Do schools kill creativity? | Sir Ken Robinson | TED
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 кві 2024
- Visit TED.com to get our entire library of TED Talks, transcripts, translations, personalized talk recommendations and more.
Sir Ken Robinson makes an entertaining and profoundly moving case for creating an education system that nurtures (rather than undermines) creativity.
The TED Talks channel features the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more. You're welcome to link to or embed these videos, forward them to others and share these ideas with people you know.
Follow TED on Twitter: / tedtalks
Like TED on Facebook: / ted
Subscribe to our channel: / ted
TED's videos may be used for non-commercial purposes under a Creative Commons License, Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (or the CC BY - NC - ND 4.0 International) and in accordance with our TED Talks Usage Policy (www.ted.com/about/our-organiz.... For more information on using TED for commercial purposes (e.g. employee learning, in a film or online course), please submit a Media Request at media-requests.ted.com
It's incredibly upsetting how old is this and how everything is still the same.
That is because educational leadership like principals never listen/watch, "TED TALKS."
ua-cam.com/video/h11u3vtcpaY/v-deo.html
This little dude refers to this.
@@--Skip-- I debate with my principal about the fact that school should change and he said that he totally agree but he can't do anything... LOL
agree!
@@ElynnLight but people are close minded because of it so they never understand
Modern education: Creating people who are smart enough to accurately repeat what they're told and follow orders, and dumb enough to think this makes them smarter than everyone else.
At least I'll be able to make money. EDIT: 6 yrs later i failed out of college now im actually making money no degree needed its not for everyone guys 😅
Money is an illusion. You're welcome.
+Turn_off_TV (Stop voting for puppets. The system is rigged.) Works for me.
Re3iRtH Good for you. Try eating it when the system crashes. It makes good toilet paper though; works for me.
+Turn_off_TV (Stop voting for puppets. The system is rigged.) All else being equal, having more money is better than less. But money just came freely as a result of following my passions, not money. The alternative I would have probably been married, with a kid, and miserable. Rather, I can chose to work, not work, travel, pursue any projects I want. Happiness I agree, its internal. But, as Ben Affleck said in Boiler Room "he who said money is the root of all evil, doesn't fucking have any" :p
R.I.P Ken Robinson (1950 - 2020). Thank you for your work.
Arggghhh... geez:) I am going to buy his book Epiphany to keep him lasting.
What?!!! He died?! 😭
It's SIR Ken Robinson, you gotta respect his feudalist title.
14 years and this is still relevant. When will schools realize that grades aren’t a fair way to test effort and just imposes the notion that failure is wrong? I could only hope some brilliant people would think of a way to design school and the whole system such that kids learn and teachers teach, where everyone does their job in an environment that fuels each kids interests and potential.
@@zombiekiller7101 that's everywhere.
@@abstract_extremist indeed, happens in like every school, no one shows up for lectures but everyone shows up for exams
the geniuses WILL design a better schooling system, but YOU people WILL oppose it
it's ALWAYS like that
@@AcidiFy574 YOU people.
And who are YOU? A possum?
@@pawelzietek A human being
Clap clap. 12 years have gone by, we're still in the same boat.
aerozg truth
Why?
i would say hundreds of years passed by and we still educate the same way
They will first tell you about how it won't fit into the budget. So sad!
yeah people doesn't want that.. government want cheap labor who has no critical thinking, just do as they told, never question anything, and pay tax..
I hate it when you do something a certain way that works efficiently and correctly but the teacher gets mad because it's not the way you're supposed to do it.
I solved this math problem and it was correct but my teacher made me do another method that was more difficult but faster and I got a billion mistakes with it smh
yeah thats really dumb.
Imagine that, but it's every student in the school getting annoyed instead...
It's the way they are programmed. Anything that goes against their rules they can't even comprehend anything different. It's like this for everyone who isn't awake. Anyone who acts differently than the rest of society is told they are wrong or bad. I have to laugh at them because it's so ridiculous.
Yes- even my kindergarten teacher (in public school) insisted that I draw eights with and "S" and a cross over it, rather than 2 circles on top of each other. What I always heard-from parents, teachers, etc was: "Do it RIGHT or don't do it at all!" Translation: "I am not here to teach you anything so be perfect (i.e. do it MY WAY) or leave." I was never perfect, so I spent a great deal of time scared to even try. Then I was labeled "LAZY."
16 years later, still my favorite TED talk. RIP sir Ken
Ken is the goat
Amazinh
It's SIR Ken Robinson, you gotta respect his feudalist title.
11:27 - 11:50 - his words were spot on. In a world of youtubers, digital creators and meme makers, you actually don't need a degree in, you need creativity.
True, it's killing me to see school slowly killing off creativity in nieces and nephews as it robs them of qualities they will need later on in life. Much more than that though it's robbing them off the ability to have fun for about 6 hours a day. And that's just in elementary.
To make and maintain the devices you consume the memes and videos on, you do need degrees.
@@akshat8586 Yep. And if no one had degrees, nobody would have made those technologies.
@@codixbrinton4831 that's actually not very true but yeah, degrees help us get all the previous knowledge humanity has collected over the thousands years.
You took that the complete wrong direction bro, don't gas up youtubers and "meme makers" like these are desirables which have skills worth changing a foundation around ☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠
Loved this quote:
"If you're not prepared to be wrong, you'll never come up with anything original"
- Sir Ken Robinson
Omar Balfaqih The only person who never made a mistake is the person who never did anything!
I used that quote in a speech I gave about the crisis of creativity (ie, the LACK thereof). "Children are not afraid of being wrong. If they don't know... they'll have a go. And I'm not saying that being wrong is the same as being creative. But I AM saying that if you're not prepared to be wrong, you never will be creative. Write that down."
@@EndlessSummer888 NICE!
@@MikeS-um1nm No success happens without failure.
I literally read this as he said it 😂😂
Almost 10 years since this video was posted and unfortunately nothing has changed.
:(
Things will most likely never change unfortunately :(
The awareness since then has grown drastically, both in students, and those in the workforce. I'm waiting the the college bubble to pop, then things will change. 😉
haha same observation, mmm
I dont agree. As Skylighter !!!! pointed out, the awareness of this problem has grown immensely . I believe that the education system, like everything that needs reform, is going to get it in 20 years at the most. People are not stupid, they can see its not effective, it will just take some time to shift the paradigm, as with every core social construct.
I remember watching this years ago as a teenager. It's amazing how forward-thinking he is! Can you imagine that the issues that he mentioned happening 15 years ago are still relevant till this day.
Issues like misogyny?
Shut up.@@isabeljaramillo3835
@@isabeljaramillo3835 ?
"The whole purpose of public education, throughout the world, is to produce university professors...The universities designed the system in their own image [and the system itself] is a protracted process of university entrance. "
*Finally,* someone *said* what so many uni students have been *thinking* and *realizing.*
So that in the end, it's a none stop loop
@@froneotm9565 Exactly
Its been a while since I watched this video, but after two STEM degrees I really think college should be presented as a selection and vetting process. Being selected against is really fun. Lets not kid ourselves and pretend the main purpose is increasing knowledge or problem solving ability.
Do schools kill creativity? Making an entire class write something they have no interest in and forcing them to have X amount of words. Yes. I would say it does. It kills the want to learn.
While it may kill creativity, school does help to expose kids the work that they will have to so in the future. Without it, future adults will be overwhelmed and unprepared for jobs that actually makes a difference, i.e. Engineers and doctors where there are a lot of work as well as pressure against mistakes
It's because our system works that way. What we need is a sustaining system that maximizes the human capacity of doing things at the same time preserving this to our specie.
Who will invest though? I do agree what you are saying but to make a change, somwonw need to first propose a system, and then test it which is time consuming and could be excrutiatingly expensive
VinzPDL And what do you propose though, living on a crappy anarchic capitalist society? Human successfully change societies according to history and we can do that again. Maybe when everybody is suffering.
VinzPDL When this living continue, humanity will kill its own specie. Our system mainly focus on progress and development rather than preservation thus ending our only home in a not-so-far-away future.
It’s so sad now that he’s gone, he will be dearly missed, Rest in peace Sir Ken
1950 - 2020 RIP Sir Ken
Actually?! Sorry to hear that, damn... rip
Press f to pay respect
F
😢😢
RIP. 😢😢😢♥️
I'm from those kids who had started there education journey in 2006
I'm not willing to retired in 2065!, instead I'll retire before middle 30's.
I quit from studying Dentistry because it wasn't my passion and I'm that crazy dude in the entire family who believes in what he capable of, and I'll Push myself in sake for helping others and stand against greedyness❤
I come back to this every couple of years as it is simply the perfect speech.
It's very rare to be so academic, so funny and so confident in public speaking, he was truly the perfect blend of the three
agreed, so many great pointers to giving a speech.
So do I. It's an education in how to give a good speech besides his great words of wisdom.
As Mark Twain said: "I have never let my schooling interfere with my education".
Theo MacMillan Wonderful
Mark Twain was such a forward, incredible thinker
Theo MacMillan u said it
One of my favorite human beings.
Steven Lacey a reflection of glib and to a lesser extent, attitude of the time rather than genuine personal, racial vitriol, I feel. Sometimes it's good to actually use your head
“I never let school get in the way of my education” -Mark Twain
Carter Yott same for me
I think it was "I never let school interfere with my education."
@@wolfsoul7016 How do you? What other is the other source of your education?
@Jonathan MOROSHKO yeah ted talks teach a lot
@warner tesla yeah
To this day I get anxiety when summer ends only because the little boy in me is terrified of having to go back to school. Schools did everything to make pupils the same and discourage any form of creativity
My whole dissertation stemmed from this ted talk, I am an actor and have just started temporarily working in Education in between jobs, heartbroken to find the education still in the exact same state as he talks about, academic subjects with such a hierarchy and creativity still being shrinked if not killed. I hope I live to see this change
The audience is laughing but actually what he says is very painful.
Schools kill not only creativity, but also innocence.
And rid out possible leaders in intellect fields, we must learn by our own for now
And they also create bullies and victims.
they kill individualality
KMSL everything the parents didn’t kill.
@@JuliaBl right. Actually the psychological damage that some parents cause to their children can be more fatal.
Now im staring at my Homework thinking if I should do it or not,
Do it but be clever. Have fun. Maybe put jokes in it or something, if you can. Surprise your teacher. Open his/her mind with your personal approach to it.
Although, this was 3 weeks ago so you probably don't have the assignment anymore haha. But keep this in mind for future assignments I guess
+HoneyNutHijoles this is actually a good idea, im a senior in high school
+HoneyNutHijoles this is actually a good idea, im a senior in high school
+HoneyNutHijoles yeah i was bad at school only good at math and IT, but what i did later on was do my math, science and IT together in programming and try to apply them to some easy short projects.
English together with biology and humanities into a thinking puzzles or rhythms to make it more interesting or music and sports. those helped me be more creative and understand those methods/theories better
it is just finding the best way to do those subjects and don't just do it but apply it in a way that will make it relevant to you. i used to get around 60% in all the subjects except math which was around 75% But later on as i applied them in a enjoyable way all my marks went to 80%+
In English i went to 90% which was mind blowing because all i wrote was what i watched in TED and UA-cam and changed to fit the topic, they told me i was thinking outside of the box and was being creative and thus was better expressing the topic and my point of view, whereas before and others were being static and limited.
+BHaDizzle Awesome! Have a blast! Who says homework can't be crazy fun?
At first I felt despairing for my kids who have adhd, are medicated and are schooled in a mainstream school that they get bored by...
But I also see that I can support their creativity outside of school by listening to and observing them, taking note of their interests and offering them space and opportunities to explore them.
Dr Gabor Mate's videos about ADHD (he also has a book) will open you up to the truth behind this diagnosis and set you and your kids free
@@moka91808 He's a snake oil salesman. Learn the science behind ADHD before helping him mislead people suffering with ADHD. Sufferers deserve the truth, which leads to effective treatment.
I unschooled my kids. It’s a form of home schooling, and legal in all states in the U.S.
I shall cherish this day that I'm here watching this as a perspective teacher... Shall try and bring change 🙏
Education system cause many highly-brilliant people think they're not.
-Sir Ken Robinson
Best quote ever!
Relatable. I tend to think that I’m inferior to others just because I don’t perform as well in the subject as they do.
this makes me mad, because it's true
@@avelus5984 Sadly some people ARE naturally smarter than us especially those with Photographic Memory but 99% of the population doesn't have that but... you can't take anything The Education System says as serious cos it's just 1 giant elaborate scam to get your money and sadly politicians have their hand in it too. It doesn't mean we still can't learn things to the point it's automatic though WE CAN just you need to learn it the way YOU do, Why is someone with a high IQ aloud to do that but not the rest of the population? it's absurd but again it's about money and they'll only put money into people who're A) high IQ and B) Have gotten the right support from all sides especially their families, and then they use them and control them in order to make money by their skills.
This is actually very true and this makes me upset
Who's here after hearing of his passing? This is one of the best TedTalks I've watched. It definitely helped me shape my principles as a teacher. You will be missed.
as a stutdent who aspires to become a teacher would u mind sharing said principles
Boyten88 huh i didn’t know he wrote a book I’ll have to read it
Oh god prayers to his family. I usually come back to see this awesome time to time. Shocked to hear him passing
Agreed
Omg you’re a teacher? Where do you teach?
"Academic inflation" is a good way to describe it. One of the main problems is that individual students don't get the required help they actually need, and many children that have one or more talents never discover what their talents really are.
I also strongly agree that intelligence is interactive. That's how you learn. Later, when you have accumulated enough knowledge and experience, you can use this in combination with your intelligence, but before that you need to learn through an active feedback system.
I'm an educator and on the way to reach higher levels. Everything start from THIS video.
My kindergarten teacher crushed my dreams when she told me that I can't be a Jedi because they don't exist. Many tears were had that night.
Don't let your dreams be dreams
Achieving your dreams also has hindrances that you must overcome.
Don't listen to your kindergarten teacher! Follow your dreams, one day you will be a Jedi! I believe in you
take some sword class and do some meditation it help to achieve your dream
I think your teacher was a Sith Lord.
He's the funniest comedian I've ever seen and he's not even a comedian
@Ryder Loquendero lol you lack sense of humour bud
There arent many things nowadays that are funny... it may just be me, though
You haven't heard a lot of comedians.
@@rr.studios omg he's making a joke. jesus u dumb!
He is not funny, most of the time his jokes are annoying.
The best TED talk ever.
Indeed, without a doubt.
This video is mind blowing..... We need more Ken Robinsons in this world today.....
It's SIR Ken Robinson, you gotta respect his feudalist title.
School kills everything. Creativity, The Soul, Self Esteem, Individuality, Innocence, Critical Thought, etc.
William Koscielniak true
Totally agree, if you are lucky you will keep the want to learn but if u aren't then it's done...
Exactly
Yes its called a liberal college!!!
The will to live...
14 years later after this video I'm still sitting sitting in a room 7 hours a day not learning anything. Nothing changed what a waste.
So, you should start now to avoid wasting another 14 year
We may need a revolution. Technology will be our primary weapon.
@@Fun-io9kv that's y reddit was invented
@@jollyroger1357 then lets start a struggle and a revolution
Right there with you pal.
Intelligence, irony, comedy and depth united in this conference. Extraordinary. Thank you👋👋👋
This is the best Ted Talk out there. Period . Equally engaging, enlightening and hilarious; delivered in a way that people are not bored nor swaying away from the topic at hand ! All Hail Sir Ken Robinson 🙌
I really do think school kills creativity.
+Romain Vincent I know. I think that my school tries to destroy free thinking, and only myself and my friends think for ourselves and question what we are taught.
+Superawesomness321 Well that's pretty narrow minded, loads of people think about that mate.
school kills everything about school. it's not even school. It's a indoctrination center for the system to literally raise your kids instead of parents duh
+Romain Vincent it's actually deliberate and getting even more deliberate. It's all in the book called the deliberate dumbing down of America by Charlotte Iserbyt
right. I try to do things my own way, a way that helps me most, but I have to use the schools method or it's wrong. it's fucking annoying. you can't even be creative in work.
Watching this 13 years later. It Makes more sense.
His son is still four.
He said son was four " everywhere" not Everytime.
"Imagination is a weapon. Those who lack it are first to die."
This video is 15 years old and already true about education inflation. People are educating and competition is so high that creativity is becoming extinct and noble pursuits of life unfollowed.
came for learning, stayed for comedy.
and learning.
Very Good.
Loved this.
thats how school should be
This video was 10 years ago. Nothing's changed.
Kwekinator117 I think u have changed and that's the biggest change
how exactly?
Brilliant .. having ADHD and being an artist and one of lifes creatives, I can totally relate to this 🙏🏿
I will continue to watch this over and over and over again and recommend it to others for the rest of my life. It will always be relevant and enjoyable. You live on sir Ken
Reminds me of how much I HATED school and school hated me.... except for a handful of wonderful teachers who made a difference. Thank you to Tommy Jones (simply for conversations) R Gerallt Jones (who gave a label to what I was interested in... and gave me a book "The Prison Letters of George Jackson"), Dr I D Williams (hands on Nuffield Physics) and Mrs Bowen (English Language and Literature). There were some who should have been put in jail and I spit on their graves; but not these.
Stephen Smith Q
I wish I had seen this video when I was at school
+Eliza Lopez Well that would be ironic for them.
Huh?
+Eliza Lopez he meant it as in if they showed it in school it would be ironic, even though that's not what you said at all
Alyers oh ok thanx
Same, feel iv been let down by school 😓
I consider this a valuable lecture. RIP Sir Ken Robinson. I didn't know he had passed away. A man with a great mind. I hope my creativity hasn't dissapeared yet 😭
Don't worry, no worries. Your creativity will NEVER BE DISAPPEAR. If you find yourself getting stuck. Fight for it and get it back. You can do it i promise!!!!!!!!!🔥❤
He was a symbol of wisdom for me. :( Rest in Peace! 💚
Mistakes were punished so harshly in my family that I learned how to expertly avoid responsibility. Can't fail if you never try, right? What a wonderful lesson that was imparted onto me, thank you education system and parents!
I feel for you! I have the same issue, but never give up! You can reverse that process. I personally find the answer in therapy. But my therapist is very very good, which doesn't apply to all of them.
i live with the policy "MISTAKES HAPPEN AND IT HAPPENS ONLY BY ME" with pride, and that's working out good for me buudy. you can try it. ;)
Is this guy an educator or comedian? Apparently he's both and he seems quite effective at them as well.
Yep, both. He's a genius :D
It helps that he's from Liverpool The survivors from there have to have been one of three things: A good fighter, a fast runner, or able to tell jokes. He got at least number 3.
Gifted people are more humorous! My daughter's G&T class tested them on humour before accepting them.
Good Educators come from Good Comedians ;)
NitoriKun e
I started kindergarten the year he gave this talk, so the kids that he mentioned as “entering school this year” just graduated high school. Time flies
I had the pleasure and honor to spend time with Sir Kenneth Robinson in October of 2017. I sat next to him at a dinner I hosted at my family's restaurant. He told a story of meeting Sir Paul McCartney, and how they mutually agreed to stop calling each other with a "Sir" prefix since both were "Sirs." I couldn't stop laughing. He asked me my favorite Beatle song ("not fair, there are so many. All of them?" I replied) I finally decided on A Day in the Life as my current favorite. He told me that use to be his favorite, but now it's Please Please Me because it was one of the few helped launch them into eternity. RIP Sir Kenneth Robinson (my dinner friend).
10 years later and still relevant, that's the problem
BRBPancake Come back in 5 years and everything will be the same.
BRBPancake now we got common core too
its not the problem he told you about the system and why it is problem, but not why it needs to be so. you need basic mathematics to get through you life but not dance or art or drama, thats why maths is on the top.
BRBPancake 11
Let’s have a moment of silence for the memory of Sir Ken Robinson, rest in peace
Sir Ken Robinson may rest in peace
How did he died?
@@Sky97260 he stopped living
"Classes will dull your mind
Destroy the potential for any creativity"
This was like watching the smartest standup ever
So sad to hear of Sir Ken Robinson’s passing yesterday (Aug 21, 2020). This talk from more than a decade ago was one of my favorites growing up, and I hoped to meet him in person someday. An inspiration to so many. RIP Sir Ken Robinson (1950-2020).
RIP. His TED talks are legendary.
rip bozo 🤡🤡 smokin on his pack 🚬🚬
@@nupkins7813 what?
@@nupkins7813 excuse me?
Was it Covid?
It's incredibly upsetting how old is this and how everything is still the same.
School killed my will to live
Yeah schools are still the same... what if I told you schools from 50 years ago was the same as school nowadays? Nothing changed...
Dude you okay
@@siegwardofcatarina100 most students aren't we're either depressed and tired or mentally ill because of it.
asian kids: understandable, have a good day
@@ejynk Can confirm that, my mental health is really poor bc school.
I come back to this talk every now and then to remind me how to present. Its just incredible.
Still rewatching, and re-laughing at all of his jokes right now And for sure will watch and laugh in the future. Truly an inspiration!
School can also kill self esteem.
reg4321 it killed mine for sure
🙋
🙋♀️
Facts
Lmao middle school fucked my confidence up
I hope that people don't misunderstand this video. It's not that school isn't important. It obviously is. However, creativity is not something you learn through typical education. Art is more about experience than it is about knowledge. That being said, knowledge is still very important.
TrueUnderDawgGaming What would happen if this school-system will run for 20-50 years `now on? I can't tell how many "experience-humans" we have but i would say we got a high push of knowledge (we should use that knowledge now, something needs to change), some people are not able to put creativity on the same level as knowledge. EVERY artist is different - that's the funny part about it, everyone has his own mind - so many people believe they are born with this thing called "talent". Most of my friend are involved in art-jobs, one of them always got his sketchbook, the other one is a dance-machine, so go on... i don't have many "knowledge"-people around, some of them just can't appreciate the passion they've got and never lost...
(sry for my english, not my native language)
TrueUnderDawgGaming But wait a minute. I thought extra curricular classes were meant for those with a more creative mind. In other words, classes like home economics, video game design, computer science, music, etc. are all art classes. (Yes, even computer science has art in it)
Engineer Diep Yes. Exactly.
For example today in my psychology class they told me that you should not try to treat people if you dont have work experience or the diploma. This implies that they dont want any new possible ideas or self expressive human being that just helps people to get over their trauma. This notion they are doing right now will create more and more people scared of being wrong and always follow the book.
+Eddie Enke The most critical role school can play is to teach you how to teach yourself and how to adapt to the changes in your life. You do need a basic understanding of things like grammar, marth, sports. But adapting and self educating is important as well.
Many people lament here that nothing has changed. I am working on "changing things" and putting things like embodiment, self-awareness into curriculum. You would not believe the resistance that comes from the institutions (it's getting better) BUT it also comes from the students themselves. The students are interested in doing things that will give them a mark and then the degree. Think about it people, next time a lecturer proposes to do the class in a forest (or something similar). There exists a strong bias against innovative ways and transactional attitude towards education.
Look up the aquatic ape theory.
Here we are in 2024 and many schools still have the same education system 😢
A decade later and nothing has changed
français
A 999 later and nothing has changed
I rarely put my hand up to answer a question or ask a question in fear of getting it wrong and being yelled at. Some of my teachers get angry when we ask a "stupid" question or don't know easy things and this is putting me off learning.
I find that very weird, considering most teachers say "there are no stupid questions." Liars.
cromusic ibra I actually had a teacher once who said this and then contradicted it by laughing at my question.
you are paying fee...have all rights to ask a question....no matter how idiotic they are.........be an idiot for a second or for the rest of your life....!!!!
anon I feel sorry for you. it would seem I received the better share of good teachers.
you might want to remind that idiot teacher that your being in that school is what pays their salary and without you asking them, they would be sitting on the unemployment line
This is a great video. Every parent and teacher should watch this. As a parent, I let my child be creative and use her imagination. They won't be little forever, let them enjoy the wonders of life before the real world ruins everything for them. Just look up the history of education and that will explain everything. It was created because of Rockefeller's thought process of "I don't want a nation of thinkers, I want a nation of workers."
Rest in peace Sir Ken Robinson...I rewatched this at times for some inspiration. Just learned about it today.
I forgot 75% of what I learned in high school. The other 25% that I remember is useless.
I bet that 75% you forgot is useless too.
Nagito Komeada Oh, no doubt.
thats funny, cuz im studying robotics in a university right now and that 25% was the basis of all im doing now (math)
JoMaFjErynMaLaZOr Yeah ,but how about other subjects, they helped you too?
Teacher teach me biology while i want to be a programmer .
Is that wrong ?
I'm 16, I've been telling stories for as long as I can remember, and I started putting them to paper three years ago. I've always been a "gifted" child--I excelled in math and science, and everyone told me how important and special I was because of my academic achievements, so I thought that my passion for writing was unimportant. I hid it. Even my parents and many of my closest friends had no idea I would pour hours and hours into my stories weekly, or even daily. This year, though, I took a high school writing class, which accompanied my English class. My teacher not only writes but is also very well-respected in the theater community, and has written several original pieces. It was only recently that I had the opportunity to write something creative for his class--a script for an original scene--and by the time I got around to it, I was exhausted from all of my academic work. I wrote the script in under two hours. It was far from my best work, but I simply didn't have the extra time to put into it. After I turned it in, my writing teacher approached me and told me it was outstanding, that he wished he'd had the opportunity to read my creative writing earlier, and that he wanted me to polish it and enter it in a short play contest next year. I'd hidden my love of writing for three years, and almost nobody had ever read, let alone praised, my work, so I was blown away--and I still am. I never dreamed that my "hobby" could be worth acknowledging, but now I was finally being told it was--not by the school system, but by a man who worked in a creative field. In the past few weeks I've opened up more and let more and more people read my work, again, outside of the school curriculum, and I've been told time and time again that I have a promising future in creative writing, if I choose to take it. I've been offered advice, I've been called a prodigy, people have offered to mentor me--it's astounding. And nothing I've shown people has been my best work! But I still have a hard time wrapping my mind around the idea that my creative achievements are more important than my academic ones...because only academic achievement is praised by the school system. I still have to sacrifice most of my time to math and science, because in the eyes of the school system, my writing is not worth a grade. In the eyes of the school system, my passion, my devotion to a creative outlet, means nothing.
I'm not the only person I know in this situation--my experience might be somewhat of an extreme case, but I know gifted artists and musicians who are also seeing their talent and creativity squandered by the school system. I've seen it at every school I've ever been to, with dozens and dozens of passionate people. I've witnessed the exact moment when people gave up on their dreams because they were told math and science were more important than what they loved. The school system kills creativity.
how is your writing going?
Hey buddy, how did your writing go? Honestly, I'd like to get a glimpse of it (hopefully my notifs work when you reply)
Each of us can be a creative person, the main thing is to understand what we like to do the most, what brings pleasure, and also delights other people. It is very important to learn to listen to yourself and realize your talents, to be creative. I really liked Ken Robinson's monologue
I totally agree. As said in the video. “All children are born artists, the problem is to remain an artist as we grow up.” -Pablo Picasso. When we grow up, we become frightened for being wrong and in the school system, mistakes are the worst thing you can make. But isn't school supposed to prepare us for the future? The knowledge we gain from school matters but creativity is still necessary. Students spend 18+ years in their lives taking tests, memorizing informations and spent hours finishing homeworks. However, true learning is born out of lasting understanding, not grades and tests. The informations we memorize fades by the time, but our creativity won’t. In school, even if you’re allowed to be creative, they put a lot of restrictions in it. Students are expected to follow methods instead of creating their own. For example, in Literature. Students are often given strict guidelines for writing things like poems. School makes us create poems that have precise rules for each individual line, making poetry seem very constricted and uncreative. School drains out creativity of oneself.That’s why school must focus on empowering students’ creativity.
well said.
A pervasive concept in the adult world known as "best practices" clearly illustrates your point. We don't stray from "best practices," you don't know a better way, how can you, our way is best?
Of course this has the side effect of reinforcing old methods and behaviors, limiting growth, and stifling innovation (the cardinal sin of the free market). But as long as we don't lose a dollar trying it "your way" today, Corporate America is happy.
I did 8 years active duty. If I had a dollar for every "we're not paying you to think" I could retire today. The rich think, the poor obey. Consider that next time you go to the polls.
there are rules in poems because there are, its same argument as saying i want to make a painting but the edge of the paper is restricting me.
As my father said
Schools only want what they want and we can't say anything about it
Thank you for writing this down.
I learned more maths, physics, biology, philosophy, law, history, critical thinking and skepticism from my public library than I ever did in school. School should be a place where you find your happiness in what you want to do for the rest of your life, not kill your passions.
Literally got an A- on an exam and my teacher didn’t even congratulate me, just said: yOu nEeD tO hAvE a bEtTeR pArAgRaPh sCtRuCtUrE 🤦♂️
First and foremost, the schools are here to teach you to make a living. If that can be combined with your passion than lucky you...but if your passion isn't very marketable than should the school really waste limited resources to develop something that of no benefit to you or the society? If your passion is not marketable than have it as a hobby at the side while school teaches you to make a living.
@@marcellgellert5498 It's hard to teach people things they don't want and probably won't use. Proper grammar, math, and knowledge on the world and your own history.
@Matthew Schlosser I learned my math from video games because they expected us to know spreadsheets and etc for determining the best gear worked with what boss.
Matthew Schlosser half of my family is from Britain they say “maths”.
The Gillian Lynne story brought chill thru me. How many of our wonderful children are wasted because we the adults mistakenly think we know best.
I concur. Brilliant. I have worked in education and said to many colleagues that we are killing the creativity out of a diverse set of learners with a rigid curriculum that is meant to fit one size all.
video quality: 240p
speech quality: 4K
@Airzae ✔👍
"She's not sick... she's a dancer." Best line ever.
After so many years still such a great talk. Guy deserves all kinds of praise... 🙌😌💐💐🎉
I love how he cracks the audience up each time he delivers his speech!! 😂 very powerful speaker. ✨
I remember vividly my mother defending my right to be left handed in 1954. "Common sense" was the argument for swatting my hand if I used the "wrong" one. Love ya mom.....
I can definitely tell you that school killed my creativity. I used to come up with so many different charecters and stories and all that when I was younger, but I seperated myself from my younger self. I had more important things to do like get good grades and write 3 page essays about a debate as stupid as apples to oranges. And when he came back to me in 9th grade and asked me if I wanted to write a story, I felt nothing but disgust at the thought of having to open microsoft word again having already done so for so many hours. And now I'm in 10th grade and I regret pushing him away and letting him go, and I keep trying to trace his footsteps but he's running faster than I can track and his voice becomes more and more faint.
I try and I try so hard but I can't bring back the person I once was after so many years of being told to let him go.
Me too. I don't know how to bring back that creative writer I once was as a child. My senior English teacher literally bullied me in front of the entire class because my prose was different and "too advanced." I've been scarred by this ever sense and am having difficulty restoring my joy for writing.
It feels like you're already catching up. Your younger self has decided to slow down and give you a second chance. You're running and reaching closer to that creativity of yours. You may not feel it, but it's subconsciously filling your brain to help you create metaphors like these. You're getting your child back.
The best thing i think all of us can do for this problem is to let the past go. Don't focus on what happened back then, focus on what is happening right now. Don't worry about the future and don't brood over the past. Your present life needs your creativity and you can access it by just letting it flow naturally.
My thoughts.
I used to do the same thing. My family literally told me the same three points: grow up, pay attention, stop daydreaming. I always wanted to be creative. I went into college for graphic design, and I spent the entire 4 years thinking I simply can't be as creative as these other people. They've already got their foot in the door. Their drawings, art, coloring, programming knowledge, cameras, etc. are all better than mine.
Profound. Indeed. I do hope we can each reconnect to our individual creative spirit, completely.
its the fact that this was posted 16 years ago, yet the system barely changed.
I absolutely LOVE this presentation!!! I pray we all awaken in time to wholistically educate our children!
That's why I prioritize my personal work rather than school
Karl Beltran same here! :D
Glad I'm not the only one
Same here man.
Same bro
Failure is a necessary stepping stone to sucess, so if you punish failure, you're limiting sucess.
That is a good point, I dislike the fact that teachers will shout if you 'are disrespectful' simply by trying to talk human to human over a minuscule disagreement
Whoever got to see this in person, witnessed one of the greatest speeches of all time.
Arguably the mosty important TED talk ever. Its relevance increases every year. I laugh and I cry every time I watch it.
I wasn't ready to watch a 20 minute video but this guy is such a great speaker! Loved his wit and those jokes in between.
I didn't even realize until I'd read it in the comments.
My creativity died long ago, still finishing thesis for master degree. Now I'm afraid to get wrong, I punish myself when doing it wrong.
I hate myself because why now I realized that all the time I insulted my creativity.
I hope when I'm graduate, I can get my creativity back.
Creativity is within everyone, you just have to find it.
Smoke weed
do cocaine, lsd, weed
+Kigoz4Life you nut haha
hey love. You get it back by surrounding yourself with other people's authentic artistic genius. if you have yet to get your creativity back take a look at the poetry on my page and if you have a warm thought right it down, look at it, squint and tilt your head a little you may discover the natural rhythm your soul undulates to. I encourage you to say it aloud, tilt your head to the other side and look for the next line. Creativity can strike at any moment but it is far more interesting when the lightning is at your fingertips. Ready to fire at any moment.. and you can electrify aNyBoDy >:] passion is the best wine, the most whimsical high. The joys of being Human!
Absolutely phenomenal - his message, and his delivery!
I never tire of listening to this man, never. RIP Sir Ken.
Yes, it does. I love writing, I'm trying to write a book, but I never have time to do so. I have no time to do anything I love - I have to write essays, tests, worksheets about things I don't care about. Now to open MS Word brings a tsunami of anxiety down upon me when I want to work on my passion project. My mind is mush by the end of the day, and I can't do it anymore... it's disheartening.
General Nuisance I feel this so much. I do a sport after school as well. I really love art and crafts, and this quarantine is helping me enjoy art and crafts more than school ever has. It makes you really think.
I LOVE to write and read books; I’ve always avoided listening to teachers in terms of writing lessons, etc because I fear that’s going to ruin the creativity of writing within me and potentially discourage me from ever writing again. I’ve avoided anything that has to do with writing in school in particular actually. I don’t want to lose that writing creativity AT ALL!!
Then don't... leave The Education System and be done with it i did eventually... it's totally fruitless staying and certificates and degrees mean nothing now they managed to fool people for a while but then they went and broke the certification system by giving them out like candy especially to school leavers, here in england they hand out Level 2 certificated to most people who just left high school which is one level away from Level 3 which you need to get into University but... they weren't given anything in the course that could justify that but the whole problem with the Grading System is it tries to Grade people's level of knowledge and intelligence and tried to curb our intelligence through it by defining it by Grades, logically Can you say that makes any damn sense?.
But the main reason not many people take Certifications and Degrees seriously now is because a piece of paper can't prove you actually know how to do something but they sell you WAY short by miles when you need to know a lot more than that, you need to have actual Skills and you need to be well practised at them where you can just do it automatic, where you aren't making SO many mistakes at every turn and don't need to constantly keep asking people things and relying on them but not many people have that these days... there's a HUGE Skills shortage and has took us in a very bad direction, the 80s, 90s and 2000s generations are screwed well and truly we aren't getting anywhere now especially with the pandemic and the world's economy is just stagnant because they're ran out of ideas with what we had and are now trying to figure out what the future looks like because we need to adapt our planet to be entirely Eco Friendly in order to save it because of the damage that's been done to it *sigh*.
So try and really make something of it and don't rely on others to constantly teach you things because face it we can't... when people cannot be trusted and well there's the dilemma of everyone understanding things differently/
@Leandro Aude That gives you no excuse to take advantage of the fact they can't understand and same for Teens and Young Adults too i've only just really started to understand things in the past 2 years and i'm nearing 30 now, all teachers do is use people and hate when people leave because they might lose the funding for that student but they loathe them actually progressing anywhere "better" than them but it's blatantly obvious The Government doesn't want too many people progressing and becoming more than they are, Why? cos of sheer spite really... they know it makes no sense and now look where we are... we're in financial trouble, skills shortage, corruption up to it's eyeballs where it doesn't even benefit the original perpetrators mainly fraud, people have ran out of ideas, lack of imagination and creativity, total economic stagnation, damaged environment and oh now look... a pandemic because people neglected the warning signs in the early 2000s of animals developing more viruses and diseases as if Mad Cow and Bird Flu wasn't enough warning :\
You know just because we don't understand things when we're younger doesn't mean we're mentally retarded and can't learn things... you consciously know this and you know people learn differently too people just blatantly go against it while making us think it isn't what it is so we can't reach the right conclusions but you know that even kids sense what you're doing is wrong so clearly they understand things enough, totally absurd and illogical trying to use younger peoples biological inability to understand more complex emotions, thoughts and ideas for peoples selfish desires.
@Leandro Aude im sorry but just because you have experienced something doesnt make it a fact, you can’t form any conclusion about “most kids” just basing on personal experience it doesnt make sense
I'm an English teacher who is still at the bottom of the totem pole but when I get onto campus, my students gather around me while each one of them is trying to chat with me. I don't go to the office for a while. I just stay there between them while the other experienced teacher usually sneer at my from behind the window. I'm not sure whether this is completely correct, but I've never been too strict with my students. When I'm with them I don't worry to wear my heart on my sleeve. We love and understand each other. Sometimes we don't do homework. Sometimes we watch movies instead of doing grammar exercises. I believe they learn much better this way and I've seen it they do. I just hope in the long run, I'll be remembered as the English teacher who made them smile at class.
Great job. Do keep it up :)
We need more teacher like you.
I had a teacher like this in high school. Needless to say, I still remember him as my favorite teacher and he inspired me to do what I'm doing now. I think you're on a good track ;)
Can I be in your class lol
As someone who's been fortunate to have teachers like you, thank you!
Something that school definitely kills for me is the desire to read. At the end of last summer I decided to finally finish the Mistborn books. I read through books 2-6 in about 2.5 weeks. The fastest I'd ever read a series. Then this past school year came along and as usual we had to read some "classics" in English and do some personal reading. I read roughly the same amount of book in those 2.5 weeks as I did over a 9 month school year. Only now when I have nothing to occupy my time in summer am I now dipping my toes back into reading on my own. Luckily, I don't need to take an English class next year.
I enjoyed those books so much! 😊
Rip Sir Robinson, thank you for your passion and dedication, for changing my perspective on education and myself. I really hope to be able to put everything you spoke about into action. You were a blessing to us all.
It blows my mind that this talk was on Buzzfeed's list of worst TED Talks of all time. It very well may be the best.
Josh Sideris buzzfeed is pathetic.
It's expected because Buzzfeed isn't accurate.
Buzzfeed is trash. Modern journalism is clickbait trash.
Josh Sideris It doesn’t blow my mind, it’s Buzzfeed.
The subject is important and the observations relevant, but the actual shape of the speech is... abysmal. He is all over the place, which is a shame since he has interesting and important things to say.
16:58 "Jillian isn't sick, she's a dancer" Love this quote now xD, was the same in Elementary school, and yes I did end up going to dance school and I still love theater to this day!
One of the worst things about school is the wonky distribution of subjects.
For some reason you just get way more time for some subjects than you do for others.
I am failing one of the classes I care about the most and put some of the most effort into simply because I haven't had the time to work on some of the tasks.
Meanwhile, I'm doing just fine on my least favourite subject, English, because we've got two periods of it every day except Wednesday (and the weekend).
It pisses me off how I have to spend more time on the subjects I hate than the ones I actually want to be doing.
You have to practice all subjects in school, even if you don't like them. After graduating from school you can study English and get a degree in it.
@@nothingmuch1039e9 English is for the most part just essay writing, but with a bunch of bullshit thrown in. Almost every other subject also has a bunch of essay writing, but aren't as BS. Thus it's extremely stupid that English is not only compulsory, but also the ONLY compulsory subject for the HSC.
I've just started reading ''Out of Our Minds'' by Sir Ken R., which brought me here. He did so much; I so enjoyed this video--especially as an artist and art educator. So for more of his ideas--and humor--there is the legacy of his books.
I eventually taught teachers--Art in the Classroom, and Art for themselves, and heard again that the art activities (where probably almost none would have chosen an art course) were the highlight of their week, their only time of pure pleasure.
video in 2007, 10 years later and nothing had changed.....
make that 11
A Cringy Person - okay 11 years now :(
It’s got worse
DayDreaming_ man, it has been like this for many decades
We need to take our kids out of public school
And homeschool them until we demand a change. Starting in our own communities