Rega Planar 10 Turntable Review Pt 2: w/ Hana SH MC Cartridge

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 46

  • @dazaaw
    @dazaaw 2 роки тому

    Wow thank you for putting these videos out there. For me It's been a real pleasure listening to your impressions of the various Rega turntables, and it's rekindled my prior love for analogue reproduction, but for me and in particular your music selections have help me discover a whole new love for the genre of music that you selected.
    I've always dismissed jazz type music as just demo material but listening more closer I have started to appreciate the interplay that exists and the way the artists play off each other and also compliment themselves too.. Looking forward to watching more of your reviews. Thanks man.

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks, Darren! I hope to share more as I put out more videos. My recent purchase was a Yusef Lateef album titled “ live “ Germany oct 20, 1971. It’s amazing. Check it out!

  • @jazzonlp
    @jazzonlp 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for sharing. You certainly are putting the P10 through it's paces.

  • @opnarth
    @opnarth Рік тому

    I love a review with a fine analog pioneer 707 in the background.

  • @evowhite777
    @evowhite777 3 роки тому +1

    Another thumbs up from me Rohit - nice presentation well done sir,these turntables (P8 & 10) are truly high-end for not "totally outrageous" prices - not in the u.k anyways!

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому

      Thank you sir! And I completely agree; real high-end and superb value for 💰

  • @hbaboris
    @hbaboris 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you for the excellent review !!! I think some audiophiles do not pay attention to the P10 due to its "low" price ( comparing to others high end turntables ) and its appearence ( it does not weight 10tons , you can't use it as a mirror to comb your hair and it does not look like an spaceship )....For sure there are some preconceptions against Regas....these guys should listen to the P10....I am sure they would be shocked by the performance level you can get from this turntable that in some areas can not be achieved by any other turntable ( believe me ).

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому +1

      I completely agree. Quite a number of audiophiles really believe only heavy turntables can deliver high performance. The P8 and P10 need to heard and then watching the disbelief in those people’s faces is also entertaining 😂.

    • @garth56
      @garth56 2 роки тому

      I agree it's a nice little reasonable turntable that punches above it's weight... A great starter to get into this passion for music :-)

  • @davidfranklin4534
    @davidfranklin4534 2 роки тому

    Very much enjoy your insights. Probably because you have a love for music so a musicphile more than an audiophile.

  • @ericdimson1
    @ericdimson1 3 роки тому +3

    Thanks for doing another excellent review on the P10, this time with the Hana. Once again, while listening to the description of your impressions I felt transported to your listening room, as if I could hear the music for myself! You have great descriptive abilities indeed. I think the P10 does step out of the way to show the capabilities of any good cartridge. Did you use the Rega 2mm spacer or a non Rega one?

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому +1

      Hi Eric, I used the 2mm Rega spacer that requires removal of tonearm. I am thinking of getting the acoustic VTA spacer set as well!

  • @HRazmikify
    @HRazmikify 2 роки тому

    I love your reviews. I wish you would comment on the E series, more in my budget.

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  2 роки тому

      Thank you! If I get access to the Hana E series, I will surely make a video review.

  • @anechoicchamber3237
    @anechoicchamber3237 Рік тому

    Thanks for these videos. You’re one of the reasons I bought the P10! I had the HANA ML on my last deck and opted for the Apheta 3 package on the P10. Now would like to reinstall the HANA ML. I think it’s the same body as the SH? Did you have to add any shims to the tonearm pivot, or did you just run it ‘tail down’ please? Many thanks

  • @saugghos
    @saugghos 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent review. The only mc cartridge I have is audio technica atf2 and I use it on my clearaudio concept. Do you think upgrading to hana sh will make a sound difference.

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому

      Thank you! The ATF2 is an outstanding value in MC carts. It does come with an elliptical stylus whereas the Hana SH comes with Shibata. While I have not heard the ATF2, I suspect the Hanas with Shibata will make a sonic improvement. But it also depends on your setup. What TT are you using?

    • @saugghos
      @saugghos 3 роки тому +1

      @@analogholic_reviews My turntable is clearaudio concept. My phono pre is limetree. My amp is Sugden 21 . I like a lot of midrange punch. Not a big fan of bass and trebble. Thanks again for your advice.

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому +1

      @@saugghos Wow! sounds like a sweet setup! You will likely love the Hana's presentation if you like mids. Just give it at least 50 to 60 hours of playtime before you make any conclusions though. At least that was my experience.

  • @ptg01
    @ptg01 3 роки тому +1

    Wonderful review.. What phono pre-amp do you use ?

  • @F1fletch
    @F1fletch 3 роки тому +1

    Great review! I have a Rega P8 with the Hana MH Cartridge. I only have 25 hrs on the table if that. As the MH is of the same design as the SH I am glad to know I should give it many more hours before the final sound character can be defined. I also want to play with the settings on my Moon 110LP V2, I am currently 100pf on capacitance (choices are 0,100,330,430pf) and 47kohm on resistance (choices are 10ohm,100ohm, 475ohm, 47kohm). Any suggestions are appreciated! I am a new subscriber, keep up the great content ;)

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому

      Thanks for the comment F1fletch! You can increase capacitance but IMHO the impact of capacitance increase would be more audible on higher output MMs than on MCs even tho it is high output. But generally increasing capacitance loading would increase peak response in mid treble region and at the same time have a steeper roll off. Giving the impression of clarity when in fact it is brightness. I would play with gain instead and go up to 50db or even 54db depending on rest of your system. Also, give it another 25 hours at least.

    • @F1fletch
      @F1fletch 3 роки тому +2

      My ears agree with what you have said, although with gain it’s strange. I find the “smoothest” sound to be 40db but 50db matches more with other music sources and I don’t have to turn it up as loud. The perception of surface noise etc seems to go up a lot at 50db. Of course it’s raising the volume but also has a lower s/n ratio with 40 being the highest. Right now I believe my Pre-amp is my weakest link and will upgrade when possible.

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому +1

      @@F1fletch I think your plan is a good one. Leave it at 40db if you fi d it the smoothest sounding. Give the Hana some time to break in.

  • @MichaelDoran-gh6pv
    @MichaelDoran-gh6pv 4 місяці тому

    Did you do a formal VTA check with the 2mm shim ? on the Hana Is there a device for measuring the angle ?

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  4 місяці тому

      Yes, there are quite a few VTA/Azimuth tools you can buy online that allow you to visually measure the impact to VTA by using shims. Combine that with a headset mounted magnifying glass and light to make this easy.

  • @garth56
    @garth56 2 роки тому

    Nice little cheap cartridge. There are others that tbh are better one a moving iron would you believe, this is great for a cheap system!! Nice

  • @existentialquest1509
    @existentialquest1509 3 роки тому

    👌

  • @Borednlonely
    @Borednlonely 3 роки тому

    Hey buddy, where do u live?

  • @johnsweda2999
    @johnsweda2999 3 роки тому

    No I believe it's beryllium cantilever

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому

      Hi John, the Hana SH cantilever material is aluminum.
      www.musicalsurroundings.com/products/hana-sh-mc-cartridge

    • @johnsweda2999
      @johnsweda2999 3 роки тому

      @@analogholic_reviews is it surprises me I know the HM-L is boron

    • @analogholic_reviews
      @analogholic_reviews  3 роки тому

      The Hana ML is spec’d with Al cant as well. Perhaps the boron is an aftermarket retip? Only the Umami seems to come from factory with Boron per the published specs.

  • @zzh-mailcolm9
    @zzh-mailcolm9 3 роки тому

    Hi, thanks for your review! And I would like to hear your opinion about the inability of REGA for VTA adjusting of big caartridge?

    • @evowhite777
      @evowhite777 3 роки тому +1

      I'd like to know"who told you that a Rega tonearm can't be adjusted via v.t.a"?
      Mine can and is "currently adjusted by about 5mm"!!!

    • @evowhite777
      @evowhite777 3 роки тому +1

      All Rega "RB" Tonearms can be v.t.a adjusted.

    • @zzh-mailcolm9
      @zzh-mailcolm9 3 роки тому

      @@evowhite777 How? I was told that Rega's arm can't be adjusted and can only use small cartridges. If the VTA is adjusted will the sound be affcted?

    • @evowhite777
      @evowhite777 3 роки тому +2

      @@zzh-mailcolm9 Hi - I'm afraid you were given the WRONG ADVICE!
      These are my "latest" set i l recieved this week via ebay:Rega Vta Spacer 6,5mm Spacer Single Höhenjustage for All 3-Punkt Tone Arms.
      I've also got TWO other different sets that are not "split metal washers",one set are plastic & the other are full metal. If you go online & just Google Rega tonearm v.t.a washers you'll get many results back,even J.A. Michell(of the Michell Gyrodec fame)make a three point fixing adjustable collar to fit the new style Rega Tonearms - & one for the "old style" arm fitting too.
      Rohit is COMPLETELY CORRECT when he says that the Hana "sounds better' with a 2mm spacer fitted, I used a spacer when I had the Hana too!
      Please search online for your washer,all Rega Tonearm owners should have them.

    • @zzh-mailcolm9
      @zzh-mailcolm9 3 роки тому +1

      @@evowhite777 Great! Thank you for letting me know, will do!