VRS Pedals Vs Heusinkveld Sprints. Sim Racing pedal Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 107

  • @KeeganLeahy
    @KeeganLeahy 3 роки тому +13

    First time watcher and impressed with your presentation :) As a VRS datapack creator, but not so much intertwined with the hardware projects, it was nice for me to be able to get your perspective on these. I'm going to make the jump to these from G29s and having never used quality pedals, so I'm quite excited. I know software IS on the way, and I've forwarded your suggestions to the guys about conveniently loading profiles and adjusting force curves.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +4

      Thanks Keegan really good to hear that. So far they are doing really well. Jumping from the G29s will be a massive leap!

  • @malgrif091
    @malgrif091 11 місяців тому +4

    it looks like you were experiencing the limitations of elastomers, where you see the peak and then the drop off. Great to see the data that the VRS eliminates this, will definitely be getting the VRS pedals since i'm a bit fed up the same way you are about the annoying brake drop off.

  • @EricGibson1
    @EricGibson1 3 роки тому +6

    I believe the sprint pedals face can be moved but not as much adjustment. They can be flipped to give you a taller pedal face or shorter. There is no left or right adjustment.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +2

      Yes apologies I probably wasn't clear enough in what I meant by adjustment. I was meaning in terms of moving and angling the faces back and forward. What I found was different parts of the sole of my boot touched different parts of the pedals throughout the depression of the pedal. Being able to angle the faces slightly would solve this.
      But well spotted! And thanks for the Comment.

  • @espressoryen-grdahl9144
    @espressoryen-grdahl9144 3 роки тому +5

    Another awsome review. I did not expect this result. I love my sprint. But as you say, you have to push a bit long distanse/travel. But curious on the vrs. What you try next? Vrs with the dampers? Or bj simpedal hydraulic at same pricepoint as vrs/sprint..

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +3

      Thanks for watching and the feedback! Next will be a long term review once I have some serious hours to experiment with the VRS more, we are waiting for the dampers to be released and as son as I have them I will do a review, hoping to get a set of Ultimates in the next few weeks for another comparison and it would be great if I can secure some other pedals as well. Thanks again and stay tuned!

  • @MattinhoGG
    @MattinhoGG 3 роки тому +8

    The lap times here I'd put firmly in margin of error catagory. Having said that though I own some Sprints and I really dislike the rubbers bushings. You hit the nail on the head with the coming off the brakes and the on/off feel of the hard rubbers... I still struggle to get a decent feel for them sadly. I'm seriously tempted to go grab some VRS pedals and sell the HE's

    • @angryginger791
      @angryginger791 2 роки тому +1

      If you can find a deal on a used set of HPP PRX pedals (they have a newer model out, but good luck finding them used. People just don't sell them.) jump on it. The hydraulic brake is by far the best I've ever felt. Just like a real car. The throttle is buttery smooth and the clutch has a really cool cam system that feels like a real pressure plate. They are very reliable too. I got mine used and I've had them for a couple years of constant use with zero issues.

  • @jenscee7679
    @jenscee7679 3 роки тому +4

    I’ve got Sprints but this is a very interesting video.

  • @simpatgaming7828
    @simpatgaming7828 3 роки тому +3

    What I'd do for another inch! 🤣 I'm in queue (blue line almost full) for purchasing these exciting pedals!

  • @kevin_m
    @kevin_m Рік тому +2

    Just a note that you can rotate the Sprint pedal faces to position them a little higher or lower. So they have a bit more customization than you stated. Both pedals look like they’d get the job done.

  • @BoosiveFPV
    @BoosiveFPV 3 роки тому +6

    The Heusinkveld ultimates have come right down in price now. Id save up the extra for them personally.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +1

      Mydas Simulations hopefully have some they are going to loan me to do a long term back to back now. So fingers crossed we can see if they are still too dog. And I’m keen to try them as well. 👍

    • @BoosiveFPV
      @BoosiveFPV 3 роки тому +1

      @@SmokingSteelGarage they seem the pedal of choice for most that go for more high range setup. Much more affordable now as well. Will look out for your vid.

    • @EnzoFazzi
      @EnzoFazzi 3 роки тому +6

      I'm not sure what you mean, they haven't changed in price in 8 years. If you're from the UK, it's most likely that you're now seeing the price excluding VAT, because of Brexit.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +1

      @@EnzoFazzi if he is from the UK they got more expensive as they now pay import duties on them. I'm guessing he means second hand market prices.

    • @EnzoFazzi
      @EnzoFazzi 3 роки тому

      @@SmokingSteelGarage for the Ultimates it's actually ever so slightly cheaper than before. We still have free trade with the UK, so you're only paying VAT (and a small brokerage fee) when the order enters the UK. In the past, you'd pay 21% Dutch VAT, now it's 20% UK VAT, so slightly cheaper.

  • @pliniomonteiro
    @pliniomonteiro 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks for your video. Do you use a heel plate? I got one and I'm using it flat on the pedal plate, but I feel very uncomfortable as my right foot stays "in the air"

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +3

      Yes I do, my pedal box has about a 20mm lift for my heels. and I also have a heel stopper so my heels don't move as I push the pedals.

  • @robcampbell6099
    @robcampbell6099 3 роки тому +3

    3 weeks later... how are you liking them now?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +6

      They are superb. Miss the sprint software mostly for race starts and being able to tune the clutch quickly before a race, but that all. Mecca Cups arrived today so will finish their review this week then revisit the VRS and update you all

    • @adamleblanc5294
      @adamleblanc5294 3 роки тому +3

      @@SmokingSteelGarage They released the software for it. Has the curve stuff like the sprint software does as well.

  • @robcampbell6099
    @robcampbell6099 3 роки тому +2

    Hold on.... the fastest lap times were 1.35's and the avg was 1.45's I assume the fast lap times should be 1.45's ??
    Great feature looking at the telemetry

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +3

      Fastest laps were 45's, in the race runs all the laps were in the mid to low 45's as well. I had a habit of saying the wrong times whilst driving though, thought I edited most of that out! Its hard to drive fairly quick and think about talking at the same time 😬

    • @robcampbell6099
      @robcampbell6099 3 роки тому +1

      @@SmokingSteelGarage Lol, I get it... If the wife comes and asks me a question while racing it almost always ends in a wreck.... :o
      Looking forward to my pedals showing up

  • @Simlife101
    @Simlife101 2 роки тому +2

    I think springs work way better for trail braking when no dampener is installed so maybe that is the difference

  • @SmokingSteelGarage
    @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +6

    We are trying to secure some Heusinkveld Ultimates for a long term test against the VRS next.

    • @963robo
      @963robo 3 роки тому +1

      why Pros, arent the spints their successor

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому

      😬 DOH! Sorry fingers and brain not engaging today. Post edited. Thanks for spotting it!

  • @wayneshephard
    @wayneshephard 3 роки тому +3

    Enjoyed your review, comparison, they seem awesome, can't wait to get mine

    • @SamKatakouzinosRacing
      @SamKatakouzinosRacing 2 роки тому +1

      Haha I'm in the market for new pedals. Fancy seeing you here! :)

  • @barrymanon9459
    @barrymanon9459 3 роки тому +3

    Great review. In depth and technical showing what you found better on the VRS.
    I look forward to another review in a few weeks as currently if your a sprint owner it doesn’t really make sense to suddenly sell them and buy these for a large upgrade.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому

      Thanks for the feedback, much appreciated and glad you enjoyed it.

    • @barrymanon9459
      @barrymanon9459 3 роки тому

      Just found out you were a driving Instructor here in NZ Manfield. My mate Greg bought that blue mr2 from you.
      I did a Wilwood brake upgrade on that car for Greg.
      Small world 🌎

  • @badbrains7
    @badbrains7 3 роки тому +2

    I found a major problem with the bearings in another review.
    I had a reservation but will hold off on purchasing until the problem is corrected. Are your pedals ok so far?
    ua-cam.com/video/dQ_h-TDFzFA/v-deo.html

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +2

      Yeah all OK here. Hard to say what's happened there looking at the vid.

    • @adamleblanc5294
      @adamleblanc5294 3 роки тому +1

      Something seems off with that video. Don't know what it is but it doesn't look like a "normal" failure. it's also a troll channel and all his replies asking if he contacted VRS are trolls, so I wouldn't put too much stock in it. From what I've been seeing the customer services has been on point with these and anyone who has them has been loving them.

  • @kezman82a
    @kezman82a 3 роки тому +2

    I don’t like the feel in the sprints. It’s the same feel all the way to the ”bumpstop”. I think the progressive feel in VRS must be great. Will prob buy them.
    But I say as you. I don’t hate the sprints. I just think it could be better.

    • @chrisjohnson261
      @chrisjohnson261 3 роки тому

      The sprints need a damper in my opinion. I've been trying figure out how to add the fanatic damper to them. I feel like people are big fan boys and Enzo and niels seem really nice and professional and when u have issues they help you the best they can. I feel people may not be being honest about the sprints. I have them. I like them but they leave some travel feel to be desired.

    • @kezman82a
      @kezman82a 3 роки тому +3

      @@chrisjohnson261 yeah. They are good but not great. Overhyped. Maybe a lot of people are underaged and never drove a real car or something.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +1

      Yeah its a tough call, I'm actually going to revisit the sprints soon and shoot a film on them using some varying settings just to make double sure. But right now I feel like I have a lot more control with a spring setup vs rubbers. But lets see. I might be wrong in my opinion.

  • @tonyhobbsuk
    @tonyhobbsuk Рік тому +1

    Really nice comparison, great video. Can I ask what baseplate / foot-plate you were using with the VRS pedals?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  Рік тому +1

      With this the pedals are mounted to my DIY build rig, I featured near the start of this channel.

  • @Peterjan1995
    @Peterjan1995 Рік тому +1

    U still use them?

  • @_xndrzt
    @_xndrzt 3 роки тому +7

    they seems okay, i just can't get over that throttle crippled spring..it looks broken

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +3

      It is horrible, the only plus side is once they are on my rig I cant see it anymore. then it looks a lot better 😂

  • @3Slippers
    @3Slippers 11 місяців тому +1

    Subscribed when you described the differences coming off the VRS brake to the Sprints. Really helpful stuff, thanks.

    • @tobytoxd
      @tobytoxd 7 місяців тому

      Keep in mind, that the VRS software has much more improved in those 3 years, as from what i've heard in the Boosted Media revisit of their wheel base and read on Reddit.

  • @RacingWithChuck27
    @RacingWithChuck27 2 роки тому +2

    It’s been a year, what the story now?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  2 роки тому +2

      All good and still my favourite. Maybe I should do an update?

    • @RacingWithChuck27
      @RacingWithChuck27 2 роки тому +2

      @@SmokingSteelGarage the Aztecs now I think are at the top of my list. Watched some reviews last night. Looked at these before but didn’t like the pedals being permanently attached to their plate. But the brake feel is what’s important. Hard to make a decision without trying. Why I don’t buy shoes online haha

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  2 роки тому

      😂 Yes I totally understand that. 😂

  • @rcwck
    @rcwck 3 роки тому +1

    Did I miss software comparisons? Does VRS have curve plotting capabilities?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +3

      Yes it does now, software has finally been released. It wasn't out when I made this review.

  • @NylonStrings46
    @NylonStrings46 3 роки тому +1

    Hi....Do you need a Brake pedal to use a H-pattern or sequential shifters....

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +2

      Hi. Not sure what you mean by that. if its a typo and you meant a clutch pedal then no you don't need, most cars you can set to auto clutch and just lift off the throttle as you change gear.

  • @masterphil156
    @masterphil156 Рік тому

    If you want to drive an older 997 911gt3 cup Porsche, you need to have a degressiv brakepedal like known in your normal car an a clutch 4 downshifting with "zwischengas" like we say in 🇩🇪. In a current Gt3 car like the r8 or AMG GT3 you need a progressive brake with a short travel and a pressure of 70kilo. To simulate that, your brake has to be extreme good. The GT3 Cup Porsche Pedals could be HE Sprints and for the Hard Brake I use the Asetek invicta. But to have fun with racing, just buy a pedalset that is fitting to your style. The fanatec v1 were a long time my choice 20years ago. Now I have v3 and invicta and HE are ordered. 😊 I will give the v3 bpk away. They are new but squeeky. Don't buy fanatec. Quality is worse.

  • @H0urg1ass
    @H0urg1ass Рік тому +1

    Sooo, basically $250 USD extra cost for less than 1% performance gain over the Heusinkveld. Well, as a weekend hobbyist sim racer, I'll take the Sprint's value since I'll never race enough to make use of the fractional gains.

  • @captainslav6528
    @captainslav6528 Рік тому

    Even with the stiff rubbers do you still think the sprints are better than the Fanatec V3's I would assume so but what do you think ?

  • @peadookie
    @peadookie Рік тому

    Do you think the VRS is worth the extra money (over $300USD) over the HE sprint?

  • @rcwck
    @rcwck 3 роки тому

    Is there any recommendations where to buy the Heusinkveld Sprints in the USA? A place that offers decent prices and good support. Thanks

  • @CliffFong
    @CliffFong 3 роки тому +1

    Couldn't you put the plastic inserts to have the stiff pedal you would prefer on the sprints?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому

      I just found them to be really switchy then, on/off, no progression. I had much more control over pressure with the softer rubbers, but had to get used to the slightly longer peddle they produced. Its still good, and I was amazed how quickly I settled back into them after using the VRS for a few hours.

    • @jenscee7679
      @jenscee7679 3 роки тому

      I use my HE Sprints without the spring and the medium rubber. It’s quite easy to feel the braking, even in the Cup car and Radical.

    • @dominikka7610
      @dominikka7610 3 роки тому

      @@jenscee7679 you use it without the spring and without the medium rubber? or without the spring and you use the medium rubber on it?

  • @tobytoxd
    @tobytoxd 7 місяців тому

    Great review and observations! Thank you very much!

  • @kezman82a
    @kezman82a 2 роки тому +1

    Is the vrs dampers kit worth it?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  2 роки тому

      Hi, Sorry I still haven't managed to get hold of any to try them. But TBH I doubt they need it. They are very good as is.

  • @vyacheslav_potapenko
    @vyacheslav_potapenko 2 роки тому

    your brake inputs are totally wrong (by looking into labs graph)

  • @jonferraez
    @jonferraez 3 роки тому +3

    Some very nice detail on the properties of each pedal versus the HE Sprints. The side by side analyzer graphs bit is quite interesting. It does tell me we need software from VRS, to be able to quickly change profiles per type of car. I like the comparison format, as we don't often see that with sim gear. The matter of the fact style is refreshing. The Sprints are one of the main competitors at this price point and hardware wise seem to punch above the Sprints to even a higher level. For customers in North America the cost of the Sprints adds $87 USD ($112 USD for the HE Ultimates) or so to the price as compared to the VRS, which is cheaper due to their location, which weighs on the decision. It will also be interesting to see how the add-on hydraulic dampeners ($149 USD) will perform and enhance the VRS. That dampener may take it very close in performance and feel to the HE Ultimates, which are the benchmark for performance pedals currently. It will be good to get an updated lap times stat after you get closer to the amount of hours that you have in the Sprints, and to compare the two models in another type of car, like a Radical or a Formula, while you still have them in house. I do get this is your early take on how the initial form of the pedals are, and that it is likely to release software for them, and would really like to see another review of the completed set with software + hydraulic dampeners kit for all 3 pedals, because at that point they should really shine. Thanks Gavin.
    Detail on the hydraulic dampener kit, which VRS will sell as an add-on:
    Optional throttle, brake, and clutch hydraulic damper kit (to available later): USD 149 / EUR 149 VAT incl.
    Damper kit description: The DirectForce Pro Pedals Damper Kit consists of three hydraulic dampers for the VRS DirectForce Pro Throttle, Brake, and Clutch pedals. Recommended for people who’d like their sim racing pedals to feel a bit more like real-life hydraulic pedals. These dampers will provide extra resistance against rapid input changes which can help to smoothen out your inputs but can add unwanted friction and take away some responsiveness, which is why we offer them as an optional add-on rather than pre-installing them on our damper-less Throttle, Brake and Clutch pedals.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +1

      Awesome feedback and spot on. Thanks so much for taking the time to write it.
      The only concern I have for the dampers is they may take some of the snap out of the throttle pedal. So I can't wait to try them and see. I'm also keen to see how they react to the brake feel. Because it feels great at the moment so I'm a little apprehensive if in terms of pure performance they will be a benefit. In terms of real life feeling and mimicking the feeling of hydraulic brakes I'm sure they can only help. But at some point irl feel and Sim lap times have to go their separate ways. Hopefully soon we have some available to bolt on and see. 👍

  • @Scott-jg1it
    @Scott-jg1it 3 роки тому +3

    1st watcher and really enjoyed the show.
    Id say that you would only get more speed out of the VRS pedals, especially considering the minimal time you have been using them and they are so close in times.
    Maybe a follow up review on what you did with the VRS pedals today, to what they are like after some more time spent on the VRS pedals.

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому

      That's the plan, I will revisit them in a few weeks once I have some good hours on them. and hopefully if iRacing leave the Cup Car alone we can revisit the sprint data to compare them again and get a good view on were the VRS really sit in terms of performance.
      Thanks for watching and the feedback!

  • @roadi7
    @roadi7 3 роки тому +1

    are you still selling the sprints?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому

      Yes. Shipping to uk tomorrow. If you want them contact Mydas simulation. Matt will sell them for me.

  • @markchandler5721
    @markchandler5721 3 роки тому +1

    Any updates since this video?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +5

      They are really working well. No faults or issues so far. I will shoot an update soon and go back over the data to see if anything really stands out. We also have some other pedals in the price range on the way for more comparisons.

  • @carlhazelton1735
    @carlhazelton1735 3 роки тому +2

    Great review Gav!

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому

      Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it Carl 😊

    • @jonferraez
      @jonferraez 3 роки тому +1

      Agreed! Some nice detail on the properties of each pedal versus the HE Sprints. Love the side by side on the graphs. Thanks Gavin.

  • @DarkChild1758
    @DarkChild1758 3 роки тому +1

    Bathurst is the best place to test pedals imo

  • @lamesheepracing
    @lamesheepracing Рік тому

    One year later, what’s the long term review?

  • @VishnuRajam4x4
    @VishnuRajam4x4 3 роки тому +1

    Fantastic work

  • @stevek7760
    @stevek7760 3 роки тому

    Wow nice vid mate. Fellow P cup driver from Aus. Subscribed!

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +2

      Awesome. Thanks for the sub! Can't wait for the new car to drop this week!

  • @phl2009
    @phl2009 3 роки тому +1

    Great review.

  • @MrMurfMan
    @MrMurfMan 3 роки тому

    That mic sounds like cheeks

  • @stavvyy5456
    @stavvyy5456 3 роки тому

    Great video Gav , how did you have your sprints setup ? Did you have the spring at the bottom , I've taken mine out feels much better

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +2

      Hi Stavvy, thanks for the comment. Yes I still have the spring fitted but all the preload is taken out of it. I'm going to revisit the sprint settings in the next few weeks and see if we can find something a bit better for them. Having the VRS as a benchmark........ Every day is a learning day!

  • @frankd.b.9233
    @frankd.b.9233 2 роки тому

    Sprit vs pro, why

  • @KuSQ3N
    @KuSQ3N 3 роки тому +2

    I see a lot of fanboys in the comments :)

  • @juliusd4181
    @juliusd4181 3 роки тому +1

    I have the same issue with constant brake force on the Sprints, however: I would assume, after having watched interviews with niels, the Sprints might be more durable, he talked especially about the springs. The deformation on those looks like it strains the springs in the VRS a lot more. Anyway, great looking pedal set, but I will pass on these.

  • @chadharris6625
    @chadharris6625 Рік тому

    Great video man! But damn your frame rate is horrible! That's why I stick to ultrawide lol

  • @reviewforthetube6485
    @reviewforthetube6485 3 роки тому +1

    I have to give it to vrs they are killing it with price/performance ratio and there dd wheel is insanely good mabye the best road detail I've ever felt from any dd and I've used them all absolutely amazing now some things don't come through as good for me but man that road feel is 4vrrything to me it always feels like you are engaged and to me that's that's matters since all of these wheels can do the job amd be competitive it comes down to which one makes you more immersed or which one sre you most comfortable with or what details do you like to feel the most lol if I had my choice tho of any dd wheel people may be shocked by this but the dd1 I liked it for me it wasn't overly sensitive some of these dd wheel are so sensitive and that shale that happens bugs me sometimes with the dd1 you can tune that out beautifully and I feel everything I need to but without feeling the unwanted effects once setup correctly funny because at first it was the opposite and it couldn't be fixed now with rhe newer drivers and stuff yesh it's outstandingly good imo sure we all know the semucube is the best in most opinion s but I actually enjoyed using the dd1 more and i don't need 20nm I like sitting at 8 to 10nm and it's perfect it's absolutely for me the most weel rounded due to how it feels the power the price and the entire fanatec ecosystem and they keep doing more things and new things I think the new csl elite dd is absokutely outstanding I'm hearing from testers it feels identical to the dd1 and dd2 and that's even without new drivers that's with the first drivers for it not 1 wheel from fanatec comes out on release that dialed in so to hesr that it's amazing and I may get one to use during my competitions dude to only setting 8nm when I compete I don't go higher then that and I like that it will be maxed as I've found dd wheels that are only 10nk when I max that out compared to just putting another dd wheel to 10 that cna go to 2p I feel the 10nm wheel maxed has a bit more to it then oen that you have to lower but again I think its an outstanding move on fanatec end I mens they may change the entire game with this wheel base and that's exciting DD wheels may become the standard how insanely good is that? Also I feel every dsmn place that has wheels will have a csl elite dd wheel due to it having the power but not to much and the price I just feel so many things including f1 comps and others will be using it i just know it lol

    • @theonlyegg
      @theonlyegg 3 роки тому +4

      Dude. Punctuation. I can't read this.

  • @maas7740
    @maas7740 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for your review :) I currently drive the Sprints and am considering switching from the Sprints to the VRS even before your review was online because I am super satisfied with my VRS Base.
    Would you say a switch from the Sprints to the VRS is worth it or are they too close together?

    • @SmokingSteelGarage
      @SmokingSteelGarage  3 роки тому +3

      It's too close at the moment. But if VRS do launch some software then I'd say that would be the tipping point. Also awaiting the dampers which could potentially improve the VRS even more.

  • @TheDoctor46vr
    @TheDoctor46vr 10 місяців тому

    Did you redo the test?