I'm very happy with mine, after a few months. It felt very awkward at first because I never wore such a high heel. But I quickly adjusted to that and they are the most comfortable pair of shoes I have owned now. But it's also the most expensive pair I ever bought. I'm very curious to try something else in the same price range to compare but haven't found anything yet that isn't much more expensive.
I love redwing and througood boots. That said; 2 years ago i bought a pair of Thursday captain's (black). They are than iron rangers. Alot cheaper. They're my dayoff boots during summer months. Leather soles are not my thing. Wear too quickly. Look awful in 2 months. Thursday offers a good boot at decent price. You take care of them and you'll get 8 years out of them. Just started watching this channel. I like what i see so far.
@@Thursdayboots Bought one pair and returned. too low instep for me. Not traditional construction style which means not very breathable. Moved on and found Gokey and Rancourt. Nobody can beat them. sorry.
@@waynewang8904 We know that everyone's feet are a little different. What works best for you may not be the best for someone else. We're always coming out with new designs so we'd love for you to check back in. Thanks for giving us a try!
I just ordered a pair of Captains in black thanks in large part to your reviews. I was strongly considering the Taft Dragon boot, but I'm a professor and on my feet a lot for teaching - I need something comfortable that I can move around in, and the Thursdays seem to have comfort in mind far more than the Tafts. They arrive on Monday!
Get excited! The Taft Dragon is a great boot as well but less versatile and more expensive, I think you made a good choice. Hope you like 'em, Professor Bakos!
Oh man, these things are so freakin' great. Fit right the first time, comfortable right out of the box. I have to adjust how I walk a bit since this is my first pair of boots, but I really like them.
A little shoe polish can help you overcome the “negative aging” of the leather, and preserving the leather (including the part of the outsole that does not come into contact with the pavement). Mixing colours of polish can give you very nice tones and helps the leather age well.
This type of leather shouldn’t be polished like traditional dyed leather. A greasy cream conditioner would help hide the scratches and keep the leather looking great. Saphir makes a great lotion just for this type of leather.
While I can’t comment on the Wolverine boots as I’ve never owned a pair, I can say that the Thursday Captain boots break in fast, look and feel great, and are the most comfortable & versatile boots I’ve ever owned. I own 2 pairs of Captains: one in Natural (in actual Horween Chromexcel, the only color though) and Dark Olive Suede. The only boots more comfortable for me are my Thursday’s Cavalier Chelsea boots in “Desert” color. And now they’re doing killer sneakers! Great Co.!
I got a pair of 1000 mile boots and I love them: Went straight to the cobbler after purchase and added a thin rubber sole to the foot pad and heel. It will last for a couple of years and is easy and cheap to resole again and again. Treat them with som Bick 4 and Saphir Renovateur and they look as good as new all the time!
THe 1000 mile boots just killed my feet I tried to wear them for 20 days but they continued to hurt my feet. Took them back! Very disappointed as I researched them extensively before purchase.
I happen to have both as well (though I got the President instead of the Captain), and I'm a big fan of both of them. In my case, both of them actually got worn just about evenly, I had more problems with the Thursday's sole actually, but in close to 4 years of use each, aside from having both re-sold (and I got leather for the Thursday at that point as well, just preferring the look), both have performed very well for me alternating them so I'm wearing each every other day. If I had to pick between the two, I'd probably go with the Wolverine even with the price difference, but it's still pretty close and both are workhorses to me. From my experience, with proper care both will be workhorses for you.
I own four Thursdays. Three Captains in different colors and a President. I also own a pair of thousand mile boots. My thousand miles are taking forever to break in. I'm hoping I got the right size. I sent back 9.5s and got 9s, but they are leaving blisters just before my big toe. I never had a difficult break in period for the Thursdays.
Well done comparison & video & I think you were spot on & right concerning your conclusion that the thursday boot was over all better although they're both good boots. Thank you Sir.
I know absolutely nothing about nice boots. I live in Florida so I don’t have much use of them but my style is changing as I’m in my early 30’s. I just bought a pair of captains boots. Thanks for the great info
Even compared to higher quality boots, I prefer Thursday's silhouettes. They get it just right imo. Meanwhile, a lot of more pricey boots have bold arches or sharp, wide angles like they're made on a rhombus-shaped last.
Call me crazy, but when I wear a pair of boots, I don't particularly want a leather sole. There are almost zero advantages to having a leather sole, while the disadvantages are numerous: (1) not that durable, (2) terrible traction, (3) don't look that great when scuffed up, and (4) hate water and snow.
I've been trying to be really open minded about the potential benefits of a leather sole but they're just so ugly and the grip is so bad. Maybe if you only ever wear them inside I can see the groundfeel being a worthwhile aspect, but the Wolverines tout themselves as work boots.
Nick Ridgeway they have leather soles because they are a homage to the original wolverine boot designed 135 years ago. They are also available in rubber soles as well. Did I mention that I was a fan ✌🏽✌🏽
Stridewise YEAH - All those crazy guys of the past who ran around with those leather soled shoes on. It’s a freakin’ miracle that they made it through the Great Depression, won WWII, defended democracy, and placed a man on the moon, etc. What the hell were they thinking? We’ll never know how many countless fools stepped on an icy sidewalk and kept sliding into traffic to meet their end - oh, the humanity! We with our UA-cam channels, skinny jeans and plastic / rubber shoes know better. (Yeah, I’m a fan of leather soles)
@@DHill-qn8us How do you know they used leather soles and not rubber? And since all those victories were all so glorious, we should continue to use the guns, the cars, the clothes etc etc from those eras and say a big no to the modern equipment we have. We can go back to the steam engine, planes with propellers, he'll we might as well go back to horseback riding for transport.....
I bought the Thursday boots and found the materials to be thin. The toe box collapsed and they are very harsh on impact. They look hip, but that's it. They are going to the thrift sore.
This was my impression as well. These reviewers must get a kickback or something. The Thursday boots look like Walmart quality leather. When I see people recommending them over Red Wing or similar it's just silly
Good video. I purchased the Wolverine boot, I got them @ 1/2 size smaller than sneakers, installed a 3/4 length orthotic from AETREX and I must say that they are like wearing slippers. I also installed a VIBRAM Sole protector to remove any slippage. Just purchased Thursday president boot. Will see how they feel in comparison.
I started my quest for a pair of boots with Thursday Captains. The first pair were flawed and returned. The replacement pair were also flawed. I requested a refund after customer service suggested that I take the brand new boots to a cobbler for repairs. I just received my Wolverine 1000 Mile Cap Toe Classic boots with Vibram half soles. The quality of leather, and overall quality of the Wolverine boots, is superior to Thursday Boots in my opinion. I explained my negative experience and rating in a Thursday Boots survey. It was never posted. The last negative review I can find on Thursday’s website was from 2019. My negative review was given earlier this year.
Absolutely can't agree with you. The Wolverine 1000 Mile boot is superior. Yeah, the Thursday is a good value boot, but it's not even close in quality of materials. The issue with the sole offering less grip is easily remedied by having a Topy sole installed (or opting for the 1000 Mile Evans shoe, which has a Vibram sole piece). Don't get me wrong, the Thursday is a nice boot, but it doesn't hold up to the Wolverine. As for the ageing of the leather, dude, condition the poor thing once in a while yeah? It's basically an oiled leather, oiled leathers need a *little* care to get the best out of them.
Hey I respect your opinion Kim! And your lats, dayum. The Evans does seem like a good compromise, though I'm not sold on Wolverine's leather selection, but that's just me.
@@Stridewise I can understand that. While I do love the Wolverine, I do wish they went with a leather that wasn't quite so... well, fussy. I'd love a pair of Red Wing boots, but they're just too damned narrow! Lats? Ha! Cheers dude :)
Wolverines vary. You should check out the Wolverine Wesley wing tip. It would be a better comparison to the Thursday Captains. I have both. The Wolverine Wesley seems more scratch resistant than the Captain. The captains are a little more comfortable though.
I have both boots and completely agree with everything said in this review. I have multiple pairs of Thursdays because they are so comfortable and versatile. One is a pair of brown suede Vanguards that have a hydrophobic coating that's brilliant. Btw I'm looking forward to your review of White's MP Service Boot. I'm considering getting a pair.
Yesss, it's so good to hear someone say I nailed the review! I never really know if I'm saying the right thing haha. I don't know much about the Vanguards hey, let me know how they wear in for you. Whites is filmed but I want to do another versus video next week so probably it won't go up for two weeks. But the hype is real for that one! I don't want to spoil it but the fit is maybe the best I've ever had.
Your review was spot on! I've had the suede Vanguards for over a year. The ones I have are on the old last that were a little wider and heavier than their current Vanguards. All of my Thursday boots have had minimum break in time. The suede Vanguards felt great from get go and have gotten even more comfortable over time.
Price wise, yes Wolverine is twice as much, win for the other, but really you want to compare the 1000 Mile Evan to this boot for the most fair comparison. Evan model has the Vibram half sole and the grip / traction you’re looking for. Personally I prefer the bigger toe area, it’s sleek enough without being too slim or too big. Most comfortable boots I’ve ever put on (Wolverines).
Interesting I have the Evans model as well and compared to my Thursdays are way less comfortable. The Rugged Collection from Thursday have a shank which helps with support and I can wear all day. My 1000 Mile Boots get uncomfortable very easily. Funny, just different experiences
I mean I wouldn't call this comparison unfair, the 1000 Mile is the most popular boot of theirs, after all. But you're right that it's a tougher fight between the Captain and the Evan, maybe I should have mentioned in the video that they do offer a boot with a Vibram sole if that's the deciding factor for you. I was just comparing my experience with these two boots. Great comment!
I was lucky enough to get a pair of 1000 miles in store with huge discount for just 150. And I am agree with everything that you mentioned. The main disadvantage is that they are really slippery, but the feeling of great leather and even smell of it is just exceptional. I’m also receiving a lot of compliments about them
I’m young, in my teens, but really love leatherwork and boots and I’m looking forward to getting a pair of rugged captain boots when I’m a bit older cause god knows I can’t pull it of now. Thanks for the review.
@@NoNameNo.5 What this gentleman said! I'm a chick lol and I have a pair of the captain boots. I would just get yours a half-size or size up and wear thick socks in case your shoe size changes. Rock them and don't worry about the other dudes who are wearing dirty vans with holes in them. No offense;)
I ordered the captain boots I'm in shock 😅 I usually buy boots from places like asos and American eagle. Thursday boots are a million times better I've been playing myself for years 😂
Hahah! Glad I could have helped. Yeah I like how they have this approach of like, we don't have to use Horween and Dainite etc. to give a boot that's as good quality
So I bought the Thursday's. So much chunkier than I expected. It's no where near a dress boot. I like it but don't buy it expecting a sleek boot like this guy says.
Wolverine Chippewa Thursday boots all meant to copy Red Wing boots. Have been wearing Red Wings since 19677. While I have also worn custom for each foot, (hand-crafted for each foot) Wesco, Scapoose, OR, logger style boots, I have preferred Red Wing Chukka Boots for decades. Now in my old age,(71), I need more ankle and arch support. So yesterdsy, I orderd, (from a Red Wing store), a pair of burgandy Heritage Iron Ranger boots. Buy the most affordable best and Never look back!
Thursday boots are the most affordable, DURABLE, and stylish boots I have ever worn. I've owned my Thursday boots for 3 years, and they are broken in, still in tact, and they are very comfortable.
Wolverine by a 1000 miles (pardon the pun!)... also the finest shoes in the world (Bespoke John Lobbs) are 270 degree welt.. there's a reason they don't do 360.... it's more expensive to attach the heal with nails and glue.
The distance between stitches of the welt of the 1k's seems way to much for the price point of the wolverine. Kinda similar to a doc martin in stitches per inch.
The thursday is the boot I'd expect everyone wearing but the wolverine is what I'd see more in working environments for rougher trades But the thursday boot is the best boot for the majority of people style wise, bring classy fahsion back
I've owned both. Wolverine BLVD's (not 1000 miles) are more comfortable and better quality. I had to return 3 pairs of Thursday Boots due to defects. I have 2 pairs of the Wolverine BLVD capped toes. Both companies offer excellent customer service.
If the price was the same it'd be a tougher choice. I think there's something a little more nostalgic about the 1000 mile boot. I do think the Thursday is much nicer looking. Plus it's cheaper. I wish they made something with a more aggressive sole. Like the commando or Vibram 100.
I think they're just different. I like both designs. I just like the slimmer toe box on the Thursday a bit better. Plus I like toe caps. I have them on my Franks work boots and besides looking good it makes the boot tougher.
I'm not a big fan of smooth sole boots. I usually have my cobbler put Vibram lug half soles on the front to make them more useful as a boot. I just wear dress shoes if I want to dress up.
After more than a month of break-in time my Wolverine still felt very uncomfortable. The thick leather was really unforgiving. On the other hand I could wear the Thursday Captain without any break-in at all. They were comfortable from the moment I put the boots on. Not only they are more stylish looking but the quality of the workmanship is quite surprising. I own now 3 pair of Thursday Boots.
Today the Wolverine is $250 on Amazon and the Captain is $199. The first thing I noticed at the beginning of the video was the creases in the Wolverine. Even without any experience in fine boots (I get mine on sale from Big 5) the difference was clear and obvious. Thursday Heritage Wingtips are $220. I'm tempted.
The extra stitching at the crease helps prevent creasing elsewhere. A boot is going to crease. You either tell it where to crease or it will decide on its own. The rubber sole probably helps maintain the intregrity of the upper. Also, lined boots tend to wear better. Ever worn unlined sneakers? Chaffing to the max.
Wolverine is a work boot. Thursday is a "match your outfit" boot. Why is there even a comparison? I don't know any carpenters, painters, plumbers, roofers....... who wear Thursday.
the common thread is that both boots are popular entry level heritage boots. if i worked in the trades, i wouldn't buy thrursdays either. no argument there.
Hi Stridewise (Nick) How would you compare these Captains to the Vanguards that you reviewed? Would you rate them on-par, or are they not aging as well? Curious since they are chromeexcel too I believe...
This was really helpful. As a student I appreciate the value of quality for price that the Thursday offers. Plus I think the more modern and dressy silhouette makes it a lot better-looking too.
Jons Mustache I’m also a student and 21 years old. My names John too :D and I feel the same way and it’s crazy to be looking into these boots at the same time for the same reasons 🤔 Anyhow if you buy them, I’m buying them. Let me know what the move is lol
Yeah I was a student or an intern for most of my 20s so I'm obsessed with value and versatility, I always weigh them heavily and it's why Thursday is my favorite haha
@@Thursdayboots just wanted to update y'all and let you know that I got my first pair of brown Captain boots on the 2-6-19 and I have been wearing them everyday since. I absolutely LOVE these boots! I looking forwarded to seeing them get the beautiful aged look. Thanks again for this video Stridewise and Thursday boots for making an awesome boot.
Yeah I've softened on leather soles, I don't like the way they look but they are nice and soft and flexible and they sound great. Depends on my mood haha
There's only Two brands you need to know, Thursday Boot Company and Nicks Handmade Boots, pick out your style and your needs and that's it. If you need to have your feet more snug that put in a leather over cork insole. Any of these boots from these two companies will mold to your feet and last a lifetime, Don't forget to give them a cleaning and spit shine or just a brush with some Kiwi or Saphir. You can have them looking like new for as long as you own them.
these are both great boots if your going for the "work boot look", but I wound think twice about actually doing any work in these boots. And my vote is for the wolverine boot, this is a classic boot that will never go out of style. Its reputation has been set in stone.
True.... but I can see the solid design of the Captain being fashionable till the end of time too, both understated which IMO makes them timeless investment.
Enjoying your channel so far I’ve been thinking about getting a pair of wolverine 1000 mile. Even though more expensive and Thursday boot company is prob the best choice just starting to own a style of boot like this and being a slot cheaper I keep going back to wolverine I like that style and look better and the story behind wolverine is grabbing me I’ve owned many wolverine work boots before but wanna get a more causal boot from them. Do you think you could possibly do a review on the Wolverine 1000 mile Rough Out boot?
I don't think it'd make sense to do another review of the 1000 Mile in a different leather, but good luck with the purchase! I think even the regular Chromexcel ones are fine IF you can buy them in store and do your own leather inspection.
Don't know if it's the awesome accent or the awesome boots, maybe both, that are making me love this vid. Made my choice easier , clearly the Thursday boots for me.
A big part of your calculation for the "better" boot was based on the price. The Wolverine 1k is now listed on Amazon for $200. If the prices were equal would you still prefer the Captian?
I don't quite get the hype around the concept of boots that may last 1000 miles. It's not that impressíve, is it? I have a pair of old timberland premium that have gone at LEAST 3000 miles. The lining is failing but the outside of that 180 dollar boot is fine. A pair of decent hiking boots takes 100 miles just to break in! Has anyone experienced boots above 100 dollars NOT lasting 1000 miles?
I’ve had both and you would never be able to wear the Thursday’s for work. The Thursday is for people that want to wear a boot but just for the sole looks.
Thursday Capt Boot is a winner boot. Thanks for the great review. Super job juxtaposing these two and zeroing in on the pros and cons. Keep up the good work! Enjoy your reviews.
The heel on Thursday's boots is the biggest turn off for me (WAY too thick; like wearing heels for men) because it's horrible for posture and overall walking mechanics. It's literally bad for your health.
In my journalism job I've written articles about how bad high heels are for your health, it's my least favorite thing about boots. But every one has high heels so idk what to do! I'm wearing Danner's Jack II boots right now and they're the flattest boots I've ever tried. Low profile boots, there's an idea for a video...
In my opinion it seems like Thursday paid you for this review. I don’t remember hearing if there was a disclosure or not. Give the edge to Thursday. Get people to click on your link for Thursday and win win.
i remember hearing at some point or another that he was sponsored by them and yeah, i've seen it over and over again by this channel, and even on others. some people talking to him said he was just talking for the sake of sending them to sponsored posts.
There are quite a few negative reviews of Thursday boots because the sole is said to wear out and flatten over time. I'd be keen to know how they hold up over a 2yr time period.
I have 2 pair, the Diplomat and the Scout. I don't remember exactly how long I've had them, but it's been at least a year for the Diplomat and at least 2 years for the Scout. Both boots have held up pretty well in my opinion and I wear then pretty frequently. The Scouts went with me on a work trip to Portland, ME and a vacation to NYC this past spring. I haven't done a ton of traveling with the Diplomats, but I've done some and they've also held up very well. Of course these are my opinions and they're only going to carry as much weight as you would like them to. I would definitely not say they are "cheap" boots. You don't have to pay $400 dollars just to get a nice boot.
@antant06... When we started we chose an EVA-based insole because it was comfortable right out of the box, and we think we made a decent decision at the time. We still think a medium to high-density EVA insole is preferable to full leather insoles...but this is very subjective, and a personal opinion. With that being said, it's rebound effect as well as poron and it breaks down faster than leather and poron. On our men's boots and Goodyear welt dress shoes last spring we implemented preformed shock-absorbing antimicrobial 17 shore A poron insoles with an embedded custom-made shank for each last. We now use Poron Insoles on most of our styles and tested everything and I don't think there is a better insole on the market. It's longer-lasting than leather. It has a better rebound effect than EVA and leather, and it's antimicrobial (leather can get mold and start to smell pretty fast as some of you may know). Hope this helps clarify. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us at founders@thursdayboots.com!
Review Wolverine 1000 mile Evans.(Bought new.) After i have cut open that piece of shit boot..... 1. Boots stink like they have been worn for 5 years.Really stink like stinky feet.Without exaggeration. 2.Boots in the middle sole squeek. 3.Boots have thin leather insole,under little foam AND real insole under is 3-4mm thick dark color compressed PAPER ! Under is steal shank,than white compressed PAPER and little cork. NOT LEATHER.........PAPER is inside. 4.Left boot tongue is higher than right one and is sawn wrong,not vertical. I am not shure,maybe i have fake boots. But they are piece of stinky,squeeky shit and i have torn them appart and true them in garbage.
Great vid, as usual. Have you reviewed Thursday's Vanguard? It might be an option for those wanting to buy made in USA boots, but price is higher because of it.
I haven't reviewed them no, I want to review another pair of Thursdays but I was thinking it might be more interesting to try their new Rugged and Resilient line, it seems to have more differences with the Captain I have. Got a trip to the Middle East coming up and I'd love to put them through the paces there!
Stridewise just to give you a heads up on Thursday's newer boots sizing, they fit a half size smaller now so I recommending going up half a size from your normal Thursday boots, for example if your a 11 in the brown captain go up to a size 11.5 in there newer rugged boots
Stridewise yeah hahaha hopefully because I have the captain in brown in a size 10.5 then I ordered there dark olive suede captain in a 10.5 also, they fit really tight so I emailed Thursday's and they said that they added more cushioning on there new boots and told me to go a half size up and i did and now they fit me the same as my brown captains even though there's a half size difference
Can get the wolverines for $200-$250 often on Amazon. I have a pair and I love them. However the Thursday's are worth a long look when I decide to buy another pair of boots.
As a long time owner of 1000 mile boots. The quality it substantially better than the Thursday. My captain boot sole is nice and soft which I like, But this is the least waterproof boot I have ever worn! And I’m old! Walk through a mud puddle and water will literally squirt out of the welt. Last complaint, the toe is so narrow it is really not appropriate for anything other than dress boot and that is the deal breaker for me, Consider this a 6” tall dress shoe. These are going to goodwill. I also have diplomat. These are much better in my opinion. Except my left shank started clicking after a week. I’m a little irritated that I spent 400 on boots that really should not be compared a Wolverine or redwing. If you factor in the cost of my next boot. Could have just bought a white or viberg. You got me!
I actually just bought the 1000 mile for $215 on Amazon (maybe sales are hurting lately) so I’m just curious if you’d still go with Thursday even if the price was (basically) the same.
Mmm. I think the design of Wolverine coupled with the bad grip still matters to me. Maybe the Wolverine Evans would be a better match up, the Evans has more grip, but Thursday just looks more modern.
Stridewise interesting. I personally like a capless toe and a subtle sole on my boots, but I do indeed like the more modern look of this Thursday boot. I’ll have to check out some of their other stuff to see if I can get the best of both worlds. Thank you for the response/feedback! Great stuff
Don’t have the wolverine yet, but as for the Thursday, I think it’s overrated, or at least the quality control could have been better. The leather looks cheap, but so far it’s been holding up and comfortable. I would not buy Thursday again for the price they are asking for.
One thing that I think you overlook is that the Wolverine boots are just more handsome than the Thursday boots. I realize this is subjective but I have now compared two other boots (the Rhodes Dean and the Thursday Vanguard) to the Wolverine boot and the latter is just a better looking boot. The Vanguard is supposed to be made from Horween leather as is the Wolverine but it's not the same Horween leather. The Wolverine has more depth of color and a luster that the Thursday does not possess. And the overall shape just makes it look better on my foot. Just that minor curve at the top of the shank sets it apart. The Wolverines slightly more rounded toe box just fits my foot better than the other two and also gives it a nicer profile. I haven't worn them outside yet and the leather sole does give me pause but it is a great looking boot.
These are all great, thoughtful points, Ray! Yeah, it's all subjective, Wolverine has a rounder toe, Thursday and Rhodes don't. Some prefer it some don't, but especially if rounder toes fit your toes better, welp, sounds like you don't have any doubt. Hope you like your Wolverines!
Hipsters with skinny jeans and trendy hair cuts telling men who have worked carriers wearing real boots like White's and Nicks what boots to buy. Im still laughing my ass off.
The way the leather ages on the Wolverines can be seen by many people as a plus. A lot ( not everyone of course ) people want that beat up look to their boots. I've watched some annual videos by Magoo who has both the black and brown Wolverines. He observes that the black pair for some reason age much less than the brown. I thought Thursday put in a non metallic, airport friendly shank not a steel one in? Great video as always.
That's a really good point and something I should have mentioned in the video, some people like beat up boots and also Wolverine has a nice nostalgic angle to it as well. I thought the 1000 Mile might have had some kind of shank but I called them up to ask and they said no. Hopefully it doesn't turn out this was inaccurate!! It was stressful putting that in the video haha Edit: Oh sorry you were talking about Thursday's shank. Some of them have a fiberglass one, like the new ""rugged and resilient" line but my understanding is the classic Captain has a steel one.
nice review , I have Thursday captain naturals and Chippewas which are closer to a red wing . The Thursdays are more water resistant but they are not even close to the Chippewas for durability in hard work conditions. I do think the Captains will last perhaps up to 10l years given normal wear, not construction work. The Chippewas formed better to my foot thus more comfortable than the Captains but I added a thin additional insole to the Captains which helped a great deal. Keep up the good work ! Cheers.
you can't compare these boots, it's like saying redwings vs captain . come on not the same. captain is a good low cost boot. A Prius can drive fast , it can go to 80 or more but not the same has a Corvette or Lamborghini
Our heel height is around 1" which is the average heel height for men shoes but we completely understand if that doesn't work out for you. Glad to share any suggestions you have with our team. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us at founders@thursdayboots.com if you have any other questions!
I have to say, I am loving my Thursday Captain boots. I am wearing them too much now, my other shoes are getting jealous! The color(I ordered brown) goes with so many things. I mentioned buying Thursday boots the last time I was in Nordstrom's looking at some other brand boots and the salesman looked down his nose at me. I was not amused and let the guy know my Thursday boots are just as, if not better, than any offerings they had there! Anyhow, loved the video. Keep up the great work.
As a owner of a pair of red wings, i would say their quality is crap. If you don’t bother with the so called authenticity or whatsoever, just go for Thursday or any other premium boot makers. You will get much better value from them
As a shoe junkie you are 😀 have you ever tried Limmers? Not comparable with ever Day shoes. But the craftmenship and for hiking. I have seen your viberg rewievs and btw thanks! Viberg also makes "hiking" boots. Do you have a comment to Viberg hiking? Fashion or professioal? Look up Peter limmer and please give me your opinion, with quality in mind 😊 thanks!
Stridewise thanks! I Just got the midweights myself, 3,0 mm leather compare to 3,2 on the standards. First impession is that these will have a looong break in period. Like yourself, I like quality craftmenship and looking forward to putting my feet through some pain :)
I have the Thursday captains in Brandy. Absolutely amazing how quick they broke in and they just feel like a part of your foot! Great look dressed up or down! Chinos or Levi’s your good to go! Thursday boot took the handcrafted market by storm and I’m a very proud owner of red wing, Thorogood 1892’s, Chippewa’s service boots and Thursday’s are best out of the box good to go boot for the daily life. They may not be a work boot but for the casual boot wearer they will be the best option and for only $199 you can’t beat them. Their moc toe will be my next boot for sure!
The best 6 inch unlined boots I ever had were wolverines. They were buckskin tan. I was a meter reader. I walked usually five hours a day. I never wore a set of those soles out.. they were not Vibram cleated soles, they were a different black rubber one piece ,it was very cushiony. they were not those stupid soles that were some type of a Durashock were the center of the soul and the center of the heel had some type of a shock absorber build in that was not full width.. those stupid soles cause my ankle to kick it out many times. A few times I laid on the ground for a few minutes making sure my ankle wasn’t broke.. I think those stupid soles came on Sears/diehard shoes but I am not totally sure it’s been a while. The thing that wore out on my 6 inch unlined wolverine boots was, the dew on the grass.. your feet don’t get wet in the winter .. it’s spring through fall that your feet are soaked every morning by 9 AM walking through the grass/ dew. that’s what makes the leather finally give up.. I also learned there is no such thing as waterproof. Not Gore-Tex, not silicone spray, not mink oil , not bees wax Applied with a hairdryer to melt it in. I guarantee you there is nothing that is waterproof. rubber is waterproof, but your feet will be just as soaked from perspiration that is not permitted to escape., and there is not a pair of boots made of rubber that I have ever seen that are comfortable enough to wear for five hours a day walking..Especially those duck boots.. you need a solid sole 6 inch shoe if you’re gonna be walking all day. If you were something very flexible, that beats the hell out of your feet making them twist in all directions and bend even over pebbles..if you buy a pair of boots that claims they are waterproof, save your receipt and save the tags that are hanging from the shoelaces for when you take them back. I have taken many many boots back that were claimed to be waterproof.. Don’t buy your “waterproof “boots from a mom and pop shoe store. Buy them from a large chain that has employees that won’t give you a fight when you try to get your money back. If you go to a mom and pop to return your boots, they will often tell you to return the boots to the factory yourself. That happened to me twice.. Wolverine quit making those boots that lasted forever. I mean I would get two years out of a pair before the weather finally started separating from the soil from the wet/dry/wet/dry cycle which dried out the leather even though I would oil them to moisturize the leather. All they did was Delay the inevitable.. I can’t think of another occupation it is harder on shoes than meter reader..
Check out THE TOP _10_ BOOTS you can buy (in under 10 minutes!)! ua-cam.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/v-deo.html
I’m going with Thursday captain boot. ThAnks for the review
You got it, my man!
I'm very happy with mine, after a few months. It felt very awkward at first because I never wore such a high heel. But I quickly adjusted to that and they are the most comfortable pair of shoes I have owned now. But it's also the most expensive pair I ever bought. I'm very curious to try something else in the same price range to compare but haven't found anything yet that isn't much more expensive.
I love redwing and througood boots. That said; 2 years ago i bought a pair of Thursday captain's (black). They are than iron rangers. Alot cheaper. They're my dayoff boots during summer months. Leather soles are not my thing. Wear too quickly. Look awful in 2 months. Thursday offers a good boot at decent price. You take care of them and you'll get 8 years out of them. Just started watching this channel. I like what i see so far.
Did the black lose that shine after awhile? I don't like how shiny they look. I like the more faded/worn look.
You can get a matte/suede looking finish anyway
Just found your channel, and your boot videos convinced me to pull the trigger on the Thursday's captain boot in terracotta.
That's a great color! I think about it a lot in my 'what if' boot fantasies. Because I'm the kind of guy who has those haha
Welcome to the Team!
@@Thursdayboots Bought one pair and returned. too low instep for me. Not traditional construction style which means not very breathable. Moved on and found Gokey and Rancourt. Nobody can beat them. sorry.
@@waynewang8904 We know that everyone's feet are a little different. What works best for you may not be the best for someone else. We're always coming out with new designs so we'd love for you to check back in. Thanks for giving us a try!
I just ordered a pair of Captains in black thanks in large part to your reviews. I was strongly considering the Taft Dragon boot, but I'm a professor and on my feet a lot for teaching - I need something comfortable that I can move around in, and the Thursdays seem to have comfort in mind far more than the Tafts. They arrive on Monday!
Get excited! The Taft Dragon is a great boot as well but less versatile and more expensive, I think you made a good choice. Hope you like 'em, Professor Bakos!
Oh man, these things are so freakin' great. Fit right the first time, comfortable right out of the box. I have to adjust how I walk a bit since this is my first pair of boots, but I really like them.
Welcome to the Team!!!
A little shoe polish can help you overcome the “negative aging” of the leather, and preserving the leather (including the part of the outsole that does not come into contact with the pavement). Mixing colours of polish can give you very nice tones and helps the leather age well.
never use wax
This type of leather shouldn’t be polished like traditional dyed leather. A greasy cream conditioner would help hide the scratches and keep the leather looking great. Saphir makes a great lotion just for this type of leather.
While I can’t comment on the Wolverine boots as I’ve never owned a pair, I can say that the Thursday Captain boots break in fast, look and feel great, and are the most comfortable & versatile boots I’ve ever owned. I own 2 pairs of Captains: one in Natural (in actual Horween Chromexcel, the only color though) and Dark Olive Suede. The only boots more comfortable for me are my Thursday’s Cavalier Chelsea boots in “Desert” color. And now they’re doing killer sneakers! Great Co.!
I got a pair of 1000 mile boots and I love them: Went straight to the cobbler after purchase and added a thin rubber sole to the foot pad and heel. It will last for a couple of years and is easy and cheap to resole again and again. Treat them with som Bick 4 and Saphir Renovateur and they look as good as new all the time!
THe 1000 mile boots just killed my feet I tried to wear them for 20 days but they continued to hurt my feet. Took them back! Very disappointed as I researched them extensively before purchase.
@@jackcarr1267 Did you try inserts?
I happen to have both as well (though I got the President instead of the Captain), and I'm a big fan of both of them. In my case, both of them actually got worn just about evenly, I had more problems with the Thursday's sole actually, but in close to 4 years of use each, aside from having both re-sold (and I got leather for the Thursday at that point as well, just preferring the look), both have performed very well for me alternating them so I'm wearing each every other day. If I had to pick between the two, I'd probably go with the Wolverine even with the price difference, but it's still pretty close and both are workhorses to me. From my experience, with proper care both will be workhorses for you.
I own four Thursdays. Three Captains in different colors and a President. I also own a pair of thousand mile boots. My thousand miles are taking forever to break in. I'm hoping I got the right size. I sent back 9.5s and got 9s, but they are leaving blisters just before my big toe. I never had a difficult break in period for the Thursdays.
Well done comparison & video & I think you were spot on & right concerning your conclusion that the thursday boot was over all better although they're both good boots. Thank you Sir.
I know absolutely nothing about nice boots. I live in Florida so I don’t have much use of them but my style is changing as I’m in my early 30’s. I just bought a pair of captains boots. Thanks for the great info
Even compared to higher quality boots, I prefer Thursday's silhouettes. They get it just right imo. Meanwhile, a lot of more pricey boots have bold arches or sharp, wide angles like they're made on a rhombus-shaped last.
The captain dressed so well compared to the other one
Creased*
Oh I thought you meant dressed as in dressed up, which is also true haha
@@Stridewise same lol, I want the wolverine but the value doesn't seem to be there
Call me crazy, but when I wear a pair of boots, I don't particularly want a leather sole. There are almost zero advantages to having a leather sole, while the disadvantages are numerous: (1) not that durable, (2) terrible traction, (3) don't look that great when scuffed up, and (4) hate water and snow.
I've been trying to be really open minded about the potential benefits of a leather sole but they're just so ugly and the grip is so bad. Maybe if you only ever wear them inside I can see the groundfeel being a worthwhile aspect, but the Wolverines tout themselves as work boots.
Amen to that......
Nick Ridgeway they have leather soles because they are a homage to the original wolverine boot designed 135 years ago. They are also available in rubber soles as well. Did I mention that I was a fan ✌🏽✌🏽
Stridewise YEAH - All those crazy guys of the past who ran around with those leather soled shoes on. It’s a freakin’ miracle that they made it through the Great Depression, won WWII, defended democracy, and placed a man on the moon, etc. What the hell were they thinking? We’ll never know how many countless fools stepped on an icy sidewalk and kept sliding into traffic to meet their end - oh, the humanity! We with our UA-cam channels, skinny jeans and plastic / rubber shoes know better. (Yeah, I’m a fan of leather soles)
@@DHill-qn8us How do you know they used leather soles and not rubber? And since all those victories were all so glorious, we should continue to use the guns, the cars, the clothes etc etc from those eras and say a big no to the modern equipment we have. We can go back to the steam engine, planes with propellers, he'll we might as well go back to horseback riding for transport.....
I love my caption boots but now it's time for the 1000 mil boots .
I bought the Thursday boots and found the materials to be thin. The toe box collapsed and they are very harsh on impact. They look hip, but that's it. They are going to the thrift sore.
This was my impression as well. These reviewers must get a kickback or something. The Thursday boots look like Walmart quality leather. When I see people recommending them over Red Wing or similar it's just silly
I just wish there was a showroom in LA that I can go and try them on before I buy them. :-/
Saving up for a pair of White's. I do own Thursday Diplomat boot and the Captain Dark Olive .
Good video. I purchased the Wolverine boot, I got them @ 1/2 size smaller than sneakers, installed a 3/4 length orthotic from AETREX and I must say that they are like wearing slippers. I also installed a VIBRAM Sole protector to remove any slippage. Just purchased Thursday president boot. Will see how they feel in comparison.
I started my quest for a pair of boots with Thursday Captains. The first pair were flawed and returned. The replacement pair were also flawed. I requested a refund after customer service suggested that I take the brand new boots to a cobbler for repairs. I just received my Wolverine 1000 Mile Cap Toe Classic boots with Vibram half soles. The quality of leather, and overall quality of the Wolverine boots, is superior to Thursday Boots in my opinion. I explained my negative experience and rating in a Thursday Boots survey. It was never posted. The last negative review I can find on Thursday’s website was from 2019. My negative review was given earlier this year.
Any opinion on the 1000 mile 1940 boot? I have not seen them in person but the moc toe look like a goo cross between a dress and work boot.
Absolutely can't agree with you. The Wolverine 1000 Mile boot is superior. Yeah, the Thursday is a good value boot, but it's not even close in quality of materials. The issue with the sole offering less grip is easily remedied by having a Topy sole installed (or opting for the 1000 Mile Evans shoe, which has a Vibram sole piece). Don't get me wrong, the Thursday is a nice boot, but it doesn't hold up to the Wolverine. As for the ageing of the leather, dude, condition the poor thing once in a while yeah? It's basically an oiled leather, oiled leathers need a *little* care to get the best out of them.
Hey I respect your opinion Kim! And your lats, dayum. The Evans does seem like a good compromise, though I'm not sold on Wolverine's leather selection, but that's just me.
@@Stridewise I can understand that. While I do love the Wolverine, I do wish they went with a leather that wasn't quite so... well, fussy. I'd love a pair of Red Wing boots, but they're just too damned narrow! Lats? Ha! Cheers dude :)
Wolverines vary. You should check out the Wolverine Wesley wing tip. It would be a better comparison to the Thursday Captains. I have both. The Wolverine Wesley seems more scratch resistant than the Captain. The captains are a little more comfortable though.
Interesting! I've been meaning to try another pair of Wolverines. Thanks for the tip Peter.
I have both boots and completely agree with everything said in this review. I have multiple pairs of Thursdays because they are so comfortable and versatile. One is a pair of brown suede Vanguards that have a hydrophobic coating that's brilliant. Btw I'm looking forward to your review of White's MP Service Boot. I'm considering getting a pair.
Yesss, it's so good to hear someone say I nailed the review! I never really know if I'm saying the right thing haha. I don't know much about the Vanguards hey, let me know how they wear in for you. Whites is filmed but I want to do another versus video next week so probably it won't go up for two weeks. But the hype is real for that one! I don't want to spoil it but the fit is maybe the best I've ever had.
Your review was spot on! I've had the suede Vanguards for over a year. The ones I have are on the old last that were a little wider and heavier than their current Vanguards. All of my Thursday boots have had minimum break in time. The suede Vanguards felt great from get go and have gotten even more comfortable over time.
Awesome :) We truly appreciate all your support!!!!
Price wise, yes Wolverine is twice as much, win for the other, but really you want to compare the 1000 Mile Evan to this boot for the most fair comparison. Evan model has the Vibram half sole and the grip / traction you’re looking for. Personally I prefer the bigger toe area, it’s sleek enough without being too slim or too big. Most comfortable boots I’ve ever put on (Wolverines).
Interesting I have the Evans model as well and compared to my Thursdays are way less comfortable. The Rugged Collection from Thursday have a shank which helps with support and I can wear all day. My 1000 Mile Boots get uncomfortable very easily. Funny, just different experiences
I mean I wouldn't call this comparison unfair, the 1000 Mile is the most popular boot of theirs, after all. But you're right that it's a tougher fight between the Captain and the Evan, maybe I should have mentioned in the video that they do offer a boot with a Vibram sole if that's the deciding factor for you. I was just comparing my experience with these two boots. Great comment!
I was lucky enough to get a pair of 1000 miles in store with huge discount for just 150. And I am agree with everything that you mentioned. The main disadvantage is that they are really slippery, but the feeling of great leather and even smell of it is just exceptional. I’m also receiving a lot of compliments about them
I’m young, in my teens, but really love leatherwork and boots and I’m looking forward to getting a pair of rugged captain boots when I’m a bit older cause god knows I can’t pull it of now. Thanks for the review.
What!? Do it now, you’ll be way ahead of all the other dudes chicks did a man in boots! No shit kid.
@@NoNameNo.5 What this gentleman said! I'm a chick lol and I have a pair of the captain boots. I would just get yours a half-size or size up and wear thick socks in case your shoe size changes. Rock them and don't worry about the other dudes who are wearing dirty vans with holes in them. No offense;)
I ordered the captain boots I'm in shock 😅 I usually buy boots from places like asos and American eagle. Thursday boots are a million times better I've been playing myself for years 😂
Hahah! Glad I could have helped. Yeah I like how they have this approach of like, we don't have to use Horween and Dainite etc. to give a boot that's as good quality
Hahaha! Welcome to the Team!
Welcome to the light, friend
Would rather have the allen edmonds higging seconds than a new Thursday boots 😂
boots from american eagle? lmao
So I bought the Thursday's. So much chunkier than I expected. It's no where near a dress boot. I like it but don't buy it expecting a sleek boot like this guy says.
It looks like what it looks like in the video, doesn't it? Sleeker than a work boot, not as sleek as a dress boot 🤷
Wolverine Chippewa Thursday boots all meant to copy Red Wing boots. Have been wearing Red Wings since 19677. While I have also worn custom for each foot, (hand-crafted for each foot) Wesco, Scapoose, OR, logger style boots, I have preferred Red Wing Chukka Boots for decades. Now in my old age,(71), I need more ankle and arch support. So yesterdsy, I orderd, (from a Red Wing store), a pair of burgandy Heritage Iron Ranger boots. Buy the most affordable best and Never look back!
Thursday boots are the most affordable, DURABLE, and stylish boots I have ever worn. I've owned my Thursday boots for 3 years, and they are broken in, still in tact, and they are very comfortable.
Glad it's not just me! i'd feel pretty dumb if all the comments were from people who hated their pair, but they really have a solid rep.
So great to hear! :)
Wolverine by a 1000 miles (pardon the pun!)... also the finest shoes in the world (Bespoke John Lobbs) are 270 degree welt.. there's a reason they don't do 360.... it's more expensive to attach the heal with nails and glue.
The distance between stitches of the welt of the 1k's seems way to much for the price point of the wolverine. Kinda similar to a doc martin in stitches per inch.
The TBCs would win if they cost the same - at half the price there's absolutely no discussion.
Then you’re accepting an inferior product without fully exploring the reasons. Good luck with your trendy boots.
^he ain’t lying! This dudes channel shills for Thursday constantly. Get a thorogoods
The thursday is the boot I'd expect everyone wearing but the wolverine is what I'd see more in working environments for rougher trades
But the thursday boot is the best boot for the majority of people style wise, bring classy fahsion back
I've owned both. Wolverine BLVD's (not 1000 miles) are more comfortable and better quality. I had to return 3 pairs of Thursday Boots due to defects. I have 2 pairs of the Wolverine BLVD capped toes. Both companies offer excellent customer service.
If the price was the same it'd be a tougher choice. I think there's something a little more nostalgic about the 1000 mile boot. I do think the Thursday is much nicer looking. Plus it's cheaper. I wish they made something with a more aggressive sole. Like the commando or Vibram 100.
Oh for sure Robert, the nostalgia is an undeniable factor with the 1000 Mile. Damn, I should have mentioned that in the video!
R. M Well fashion is subjective so the good news is you're both right!
I think they're just different. I like both designs. I just like the slimmer toe box on the Thursday a bit better. Plus I like toe caps. I have them on my Franks work boots and besides looking good it makes the boot tougher.
I'm not a big fan of smooth sole boots. I usually have my cobbler put Vibram lug half soles on the front to make them more useful as a boot. I just wear dress shoes if I want to dress up.
Try checking out the Vanguard made by Thursday Boots, much beefier sole to them too if you click on the different colours
Brought to you by: Thursday Boot Co.
After more than a month of break-in time my Wolverine still felt very uncomfortable. The thick leather was really unforgiving. On the other hand I could wear the Thursday Captain without any break-in at all. They were comfortable from the moment I put the boots on. Not only they are more stylish looking but the quality of the workmanship is quite surprising. I own now 3 pair of Thursday Boots.
I just got the 1000 mile boot and man is it an awesome boot. Very happy
Today the Wolverine is $250 on Amazon and the Captain is $199.
The first thing I noticed at the beginning of the video was the creases in the Wolverine. Even without any experience in fine boots (I get mine on sale from Big 5) the difference was clear and obvious.
Thursday Heritage Wingtips are $220. I'm tempted.
The extra stitching at the crease helps prevent creasing elsewhere. A boot is going to crease. You either tell it where to crease or it will decide on its own. The rubber sole probably helps maintain the intregrity of the upper. Also, lined boots tend to wear better. Ever worn unlined sneakers? Chaffing to the max.
Wolverine is a work boot. Thursday is a "match your outfit" boot. Why is there even a comparison? I don't know any carpenters, painters, plumbers, roofers....... who wear Thursday.
the common thread is that both boots are popular entry level heritage boots. if i worked in the trades, i wouldn't buy thrursdays either. no argument there.
super informative. thanks!
Love the quality of your videos man!
Thanks! Sorry the lighting was a bit yellow in this one, gotta work on getting new lights :)
Hi Stridewise (Nick) How would you compare these Captains to the Vanguards that you reviewed? Would you rate them on-par, or are they not aging as well? Curious since they are chromeexcel too I believe...
This was really helpful. As a student I appreciate the value of quality for price that the Thursday offers. Plus I think the more modern and dressy silhouette makes it a lot better-looking too.
Jons Mustache I’m also a student and 21 years old. My names John too :D and I feel the same way and it’s crazy to be looking into these boots at the same time for the same reasons 🤔 Anyhow if you buy them, I’m buying them. Let me know what the move is lol
Yeah I was a student or an intern for most of my 20s so I'm obsessed with value and versatility, I always weigh them heavily and it's why Thursday is my favorite haha
Thank you for this video. I have been trying to decide between the two boots and now I'm pretty sure I will be going with Thursday.
So glad you enjoyed it Mike!
WOO HOO :) Looking forward to having you apart of the Team!
@@Thursdayboots just wanted to update y'all and let you know that I got my first pair of brown Captain boots on the 2-6-19 and I have been wearing them everyday since. I absolutely LOVE these boots! I looking forwarded to seeing them get the beautiful aged look. Thanks again for this video Stridewise and Thursday boots for making an awesome boot.
@@Mike-Ybarra So glad to hear :) !!!!!
I can’t say anything about the grip, but imma say that I actually really like the leather sole aesthetic, more than rubber
Yeah I've softened on leather soles, I don't like the way they look but they are nice and soft and flexible and they sound great. Depends on my mood haha
Thursday hybrid is a perfect name. To me it looks like there goal was to knock off the look of the Red Wing iron ranger and the Wolverine 1000 mile.
Haha yeah but neither of those boots are this slim/dressy. Seems Red Wing's new Williston/Sheldon boots are directly aimed at ripping off Thursday tbh
Stridewise yeah noticed that too
thats why they make the 1000 mile Evans, pretty much the same just has a better traction outsole
Where did you come up with no shank?Trenton and Heath have re soled a couple pairs on their channel and they had shanks.
I called them and they told me they didn't!
There's only Two brands you need to know, Thursday Boot Company and Nicks Handmade Boots, pick out your style and your needs and that's it. If you need to have your feet more snug that put in a leather over cork insole. Any of these boots from these two companies will mold to your feet and last a lifetime, Don't forget to give them a cleaning and spit shine or just a brush with some Kiwi or Saphir. You can have them looking like new for as long as you own them.
Great comment, Paul
these are both great boots if your going for the "work boot look", but I wound think twice about actually doing any work in these boots. And my vote is for the wolverine boot, this is a classic boot that will never go out of style. Its reputation has been set in stone.
Sure, one is traditional and one's modern! Depends on what you're after.
True.... but I can see the solid design of the Captain being fashionable till the end of time too, both understated which IMO makes them timeless investment.
Enjoying your channel so far I’ve been thinking about getting a pair of wolverine 1000 mile. Even though more expensive and Thursday boot company is prob the best choice just starting to own a style of boot like this and being a slot cheaper I keep going back to wolverine I like that style and look better and the story behind wolverine is grabbing me I’ve owned many wolverine work boots before but wanna get a more causal boot from them. Do you think you could possibly do a review on the Wolverine 1000 mile Rough Out boot?
I don't think it'd make sense to do another review of the 1000 Mile in a different leather, but good luck with the purchase! I think even the regular Chromexcel ones are fine IF you can buy them in store and do your own leather inspection.
Don't know if it's the awesome accent or the awesome boots, maybe both, that are making me love this vid. Made my choice easier , clearly the Thursday boots for me.
Haha thanks! That's my mangled Australian-living-in-America accent :) Glad you liked the video, Martin!
@@Stridewise keep up the good work!
woohoo! :)
@@Thursdayboots best boots ever!
So, check Nordstrom rack for sales in the wolverine...I picked mine up for 169.00
Nice work bro!
A big part of your calculation for the "better" boot was based on the price. The Wolverine 1k is now listed on Amazon for $200. If the prices were equal would you still prefer the Captian?
Tough one! I still prefer the versatility and comfort of Thursday, though the Wolverine benefits from a slightly lower heel
I don't quite get the hype around the concept of boots that may last 1000 miles. It's not that impressíve, is it? I have a pair of old timberland premium that have gone at LEAST 3000 miles. The lining is failing but the outside of that 180 dollar boot is fine. A pair of decent hiking boots takes 100 miles just to break in! Has anyone experienced boots above 100 dollars NOT lasting 1000 miles?
I have my captain for about 4 years still is great.
Great review. I'm ordering a pair of Captain!
Hope you like them, Jason!
Looking forward to having you a part of the Team :)
I’ve had both and you would never be able to wear the Thursday’s for work. The Thursday is for people that want to wear a boot but just for the sole looks.
Thursday Capt Boot is a winner boot. Thanks for the great review. Super job juxtaposing these two and zeroing in on the pros and cons. Keep up the good work! Enjoy your reviews.
Thursday is a dress shoe, doesn't look like a boot to me. It's way to flat in toebox. 1000 mile made in USA looks like a beautiful well made boot.
Just got a Thursday vanguard boot today
Nice! They feel quite different to the Captain
The heel on Thursday's boots is the biggest turn off for me (WAY too thick; like wearing heels for men) because it's horrible for posture and overall walking mechanics. It's literally bad for your health.
In my journalism job I've written articles about how bad high heels are for your health, it's my least favorite thing about boots. But every one has high heels so idk what to do! I'm wearing Danner's Jack II boots right now and they're the flattest boots I've ever tried. Low profile boots, there's an idea for a video...
I would enjoy this video. thumbs up@@Stridewise
Agree
In my opinion it seems like Thursday paid you for this review. I don’t remember hearing if there was a disclosure or not. Give the edge to Thursday. Get people to click on your link for Thursday and win win.
i remember hearing at some point or another that he was sponsored by them and yeah, i've seen it over and over again by this channel, and even on others. some people talking to him said he was just talking for the sake of sending them to sponsored posts.
MY GRANDSON OWNS TRUMAN BOOTS COLORADO WHATS YOU TAKE/OPINION ON THEM
Here ya go ua-cam.com/video/PMjTRl1EVzM/v-deo.html
Nick can you please review the Allen Edmonds Normandy Boot?
So many people have asked me to do that I think I will, haha. I was going to do the Sullivan Street first, maybe I'll do both!
There are quite a few negative reviews of Thursday boots because the sole is said to wear out and flatten over time. I'd be keen to know how they hold up over a 2yr time period.
I have 2 pair, the Diplomat and the Scout. I don't remember exactly how long I've had them, but it's been at least a year for the Diplomat and at least 2 years for the Scout. Both boots have held up pretty well in my opinion and I wear then pretty frequently. The Scouts went with me on a work trip to Portland, ME and a vacation to NYC this past spring. I haven't done a ton of traveling with the Diplomats, but I've done some and they've also held up very well. Of course these are my opinions and they're only going to carry as much weight as you would like them to. I would definitely not say they are "cheap" boots. You don't have to pay $400 dollars just to get a nice boot.
@antant06... When we started we chose an EVA-based insole because it was comfortable right out of the box, and we think we made a decent decision at the time. We still think a medium to high-density EVA insole is preferable to full leather insoles...but this is very subjective, and a personal opinion. With that being said, it's rebound effect as well as poron and it breaks down faster than leather and poron. On our men's boots and Goodyear welt dress shoes last spring we implemented preformed shock-absorbing antimicrobial 17 shore A poron insoles with an embedded custom-made shank for each last. We now use Poron Insoles on most of our styles and tested everything and I don't think there is a better insole on the market. It's longer-lasting than leather. It has a better rebound effect than EVA and leather, and it's antimicrobial (leather can get mold and start to smell pretty fast as some of you may know). Hope this helps clarify. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us at founders@thursdayboots.com!
@@ThursdaybootsThanks!
Review Wolverine 1000 mile Evans.(Bought new.)
After i have cut open that piece of shit boot.....
1. Boots stink like they have been worn for 5 years.Really stink like stinky feet.Without exaggeration.
2.Boots in the middle sole squeek.
3.Boots have thin leather insole,under little foam AND real insole under is 3-4mm thick dark color compressed PAPER !
Under is steal shank,than white compressed PAPER and little cork.
NOT LEATHER.........PAPER is inside.
4.Left boot tongue is higher than right one and is sawn wrong,not vertical.
I am not shure,maybe i have fake boots.
But they are piece of stinky,squeeky shit and i have torn them appart and true them in garbage.
The 1000 mile has a shank... Just FYI
Great vid, as usual. Have you reviewed Thursday's Vanguard? It might be an option for those wanting to buy made in USA boots, but price is higher because of it.
I haven't reviewed them no, I want to review another pair of Thursdays but I was thinking it might be more interesting to try their new Rugged and Resilient line, it seems to have more differences with the Captain I have. Got a trip to the Middle East coming up and I'd love to put them through the paces there!
Stridewise just to give you a heads up on Thursday's newer boots sizing, they fit a half size smaller now so I recommending going up half a size from your normal Thursday boots, for example if your a 11 in the brown captain go up to a size 11.5 in there newer rugged boots
Adrian Ortega whaaaaat. i just ordered a pair! i hope you're wrong haha
Stridewise yeah hahaha hopefully because I have the captain in brown in a size 10.5 then I ordered there dark olive suede captain in a 10.5 also, they fit really tight so I emailed Thursday's and they said that they added more cushioning on there new boots and told me to go a half size up and i did and now they fit me the same as my brown captains even though there's a half size difference
Adrian Ortega Yikes, good to know
Can get the wolverines for $200-$250 often on Amazon. I have a pair and I love them. However the Thursday's are worth a long look when I decide to buy another pair of boots.
Yeah the price on Amazon changes all the time, a lot of the time they're over $300 there.
Great video..I definitely feel better now about leaning towards the Thursday Captains. I love your videos. Keep up the great content
As a long time owner of 1000 mile boots. The quality it substantially better than the Thursday. My captain boot sole is nice and soft which I like, But this is the least waterproof boot I have ever worn! And I’m old! Walk through a mud puddle and water will literally squirt out of the welt. Last complaint, the toe is so narrow it is really not appropriate for anything other than dress boot and that is the deal breaker for me, Consider this a 6” tall dress shoe. These are going to goodwill. I also have diplomat. These are much better in my opinion. Except my left shank started clicking after a week. I’m a little irritated that I spent 400 on boots that really should not be compared a Wolverine or redwing. If you factor in the cost of my next boot. Could have just bought a white or viberg. You got me!
I actually just bought the 1000 mile for $215 on Amazon (maybe sales are hurting lately) so I’m just curious if you’d still go with Thursday even if the price was (basically) the same.
Mmm. I think the design of Wolverine coupled with the bad grip still matters to me. Maybe the Wolverine Evans would be a better match up, the Evans has more grip, but Thursday just looks more modern.
Stridewise interesting. I personally like a capless toe and a subtle sole on my boots, but I do indeed like the more modern look of this Thursday boot. I’ll have to check out some of their other stuff to see if I can get the best of both worlds. Thank you for the response/feedback! Great stuff
Don’t have the wolverine yet, but as for the Thursday, I think it’s overrated, or at least the quality control could have been better. The leather looks cheap, but so far it’s been holding up and comfortable. I would not buy Thursday again for the price they are asking for.
One thing that I think you overlook is that the Wolverine boots are just more handsome than the Thursday boots. I realize this is subjective but I have now compared two other boots (the Rhodes Dean and the Thursday Vanguard) to the Wolverine boot and the latter is just a better looking boot. The Vanguard is supposed to be made from Horween leather as is the Wolverine but it's not the same Horween leather. The Wolverine has more depth of color and a luster that the Thursday does not possess. And the overall shape just makes it look better on my foot. Just that minor curve at the top of the shank sets it apart. The Wolverines slightly more rounded toe box just fits my foot better than the other two and also gives it a nicer profile. I haven't worn them outside yet and the leather sole does give me pause but it is a great looking boot.
These are all great, thoughtful points, Ray! Yeah, it's all subjective, Wolverine has a rounder toe, Thursday and Rhodes don't. Some prefer it some don't, but especially if rounder toes fit your toes better, welp, sounds like you don't have any doubt. Hope you like your Wolverines!
Hipsters with skinny jeans and trendy hair cuts telling men who have worked carriers wearing real boots like White's and Nicks what boots to buy. Im still laughing my ass off.
I mean I've reviewed White's as well, they're one of my favorite boots. stridewise.com/whites-service-boot-review/
Are Golden Fox boondockers any good?
The way the leather ages on the Wolverines can be seen by many people as a plus. A lot ( not everyone of course ) people want that beat up look to their boots. I've watched some annual videos by Magoo who has both the black and brown Wolverines. He observes that the black pair for some reason age much less than the brown. I thought Thursday put in a non metallic, airport friendly shank not a steel one in? Great video as always.
That's a really good point and something I should have mentioned in the video, some people like beat up boots and also Wolverine has a nice nostalgic angle to it as well.
I thought the 1000 Mile might have had some kind of shank but I called them up to ask and they said no. Hopefully it doesn't turn out this was inaccurate!! It was stressful putting that in the video haha
Edit: Oh sorry you were talking about Thursday's shank. Some of them have a fiberglass one, like the new ""rugged and resilient" line but my understanding is the classic Captain has a steel one.
TSA Pre-Check. You don't have to take off your shoes.
If you walk up to a mile a day, 1,000 miles is only a few years.
ORDERED MY 1ST PAIR OF CAPTAINS. Have no plans to check out the 1000 Wolverine
I had to switch from Thursday Boots to Wolverines because the toebox in the Thursday Boots Chelseas and chukkas was too narrow for my toes.
nice review , I have Thursday captain naturals and Chippewas which are closer to a red wing . The Thursdays are more water resistant but they are not even close to the Chippewas for durability in hard work conditions. I do think the Captains will last perhaps up to 10l years given normal wear, not construction work. The Chippewas formed better to my foot thus more comfortable than the Captains but I added a thin additional insole to the Captains which helped a great deal. Keep up the good work ! Cheers.
you can't compare these boots, it's like saying redwings vs captain . come on not the same. captain is a good low cost boot. A Prius can drive fast , it can go to 80 or more but not the same has a Corvette or Lamborghini
Ew. Wolverine boots look so stupid. Bulbous is an understatement when describing this shoe.
The wolverine has the same creasing that fake leather has, I'll take Thursday over that any day
thursday midsole is garbage sawdust wood and can snap in two, unlike a good boot with a one piece full leather midsole
Not fond of the heel rise on Thursday boots. Seems quite a bit higher than its competitors.
Our heel height is around 1" which is the average heel height for men shoes but we completely understand if that doesn't work out for you. Glad to share any suggestions you have with our team. Please don't hesitate to reach out to us at founders@thursdayboots.com if you have any other questions!
Yea it looks very uncomfortable
I have to say, I am loving my Thursday Captain boots. I am wearing them too much now, my other shoes are getting jealous! The color(I ordered brown) goes with so many things. I mentioned buying Thursday boots the last time I was in Nordstrom's looking at some other brand boots and the salesman looked down his nose at me. I was not amused and let the guy know my Thursday boots are just as, if not better, than any offerings they had there! Anyhow, loved the video. Keep up the great work.
haha I love that story. Yeah versatility is really important for me and Thursday goes super well with almost anything. Thanks for the update Bill!
So glad you're enjoying your boots :)
Wolverine wins on leather quality alone.
It wins the ugly creasing award for sure. Gold medal!
Leather soles 👢 aren't as rugged but make a more comfortable boot. (Dry weather 🌤)
Just ordered my first pair of Captain’s. Got the Brandy ones. Can’t wait. Thanks for doing the reviews man.
You're welcome dude! Glad to be of use
As a owner of a pair of red wings, i would say their quality is crap. If you don’t bother with the so called authenticity or whatsoever, just go for Thursday or any other premium boot makers. You will get much better value from them
As a shoe junkie you are 😀 have you ever tried Limmers? Not comparable with ever Day shoes. But the craftmenship and for hiking.
I have seen your viberg rewievs and btw thanks! Viberg also makes "hiking" boots. Do you have a comment to Viberg hiking? Fashion or professioal?
Look up Peter limmer and please give me your opinion, with quality in mind 😊 thanks!
Their site is a nightmare to navigate! I like that rubber midsole and the single cut leather. You're talking about the standard boot?
Stridewise thanks!
I Just got the midweights myself, 3,0 mm leather compare to 3,2 on the standards.
First impession is that these will have a looong break in period.
Like yourself, I like quality craftmenship and looking forward to putting my feet through some pain :)
I have the Thursday captains in Brandy. Absolutely amazing how quick they broke in and they just feel like a part of your foot! Great look dressed up or down! Chinos or Levi’s your good to go! Thursday boot took the handcrafted market by storm and I’m a very proud owner of red wing, Thorogood 1892’s, Chippewa’s service boots and Thursday’s are best out of the box good to go boot for the daily life. They may not be a work boot but for the casual boot wearer they will be the best option and for only $199 you can’t beat them. Their moc toe will be my next boot for sure!
Glad you like 'em so much, John!
So glad to hear you had this initial experience with out boots :) Welcome to the Team !
The best 6 inch unlined boots I ever had were wolverines. They were buckskin tan. I was a meter reader. I walked usually five hours a day. I never wore a set of those soles out.. they were not Vibram cleated soles, they were a different black rubber one piece ,it was very cushiony. they were not those stupid soles that were some type of a Durashock were the center of the soul and the center of the heel had some type of a shock absorber build in that was not full width.. those stupid soles cause my ankle to kick it out many times. A few times I laid on the ground for a few minutes making sure my ankle wasn’t broke.. I think those stupid soles came on Sears/diehard shoes but I am not totally sure it’s been a while.
The thing that wore out on my 6 inch unlined wolverine boots was, the dew on the grass.. your feet don’t get wet in the winter .. it’s spring through fall that your feet are soaked every morning by 9 AM walking through the grass/ dew. that’s what makes the leather finally give up..
I also learned there is no such thing as waterproof. Not Gore-Tex, not silicone spray, not mink oil , not bees wax Applied with a hairdryer to melt it in. I guarantee you there is nothing that is waterproof. rubber is waterproof, but your feet will be just as soaked from perspiration that is not permitted to escape., and there is not a pair of boots made of rubber that I have ever seen that are comfortable enough to wear for five hours a day walking..Especially those duck boots.. you need a solid sole 6 inch shoe if you’re gonna be walking all day. If you were something very flexible, that beats the hell out of your feet making them twist in all directions and bend even over pebbles..if you buy a pair of boots that claims they are waterproof, save your receipt and save the tags that are hanging from the shoelaces for when you take them back. I have taken many many boots back that were claimed to be waterproof..
Don’t buy your “waterproof “boots from a mom and pop shoe store. Buy them from a large chain that has employees that won’t give you a fight when you try to get your money back. If you go to a mom and pop to return your boots, they will often tell you to return the boots to the factory yourself. That happened to me twice..
Wolverine quit making those boots that lasted forever. I mean I would get two years out of a pair before the weather finally started separating from the soil from the wet/dry/wet/dry cycle which dried out the leather even though I would oil them to moisturize the leather. All they did was Delay the inevitable.. I can’t think of another occupation it is harder on shoes than meter reader..
The winner is clearly R.M Williams ;)
Oh man, is that a great boot.
Understood probably 30% of your talking.... it’s not the 1000 miles boots, it’s like you talking 10 miles / minute...
Every year I resolve to go to a speech therapist and learn to talk more slowly