Dream Theater - The Great Debate (Live 1080p) 23/07/11

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 89

  • @kingbasil
    @kingbasil 13 років тому +18

    A very difficult and a highly technical song especially for mangini! I think he nailed it

    • @BBHemisnJets
      @BBHemisnJets 3 роки тому

      Yup !!!

    • @pipps1158
      @pipps1158 2 роки тому

      Mangini’s symmetrical kit and isolated limb system in playing it is beyond normal human beings.

  • @sandysatya2625
    @sandysatya2625 7 років тому +15

    9:30 Mike Mangini is attacking by mosquitos

  • @ShadowMKII
    @ShadowMKII 12 років тому +5

    Wow, this song actually makes for a very good concert performance

  • @glennw53
    @glennw53 13 років тому +3

    Truly Epic. Watching MM gives me chills just like MP did{And Does) in the early days. Fantastic choice for the band. As times goes on we will see what music MM has in him too.

  • @SvenHild
    @SvenHild 13 років тому +2

    what an awesome song! great to see the guys perform their great stuff from the good old times!...

  • @RadityoArdiH
    @RadityoArdiH 13 років тому +10

    Mike Mangini plays this energic song without dificulties......
    I respect Mike Portnoy, Mike Mangini, and all of greatest drummer in the world....
    Don't have to be "The Great Debate" of who is the best drummer, right?

  • @jaspergillgannon4991
    @jaspergillgannon4991 4 роки тому +3

    No one's commenting on it, but that light show is amazing!

  • @DreamWorldwide
    @DreamWorldwide 11 років тому +4

    I really wish they had dome this song for Live at Luna Park.

  • @gianfrixmg
    @gianfrixmg 13 років тому +9

    Rudess @0:45
    *changes hand*
    *watches audience*
    *trollface*

  • @rotopaj
    @rotopaj 12 років тому +2

    Yeah, you're right. After seeing Marco in live concert with The Aristocrats I really think he would had brought a new style to DT; also, he's a great composer. But we will see, I hope they'll do their best... I want to believe :_D

  • @ProgressiveForest
    @ProgressiveForest 12 років тому +3

    @Vinterless I prefer Images and Words era's songwriting too, I'll give you that. But I think Jordan is one of a few that still haven't lost the true 'progressive' spirit. I mean, the genre labels itself 'progressive' but recently it degenerated into technicality circus... Rudess still does the circus but he experiments with so many instruments, which I think is a truly progressive attitude towards music. For example check out his Geo Synthesizer.

  • @ChrisHaspeck
    @ChrisHaspeck 12 років тому +2

    I agree. Who else can make that 'Continuum' sing like it does ?

  • @bateria1000
    @bateria1000 11 років тому +1

    extraordinario D T lejos la mas potente banda que ha pisado la tierra !

  • @redelexa1
    @redelexa1 13 років тому +1

    @KrixPrix I think you are right, i thought it was the OASYS but if you look carefully you can tell the difference in the screen, and also the knobs (OASYS has colored knobs and KRONOS doesn´t) such a good observation !!!!

  • @Siphonoglyph
    @Siphonoglyph 13 років тому +1

    @gigman74 : Starting at about 9:20 on "Lost Not Forgotten" Mangini plays 16th notes riding on a hihat (or some kind of stack) and without missing a single note, also plays the snare on the up beat in 1/4 notes. Now, it is physically impossible to do this in the "traditional" way of playing drums without missing a note on that 16th ride on the hihat. So, you trying playing 16th notes on a hihat and 1/4 notes on the snare on the upbeat WITHOUT missing a single note on the hihat. Go ahead.

  • @ethanbruley8858
    @ethanbruley8858 4 роки тому +1

    The intro is always insane

  • @0611dean
    @0611dean 13 років тому

    @gigman74 hi gigman74 . fantastic quality vids.i was down the front with my TZ10 but it was impossible to shoot down there but what i did get the sound quality is still awesome. you cant beat these panasonic point and shoot cams.awesome gig by the way :-)

  • @Onamorata
    @Onamorata 13 років тому +1

    @gigman74 How about on the ride cymbal at 1:51? Thats pretty cool.

  • @AdhidaZ
    @AdhidaZ 9 років тому

    great performance...specially for MM

  • @metaldoood
    @metaldoood 13 років тому

    Going to San Francisco in 1 1/2 months :) .. Can't wait

  • @0611dean
    @0611dean 13 років тому

    @metaldoood youare gonnahave a blast. MM has given them a new lease of life.i was at this gig, they were on fire, best ive heard them in the last 10 years, even JLB was on his game :-) ENJOY.

  • @shplog2
    @shplog2 13 років тому +4

    Just noticed Petrucci almost lost his superpowers @ 6:22

  • @rotopaj
    @rotopaj 12 років тому +1

    The "drum" parts were written (by JP if i'm not wrong) before Mangini joined the band. He just recorded based on it. I think we have to wait for the next album to see how far Mangini fits this band.

  • @chaneppchannel_365
    @chaneppchannel_365 5 років тому +2

    Maggini plays good with song.

  • @reisselpud
    @reisselpud 13 років тому

    The drum part is fucking awesome ! : )

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @noconflictbanana Panasonic tz20. All other band videos on my profile were recorded with a Panasonic ft1 which is 720p

  • @KrixPrix
    @KrixPrix 13 років тому +1

    lol rudess has a korg oasys look a like stand but its another one (kronos?)

  • @Siphonoglyph
    @Siphonoglyph 13 років тому

    @gigman74 : Don't have to. He does it right here in front of your eyes if you're paying attention. Starting at 7:20, he rides on the chinese with his right hand while doing fills that would otherwise require both hands to play (variations of quadruplets, quintuplets, etc) unless you have seriously fast hands and are totally ambidextrous. Which, I can't think of another drummer that is capable of doing that. I'm sure someone out there is...but I haven't seen it.

  • @ericgrimm7722
    @ericgrimm7722 Рік тому

    Not enough JMX footage...but pretty good coverage nonetheless

  • @anti7gn
    @anti7gn 13 років тому +1

    7:06 ,that's very accurate

  • @TakanashiIori
    @TakanashiIori 9 років тому +1

    Was Labrie late for 4 bars at 8:06??

  • @ShadowMKII
    @ShadowMKII 11 років тому

    Agreed!

  • @aliriocastillomoreno5139
    @aliriocastillomoreno5139 4 роки тому +2

    HOLY SHIT JORDAN AT 11:41

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @shimyns Thanks :-) That's all the videos i have. I was told to stop recording :-(
    I'll try and record them again when they tour the album.

  • @RyanCarraher
    @RyanCarraher 12 років тому +1

    There is nothing like seeing Dream Theater live! Check out my cover of this solo on my channel!

  • @RadityoArdiH
    @RadityoArdiH 13 років тому +1

    @Chuck04606 the people who loved to debate, especially great debate, actually it's coming out from their DNA. :p

  • @CaptainOffensive
    @CaptainOffensive Рік тому

    Mangini is so fricking good here omg.

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @shimyns Yeah i mean, if they were THAT bothered then why didn't they search anyone for cameras on the door?? My camera is a panasonic tz20 and looks like a normal point and shoot but i was right by the door and the security were going through there quite often. I have recorded whole gigs before and it hurts the arm after a while. I used a panasonic ft1 on all my other recordings and that is much lighter, which helps! That only records in 720p though but it's still better than most cams

  • @shimyns
    @shimyns 13 років тому

    Dude, awesome quality! I just some them in Israel. Do you have any vids you have yet to upload?

  • @soocool78
    @soocool78 12 років тому

    thats true, but i still think his style is similar to MP (basing off stuff mangini wrote)...and would have loved to hear a new sound from DT...but a lot of people like their sound from the last albums so i guess we can't all be happy :D

  • @SilasRNold
    @SilasRNold 12 років тому

    But if Rudess is willing to explore new instruments, that will add a greater progressive element to the band. i.e., his use of the Harpejji. Oh, and if you ever see him talking about his parts, his is as series as any other keyboard player out there.

  • @MrSixxen
    @MrSixxen 13 років тому

    @gigman74 You´re kidding right? 7:20?
    1º He don´t rides on chinese. It´s just a simple and relative slow 4\4 compass.
    2º The left hand is making just doubles, and in this case that requires just ONE hand. Maybe you´re confused because his feet are playing fast single strokes at the same time of left hand fills.
    If i wrote some error sorry, but i´m not very good in English.

  • @Cleaverson
    @Cleaverson 13 років тому +2

    12:00 the stage lights can't even keep up with petrucci ;)

  • @Chuck04606
    @Chuck04606 13 років тому

    LOL I love DT and everything, but watching this at the 3:16 mark, I can't help but think that the video being played on the screen is DNA :p

    •  3 роки тому

      well, it is DNA, because of the lyrics

  • @kana9443
    @kana9443 Рік тому

    what ibanez s model is that

  • @shimyns
    @shimyns 13 років тому

    @gigman74 LOL yeah I can see why. I recorded a few bits on my iphone but the sound was sh1tty. You must have been toting a good camera and they didn't want you to make a profit off the outcoming video. Cheers

  • @hilariusdemu4550
    @hilariusdemu4550 3 роки тому

    7:06 mangini is a beast

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @oikonomidis1 Please name one thing that Mangini can do with one limb that others cannot do with two.... I'm waiting! ;-)

  • @drummingdude47
    @drummingdude47 13 років тому +1

    crowd looks dead

  • @thecrazydiamond5229
    @thecrazydiamond5229 9 місяців тому

    Best Mangini

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @noconflictbanana £235.90 Great camera for the price!

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @drummingdude47 The trip happens in the mind! If only you could see the neurons in the brain...

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @Siphonoglyph Now if YOU were paying attention to the original comment, "It's awesome to see Mike Mangini doing things with ONE limb that others can't do with two!" then you wouldn't have commented! No drummer can do more on ONE hand than others can do on two!

  • @MrSixxen
    @MrSixxen 13 років тому

    @gigman74 Sorry man. My mistake.

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @Siphonoglyph You're not listening are you????
    NO drummer in the world can play more with ONE limb than ANY other drummer can with TWO. It's impossible!

  • @pecavallo
    @pecavallo 12 років тому +1

    Playing complicated riffs your paid to play? sure, it must be hell.. come on.

  • @VideoMask93
    @VideoMask93 12 років тому

    What's wrong with experimenting and having an awesome goatee?

  • @ShadowMKII
    @ShadowMKII 11 років тому

    THIS.

  • @afriandc7519
    @afriandc7519 7 років тому +1

    12:03 portnoy cant do that wkwkw

    • @allrounder1992
      @allrounder1992 7 років тому

      Afrian DC lmao even i can do that.. i happens when a moron think that he is better than the world's best

  • @gigman74
    @gigman74  13 років тому

    @MrSixxen Why are you replying to me??

  • @ArnonRaposo
    @ArnonRaposo 13 років тому

    mangine nunca tomará o lugar de mike. mike eternity

  • @soocool78
    @soocool78 13 років тому

    i still wish they picked Marco or Thoams Lang....i feel that Mangini doesn't add anything more to the band, but is a really good replica for MP, which i guess is what the band is looking for...but after the last few albums i hoped for something different...new album was good, but no drum parts were noticeable

  • @shplog2
    @shplog2 13 років тому

    @anti7gn OMG. hahahaha

  • @Kivek12
    @Kivek12 12 років тому

    what the fuck! they didn't play ANY of these badass songs while on the dramatic tour of events at the Atlanta stop. I feel robbed!! I fucking hate this band now. :( lol

  • @mashudi2372
    @mashudi2372 9 років тому +6

    Please please please...Bring Mike Portnoy back to DT

    • @jackandylan123321
      @jackandylan123321 8 років тому +1

      +Mashudi Cules No thanks, Portnoy would never allow something like the Astonishing so he can fuck off

    • @Beefnhammer
      @Beefnhammer 8 років тому +1

      They would probably still make The Astonishing if MP stayed, it would just have more heavy metal influence and that stupid growling.

    • @jordankelsomusic
      @jordankelsomusic 7 років тому +1

      Really? All I could think after watching this was Mangini played that song pretty fuckin good!

    • @AdhidaZ
      @AdhidaZ 7 років тому

      Mashudi Cules sorry but this mike is better than old mike here. .

    • @allrounder1992
      @allrounder1992 7 років тому +1

      Only a moron will say that magini is better than old mike here

  • @jackandylan123321
    @jackandylan123321 13 років тому

    nevr heard of dream theater before but after the gig they were my (second) favourite band that have ever been
    not as good as metalica

  • @Hockeyguy8541
    @Hockeyguy8541 11 років тому

    On the other hand, Labrie seems to be struggling just a little bit by my ears....

  • @pecavallo
    @pecavallo 12 років тому +1

    What's that stupid Rudess caricature animation? I miss the true DT so much.. with a serious keyboard player that wanted to play music instead of having fun with experimental instruments and shaving like a wizard.

  • @HebbyMetal
    @HebbyMetal 11 років тому +2

    Lol Mangini has such an epic face in the beginning !