I went to a watch shop today to see BB58 blue and black in person, and I gotta say the blue one was absolutely stunning. Initially, I was leaning towards the black over the blue one, but I changed my mind once I saw the blue one on my wrist in person. The black one was still great too though.
Walked past the Tudor AD the other day in my city and wow the blue one looks so much better in person. I was initially think bb54 but that blue bb58... I can't stop thinking about it.
I very recently bought the Black Bay 58 Navy Blue to compliment a range of predominantly black-dialled watches in my collection that include the classic Rolex Submariner Date 16610 that I've cherished for 19 yrs. The Tudor is a super, very well-made luxury timepiece and I appreciate its rather understated blue dial and aluminium bezel compared to the 'bling-blue' ceramic of my Omega Seamaster 300. Like-for-like think of the Blue 58 as a more modern take on its original black and gilt sibling. The blue really pops in daylight or in well-lit rooms and a pleasure to wear. Although not quite up there with the Rolex in the absolute quality stakes - but why should it when it's barely 35% of a Sub's retail price - go to an AD and try one on. An in-house COSC certified movement, 70 hrs power reserve.... you won't be disappointed.
Bought the 39 BB blue last week for my son's 34th birthday later this month. He's mentioned a preference for blue dials several times. I looked at the 41 and found it to be a bit overwhelming myself. He can always trade up for it or the black if he so chooses, but I believe he'll be very happy with this one. Enjoyed your vid, thanks.
I just turned 34 myself and am looking to buy one for myself that I found used for $2,700. Yours was a very generous and useable gift and I'm sure he's going to appreciate it for a lifetime.
I’ve now owned and daily-driven my BB58 for over a year now. I must say…it’s a spectacular piece! Checks all the boxes and is incredibly accurate. Literally +/- 0 seconds. The only problem is that I now have a watch box full of pieces that seldom get worn anymore
I’ve had mine for about 3 months now & it’s an outstanding watch! The 70-hr power reserve is nice but overkill…in 3 months I haven’t taken it off my wrist for more than 8 hrs at a time!
@@chriscon8463 Better to have an overkill power reserve, than one that doesn't get the job done. For example, the Tag Heuer Aquaracer 200 would literally be an amazing competitor in the $2000-$3000 price bracket of dive watches, but its 38 hr power reserve and middle-of-the-road movement is a tough ask at its price point. I feel like if a company is charging you above $2500 for a watch, it needs to either be COSC, have an extended power reserve, or both. Otherwise the value for money proposition suffers a lot imo.
@@OneLordeAnimeClipstotally agree, how on earth can extra power reserve possibly be overkill 🤷🏻♂️ I love the 80 hr on my Certina DS action 38, if I take it off on a Friday it’s still going on a Monday morning, surely every watch owner wants the most power reserve possible, one of the reasons the Quartz crisis happened was because they have (battery dependant of course) infinite power and that’s what people wanted.
@@pompeylad1977 Agreed. I got a BB54 last summer and the triple punch of the 70hr power reserve, anti-magnetic properties, and COSC certifications gives me some much needed peace of mind. Love the Certina DS Action diver, it was one of my finalists when I was considering what watch to get alongside the Tag Aquaracer 200 and Longines Hydroconquest.
@@OneLordeAnimeClips my next watch will be either the 54 or 58, I do like the Hydroconquest too, ah I’m not sure now, I think it has to be a Black Bay though, such great looking watches, I also really like the Pelagos 39 too, next watch will be my grail watch so have to choose carefully 👍🏻
I never liked the faux patina and gilt of the original BB58 but loved its size and wearability. Picked up the blue when offered and very happy with my purchase. Only gripe is lack of an adjustable bracelet
Hey! I know this is an old comment, but I hope you still reply. Are you referring to the lack of a micro-adjustment? I'm curious, because I'm considering one of these. Thanks!
I bought one. I love it. I had a maxi case no date Sub. I prefer this to that. It is a fun watch. Maybe it doesn't have the gravitas of your vintage Tudor Sub, but it has vintage design cues and modern durability. Of course, I have owned other Rolex and Tudor steel sports watches and have learned the case dimensions that work best for me. We all get to our ideal size/color/brand watch on a different path. That said, I do understand why people have been critical of the new Blue. But before anyone writes it off completely, it is worth a trip to a dealer to see it in person. The color is charming. --Michael
For me the watch is just right in size. The first good mechanic watch I bought 16 years ago was the Explorer II - and now around 10 watches later I still use my Explorer II very much because of the size and the fact that the watch is so universal - which I think the 58 is as well. Plus I love wearing blue jeans and a shirt or t-shirt so the blue version would match the style. And let’s not forget the price/value here which is just amazing.
Bryan Davis Yes - been wearing it the last week. The quality of the watch is what I expected - good value for money but I have to say that finish on Rolex watches are on a higher level which is also the way it should be. I knew that I would love the size of the watch because it’s like my Explorer II. I got mine on the steel bracelet but I also ordered the fabric strap which I think will be great for summer wear. I love the fact that the watch fits so well with different straps so one can change the styling. I didn’t buy the watch to resale it but the fact that it will properly keep its value is of course not bad. The watch is very universal but I would not use it with a suit as a dress watch.....but everything els will be just fine.
Just bought this watch after debating it for over a year. Used to worry it's too small or the blue is too muted. But having bought it I'm loving it more and more each day, the size is perfect on my wrist, and the blue really is deep and pop in natural light. There other thing to note is the slightly lighter silver steel colour compared to the original BB58. Really suits the watch, for the money I can't find a better driver out there
I bought the same watch about a month ago and absolutely love it, I can feel the Rolexness in it. The proportions are perfect for my wrist, hopefully I can keep this piece for a very long time, worth every penny.
This is a great comment. I saw the blue one at the AD today in person. I like it, but it does look lighter blue vs. some of the deeper blue I see in many wrist shots online. SO, I was wondering this very thing.. what does it really look like outside with the sun etc. So, your saying it does get darker.. thats good!
Respectfully disagree. Bezel and dial colors play important roles imho. Yes color doesnt affect the movement but I think Tudor picked the right blue for this watch which makes it a good release in my eyes.
Nathan Mawhinney I think it’s better because it doesn’t have the fauxtina (a fad that will date badly). Too small for me, but the 58 Blue Smurf is perfect for lots of guys,
Aesthetics is the only reason these luxury watches exist. Otherwise everyone would just get a $5 timex which can tell time more accurately, or just reach for their phone.
Really a hard combo to beat. I do wish they’d make a version that is just steel, non faux-patina lume, and produce a version of the bracelet w no rivets.
This is watch is brilliant. Tudor did exactly what I would have done for their next iteration of the BB58: blue colorway, silver accents (instead of gilt) and replacing the red pip with white. This is my definition of a classic diver: no date complication, no crown guards, Oyster bracelet and 39mm case. Add to that an in-house movement and it packs a lot of punch for the price. I'm a guy on a budget and $3,700 is not chump change. However, I like everything I've seen (online) and read. The next step is checking it out in person (once things open back up). It would be something I break open the watch fund for. Great video---especially the macro shots. I like your reviews. You present well without a bit of arrogance or snobbishness I detect with some other YT reviewers.
I’m happy you recommend the Orient Kano Teddy, it haven’t got the love like the Kamatsu...... I truly love my burgundy one!👍🏻🤩 Great video, Teddy! 👏🏻👏🏻😃
I think you’d be a bit crazy to sell the Tudor Submariner for the 58 Navy. Just because the T-sub is so iconic. I have the black 58 and I love it but that vintage piece is stunning!
I've owned the M79030B for a couple months. I love the watch though I've found I rarely wear it. In my experience it feels much larger than the numbers would suggest. It looks fantastic and is of extremely high quality but each morning I pull a smaller watch from the winder and this beautiful piece sits idle and I just can't pinpoint why. Still it's a wonderful watch that's well worth the money. The blue is the main reason I bought this particular piece.
I went my AD because I wanted to see the 54 and ended up getting the 58 Blue. I wasn’t sure what the shade I’d blue would like like in person but am glad it wasn’t the same as the Smurf. I like the snowflake hands but would like to see Tudor incorporate square and rectangular markers like they did on the Pelagos. Maybe Tudor is using style language to differentiate each model. I wear it on an Erika’s Original - a Marine Nationale strap almost seems requisite.
This is my first Tudor watch. I am in love with it. I have to say I prefer a date (no cyclops) on my watches. That’s my only issue. I also have the uncle seiko half link to get the fit right. It’s so Nice
Teddy, your recent video quality is still exploding!! Your shots and HUD-like infos you display around the watches you present are SO sharp! Really awesome presentation! I don't know any watch channel at the moment that is able to present a watch in such a professional way. Keep it up! All the best from Germany
I tried it on today...I was going to buy it before I had even seen it. Nope. It was too small and the nato was kinda junky. I opted for a brand new Tudor Heritage BB red that had been forgotten about under the counter until recently. The watch was acquired on 07/02/16, the last one the store had purchased. I sent you a pic on Instagram...It's mine now!!
Teddy, I have to say that you have really pulled me in with your quality content. You have a nice blend of a crisp and commercial style but you are also a real guy that doesn't ham it up for the camera visually or vocally. You are honest with your opinions and seemed to be a real straight-shooter about your own collection. I have to say, I also like the videos with your girlfriend... She seems legit and she is also, obviously, not hard on the eyes. I think it's cool that she pops into video sometimes. I definitely like the couple videos where she picks her favorite out of a group of watches. Always interesting to see what the ladies have to say and it is, almost always, the opposite of what all of us dudes are thinking and saying, LOL. anyway, I have become a big fan and I think you are doing a great job. Oh yeah, and killer work getting some of those VIPs you interviewed recently. Up and up Teddy!
Hi John-Carlos! I very much appreciate this comment. I have learned quite a bit in the past few years and had no expectation of where the channel was headed when I started when I posted the original video of my watch collection in 2017. Excited where this all continues to take me. Thanks for the support and look for more interviews in the future once all the craziness of the world hopefully dies down.
I called my AD today to inquiry about purchasing this model and I was politely informed that there is a waiting list for it and they don't know when they were going to get any. I thought to myself I've heard this story before!
Your lighting is aways great but the lighting on this video was exceptional! I was saving for a BB58 but Seiko released the 62mas reissue and it stole my heart.
If they added a ceramic bezel no one would ever want a sub as this is the perfect dive watch, perfect colour and perfect size. Also the historical link to Tudor mil subs makes it so desirable!! Sixth on the list at the nearest AD!!
Picking up my bb58 next month from my AD, not sure it will come in black or blue. It would be a hard pick if they have them both, the black for me is more like a vintage rolex/tudor sub in modern package, the blue inherited the original navy blue tudor which rolex will never do( except smurf)
You forgot to mention that all of the stainless steel on the original 58 is a tad darker than the stainless steel on the new Blu model. You can clearly see it when you just look at the bracelets next to each other but the blue one is a much lighter color of metal. Great review as always, and the original 58 will always be my Grail oh, that is until I find a new grail. Thanks!!
hmm that's curious and hard to believe why they would do that... i'll have a look next time in an AD. on the website they are identical, but i guess they've just been photoshopped.
The 58 is simply the perfect size for a sports watch. I have a 6.75" wrist and I still wear 36" dress watches just fine. 42mm is my absolute limit and gets in to looking ridiculous.
Diameter is not the only thing on play. Height, lugs, how it sits on your wrist plays a bigger role. Personally i wear a 44mm panerai bettarini case with ease but the original black bay ( with in house mvt) looked too big on me. The panerai just hugs the wrist. So bottom line, you need to try a watch in order to decide
I think it’s a bit silly when people say “this is the right size”. A tall guy with a 7 inch plus wrist will look like a boomer with a 36mm dress watch, but the same watch will look great on someone 5.9 with a 6.5 wrist. We aren’t all one size, and watches shouldn’t be either. I have the GMT, I love it and has perfect size / presence for me, but the 58 looks too small on me. It’s great Tudor offer choices.
The Pelagos is a better watch. I looked at both and bought the Pelagos. I have a fairly large wrist, so the size isn’t an issue. It didn’t hurt I was able to get a 25% discount on the Pelagos and the BB58 was at retail.
Just picked this watch up last week The ad called me and said she just got one in. The watch is stunning. The blue is perfect. I also have the bb gmt. It’s a nice addition to my collection
I love the black one and will probably pick up the blue one too. This has now become tied for my second favorite diver with my 14060 (Tudor is getting much more wear time)The only thing that would beat them is the 5512/3 (which is on my maybe sometime in the future list). Tudor hit an absolute home run with this watch in both colors
I agree that this is a great watch and even I'm more than likely gonna get it myself but damn Teddy - you wanna move out the Tudor Sub for this guy? I mean....your Sub though..it's fire. If I had it, I'd still keep it lol and get this guy
Tudor's sizing is the reason I have been a fan and have two 58's in my collection. I have proportionately small wrists compared to my body and the Tudor's compliment that well. Although it could be some optical illusion of mine LOL
Gonna admit that the blue dial has that casual look unlike the black dial/gold tone which can suit a formal wear.. But that shade of blue is great. Again nice vid brother and keep it up ☺️
I gotta thank you Teddy, you saved me from buying a MVMT or Vincero as my first watch. I just received my first promotion and I have an orient on the way! Keep up the good work!
The release of this watch couldn’t have been better timed. We’re in a pandemic, no Basel, no good news... then comes a “new” BB from Tudor! It’s a great watch, but widely hyped IMO. I still prefer the original BB58.
I love this blue!!! I’ll probably end up with this, as well as the black, with guilded markers, as well, in the case. Both just jump out to me. I’ve seen both of them in person, and just can’t decide which one to buy first.
I was looking out for this watch and by chance walked into a local dealer today. With the affordable Oysters (39mm being discontinued or with a waiting list of lighyears) not attainable, I asked for the 58 and the gentlement came back with this beauty. I was very surprised by the leather strap with its softtouch upper and what I though was either rubber or thin flexi leather piece on the bottom of the strap which makes this a perfect summer watch to wear. The 41mm are just too chunky and the 58 appears all so light with non steal bracelet. It was big on my list so looking forward to rocking it and hope to pass it on to my son once he is older. Love the blue/blue combo and the specs are pretty impressive.
Really hard not pick it up right Now. 4 weeks until w&w ...I hope tudor releases than an updated 58 in blue or a new green/blue pelagos39/bb54 Otherwise I waited for nothing and could buy immediately this really fine piece
I tried on a BB58 in blue today and it looked stunning. Is there any harm in waiting for W&W? Worse case they don't release any new updates for BB58 and we can just buy it right?
Really enjoy tour content Teddy. While the BB 58 is super popular, and this color way is attractive, I’m still partial to my BB Heritage 79230 with maroon, black and gilt. It’s a beautiful combination and despite standing a tad tall, wears great on my 7” wrist. Keep up the great work.
Really think it’s awesome..... I have a 41mm blue. The 39mm just feels to small on my wrist but I love the all blue. I think Tudor knock it out the park here
Are you going to make a video on the hot seiko of the moment? The spb143/spb149. I think it's one of the best watches seiko has made in years. And it seems like many others feel the same way.
Great Video! Had a 16610 with a 114270, sol them both and got OG58. Super happy with it only now I want to add a 16570 polar to complement it. The blue is gorgeous as well but I prefer the more classic black and gold, something about it is more special to me than the monochromatic watches on the market. Having said that, I am tempted to pick up a blue one as well.
Loved your video 😍! Very detailed, not to long. And well done 👍🏽 for the part you give the dimensions of the watch . Hope you get more and more watch to review .
I think a 36mm diver is a mockery and a fashion statement of the concept. Yours looks amazing but I just don't think the size works, even on a small wrist (at least on a man). This might be a good replacement and honestly you're getting a modern robust watch that you don't have to worry about.
I think you nailed my thoughts. A 36 mm watch is fine but it sometimes is a bit weird on a diver since the bezel makes the dial appear very small. I think this 58 size is perfect for me. You also nailed the aspect of this being a modern watch. The submariner is as old as me so it qualifies as being vintage so it can't really handle the banging around that it originally could. No rush to make that move but I really think this piece is great. I am going to sit put for a bit but we will see.
What version is shown at 2:12? Looks like a black bay heritage with black dial but not the typical gold/Gilt on the dial. I like it! Seems photoshopped though?
It's the double denim version. Which is good, and great easy wearing watch. I had a Black Bay black version and is was great apart from the height to width issue that was just all wrong.
I bought mine last week and buy am I in love!! I love it all. And even prefer the snowflake hands over the big R’s Mercedes. Mine is keeping -0.30 seconds a day btw.
I picked up mine last week and only thing I don’t like the micro-Adjustment on clasp is not as easy on models like Sub/GMT Rolex, other than that I love the watch from size and colour point I think you should get one and keep your Tudor Sub too 👍
Seiko 5 SNKP21J1 is quite cool, I just found it... it is basically special for the dial which is Arabic/East Hindi numerals and Arabic day window... chrono time
The Black Bay is a nice watch, but the shape of the winding crown isn't particularly to my liking. I like the Pelagos but wish it could be had in steel. Titanium makes it a niche product. The north flag is my favorite tudor.
Great review as always. I keep going back and forth on this watch and the Breitling Super Ocean Heritage B20 in Blue, or the new Blue and 18K Red Gold model (If I went Breitling, I would pick up pre-owned to come in closer to a Tudor price).
Get the Breitling. Beautifully made, great heritage, readily available, and can be had at a discount off msrp. Tudor is nice but so overhyped by the watch community.
Pure quality from your content buddy, keep it up, i’m thinking about taking it as a first watch! I love what tudor did with this one, it is hyped but it is great, quality watch.
Probably my next timepiece. Just acquired the Tudor Chrono Reverse Panda which I love. Looking for something a little smaller for my 16.5 wrist and I think this nails it.
i am from Hong Kong, working in Japan now, a huge fan of you videos. Been saving up for a second hand Breitling Navitimer in a second hand shop, and i am almost there. I am so excited that i am going to have it and wear it on my wrist but the problem is there is no certificate for that watch. The staff said they checked it and its real, but should i still risk it or buy one that is a bit more expensive but with a certificate?
Great watch and great review Teddy. I wish I could find one of these somewhere. The AD's won't even order one for me. What is up with these watch companies that can't increase production to meet demand?
Chris, where are you located? I have one that I've bought out in a whim. I haven't worn it (was shortly offered the 126710-BLNR) and it's not sized. I refuse to part with it anything over MSRP. Let me know, I'm willing to part with it for what I paid for...at MSRP! Cheers!
What I'd REALLY like is the 2020 release Glashutte Original 39.5 SeaQ blue-dialled version. But sadly that's out of my reach financially. So I'm considering this BB58 blue as an affordable alternative.
Just picked up this on a blue nato strap. First AD experience, so stoked. Loved the navy Tudor submariner but couldn't justify the chrono24 resale prices.
the black bay is the best no nonsense decent watch if you cant afford a rolex, they look good on the wrist, its got good heritage and rolex affiliations, if you have circa 2k to blow on a wristwatch you will not be sorry.
This review is great, thanks for your hard work. Just a quick question, I have the BB36 blue already, do you think getting the BB58 blue will double up?
Just picked one up in Seoul. Micro adjustment is a bit of a letdown (learn from IWC..), but the fit on my smallish wrist is superior to the current Submariner thanks to the 39mm diameter and absence of the bulge on the back. Well done Tudor.
A memo to the CEO of Tudor.Put the Tudor rose on the dial instead of the shield.and print 200m in red and people will go even more crazy.Still a good watch .l would recommend it to a college graduate as a solid ,only watch.
Wise man! Save and you will be rewarded big time for your efforts. Once you get a BB58 on your wrist you will wonder why you wasted time on those other watches. The same thing happened to me. This Tudor is a watch for life and will always be a keeper!
Angelo Soulas Not to sound condescending, but why do people advocate for buying a Tudor Black Bay 58 over Omega Seamaster 300M? I can understand if you like the classic style. But in terms of technical value the Seamaster has a better movement, greater water resistance, greater lume, ceramic bezel, better magnetism resitance, better corrosion resistance and more dial variations. Tudor 58 is going for $5,500 - $6,000 New seamaster 300M co-axial is $4,200 What are you getting in the extra $1,500 to $2,000 you’re spending?
@@brian2440 Thanks for not being too condescending but your argument is completely lost on me. As well owning the Tudor BB58, I also have a new Omega Seamaster 300m co axial silver dial version in my collection.
@@brian2440 I prefer to wear the Tudor over the Omega so I guess if I could have only one it would the Tudor. I like the classic looks and it fits my wrist size perfectly. The Tudor has personality! The Omega is nice but is a bigger and more cumbersome on my wrist than the Tudor. It feels and looks more sterile than the classic looking Tudor. The non tapered bracelet doesn't do it any favours either. I'm not too fussed about the technical aspects. I just want a watch a that makes me feel good when I wear it. The Tudor gets more wrist time than Omega. If I had to sell one , the Omega would be the first to go. It's all about what you like and it how it fits you. Even though though the Tudor costs more money and is not up to the Omega as far as specs go, it's better value for me because it gets more wrist time.
I went to a watch shop today to see BB58 blue and black in person, and I gotta say the blue one was absolutely stunning. Initially, I was leaning towards the black over the blue one, but I changed my mind once I saw the blue one on my wrist in person. The black one was still great too though.
Walked past the Tudor AD the other day in my city and wow the blue one looks so much better in person. I was initially think bb54 but that blue bb58... I can't stop thinking about it.
I've had my BB58 for a year..its my "go to" watch for all occasions..great value, subtle & discreet 👍🇬🇧
I very recently bought the Black Bay 58 Navy Blue to compliment a range of predominantly black-dialled watches in my collection that include the classic Rolex Submariner Date 16610 that I've cherished for 19 yrs. The Tudor is a super, very well-made luxury timepiece and I appreciate its rather understated blue dial and aluminium bezel compared to the 'bling-blue' ceramic of my Omega Seamaster 300. Like-for-like think of the Blue 58 as a more modern take on its original black and gilt sibling. The blue really pops in daylight or in well-lit rooms and a pleasure to wear. Although not quite up there with the Rolex in the absolute quality stakes - but why should it when it's barely 35% of a Sub's retail price - go to an AD and try one on. An in-house COSC certified movement, 70 hrs power reserve.... you won't be disappointed.
Bought the 39 BB blue last week for my son's 34th birthday later this month. He's mentioned a preference for blue dials several times. I looked at the 41 and found it to be a bit overwhelming myself. He can always trade up for it or the black if he so chooses, but I believe he'll be very happy with this one. Enjoyed your vid, thanks.
I just turned 34 myself and am looking to buy one for myself that I found used for $2,700. Yours was a very generous and useable gift and I'm sure he's going to appreciate it for a lifetime.
@@joshitheyoshi2533 he loves it and is taking great care of it. His work beater takes quite a pounding, so I'm glad he leaves the BB at home.
I’ve now owned and daily-driven my BB58 for over a year now. I must say…it’s a spectacular piece! Checks all the boxes and is incredibly accurate. Literally +/- 0 seconds. The only problem is that I now have a watch box full of pieces that seldom get worn anymore
I’ve had mine for about 3 months now & it’s an outstanding watch! The 70-hr power reserve is nice but overkill…in 3 months I haven’t taken it off my wrist for more than 8 hrs at a time!
@@chriscon8463 Better to have an overkill power reserve, than one that doesn't get the job done. For example, the Tag Heuer Aquaracer 200 would literally be an amazing competitor in the $2000-$3000 price bracket of dive watches, but its 38 hr power reserve and middle-of-the-road movement is a tough ask at its price point.
I feel like if a company is charging you above $2500 for a watch, it needs to either be COSC, have an extended power reserve, or both. Otherwise the value for money proposition suffers a lot imo.
@@OneLordeAnimeClipstotally agree, how on earth can extra power reserve possibly be overkill 🤷🏻♂️
I love the 80 hr on my Certina DS action 38, if I take it off on a Friday it’s still going on a Monday morning, surely every watch owner wants the most power reserve possible, one of the reasons the Quartz crisis happened was because they have (battery dependant of course) infinite power and that’s what people wanted.
@@pompeylad1977 Agreed. I got a BB54 last summer and the triple punch of the 70hr power reserve, anti-magnetic properties, and COSC certifications gives me some much needed peace of mind.
Love the Certina DS Action diver, it was one of my finalists when I was considering what watch to get alongside the Tag Aquaracer 200 and Longines Hydroconquest.
@@OneLordeAnimeClips my next watch will be either the 54 or 58, I do like the Hydroconquest too, ah I’m not sure now, I think it has to be a Black Bay though, such great looking watches, I also really like the Pelagos 39 too, next watch will be my grail watch so have to choose carefully 👍🏻
A vintage fitting watch with modern styling is exactly what people with smaller wrists are looking for now. To me a perfect sports watch.
I never liked the faux patina and gilt of the original BB58 but loved its size and wearability. Picked up the blue when offered and very happy with my purchase. Only gripe is lack of an adjustable bracelet
are you really happy?
Hey! I know this is an old comment, but I hope you still reply. Are you referring to the lack of a micro-adjustment? I'm curious, because I'm considering one of these. Thanks!
I bought one. I love it. I had a maxi case no date Sub. I prefer this to that. It is a fun watch. Maybe it doesn't have the gravitas of your vintage Tudor Sub, but it has vintage design cues and modern durability. Of course, I have owned other Rolex and Tudor steel sports watches and have learned the case dimensions that work best for me. We all get to our ideal size/color/brand watch on a different path. That said, I do understand why people have been critical of the new Blue. But before anyone writes it off completely, it is worth a trip to a dealer to see it in person. The color is charming.
--Michael
Nice pick up! It is a great watch now and it will definitely hold its value and become a classic down the line. wear it in good health!
For me the watch is just right in size. The first good mechanic watch I bought 16 years ago was the Explorer II - and now around 10 watches later I still use my Explorer II very much because of the size and the fact that the watch is so universal - which I think the 58 is as well. Plus I love wearing blue jeans and a shirt or t-shirt so the blue version would match the style. And let’s not forget the price/value here which is just amazing.
Update. Just got a email from my AD that I can get one next week. #lifeisgood
Bryan Davis Yes - been wearing it the last week. The quality of the watch is what I expected - good value for money but I have to say that finish on Rolex watches are on a higher level which is also the way it should be. I knew that I would love the size of the watch because it’s like my Explorer II. I got mine on the steel bracelet but I also ordered the fabric strap which I think will be great for summer wear. I love the fact that the watch fits so well with different straps so one can change the styling. I didn’t buy the watch to resale it but the fact that it will properly keep its value is of course not bad. The watch is very universal but I would not use it with a suit as a dress watch.....but everything els will be just fine.
If they had the pelagos adjustable clasp on all their watches, they would be perfect.
Just bought this watch after debating it for over a year. Used to worry it's too small or the blue is too muted. But having bought it I'm loving it more and more each day, the size is perfect on my wrist, and the blue really is deep and pop in natural light. There other thing to note is the slightly lighter silver steel colour compared to the original BB58. Really suits the watch, for the money I can't find a better driver out there
I bought the same watch about a month ago and absolutely love it, I can feel the Rolexness in it. The proportions are perfect for my wrist, hopefully I can keep this piece for a very long time, worth every penny.
This is a great comment. I saw the blue one at the AD today in person. I like it, but it does look lighter blue vs. some of the deeper blue I see in many wrist shots online. SO, I was wondering this very thing.. what does it really look like outside with the sun etc. So, your saying it does get darker.. thats good!
I am now the owner of this watch! So In love with it!
@@huckinator Yeah, I love mine! Bought it end of April and still on the wrist. It's become my fav. watch of them all :-)
@@travisharrisphotography How's it holding up 10 months later?
got mine yesterday after 3 weeks. love it. But guys, don't pay over retail
Shout out to Howard Frum in Chicago where I got mine 🤟
Will it rise or fall in value?
@@ELLIOT1311 don't give a fuck. If I want to make money I buy stocks and not watches
@@IvanBustos you mean if you wanted to lose money, you’d buy stocks at the worst time.
got mine in Jan, shout out to my local Tourneau!
It’s a good watch because the black bay 58 is a good watch. It’s just not suddenly better because it’s blue lol.
Respectfully disagree. Bezel and dial colors play important roles imho. Yes color doesnt affect the movement but I think Tudor picked the right blue for this watch which makes it a good release in my eyes.
Nathan Mawhinney I think it’s better because it doesn’t have the fauxtina (a fad that will date badly). Too small for me, but the 58 Blue Smurf is perfect for lots of guys,
Totally agree, the colour scheme esthetics is a personal choice
Aesthetics is the only reason these luxury watches exist. Otherwise everyone would just get a $5 timex which can tell time more accurately, or just reach for their phone.
They really just need to make the 58 GMT NOW
I prefer the original black dial and rose gold. I feel it's a little more flexible in terms of the types of strap options.
Really a hard combo to beat. I do wish they’d make a version that is just steel, non faux-patina lume, and produce a version of the bracelet w no rivets.
@@dirtyhipstergolf8412 thats the dream. without the gold too.
True. The original (which I have) works on virtually anything, whereas I feel the blue will work best on the bracelet.
Richard Northwood agreed. That and the BB36 are a perfect 2 watch collection IMO.
This is watch is brilliant. Tudor did exactly what I would have done for their next iteration of the BB58: blue colorway, silver accents (instead of gilt) and replacing the red pip with white. This is my definition of a classic diver: no date complication, no crown guards, Oyster bracelet and 39mm case. Add to that an in-house movement and it packs a lot of punch for the price.
I'm a guy on a budget and $3,700 is not chump change. However, I like everything I've seen (online) and read. The next step is checking it out in person (once things open back up). It would be something I break open the watch fund for. Great video---especially the macro shots. I like your reviews. You present well without a bit of arrogance or snobbishness I detect with some other YT reviewers.
Definitely buying this as my first “expensive” watch. Lol. Big fan of Tudor.
I just did.. bought it today, and it was my first "expensive" watch :)
MythoVirus Congrats man! :)
It's a lovely watch, am very pleased with mine, good choice
I’m happy you recommend the Orient Kano Teddy, it haven’t got the love like the Kamatsu...... I truly love my burgundy one!👍🏻🤩 Great video, Teddy! 👏🏻👏🏻😃
This watch is about a close to perfection as one can get. The 39mm is perfection and the shade of blue so nice!
I think you’d be a bit crazy to sell the Tudor Submariner for the 58 Navy. Just because the T-sub is so iconic. I have the black 58 and I love it but that vintage piece is stunning!
Yes it’s the best by far of these 3
On the waiting list for the BB-GMT Pepsi
@@paulvon2378 I’m surprised by the waiting list? Where are you based?
Las Vegas, Nevada. My AD said they will have the GMT in June for $4,050.00 USD
@@paulvon2378 Ahhh fairs.
I've owned the M79030B for a couple months. I love the watch though I've found I rarely wear it. In my experience it feels much larger than the numbers would suggest. It looks fantastic and is of extremely high quality but each morning I pull a smaller watch from the winder and this beautiful piece sits idle and I just can't pinpoint why. Still it's a wonderful watch that's well worth the money. The blue is the main reason I bought this particular piece.
Literally just ordered the 58 black. I like the blue but for me it seems too modern for the line. Gilt is the one for me!
I went my AD because I wanted to see the 54 and ended up getting the 58 Blue. I wasn’t sure what the shade I’d blue would like like in person but am glad it wasn’t the same as the Smurf. I like the snowflake hands but would like to see Tudor incorporate square and rectangular markers like they did on the Pelagos. Maybe Tudor is using style language to differentiate each model. I wear it on an Erika’s Original - a Marine Nationale strap almost seems requisite.
I’m not a fan of anything gilt so the new color makes the BB58 basically the perfect diver at this price range for me.
This is my first Tudor watch. I am in love with it. I have to say I prefer a date (no cyclops) on my watches. That’s my only issue. I also have the uncle seiko half link to get the fit right. It’s so Nice
Teddy, your recent video quality is still exploding!! Your shots and HUD-like infos you display around the watches you present are SO sharp! Really awesome presentation! I don't know any watch channel at the moment that is able to present a watch in such a professional way. Keep it up! All the best from Germany
I tried it on today...I was going to buy it before I had even seen it. Nope. It was too small and the nato was kinda junky. I opted for a brand new Tudor Heritage BB red that had been forgotten about under the counter until recently. The watch was acquired on 07/02/16, the last one the store had purchased. I sent you a pic on Instagram...It's mine now!!
Nice review on the Black Bay Blues. Really, you nailed this, crisp, clear, articulation. The best review I’ve seen yet. Keep up the great work.
Teddy, I have to say that you have really pulled me in with your quality content. You have a nice blend of a crisp and commercial style but you are also a real guy that doesn't ham it up for the camera visually or vocally. You are honest with your opinions and seemed to be a real straight-shooter about your own collection. I have to say, I also like the videos with your girlfriend... She seems legit and she is also, obviously, not hard on the eyes. I think it's cool that she pops into video sometimes. I definitely like the couple videos where she picks her favorite out of a group of watches. Always interesting to see what the ladies have to say and it is, almost always, the opposite of what all of us dudes are thinking and saying, LOL. anyway, I have become a big fan and I think you are doing a great job. Oh yeah, and killer work getting some of those VIPs you interviewed recently. Up and up Teddy!
Hi John-Carlos! I very much appreciate this comment. I have learned quite a bit in the past few years and had no expectation of where the channel was headed when I started when I posted the original video of my watch collection in 2017. Excited where this all continues to take me. Thanks for the support and look for more interviews in the future once all the craziness of the world hopefully dies down.
I called my AD today to inquiry about purchasing this model and I was politely informed that there is a waiting list for it and they don't know when they were going to get any. I thought to myself I've heard this story before!
Your lighting is aways great but the lighting on this video was exceptional! I was saving for a BB58 but Seiko released the 62mas reissue and it stole my heart.
It’s the best Black Bay to date.
Hello Teddy your chanel inspired me to start my watch collection and now I'm a proud owner of a new Omega moon watch😀!
Your macro shots are unbelievable. So awesome.
If they added a ceramic bezel no one would ever want a sub as this is the perfect dive watch, perfect colour and perfect size. Also the historical link to Tudor mil subs makes it so desirable!! Sixth on the list at the nearest AD!!
Got it in 22 days after ordering it on July 6th. You're gonna love it.
Picking up my bb58 next month from my AD, not sure it will come in black or blue. It would be a hard pick if they have them both, the black for me is more like a vintage rolex/tudor sub in modern package, the blue inherited the original navy blue tudor which rolex will never do( except smurf)
You forgot to mention that all of the stainless steel on the original 58 is a tad darker than the stainless steel on the new Blu model. You can clearly see it when you just look at the bracelets next to each other but the blue one is a much lighter color of metal. Great review as always, and the original 58 will always be my Grail oh, that is until I find a new grail. Thanks!!
hmm that's curious and hard to believe why they would do that... i'll have a look next time in an AD. on the website they are identical, but i guess they've just been photoshopped.
The 58 is simply the perfect size for a sports watch. I have a 6.75" wrist and I still wear 36" dress watches just fine. 42mm is my absolute limit and gets in to looking ridiculous.
Diameter is not the only thing on play. Height, lugs, how it sits on your wrist plays a bigger role. Personally i wear a 44mm panerai bettarini case with ease but the original black bay ( with in house mvt) looked too big on me. The panerai just hugs the wrist. So bottom line, you need to try a watch in order to decide
Yeah I have a 6.5“ wrist and wore a ap roo 42mm and it looked ridiculous
I wear a 2551 Omega SMP and wears the same as BB58.
Pa Tek Or is it just because you like Patek, Mr Tek? :P
I think it’s a bit silly when people say “this is the right size”. A tall guy with a 7 inch plus wrist will look like a boomer with a 36mm dress watch, but the same watch will look great on someone 5.9 with a 6.5 wrist. We aren’t all one size, and watches shouldn’t be either. I have the GMT, I love it and has perfect size / presence for me, but the 58 looks too small on me. It’s great Tudor offer choices.
I was able to pay MSRP for the BB58 B. I wouldn't pay the premium that is on the grey market right now. Glad to help out Teddy!
Thanks again Chris!
The Pelagos is a better watch. I looked at both and bought the Pelagos. I have a fairly large wrist, so the size isn’t an issue. It didn’t hurt I was able to get a 25% discount on the Pelagos and the BB58 was at retail.
Just picked this watch up last week
The ad called me and said she just got one in. The watch is stunning. The blue is perfect. I also have the bb gmt. It’s a nice addition to my collection
I love the black one and will probably pick up the blue one too. This has now become tied for my second favorite diver with my 14060 (Tudor is getting much more wear time)The only thing that would beat them is the 5512/3 (which is on my maybe sometime in the future list). Tudor hit an absolute home run with this watch in both colors
I agree that this is a great watch and even I'm more than likely gonna get it myself but damn Teddy - you wanna move out the Tudor Sub for this guy?
I mean....your Sub though..it's fire. If I had it, I'd still keep it lol and get this guy
Absolutely, don't sell the original Tudor sub. It's gold.
Teddy is the only guy on the internet that brings up RADO watches
Tudor's sizing is the reason I have been a fan and have two 58's in my collection. I have proportionately small wrists compared to my body and the Tudor's compliment that well. Although it could be some optical illusion of mine LOL
Gonna admit that the blue dial has that casual look unlike the black dial/gold tone which can suit a formal wear.. But that shade of blue is great. Again nice vid brother and keep it up ☺️
It’s a beauty it’s it Teddy! It’s still the watch that is my grail! Think the gilt dial is still better!
I gotta thank you Teddy, you saved me from buying a MVMT or Vincero as my first watch. I just received my first promotion and I have an orient on the way! Keep up the good work!
lol! vincero lol.......lol......lol...where do you buy that? Gum ball machine?lol
The release of this watch couldn’t have been better timed. We’re in a pandemic, no Basel, no good news... then comes a “new” BB from Tudor! It’s a great watch, but widely hyped IMO. I still prefer the original BB58.
I wouldn’t sell the old Tudor sub if I was you
This!
I’d buy that 75090 from you and take it over the BB58 literally any day! Seriously if you want to sell... haha
I would.
Tudor subs are too legit. So good.
I love this blue!!! I’ll probably end up with this, as well as the black, with guilded markers, as well, in the case. Both just jump out to me. I’ve seen both of them in person, and just can’t decide which one to buy first.
I was looking out for this watch and by chance walked into a local dealer today. With the affordable Oysters (39mm being discontinued or with a waiting list of lighyears) not attainable, I asked for the 58 and the gentlement came back with this beauty. I was very surprised by the leather strap with its softtouch upper and what I though was either rubber or thin flexi leather piece on the bottom of the strap which makes this a perfect summer watch to wear. The 41mm are just too chunky and the 58 appears all so light with non steal bracelet. It was big on my list so looking forward to rocking it and hope to pass it on to my son once he is older. Love the blue/blue combo and the specs are pretty impressive.
I love this watch, except for these two things
1. luminum bezel will scratch easily.
2. No date complication.
Really hard not pick it up right Now. 4 weeks until w&w ...I hope tudor releases than an updated 58 in blue or a new green/blue pelagos39/bb54
Otherwise I waited for nothing and could buy immediately this really fine piece
I tried on a BB58 in blue today and it looked stunning. Is there any harm in waiting for W&W? Worse case they don't release any new updates for BB58 and we can just buy it right?
The black is so much better imo! 👌
The BB58 and a BB36 is probably my grail collection.
I have the original and think l will stick with that one. Blue is nice, but there's something about the black and gilt that looks better to me
I thought that, too. Just put down a deposit for the black one.
To me, this watch is absolutely stunning.
Really enjoy tour content Teddy. While the BB 58 is super popular, and this color way is attractive, I’m still partial to my BB Heritage 79230 with maroon, black and gilt. It’s a beautiful combination and despite standing a tad tall, wears great on my 7” wrist. Keep up the great work.
Really think it’s awesome..... I have a 41mm blue. The 39mm just feels to small on my wrist but I love the all blue. I think Tudor knock it out the park here
Don’t sell the sub! Think less of it like overlap and more like the old and the new. They belong together in the collection. Great work!
Are you going to make a video on the hot seiko of the moment? The spb143/spb149. I think it's one of the best watches seiko has made in years. And it seems like many others feel the same way.
Great Video! Had a 16610 with a 114270, sol them both and got OG58. Super happy with it only now I want to add a 16570 polar to complement it. The blue is gorgeous as well but I prefer the more classic black and gold, something about it is more special to me than the monochromatic watches on the market. Having said that, I am tempted to pick up a blue one as well.
Fantastic watch for the price.
The number one thing Tudor is missing with this watch that makes me want Omega vs. Tudor is that there is no display back. This watch should have one.
A diver watch shouldn't have a display back.
Giuseppe Rocchi True, but the Seamasters have an undeniably better movement
Loved your video 😍! Very detailed, not to long. And well done 👍🏽 for the part you give the dimensions of the watch . Hope you get more and more watch to review .
I think a 36mm diver is a mockery and a fashion statement of the concept. Yours looks amazing but I just don't think the size works, even on a small wrist (at least on a man). This might be a good replacement and honestly you're getting a modern robust watch that you don't have to worry about.
I think you nailed my thoughts. A 36 mm watch is fine but it sometimes is a bit weird on a diver since the bezel makes the dial appear very small. I think this 58 size is perfect for me. You also nailed the aspect of this being a modern watch. The submariner is as old as me so it qualifies as being vintage so it can't really handle the banging around that it originally could. No rush to make that move but I really think this piece is great. I am going to sit put for a bit but we will see.
Best looking watch in the world!!
What version is shown at 2:12? Looks like a black bay heritage with black dial but not the typical gold/Gilt on the dial. I like it! Seems photoshopped though?
I'd say it is just the way they have filtered the photo. It looks like the gilt with the red triangle.
It's the double denim version. Which is good, and great easy wearing watch. I had a Black Bay black version and is was great apart from the height to width issue that was just all wrong.
A great bonus is the lack of faux patina compared to the black 58.. White details on blue look great.
The more I see the Black Bay, the more I like it.
I bought mine last week and buy am I in love!! I love it all. And even prefer the snowflake hands over the big R’s Mercedes. Mine is keeping -0.30 seconds a day btw.
I picked up mine last week and only thing I don’t like the micro-Adjustment on clasp is not as easy on models like Sub/GMT Rolex, other than that I love the watch from size and colour point
I think you should get one and keep your Tudor Sub too 👍
Seiko 5 SNKP21J1 is quite cool, I just found it... it is basically special for the dial which is Arabic/East Hindi numerals and Arabic day window... chrono time
Love the new BB 58 blue . It’s a winner
Very happy with mine,was on waiting list for original but blue is my colour of choice. Nice simple classic watch that can be worn with most things,
The Black Bay is a nice watch, but the shape of the winding crown isn't particularly to my liking. I like the Pelagos but wish it could be had in steel. Titanium makes it a niche product. The north flag is my favorite tudor.
Great review as always. I keep going back and forth on this watch and the Breitling Super Ocean Heritage B20 in Blue, or the new Blue and 18K Red Gold model (If I went Breitling, I would pick up pre-owned to come in closer to a Tudor price).
Get the Breitling. Beautifully made, great heritage, readily available, and can be had at a discount off msrp. Tudor is nice but so overhyped by the watch community.
Pure quality from your content buddy, keep it up, i’m thinking about taking it as a first watch! I love what tudor did with this one, it is hyped but it is great, quality watch.
Is the regular Black Bay really too chunky for people with medium sized wrists?
on my 16cm wrist the regular BB is too big, it's like a child with daddy's watch :)
Probably my next timepiece. Just acquired the Tudor Chrono Reverse Panda which I love. Looking for something a little smaller for my 16.5 wrist and I think this nails it.
Lovely watch
The one thing I don't like about the 58, the minute hand points over the minute indices instead of pointing at them.
Pentti Hilkuri Totally agree with you - I’m surprised that yours is the 1st comment I’ve seen pointing this out👍
@@macrolex2899 Most if not all black bays seem to commit the same sin.
Love the review, owned my baby smurf since 1 July and wears so well, is colour wise to Tudor what hulk is to Rolex
I recently purchased the Tudor BB Steel. Love it!!
i am from Hong Kong, working in Japan now, a huge fan of you videos.
Been saving up for a second hand Breitling Navitimer in a second hand shop, and i am almost there. I am so excited that i am going to have it and wear it on my wrist but the problem is there is no certificate for that watch. The staff said they checked it and its real, but should i still risk it or buy one that is a bit more expensive but with a certificate?
Great watch and great review Teddy. I wish I could find one of these somewhere. The AD's won't even order one for me. What is up with these watch companies that can't increase production to meet demand?
I'll wait a few years until the price comes down. Great video as always Teddy!
I don't think price is going down on this one.
@@drgeek100 you are probably right
Chris, where are you located? I have one that I've bought out in a whim. I haven't worn it (was shortly offered the 126710-BLNR) and it's not sized. I refuse to part with it anything over MSRP.
Let me know, I'm willing to part with it for what I paid for...at MSRP!
Cheers!
@@kevinc7407 right now, I am trying to save for such a purchase, but I don't have the funds right now. Thanks for the offer though, good luck!
I own it, color is perfect.
What I'd REALLY like is the 2020 release Glashutte Original 39.5 SeaQ blue-dialled version. But sadly that's out of my reach financially. So I'm considering this BB58 blue as an affordable alternative.
If only this had the T-Fit clasp I'd get one.
Just picked up this on a blue nato strap. First AD experience, so stoked. Loved the navy Tudor submariner but couldn't justify the chrono24 resale prices.
It’s beautiful. I’m going to get the Black Bay Steel shortly with date function on the stainless steel bracelet. Love these watches.
the black bay is the best no nonsense decent watch if you cant afford a rolex, they look good on the wrist, its got good heritage and rolex affiliations, if you have circa 2k to blow on a wristwatch you will not be sorry.
This review is great, thanks for your hard work. Just a quick question, I have the BB36 blue already, do you think getting the BB58 blue will double up?
Just picked one up in Seoul. Micro adjustment is a bit of a letdown (learn from IWC..), but the fit on my smallish wrist is superior to the current Submariner thanks to the 39mm diameter and absence of the bulge on the back. Well done Tudor.
Thinking about buying black version of this for my first automatic watch.
A memo to the CEO of Tudor.Put the Tudor rose on the dial instead of the shield.and print 200m in red and people will go even more crazy.Still a good watch .l would recommend it to a college graduate as a solid ,only watch.
I decided to not get a Rado or an Oris diver earlier this summer. I am now saving up to get this instead.
Wise man! Save and you will be rewarded big time for your efforts. Once you get a BB58 on your wrist you will wonder why you wasted time on those other watches. The same thing happened to me. This Tudor is a watch for life and will always be a keeper!
Angelo Soulas Not to sound condescending, but why do people advocate for buying a Tudor Black Bay 58 over Omega Seamaster 300M?
I can understand if you like the classic style.
But in terms of technical value the Seamaster has a better movement, greater water resistance, greater lume, ceramic bezel, better magnetism resitance, better corrosion resistance and more dial variations.
Tudor 58 is going for $5,500 - $6,000
New seamaster 300M co-axial is $4,200
What are you getting in the extra $1,500 to $2,000 you’re spending?
@@brian2440 Thanks for not being too condescending but your argument is completely lost on me. As well owning the Tudor BB58, I also have a new Omega Seamaster 300m co axial silver dial version in my collection.
Angelo Soulas ok but if you could only get one; what are you getting more value in the Tudor for $1500 more than the Omega?
@@brian2440 I prefer to wear the Tudor over the Omega so I guess if I could have only one it would the Tudor. I like the classic looks and it fits my wrist size perfectly. The Tudor has personality! The Omega is nice but is a bigger and more cumbersome on my wrist than the Tudor. It feels and looks more sterile than the classic looking Tudor. The non tapered bracelet doesn't do it any favours either. I'm not too fussed about the technical aspects. I just want a watch a that makes me feel good when I wear it. The Tudor gets more wrist time than Omega. If I had to sell one , the Omega would be the first to go. It's all about what you like and it how it fits you. Even though though the Tudor costs more money and is not up to the Omega as far as specs go, it's better value for me because it gets more wrist time.
Amazing watch elegant in looks and great price , it’s a watch everybody should purchase in there collection 10/10.