Band Maid Without Holding Back - Form and Analysis
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2022
- This video analyses the form of the tune "Without Holding Back" by Band Maid. Music starts at about 1:02.
Music video:
• Video
Live versions:
• Video
#bandmaid #withoutholdingback #formandanalysis
A great in depth look at the genius of Band-Maid
Nice job. The more I listen to WHB, especially with a good breakdown, the more I realize just how distributed and interacting the parts are. But as always with Band-Maid, the individual lines exist for the song, never the ego.
素晴らしい才能を持った 子たちですよ！！、、と。
Non musician BAND-MAID lover here. Thanks for the fascinating analysis!🤘🤩🤘
You are welcome. I'm glad you got something out of it!
Fire!!!
Intro (short) 2
Without Holding Back 8
Plus one (guitar) 1
Miku solo (loud) 8
Interlude 8
Ritornello 16
Without Holding Back 4
Plus one (drum and bass) 1
Miku solo (quieter in live) 8
Misa solo 8
Ritornello 16
Plus one (guitar) 1
Pounding theme (drums) 4
Bass solo 4
Guitar solo 8
Plus one (band) 1
Ritornello 16
Plus two (on ritornello) 2
Without Holding Back 8
Thanks for the analysis. Not sure why it’s taken so long for your video to pop up on my screen. I guess it’s better late than never. Cheers!
I'm glad you enjoyed it. I enjoyed making it too!
Late ☺
Someone else observed that the guitar solo - 5:29 - uses a 'Phrygian' or classical-Spanish scale. It, the whole song actually, really reminds me of 90's Joe Satriani, for e.g. the album _The Extremist._
Sounds like Phrygian to me too. Songs like this and other instrumental songs they have done lead me to think they could do a tour like Satriani or Buckethead with just chop-heavy instrumentals.
Nice breakdown from a Maidiac & aficionado ! Of all the labels attached to Band Maid, prog rock usually isn’t one of them, but their instrumentals say otherwise. I found “Onset” impressive, especially live, and set a high standard, but “Without Holding Back” is next level. I grew up on great music from the 60s & 70s and Band Maid is on par with all of that music, currently they’re the best band going !
What impresses me the most about them is that they have a very wide range of musical styles. And yet she remains a Band Maid. Always...
I'm thinking I would like to do an analysis of "Onset."
@@shawngraham4155 please!
@@edhunt Here it is! ua-cam.com/video/e4YO4ALGURw/v-deo.html
@@shawngraham4155 Thank you! Just subscribed earlier so didn't think to look....any chance of From Now On breakdown? Don't Be Long?
A masterful breakdown. I feel honored to be one of your first 100 subscribers!
Thanks!
Thanks Shawn!
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Wonderful analysis--thanks!
Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it! Please subscribe!
If my discussion at the beginning is too slow for you, skip to 1:02 and see what I've done. Afterward, you can listen to my intro if you are want additional explanation.
I would be ok if they did a few songs with these longer, heavier guitar segments. Saiki would not have to sing constantly. Plus Kanami’s solos are always short.
Yes, that would be great! I did an analysis of "Onset" too. ua-cam.com/video/e4YO4ALGURw/v-deo.html