Zank.memes7 Boi I talk about this game everyday to my friends (all girls) (I’m also female) and they are like it’s just a game and I say back to them NO ITS A LIFESTYLE, I just cried for 4 or 5 days to mourn Arthur I even cried when my friend brought him up.
Red dead redemption 1 final: i wanna play with John, not Jack! Red dead redemption 2 final: i want tô play with Arthur, not John! Rockstar: thats the way It is
During the ending sequence when John and Arthur are standing off again the rest of the gang, Im sure that if Sean, Lenny, Kieran, and Hosea were still alive they’d all side with Arthur
the moment when you finish the game and playing as marston u realize how deeply addicted you are for Arthur... you don't feel the same way... searching stupid videos "can you save Arthur in rdr2" you know u can't but still the character isn't dead in you and all the time u speak to NPC character u want to hear Arthur's "sure" "okay" the manner he talks and it makes you sad... what a character...
yep epilogue hard to play after Arthur...problem is middle of the game its weaste of money to spend on camp and anything because in the end its doesnt matter :)) great experience but very SAD game
You know what affects people the most about RDR2? The story. No one cares about the gameplay and so you could argue that Rockstar were better off making an animated film instead of a game.
Yeah I agree playing as Arthur makes you more attached because you can affect the ending with your actions, you can interact and see things you wouldn't normally see in a movie. I loved Arthur I cried my eyes out and tear up when I hear "unshaken" such a beautiful game
This was my reaction as well. This story was so well thought out, and executed brilliantly. This moment, by far, articulated who Arthur was as a person. The moment as his horse lie dying and he comforts him, was a very close second. It takes a lot for a character to claim such a place in so many peoples thoughts and hearts. Especially a video game. As I write this, I just completed the final story arc for Arthur a few hours ago. I honestly find myself feeling a bit depressed. I know it’s just a video game. Just a fictional story. It captured and articulated Arthur, as a person, so damn well he feels like a real person. This story line captivated me from start to finish. I spent many nights playing into the early hours of the morning. The look on his weary face as he admits his fear of death. A man contemplating his own mortality. They captured the look of a real man, realizing his impending doom and his fate sealed. It looked and felt so authentic. This story, and Arthur, will stick with me for a long time. Absolute masterpiece, in my opinion. Rockstar knocked this one out of the park.
There is no canon. Our individual choices in this masterpiece gave us a choice. It was the only way. We played as Arthur, and then we played for Arthur.
*God of war: I’m the game of the year Arthur Morgan: Outta the damn way! RDR2 is & always will be THE BEST GAME ARTHUR MORGAN is & always will be best protagonist
I played Arthur as honorably as possible after he got the disease, and I got him shaved and trimmed up and put on his brown jacket for his final mission. A truly legendary character
Chris Mitchell I wish I could have done that, but the damn mission extended over 3, so I could only get his hat. I was wearing a red outfit almost like Dutch’s
Same, that's why it was such a good play through for me, I was a terrible person untill the tuberculosis. I felt like I had to help everyone before I died. 10/10
I named the horse after my grandma and chucked my remote a cross the room 2 two months and I still don't have a new one Update I got a new one four months but I can play the epilogue now
Like a lot of people i was spoiled of the ending of red dead redemption 2, I genuinely thought i would never play this game, then I saw it on sale a couple of months later and thought, what the hell, its 20 bucks, so i download it, heard it was good, saw some videos on it, looked nice, though it would be fun for like 10 hours and I would put it down. about 40 hours later I’m still in the story mode exploring this beautifully crafted piece of human ingenuity, the way that rockstar crafted all of the npc’s in this game to be something more, about the ending being spoiled, I knew Arthur was going to die at the end of the first part, it didn’t mater though, its not about the destination its about the journey, and the journey was a memorable one to say the least. Arthur Morgan is such a great protagonist and I wish other devs would put as much work into their characters as rockstar did, I’ve since played the first red dead redemption and its almost as good as RDR2, its just got something missing, I know nobody will read this comment and will just scroll though in search of memes and people saying they cried for three days when Arthur died, thats fine, but I encourage anyone who went though this game and felt sad or alone without Arthur, just think about all of the things him and Lenny are getting up to in heaven (or hell depending on how you played) and how much you’ve experience with him, I’ve honestly never experienced the friendship i felt with Arthur in any other video game, I felt I was learning with him, and if your here you probably did too, keep thinking about how much fun you had with Arthur, Thank you for getting to the bottom of this rant it was good to get thing on soothing and this seemed like a good place to put it.
What makes his death so hard is that he tried his hardest to be good in the end and died just how he wanted to. I sometimes forget that he’s a video game character, and not an actual family member I’ve lost. Been months and his death still makes me cry
Well, that's what makes this game such a work of art. You're so immersed along the journey with Arthur because you're making those decisions with him to be good.
Yes I know these are not real people, but bare with me for a moment. Imagine this. I'd like to imagine Arthur joining Lenny and Hosea in a big tavern in the sky. They rejoice to see each other again and look back on the good times together. They drink, they laugh, they sing together until what feels like years go by. All of a sudden, they here the door swing open once more. They turn in shock to meet John step in and remove the very same hat Arthur gave him all those years ago. Silence fills the air for the first time in forever. The group stand to meet him in sorrow. "I tried guys" John says. Arthur puts a hand on John's shoulder and utters the only thing honest enough. "We all did son."... "Now give me my damn hat back and grab a beer!" Just a little edit. Thank you all for your kind words. Knowing that my arguably ok writing got some kind of positive emotions really brightens my day. Again, thank you so much!
yep that few minutes....never forget..... that ride....never saw such a thing and never feel the same in any game. That moment and the last one with the sunlight....worth every penny.
You know what’s so fucked up? I couldn’t really play the game no more after his death. It took me a while to finish the epilogue chapters but even when I was out in town or at work I legitimately felt like I lost a very good friend. To this day I have a sad feeling in his story. Rockstar did a beautiful job in making Arthur Morgan. Since I was a child my favorite game of all time was Ocarina of Time, RDR 2 is honestly right next to it now, if not surpassed it. One things for sure tho, Arthur Morgan to me, is the best character I’ve ever seen in any video game or movie.
Arthur Morgan I’m actually playing the game right now as Arthur 😂😂 Just gave a dollar to the blind man “You are not who you think you are sir.. which is a good thing”
“We’re more ghosts then people” damn to see Arthur just giving up on his own life and worrying about John more then himself really makes you bond with Arthur and it makes you realize who he really is
Leudwig vonshwartsenhelm Same with the first game. You grow so attached to the characters in their own stories that once it ends, you’re just left wanting more
I have never cried When a character in a movie or a game dies. But this game, Arthur he changed my life.... i cried like never before Not even all these likes Will make me change the way i loved Arthur ( and this is the most i got)
I usually don't either, but when Arthur pulled his hat out from his bag, I balled my eyes out. I have never loved a video game character this much until I met Arthur Morgan.
It wont change the ending or the scenes because its programed like that curing TB would be just a freeom affect in mission cutscenes Arthur would steal cough and probably look the same
I recently had the great pleasure of watching someone dear to me do a playthrough as Arthur, and this tribute made me cry. As a non-gamer person, I was blown away by the storyline, character development, and the graphics. The landscapes, the light, and the rain are truly something extraordinary. I miss Arthur now.
I didn't think another video game or character could ever affect me the way RDR1 and John Marston did. Enter Arthur Morgan. Beginning of the game: Who's this douche? Why can't I play as John? End of the game: Arthur, noooo!! 😭
I'm trying to play the epilogue but I'm struggling to like it because everything makes me think of Arthur. When I realized John's horse now has Arthur's saddle, it nearly broke me
Yeah that transition from a hearty belly laugh in to a voice cracking, teary puppy dog eyed "I'm afraid" really shook me to the core. That was the first time I'd seen Arthur near tears as he finally expressed his fear to someone. The entire time before those few seconds he puts on the bad ass act and pretends not to care. That was the moment I realized Arthur was my favorite Rockstar character.
The fact that over a million people have watched proves it was an amazing story and I dont believe it will ever be topped by video games as we know of them
It doesn't matter if Arthur morgan is just some code in s game, he touched all our lives, and connected all of us, all players of red dead redemption 2, isn't that becoming a legend.
I'm currently playing RDR2 for the first time. I haven't even finished it yet but I dare to say it's the best game I've ever played. What a master piece. One part of me begs for a series by HBO the other chills with the possibility of they ruining it. Arthur Morgan is the most incredible character ever presented in a game.
I think the reason why Arthur is so lovable is the fact that we mold this character. We make him the person we are... on the inside, and when he died we see something in our selves dying as well.
I started with my second play through. I will never rescue Micah and never go near Strauss. Doesn't matter if the story doesn't progress, I just roam around with Arthur.
I hear yah man but unfortunately Arthur dying is his destiny, if he didn't get TB he would have never realised the importance of life. RIP to a legend of the west.
Oh my lord. The scene with the nun, when Arthur admits that he's scared.... I was heartbroken! The look of fear that rockstar captured on his face was so emotional and real. I wanted to cry for him.
in 2021 I have finished several new games such as AC Valhalla, WD Legion, even Cyberpunk2077, but again and again I finished RDR2 for the 3rd time, Really a good game. This game is very interesting to repeat. And for me Arthur One of the best characters.
It's amazing how a video game with such deep heart warming story can change a person to be more responsible and just a better person in general, and people say video games are bad
The whole ending sequence was beautifully painful, but honestly the part that got me the worst was when he says "thank you" to his horse as it dies. I used the incredibly fast and tall reverse dappled black thoroughbred stallion from the special addition the entire game and absolutely adored it. That scene completely killed me.
The fact that Jack Marston at the end of RDR1 becomes an outlaw makes Arthur's death even more sad. He died for a better future for Marstons. Ended in a cycle.
We dont know if he lived the outlaw life though, if I remember it was just the pinkerton Ross you kill for revenge, but that also goes back to the cycle you talk about since Arthur talks about not believeing in revenge.
Sometimes being the outlaw is the best way to live. Live your way, fuck the rest, and if it ends in a hell fire of bullets take as many as you can before you take your last breath.
Arthur is my favorite character in any game or movie. I look up to him (the good play through) as if he was a friend. He’s more loyal to the people that he cares about than most of the people I know in life.
Arthur always reminds of Wolverine/Logan. A man who is deeply flawed and in deep pain who despite saying otherwise is still a good man. A hero in the eyes of some. In the end they died their own way and lived their own way. Arthur is a tragic hero.
You’re not alone, I’m fully willing to admit I cried at the very end with John on the mountain. I’ve never gotten that emotional over a work of fiction, let alone a video game.
yeah I feel yuh, Rockstar have created a truly next level immersive ancestor simulator - they almost need to take responsibility for the grief they cause creating such a bond with a fictional character. If this is the future of games / simulations we have already acknowledged we will create a true emotional bond with AI, even weak AI, let alone real AI.
Purkiss Boy That exact sentence made me tear up several times, because it shows just how human and real of a person he was. Truly an honorable man, he was
Arthur wasnt just..... some character in a video game he was.... more way more and I'm happy n proud that I was able to be with arthur for that short period of time... R.I.P arthur morgan😔✊
I don't remember the last time I cried as much as I did when I finished Arthur's story and watched him peacefully drift off, watching that one last sunrise. In fact I couldn't even hear him take his last breath, I was sobbing way too loudly. Rockstar really did create the greatest character ever, because losing him truly felt like losing someone very dear to me.. like a close friend or a family member. I got to know him so well during all the hours I spent roaming the land, and the bond I formed with him.. it's really strong and special. I've taken a liking to quite a few of fictional characters, but the bond I formed with Arthur is the strongest of them all. Even after I witnessed him die I've mourned him and visited his grave many times. One night I was heading off to sleep and just buried my head in the pillow and honest to god, cried for Arthur like there's no tomorrow. Rest in Peace, Arthur Morgan, the greatest and most real protagonist who ever lived.
God i felt the same, i cried myself to bed for days. I’m still depressed and every time i hear the songs or see videos like this i cry again. Even tho he is a fictional character, Arthur Morgan will forever be a dear friend to me.
When he died I bawled my eyes out. I know, hes not real, he never existed. But he made such a huge impact. I see things a little differently now. Sometimes I wonder what I'd be like if it werent for the impact that game made on me. Thank you, Arthur Morgan. For changing my life.
This game is what makes me try to be better for my self and my friends and family. Because of this game, I’m not afraid to stand up for my faith. I’m not afraid to die to save other people.
I saw the ending of this Game when it came out, I was curious never thought I would play it, in Christmas 2019 I got it, I know what was coming, still this was the first Game that has made me cry Ever. Arthur and his goodbyes Hurt like hell, Hosea, Lenny and Sean. This is a masterpiece in storytelling, gameplay, all of it. Arthur made his best in the ending, as we all should.
Small Floof Dutch realised what he did and when you play as John and go to kill Micah Dutch is there and John asks “What are you doing here?” And Dutch says “Same as you I guess”, so Dutch knew what he did and wanted to get revenge
And so did John. Arthur gave his life for John and had told John in many different occasions to “not look back”... Then John completely ignores what Arthur says and goes after Micah and gets himself killed.
Well that mission we done who robbed how is that missions we did oh yeah Dutch hit his head and he's crazy now that's why he did it I bet you didn't understand what did I say
After Arthur dies and John took over I barely could get myself to finish the epilogue. While playing as John, I couldn’t get rid of this sad feeling of being alone and no home to go back to. Despite that John has his own house and family, it didn’t feel the same as getting back to camp as Arthur. That gang really felt like a family. And getting back to camp, after a long time out in the world, sure as hell felt like being back home. It’s amazing how a video game can have such an impact. Changed the way I look at things in life
I thought I was nuts getting so upset about this game till I came here and saw I’m not the only one. I played the whole game believing that Arthur would get a happily ever after with Mary. I just fell in love with him and really wanted him to have the love and happiness that he deserved. I’ve cried and cried over it, and I’ve never gotten so upset over a character in a game ever. He was just so real. The way he was so self deprecating and couldn’t see the man inside we could all see. I cant play the epilogue, everything just reminds me of him and makes me upset again 😥🥺 xx
I hated seeing him go out like that as well, alone on the mountain. I had the honourable ending so he watched the sunrise one last time, but I hated him being alone. Wish Dutch would have killed Micah and stayed with him. It set me right off when he said to Dutch he had given him everything and Dutch just walks away!! Absolutely savage 😡
Yeah it sucked that he was left there alone. All the love he gave . N love he had from others. N every self less act he did just to be left alone in the end.. it sucks cuz he put everyone else before him self. That's just priceless
I’m not gonna lie as soon as I played the epilogue I didn’t feel like I was playing rdr, I felt like I was playing a game where Arthur never really existed at all and I just sat there watching John take up the mantle and cried knowing that we will never see Arthur again....
I have a salutation I call it Start New Game but yeah you are totally wright when arthur died and it went to the epilogue I restarted and did more side stuff and took longer to complete then I get to the epilogue play for about 10 minutes. Stop playing cause it dident feel wright played again in 2 days and finished the main epilogue story the next night
When he said “I’m afraid” my heart shattered. I’ve played this game over and over three times now and I still cry every time. Arthur Morgan has made me feel more emotion than anyone in my real life. He made me feel alive. To one of my best friends, thank you Arthur
I felt so close to him. That’s weird his not real, he felt so real. When he died it was to hard for me to take it, I was really sad for a week or so. Rip Arthur, thank you for the experience.
Somehow I've found myself very spiritual in the last two years. So this may sound like the talk of a crazy person.....😅 This is something I've heard. All works of fiction are real. We breathed so much emotion and pieces of ourselves into it takes on a life of it's own. Our belief and emotions give it power. So Arthur is very much real. In some small bit he is real.
The song gets me every time. Arthur's death felt so real to me. Losing him was heartbreaking. I cried when John died too in RDR... but Arthur... His death cut deep.
A new Arthur Morgan tribute is out: ua-cam.com/video/UtvOhzMTxwc/v-deo.html
You know a game is good when the players want a prequel to the prequel.
Dutch fighting in the Civil War
Lol.... that would be red dead revolver my dear boy... if you know you know
nota mortum I mean we want the story of the beginning of Dutch’s gang, when it was just Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur.
@@arizexas that would be cool but how about Arthurs father or Hosea.
@@matteo-nf1kvno shit.... it was a ps2 game numbnut.
How can Arthur not be real but be so real
Yeah, such a paradox
He's very much real
Arthur are real if you believe
I honestly feel like he was a real person and i actually got sad when he died
Zank.memes7 Boi I talk about this game everyday to my friends (all girls) (I’m also female) and they are like it’s just a game and I say back to them NO ITS A LIFESTYLE, I just cried for 4 or 5 days to mourn Arthur I even cried when my friend brought him up.
”Get the hell out of here and be a goddamn man”, that was the day John Marston became a man.
I love this coment
Yeah, He didn't care about his family at the start. Until Arthur told him to go to his family and be a man
Yes
In my opinion, the day when John became a true man is when he sacrificed himself for Abagail and Jack
He was a gay goddammit
Red dead redemption 1 final: i wanna play with John, not Jack!
Red dead redemption 2 final: i want tô play with Arthur, not John!
Rockstar: thats the way It is
N creio q achei um br
@@lucasduartezajac3786 gay
@@eduardizando836 emocionante mano 😔✊
Red Dead 3: I want to play as as Jack not Don!
@@lucasduartezajac3786 porra demais
Red dead depression.
Really though
Seriously...
Yes, I was very sad for Arthur .. :(
Exactly what I was thinking
Nopitron You have no idea what depression is, you asshole. A game can’t give you it. Can a game give you schizophrenia?
For Sean
For Lenny
For Kieran
For Hosea
For Arthur
Gone to soon. But will never be forgotten. RIP.
And last but not least, for John bad Abigail Marston... They died too
and Mac Davey and Jenny
Damn... A lot of good friends were lost in this story
@@CrafterVSWild and Uncle, he will always be my favorite parasite
During the ending sequence when John and Arthur are standing off again the rest of the gang, Im sure that if Sean, Lenny, Kieran, and Hosea were still alive they’d all side with Arthur
the moment when you finish the game and playing as marston u realize how deeply addicted you are for Arthur... you don't feel the same way... searching stupid videos "can you save Arthur in rdr2" you know u can't but still the character isn't dead in you and all the time u speak to NPC character u want to hear Arthur's "sure" "okay" the manner he talks and it makes you sad... what a character...
I couldn’t even play the epilogue. I had to start a new game so I could play as Arthur again
@@TK-rz6ni you have to play it brother. It's amazing.
I legit spend 15 mins on "how to save Arthur"
yep epilogue hard to play after Arthur...problem is middle of the game its weaste of money to spend on camp and anything because in the end its doesnt matter :)) great experience but very SAD game
T K Lol same
When Arthur talks to sister... that really hit me in the face.
Omg I know the way his voice changes when he says he's affraid breaks my heart every time
He calls her sister because she's a nun
@@ShinGojira-xq7fm no fucking shit you muppet
@@ShinGojira-xq7fm thank you captain obvious, Dunno how we gonan figure that out without you
@@Desmond-xp4wr I thought it said his siter, I misread his comment. My bad y'all
That part when he’s talking to the nun and says “I’m afraid” with that sad expression on his face actually sent shivers down my spine.
You know what affects people the most about RDR2? The story. No one cares about the gameplay and so you could argue that Rockstar were better off making an animated film instead of a game.
@@colin-campbell I did loved the gameplay... Playing the game makes you live his life than just watching a movie
Sent tears down my cheeks instead
Yeah I agree playing as Arthur makes you more attached because you can affect the ending with your actions, you can interact and see things you wouldn't normally see in a movie. I loved Arthur I cried my eyes out and tear up when I hear "unshaken" such a beautiful game
This was my reaction as well. This story was so well thought out, and executed brilliantly. This moment, by far, articulated who Arthur was as a person. The moment as his horse lie dying and he comforts him, was a very close second. It takes a lot for a character to claim such a place in so many peoples thoughts and hearts. Especially a video game. As I write this, I just completed the final story arc for Arthur a few hours ago. I honestly find myself feeling a bit depressed. I know it’s just a video game. Just a fictional story. It captured and articulated Arthur, as a person, so damn well he feels like a real person. This story line captivated me from start to finish. I spent many nights playing into the early hours of the morning. The look on his weary face as he admits his fear of death. A man contemplating his own mortality. They captured the look of a real man, realizing his impending doom and his fate sealed. It looked and felt so authentic. This story, and Arthur, will stick with me for a long time. Absolute masterpiece, in my opinion. Rockstar knocked this one out of the park.
When arthur died i felt like I lost a Family member. He's a real one 💯
Adi Atti Me too!! I Fucking cried real tears..for days and I still do
I cry today... again...
Uncle Arthur is the only uncle i need
me too man
Dude I cried
"Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness."
~Arthur Morgan's grave inscription
I’m happy that Arthur looking at the sunset is the canon ending
no dude im sorry to say it but the canon final is when micah shoot you in the face
There is no canon. Our individual choices in this masterpiece gave us a choice. It was the only way. We played as Arthur, and then we played for Arthur.
@@taxsman3163 what? No its not
@@taxsman3163 game has redemption on the title, i wonder why.
@@taxsman3163 it aint, thatll only happen when u get the bad ending
*God of war: I’m the game of the year
Arthur Morgan: Outta the damn way!
RDR2 is & always will be THE BEST GAME
ARTHUR MORGAN is & always will be best protagonist
toxic Roach bruh that game is dead
God of war is the better game I'd say, but Arthur Morgan is single handedly the better character.
Hold my beer.
Grayson Winans nah. GoW isn’t bad, but it’s overrated.
@@alphagraybear9224 Nah, Rdr2 has more things to do, better storyline, And you get a better relationship with characters
You know what’s sad? Arthur’s last words was this
“But..I tried..in the end..I did” If you
Chose the John ending that is, and got high honor.
The "I gave you all I had" to Dutch also broke me.
His last words are “Whatever you say you fool.” to Micah I thought.
@@iamadam8050 his last words are damn us both
Jake Roski but in the other ending you cut Michas eye out
REDACTED That’s if you get the low honor ending. If you got the high honor you get the good ending.
I played Arthur as honorably as possible after he got the disease, and I got him shaved and trimmed up and put on his brown jacket for his final mission. A truly legendary character
same as you, I reached maximum honor, I am glad I did
Same but I put him in his snow outfit
Cuz ya know started on a mountain ended on a mountain
Chris Mitchell I wish I could have done that, but the damn mission extended over 3, so I could only get his hat. I was wearing a red outfit almost like Dutch’s
@@jacket0519 actually it extended over 2 one if them you had to greet dutch
Same, that's why it was such a good play through for me, I was a terrible person untill the tuberculosis. I felt like I had to help everyone before I died. 10/10
“My Pa used to say if you stare into the fire long enough, you can see the whole world pass by.” - Hosea Matthews
When the O’Driscolls caught me and my horse brought me back, I gave that horse the best life.
My Horse name is " FREEDOM " I gave him that because Arthur became really free from the shackles of Dutch ,when it died
@@sheikhalieuswarray-deen581I named my horse Alejandro not realising he was really a she. Rest in piece girl
RIP Arthur Morgan the greatest character in video game history.
Ogonda Smith true words
Ogonda Smith im in heavan with mary laughing at micha
Arthur Morgan Micah’s in Hell like he should be.
Because of rdr1 i have to say John ist the best character ever made...but Arthur is close
Arthur Morgan hate to say it but Arthur is in hell dog
Who else lost their shit and cried a little when Arthur said goodbye to his dying horse ? 😪
Gareth Pritchard A LITTLE???
Buelle!!!!! Gah!!! Why you gadda bring up the good boah!
Me too. I had a horse when I was a kid, I named my horse Misty, I didn't have a clue I was gonna say goodbye again. Tears in my eyes. Wow
I named the horse after my grandma and chucked my remote a cross the room 2 two months and I still don't have a new one
Update I got a new one four months but I can play the epilogue now
GrantMC100 I too threw my remote. Can’t even play the game
Like a lot of people i was spoiled of the ending of red dead redemption 2, I genuinely thought i would never play this game, then I saw it on sale a couple of months later and thought, what the hell, its 20 bucks, so i download it, heard it was good, saw some videos on it, looked nice, though it would be fun for like 10 hours and I would put it down. about 40 hours later I’m still in the story mode exploring this beautifully crafted piece of human ingenuity, the way that rockstar crafted all of the npc’s in this game to be something more, about the ending being spoiled, I knew Arthur was going to die at the end of the first part, it didn’t mater though, its not about the destination its about the journey, and the journey was a memorable one to say the least. Arthur Morgan is such a great protagonist and I wish other devs would put as much work into their characters as rockstar did, I’ve since played the first red dead redemption and its almost as good as RDR2, its just got something missing, I know nobody will read this comment and will just scroll though in search of memes and people saying they cried for three days when Arthur died, thats fine, but I encourage anyone who went though this game and felt sad or alone without Arthur, just think about all of the things him and Lenny are getting up to in heaven (or hell depending on how you played) and how much you’ve experience with him, I’ve honestly never experienced the friendship i felt with Arthur in any other video game, I felt I was learning with him, and if your here you probably did too, keep thinking about how much fun you had with Arthur,
Thank you for getting to the bottom of this rant it was good to get thing on soothing and this seemed like a good place to put it.
You and me both brother.
I love you
You said everything I felt.
Man that's exactly how I got rdr2 tho wow and yeah you said all man 😭
That’s the way it is
What makes his death so hard is that he tried his hardest to be good in the end and died just how he wanted to.
I sometimes forget that he’s a video game character, and not an actual family member I’ve lost. Been months and his death still makes me cry
Well, that's what makes this game such a work of art. You're so immersed along the journey with Arthur because you're making those decisions with him to be good.
takes more than tuberculosis to kill a legend
He will be in our hearts forever!
Ya
it takes a bullet
Legends never die
@@funk1130 more it take 1000 Micah's to kill Arthur
It takes a beating from Micah as well.
(Arthur in heaven)
Arthur: there u r Lenny
FOUND YOU LENNY
haahaaaaa, FOUND ya Lenny!
In heaven I’m not sure about that
I have No life of course he would be in heaven
Cristian Ortiz of course he wouldnt. he killed thousands of law, & not to mention innocent people. killers dont go to heaven.
“We’re more ghosts than people” is one of the most powerful and surreal lines in the entire game.
It's a based philosophy for life
“ your my brother”
“ I know “
The boys level 10000000000
Be a God damn man and get the hell outta here ( DAMN I got goosebumps)
Mary: Oh Arthur
Sadie: Oh Arthur
Abigail: Oh Arthur
Arthur: GET THE HELL OUT OF HERE
Rafas _06 Who the hell is Sandy???
who's Sandy?
Mary: OH ORTHOR
@@chickenbreast5470 Arthur: Don't you OH ARTHUR ME
AND BE A GOD DAM MAN!
Yes I know these are not real people, but bare with me for a moment. Imagine this.
I'd like to imagine Arthur joining Lenny and Hosea in a big tavern in the sky. They rejoice to see each other again and look back on the good times together. They drink, they laugh, they sing together until what feels like years go by. All of a sudden, they here the door swing open once more. They turn in shock to meet John step in and remove the very same hat Arthur gave him all those years ago. Silence fills the air for the first time in forever. The group stand to meet him in sorrow. "I tried guys" John says. Arthur puts a hand on John's shoulder and utters the only thing honest enough. "We all did son."... "Now give me my damn hat back and grab a beer!"
Just a little edit. Thank you all for your kind words. Knowing that my arguably ok writing got some kind of positive emotions really brightens my day. Again, thank you so much!
That's beautiful
You made me tear up a bit
what about sean
@@jacobjimenez6484 whoops. He's there too. Lol
Imagine if they gave Arthur and the rest of the gang a Assassin's Creed Black Flag Send off, with John at his wedding.
That would make me cry.
"We're thieves, in a world that don't want us no more" -Arthur Morgan
Arthur's last ride has to be the best and most saddest moment in gaming history😢😢when I played that moment myself it hurt my feels😭😭😭
Facts Man Timeless Masterpiece😭😭😭
yep that few minutes....never forget..... that ride....never saw such a thing and never feel the same in any game. That moment and the last one with the sunlight....worth every penny.
'Sure'
- Arthur Morgan, 1899
Shoa
’Boah’
- me, 1899
Nice
Just about🤠
OK catch you later then
You know what’s so fucked up? I couldn’t really play the game no more after his death. It took me a while to finish the epilogue chapters but even when I was out in town or at work I legitimately felt like I lost a very good friend. To this day I have a sad feeling in his story. Rockstar did a beautiful job in making Arthur Morgan. Since I was a child my favorite game of all time was Ocarina of Time, RDR 2 is honestly right next to it now, if not surpassed it. One things for sure tho, Arthur Morgan to me, is the best character I’ve ever seen in any video game or movie.
Zay Flacko same man
Zay Flacko i miss you too 😪
Arthur Morgan
I’m actually playing the game right now as Arthur 😂😂
Just gave a dollar to the blind man
“You are not who you think you are sir.. which is a good thing”
Same here man. It still hurts when I see videos like this
I haven't felt this much for a video game character since Final Fantasy 7
“We’re more ghosts then people” damn to see Arthur just giving up on his own life and worrying about John more then himself really makes you bond with Arthur and it makes you realize who he really is
Never thought a game would make me cry like a baby, Arthur is in my heart forever...
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
[Redacted]
LT103 me
Yes. All the time.
Me
Me😭😭
I only wear Arthur's hat. Felt like they almost forgot him
I almost stopped playing the game when Arthur died. I seriously didn't want to play as Marston nothing against him just I wanted to be Arthur....
Leudwig vonshwartsenhelm spoiler: I kept playing just so I could put 6 bullets in michas head
Leudwig vonshwartsenhelm Same with the first game. You grow so attached to the characters in their own stories that once it ends, you’re just left wanting more
I just reset so I could stay as Arthur!
I actually stopped playing
Ikr
it’s enough to make a grown man cry... and that’s ok...
RIP Arthur Morgan, best character in gaming history...
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
"I'm afraid, sister"
He's the man.
I have never cried When a character in a movie or a game dies. But this game, Arthur he changed my life.... i cried like never before
Not even all these likes Will make me change the way i loved Arthur ( and this is the most i got)
I cried like a pussy-ass bitch too.
Me too man I had to have a fucking whiskey afterwards while still crying my eyes out
I usually don't either, but when Arthur pulled his hat out from his bag, I balled my eyes out. I have never loved a video game character this much until I met Arthur Morgan.
Tompan200 I couldn’t stop the tears from streaming down my face when he just stared off into the horizon. No shame in it.
I did too
If they ever make this game for pc it will only need these two mods:
Kill micah whenever.
Cure tuberculosis.
Rockstar is a sellout
Then that would defeat the whole purpose of the game
It wont change the ending or the scenes because its programed like that curing TB would be just a freeom affect in mission cutscenes Arthur would steal cough and probably look the same
@@noobnoob7499 we ain't talking about rockstar dumbass
@@culturalghost1138 but ease our depression
RIP Arthur.. the greatest character Rockstar concieved even years after and multiple playthroughs shit still gets me
I recently had the great pleasure of watching someone dear to me do a playthrough as Arthur, and this tribute made me cry. As a non-gamer person, I was blown away by the storyline, character development, and the graphics. The landscapes, the light, and the rain are truly something extraordinary. I miss Arthur now.
We all miss him 😌😭
One of the greatest protagonists in all of fiction.
True
*is
luis gan The greatest*
luis gan i know im pretty great
I didn't think another video game or character could ever affect me the way RDR1 and John Marston did.
Enter Arthur Morgan.
Beginning of the game: Who's this douche? Why can't I play as John?
End of the game: Arthur, noooo!! 😭
That's how it was for me, when I found out you play as Arthur, I felt the same way, and I really got attached to him.
I'm trying to play the epilogue but I'm struggling to like it because everything makes me think of Arthur. When I realized John's horse now has Arthur's saddle, it nearly broke me
Anthea May SEO I was so sad I named my horse Arthur while playing as John
Medicx_ same
Anthea May SEO Wait, we get Arthur’s SADDLE TOO?! Okay, now I wanna cry in a corner again 😭
It’s Sept 2020 and I am still crying.
D-VLogs same bro same..
its January 2021 and im still crying
It's sad to hear a strong man say "I'm afraid"
May Arthur Morgan live forever in our hearts as the best developed rockstar character ever.
Joshua Godfrey I hate to say how much I love Master Chief but Arthur is by far the best character in video game history.
l Mastiff l same asf
FUCK YES
Kratos and Arthur Morgan are my mains
True indeed
That “ I’m afraid” from Arthur makes me tear up ever time. Rest In Peace Arthur Morgan a truly good man 😞😞
Me to
I'm just a video game character my bra, you aint nevee gonna see me in real life
@@Randomized_tv we ain't gonna see him in real life because he dead my boy 😢
@@angelguerrero5925 he was never here from the beginning to start with. But i feel ya bruh
Yeah that transition from a hearty belly laugh in to a voice cracking, teary puppy dog eyed "I'm afraid" really shook me to the core. That was the first time I'd seen Arthur near tears as he finally expressed his fear to someone. The entire time before those few seconds he puts on the bad ass act and pretends not to care. That was the moment I realized Arthur was my favorite Rockstar character.
-“Mom are you peeling onions”
-“No, Why?”
This video made me shed in tears, thanks for making this video.
The fact that over a million people have watched proves it was an amazing story and I dont believe it will ever be topped by video games as we know of them
When I realized that Arthur would die...I maxed out honor till the end
I went from full red to full white
So did I
That's a lot of damage *flexseals eyes shut* i honestly loved the character and story so much i had to do right by them at the end
Really? I shot everyone lmao
Me too
Its incredible how many people Arthur's "life" touched. The man aint real but more real then nearly all men I know
It doesn't matter if Arthur morgan is just some code in s game, he touched all our lives, and connected all of us, all players of red dead redemption 2, isn't that becoming a legend.
Thats because redemption is such an empathetic emotion
@Ichigo Sensei in al fairness Arthur Morgan’s been shot at beaten tortured and he’s just like ight whatever what’s next so idk bud you tell me 😂
🥲
@@tylerrussellmusic1562 Arthur is real through the message he leaves us and will always be alive through us
I'm currently playing RDR2 for the first time. I haven't even finished it yet but I dare to say it's the best game I've ever played. What a master piece. One part of me begs for a series by HBO the other chills with the possibility of they ruining it. Arthur Morgan is the most incredible character ever presented in a game.
*Arthur:Go don't look back*
*John:looks back*
*I've been loyal..you know what ever mattered to me was loyalty* *~Arthur Morgan ಥ‿ಥ*
Where's bum?
I think the reason why Arthur is so lovable is the fact that we mold this character. We make him the person we are... on the inside, and when he died we see something in our selves dying as well.
Andrew Maxwell shit 😢😭 you’re right
Truest and deepest words I've read ❤️
So true.
That’s deep bro
That’s deep man
I started with my second play through. I will never rescue Micah and never go near Strauss. Doesn't matter if the story doesn't progress, I just roam around with Arthur.
Bro I tried to avoid Strauss too but if you avoid the mission for too long you're forced to start it
You a smart man
Ya it sucks
I hear yah man but unfortunately Arthur dying is his destiny, if he didn't get TB he would have never realised the importance of life. RIP to a legend of the west.
I want DlC where you kick Strauss of the cliff and blow up/watch Micah hang
Never have I ever been so emotional over a video game character. Arthur's death was a gut punch for real.
Arthur is the best video game character ever. I felt like I lost a real life friend when he was gone
Oh my lord. The scene with the nun, when Arthur admits that he's scared.... I was heartbroken! The look of fear that rockstar captured on his face was so emotional and real. I wanted to cry for him.
He seemed like he was holding back tears, and the slight voice crack.. so freaking heart breaking.
You just wanted? My farher had to come in my room and question why i was crying over a fucking game. Was a real buzzkil.
What mission was that in guys ?!
@@coollovejoe "The Fine Art of Conversation" , you only get to talk to her there if you have high honour though.
I was looking for this comment, it really felt so heavy by looking at his face when he said that, Arthur Morgan Love you Man! 💔
That one dislike is Micah
Lmao
That rat!!
The rest are the pinkertons
The rest are Pinkertons
@@barnabyabbott3732 and the o'driscolls
in 2021 I have finished several new games such as AC Valhalla, WD Legion, even Cyberpunk2077, but again and again I finished RDR2 for the 3rd time, Really a good game. This game is very interesting to repeat. And for me Arthur One of the best characters.
I can’t even listen to ‘ That’s the way it is ‘ without tearing up
It’s such a powerful song and such a powerful moment
Arthur changed my life to be more responsible and think before I act
Same
Same as you
Same here
okay don’t push it all of you😂
It's amazing how a video game with such deep heart warming story can change a person to be more responsible and just a better person in general, and people say video games are bad
The whole ending sequence was beautifully painful, but honestly the part that got me the worst was when he says "thank you" to his horse as it dies. I used the incredibly fast and tall reverse dappled black thoroughbred stallion from the special addition the entire game and absolutely adored it. That scene completely killed me.
Mine was a 1000 arabian horse, rip poopy.
I went through about 50 horses and I was still upset
Rip buell the wonder horse
mine was the shire horse hosea gives me, had it the entire game, and legit almost cried when he got shot and arthur said thank you
Man same I could not handle it at all.
Everytime I hear Arthur's voice change when he tells the nun he's affraid I get goose bumps. Facial expression and voice it's super sad
I’ve never ugly more than I did when Arthur died. The voice acting was spectacular and I never knew one could get so attached to a character.
The fact that Jack Marston at the end of RDR1 becomes an outlaw makes Arthur's death even more sad. He died for a better future for Marstons. Ended in a cycle.
We dont know if he lived the outlaw life though, if I remember it was just the pinkerton Ross you kill for revenge, but that also goes back to the cycle you talk about since Arthur talks about not believeing in revenge.
Anthony he said revenge is a fools game which is right but everyone was with John on killing Micah lol
Jack eventually becomes a writer in Los Angeles if it makes you feel better. He gets to live to old age unlike everyone else, except for uncle
Jack Marston wanted revenge for this father. You don't really know is he an outlaw or not
Sometimes being the outlaw is the best way to live. Live your way, fuck the rest, and if it ends in a hell fire of bullets take as many as you can before you take your last breath.
R.I.P TO ALL OF THOSE WHO FINISHED THE GAME
Arthur Morgan rip
Arthur Morgan Arthur morgan without his profile picture?
Milk sop
Wat
Yes R. I. P
I know who the sister is. She gives John Marston the Rosemary while he is in Mexico looking for Bill Williamson.
アーサー大好き😆💕Good man⭐
死んじゃ嫌だ…。
241 dislikes ????? These must be “them damn O’ Driscolls”
Michael Garcia nah it’s people who can’t see which button is which through the tears
Michael Garcia damn those o Driscolls we gotta call sadie she’ll fix this
Copyed
😂 😂 😂
That or this terrible choice of music overpowering in the beginning...
Arthur in afterlife:
"LENNY? LENNY? THERE YOU ARE LENNY!".
JAJAJAJAJA I'M LAUGHING AND CRYING AT THE SAME TIME
!!!!YENNEL
¡¡¡YENNEL
Lenny is with Gavin
LENAAAAAAAAYYY
Great tribute. That song never ceases to bring me to tears.
😢😢😢😢😢😮
This tribute makes me so emotional. Arthur was definitely one of the best game characters I have ever played! 😭
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
The best
when arthur gave john the hat...... JESUS 😢😢😢
Edit: thanks for the likes :)
I think it would have been amazing if Arthur's hat turned out to be John's hat from rdr1
@@omni2129 it is, johns hat is Arthur's only older with a feather added
wolfie nope it’s not Arthur’s hat
Javie Ibarra it is, it’s the same hat, that’s why they make a big deal about it, if you customized your hat with feathers obviously John took them off
@@cptcarrot5455 johns hat isnt made of leather
Arthur Morgan: the only man who can have an infinite amount of hats in the same satchel.
Arthur Morgan: the only man who can have an infinite amount of love and afection from all of us
20 fish, but infinite hats
Legend of the east satchel lol
Thank you for the laugh, I needed it lol
Best satchel in the west
Arthur is my favorite character in any game or movie. I look up to him (the good play through) as if he was a friend. He’s more loyal to the people that he cares about than most of the people I know in life.
Arthur morgan is no 1 fan 😢😢😢😢
Arthur always reminds of Wolverine/Logan. A man who is deeply flawed and in deep pain who despite saying otherwise is still a good man. A hero in the eyes of some. In the end they died their own way and lived their own way. Arthur is a tragic hero.
I, a thirty year old man, legitimately cried on the way back to the camp! That last ride took the best of me. RIP Arthur Morgan :(
Man i am near 40 .. and i cried . On the way back to camp and the scene with the horse dying .
You’re not alone, I’m fully willing to admit I cried at the very end with John on the mountain. I’ve never gotten that emotional over a work of fiction, let alone a video game.
I also cried. This game left an impression unlike anyother gane i've ever played.
yeah I feel yuh, Rockstar have created a truly next level immersive ancestor simulator - they almost need to take responsibility for the grief they cause creating such a bond with a fictional character. If this is the future of games / simulations we have already acknowledged we will create a true emotional bond with AI, even weak AI, let alone real AI.
I'm still crying after watching this video, i never cry.i haven't cried even at the funeral of my grandpa and i loved that man
It broke my heart when I hear such a strong loving compassionate 37 year old man say "I'm afraid" 😢
36 you mean
Hold up just a minute I thought he was 42 holy crap I’m a little on the slow side
DRoidzzz nope 36
Purkiss Boy That exact sentence made me tear up several times, because it shows just how human and real of a person he was. Truly an honorable man, he was
Arthur wasnt just..... some character in a video game he was.... more way more and I'm happy n proud that I was able to be with arthur for that short period of time...
R.I.P arthur morgan😔✊
Never cried before over a video game. Red Dead Redemption 2 had me sobbing.
I don't remember the last time I cried as much as I did when I finished Arthur's story and watched him peacefully drift off, watching that one last sunrise. In fact I couldn't even hear him take his last breath, I was sobbing way too loudly. Rockstar really did create the greatest character ever, because losing him truly felt like losing someone very dear to me.. like a close friend or a family member. I got to know him so well during all the hours I spent roaming the land, and the bond I formed with him.. it's really strong and special. I've taken a liking to quite a few of fictional characters, but the bond I formed with Arthur is the strongest of them all. Even after I witnessed him die I've mourned him and visited his grave many times. One night I was heading off to sleep and just buried my head in the pillow and honest to god, cried for Arthur like there's no tomorrow. Rest in Peace, Arthur Morgan, the greatest and most real protagonist who ever lived.
I'M the greatest character!
Why is this true?? He’s just so real to me...
God i felt the same, i cried myself to bed for days. I’m still depressed and every time i hear the songs or see videos like this i cry again. Even tho he is a fictional character, Arthur Morgan will forever be a dear friend to me.
@@whotookmyhandle u dirty son a bitch u killed arthur in the end I laughed when you were murdered
I didn't know that he died peacefully, Micah shot me in the face
When he died I bawled my eyes out. I know, hes not real, he never existed. But he made such a huge impact. I see things a little differently now. Sometimes I wonder what I'd be like if it werent for the impact that game made on me.
Thank you, Arthur Morgan. For changing my life.
It's ok to feel emotion. We understand. I haven't gotten to this part yet, but trust me lol I will be crying as well.
This game is what makes me try to be better for my self and my friends and family. Because of this game, I’m not afraid to stand up for my faith. I’m not afraid to die to save other people.
I saw the ending of this Game when it came out, I was curious never thought I would play it, in Christmas 2019 I got it, I know what was coming, still this was the first Game that has made me cry Ever. Arthur and his goodbyes Hurt like hell, Hosea, Lenny and Sean. This is a masterpiece in storytelling, gameplay, all of it. Arthur made his best in the ending, as we all should.
He’s real in our head
You're not alone
Some of the best writing I have ever seen, it doesn't matter that it's a video game. If this were a movie it would sweep the Oscars.
Tears in my Eyes !!!! R.I.P. ARTHUR !!!!!!!!
Why did I watch this?
It just made me fucking sad again, this game is so damn powerful.
Why Arthur, WHY!?!?!
Lol
I WAS JUST thinking that as I was watching... What a good FUCKING game!
this game is incredibly powerful
Him live in our minds
Arthur gave so much and Dutch just threw it all away. I feel so sad for Arthur.
Small Floof Dutch realised what he did and when you play as John and go to kill Micah Dutch is there and John asks “What are you doing here?” And Dutch says “Same as you I guess”, so Dutch knew what he did and wanted to get revenge
DeathBy Horison I know. Too little too late though
And so did John. Arthur gave his life for John and had told John in many different occasions to “not look back”... Then John completely ignores what Arthur says and goes after Micah and gets himself killed.
Well that mission we done who robbed how is that missions we did oh yeah Dutch hit his head and he's crazy now that's why he did it I bet you didn't understand what did I say
@50k subscribers with no videos it was his fault he got killed but I would never call anyone a fool for getting revenge for his friend..
Will never forget you, Arthur.... ❤
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
The best game i have ever played without a doubt.I dont think any other game will ever top it
After Arthur dies and John took over I barely could get myself to finish the epilogue. While playing as John, I couldn’t get rid of this sad feeling of being alone and no home to go back to. Despite that John has his own house and family, it didn’t feel the same as getting back to camp as Arthur. That gang really felt like a family. And getting back to camp, after a long time out in the world, sure as hell felt like being back home. It’s amazing how a video game can have such an impact. Changed the way I look at things in life
Im in this spot right now.
gave me goosebumps reading that
I thought I was nuts getting so upset about this game till I came here and saw I’m not the only one.
I played the whole game believing that Arthur would get a happily ever after with Mary.
I just fell in love with him and really wanted him to have the love and happiness that he deserved.
I’ve cried and cried over it, and I’ve never gotten so upset over a character in a game ever. He was just so real. The way he was so self deprecating and couldn’t see the man inside we could all see.
I cant play the epilogue, everything just reminds me of him and makes me upset again 😥🥺 xx
"That's the way it is"...
I hated seeing him go out like that as well, alone on the mountain. I had the honourable ending so he watched the sunrise one last time, but I hated him being alone.
Wish Dutch would have killed Micah and stayed with him. It set me right off when he said to Dutch he had given him everything and Dutch just walks away!! Absolutely savage 😡
Yeah it sucked that he was left there alone. All the love he gave . N love he had from others. N every self less act he did just to be left alone in the end.. it sucks cuz he put everyone else before him self. That's just priceless
@Vicki Thanks for sharing your experience!!! It's nice to know that others share the same feels
The ending is really satisfying
When Arthur says I'm Afraid
his facial expression is just real good
R.I.P Arthur Morgan you where a Hero I hate that you had to die my friend your as real as anyone else man Much Respect for ya brother
I’m not gonna lie as soon as I played the epilogue I didn’t feel like I was playing rdr, I felt like I was playing a game where Arthur never really existed at all and I just sat there watching John take up the mantle and cried knowing that we will never see Arthur again....
Sunny Baig yea it doesn’t feel the same
I have a salutation I call it Start New Game but yeah you are totally wright when arthur died and it went to the epilogue I restarted and did more side stuff and took longer to complete then I get to the epilogue play for about 10 minutes. Stop playing cause it dident feel wright played again in 2 days and finished the main epilogue story the next night
He's gonna be back in rd3 most likely
Hitman Storys HOW?!?
But rdr3 will probably be Dutch picking up Arthur all the way to blackwater
*tears have joined the chat*
So many emotions with this Game. I love arthur so much. When theyre singing at the campfire... i cant help but cry.
When he said “I’m afraid” my heart shattered. I’ve played this game over and over three times now and I still cry every time. Arthur Morgan has made me feel more emotion than anyone in my real life. He made me feel alive. To one of my best friends, thank you Arthur
This isn't a "Cowboy-Yee-Haw-Typed" game. It's a realism in a video game.
Maybe more than that.
@Dux Ad Regnum awe, stfu
@Dux Ad Regnum hey look! It's a wild dumbass! Don't startle him, otherwise he'll say more stupid shit.
IT IS MORE it's... It's....
Emotional
Dux Ad Regnum it’s called making a good game dumbass, try looking it up instead of playing fortnite
@Dux Ad Regnum shut the fuck up
I felt so close to him. That’s weird his not real, he felt so real. When he died it was to hard for me to take it, I was really sad for a week or so. Rip Arthur, thank you for the experience.
Sharko J honestly...you get so connected to him it feels like you become him...
Somehow I've found myself very spiritual in the last two years. So this may sound like the talk of a crazy person.....😅
This is something I've heard. All works of fiction are real. We breathed so much emotion and pieces of ourselves into it takes on a life of it's own. Our belief and emotions give it power. So Arthur is very much real. In some small bit he is real.
The song gets me every time. Arthur's death felt so real to me. Losing him was heartbreaking. I cried when John died too in RDR... but Arthur... His death cut deep.