I actually bought a Carlisle 78% and sold a bottle of Carlisle new 82%… it’s not bad…but you can definitely smell the difference. The dry down is about the same.
Hi Erica, I started following you after seeing a video with Mr Smelly on 5 fragrances you hate. You mentioned Bleu de Channel and you caught my attention because I do not like it either. Today you mentioned Herod as one of you recent discoveries and that happens to be my favorite tobacco scent. Thanks for making it brief and to the point and for bringing new scents into the table. I am looking forward for your designer picks.
I think Herod is the king of PDM, but it does not get the hype like Layton, and there are cheaper fragrances on the niche/designer side that could replace it for folks like Mancera Red Tobacco, and Spice Bomb Extreme.
both of those just smell cheap compared to Herod you cant replace quality ingredients and art of blending with something for much lesser price and expect the same quality
Nothing is as cozy and warm as your smile! Okay, simp mode off: I hate Herod and all of Marly. Nothing beats the two best releases in the last 20 years: Tauer L'air du desert marocaine and Ganymede!
Love your choice 😃 My top 5 Ambre Tabac Daniel Josier Oud for Greatness Initio Parfums Ambra Jeroboam Oajan Parfums de Marly And nr one Rosendo Mateu Nº 5 😍
Who are these people who are constantly 'complimenting' other people's scents? Is that some creepy Miami old men thing? Or is it just another thing you picked up from Jeremy Fragrance since he's always saying such things?
I think it's just nice people! I was in a gallery on Thurs and a man asked me what I was wearing as he loved it and wanted some for himself, another time a lady in a small shop shouted from behind the counter, "Hey someone smells amazing, who is it? (Both Sedley) another time I was going to umpire a ladies field hockey game and as I walked to put my things down a player said "Oh my God is that beautiful smell you? That's so gorgeous." Another time a lady shopkeeper walked down her store amd stood near me. She then just smiled and aaid "I just wanted to see who smelt so beautiful. I caught a whiff as you walked by and came to see who it was." She took the name to give to her son to buy (Both Naxos) These were complete strangers, nothing odd or sleazy, just nice compliments. I gave them the information with a smile and thanked all of them for taking the trouble to compliment me as it made my day. Mark
I don’t see why you’re not getting compliments with that pleasantly stellar personality of yours. Being a snarky jerk always lands me a grip of compliments.
I am a year late but "random compliment culture" isn't necessarily prevalent everywhere. In Texas, everybody minds their business. They do however love striking up conversations when shopping next to each other or standing in line for extended periods of time or nearly bumping into each other with their baskets.
I would have replaced Initio Side Effect with Initio Blessed Baraka. I bought a decant sample of it because of Jeremy Fragrance. It was on his top 10 niche fragrances for life list 3 years ago, and it was number 3 on his list. It is an Initio fragrance that is underrated and a niche masterpiece that not many people talk about. ua-cam.com/video/GZUg7hCAyGI/v-deo.html
The performance of side effect is SICK , absolutely beast.
An EXCELLENT fall list! Carlisle was an especially good choice!
Good list. I enjoy Initio Side Effect very much. Autumn...best season of the year.
Agreed!!
Black Sabbath...Iron Man and Paranoid...you've definitely heard them even if you didn't know it was Sabbath. Great video Erica.
PDM Oajan gets compared more to By Kilian Angels Share, not Carlisle.
Herod is on another level it’s my absolute favorite PdM incredible perfect 10
I have no issues with reformulated Carlise. If you think you do just macerate your bottle.
Finally another good fragrance channel🙏 subscribed
Thank you so much (:
I actually bought a Carlisle 78% and sold a bottle of Carlisle new 82%… it’s not bad…but you can definitely smell the difference. The dry down is about the same.
Is there any performance difference ?? How much longer does the old one last??
@@tracer073 no, they are about the same to me. Still a good performer
Most of these I really enjoy especially side effects and Zaharoff and Tony I is on the to buy list . Great video Erica !!
Yay, PDM & Initio. 🤩
❤️
Hi Erica, I started following you after seeing a video with Mr Smelly on 5 fragrances you hate. You mentioned Bleu de Channel and you caught my attention because I do not like it either.
Today you mentioned Herod as one of you recent discoveries and that happens to be my favorite tobacco scent.
Thanks for making it brief and to the point and for bringing new scents into the table. I am looking forward for your designer picks.
You and her would make a great couple then.
If you have to chose between Herod and Carlisle which one would you chose ?
Of course carlisle
Which one is more seductive side effect or spice bomb extram ? ❤
PDM Oajan is closer to Angel's Share than Carlisle right?
Excellent list for Fall
Thank you!
Should i tell her? Should I? Ok I'll tell her: Herod is an absolute staple in the fragcomm and it pretty much makes everyone's fall/winter list 😊
I’ve only heard Demi mentioned it!!! 😻
@@eauderica say whuuuuu....
Herod has been around since 2012, everyone has covered it... it's held in high regard in the frag community
That woman has zero clue what she's talking about in any of her videos xD
@@DeeKayCinematography Being a fragrance reviewer doesn't mean you need to be an expert. Today I found out about Iommi.
I think Herod is the king of PDM, but it does not get the hype like Layton, and there are cheaper fragrances on the niche/designer side that could replace it for folks like Mancera Red Tobacco, and Spice Bomb Extreme.
both of those just smell cheap compared to Herod
you cant replace quality ingredients and art of blending with something for much lesser price and expect the same quality
Is it me or does Carlisle and side effect kinda smell the same ?
side effect has “ok” performance? it’s beast mode def, but all skin is different
If you had to choose one: Herod or Side Effect? (I love both.)
Herod ❤️
@@eaudericaand between Herod and Oajan?
Theese are pretty popular frags and all bangers🔥
I’m hella confused, how is Carlisle the men’s equivalent to Angel’s Share? Oajan may as well have that title
Side effect smells like Strawberry sirup and tobacco.
My fav will always be Oajan.
Have you tried Tango from Masque?
Great video! :) I would love to get your thoughts on Xerjoff Naxos and Parfums de Marley Pegasus. Have you tried either of them?
Try DesirToxic by Micallef
Ever heard of Ozzie Osbourne, Erica? He was the front man for Black Sabbath (before he was fired and replaced by Ronnie James Dio)
Ozzy who? Nobody has ever heard of him .. who is he?
Perfect list!!! Greetings from Greece 🇬🇷
Hello ❤️
My go to niche for Fall r Carlisle , Naxos and Tony Iommi.
I loove Herod🖤
PDM barely last anymore due to the 2021 reformulation. $$$ for a perfume that only lasts 2-3 hours and smells weak.
I’ve never heard carlise being polarizing 🤔
Some people are not happy with the reformulation
Seriously great list.
Erica... Carlisle OR side effect..
Carlisle
Solid list. I'd add Halfeti from Penhaligon's ;)
😉😉
Halfeti from Penhaligon's is an amazing fragrance. It is their best seller.
Hi I am reaching out just letting you know your doing a great job 👍 keep up the great videos.
Nothing is as cozy and warm as your smile! Okay, simp mode off: I hate Herod and all of Marly. Nothing beats the two best releases in the last 20 years: Tauer L'air du desert marocaine and Ganymede!
Tony Iommi - “a little patchouli “ ??? It’s a patchouli 💣
Great selections 👍🏻
Zaharoff Tabac is 🔥🔥🔥
Yes it is!
How could you not know the Black Sabbath song Iron Man? ??
I probably would know it instantly if I heard it
I have Herod and Carlisle!🥵
Yessss 😊😊
@@eauderica Thanks for the follow on insta! Just saw this reaction haha!👌🏻
When ı wear casual on date ı use carlisle... girls say every time waow u smell manly. Best date frgrnc i think
Black Sabbath: Iron man, War pigs, Paranoid, Sabbath blood Sabbath, Headless cross.
Ha! Alithia, those are the same songs I would list, not kidding, except for instead of Headless cross I probably would have said N.I.B.
All of these fragrances are in everyone’s top 10 list I hate to tell you. Good video though.
Carlisle smells like rose and the geriatrics in the nursing home. I gave my bottle away.
Side Effect has bad performance? You must be kidding right?
Love your choice 😃
My top 5
Ambre Tabac Daniel Josier
Oud for Greatness Initio Parfums
Ambra Jeroboam
Oajan Parfums de Marly
And nr one
Rosendo Mateu Nº 5 😍
Nice list!
Carlisle > Herod
Let’s fight about it 😈
Who are these people who are constantly 'complimenting' other people's scents? Is that some creepy Miami old men thing? Or is it just another thing you picked up from Jeremy Fragrance since he's always saying such things?
I think it's just nice people! I was in a gallery on Thurs and a man asked me what I was wearing as he loved it and wanted some for himself, another time a lady in a small shop shouted from behind the counter, "Hey someone smells amazing, who is it? (Both Sedley) another time I was going to umpire a ladies field hockey game and as I walked to put my things down a player said "Oh my God is that beautiful smell you? That's so gorgeous." Another time a lady shopkeeper walked down her store amd stood near me. She then just smiled and aaid "I just wanted to see who smelt so beautiful. I caught a whiff as you walked by and came to see who it was." She took the name to give to her son to buy (Both Naxos) These were complete strangers, nothing odd or sleazy, just nice compliments. I gave them the information with a smile and thanked all of them for taking the trouble to compliment me as it made my day. Mark
I don’t see why you’re not getting compliments with that pleasantly stellar personality of yours. Being a snarky jerk always lands me a grip of compliments.
I am a year late but "random compliment culture" isn't necessarily prevalent everywhere. In Texas, everybody minds their business. They do however love striking up conversations when shopping next to each other or standing in line for extended periods of time or nearly bumping into each other with their baskets.
Wow you are beauty baby 😍😘
I would have replaced Initio Side Effect with Initio Blessed Baraka. I bought a decant sample of it because of Jeremy Fragrance. It was on his top 10 niche fragrances for life list 3 years ago, and it was number 3 on his list. It is an Initio fragrance that is underrated and a niche masterpiece that not many people talk about. ua-cam.com/video/GZUg7hCAyGI/v-deo.html