Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT vs Porsche Cayenne Turbo S vs BMW X5 M - performance SUV drag race
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лют 2016
- Subscribe to the channel now: smarturl.it/autocar
America versus Germany and ... er, more Germany. We've put together three brutal V8 SUVs, with a combined power output of nearly 1600bhp, to do battle on our quarter-mile drag strip.
Our US representative, the Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT, comes with 6.4-litres of HEMI V8; which is plenty for most circumstances, but will it be enough against the BMW X5 M and Porsche Cayenne Turbo S? Let's find out.
Autocar, the world's leading motoring magazine and website, delivers industry-leading news, the most in-depth car reviews and opinion from our team of experts. Our presenters include some of the world's top motoring journalists who have unrivalled access to the world's fastest, rarest, most exotic and most exciting cars on some of the world's best roads and race tracks.
Visit www.autocar.co.uk for the latest news, reviews and analysis
New videos are uploaded to Autocar's UA-cam channel each week. Don't miss a single one. Subscribe to the channel now: smarturl.it/autocar
/ autocar
LIKE Autocar on Facebook: www.autocar.co.uk/facebook
FOLLOW Autocar on Twitter: / autocar
+1 Autocar on Google+: plus.google.com/+autocar - Авто та транспорт
That X5 M is an absolute animal.
+Tuddec
For $100k, it had better be. ;)
+Tuddec BMW>Everything. Audi maybe has nicer interior to some. Merc has better engines to some. Overall nothing touches a BMW interns of being an All Round Savage. Class, Race, Space, Handling, Feel, Precision and it costs Half as much as the Porsche. New turbo m3 with a tune is faster around a track than turbo although it still gets smoked in a straight line. Again half the price, 85% 911 Turbo performance. BMW is truly a Savage.
+Robert LeBlanc Try 300K´s here in Denmark, due to our taxes :)
+luskimarli
$100k USD.
+Robert LeBlanc well I'm Porsche fan and thought Porsche would win, Porsche turbo s is 150k
THE X5M iS JUST A BEAST!!! i Love it!
You do realise its a staged video... right? lol poor bmw fanboys
AKA Zeus my friend got a Porsche like that one and my bmw beat it
TRACKHAWK Would smoke that
it was obvious the BMW was going to win. The torque and power of that engine is just ridiculous.
+Honey Lam I think they come pretty underrated from the factory. Same with the AMG 5.5s.
Not so obvious, actually.
The Porsche Cayenne Turbo S is slightly more powerful, and has more torque, and is lighter than the BMW.
It's not obvious that it won, it's shocking.
GBDJ_45 no. on paper the BMW has more power, same torque. But that's the same engine put in the M6 which could outdrag supercars. It's got at least 600hp.
+Honey Lam BMW tune their machines to put whatever into it down. My father bought an X5 a few years ago. Whenever we meet up he takes it out. Dam thing is a missile.
+GBDJ_45 Bmw rates its cars assuming the worst so a 120f desert day at high altitude it will get the advertised numbers anywhere else well it will be higher. My buddy put his 335i stock on a dyno and it got its advertised hp to the wheels.
BMW always kicking some assess
BMW - the ultimate driving machine!!!
Ultimate dragrace machine :)
+sasajungic89 more like, the-ultimate-forward-and-turns machine-bc-BMW's-are-actually-track-focused-but-road-ready
+bumbastiik I think thats VW...
+kawaZR1000 not anymore with fake engine noises and crap steering feel
+kawaZR1000 Sheer Driving Pleasure!!! ^^pathethic butthurt lol
Now try to take a corner with the Jeep..lmao
try to take a corner with any truck and let me know how it goes idiot.....
Andy C7/SRT Nope, just shows how ignorant you are.
+Andy C7/SRT corner with the bmw x5m is actually amazing
***** Don't change the subject.
***** Cherry picking my words doesn't works. I'm talking about those three vehicles.
Your argument is invalid kid.
Try this race with a srt track hawk Jeep ;)
Best overall value = jeep srt
Most refined= Porsche Cayenne turbo s
Best performer = BMW X5 M
fastest= BMW
k cass but I heard the bmw has a really bad electrical problems the blinkers never work
future tech BMW has always had issues with their tail lights. E53's would melt the housings..there is TSBs for it. E46 had so main issues that they had a TSB that you needed to add an additional Ground. E70 X5's had problems too. The X5 is the BMW model with the MOST problems...then comes the 7 series.
@@pascalmpower7944 SRT8 Trackhawk
Think people missed the point that srt is just a scat pack AKA X550D. Trackhawk is on that level and beats all. Not as refined but that’s a valid comparison
No one can beat M Power Guys
Its actually the slowest among the suvs.. this was a staged race
AKA Zeus lol check UA-cam it’s ten others
yeah the 707hp jeep would
@@IssaBendeck1 Wasn't around when the original comment was posted, but still wasn't true as the Bentayga was still fastest SUV. Trackhawk has the title until the new X5M/X6M hit the streets.
TRACKHAWK would smoke any bmw
BMW X5M all the way yupppppppyyy
Хуйня это всё, видно же на реплее, что водила порше старт проебал.
Dubstep blow English please
Should take on my SRT!!! 😉 Will be a whole different story lads! 🇺🇸🔥✊🏾
i think we should give the jeep some credit here
1. cheapest buy far
2. natural aspirated engine
3.475 hp vs 550+
if srt jeep had turbo like those cars it would have Flown away and they couldn't even catch its exhaust.
Your affirmations are ridiculous : if Jeep have 2 turbos ....... if jeep have a bigger engine........ if jeep would have nitrous oxide ...... if jeep bla bla bla , excuses ! Since excuses are invented nobody goes bad ! They know that they compete with germans suvs , so why dont improve that car so it would get supremacy ?
@@plusultra9464 are you stupid? They have it's called the trackhawk... doubt the x5m would be close 😂
You Maron... Jeep already has a faster model and its called the Trackhawk. You should know that it does 0 -100 [0-60] in 2.7 Seconds, Which will blow the slow Germans back to the drawing board!, so don't mess with pure American V8 HORSEPOWER!!!!
And we can all agree most reliable out of the 3
The BMW X5M is one fastest machines there is and the power delivery is smooth but like a hammer at the same time. It truly is "The Ultimate Driving Machine".
Even with BMW's outstanding X-Drive system and 285 front / 325 rear tires, you can still create wheel spin from a complete stop.
B M W. That's Right.... The Ultimate Driving Machine. Smokin M.
Lol
The Jeep was held back by the drag from the driver's ears!
Shut the fuck up honda vitek
Nice spelling *thumbs up*
Drew Vitek look at your last name...
No, I know what you mean, but you spelled it wrong and just edited it to be correct.
Drew Vitek it is still wrong in honda terminology dumbo...
off course BMW
its verry underrated those X5/X6M and M5/M6 engines, they leave factory around 600ps for sure
Just wait for the Jeep Cherokee SRT Hellcat to arrive ☺
I have come from the future
Your wish has come true, need a rematch versus the Trackhawk
Just test drove an x5m 2017 it was pretty damn sweet my current car is a 507 and an x5 and trying to just get 1 car instead of two any recommendations ? Looking for big fast sedan on x5m style of SUV ( no American cars lol )
is the guy in the bmw the same guy in the speciale vs gt3 video by chris harris? the one with the weird shoes?
I regularly run 4.0 with my stock srt. Best 0-60 to date 3.8 with an AFE intake and nice cool day in the 30's. 1/4 mile mid to high 12's at 108/109 all day. If you know how to use the adjustable launch control you can achieve much better times. I ran 4.4 with 300 miles on the truck so this guy does know the truck. More horsepower the will always pull on the top end so Im not surprised the results of that race.
In America, that jeep doesn't even come close to the price. Not even competition for those cars. Where's the amg?
AMG already lost against the X6M, watch the comparison on MotorTrend
+Dashte this isn't motor trend. I like to see differing perspectives from the review sites. For me, this review is like comparing the phantom, mulsanne and the equus. Jeep way out of its league
Trackhawk is here to kick some ass 😁
Well done Beemer ... what a sonorous slap !
George Veltchev It’s Bimmer, not “Beemer.”
What BMW has forgotten all other car manufacturers must still find out. BMW is light years ahead
So $67,00 vs $100,00 vs $160,000 o yea this was a fair race..........
@@mohammadnizam2156 wow that's what you got from my post. And your name is Mohammad? what a waste of a good name.
@@Qugie the track hawk is not 67k
@@khaledmaher6602 That's not a Trackhawk. It's an SRT. Trackhawk wasn't even out yet duh!
@@Qugie well I don't think this is the turbo s if it was it whould blown the srt
@@khaledmaher6602 For the Cost of the Turbo S you can get a Trackhawk. but my Point stands....the Price of the SUVS are 2 different for a fair compare. Might as well compare Off road with a Jeep Grand Cherokee and a Jeep Patriot....
That Hemi v8 SRT 😍😍😍
It suddenly occurred to me-how many super CUVs exist: Model X P90D(L), Range Rover Sport SVR, GLE 63 AMG, X5M, Grand Cherokee SRT, Cayenne GTS/Turbo, SQ7 [will be released soonish] and probably a bunch more that I'm missing right now. It would certainly be a treat to see a comparison of all of them.
pretty completely the opposite result I had expected! That X5M is quick!
I knew either the BMW or Porsche were going to win. Their launch control, AWD and power delivery is way ahead of the Jeep.
The SRT is something unique
Wait for Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk with Hellcat engine!
///M Power!
in 0:04 I'm only here for the BMW
I'm confident the BMW will make it
///M Bimmer all the way !
YESSS SIR
The best looking suv is also the only one under 6 figures? Wow that Jeep is a bargain.
I'm not surprised, even if you had a ML63 the BMW would still win.
Thats right, the new GLE was tested against the X6M on MotorTrend. X6M won.
I doubt that very seriously
Bimmer looks the best & is clearly the best :)
The X5M is amazing! I was taking my R33 GTR (600hp dyno checked) out for a w/e spin and (long story short) ended up "drag" racing some dude in his new(ish) X5M, I think a 2017 model as it looked really new... had to use more foot pace than expected to get in front of him... was impressed tbh! They are fast for an SUV!!!!!!
This is not particularly important for any buying decision. It's not how fast you get from one end of an airfield to the other, it's how good it feels to drive each and every day.
X GONNA GIVE IT TO YOU!
I am very surprised by the results, I thought the Cayenne Turbo S would win hands down. Did they use launch control?
+Alex Fu Probably not, as Autocar are usually bias against the cayenne. They only used it on the BMW.
No wonder.
+Alex Fu i've seen some results on bmw forums that launch control doesn't always give the X5 M the fastest 0-60 time
Well, I will just say this. If the Cayenne Turbo S is indeed slower than the X5M, I am pretty confident Porsche will make sure in the coming next generation of Cayenne will definitely beat it and probably by some margin. The next Cayenne will not be just a facelift, it will be a completely new car, it will be interesting to see what they come up with.
First of all, the X6M is not comparable as it has no cargo space. Nah the BMs won't be faster especially not around the track. Ever since the Cayenne surpassed the X5, I am yet to see a more favourable review of the X5 over the Cayenne.
They Jeep was against an M5, however if you compare the M5 against a trackhawk there is no comparison.
Is this not the same video we saw on Pistonheads months ago?
bmw an absolute beast. ///M
M power everyday
Jeep Trackhawk is here :)
Soon as my mans said airbase I thought he was bout to start flying
M Power
As an SRT owner i would have had money on the Porsche over the M but doesn't matter I like the way Jeep looks and rides. I don't need to be the fastest cause last time I checked I don't drive on closed roads.
Jav L the Jeep looks and ride better than a Porsche or BMW? Have you ever driven Porsche and BMW?
Imagine the Trackhawk was in this
X5 Steering wheel is so COOL.
Germans both cost about 30-40 grand (GBP) more. We all know reverse would be the case when the SRT is placed among similar priced variants of the X5 and Cayenne. That said, the BMW is astonishingly fast.
maybe, but this video wasn't about cost, it was about each company's respective 'hero' cars (or rather, SUV's) battling it out for drag-strip supremacy. I've always loved the X5M, but I was actually expecting the Porsche to win...
M Power!
Have some dignity, roll your sleeves, put a blower on the Jeep, maintain the "I chosen the wrong car " which is right and then go race anything..
Wait for the Hellcat version. I imagine the result will be quite different, and much louder.
X5M !!!
I have a x5 M sport 🙃😍🙂🤗
X5M looks really good now. I mean it didnt look bad previously but now its really nice on the eyes. Looked at the new x6m just gorgeous as well
1 boat vs a luxury crossover vs a sports crossover
BMW Wins again! What a surprise.
...Now take them offroad lol
c'mon @Autocar, do a video of a hotlap in each of them.
That was a huge surprise. I thought the Cayenne Turbo S would cream it like it has always done.
They underrated the monster x5m 😂..
Be scared of BMWs’ 😦 😱
This was pointless. Why not do an actual comparison on the track and produce a potentially viral video if you had these three cars?!
+Nik Brudar because these cars are not build for track purposes. They are build for straight line performance, comfort for daily use and off road capabilities. However the X5M would win on a track...
Dashte they're meant to perform well, although none of their buyers will take them there. Nevertheless, it'd make for an awesome video!
sorry but i think porsche would win on a track...but im not 100% sure
please also bring in AMG GLE 63, Range Rover Sport SVR in future episodes. also want to see them corner.
Would like to see that again with a jeep trackhawk.
BMW is great
i think id still have the jeep
Anyone what year is the bmw ?
Interesting would be to see how Range Rover SVR does in this company...
why is there a giant lemon on tires rolling around? what kind of comparison is this??? giant lemons vs luxury SUVs??
shbly zaher ;P
BigMarks jeeps, one of the worst reliability records. you tube "i made a mistake and bought a jeep"
+justin bouche I actually own a Jeep SRT and have never had a single problem with it. Always runs flawlessly. Considering it is over $50k cheaper than the other 2 in this test...i'd take it all day
+Andrew Howell Same here.
+Jason Mosler
I three for sure
what happened to this channel?
+BLITZKRIEG Budget Cost ?
do this race again when the trackhawk comes!
Vastly different results from different channels. This means one thing. These editors/drivers have absolutely no clue how to extract the peak performance of these vehicles. 🤦♂️
Where is the Range Rover Sport SVR...?
+Tomás García Martínez Should be there ;) Click in our channel to watch all Land Rover Reviews
+Tomás García Martínez Not being made by U.S. or Germany.
+Tomás García Martínez It broke down on the way
+Tomás García Martínez more slowly than X5M & Cayenne Turbo S. just cheerleaders alone :))
But more spectacular. I think RR just sound a little bit better (just a little bit) ;)
BMW POWER FTW! BMW4LIFE.
Wait for these two Germans vs srt hellcat vs the new BENTAYGA..... Crazy SUVS
Cannot believe that anyone would even think about a Jeep as an option in the company of the other vehicles, however I’m impressed Jeep did not break down during filming! There was a recall however!!
BMW ROCKS!
Well if your gonna use launch control in the x5m , You better use it in the Turbo S as well new facelift models have sport chrono package which has launch control !
well you can also say why not wait for BMW's competition package？
Now try this race again with a Jeep SRT Trackhawk
Lets try this race again with the Trackhawk!
American brutishness failing against German technical prowess
Your an idiot you tell me how a vehicle weighing the same as a vehicle that has nearly 100 More hp and ton more torque suppose to win a drag race ?
You sir are a idiot by definition
If the srt was the one with hp and tq advantage your comment would have some validity.
robfrmny21
Well I maybe an idiot in ur eyes, but think of it, the Jeep dosent get mpg,aint fast,its horribly expensive, built cheap nside compared to the Germans,ride is utterly harsh,the 8 speed AT is bull shit as well, so what shall I say, say praises for such a crappy FCA product
+Ponygt 662 yeah that garbage zf trans is the same one bmw,jaguar,Audi use so it much be garbage. Since when is a high 12 sec low 13 sec quarter mile time in a suv is slow ? For a na motor to even be in the same video clip is amazing . Srt cost 65-70k and some how that's expensive but the Germans costing 90+k you don't even blink at.
I don't understand the angle your getting at. Some how the srt is pricey but the bmw and Porsche which cost easily 30-50k more get a pass ?
Do you really think those two suv are that much better with their inflated price tags ? I just don't feel they are 30-50k better . My buddy with a x5m has had his truck in the dealer for repairs way to many times enough that he's not going to keep it. Money doesn't fix everything
robfrmny21
Firstly the SRT is as expensive as X5m in certain countries due to hi taxes, thats what makes me think its not worth,
Sure BMW ,Audi all use ZF, but Y the hell is ZFs used by FCAs fail so damn often and r mostly towed to dealerships for software changes and tranny overhaul etc shile Bimmers etc do fine at least till 75k miles?
Its an over used term that Germans r unreliable, but I for one tends to disagree sure,BMWs,Audis etc tend to break down a lot once but since 2012 they have been mucj better specially Audis,reliability is top notch, even rivaling Hondas reliability, dont believe me check consumer reports or autocar reliability survey.
I dont kno anybody with X5M or even SRT but the regular Jeep is worst reliable SUV money can buy in Europe,somehow they r reliable in Australia tho
This video also shows how much turbo charging is compared to super charging and big displacement engines,
This is before the Jeep Trackhawk came out so they should try it again.
I drive the X5M... the exact one in this video actually as my daily driver. and the car can handle better then most sports cars I've been in, actually almost all of em... I'd say its almost up there with my 13 corvette 505HP 427, as far as accelerating goes, and handles nearly as good. I've test driven the SRT jeep just before I bought the X5. Its impressive in corners, but nothing like the BMW. its also half the price...
Porsche driver has clearly missed the launch, I've seen Turbo S running 1/4 mile @ 12.3 sec, while X5M does 12.6
So it's not the "wrong car" after all, rather a "wrong driver" :/
MaX VRZ lmao my x6m does the quarter mile in 11.8 accept the fact that bmws are always superior to their competition
Try that with the trackhunk
Once they get a hold of the new Grand Cherokee Trackhawk, it will dominate the X5 and Cayenne, 707hp, 0-60 in 3.5 sec. The fastest SUV in the world!
Of course they choose porsche and BMW models that are $60k+ MORE than the SRT8 Jeep. The tricks on them as the 707hp Trackhawk is coming next year...mid 3 second 0-60 times;-P
its not trailhawk The trailhawk version is off road or trails... What you ment was the TrackHawk Or how people want to call it... The Hellcat
Regardless of price, they chose the vehicles in the category the SRT claims to be in. Luxury sport SUV. It isn't even in the same ballpark.
Actually if your going by the Luxury Sport SUV category....The X3 or other X5 models would be in the same category. The other Mercedes SUVs are the same. The fact is....the SRT jeep will easily spank any other manufacturers SUV with $30k of it. The Hellcat jeep will embarrass these SUV's like the SRT jeep did when it first came out.
Sure they are nice and quick...but nowhere near "worth" that amount. I work for BMW "certified Tech" and the X5 is the biggest POS they make.
Wow, then why do you work there? I actually had an X5M and it was the best SUV (not really an SUV in my opinion, but definitely more versatile than a sedan) I've ever owned, and I can't wait to purchase another one. The jeep handles like a sloppy squid with tires. It's not a high performance setup. Just a jeep, with a big engine. I'll take a X5 any day over a POS Jeep.
Eric Roberts "Wow, then why do you work there?"
When the economy dropped..."well off" people weren't hurt by it as much..more business. I actually was certified/worked at Ford before going to BMW. I also loved M cars...but the romance faded when they stopped the E46 M3 and the E60 M5. BMWs went down hill when they started making the turbo engines.
A car that needs constant maintenance is Job security for a Technician;-)
The M5X ran/handled well...but the rest of the X5 was sub-pare quality wise.
As for the Jeep..comment, "The jeep handles like a sloppy squid with tires. It's not a high performance setup. Just a jeep, with a big engine."
Completely untrue...it's as different from the base jeep as the X5M is from the 3.0i X5. Springs/shocks,tires, ride height...alll have been changed. I've only been in the early SRT8 Jeeps and it handle amazingly for an SUV with a relatively narrow track.
SRT8 jeep .87 Gs, 62.6mph salom
X5M - .89g's, 63.3mph salom
When the first 6.1L SRT jeep came out it easily out performed the then Turbo Cayenne. It forced Porsche to up there game and bring out the Turbo S model.
what about the range rover sport svr
With 10k in mods in the Jeep you have a 1500hp twin turbo monster.
Where's the Tesla model x p90d?
Inner Hammer ..and still lose to the Tesla
Inner Hammer It still would win. The only SUV that can beat the model x is the upcoming SRT trackhawk ;)
blazzing4321 Unfortunately that car's insane mode just doesn't last long.
Light Yagami oh god, what is it with people and these damn Chinese cartoons
What about the fact that a car that boasts American technology uses electric motors made in Taiwan?
*X5M all the way*
The best sport SUV.
The fastest SUV on the market today.
they should do the race with them towing trailers
This dragrace is probably the reason why we had such a mild winter...
Really thought the SRT would make its way to the 1st
+Omar Its down over 60 HP, now way. Still a lot cheaper and almost as fast, so I'd still take the SRT.
+Omar I'm waiting for them to put the Hellcat engine in that Jeep...
+john marsh You've clearly never driven or been in the current generation Grand Cherokee
+MarcoPiperr that will be awesome... I think they might reveal it this year, 707 horse power is well above any of its competition lol
MarcoPiperr I guess a Hellcat Grand Cherokee would take this race to another level
this Porsche is very ugly
“That bmw is so fast again” mhm it’s always been
Where is the price comparison vs drag speed?