Being a watch collector like yourself. I just brought the Tudor black bay fifty eight in black. Also the black bay gmt. I am going to pick up the blue one today. Owning Rolex's and omega also. I can say Tudor did a amazing job. Making these watches.
I recently pickup my BB58 Navy. It was a tough choice between the black and navy. Both are stunning, well priced and 100% wearable. I actually found the size of the standard BB range too large on the wrist. I landed on the navy based on how it felt on the day. Super happy with my purchase.
Tbh, I think you made the right call. I think they’re both GORGEOUS, but the Blue is next level. I bought my Omega SM300 Heritage in blue, so I can’t see myself buying another diver in Blue, but I think it’s nicer than the Black, which by itself is truly stunning. I also really like the subtle differences in steel. I echo Adrian here. I’d get the BB58 or an explorer as like a daily driver that goes with everything. I also really don’t like the faux rivets on the BB58
I have to give it to the OG version. It has that 50's submariner vibe and color scheme I like. And the gilt gives it a little .. something. To me the black is not only more versatile, but that gilt and hint of red also make it more exciting. But that is just personal.
I sold a 2016 Submariner 114060 and have been wearing a BB58 ( Black ) for last 7 months. No regrets. Fantastic looking watch. So much more character. Never get tired of looking at it. For the money it is the best watch I’ve owned.
It all seemed so simple: I wanted a black BB58. Everyone does. And it still looks better than the blue... Unless I look at the blue for too long. And then I start to question myself... Damn you, Tudor. Damn you all to hell!
The black bay 58 is gonna be my first big watch purchase and I just want one to wear everyday forever, so I think I'll go with the black since it's more versatile. The blue does looks stunning, both are a great choice
Both. I'm of the mindset that Tudor absolutely hit a home run with their Black Bay Line. I really don't mind owning a few of them. This includes the 32/36/41 line as well. I already have the Black Bay Black. Will most certainly be picking up the Black Bay blue as well.
I got the blue last month and it's been my daily driver ever since. The blue goes with everything because it's not that smurf blue, its more subtle and classy. What a watch!
My head says that I have to have the blue, I have too many black dial watches already.... But my heart still says black all day long. Its just warmer and less sterile.
“Too many black dial watches already” You’re obviously a watch collector which makes it even harder to believe you haven’t added a blue to your collection. I can’t believe also, that you haven’t got one of the beautiful blue based Omega Seamasters
Just picked up my BB58 in Navy yesterday, and I'm in love! It was a difficult decision with the black version being so beautiful! But I don't find myself wearing gold often or dressing up much. I love that you showed the navy in various straps, I think I'll be getting a suede leather one soon! Just wish it had drilled lugs, the swapping process seems to look annoying....
The Navy Bay is my favorite Tudor release. They finally got the proportions and color right for my taste. I still need to see it in the metal to confirm. They should have removed the rivets from the bracelet and added an adjustable clasp thus paving the way for more modern Black Bay 58’s after giving a nod to the past by making the black/gilt/fauxtina/rivet version. At least that’s what I thought they should do.
I would go for "Blue Bay 58" since I have too many black watches. I agree with Adrian, it's not like bright blue like "Smurf", looks very quite and versatile. It doesn't scream at ppl's faces "Look at my fking watch!!!!!"
All the info I have read about the 58 Blue, nobody has mentioned the colour of the steel against the Black version (for those who have seen both together)
I very recently bought the Black Bay 58 Navy Blue on the steel bracelet to compliment a range of predominantly black-dialled watches in my collection that include the classic Rolex Submariner Date 16610 that I've owned for 19 yrs. The Tudor is a super, very well-made luxury timepiece and I appreciate its rather understated blue dial and bezel compared to the 'bling-blue' ceramic of my Omega Seamaster 300. Like-for-like think of the Blue 58 as a more modern take on its original black and gilt sibling. The blue really pops in daylight or in well-lit rooms and a pleasure to wear. Although not quite up there with the Rolex Sub in the absolute quality stakes - but why should it when barely 35% of the retail price - go to an AD and try one on. In-house COSC certified movement, 70 hrs power reserve, staggering lume.... you won't be disappointed.
Love my original black BB58-its charm puts a smile on my face whenever I wear it after over 18 months. I’ll take a good at the steel tones when I get hands on. Not heard that from anywhere else. Enjoy your BB, I’m sure you will love it!
I prefer black watches but the gold, faux lume and red pip marker are a deal breaker. If Tudor make a black version with white gold and white lume like the blue has I’m definitely interested
THANK YOU! FINALLY someone else has mentioned how wide the handset is. Once you see the handset on the GMT you will not be able to unsee how clunky the regular black bay handset is
I got my blue BB58 from my AD last week, the day it was released. It's awesome and even more awesome considering the price vs. other pieces in my collection.
Great video. I’m a fan of the blue. Tried one on at the AD and was very impressed at how comfortable the watch it. Very smooth and rather understated, comparatively. That said: not fond of the black due to the vintage treatments of the faux patina and the dull gold. And, as much as I like the blue, thank you for calling out the snowflake hands. The Mercedes hands of a Rolex tool watch are hard to beat, but availability and at 1/2 the price I could maybe get used to them.
Couldn't decide which one I preferred in the Ad, so I bought both. 4yr interest free... No brainer. Black for winter, blue for summer jeans and t-shirt.
I love both watches, and intend to buy the blue and keep the black. I don't like the faux rivet bracelet either, but find the snowflake hands fantastic. It is interesting that the stainless is a different color. Thank you very much for the comparison review!
Great comparison shots! I think they hit it out of the park with the blue but whenever the black comes back on the screen for me its a no brainer. So much presence and I just love the black/gilt accents with the red marker on the bezel. My 58 black is still my favorite in my collection! I agree the rivets are unnecessary and an odd choice, but also never think about them. I also don't think they look BAD.. just no point to them. The lume on the OG 58 is a bit darker but I personally hold off on calling it fauxtina (but maybe I'm in denial cuz I hate fauxtina?!)
I've got the black version and it is by far, my favourite watch in the collection. It's currently my everyday-er. Thinking about getting a nice tan Monaco strap for it as well.
about to buy the black one, for me it is the clear favorite. It reminds me of the 1958 submariner and in general conveys the feeling of wearing a vintage looking watch, however still having the best modern functionalities such as a 70 hour power reserve
My favourite is the Blue One :) I think it’s more timeless than the Black one...there are just too Many Gold accents on the Black one 🙈 looks strange in combination with stainless steel 😅
I was never a big fan of the black bay 58 until I saw this video. There’s just something about the blue dial to me and it all just clicked. Fantastic camera work and lighting as usual. I will definitely be adding this watch to my collection in the future.
Never in my life bought a watch with a blue dial, just not my thing. Black is much more versatile and better looking. However.... this blue black bay is strangly captivating my eyes. Beautiful watch. With that said, plot twist, I'm not going for either, I'm gonna buy the gmt this week....but Thanks for sharing! They both look stunning.
This video is a strong argument for only judging a watch once in your hands, photos are simply not enough. Adrien confirms this, having a very different opinion from last week once he’s actually handled the blue bay.
Picked up the BB 41 blue (in house) a couple years ago, and I love it. I've got a big wrist though. Just pulled the trigger on a BB 58 black yesterday. Not sure if I'm going to wear it yet (wrist size), but I honestly think I could sell it at any time going forward and not lose a dime.
I'm very happy I got the black BB58. I like the blue, but on the black I really like the red triangle and (although I never thought I would like it ) I like the rose gold. If I find a blue I will probably buy that one too
Bought this in blue. I actually went in to look at the 41 and the blue 39 caught my eye. Just a beautiful shade of blue and checked all the boxes for me, 39 mm 11.9 mm thick, dive watch, three hands, MSRP under $4k, Rolex pedigree, what's not to like?
For somebody who wears watches, and I believe in enjoying beautiful watches like this model, the Black one looks fantastic. The timeless color design is immediate BB58, the blue is just as nice but as he stated "you already have your daily driver and want something fun" this is where I think it makes the most sense in the color choice.
I am sure my reason for my choice between the blue vs black will be unique, but I guess that is what makes watch collecting a very personal and unique experience. My choice would be the blue and my reason would be the lighter color of the steel. I didn't realize this as the reason until after this video and then it became crystal clear. Great content, keep up the great work!
The black is just a better looking watch to me. Best bang for your buck diver though has to be the Omega Seamaster 300. In house movement, 15,000 gauss protection, ceramic bezel, black dial and vintage style and you can find it for $4,300 new. Slightly more than the BB 58, but worth it IMO.
Hi Adrian , great observations. I would like a blue watch to add to my collection but I also would like an Omega . How does the 58 blue stack up against the blue sea master . Both contenders to be my next watch among some others . I’d love your input , cheers
I bought the black one yesterday..I feel black is more elegant and matches all occasions. Plus its the vintage look with exactly the 1958 style of the tudor submariner. Blue is a new color and just looks more of a hype since its promoting the new color. The value of the black will be more in future and harder to get than the Blue.
A black watch that they have coloured blue - amazing innovation for Tudor. They should have changed the bracelet, before the colour! - Although the ideal of Blue Jeans, seems to go with most things. A Ranger may have been a little more interesting? Thanks for the straps the yellow nato has gone down a storm
I watch this video at least once a week … maybe I will slow down with that once I pull the trigger on one of these. Great video my man! …its going to be the black one. I’m certain of that. Maybe.
Really interesting question about the steel - i cant confirm or deny your impressions on these watches BUT I definately think you are on to something I've been trying to research. 316L steel is a surprising wide catagory with potentially large physical and aesthetic differences between cheap/expensive and just different steel that you can see between watches.
Awesome looking together - what a pair - the change in steel tone is such a nice touch by Tudor. The Blue Bay is true to its history - and Wilsdorfs Tudor philosophy , high tec, great build , great price , and made available to its clients and fans . You have to love the idea and purpose of the alpha macho diver design tool hands from the past or else the piece loses much of its meaning. Tudor making the piece obtainable is to be applauded. Definitely a cool piece. Truly great observations.
I agree. The blue one is for someone who has a lot of watches. The black one is for the person who wants to keep his watch forever and needs to wear it with all of his sportswear and some of his sport jackets.
A “darker” steel, are you absolutely sure? How do you get a darker steel? Oh and the Snowflake hands are great, they help give the Tudor a unique identity, rather than just a Rolex on the cheap.
Good discussion. I would have enjoyed a discussion with both watches and an Everest rubber wrist band. Note: I had a Tutor submariner for 43 years and traded it for a new Rolex Datejust. After a year, got tired of a 36 mm Datejust and went back to a Tudor - the Black Bay 58 Blue for a day to day rugged watch that I so much missed with my old Tutor. And hen bought a IWC Pilot Mark 18 watch sized at 40mm. Love that trade in of a Rolex for the Tudor and the IWC. I am happy now and am looking for a rubber wrist band for the Tutor.
I went for the BB36 over the 58 because I felt it had more versatility. Your love for the explorer 36mm 100% inspired me too, although sometimes I do miss the dive bezel. Great video as always! Will the new straps be coming in 19mm?
I have the blue, and I love it. I have over a dozen watches so I was not looking for a watch to be everything for me, still I wear the blue with a suit and with jeans and it does seem to be a very versatile watch to me for the week I've owned it. The black is also a great watch, but it didn't stir any emotions for me. I personally love the rivets, even if it is just a design element and not "real rivets".
I have both the black 58 and the black pelagos. 2 entirely different watches. The pelagos wears its size well, for smaller wrists it is a great 'bigger' watch.
The blue Pelagos is striking in person. Totally agree. But it's a bit apples and oranges because the Pelagos is so much bigger (and a much more capable dive/tool watch).
I am a Tudor fan and I love my Tudor GMT, so I’ve wanted to add another Tudor sports watch. I have been debating getting a BB58 or a Tudor BB black with the red triangle, but I just can’t get past the gilt markings on the dial of the BB58. Then the blue BB58 was released, and now I’m confused.... but MAYBE Rolex releases a blue dial Explorer1 this September and I get that one, but this blue... is nice. I see this as a nice competitor to the Omega Aqua Terra 8900 blue.
For me personally, I cannot think of a better produced, fine Swiss watch for the money, ever. Loving what Tudor are doing and they way they do it. I just wish they'd make something a little bigger that would look good on me! Even my Black Bay Dark looks tiny on my wrist.
Objectively, it doesn't Paul. It's just that you are so accustomed to wear monstrously sized watches like the Deep Sea that anything looks small in comparison. Also, a fully blackened watch will always seem optically smaller than its stainless steel equivalent.
Fantastic video! I think I'm going to go with the black as I have the Tudor GMT already so I feel the blue is more sporty and similar to the GMT. I love the vintage look of the black!
As of last Wednesday, I got them both. 1st was BB 58 on strap in August only one that came at the time.. And now the Blue on bracelet. 😀👍⌚⌚❤❤ And my AD looked out for me there.
I was in the market for a BB 58 last year and it was between that and a Blue Seamaster professional 300 ceramic. The Omega was cheaper and was the better watch in every aspect possible....In my humble opinion.
Not gonna lie, I personally start to tend to purchase the bb58 black over the submariner. The submariner for the young chad is the counterpart for the obnoxiously overused LV bag. The sub might be one of the coolest watches ever, but holy hell did it attract the wrong crowd...
The more important discussion for me is this : why the fuck would anyone want to buy a maxi case Subby when you can buy *both* of these *far* better looking BB's for the same $? No 904 or Ceramic I hear you say! *Good!* We seem to covet a gorgeous vintage Rolex & shell out enormously for them, yet go and buy a watch that basically won't grace us with a patina!, well certainly not in 20-30 yrs. I don't know about you guys but when my pieces are 30yrs old I don't want them looking like old-new stock! I want them looking like a 30yo watch should. Long live the aluminium bezel!
To each their own. The aluminum bezel looks too subdued for me and I want my watch to look the best it can for as long as it can so the 904L steel and cermic bezel are the way to go for me.
Actually, the engine cover that is used on top of the engine is to make the sound of the direct injection ticking lower. So it's actually not useless because car manufactures would not spend unnecessary money on that stuff if they already cutting costs by replacing everything metal with plastic.
Well, the smurf is just a Sub, which is basically a €3000 watch that costs over twice that much because it's a Rolex, and the smurf still costs €30.000 more because its white gold... As a time piece, the Sub is not significantly better than the BB58. As a status symbol and a snobbish accessory, it is...
Visit our website: barkandjack.com
Check out our shop: barkandjack.shop
Thank you for pointing out the different metal colors of the two Tudor watches.
Being a watch collector like yourself. I just brought the Tudor black bay fifty eight in black. Also the black bay gmt. I am going to pick up the blue one today. Owning Rolex's and omega also. I can say Tudor did a amazing job. Making these watches.
I recently pickup my BB58 Navy. It was a tough choice between the black and navy. Both are stunning, well priced and 100% wearable. I actually found the size of the standard BB range too large on the wrist. I landed on the navy based on how it felt on the day. Super happy with my purchase.
Tbh, I think you made the right call. I think they’re both GORGEOUS, but the Blue is next level.
I bought my Omega SM300 Heritage in blue, so I can’t see myself buying another diver in Blue, but I think it’s nicer than the Black, which by itself is truly stunning. I also really like the subtle differences in steel.
I echo Adrian here. I’d get the BB58 or an explorer as like a daily driver that goes with everything.
I also really don’t like the faux rivets on the BB58
Beauty in the eye of beholder, I will go for the navy blue.
I didn’t think there was much more to talk about this much hyped watch and then Adrian discovers the the steel!
Totally incredible discoveru
To be recorded in the annals of horology.
Agreed; very informative.
He's a tool
We can call it Adrian Steel now!
“Blue Bay” looks reserved, crisp and classic. That said,
Black Bay 58 Black is the BOSS!!!
Yeah, the Black is still the best.
And boring. Tried it and was unimpressed. It was on a blue fabric strap, so perhaps thats why. The steel would give it some punch, I assume.
"Black Bay 58 Black is the BOSS!!!"
"Yeah, the Black is still the best."
Let me guess... because you boys own one, right?
I own neither and black bb58 is much nicer
z00h Don’t own one yet , but gilt with red pops look dope!
I have to give it to the OG version. It has that 50's submariner vibe and color scheme I like. And the gilt gives it a little .. something. To me the black is not only more versatile, but that gilt and hint of red also make it more exciting. But that is just personal.
As a proud owner of the OG I have to agree.
@@dirtyhipstergolf8412 I agreed. Same here.
@@dirtyhipstergolf8412 best watch i ever bought.
Agree
Just got mine for my first piece. I’m in love. I agree
I sold a 2016 Submariner 114060 and have been wearing a BB58 ( Black ) for last 7 months. No regrets. Fantastic looking watch. So much more character. Never get tired of looking at it. For the money it is the best watch I’ve owned.
It all seemed so simple: I wanted a black BB58. Everyone does. And it still looks better than the blue... Unless I look at the blue for too long. And then I start to question myself... Damn you, Tudor. Damn you all to hell!
They are both great and what ever you buy will be great.
The black bay 58 is gonna be my first big watch purchase and I just want one to wear everyday forever, so I think I'll go with the black since it's more versatile. The blue does looks stunning, both are a great choice
Same feeling !! Black looks great but the blue ... shit it is GREATTTTT
Just gone and bought the blue! Stunning!
Both. I'm of the mindset that Tudor absolutely hit a home run with their Black Bay Line. I really don't mind owning a few of them. This includes the 32/36/41 line as well. I already have the Black Bay Black. Will most certainly be picking up the Black Bay blue as well.
2:20 so satisfying that the boys are synched up, thank you Adrian
I got the blue last month and it's been my daily driver ever since. The blue goes with everything because it's not that smurf blue, its more subtle and classy. What a watch!
My head says that I have to have the blue, I have too many black dial watches already....
But my heart still says black all day long. Its just warmer and less sterile.
Same
Go Green, get the Harrods edition.
Sterile is the perfect adjective for the blue.
“Too many black dial watches already” You’re obviously a watch collector which makes it even harder to believe you haven’t added a blue to your collection. I can’t believe also, that you haven’t got one of the beautiful blue based Omega Seamasters
Blue for me. The occasion needs to suit my blue watch. In other words, I don’t give a f about occasions.
Just picked up my BB58 in Navy yesterday, and I'm in love! It was a difficult decision with the black version being so beautiful! But I don't find myself wearing gold often or dressing up much. I love that you showed the navy in various straps, I think I'll be getting a suede leather one soon! Just wish it had drilled lugs, the swapping process seems to look annoying....
Disgusted that Tudor didn't consult Adrian on strap option before launching this
To be fair to them, they did apologise and will be consulting me befor future launches.
Bark and Jack good on you, a force in the industry.
I brought the black one approx a year ago, and never regretted it. It radiates a rich warmth, as well as good looks, and is still a talking point.
OG Black version all day, every day.
The Navy Bay is my favorite Tudor release. They finally got the proportions and color right for my taste. I still need to see it in the metal to confirm. They should have removed the rivets from the bracelet and added an adjustable clasp thus paving the way for more modern Black Bay 58’s after giving a nod to the past by making the black/gilt/fauxtina/rivet version. At least that’s what I thought they should do.
Love my BB58 “ BLACK “.... I’m sure the “BLUE “ will make its mark too!👌🏼
I agree !
The black is warmer, classical lookin'....the blue has a sportier, summery vibe.
I have both:- the Rolex Smurf and the BB 58 Blue and I must agree with you, the BB 58 Blue is a better looking watch.
I would go for "Blue Bay 58" since I have too many black watches.
I agree with Adrian, it's not like bright blue like "Smurf", looks very quite and versatile.
It doesn't scream at ppl's faces "Look at my fking watch!!!!!"
The blue on the leather looked great, I didn’t expect that either. It works similarly to denim jeans and leather boots.
All the info I have read about the 58 Blue, nobody has mentioned the colour of the steel against the Black version (for those who have seen both together)
I very recently bought the Black Bay 58 Navy Blue on the steel bracelet to compliment a range of predominantly black-dialled watches in my collection that include the classic Rolex Submariner Date 16610 that I've owned for 19 yrs. The Tudor is a super, very well-made luxury timepiece and I appreciate its rather understated blue dial and bezel compared to the 'bling-blue' ceramic of my Omega Seamaster 300. Like-for-like think of the Blue 58 as a more modern take on its original black and gilt sibling. The blue really pops in daylight or in well-lit rooms and a pleasure to wear. Although not quite up there with the Rolex Sub in the absolute quality stakes - but why should it when barely 35% of the retail price - go to an AD and try one on. In-house COSC certified movement, 70 hrs power reserve, staggering lume.... you won't be disappointed.
Love my original black BB58-its charm puts a smile on my face whenever I wear it after over 18 months. I’ll take a good at the steel tones when I get hands on. Not heard that from anywhere else. Enjoy your BB, I’m sure you will love it!
I prefer black watches but the gold, faux lume and red pip marker are a deal breaker. If Tudor make a black version with white gold and white lume like the blue has I’m definitely interested
THANK YOU! FINALLY someone else has mentioned how wide the handset is. Once you see the handset on the GMT you will not be able to unsee how clunky the regular black bay handset is
It really bugs me. 🙈
Came here to say this. I call it the "clown nose."
Bark and Jack I have the original black bay with the smiley face and rose on the dial. It kind of want to get rid of it now after getting the GMT.
I got my blue BB58 from my AD last week, the day it was released. It's awesome and even more awesome considering the price vs. other pieces in my collection.
I love it, the blue looks so great. I just wish it had the option for a date window.
Hello from France , This week i bought my first Tudor. A bb58 in ... blue. I love this color. But yes the original is beautiful ! Cheers !
Oh my, both the BBs with the mocha strap🤩🤩🤩
Great video. I’m a fan of the blue. Tried one on at the AD and was very impressed at how comfortable the watch it. Very smooth and rather understated, comparatively. That said: not fond of the black due to the vintage treatments of the faux patina and the dull gold. And, as much as I like the blue, thank you for calling out the snowflake hands. The Mercedes hands of a Rolex tool watch are hard to beat, but availability and at 1/2 the price I could maybe get used to them.
Interesting point about the steel color - You're the first one to point it out. I really enjoyed this video ! Cheers man
Couldn't decide which one I preferred in the Ad, so I bought both. 4yr interest free... No brainer. Black for winter, blue for summer jeans and t-shirt.
Yes!!
I love both watches, and intend to buy the blue and keep the black. I don't like the faux rivet bracelet either, but find the snowflake hands fantastic. It is interesting that the stainless is a different color. Thank you very much for the comparison review!
Adrian, you are a genius. It’s really that simple. 1) the steel color, 2) the comparison to the smurf. Wow.
Great comparison shots! I think they hit it out of the park with the blue but whenever the black comes back on the screen for me its a no brainer. So much presence and I just love the black/gilt accents with the red marker on the bezel. My 58 black is still my favorite in my collection! I agree the rivets are unnecessary and an odd choice, but also never think about them. I also don't think they look BAD.. just no point to them. The lume on the OG 58 is a bit darker but I personally hold off on calling it fauxtina (but maybe I'm in denial cuz I hate fauxtina?!)
I've got the black version and it is by far, my favourite watch in the collection. It's currently my everyday-er.
Thinking about getting a nice tan Monaco strap for it as well.
The Blue is just so damn good!!!
about to buy the black one, for me it is the clear favorite. It reminds me of the 1958 submariner and in general conveys the feeling of wearing a vintage looking watch, however still having the best modern functionalities such as a 70 hour power reserve
My favourite is the Blue One :) I think it’s more timeless than the Black one...there are just too Many Gold accents on the Black one 🙈 looks strange in combination with stainless steel 😅
I like both. Would go for the black probably out of the 2 but have to say the Harrods Green would be my pick of them all!
I was never a big fan of the black bay 58 until I saw this video. There’s just something about the blue dial to me and it all just clicked. Fantastic camera work and lighting as usual. I will definitely be adding this watch to my collection in the future.
Never in my life bought a watch with a blue dial, just not my thing. Black is much more versatile and better looking. However.... this blue black bay is strangly captivating my eyes. Beautiful watch. With that said, plot twist, I'm not going for either, I'm gonna buy the gmt this week....but Thanks for sharing! They both look stunning.
This video is a strong argument for only judging a watch once in your hands, photos are simply not enough. Adrien confirms this, having a very different opinion from last week once he’s actually handled the blue bay.
I've now got both with no regrets! Superb watches with a sensible price point
Blue Bay with blue steel.
And complete it with ...
Zoolander’s “Blue Steel” 😗
I reckon that should be the official nickname haha
Picked up the BB 41 blue (in house) a couple years ago, and I love it. I've got a big wrist though. Just pulled the trigger on a BB 58 black yesterday. Not sure if I'm going to wear it yet (wrist size), but I honestly think I could sell it at any time going forward and not lose a dime.
For the price of a Submariner, I can buy them both!
I think you can buy 3
Probably 4 lol
I'm very happy I got the black BB58. I like the blue, but on the black I really like the red triangle and (although I never thought I would like it ) I like the rose gold. If I find a blue I will probably buy that one too
BBB58 makes me imagine I’m wearing a sub smurf but I can actually afford it. It gets me all warm and fuzzy inside 🥰
Bought this in blue. I actually went in to look at the 41 and the blue 39 caught my eye. Just a beautiful shade of blue and checked all the boxes for me, 39 mm 11.9 mm thick, dive watch, three hands, MSRP under $4k, Rolex pedigree, what's not to like?
I love both of these, recently picked up the black fifty eight and currently waiting on a call for the blue fifty eight. Awesome video! 👍🏼
Did you get both in the end?
For somebody who wears watches, and I believe in enjoying beautiful watches like this model, the Black one looks fantastic. The timeless color design is immediate BB58, the blue is just as nice but as he stated "you already have your daily driver and want something fun" this is where I think it makes the most sense in the color choice.
The steel difference was really interesting, surely something you can only spot if you have them both in your hands. Great watches and video Adrian!
I am sure my reason for my choice between the blue vs black will be unique, but I guess that is what makes watch collecting a very personal and unique experience. My choice would be the blue and my reason would be the lighter color of the steel. I didn't realize this as the reason until after this video and then it became crystal clear.
Great content, keep up the great work!
Love the mocha strap on it! Just ordered it for my BB58 Blue!
Thanks buddy. 🙌🏻
The black is just a better looking watch to me. Best bang for your buck diver though has to be the Omega Seamaster 300. In house movement, 15,000 gauss protection, ceramic bezel, black dial and vintage style and you can find it for $4,300 new. Slightly more than the BB 58, but worth it IMO.
Hi Adrian , great observations.
I would like a blue watch to add to my collection but I also would like an Omega .
How does the 58 blue stack up against the blue sea master .
Both contenders to be my next watch among some others . I’d love your input , cheers
The blue is absolutely amazing!
but how long is the wait going to be to get one in the "correct" price though?
A long time, Rolex marketing.
I bought the black one yesterday..I feel black is more elegant and matches all occasions. Plus its the vintage look with exactly the 1958 style of the tudor submariner. Blue is a new color and just looks more of a hype since its promoting the new color. The value of the black will be more in future and harder to get than the Blue.
Always a blue watch IMHO. It's my favorite color
“No watch it’s perfect ....”. As he sits with an explorer 1 on his wrist. Sir, you have perfection already.
Totally agree with this!
the bracelet's pretty janky tho by today's standard.
A black watch that they have coloured blue - amazing innovation for Tudor. They should have changed the bracelet, before the colour! - Although the ideal of Blue Jeans, seems to go with most things. A Ranger may have been a little more interesting? Thanks for the straps the yellow nato has gone down a storm
It would definitely be blue for me. On that note, what paint did you use for your back wall?
I'm guessing Farrow & Ball Stiffkey Blue
Black all day! the blue was a quick craze, now they are the easy one to get and the black still has waiting lists at some places
Looking at your video Adrian I guess I made the right choice, I own both !! They complement each other very well.
I love the BB58 but I really love having a date function
When did you buy the BB58 black?! Congrats 🎊 I guess I missed it....
Think he just announced on Instagram and not any other platform yet
Probably after selling his Grand Seiko quartz?
I haven't had a chance to do a video on it. But it will be coming. 👍🏻
Wanted to buy the Seamaster 300 (2021 version). Then I tried the BB58. Already ordered it
I watch this video at least once a week … maybe I will slow down with that once I pull the trigger on one of these. Great video my man! …its going to be the black one. I’m certain of that. Maybe.
Haha thanks a lot mate. They are great watches.
2 years later. Finally pulled the trigger on the black bay … I went with Blue. But … I had to watch the video again. 😂
I own both and NEVER picked up on the slight difference in metal color. Great eye you have there.
Really interesting question about the steel - i cant confirm or deny your impressions on these watches BUT I definately think you are on to something I've been trying to research. 316L steel is a surprising wide catagory with potentially large physical and aesthetic differences between cheap/expensive and just different steel that you can see between watches.
100% agree, the blue is beautiful but the black is timeless and goes with anything
Awesome looking together - what a pair - the change in steel tone is such a nice touch by Tudor. The Blue Bay is true to its history - and Wilsdorfs Tudor philosophy , high tec, great build , great price , and made available to its clients and fans . You have to love the idea and purpose of the alpha macho diver design tool hands from the past or else the piece loses much of its meaning. Tudor making the piece obtainable is to be applauded. Definitely a cool piece. Truly great observations.
I agree. The blue one is for someone who has a lot of watches.
The black one is for the person who wants to keep his watch forever and needs to wear it with all of his sportswear and some of his sport jackets.
A “darker” steel, are you absolutely sure? How do you get a darker steel? Oh and the Snowflake hands are great, they help give the Tudor a unique identity, rather than just a Rolex on the cheap.
David Datura its fake news. This guy is confused.
Darker steel with an older watch and oxidation of surface layer 🤷🏻♂️
So... different steel? Prob not.
Good discussion. I would have enjoyed a discussion with both watches and an Everest rubber wrist band. Note: I had a Tutor submariner for 43 years and traded it for a new Rolex Datejust. After a year, got tired of a 36 mm Datejust and went back to a Tudor - the Black Bay 58 Blue for a day to day rugged watch that I so much missed with my old Tutor. And hen bought a IWC Pilot Mark 18 watch sized at 40mm. Love that trade in of a Rolex for the Tudor and the IWC. I am happy now and am looking for a rubber wrist band for the Tutor.
I went for the BB36 over the 58 because I felt it had more versatility. Your love for the explorer 36mm 100% inspired me too, although sometimes I do miss the dive bezel. Great video as always! Will the new straps be coming in 19mm?
The blue watch on the navy NATO strap is perfect.
You have to ask yourself do you want to own a watch nicknamed Smurf... Black Bay all the way.....
I have the blue, and I love it. I have over a dozen watches so I was not looking for a watch to be everything for me, still I wear the blue with a suit and with jeans and it does seem to be a very versatile watch to me for the week I've owned it. The black is also a great watch, but it didn't stir any emotions for me. I personally love the rivets, even if it is just a design element and not "real rivets".
.. and then there is me: I bought the Black Bay GMT today :D
Bravo! The BB GMT is a terrific piece. The wrist presence is superb and perfectly satisfies my travel / tool watch needs. Enjoy!
Hope the date doesn’t go wrong for you 🙈
Great choice, as well ! I'd love myself all of them :D
My wrist too small for a gmt
Didn't like mine at first. Now I love it
Great video! Do you have plan doing a hands on with the new seiko divers? Spb143, etc
Excellent, excellent review.
That blue looks amazing on the mocha strap!!
I would still go with the blue Pelagos.
That, the black bay coke or green harrods, are really the only nice tudors worth owning atm.
The Pelagos is beautiful but it is to big for my taste.
I have both the black 58 and the black pelagos. 2 entirely different watches. The pelagos wears its size well, for smaller wrists it is a great 'bigger' watch.
Pelagos LHD all day long 👍
The blue Pelagos is striking in person. Totally agree. But it's a bit apples and oranges because the Pelagos is so much bigger (and a much more capable dive/tool watch).
I am a Tudor fan and I love my Tudor GMT, so I’ve wanted to add another Tudor sports watch. I have been debating getting a BB58 or a Tudor BB black with the red triangle, but I just can’t get past the gilt markings on the dial of the BB58. Then the blue BB58 was released, and now I’m confused.... but MAYBE Rolex releases a blue dial Explorer1 this September and I get that one, but this blue... is nice. I see this as a nice competitor to the Omega Aqua Terra 8900 blue.
I’ve got my first luxury watch today a Tudor gmt love it.
Congrats mate. And great choice. 🙌🏻
For me personally, I cannot think of a better produced, fine Swiss watch for the money, ever. Loving what Tudor are doing and they way they do it. I just wish they'd make something a little bigger that would look good on me! Even my Black Bay Dark looks tiny on my wrist.
Objectively, it doesn't Paul. It's just that you are so accustomed to wear monstrously sized watches like the Deep Sea that anything looks small in comparison. Also, a fully blackened watch will always seem optically smaller than its stainless steel equivalent.
Fantastic video! I think I'm going to go with the black as I have the Tudor GMT already so I feel the blue is more sporty and similar to the GMT. I love the vintage look of the black!
Love my GMT. The 58s are a great release, but a bit small for me (whereas GMT is my sweet spot).
@@mkyhou1160 heritage for me sit, agreed 39 is also too small for me 👍
As of last Wednesday, I got them both. 1st was BB 58 on strap in August only one that came at the time.. And now the Blue on bracelet. 😀👍⌚⌚❤❤ And my AD looked out for me there.
Nice that you are using child labur to make this video .. just kidding, cool that you involve the kids in this hobby :)
🤣
I was in the market for a BB 58 last year and it was between that and a Blue Seamaster professional 300 ceramic. The Omega was cheaper and was the better watch in every aspect possible....In my humble opinion.
Not gonna lie, I personally start to tend to purchase the bb58 black over the submariner.
The submariner for the young chad is the counterpart for the obnoxiously overused LV bag.
The sub might be one of the coolest watches ever, but holy hell did it attract the wrong crowd...
The more important discussion for me is this : why the fuck would anyone want to buy a maxi case Subby when you can buy *both* of these *far* better looking BB's for the same $?
No 904 or Ceramic I hear you say!
*Good!*
We seem to covet a gorgeous vintage Rolex & shell out enormously for them, yet go and buy a watch that basically won't grace us with a patina!, well certainly not in 20-30 yrs. I don't know about you guys but when my pieces are 30yrs old I don't want them looking like old-new stock!
I want them looking like a 30yo watch should.
Long live the aluminium bezel!
To each their own. The aluminum bezel looks too subdued for me and I want my watch to look the best it can for as long as it can so the 904L steel and cermic bezel are the way to go for me.
Please Cut out the foul language. Thank you.
Actually, the engine cover that is used on top of the engine is to make the sound of the direct injection ticking lower. So it's actually not useless because car manufactures would not spend unnecessary money on that stuff if they already cutting costs by replacing everything metal with plastic.
Everything went well until the end. “Better than the Smurf Blue”!! Are you having a laugh 🤷🏻♂️
😂 Yes,
He can’t hold the smile , like ..... I don’t even believe what I say 😂
What he meant was, blue 58 is just so more proportionate than 40mm smurf.
Well, the smurf is just a Sub, which is basically a €3000 watch that costs over twice that much because it's a Rolex, and the smurf still costs €30.000 more because its white gold... As a time piece, the Sub is not significantly better than the BB58. As a status symbol and a snobbish accessory, it is...