Not really. He is learned in his field, but his logic is bad. There has been no war in space yet, all war has been localized to earth and generally because people are forced to interact who don't get along. Let people out into space and I'm pretty sure people will start getting along. Need Lebensraum? Have an entire planet.
@@thomaswillard6267 so should we wait for one to happen? and other countries (cough china cough) are already starting to develop space weaponry, no point in waiting to lose
Thomas Willard think about it though, some planets have more valuable recourses or a better a location in the solar system, etc. People would fight over them.
PURPLEFISH why not call him science guy with the cool voice or popular science guy other than bill nye or something but come now- “black science guy”? That’s a bit vague don’t you think? Abit arbitrary? Abit unnecessary? Anyone that follows this man would know that his color is very much a side factor of his life. His thoughts and values matter to him. He happens to be black- just like everyone else happens to be white, brown, yellow, red etc
Joe is not the best entertainer by himself, I mean he's good, but what makes this show the best is that the guests are able to speak for 3 hours without interrogation or going over the same sound bites over and over. This format could never happen on TV.
He is also quiet because Neil has no manners and interrupts Joe nonstop in the full interview. He acts as if it is a debate for most of the time he was on.
"A rouge enemy will take out your military satellite and you wont have Uber, and you won't be able to have sex tonight." That's the most meaningful thing he said in the whole video.
I was in the Air Force for 24 years and first heard that they were planning a Space Force in the early 90s. I was actually shocked that it took so long for them to finally act on it. Point is, Trump wasn't the first to think about developing a Space Force. However, he was the first to have the cojones to move forward with it.
Other countries you idiot. Ever heard of square satellites? China and Russia deploy them to destroy our satellites. We must defend ourselves. Not to mention we need a government version of NASA.
Romans were dominant because they built roads enabling them to control the land quickly. British Empire dominated because they ruled the seas. I hate Trump but Space is the next logical step.
@@Krytern What if you don't want a single nation dominating in space? Space is a great opportunity to go beyond tribalism and bring the countries of the Earth together. One of the best ways we de-escalated tensions with the Soviet Union was through working together in space, if we could do something similar with China it would be great.
@@Krytern How does "I hate Trump but" add to the value of your statement? It doesn't. You're just virtue signalling to random people on the internet to make yourself feel good. It shouldn't be necessary to display you politics just to comment on something. We need to re-learn how to isolate logic and emotion in discussions. All you do by identifying your hate for Trump is allow people to claim you're biased. Let your argument stand for itself!
@@lukeg8466 I do agree with you but unfortunately that just isn't going to happen. The sea was used tor trade and bringing countries together until they figured out how to weaponise it, the same will happen with space.
@@jenkinsjohn15 Virtue signalling? Save me the bullshit mate. I was just pointing out that I disagree with most of what he says and no but sometimes he has a point, which is a very common thing for people to do with then agree with someone they typically disagree with. No need to look too far into it and start making shit up is there?
Ryan Hoffer more deportation were under Obama than under trump, trumps Muslim ban was on the bases of Obama’s countries that were suspect, there are bearing similarities but not exact
That's what high IQ does, it doesn't make you automatically "know" things, but it enables you to take in new information much faster than a person with an average IQ. The ability to learn much faster than average, coupled with deep curiosity (and charisma) gives you a Neil deGrasse Tyson.
@@HaugeBauge It was pretty easy to read and easy to understand. For someone who clearly is very knowledgeable on the English language and grammar, I find it weird that 2 short sentences with potentially one missed comma is hard to understand for you.
This is what I've been telling people, we aren't sending people up with laser guns to fight aliens which was the first thing people think because "lol funny name" It's literally just granting more autonomy to the existing US Satellite Command, we have had a space force for years, it was just under the air force. And for the record, Russia, China, and France have separate space forces already, this isn't a new idea.
To be honest, I'm pretty sure the ridiculous name has earned the ridicule, not the idea itself. "Satellite Command" sounds like a legitimate branch of the government that oversees the security of orbital assets. "Space Force" sounds an 80s action movie starring Dolf Lundgren as astronaut Rip Powers fighting men in cardboard robot suits and green glitter paint.
This will lead to the weaponization of space if not it already exist to a degree. We are signaling to the other realms that earth is ready for a different kind of warfare lol
No but seriously, we've been fighting aliens for a long time. We're actually a lot better at war and learning than most spices out there. *Stargate isn't just a show* Closest thing I could compare it to.
OMfuckingG... How many videos of NASA faking space do you people need before you finally realise its all bullshit and doesn't exist. Nevermind, keep watching the Sci-fi channels & listening to this prick playing the role of scientist. Because that's all he's doing here, playing a role. Coz he's an actor and that's what actors do. Remind me again of the annual budget given to NASA year in, year out no questions asked. And remind me again where the money comes from. Ask this fool Tyson... What is Gravity? Uhhhhhhhhh will be his response. OMG... Rogue Satellites, are you fucking kidding me. I build cell tower sites for a living, been doing it for 10yrs and will continue to build these sites for the foreseeable future. There is no receiving equipment at these sites in order to receive a signal from an imaginary satellite, in imaginary space. If satellites existed, I'd be out of a job. I'm calling bullshit on this guy, NASA, the US Government. Stop letting these clowns syphon the billions of your tax dollars every year to provide you with a few CGI Videos and science fiction stories of space travel. Demand they put this money to better use, that serves the needs of the American people like a free health service. No one has left earth's atmosphere ever, we are the centre of the Universe. In 1962 the American military launched hundreds, if not thousands of missiles to hit an high altitude target. The target was the firmament. They were trying to break through. They FAILED.
+Ningishzidda Shar That was us in the 60's with the nuke my dude. ;D. What if I told you the aliens at Roswell were real and that even then, our technology was better than theirs, they just had some unique things that we have made great use of. Classification only lasts 50 years, unless it is reclassified. A lot of what happened back than has been written about by people in the military that were there. *edit note* Frankly, they want us to know, without telling us straight up. You probably have a good idea about the truth just through shows and movies. None of the stories are directly true, but they are relay some truth hidden behind it. Take the Independence day remake, slightly real threat. Look at the "spiral in the sky over Norway" (ua-cam.com/video/z56YBWd77XA/v-deo.html). Then this ua-cam.com/video/SmUh3yjJInY/v-deo.html from ID2
He got some of the details wrong when it comes to putting offensive weapons in space, the reason you would put weapons in space is because it would drastically decrease the response window your opponent has. The idea that I cant drop something from a satellite orbiting around latitude 20 and hit something at latitude 80 is ridiculous, it's certainly not trivial but if I can put a satellite in orbit there's a very good chance I can work out the mechanics required to move a weapon from one point to another. With that, its possible to decrease the response window to 5-10 minutes, or less depending on the trajectory of the originating satellite or countermeasures placed on the weapon, and the trouble with shortening that window is that it forces the other side to shorten their response time to just a few minutes. Having any system run in that short of a time period requires that they drop controls that might prevent accidental launches or other mistakes, and makes it more likely that we have a something break and all of a sudden WW3 has started. THAT'S why you don't put strategic weapons in space, not because "it's hard" but because it makes everyone inherently LESS safe.
Yea I agree with you completely he gets a lot of details wrong and isn't really that open minded to contradictory opinions. He's not as smart as he thinks
@@JesusChrist-vx7jo “isn’t really that open minded to contradictory opinions.” You’re right Jesus, he is skeptical when people claim things with no evidence or facts. “Faith” and “trust” are not valid reasons for him to listen to someone’s opinion and believe them. You claiming that makes him not smart is hilarious lmao
Yeah, that comment of Neil's didn't age well either. Bezos, Musk, and others did step up and "do it first" without waiting for the government to lead the way. Lol
*Joe Rogan* - "uhh yea bro" *NDT* - "And then space planets" *Joe Rogan* - "i don't think they grind on Tinder" *NDT* - [pulls new category from hat] "Japanese bomb shelters"
Man, he's explains so many things that should have been obvious, but we have never really thought about it. I am amazed at the amount of knowledge in this 18 min video
Chris my grand father was an army air corps soldier during WW2 and post war managed not only to stay in but when they split the branch he was able to be part of the first group to move into the Air Force. Always respected him for that.
Officially, Army Air Corps prior to 1941, Army Air Forces from 1941-1947. The Air Corps name just stuck around during WWII and used interchangeably with the Army Air Force.
His "real knowledge" boils down to Government sets a foundation but the private sector innovates and improves that foundation. His entire story about how planes came about is an example of that. Government doesn't innovate, because their goal is not innovation but discovery. Capitalists innovate. Government can discover because it can afford to lose money, but it can't afford to innovate without a return which it seldom if ever gets.
mike lyles he was saying the same thing about space x but he was wrong. government funding didn't come until successful launches and landings. I like Neil alot but he definitely knows he was wrong about space x so he's kinda doubling down lol
James Hanley your probably right... I just think Tyson was just trying to highlight symbiotic relationship between government & private industry. Perfect world Government innovates & private sector focus is profits do cost effectiveness always top priority.
You just made Neil’s point. The USAF was, originally, the AAF. His point is that this should become a separate and distinct branch of the military. And I used to work at Naval Space Command HQ and worked with officers from both US Space Command, AF Space Command, and US Army Space Command (known then as USARSPACE or We Be Space)so there will be impacts to all current branches of the military as they all use space to some extent.
neils brain is amazing, it runs so fast with so many different things going on and he sometimes forgets what he’s saying because of how much is his brain is processing . truly a remarkable person.
I was in the Air Force for 24 years. I first heard of plans to begin a Space Force as a spin-off as early as 1992 and when working at the Pentagon in the late 1990s, we were informed then that it was 'within a decade' of coming into being. This was the next logical step and was bound to happen sooner or later.
16:15 He's describing deflagration vs detonation (which he mentions and explians later. I'm just adding to it); A detonation is an "explosion" who's shock wave is the same speed or greater than the speed of the flame front (speed of the flame front is how quick the fuel is igniting. Black powder for instance has a really slow burn rate and thus a slow flame front, though the shock wave is still faster than the flame front and so is why it's used). A deflagation though, is the opposed. The fuel doesn't burn fast enough to have a shock wave, or at least not one faster than the flame front. So basically what you get is the inside of an oven.
Yes and that is one of the things that make him great. His boundless inquisitivness. Him and Tyson are great together. Of course Tyson is great anywhere.
I actually bought the book Neil mentioned in this podcast and it is a very good read! I highly recommend it, especially since Neil is such a great educator. He explains complex concepts in a way for readers to understand and he goes over the history of space-related topics.
It makes perfect sense when your stop listening to imbeciles who think they’re smart, but aren’t thinking. They’re mindlessly making fun of everything. If you think about everything that uses satellites then realize the Chinese war game destroying all that stuff in space, it makes perfect sense. Like Neil said in his first paragraph. You judge everything Trump (or any other politician) says on its own. The problem with Trump is; he still hasn’t realized how every little word the president says is hung on. He should have said we need a satellite defense force, which we’ll call the Space Force.
Eddie would have plenty of questions, but wouldn't understand the answers given unless they were in the form of an amateur UA-cam documentary with no credible sources, but plenty of baseless speculation
8:11 This is why people love this podcast so much. Neil is talking all educational like he's on PBS and in zero seconds flat Rogan brings us all right back to the front row of a comedy club. Brilliant.
Neil has a very solid grasp on how the advancement of space industry could happen. My personal view is that anything that moves people into space, in the long run, is desirable.
1. It wasn't called the Army Air Force, it was called the Army Air Corps. 2. US Space Command was active from 1985 until 2002. What Neil is thinking of is Air Force Space Command, and they're already really good at space stuff. That's why the new US Space Command is going to be a USAF asset, run by an USAF general - at least at first. 3. If war breaks out with us and Russia or China, the first thing to be destroyed will be the GPS satellites to stop us from sending smart bombs and missiles, navigation of forces, etc. Don't get me wrong, I like Neil. His words aren't always 100% accurate, though.
Yes correct, BTW, WW2, 1943+, many crews B-17's saw Foo Fighters, my Dad and his crew witnessed many zoom around them in daylight runs to Germany. Now same as Tic Tac craft, Neil is ignoring proof still? USS Nimitz encounters again, USS Princeton and many more, as John Glenn said they are "Friendly Critters", oneday ET may land on Neil's yard, LOL
1) Those are semantics. He misspoke on the name, but you still knew exactly what he meant. 2A) see point one 2b) & 3) he addressed both topics the same way you did
16:09 Only this man would get a front-row seat to a calamity of that magnitude and go, “Wait... why didn’t I experience this particular phenomenon of physics...?”
Yeah Neil is known to get in trouble for this kind of thing. When a shooting spree happened and the country was in an emotional rage against guns he tweeted a reminder that in the past 48 hours in the USA, 34 people have died from shootings. 500 from medical errors, 300 from the flu, 250 to suicide, 200 to car accidents, 40 to homicide via handgun. Sjws blew a fuse
The Space Force needs to do a number of things, in this order: 1. Monitor all global satellite traffic 2. Establish a semi permanent settlement on the moon. 3. Establish foreign body tracking systems on the moon (easier to track and detect extraterrestrial objects from an environment without an atmosphere) 4. Create a deep space launch facility on the moon (much more cost effective and safer to launch from moon than Earth) 5. Head an international Earth Defense Coalition, to take over monitoring of orbital AND extraterrestrial objects. 6. Head up Mars Exploration and Colonization program, using the moon as the launch and recovery location. 7. Create a semi permanent settlement on Mars, complete with manufacturing and launch facility. 8. Head an international coalition with the goal of terraforming and seeding Mars. 9. Head an international coalition to establish a permanent settlement on Mars. 10. Head an international coalition to create a deep-space exploration program, from Mars.
I think the Space Forceis a Garbage Idea. . . In that a priority should be figuring out how to clean up all the Space Junk out there. The movie “Gravity” should give anyone a good idea of the deleterious effects of Space Junk.
The only thing I see being a legit problem is the amount of money and resources it would take to terraform the surface of Mars in order to sustain life. It seems like it would be too much for our government to take full control of this plan. If we’re gonna terraform and colonize, it would have to be a global thing.
People are saying Joe Rogan is high. He clearly is, but I think Neil is TOO! How many times did he forget what he was talking about? LOL! I bet they both shared a joint before this podcast started.
And thats why I always said you cant have everyone smoking pot and we need sober people cause otherwise ull have a bunch of fuckheads doing engineering and the equipment will get blown up. Bridges will collapse and stuff will just be in shambles.. we totally need at least 70% of humans sober to function. Dont ever wish everyone smokes weed. Allow anyone to smoke weed... But culturally shun it as loser actions, cause it is. Otherwise lose ur engineers to goofy pothead antics.
Well I think its clear that one shouldn't smoke weed if hes working, especially if hes working something complex and important. The same as with alcohol. I don't know what your problem is though, you seem to have some personal issues. You can bet that plenty of engineers light a joint when they come home from a hard day at work, or drink a beer for that matter. That doesn't make them losers in any way LOL. Actually, the shit you said is pretty much what an ignorant loser would say to someone. xD
I was in the USAF for 26 yrs and back in the 80's we had posters in my building for "Air Force 2000" with an air craft/space ship flying above the earth. The announcements made it sound like an entirely new service, but it's 'Space Command', like many other commands within the AF. Also, I could listen to NDT, PhD all freak'n day!!! 🤯
July 1916, France: "Captain Edward. How, with the use of the King's finest technology, did you fail to penetrate the enemies lines?" Edward: "Oops... the wind changed directions"
I really used to be in to the idea of space force for the meme and the joke I could pull of "job security my man" (aerospace major in college). But this video really is making me reevaluate my stance more seriously
I recall some sci-fi writer saying that we should go ahead with Reagan’s “Star Wars” idea. He said...”It won’t work, of course, but it’ll get us into space.”
@@bobsorace8306 infrastructure. Try getting a private corporation to provide the same thing as an interstate highway system in this day and age. A government that publically taxes people and spends that money as equally as possible across 50 states has *fewer* chances of making decisions out of selfish interests. It still happens, but it would be a lot worse if a corporation did everything.
I think to some degree Neil is a big supporter of NASA so he has to say that. There is some truth to it in some instances but most of the time its not true.
“What was I saying before i interrupted myself?” Deep.
He remembered what he was talking about before he interrupted himself, he was just trying to sound smart
@@jamesfranco8766 could be,still sounds
deep to me cause i´m dum
76tattooartist read this comment as he said those exact words it felt amazing 🙏🏼
Looked down to read this as he said it
76tattooartist dont call yourself dumb just because your talking to James Franco
"Here's another question" video ends. I die a little inside.
Feral Cyborg Gaming same bro same
Well, here's the other 3 hours - ua-cam.com/video/vGc4mg5pul4/v-deo.html
@@NickSquids lol dude uh da bom
Watch the full podcast?
@@NickSquids thanks my guy,you're a trooper
His ability to explain everything in layman’s terms shows how much he really understands this stuff
He doesn't need to pretend be smart by using buzz words. He shows his intelligence through his behaviour.
Not really. He is learned in his field, but his logic is bad.
There has been no war in space yet, all war has been localized to earth and generally because people are forced to interact who don't get along.
Let people out into space and I'm pretty sure people will start getting along.
Need Lebensraum? Have an entire planet.
Pablo Pulido pretty badass you can swear
@@thomaswillard6267 so should we wait for one to happen? and other countries (cough china cough) are already starting to develop space weaponry, no point in waiting to lose
Thomas Willard think about it though, some planets have more valuable recourses or a better a location in the solar system, etc. People would fight over them.
"The early bird catches the worm"
"Yeah, but the second mouse got the cheese".
Not always
@Mark van Slooten: Lol. Nice. 😁👍🏻
Second mouse may have gotten the cheese, but a cat ate it.
@@TURBOMIKEIFY A cat might have eaten it, but the cat got hit by a car.
@@pearodox a car might have hit a cat, but it was stopped by a lamppost
Thank you black science man
Tyche Dionysus something feels weird about this comment or is it just me
PURPLEFISH why not call him science guy with the cool voice or popular science guy other than bill nye or something but come now- “black science guy”? That’s a bit vague don’t you think? Abit arbitrary? Abit unnecessary? Anyone that follows this man would know that his color is very much a side factor of his life. His thoughts and values matter to him. He happens to be black- just like everyone else happens to be white, brown, yellow, red etc
None of you know what a joke is do you haha
Wispa maybe it is a joke- I feel it’s in bad taste bro. Like the grinder mating thing was funny
@@jesseleighgordon33 What you call "Bad taste" is nothing more than a subjective view.
I love it when Neil is on the show. Joe just sits there and goes "yeah....yeah...mmm...AHHH!"
🤣🤣🤣
That's because often when Joe says something to Neil Joe gets corrected 3:50
Joe is not the best entertainer by himself, I mean he's good, but what makes this show the best is that the guests are able to speak for 3 hours without interrogation or going over the same sound bites over and over. This format could never happen on TV.
Yeah, and yet when hes by neill what he was talking about, joes quiet as a grave.
He is also quiet because Neil has no manners and interrupts Joe nonstop in the full interview. He acts as if it is a debate for most of the time he was on.
Not to mention Joe is probably higher then the ISS
"A rouge enemy will take out your military satellite and you wont have Uber, and you won't be able to have sex tonight."
That's the most meaningful thing he said in the whole video.
Hes so right dude its fucked up
I hate those red coloured enemies, they're always the hardest!
Hah! No sex tonight!! Well it's a good thing I'm marr.....aw crap
I was in the Air Force for 24 years and first heard that they were planning a Space Force in the early 90s. I was actually shocked that it took so long for them to finally act on it. Point is, Trump wasn't the first to think about developing a Space Force. However, he was the first to have the cojones to move forward with it.
True, but who u going to fight in space ? aliens !
@@ahmedalfatih7723 lizard men
Russia formed independent Russian Space Forces in 1992 and 2001 before merging both entities to different entities.
Funny thing is that there was a "Space Force" before the space force. Lol
Other countries you idiot. Ever heard of square satellites? China and Russia deploy them to destroy our satellites. We must defend ourselves. Not to mention we need a government version of NASA.
The space force is an Air Force for the Air Force
Yeah basically
Airless Force
How high are you?
Accurate
Shut up butt pussy
Neil "I'm screaming at you, sorry" deGrasse Tyson
" what was I saying before I interrupted myself?". Poor joe
Neil's passion for what he is saying gets away from him, once in a while.
Never Trumpers: Space Force is stupid
Native Americans: If only we had taken that Ocean Force guy seriously
Romans were dominant because they built roads enabling them to control the land quickly. British Empire dominated because they ruled the seas. I hate Trump but Space is the next logical step.
@@Krytern What if you don't want a single nation dominating in space? Space is a great opportunity to go beyond tribalism and bring the countries of the Earth together. One of the best ways we de-escalated tensions with the Soviet Union was through working together in space, if we could do something similar with China it would be great.
@@Krytern How does "I hate Trump but" add to the value of your statement? It doesn't. You're just virtue signalling to random people on the internet to make yourself feel good. It shouldn't be necessary to display you politics just to comment on something. We need to re-learn how to isolate logic and emotion in discussions. All you do by identifying your hate for Trump is allow people to claim you're biased. Let your argument stand for itself!
@@lukeg8466 I do agree with you but unfortunately that just isn't going to happen. The sea was used tor trade and bringing countries together until they figured out how to weaponise it, the same will happen with space.
@@jenkinsjohn15 Virtue signalling? Save me the bullshit mate. I was just pointing out that I disagree with most of what he says and no but sometimes he has a point, which is a very common thing for people to do with then agree with someone they typically disagree with. No need to look too far into it and start making shit up is there?
I think Joe got Neil high. He's talking awfully fast and real intense.
That dude is high on his own knowledge. He gets so excited when he's explaining something. It's great.
He always speaks and thinks at a fast rate,not everything is about drugs smh ...
Bereck David high on coke
You don't need drugs to be intelligent.
@@charlesthegreati9794 but you do need the three I's to be kurt angle.
Neil "show me mateable people within twenty square blocks of where I am'' Tyson
ikr
Orbital mateable matching
Lol bruh
Start conversations in the Tinder talking about satellites
It's dang difficult with an IQ that big.
I'm defenity down to be a Space Marine or Storm Trooper. Sign me up!
Well you already got the look down
Space trooper marksmanship is lacking.
Rogue is spelled wrong in your name, unless you meant rouge lol.
Outrageously Handsome Dashing Rouge I’ll sign up for the ODST’s.
Mobile infantry for me baby
"Trump's idea is great - glad I thought of it"
carlos Rivas What are you even talking about?
@carlos Rivas Just false. I love how people read exclusively propaganda and think they are well informed.
Ryan Hoffer more deportation were under Obama than under trump, trumps Muslim ban was on the bases of Obama’s countries that were suspect, there are bearing similarities but not exact
No matter what party. They don't give a shit about us fellow Americans. Parties are there to turn on eachother
Zach Balko that’s why they have trump who was outside political areas and ipthats why it works
When you realise that if we start landing on other planets with the military there will be literal Space Marines.
Holy shit
Was so disappointed when God Emperor called it "Space Force" instead of "Space Marines" ._.
@@MrGoatflakes it be like that sometimes
I thought military is banned in space?
@@faisalbantog4704 when did that ever happen. They’ve always been in space
One of the few time Joe should not have gotten "so stoned" before the recording. Neil comes at you fast and hard. He's a wrestler.
Trent Ditto you gotta get stoned because anytime you start talking Neil just asks himself a question and takes off. Lol
Honestly I think neil is the one who's stoned in this video lmao. He forgot what he was talking about twice in 20 minutes! Hahah
Lmao 'fast and hard" 😂
He is a wrestler. In the words of Dave Chappelle "He's a god damn pile driver. Once he gets on those turn belts. There is no stopping him! "
+Great Gig Just wait till you get a bit older pal.. I'm 36 and that happens more and more
So where will we put the US Space Force Academy? And can we call those who attend it "Space Cadets?"
Buzz Lightyear: I think the words your looking for is "Space Ranger".
Greenland, and yes lol
Chad Vader and when they graduate they’re space rangers.
carlos Rivas it’s separate now dipshit
Space marine
I’m amazed at how much information Neil is so enthusiastic about, like every topic it seems like he’s studied it for years.
The trick is to not speak it you have nothing meaningful to add.
That's what high IQ does, it doesn't make you automatically "know" things, but it enables you to take in new information much faster than a person with an average IQ. The ability to learn much faster than average, coupled with deep curiosity (and charisma) gives you a Neil deGrasse Tyson.
@@homiefizzle5260 i wish I had the drive to learn things, but their memory is so great, mine isn't :{
@@huskiehuskerson5300I bet it is when you're taking in things that your passionate about
"Just because it came out of Trump's mouth doesn't make it a crazy idea..."
I wish more people were as rational as Tyson.
Mate the only reason you say that is cuz it was towards trump... say that about the left and youd damn near shit yourself lets not play around
@@alwaysplay13 if you used some commas every now and then, it would be easier to understand you.
@@HaugeBauge thanks, fuckin scholar in rogan comments
@@alwaysplay13 No problem, mate
@@HaugeBauge It was pretty easy to read and easy to understand. For someone who clearly is very knowledgeable on the English language and grammar, I find it weird that 2 short sentences with potentially one missed comma is hard to understand for you.
The only intelligent thing Rogan said this whole time was "I don't think Grindr is used for making babies..."
He didn't say that.
lmao
He would know...
I did, and didn't find anything credible to your bullshit claim. But you're trying to be funny, so you succeeded.
I like that he let Neil do all the talking.
Joe "I'm too high for this" Rogan
Rusty Shackleford I think he just finds him a bit annoying and listens to every single word extremely carefully to try and catch him out
Nicky James nah they’re good friends. Some differing opinions. Joe is DEF stuuuupid high in this lol.
i'm just saying he was too high for someone like NDT
You said it..... to must be high to believe anything Joe says...
Rusty Shackleford I think Neil was smoking with joe before the interview
Just a brilliant mind, and a brilliant human being, always a pleasure to watch and listen to Neil deGrasse Tyson
“I’m screaming at you”,
I wish he watched Alex johnes interview
IQ goes up every 2 minutes listening to Neil talk
Monkey D. Luffy lol I feel the same way whatever this space force shit thing is I want apart of
After watching the whole podcast i think i am finally able to understand rick and morty
Monkey D. Luffy so if watch the entire podcast I might be able as smart as Forrest Gump.
@@danny3640 If you can't understand Rick and Morty you're a dipshit and there is no hope for you.
So does his, according to Twitter
This is what I've been telling people, we aren't sending people up with laser guns to fight aliens which was the first thing people think because "lol funny name" It's literally just granting more autonomy to the existing US Satellite Command, we have had a space force for years, it was just under the air force.
And for the record, Russia, China, and France have separate space forces already, this isn't a new idea.
To be honest, I'm pretty sure the ridiculous name has earned the ridicule, not the idea itself. "Satellite Command" sounds like a legitimate branch of the government that oversees the security of orbital assets. "Space Force" sounds an 80s action movie starring Dolf Lundgren as astronaut Rip Powers fighting men in cardboard robot suits and green glitter paint.
This will lead to the weaponization of space if not it already exist to a degree. We are signaling to the other realms that earth is ready for a different kind of warfare lol
No but seriously, we've been fighting aliens for a long time. We're actually a lot better at war and learning than most spices out there. *Stargate isn't just a show* Closest thing I could compare it to.
OMfuckingG... How many videos of NASA faking space do you people need before you finally realise its all bullshit and doesn't exist. Nevermind, keep watching the Sci-fi channels & listening to this prick playing the role of scientist. Because that's all he's doing here, playing a role. Coz he's an actor and that's what actors do. Remind me again of the annual budget given to NASA year in, year out no questions asked. And remind me again where the money comes from. Ask this fool Tyson... What is Gravity? Uhhhhhhhhh will be his response. OMG... Rogue Satellites, are you fucking kidding me. I build cell tower sites for a living, been doing it for 10yrs and will continue to build these sites for the foreseeable future. There is no receiving equipment at these sites in order to receive a signal from an imaginary satellite, in imaginary space. If satellites existed, I'd be out of a job. I'm calling bullshit on this guy, NASA, the US Government. Stop letting these clowns syphon the billions of your tax dollars every year to provide you with a few CGI Videos and science fiction stories of space travel. Demand they put this money to better use, that serves the needs of the American people like a free health service. No one has left earth's atmosphere ever, we are the centre of the Universe. In 1962 the American military launched hundreds, if not thousands of missiles to hit an high altitude target. The target was the firmament. They were trying to break through. They FAILED.
+Ningishzidda Shar That was us in the 60's with the nuke my dude. ;D. What if I told you the aliens at Roswell were real and that even then, our technology was better than theirs, they just had some unique things that we have made great use of. Classification only lasts 50 years, unless it is reclassified. A lot of what happened back than has been written about by people in the military that were there.
*edit note* Frankly, they want us to know, without telling us straight up. You probably have a good idea about the truth just through shows and movies. None of the stories are directly true, but they are relay some truth hidden behind it. Take the Independence day remake, slightly real threat. Look at the "spiral in the sky over Norway" (ua-cam.com/video/z56YBWd77XA/v-deo.html). Then this ua-cam.com/video/SmUh3yjJInY/v-deo.html from ID2
Dr. Tyson is a person that can see the good in any person or race, I admire him and he's an inspiration to me.
He got some of the details wrong when it comes to putting offensive weapons in space, the reason you would put weapons in space is because it would drastically decrease the response window your opponent has. The idea that I cant drop something from a satellite orbiting around latitude 20 and hit something at latitude 80 is ridiculous, it's certainly not trivial but if I can put a satellite in orbit there's a very good chance I can work out the mechanics required to move a weapon from one point to another. With that, its possible to decrease the response window to 5-10 minutes, or less depending on the trajectory of the originating satellite or countermeasures placed on the weapon, and the trouble with shortening that window is that it forces the other side to shorten their response time to just a few minutes. Having any system run in that short of a time period requires that they drop controls that might prevent accidental launches or other mistakes, and makes it more likely that we have a something break and all of a sudden WW3 has started.
THAT'S why you don't put strategic weapons in space, not because "it's hard" but because it makes everyone inherently LESS safe.
Yea I agree with you completely he gets a lot of details wrong and isn't really that open minded to contradictory opinions. He's not as smart as he thinks
@@JesusChrist-vx7jo “isn’t really that open minded to contradictory opinions.” You’re right Jesus, he is skeptical when people claim things with no evidence or facts. “Faith” and “trust” are not valid reasons for him to listen to someone’s opinion and believe them. You claiming that makes him not smart is hilarious lmao
I could listen to Tyson for hours.
Yea, that "space" fantasy stuff is pretty entertaining.
Ditto
Ya. Me to
These mofos are high... Neil souNds like he believes his own BS! Lol, whos been to the moon? 😂😂 "wheres the edge of the earth?"
Ur girl probably cheats on you
*blank stare*
... space command.
*giggles*
I never thought I'd say this but you might be a bit too baked Joe.
Joe: Are they gonna make space weapons and spaceships?
Neil: Sooooo
I could listen to joe and Neil all damn day
Mobile Suit Gundam 🤔
RX-78 OR GET THE FUCK OUT.
Does this mean i get to slap Frawbow around?
Trump MAGA Gundam
00
G Gundam
Dibs on the first Spartan suit.
Damn....
WaterxDragon 2:56
You can have the first one I remember what happened to that guy putting on the first spartan suit it wasn't pretty
Hello, this is the Government, No.
@@jasonbrophy5567 yup the ONI days lol. Ill join spartan II despite the risks
I came to hear Neil y’all about why the government is making a space force and learned how the airplane industry grew its teeth to modern society...
Yeah, that comment of Neil's didn't age well either. Bezos, Musk, and others did step up and "do it first" without waiting for the government to lead the way. Lol
Joe “I don’t think they mate on Grindr” Rogan
*Joe Rogan* - "uhh yea bro"
*NDT* - "And then space planets"
*Joe Rogan* - "i don't think they grind on Tinder"
*NDT* - [pulls new category from hat] "Japanese bomb shelters"
LMAO Joe is so stoned!
"I'm screaming at you, sorry"
Thanks
"I'm screaming at you, sorry."
What a wholesome little moment that was.
Neil is beyond brilliant! Always fun to hear him talk... about anything!
He’s brilliantly full of shit one thing for sure
Darling Hernandez Please impress us with your brilliance
Except mating.
@EytschPi42, what are you doing here? :)
Dont you have guitars to play and equipment to check?
Have a nice day.
Umm... No. Go to class until you're about 10 years old and you can calculate this.
Make Space Great Again... Build the space wall... Keep them aliens out
If we last 2000 more years, I'm sure we'll be able to piss someone off billions of miles away.
More like keep them asteroids out haha.
Mike Stagg the combination will be 12345
Make the aliens pay for it.
Mike Stagg logic bro
Man, he's explains so many things that should have been obvious, but we have never really thought about it. I am amazed at the amount of knowledge in this 18 min video
Correction to Tyson... Army Air Corps. They got their independence and self establishment in 1947... and in a few days, the anniversary - Sept 18.
Chris my grand father was an army air corps soldier during WW2 and post war managed not only to stay in but when they split the branch he was able to be part of the first group to move into the Air Force. Always respected him for that.
Officially, Army Air Corps prior to 1941, Army Air Forces from 1941-1947. The Air Corps name just stuck around during WWII and used interchangeably with the Army Air Force.
Joe is WAY too high lol
Neil looks pretty high too !
Justin Sklenar i
No such thing?
Yeah, seriously!!!
flying loose and hands free, mind in overdrive, with the emergency brake engaged, hard.
neil degrasse tyson drops some real knowledge on initial government funding being the spark for the “self made private industry/companies”
His "real knowledge" boils down to Government sets a foundation but the private sector innovates and improves that foundation. His entire story about how planes came about is an example of that. Government doesn't innovate, because their goal is not innovation but discovery. Capitalists innovate.
Government can discover because it can afford to lose money, but it can't afford to innovate without a return which it seldom if ever gets.
mike lyles he was saying the same thing about space x but he was wrong. government funding didn't come until successful launches and landings. I like Neil alot but he definitely knows he was wrong about space x so he's kinda doubling down lol
yeah too bad it doesn't apply to cars and many other inventions
James Hanley your probably right... I just think Tyson was just trying to highlight symbiotic relationship between government & private industry.
Perfect world Government innovates & private sector focus is profits do cost effectiveness always top priority.
I have one word for you sir "railroads".
Also "electricity"...
I was in the Space Command in the Air Force. I used to control GPS for 1st Space Operations Squad. There’s already a space force.
Elaborate please. I'm intrested.
You just made Neil’s point. The USAF was, originally, the AAF. His point is that this should become a separate and distinct branch of the military. And I used to work at Naval Space Command HQ and worked with officers from both US Space Command, AF Space Command, and US Army Space Command (known then as USARSPACE or We Be Space)so there will be impacts to all current branches of the military as they all use space to some extent.
space pirates?
neils brain is amazing, it runs so fast with so many different things going on and he sometimes forgets what he’s saying because of how much is his brain is processing . truly a remarkable person.
Enter *MASTER CHIEF*
Lyndii Mey are you single?😉
Neema sorry buddy pretty sure that’s just an avatar
Asking people on UA-cam if they are available is an all time low for anyone.
Neema Fouladi Dude, just because they have a picture of a celebrity as their picture, doesn't mean its them. Thirsty ass incel.
We already have those in the navy
Neil DeGrasse “This is Grindr” Tyson
Excellent
Bobby Dragon "Cash Money"
Neil De"high"tyson.
Bobby Dragon where's B.o.B. at when you need him?
the android with purple tape
Lmao Joe is thinking, "I would kick the shit out of those flight attendants"
I was in the Air Force for 24 years. I first heard of plans to begin a Space Force as a spin-off as early as 1992 and when working at the Pentagon in the late 1990s, we were informed then that it was 'within a decade' of coming into being. This was the next logical step and was bound to happen sooner or later.
I love when NDGT is on the podcast because it gets Joe to shut up for a minute
Q Crew #NDGTftw
You must love it when Jordan Peterson is on then. That dude is 80% of each of his podcasts.
He sounds like Dutch Van Der Linde
Expired Tylenol omg your profile pic i know where its from
De Be you have made me proud :,)
Your awesome
We need money ! One last score Arthur
He sounds like a black Dutch van see linde
"Who are you gonna mate with on grinder?" LMFAO he was quick AF on that! hahahahaha!!!!
16:15 He's describing deflagration vs detonation (which he mentions and explians later. I'm just adding to it); A detonation is an "explosion" who's shock wave is the same speed or greater than the speed of the flame front (speed of the flame front is how quick the fuel is igniting. Black powder for instance has a really slow burn rate and thus a slow flame front, though the shock wave is still faster than the flame front and so is why it's used). A deflagation though, is the opposed. The fuel doesn't burn fast enough to have a shock wave, or at least not one faster than the flame front. So basically what you get is the inside of an oven.
Am I the only one who wants Neil Theo and Joey Diaz all on 1 episode just to see how it turns out
ETA isNOW feel like Theo would make so many classic jokes
And Eddie
Bravo Theo
No Eddie bravo and Neil haha he needs to shut him up and stop Eddie from sounding so stupid lmao
EDDIE BRAVO lol I think Neil would say FUCK NO JOE to that one. Though he says he is an educator so maybe he will take the challenge.
Joe "Here's another question" Rogan.
Neil "What was I talking about again?" Tyson
That's what happens when you smoke weed and talk :) it happens all the time =D
both of them are entertaining as fuck....
Yes and that is one of the things that make him great. His boundless inquisitivness. Him and Tyson are great together. Of course Tyson is great anywhere.
Well obviously! It is an interview😂
this is why i like Neil deGrasse Tyson he knows both science and human nature
I actually bought the book Neil mentioned in this podcast and it is a very good read! I highly recommend it, especially since Neil is such a great educator. He explains complex concepts in a way for readers to understand and he goes over the history of space-related topics.
Am I the only one who thinks that's Neil's voice is the most satisfying thing ever
He ain't Morgan Freeman.
Zero vocal fry. It's the most important thing.
Probably, but not in the majority, he's a little obnoxious lol
Carl Sagan's voice blows Tyson's out of the water
I was not on board w space force initially, but this has me thinking again! Thank you Neil de Grasse Tyson!
Bernadette kiss me
In space
It makes perfect sense when your stop listening to imbeciles who think they’re smart, but aren’t thinking. They’re mindlessly making fun of everything. If you think about everything that uses satellites then realize the Chinese war game destroying all that stuff in space, it makes perfect sense.
Like Neil said in his first paragraph. You judge everything Trump (or any other politician) says on its own.
The problem with Trump is; he still hasn’t realized how every little word the president says is hung on. He should have said we need a satellite defense force, which we’ll call the Space Force.
Your concerns are well founded. Google worldview.stratfor.com
US space-force = private "defense" contractors profits while increasing military budget. Not a good idea at the current moment.
This guy really is our generation's Carl Sagan; an ambassador of science. No agenda, no politics, just love for the subject.
He's literally talking about politics
@@lavabubble8255 say that to my face and see what happens
4:13
Say hello to Elon Musk, Neil.
I love listening to Neil deGrasse Tyson. Such a brilliant guy, such a good educator.
fast talking salesman for gov't promo
@@kimokla3874
... Who is explaining facts and who is 1000% more intelligent than you!
This salesman keeps you listening and learning so np
"I don't think they mate on Grindr" 😂
LMAO!
They don't
@@JesusChrist-vx7jo how do you know jesus? Do you watch? Do you enjoy watching?
@@SamuelEMPowell131 👏👏👏
These days gay men can have vaginas though. LOL
Just because someone you don't like says something doesn't mean it's wrong.
More people need this mentality
Neil “why am I bringing this up? What was I talking about?” Tyson.
I read this comment as he said it.
It felt like subtitles.
Spooky!
War in space... "Fight Em up there so we don't have to down here!"
Where's Eddie Bravo? I'm sure he's got some questions for Mr. Tyson.
Space Force will be the gatekeeping force to Keep all the flat eathers from the truth! they shall not know we live on a sphere!
Eddie would have plenty of questions, but wouldn't understand the answers given unless they were in the form of an amateur UA-cam documentary with no credible sources, but plenty of baseless speculation
Jeff Sager look into it
Indeed.
LOL
“Here’s another question-“
*clip ends*
Damn it!
8:11 This is why people love this podcast so much. Neil is talking all educational like he's on PBS and in zero seconds flat Rogan brings us all right back to the front row of a comedy club. Brilliant.
Neil has a very solid grasp on how the advancement of space industry could happen.
My personal view is that anything that moves people into space, in the long run, is desirable.
Exactly, if technology advances enough for a space force its just going to lead to better technology for everyone
1. It wasn't called the Army Air Force, it was called the Army Air Corps.
2. US Space Command was active from 1985 until 2002. What Neil is thinking of is Air Force Space Command, and they're already really good at space stuff. That's why the new US Space Command is going to be a USAF asset, run by an USAF general - at least at first.
3. If war breaks out with us and Russia or China, the first thing to be destroyed will be the GPS satellites to stop us from sending smart bombs and missiles, navigation of forces, etc.
Don't get me wrong, I like Neil. His words aren't always 100% accurate, though.
Yes correct, BTW, WW2, 1943+, many crews B-17's saw Foo Fighters,
my Dad and his crew witnessed many zoom around them in daylight runs to Germany.
Now same as Tic Tac craft, Neil is ignoring proof still?
USS Nimitz encounters again, USS Princeton and many more,
as John Glenn said they are "Friendly Critters", oneday ET may land on Neil's yard, LOL
1) Those are semantics. He misspoke on the name, but you still knew exactly what he meant. 2A) see point one 2b) & 3) he addressed both topics the same way you did
Your way off on attacking satliletles. A destruction of a satiliete can cause projectiles to destroy your own. It’s a very unwise move.
@@SerDezBlackfyre Yeah he is just nitpicking so he can seem more intelligent than he actually is.
16:09
Only this man would get a front-row seat to a calamity of that magnitude and go, “Wait... why didn’t I experience this particular phenomenon of physics...?”
‘Pulverized pile of goo’ that’s exactly how I’d want to remember the people I cared about who died in that crash
Yeah Neil is known to get in trouble for this kind of thing. When a shooting spree happened and the country was in an emotional rage against guns he tweeted a reminder that in the past 48 hours in the USA, 34 people have died from shootings. 500 from medical errors, 300 from the flu, 250 to suicide, 200 to car accidents, 40 to homicide via handgun. Sjws blew a fuse
Cleveland Brown is smart asf.
Thats racist
Lol
That's true!!
@Poopy Mcpoopersons ik its a joke lol
Hehehe
Neil is all about getting more money for space, even if it is a military budget. \space force!/
He's getting paid for what he loves I see no problem with that
Space Force! Space Force!
Party Time! Excellent!
What lying to people? see no problem with that?
@@masterblou2119 lying?
@@masterblou2119
Lying about what. U got tds?
He spends all day surrounded by people who will gladly stop speaking to listen to him
Cause his good to listen to you would do it to
I so love his ability to speak about important scientific issues while also totally palling around with Rogan, it’s such a pleasant mix to listen to
The Space Force needs to do a number of things, in this order:
1. Monitor all global satellite traffic
2. Establish a semi permanent settlement on the moon.
3. Establish foreign body tracking systems on the moon (easier to track and detect extraterrestrial objects from an environment without an atmosphere)
4. Create a deep space launch facility on the moon (much more cost effective and safer to launch from moon than Earth)
5. Head an international Earth Defense Coalition, to take over monitoring of orbital AND extraterrestrial objects.
6. Head up Mars Exploration and Colonization program, using the moon as the launch and recovery location.
7. Create a semi permanent settlement on Mars, complete with manufacturing and launch facility.
8. Head an international coalition with the goal of terraforming and seeding Mars.
9. Head an international coalition to establish a permanent settlement on Mars.
10. Head an international coalition to create a deep-space exploration program, from Mars.
This is surprisingly well thought out for a UA-cam comment.
I think the Space Forceis a Garbage Idea. . . In that a priority should be figuring out how to clean up all the Space Junk out there. The movie “Gravity” should give anyone a good idea of the deleterious effects of Space Junk.
Stop making sense. Space force is a government department which means making sense is not allowed
The only thing I see being a legit problem is the amount of money and resources it would take to terraform the surface of Mars in order to sustain life. It seems like it would be too much for our government to take full control of this plan. If we’re gonna terraform and colonize, it would have to be a global thing.
Those mostly aren't and shouldn't be goals run by a military organization. NASA should do those things.
People are saying Joe Rogan is high. He clearly is, but I think Neil is TOO! How many times did he forget what he was talking about? LOL! I bet they both shared a joint before this podcast started.
I guess people discussing joint space operations always hit it off with a joint... explains why their discussions end up so wacky lol
Jordan Dewey joe looks like he just woke up from a nap.
And thats why I always said you cant have everyone smoking pot and we need sober people cause otherwise ull have a bunch of fuckheads doing engineering and the equipment will get blown up. Bridges will collapse and stuff will just be in shambles.. we totally need at least 70% of humans sober to function. Dont ever wish everyone smokes weed. Allow anyone to smoke weed... But culturally shun it as loser actions, cause it is. Otherwise lose ur engineers to goofy pothead antics.
Well I think its clear that one shouldn't smoke weed if hes working, especially if hes working something complex and important. The same as with alcohol.
I don't know what your problem is though, you seem to have some personal issues. You can bet that plenty of engineers light a joint when they come home from a hard day at work, or drink a beer for that matter. That doesn't make them losers in any way LOL. Actually, the shit you said is pretty much what an ignorant loser would say to someone. xD
Def! That's why he keeps talking super loud and getting extra excited.
The kinetic energy of spacecraft would be a weapon in itself.
Thank you General Holdo
@@reinforcedpenisstem you are a legend
I was in the USAF for 26 yrs and back in the 80's we had posters in my building for "Air Force 2000" with an air craft/space ship flying above the earth. The announcements made it sound like an entirely new service, but it's 'Space Command', like many other commands within the AF. Also, I could listen to NDT, PhD all freak'n day!!! 🤯
6:32 Neil saying "cash money"...your welcome
BardocksSynphony sheesh
That was very cash money of you
2:46 dosent even flinch grindr
Hey fuck you, you're not the real George Cain!
Neil: This is Earth.
Me: You're high. 😆
July 1916, France:
"Captain Edward. How, with the use of the King's finest technology, did you fail to penetrate the enemies lines?"
Edward: "Oops... the wind changed directions"
TL;DR
socialize the losses
privatize the profits
Exactly! This guy is a shill from top to bottom.
@@TanukiDigital one man's shill is another man's realist
I mean the GPS is a good example where the "profits" are socialized.
Shill is Joe Rogans fans favorite word to call every guest. LOL
Lot's of respect for Tyson. He needs to be appointed to a high position in Government in charge of Space and Science.
Werrrrrrrrd!
If we had a space force we’d be living in a Star Wars movie irl
Love Neil deGasse Tyson, this guy is awesome.
Joe's looking a bit stoned in this one. More than usual.
He just looks like that whenever anyone speaks intelligently around him. He's used to meathead conspiracy theorists.
I really used to be in to the idea of space force for the meme and the joke I could pull of "job security my man" (aerospace major in college). But this video really is making me reevaluate my stance more seriously
Joe: "I've seen that opening, you can get through it."
Neil: "So you think you could do it?"
Joe: "I'm just built different"
I recall some sci-fi writer saying that we should go ahead with Reagan’s “Star Wars” idea. He said...”It won’t work, of course, but it’ll get us into space.”
100 years from now we are gonna be piloting gundams fighting each other on mars lmao
Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare already called it
Sadly, mechs are way less effective then tanks so their use will be limited.
Government does it first private does it better.... Sometimes.
Factz 100 because the trial and error information has been recorded and released by the government doing it first.
What has government done better?
@@bobsorace8306 infrastructure. Try getting a private corporation to provide the same thing as an interstate highway system in this day and age. A government that publically taxes people and spends that money as equally as possible across 50 states has *fewer* chances of making decisions out of selfish interests. It still happens, but it would be a lot worse if a corporation did everything.
Patrick S What are you taking about? Private companies are contracted to build highways.
I think to some degree Neil is a big supporter of NASA so he has to say that. There is some truth to it in some instances but most of the time its not true.
Neil you are the absolute MAN!!!! Amazing brain, I could sit and listen to you talk all day!
Shoot, move, and "Communicate". Communication is very important in any battlefield.