My choice is 556 LE with fine link bracelet. Sporty and elegant, all satinized without polished surface, sunburst anthracite dial adds a touch of elegance. And practical too, 200 WR. Thanks for the wrist shots.
@@ClickSpringReview I can imagine it'll add more muscle to the watch, greater wrist presence. I prefer H-link on the standard 556. On the more elegant LE, fine link. Having both bracelets would be fun.
The finish on the 556ib sunburst dial is purely perfection. With the bracelet the beauty of the watch is compromised, in my opinion. On a brown leather strap you can truly admire the watch itself.
I'd have to go with the Sinn. The beefy lugs of the OP seem out of place with the character of the watch. In general, I just don't care for the "Super Case" or whatever the name is. They're both really nice watches and it's close, but I wouldn't pay the huge price differential for the Rolex. Nothing wrong with the ETA 2824 for reasons mentioned elsewhere..... Just to be clear, if price isn't an issue, it's still the Sinn for me,
I love the Sinn. I have the glossy black 556i with a date and it is perfect for me. I quite like the Rolex OP too, but I would stay with the Sinn. Regards Oni
That grape dial is so nice. Rolex are Daft for discontinuing the 39mm OP. So with new size and price in mind I’d go Sinn. But between these two I like the Rolex
The Rolex just feels a lot more refined than the Sinn and has an beautiful in house movement were the Sinn feel more like a tool watch but both feel solid . Rolex say it only needs servicing every 10 years were the Sinn is 3/5 years
Sinn is nice enough for me...and i can service the Sinn for the rest of my life and Beyond with the money I would have from the Rolex sale. At the direction of Rolex Canada I took a bubble back that belonged to my father in for service at damiani Jewelers in Ontario Canada. It went in almost a chronometer standard and waterproof it came back not running and they had drilled the case to change the crown tube and therefore it was no longer waterproof they say. A long sad story that took the better part of a year resulted in a watch with horrendous positional variability that isn't waterproof and usually runs but not always. One of the times it was given back to me I took at the Rolex Canada were they verified that at that moment was running 3 and 1/2 minutes fast per day. They would do nothing for me in spite of having recommended the a d. I couldn't stand to own another Rolex after being treated so poorly. The claim check didn't even have the serial number on it and at that time I didn't realize the movements were also serial numbered how else could you explain the complete degradation in function unless they had stolen the movement? They also accepted responsibility up to a total of $86 for loss or damage. To get full coverage i had to pay a high appraisal fee. Even the promised rolex strap didnt materialize...got a hirsch. So.... I've got a very very bad taste in my mouth from Rolex! Never again!
@@think2023 Wow what a nightmare I've never heard of anything like that happening before ,I've sent a few Rolex models in for service over the years and never had any problems , I can fully understand why you would feel like that about them after all that trouble
It'd be the Sinn for me, I prefer the look. I think the dial and handset is nicer, and I'm not a fan of the maxi case on the OP. It looks odd going from such a broad width at the base of the dial in to such a tapered bracelet. I like the more toolish elements of the Sinn, too.
Hi Desmond I love both models but I have replaced the Sinn Anniversary 556 model with the standard 556A non anniversary model now as I preferred the dial , The OP39 doesn't have a maxi case sir that was the sub , The Sinn is more the tool watch as you say with its crown guards and extra WR to .
@@ClickSpringReview Whoops, thanks for correcting me. Don't get me wrong, the Rolex is a nice enough watch but the Sinn has a hell of a lot going for it. I'm sure you'll enjoy wearing both.
Regardless of price the Rolex looks a classier watch. The grape dial has a lovely richness and the case and bracelet are better finished. The Sinn appears “tub-sided” when viewed from the side whereas the Rolex has svelte lines. If the Rolex had the fluted bezel instead of its plain polished one then while it would add to the cost it would make the Rolex “pop”. I’ve always preferred the sportier Rolex models but at its lower price point this might suit many pockets better and for some is not so “ in your face” as the popular and more expensive sports and GMT models. Also right now I suspect these are less desirable even if stainless steel so second hand there are probably deals to be had. Thanks for an interesting and detailed review.
Glad you enjoyed it the Rolex is by far the more classier of the 2 that's for sure but sometimes when your just wearing jeans and T the Sinn looks just right , My wife always tells me the OP is more a ladies watch but I still love
The Sinn is an absolute workhorse of a watch! I have the same one, but with white MOP dial. I do have a bit of a love-hate relationship with the bracelet though. It gets uncomfortable after a few hours, whereas my Omega does not. Don't know why. Also, the bracelet is very hard to detach and re-attach. Now I just leave it on a strap and it looks great! Brushed case hides all manner of nicks and dings. Safire crystal seems impervious to scratches. Second complaint would be ETA movement has only 38 hour power reserve. I'd prefer 60 or 70 since I don't wear daily.
I've reviewed 5 different 556 but never the MOP dial 👍🏻 I find the H-link super comfortable I also have a fine link on one of my other Sinn models but have to say I really like it Sir , I see what you mean about the power reserve if its not your every day watch , Models like the U50 have almost 60 hours of power to them
1:05; that’s the deal killer right there. The side view of the Rolex might not be worth an extra $4000 , but the Sinn looks like a shovel next to a scalpel. BTW I’d take a Sinn 836, but I’d send it out to have the dial redone in a Damasko blue.
From the side the Rolex is much better looking, but from above the Sinn is more svelte and balanced. I'd actually put both on the wrist and ask someone else to tell me how they look.
I only paid 3k for the watch 11 months old full box and papers and it just would of been rude not to really , When I got the watch posted to me and I got to handle the watch for the first time I just loved it I find Rolex just feel so solid which isn't bad for there entire level model
@@ClickSpringReview it does have a good balance and it's probably the most comfortable watch they make. It's a pity they don't have 39 mm models anymore. 3k is a great price! I do love the color.
@@bicmac333 I got both watches for amazing prices but because the Rolex was discontinued the prices started rising, its almost worth more than double I paid for it just over 3 years ago , were as the Sinn hasn't moved , But I still enjoy both of them
@@bicmac333 I'm lucky and have a few Rolex models and to be fair the are so well made and feel so solid plus they are the only guys who guarantee there watches to be with in + or - 2 day for 5 years , I've never had a problem with any of them , But I have had with IWC , Seiko , Sinn and Corum, Seiko was the worst and cost £800 to fix
Enjoyed the video and I think money no object then the Rolex has it, bring price back into the equation and the sinn becomes very tempting. Nice watches.
the rolex wins every time because it so rounded and smooth.........im surprised Sinn never copied those attributes....the sinn has too many corners and sharp ones too. the rolex tends to disappear as a watch while its beauty stands out and you can forget its there....i bet you can sleep with it and wake up in the morning without any red marks on your wrist.......thats different with the Sinn.
I see wear your coming from Rexa and you have a good point , I find both very comfortable due to there size and weight The Rolex is more elegant and refined were the Sinn has that German engineered look about it , I’ve now sold the Sinn as I have the 556a which has a black dial with 12/3/6/9 hour markers which I prefer more
@@ClickSpringReview A rolex always sits and looks (from the side) on the wrist as comfortable as a wedding band on a woman's finger........while most other watches look and sit on the wrist as UNcomfortable as a diamond engagement ring on a woman's finger.......thats why women prefer the wedding band for daily wear and the engagement ring for special occasions!
@@ClickSpringReview that is interesting, why did you switch to that watch? I think Sinn is the perfect one watch collection at this price point and I’m torn between which model to get!!
@@jeffthompson1231 I've now sold the Sinn in the video because I also got myself another 556 the A model and found myself wearing that one more , I'd say the prefect Sinn for a 1 watch collation would have to be a 104 I picked one up a few months back and love it you should check out my review
the op looks fat and bloated , the lugs just dont look right and the bracelet looks like an after thought ,,, the case just didnt need maxed out , it was sleek at 36 , now its a bloater.
@@ClickSpringReview Indeed ,, I have a couple of 36mm rolexes , an explorer1 and a 6538 , one gets worn more than the other , I just never got why they didnt widen the bracelet to 22mm or something to keep the proportions correct ,, The Sub is worse again with the maxi case and crown guards ,,, but when you look at the prices today ,,, what do I know ,, lol as you say Sir , to each their own , health to wear .
@@tomthompson7400 I'm lucky and have a DRSD and Red Sub and couldn't imagine them with a 22mm bracelet but still I prefer my Kermit as to me its just the prefect size and weight and the a great allrounder
This is the most boring watch design. This is why I always think oyster type watches including rolex are just cheap looking work horses. Yeah maybe reliable but really boring. And of course over expensive things are made for stupid people who need to something to be visible. BTW I prefer Sinn.
I started of liking Chrono’s and dive watches but now I really like the more simple 3 hand models without bezels these days , I think they have a more classy you to them
@@ClickSpringReview Actually almost the same case. Getting older prefering more stable and clear design. Really love flieger uhr so wearing now B-Uhr (Flieger Klassik 40 Baumuster B by Stowa), dream about to have couple of Sinn. And when I turn into an old mushroom who never rush I'll make up my mind to wearing just onehand watch like Meistersinger :)
The case, bracelet, and movement are better on the Rolex. Not really close. Sinn is a bargain for the price, but you will tire of it in a year and lose money flipping it
I've had my 556ib for a year and 4 months. I doubt I will ever tire of it, and in truth, if I wanted to sell it I don't believe I'd lose all that much, really. Moot point: I'll never sell it.
Only 1000 made. They are rising in price all the time. Had mine a couple of years and sold my Explorer as I wear the Sinn most of the time. The watch is amazing.
My choice is 556 LE with fine link bracelet. Sporty and elegant, all satinized without polished surface, sunburst anthracite dial adds a touch of elegance. And practical too, 200 WR. Thanks for the wrist shots.
Me too but I'm still thinking of getting an H-Link to try it out as the one of my EZM2 doesn't it
@@ClickSpringReview I can imagine it'll add more muscle to the watch, greater wrist presence. I prefer H-link on the standard 556. On the more elegant LE, fine link. Having both bracelets would be fun.
@@tobacco118 I would have to agee with you there
Kudos to you for synchronizing both watches to the same time for side by side comparison, my OCD thanks you.
Always nice when somebody notices :)
I like the Sinn for being a stronger watch. WR, crown guards and it’s got the X factor for me
Thats a fair comment Sir
The finish on the 556ib sunburst dial is purely perfection. With the bracelet the beauty of the watch is compromised, in my opinion. On a brown leather strap you can truly admire the watch itself.
I'd have to go with the Sinn. The beefy lugs of the OP seem out of place with the character of the watch. In general, I just don't care for the "Super Case" or whatever the name is. They're both really nice watches and it's close, but I wouldn't pay the huge price differential for the Rolex. Nothing wrong with the ETA 2824 for reasons mentioned elsewhere.....
Just to be clear, if price isn't an issue, it's still the Sinn for me,
Spot on! Very well said 👍
neville grimshaw they use high grade ETA / Sellita movements not the ones you find in 500£ Hamilton’s
Sinn cases are made by same company that makes cases for lange sohne
I’m a fan of the Sinn. Hard to get hold of but looks worth it.
It is a super watch and worth hunting down
I love the Sinn. I have the glossy black 556i with a date and it is perfect for me. I quite like the Rolex OP too, but I would stay with the Sinn. Regards Oni
Fair comment glad you like the video
That grape dial is so nice. Rolex are Daft for discontinuing the 39mm OP. So with new size and price in mind I’d go Sinn. But between these two I like the Rolex
I think right on both counts Sir
I'd take the rolex...then sell it, buy the Sinn and pocket the difference...lol
The Rolex just feels a lot more refined than the Sinn and has an beautiful in house movement were the Sinn feel more like a tool watch but both feel solid . Rolex say it only needs servicing every 10 years were the Sinn is 3/5 years
Sinn is nice enough for me...and i can service the Sinn for the rest of my life and Beyond with the money I would have from the Rolex sale. At the direction of Rolex Canada I took a bubble back that belonged to my father in for service at damiani Jewelers in Ontario Canada. It went in almost a chronometer standard and waterproof it came back not running and they had drilled the case to change the crown tube and therefore it was no longer waterproof they say. A long sad story that took the better part of a year resulted in a watch with horrendous positional variability that isn't waterproof and usually runs but not always. One of the times it was given back to me I took at the Rolex Canada were they verified that at that moment was running 3 and 1/2 minutes fast per day. They would do nothing for me in spite of having recommended the a d. I couldn't stand to own another Rolex after being treated so poorly. The claim check didn't even have the serial number on it and at that time I didn't realize the movements were also serial numbered how else could you explain the complete degradation in function unless they had stolen the movement? They also accepted responsibility up to a total of $86 for loss or damage.
To get full coverage i had to pay a high appraisal fee.
Even the promised rolex strap didnt materialize...got a hirsch.
So.... I've got a very very bad taste in my mouth from Rolex!
Never again!
@@think2023 Fair play sir :)
@@think2023 Wow what a nightmare I've never heard of anything like that happening before ,I've sent a few Rolex models in for service over the years and never had any problems , I can fully understand why you would feel like that about them after all that trouble
The moot point is only one is really available for the average punter at retail . Both lovely watches , i would happily own both
Unfortunately you are right there David but like you say you cant go wrong with either model
It'd be the Sinn for me, I prefer the look. I think the dial and handset is nicer, and I'm not a fan of the maxi case on the OP. It looks odd going from such a broad width at the base of the dial in to such a tapered bracelet. I like the more toolish elements of the Sinn, too.
Hi Desmond I love both models but I have replaced the Sinn Anniversary 556 model with the standard 556A non anniversary model now as I preferred the dial , The OP39 doesn't have a maxi case sir that was the sub , The Sinn is more the tool watch as you say with its crown guards and extra WR to .
@@ClickSpringReview Whoops, thanks for correcting me. Don't get me wrong, the Rolex is a nice enough watch but the Sinn has a hell of a lot going for it. I'm sure you'll enjoy wearing both.
No worries Sir you wouldn't believe how many guys on here like to tell me I'm pronouncing something wrong when reviewing a watch lol
Regardless of price the Rolex looks a classier watch. The grape dial has a lovely richness and the case and bracelet are better finished. The Sinn appears “tub-sided” when viewed from the side whereas the Rolex has svelte lines. If the Rolex had the fluted bezel instead of its plain polished one then while it would add to the cost it would make the Rolex “pop”.
I’ve always preferred the sportier Rolex models but at its lower price point this might suit many pockets better and for some is not so “ in your face” as the popular and more expensive sports and GMT models. Also right now I suspect these are less desirable even if stainless steel so second hand there are probably deals to be had.
Thanks for an interesting and detailed review.
Glad you enjoyed it the Rolex is by far the more classier of the 2 that's for sure but sometimes when your just wearing jeans and T the Sinn looks just right , My wife always tells me the OP is more a ladies watch but I still love
The Sinn is an absolute workhorse of a watch! I have the same one, but with white MOP dial. I do have a bit of a love-hate relationship with the bracelet though. It gets uncomfortable after a few hours, whereas my Omega does not. Don't know why. Also, the bracelet is very hard to detach and re-attach. Now I just leave it on a strap and it looks great! Brushed case hides all manner of nicks and dings. Safire crystal seems impervious to scratches. Second complaint would be ETA movement has only 38 hour power reserve. I'd prefer 60 or 70 since I don't wear daily.
I've reviewed 5 different 556 but never the MOP dial 👍🏻 I find the H-link super comfortable I also have a fine link on one of my other Sinn models but have to say I really like it Sir , I see what you mean about the power reserve if its not your every day watch , Models like the U50 have almost 60 hours of power to them
Love the Sinn. However no micro adjustment... bummer
If the Sinn was on there H-link bracelet it have some micro adjustment but I have to say I do like the fine link feels great
Tough choice, I can’t pick. However, I really really would appreciate SINN switching times BGW9.
Both are great to be fair
Good video. Did you say what color the Sinn dial was?
Its a anthracite colour here is a link to my full review of the watch you may like or find helpful Sir ua-cam.com/video/1JUUOpYnsso/v-deo.html
1:05; that’s the deal killer right there. The side view of the Rolex might not be worth an extra $4000 , but the Sinn looks like a shovel next to a scalpel.
BTW I’d take a Sinn 836, but I’d send it out to have the dial redone in a Damasko blue.
From the side the Rolex is much better looking, but from above the Sinn is more svelte and balanced. I'd actually put both on the wrist and ask someone else to tell me how they look.
Thats a good way of doing it :)
yah, ultimately I didn't by the 👑 because the lume on just 3 indices is just dumb. Seriously, they can do better if they want to wear the 👑👑
I only paid 3k for the watch 11 months old full box and papers and it just would of been rude not to really , When I got the watch posted to me and I got to handle the watch for the first time I just loved it I find Rolex just feel so solid which isn't bad for there entire level model
@@ClickSpringReview it does have a good balance and it's probably the most comfortable watch they make. It's a pity they don't have 39 mm models anymore. 3k is a great price! I do love the color.
I choose the Rolex, sell them on Chrono24 and buy two Sinn, a 556i and a 556 Jubilee ... ;-)
(That makes sense)
If I sold the Rolex I could get 5 Sinn 556's :)
@@ClickSpringReview then it might make more sense to keep the Rolex after all...
@@bicmac333 I got both watches for amazing prices but because the Rolex was discontinued the prices started rising, its almost worth more than double I paid for it just over 3 years ago , were as the Sinn hasn't moved , But I still enjoy both of them
@@ClickSpringReview I can't understand the hype about Rolex, the price development reminds me a lot of the story with the Dutch tulip bulbs!
@@bicmac333 I'm lucky and have a few Rolex models and to be fair the are so well made and feel so solid plus they are the only guys who guarantee there watches to be with in + or - 2 day for 5 years , I've never had a problem with any of them , But I have had with IWC , Seiko , Sinn and Corum, Seiko was the worst and cost £800 to fix
Thanks. I really enjoyed this.
Glad you enjoyed it!
put the rolex hands on the Sinn and you've got my pick
sidewinderxx that’s an interesting idea I like it
The Sinn all day. Just wish it was a solid back..
Out of interest Howard why do you not like a display case back ?
i would take the Sinn becouse of crown gards, no reflection on the Glas, Glas on the backside and much cheaper Revisions.
The 556 is hard to beat Berndt its just a perfect all rounded
Enjoyed the video and I think money no object then the Rolex has it, bring price back into the equation and the sinn becomes very tempting.
Nice watches.
Well said!
Good review.
Thank you Sir I'm wearing the Sinn as I text :)
when you go to battle you want the german watch,durability Germans watches are winners
Tell that to a A. Lange und Söhne
the rolex wins every time because it so rounded and smooth.........im surprised Sinn never copied those attributes....the sinn has too many corners and sharp ones too.
the rolex tends to disappear as a watch while its beauty stands out and you can forget its there....i bet you can sleep with it and wake up in the morning without any red marks on your wrist.......thats different with the Sinn.
I see wear your coming from Rexa and you have a good point , I find both very comfortable due to there size and weight The Rolex is more elegant and refined were the Sinn has that German engineered look about it , I’ve now sold the Sinn as I have the 556a which has a black dial with 12/3/6/9 hour markers which I prefer more
@@ClickSpringReview A rolex always sits and looks (from the side) on the wrist as comfortable as a wedding band on a woman's finger........while most other watches look and sit on the wrist as UNcomfortable as a diamond engagement ring on a woman's finger.......thats why women prefer the wedding band for daily wear and the engagement ring
for special occasions!
@@rezamotori5709 I have never thought of it like that Reza :)
@@ClickSpringReview that is interesting, why did you switch to that watch? I think Sinn is the perfect one watch collection at this price point and I’m torn between which model to get!!
@@jeffthompson1231 I've now sold the Sinn in the video because I also got myself another 556 the A model and found myself wearing that one more , I'd say the prefect Sinn for a 1 watch collation would have to be a 104 I picked one up a few months back and love it you should check out my review
Sinn
Interesting and thanks for the comment Sir
the op looks fat and bloated , the lugs just dont look right and the bracelet looks like an after thought ,,, the case just didnt need maxed out , it was sleek at 36 , now its a bloater.
I'm wearing the OP right now and have to disagree Tom but each to there own Sir
@@ClickSpringReview Indeed ,, I have a couple of 36mm rolexes , an explorer1 and a 6538 , one gets worn more than the other , I just never got why they didnt widen the bracelet to 22mm or something to keep the proportions correct ,, The Sub is worse again with the maxi case and crown guards ,,, but when you look at the prices today ,,, what do I know ,, lol
as you say Sir , to each their own , health to wear .
@@tomthompson7400 I'm lucky and have a DRSD and Red Sub and couldn't imagine them with a 22mm bracelet but still I prefer my Kermit as to me its just the prefect size and weight and the a great allrounder
@@ClickSpringReview but they were pre maxi case ,, they were still sleek , even the sd was sleek back then ,,,
@@tomthompson7400 Thats one reason I like the SD4K it still has slim lugs
Sinn win...
Sinn Win
I like both but have sold the Sinn and replaced it with the 556A model Ed
Not Sinn's best bracelet, but I don't see me wearing a purple watch.
rammstevie I like the Red dial myself something different as for the fine link I think it suits this 556 as it’s more of a dress style watch
This is the most boring watch design. This is why I always think oyster type watches including rolex are just cheap looking work horses. Yeah maybe reliable but really boring. And of course over expensive things are made for stupid people who need to something to be visible. BTW I prefer Sinn.
I started of liking Chrono’s and dive watches but now I really like the more simple 3 hand models without bezels these days , I think they have a more classy you to them
@@ClickSpringReview Actually almost the same case. Getting older prefering more stable and clear design. Really love flieger uhr so wearing now B-Uhr (Flieger Klassik 40 Baumuster B by Stowa), dream about to have couple of Sinn. And when I turn into an old mushroom who never rush I'll make up my mind to wearing just onehand watch like Meistersinger :)
@@HISPEEDLEVEL Cool I have a nice Laco Memmingen I enjoy wearing from time to time, I did do a review of it which can be found on my channel
The case, bracelet, and movement are better on the Rolex. Not really close. Sinn is a bargain for the price, but you will tire of it in a year and lose money flipping it
You'll also lose money on the Rolex to be fair in fact the price of the Sinn
I've had my 556ib for a year and 4 months. I doubt I will ever tire of it, and in truth, if I wanted to sell it I don't believe I'd lose all that much, really. Moot point: I'll never sell it.
I only paid 3K for the OP it was less than 1 year old full with full box and papers so that was 1.5k of RRP matey
Sinn cases are made by SUG, SUG also make cases for lange sohne...
Only 1000 made. They are rising in price all the time. Had mine a couple of years and sold my Explorer as I wear the Sinn most of the time. The watch is amazing.
Sinn
I've sold the the 556 anniversary as I found myself wearing the 556A model I have more but I still have the Rolex