it’s arguably the opposite, but in a good way. he thought he wasn’t a good man, when in reality he was admired for the good deeds he did by many, he just felt too guilty to see it.
"No, I've pushed all I can" "It would mean a lot to me" "I tried... and in the end I did" "I gave you all I had.... I did" 4 lines that give instant goosebumps
"John made it...He's the only one...And I did..The rest of us....No." "It would mean a lot to me.." "Now get the hell out of here and be a god d@mn man!" "Ya' Got tuberculosis..I'm sorry son it's a hell of a thing...The best thing to do is,Get some rest..and lay low for a while. Is that possible?" "Oh sure,I'll just take my holiday club all the way to California,No it's not possible!" "Oh,I'm sorry I didn't know I was talking to a "LaDy".." "LEnNyYyYyY MY BOI!!!!!!!!!! WHERE ARE YA LENYYYYYYYYYYY,AH! FOUND YA LENNY!" "I got tuberculosis,I'm dying,and I'll be dead soon..And you with me Mr.Milton!!" "He's a rat...He always was...He's a rat..." (Note:All of these are NOT is the right order,they are just random quotes from the game I like.Thats all!) Like:Dutch dead Comment On this: Micah Dead Subscribe to me:Both of them dead and Arthur never gets tuberculosis.
Arthur Morgan has become some kind of a role model to me. I didn't really have anyone who I could relate to as a kid, but Arthur has taught me how to deal with my own past and it's never too late to do the right thing. And that in the end, the most important thing is that you can forgive and be proud of yourself. Ofc I'm still struggling but Arthur has shown me the way to self-acceptance. "Make your last moments your best moments, Sir. Feel glory and forget about shame". For me, Arthur is what manhood is all about.
Arthur is a legend Dante is a legend Joel is a father figure legend Nathan is a treasure hunter legend Jin is a legendary samurai But also Nathan drake taught me stuff too
This game means a lot to me. Reason I got it was because all my friends were playing rockstar games like gta V and my friend told me about a new game Read Dead Redemption 2. I looked into it and it seemed really fun plus it would be my first rockstar game. I did get gta V later on but it didn’t really appeal to me. I started up the game and immediately I was in Aw even thought nothing was happening yet. I beat the game in 2 weeks if I remember right while my friend was on chapter 2 and had the game a week before me. This was the first game that was able to make me cry or shed a tear at least. I love this game and all it’s characters. It always makes me feel like I can do better and be better if that makes sense. I love seeing tributes about this game. My friends used to bully me for liking it and they always said it was boring even though they didn’t even get passed chapter 1. Again I love this game and it has changed me for the better.
They're probably too used to blowing everything up and shooting a minigun/LMG, Red Dead is so much more than its fancy old timey guns, the story and experience of the world around you not just in the main story are what I love so much about the game. Definately gonna be in my top ten favorites for years to come
Not too many find the struggle of Red Dead 2 so appealing , I guess why so many feel so close to the story it's cuz' there are a lot of life lessons and a whole lot to be seen and learnt from . Of course it's just a game , but in my opinion , best game i've ever played , story/gameplay . It touches your soul like no other . Eight years to be produced and every detail was worth it .
I think Micah has to be one of the best antagonists in a video game. We never liked him. But we didn’t think he was slithering his way through the gang to rip it apart. It was so obvious yet so unnoticeable.
Everyone in both games was amazing john,dutch, hosea, micah, arthur, only game that comes close imo is Assassins creed black flag only 2 games i cried at when i completed them
No he is pathetic , he told Milton everythingafter a little bit of torture (the debt collector Herr Straus DID NOT), died like a idiot , everyone hated him throughout the game , he had no ifluence , all he did was manipulate another fool with a "plan" .
I remember playing in the beginning, I wanted to be John. But in the end, I seriously missed Arthur, I couldn’t play anymore because I missed him. I wonder if Rockstar realizes what they made here
Arthur honestly changed my life. Before the game I didn't really care about other people but now I care about other people more than myself most of the times
When i started to care about other people was when I was around 5. So I was at school and these kids were having a race but they didn’t let me be in it. (I was pretty small and skinny) I look for the smallest kid who was a bit taller than me and pin him to the wall to let me play and then I trip and come last. Later when I was at home I felt bad and cried and after that I cared abt others but Arthur enhanced that feeling in me
@@doomslayer5453 The same thing happened to me about 4 years ago I just didn't threaten the guy I just entered the race with the help of one of the teachers and won 😂
I'm sure he's in the memory of so many others whom he touched--both fictionally (gang and others in the game) and realistically (us in the gaming world)!
When Arthur tells John “it would mean a lot to me.” Was the exact moment in the game that i started bawling my eyes out. Few games have ever made me cry and only one game has made me ugly cry. RDR2 will go down as my all time favorite game no matter what.
Was RDR2 the game that made you ugly cry (for me it was 😂)? And what other games? I'm still looking for a game to start playing after finishing RDR2 for the 5th time and would like to have my feelings shattered again.
@@brightside10 The witcher 3 bro...........its honestly the Fantasy rdr2 ngl... i had some emotional moments and i replayed it 3 times the second to do all the stuff i didnt do and the 3rd was just to experince it again but this time seeing what i missed! easily my top 10 games so is rdr2 but the witcher 3 has such an amazing world just like rdr2 all the side stuff doesnt feel like side activities/quests. bro how am I enjoying/laughing at a quest where I have to track down a sheep and bring it back? because the game knows wtf its doing!!!!! trust me and i havent even talk bout the dlc! which is without a doubt better then the story like wtf!!!! how did they do that!? i cant remember the last time a dlc was as good or better then the base game. far cry blood dragon skyrim dragon born dlc a few other im sure but its that good. sorry for the long message but i love rdr2 as well and know people who feel empty after trust the witcher 3 will fill it.
After playing RDR2, I can't play any other open world Games anymore. They're not even close to the level of RDR2, we need more game like RDR2. Please rock star make one more RDR!
@Joshua Kelly I doubt they’ll make another one. The storyline is complete and there isn’t really much content to make into a RDRIII. Jack ended the story and got redemption and revenge for his father so there really isn’t anything else to make a story about
@@ledzep1023 you are so incorrect its actually hilarious, they can make an entire game of the whole gang before the ferry job, just like how they made a game right before john hunting down dutch. please for the love of god use your brain before spewing nonsense.
It’s sad to see Javier point his gun at John and Arthur- he’s even hesitant to do so-he genuinely cared for them both but his loyalty for Dutch was more to him and he was sad by it you could tell
In an interview the actor for Javier said he chose not to point his gun at them because he said Javier wouldn’t do that, even after the directors told him to point it he refused
@@JohnnyC01 a lot of the scenes were motion captured. It's just that not all the actors are always in the same room. Cause of conflicting schedules so they pieced them together in each scene after recording
Nah he cared but bad luck after bad luck and then he’s losing his only family his only lively hood and then his son Arthur he snapped. He needed someone to save him cause he was beaten down from trying to save everyone else Micah pretended he cared, and Dutch wanted to believe so bad that someone could help that someone had an out and sadly he put his faith in the wrong man
@@elijahperry9224 he never even said anything to calm arhtur down after the gang knew that he had tb, not even when he was semi normal, it looked like only reveren cared when you talk to him
I love how he goes from a bandit who could care less about almost everyone to a still rough but caring man who gave his life for John and his family best character arc and best story of any game I’ve ever played
@@7ethargy not really. i think both rdr games showed that there is no real redemption how hard you try. you can just have your personal redemption while saving the ones you care about.
Arthur no matter what at his core is a good man, whether you play the most evil playthrough or not. He was always intended to be good, he just didnt always follow the right path. Look at how much he suffered. He lost his real dad, his young wife and daughter when he was barely even a man. On top of that, the only girl after his wife who he ever loved after could never be with him because of her father
Just the most jaw dropping heart wrenching game ending I’ve ever had the privilege to play, the game from start to finish was just a once in a lifetime experience
wow, sorry for your loss friend, I'm glad that you were able to have a father be in your life, and I'm also glad that the story of this incredible person, though fictional, can still give you some reminders of your father.
Arthur Morgan really reminds me of my father. He’s serious when he absolutely needs to be, but he can also be goofy, like the scene with Lenny and Arthur in the bar in Valentine. Watching Arthur pass on the mountainside ripped my heart out and tore it into pieces, I sat there crying for what felt like hours. I’m not saying this to make up some sob story about my father, I’m saying this to say that Arthur was hands down the best protagonist in any game, and is by far the most memorable. Thank you, Rockstar, for making a game/series I absolutely fell in love with. And Arthur, Rest In Peace. You surely will be missed by millions. ❤️
Shed a tear on this so deep and relevant today no more hoarses and wagons only thing we did is upgrade to cars and planes ...Betrayal & disloyalty will never die .
Straight up I knew Arthur was going at the end, TB don't fuck around. When the horse died, the same horse I kept through the whole game my first time, I fucking lost it. Named her Jenny after one of the gang members that died in the beginning after the blackwater incident.
I remember when I first started playing, I was mad because I wanted to play as John. Then, when I saw Arthur die, I was devastated. I liked Arthur so much. I didn’t even wanna play the epilogue because I didn’t wanna play as John anymore. I just wanted Arthur back. I had to stop playing for like a week, then I came back. I’m glad I beat the epilogue because I got some closure for Arthur
I even played the game again to see if I could skip that collection mission because all the others had been optional. Didn’t feel that bad when I kicked Strauss out either >.>
I literally stopped playing the story there on my second playthrough and beat every other part of the game that I could before reluctantly going to Strauss and trying everuthing in my power to not get Arthur turburculosis but in the end nothing changed.
As much of a heartbreak as it was seeing this as the point which eventually killed Arthur it felt like his destiny, I don't know if we would have had the great man we had at the end if this never happened
It was actually a good thing it gave him the opportunity most don't have and that's to correct their ways before they die and make peace. The tuberculosis wasn't what killed him therefore avoiding it would only make him a worse man
I like how all the games i played and all the characters with it were just characters, but this game, everything about it, i loved and it even felt like i connected with the horse i had, and arthur, the only virtual character that taught me it was possible to connect with some1 who doesnt even exist. But the game, the story, how everythings you do leads to another, one choice can change alot. I have played this game 4 times now, right now im at chapter 4 again and every time i have to watch arthur die, it feels like the western american voice in my head dies with him. And my parents and friends think its weord and it may be, but its just an amazing game and the fact that the man who played micah made us all hate him means that he did a great job, everyone did. I guess lets wait for rdr3
As soon as he said "I gave you all I had" I just teared straight up. This game got spoiled for me and I still cried at the end because it was just a serious masterpiece
Arthur is the best character ive seen in gaming, and nobody will ever change my mind. This game made me love him like family and it made losing him so much harder.
For so long I was hoping and waiting for the time to go west and at least ride a little in the desert with him. But I got to chapter 6 and it hit me he would never see the west again
@@anneshepard I like this tragically ironic aspect of Arthur's character arc, he hates the modernity and corruption riddling the east and wants to head back west - even wishing to being faced towards there when he dies. But it's ultimately within the place he wanted to run away from is where he finds his redemption and ultimate life fulfillment.
Im sure most of people doesnt notice this, when you fight micah in the final mission you take off from his hat, but suddenly in the epilogue we see him old and with his hat this could mean he came back looking the death body of arthur
@@TRGUZEYFX he's saying that when micah fought arthur his hat fell off but then in epilogue he's seen with his old hat meaning that he came back to arthur's grave since his hat was there.
I think Micah only started to hate Arthur when Arthur started to stand up in Micah's way, as Dutch's ideals rot Arthur got to face Micah almost everytime, as if they were a little angel and a little devil around Dutch's head
Every little detail every little moment all the realtionships it all feels so real when he dies on that cliff with injustice it hurts I cried my first playthrough
I cried for 2 days after playing Arthur's storyline... Then when I was visiting all the people that he connected with and all shared fond memories of him, I cried one more time. This character is one of the greatest ever written and the voice actor Roger Clark breathe so much life into such a character.
Best tribute yet . Literally bought the game again last night just because of this tribute video and how it reminded me of how good this game is . Beautiful editing man keep it up
I just finished my 2nd playthrough the other week after such a long time, and the Swanson calling Arthur a warrior, will always break my heart. Not because Arthur was Dying, but because deep down Arthur didn't realize how much he helped Swanson change into a better man. And when Arthur admits to the Sister hes afraid, maybe not death being the reason, but because he believed in family and didnt care how his own life ended up as long as everyone was okay. And maybe we fail to see how much guidance Arthur really needed, instead of Dutch. Dutch only pushed inconsistent thoughts into into Arthurs world perspective.
Truly the best the goat of protagonist. I know most comments say this. But me and other people too have felt this wierd and emotional connection to Arthur. I had to step back because my personality almost adapted Arthur. Were both stigma similar life style different era. Thanks for this tribute well done
Finally got to play it and finished it a couple of days ago. I was so stunned by the ending that I couldn't express any feeling until I watched this video. Thanks for making it. And no I'm not crying... You're crying 😭
I found this game on my own, desperate for something. Something to live up too and to live for. I found this game and it woke me up. I love this game so much. It means so much to me and eventhough I never played tree he first one, it's the best. I spent all of my Christmas break playing this game and when I finished I felt an emptiness and I believe Arthur Morgan was basically like a brother though he's fiction and never knew me. This game is worth so much to me and I even think I'll name my son after Arthur even though he's tiny little pixels on a screen, but to me he's much more than that.
He has a place in so many peoples heart that when he died i acctually cried and i dont cry at games but Arthur is more than just pixels to me he is like a person he is a brother a father something more yaknow
arthur was the man we all wanne be deep inside .....thats why his story hits us so deep in the feels ,a few seconds can change your life or end it even yet this guy saved lifes while barely being able to walk at the end
It’s so strange to say how much I miss him, but it’s true. RDR2 has touched so many and its legacy runs deep. I know that I’m not who I was before it. Bless the man- Arthur Morgan, the outlaw saint.
Red dead is mainly known for its story, while the gta series is mostly known for its open world environment and all the other things that u can do, the story is only 20% of the gta, while red dead's main is story considering that its way longer than gta proves it.
I told my friend that no matter what, arthur has to have high honor, but I dont care about johns honor, I almost yelled at him when he said he wanted to do the low honor way
Arthur Morgan, v, and John/Jane Shepard are my all time favorite protagonists in games of my top games of all time they are all so special to me each playthrough i always have mine be the most human, loving, sacrificing chracters they can be and that will always be the way i play it cause thats the way i see those chracters good people put in hard, awful, evil situations but if they werent there they wouldnt be able to bring so much good to those situations and the way i view it they wouldnt want it any other way rip to all those amazing protags you will always have a special place in my heart
Most of the people left had more loyalty for Dutch, they didn't know how Dutch was in the beginning and how he naturally worked, however all the veteran members had died or left except fot Miss Grimshaw and John, both of whom took Arthur's side.
I cannot stop seeing this video, I played this game a few time ago and I still remember everything, I just can't forgot when arthur put his hat in jhon's head and say "it would mean a lot to me, please, there's no more time to talk" and in the end Jhon said that arthur is his brother and then they never saw each other again, the saddest and most beatiful good bye that I have ever seen in a game
*My personal legends:* - Kratos - Artreus - V - Jackie Wells - Takemura - Johnny Silverhand - Deacon Saint John - Alex Mason - David Mason - Frank Woods - Captain Price - Soap McTavish - Ghost - Sandman - Yuri - Roach - Joel Miller - Connor Kenway - Edward Kenway - Jin Sakai - Nathan Drake - Nomad - Batman - Nightwing - Miles Morales - Peter Parker - Master Chief - Geralt of Rivia - John Marston *- Arthur Morgan...*
Coming from rdr1 man it’s sad something like this happened to a group of mine a year ago we all knew each other for so long so many years we are all starting to make up for everything with each other but man it’s still a tender subject but This is a perfect example of stuff like that and to come from the first game you realize that Arthur is the reason we all loved John Arthur made John the man he was
This was one of the best game stories of all the time. I got pissed when Sean died and shot up all of Rhoades, and I sat back and reflected on my own life when aurther died. So rare to have a game with such an immersive and impacting story like this one.
*Arthur Morgan without a doubt is the best/most memorable protagonist* i get to play in my life, his story his arc it makes me feel for him, its astonishing and beautiful its deep and meaningfull. This is the game i will tell my children and nephews to play when they tell me some *blabla* game they played is the best game they ever played.
check out the latest video about Red Dead Redemption on my channel
thats a sick thumbnail
What’s your discord?
dix0ncl4y#0963 @@jirahloewen9457
its rlly good gj
Solid snake was better
_"He's lyin... Heee's lyyyyiiiiiiiiiinnnng."_
- Most trustworthy person ever.
Hes dying and going crazy dutch
Rat micah
🐀
🐀
Fuck that!!
If Hosea ,Lenny were alive they’ve would’ve picked Arthur’s side
Hosea wouldve kept Dutch's head straight too
Hosea, Lenny, Sean, Charles, Sadie, Uncle, Kieran, and John.
Don't forget Sean and Kieran
@@a.m6581 I know I just didn’t want to make the comment large 😃
@@gofhton Sean too
Arthur Morgan is hands down the best protagonist in any game. And will never be topped
Hey don’t forget talion from middle earth
RDR2 is probably the absolute best story I've ever played in a game. It's the best Western movie never made
@@Outlast_Gaming Ezio Auditore from Assassins Creed
@@theunitedcavalry816 Altair from the first assassin's creed
@@Outlast_Gaming yeah bloody legends all of them
Arthur is the prime example of: “I might be a hero in your story, but im a villian in mine.”
Actually I think he believes he is the villain in his story while a hero to others
it’s arguably the opposite, but in a good way. he thought he wasn’t a good man, when in reality he was admired for the good deeds he did by many, he just felt too guilty to see it.
@@shinndig9972We all have to do things for ourselves, it’s not our fault our way to love goes through a small passageway of hell
my bro arthur killed husbands of 5000 womens then he became good person by giving 1 one fews dollars funyy no😭😭
I’m pretty sure it’s the opposite
"No, I've pushed all I can"
"It would mean a lot to me"
"I tried... and in the end I did"
"I gave you all I had.... I did"
4 lines that give instant goosebumps
Also, “Thank you.”
"I guess I'm afraid"
Mrs. Adler... ride with ME!
"John made it...He's the only one...And I did..The rest of us....No."
"It would mean a lot to me.." "Now get the hell out of here and be a god d@mn man!"
"Ya' Got tuberculosis..I'm sorry son it's a hell of a thing...The best thing to do is,Get some rest..and lay low for a while. Is that possible?"
"Oh sure,I'll just take my holiday club all the way to California,No it's not possible!"
"Oh,I'm sorry I didn't know I was talking to a "LaDy".."
"LEnNyYyYyY MY BOI!!!!!!!!!! WHERE ARE YA LENYYYYYYYYYYY,AH! FOUND YA LENNY!"
"I got tuberculosis,I'm dying,and I'll be dead soon..And you with me Mr.Milton!!"
"He's a rat...He always was...He's a rat..."
(Note:All of these are NOT is the right order,they are just random quotes from the game I like.Thats all!) Like:Dutch dead Comment On this: Micah Dead Subscribe to me:Both of them dead and Arthur never gets tuberculosis.
one more thing:"TAHITI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
John was a Hero
Arthur was a Legend
Reverse that order dude. John is the legend of the west, and Arthur is the hero everyone needed.
@@FormulaVase-kp3dc nop
@@Fred-cz9fd yep!!! John didn't do shit for anybody except his own family. Arthur saved a hell of alot more people. (Referring to Chapter 6.)
@@FormulaVase-kp3dc but arthur is a legend and maybe a hero too
@@Fred-cz9fd Have you forgotten the fame system from rdr 1? Notice its absent in rdr 2. Did you ever wonder why?
It’s so hard to believe that when RDR2 was announced, we never thought somebody could come close to John Marston’s legacy
Oh how wrong we were.....
how wrong indeed
Idk if this an unpopular opinion or not, but I think that at the end of the game I found myself liking Arthur more than John
@@eduh3173 nah i feel the same, i don’t think it’s an unpopular opinion either, maybe since john is the og ya know
@K 163 how do we have anything to do with his death ? 😐😐😐 make it make sense
@Dr Phantom oh well that doesnt really changes his point
*Arthur goes to Heaven*
Arthur: FOUND YAH LENNNNNYY
😢Word.
This needs more likes
@GUNMAN Yard You take that back
@GUNMAN Yard depends on your honor level🤔
I’M AN AMERICANNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!
Stand back, children.
_This is where real men cry._
🥺🥺
I'm not crying....your crying!
@@battlecross8540 why did you have ruin it
Where is this line??
Goodbye...old friend
"I gave you all I had.. I did"
and then dutch literally being speechless was the most heartbreaking point.
You will be history Arthur Morgan
You too, mr Miller.
They did you dirty Joel :(
Both of you two will
@@enayatullahk20 Man they really did him bad. Joel deserved better.
As will i
Arthur Morgan has become some kind of a role model to me. I didn't really have anyone who I could relate to as a kid, but Arthur has taught me how to deal with my own past and it's never too late to do the right thing. And that in the end, the most important thing is that you can forgive and be proud of yourself. Ofc I'm still struggling but Arthur has shown me the way to self-acceptance. "Make your last moments your best moments, Sir. Feel glory and forget about shame". For me, Arthur is what manhood is all about.
What has anything of this to do with menhood?!?
It has to do with humanity and being a good person, boy.
If older folks understood some video games actually impacted people...
@@suatt38 I’m nearly 50 years old, and trust me I get it.
Arthur is a legend
Dante is a legend
Joel is a father figure legend
Nathan is a treasure hunter legend
Jin is a legendary samurai
But also Nathan drake taught me stuff too
@K 163 kratos: boiiiii
This game means a lot to me. Reason I got it was because all my friends were playing rockstar games like gta V and my friend told me about a new game Read Dead Redemption 2. I looked into it and it seemed really fun plus it would be my first rockstar game. I did get gta V later on but it didn’t really appeal to me. I started up the game and immediately I was in Aw even thought nothing was happening yet. I beat the game in 2 weeks if I remember right while my friend was on chapter 2 and had the game a week before me. This was the first game that was able to make me cry or shed a tear at least. I love this game and all it’s characters. It always makes me feel like I can do better and be better if that makes sense. I love seeing tributes about this game. My friends used to bully me for liking it and they always said it was boring even though they didn’t even get passed chapter 1. Again I love this game and it has changed me for the better.
Don't listen to them, it's a perfectly woven masterpiece.
They're probably too used to blowing everything up and shooting a minigun/LMG, Red Dead is so much more than its fancy old timey guns, the story and experience of the world around you not just in the main story are what I love so much about the game. Definately gonna be in my top ten favorites for years to come
Were on the same boat brother
Not too many find the struggle of Red Dead 2 so appealing , I guess why so many feel so close to the story it's cuz' there are a lot of life lessons and a whole lot to be seen and learnt from . Of course it's just a game , but in my opinion , best game i've ever played , story/gameplay . It touches your soul like no other . Eight years to be produced and every detail was worth it .
Why do we live the same life?
I think Micah has to be one of the best antagonists in a video game. We never liked him. But we didn’t think he was slithering his way through the gang to rip it apart. It was so obvious yet so unnoticeable.
Everyone in both games was amazing
john,dutch, hosea, micah, arthur,
only game that comes close imo is Assassins creed black flag
only 2 games i cried at when i completed them
I know he talked after Guarma, but the way every single mission with him goes off the rails is more than a little suspicious.
I knew immediately lol
No he is pathetic , he told Milton everythingafter a little bit of torture (the debt collector Herr Straus DID NOT), died like a idiot , everyone hated him throughout the game , he had no ifluence , all he did was manipulate another fool with a "plan" .
@@Away1910 Halo reach?
I remember playing in the beginning, I wanted to be John. But in the end, I seriously missed Arthur, I couldn’t play anymore because I missed him. I wonder if Rockstar realizes what they made here
Why don’t you wanna play it again?
I’m on the seventh playthrough
@@charliewright418 Seventh! BOAH THEM IS PRETTY BOAH NUMBERS IM IN MY 11TH! *Using Arthurs Accent*
I literally had a saved game for pre TB Arthur. Such a tank
They dont realize, with the state the games left in.
Arthur honestly changed my life. Before the game I didn't really care about other people but now I care about other people more than myself most of the times
I'm the same way. Thank you Arthur
And people say video games have bad affects
@@asimh2412 yeah that's life. People always see the bad things of what they don't like and ignore the good things
When i started to care about other people was when I was around 5. So I was at school and these kids were having a race but they didn’t let me be in it. (I was pretty small and skinny) I look for the smallest kid who was a bit taller than me and pin him to the wall to let me play and then I trip and come last. Later when I was at home I felt bad and cried and after that I cared abt others but Arthur enhanced that feeling in me
@@doomslayer5453 The same thing happened to me about 4 years ago I just didn't threaten the guy I just entered the race with the help of one of the teachers and won 😂
Arthur Morgan=One person I won’t forget in my life
Yeah he was the man with the loyalty and the man to gun down 51 guys with a Lancaster repeater.
yes
I'm sure he's in the memory of so many others whom he touched--both fictionally (gang and others in the game) and realistically (us in the gaming world)!
Girls: Why didn't you cry on Titanic?
Boys:
FACTS
Nah. I'm a woman and Arthur's death made me cry.
@@ANNEKE1999 OK
cryed
Bout to cry for that grammar
Still gives out heavy feelings. A bunch of pixels that feel to me like a long lost brother.
When Arthur tells John “it would mean a lot to me.” Was the exact moment in the game that i started bawling my eyes out. Few games have ever made me cry and only one game has made me ugly cry. RDR2 will go down as my all time favorite game no matter what.
Was RDR2 the game that made you ugly cry (for me it was 😂)? And what other games? I'm still looking for a game to start playing after finishing RDR2 for the 5th time and would like to have my feelings shattered again.
Only other game that got me close to tears I had when finishing was cod 4 and gaz dies and price considering at the time we didn’t know mw2 be a thing
@@brightside10 The witcher 3 bro...........its honestly the Fantasy rdr2 ngl... i had some emotional moments and i replayed it 3 times the second to do all the stuff i didnt do and the 3rd was just to experince it again but this time seeing what i missed! easily my top 10 games so is rdr2 but the witcher 3 has such an amazing world just like rdr2 all the side stuff doesnt feel like side activities/quests. bro how am I enjoying/laughing at a quest where I have to track down a sheep and bring it back? because the game knows wtf its doing!!!!! trust me and i havent even talk bout the dlc! which is without a doubt better then the story like wtf!!!! how did they do that!? i cant remember the last time a dlc was as good or better then the base game. far cry blood dragon skyrim dragon born dlc a few other im sure but its that good. sorry for the long message but i love rdr2 as well and know people who feel empty after trust the witcher 3 will fill it.
After playing RDR2, I can't play any other open world Games anymore. They're not even close to the level of RDR2, we need more game like RDR2. Please rock star make one more RDR!
@Joshua Kelly I doubt they’ll make another one. The storyline is complete and there isn’t really much content to make into a RDRIII. Jack ended the story and got redemption and revenge for his father so there really isn’t anything else to make a story about
Don't be greedy. It's one of a kind for a reason
I heard amazing things about the Witcher 3 for it’s story and world, and although I love it now, it will never compare to Rdr2.
@@ledzep1023 you are so incorrect its actually hilarious, they can make an entire game of the whole gang before the ferry job, just like how they made a game right before john hunting down dutch. please for the love of god use your brain before spewing nonsense.
Wow bro I feel the exact same way. Every time I try to play a game I find myself comparing it to RDR2.
It’s sad to see Javier point his gun at John and Arthur- he’s even hesitant to do so-he genuinely cared for them both but his loyalty for Dutch was more to him and he was sad by it you could tell
Actually in wiki it says everyone points his gun at arthur and john but javier doesnt he points at somewhere else there is a foreshadowing about that
In an interview the actor for Javier said he chose not to point his gun at them because he said Javier wouldn’t do that, even after the directors told him to point it he refused
@@Kermitsspliff I don't really get it. Did they actually shoot the whole scenes in real with motion capture or something?
He points his gun to the sky...
@@JohnnyC01 a lot of the scenes were motion captured. It's just that not all the actors are always in the same room. Cause of conflicting schedules so they pieced them together in each scene after recording
Dutch never cared that Arthur has tb he only cared for himself
Nah he cared but bad luck after bad luck and then he’s losing his only family his only lively hood and then his son Arthur he snapped. He needed someone to save him cause he was beaten down from trying to save everyone else Micah pretended he cared, and Dutch wanted to believe so bad that someone could help that someone had an out and sadly he put his faith in the wrong man
He was indeed a narcissist
@@elijahperry9224 he never even said anything to calm arhtur down after the gang knew that he had tb, not even when he was semi normal, it looked like only reveren cared when you talk to him
well maybe you just needed a LITTLE FAITH!
I really wonder how Dutch was way before blackwater incident or before Micah came.
The start of the game: who's arthur i want to play as john
Ending:GIVE BE ARTHUR!!!
true
I love how he goes from a bandit who could care less about almost everyone to a still rough but caring man who gave his life for John and his family best character arc and best story of any game I’ve ever played
Redemption
@@7ethargy not really. i think both rdr games showed that there is no real redemption how hard you try. you can just have your personal redemption while saving the ones you care about.
*couldn't care less
Arthur no matter what at his core is a good man, whether you play the most evil playthrough or not. He was always intended to be good, he just didnt always follow the right path. Look at how much he suffered. He lost his real dad, his young wife and daughter when he was barely even a man. On top of that, the only girl after his wife who he ever loved after could never be with him because of her father
THE FACT THAT SOMEONE DISLIKE THIS IS DISGUSTING
It’s Micah Dutch... he’s the rat
And 8 people did it I hope they had a good reason if not f*ck them
They clearly dont have the ability to feel things
@@alexkhaid it is the pinkertons and the O'Driscoll Boys
@@madhavanmenon4197 yes
Just the most jaw dropping heart wrenching game ending I’ve ever had the privilege to play, the game from start to finish was just a once in a lifetime experience
This is why I love you, Josey Wales. 😌💕
I wish I could play it for the first time again
The people who dislike loved the part Micha Lives, shoots Arthur, tricks the gang, and etc.
You fools, don’t think for Micha!
Think for yourselves!
@Dêrsimi Don't forget those Angels of death pricks too
Hey, I didn't dislike, but I liked how brutally pulling the end of the story was, because it felt so...human. 11/10
This tore my heart out. I lost my dad to covid while playing this. Shit hit hard. Real hard
Don’t know if you’ll see this but I’m sorry for your loss partner. Keep your head high and keep on riding❤️🤞🏾
wow, sorry for your loss friend, I'm glad that you were able to have a father be in your life, and I'm also glad that the story of this incredible person, though fictional, can still give you some reminders of your father.
May he RIP, honestly there is no better game to play at a terrible time like that, hope you're well.
I hope your doing well..
May God protect your father, my brother, and you too.
Arthur Morgan really reminds me of my father. He’s serious when he absolutely needs to be, but he can also be goofy, like the scene with Lenny and Arthur in the bar in Valentine.
Watching Arthur pass on the mountainside ripped my heart out and tore it into pieces, I sat there crying for what felt like hours.
I’m not saying this to make up some sob story about my father, I’m saying this to say that Arthur was hands down the best protagonist in any game, and is by far the most memorable.
Thank you, Rockstar, for making a game/series I absolutely fell in love with.
And Arthur, Rest In Peace. You surely will be missed by millions. ❤️
Shed a tear on this so deep and relevant today no more hoarses and wagons only thing we did is upgrade to cars and planes ...Betrayal & disloyalty will never die .
sadly you are right
And the freedom they were looking for moves ever farther away. Not many wild places left now.
Been playing games for years and this is the only game that made me cry
Straight up I knew Arthur was going at the end, TB don't fuck around. When the horse died, the same horse I kept through the whole game my first time, I fucking lost it. Named her Jenny after one of the gang members that died in the beginning after the blackwater incident.
It truly is a shame that he died the way he did.Betrayed by the man who raised him since he was young
"People don't change they just become more of who they really are" -arthur morgan
A man who lived for others. Arthur Morgan, a hero we didn't deserve, but a hero we needed. A great man, Arthur Morgan
I remember when I first started playing, I was mad because I wanted to play as John. Then, when I saw Arthur die, I was devastated. I liked Arthur so much. I didn’t even wanna play the epilogue because I didn’t wanna play as John anymore. I just wanted Arthur back. I had to stop playing for like a week, then I came back. I’m glad I beat the epilogue because I got some closure for Arthur
Idk if I'm the only one who Arthur Morgan changed his mind to the society, people, reality...
You are not the only one,i am kinda the same,this game made me see that we all have limited time left and all we can do is live the best of our lives
You’re not alone, my outlook on life changed entirely after watching Arthur’s story come to a close
Yep - it also made me want to spend waaaay more time in nature and get back to horse riding, beyond the social learning
I wish Arthur just never talked to Strauss in Chapter 2 lol
I even played the game again to see if I could skip that collection mission because all the others had been optional. Didn’t feel that bad when I kicked Strauss out either >.>
I literally stopped playing the story there on my second playthrough and beat every other part of the game that I could before reluctantly going to Strauss and trying everuthing in my power to not get Arthur turburculosis but in the end nothing changed.
As much of a heartbreak as it was seeing this as the point which eventually killed Arthur it felt like his destiny, I don't know if we would have had the great man we had at the end if this never happened
It was actually a good thing it gave him the opportunity most don't have and that's to correct their ways before they die and make peace. The tuberculosis wasn't what killed him therefore avoiding it would only make him a worse man
I like how all the games i played and all the characters with it were just characters, but this game, everything about it, i loved and it even felt like i connected with the horse i had, and arthur, the only virtual character that taught me it was possible to connect with some1 who doesnt even exist. But the game, the story, how everythings you do leads to another, one choice can change alot. I have played this game 4 times now, right now im at chapter 4 again and every time i have to watch arthur die, it feels like the western american voice in my head dies with him. And my parents and friends think its weord and it may be, but its just an amazing game and the fact that the man who played micah made us all hate him means that he did a great job, everyone did. I guess lets wait for rdr3
I hope there is a read dead 3
@@horseedits9239 it takes place in like 1887
@@mushroomybod8006 and?
I found a horse I loved and I managed to keep it alive the whole game. I shed a couple tears when it died
As soon as he said "I gave you all I had" I just teared straight up. This game got spoiled for me and I still cried at the end because it was just a serious masterpiece
Yes me too!! I knew he was going to die and what of but you spend so long “bonding” with this character that it’s still heartbreaking at the ejd
This masterpiece needs to be made into a movie.
I think a TV series with every chapter having its own chapter because a film would make it feel rushed in my opinion.
Arthur is a damn legend
Authur= LEGEND
*Arthur
Arthur the person that wanna live for the rest of his life with a wife and kids and he died in old age not sickness
Boi that could’ve been better
Rockstar for creating Arthur and rdr/rdr2 ❤
Grammar please
I don't care about the grammers but at least spell the name of a character right.
If it weren’t for Arthur... John wouldn’t have survived...in a way... Arthur was always with John and was a hero. Arthur, You will be missed.
One of my best friends died recently. This hit me really hard. With all of my heart, thank you.
Arthur is the best character ive seen in gaming, and nobody will ever change my mind. This game made me love him like family and it made losing him so much harder.
Man, I thought I was going to ride around the desert with him. 😞
i think we all did and w all wanted too
For so long I was hoping and waiting for the time to go west and at least ride a little in the desert with him. But I got to chapter 6 and it hit me he would never see the west again
Honestly blocking out New Austin before the epilogue wasn't the the best decision imo.
@@themadtitan7603 I have never played RDR1, but isn’t New Austin meant to be new to John in that game? So I guess it doesn’t make a lot of sense
@@anneshepard
I like this tragically ironic aspect of Arthur's character arc, he hates the modernity and corruption riddling the east and wants to head back west - even wishing to being faced towards there when he dies. But it's ultimately within the place he wanted to run away from is where he finds his redemption and ultimate life fulfillment.
Im sure most of people doesnt notice this,
when you fight micah in the final mission you take off from his hat, but suddenly in the epilogue
we see him old and with his hat this could mean he came back looking the death body of
arthur
You're sayin arthur didn't die?
@@TRGUZEYFX No that micah i could probably see the death body of arthut for going back for his hat
@@TRGUZEYFX he's saying that when micah fought arthur his hat fell off but then in epilogue he's seen with his old hat meaning that he came back to arthur's grave since his hat was there.
I think Micah only started to hate Arthur when Arthur started to stand up in Micah's way, as Dutch's ideals rot Arthur got to face Micah almost everytime, as if they were a little angel and a little devil around Dutch's head
@@lucky6961 Possibly.
Every little detail every little moment all the realtionships it all feels so real when he dies on that cliff with injustice it hurts I cried my first playthrough
Same, I knew he would die, but it still got me
I cried for 2 days after playing Arthur's storyline... Then when I was visiting all the people that he connected with and all shared fond memories of him, I cried one more time. This character is one of the greatest ever written and the voice actor Roger Clark breathe so much life into such a character.
Whenever he talks to the sister he looks so tired and sad
Thats because he was tired, sad and afraid.
Best tribute yet . Literally bought the game again last night just because of this tribute video and how it reminded me of how good this game is .
Beautiful editing man keep it up
RDR2 story is so good that it gives people such strong emotions that they go out and make tributes on those emotions. By far my favorite game.
I just finished my 2nd playthrough the other week after such a long time, and the Swanson calling Arthur a warrior, will always break my heart. Not because Arthur was Dying, but because deep down Arthur didn't realize how much he helped Swanson change into a better man. And when Arthur admits to the Sister hes afraid, maybe not death being the reason, but because he believed in family and didnt care how his own life ended up as long as everyone was okay. And maybe we fail to see how much guidance Arthur really needed, instead of Dutch. Dutch only pushed inconsistent thoughts into into Arthurs world perspective.
I finished my 2nd playthrough last week too, i got the good ending this time, it took a while after slaying everyone in valentine, but i managed.
Dutch didnt even believe in his own views Hosea was the one who did that he was a hard working and intelligent criminal with a heart and strong morals
Truly the best the goat of protagonist. I know most comments say this. But me and other people too have felt this wierd and emotional connection to Arthur. I had to step back because my personality almost adapted Arthur. Were both stigma similar life style different era. Thanks for this tribute well done
Acho que eu nunca chorei tanto na minha vida quanto esse personagem me fez chorar... meu Deus.
Melhor personagem
The best character in history of gaming , RIP I will never forget you. 💔
Finally got to play it and finished it a couple of days ago. I was so stunned by the ending that I couldn't express any feeling until I watched this video. Thanks for making it.
And no I'm not crying... You're crying 😭
I found this game on my own, desperate for something. Something to live up too and to live for. I found this game and it woke me up. I love this game so much. It means so much to me and eventhough I never played tree he first one, it's the best. I spent all of my Christmas break playing this game and when I finished I felt an emptiness and I believe Arthur Morgan was basically like a brother though he's fiction and never knew me. This game is worth so much to me and I even think I'll name my son after Arthur even though he's tiny little pixels on a screen, but to me he's much more than that.
He has a place in so many peoples heart that when he died i acctually cried and i dont cry at games but Arthur is more than just pixels to me he is like a person he is a brother a father something more yaknow
arthur was the man we all wanne be deep inside .....thats why his story hits us so deep in the feels ,a few seconds can change your life or end it even yet this guy saved lifes while barely being able to walk at the end
I can’t describe how emotionally it hits me and how beautiful it is , what a wonderful tribute
It’s so strange to say how much I miss him, but it’s true. RDR2 has touched so many and its legacy runs deep. I know that I’m not who I was before it. Bless the man- Arthur Morgan, the outlaw saint.
Arthur was one hell of a character! They did so well with him and the ending just kills me
I still tear up everytime I see Arthur take his last breathe while he watches the sun rise
This is the best Arthur Morgan, tribute! Thank you
This was an absolutely amazing edit. I wish I could relive this entire story for the first time all over again.
Imagine if rockstar put this effort and emotions into the stories for GTA.
They did, but only in GTA 4
Red dead is mainly known for its story, while the gta series is mostly known for its open world environment and all the other things that u can do, the story is only 20% of the gta, while red dead's main is story considering that its way longer than gta proves it.
They do.
RDR2 i special than Gta v and other games
@@ShadowMarcus77 And yet Rdr2 has a masterpeice of a story, and a much better open world, that is more detailed
This brings back the sad memories and Arthur was a main part of the game it is sad to see him go.
The song made this the most emotional edit/tribute ive ever seen
Wish I could forget this game and play it all over again to experience it again as it was my first time playing it
Im 30y and cried, that's why I enjoy this game so much, feeling som emotions.
I’ve played the game 3 times going on 4 each time doing a little more and I can’t bare to watch Arthur die the bad way.
I told my friend that no matter what, arthur has to have high honor, but I dont care about johns honor, I almost yelled at him when he said he wanted to do the low honor way
For real man
This make me cry thx arthur, you are a legend
That thumbnail is the most epic thumbnail in the history of thumbnails. Well done!!!!!!
I swear
This game changed my life fr back when I played it in 2019. Its 2022 and no other game comes close to this.
Remembrance from last of us 2 one of my favorite songs from a game and you added it perfectly this is beautiful
This song was out before last of us 2
So was this video
I would do it all again for eternity, if I could live that long
Rest In Peace Arthur Morgan you have earned your rest and honor you will be missed
If I could I'd like this multiple times I would. I miss Arthur so much 😭😭😭😭😭 Legends never die. 😭😭
its a true crime this doesn't have a million views. keep pushing your art, keep pushing your art.
Thank u man
Arthur Morgan, v, and John/Jane Shepard are my all time favorite protagonists in games of my top games of all time they are all so special to me each playthrough i always have mine be the most human, loving, sacrificing chracters they can be and that will always be the way i play it cause thats the way i see those chracters good people put in hard, awful, evil situations but if they werent there they wouldnt be able to bring so much good to those situations and the way i view it they wouldnt want it any other way rip to all those amazing protags you will always have a special place in my heart
This is just a game and i got more goosebumps and cried more tears than in every existing movie this story just goes to the heart
Wow awesome work dude congratulations !!!
Surprised me more people didn’t side with Arthur, especially the people who were relatively new to the gang because he had a bond with most of them
there wasnt many people left at the end.
Most of the people left had more loyalty for Dutch, they didn't know how Dutch was in the beginning and how he naturally worked, however all the veteran members had died or left except fot Miss Grimshaw and John, both of whom took Arthur's side.
The only game I have ever played that brought me to tears.
I gave you all I had.... That line is iconic. And breaks my heart.
Oh god good f**** work on this art
God this game is a masterpiece it gives you such a special feeling
um dos melhores personagens ja criados em toda a historia dos games.
That was an amazing edit man, made me tear up. RIP my man Arthur ;(
I cannot stop seeing this video, I played this game a few time ago and I still remember everything, I just can't forgot when arthur put his hat in jhon's head and say "it would mean a lot to me, please, there's no more time to talk" and in the end Jhon said that arthur is his brother and then they never saw each other again, the saddest and most beatiful good bye that I have ever seen in a game
Man fuck, as soon as i heard him say "you gotta go" the feelings hit hard 💔
*My personal legends:*
- Kratos
- Artreus
- V
- Jackie Wells
- Takemura
- Johnny Silverhand
- Deacon Saint John
- Alex Mason
- David Mason
- Frank Woods
- Captain Price
- Soap McTavish
- Ghost
- Sandman
- Yuri
- Roach
- Joel Miller
- Connor Kenway
- Edward Kenway
- Jin Sakai
- Nathan Drake
- Nomad
- Batman
- Nightwing
- Miles Morales
- Peter Parker
- Master Chief
- Geralt of Rivia
- John Marston
*- Arthur Morgan...*
Finally someone recognized Edward kenway. Fuckin legend
Word
Kiryu of yakuza to
Jin sakai my man
NATHAN DRAKE huh I’m having loving flash backs on playing uncharted 4
I’ll be back for 10 years just hold on stay there
Magnificient work bro!
MASTERPIECE! ⭐
❤️
Arthur is the best teacher i ever had. Thanks pal.
Coming from rdr1 man it’s sad something like this happened to a group of mine a year ago we all knew each other for so long so many years we are all starting to make up for everything with each other but man it’s still a tender subject but This is a perfect example of stuff like that and to come from the first game you realize that Arthur is the reason we all loved John Arthur made John the man he was
This was one of the best game stories of all the time. I got pissed when Sean died and shot up all of Rhoades, and I sat back and reflected on my own life when aurther died. So rare to have a game with such an immersive and impacting story like this one.
“You’re my brother” - still gets me!
Beautiful song choice. Heartbreaking. Could not have done it better. Damn, this game is painful.
*Arthur Morgan without a doubt is the best/most memorable protagonist* i get to play in my life, his story his arc it makes me feel for him, its astonishing and beautiful its deep and meaningfull.
This is the game i will tell my children and nephews to play when they tell me some *blabla* game they played is the best game they ever played.