I've very much enjoyed the Ed Painter series! Thank you so much, Ed, for sharing these with Drayton and allowing him to put his great editing skills to use and sharing them with us.
This brought back great and terrifying memories. In 1985 I worked for ENSCO, Inc doing a track geometry survey of railroads in the Southeast. We used a Budd SPV, FRA # T-10. We surveyed Saluda grade, gingerly, with an NS pilot engineer on board. going downhill, the SPV's brakes began to fail. I popped the door and got ready to jump. Our protection power, a couple of high-nosed southern SDs, ran into us from behind and roughly coupled up on the fly. It was quite the afternoon. See TRAINS magazine, September 2009 for my story about the previous Amtrak survey in 1984. Great memories.
Great footage and I love the SD40-2s. I get to see them here In Akron Ohio on the Wheeling & Lake Erie while they haul stone trains to several destinations locally. Thank you for this video.
Thank you so much for publishing this video. It is a shame that the marvelous engineering wonder Saluda grade got dismantled . At least we can watch now thanks to your efforts how the might grade once was operated.
Vintage Railroading at its best,great video and footage, like seeing those old SRR high hoods and hearing those Leslie air horns. An iconic grade in all it's glory and what a display of horsepower!🛤🚂
Thanks for sharing this video. Im very familiar with this line growing up and still living in Spartanburg SC. The line goes past a building that I think might have been a freight depot in Tryon NC. Its now home to Sidestreet Pizza and has been for at leased 30 years. I have been in there eating my pizza when a train would pass by years ago. The whole building would shake.
That's Awesome, Bro Like the hear the sound of Nathan P5 horns on the Hi-Hoods riding on From Asheville to Spartanburg on the W line of trains ran on the line until 2001 when it was abandoned. We seen Coal Trains left Andover Va through Natural Tunnel through Speers Ferry Daniel Boone Rd through Watkins and on to Asheville I've seen Coal Trains passed by my house at Daniel Boone Rd years ago back in the 90's It was good times Saluda Grade will always be the class 1 mountain railroad grade in the US
I live near Campton Road, Inman SC. They have switches for tank cars for Milliken and a nearby liquid asphalt storage company. Between here and Landrum, I think they go there for the lumber yard in Landrum, occasionally.
Here's a bit of irony: Saluda Grade would be technically viable in 2023 because Norfolk Southern now has a large fleet of EMD/Progress Rail SD70ACe, and GE/Wabtec AC44C6M, ES44AC and ET44AC locomotives that could easily handle this grade, especially in Distributed Power Unit (DPU) mode.
Here's a wild thought: What if N&W had kept the Alco C628s that they sent to CNW in 1975, long enough to see the NS merger, and THEY could've run on Saluda!
What was the gradient on Saluda? Wasn't it like 4.2% at it's steepest point? Makes one wonder how any consist of locomotives could pull a train up that... Wow! Super cool.
Several groups here in South Carolina have banded together and have a tentative agreement worked out with NS to purchase this line and turn it into a rail trail. According to their press releases, it will take several years for this process to be worked out.
I agree but over the past several years the line has not been intensively maintained. There are several large segments where the road bed has been washed out. It's going to take a lot of work and money to rebuild it.@@RailPreserver2K
Would be cooler if it could become a historical / excursion railroad Edit: also being areas of double and even triple tracks seems a bit wide for just a trail
@harrisonashley1631if they could arrange something like what you’re suggesting, I think it would honestly be the best possible realistic outcome (considering how sadly improbable the revival of the Grade would be at this point). I typically kinda resent rail trails, which I’m sure is probably common among railfans (lol), but the idea of Saluda being transformed into a combined open-air rail museum & linear park is pretty damn intriguing. I guess anything beats the depressing state of disrepair that it currently suffers from.
If traffic levels were to increase greatly, NS could repair the washout damage and restore the line. But because of the grade, it would take a real demand to make it financially worthwhile.
You know, the statement about Pentrex is actually a really good point. Why DIDN'T they cover saluda grade?! Shocking in hindsight, and it's forever a missed opportunity. Considering the current state the line's in and how NS completely severed these tracks from their system, I don't think there's any way in hell Saluda will ever see rail traffic again.
The good old days of railfanning when you could actually visit operating railyards. Today in 2023/24 you can't get anywhere near Hayne Yard or the old Clinchfield or ACL Yards in Spartanburg, fences with barbed wire, locked gates and tons of "No Trespassing" signs abound. Also notice how little graffiti was present, I saw just 1-car that had been defaced.
Oh yeah! This is the Southern and NS that I grew up watching in the 80’s and 90’s just west of Louisville Kentucky. Not a wide cab in sight. It is still a pusher district today with Duncan Hill a 2.8% grade, but the variety of power is sadly gone.
Everybody has an opinion about the trail conversion. I’m glad to see it repurposed. It was highly unlikely to be reactivated as a rail corridor. The only alternative was to see nature reclaim it. If that’s what you prefer, then be honest about it. I’ve seen that happen far too many times.
NS still operates every locomotive seen here EXCEPT the oddballs...the C39, the U-boat, the Sd60 and the standard Sd40, which wound up in Pittston PA on the Reading & Northern, derelict. Standard SD40's are built on a different frame.
Saluda grade would make an amazing rail sim world route, as long as it gave you 6 ac4400’s to get up the grade. If it’s raining or snowing and your under 25 and have 15-20 miles to go up 1.5-2% grade good luck not stalling.
They had to put that gondola behind the GE C39 because the fixed rear anticlimber would jut into the lead passenger car's diaphragm. Primary reason why you rarely, if ever, saw earlier six-axle GEs pulling passenger trains.
That was awesome great video I live in central Florida and was born in Asheville Nc I will be visiting again and will be rail fan there, I also have the dash 8 Ns in my collection along with Csx I run on my layout and share my channel on UA-cam, I am a new subscriber to your channel I look forward to next videos u share Love the information u are giving also Thanks
Two possible reasons. Back in the day as a rule certain freight locomotives on NS we’re not allowed to couple against passenger cars because of the snow plows (most of the time located on both ends of the locomotive because the long hood was still considered the front) would not clear the vestibule on a passenger car. Another reason was most of the GE locomotives such as the C39-8 pulling the train had very high catwalks ( walkways) and anticlimbers which also would not clear the vestibule of a coach.
Rail to trail is the worst. Out of the main People who run it only one has any background to railroading and it was a guy who worked for NS. They rip everything up and just put a plaque. The rails should stay in place cover the top with gravel and keep the line intact in case of reviving the line. As well as signals Mile markers switch stands etc. it’s a shame this lines been another taken, understandable as to the reason it was abandoned but man it would’ve made a solid excursion run
Willing to bet..alot of those ties are still good, ballast (always reusable) tie plates, joint bars, and track components are prob all still good. My only hope is that if Saluda does get torn up....that all its steel and any other components get reused and distributed amongst other railroads!
@@rockguitarist931 Former railbeds often make the best trails...to be fair. Saluda makes zero sense as an operational railroad these days. Why not let the community and visitors get the most out a right of way that the railroad has no use for. Railroads nearly always reserve the right to return the right of way to use...but they almost never do. Railroads are in the business to tighten operating expenses...and this former route no longer fits into that plan.
@@NielsenSTL lmao you must be a blast at parties. I'm just saying, people who hike usually want to look at nature, not a former right of way. Why not preserve a historic route with an excursion run at least???
At 45:20 I see the white flags on the lead unit denoting it’s running as an extra. I miss those days too. Green flags meant a following section was called.
I believe crews needed a special endorsement to run Saluda. I think my dad had one in case of strike duty. Sadly, it is now washed out in several places.
Dam, someone needs to teach this engineer the proper sequence for blowing an engine horn. Its evident he hasn't the foggiest idea on how to blow the horn. How do I know, I'm a retired engineer!
Man apparently they never taught the passenger engineer how to properly blow a train horn! (had nothing to do with the people on the tracks, was doing it the whole time)
Must have been a excited rookie driving the C39-8. He has no idea how to operate the horn correctly at grade crossings. His operation goes against everything engineers are taught!! Just pure laziness!!! Super great video Drayton!!
@@jwrailve3615 couldn't agree more my great grandady have southern railway a right of way thru our farm in Virginia it was jus a branch which was abonded in the 70s an left to rot an grndad talked to them an wa allowed to turn it back into one feild but leave tracks so the cows could cross an keep it from growing up.ever now an then sombody would walk thru which was fine we are friendly people an most people we new an we had no problems until one day in the early 2000 some people came thru an wanted to no whywe had a gate on each end an that he would see that. They were removed in the near future cause he was somebody like I should no him an he was turning this into a rail trail an he was goina do Al this crap well the neibors aren't as friendly an especially to a prick an it turned ugly an went to court my dad told all them they is no way to stop them unless you can produce about 10 percent more than what this peick is buying this right of way for which is bull shit everybody gave thr right of way but let's jus say a little north of here the people are like the old west you have a pistol on your side an it was jus about to turn into a civil war cause the people will shoot your ass an go eat dinner before the bury you an nobody talks but needles to say now we got a rail trail an the dam people are asholes an Karen's an its a dam nitemarre. You have your dream place one day that is a paradise only to loose it to people you have no peace an you can't do shit .rail trails outa be bannned
@@EstorilEm Dynamic brakes require excitation provided by a field current to work, all locomotive prime movers will increase their output in heavy dynamics to generate a suitable field current.
It was a pleasure to narrate this program for you Drayton! Happy Railroading!
I asked Ed who did the narration on this at the SER convention as I didn't quite recognize your voice on this. You did a great job narrating this.
I thought it was you, did great, bud.
I've very much enjoyed the Ed Painter series! Thank you so much, Ed, for sharing these with Drayton and allowing him to put his great editing skills to use and sharing them with us.
Excellent simply excellent thanks
You are welcome!
This Area is where I grew up …I know every place…thanks for the memories from 50 years ago.
This brought back great and terrifying memories. In 1985 I worked for ENSCO, Inc doing a track geometry survey of railroads in the Southeast. We used a Budd SPV, FRA # T-10. We surveyed Saluda grade, gingerly, with an NS pilot engineer on board. going downhill, the SPV's brakes began to fail. I popped the door and got ready to jump. Our protection power, a couple of high-nosed southern SDs, ran into us from behind and roughly coupled up on the fly. It was quite the afternoon. See TRAINS magazine, September 2009 for my story about the previous Amtrak survey in 1984. Great memories.
What a great story!! Thank you for sharing that with us. 👍💯
Great footage and I love the SD40-2s. I get to see them here In Akron Ohio on the Wheeling & Lake Erie while they haul stone trains to several destinations locally. Thank you for this video.
I love how those NS crews tossed the 2 longs, a short and long right out the window opting for one long horn blast lol
I was thinking the same thing I was like damn that engineer really likes to lay on that air horn 😂
😂😂😂😂 same
I suspect the number of people standing on the grade and tracks has something to do with the amount of horn use.
Me in a traffic jam
@forthbrdge6162 during the passenger special yes, but later on when just chasing the locals, the horn use was very similar
Thank you so much for publishing this video. It is a shame that the marvelous engineering wonder Saluda grade got dismantled . At least we can watch now thanks to your efforts how the might grade once was operated.
Thank you Drayton! Happy Railroading.
39:23, those Nathan P5's sound fantastic. Warm, rich, musical. The sound of the Southern Railway.
Vintage Railroading at its best,great video and footage, like seeing those old SRR high hoods and hearing those Leslie air horns. An iconic grade in all it's glory and what a display of horsepower!🛤🚂
In this case, Nathan air horns.
Thanks for sharing this video. Im very familiar with this line growing up and still living in Spartanburg SC. The line goes past a building that I think might have been a freight depot in Tryon NC. Its now home to Sidestreet Pizza and has been for at leased 30 years. I have been in there eating my pizza when a train would pass by years ago. The whole building would shake.
This video is absolutely amazing, I absolutely love the ed painter series 😊
That's Awesome, Bro
Like the hear the sound of Nathan P5 horns on the Hi-Hoods riding on From Asheville to Spartanburg on the W line of trains ran on the line until 2001 when it was abandoned.
We seen Coal Trains left Andover Va through Natural Tunnel through Speers Ferry Daniel Boone Rd through Watkins and on to Asheville
I've seen Coal Trains passed by my house at Daniel Boone Rd years ago back in the 90's
It was good times
Saluda Grade will always be the class 1 mountain railroad grade in the US
I live near Campton Road, Inman SC. They have switches for tank cars for Milliken and a nearby liquid asphalt storage company. Between here and Landrum, I think they go there for the lumber yard in Landrum, occasionally.
Sd40s were awesome to watch on saluda mountain
Here's a bit of irony: Saluda Grade would be technically viable in 2023 because Norfolk Southern now has a large fleet of EMD/Progress Rail SD70ACe, and GE/Wabtec AC44C6M, ES44AC and ET44AC locomotives that could easily handle this grade, especially in Distributed Power Unit (DPU) mode.
I had the same thought while watching
Can't wait to see new videos of those bad boys pulling the grade.
@@donbearden2618 You Know Saluda Grade Was Abandoned In 2001 Right?
It was technically viable when these videos were recorded, too. Good luck making it financially viable though.
Here's a wild thought: What if N&W had kept the Alco C628s that they sent to CNW in 1975, long enough to see the NS merger, and THEY could've run on Saluda!
Thanks for sharing this wonderful history.
What was the gradient on Saluda? Wasn't it like 4.2% at it's steepest point? Makes one wonder how any consist of locomotives could pull a train up that... Wow! Super cool.
Several groups here in South Carolina have banded together and have a tentative agreement worked out with NS to purchase this line and turn it into a rail trail. According to their press releases, it will take several years for this process to be worked out.
I kinda wish they could use it to run excursions like what tvrm has done with the hiawassee loop and other railroad marvels
I agree but over the past several years the line has not been intensively maintained. There are several large segments where the road bed has been washed out. It's going to take a lot of work and money to rebuild it.@@RailPreserver2K
What's the point of a rail trail when there are plenty of hiking trails already? Revive the damn thing or let it rot.
Would be cooler if it could become a historical / excursion railroad
Edit: also being areas of double and even triple tracks seems a bit wide for just a trail
@harrisonashley1631if they could arrange something like what you’re suggesting, I think it would honestly be the best possible realistic outcome (considering how sadly improbable the revival of the Grade would be at this point). I typically kinda resent rail trails, which I’m sure is probably common among railfans (lol), but the idea of Saluda being transformed into a combined open-air rail museum & linear park is pretty damn intriguing. I guess anything beats the depressing state of disrepair that it currently suffers from.
This is so awesome!
If traffic levels were to increase greatly, NS could repair the washout damage and restore the line. But because of the grade, it would take a real demand to make it financially worthwhile.
Looks like its gonna get turned in to a trail sadly would of been cool if at least a historical railroad took it over
It’s nice to see that raven hawk is doing narration for this video.
You know, the statement about Pentrex is actually a really good point. Why DIDN'T they cover saluda grade?! Shocking in hindsight, and it's forever a missed opportunity. Considering the current state the line's in and how NS completely severed these tracks from their system, I don't think there's any way in hell Saluda will ever see rail traffic again.
The sound of those SD40-2's Mmm.
The good old days of railfanning when you could actually visit operating railyards. Today in 2023/24 you can't get anywhere near Hayne Yard or the old Clinchfield or ACL Yards in Spartanburg, fences with barbed wire, locked gates and tons of "No Trespassing" signs abound.
Also notice how little graffiti was present, I saw just 1-car that had been defaced.
Oh yeah! This is the Southern and NS that I grew up watching in the 80’s and 90’s just west of Louisville Kentucky. Not a wide cab in sight. It is still a pusher district today with Duncan Hill a 2.8% grade, but the variety of power is sadly gone.
Everybody has an opinion about the trail conversion. I’m glad to see it repurposed. It was highly unlikely to be reactivated as a rail corridor. The only alternative was to see nature reclaim it. If that’s what you prefer, then be honest about it. I’ve seen that happen far too many times.
Great video, well filmed.👍🎥👍👍👍😊
This was so cool!
Awesome video
excellent video.
Awesome vid!!!
Grade so steep it's like an overachieving logging railroad.
NS still operates every locomotive seen here EXCEPT the oddballs...the C39, the U-boat, the Sd60 and the standard Sd40, which wound up in Pittston PA on the Reading & Northern, derelict. Standard SD40's are built on a different frame.
Saluda grade would make an amazing rail sim world route, as long as it gave you 6 ac4400’s to get up the grade. If it’s raining or snowing and your under 25 and have 15-20 miles to go up 1.5-2% grade good luck not stalling.
It was recently released for Train Simulator Classic
This was some great old railfan footage. The only thing that could have made it better is if they were running the lead SD40-2 long hood forward. 👍
Including a high hood in a consist without running it long hood forward just seems like an egregious missed opportunity.
They had to put that gondola behind the GE C39 because the fixed rear anticlimber would jut into the lead passenger car's diaphragm. Primary reason why you rarely, if ever, saw earlier six-axle GEs pulling passenger trains.
That was awesome great video I live in central Florida and was born in Asheville Nc I will be visiting again and will be rail fan there, I also have the dash 8 Ns in my collection along with Csx I run on my layout and share my channel on UA-cam, I am a new subscriber to your channel I look forward to next videos u share Love the information u are giving also Thanks
This line is long gone almost 22 years no trains
Nice video! Why is there a gon in between the engine and the passenger cars? Is it for a buffer?
Two possible reasons. Back in the day as a rule certain freight locomotives on NS we’re not allowed to couple against passenger cars because of the snow plows (most of the time located on both ends of the locomotive because the long hood was still considered the front) would not clear the vestibule on a passenger car. Another reason was most of the GE locomotives such as the C39-8 pulling the train had very high catwalks ( walkways) and anticlimbers which also would not clear the vestibule of a coach.
@@Inrun8 interesting. Thanks!!
good vid.on saluda.
It’s a shame that this route is going to be torn up only for a rail trail to replace it
rail trails make terrible hiking routes anyhow, they need to put it back into service or turn it into an excursion line
Rail to trail is the worst. Out of the main People who run it only one has any background to railroading and it was a guy who worked for NS. They rip everything up and just put a plaque. The rails should stay in place cover the top with gravel and keep the line intact in case of reviving the line. As well as signals Mile markers switch stands etc. it’s a shame this lines been another taken, understandable as to the reason it was abandoned but man it would’ve made a solid excursion run
Willing to bet..alot of those ties are still good, ballast (always reusable) tie plates, joint bars, and track components are prob all still good. My only hope is that if Saluda does get torn up....that all its steel and any other components get reused and distributed amongst other railroads!
@@rockguitarist931 Former railbeds often make the best trails...to be fair. Saluda makes zero sense as an operational railroad these days. Why not let the community and visitors get the most out a right of way that the railroad has no use for. Railroads nearly always reserve the right to return the right of way to use...but they almost never do. Railroads are in the business to tighten operating expenses...and this former route no longer fits into that plan.
@@NielsenSTL lmao you must be a blast at parties. I'm just saying, people who hike usually want to look at nature, not a former right of way. Why not preserve a historic route with an excursion run at least???
At 45:20 I see the white flags on the lead unit denoting it’s running as an extra. I miss those days too. Green flags meant a following section was called.
Why the gondola car? For spacing?
Are these cars pre-HEP? What provided power for the passenger cars?
Only thing better than a high nose , is a high nose long hood foward
Nice train
Nice Video!
🚂🎊🇮🇳🎊🚂
Is there any possibility of them running trains on saluda grade again?
Probably not sadly most likely will be sold off and become a hiking trail
if this line is stilled used 2day why dont they use dpu units on it or did they shut it down and does it run along interstate 40
51:45 best shot
I believe crews needed a special endorsement to run Saluda. I think my dad had one in case of strike duty. Sadly, it is now washed out in several places.
😮 P5 ❤
28:58 why does that P5 sound like a fist Gen K5LLA? Even though ACEs were made in like the 2000s
I don’t understand why there’s a gondola car on the drain between the passenger cars
Dam, someone needs to teach this engineer the proper sequence for blowing an engine horn. Its evident he hasn't the foggiest idea on how to blow the horn. How do I know, I'm a retired engineer!
Could you possibly make a sand patch grade video
I wonder if in all those years, a loop was ever considered.
This was filmed a few months before I was born
So is this line still intact?
Did anyone have an answer for where the auto racks was heading
I ENJOYED THE TRAINS COMPLETELY, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE ENGINES SIDE NUMBERS AND NOT SO MUCH OF THE FRONT VIEW.
This isn't a new video. All you did was re-upload it with a new new narrator
Actually, it is a new video. There’s 9 hours of Painter footage from Saluda Grade. Our first episode was posted last year.
Man apparently they never taught the passenger engineer how to properly blow a train horn! (had nothing to do with the people on the tracks, was doing it the whole time)
?No ditch lights?
Not back then their wasn't
Must have been a excited rookie driving the C39-8. He has no idea how to operate the horn correctly at grade crossings. His operation goes against everything engineers are taught!! Just pure laziness!!! Super great video Drayton!!
Lighten up, Francis
First Comment PIN
kind of a nice vid, but the engineer blaring the horns like that all the time is damned annoying. Watched 6 minutes and couldn't take it anymore...
Those horns sound lovely!
Thanks for sharing hope this isnt turned into a rail trail but im afraid its gone forever
Rail to trails ruins everything
@@jwrailve3615and it’s happening everywhere
@@jwrailve3615 couldn't agree more my great grandady have southern railway a right of way thru our farm in Virginia it was jus a branch which was abonded in the 70s an left to rot an grndad talked to them an wa allowed to turn it back into one feild but leave tracks so the cows could cross an keep it from growing up.ever now an then sombody would walk thru which was fine we are friendly people an most people we new an we had no problems until one day in the early 2000 some people came thru an wanted to no whywe had a gate on each end an that he would see that. They were removed in the near future cause he was somebody like I should no him an he was turning this into a rail trail an he was goina do Al this crap well the neibors aren't as friendly an especially to a prick an it turned ugly an went to court my dad told all them they is no way to stop them unless you can produce about 10 percent more than what this peick is buying this right of way for which is bull shit everybody gave thr right of way but let's jus say a little north of here the people are like the old west you have a pistol on your side an it was jus about to turn into a civil war cause the people will shoot your ass an go eat dinner before the bury you an nobody talks but needles to say now we got a rail trail an the dam people are asholes an Karen's an its a dam nitemarre. You have your dream place one day that is a paradise only to loose it to people you have no peace an you can't do shit .rail trails outa be bannned
Excellent!!! Technical question: at 32:50 i hear dynamic brakes howling but why are the diesels revved up too?
Can only be in Dynamic Braking or Power, as they are interlocked.
If it is revving in Dynamic Braking, maybe a cold engine?
The prime mover needs to rev up to produce enough juice to make the dynamics function.
@@sharkheadismthat’s exactly the opposite of how dynamics work. 🤦♂️
@@EstorilEm Dynamic brakes require excitation provided by a field current to work, all locomotive prime movers will increase their output in heavy dynamics to generate a suitable field current.
All those cameras and NS couldn’t even spray the grime off the engine ? Lol
Would be very nice if he used a camera that had autofocus instead of that out of focus headache I just watched! 😡
You do realize this was recorded atleast 20yrs ago right? Cameras have evolved a lot since then.
Why the gondola???