u r the first person who narrated this false aligation that panjabi did not allow urdu speaking people at the time of partition.your information absolutely presented true and real historical facts.You have done a great job ,sir.
Do anothet podcast with your father and Tell about places other than Old Karachi like nazimabad,north karachi,korangi,etc and Also tell about the migrant nation How were other areas of Karachi settled?
There are many Pathan territory in India such as state of Rampur and state of Bhopal and the oldest state was Rohillakhand which was rule by najib Khan Yousufzai. Pathan have state in india at the time of Mughal empire. But due culture change they speak Urdu language in India. Thanks. Please don't deny about it.
@@MukeshPanicker Respected Sir, This is the history the link for rohilla state of Rampur is given below: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rampur,_Uttar_Pradesh#:~:text=founded%20in%201775.-,Originally%20it%20was%20a%20group%20of%20four%20villages%20named%20Kather,Khan%20ruled%20for%2020%20years. Secondly Bhopal state of Pathan rulers the link is below: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_State Rohillakhand state of Pathan in which there is bareilly, Moradabad etc. The link is given below: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohilkhand Thanks.
There is difference between present claim and history of a particular place maybe rampur was a territory of Pathan in past but currently that area has different land owners you can’t say particular caste or community control all the territory. If you go by the history then entire Afghanistan Pakistan were part of Mauryan empire but today it is not the case. Harshvardhan controlled vast area of central Indian peninsula and Buddhist king Kanishka also ruled over Afghanistan but today you can’t find Buddhist territory in Afghanistan.
@@Vishwajeetvpsingh Respected Sir, I completely agree with your point of view now there is no princely state there I was taking about history and I also know that Mauryan have ruled Afghanistan also there is a great Buddhist civilization near by swat region. Moreover, there are stupas of Buddhist community are and very religious place for Buddhism also for Hinduism. However, now history changes on both sides. Thanks.
@@ArbazKhan-hr5rg gentleman you used present tense ‘’ there are many PATHAN territory in India” instead of there were many; that’s why I tried to correct you. Podcasters already established the fact that there were Pathan or central Asian territories in India in past but they were talking in present context that pathans identity is not restricted to a particular territory in India they live all over India and but in Pakistan they are limited to norther Pakistan near Pashtun belt. Indian pathan can be a Marathi GUJARATI OR RAJASTHANI they assimilated with the population and culture of India but in Pakistan it appears from the podcast that they have pasto identity in Pakistan and are not considered Sindhi balochi or punjabi. I hope you understand the crux of the difference discussed in podcast.
@3:55 I have watched the previous videos as well, it was very insightful even though i have no relation with Karachi or Sindh. But, with all due respect, calling Gandhi a "leader of Hindus" is so incorrect, he always represented every Indian (United India of that time). Infact, this was the reason why he lost his life as was considered too pro-Muslims by some. So, please read about this a little.
there is no place in the world where there is no any discrimination, racism. how this guest can say that India has no discrimination. and pathan movie didn't face any problem while releasing.
There are so many bones of contention with this episode, apart from the total disgraced that so called Muhajirs proposed for the creation of Pakistan when in fact the populous of now territorial Pakistan had differing opinions. Muhajirs aren’t only a Urdu speaking community but the majority of Urdu speakers hijacked the electoral base.
Well said brother. This Father-Son duo are doing nothing but peddling lies in the name of podcast. Fooling people around with their half baked knowledge! 😂😂
Do you need to realize that Urdu was a reason for the death of millions of Bengali’s. This elitist Lukhnavi/Aligarh culture resulted in the imposition of one language for a multi-lingual nation of Muslims. 🤦🏻♂️
Bro your content is great but me being from India I wish to see the visuals too like when your Abba is talking you should show some visuals this will have more impact to your videos and the podcast I don't wish to compare Abt your counterparts from India but they have an dialogue along with visuals it will help us as Indians to see and visualize our beautiful or say dark past of life ... Thanks Jai Hind
aaj kal hamir mir ki aik vedio clip social media per virol he jis me woh batata he k karachi me 1947 sy qabl fulan fulan buildings thin mahjron ne karachi ko kia dia tu mqm ki khushbakht shujaat kehti he ke han habib bank plaza aur mazar e quaid k siwa kuch nahi dia halanke aisa nahi he 1947 ke baad mahjron ny more than 100 colleges and more than 1000 schools banaye ,industries ka net work lagaya.hosptial,blood bandk,labs,masaji o madaris,new areas like liaquat abad,nazimabad,new karachi,north karachi,korangi,shah faisal colony,gulshan e iqbal,gulistan e johar gulshan e maimar etc banay aap se request he hamid mir ka bharpor jawab den aur aik video banaden thanks
Bhai establishment kei kehna par yeibsaraa podcasts huu rahaa. Yei script writwr koi likh dee raha haa kei mahjaroon kei khilaaf bakwas karoo. Yei sub establishment karwa rahee haa. Mei punjabi tasleem karta huu 2014 karachi operation was biggeat foul play. ❤
Daniyal bahi next podcast on buttho. How buttho racism affects Karachi. Eamring of MQM, and MQM, MQM MANIFESTO, IS MQM fulfill their promises, Discuss in detail, other ethnic groups of Karachi and clashes.(WHAT is pakka qila , what is mahijir camp) etc
Hindustan me Qaum parasti isliye nahi hai kyunki waha har zaban ko azadi hai apne Soobe me isliye wo relax hain jabki tum jese logo ne Bharat se aakar yaha pure multicultural mulk me urdu thopi or Punjabi , Sindhi, Bengali, Pashto, Balochi etc zubano ko dabane ki koshish ki gayi. Zahir si baat hai jesa boge wesa hi katoge ullo ke pathoo. Pakistan kal ka bana mulq hai jabki ham Sindhi, Pathan, Baloch hazaro salo se hain.
Yeh log Islam Islam karta hai lekin kitne musalmano ne ek doosre ka gala kata hisap nhi 😂😂....itna obsession apne religion ke uppar ki aadmi jitna bhi bura ho,lekin musalman hota toh gunaah maaf 😂😂...baad mein wohi aake gala kaata hai......
u r the first person who narrated this false aligation that panjabi did not allow urdu speaking people at the time of partition.your information absolutely presented true and real historical facts.You have done a great job ,sir.
Well done dil khush hoa karachi ki history sun ker
Do anothet podcast with your father and Tell about places other than Old Karachi like nazimabad,north karachi,korangi,etc and Also tell about the migrant nation How were other areas of Karachi settled?
There are many Pathan territory in India such as state of Rampur and state of Bhopal and the oldest state was Rohillakhand which was rule by najib Khan Yousufzai. Pathan have state in india at the time of Mughal empire. But due culture change they speak Urdu language in India.
Thanks.
Please don't deny about it.
Rampur is not pathan terroritary. There is no pathan terroritary in India.
@@MukeshPanicker Respected Sir,
This is the history the link for rohilla state of Rampur is given below:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rampur,_Uttar_Pradesh#:~:text=founded%20in%201775.-,Originally%20it%20was%20a%20group%20of%20four%20villages%20named%20Kather,Khan%20ruled%20for%2020%20years.
Secondly Bhopal state of Pathan rulers the link is below:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_State
Rohillakhand state of Pathan in which there is bareilly, Moradabad etc. The link is given below:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohilkhand
Thanks.
There is difference between present claim and history of a particular place maybe rampur was a territory of Pathan in past but currently that area has different land owners you can’t say particular caste or community control all the territory. If you go by the history then entire Afghanistan Pakistan were part of Mauryan empire but today it is not the case. Harshvardhan controlled vast area of central Indian peninsula and Buddhist king Kanishka also ruled over Afghanistan but today you can’t find Buddhist territory in Afghanistan.
@@Vishwajeetvpsingh
Respected Sir,
I completely agree with your point of view now there is no princely state there I was taking about history and I also know that Mauryan have ruled Afghanistan also there is a great Buddhist civilization near by swat region.
Moreover, there are stupas of Buddhist community are and very religious place for Buddhism also for Hinduism.
However, now history changes on both sides.
Thanks.
@@ArbazKhan-hr5rg gentleman you used present tense ‘’ there are many PATHAN territory in India” instead of there were many; that’s why I tried to correct you. Podcasters already established the fact that there were Pathan or central Asian territories in India in past but they were talking in present context that pathans identity is not restricted to a particular territory in India they live all over India and but in Pakistan they are limited to norther Pakistan near Pashtun belt. Indian pathan can be a Marathi GUJARATI OR RAJASTHANI they assimilated with the population and culture of India but in Pakistan it appears from the podcast that they have pasto identity in Pakistan and are not considered Sindhi balochi or punjabi. I hope you understand the crux of the difference discussed in podcast.
@3:55 I have watched the previous videos as well, it was very insightful even though i have no relation with Karachi or Sindh. But, with all due respect, calling Gandhi a "leader of Hindus" is so incorrect, he always represented every Indian (United India of that time). Infact, this was the reason why he lost his life as was considered too pro-Muslims by some. So, please read about this a little.
who told you gandhi was leader of hindus?.
there is no place in the world where there is no any discrimination, racism. how this guest can say that India has no discrimination. and pathan movie didn't face any problem while releasing.
There are so many bones of contention with this episode, apart from the total disgraced that so called Muhajirs proposed for the creation of Pakistan when in fact the populous of now territorial Pakistan had differing opinions. Muhajirs aren’t only a Urdu speaking community but the majority of Urdu speakers hijacked the electoral base.
Well said brother.
This Father-Son duo are doing nothing but peddling lies in the name of podcast. Fooling people around with their half baked knowledge! 😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂آدھا سچ آدھا
جھوٹ.
nice content bro love u
Do a podcast on stand-up comedy
Do you need to realize that Urdu was a reason for the death of millions of Bengali’s. This elitist Lukhnavi/Aligarh culture resulted in the imposition of one language for a multi-lingual nation of Muslims. 🤦🏻♂️
Bro your content is great but me being from India I wish to see the visuals too like when your Abba is talking you should show some visuals this will have more impact to your videos and the podcast I don't wish to compare Abt your counterparts from India but they have an dialogue along with visuals it will help us as Indians to see and visualize our beautiful or say dark past of life ... Thanks Jai Hind
نواب آف بھوپال افغانستان کے صوبه هرات کے پشتون قوم کی شاخ نورزئی سے تعلق رکھتے تھے
ys plz next episode from bhutto rule
aaj kal hamir mir ki aik vedio clip social media per virol he jis me woh batata he k karachi me 1947 sy qabl fulan fulan buildings thin mahjron ne karachi ko kia dia tu mqm ki khushbakht shujaat kehti he ke han habib bank plaza aur mazar e quaid k siwa kuch nahi dia halanke aisa nahi he 1947 ke baad mahjron ny more than 100 colleges and more than 1000 schools banaye ,industries ka net work lagaya.hosptial,blood bandk,labs,masaji o madaris,new areas like liaquat abad,nazimabad,new karachi,north karachi,korangi,shah faisal colony,gulshan e iqbal,gulistan e johar gulshan e maimar etc banay aap se request he hamid mir ka bharpor jawab den aur aik video banaden thanks
Bhai establishment kei kehna par yeibsaraa podcasts huu rahaa. Yei script writwr koi likh dee raha haa kei mahjaroon kei khilaaf bakwas karoo. Yei sub establishment karwa rahee haa. Mei punjabi tasleem karta huu 2014 karachi operation was biggeat foul play. ❤
Daniyal bahi next podcast on buttho. How buttho racism affects Karachi. Eamring of MQM, and MQM, MQM MANIFESTO, IS MQM fulfill their promises, Discuss in detail, other ethnic groups of Karachi and clashes.(WHAT is pakka qila , what is mahijir camp) etc
Buttho kya hai?
Abhijeet Sir plz Sir ek bar inhe bulao
vote for jin or jaduu part 2
@8:40 LK Advani was never a president sir.
Daniyal bhai aapke yaha Choot ko kya bolte hai??
Hindu, Muslim, Sikh , Eesaai... sub ka Pakistan...!!!! hosakta hai... agar suno to...
Hindustan me Qaum parasti isliye nahi hai kyunki waha har zaban ko azadi hai apne Soobe me isliye wo relax hain jabki tum jese logo ne Bharat se aakar yaha pure multicultural mulk me urdu thopi or Punjabi , Sindhi, Bengali, Pashto, Balochi etc zubano ko dabane ki koshish ki gayi.
Zahir si baat hai jesa boge wesa hi katoge ullo ke pathoo. Pakistan kal ka bana mulq hai jabki ham Sindhi, Pathan, Baloch hazaro salo se hain.
Panjabi sab se tasoobi Quam hai . They hate Karachi .
Pakistani youtubers: Islam! Islam!. Pagal ho kya 😂
Yeh log Islam Islam karta hai lekin kitne musalmano ne ek doosre ka gala kata hisap nhi 😂😂....itna obsession apne religion ke uppar ki aadmi jitna bhi bura ho,lekin musalman hota toh gunaah maaf 😂😂...baad mein wohi aake gala kaata hai......
Abhijeet Sir plz Sir ek bar inhe bulao