NO OBSERVERS NO NETHER Easy Minecraft Starter Farm Minecraft 1.18 Survival Bamboo & Sugar Cane Farm
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 січ 2022
- This combined Minecraft 1.18 Bamboo Farm & Minecraft Sugar Cane Farm uses NO QUARTZ so No Observers but is Fully Automatic. Starter Farm!
WORLD DOWNLOAD for Java Edition
In today's Minecraft 1.18 Survival Starter Farm Tutorial series, with Avomance, I am giving you a Farm that can give infinite Bamboo and Infinite Sugar cane in an Automatic Starter Farm WITHOUT having to go to the Nether! No Quartz required, yet this farm is fully operational and gives hundreds of drops per hour!
***
Quick Holla for Logical Geek Boy for giving me the idea to use a villager. You can find my mate Logic here:
/ logicalgeekboy
Total dude!
****
This is an Easy Minecraft Starter Farm will give you so much bamboo and sugar cane while you build or mine nearby. As long as the Minecraft Chunk is loaded the farm will run forever!
***
To get the Minecraft 1.18 World Download for this farm, and the Best Minecraft Seed that it is built in, simply go to avomance.com and click on the "Free Downloads" tab. You will find it there in the Java section!
***
An Easy Minecraft 1.18 Bamboo Farm and an Easy Minecraft 1.18 Sugar Cane Farm all rolled into one!
***
For searchability - a strange paragraph for you!
Not Minecraft, But Water Rises or Minecraft, But Lava Rises, or any other but challenge like that. This is not a speed run / speed runner of Minecraft against a killer / assassin and its not me and my good friends playing the NEW FUNNIEST MINECRAFT MOD EVER!!! POG CHAMP!!! With Hermitcraft and also Hermit Craft, that MrBeast does not play on!
***
This is one of the best Minecraft 1.18 Seeds and it is available to you in a download WITH the farms already made!
Go to avomance.com for details and the link!
***
Also, Go to avomance.com for more information on Minecraft Skyblock and the perks, like the chunk hopper, minions and more!
Free to play!
***
Want to play Minecraft Skyblock - but a totally unique Skyblock?
(Java Edition)
Take a look at the isles - free to play with CASH prizes!
Take a look here:
avomance.com/the-isles-of-avo/
A great Skyblock community!
***
Want to try and kill me in Minecraft hardcore Survival?
Try now!!!!
Join me now on Twitch!
/ avomance
***
If you would like to become a Patron of the Channel & help support the content produced then you can get details of how right here:
/ avomance
Your support makes a HUGE difference to the channel an allows me to continue producing content
However, you don't just get the warm fuzzies when you become a patron, you get LOTS more, such as:
• Statue in the Hall of Heroes in the AvoVerse
• Shout out when the statue is introduced, in video
• Access to AvoTopia, my Patron only server, where I play and make videos
• Access to the AvoVerse Discord with dedicated patron chat area, (where I regularly get involved personally, a LOT)
• Extra perks in AvoTopia, dependant upon your Patron level
• Patreon exclusive Google drive with downloads & files ONLY for Patreons
• Access to the AvoVerse Resource World
• Diamond Patrons have an exclusive world called Diamond Deck
• LOTS more being added over the coming months
Thank you SO MUCH. For literally the price of a cheap cup of coffee or Soda you make a BIG difference
***
If you would like to join my AvoVerse Discord then you are very welcome:
/ discord
Please note that the AvoVerse observes the discord policy of no under 13 year old users. If you are under 13 then you are VERY welcome on my minecraft servers but you cannot join my discord.
Perhaps your parents or guardians could join the discord and get you the information you need to join the AvoVerse servers, such as QuarryCraft or Avotopia
***
Don't forget to follow me on Social Media
Twitter: @AvoMinecraft
Instagram: AvoMinecraft
Twitch: twitch.tv/avomance
***
Some great Tutorials for 2021 right here:
• How to Build a Wooden ...
***
What else would you like me to do a Minecraft tutorial on?
LOTS of options on my channel for Minecraft Tutorials & great Minecraft ideas, including Lets Play and SMP
Watch the whole series from Minecraft Episode 1. Ep1 is great fun!
• Avomancia Minecraft Su...
***
(C) Avomance 2021
Minecraft 1.18 Farm Series - Ігри
i built this but modified it so the villager is a librarian who trades paper and the lecturn is at surrounding ground level so i can trade the sugarcane away
I hope you like the design of this Farm. If you have any thoughts, please do let me know in the comments below! Don't forget to hit the LIKE button as it really helps... and smack the sub button and bell too so you don't miss any content from me!
Hi Avo... I love these ideas. I usually riff on them a bit. I played around with the trigger design and found that if you replace the villager with a sheep it should work in a similar way. I built the trough, put a grass block (touching grass) at each end and let the pressure plate trigger a dispenser with a stack of potatoes... after a minecraft day I had 30 potatoes in the chest... so the sheep had triggered the plate 30 times, you can also replace the redstone blocks with a redstone torch under a conducting block to make it even cheaper! thanks so much for these great ideas ~ Jeove
thats a great Idea J - I may magpie it ;P
@@Avomance absolutely! it would never have occurred to me to use the passive mob AI as a timer... very clever... thanks for keeping the grey cells jumping! :)
@@jovertoncan he just created a whole new concept of activating process.
To sum up: normal sugar farm, but uses a villager walking over a pressure plate to trigger the pistons instead of observers.
I was having major problems with my observers and pistons in my farms. Anyone who plays both java and bedrock knows what I'm talking about. This fixes everything and makes the farms look better too. You sir, are a genius!
That’s brilliant!! Glad it’s worked well for you!
I feel your pain. Very off topic but they need to change the fact that skeletons have aimbot. It's stupid
@@DarkXWolf17-If-yk-yk This can probably be done with a behavior pack for bedrock or datapack for java. You just need to know how to code it or find someone who can.
Still the Bob Ross of minecraft! (it's a good thing, I love Bob Ross)
lol William!
Bob Ross is a legend of painting
This is so accurate!!
Doesnt thw sugarcane need sunlight/open sky above it to grow? Cam someone confirm it for me?
This is a great idea for getting it to be automatic and never thought of using a villager as the triggering mechanism for that. Thank You again for all the great early farms in 1.18 and can not wait for the avoverse servers to reopen. Waiting for the next great video 😁☕️
Great tutorial. I had no villagers nearby, but I was inspired by this video and came up with another solution. I put a detector rail on the track, and when the minecart goes over it, it sends the signal to the pistons.
Exactly what i was looking for thank you. I don't know how any build needing observers can call itself a STARTER build, yet its like 90% of the videos that come up in my search are guilty of it.
I love the idea of villagers doing the harvesting! It would be cool to run all my farms this way.
Going to build this farm this weekend, never thought of using a villager before with a pressure plate.
Thank you very much for this tutorial.
So clever!! I feel like this villager mechanic could be easily implemented into other uses 🤔 gotta put my thinking cap on now!!
I love it just because of how creative it is! Awesome stuff! ♥
I think I'll use a daylight sensor instead of villagers, since the materials are not a problem in my case, and I like that better than 100 observers, but I gotta say, I appreciate you taking the time to make it look pretty. That's the part I struggle with the most, so kudos :)
Thank you for this idea. Villagers were the greatest addition to Minecraft. I utilize them in every build. Having them farm food for you and power your machines is brilliant. Not to mention the build is beautiful.
absolutely love this! im using this for sure! thanks Avo!
Enjoy!Thanks Flooff! Am looking forward to seeing your Skyblock later!
This farm is a million times more productive than another I’d tried. I actually made a mistake when building and had 4 blocks in the middle but I figured out how to make it work without redoing it. Great tutorial thanks!
Avo's farms are always great. I wish he could do all of silentwisperer's farm with his own final touches. Silent's farms are great too, don't get me wrong. I have some of them, we would be completely lost without him in Bedrock. But he has said himself he never does interiors, or decoration and stuff like that. Only the technical part. So you end up with an amazing machine that works wonderfully but it's just kinda ugly. Or floating plataforms and blocks. Imagine if Avomance finished all of those Bedrock Villager Breeders and Iron Farms in his personal style.
Very educational, I learned a lot. I swopped out the villager for a sheep and that worked great - the sheep walks back and forth and doesn't need to sleep.
I think an etho hopper clock with a mono stable circuit would be easier than a villager. You already have redstone blocks, hoppers, and pistons after all.
Wouldn't you need a comparator for that?
@@Avomance oh right, that takes quartz
I have expected repeater clock since it doesn't require quarts. In a one hand, it might be too fast and noisy. But in another hand you can build a quite long circuit along your roof and with maximum delay on repeters it might give you about half-minute between impulses.
Thanks for sharing Avo
This is a great idea using the villager as the trigger. I never thought of that with them just going over a pressure plate. Thanks for all the great early farms Avomance. Can not wait for the avoverse servers to reopen. Waiting for the next video 😁☕️
Great new farm design Avo! And happy new year too you.
Happy new year!And to you Fyremane!
I like the villager clock, very clever.
This could also be an easy kelp farm btw, only the collection system needs modifying because kelp floats to the top
Yea. Just change the glass in front of the pistons/bamboo/sugarcane into glass panes/iron bars (whichever is more convenient) add a water stream/hopper minecart or hook it up to the other system and then decorate if you want too. Not that hard
Another killer build. I win when I watch you build it and when I shall try to make my own farm. You are such an excellent and generous MC Pro. I am glad I subscribed many months ago.
Bless you Lainey.... again :)
This is a cheeky implementations for alternating the observers. +10 for you.
🤪
Thank you. I started a new world and don't want to go the nether until I have gotten all my bases covered in the overworld.
a redstone tourch under the block where your powered rail is on is much cheaper then the redstone block...
I agree Andre - can totally do that.
@@Avomance Great video !! Great farm !!
i like this farm. LGB used the villager idea for a farm in his latest world but he billed as kind of a goofy or unusual farm. yours is stepped up a bit and makes it make sense and pretty useful as an alternative to using quartz based redstone.
Thanks Yoda - I am pretty sure that Logic's uses a ton of observers too?
in theory you can combine this with a Carrot or similar farm, having the farmer walk in and over the presure plate when night comes, and again when it changes to day.
thats an awesome idea
Tripwire too
thats such a good idea!!
Built this this morning - works great! thank you! Put sugarcane on one side, and bamboo on the other. Only thing I've noticed is that the sugarcane doesn't grow as fast as the bamboo - but I suppose if that's the case, could just add more sugarcane! Again, thanks! (edit: used this in 1.15 version)
Definitely going to use this method for a kelp farm I was planning to build!! Now I don't need to go to the Nether!!
Just make sure that you have the system activate enough, kelp will float to the top and most farms have the water have it flow to the end and into a hopper, if kelp is allowed to grow up all the way it will create source blocks and remove the flowing water effecting stopping your hoppers from working, you just can’t let it grow to the top. Just my advice
@@aidanatkinson7717 you can put buttons on the structure blocks right under your water channel to keep the kelp from growing that high....that's what I did anyway and it works. 😁
I miss this farm, I do love how your mind works. I'm using it in 2.20 snapshot now. Got a little island I'm working up, so I decided your farm fit the footprint of a cargo ship, roughly. I'm giving it a shot, but real decorating will happen tomorrow I think lol, I've been minecrafting all night lol. Thanks for the tutorial.
I'm setting this farm up but the pistons will be actuated by a redstone signal generated from an automatic melon farm, which activates every minute or so as opposed to a once-daily only set up. Saves a lot on observers.
nice idea! Thanks for the tip.
Look into using a bud switch, uses a couple comparators and a target block, but no observers needed.
Though I do like the idea of being able use the villager for trades in this case....
always a good Saturday when avo releases a farm tutorial!
Enjoy!Scott - dude! Good to see you my friend!
This is a great concept, but I think you could have taken it a step further and set it up to trade with the villager. In effect selling him the fruits of his own labor
When you put that pressure plate in for the villager to walk on, it was a real Eureka moment for me, you're a genius. Fresh Thinking.
It's easier to lure the villager if you use both the workstations; attract them to one then go off and place the 2nd, then break the first. Just repeat the relay race and they're less likely to wander off when you break one as, they'll instantly be attracted to the next 👍🏻
Boats help just for keeping them in one spot, too... As a safeguard 👀
This is genius, I love this. I'm building this immediately
Excellent tutorial. Thank you.
You are welcome!
Couldn't you use a chicken instead of a villager? Would save the bed, workstation and some blocks. Also chickens are easier to lure in :)
I find it much easier to acquire some quartz then coaxing a villager tbh. They do not like me.
Thank you for the build Avomance :)
Thank YOU Dusan
@@Avomance No...No....No.... THANK YOU for the great farms that you are giving us 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🤗🤗😎😎😀😀 !!!
Another home run by one of the greatest creators to grace this platform!
Very good one....WP
Fyi, couldn't find the world download link today (will find main page on another video). These are simple ideas but so much has changed that I feel lost. A tutorial would rock. Redstone basics - lighting (level, options, etc) Thanks mate.
watches as the job station, and the bed are placed. "waaaiiiit. a villager clock?" *snerks*
I'm glad he keeps reminding us that the cosmetic look of our builds is completely up to us. I kept forgetting.
Great idea, beautifully implemented. Win/Win! Thank you Avo!!
Glad you liked it my mate - good to see you!
Good idea using the villager as the trigger.
Put in water where the bamboo or sugercane is, and make it with kelp?
yep - that could work too!
Hm. This mechanic could also work with your Kelp farm, but using the water tower gathering method from that one. Neat!
Good call! DEFO COULD
So has anyone else been asking when stairs and slabs going to be added to the concrete blocks?
EVERYONE - I also want dirt slabs and stairs please
This is genius. Thanks Avomance!
thanks my mate
The beginning was starting to feel like a counting with avo video lol thanks for the great farms you make
How about a villager based crop farm those are always fun
Thanks for the idea!Thanks Keith - it was Counting with Avo-ey wasn't it! Villager crop farms haven't changed much, but I'd be happy to put one out if people wanted one!
you can combine a villager crop farm with this one, making the farmer go in here each night to sleep, running over the pressure plate :)
@@32Loveless50 that is a great idea
Lovely done good sir!
Thank you kindly my friend
I was wondering when this would be tackled as the nether is slightly more challenging these days and not the free ride of days gone by. Nice build and very similar to the way I thought of a solution, but I opted for a massive underground clock, as I had the resources, over a villager, as they're a pain in the rear end to coerce at times.
I mean you're not wrong, but you can't really ignore the Nether for long. Personally I'd be surprised at anyone that goes for villagers first, but of course YMMV. It's certainly a clever idea to use a villager trigger.
@@garysturgess6757 - It just depends on how you prioritise your farms and this farm is a smart idea for someone who hasn't the tools or goodies to keep themselves safer in the Nether, due to modern changes.
If you have have immediate access to villagers it's perfect. If you prioritise mining over things you're more likely to get redstone dust/blocks sooner, offering you the auto clock option which is all under your control and not the flippancy of villagers, who can be a right pain to coerce.
"Trapdoors can be quite expensive"... he says as he willy-nilly puts down 8 redstone blocks 😂
as someone who just started playing this game these automatic farms are nuts freaking PHD engineers playing this game also how does one kidnap villagers is now something i have google lol
Boats will be your friend
They only seem complicated because you're not used to them. It's not difficult once you've built some on your own.
oh my gosh this is the funniest thing I've ever seen I love it
Tip : Put a pair of powered rails on the end of the hoppers too (power it too). If not done, the minecarts tend to not bounce back and get halted. (I'm on Java 1.18.1)
First, my english is no very good, ok? But, i think that block up your hopper, except if you move the chests for collecting
I miss zero ticks builds
Did you know that you can do 2 rows of 8 with a red stone block torch or switch on the 9th so you end up with 17 blocks powered
If you make the workstation a lectern and leave a hole to interact with the villager then you can craft excess sugarcane into paper and trade it right there for emeralds or spellbooks.
Amazing and ingenious
Thanks Ozel
since all you need is some one to stand on the plate. could you change the villager for an animal ??? easier to get in
you could - but movement control is more random and mods stop moving when you move away fro them enough
Just get nether quartz from Stone Mason villagers. A little trading to level them up. Easy method. Then you can make your observers without going to the nether.
They trade quartz BLOCKS. Not nether quartz. Quartz blocks can't be crafted into nether quartz. That's why this wont work
A much more simple method would be to build a burnout clock style farm. Navy nexus has a good tutorial on that method.
That is brilliant! Hopefully it works on console. I seem to have had a slight problem with the redstone builds using torches on console vs. Desktop.
no reason this shouldn't work on Bedrock at all
A lot of the Java builds won't work on console. Be sure to check that the builds your looking up have bedrock in the title.
@@LayZeeSlaya this style is simple enough for it to work since it doesnt require any Redstone programming, just simple on and off.
@@chubbygardengnome Still a valid argument. Any and I mean ANY mob farm that works on java won't work on bedrock. Spawn mechanics are too different.
@@DarkXWolf17-If-yk-yk nah, a number of them do, they're just not as efficient since bedrock doesn't spawn mobs as fast. It just depends on the farm, many work across both.
@ Avomance I thought this was brilliant. I made the farm. And, my villager sells Infinity books, so I felt that was also a bonus. It works; however it does not produce well. In the several (irl) days it’s been running and as I’ve played, each side has only collected 1.5 stacks. It took more to make the farm (sugar cane both sides). I’ll be adding observers and moving the villager out. If you can think of a reason, let me know. I’m on a small private server. Anyone else having better results?
For the sugarcane and bamboo to grow, you have to be near the farm so it will do random ticks. If it’s not in your spawn chunks, it won’t stay loaded to operate when you aren’t near unless you have a chunk loader (which still won’t allow it to grow). So a farm like this has to be near where you spend your time or you should AFK near it.
2:41 you need powered rail on the hooper near the chest. Next image : not the case. ;)
cool idea to let the farmer fire the pistons
haha - perfect - make the villager do the work :D
It’s the lazy man’s farm 😜
And then sell the product of the farm back to the villager. Love it.
If you are building something similar on Bedrock then you may want to use a Fletching Table the villager will also work on rainy days. For some reason the other professions don't go to their workstations when it's raining. That's why they're best for iron farms on Bedrock. Java allows working in the rain for all villagers, as far as I know, they also don't need to work to spawn golems, unlike on Bedrock.
Thats a really good point GothBoy - same goes for Iron farms too I believe!?
@@Avomance Sure does!
it's funny with daylight sensors and observers a lot of people forgot 'plates and some mobs' works as a random redstone output, hah thanks for the reminder on that
What'd I'd do actually now I think about is have it criss cross with a tiny wheat farm. Nothing massive, that way you've got the villager doing 'work' on top of the work they already do.
absolutely true... its unreliable, well... perhaps just unpredictable, but it works
Nice farm
Thank you my mate
Wish I'd have seen this a while back before fighting through the nether to get crystals lmao.
Would a minecart and pressure plate work instead of a villager?
Or activator rail, yes. A simple repeater clock works. All you need is the pistons to fire regularly. Villagers work and sleep schedules make this a decent delay.
OOOH i just realised with a couple ajustments you could farm pumpkins and melons this way too you just need to swap the farm designs
You could actually... thats a possibility!
With some adjustments you and get a kelp, bamboo, sugarcane, melon, and pumpkin farm! If you go for a kelp and bamboo farm you could get dried kelp which gives xp when collected then you could craft it into dried kelp blocks then either sell it to a villager or use it to smelt things. Wow!
..... I literally walked through a nether fortress and came to the realization that I was overprepared. The nether really isn't that bad especially if you stick to making tunnels
True. Plus, it's even less of a deal if you're just there to farm some quartz. Just bring some building blocks to protect your nether portal as well as flint and steel.
Thank you for this amazing tutorial!
One question about this...
Is there a way to make this work for kelp?
Kelp is similar to bamboo. Flood the chambers you want kelp in. The main difference is that the harvested kelp will float, so instead of the hopper minecarts to pick up the items, place water sources at the top over a temporary solid block so that the water flows sideways into a collection channel and then remove the temporary block. Then direct the collection channel with water toward collection hoppers.
@@another_jt Awesome! Thanks!
Nice
Here’s how to dance to Avo’s Waltz…
1,2,3… water
1,2,3… water
Do this as long ad needed!!
Thanks Avo!! Quite clever!!!
👽👍
Nice one! GENIUS
I thought if you can't get a villager, if you can adjust as a pathway, then you can set it off everytime you want by..
or, perhaps a cow or other mob that can still also trigger the plate if you can't get a villager or you don't want to bother with them
Can even use an empty boat in a water stream to trigger it. Other animals are a bit unpredictable. Bees have a regular pattern between flowers and hive but won’t trigger pressure plates. Maybe sheep between grassy areas but still unreliable, they may just stand around without wandering.
@@Barghaest I'm not sure if bees can trigger tripwire but if they can that might work. Either way I would just use a simple repeter clock or some other redstone clock that doesn't use quartz.
Flipping genius
I so prefer this. Redstone gets confusing as fuck REALLY fast. I envy people who have just more of a quick, intuitive grasp of redstone. I feel like more engineering-minded people maybe are that way. For me it is NOT intuitive at all, and even "simple" redstone builds confuse the fuck out of me lol, circuitry is not my thing at all.
Anyone else here gordon ramsey? ALso thank you I needed an easier less expensive bamboo/sugarcane farm in my village.
Smart!
I think the kelp/bonemeal farm can be applied with this same method
Hmmmmmm, saw Logical Geek Boy use villager as trigger 🤔
The only thing missing is a lightning rod, to guard against the chance of fire and/or converting into a witch
@Avomance:
Are there ever any situations where you wouldn't want to protect your villagers from lightning striking them?
If you are being a bit cruel and wanted to make a witch? other than that, nope, a lightening rod is a good call!
@@Avomance
Wait-a-second...
...I wonder just how efficient it would be if you used your Villager_Breeder design (w/lightning protection) & shuttled the excess population to an area that deliberately lacks lightning protection, so that the resulting witches could be processed for their drops? This might help prevent server lag, since the breeder design has no off-switch. How close to the lightning rod must a villager be, to be converted into a witch?
Very clever
Thanks my friend
I just built this farm. I'm new to the game. My mine cart isn't picking anything up. I can see it set in its place until it times out. What did I do wrong?
Is it a hopper minecart? A regular minecart will not gather items, but a hopper minecart on a rail can pull them through blocks.
You can craft a hopper minecart with a hopper above a normal minecart in the crafting grid.
A little resource heavy, love the build. I think instead of a villager + pressure plate, build this but set it up into a house build or path to ur house. Then u just walk on the pressure plate once a day. Or hell if possible, set up a daylight sensor like others have stated, then u know it will fire off once a day, however I like the old school 7 long water flow method lol. Yeah it's not super high efficiency but hey, it works with less resources lol
You need quarts for a daylight sensor
Homie sounds just like young Ricky Gervais
Could you do this with a red stone clock?
Just put a chicken to do the pressure plate stepping?
Too random... it could just stand on the plate and that would stop the crops growing
How about a sheep, with a few grass blocks on either side, so it would walk across to eat the other grass?
Possibly, you could add a dispenser with shears to that and it could be a wool farm too!
Villager is better it will walk from bed to loom and vice versa
The only animal with a predictable enough pattern similar to a villager is the bee, which won’t trigger pressure plates. The only replacement would be a clock timer (either just redstone or using something like an empty boat in a looping water stream or an activator rail on the mine cart track).
It would seem to me you could use any mob that wanders to randomly trigger the pressure plate.
you could - but then its random rather than directed, and they cold just stop ON the plate so the pistons are fired and the crops wont grow
Instead of a villagers get a chicken or cow...it'll still set off the pressure plate
they do - but they don't have to walk across it ever... they can just "freeze" in place. The villagers will walk from bed to workstation at least once per day
Really nice farm. Thanks for sharing :-)
So nice of youThanks loads Colin
I replaced the villager with a daylight sensor, and that works okay, but the minecart doesn't run. I followed the design, but it stays stopped on the hopper side.
Do you have a powered rail there and a solid block at the end? You do need both
@@Avomance yes, although there isn't any redstone power at that end? I tried putting a redstone block there also but it didn't work. What have I don't wrong?
@@thomaswalker.5030 the redstone block can't touch the hopper
Couldn't you just use a repeater clock instead of messing about with a villager?
That’s was my thought or use a day light sensor
@@honoredsage4946 Well the premise is "no nether", so daylight sensors are off. So are hopper clocks because of their reliance on comparators.
What's wrong with the nether that's where nether wart is.
@@MediHusky ..Yes i know.. the video you are on specifies no nether. As in... this farm is for people who want to build a farm without going to the nether. So my comment was a suggestion that does not require going to the nether.
If you're going to the nether, just use a hopper clock. That'll activate more often than a daylight sensor.
@@mowsey98 Uhhhh in your other comment you said hopper clocks are off the table because of comparators? Why say they are back on the table now? Or is that a typo?
genius!