
Same sentiments. I thought I'm crazy for tearing up, how I wish I learned this way in university. Sadly, more than 1 year of my college life was spent in home because of COVID.
@@otamaoright6811 ++++
Everyone can be genius if they have a cool teacher like her.
True 😥😫
Excuse me for pointing out my view, I think that everybody needs a teacher who can see their talents and guid them to achieve that what they want. For everyone it's different and for somebodies she wouldn't be the right teacher.
if they get into harvard, point is if they got into harvard they are already pretty close
@@kiyanaak3269 you're goddamn right
gotta disagree. in high school i had an amazing legal teacher who was motivated just like this. she gave us so many resources, real life examples, tips to succeed in the subject yet so many students could care less about their education.
The first time I watched this, I can barely understand them without subtitles. Right now, I can totally understand them without subtitles. I'm so happy!
This looks like a "How to get away with murder" episode.
How is that show btw
@@nandinijain4715 OMG SOOO GOOD
@@nandinijain4715 not realistic whatsoever but it's good!
@@nandinijain4715 REALLY good. definitely recommend
haha nice one
This is not for students, this is actually for teachers to learn how they need to be passionate and create an environment for the students especially for those who are not so expressive or introverts
Period.
What they do is called brainstorming, which is very effective for getting quick results, for problems that require quick decision making
I don't understand how people blame and insist that the teachers are driving the social atmosphere, this problem legitimately resides on the students shoulders, the engagement usually depends on the students interest in the subject.
This is grad school not elementary school. You go to this to learn how to manage groups of people - if you are not expressive, introverted to the point of not being able to participate in a conversation you are not ready to lead anyone. People will be coming to you for solutions right or wrong you have to think quick and make a choice. If you spend your time getting anxious about having to speak in front of folks who might disagree with you. Not sure what to tell you but you won't be running a good business or managing people well.
nah shes overrated... just mediocre at best..
It's not just the teacher that's creating this wonderful learning environment. The main contributors are the students who are willing and eager to participating in this exchange. From my experience from a small local college, getting a class like this is also every teacher's dream, because the fun part of teaching is in the class
I agree. If the students are interactive enough, the teacher can maintain this sort of atmosphere where students are pushed through the limits and made to think about different possibilities of a situation. This makes students smarter and helps them grow personally and professionally.
This is what I love for being a teacher.
enabled by the teacher...
Totally enabled by the teacher. I was an introvert and wouldn't say a word in class until I met a teacher who encouraged me to. Now, I always look forward to contributing not minding the vulnerability. 100% on the teacher.
@@iamrising7176 Yes, enabling is definitely needed for this environment and there will always be students like you who are willing to open up to that enabling. But from a teacher's perspective, just like how students find different kinds of teachers, they also find that different classes have different collective nature. It will just depend on what mindset most of the students have. Some students are receptive while some are not, and in college level it's extremely difficult to give enough individuals attention to each student and employ what they are receptive towards.
For a teacher, every class is different.
i truly truly truly admire the way she teaches and how engaging the students are. This is exactly what i crave in teaching and learning at school, unlike what i am now experiencing which is so boring and tiring.
I dream of being in a brilliant room with brilliant minds like this one.
Ummm .....maybe you should try dreaming bigger ...why lower your standards ?
@@memecoinmafia2732 wtf dood how is getting to be in a brilliant room with brilliant people a low standard?
@@memecoinmafia2732 All big dreams stem from smaller things. Little steps my friend
@@adorapauig4474 i don't think they are that brilliant .......
@@memecoinmafia2732 u sound jealous
My IB history teacher teaches like this and barely ever gives out homework and all of his students have As because we learn more through engaging conversations and not through lecture/note taking
My ib history teacher is the exact opposite. Minimal conversation, and many PowerPoint slides
My high-school teacher was like that and unfortunately she left for retirement last year, right as I entered my senior year at the age of 81. I now plan to study History after my gap year all because of that wonderful woman.
@@blakemiller7906 that's how my IB Bio teacher is, I hate it so much
my IB psychology teacher is one and the same, truly my greatest blessing
My IB business teacher is like this. She’s so amazing at explaining things I come out of her class sad because it ended yet full of ideas and knowledge. I love her!
If they teach kids like this in primary school and higher, then we wouldn't need a Harvard
Edit: cheers for the likes. Goes to show how bad the system is
I want a science and engineering class just like this. Volatile environment where there is no chance to get sleepy.
you dont get doctors and professors to teach elementary subjects, unless they happen to be your parents.
@@helloeveryone0123 Yeah
@@helloeveryone0123 well you can get better than whats available now. If teachers were paid better and vetted with excellent grades and teaching ability then we wouldn't have a stupid society. Same goes for police
I totally agree. And I’m guessing here, but I think what you’re pointing out is not having doctors and professors teaching elementary subjects, but rather instilling a culture in the classroom of vulnerability, authentic engagement, comfort with failing and doing so with intention. That is something all grades desperately need.
why is this teacher acting like business majors need hearts
For sustainability it would be an advantage. Usually, people think too much on the short term. Business education is often too much short term thinking.
@@nanashipersonne4151 So you're sayin' it's all about the sustainability of profit? And any heart stuff is a means to an end? You're trying to kill two birds with one stone. Might work, but more likely one needs prioritizing over the other as they're inherently in conflict. That means policy needs to flexibly fit the situation. How is that possible if the policy is written from above? Should the workers make policy?
Standard procedure would continue operations while someone investigated. Better would stop the operation and have the CEO fly down with her own interpreter to interview workers to find the problem and solution. Can't use a local interpreter as the workers would not trust them. I'd guess the CEO would learn all about everything allowing her to elevate safety, satisfaction, and profit. Would get to know the people too; every CEO should know the people underlying her operation.
Im getting scared watching this I feel like someone might call me to answer.
Duh then don't watch it🙃
Jm jm brilliant 😀👍
@@ayushshende414 jm jm is making an observation on how much they appreciated this video tbh!
@@shairsko9360 what- dude no
Actually same. Lol
The fact that Cynthia Carroll herself was actually there listening to these students makes me so happy.
Didn’t notice that was her at 7:30. That’s amazing!!
Who is she?
@@KiniboKinny She was the CEO of Anglo American PLC, you can see her at 0:07 and 7:30, the class' case method was based on her experience.
@@indie8732 wow! Thanks. I was just wondering why there's an old lady among the youthful students 😁.
That is the power of Harvard!
she said CARDIO‼️
OMG Damon HI
ngl surprised to see you here lol
Damon wasn’t playing when he said “I be just watching television”
🤣🤣🤣
@@amina6489 hahahahaha
after seeing this , i want to give every student that doesn't have good grades in the world an opportunity to witness what school was really meant to be.
2:04 "like an orchestra, they kind of direct the music, but they're not necessarily playing it" wow i love this analogy
Thanks
I'd die of anxiety just keeping my Name printed out like that.
i'm gonna make sure its blurred
Why?
Omg it’s not just me 😭
Ha.... I don't want anybody to know that I have a first name lmao
I would put my books in front of name printout lol
This professor is passionate about teaching and her field. It comes across clearly. She is in constant motion around the room. She is sparking interest and conversation. When you get a professor like this it makes all the difference in your education. I was a Political Science major and one of my professors was former CIA. He had such high energy. He loved teaching and had a great wealth of first hand knowledge.
Ich würde es als typisch "Ami" bezeichnen. Vielleicht hätte die "Dame" eher Schauspielerin in Hollywood werden sollen *augenroll*. In Europa wären ihre Chancen und ihre Glaubwürdigkeit bei.... ungefähr.... NULL.
professor is woke as f
100%
Did he waterboarded you guys if you scored F in his class ??
@@nish9 Don't know, I didn't get an F.🤣
These are mature not mischievous and highly serious towards learning. It helps a teacher a lot.
If you're paying $160K + USD on a degree, this is how the education should be.
yeah, it's you're* though :)
Bruh, I paid $650 USD+ on a degree each month and still find some lecturer absent in class, not even mention that I can't even access the internet properly when my degree is in computer engineering.
@@kuzumasinner4508 I think he/she meant 160K USD+
@@MO-xq2wm 160k as a whole or each month? Either way, the point is there are people pay sum of money and still get low quality of education.
bro here in Nepal we pay around $3000 for the whole 8 sem undergrad program and we're kind of lucky as our teachers got same kind of teaching skills.
Even if I get social anxiety when it comes to talking to a lot of people I can definitely say I would love this class, I would participate very eagerly
I applied for Harvard University and I got admission too. And then I woke up. Stupid alarm clock
You can get the same information for 1/20th the price these days anyway. The Ivy League schools were only ever a rich status symbol. There are passionate and incredibly talented teachers in schools all over the world--not just Harvard.
Bruh why even bother wasting time getting an admission, at the end we all are gonna die anyways, live your life to the fullest you never know if death comes at your door tommorow itself
@@jasonfrost5025 truth 💯
@@justsomeguy4260 cuz then we dont get into better jobs . cuz u see the guy next seat has a Harvard degree and more qualifications . a higher paying job will equal to ( for me) atleast getting out of my country and seeing the world . I am not even asking much like being in Harvard. I just want enough qualifications that is needed for me to get into a business mnc abroad to see the world. but the problem is I am not rlly aware of what is needed. neither google searches solves it when literally they can be one thousand variant of the same question by different people
@@justsomeguy4260 maybe to some people that's how they live their life to the fullest. some people spend their time differently enjoy things differently. it's good to live to the fullest, but every person takes it in their own ways, so it's not a waste of time.
I’m probably one of the oldest MBA students to be found anywhere. At 65 I’m learning more from the programme than I could possibly have imagined. This professor has so beautifully articulated the joy and value of learning by orchestrating her students into the realm of critical thinking. To all of you that may be pondering the value of an MBA, think no more. The value is incalculable - do whatever you can to follow this course of learning. You’ll never regret it.
Seriously, you're such an inspiration
Thanks for leaving this inspiring and encouraging comment here.
Wow, this is quite encouraging because I thought I was too old to get my MBA. I plan to apply.
My literature teacher is practically just like this when we're in lessons. My class loves her
Same here.. My professors are wonderful. It's amazing when one body can communicate with active listening
If the world had more educators such as Professor Neeley, I guarantee the drop out rates would significantly decline and more people would yearn for education. Amazing job!
But its also important to know that good education would not necessarily make you a succesful person but life experiences will
@@hey_there1234 life experience aint doing shit if you dont want to be successfull
If the world had more students like the students in the video, the amount of teachers willing to improve their teaching methods will probably be higher...
@@BlackCat-yt4gp I love how people blame the education system for failing to nurture their children, which is not their responsibility, and whenever they propose new education methods it's usually some secular or liberal political justice issue.
@@hey_there1234 life experience no buddy have you seen unskilled wworkers doing day labour you will get your answer
I love the name cards. Lol. Great way for the professors to teach “personally” and “intimately”.
I believe this is a common practice at a lot of B schools.
@@myfirstmylastusa they don’t practice it they just do it simply they don’t need practice
Its like they actually care who's speaking🤔😛
I'm a medical officer who currently specialized in Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health and hearing all of this discussion really open my mind. Really inspire.
She seems like best teacher ever
Ofc
Hell no
@@cromeaxe why not
She's persuasive to her own conclusion........
She’s got cameras on her..u think she’ll be rude to her students?
I get instant anxiety when i see the teacher starts running towards me lol
I would have died right there😂
💀💀💀💀
Same problem 😭
Sameeeee
HAHAHAH
I see all of them laughing all the time, but yet here I am wanting to CRY everyday I go to class. I wish I had the brains and dedication like they do. Truly inspiring!
May I offer the comment, you may definitely have the brains but possibly not a dedicated teacher like the one in this video. 🤷🏽♀️ . affirm yourself always 💛
Don’t worry you got the brains. Plus this is exactly how this video is meant to make you feel,it’s made by Harvard and edited for publicity. Focus your study on what you like and don’t forget that education is a personal quest for knowledge: you decide the ending and the way.
@@timothyjacque1795 facts
You’re so beautiful🥰even Aphrodite is a pale copy of your 😘beauty,🌺if you don't mind can you tell me your name and where you from🌹
Having brains will likely keep you out of a classroom like this. These universities aren’t the end all be all. I noticed that not one person said, “I need more information before making this decision.” Some of them went straight for the race card, etc. Dedication comes in many forms and they aren’t all in a classroom setting 👍🏽
AWESOME, i am from Pakistan. This type of study culture is new to me. What the incredible 10 minutes i consumed to see and learn this lecture not only view but see by heart. The professor you are remarkable. Hats off.
I'm jealous of classes like this. Some teachers in the schools I've been to require "class participation" yet shut down/shame/intimidate students the moment they answered incorrectly in class. Moreover, some students get shamed for being stupid or being smart (ie. teacher's pet, a showoff, or overachiever). In some cases, students would be waiting on whoever raises a hand first before they even attempt to participate in classroom discussions.
It's probably why my Literature teacher back in high school was the one I remember the most: she instilled the idea that "there are no wrong answers in her class" because everyone has a different interpretation whenever we were discussing literary works - my answers may not be perfect all the time, but I felt more confident in participating because I wasn't scared of sharing my thoughts on the topic.
The reason why she is a good teacher is because the students are paying so much money to be in her class they paid at least $25,000 to be at this college,
so of course she's going to be a good teacher, after all you get what you pay for.
Sana all
In a well run MBA course there are no right or wrong answers. Simply participating on the topic at hand is enough… and everything else required in the course flows right along by doing that.
Same here
@@grimmygrinda3267 but the fact that she was chosen to be a teacher there means that she is a professional, so it's not only about the amount of salary that is given to her, but her own skills that she is paid for
I was so inspired by the professor and how she uplifts her students.
oh my god, this makes me want to study again. such a vibrant class
Hahaha me too😂
For real and I graduated uni last year and never looked back in being in a classroom but this ..omg take my money introduce me this teacher and give me the learning experience I’ve always wanted 🥲
I feel u 🥺🤦♀️
I really feel the synergy in this workplace culture. The customer journey one goes through on this deep dive really allows them to ballpark their future in possible startups. The visibility on these pain points is so important to improve product sustainability and genuine core competency within the next generation of hyperlocal to nationwide companies. It is so holistic to teach logistics in a way that doesn't only focus on what their quotas and quick wins would be, rather aligning with an ecosystem of good business. These students have such high bandwidth and placing them in such an ecosystem really incentivizes them to see all the big data and move the needle in a positive direction!
I wish I could be in that exact room and experience the same energy of free thinking.
I so want to be in that class!!
If only best education is accessible to everyone at affordable prices.
*THIS*
Would be cool but impossible, think of how everything can be funded for everyone
@Nicholas George "lose value" so should everyone wanting education be kept in the dark simply because they were unfortunately born poor?
@@skyward7903 you do realize that scholarships exist
@@chandyalexander9504 Not everyone gets scholarships lol. Only a few get it. Imagine living in a poor country where the government does NOT want to spend on education at all.
The way Professor keep challenging the students leadership qualities is commendable. A teacher must have high level of energy to keep the class on toes and that exactly what she was doing. Fantastic.
I've had the privilege of sitting in the classroom of a teacher with an extraordinary presence-passionate, brilliant, and masterfully engaging, leaving the class captivated with his thought-provoking orchestration of each case.
If this was how every teacher taught I wouldn’t have purposely skipped school
Ur expectations are too high then
@@nobody7708 I don't think so his expectation is good for future
then every school would be Harvard lol
Bruh u still would've skipped
You sort of have to deal with the bad along with the good, it's called life. Not every class will be engaging.
She's like a bolt of lightning flashing through the room. Wow.
I had a teacher like her in college. I wished she was my teacher in elementary and high school so that we started a great foundation making us interested in the idea of school.
Yea, I've had one or two like this. I promise you not all teachers are like this in Ivy League campuses. They have just as many dry, boring, and unreasonable or disinterested professors as anywhere else.
To those whom isn’t lucky to be there, become an entrepreneur today. You will learn from real life, experiences, failures, mistakes, struggles, tears, successes, personal growth, everything. I would argue it’s more satisfying especially when you experience success from your own doing. You don’t need Harvard. You need you.
Professor Neeley - your approach, attitude, excitement, passion and ability to engage in the conversation! Simply amazing! I wish all professors could share the same charisma! Hats Off!
Lies again? Grab A Chair
Professor you look like a person who never has operated a real business
Eww it's Hamas Universty / Plagarism University
Disgusting school
Let's take a moment to appreciate the teacher, She's not just hearing but listening to the student's responses!
Every student deserves a teacher like her!
If you’re reading this, I celebrate your unique brilliance. Feeling inspired by this video.
You’re 😉
@@jonderbyshire ummm... no actually. Hahahah
@@adinp9384 great. Thanks for the unprompted grammar lesson.
Its a blessing to have that kind of professor and well-prepared students.
Omg, I love the professor, her energy, her knowledge, and especially her smile, her spirit and the way she teach made an often times, dark and dividing case study like this, to become a form of unity where at the end of the day we’re all working towards one goal. Love the energy of the classroom as well, their all so determined, but it’s not in the form of competition rather their all one team but with different opinions and ideas👏👏👏
Yes, I think so.
Meanwhile:
In my university: Assignments, Assignments, Assignments, Assignments, Assignments, Assignments, More Assignments.....
Go to usa only option
R u frm cu ?
Me: *asks the teacher a question*
Teacher: Good question. That will be your assignment for the week.
What wierd business school are you studying in where they don't do case discussions??
@@NONAME-wx9tc
University of SARCASM
Imagine if every school and university has this kinds of learning atmosphere and staff. I would go to school everyday.
Until they give you a 100 pg research paper at the end of the semester, and not forgetting the other extremely difficult homework lol
if every school becomes Harvard then what would harvard be doing
@@vidushisharma2695 Be harvard
Harvard doesn't have this type of learning everyday. It's a promotional video designed to engage with the viewer. I guarantee that most of the other MBA courses aren't this exciting to watch. A lot of work in everyday life is boring, but you still have to put in the time and effort to do it. You need to find something interesting about it. This is probably why most people don't want to go to class. You can't sit around and expect it to be as fun as a promotional UA-cam video like this. If you're better prepared for class and read the assigned reading or did the work before hand, you would probably find it more exciting that day. Most people don't do this.
@@ygerman1539 I'm willing to do that
Tsedal Neeley, you are an incredible teacher. Whenever I am watching the video, I feel like I am sitting in front of you and literally I am answering. Love the method
What a great teacher. She had everyone in the class engaged. I wanted to seat in on the class and be apart of it.
As a person with ADHD this is the only teaching method that actually engaged me in any class I've been in. I remember professors with this teaching style quite fondly
I have a kiss
The best 10 minutes I spent today on UA-cam. What a teacher!
The professor is truly remarkable! I only wish that Stern could offer the same level of exceptional teaching.
Watching this video makes me think in-person class never be the same as online class. I admire with the way that professor facilitated the clas and how all the students expressed their ideas.
Unless we have augmented/virtual reality technology at hand.
@@thelastcipher9135 Not gonna have same effect.
I agreed
A bunch of ADHD patients, more like.
@Rieski Kurniasari R.
RE: "Watching this video makes me think in-person class never be the same as online class."
I could've told you that in a heartbeat! Given a choice, I would ALWAYS choose an in-person class over an on-line class.
Im pretty confident that this professor’s teaching style is unique in Harvard and you have to bid for this class like crazy.
I have had teachers like this in high school (public), undergraduate (private), and post graduate (private). That was 15 years ago.
Hello from NZ. Not unique to Harvard. My lecturer does this in my post grad lectures and I had this in undergrad as well 👩🎓
The case method aka teaching thru class debate was created at Harvard decades ago. Fortunately other schools have adopted it
@@marcomoriarty6049 This is a slight variation of The Socratic method - which derived from the Greek philosopher, Socrates. SO no Harvard didn't "create" this methodology of teaching.
This is the case method with cold calls, I think all of HBS classes are like this.
as someone who has a social anxiety, watching this scares the sht outta me
Yeah me too
same and everyone saying this is ma dream class 😃
I too have a social anxiety, but sometimes with some people and certain topic I have fun engaging.. but not most of the time tho 🤣
I have so many opinions I want to share but I get too anxious talking in front of the class, perks of online schooling is I can use the chat and I don't see other people's face and they don't get to see mine if I don't want to show it. My teachers have the choice either they see my face but don't hear me talk or I don't show my face and I make the class 10 times more interesting for everyone
yupp
You are the embodiment of what teaching should be. You're amazing and spectacular. I wish I could be in one of your class. Transmitting information through excitement involvement with an emotional connection is called Education. This should be the norm. Not the exception.
Having teachers that are passionate about what they're teaching is a huge key in students actively wanting to learn and retain information. Too many classes I've had monotoned professors who just ramble information at us and we have to take notes and study notes. That sucked and frankly is hard to learn. Then I've had professors who care about what they're teaching, and teach us through conversation and engagement to the point where you never really even have a chance to take notes because you're so engaged in the lesson. Yet even without the notes, everything that was spoke on that day, you retained and remembered, and enjoyed. We need more teachers like this.
Everyone in this room look like stock models, except these guys are legit smart
It’s still just business school and not rocket science as they say. Apparently some people in the class still aren’t smart enough to pick the obvious answer the SJW professor was looking for. Fall in line with your professor’s ideology and preserve your GPA, especially when being judged on an opinion as opposed to true or false.
@@LetterSignedBy51SpiesWasA-Coup you have to be kidding me right? their acceptance rate for the business school is 12%. Whilst, "Smart" maybe subjective, the fact is everyone of them are on the above average at the least.
Smart in business sense got nothing to do with "smart" academically
@@junyaophoon7671 again, most of the people pursuing MBAs in Ivy Leagues, are already in some sort of managerial position. Academics is one of the many factors taken into consideration for acceptance into Ivy leagues, you need to have a bunch load of extra curricular achievements to even be considered.
Legit smart?
Woah, that teacher is amazing. She really bounds with students in order to build a strong interaction between teacher and student.
She is indeed amazing.. Just the way she interact with her students
What an amazing educator - so inspiring, engaging, dynamic, passionate and powerful. Although I’ve been teaching for 30 years, I can still do better and do more after watching this professor - thank you maam 🙏 for being such an aspirational teacher ❤
This is how my Architecture Design class is, especially when we’re critiquing; I definitely learn better this way than having a boring instructor read word from word out of a book.
Where are u studying?
Having a mini breakdown realizing, most of us will never experience this in real life.
We will find another way to make ourselves happy
You are on the world wide Web and surrounded by UA-camrs! You have all you need!
damn.....
@@TechViking qsQ
This is why they have to teach them at school… lol
You don't have to go to Harvard to become great. It's how you use your brain that will make you great.
Needed to hear this
This is my issue with MBA Programs. I was in one after being in the real world for about five years and they don't relate to the real world in anyway. They teach you how to value money over people. If you put the value in People the bottom line will increase. I have always and will always hire experience over education
@@danmorowitz Could not agree more
True, but am still going to Harvard!
@@danmorowitz that's great but what about beginners? They have to start somewhere to build up "experience". And in some countries it's strict that you don't get an employment below 18. So they try to get into best colleges like these where getting your first job is more likely than not.
"One day, not only that could be you, I know that one day it will be you" This is the best punchline not me crying in my seat while studying, such a great motivation that I need.
💯💯💯💪💪💪
Too often people have trouble seeing just how skilled and capable they are!
“And that’s HOW YOU GET AWAY WITH MURDER....”
as someone with social anxiety this is my absolute worst nightmare LMAO
Agreed! 😳😳😳😬😬😬
No doubt.
Safe to say anyone with social anxiety that’s found their way into HBS knows how to manage it very well.
If I were David I would die from a heart attack
vlKenzo very true
I got anxious just by seeing these students share their opinions without hesitation
I’ve worked with many of MBA grads, in all sorts of industries, both as coworkers or clients. I have worked with thousands of clients, save hundreds of millions of dollars in annualized savings. Many MBA-ers I’ve struggled with were those who had difficulty relating to the working people who’s jobs they’re trying to affect: above all the skill of listening. Classroom brainstorming and debates has a place, certainly, but an important lesson often missed by most MBA-ers is actually listening to the people. I must say 80% of my work is listening to everyone (to see how the system functions or not), and 20% is getting these people to work together as a team to accomplish the company’s business plan. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard, “We’ve been telling them (mgt) for years and no one listens to use. Workers - management work together as a team to solve problems before it requires any serious changes, like shutting down an operation, except of course due to safety reasons.
agreed. The guy who wanted to do the review was pushed into a "decision" for show. Vs getting to any detail about the fatality. Pretty quick analysis can determine if there's a systemic factor at play, be it culture, equipment maintenance, training, that necessitate a safety stand down - or if it's pretty clearly a one off that has more of a nudge solution to prevent in future.
@@brentdavidson1 The guy who wanted to do the review was *not* pushed into a 'decision' for show. She asked a second time, he stayed with wanting an investigation, she switched to "What are you learning in this investigation?" She asked for *exactly* the answer you just gave.
Whats apparent to me is a lack of deep thinking and ability to listen for long periods of time.
@@jamesskinner1902 How did you make that evaluation based on about seven minutes of class time?
@@jamesskinner1902 wow - you don't even see the irony of accusing the students of the thing that your are exactly GUILY of.
I like the way the teacher gives the class and the way she integrates the participants, with a good attitude and making the class enjoyable.
Harvard still using blackboard and chalk, feeling nostalgia of school time
Most universities used blackboard/whiteboard here. Is it different in America?
@@skyward7903 Whiteboard or smartboard are used these days
.
"If the world had more educators like her" honestly it plays both ways. I've seen students not raising their hands, not participating and no engaging with the lessons despite how amazing the teacher is. Education can definitely be like what's in the video if teachers are ready to orchestrate and students are ready to play.
That's true but at the same time a class consist of a lot more students for 1 educator, if only 50% of the students are willing to play it's already a step into the right direction and will influence the 50% remaining, on the other side if the only educator isn't willing to orchestrate then it just does nothing.
Sure but, wouldn’t it make more sense if a passionate teacher who is willing to bring out the best in students no matter how much it takes be more better than a participating student? I mean what’s the point of participating if doing so won’t do anything for you. A good teacher wouldn’t need to have all kids be able to participate, a good teacher will inspire them to.
@@lethalbutterknife2311it should be a two way street. & you shouldn’t just do things just to get something out of it for your sole benefit. Being a teacher is hard work & they deserve to have students interacting. It’s not their job to make you put effort in.
@@kendramills2138 Right, both teachers and students should participate, but it’s more important to have a passionate teacher. Think of it, what would be the point of buying a whole car but not the steering wheel…it wouldn’t be reasonable. In the same way, although it’s a factor to have students participate, it is of much more importance for a teacher to be driven to teach them, to work with them to make them a better..more knowledgeable person. That is what a teacher is, and that is the point of teaching.
@@lethalbutterknife2311 There's no but in this. It's an equal two way traffic. I've been in a class of a very lively and engaging lecturer but we the students just didn't catch the vibe.
Her energy the way she treat and looking at the student.