Jinnah, Nehru and the Great Game of Partition - Faisal Warraich - Dekho Suno Jano -
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 тра 2024
- Faisal Warraich is a Storyteller who runs Pakistan's most popular UA-cam channel on Politics and History, "Dekho Suno Jano".
Faisal Warraich comes on The Pakistan Experience to discus the History of Pakistan, from Partition to the Afghan Jihad, and the current political crisis. On this episode, we also discuss Faisal Warraich's personal journey from wanting to go to Afghanistan, to reading books and launching 'Dekho Suno Jano'.
Was the creation of Pakistan part of the Great Game?
Did Nehru want Pakistan to be created?
Did Russia want to invade Pakistan?
Is there any hope in the Pakistani system?
Find out this and more on this week's episode of The Pakistan Experience.
Follow Faisal Warraich:
/ @dekhosunojano
/ @faisal.warraich
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
2:00 Developing an interest in History
6:00 1857 and the Partition Movement
11:30 Aligarh Movement and the British plan
16:00 Muslim League and Partition
21:00 Great Game and the Garrison State
27:30 Jinnah and Gandhi
30:30 Indus History and Nation Building after Partition
45:00 Why couldn’t Pakistan be a Nation of Nations
49:00 Russia, Afghanistan and Pakistan
51:30 United States, Nehru and Pakistan
1:00:00 Establishment, the Youth and Narrative Forming in Pakistan
1:08:45 Faisal Warraich’s fascination with Afghanistan and Jehad
1:17:00 Faisal Warraich’s childhood and the books he read
1:26:00 Why did Faisal Warraich start Dekho Suno Jaano
1:31:30 Finding the “truth” in History
1:41:30 Kabhi “phone” aya hay Faisal Warraich ko?
1:43:30 Audience Questions - Розваги
Dear Shehzad Ghias, I wanted to extend my heartfelt gratitude for inviting me to your podcast and engaging in such an insightful conversation. Your thoughtful questions and the platform you provided allowed for an enriching discussion that I truly enjoyed. I also want to express my appreciation to the viewers and everyone who took the time to comment on the podcast. Your interest and engagement have made this experience even more rewarding. 💝🕊
Sir hum toh aap kay fan hay..it was an honour and a pleasure for us. Thank you so much boss ❤
Follow Faisal Warraich:
www.youtube.com/@DekhoSunoJano
www.youtube.com/@Faisal.Warraich
Faisal Sir !!! Please make that video on Rationality how we lost it & how we can gain it again as you said in the last 🙏🏻 Thanks for your precious time ❤
1 suggestion for both of u, u can talk as freely as u want about politics, establishment etc but be careful about talking about ur religious beliefs, 1 minute kelye muje laga Faisal bhai thoda zyada kehgaye which wasn't required.
Bhai ziada nahen kaha main samjh sakta hon kion k jis bachpan k romance ko faisal ny enjoy kia hy ham bhi ussi mohobat k aseer thy or ab ja k samjh aaya k jb parha samjha or daikha or aakhir main socha k aytadal hi asal hy or deen bhi aytadal ki nasihat krta hy Jo bhi kaam aytadal sy hat jata hy wo nuqsan dyta hy ab issy ap aytadal kahain ya secularism han issy murad ya iski side laykr agr nangay hona chahain gy to wo phr extremism hoga aytadal ya secularism nahen hoga
Marathas defeated Mughal and ruled near 60-80 years and then East India Company took India from Marathas by defeating.
Thank you for this Podcast. I always knew my history even when no one told me. Finally, someone said we belonged with Indus Valley, and this podcast made almost 500k people aware of it.
So you are Hindu and converted Muslim, thank god now you know and you'll think twice before killing innocents
Waisal is good but other is gandoo arsto
I am an Indian and had seen most of the videos of Faisal Warraich. I was appreciative of the detailing and his honesty in narrating them. After seeing this podcast, I understand why he made such honest videos. He is a rare Pakistani who is so balanced and well versed in his domain. Wish there were many more like him in Pakistan. That would end the unnecessary animosity between our nations.
Thank you. Can you now point out the rare Indian who is balanced?
@@AwaisKhan-bf7pf valid question.
@@AwaisKhan-bf7pf the lost is toooo lonnnng.
@@AwaisKhan-bf7pf Indians with an open mindset like Mr. Warraich are in millions. Can't list them out. That is why India is progressing so rapidly !! You too need to open your mind and contribute to building a prosperous Pakistan.
Emotions always block the rationalism
Thanks for bringing people like Faisal warraich, dr umar saif, syed Muzammil, adeel and many more to your podcast. They are gems of the society.
🙌
ua-cam.com/video/ufOXuuCineQ/v-deo.html
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
Umer Abbas, hm Pakistani Sach ne sun sktay.
Munafic log, Faisal itna ghalat bhe ñahi😮 kr Raha. Pakistan hmara watan inshallah hmesha qaim rahay ga inshallah.hm log sch ka hosla rkhen
If am rude so sorry bro
It gives me immense joy to observe that the youth of Pakistan is trying to figure out the actual 'nature' of things instead of needlessly kneading the dough of religion. The people, especially the literate youth, of Pakistan with their thrust on scientific methods will most certainly change the destiny of this nation. Best wishes and love from Amritsar, Shehzad.
🙌
But I am not joyed by seeing religious extremism in India, don't you look them they manipulate history with their religion.
@@gujjo9825so who will be the khalifa? Mindless ideology will give you nothing.
@@gujjo9825We are "Republic"
@@gujjo9825Humme Democracy ki taraf shift hona chahiye Republic ka koi faida nahi hai
I am from India, Faisal is outstanding in the logic with which he understands a historical situation
Faisal sab about Kashmir Jihad is a story of me and my age group friends,he reminded me my childhood and childhood friends those who got brain washed and lost their lives,it's one of the best Podcast i have ever heard,thanks a million for inviting such a intellect ❤
❤❤❤
As a Bengali from West Bengal(Kolkata), India, i must say good to see that pakisthani youth can think like this. ❤
They are just 1 percent of typical pakistani..
Jab pet me roti nhi hoti tab aise baatein hi hoti hai. Jis din inn pakistaniyo ke pass paisa aaya they will get back to their usual business i.e. terrorism.
Bro fight against jihadi and recent tanatani hindutva in Bengal.....( That's where the state youths are going with communal politics)
@@nikhildeshmukh6221Marathis are very selfish and frugal plus they feel like their language is superior than others but actually every language should be respected
@@abhishekarya5685 any community which feels threatened about their identity should fight.... We are known for that spirit.... be it against Mughals, british or bramhins, indian government.......south india is developed mentality only because they preserved their language and culture ....if this hindi hindu hindustan naara was succeeded in Maharashtra....we also would have ended up like UP bihar zarkhand MP rajasthan hryana.....hindi killed those states by sucking their culture and literature....and then enters bjp and congress with their exclusive,hatred ideas of secularism and hindutva. Think over this
I am from India. Loved this episode with Faisal. Really appreciate thought process of Faisal on how emotions played important role in History of Indian Subcontinent and is being used again by various players of this region, bringing instability in region.
Kudos to 'The Pakistan Experience ' for touching important historical aspect of this region
You'll definitely an anti pakistan and anti muslim podcast
amazed to see you are not surprised or dusgusted by his lack of real know-how of India, he was crying about Modi and RSS all along. . . shows his sheer lack of knowledge of Modi and his policies as well as RSS and its functioning!
I disagree with the facts that he lined up for India. Definitely not true and shows his lack of depth of knowledge in context of India.
Ita refreshing to hear pak perspective about itself from within.
Behind every evil is a dynastic politician
Behind abrahimism is dynastic rule and fake god
which facts? India trying to transition from secular to Hindu state or some other?
Happy to see, there are such type of Pakistani Youth also. You are the real and Rare Hope of The Pakistan as Nation 🙏!
Realy good and logical talk from this gentleman Guest!
Faisal bhai really gets emotional while discussing past, present and future of Pakistan. I can clearly feel pain through his facial expressions.
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
I have studied in a school where recruitment days were organised for Afghan n Kashmir Jihaad. My father used to protest it as teacher but wahan JI k log was his biggest opponents
yes JI people are goons ..
😮😮 really can you tell me more about this
Much Love from India. Your country needs guys like you to educate the young ones of your country.
❤
Ya it's time to come back United
@@yjkbuddyexactly
@@urrasscal8380Cry louder. They will remain there and make you cry every day. 😂
In Computer Science and Information Technology. I agree completely. If you are talking about history, Indians are stoned on fake news by Goswami et al., but they're doing just fine.
Thank you so much Faisal bhai & Shahzad bhai So glad to learn so much about ourselves and another side of our history. I greatly appreciate the idea of being a "دریائے سندھ کے بچے "...I believe we still have time and a lot of potential to change our thoughts and way of thinking for the betterment of our future
🙌
Impressed with the level of knowledge and the demonstration of maturity and unbiased analysis... He identifies the true root cause of the conflict between Pak and Bharat
He is a very learned man.. u should bring him more often.. meanwhile also subscribing to dekho suno jano...
Loved this podcast out and out... ❤
Love from India 🇮🇳
❤
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
Love from India mane? 😂Uni Indiar e lok, from West bengal
This guy is incredible. I didn't think you could top some of your best podcasts. This is the best! By far
🙌
First pakistani knows his real history
@Faisal.warraich after watching this video im big fan of your...❤❤❤..I love you ideology ...sir aap ki ek ek baat dill ko chhuliya .... I'm from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳...aap se bohat kuch sikhne ko mila ...taa pa mere guru hua ....ap ko mera pranam 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sir- I have from India and a regular follower of your podcast. And in my opinion it is is one of the best podcast you have made till date and followed by me.. It is a Pathfinder for every youth of India and Pakistan..
As an Indian found this discussion very fascinating. Binge watched entire 2 hours.
@@urrasscal8380 andhbhakt rattled. LOL.
Andhbhakto ki wajhe se hi gdp itna hai India ka 🤣.
@@fredrickdemello2260this guy made so many blunders in most of the topics he covered, he literally said muslims believed congress as hindu party while most of the muslims voted for congress but not muslim league until Jinnah started communal speeches for second election😅
@@fredrickdemello2260chamche 😂
Just finished it and Yeah man I'm kinda Hopeful
My God! I am transported by the intellectual content of this podcast. I had in an earlier post congratulated the interviewer. And, his guests are intellectual gems. Can’t get enough.
❤
Shehzad Ghias, you are one of the best interviewer, after you’ve asked the question you allow your guest to finish his answer and his story before you ask another question👍🏼. Most interviewers interrupt and want to show they also are wise and knowledgable. Your thoughtful questions, your listening skills and patience is what makes you standout from the others👏🏼 Faisal bhai is an asset for Pakistan, his channel is one the best❤️👍🏼
❤
After Adeel Afzal this is the masterpiece podcast.. Very honest, to the point , deep knowledge.. hats off you...best wishes from India 🇮🇳
🙌
Adeel Afzal podcast had so many lies....
It had rookie level mistakes. I was so disappointed listening to that.....
@@nitishsingh8005true
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
@@nitishsingh8005 yes..At some point, Adeel Afzal doesn't have a neutral logic.. He targeted Patel for partition of Punjab...but never targeted Britishers and Zinnah for partition. And behind the partition of India there is a geopolitical strategy of Britishers nothing else.. Britishers want a country in this region to secure their interest to stop the USSR in this region... The Public doesn't want any partition...
Destroyed entire hindu buddhist heritage in Afghanistan 😢
In 1970s many cities were thriving with hindus and sikhs
Now it feels like they never even existed there everything was destroyed 😢
Read sai deepaks india bharat pakistan the constitutional journey of a sandwiched civilization
Will understand the seeds of two nation theory
In afganistan not just budh , shiks , or hindus , heritage were distroyed but mosques homes buildings hospitals and Schools .
We're distroyed.
But from all of this
About 4 5 lak's of innocent people were killed you fool.
And you are talking about buildings.
Which were no greater than a human life.
@@zeo.AWhy were they destroyed genius? Will you call out the ideology?
Pakistani hamesha apne aap ko kisi bhi tara sahi hi kehate hau😅
@@shreekannadati1455
Ab Pakistani 🇵🇰 ki bat achi nahi lagti.
To ya dhak lo ka wo ak human b ha.
Muj jasa insan ap jssay differences par mabni biyan ya insaf nahi karta.
Without being a Pakistani 🇵🇰.
It's a true human kills humans by themselves and calls it bravery.
A disgusting think it is.
Do you know it's a reality that .
Jis ki leadership ho
Minority ko deficulties mlti hain .
In india/Pakistan/ or somewhere else.
Wish there are more from either side to understand our history in perspective. One of the best interviews I have seen. .. the person is so honest and much evolved.
I am from India and I love historical subjects personally. And I am delighted to hear the commenter to have such a good deep knowledge of history of combined India and Pak. Kudo Faisal waris.
Pausing this at 1:16:39 to comment. I am simply mind blown by the candid admission of creating trouble in Indian Kashmir. Esp. during Musharraf. I mean, I have never heard any Pakistani make such an emotional confession of events he has witnessed. When militancy peaked in Kashmir, it snatched away all light and hope from there. Kashmiris can possibly never forgive those who enabled this.
Search about Harris Sultan. He too explained how he almost became a terrorist. They had open terrorist camps for training.
Back here in India students were getting trained for IT companies and in Pakistan they had other on campus placements.
@@Malik-oe6md We? Whom are you representing?
Assuming you could be either Hindu or Muslim. Malik’s normally were Hindu Punjabis. Later on some converted.
@@Malik-oe6md understood. I was referring to your comment which I guess you deleted where you said we’re not happy with both India and Pakistan. I was wondering which community you were representing with we. I would’ve never asked if you used I instead.
Nevertheless 👍🏻
@@VijilGuptathat's why you can see their state of affairs. Karma !!!
@@Malik-oe6mdI know both Pakistan and India didn't do justice to you guys. Hope things get better for all of you soon. I pray. From an Indian.
I have never heard such unbiased analysis and a rationale regarding 2 nation theory...we need many such discussions..more power to you!
🙌
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
@@muhammadumerabbasi878 abe aaa chuitye hamara desh jal ra h or tu pak ki parvi karrs h stupid old grumppy man
Love to see Pakistani learning from this great in depth knowledge of waris bhai... Every Pakistani should listen to this atleast once a week and hurray all your problems as a nation gonna start disappearing sooner
Form every video of Faisal Warraich I learn a new perspective of History. ❤
Never heard a more agreeable person especially on these topics. History is really a teacher like no other, now we are finding out that he had personal experience to boot.
🙌
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
You can’t be more honest and relatable. Great work indeed. You should continue to invite him;
❤
@@urrasscal8380 Mat Bol Bhai Unko Yeh Sab.
Ek Toh Woh Gandey Nafrati Religion Se Acchay Religion Ki Taraf Jaa Raha Hai
Aur Tu Uska Mazaak Bana Raha Hai ..
I also used to comment like you, but i learnt, that it's best to spread positivity.
@@Health-BlitzIf they get educated, they will stop supporting their enemies like the Afghans, Arabs and Turks, and start appropriating our icons like Puru to Chandragupta up to Ranjit Singh to Bhagat Singh. Imagine some random Lahori telling us Ye Chanakya or Ye Panini hamare eschool ka Professor tha.
@@AjitJoshi686 It will never happen on a mass scale.
At most some of their Elites, who are less than 0.001 % of the population will follow this way.
Can you ever imagine it happening on mass scale in their society where they have the lowest levels of tolerance on earth for a country.
@@AjitJoshi686 Thier Army uses 1. Islam, 2. Fear of India, 3. Propaganda to show their Army as protectors to keep control over the population.
So they will never let Option ( 1 ) slip out of their hands.
Its unimaginable brother 😂
And we are 1.2 Billion Hindus, Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists✌
I have learned so much from Faisal bhai. I've been watching him for 3 years almost. He has made me more curious and especially his narration in FSW vlogs has given me a growth mindset.
I am from India.. And I am very impressed of his thoughts and knowledge 👌
My cousins r waraich in India they r jat sikhs. Good to see same surname ppl beyond borders. My surname is Toor. Even this surname is in Pakistan. My many relatives have surnames of Bajwa, sidhu and Khosa. All the surname ppl r still in Pakistan. I wish prosperity for all.
They are all Muslims now, and they relate themselves to Arabs and other Islamic States, Better for u to forget the past because they never accept their Hindu/Sikh identity
Ye indians ko lagta ha k hamaray surname or caste b change ha sab topi daal kr bomb bnana sikhtay ha.
All belongs to same ancestors.
They got converted. Your line of ancestors didn't.
Your so called cousins are converted by force or greed or coercion etc and now they happily marry their immediate cousins , underage girls , eat beef , hate kaffirs etc etc
Another one of the episodes that I want every school student to watch carefully ❤
❤
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
I started watching and could not change the channel . 2 hrs gone in sometime . This guy is must watch for all South Asians .
I am an Indian scholar of economics and history...congratulations Mr. WARAICH, you came as a fresh breeze in the drought
Of sense and facts in the official and oft discussed Pak narrative on history! Bless you.
As an Indian,This guy breaks the stereotype of Pakistanis being irrational. Only honest conversations like this will bring permanent peace between India and Pakistan. God bless this guy for starting such kind of conversation.
🙌
Lol Indian are irrational not Pakistani can have a debate on this.
😂
पाकिस्तान में ऐसे समझदार विचारशील जागरूक नागरिक सदैव ही रहें हैं। विभाजन के दौर में साम्प्रदायिक सोच पर हत्या करनेवाले लोगों का विरोध करने का साहस किया था मगर उनकी चर्चा करनेवाले और सुनने वाले मंच नहीं थे।
आप फ़ैज़ अहमद फ़ैज़ को पढ़िए।
Breath of fresh air. Faizal was quite right about someone being stigmatized as traitor and emotion over reality. Very surprised to hear such sane voices. Kudos to Shehzad, you are so cool and composed. Your questioning and methodically running the podcast is amazing.
🙌
Quite Right
Wacthed this episode multiple times. One of the best podcasts I have ever watched. What a balanced, rational, and objective analysis. Hats off to this man Mr Warraich. The only way to educate ourselves and get to the truth is to start reading all kind of books irrespective of our religious beliefs.
Listened it second time... what a brilliant podcast learnt a lot today from faisal warraich...thanks shehzad for such conversation.❤
❤️
I want a logical answer to this question - The British came to India as traders and captured the whole of India. We fought for the freedom of our country India. In 1947 the British agreed to leave India and moved from Mumbai to England. Before leaving India, they divided its land into three parts, 1. India 2. West Pakistan 3. East Pakistan. Now the question is that , you will not find anywhere in history that when the British came to India, a country named Pakistan existed. When the name of Pakistan came into existence after the partition of India, then how can this celebration be called Independence Day instead of Foundation Day? Technically Pakistan was never under the rule of the British Government. That's why this day should be called India's Independence Day and Pakistan's Foundation Day.
Agree...
Well India was never a single state before Britishers . . . Only during two rulers India operated as a single administration, Ashoka the great and Akbar the great
@alihaider5190 how conveniently you people forget Shivaji Maharaj, the great.
@@preethamkumar125 he nvr really ruled . Marathas conquered punjab n soon after lost it in no time
@@alihaider5190India was always a commonwealth with a common culture
You guys are doing great service to your nation and the humanity. Wish you all the best!
Bhai ye shehzad bari thin ice p khel raha hai. Iska channel band honay k qareeb hai 😢
Why are you so concerned about Pakistan? Do you know their idea of humanity, Hinduism and coexistence??
Pakistan is not part of Indian culture, we have islamic arab persian turkish kurdish afghan morrocon libyan uzbek and chinese culture@@ThePakistanExperience
@@user-wm9ti8fk7vcan you stop all this nonsense and listen to them with compassion
I am a Bangladeshi and I thoroughly enjoyed this podcast and it is satisfying to hear some of my opinions on the effect of WW2 building the partition narrative voiced in such an articulate manner by Faisal bhai.
Really liked the episode. Probably my first time listening to a perspective from Pakistan. Keep going guys!
This one was seriously one of the best podcast ever. Didn’t even realise when the whole 2 hours went by. I was planning on sleeping after work but then this happened 😂
❤
Hope you are Pakistani.
True, same here
@@akashvalsan6609 I am not
Raja Porus's name was Raja Purshottam 😊
Greek Called him Porus
I am from Bharat. Amazed to listen Faisal. His analysis of Nehru on partition is absolutely correct and his knowledge of Indus valley civilization is also great. Partition was greatest mistake.
Absolute true
Faisal is a very knowledgeable person..My fullest respect to him….
Bhai India has been here for thousands of years. We are known for our civilization, culture and religion not because of any one river.
There is no existence as such as "India" before 1947. Before 1947, it was a land that was amalgamation of various princely states.
@@muhammadfaridzamir867 Bharatvash suna hai?
@@muhammadfaridzamir867even Hindu hymns also talk about Zambudweepa, Bharatha Varsh. Just because some one gave name India doesn't take away anything about the concept of India.
@@muhammadfaridzamir867 tujhe apne islamic identity ko protect karne ke liye princely state ka concept pasand hai par hamee United India under New Delhi Administration ka Concept pasand hai
@@muhammadfaridzamir867 lol living in a dream or what?? Ever heard of arabs..they did existed in different political fraction still their identity is what Arabs same Is for whites today's west of Europe or the slavs..that are Russians Ukranian Georgian..or the nordics which were finland Iceland and Denmark..
So pls keep this shit idiotic brain of mixing culture and Identity that to just idea of a nation state..
When talked about Bharat it's Indian land for Indic people from the spanse of hindukush to the seas in South
While Pakistani Muslims acknowledge ancestory to,Porus, Chandragupta Maurya, Chanakya…Indian Muslims still call them children of Arab. Faisal has put forward the facts very candidly. Loved this episode. Wish we have more people like Faisal in India and Pakistan. Love u brother 👍
Who says that? I have seen many Indian Muslims who proudly call themselves Arabs. You probably heard it from Indian media which deliberately bring those kind of people.
Not all Pakistani Muslims brother.
Only some.
Bhai koi india ke muslim apne aapko aarab nahi samjte.
Tum ko ye sab juth BJP it cell ki whatsapp univercity padhaya gaya hai.
We Indian Muslim never said that we are children of Arab..
We are proudly converted to Islam from worshipping idol (what you make as God).
You even didn't know who is the real creator of this universe-Brahmand*.
You Hindutavas support this Golu for his left views that criticize mostly the creation of Pakistan and sometimes Islam.
His most of viewers are Hindutva supporters from india want to make this subcontinent Akhand Bharat Hindu Rastra*
When your book, God, prophet is Arabic , tho arabee hee banega. Loyalty to a country where they are minority is a concept alien to Islam and its followers. An Indian Muslim can never feel the patriotism that everyone else naturally does. For them ummah is ultimate.
History lover can relate with this guy's....🎉
wah.. what a start.. space and history... love it from an Indian
🙌
Uffff !!!!!…..Faisal Warraich!!!!!…what a storyteller you are. Spoke for almost 2 hours with such energy and enthusiasm. It was so riveting that I managed to watch the entire episode without a break. Your background and experience also made podcast so interesting. And, Shehzad Ghias…what an incredibly skilled podcaster you are!!! How deftly you change your role based on the profile of your guest…Fantastic!!!!
❤
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
I was thinking the same thing about us disowning our history of subcontinent and now hearing the same thoughts ..So loving it😍
History of sindh civilization...not subcontinent
@@dourbeendo u think the people from sindh and the people of Indian subcontinent are different 😮? Nu bro this not 😊
@@s..2062 indus valley civlization / sindh had toilets and sanitation system 5000 years ago.
@@dourbeen also chankya acharya chandrgupt .. punjab rulers...they are portraid as evil people but instead they were the real heros of our land and we should own them instead of making a fake conncection with The middle east ... (talking bout political nd historical connection. besides islamic connection . It is , nd will be .. forever... )
Faisal bhai knows a lot more history than my history teacher without reading any book/s when telling the story. I would be very happy if Faisal bhai comes to visit India, especially to see their Quaid-e-azam's mansion in Mumbai which he never gave up even after formation of Pakistan. And I hope to see such awesome podcasts in the future too.
You are Right because that history teacher is your Father And You His Student ........... Teacher and Student Both ................ A BIG ZERO 👌👌👌👌👌👌🤣🤣🤣🤣😁😁😂😂
Iam an ideological Pakistani.A combined Subcontinent(India,Pakistan,Bangladesh) has almost 40 percent muslim population. The best n easiest solution wud have been to allocate proportional 'quota' in each n every State institution for muslims in a 'United India'.
Ex Indian External Affairs minister late Mr Jaswant Singh's research book on this subject is a must read for anyone interested in objective insight. Mr Jaswant Singh lays the blame pretty much squarely on Indian National Congress leadership of the time(Mr Nehru in particular) for the 'Partition' !!
👌🙌✨This is the first time I've watched your podcast from start to end. You are an incredibly humble and patient listener. Throughout the two-hour duration of this extensive podcast, you spoke for only about 5-7 minutes, generously allowing your amazing, insightful, and intellectual guest to express themselves for the full 2 hours. Keep up the fantastic work, dear.
🙌
This is one of the best podcasts on the partition of India, The speaker was logical and rational in his perspectives, and one of the best points he said: "We are children of Indus Valley civilization". We need more people like him on both sides of the border, to talk about the partition logically and that going to heal the wounds of the partition on both sides......keep on doing more such podcasts ❤ from India...Jai Hind
❤
Are you Sindhi or kashmiri? If not then you have no connection to Indus valley. Ganga jamnis south India and Chinese burmese regions of so called Northeast India has no connection to Indus valley. India was created by the British. Kashmir is a natural part of Harappa Pakistan for 1000's of years. I bet you don't know over 95% of Pakistanis are natives of this land now called Pakistan. Only less than 5% came from Ganga jamuna.
@@sabrinakhan8217 kashmir has fuckall to do with Indus Valley culture and the IVC has sites that connect it to the Ganga Yamuna doab - the largest IVC site found is in India and another along the Yamuna.
@@AKumar-co7oe No it doesn't. Ask South Indians. They hate indus valley and its kingdoms. Kingdoms from northwest ( current Pakistan) like Maurya, Porus, Dahir, Pithiviraj etc have always invaded , plundered and killed ganga Jamuna. Mauryans alone killed 5 million ganga jamnis. Northwest ( current Pakistan) have always trade and cultural ties with Central Asia and invasions towards Ganga jamuna.. Tamil Tigers didn't want to call themselves Hindus ( ppl of Indooz Indus Sindh) until Indra gandhi bombed them thrice. What about rat and snake eating Chinese burmese states of so called Northeast India captured by the British? Don't they deserve freedom? Remove the British given armies and then see what is left of British created india.
@sabrinkhan8217
ReLigion is an evil construct, a gang/legion created in 1600 years back to grab REgal political power to enslave, rob, ra*pe and deracinate natives. First such gang hijacked Jewish theology and enticed crooks & criminals among Jews with plum postings in the service of Roman enslavers. A fake narrative was created that a Jew killed the fake invented son of God. Romans gave license to keep Jews as slaves. These brutalized rootless MidEasterns were used to attack & enslave European natives by calling them Pagan. Arabs saw the success of Romans in creating an evil empire for one VatiCunning Pope & Roman king, so they copied Romans and created more brutal criminal gang and thus started complete brutalization, genocide, slavery especially sex-slavery of natives all over the world. All lands West of India got brutalized, enslaved & deracinated. The wealth of the West & Turkey is based on loot & plunder of natives especially India. Marxism is later day AbraHarami gangs. It also deracinates the converts and makes them rootless parasite like Islam & Christianity. Rootless parasites might get training to be Doctors, Engineers, Accountants and Civil Servants but they can't get rid of hate for everything native. They are anti native & so anti-national by design. ISIS, Al Kids, Naxals & Christian EvanJihadis are threat to nation building. China was smart it put burkha of Marxism and killed Islam & Christianity in China. Colonialists and their deep state aka Neo East India Company can't partition China, can't create CashMere, East Timore or Kuki Land out of Xinjiang.
China treats MohMadism as Mental disease, so puts MohMadden males in concentration camps like mental asylums and uses MohMadden wombs to breed Haan Chinese kids. Neo East India Company mastered use of Islam as Weapon of Mass Destruction by breeding Khalifas like Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah, Khalifa Al Lootyani ConAngrez Taimurid-Mughal Fake-KaamRaid Bandit NoWheru to create first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent) called Pakistan and second ISIS using Khalifa Al Baghdadi.
Ghar Wapasi & growing native roots is the only solution.
Loved listening to Faisal. Quite impressing journey he had with life and his eagerness to look for pure truth. Love from Bharat.
Modi is an elected leader of India. Not a single rupee corruption can be alleged against him. Not a single member of his family including his mother took any state benefits. RSS is an ideology …it’s not anti Muslim. We are never in denial of our past or our historical mistakes. We admire and adore our diversity i🇮🇳
I must say one thing bro....apko dekh ke aisa lgta hai pakistan ka kuch future hai wrna mujhe to lg rha tha ki Pakistan syria iraq Afghanistan bn jayega...keep it bro i wish you will be success
This should be included in high school history classes. What a wonderful podcast
❤
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
Its a wish coz we live in Pakistan
What gems these two guys are. It was an eye opening podcast
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
He completely forgot the marathas . Dont trust him😂
As a south indian, I wish I understood urdu/punjabi enough to get the full import of this podcast. From whatever I understood, I'm happy to see the pakistani youth questioning what they've been fed all these years. India has also been going through a similar churn, un-learning what was taught to us by the gandhi-nehru's left wing bullshit.
Problem is with your mindset and not with Congress left wing mindset. What policy of BJP is different?. Yes, the only different bit is supporting a few tycoons like adani. All of the others (industrialists) can't raise their voice on anything (decision making). Be it mgnrega, Foreign policy, FDA from abroad. Only one more difference is borrowing from wall street and USA for infra structure building. If you doubt that then check the level of debt in 2014 (49 %) to current 89% of gdp in 2022.
Do some fact checking before endorsing the bull shit delivered by Modi from any platform including RedFort. This guy (Modi) is shame less in lying unflinchingly in your face but travesty is his naive supporters endorsing him without checking anything. What Congress didn't do and BJP doesn't seem inclined to do and still claim itself to be a party of capitalism is privatisation of banks. Crony capitalism is the hallmark of BJP.
Ideally, if Congress was not derided so big, I would not have commented on a UA-cam channel of a Pakistani blogger. So, to avoid discussing India or somehow someone not pointing anything wrong there, one should not start attcking one element of its body politic .
We also know that you had no religion until the 19th century and Harappan civilization has no relation to the 1812 Sanathana Dharma/Hinduism.
hahahahaha.. very clear that u have not heard the entire podcast.
@@hawkingdawking4572 sanatan dharma is a culture,we were forced to make it a religion to protect from barberic Islamic invaders...well the truth is your ancestors were also hindus..
@@kanhaiyakumar-vh2un
There was no such Sanathana Dharma before the 19th century. You just copied that name from Budhists just like you copied the heavenly god, heaven-hell, anti-casteism, aversion to meat etc. Even your Chapati, Sabzi, Salwar, horses, shoes, swords, biriyani, blouses of goddesses, music, literature, Arabic laced mashup language, architecture are all given by foreign rulers. All you had was some weird stories and loin cloths. Even the 8th century folk story Ramayana and state god Rama became popularised in the Mughal era and were written on paper then.
Should have mentioned "Subhash Chandra boss the founder of INA(Indian national Army)" to fight against British, he even sought Hitler's help to fight British, you can see his pic with Hitler on Google
Bose
Bose even spoke German and gave a speech in German where the Japanese and German Leadership were Seated.
He had a german daughter as well
What an amazing well-read guy. Loved the perspective of life, history, politics and the subcontinent. Much respect from Delhi, India
You two are my favourite Pakistanis . Lets have more people like you on both sides of the border . We will be one again . .......one day . A nation beyond religion
Subhash chandr Bose and Ambedkar was also frustrated with Gandhiji
Love from india I think format of this show is brilliant
I never took your podcasts seriously. But this is definitely one of my most favourite videos on UA-cam. My mind is blown today. Massive respect to Faisal Warraich from 🇮🇪
Allah nei Kiya hi faraasat Ata ki hai Faisal ko ..m a fan of his series and first time Moka Mila interview mei dekhnay Ka toh or bhi inko research Jo ke shandaar wasee or bohat hi solid hai ..
Allah salamat rakhay Faisal apko and thanks for this talk 🎉
Shehzad dude, you're kittling it. All the guests you're getting on the show collectively are like a toolkit for awakening. great going man.
❤
Syed Muzammil and You two are real Gem of Pakistan. Main aap teeno ke channels ke sarey videos dekhta hoon.
❤
main toh chahta hun is podcast ko 10million like dedu love from India🇮🇳
What an amazing podcast. Hats off to you & your team for bringing such gems on your podcast.
❤
Glad to listen such insights, very deep and very intellectual....Loved it..... Best wishes from India 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
I'm a mbbs student from. Aiims madurai. I'm a big fan of fsw plz convey him that he should make a series on modern india history.
Love frm india you both r doing great work for your country
❤
Better watch Awadh Ojha history lessons or from Vikas Divya Kirti Sir
@@avinash7335-- That is biased history.
@@P.Babrah58and you think these pakistanis are unbiased 😂😂😂
Why do you want a history from a non Indian. Read Vikram sampath
Main reason of Divison ? English plan atleast 50 years ahead, Hindus also knew that with Muslims around they will never get India. Poonja Chap whom we fondly call Quaid e Azam was a Parsi, he was launched and his CV built up, initially it was said he is Agha Khani, but Ismalis did not accept him. So in1900 it was revealed he is a Sunni Muslim. Hindus were in the game , they started promoting Poonja Chap as a great Muslim leader. Secondly at end of WW2 Russia, who had defeated Germans , had 5 million strong well trained army and they could just march down to Indian Ocean., American and English , changed plans, Hindu leaders were tasked to create a fear of Hindu majority. Poonja Chap plaed his part. A buffer state using loyal subjects who helped English regain India in 1857 was created. Hindu Muslims had lived side by side for over 800 years, by inciting riots, Poonja Chap got 1.5 Million Muslim, Women, Children and men Slaughtered and handed India to Hindus, who never had any claims to rule
Initially English had planned to leave in June 1948, but were told Poonja Chap was about to conk off, so they left immediately in August 1947, Poonja declared independence on 14 August without knowing where are the borders. Once Poonja had played his part Border were announced on 17 August. Rest history we know
First time in Pakistan i have a love for a free thinker faisal warraich,,,,,great to listen ,,,, being bold ,,,,,being curious ,,,, plannable execution❤❤❤
"India is a democratic country with Hindu values " and it's different from your religious values we are secular by nature.
By the way, love your insight into ancient India 🇮🇳
do u have any unbiased podcast show,where they r discussing openly about bjps atrocities.plz recommend
@@imrikk1 watch wire
@@imrikk1Please try reading mainstream media and you will find the answer.
What Muslim face in India are not atrocities
but
they are no longer appeased by the government. Muslim strong- men are no longer able to encroach on public land , not able to sell smuggled stuff. .
@@imrikk1Mention BJP Atrocities that you believe are happening. I'm not talking about the Communal Riots, That happens in every nation which has diverse sects, religions, races and languages. I'm talking about direct action by the BJP Government that strategically discriminated against Muslims in India in Policy Making and Bureaucracy. BJP has done more for Muslims in India than any other party in the past decade. They have gone significantly higher in the HDI Index i.e Education, Health and Per Capita Income. Refute with Facts, Not Hocus Pocus and Delusions.
Why don't you list out the attrocities being committed by BJP over here...why do you want to hear it from others??? Or you just want to make noise???
For the past two days, I have been refreshing your UA-cam Channel / Alien Broadcast after 6-7 hours just to check if there is any new podcast. Finally, the most awaited podcast with Sir Faisal and the obvious Shehzada Shehzad Ghias. Thank you for this. Time to watch
I listen to this man from India. He is absolutely learned and I am glad to see such intellectual people come out of the subcontinent. I am glad learning the lessons life from a man that has had an interesting story behind him.
A country where more of such people are needed who can convey their thoughts with solid arguments. A gem
ask our narrative..jo ata hy pakistan ky khilaf bolna start..we challenge faisal warraich openly..
Well done guys 👏 I hope young Pakistanis listen to this kind of discussion, unlearn the made-up history that they have been taught in schools and colleges for petty politics, learn the real history, get rid of religious brain fog and work towards their nation building. Love and kudos to you guys from 🇮🇳 for discussing facts and history fearlessly ❤ 🙏
🙌
"Jo plan execution ke laik nhi hota woh plan nhi Khwahish hota hai" Beautifully said Faisal bhaaji... ❤❤ from. India
Faisal Waraich is a nutral true story teller. I Saw his many vedios on U tube about Kargil war and few other. His way of attrection of vewers is marvelous. Today I saw him live and much impressed.
Doctor Ishtiaq Ahmed boht achi baat kahi hai "selective history is not a history it's an ideology"
One of the best podcast I have heard till date. Binged watched the entire 2 hours as well. Hats off to excellent host/guest.
❤
To much interested and informative ❤🎉
I wish people like him get into mainstream politics of Pakistan and become a big leader. Pakistan deserves better.
After Istiaq Ahmed he is the second guy from Pakistan who I have seen has dedicated time and tried to learn history just as history. (There may be many like them but I know only the people who appear in Digital platforms.)
Istiaq Ahmed to aurangzeb ki praise karta firta hai ... Us bande se kya hi hope karna bhai....🙏
As an Indian am proud my ancestors choose akhand bharat for their best❤
But Pashtuns and Baluch are Iranians but other areas can be in your Bharat. Kashmiri language is also really close to Persian.
Wait for ghazwa e hind
@@Passque666 it's not about language it's about culture, in India own has tons of languages
@@arandomguy007 beta wo ho chuka now it's time for judgement day
@@tariqanwarofficial arry mere bete jab ghazwa e hind hoga na tab tab teri gaand chud chuki hogi.
I'm simply amazed listening to FW. Thank you SG for bringing up another great discussion. Much respect ❤
❤
Wow what a profound statement 'jo plan execution ke kabil na ho, wo plan nahi, khawaish hoti hai'
Nehru was convinced by the British due to his proximity with the Mountbattens that creating a buffer zone with Afghanistan was good for India’s stability. Maybe he was right but the other angle to this was the discomfort of the British with the Independence of such a large country with a huge population. Perhaps Nehru thought it wasn’t a big deal.