Comparing Foscam FI8918W vs FI8910W vs FI9820W Indoor Test

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 60

  • @Djtubbs1
    @Djtubbs1 11 років тому

    Great! looking to get a couple of the FI8910W. Did they work well for you as a baby monitor? Do you find you actually use the tilt/pan feature? Did the cams come with any mounting accessories. Thanks!

  • @aussiegeekrider
    @aussiegeekrider 11 років тому

    Thanks for the review. I own a 10w and a 18w. Both good for the price. I also made an app for iPhone to control them both with many settings and options and made it free on the AppStore for us techs. It's called ipCamControl-Lite. Don't take this as spam as the app is free. I love technology like you and made this for us :)

  • @junior110876
    @junior110876 11 років тому

    Great Review! Do any of the Cameras work directly in the Safari Browser on the Iphone and Ipad?

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    Tough call because I haven't finished my review of the FI9821W. My last review was the FI9820W. I got a trade shows to cover this weekend, PAX East, so I'll review the FI9821W afterward.

  • @optical10
    @optical10 11 років тому

    Hi, Very comprehensive review. can I ask you if you tested the cams through a window for detection of movement outside as I don't want to mount it outside? Thanks

  • @gtamayo1
    @gtamayo1 10 років тому

    Hi I have a couple of 8910w cameras. I've been looking into recording with maybe an nvr but still be able to see it through my Android. Do you know of an nvr under $100 that works well with them being mjepg

  • @privateprivate8366
    @privateprivate8366 11 років тому

    Thank you. I will be getting my money back. He tried to convince me that the F19820W is better than the F19821W. Either way, on Ebay you must ship what you list, not what you decide. Thanks so much for your advice. You've been very helpful.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    The Tilt Pan is a must for me. My son moves around in the crib.

  • @Djtubbs1
    @Djtubbs1 11 років тому

    Thanks for posting. looking into using something like this for a baby monitor. Have you had any issues connecting these cams to WPA/2 not WEP. Also do they support wireless N.
    Cheers

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    I tried this once. I think it was in my very first Foscam video. The result was invalid because the IR LED light bounced off the wire mesh outside my window and ruin the video quality. All I saw was a white image. All the windows in my house have a wire mesh. It's not something I can take off and put back on easily. If I think of an alternative, I'll let you know.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    I think $140 is a good price, but I would wait for it to be at that price from an authorized reseller, whether it's on eBay, Amazon, or others. It makes calling their test support easier. I had to call them when I got my FI9821W because of the wifi speaker issue.

  • @JazdaBham
    @JazdaBham 11 років тому

    both your videos are amazing and helps so much when i made a decision

  • @Jeffshitlist
    @Jeffshitlist 11 років тому

    I was wondering what do you recommend for a security camera? The Fi8918W, or the Fi8921W or the FI8916W? I think I watched all your videos and I can't make up my mind. It seems that the Fi8921W would have the best video quality but the issues that you mentioned and what I found on the website kind of scare me about purchasing it. Anyway I really value your opinion so what do you honestly think?

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    When the camera loses Wifi, it's suppose to reconnect when it finds the wifi again. But, a lot of my viewers have been telling me their Wifi issues. You can buy 3rd party AC adapter devices to let you restart the Foscam remotely. Those probably cost as much as the Foscam.
    Can't comment on the failure rate because I had 3 FI8918W. One had problem focusing, 1 would freeze, 1 was OK.. Had many FI8910W but I gave them all away after a month so I don't have any long term usage data. FI9821W is new.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    It can. Some do. I don't recommend it because it's not rated for outdoor use and if you live anywhere near where I live, it won't survive the winter.

  • @venuslnd
    @venuslnd 11 років тому

    Hi, I've just one of the 8910W and I was wondering if the Infrared will come on automatic at night? And what IP cam App you use on IOS?

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    All 3 IRs came on at the came time. It's automatic so I can't adjust when it'll come on by itself. The FI8920W requires a longer throw distance. So when the object is 6 feet away, then it doesn't look so washed out.
    The next time I perform the audio test, I'll move the computer to a different room. Thanks for watching.

  • @johntsingis
    @johntsingis 11 років тому

    Is it true that the FI9820W will not retain Network Settings during a power failure? Does the FI8910W have this issue? Does 2-way audio work simultaneously allowing a conversation to take place? A lot of reviews have stated that 2-way audio does not work. Thank you.

  • @Niko-Suave
    @Niko-Suave 11 років тому

    hey Hammy! Just curious before I buy the FI8921w...I guy has one on ebay for $141.99 should I buy that one? like is that a good price? btw I have the 8910 right now and its good and all... what's your suggestion?

  • @TheSgtk9
    @TheSgtk9 11 років тому

    Do you have a vid regarding multiple camera install setup steps? I was not able to find your vid regarding dnds. Thanks

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    That minded me. I recorded the video but haven't edited yet. I'll let you know when it's online. I have 2 video on dns.
    How to Access Foscam Wireless IP Camera From an iPhone, Android, & Internet (HD)
    and
    NoIP DNS vs Dyn DNS (HD)

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    It retains the network settings after a power failure. They all do. The audio can be two way if you turn both mic and speaker on. But I personally don't like the quality so I don't use the audio.

  •  11 років тому

    Thanks a lot for the review. I'm considering to buy the 9820W or 9821W. According Foscam the 9821W is much more improved and the cam angle is wider by 20 degrees. Looking at your review of the 9820W I'll need to buy 9821. Thanks really a lot!

  • @venuslnd
    @venuslnd 11 років тому

    Thanks, do you know how to set the preset camera rotation position? Such as position 1, 2 ,3?

  • @keebert
    @keebert 11 років тому

    Have you tried the D-Link 5000 (DCS-5222L)? I am looking for comparisons between that one and the Foscam FI8910W...

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    I just uploaded this video.
    How to view multiple Foscam Cameras
    Thanks for watching.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    They support WPA/2 but I haven't used it. The 1MP one, FI9820W supports wireless N, but the flaws of the 1MP model is significant enough for me to not buy it.

  • @KentEssex
    @KentEssex 11 років тому

    If I put it next to a window inside my house that have strong sunlight in the daytime, do you thing it can survive? Thank you.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    Try to get your money back or get the FI9821W. The FI9820W is not the same as the 21W. They're different in so many ways. I was going to make a comparison video of the 20W vs the 21W but decided against it because all I would have been doing was bashing the 20W. Besides, it's not that easy to buy the FI9820W now a days so I just focused on talking about the FI9821W.
    I have a link to the 21W in the description of this video.
    I wish you luck.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    If you can make a video of what you did, I think it'll be a hit. It will also save me a lot of money.

  • @privateprivate8366
    @privateprivate8366 11 років тому

    Perhaps you have and I didn't see it but have you compared the F19820W vs. F19821W? I only ask because I purchased the F19821W direct from Foscam and bought another on Ebay, only the Seller "decided" to send me the F19820W and claims it's better, although I'm reading about a firmware update fault. Neither show up for me as I get a Socket Error in the IP Camera Tool software but, ultimately, should I return the F19820W.

  • @jasneet1australia
    @jasneet1australia 10 років тому

    Hi hammy I was wondering if receiving alerts via email or pics is better, is it easy to set up the alerts . Also how do we record video and where. Please help

    • @AwkwardHamster
      @AwkwardHamster  10 років тому

      Setting up the alerts is easy. ua-cam.com/video/Iz7F7Vyf-EQ/v-deo.html
      But, I don't use it because of the sheer amount of false alarms and blurry images.

    • @wagdinagi7220
      @wagdinagi7220 9 років тому

      AwkwardHamster . hey whats bast app i can download for my galaxy s5. i tryed most app dont work

    • @AwkwardHamster
      @AwkwardHamster  9 років тому

      Try Tinycams. There is a free version and a paid version.

  • @jasneet1australia
    @jasneet1australia 10 років тому

    It will be great if you can post a video to explain whole set up including how to record videos n send alerts

    • @AwkwardHamster
      @AwkwardHamster  10 років тому

      I did post a video on each of their setup. I also made 1 video on how to set up motion alerts with e-mail notification. They can all be found in my Foscam video playlist.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    I haven't not tried D-Link.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    Infared LED lights come on automatically. I use Live Cams Pro the most on my iPad and iPhone.

  • @RoyAndrews82
    @RoyAndrews82 11 років тому

    Foscam FI9821W ? I want to see how well it can see in total darkness. It's $159.99. 1280 x 720p, 1.3MP. I don't understand how it's 1.3MP, seeing that 1280 x 720 is only 0.9MP (921,600 pixels). I want to also know if I can buy an IR floodlight for it. Will any IR Light work for this, which I'm pretty sure it will, just want to make sure before I buy the Foscam FI9821W, which is the best one, and it costs just as much as my HD PVR 2 Gaming Edition. Thanks, great video btw.

  • @logann001
    @logann001 11 років тому

    can the FI8918W cam be used outside?

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    I don't know. I haven't tried it yet.

  • @DirtyDog3
    @DirtyDog3 11 років тому

    These are IP cameras which connect directly either wired or wireless to a router. A web cam has to be connected to a PC which intern has to be switched on continuously for it to act as a security camera and be accessed from the web and requires software to adapt it. The camera might be £7 but the PC and the software cost considerably more and limit the web cameras capabilities.

  • @junior110876
    @junior110876 11 років тому

    Thx! I will then get the FI8910W. I bought the Dlink DCS5222L this week to find out that the Camera is not playing on the Iphone in Safari ;-((

  • @pbsing
    @pbsing 11 років тому

    Sorry that you wasted your money on the FI8920W camera. Foscam does have a newer model called FI8921W and let's hope it is not just a rebadged FI8920W. I have several FI8910W and thanks to your videos I set up my cameras with ease. I also recommended some friends to your videos because they wanted to set up some cameras as well. I have an iPhone and need the compatibility to view the cameras. I like the FI8910W but wishing for better video quality. Hoping the FI8921W is the answer.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    I think the cam casing would change color but it should be OK.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    cool. thanks for watching

  • @goodhorsekeeping
    @goodhorsekeeping 11 років тому

    You really take the guess work out of this!! Thank you!

  • @محمدمحمد-ط6ب3خ
    @محمدمحمد-ط6ب3خ Рік тому

    مرحبا كيفك كيف عمل برنامج فوسكام على التلفون يطلب كلمت المرور ولا اعرف كلمت المرور ارجو المساعده بخصوص كلمت المرور

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    You're welcome.

  • @KentEssex
    @KentEssex 11 років тому

    Thank you very much

  • @محمدمحمد-ط6ب3خ
    @محمدمحمد-ط6ب3خ Рік тому

    مرحبا كيفك هل لديك فيدو شرح كيف توليف الكامره على التليفون وتحكم بها من التلفون 👍👍👍👍🖐🖐🖐🖐

  • @ashwilliams1633
    @ashwilliams1633 11 років тому

    Consumers should also be aware how powerful the IR lights are on these things, I was almost blinded by exposure to them. You should be very careful, especially with infants if you are using this as a baby cam as they cannot tell you what is happening to them. IR light can not be perceived by your eyes, so you have no idea how bright it is and how much damage you are receiving until your vision starts to blur. It comes on automatically and there is no way to turn it off permanently.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    They all work in safari. But with the FI9820W, it's not that good. Poor interface in Safari.

  • @ohsyzygy1
    @ohsyzygy1 11 років тому

    Thank you so much from a technically challenged grandma

  • @venuslnd
    @venuslnd 11 років тому

    I use Mac OS.

  • @sma1968
    @sma1968 11 років тому

    For what it's worth, I am looking at these various reviews because I just RETURNED a 9821w. The software is absolute junk. Doesn't work, Won't send emails reliably, FTP doesn't work, Camera might not be bad, but the interface is horrific.

  • @AwkwardHamster
    @AwkwardHamster  11 років тому

    Hi. I posted my review of the FI9821W yesterday and a followup video today. Please check it out. Hope it helps!

  • @canon5dmarkiiii
    @canon5dmarkiiii 11 років тому

    Yes but you have to leave your computer on 24/7

  • @ashwilliams1633
    @ashwilliams1633 11 років тому

    The Foscams are overpriced for what they are, and don't even bother getting the older models, as they have no innate compression and .3 mp is worthless for any serious security monitoring. 1MP is a minimum.
    I recommend the Edimax 3015/3115, as it's 1.3 MP and only $50-60. You don't get IR and no PTZ, but I don't need it.