Red Wing Vs. Thursday - Who Makes the Better Boot??
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 чер 2019
- ✪ SEE MY LIST OF THE 10 BEST BOOTS, PERIOD: • THE 10 BEST BOOTS FOR ... ✪
TEAM THURSDAY? BUY 'EM HERE: thursdayboots.com/products/me...
TEAM RED WING? BUY 'EM HERE: bit.ly/3wYYuTv
READ THE FULL REVIEW: stridewise.com/red-wing-vs-th...
After dozens of requests I'm putting two of the most popular boot companies on trial to see who makes the better cap toe boot: Red Wing's Iron Ranger or Thursday's Captain Boot.
Who comes out on top: time-tested traditionalist or industry-disrupting new guy? I’ve worn the hell out of both of these boots, and it’s a tough call. Let’s take a look.
OVERVIEW
Red Wing
The Iron Ranger is a timeless workboot that’s barely changed in decades. It’s firmly casual, with a chunky silhouette. The toecap is a true toecap, made from two layers of leather. Other features include thick, full grain, oil tanned leather; shiny nickel eyelets; and a Vibram mini lug sole. (Mine are nitrile cork; Red Wing changed the soles from cork to Vibram in 2018.)
Thursday Boot Company
The Captain boot is intended to be a hybrid work and dress boot, and it’s much lighter and sleeker than the Iron Rangers. The inner is fully lined, and the upper is a combination tanned leather. The sole is studded rubber and has a nice grip.
Overall, these are two completely different aesthetics: the Iron Ranger is a beefy workboot and the Captain is more versatile. But is the quality comparable? Let’s take a closer look.
SEE MY THURSDAY CAPTAIN BOOT REVIEW: • Thursday Captain Boot ...
LEATHER
Red Wing
Red Wing tans all their own leather at their tannery, SB Foot Tanning Co, including the amber harness leather on these Iron Rangers. This leather has a nice, rugged, outdoorsy feel and can go a long time without treatment. (I made the mistake of conditioning them with Obenaufs which darkened the color - see my video on conditioning Red Wings to avoid repeating this mistake: • Boot Oil vs Mink Oil -... ).
Thursday Boot Company
The Captain is available in a variety of leathers, but these are made with Thursday’s Chrome - a combination tanned leather out of the LeFarc tannery. It’s really lustrous, and easy to dress up.
SOLE
Red Wing
The outsole is a flexible, rubber Vibram mini lug (unless you have an old pair, like mine, which are nitrile cork) and there’s a cork midsole, steel shank, and leather insole. The stitching is a 270-degree Goodyear welt - slightly less waterproof than the full 360, but still easy to resole.
SEE MY REVIEW OF THE RED WING IRON RANGER: • Red Wing Iron Rangers ...
Thursday Boot Company
There’s a recessed lug rubber outsole, cork midsole, steel shank, and Dura EVA comfort strip, which you usually find in athletic sneakers. All of it is held together is a subtle 360-degree Goodyear welt.
The soles of these boots feel very different - and the lack of shock absorption on the Iron Ranger is my least favorite part. The EVA strip in the Captains is really nice, and between that and the (slightly more waterproof) 360-degree welt, I’d give the Captains an edge on soles.
FIT & SIZING
Both boots run a half size large - I’m an 11.5 and I ordered an 11, which fit. Thursday’s come in sizes 6 to 15, while Red Wing offers 7 to 14.
Comfort-wise, I prefer the shock absorption on the Captains to the Iron Rangers. They’re a bit sleeker too, and cradle the foot better. The one downside is that because they’re direct-to-consumer online, you can’t try the Captains on before you buy them.
PRICE
Red Wing
Typically $300-$320, though you can sometimes find them on sale for less.
Thursday Boot Company
$199 from Thursday’s website.
Pros/Cons
While I love the Iron Ranger, and I understand its popularity, I think you can’t beat the Captain boot for price and versatility. If you’re just getting one boot, I think you’ll get the most wear out of the Captains.
Red Wing Iron Ranger
PROS
True, tough workboot
Rugged, outdoorsy vibe
Minimal leather care
Grippy Vibram sole
CONS
$100+ more
Lousy shock absorption
270-degree welt
Informal, workboot aesthetic
Thursday Captain
PROS
Really affordable
Versatile work/dress hybrid
Lightweight
Fully lined
Comfortable EVA strip - good shock absorption
360-degree Goodyear Welt
CONS
Direct-to-consumer, can’t try on
Less outdoorsy
Leather shows scratches more easily - Навчання та стиль
Check out THE TOP 10 BOOTS you can buy (in under 10 minutes!)! ua-cam.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/v-deo.html
I'm not hating... but there's something funny about you talking about how "outdoor"sy the iron rangers are whilst you walk around concrete streets sipping a frappacino :)
@@dallasmed65 woooosh
Tbh I am wondering if he only likes the Thursdays more because he doesn't rough up boots/shoes very badly.
That's an iced coffee
J94 C’mon... That’s obviously an iced soy latte.
@@yeenosaur2620 nah, they are half the price after all, and the quality seems to be there
I own a pair of the Thursday Captains and really like them. However they really dent and scratch easily. This is probably because of the type of leather and that’s fine for office work and day to day life. The old well worn boot aesthetic is nice anyway. However the Red Wings are built to take punishment, not trips back and forth in the office. Using the Red Wings on casual Friday is like the guy that uses his lifted apocalypse Jeep just for grocery getting.
Yeah for sure. I'm surprised how easily the scratches go away with a bit of shoe cream though, so it's not a massive deal to me. But like I say in the video, oil tanned leather is real tough and doesn't need much care.
Stridewise do you use shoe polish for your Thursday boots? If so, what color do you use for the brown/slightly burgundy boots? Thank you so much!
Dracstar I use brown/slightly burgundy shoe polish;)
I use saddle soap on mine and they have darkened considerably
I find that the leather on Iron Rangers, especially the amber harness, scratches extremely easily. I don’t even know how I got this slice in the side of them. I don’t do anything remotely dangerous in them.
Fun fact! The 270° welt is so you can replace the heel without doing a whole resole
Great, review and comparison! I would say that longevity is a pretty big factor in boots. Thursday has great potential and I expect them to branch out (and ideally upgrade) over the next few years. Personally ill stick with my RW Blacksmiths over either of these :)
Having owned both as well, I think where Red Wing stands out in general is quality and durability. The Thursdays I own just didn’t hold up as well, and I’ve only had them a year. My Red Wings are 4+ years old with a lot more miles and are in better condition.
I think comparing Thursday to something like the Higgins Mill would probably be a more practical comparison anyway, because you’re correct in that Red Wings are much more work boot oriented.
If I could only have one pair of do-it-all boots? I think no question that would have to be my Alden Indies.
Yeah I did this video because a million people have asked, and I focus on value and versatility myself. But you're now the second person to say I should compare with the Higgins Mill - not a bad idea!
I feel it’s more appropriate to compare Thursday with thoroughgoods, they both don’t hold up against time😂
Great video! When I was looking for my first pair of boots, two of the top suggestions were iron rangers and Thursday captains so this would have been helpful then so I appreciate you making the video. I have always found your videos to be helpful and informative.
That being said, I now own both and although the Thursday’s check all the boxes, the quality is not quite as nice as my iron rangers. I also find myself enjoying the iron rangers more now that they are broken in. Also, not that it matters much, but I have definitely gotten more compliments on them over the Thursdays.
I completely agree that the Thursdays are more versatile though, I can dress them up easily whereas the iron rangers definitely can’t.
@@Stridewise do eeeeet
@@MC-yg7tx Yeah the construction is very solid on the Red Wings, no doubt. I think that came through in the video, I tried to convey they were more solid heavy boots while Thursday is more versatile and better value and has nicer leather. Of course, I own both and adore them. Really glad you liked the video!
Thank you for this video! I’ve been struggling with this decision and you’ve really helped.
You are so welcome Adam!
Thanks for the honest review. I just ordered a pair of Thursday Captains.
Still waiting on my Nick’s Waterworks to come in around August.
Great review! I own both boots. My addiction started with the Thursday Captain. I think you're right on the money in this review. I love my Iron Rangers because of their heritage, they're just a cool, old school, tough as nails boot.
But the Thursday Captain is great in it's own right, modern, pretty tough and fits with so many outfits.
Basically, if you love boots, you gotta have both.
Good summary, David!
I agree! The correct answer is obviously both! lol
I really appreciate your straight forward and honest reviews. Hearing your opinions and you reviewing the pros AND cons of each boot has gained my trust as a consumer. Btw, just recently getting into boots and bought the Thursday Captain and the Helm Zind based on your reviews. Feeling pretty awesome with both purchases so far. Thanks and keep sharing your passion for boots!
Oh great! Both quality boots and crazy versatile. Glad you're enjoying them, Eric
I did the same, Eric! I love both, but I have to admit my zinds are amazing now that I’ve got them broken in. Nick has cost me some $. ;-)
Sean Dooley Good to know about the Zind. Mine arrived yesterday and seeing as its been 100 degrees in Cali I haven't had a chance to break them in yet! Nick is doing a good job of emptying my wallet. 😉
Hahah but don't material goods make you *happier*, guys?
Stridewise Looking good makes me happier and you go a long way to make that happen. Thanks Nick for all that you do!
Excellent review! I had to watch it before I buy. I'm going for the Thursday. Thanks Nick.
I love this video. I personally own both boots. The Thurdays in black and the Iron ranger in copper rough and tough. I would say this combo is all you ever need. I do find that the Thursday are a little more dressy but owning both boot really give you versatility. Thanks for this video is really fun to watch.
Redwing IR is the boot u wear to kill zombies
Thursday Capt is the boot u wear to date a proper woman when u have kill all the zombies
I think I'm OK with this
Haha.. well put
That’s where I’ve been going wrong.
@@gavingodfreyYT you sir are not WRONG if u use the redwing iron ranger to date a proper woman after you kill those herds ... with all their decomposed brains and organs on your iron ranger you sir will still get a proper lay from that woman as she sees you as the God of All Alpha .. HOWEVER...if you put on a Thursday Capt for a zombie killing spree chances are that you might not be making it back alive to go for a date with that proper woman and that woman will end up with me since i sleep eat and shat in these Iron Rangers .. now that is what you need to avoid my good man.. " either u put on those Redwing Boots or you go barefoot son"- using the voice of jack nicholson from a few good men
@@Stridewise when Stridewise says he is OK with it ... all yous better go get your gard dannng Redwing
I own 2 pairs of thursday boots, and honestly learning more about red wings, i'm definitely happier with my choice. The main reason I went with thursdays is not the price(which itself is already a BIG bonus) but the fact that as you mentioned, they look much sexier and are much more versatile. The iron ranger for me looks too much like a work boot(probably because that's exactly what it is), but I'm mostly looking for boots for casual wear in day to day life.
The boots I wear for my job are 5.11s I bought for $100 and I honestly don't care how they look. I don't go to work to try to look good. But thursdays allow me to look good outside of work.
I have a pair of Arizona Adobe Captain and I love them. Although, when I first got them, there was a leather heel patch on the inside of the boot. And it was just in the right spot to tear my feet to shreds within 5 minutes. After I tore that out though, the boots were absolutely comfortable. The captains do wear easily, I have glued the toe of the sole back on with super glue. But, I still love them.
THANKS HELPED ME A LOT IN MY FUTURE ACQUISITIONS NEED TO DECIDE BETWEEN THEM TWO AND ITS HARDER TO ORDER WHEN YOU ARE IN AN OTHER COUNTRY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
Thank you for comparing these. I am interested in both and I rolled the dice when I searched this and someone (you) actually took the time to make the comparison! VERY HELPFUL IN MY SEARCH! Pretty much pausing it at 1:17 is what I wanted to see. The side profile of the Thursday boot is much nicer and more refined like a dress boot, whereas the redwing is chunky at the toe cap.
Really glad this was useful for you, my friend! Hope you stick around.
I've tried to like Thursdays, they just don't hold up and feel cheaply made. You can just feel the difference in quality when wearing Red Wings.
So true. I also wanted to like them until my wife looked at them and told me they looked cheap.
Damn you can just smell the leather after wearing. Thursday had more of a chemically leather smell that vanished after a couple wears.
Had my Thursdays for over a year and walk everywhere in NY from streets to upstate farms. They are a comfortable and versatile boot that you can where anywhere.
Thanks for the sharing this idea, wonderful
The Red Wings look like they’ll last a lot longer,
GrayMan
They do. The quality is there. As long as you aren’t buying factory seconds with obvious construction issues then you should be solid.
That they will. I have had mine for 10 years and now work demolition in them.
Red wing! 16 years until a rip appeared! Back country hunting and backpacking into wilderness and hauling and cutting fire wood!
Totally agree
Comparing apples and oranges. Both good shoes with slightly different things in mind. I will say I wouldn’t wear the red wings on a day to day casual setting or walking through the streets of a city. Too beefy looking.
I have both boots and this is a good comparison. Depends what you're looking for.
The Iron Rangers look great but kill my feet. Work boots that people really work in, which Red Wing also makes, have modern technology that makes them comfortable to wear.
Thursday boots look great and are really comfortable to walk around in. I have three pairs of their boots and they have all held up well. They're also "versatile" (sorry couldn't resist :)) Great bang for buck.
Great video but I would add a few critical sizing things.
I just got my Thursdays after having to return for size change. The Thursdays have a very shallow toe box and my big toe hit the top and I had to size up. I wear an 8.5 in IRs but a 9.5 in Thursdays and my brannock size is 9.5.
Very well-done, as always. I own both brands. While I will have my Redwings for years, I can’t see the Thursdays holding up. Resoling a Thursday is pretty pointless. I’ll probably just chuck them once they are worn out.
No question iron ranger. You know what you’re getting and it’s quality and it’s reliable. The vibram sole, leather quality, and general worksmanship and quality is so much better with the red wings.
Not mine. Poorly made crap. The company is cutting corners to make a profit, bigger profit and living off their once good name. I have owned well over ten pairs ,but my Iron rangers had staples pop through the insole. I will tell you staples in the bottom of the feet is no fun. I loved the look of the black iron ranger with the nickel eyelets, but $330 and I have to hammer the staples down, now way!
That's a rare case. And even still, Red Wing has higher quality materials and if that was the case they would've exchanged them for you. They have better customer service than other boot companies. Iron rangers are much more durable than Thursdays.
Joe Boyd i suppose it is rare. I was literally told to hammer the staples down. I’m blue collar so I know mistakes happen, it is how you respond to them. I didn’t want a free pair or the employee fired just wanted quick response. It took corporate customer service a week. Luckily the store refunded my money after attempting to hammer the staples down.
The Iron Ranger must be made for me because my break-in was instant. Felt like a boot I'd been wearing for years on the first day. No discomfort. No chaffing. No hot spots. Nothing. Iron Ranger is definitely the superior boot in this review.
Got a pair a few weeks ago, and they were mediocre for the +$350 I spent. Returned them immediately
Same with me, when I first put it on I instantly fell in love with em. Felt great from day 1
They are very much wearable out of the box, but give them a month and they are awesome. Not sure why anyone would return them “immediately” without breaking them in
Nice comparison of two good shoes. This video will certainly help anyone trying to decide between the Thursday boot versus the Iron Ranger. I’ve exhausted my boot budget on Allen Edmonds, ie.; Higgins Mill, Normandy, Long Branch, etc. :) As always, a well produced, informative video Nick.
Thanks Ed! Glad to see you here. Allen Edmonds make some very fine shoes indeed.
Go with the Red Wing Iron Rangers. They will last forever. You can pick up a pair of Iron Rangers factory seconds for about $220 shipped.
Good video. I'm seriously considering a pair of these. I don't realistically need something to slog through construction sites or anything, but I do want something made to last for everyday wear as well as being able to be resoled. I'm tired of paying for crappy disposable boots that can't be resoled.
Take a shot every time I say the word "versatile"!
I'm now dead, thanks.
🤔
lol, alcohol poisoning coming right up!
I died of alcohol poisoning. Don't play drinking games with absinthe kids.
As someone who works for Red Wing, some thoughts to add for potential buyers. The eyelets can be changed out for another metal, doesn't have to be nickle. You can have that done at almost any Red Wing Store for free, as well as oiling and cleaning. We also do free repairs depending on the condition of the boot, as well as resoling which does cost a bit of bit of money.
Like he mentioned the Heritage isn't a forgiving boot until broken in, but we do sell leather foot-beds to help add a bit more cushion as well.
He makes some very good points, but I don't think I've ever heard the term 'clown shoes' when it comes to our Iron Ranger's. But I can see why some would think of it, that way. ^^
This video has a lot of insight and information, so definitely watch. ^_^
Have a great day everyone~!
Disappointed to say the least, was hoping the Macarena Dance Tutorial was going to be the next video. Sad times indeed :(
With my Arizona-Adobe Captains, it took over a week to break in, about 2. and it gave me a brutal blister on my right head and on my left pinkie toe and they hurt so bad. After the two weeks, they do not hurt at all but they are my first real boots. Wasn't expecting such a painful break in but it was worth it.
Yeah Will I think the Arizona Adobe is their rugged and resilient leather, it's not quite as soft. But it is resilient!
I have two pair of the Iron Rangers - one black and one chestnut. Once they are broken in they are much more comfortable than they appear. The trick is staying with them long enough to break them in.
Thursday boots also have a stacked leather heel (I found this out on a cobbler video) so really good quality.
My husband though likes the Red Wing style of boot and he wears them everywhere except out for dinner. Then he puts on his R.M.Williams.
I never mention when boots have stacked leather heels, thanks for mentioning that Jenny. If your husband has RM Williams he's a man of taste that's for sure :)
Red Wings are tough end of the world scenario boots that can be resoled a dozen or so times. Don't know if this was brought up but Red Wing's heritage line is completely made in the USA. The Thursday boots are made in the USA, Mexico, Portugal, and Spain. Both are great boots though.
They are made in Mexico actually.
They are made in Mexico thats why they are $100 cheaper
Great video!! Thank you. Make you reviewed Mark Albert boots? Was thinking about buying some. Thanks
I did! ua-cam.com/video/bmiWhKehEd0/v-deo.html
I totally agree! Versatility is the most important. It really depends on your work/casual preferences. If you can get away with a dressier boot at work, just do yourself a favor and get the dressier boot.
Thanks for your comment Joe!
I love my Thursday boots! They look great and are comfortable
I like how you wear them without cuffing your jeans. I'm afraid of buying these. I mainly wear thorogood moc toe boots
I’m excited to get both of these!
Got my Thursday’s in highschool like 3 years ago I hardly wear them now but good boots
Thursday Boots are great, just like cigarettes and beer.
Red wings are awesome, just like cigars and liquor.
Exactly
I’ve seen a couple reviews from cobblers who are re-soleing Thursday Boots. So far, each review has been very critical of the materials, especially the welt. It will be interesting to see over time if the cost per wear ales thema good value over the long term.
Also, Red Wing factory seconds are a great value. My IRs are pretty much flawless and cost $200 as seconds.
Where are those reviews?
@@richardshipe4993 Nowhere. He's just making it up to justify his own purchase decision.
I have 4 Thursday Boots that are just fantastic! I wear my first pair most of all and I'm surprised I haven't needed them resoled.
Thanks for the awesome review
You're very welcome my man thanks for stopping by
I love the Look of the Iron Ranger. That "bulbous" toe has more apeal to me than that of the narrower flat toe of the Captains. Im looking for a boot that could essentially do both. Dress Up for church or just to wear out for the day. Any recommendations?
How about the Red Wing Blacksmiths? They’re basically the Iron Rangers but without the cap toe and just ever so slightly sleeker.
Hi Nick,
Watched most of your videos and enjoyed them a lot. Now that you have 14K+ subscribers, are you going to do a video about who are you? Thx
I kind of did that in the last video when I mentioned all the places I've lived ua-cam.com/video/uuk6dUY4dyg/v-deo.html but otherwise I'm too shy to talk about me me me for now!
Hey! You got the pronunciation of the Iron Range correctly! Much love from Hibbing, MN!
Haha and I just guessed it, too. Thanks for chiming in, Alex!
Say hello to Bob Dylan for us. He just sold his catalog for $200 million
love my thursdays and my redwings. I agree the thursdays are easier to dress up. But I wore through the heel liner in less than a year. theyre fantastic office and date night boots. but theyre not nearly as well built.
This seems like kind of an odd comparison to me - I own Captains and love them, but I was looking at Iron Rangers specifically because I wanted something I could stomp around outside in and not worry about messing them up. These two boots just don't seem that similar at all, so doing a head-to-head is a bit confusing. The Thursday Chromes are super-easy to scuff up, which to me limits them to wear where I care about the appearance. Iron Rangers are built for punishment, and honestly, look pretty ridiculous for appearance.
It's hard to imagine situations where I'd be torn between wearing one of these two "Going to the club - hmmmm should I wear the Iron Rangers??" or "Gotta unload the tools from the pickup, lemme get on my nice shiny Thursdays"
A lot of other comparisons would make much better sense (for example, your 1000 Mile/Iron Ranger video), or comparing the Thursdays to Parkhurst Delawares or AE's Higgins Mill. If you wanted to compare a Thursday boot to the Iron Ranger, the Vanguard seems like a more appropriate pick, since they have the thicker leather and some varieties aim to be more rugged.
Not quite, he talked about the construction, feel and price of the Thursday’s, and you can get them in one of their more rugged leathers if you so choose to. That would only affect the “dressier” part of the final review, but everything else would hold true. Vanguards are pretty much the same as Captains, just different leathers, different lasts and no EVA strip, but on foot they feel fairly similar.
I think the video is spot on, and there are specific audiences for both types of boots 🤷🏻♂️
A fair comment, I'd say my viewership is mostly young urban dudes who wear boots casually, so I think the versatility and value and comfort comes more into play, which is why I emphasized all that in my video.
@@Stridewise That definitely makes sense - when I tried Iron Rangers on at the store your analogy of them being made of wood felt *very* fitting - they were ungodly uncomfortable. A big reason I like the Captains is that I can teach a two-hour class on my feet and they still feel great. I actually ended up ordering a pair of Tricker's Stow boots with a Commando sole, partially based on your review of them - they sound well-suited to Indiana outdoors, and you commented that they had good shock absorption and comfort. I did go for a less... *bold* color, though ;) Still waiting for them to arrive, but I'm really excited.
They’ve made new models of Captains with leather made to get tougher around. They develop a great patina after some time.
Thursday boots offers a good boot for a good price, and their look is very well designed for a boot like that. Many boots have every line designed entirely around comfort and durability (thats why the design of the Iron Ranger looks so awkward).
That being said, the taller Thursdays definitely look better IMO.
Great video as usual!
Thanks Damon!
I have no idea how this video popped on my feed but oddly enough I worked at the factory Red Wing Shoes, great video though!
Great! Glad you liked it Scott. Big fan of Red Wings :)
I think Redwing can make a classic looking tough boot with a more modern and comfortable footbed. I love mine but I hate the comfort level, compared to some other brands I have owned.
Yeah. Red Wing are great but yeah, definitely more comfy options out there.
Carlos Maldonado Redwing has a boot called the merchant boot and it looks like it’s a more dressy boot .. the iron rangers are good to hang out in, all around great boot
try the Blacksmith my man.
Sorry but Thursday Boot Captains just looks more modern and sleek, sort of like tapered helmed pants. The redwing looks outdated plus I don’t want to look like Krusty the clown.
I hear that a lot with Red Wings, even with other Red Wing boots like Blacksmiths
Got an issue with clowns Spock ? :D
I'm going on 2 years on my caption boots .. they still look so new . Sometimes I think I need to beat them up but I can't do it. Lol .
After seeing my Thursday Boots Captains, my brother in law thought he'd one up me and bought a pair of Red Wings.
We were together at a family dinner and the consensus was his boots looked like clown shoes compared to mine.
My boots were totally broken in at a week and a half.
He won't admit it but I think he gave up trying to break in his Red Wings.
I can and do wear my Captains all day every day.
He went on about how he'd never buy off a website...
I was completely satisfied ordering my regular size.
And they arrived in three days !
Mine aren't heavy work boots, because I don't do heavy work anymore.
Thanks for the fair comparison !
I own a pair of thursdays bec of you strideman. No regrets 🤘
Strideman is my favorite nickname ever. Glad you like 'em!
I agree it's an apple and orange comparison. I think a comparison between 100 mile would be better.
BAM ua-cam.com/video/kYvcLK864n8/v-deo.html
I would say it really depends on what you are looking for. Do you want a pair of bulletproof boots that are heavier and more workman like then the Redwings obviously. If you are looking for more of a stylish/dressy boot that is good for just regular use walking around in town, then the Captains would be a good choice. There doesn't really look to be one that is obviously better than the other.
I have not tried Thursday boots but I get their ads on my feed all the time. I love the Iron Ranger. The uppers feel great once they're broken in and I like a clunkier boot. I also have a pair of Frye Tylers that I like. I think the comparison between the Iron Ranger and Frye's Logan might be better as they're closer in price point.
Just get both, one for outdoors stuff, the other for casual/dress. I prefer the van guards though. Love my red wings too.
They're both great boots, no doubts there. I think the Vanguards in oil tanned leather are a good midway between the two.
Can i wear the Thursday boots in a kitchen setting for work? I like the fact they have a rubber sole
I own Red Wings, a pair of Thursday boots, I've worn Clarks desert boots, and other chukka styles. My best bet for kitchen shoes were some $50 Sketchers. They were black Chelsea boots and they worked wonderfully. I'd recommend those
Can I also say, in terms of resoling the boots. There have been two cobblers that said 360 degree welts are easier to resole. Perhaps lowering the cost (not sure on that part) I can provide a link to the information if required :)
Oh cool, thanks for the tip!
Love the video , very informative, just wondering if you know any similar design boots with zipper ? Thanks
No, I don't really like boots with zippers up the side I'm afraid Eric! Maybe in the future.
For my city-hipster pedestrian purposes I'd go for the Thursday Captains. They're cheaper, more comfy, the suede leathers are nice, and the customer service from Thursday is swift and responsive. And I do trust my Captains with rough environments. I had to muck through muddy fields at an Oktoberfest where the Captains kept my feet dry and cleaned up decently afterwards.
Yeah they're far from useless outdoors
I own a good ten pair of heritage high end boots....Red Wing, Adlen, Allen Edmond, Thursday, Florsheim, Wolverine..... I fought it for many years but Thursday is the best boot. Money aside. Overall, if you're going to own one pair, the Captain is the best bet. Comfortable, versatile, durable, easy to get into and out of, stylish, affordable. I hate to say it as it is such a new and trendy company, but the product speaks for itself. I may love more things about other specific boots, but overall, the Captain is the best!
So gad to hear that you're enjoying your Captains :) These are the reviews we love to hear as a team! Enjoy!
nice video keep up with more great videos!!
Thanks man!
Thank you for taking the time to make this video!! I’ve been trying to decide if I should spend the money on Red Wings or Thursday. Also, what style or leather are those Thursday boots?? I really like the look/color of them!
They're Thursday Chrome! They might just call them 'brown' now. thursdayboots.com/products/mens-brown-captain Enjoy, Tyler!
Your review is comparing two different types of boots, the Thrusday Vanguard boot is a much closer match to the Iron Ranger.
Nahhh. Come on that boot is so similar to the Captain. There's a better argument that I should have reviewed a Thursday with oil tanned leather, but I guess I just went and reviewed the most popular boots int he most popular leather
I've worn a pair of Thursday boots almost every day for about 1.5 years and they are holding up great. The only other boot I have to compare it to are Die Hards and they fell apart after 8 months of work. Thursday leather does show lots of character with scratches and scuffs but it doesn't affect the durability, just makes them look better in my opinion. Worn in boots make you look like a man, if you're trying to keep them pristine and walk around sippin' coffee then you might want to rethink about what footwear to go with.
I just bought a pair of Thursday boots Captain mainly for the aesthetics, you can wear them with a more tapered pant look.
Right, exactly. Red Wings are great quality but they just don't fit in as well in urban environments.
I wonder whether the 0.2mm difference in the leather thickness makes them a less good boot to use as a motorcyclist
Damn, this dude goes in with the details!
The red wing is a work boot, the Thursday is a dress boot. Depends what you're getting it for.
You wouldn’t really get an iron ranger boot for work though, especially not at a construction site.
Watched a bunch of your vids recently. Really helped me pick some boots (thursday captains) thanks! great content.
Really glad to have been of help, Joseph!
Outstanding review and comparison, as always, thanks a lot Nick! I'd like to emphasize on longevity, that's were value lies in my humble opinion. Plus, it's far easier to get RedWi gs in Europe, than Thursdays. A shame really, I'd like to give them a serious try. Currently I have three pairs of Iron Rangers in the rotation, some other heritage boots would be nice. Wolverines are out of the question, my feet don't like them ..😱
Yeah Thursday's value isn't quite as awesome for Europeans, for sure. Impressive you've got 3 pairs of Iron Rangers! Get a moc toe next
@@Stridewise I have the Irish Setters, awesome boots! :-) I think I´m covered right now...
Interesting that the Wolverines are not comfortable for you. The 1000 Mile boot is the most comfortable boot I've ever worn. More comfortable than the Iron Ranger, that's for sure (even if the IR is already comfortable enough for me).
It slightly pains me to hear many reviews mention red wing's repeatedly with "like your grand father's boots" . I was on a search for a brown boot in the style and durability of the black boots I was issued in the mid 90's(USMC). At 42yr I guess I have to admit I'm an OLD Man.. Good review. Considering Thursday's for a transition from rugged/ tradesmen style of beckmen and Iron ranger to an older gentlemens/ fashion focused look.
Great! Yeah that's the main difference, RW is rugged/tradesman and Thursday is more fashion focused. Which is "best" depends on where your aesthetic is at.
Red Wing, why is this even a video?
Chenler 😂
Right?
We aren’t all rolling in cash
@Tom Reid But they'll fall apart after a couple of years while RW would probably last you a decade.
Well executed comparison. I own the Captain in Natural.
I have Parkhurst's Delaware in natural which looks almost identical so we kiiinda have the same boot haha
Gr8 videos! Can someone please review Doc Martens vs. Thursday Boot co. "New Statesman"
Red Wing all-day 👍🏽
Red Wing all the way m8
I've been wearing Thursday Captain, but I wanted to "upgrade" to Iron Ranger. I really wanted to like them. I bought three different sizes of Iron Rangers to try them all, also tried them all with different thickness socks. Honestly couldn't find one that was the Goldilocks, so I sent them all back. I stuck with the Thursday Captains.
It was a laborer boot for low income people and looks like it, yet they are very expensive. Meindl, Scanner, Lowa are companies that make outdoorsy boots. Red wing makes boots for laboring outdoors or unground.
I wish you also compared the quality of the construction. Although Red Wings are far from perfect, I’ve heard nothing but bad things from Thursday’s recently in this department.
It's hard to talk about the construction beyond the Goodyear welt and the layers of the sole, you know? I'm happy with both, anyway. Red Wings are a bit sturdier though.
Red Wings all day....no question about it
I absolutely hate my Thursdays. I find them to be a boot you'd wear if you don't live life at all. I barely used mine and they are pretty ugly and beat up at this point. And yes, I took care of them, they just couldn't take the heat.
They lasted me about 4-6 months of wear. I have had them for 2 years but I have definitely not worn them for anywhere near even a year, and it's pushing it to say I've worn them for even half a year.
Honestly, just save your money and buy Red Wing Iron Rangers and honestly if you can spare it just buy some Nicks or something. I have a pair of Nicks and just bought a pair of Iron Rangers and I will never buy another pair of Thursdays for myself ever again.
P.S. if you are easy of boots, Thursdays are fine. I bought my girlfriend a pair for Christmas and she absolutely loves them. But she's also super easy on boots.
I just got sent the nirvana last of the Captains. Guess they were old stock from Amazon. Looked decent but the new shape is much better.
Red wing! It’s casual yes. I won’t even wear mine with a button shirt, usually T-shirt’s. I treat them as work boots sort of. My Thursday’s would not confirm to my footprint. I’ve had my red wings longer and they’ve held up better.
Thursdays are too pointy. They look a lot dressier than the Red Wings.
I’d like to see you compare Thursday captains to Wolverine blvd cap toe
I have both. Thursday’s are more comfortable out the box, a little tight on my foot. After break in, Red Wings softened up more than the Thursday’s. I absolutely love both but if I had to choose one to keep it would be the Red Wings. Fashion is subjective. I wear my wings with slacks and think it looks great. Thursday’s are way more dressy to me.
Yeah I'd agree Thursdays are more comfy out of the box. There's a real feeling of accomplishment once the Red Wings break in! Fashion is subjective, indeed. I'm just some dude!
Wear thicker socks to prevent blisters.
Good advice!
@@Stridewise check out sock liners! I like coolmax
As a hiker, I always wear sock liners. Even an inexpensive nylon men's dress sock can fill the role. Then a thicker wool sock over that. I got that bit of advice as a Boy Scout and it works well for me.
The only valid argument is the construction quality of each. Style is subjective.
You should try reviewing leather sneakers or leather dress shoes if you are looking to diversify your content! I know you put out a video earlier this year about what you should explore next.
Yeah I'm trying out a few sneaker reviews, Josiah! Mostly canvas but I did shell out for some stupid expensive Common Projects sneakers! Nervous to get started
I'm not sure where you see that Thursday offers wide sizes but I've not been able to find it on their website at all. Also, they look more like women's boots to me than men's boots. The leather on the Red Wings is also so much better, a coworker has a pair of Thursday captains and they scratched and scuffed so easily he had to stop wearing them...in an office environment.
Great review! when I bought my IR boots, it was not because I wanted a boot I could dress up. I wanted a casual every day boot that could take a beating. I don't use boots when I dress up, I have a pair of Saint Laurent lacquer shoes I use for those occasions. My RW IR are very comfy though, and the lack of shock absorption, have never been a problem to me what so ever. And yes you really fucked your IR's up, with to much conditioner, they look like charcoal.. Almost a crime lol
Nice one on the Saint Laurents, Stefan! Live and learn with my iron rangers, at least they're super waterproof lol
There are reasons the RedWings are so popular, Their QUALITY! The " Copy Cars", like "Thursday" and "White" attempt to copy The RedWing Heratage Iron Ranger but fail to achieve quality parity. White Boot Co produces a low quality copy for $530, 1/3 MORE than the Iron Ranger!!!
I have worn RedWing "Chuka" shos since 1967. Wore the 1st pr until they literally fell apart. Then I made a knife sheath out of them, which I still have!
Pairs #2, #3 and #4 are still wearable, but my feet have lengthend to the point that they are too short now, but still in good shape. The last pair of RW , ( Thr "Postman", (sz12), I still wear! I love the Oil Tanned leather eventuall morphs from hard and stiff to soft, moccasin or even glove leather.
But my Wesco 12" logger style boots were carefully custom, hand crafted FOR EACH FOOT in 1974! I STILL WEAR THEM TODAY! They cost $125 in 1974. The same Wesco boot today costs $700 or more.
Your shoes/boots are your most important wearable technology. Your body deserves the best you can afford!
There is nothing low quality about White's.
Would love to see you do a head to head Thursday Captain v Wolverine BLVD 😊👍
Haha wow, $199, goodyear welt, slim toe, even made in the same city
He will definitely like the his Captain better. The Wolverine are tougher, like they have more substance to it. The sole, and heel are tougher and better balance height wise. It's very clear from his reviews that he always favor the more "versatile" boot, and that basically translate to the lighter, slimier boot.
In Australia, the Red Wing Iron ranger is $530 and the Thursday Captain is $370. It will be my first pair of boots, what should i get? From my understanding, Iron Ranger is more durable and less dressy. My goal is just an every day shoe, i want to be able to hike in mountains, walk in a bit of mud easily but also just normal stuff.