Danny Carey 'Pneuma by TOOL (Live in Concert) Drum Cam | 1st Time REACTION for Scott
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 кві 2024
- 00:00 Intro
01:04 Reaction
15:27 Final Thoughts
I play the Vic Firth Danny Carey drum cam video of Pneuma from my long time friend and band mate, Scott. Scott is a drummer and is very much into the jam band scene. He doesn't follow TOOL the way I do. I've seen this video a lot, but this is the first time for Scott.
SOURCE VIDEO
• Danny Carey | "Pneuma"...
Follow us on Instagram
@secondhandreactions
If you'd like to support our channel you can buy us a beer - Cheers! 🍻
www.buymeacoffee.com/secondha...
If you'd like to help raise awareness for Suicide Prevention here in the US - click here:
afsp.org
Here's a link for Suicide Hotlines around the world. If you're struggling, or know someone who is, don't wait! Help is out there. You are not alone!
blog.opencounseling.com/suici...
Time became a concept because Danny Carey decided to play drums 😅
Energy = Mass x Carey^2
I've seen this video at least 200 times in 2023 and it never gets old! Class!
Agreed. It blows my mind every time I see it
Same here
Same. At least a dozen times in just over 4 years.
Literally me too...I can't get enough!!!!
Epic. Epic behavior.
I like watching drummer react to this video... Seeing them being baffled by, and trying to figure out the time signatures is entertaining
Danny's brainlock is breathtaking. A gentle giant with an incredible talent, best in the business. ❤
Agreed.
Watching the host feel proud of what danny is doing is so heartwarming!
Danny is my fn hero but you are correct. Its those 4 guys that make the magic.
Danny Carey a an actual Rockstar.
So few have surfaced over the years.
🤘
Hit the nail on the head. “Boomers had Pink Floyd, Genxers have Tool.” I’ve always thought of Tool as a modern day Pink Floyd, not that they sound like Pink Floyd, but that they are on the creative level of a band like Floyd and do not sound like anything else.
Seriously, i've watched this Danny's video a thousand times. I watched the original video and MANY reactions to it, i will never be tired of it. And my praise for Danny grows even more with each new reaction i saw.
There are some great reaction videos. I really like the professional drummers' reactions.... those two in the UK and probably my favorite - Drumming with Jarvis and Michael Palmisano.... I'm positive you've seen all of those.
I didn't even know about Tool until a few years ago and I was like "How in the hell did I not know about these guys and especially Danny Carey?" I'm a reformed drummer but it's still in my blood. It's so difficult to describe what makes Tool so unique, fascinating, and mesmerizing to those who have never played an instrument and dealt with something other than 4/4 time signatures. In songs like Invincible, there are sections where each musician is playing in a different time. Normally, something like that wouldn't be at all musical. Yet Tool manages to pull it off and then they bring the time back together seamlessly. The complexity is just off the charts and each of them make it look so effortless. There are just not enough superlatives. Each song is an incredible musical accomplishment.
Totally agree. Well put!
I have watched that vid dozens of times, and I never tire of it. Crazy.
This is a master craftsman who has mastered his trade, he is the one that makes the ones who follow better, Carrey on
“Humanity has a chance!” Exactly right, I feel the exact same way when watching Danny drum.
Watch this at least once a week,when I need to ground myself. It's like watching a guy spin a hundred plates without dropping any
💯
I get to see these guys again in Phoenix in a couple weeks. Last time I saw them was in Hershey PA and it was one of the best concerts I’ve ever been to.
I was lucky enough to see them in NYC on their precursory tour for Lateralus. I missed them this time around - unfortunately
That smile at 14:30 says "The hard part is done, the rest is just fun.
God Tier!
No other drum cam can compete with the octopus. He becomes 1 with the machine and you can see it happen.
I think Danny is a prototype of a much more evolved human being. Our current society is not ready for a collective transformation to this type of human.
I've probably ACTUALLY listened to this a thousand times since 2019.
I know I've listened to the Ænima album at least 5000 times
I watch that video at least 5 times a week. While I am at work, while I am goofing off on the internet, etc. And Danny is 6'5" tall
This album is a Fucking Masterpiece!!
That snare. And the roto Toms and the savageness of this song. The breakdown is glorious.
GLORIOUS!
I would love to know how Danny and Neil became friends before his passing. Can you imagine being A fly on the wall for that?
You’ve probably seen it, but there’s a great video of Danny sitting in with Rush playing YYZ - great tribute to Neil
He flat out knocked it out of the park too. He and Geddy were in sync all the way through. Never missed a lick.
When you're a very well regarded drummer in your own right and see who you've got in your own home studio and decide to play guitar instead. :)
Stewart Copeland's "Grove" with both Neil and Danny.
ua-cam.com/video/1mUjLAWIj7E/v-deo.html
If Rush ever does a tour again Carey is the protégé of Neil he would have to be the only choice
These four artists in a musical group is a rare and awesome thing.I first saw them live in 1993.Seven live shows in all.Worth every penny.Tool is their own genre...How cool is that?
Rush is the group that comes to mind that showed the way to Tool. In fact having Alex Lifeson play live with Tool was a perfect synergy. The other band that comes to mind is Iron Maiden, who are a band of five ( Janick joined), that have amazing time changes and perfect unity, in very complex music
The half time angry breakdown is so amazing
spot on with the description .. this is only keeping one song in check.. every damn song they got is another brain fucker,,, 100 of these mind bombs!!!
You’re right. Good point!
How do you like how smoothly he goes from double strokes to singles in the first minute?
A sign of what's to come.
I fucking love this video and the reactions… I’ve been thinking in this rabbit hole for 20 plus years now haha
I’m with you. I’m still watching it and other people react to it.
Hey guys, just stumbled on this channel, as I was in search of this particular Tool video where Danny Carey absolutely, with precision, executes a masterful performance.
It was great to see someone who completely appreciated that level of sophistication and knew it was genuine and not contrived.
Hey! Thanks for watching with us. He’s super human!
4:15 "I think this band with a different drummer would be completely different."
I once jokingly asked a friend, "What if Danny Carey played drums for Metallica one concert? What if Lars Ulrich played drums for Tool one concert?" His response was, "One band would have their first good live performance in years, one band would have their first bad live performance in years." 😂
Accurate. I couldn’t imagine Tool with Lars. Lol
Sometimes I’ll miss a loop when tying my shoe, and he’s out here doing all this not even working up a sweat lol
Seriously! lol - Well put. Crazy talent
Danny’s left arm is like, “ you guys good? I got this over here.”😊
lol
i have a theory: the reason you can't "find the 1" in the song is because they're basing this song around the act of breathing. There's no "time signature" to that, so what I think Danny is doing is playing in a very "reaction"-based way, where his drumming is literally having a conversation or playing in such a way that with adam's guitar, and justin's bass riffs, it seems like a completely subliminal action, like it is with breathing. we don't think about it, but it always happens. it's just a part of our existence, and it's rarely "in the way" of anything we do.
I didn’t really have trouble finding it. But I understand the effect of the loop and how it sounds as though the 1 is hidden.
I wish Danny had more drum 🥁 cam videos 😅
Me too
So looking forward to see them this year live in Germany! Bought tickets for 2 concerts and will take my 6 year old son with me, he absolutely loves Pneuma.
Good Parenting!
And he was 58 HERE!!!! that's wild!
Amazing
As a drummer for over 30 yrs myself. If you still have the passion to play, age doesn't really matter. The only issue is when the body or mind is broken and playing is not possible anymore. Up to that point, you can keep going and evolving
Yep. I'm the same age as Carey. I just saw them live for the first time two nights ago. I can't even imagine how in the hell he has the stamina to do a show like that. Peart hung it up because he was getting to the point where he could no longer play to his high standards.
Neil Pert says, HeII yeah!!!!
The best in the business.
That was insane. God I love TOOL
Me too brother!
So right about Tool as a generational band. I had heard of them for a while before checking them out. It was this song that really hooked me. Explored the rest of Fear Inoculum. Went back to the Pot, Lateralus, 46 & 2 and others. Incredible.
Ive seem many of the greatest drummers over the past 40 years live, he’s different level great compared to the rest. Recent MSG show was tremendous.
checkin in...
He's 6'5" 😊 Best drummer out there
TOOL.. Love these guys is an absolute understatement. This video brings me tears of joy and healing every single time. Seen them 6 times. True masters of their art and I am so grateful to have had them in my life. They are truly a spectacle to watch and the alchemy that resonates from there music is on a metaphysical scale from the gods! ❤️🙏💫🙌
Well put!
I remember this fondly, heartbeat drumming
I can never see this too many times, what a beast. From a drummer who is not worthy. The music and the drumming is next level. I think he has to be very relaxed or he would become exhausted, I would. Unless he's not human. Thank you.
🤘😆🤘
Band fact: Danny, Adam and Justin do all of the music first. Then Maynard comes to the studio and adds his poems after. New subscriber 👌
I was coming to the comments to say the exact same thing.
Would love an up close vid of Danny on The Grudge
Yes. 💯
I watch that video about 5 times a week lol
I trip going up a flight of stairs. The coordination he exudes is phenomenal.
Also a 100+viewer
Tool's song writing process is Danny, Adam, and Justin write all the music first. Then, it goes to Maynard to complete the lyrics.
Justin Chancellor would be the bassist. He followed up Paul D'Amour.
You knew I'd be back for this Clay! I love a drum cam and you and Sue reacted to it for me a few months ago. Great to hear Scott's input!!
This one is timeless. It should be put into a time capsule and buried so future civilizations can one day witness the high point of humanity
Agreed
Put it in that safe with all the seeds in Finland 😂
Using the tom as a ride symbol is about the best thing about this song...
Where there's a master in kung fu.. He is the master of drumming..
Been listening to tool since they started and they never seem to disappoint. 👍
By far the best version of this song is the drum version
It’s insane to watch him play this
Danny, Justin and Adam write to 'songs' and only send it to Maynard once it's basically complete. Maynard at the point will immerse himself in it in for weeks or more and just let the lyrics flow from the composition. He said he'll intentionally listen to it on different audio sources, different environments etc...to ensure it fits everywhere possible. He's a modern day genius poet the way I see it...and this is just Tool, he has 2 other bands, Puscifer and A Perfect Circle as well!
Octopus 🤘🏻
Just an fyi several of my grandchildren are 3rd generations of Tool fans❤🔥
That’s awesome!
I LOVE DANNY I LIVE TOOL! I think Luke Holland is pretty damn talented as well!
My holy trinity of drummers is Danny Carey, Thomas Haake of Meshuggah, and Vlad Ulasevich of Jinjer. Watch drum playthroughs for those two as well. Clockworks for Thomas Haake and Mediator (among others, there’s a ton) for Vlad.
Ah nice- I only know that one Jinjer song everyone reacted to. I never thought to look deeper into them. Thanks for these suggestions
@@secondhandreactionsthat’s not even one of their top 10 songs. It’s just the most surprising with the vocal switch up. Teacher, Teacher and I Speak Astronomy are their best in my opinion.
I love Vlad Ulasevich' drumming but I think Mario Duplantier from Gojira is still a little above him (and maybe even above Haake who I also love)
100% we need to hang out!
I had never heard of Jinjer, so I checked out some of their videos. The drummer is very, very good, but he’s just not on the same level as Haake or Carey.
Fun part is that Danny Carey joining Tool was an accident. He rented out a rehearsal room and Tool showed up for their first rehearsal but their drummer didn't and Danny offered to fill in that day.
I don’t believe in fate but damn
I saw a video a couple years ago where Adam was talking about this with a reporter. Apparently, Danny said no at first, but changed his mind once he heard Paul, Adam, and Maynard start jamming. He decided to sit in with them for a few songs and the rest is history.
tool’s Mona Lisa
Everyone of these guys are the best or one of at what they do… it’s subjective I know. This is your favorite bands, Favorite band 🤘🏼🌀
I love your last sentence. Very true.
The octopus is the best ever
One has to wonder what the readout would look like if electrodes were attached to Danny's head to capture his brain activity during this song. I'd love to see that.
That would be interesting 🤔
I can’t count it either an usually I can count any rhythm. It’s odd and beautiful too.
Agreed. This might be my favorite song on the album
🤘🏻🌀
🤘😆🤘
Technically they had a few first drummers in 1990 and 91. But they wouldn't be who they are without Carey
As weird as it seems, the time signature seems to be 33/8. At least it works to count it out as 6/8 6/8 5/8 5/8 6/8 5/8 or other combinations of those.
Also the number on the jersey he’s wearing 🤯
@@secondhandreactions Was it intentional? I can totally see Danny getting together with the Vic Firth people to choose a date on the tour to do this next level drum cam setup, and Danny just tells them, "Hey, I'll be wearing #33 in Boston, so let's do it then and really blow their minds!"
@@Nulli_Di Great, as a guitar player put my money on 27/8. When drummers speak I lose
@@hockeyfreak66666 I think there are sections that are 27/8
Larry Bird. I also came up with 33/8. Six times.
Danny is an amazing drummer, however look at who his influences are; a fair amount of Jazz players. Polyrhythms are a home of creativity along with the harmonics used. Independent drummers are always amazing, Danny shows this. It would be interesting to know the hours he's spent over his life working on his craft, my guess is over 100,000, generally 10,000 hrs wil get you a high level.
He didn’t want to drum with them but he did them a favor because someone else didn’t show up. They all felt it click and he said hey let’s do this again.
Didn’t know this. Thanks for the insight 🤘
Tribal drummer
Rumor has it when he smiles, it's because of a mistake. Hell if I can indicated it.
I’ve heard this too. I can’t see/hear it either.
He only looks at the kit 2 or 3 times during the entire song. I guess playing drums for 50-ish years, you just know.
Dialed in
1961 :)
This song is more about the time signature than the playing, nothing he’s doing is out of the ordinary that makes me say wow, yes he’s good, it’s nice and clean I’ll give him that….that section where he plays the Tom’s continuously over the bar line, is just putting it on auto pilot. Maybe in the rock world he’s one of the best but this idea of him being the greatest out there is ridiculous, go check out some fusion drummers, one guy who comes to mind is Marco Minneman if you want to talk about 4 way independence or polyrhythmic drumming. There are too many to list you just have to leave the rock world.
And tell us your inspiration from the World music side of things. Reggae? How about a didgeridoo reaction? Enlighten our cannabis and DMT soaked brains with your wisdom and guidance to find all that is the best anywhere in the Universe one may travel, no matter what anyone else thinks. I'm sure that they've heard of you on Proxima Centaurii and are transmitting the message as I write that they will be here for you next Wednesday.
So get ready.
To go.
There.
The music is created before the lyrics…. Maynard writes to the music.
if there were a god, he wishes he could play like Danny.
Amen
Number One still is John Bonham, Second Danny Carey… yeah I know what you’re saying… Jazz Drummers are in a separate Category!
6"5"
Chamberlain lol
Danny Carey can play one time signature with each limb, he’d do five, but not with his pants on…
lol
100% disagree with the comment that he must be in his own head and not aware of or listening to anything else around him. The band has said they don't play to a click track. So they are 100% listening to each other, as any good musician should.
While I do agree it is usually the drummer who keeps the time so the guitarist and bassist keep up with them. Tool isn't just any band, obviously, but Danny in some parts probably just does his thing.
@@princeofpcos9804 Check out the new (today) rig rundown from Premier Guitar with Justin. No click. And Justin explains he has to run multiple delay time settings on his pedal board because the tempo of some songs changes by the end (mostly because of Danny speeding up).
Rush wouldn't be Rush without Neil these are drummers of a different breed
I tried to figure out the count. I'm still????
The count is 12/8 11/8 10/8. I wasn't able to figure it out, another drummer did.
Add up those 3 counts.
hey! really hope tool pushit doesnt trigger you to much
Thelema like it or not
Danny's just trolling at around 10:20. He does a little drumstick flip before and then a little after, for no real reason other than flair. Play on playa.
Their warm-ups are pro'ly out of most people's league.
For real
Probably? I'm in in a 27/8 head space as a guitarist. I'm complicating everything
If you pay the extra money you can watch it before the concert. They always warm up with songs they are not playing that night. Maynard almost is never there. Seeing them tomorrow night in Baltimore. 🤘
You compare them to pink floyd.....I consider then US' Rush....
They got some prog chops like Rush for sure, but also some psychedelic vibes like Pink Floyd
Number 33 huh? Come on, enough of that. Everyone knows what it means now. Incredible performance though.
Enough of what?
@@secondhandreactions Enough of 33 and 13. It refers to the one third of the angels fallen.
@@ericbitzer5247 Never heard that. I know the song is in 33. And also 33 is Larry Bird’s number.
As a drummer myself over 30 yrs I can't clearly find the count. The person in the brown shirt must be the master of all drummers to count the notes correctly.
Watch Metallica currently and it’s embarrassing
lol
Danny is better than ezra
And Ezra is a Jedi
If you can't headbang to this song...keep trying.Tool is messing with you.Keep trying.
Not from this world
These two think they know who the best in the business is, but they have yet to even watch the best in the biz. There are several drummers that existed who are way better than Danny Carey. John Bonham performed things on the drums that Carey wouldn't have a clue how to do. Buddy Rich is another, Carl Palmer, and let's not forget Neil Peart, just to name a few who are on the list of better drummers.
I don’t think we said he’s the best. Just appreciating his next level, and clearly undeniable, talent. ✌️
Too bad Bonzo was such an alkie. If he'd lived, he might convince me he was the greatest. But he didn't, and he isn't.