I love my Redback Bobcats. I bought brown Redwing Heritage Chelseas $310 and Black Redbacks $165 last year. I have to tell myself to wear the Redwings. I wear the Redbacks most everyday at work and home. Whenever they wear out I will buy a new pair instantly. Comfortable is an understatement. I hope they never change.
Love my Redbacks. Got a pair of Bobcats/Easy Escape for two years and purchased a pair of Nevada/Great Barrier recently. Both pairs in black and I condition them with mink oil. Walking-on-cloud comfort yet tough enough to handle so many environmental and social surroundings. Once I started wearing them there’s no need for other shoes. Thanks for your video.
I've had the Bobcat in Crazy Horse for about six months and they are easily my most worn boot. Almost daily wear have made these incredibly comfortable and they've withstood everything I've done in them. They sit by the door because they're my go to boots.
I absolutely love my REDBACK boots. For sure one of the most comfy and affordable work boots out there. They actually saved my feet from extreme pain caused by the Doc Martins I was wearing at the time. REDBACKs are an amazing boot for those who have to be on their feet for long work hours. I recommend buying a pair just to have for the comfort alone. Loved the video!
I'm in the USA and I love my Great Barrier Redbacks. My Blunnies started to hurt my feet over time. The Redbacks are like walking on clouds. I also think the leather is much higher quality. The only drawback is you have to order them. I don't think they have retail stores here. And, I will admit they aren't as fashionable as Blundstones.
On my second pair of Redback bobcats here in the UK. Nothing else feels as ready to wear straight out of the box, I wear them all summer and most of the winter except when I switch to Haix goretex military boots for the real muddy wet conditions. Great in depth review vid!
Fantastic review. Spent most of my teenage years in either Blundstones, Redback Alpine or Highmark GPs when you could see still get them. Only got on the UBOKs recently. They're relegated to garden duty with a few line trimmer slashes on them 😂 Will probably pick up some of the Nevada ones as a more every day boot at some point.
Love my Redback Nevada UNPU, the most comfortable pair of shoes I own and that includes all my rubber shoes or sneakers. Managed to wear them across Europe and Japan without a problem. Knowing that it's made right here in Sydney is a plus as well. They are also waterproof from my experience walking in heavy rain and walking thru puddles.
I second that! I tried on a pair of Bobcats recently and found that my Nevada's are somehow far more comfortable. They've held up well with everyday wear through 2 Canadian winters so far and are still the most comfortable footwear I own. I condition them with mink oil once or twice a year and have had no issues. Love my Redbacks. Teik, I'm really enjoying your channel! Your content is wildly informative and consistent. Your effort and passion to create really shines in these videos. Let this be validation to keep doing what you love. Looking forward to your next video. Cheers mate:)
Redbacks are the most comfortable and practical boot out there. What you give up in fashion with them you make up for with extreme comfort and versatility. Get Redbacks and one or two other pairs of boots and you're set!
Hands down the best work boot I’ve owned. I work in a warehouse/roastery. Dramatically more comfortable and supportive to my Rossi Endura’s to the point I’ll change into my red back’s after wearing Rossi’s if I take my dog for a walk at the end of the day. Better ankle support too. Not dressy, but common sighting in any pub.
Redbacks are the best work boots i’ve ever owned, unfortunately hard to get here at the moment because they are getting more popular. Greetings from Germany 🇩🇪 😊
Good review.i have four pairs most comfortable boot I have had.2 bobcats and to great barrier/nevada.and appreciate your extensive knowledge makes me want to buy 1 more pair
Been wearing redbacks and mongrel boots for years farming in Ireland. They're called dealer boots here, if they're a work boot. A fancy dress boot in the same style is known as a chelsea boot
Chelseas and Romeo’s ( a little bit shorter ) are definitely work boots. Redbacks are great boots. Especially for a throwaway( you can resole them, but a cobbler has to grind everything down and attach a midsole etc. ) There great boots for what I do . I generally work in wesco or franks. But these make for a nice hybrid if I want a more tennis shoe type feel at work
i have these in brown with steel toe. i used them for work. they are super comfortable and strong leather. i always claan them with saddlesoap and put snow seal on about twice a year. that keeps the water beading off the leather. The sizing is a little different. i wear 11.5 or 12 in american sizes, but i wear a 10 australian size in these red backs. these are the most comfortable boots
They are better than Blundstones in regard to being harder wearing, but they don’t look as good for casual or smart casual wear unlike Blundstones. The chunkier sole and clear part makes them look distinctly like safety boots imo. Nice boots in their own right though. Nice review.
Hi there, while I agree the fit and comfort of these boots is better than Blundstones, I won't be buying them again. I'm on my second pair now and both pairs have had the same issue of the sole coming unstuck at the toe. They were bought from different sellers about 2 years a part but each pair after a year or so started to delaminate at the toe. This is really disappointing as the rest of the sole shows very little wear. I have tried resticking with ShoeGoo, but it has been a temporary fix and eventually the boots gave up.. I'l probably get Jil Greens as my bnext pair as at least they can be resoled.
I enjoyed my redbacks, but for a boot that isn't inherently made to be resolved, the US price hike is a bit much. I've seen Australian pricing at $70 while they're almost $200 shipped to America. Jim green's are $160 and resoleable.
Redbacks in Ireland are about €130, I've bought a few pairs here and also bought them from smaller outlets in Australia for about € 60 if I'm not in a hurry, currently have 2 pairs of redback, one steel toe and one standard, and a pair of suede Mongrels for really hot weather, just back from 40.C in Spain ( everyone's going around in Crocs and sandals and I'm in Aussie work boots 😅. Love em
Love the segment with boots and pants. Gives me a good idea of what they'll look like if I get them. What do you think of the Mongrel K9 boots in comparison?
Hi Teik have a question. There’s a local store near me that sells Redbacks. I’m a solid 8.5D on the brannock. Went into the store today to buy a pair. Tried on the 8.5 US / 7.5 AUS and my foot was swimming. Tried on a 8 US / 7 AUS and the only thing was on my right foot a little too close to the front of the boot. I would say 2/3 thumbs width. I couldn’t believe my foot was swimming in the 8.5D. Did you run into this?
@@BootlosophyI just watched that Australian sizes only come in whole sizes not 1/2 sizes like US. In other words 7 Aus is 8US. Australian 1/2 sizes are the wide width to the respected #. Example 7.5 Aus is a 8US wide.
I am looking at ordering a pair for myself, and have to order online because no retailers carry these in my country. But I'm utterly confused about the sizing with the transition to UK/Aus sizing; please help! If I'm a 10 (Brannock US) for sneakers and a 9.5 (Brannock US) for boots like Redwing, does that mean I should aim for an Aussie/UK size to match my sneaker size or my usual boot size? i.e. Should I go for a 9 (down from a 10 US) or an 8/8.5 (down from the 9.5 US)?
Unfortunately their half size isn’t half down but a wide size or I’d say go for an 8 ½. I think in your case I’d go for a 9 but be prepared to wear thick socks. If the site you’re ordering from offers free returns, I’d get an 8 and a 9 and return one.
Do you know how fast the foam soles break down from non use? I've stored mine in the closet since winter, and I'm worried I may have damaged them. They still feel normal though.
I had a pair of the Redback Everest and was not a fan. They took ages to wear in and the speed hooks dislodged from the leather. Aussie made isn't always better.
You lost me at 20 seconds of your video. I don't understand why people are so bloody insecure, that they feel they have to fall in line with the latest political trend, in this case, acknowledging the original inhabitant of our country. I live in a small NSW community, 400 people. Three homes of my neighbours are aboriginal. several homes from India, others from different parts of Asia, Ireland, and the rest of the people are of varying European decent. All are good people who contribute to our community. None deserve greater acknowledgement over the others because of their race. That's called racism. The people that deserve the acknowledgement are those that contribute, helping others in need and protect. Those volunteers who saved our homes in the bushfires and those who risked their own lives to help others in the flood. Those people in our community who for eight weeks, set up a shop in the local hall after the flood and charge nothing for anything people wanted. Those people were from all parts of our community, not just first nations people. All of this "bullshit acknowledgement" on basis race does, is to create further harm and division, problems for future generations. It's done to appease the whims of politicians, a few misguided loud voices and self interest groups. Surely a person in Australia, should be judged on what they do and not what race they are born in to. I'm sure that you mean well, but I implore you to consider the possibility that you might be contributing to harm, by your short, but well meaning acknowledgment. I Wear Redback boots, they are wonderful. I came to your channel to hear an insightful review on them. Thank you for your time, all the best...
@@CliveWebbAustralia there’s a lot of anger in there. An acknowledgment is not admitting to be a bad person. It’s a form of respect. When you walk into a church, the cultural protocol is to talk quietly, stand when people stand, respect the Minister. When you walk into someone’s home, you wipe your feet, say hello, sit when you’re invited, not before. When you are in an Asian country visiting a mosque or temple, you follow what people do, you don’t spit and shout. Just because a cultural protocol is different from what we’re used to doesn’t mean it includes all sorts of hidden meanings.
@@Bootlosophy Yes, I’m angry when politicians and self-interest groups hijack the narrative of our county in favour of a small group, to the exclusion of all other people. Australia is either one multicultural country, for all, or it’s not. To acknowledge a group of people, above all others, mealy because they were here first, is ridiculous. If it were not for the armed forces that defended this continent in World war II, the men and women that gave their lives, the language of Australia today would be Japanese and most likely the indigenous population would be little more than slaves. History tells us this. And yet, in all of the thousands of Australian videos that I have seen on UA-cam, with the possible exception of some, covering the armed forces, I am yet to hear anyone thank those who died, leaving behind orphans and widows. Tell me honestly that those people don’t warrant acknowledgment first, before a group, that you acknowledge “just because they were first people to inhabit the place”. I know that people will be quick to call me a racist, but that just not true. I, in no way devalue the heritage, culture or contribution of first nation’s people to this country. It’s a rich and timeless culture as worthy as any throughout the world. But nor should these people be held higher than those from elsewhere, merely on the basis that they were here first. This kind of thinking does not bring about a fare and just society for all, it only segregates on basis of race. It’s racism. You said “It’s a form of respect. When you walk into a church, the cultural protocol is to talk quietly, stand when people stand, respect the Minister. When you walk into someone’s home, you wipe your feet, say hello, sit when you’re invited, not before. When you are in an Asian country visiting a mosque or temple, you follow what people do, you don’t spit and shout” I presumed that you are an Australian, legally and morally entitled to be in Australia. If this is not true and you are perhaps, a guest of my country, then I somewhat understand your desire to thank those whose country you are visiting. However, if this is your country. I’ll ask you to think about things just a little deeper, before going along with these ridiculous protocols, just because they are, those of the day. The fact that they are protocols, in its self does not make them a good idea, good protocols or even constructive. I can, if you wish give you examples of protocols from history, from around the world, that “good” people blindly followed and never questioned. Today those same protocols would be described as divisive, misguided, inhumane or even barbaric. You have the choice if you wish, to just think objectively, and question these protocol before you once again perpetuate them and contribute in inflicting them on the youth of today. Of course you can ignore me. You’ll not suffer or pay a price, in any way. This things are left for future generations to endure and try to correct. All the best to you… PS: I did not and do not write or imply that you are a bad person...
@@Bootlosophy Yes, I’m angry when politicians and self-interest groups hijack the narrative of our county in favour of a small group, to the exclusion of all other people. Australia is either one multicultural country, for all, or it’s not. To acknowledge a group of people, above all others, mealy because they were here first, is ridiculous. If it were not for the armed forces that defended this continent in World war II, the men and women that gave their lives, the language of Australia today would be Japanese and most likely the indigenous population would be little more than slaves. History tells us this. And yet, in all of the thousands of Australian videos that I have seen on UA-cam, with the possible exception of some, covering the armed forces, I am yet to hear anyone thank those who died, leaving behind orphans and widows. Tell me honestly that those people don’t warrant acknowledgment first, before a group, that you acknowledge “just because they were first people to inhabit the place”. I know that people will be quick to call me a racist, but that just not true. I, in no way devalue the heritage, culture or contribution of first nation’s people to this country. It’s a rich and timeless culture as worthy as any throughout the world. But nor should these people be held higher than those from elsewhere, merely on the basis that they were here first. This kind of thinking does not bring about a fare and just society for all, it only segregates on basis of race. It’s racism. You said “It’s a form of respect. When you walk into a church, the cultural protocol is to talk quietly, stand when people stand, respect the Minister. When you walk into someone’s home, you wipe your feet, say hello, sit when you’re invited, not before. When you are in an Asian country visiting a mosque or temple, you follow what people do, you don’t spit and shout” I presumed that you are an Australian, legally and morally entitled to be in Australia. If this is not true and you are perhaps, a guest of my country, then I somewhat understand your desire to thank those whose country you are visiting. However, if this is your country. I’ll ask you to think about things just a little deeper, before going along with these ridiculous protocols, just because they are, those of the day. The fact that they are protocols, in its self does not make them a good idea, good protocols or even constructive. I can, if you wish give you examples of protocols from history, from around the world, that “good” people blindly followed and never questioned. Today those same protocols would be described as divisive, misguided, inhumane or even barbaric. You have the choice if you wish, to just think objectively, and question these protocol before you once again perpetuate them and contribute in inflicting them on the youth of today. Of course you can ignore me. You’ll not suffer or pay a price, in any way. This things are left for future generations to endure and try to correct. All the best… PS: I did not say or imply that you are not a good person...
I love my Redback Bobcats. I bought brown Redwing Heritage Chelseas $310 and Black Redbacks $165 last year. I have to tell myself to wear the Redwings. I wear the Redbacks most everyday at work and home. Whenever they wear out I will buy a new pair instantly. Comfortable is an understatement. I hope they never change.
Love my Redbacks. Got a pair of Bobcats/Easy Escape for two years and purchased a pair of Nevada/Great Barrier recently. Both pairs in black and I condition them with mink oil. Walking-on-cloud comfort yet tough enough to handle so many environmental and social surroundings. Once I started wearing them there’s no need for other shoes. Thanks for your video.
I've had the Bobcat in Crazy Horse for about six months and they are easily my most worn boot. Almost daily wear have made these incredibly comfortable and they've withstood everything I've done in them. They sit by the door because they're my go to boots.
I absolutely love my REDBACK boots. For sure one of the most comfy and affordable work boots out there. They actually saved my feet from extreme pain caused by the Doc Martins I was wearing at the time. REDBACKs are an amazing boot for those who have to be on their feet for long work hours. I recommend buying a pair just to have for the comfort alone. Loved the video!
I'm in the USA and I love my Great Barrier Redbacks. My Blunnies started to hurt my feet over time. The Redbacks are like walking on clouds. I also think the leather is much higher quality. The only drawback is you have to order them. I don't think they have retail stores here. And, I will admit they aren't as fashionable as Blundstones.
I have no idea why Blunnies became so trendy on North America
@@Bootlosophy i see a lot of women wearing them. not for work but for fashion.
I’ve just stumbled upon these. People are buying them from tool trucks.
They have a store near San Diego
Dunno about not being as fashionable. The Bobcats are beautiful.
On my second pair of Redback bobcats here in the UK. Nothing else feels as ready to wear straight out of the box, I wear them all summer and most of the winter except when I switch to Haix goretex military boots for the real muddy wet conditions.
Great in depth review vid!
I've been wearing these (that exact model) non-stop for a year now. I gotta say, these are the most comfortable shoes I've ever wore
I wear these with chinos everyday to the office - I’ve got to be ready for anything. I polish them up and they pass as dress shoes with ease!
Lovely review, technical enough and well spoken to give a sense of the feel of using these boots, much appreciated.
Fantastic review. Spent most of my teenage years in either Blundstones, Redback Alpine or Highmark GPs when you could see still get them.
Only got on the UBOKs recently. They're relegated to garden duty with a few line trimmer slashes on them 😂 Will probably pick up some of the Nevada ones as a more every day boot at some point.
Check out Mongrel Boots K9 for everyday boots
Love my Redback Nevada UNPU, the most comfortable pair of shoes I own and that includes all my rubber shoes or sneakers. Managed to wear them across Europe and Japan without a problem. Knowing that it's made right here in Sydney is a plus as well. They are also waterproof from my experience walking in heavy rain and walking thru puddles.
I second that! I tried on a pair of Bobcats recently and found that my Nevada's are somehow far more comfortable. They've held up well with everyday wear through 2 Canadian winters so far and are still the most comfortable footwear I own. I condition them with mink oil once or twice a year and have had no issues. Love my Redbacks.
Teik, I'm really enjoying your channel! Your content is wildly informative and consistent. Your effort and passion to create really shines in these videos. Let this be validation to keep doing what you love. Looking forward to your next video. Cheers mate:)
Redbacks are the most comfortable and practical boot out there. What you give up in fashion with them you make up for with extreme comfort and versatility.
Get Redbacks and one or two other pairs of boots and you're set!
Hands down the best work boot I’ve owned. I work in a warehouse/roastery.
Dramatically more comfortable and supportive to my Rossi Endura’s to the point I’ll change into my red back’s after wearing Rossi’s if I take my dog for a walk at the end of the day. Better ankle support too.
Not dressy, but common sighting in any pub.
Best, most comprehensive review I've ever seen. Thank you.
Redbacks are the best boots I've ever owned... Lovely review, thanks so much!!!
Redbacks are the best work boots i’ve ever owned, unfortunately hard to get here at the moment because they are getting more popular. Greetings from Germany 🇩🇪 😊
An auto mechanic at work wears these. He says they are super comfy and he’s been wearing Red Backs for years.
Good review.i have four pairs most comfortable boot I have had.2 bobcats and to great barrier/nevada.and appreciate your extensive knowledge makes me want to buy 1 more pair
I have the Redback walking/hiking boots and they're great. The outsole is quite unique and I'm a fan. Comfort is great too.
Been wearing redbacks and mongrel boots for years farming in Ireland. They're called dealer boots here, if they're a work boot. A fancy dress boot in the same style is known as a chelsea boot
I’ve always wanted to know what a Dealer Boot was!
Probably worth doing a review on Rossi Boots as well. They are still made in Adelaide except for their reintroduced Goodyear welted boot.
Chelseas and Romeo’s ( a little bit shorter ) are definitely work boots. Redbacks are great boots. Especially for a throwaway( you can resole them, but a cobbler has to grind everything down and attach a midsole etc. ) There great boots for what I do . I generally work in wesco or franks. But these make for a nice hybrid if I want a more tennis shoe type feel at work
i have these in brown with steel toe. i used them for work. they are super comfortable and strong leather. i always claan them with saddlesoap and put snow seal on about twice a year. that keeps the water beading off the leather. The sizing is a little different. i wear 11.5 or 12 in american sizes, but i wear a 10 australian size in these red backs. these are the most comfortable boots
What a fantastic, informative video. Thank you so much.
"They go with outfits like going to dig a bloody big hole somewhere" haha
Great review! I’d love to hear how you think these compare to the Rossi Endura boots. Thanks!
They are better than Blundstones in regard to being harder wearing, but they don’t look as good for casual or smart casual wear unlike Blundstones. The chunkier sole and clear part makes them look distinctly like safety boots imo. Nice boots in their own right though. Nice review.
I had a pair take the worst beating for two years. Very good boots.
Hi there, while I agree the fit and comfort of these boots is better than Blundstones, I won't be buying them again. I'm on my second pair now and both pairs have had the same issue of the sole coming unstuck at the toe. They were bought from different sellers about 2 years a part but each pair after a year or so started to delaminate at the toe. This is really disappointing as the rest of the sole shows very little wear. I have tried resticking with ShoeGoo, but it has been a temporary fix and eventually the boots gave up.. I'l probably get Jil Greens as my bnext pair as at least they can be resoled.
I enjoyed my redbacks, but for a boot that isn't inherently made to be resolved, the US price hike is a bit much. I've seen Australian pricing at $70 while they're almost $200 shipped to America. Jim green's are $160 and resoleable.
Redbacks in Ireland are about €130, I've bought a few pairs here and also bought them from smaller outlets in Australia for about € 60 if I'm not in a hurry, currently have 2 pairs of redback, one steel toe and one standard, and a pair of suede Mongrels for really hot weather, just back from 40.C in Spain ( everyone's going around in Crocs and sandals and I'm in Aussie work boots 😅. Love em
Great video, as usual! I'm looking forward to JG Stockman follow-up video.
Coming up soon!
I wear redbacks everyday outside of work. My last pair lasted 3 years and I was quick to buy a second.
What a great review
Love the segment with boots and pants. Gives me a good idea of what they'll look like if I get them. What do you think of the Mongrel K9 boots in comparison?
Mongrel K9 review is in the queue
Are the elastic bands waterproof? Does the elasticity of the bands outlast the outer sole? Thank you for a thorough review.
Like all textiles no it isn’t water proof
What are your thoughts on the Rossi 303? Debating between the Redbacks and those. Great video!
Don’t know Rossi’s but I’m interested enough to probably buy a pair at some stage
Hi Teik have a question. There’s a local store near me that sells Redbacks.
I’m a solid 8.5D on the brannock.
Went into the store today to buy a pair. Tried on the 8.5 US / 7.5 AUS and my foot was swimming.
Tried on a 8 US / 7 AUS and the only thing was on my right foot a little too close to the front of the boot. I would say 2/3 thumbs width.
I couldn’t believe my foot was swimming in the 8.5D.
Did you run into this?
@@MarcP5267 no, I’m 8.5D Brannock and I’m good with Aus 7 all around.
@@Bootlosophy so technically you’re a 1/2 size down from brannock?
Isn’t there a G and H width in 7 Aus?
@@BootlosophyI just watched that Australian sizes only come in whole sizes not 1/2 sizes like US. In other words 7 Aus is 8US. Australian 1/2 sizes are the wide width to the respected #. Example 7.5 Aus is a 8US wide.
Thank You for sharing! Jim green vs redback which do you like better?
Chelsea JG? I prefer Redback for everyday comfort but no denying JG is sturdier and more protective
Yes chelsea's I should have clarified. Thank You well I know which one to get now
Hey I have narrow feet
Do they have a boot for narrow feet
Nice video
Fantastic content 👌 👏 👍
Comparing with bloundstone??? Which is best quality
@@mehdi6797 see my other video comparing Aussie work boots
I am looking at ordering a pair for myself, and have to order online because no retailers carry these in my country. But I'm utterly confused about the sizing with the transition to UK/Aus sizing; please help!
If I'm a 10 (Brannock US) for sneakers and a 9.5 (Brannock US) for boots like Redwing, does that mean I should aim for an Aussie/UK size to match my sneaker size or my usual boot size? i.e. Should I go for a 9 (down from a 10 US) or an 8/8.5 (down from the 9.5 US)?
Unfortunately their half size isn’t half down but a wide size or I’d say go for an 8 ½. I think in your case I’d go for a 9 but be prepared to wear thick socks. If the site you’re ordering from offers free returns, I’d get an 8 and a 9 and return one.
@@Bootlosophy thank you very much!
Do you know how fast the foam soles break down from non use? I've stored mine in the closet since winter, and I'm worried I may have damaged them. They still feel normal though.
Years
From my experience pressure washing is one of the few things that will soak through a full grain leather
I had a pair of the Redback Everest and was not a fan. They took ages to wear in and the speed hooks dislodged from the leather. Aussie made isn't always better.
Too true. It’s quality I look for, not country of construction
Yes. Better than Blunnies
Beg to disagree, they would go great with chinos! 😃
That’s what’s so great about boots - you can make them rock your way!
‘Bits and bobs’ 😂
Redbacks are good to work in, great for spring and summer. Basically a short Wellington boot.
Never been a Wellington boot 🤔🤔
@@matthewdickson7838you’d be correct they’re not a Wellington boot… just making a simplistic comparison. Thank you.
🇦🇺
You lost me at 20 seconds of your video. I don't understand why people are so bloody insecure, that they feel they have to fall in line with the latest political trend, in this case, acknowledging the original inhabitant of our country. I live in a small NSW community, 400 people. Three homes of my neighbours are aboriginal. several homes from India, others from different parts of Asia, Ireland, and the rest of the people are of varying European decent. All are good people who contribute to our community. None deserve greater acknowledgement over the others because of their race. That's called racism. The people that deserve the acknowledgement are those that contribute, helping others in need and protect. Those volunteers who saved our homes in the bushfires and those who risked their own lives to help others in the flood. Those people in our community who for eight weeks, set up a shop in the local hall after the flood and charge nothing for anything people wanted. Those people were from all parts of our community, not just first nations people. All of this "bullshit acknowledgement" on basis race does, is to create further harm and division, problems for future generations. It's done to appease the whims of politicians, a few misguided loud voices and self interest groups. Surely a person in Australia, should be judged on what they do and not what race they are born in to. I'm sure that you mean well, but I implore you to consider the possibility that you might be contributing to harm, by your short, but well meaning acknowledgment. I Wear Redback boots, they are wonderful. I came to your channel to hear an insightful review on them. Thank you for your time, all the best...
@@CliveWebbAustralia there’s a lot of anger in there. An acknowledgment is not admitting to be a bad person. It’s a form of respect. When you walk into a church, the cultural protocol is to talk quietly, stand when people stand, respect the Minister. When you walk into someone’s home, you wipe your feet, say hello, sit when you’re invited, not before. When you are in an Asian country visiting a mosque or temple, you follow what people do, you don’t spit and shout. Just because a cultural protocol is different from what we’re used to doesn’t mean it includes all sorts of hidden meanings.
@@Bootlosophy Yes, I’m angry when politicians and self-interest groups hijack the narrative of our county in favour of a small group, to the exclusion of all other people. Australia is either one multicultural country, for all, or it’s not. To acknowledge a group of people, above all others, mealy because they were here first, is ridiculous. If it were not for the armed forces that defended this continent in World war II, the men and women that gave their lives, the language of Australia today would be Japanese and most likely the indigenous population would be little more than slaves. History tells us this. And yet, in all of the thousands of Australian videos that I have seen on UA-cam, with the possible exception of some, covering the armed forces, I am yet to hear anyone thank those who died, leaving behind orphans and widows. Tell me honestly that those people don’t warrant acknowledgment first, before a group, that you acknowledge “just because they were first people to inhabit the place”. I know that people will be quick to call me a racist, but that just not true. I, in no way devalue the heritage, culture or contribution of first nation’s people to this country. It’s a rich and timeless culture as worthy as any throughout the world.
But nor should these people be held higher than those from elsewhere, merely on the basis that they were here first. This kind of thinking does not bring about a fare and just society for all, it only segregates on basis of race. It’s racism.
You said “It’s a form of respect. When you walk into a church, the cultural protocol is to talk quietly, stand when people stand, respect the Minister. When you walk into someone’s home, you wipe your feet, say hello, sit when you’re invited, not before. When you are in an Asian country visiting a mosque or temple, you follow what people do, you don’t spit and shout”
I presumed that you are an Australian, legally and morally entitled to be in Australia. If this is not true and you are perhaps, a guest of my country, then I somewhat understand your desire to thank those whose country you are visiting. However, if this is your country. I’ll ask you to think about things just a little deeper, before going along with these ridiculous protocols, just because they are, those of the day. The fact that they are protocols, in its self does not make them a good idea, good protocols or even constructive. I can, if you wish give you examples of protocols from history, from around the world, that “good” people blindly followed and never questioned. Today those same protocols would be described as divisive, misguided, inhumane or even barbaric. You have the choice if you wish, to just think objectively, and question these protocol before you once again perpetuate them and contribute in inflicting them on the youth of today. Of course you can ignore me. You’ll not suffer or pay a price, in any way. This things are left for future generations to endure and try to correct. All the best to you…
PS: I did not and do not write or imply that you are a bad person...
@@Bootlosophy Yes, I’m angry when politicians and self-interest groups hijack the narrative of our county in favour of a small group, to the exclusion of all other people. Australia is either one multicultural country, for all, or it’s not. To acknowledge a group of people, above all others, mealy because they were here first, is ridiculous. If it were not for the armed forces that defended this continent in World war II, the men and women that gave their lives, the language of Australia today would be Japanese and most likely the indigenous population would be little more than slaves. History tells us this. And yet, in all of the thousands of Australian videos that I have seen on UA-cam, with the possible exception of some, covering the armed forces, I am yet to hear anyone thank those who died, leaving behind orphans and widows. Tell me honestly that those people don’t warrant acknowledgment first, before a group, that you acknowledge “just because they were first people to inhabit the place”. I know that people will be quick to call me a racist, but that just not true. I, in no way devalue the heritage, culture or contribution of first nation’s people to this country. It’s a rich and timeless culture as worthy as any throughout the world. But nor should these people be held higher than those from elsewhere, merely on the basis that they were here first. This kind of thinking does not bring about a fare and just society for all, it only segregates on basis of race. It’s racism.
You said “It’s a form of respect. When you walk into a church, the cultural protocol is to talk quietly, stand when people stand, respect the Minister. When you walk into someone’s home, you wipe your feet, say hello, sit when you’re invited, not before. When you are in an Asian country visiting a mosque or temple, you follow what people do, you don’t spit and shout”
I presumed that you are an Australian, legally and morally entitled to be in Australia. If this is not true and you are perhaps, a guest of my country, then I somewhat understand your desire to thank those whose country you are visiting. However, if this is your country. I’ll ask you to think about things just a little deeper, before going along with these ridiculous protocols, just because they are, those of the day. The fact that they are protocols, in its self does not make them a good idea, good protocols or even constructive. I can, if you wish give you examples of protocols from history, from around the world, that “good” people blindly followed and never questioned. Today those same protocols would be described as divisive, misguided, inhumane or even barbaric. You have the choice if you wish, to just think objectively, and question these protocol before you once again perpetuate them and contribute in inflicting them on the youth of today. Of course you can ignore me. You’ll not suffer or pay a price, in any way. This things are left for future generations to endure and try to correct. All the best…
PS: I did not say or imply that you are not a good person...